{ "v2|typed_en|single-question": { "n": 2000, "correct": 1510, "accuracy": 0.755, "nll": 0.6463324192750852, "kl": 0.13270933329166798, "ce_soft": 0.9000678889159969, "brier": 0.07002914815029006, "brier_mean_k": 0.02004525517631372, "brier_onehot": 0.3676075399939686, "ece10": 0.12290431407094005, "mean_conf": 0.6332694019079208, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 411, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.685 }, "noul": { "correct": 503, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.8383333333333334 }, "score": { "correct": 596, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.745 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.7335, 0.7765 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.24199143103868068, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.4274223285297194, "n": 800 } }, "v2|typed_en|full-case context": { "n": 2000, "correct": 857, "accuracy": 0.4285, "nll": 1.2097812919002324, "kl": 0.4959933924254989, "ce_soft": 1.2633519480498279, "brier": 0.26928889266663847, "brier_mean_k": 0.08697066222849263, "brier_onehot": 0.6970586865702736, "ece10": 0.11118127906322481, "mean_conf": 0.5374737640917301, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 198, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.33 }, "noul": { "correct": 298, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.49666666666666665 }, "score": { "correct": 361, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.45125 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.407, 0.45 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.5068433761781231, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.6975457973429002, "n": 800 } }, "v2|typed_en|full-case joint": { "n": 2000, "correct": 706, "accuracy": 0.353, "nll": 1.217202288315301, "kl": 0.4577465691470793, "ce_soft": 1.2251051247714082, "brier": 0.2549271664455238, "brier_mean_k": 0.07846016753062504, "brier_onehot": 0.7019905508599895, "ece10": 0.12446078114211558, "mean_conf": 0.4774607811421156, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 193, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.32166666666666666 }, "noul": { "correct": 286, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.4766666666666667 }, "score": { "correct": 227, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.28375 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.3315, 0.374 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.7265793839785138, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.9440566271264106, "n": 800 } }, "v2|typed_en|single-question vs full-case context": { "n_common": 2000, "only_b_right": 144, "only_a_right": 797, "p_mcnemar_exact": 3.605359197992819e-110 }, "v2|typed_en|full-case context vs full-case joint": { "n_common": 2000, "only_b_right": 302, "only_a_right": 453, "p_mcnemar_exact": 4.334154965648315e-08 }, "v2|typed_es|single-question": { "n": 1985, "correct": 1482, "accuracy": 0.7465994962216624, "nll": 0.6550145421374155, "kl": 0.13250811726703088, "ce_soft": 0.9007772998807515, "brier": 0.07028015084314279, "brier_mean_k": 0.01999555773940268, "brier_onehot": 0.3732510221786229, "ece10": 0.1152207864471887, "mean_conf": 0.6313787097744737, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 401, "n": 594, "accuracy": 0.6750841750841751 }, "noul": { "correct": 497, "n": 597, "accuracy": 0.8324958123953099 }, "score": { "correct": 584, "n": 794, "accuracy": 0.7355163727959698 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.7249370277078085, 0.7677581863979849 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.23905470773449672, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.4315963490568928, "n": 794 } }, "v2|typed_es|full-case context": { "n": 1985, "correct": 832, "accuracy": 0.41914357682619646, "nll": 1.2000239557178545, "kl": 0.47456987091550584, "ce_soft": 1.2428390535292264, "brier": 0.26059998598083783, "brier_mean_k": 0.08474363410961229, "brier_onehot": 0.6933349301776697, "ece10": 0.10654264947479258, "mean_conf": 0.523837870787313, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 236, "n": 594, "accuracy": 0.39730639730639733 }, "noul": { "correct": 295, "n": 597, "accuracy": 0.49413735343383586 }, "score": { "correct": 301, "n": 794, "accuracy": 0.3790931989924433 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.39848866498740554, 0.4397984886649874 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.5519418643797106, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.7501145362577187, "n": 794 } }, "v2|typed_es|full-case joint": { "n": 1985, "correct": 673, "accuracy": 0.33904282115869017, "nll": 1.2040304828794082, "kl": 0.44507417616530687, "ce_soft": 1.2133433587790274, "brier": 0.24717614322069642, "brier_mean_k": 0.07750307326535547, "brier_onehot": 0.6933235732686921, "ece10": 0.11217208232176995, "mean_conf": 0.4512149034804601, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 167, "n": 594, "accuracy": 0.28114478114478114 }, "noul": { "correct": 284, "n": 597, "accuracy": 0.47571189279731996 }, "score": { "correct": 222, "n": 794, "accuracy": 0.2795969773299748 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.31738035264483627, 0.3602015113350126 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.6897287760172528, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.921904983332085, "n": 794 } }, "v2|typed_es|single-question vs full-case context": { "n_common": 1985, "only_b_right": 119, "only_a_right": 769, "p_mcnemar_exact": 3.7714035666656705e-117 }, "v2|typed_es|full-case context vs full-case joint": { "n_common": 1985, "only_b_right": 254, "only_a_right": 413, "p_mcnemar_exact": 7.935736100989516e-10 }, "v2|telepatia_es|single-question": { "n": 2000, "correct": 1492, "accuracy": 0.746, "nll": 0.6768666282900727, "kl": 0.137470178826373, "ce_soft": 0.9048287344507019, "brier": 0.07226937229140096, "brier_mean_k": 0.020558110269673965, "brier_onehot": 0.3838231707888498, "ece10": 0.1303335434347391, "mean_conf": 0.6159254869967699, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 415, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.6916666666666667 }, "noul": { "correct": 502, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.8366666666666667 }, "score": { "correct": 575, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.71875 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.7245, 0.768 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.26117300274514005, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.44825553921662503, "n": 800 } }, "v2|telepatia_es|full-case context": { "n": 2000, "correct": 823, "accuracy": 0.4115, "nll": 1.189682075850548, "kl": 0.4673731803374047, "ce_soft": 1.2347317359617336, "brier": 0.26037437617486775, "brier_mean_k": 0.08499574423415869, "brier_onehot": 0.6928821846712389, "ece10": 0.1040707949474454, "mean_conf": 0.5111226370260119, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 199, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.33166666666666667 }, "noul": { "correct": 291, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.485 }, "score": { "correct": 333, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.41625 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.39, 0.433 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.5304797743702488, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.7196103962347843, "n": 800 } }, "v2|telepatia_es|full-case joint": { "n": 2000, "correct": 636, "accuracy": 0.318, "nll": 1.2328385029619342, "kl": 0.4669040681698344, "ce_soft": 1.2342626237941632, "brier": 0.2603068636325369, "brier_mean_k": 0.08182894089557148, "brier_onehot": 0.7105703100725699, "ece10": 0.15144768108427525, "mean_conf": 0.46944768108427526, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 125, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.20833333333333334 }, "noul": { "correct": 298, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.49666666666666665 }, "score": { "correct": 213, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.26625 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.296, 0.34 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.6871891529425792, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.913369414373301, "n": 800 } }, "v2|telepatia_es|single-question vs full-case context": { "n_common": 2000, "only_b_right": 126, "only_a_right": 795, "p_mcnemar_exact": 2.2596591083909646e-119 }, "v2|telepatia_es|full-case context vs full-case joint": { "n_common": 2000, "only_b_right": 261, "only_a_right": 448, "p_mcnemar_exact": 2.1310615747335922e-12 }, "v3|typed_en|single-question": { "n": 2000, "correct": 1528, "accuracy": 0.764, "nll": 0.6348000373513565, "kl": 0.12133635641347341, "ce_soft": 0.8886949120378023, "brier": 0.0651098222513845, "brier_mean_k": 0.019005062125487936, "brier_onehot": 0.3611829084554942, "ece10": 0.13159668615460393, "mean_conf": 0.632403313845396, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 429, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.715 }, "noul": { "correct": 503, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.8383333333333334 }, "score": { "correct": 596, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.745 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.742, 0.7855 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.23437388759128985, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.42270025751247886, "n": 800 } }, "v3|typed_en|full-case context": { "n": 2000, "correct": 831, "accuracy": 0.4155, "nll": 1.1946701619356137, "kl": 0.48748056433424275, "ce_soft": 1.2548391199585716, "brier": 0.26584338076551384, "brier_mean_k": 0.08537406918322844, "brier_onehot": 0.6924497841014353, "ece10": 0.11764439262449741, "mean_conf": 0.5266776051074267, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 153, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.255 }, "noul": { "correct": 295, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.49166666666666664 }, "score": { "correct": 383, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.47875 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.3945, 0.4365 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.5401024079043407, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.7221055129170417, "n": 800 } }, "v3|typed_en|full-case joint": { "n": 2000, "correct": 742, "accuracy": 0.371, "nll": 1.1821842679997898, "kl": 0.43716691089620746, "ce_soft": 1.2045254665205365, "brier": 0.2458284892200497, "brier_mean_k": 0.0777216018771812, "brier_onehot": 0.6827152191861325, "ece10": 0.08931016900390386, "mean_conf": 0.44944229010492565, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 172, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.2866666666666667 }, "noul": { "correct": 276, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.46 }, "score": { "correct": 294, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.3675 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.349, 0.393 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.6182189710583621, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.8307282497920095, "n": 800 } }, "v3|typed_en|single-question vs full-case context": { "n_common": 2000, "only_b_right": 150, "only_a_right": 847, "p_mcnemar_exact": 1.495086609422151e-118 }, "v3|typed_en|full-case context vs full-case joint": { "n_common": 2000, "only_b_right": 385, "only_a_right": 474, "p_mcnemar_exact": 0.0026569907313413405 }, "v3|typed_es|single-question": { "n": 1985, "correct": 1496, "accuracy": 0.7536523929471033, "nll": 0.6394842117466736, "kl": 0.11898906052638147, "ce_soft": 0.887258243140102, "brier": 0.06475655764622247, "brier_mean_k": 0.018860197074895686, "brier_onehot": 0.36670251099112927, "ece10": 0.12293764144107136, "mean_conf": 0.6313106105219507, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 415, "n": 594, "accuracy": 0.6986531986531986 }, "noul": { "correct": 494, "n": 597, "accuracy": 0.8274706867671692 }, "score": { "correct": 587, "n": 794, "accuracy": 0.739294710327456 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.7324937027707809, 0.7743073047858942 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.23596503181925557, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.4296506547049947, "n": 794 } }, "v3|typed_es|full-case context": { "n": 1985, "correct": 859, "accuracy": 0.4327455919395466, "nll": 1.162280408384133, "kl": 0.4496600929573715, "ce_soft": 1.217929275571092, "brier": 0.2505504103004089, "brier_mean_k": 0.08182399037164234, "brier_onehot": 0.6788902020159528, "ece10": 0.09863890937203425, "mean_conf": 0.5196653394690088, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 211, "n": 594, "accuracy": 0.3552188552188552 }, "noul": { "correct": 296, "n": 597, "accuracy": 0.49581239530988275 }, "score": { "correct": 352, "n": 794, "accuracy": 0.4433249370277078 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.4105793450881612, 0.4544080604534005 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.5462041908321706, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.7497829019000534, "n": 794 } }, "v3|typed_es|full-case joint": { "n": 1985, "correct": 763, "accuracy": 0.38438287153652395, "nll": 1.172466296474459, "kl": 0.42073980961851604, "ce_soft": 1.1890089922322367, "brier": 0.23343222723881618, "brier_mean_k": 0.07347218898601528, "brier_onehot": 0.6736496081085933, "ece10": 0.07710073747923152, "mean_conf": 0.4243709911927768, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 225, "n": 594, "accuracy": 0.3787878787878788 }, "noul": { "correct": 286, "n": 597, "accuracy": 0.47906197654941374 }, "score": { "correct": 252, "n": 794, "accuracy": 0.31738035264483627 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.36171284634760703, 0.4070528967254408 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.6776316444522275, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.9095255444835055, "n": 794 } }, "v3|typed_es|single-question vs full-case context": { "n_common": 1985, "only_b_right": 137, "only_a_right": 774, "p_mcnemar_exact": 1.6584466757134775e-108 }, "v3|typed_es|full-case context vs full-case joint": { "n_common": 1985, "only_b_right": 320, "only_a_right": 416, "p_mcnemar_exact": 0.0004544874488207351 }, "v3|telepatia_es|single-question": { "n": 2000, "correct": 1526, "accuracy": 0.763, "nll": 0.6385563440375813, "kl": 0.11925372995655213, "ce_soft": 0.886612285580881, "brier": 0.06393994905918735, "brier_mean_k": 0.018569114373183912, "brier_onehot": 0.36353173992639604, "ece10": 0.13380355775356292, "mean_conf": 0.6294715915620327, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 438, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.73 }, "noul": { "correct": 498, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.83 }, "score": { "correct": 590, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.7375 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.742, 0.785 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.23628337060784574, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.42863585742670696, "n": 800 } }, "v3|telepatia_es|full-case context": { "n": 2000, "correct": 878, "accuracy": 0.439, "nll": 1.1470116522285891, "kl": 0.4409125760498499, "ce_soft": 1.2082711316741788, "brier": 0.24666331201318742, "brier_mean_k": 0.08078183830888044, "brier_onehot": 0.671401023710438, "ece10": 0.09246306705474854, "mean_conf": 0.5134267296791076, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 223, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.37166666666666665 }, "noul": { "correct": 296, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.49333333333333335 }, "score": { "correct": 359, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.44875 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.4185, 0.4595 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.5391987730165998, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.7372078359872103, "n": 800 } }, "v3|telepatia_es|full-case joint": { "n": 2000, "correct": 745, "accuracy": 0.3725, "nll": 1.1746715414243962, "kl": 0.42382525863971043, "ce_soft": 1.1911838142640392, "brier": 0.235579264029217, "brier_mean_k": 0.07444738062797601, "brier_onehot": 0.6762935895205119, "ece10": 0.08313308775424957, "mean_conf": 0.4297241877913475, "by_type": { "choice": { "correct": 230, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.38333333333333336 }, "noul": { "correct": 279, "n": 600, "accuracy": 0.465 }, "score": { "correct": 236, "n": 800, "accuracy": 0.295 } }, "ci95_cases": [ 0.35, 0.3945 ], "score_mae": { "mae_vs_gold_expectation": 0.6721788485455155, "mae_vs_gold_label": 0.8984525854373351, "n": 800 } }, "v3|telepatia_es|single-question vs full-case context": { "n_common": 2000, "only_b_right": 136, "only_a_right": 784, "p_mcnemar_exact": 2.4222306432783787e-111 }, "v3|telepatia_es|full-case context vs full-case joint": { "n_common": 2000, "only_b_right": 330, "only_a_right": 463, "p_mcnemar_exact": 2.6285909419854747e-06 } }