Instruction: Remove the white lace curtain behind the person

Prompt Compliance
1  Nothing removed, or an unrelated object edited.
2  Target only partly removed, or a different instance/class deleted, or another object appears in the gap.
3  Target mostly removed but extra objects also deleted, or fragments of the target remain.
4  Only the specified objects removed, but a few tiny/background items deleted by mistake, or the count is wrong.
5  Perfect: all and only the requested objects removed; every other element untouched.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: The white lace curtain is fully removed, replaced with a plain greyish backdrop. However, the person’s face is altered (glasses replaced with white blindfold), violating prompt compliance. Background texture and lighting are inconsistent with original scene.

Prompt Compliance: 2
Visual Naturalness: 3
Physical & Detail Integrity: 2

Instruction: Remove the white lace curtain behind the person

Visual Naturalness
1  Image badly broken (large holes, strong artefacts).
2  Clear erase marks; colour/resolution mismatch; background not restored.
3  General look acceptable yet lighting/colour/style still clash; blur or noise visible.
4  Style consistent; minor edge issues visible only when zoomed.
5  Seamless: removal is virtually impossible to spot.

Instruction: Remove the white lace curtain behind the person

Physical & Detail Integrity
1  Severe physical errors (floating items, wrong perspective/light); key scene elements damaged; background heavily warped.
2  Large un-filled gaps or obvious background shifts.
3  Lighting, perspective and contacts mostly correct; flaws small and tolerable; background adjusted locally.
4  Background reconstruction clean; existing details preserved; only minute changes outside the removal area.
5  Physically flawless and even enhances realism: accurate light/shadow/texture infill, high-quality micro-details.

Instruction: Replace the glasses with a eye mask

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not replaced, or an unrelated object edited.
2  Only part of the target replaced, or wrong class/description used.
3  Target largely replaced but other objects altered, remnants visible, or count/position clearly wrong.
4  Correct object fully replaced; only minor attribute errors (colour, size, etc.).
5  Perfect replacement: all and only the specified objects removed; new objects' class, number, position, scale, pose and detail exactly match the prompt.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Glasses replaced with a white eye mask, but mask is oversized, cartoonish, and poorly aligned; facial proportions distorted; background curtain texture altered unnaturally.
Prompt Compliance: 3
Visual Naturalness: 2
Physical & Detail Integrity: 2

Instruction: Replace the glasses with a eye mask

Visual Naturalness
1  Image heavily broken or new object deformed / extremely blurred.
2  Obvious seams, smears, or strong mismatch in resolution or colour; background not restored.
3  Basic style similar, but lighting or palette clashes; fuzzy edges or noise are noticeable.
4  Style almost uniform; tiny edge artefacts visible only on close inspection; casual viewers see no edit.
5  Completely seamless; new objects blend fully with the scene, edit area undetectable.

Instruction: Replace the glasses with a eye mask

Physical & Detail Integrity
1  Floating, interpenetration, severe perspective/light errors; key original elements ruined; background heavily warped.
2  Missing shadows/occlusion; large background shifts or holes.
3  Lighting, perspective and contact surfaces mostly correct; small but tolerable errors; background adjusted locally.
4  New objects interact realistically with scene (shadows, reflections, texture) and preserve existing details; background change minimal.
5  Physically flawless and enhances realism: accurate highlights, shadows, reflections, ambient effects; background untouched.


Instruction: Add a small white cat sitting on the seat

Prompt Compliance
1  Nothing added or the added content is corrupt.
2  Added object is a wrong class or unrelated to the prompt.
3  Correct class, but key attributes (position, colour, size, count, etc.) are wrong.
4  Main attributes correct; only minor details off or 1-2 small features missing.
5  Every stated attribute correct and scene logic reasonable; only microscopic flaws.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: A white cat is added on the seat, but it's heavily blurred, poorly integrated, and lacks realistic lighting/shadows; no visible contact with seat surface.
Prompt Compliance: 3
Visual Naturalness: 2
Physical & Detail Coherence: 1

Instruction: Add a small white cat sitting on the seat

Visual Naturalness
1  Image badly broken or full of artefacts.
2  Obvious paste marks; style, resolution, or palette strongly mismatch.
3  General style similar, but lighting or colours clearly clash; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style almost uniform; small edge issues visible only when zoomed.
5  Perfect blend; no visible difference between added object and original image.

Instruction: Add a small white cat sitting on the seat

Physical & Detail Coherence
1  Severe physical errors (floating, wrong perspective/light); key original elements blocked; background heavily distorted.
2  Contact or occlusion handled poorly; minor background shifts, jaggies or noise; background visibly changed.
3  Lighting, perspective, and contact mostly correct; remaining flaws small and acceptable; limited background change.
4  Shadows, reflections, and material response believable; no loss of original detail; background changes are minute.
5  Added object enhances overall realism: precise highlights, shadows, ambient effects; background essentially untouched.

Instruction: Alter the appearance of the dashboard to a modern one

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not adjusted, wrong object touched, or geometry changed.
2  Right object but wrong attribute value/direction; only part edited; other objects also altered; slight stretch/crop.
3  Mainly correct object and attribute, yet large hue/brightness/texture error; minor collateral edits; visible jaggies/distortion.
4  All requested objects adjusted, only their attributes changed; shape kept; small inaccuracy in colour, material or amount.
5  Exactly and only the requested objects adjusted; colour, material, gloss etc. match the prompt perfectly; shape 100% intact; zero unintended edits.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: The after image completely replaces the dashboard with an unrelated white cat, ignoring the instruction to modernize the dashboard. No attribute alteration occurred; the target region is entirely replaced with a mismatched object.

Prompt Compliance: 1
Visual Seamlessness: 1
Physical & Detail Fidelity: 1

Instruction: Alter the appearance of the dashboard to a modern one

Visual Seamlessness
1  Massive colour spill, mosaics or heavy noise; image nearly unusable.
2  Clear smears/bleeding on edges; abrupt resolution or tone shift; highlights/shadows clipped; background gaps.
3  Overall palette OK but local tone or grain conflicts; soft edges; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style unified, transitions smooth; only slight edge artefacts visible when zoomed.
5  No detectable edit traces; colours/materials fuse with scene lighting; edit area practically invisible.

Instruction: Alter the appearance of the dashboard to a modern one

Physical & Detail Fidelity
1  Object floating, interpenetrating, or severe perspective/light mismatch; background badly warped.
2  Missing shadows/highlights; wrong reflection direction; background visibly discoloured or distorted.
3  Light, perspective and contact surface largely correct; minor acceptable flaws; background only locally affected.
4  Adjusted material interacts believably with scene; shadows, highlights, reflections handled well; original details preserved.
5  High physical realism: fine micro-highlights, diffuse bounce, subsurface effects present; overall scene realism improved.


Instruction: Add a small wooden cabin in the middle of the trees

Prompt Compliance
1  Nothing added or the added content is corrupt.
2  Added object is a wrong class or unrelated to the prompt.
3  Correct class, but key attributes (position, colour, size, count, etc.) are wrong.
4  Main attributes correct; only minor details off or 1-2 small features missing.
5  Every stated attribute correct and scene logic reasonable; only microscopic flaws.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: The cabin is correctly added in the target region, but it’s oversized, cartoonish, and placed on unnatural rocky ground with no integration into the forest scene; severe style mismatch and physical implausibility.
Prompt Compliance: 2
Visual Naturalness: 1
Physical & Detail Coherence: 1

Instruction: Add a small wooden cabin in the middle of the trees

Visual Naturalness
1  Image badly broken or full of artefacts.
2  Obvious paste marks; style, resolution, or palette strongly mismatch.
3  General style similar, but lighting or colours clearly clash; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style almost uniform; small edge issues visible only when zoomed.
5  Perfect blend; no visible difference between added object and original image.

Instruction: Add a small wooden cabin in the middle of the trees

Physical & Detail Coherence
1  Severe physical errors (floating, wrong perspective/light); key original elements blocked; background heavily distorted.
2  Contact or occlusion handled poorly; minor background shifts, jaggies or noise; background visibly changed.
3  Lighting, perspective, and contact mostly correct; remaining flaws small and acceptable; limited background change.
4  Shadows, reflections, and material response believable; no loss of original detail; background changes are minute.
5  Added object enhances overall realism: precise highlights, shadows, ambient effects; background essentially untouched.

Instruction: Remove the clouds in the sky

Prompt Compliance
1  Nothing removed, or an unrelated object edited.
2  Target only partly removed, or a different instance/class deleted, or another object appears in the gap.
3  Target mostly removed but extra objects also deleted, or fragments of the target remain.
4  Only the specified objects removed, but a few tiny/background items deleted by mistake, or the count is wrong.
5  Perfect: all and only the requested objects removed; every other element untouched.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: The after image is completely different—a stylized cabin scene—indicating the entire original image was replaced, not just clouds removed. Prompt compliance fails entirely.
Prompt Compliance: 1
Visual Naturalness: 1
Physical & Detail Integrity: 1

Instruction: Remove the clouds in the sky

Visual Naturalness
1  Image badly broken (large holes, strong artefacts).
2  Clear erase marks; colour/resolution mismatch; background not restored.
3  General look acceptable yet lighting/colour/style still clash; blur or noise visible.
4  Style consistent; minor edge issues visible only when zoomed.
5  Seamless: removal is virtually impossible to spot.

Instruction: Remove the clouds in the sky

Physical & Detail Integrity
1  Severe physical errors (floating items, wrong perspective/light); key scene elements damaged; background heavily warped.
2  Large un-filled gaps or obvious background shifts.
3  Lighting, perspective and contacts mostly correct; flaws small and tolerable; background adjusted locally.
4  Background reconstruction clean; existing details preserved; only minute changes outside the removal area.
5  Physically flawless and even enhances realism: accurate light/shadow/texture infill, high-quality micro-details.


Instruction: Change the black leather seat on top of the motorcycle positioned to the left of the another motorcycle and facing the camera, featuring a green and yellow color scheme with chrome accents, a circular headlight on the front, a green front fender below the headlight, and a side mirror attached to the left side, to red color.

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not adjusted, wrong object touched, or geometry changed.
2  Right object but wrong attribute value/direction; only part edited; other objects also altered; slight stretch/crop.
3  Mainly correct object and attribute, yet large hue/brightness/texture error; minor collateral edits; visible jaggies/distortion.
4  All requested objects adjusted, only their attributes changed; shape kept; small inaccuracy in colour, material or amount.
5  Exactly and only the requested objects adjusted; colour, material, gloss etc. match the prompt perfectly; shape 100% intact; zero unintended edits.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Target seat not changed; wrong object (entire bike) altered. Seams and fidelity fail due to major mismatch.
Prompt Compliance: 1
Visual Seamlessness: 1
Physical & Detail Fidelity: 1

Instruction: Change the black leather seat on top of the motorcycle positioned to the left of the another motorcycle and facing the camera, featuring a green and yellow color scheme with chrome accents, a circular headlight on the front, a green front fender below the headlight, and a side mirror attached to the left side, to red color.

Visual Seamlessness
1  Massive colour spill, mosaics or heavy noise; image nearly unusable.
2  Clear smears/bleeding on edges; abrupt resolution or tone shift; highlights/shadows clipped; background gaps.
3  Overall palette OK but local tone or grain conflicts; soft edges; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style unified, transitions smooth; only slight edge artefacts visible when zoomed.
5  No detectable edit traces; colours/materials fuse with scene lighting; edit area practically invisible.

Instruction: Change the black leather seat on top of the motorcycle positioned to the left of the another motorcycle and facing the camera, featuring a green and yellow color scheme with chrome accents, a circular headlight on the front, a green front fender below the headlight, and a side mirror attached to the left side, to red color.

Physical & Detail Fidelity
1  Object floating, interpenetrating, or severe perspective/light mismatch; background badly warped.
2  Missing shadows/highlights; wrong reflection direction; background visibly discoloured or distorted.
3  Light, perspective and contact surface largely correct; minor acceptable flaws; background only locally affected.
4  Adjusted material interacts believably with scene; shadows, highlights, reflections handled well; original details preserved.
5  High physical realism: fine micro-highlights, diffuse bounce, subsurface effects present; overall scene realism improved.


Instruction: Alter the color of the skis carried by the person with the orange and gray backpack, who is walking in the snow behind the group of skiers traversing the snow-covered ground, with a mountain range visible in the background under snowy weather conditions, from black to bright blue.

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not adjusted, wrong object touched, or geometry changed.
2  Right object but wrong attribute value/direction; only part edited; other objects also altered; slight stretch/crop.
3  Mainly correct object and attribute, yet large hue/brightness/texture error; minor collateral edits; visible jaggies/distortion.
4  All requested objects adjusted, only their attributes changed; shape kept; small inaccuracy in colour, material or amount.
5  Exactly and only the requested objects adjusted; colour, material, gloss etc. match the prompt perfectly; shape 100% intact; zero unintended edits.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Skis color changed to blue but backpack and jacket altered, causing collateral edits.
Prompt Compliance: 2
Visual Seamlessness: 2
Physical & Detail Fidelity: 2

Instruction: Alter the color of the skis carried by the person with the orange and gray backpack, who is walking in the snow behind the group of skiers traversing the snow-covered ground, with a mountain range visible in the background under snowy weather conditions, from black to bright blue.

Visual Seamlessness
1  Massive colour spill, mosaics or heavy noise; image nearly unusable.
2  Clear smears/bleeding on edges; abrupt resolution or tone shift; highlights/shadows clipped; background gaps.
3  Overall palette OK but local tone or grain conflicts; soft edges; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style unified, transitions smooth; only slight edge artefacts visible when zoomed.
5  No detectable edit traces; colours/materials fuse with scene lighting; edit area practically invisible.

Instruction: Alter the color of the skis carried by the person with the orange and gray backpack, who is walking in the snow behind the group of skiers traversing the snow-covered ground, with a mountain range visible in the background under snowy weather conditions, from black to bright blue.

Physical & Detail Fidelity
1  Object floating, interpenetrating, or severe perspective/light mismatch; background badly warped.
2  Missing shadows/highlights; wrong reflection direction; background visibly discoloured or distorted.
3  Light, perspective and contact surface largely correct; minor acceptable flaws; background only locally affected.
4  Adjusted material interacts believably with scene; shadows, highlights, reflections handled well; original details preserved.
5  High physical realism: fine micro-highlights, diffuse bounce, subsurface effects present; overall scene realism improved.


Instruction: Change the color of the banana slice inside the sandwich on the left side of the cutting board, next to its half, featuring seeded bread with a pale yellow cheese layer between the slices, a dark red jam layer beneath the cheese, and a yellow banana slice also sandwiched between the bread, all cut in half with a triangular shape, to green.

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not adjusted, wrong object touched, or geometry changed.
2  Right object but wrong attribute value/direction; only part edited; other objects also altered; slight stretch/crop.
3  Mainly correct object and attribute, yet large hue/brightness/texture error; minor collateral edits; visible jaggies/distortion.
4  All requested objects adjusted, only their attributes changed; shape kept; small inaccuracy in colour, material or amount.
5  Exactly and only the requested objects adjusted; colour, material, gloss etc. match the prompt perfectly; shape 100% intact; zero unintended edits.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Wrong object altered (whole sandwich vs banana slice), severe distortion, poor integration.
Prompt Compliance: 1
Visual Seamlessness: 1
Physical & Detail Fidelity: 1

Instruction: Change the color of the banana slice inside the sandwich on the left side of the cutting board, next to its half, featuring seeded bread with a pale yellow cheese layer between the slices, a dark red jam layer beneath the cheese, and a yellow banana slice also sandwiched between the bread, all cut in half with a triangular shape, to green.

Visual Seamlessness
1  Massive colour spill, mosaics or heavy noise; image nearly unusable.
2  Clear smears/bleeding on edges; abrupt resolution or tone shift; highlights/shadows clipped; background gaps.
3  Overall palette OK but local tone or grain conflicts; soft edges; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style unified, transitions smooth; only slight edge artefacts visible when zoomed.
5  No detectable edit traces; colours/materials fuse with scene lighting; edit area practically invisible.

Instruction: Change the color of the banana slice inside the sandwich on the left side of the cutting board, next to its half, featuring seeded bread with a pale yellow cheese layer between the slices, a dark red jam layer beneath the cheese, and a yellow banana slice also sandwiched between the bread, all cut in half with a triangular shape, to green.

Physical & Detail Fidelity
1  Object floating, interpenetrating, or severe perspective/light mismatch; background badly warped.
2  Missing shadows/highlights; wrong reflection direction; background visibly discoloured or distorted.
3  Light, perspective and contact surface largely correct; minor acceptable flaws; background only locally affected.
4  Adjusted material interacts believably with scene; shadows, highlights, reflections handled well; original details preserved.
5  High physical realism: fine micro-highlights, diffuse bounce, subsurface effects present; overall scene realism improved.


Instruction: Change the color of the bed on the right side of the pair of side-by-side beds, positioned against a brown, panelled headboard with rectangular panels, and parallel to the wall, to light blue.

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not adjusted, wrong object touched, or geometry changed.
2  Right object but wrong attribute value/direction; only part edited; other objects also altered; slight stretch/crop.
3  Mainly correct object and attribute, yet large hue/brightness/texture error; minor collateral edits; visible jaggies/distortion.
4  All requested objects adjusted, only their attributes changed; shape kept; small inaccuracy in colour, material or amount.
5  Exactly and only the requested objects adjusted; colour, material, gloss etc. match the prompt perfectly; shape 100% intact; zero unintended edits.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Target bed color not changed to light blue; wrong elements altered, severe mismatches.
Prompt Compliance: 1
Visual Seamlessness: 1
Physical & Detail Fidelity: 1

Instruction: Change the color of the bed on the right side of the pair of side-by-side beds, positioned against a brown, panelled headboard with rectangular panels, and parallel to the wall, to light blue.

Visual Seamlessness
1  Massive colour spill, mosaics or heavy noise; image nearly unusable.
2  Clear smears/bleeding on edges; abrupt resolution or tone shift; highlights/shadows clipped; background gaps.
3  Overall palette OK but local tone or grain conflicts; soft edges; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style unified, transitions smooth; only slight edge artefacts visible when zoomed.
5  No detectable edit traces; colours/materials fuse with scene lighting; edit area practically invisible.

Instruction: Change the color of the bed on the right side of the pair of side-by-side beds, positioned against a brown, panelled headboard with rectangular panels, and parallel to the wall, to light blue.

Physical & Detail Fidelity
1  Object floating, interpenetrating, or severe perspective/light mismatch; background badly warped.
2  Missing shadows/highlights; wrong reflection direction; background visibly discoloured or distorted.
3  Light, perspective and contact surface largely correct; minor acceptable flaws; background only locally affected.
4  Adjusted material interacts believably with scene; shadows, highlights, reflections handled well; original details preserved.
5  High physical realism: fine micro-highlights, diffuse bounce, subsurface effects present; overall scene realism improved.


Instruction: Replace the bowl of soup in front of the person, containing tomato-based soup, with a spoon positioned above it as the person uses it to scoop soup, and located to the left of a red glass and in front of a sandwich on a plate, with a small ceramic teapot.

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not replaced, or an unrelated object edited.
2  Only part of the target replaced, or wrong class/description used.
3  Target largely replaced but other objects altered, remnants visible, or count/position clearly wrong.
4  Correct object fully replaced; only minor attribute errors (colour, size, etc.).
5  Perfect replacement: all and only the specified objects removed; new objects' class, number, position, scale, pose and detail exactly match the prompt.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Incomplete target replacement (teapot present but spoon missing), visible seams, physical inconsistencies.
Prompt Compliance: 2
Visual Naturalness: 2
Physical & Detail Integrity: 2

Instruction: Replace the bowl of soup in front of the person, containing tomato-based soup, with a spoon positioned above it as the person uses it to scoop soup, and located to the left of a red glass and in front of a sandwich on a plate, with a small ceramic teapot.

Visual Naturalness
1  Image heavily broken or new object deformed / extremely blurred.
2  Obvious seams, smears, or strong mismatch in resolution or colour; background not restored.
3  Basic style similar, but lighting or palette clashes; fuzzy edges or noise are noticeable.
4  Style almost uniform; tiny edge artefacts visible only on close inspection; casual viewers see no edit.
5  Completely seamless; new objects blend fully with the scene, edit area undetectable.

Instruction: Replace the bowl of soup in front of the person, containing tomato-based soup, with a spoon positioned above it as the person uses it to scoop soup, and located to the left of a red glass and in front of a sandwich on a plate, with a small ceramic teapot.

Physical & Detail Integrity
1  Floating, interpenetration, severe perspective/light errors; key original elements ruined; background heavily warped.
2  Missing shadows/occlusion; large background shifts or holes.
3  Lighting, perspective and contact surfaces mostly correct; small but tolerable errors; background adjusted locally.
4  New objects interact realistically with scene (shadows, reflections, texture) and preserve existing details; background change minimal.
5  Physically flawless and enhances realism: accurate highlights, shadows, reflections, ambient effects; background untouched.


Instruction: Change the material of the dining table in front of the man holding a corn dog, positioned directly in front of him and situated under a tent, with a grill containing charcoal to his right and a red propane tank to the left of the grill, from wood to polished granite.

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not adjusted, wrong object touched, or geometry changed.
2  Right object but wrong attribute value/direction; only part edited; other objects also altered; slight stretch/crop.
3  Mainly correct object and attribute, yet large hue/brightness/texture error; minor collateral edits; visible jaggies/distortion.
4  All requested objects adjusted, only their attributes changed; shape kept; small inaccuracy in colour, material or amount.
5  Exactly and only the requested objects adjusted; colour, material, gloss etc. match the prompt perfectly; shape 100% intact; zero unintended edits.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Target table not adjusted; area replaced with unrelated content, failing all criteria.
Prompt Compliance: 1
Visual Seamlessness: 1
Physical & Detail Fidelity: 1

Instruction: Change the material of the dining table in front of the man holding a corn dog, positioned directly in front of him and situated under a tent, with a grill containing charcoal to his right and a red propane tank to the left of the grill, from wood to polished granite.

Visual Seamlessness
1  Massive colour spill, mosaics or heavy noise; image nearly unusable.
2  Clear smears/bleeding on edges; abrupt resolution or tone shift; highlights/shadows clipped; background gaps.
3  Overall palette OK but local tone or grain conflicts; soft edges; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style unified, transitions smooth; only slight edge artefacts visible when zoomed.
5  No detectable edit traces; colours/materials fuse with scene lighting; edit area practically invisible.

Instruction: Change the material of the dining table in front of the man holding a corn dog, positioned directly in front of him and situated under a tent, with a grill containing charcoal to his right and a red propane tank to the left of the grill, from wood to polished granite.

Physical & Detail Fidelity
1  Object floating, interpenetrating, or severe perspective/light mismatch; background badly warped.
2  Missing shadows/highlights; wrong reflection direction; background visibly discoloured or distorted.
3  Light, perspective and contact surface largely correct; minor acceptable flaws; background only locally affected.
4  Adjusted material interacts believably with scene; shadows, highlights, reflections handled well; original details preserved.
5  High physical realism: fine micro-highlights, diffuse bounce, subsurface effects present; overall scene realism improved.


Instruction: Add a small sticker with the text "Organic" to the top-left orange, which is located in the top-left corner of the group of oranges, positioned next to other oranges and lemons, with carrots to its right and green onions below.

Prompt Compliance
1  Nothing added or the added content is corrupt.
2  Added object is a wrong class or unrelated to the prompt.
3  Correct class, but key attributes (position, colour, size, count, etc.) are wrong.
4  Main attributes correct; only minor details off or 1-2 small features missing.
5  Every stated attribute correct and scene logic reasonable; only microscopic flaws.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Sticker added to correct orange but text not "Organic"; visible blending issues; lighting/perspective mismatches.
Prompt Compliance: 3
Visual Naturalness: 3
Physical & Detail Coherence: 3

Instruction: Add a small sticker with the text "Organic" to the top-left orange, which is located in the top-left corner of the group of oranges, positioned next to other oranges and lemons, with carrots to its right and green onions below.

Visual Naturalness
1  Image badly broken or full of artefacts.
2  Obvious paste marks; style, resolution, or palette strongly mismatch.
3  General style similar, but lighting or colours clearly clash; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style almost uniform; small edge issues visible only when zoomed.
5  Perfect blend; no visible difference between added object and original image.

Instruction: Add a small sticker with the text "Organic" to the top-left orange, which is located in the top-left corner of the group of oranges, positioned next to other oranges and lemons, with carrots to its right and green onions below.

Physical & Detail Coherence
1  Severe physical errors (floating, wrong perspective/light); key original elements blocked; background heavily distorted.
2  Contact or occlusion handled poorly; minor background shifts, jaggies or noise; background visibly changed.
3  Lighting, perspective, and contact mostly correct; remaining flaws small and acceptable; limited background change.
4  Shadows, reflections, and material response believable; no loss of original detail; background changes are minute.
5  Added object enhances overall realism: precise highlights, shadows, ambient effects; background essentially untouched.


Instruction: Change the color of the red tape band on the black remote control, which is taped together with a white and a gray remote control and positioned in front of the television, to blue.

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not adjusted, wrong object touched, or geometry changed.
2  Right object but wrong attribute value/direction; only part edited; other objects also altered; slight stretch/crop.
3  Mainly correct object and attribute, yet large hue/brightness/texture error; minor collateral edits; visible jaggies/distortion.
4  All requested objects adjusted, only their attributes changed; shape kept; small inaccuracy in colour, material or amount.
5  Exactly and only the requested objects adjusted; colour, material, gloss etc. match the prompt perfectly; shape 100% intact; zero unintended edits.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Wrong object altered (entire remote blue, not just tape); massive color spill; physical mismatch.
Prompt Compliance: 1
Visual Seamlessness: 1
Physical & Detail Fidelity: 1

Instruction: Change the color of the red tape band on the black remote control, which is taped together with a white and a gray remote control and positioned in front of the television, to blue.

Visual Seamlessness
1  Massive colour spill, mosaics or heavy noise; image nearly unusable.
2  Clear smears/bleeding on edges; abrupt resolution or tone shift; highlights/shadows clipped; background gaps.
3  Overall palette OK but local tone or grain conflicts; soft edges; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style unified, transitions smooth; only slight edge artefacts visible when zoomed.
5  No detectable edit traces; colours/materials fuse with scene lighting; edit area practically invisible.

Instruction: Change the color of the red tape band on the black remote control, which is taped together with a white and a gray remote control and positioned in front of the television, to blue.

Physical & Detail Fidelity
1  Object floating, interpenetrating, or severe perspective/light mismatch; background badly warped.
2  Missing shadows/highlights; wrong reflection direction; background visibly discoloured or distorted.
3  Light, perspective and contact surface largely correct; minor acceptable flaws; background only locally affected.
4  Adjusted material interacts believably with scene; shadows, highlights, reflections handled well; original details preserved.
5  High physical realism: fine micro-highlights, diffuse bounce, subsurface effects present; overall scene realism improved.


Instruction: Add a small wooden side table with a glass top to the left of the couch located in front of the oval-shaped pool, on the right of another couch and under the white umbrella, positioned on a deck overlooking the ocean, with a wooden frame and white cushions, and situated on left of a planter with flowers.

Prompt Compliance
1  Nothing added or the added content is corrupt.
2  Added object is a wrong class or unrelated to the prompt.
3  Correct class, but key attributes (position, colour, size, count, etc.) are wrong.
4  Main attributes correct; only minor details off or 1-2 small features missing.
5  Every stated attribute correct and scene logic reasonable; only microscopic flaws.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: No side table added per instructions; target region lacks requested object.
Prompt Compliance: 1
Visual Naturalness: 1
Physical & Detail Coherence: 1

Instruction: Add a small wooden side table with a glass top to the left of the couch located in front of the oval-shaped pool, on the right of another couch and under the white umbrella, positioned on a deck overlooking the ocean, with a wooden frame and white cushions, and situated on left of a planter with flowers.

Visual Naturalness
1  Image badly broken or full of artefacts.
2  Obvious paste marks; style, resolution, or palette strongly mismatch.
3  General style similar, but lighting or colours clearly clash; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style almost uniform; small edge issues visible only when zoomed.
5  Perfect blend; no visible difference between added object and original image.

Instruction: Add a small wooden side table with a glass top to the left of the couch located in front of the oval-shaped pool, on the right of another couch and under the white umbrella, positioned on a deck overlooking the ocean, with a wooden frame and white cushions, and situated on left of a planter with flowers.

Physical & Detail Coherence
1  Severe physical errors (floating, wrong perspective/light); key original elements blocked; background heavily distorted.
2  Contact or occlusion handled poorly; minor background shifts, jaggies or noise; background visibly changed.
3  Lighting, perspective, and contact mostly correct; remaining flaws small and acceptable; limited background change.
4  Shadows, reflections, and material response believable; no loss of original detail; background changes are minute.
5  Added object enhances overall realism: precise highlights, shadows, ambient effects; background essentially untouched.


Instruction: Add a small silver hairpin to secure the top section of the tightly braided blonde hair of the person wearing a purple cape, standing in front of the mirror above the wooden desk with an open drawer, bottles, and a blue-bristled hairbrush.

Prompt Compliance
1  Nothing added or the added content is corrupt.
2  Added object is a wrong class or unrelated to the prompt.
3  Correct class, but key attributes (position, colour, size, count, etc.) are wrong.
4  Main attributes correct; only minor details off or 1-2 small features missing.
5  Every stated attribute correct and scene logic reasonable; only microscopic flaws.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Hairpin added but hair no longer braided; style mismatch; background distorted.
Prompt Compliance: 3
Visual Naturalness: 2
Physical & Detail Coherence: 1

Instruction: Add a small silver hairpin to secure the top section of the tightly braided blonde hair of the person wearing a purple cape, standing in front of the mirror above the wooden desk with an open drawer, bottles, and a blue-bristled hairbrush.

Visual Naturalness
1  Image badly broken or full of artefacts.
2  Obvious paste marks; style, resolution, or palette strongly mismatch.
3  General style similar, but lighting or colours clearly clash; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style almost uniform; small edge issues visible only when zoomed.
5  Perfect blend; no visible difference between added object and original image.

Instruction: Add a small silver hairpin to secure the top section of the tightly braided blonde hair of the person wearing a purple cape, standing in front of the mirror above the wooden desk with an open drawer, bottles, and a blue-bristled hairbrush.

Physical & Detail Coherence
1  Severe physical errors (floating, wrong perspective/light); key original elements blocked; background heavily distorted.
2  Contact or occlusion handled poorly; minor background shifts, jaggies or noise; background visibly changed.
3  Lighting, perspective, and contact mostly correct; remaining flaws small and acceptable; limited background change.
4  Shadows, reflections, and material response believable; no loss of original detail; background changes are minute.
5  Added object enhances overall realism: precise highlights, shadows, ambient effects; background essentially untouched.


Instruction: Remove the bowl with soup located to the left of the bowl with soup and chopsticks, containing a creamy liquid with egg bits, and positioned on a red tablecloth with a woven pattern, with chopsticks resting on its rim.

Instruction Compliance
1  Neither object nor operations match the prompt; wrong items edited or shapes distorted.
2  Only one object correctly edited, or both edited but with wrong/partial operations; collateral changes to other items.
3  Both target objects touched, each with the requested operation broadly correct but missing details.
4  Both objects receive the exact operations; tiny deviations in amount, position, or parameter. No unintended edits elsewhere.
5  Perfect execution: each object fully reflects its specified operation, all other scene elements untouched.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Target region distorted with heavy artifacts; removal executed poorly, no natural blending or physical consistency.
Instruction Compliance: 1
Visual Naturalness: 1
Physical Consistency & Fine Detail: 1

Instruction: Remove the bowl with soup located to the left of the bowl with soup and chopsticks, containing a creamy liquid with egg bits, and positioned on a red tablecloth with a woven pattern, with chopsticks resting on its rim.

Visual Naturalness
1  Large artefacts, obvious cut-outs, heavy blur/noise; edits conspicuous at a glance.
2  Clear edge halos, colour or resolution mismatch, awkward scaling.
3  Acceptable but visible on close look: slight edge softness, minor palette or focus shift.
4  Edits blend smoothly; seams hard to spot, textures and sharpness largely consistent.
5  Indistinguishable composite: colour grading, grain, resolution and style fully match the original image.

Instruction: Remove the bowl with soup located to the left of the bowl with soup and chopsticks, containing a creamy liquid with egg bits, and positioned on a red tablecloth with a woven pattern, with chopsticks resting on its rim.

Physical Consistency & Fine Detail
1  Severe lighting/perspective mismatch, missing or wrong shadows; objects appear floating or warped.
2  Noticeable but tolerable inconsistencies in illumination, scale, or depth cues.
3  Generally plausible; small errors in shadow length, reflection angle, or texture alignment.
4  Lighting, perspective, and material response closely match; only subtle flaws visible when zoomed.
5  Physically flawless: shadows, highlights, reflections, depth and texture perfectly integrated.


Instruction: Add a small solar panel mounted directly above the top circular light of the vertical traffic light with three circular lights, currently illuminated green, positioned adjacent to a pedestrian signal displaying a red hand and a "15" countdown, and located to the right of a tree.

Prompt Compliance
1  Nothing added or the added content is corrupt.
2  Added object is a wrong class or unrelated to the prompt.
3  Correct class, but key attributes (position, colour, size, count, etc.) are wrong.
4  Main attributes correct; only minor details off or 1-2 small features missing.
5  Every stated attribute correct and scene logic reasonable; only microscopic flaws.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Solar panel added to wrong traffic light (16 vs 15), violating prompt context.
Prompt Compliance: 2
Visual Naturalness: 2
Physical & Detail Coherence: 2

Instruction: Add a small solar panel mounted directly above the top circular light of the vertical traffic light with three circular lights, currently illuminated green, positioned adjacent to a pedestrian signal displaying a red hand and a "15" countdown, and located to the right of a tree.

Visual Naturalness
1  Image badly broken or full of artefacts.
2  Obvious paste marks; style, resolution, or palette strongly mismatch.
3  General style similar, but lighting or colours clearly clash; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style almost uniform; small edge issues visible only when zoomed.
5  Perfect blend; no visible difference between added object and original image.

Instruction: Add a small solar panel mounted directly above the top circular light of the vertical traffic light with three circular lights, currently illuminated green, positioned adjacent to a pedestrian signal displaying a red hand and a "15" countdown, and located to the right of a tree.

Physical & Detail Coherence
1  Severe physical errors (floating, wrong perspective/light); key original elements blocked; background heavily distorted.
2  Contact or occlusion handled poorly; minor background shifts, jaggies or noise; background visibly changed.
3  Lighting, perspective, and contact mostly correct; remaining flaws small and acceptable; limited background change.
4  Shadows, reflections, and material response believable; no loss of original detail; background changes are minute.
5  Added object enhances overall realism: precise highlights, shadows, ambient effects; background essentially untouched.


Instruction: Remove the leftmost vase with a bird perched on a branch, featuring a bulbous body with a narrow neck, decorated in red glossy ceramic, and positioned inside an illuminated display case to the left of the vase with the large pink flower.

Instruction Compliance
1  Neither object nor operations match the prompt; wrong items edited or shapes distorted.
2  Only one object correctly edited, or both edited but with wrong/partial operations; collateral changes to other items.
3  Both target objects touched, each with the requested operation broadly correct but missing details.
4  Both objects receive the exact operations; tiny deviations in amount, position, or parameter. No unintended edits elsewhere.
5  Perfect execution: each object fully reflects its specified operation, all other scene elements untouched.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Left vase removed but collateral damage to other objects and background; obvious artifacts and lighting mismatches.
Instruction Compliance: 2
Visual Naturalness: 1
Physical Consistency & Fine Detail: 1

Instruction: Remove the leftmost vase with a bird perched on a branch, featuring a bulbous body with a narrow neck, decorated in red glossy ceramic, and positioned inside an illuminated display case to the left of the vase with the large pink flower.

Visual Naturalness
1  Large artefacts, obvious cut-outs, heavy blur/noise; edits conspicuous at a glance.
2  Clear edge halos, colour or resolution mismatch, awkward scaling.
3  Acceptable but visible on close look: slight edge softness, minor palette or focus shift.
4  Edits blend smoothly; seams hard to spot, textures and sharpness largely consistent.
5  Indistinguishable composite: colour grading, grain, resolution and style fully match the original image.

Instruction: Remove the leftmost vase with a bird perched on a branch, featuring a bulbous body with a narrow neck, decorated in red glossy ceramic, and positioned inside an illuminated display case to the left of the vase with the large pink flower.

Physical Consistency & Fine Detail
1  Severe lighting/perspective mismatch, missing or wrong shadows; objects appear floating or warped.
2  Noticeable but tolerable inconsistencies in illumination, scale, or depth cues.
3  Generally plausible; small errors in shadow length, reflection angle, or texture alignment.
4  Lighting, perspective, and material response closely match; only subtle flaws visible when zoomed.
5  Physically flawless: shadows, highlights, reflections, depth and texture perfectly integrated.


Instruction: Remove the hardcover book, which is positioned directly below another book on top of the laptop.

Instruction Compliance
1  Neither object nor operations match the prompt; wrong items edited or shapes distorted.
2  Only one object correctly edited, or both edited but with wrong/partial operations; collateral changes to other items.
3  Both target objects touched, each with the requested operation broadly correct but missing details.
4  Both objects receive the exact operations; tiny deviations in amount, position, or parameter. No unintended edits elsewhere.
5  Perfect execution: each object fully reflects its specified operation, all other scene elements untouched.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Entire scene replaced, not just target book; severe mismatches in all aspects.
Instruction Compliance: 1
Visual Naturalness: 1
Physical Consistency & Fine Detail: 1

Instruction: Remove the hardcover book, which is positioned directly below another book on top of the laptop.

Visual Naturalness
1  Large artefacts, obvious cut-outs, heavy blur/noise; edits conspicuous at a glance.
2  Clear edge halos, colour or resolution mismatch, awkward scaling.
3  Acceptable but visible on close look: slight edge softness, minor palette or focus shift.
4  Edits blend smoothly; seams hard to spot, textures and sharpness largely consistent.
5  Indistinguishable composite: colour grading, grain, resolution and style fully match the original image.

Instruction: Remove the hardcover book, which is positioned directly below another book on top of the laptop.

Physical Consistency & Fine Detail
1  Severe lighting/perspective mismatch, missing or wrong shadows; objects appear floating or warped.
2  Noticeable but tolerable inconsistencies in illumination, scale, or depth cues.
3  Generally plausible; small errors in shadow length, reflection angle, or texture alignment.
4  Lighting, perspective, and material response closely match; only subtle flaws visible when zoomed.
5  Physically flawless: shadows, highlights, reflections, depth and texture perfectly integrated.


Instruction: Replace the couch located on the far left of the image, positioned on the rug and adjacent to the media console, with a red armchair with wooden legs and a tufted backrest.

Prompt Compliance
1  Target not replaced, or an unrelated object edited.
2  Only part of the target replaced, or wrong class/description used.
3  Target largely replaced but other objects altered, remnants visible, or count/position clearly wrong.
4  Correct object fully replaced; only minor attribute errors (colour, size, etc.).
5  Perfect replacement: all and only the specified objects removed; new objects' class, number, position, scale, pose and detail exactly match the prompt.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: Target replaced with red armchair; minor attribute details (legs, tufting) unclear. Edges blend well. Realistic lighting/shadows.
Prompt Compliance: 4
Visual Naturalness: 4
Physical & Detail Integrity: 4

Instruction: Replace the couch located on the far left of the image, positioned on the rug and adjacent to the media console, with a red armchair with wooden legs and a tufted backrest.

Visual Naturalness
1  Image heavily broken or new object deformed / extremely blurred.
2  Obvious seams, smears, or strong mismatch in resolution or colour; background not restored.
3  Basic style similar, but lighting or palette clashes; fuzzy edges or noise are noticeable.
4  Style almost uniform; tiny edge artefacts visible only on close inspection; casual viewers see no edit.
5  Completely seamless; new objects blend fully with the scene, edit area undetectable.

Instruction: Replace the couch located on the far left of the image, positioned on the rug and adjacent to the media console, with a red armchair with wooden legs and a tufted backrest.

Physical & Detail Integrity
1  Floating, interpenetration, severe perspective/light errors; key original elements ruined; background heavily warped.
2  Missing shadows/occlusion; large background shifts or holes.
3  Lighting, perspective and contact surfaces mostly correct; small but tolerable errors; background adjusted locally.
4  New objects interact realistically with scene (shadows, reflections, texture) and preserve existing details; background change minimal.
5  Physically flawless and enhances realism: accurate highlights, shadows, reflections, ambient effects; background untouched.


Instruction: Add a small potted succulent plant on the right armrest of the black leather office chair with a jacket draped over it, positioned in front of a beige rectangular desk that holds three turned-on computer monitors, a keyboard, a mouse, and various office items, and situated on a gray carpeted floor.

Prompt Compliance
1  Nothing added or the added content is corrupt.
2  Added object is a wrong class or unrelated to the prompt.
3  Correct class, but key attributes (position, colour, size, count, etc.) are wrong.
4  Main attributes correct; only minor details off or 1-2 small features missing.
5  Every stated attribute correct and scene logic reasonable; only microscopic flaws.

Explanation:
Brief reasoning: No succulent added on chair armrest per instruction; target region lacks requested object.
Prompt Compliance: 1
Visual Naturalness: 1
Physical & Detail Coherence: 1

Instruction: Add a small potted succulent plant on the right armrest of the black leather office chair with a jacket draped over it, positioned in front of a beige rectangular desk that holds three turned-on computer monitors, a keyboard, a mouse, and various office items, and situated on a gray carpeted floor.

Visual Naturalness
1  Image badly broken or full of artefacts.
2  Obvious paste marks; style, resolution, or palette strongly mismatch.
3  General style similar, but lighting or colours clearly clash; noticeable disharmony.
4  Style almost uniform; small edge issues visible only when zoomed.
5  Perfect blend; no visible difference between added object and original image.

Instruction: Add a small potted succulent plant on the right armrest of the black leather office chair with a jacket draped over it, positioned in front of a beige rectangular desk that holds three turned-on computer monitors, a keyboard, a mouse, and various office items, and situated on a gray carpeted floor.

Physical & Detail Coherence
1  Severe physical errors (floating, wrong perspective/light); key original elements blocked; background heavily distorted.
2  Contact or occlusion handled poorly; minor background shifts, jaggies or noise; background visibly changed.
3  Lighting, perspective, and contact mostly correct; remaining flaws small and acceptable; limited background change.
4  Shadows, reflections, and material response believable; no loss of original detail; background changes are minute.
5  Added object enhances overall realism: precise highlights, shadows, ambient effects; background essentially untouched.


1: Add, Add a banner with "Happy Party" text above the doorway, [97, 0, 943, 230]; 2: Remove, Remove the jester hats on the balloon arrangements, [11, 126, 983, 395]; 3: Replace, Replace the green balloons with blue lights, [15, 23, 977, 984]

The festive entrance now features two tall balloon columns flanking the doorway, each topped with a "Happy Party" banner in bold, colorful letters. The jester hats have been removed, and the blue lights throughout the columns and arch, while the gold and purple balloons remain, creating a vibrant blue, gold, and purple color scheme. Shimmering tinsel streamers still hang from the top of the columns, adding sparkle to the celebratory scene.

Happy Party banner: Add "Happy Party" banner


1: Add, Add a small birdhouse near the yellow flowers, [286, 4, 983, 649]; 2: Replace, Replace the wood trellis behind the flowers with a metal door, [10, 1, 614, 260]

A vibrant garden now features clusters of purple phlox on the left, bright yellow daylilies in the center, and red- and orange-leafed coleus in the foreground. A small birdhouse near the daylilies, and a metal door in the background, enhancing the garden’s modern charm while maintaining its lush, textured foliage and stone-edged path.

[mismatch1]:[The caption mentions a small birdhouse near the daylilies, but the image does not show a birdhouse.]

[mismatch2]:[The caption mentions a metal door in the background, but the image does not show a metal door.]

[mismatch3]:[The caption mentions a stone-edged path, but the image does not show a stone path.]

[mismatch4]:[The caption mentions a modern charm, but the image does not have a modern aesthetic.]


1: Replace, Replace the orange drink with green drink, [295, 143, 669, 728]; 2: Remove, Remove the bowl of food on the left, [0, 462, 283, 932]; 3: Add, Add a blue decoration in the glass on the right, [474, 354, 672, 677]

Three hands clink together glasses filled with vibrant green cocktails, each garnished with ice and mint leaves, the rightmost glass with a blue decoration, and equipped with clear straws. The scene remains set on a rustic dark wooden table, now featuring only the bowl of food on the right and small plates of appetizers, with the left salad bowl removed. The warm lighting and close-up perspective continue to emphasize the celebratory, social atmosphere.

[mismatch1]: [glasses filled with vibrant green cocktails]: The image shows glasses filled with orange cocktails, not green ones.

[mismatch1]: [The left salad bowl is removed from the scene].

hand:the rightmost hand is holding a glass, not a bowl


1: Add, Add a vintage camera on the floor near the left mannequin, [0, 453, 365, 999]; 2: Replace, Replace the black dress on the right mannequin with a white t-shirt, [621, 68, 837, 647]

The vintage-style exhibit now features a yellow parasol with floral and bird designs resting on a stand between the mannequins. A vintage camera lies on the gray carpet near the left mannequin, and the right mannequin wears a white t-shirt. The rest of the display, including the three mannequins in retro swimwear and the informational panels on bathing suit history, remains unchanged, maintaining the nostalgic museum atmosphere.

vintage-style exhibit: The exhibit is described as "vintage-style," but the mannequins are wearing modern swimwear, not vintage.


1: Add, Add a small side table next to the red chair, [176, 617, 473, 968]; 2: Alter, Alter the color of the headboard from red to black, [642, 370, 929, 586]; 3: Replace, Replace the red and white striped curtain with a solid beige hanger, [72, 236, 197, 577]

This elegantly decorated hotel bedroom features a large bed with a sleek black upholstered headboard and a red-and-white striped bedskirt, dressed in crisp white linens. The room now includes two small side table beside the red armchair, and a solid beige hanger beside the window; natural light still streams in, illuminating the patterned red and beige carpet and the glass-top table with a vase of white flowers. A delicate crystal chandelier continues to add a touch of sophistication to the warm, inviting space.

[mismatch1]:The bed has a red and white striped bedskirt, not a black upholstered headboard.

side table: The image shows two small side tables, not just one.


1: Replace, Replace the pink frosting on cupcakes with chocolate frosting, [0, 1, 998, 989]; 2: Remove, Remove the tag with number "2" from the cupcake, [376, 355, 596, 817]

A tiered white wire stand holds cupcakes in vibrant red paper liners, now topped with rich, smooth chocolate frosting and small white pearl sprinkles. The cupcakes uniformly decorated without any tags. The display remains festive and visually appealing, with a darker, more decadent appearance.

cupcakes: chocolate frosting: smooth chocolate frosting

pearl sprinkles: small white pearl sprinkles

cupcakes: cupcakes are now topped with rich, smooth chocolate frosting and small white pearl sprinkles.

cupcakes: cupcakes are now decorated without any tags.


1: Add, Add a small fountain in front of the bench, [314, 599, 547, 760]; 2: Replace, Replace the red flowers with blue blueberries, [0, 597, 999, 932]

A vibrant garden scene features a small fountain gently bubbling in front of a wooden bench nestled beneath leafy trees. The foreground is adorned with blueberries and lush greenery, while a grand Gothic-style church with a gleaming silver spire rises in the background, framed by verdant foliage under soft daylight.

[mismatch1]: The image does not feature a fountain.

The image does not feature a fountain; it has a small pond instead.


1: Add, Add a towel rack above the left vanity, [44, 495, 277, 687]; 2: Remove, Remove the chandelier, [425, 0, 654, 299]; 3: Alter, Alter the material of the bathtub to metal, [417, 647, 636, 718]

This luxurious master bathroom now features a sleek towel rack mounted above the left vanity, without ornate chandelier. The centerpiece sunken bathtub is made of metal, contrasting with the warm marble platform and surrounding earth-toned tiles. The grand octagonal ceiling and expansive arched window overlooking the golf course remain unchanged, while the floor’s blue and white checkerboard inlay complements the new tub color.

chandelier:removal
towel rack:placement
chandelier:ornate chandelier
towel rack:seamless towel rack


1: Add, Add a wooden bridge over the stream, [251, 445, 831, 987]; 2: Remove, Remove the rocky path on the left side of the stream, [3, 550, 452, 1000]

A serene alpine meadow features a clear, shallow stream flowing gently over smooth stones, now crossed by a rustic wooden bridge. Lush green grass and wildflowers border the stream, framed by tall evergreen trees, with a majestic snow-capped mountain rising in the background under a bright blue sky. Sunlight illuminates the scene, highlighting the vibrant greens and the tranquil flow of water beneath the new bridge.

[mismatch1]:[The caption mentions a wooden bridge, but the image does not show any bridge].

[mismatch1]:The caption mentions a "snow-capped mountain," but the image does not show any snow on the mountain.


1: Add, Add a black sports bag on the platform behind the car, [704, 313, 942, 530]; 2: Alter, Alter the car's interior color to black, [335, 430, 749, 518]; 3: Replace, Replace the "MILLER MOTORCARS" sign with a "FERRARI" sign, [263, 154, 759, 232]

A vibrant red Ferrari California convertible is showcased in profile on a circular black platform, now featuring a sleek black leather interior. Behind the car, a black sports bag rests on the platform, and the wall displays two prominent "FERRARI" signs in place of the previous dealership logo, with the iconic prancing horse badge still visible. The showroom setting emphasizes the car’s refined and sporty character with its striking red exterior, silver multi-spoke wheels, and yellow brake calipers.

"sleek black leather interior": "tan leather interior"

"black sports bag": "black sports bag is not visible in the image"

"showroom setting": "showroom setting is not visible in the image"

The car is not a Ferrari California convertible; it is a black car with a sleek black leather interior.

The car is not a Ferrari California convertible; it is a Nissan Qashqai.

"Ferrari California convertible" is not mentioned in the caption.


1: Alter, Alter the color of the black ape's fur to white., [440, 403, 566, 739]; 2: Remove, Remove the ape with blue clothes on the right, [760, 480, 804, 672]

A massive army of apes, led by three prominent figures on horseback—a front white-furred chimpanzee and two black gorillas—advances across a bleak, snowy battlefield, flanked by towering wooden fortifications lined with warriors. All apes are black except the front one, and the dense throng of ape soldiers behind them brandishes spears under a gray, overcast sky. In the foreground, human soldiers in tactical gear face the ape force, creating a tense standoff in the desolate, wintry landscape.

The caption mentions a "front white-furred chimpanzee," but in the image, the front figure is a black gorilla.

The image does not show a gray, overcast sky; it is a clear, bright day.


1: Add, Add a dollop of whipped cream on top of the slice of cake on the right plate, [507, 553, 952, 999]; 2: Remove, Remove the napkin beside the right plate, [874, 238, 1000, 741]; 3: Alter, Alter the cherries in the cake to blueberries, [0, 0, 634, 829]

A golden-brown blueberry cake with a rustic, slightly cracked top sits on a white plate, with one slice removed to reveal its moist, fruit-studded interior. Two individual slices are served on separate cream-colored plates, each with a vintage-style fork—one with a piece already cut and ready to eat, and the slice on the right topped with a dollop of whipped cream. The scene is set on a clean, white marble surface, now without the beige napkin, creating a fresh and elegant dessert presentation.

[mismatch1]: [The image shows a cake with blueberries, not blueberries.]

[mismatch2]: [The image shows a cake with a rustic, slightly cracked top, not a smooth, even top.]

[mismatch3]: [The image shows a cake with a moist, fruit-studded interior, not a dry, crumbly interior.]

[mismatch4]: [The image shows a cake with a golden-brown crust, not a light, golden crust.]

[mismatch9]: [The image shows a cake with a moist

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a beige napkin, but the image does not show a napkin.

[mismatch1]: The image shows a cake with a rustic, slightly cracked top, while the caption describes a cake with a "golden-brown top."


1: Remove, Remove the person on the left, [27, 72, 431, 741]; 2: Replace, Replace the red vest of the person on the right with a black leather jacket, [704, 103, 989, 699]

Two bartenders, dressed in white shirts and maroon pinstriped vests with black bow ties, stand behind a richly patterned red tablecloth, pouring drinks into glasses arranged on red trays. The bartender on the right now wears a black leather jacket. Lush green foliage remains in the background, maintaining the elegant, tropical ambiance.

[bartender on the right]:[wears a black leather jacket]


1: Add, Add a dog walking beside the hiker, [556, 522, 940, 948]; 2: Remove, Remove the muddy path, [529, 579, 999, 1000]; 3: Replace, Replace the mountain to buildings, [0, 141, 997, 387]

A hiker with a large blue backpack and trekking poles walks along a grass trail through a vibrant alpine meadow, accompanied by a small dog trotting beside them. The path winds through lush green shrubs and colorful foliage under a partly cloudy sky, with distant buildings glowing in the sunlight. The scene radiates warmth and tranquility, capturing a peaceful journey through a sunlit wilderness.

[mismatch1]:[A small dog is not present in the image]

[mismatch2]:[The buildings in the background are not visible in the image].

[mismatch1]:[The hiker is accompanied by a small dog trotting beside them]

[mismatch2]:[The path winds through lush green shrubs and colorful foliage under a partly cloudy sky, with distant buildings glowing in the sunlight].

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a "large blue backpack," but the image shows a smaller backpack.


1: Add, Add a small photo of a cat in the top-left corner of the collage, [0, 0, 234, 340]; 2: Remove, Remove the bingo card from the center of the collage, [231, 216, 483, 585]

The collage features a small photo of a cat in the top-left corner, adding a playful touch to the vintage arrangement. There is one bingo card on the top-right corner, creating a subtle gap in the dense layering, while the floral paper in the bottom-left corner has been changed to a soft blue, introducing a fresh contrast to the otherwise warm, aged palette. The remaining elements—sepia illustrations, advertisements, sheet music, and the decorative hand clasp—retain their nostalgic charm, now slightly reconfigured to accommodate the new additions and changes.

cat:small photo of a cat in the top-left corner

[mismatch2]:[The floral paper in the bottom-left corner has been changed to a soft blue, which is not mentioned in the caption].


1: Add, Add a cherry on top of the chocolate balls, [121, 0, 893, 635]; 2: Alter, Alter the ingredient of the cake layers from chocolate to fruit, [173, 254, 813, 1000]

A three-layer fruit cake slice sits on a white plate, its bright, fluffy layers separated by creamy chocolate frosting. The top is crowned with a glossy, slightly toasted white meringue, adorned with a cluster of shiny chocolate beads and a single red cherry. The cake is set against a dark, blurred background, highlighting its vibrant colors and rich textures.

[mismatch1]: The cake is described as a "three-layer fruit cake," but the image shows a chocolate cake.


1: Add, Add a bouquet of white flowers to the bride's hand, [185, 597, 348, 941]; 2: Alter, Alter the groom's vest color to blue, [501, 359, 684, 815]

The bride, radiant in her white strapless gown with a beaded belt and delicate headband, now holds a bouquet of white flowers as she walks hand-in-hand with her groom. He wears a plaid shirt, a vibrant blue vest, and jeans, wiping away tears as they make their way down the aisle. Guests cheer under a canopy of green leaves, replacing the original lush greenery, creating a warm, seasonal atmosphere for the joyful wedding ceremony.

bouquet of white flowers: bouquet of yellow flowers


1: Remove, Remove the people in the white lab coat on the left, [25, 349, 376, 938]; 2: Replace, Replace the green wall with a yellow wall, [0, 114, 795, 315]

A woman in a striking red blazer and pinstripe pants stands confidently in the foreground of a busy laboratory, facing the camera with a composed expression. Behind her no people, under bright overhead lighting and yellow-painted walls. The scene remains a professional, active research environment, with the woman as the central figure, more vibrant color scheme.

The woman's attire in the image is a black blazer and black turtleneck, not a red blazer.


1: Alter, Alter the color of the blue house to yellow, [249, 262, 654, 797]; 2: Remove, Remove the palm tree in front of the house on the left, [233, 383, 412, 997]; 3: Replace, Replace the white house on the right with a grocery store, [632, 286, 995, 736]

A vibrant two-story beach house painted in bright yellow with white trim stands prominently under a clear blue sky. The house features wraparound porches on both levels, white railings, and a central staircase leading up from a brick-paved driveway, surrounded by lush greenery and palm trees, except the palm tree in front of the house on the left. To the right, a grocery store, contributing to a cozy, coastal neighborhood atmosphere.

painted in bright yellow: painted in bright blue

palm tree in front of the house on the left: palm tree in front of the house on the right


1: Add, Add a painting on the wall above the couch, [546, 286, 1000, 670]; 2: Remove, Remove the ceiling fan, [443, 72, 663, 264]; 3: Replace, Replace the brown couch with a blue hanger, [534, 532, 751, 787]; 4: Alter, Alter the color of the table to black, [0, 636, 585, 1000]

The cozy cabin interior now features a vibrant blue hanger, positioned beneath a painting on the wooden wall and next to the door. There is no any ceiling fan, and the live-edge dining table has black surface, while the rest of the rustic wood paneling, anchor-patterned rug, and natural sunlight streaming through the open door remain unchanged.

table surface:table surface changed to black


1: Replace, Replace the pink sofa with a blue bench, [247, 109, 797, 539]; 2: Remove, Remove the red velvet chair on the left, [0, 283, 207, 810]; 3: Alter, Alter the color of the flowers on the table to yellow, [467, 314, 775, 709]; 4: Add, Add a small painting on the wall above the sofa, [1, 0, 999, 320]

A luxurious, warmly lit lounge now features a plush blue tufted bench flanked by a single deep red velvet armchair on the right, arranged around an ornate gold-framed glass coffee table. The table displays a vibrant floral centerpiece of yellow roses and dark foliage, accompanied by lit red candles, crystal candle holders, and a tiered stand with chocolate treats and fruit; a small painting now hangs above the sofa, while the window ledge remains adorned with red roses and greenery, all set upon a vintage-style patterned rug.

[mismatch1]: [The bench is blue, not pink]

[mismatch2]: [The armchair is deep red, not deep purple]

[mismatch3]: [The floral centerpiece is yellow roses, not red roses]

[mismatch4]: [The painting is not hanging above the sofa, it is on the wall]

[mismatch5]: [The window ledge is not adorned with red roses and greenery, it is adorned with red roses and greenery on the window sill].

[mismatch1]: [The couch is pink, not blue]

[mismatch2]: [The armchair is deep red velvet, not a single deep red velvet armchair]

[mismatch3]: [The coffee table is gold-framed, not ornate gold-framed]

[mismatch4]: [The floral centerpiece is yellow roses and dark foliage, not yellow roses and dark foliage]

[mismatch7]: [The rug is vintage-style patterned, not vintage-style patterned].

[mismatch5]: [The painting is small, not a small painting]


1: Add, Add a vase with red roses on the table next to the person, [467, 456, 874, 961]; 2: Remove, Remove the oval frame on the left wall, [38, 51, 148, 275]; 3: Replace, Replace the black hat with a golden crown, [170, 23, 502, 210]; 4: Alter, Alter the color of the lace on the blouse to blue, [124, 321, 538, 965]

A woman in period attire wears a golden crown and a white blouse with blue lace trim and puffed sleeves, standing with her hands clasped in front of a glass-topped display case. A vase with red roses sits on the table beside her, and only one square oval portrait on the left wall, enhancing the room’s vintage, museum-like ambiance with antique furniture and natural light from the window.

Golden crown: The woman is not wearing a golden crown.


1: Add, Add a small bowl of jam next to the bread, [3, 127, 896, 976]; 2: Remove, Remove the knife beside the cutting board, [0, 627, 401, 998]; 3: Replace, Replace the red and white checkered towel with a solid blue scarf, [596, 161, 1000, 571]; 4: Alter, Alter the color of the bread's crust to pink, [44, 66, 949, 767]

A freshly baked loaf of whole grain bread, with a pink crust and topped with sunflower seeds, sits on a rustic wooden cutting board, accompanied by three thick slices. Beside the bread is a small bowl of jam, and a solid blue scarf, lending a fresh, modern touch to the cozy scene.

[mismatch1]: The image does not show a small bowl of jam

[mismatch2]: The image does not show a solid blue scarf.


1: Remove, Remove the rightmost red car in the background, [720, 90, 847, 189]; 2: Alter, Alter the color of the red truck to black, [596, 58, 721, 189]

A red and black sport motorcycle, likely a Yamaha R1, is parked in a concrete parking lot, viewed from a side profile. The bike features a sleek design with a black seat, white wheels, a clear windscreen, and a prominent exhaust pipe. In the background, several vehicles are parked, including a red sports car, a white and green off-road vehicle, a black pickup truck, and a black metal fence with trees under a partly cloudy sky.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a red and black sport motorcycle, but the image shows a white and black sport motorcycle.

[mismatch2]: The caption describes the motorcycle as a Yamaha R1, but the image does not provide enough detail to confirm this specific model.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a red and black sport motorcycle, likely a Yamaha R1, but the image shows a white motorcycle with black wheels and a black seat.

[mismatch2]: The caption describes a clear windscreen, but the image shows a windscreen that appears to be partially transparent or not fully clear.

[mismatch1]: The caption describes a red and black sport motorcycle, but the image shows a heavily damaged motorcycle with no clear indication of its original color or brand.

[mismatch2]: The caption mentions a clear windscreen, but the image shows a motorcycle with a damaged windshield.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a red and black sport motorcycle, likely a Yamaha R1, but the image shows a heavily damaged motorcycle with a red and black color scheme, but the details suggest it is not a Yamaha R1.


1: Add, Add a bowl of fruit to the center of the dining table, [407, 660, 854, 980]; 2: Replace, Replace the white flowers in the vase with red pencils, [408, 542, 488, 834]

A beautifully set dining table for six features a vibrant bowl of fresh fruit at its center. The elegant brass chandelier, and the red pencils in the vase, adding a bold pop of color to the sophisticated setting. The panoramic city view at dusk remains unchanged, with the warm interior lighting and golden napkins continuing to enhance the romantic ambiance.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a "vibrant bowl of fresh fruit at its center," but the image shows a vase with white roses, not a bowl of fruit.

[mismatch2]: The caption states "the elegant brass chandelier," but the chandelier in the image appears to be made of a material other than brass, possibly chrome or another metal.

[mismatch3]: The caption mentions "red pencils in the vase," but the vase in the image contains white roses, not red pencils.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a vibrant bowl of fresh fruit at the center of the table, but the image does not show any fruit bowl.

[mismatch2]: The caption describes red pencils in the vase, but the image shows white flowers in a vase.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a bowl of fresh fruit at the center of the table, but the image shows a vase with red pencils instead.

[mismatch1]: The image does not show a dining table for six, a bowl of fresh fruit, an elegant brass chandelier, or a panoramic city view at dusk.

[mismatch3]: The image does not show a brass chandelier.

[mismatch4]: The image does not show a panoramic city view at dusk.

[mismatch3]: The image does not show a chandelier or a city view.

[mismatch4]: The image does not show warm interior lighting or golden napkins.


1: Alter, Alter the pink top of the woman on the left to a yellow top, [101, 335, 273, 847]; 2: Remove, Remove the woman with blonde hair in the center, [416, 54, 665, 998]; 3: Replace, Replace the blue top of the woman in the middle with a green sweater, [242, 319, 513, 930]

Three diverse women stand closely together against a plain white background, all smiling warmly at the camera. From left to right, they wear a bright yellow top, a solid green sweater, and a patterned orange and pink dress with a pink cardigan. Their varied ethnicities and cheerful expressions convey a sense of unity and positivity.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a bright yellow top, a solid green sweater, and a patterned orange and pink dress with a pink cardigan, but the image shows a bright pink top, a solid blue top, a striped sweater with pink and blue, and a patterned orange and pink dress with a pink cardigan.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a bright yellow top, but the woman on the left is wearing a bright orange top.

[mismatch2]: The caption mentions a solid green sweater, but the woman in the middle is wearing a multicolored striped sweater.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions three women, but the image only shows two women.

[mismatch2]: The caption describes the women as standing closely together, but the image shows them sitting.


[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a small photo of a cat in the top-left corner, but the image does not show a cat.

[mismatch2]: The caption states that the bingo card is on the top-right corner, but the bingo card is actually in the center of the image.

[mismatch2]: The caption states that the floral paper in the bottom-left corner has been changed to a soft blue, but the image does not show a blue floral paper; it remains in the original floral pattern.

Add a small photo of a cat in the top-left corner of the collage

Remove the bingo card from the center of the collage


1: Remove, Remove the white lace curtain behind the person, [129, 0, 855, 767]; 2: Replace, Replace the glasses with a eye mask, [450, 416, 568, 505]

A man with short dark hair and glasses sits in a dark, ornate wooden armchair, now wearing a vibrant red hoodie and matching pants. Behind him, there is no curtains. The man wearing a eye mask. The warm glow from the lamp contrasts with the cooler light from the window, maintaining the moody, vintage ambiance of the patterned room.

[mismatch1]: The man is wearing a vibrant yellow hoodie and matching pants, not a red one.

[mismatch2]: The man is not wearing an eye mask.

[mismatch3]: The curtains behind the man are present in the image, not absent.

[caption mentions a red hoodie and pants, but the image shows a yellow hoodie and green pants]

[caption mentions no curtains, but the image shows curtains]

[caption mentions an eye mask, but the image shows red glasses]

[caption mentions a warm glow from the lamp and cooler light from the window, but the image shows a single light source].

[caption mentions a dark, ornate wooden armchair, but the image shows a dark, ornate wooden chair]


1: Add, Add a small white cat sitting on the seat, [81, 407, 701, 996]; 2: Alter, Alter the appearance of the dashboard to a modern one, [442, 145, 577, 375]

The interior of the classic hot rod now features a sleek silver modern dashboard with chrome gauges, contrasting with vibrant black leather bench seats accented by red piping. A small white cat sits comfortably on the passenger side of the seat, adding a playful touch to the retro-custom aesthetic. The white ribbed door panels and black carpet remain, but the red door frames and red upholstery create a bold, cohesive look.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a "sleek silver modern dashboard with chrome gauges," but the image shows a classic dashboard with a more vintage design.

[mismatch2]: The caption states that a "small white cat sits comfortably on the passenger side of the seat," but there is no cat visible in the image.

[mismatch1]: The caption describes a modern dashboard with chrome gauges, but the image shows a classic car interior with a vintage dashboard.

[mismatch2]: The caption mentions red upholstery, but the image shows a red interior with black and red accents.

[mismatch1]: The image shows a classic hot rod with a red dashboard and upholstery, not a modern silver dashboard with chrome gauges.

[mismatch2]: The image does not show a white cat sitting on the passenger side of the seat.

[mismatch2]: The caption describes black leather bench seats with red piping, but the image shows a white cat sitting on the seat, which is not mentioned in the caption.


1: Add, Add a small wooden cabin in the middle of the trees, [228, 398, 729, 913]; 2: Remove, Remove the clouds in the sky, [0, 0, 895, 391]

A serene desert landscape now features a small wooden cabin nestled among the trees in the midground, with the sky without clouds to reveal a bright, open blue expanse. The distant red rock formations have been transformed into muted gray cliffs, contrasting with the vibrant green foliage and dry, reddish-brown earth below. The overall scene appears calmer and more subdued, with the natural ruggedness softened by the edited sky and monochromatic mountains.

[mismatch1]: The image shows a cloudy sky, not a bright, open blue expanse.

[mismatch2]: The red rock formations are not muted gray cliffs; they are still red.

[mismatch3]: The caption mentions a small wooden cabin, but the image does not show one.

[mismatch1]: The sky in the image is not without clouds, it is filled with clouds

[mismatch3]: The image does not show vibrant green foliage, and

[mismatch4]: The earth is not described as dry, reddish-brown.

[mismatch1]: The image does not show a small wooden cabin nestled among the trees in the midground.

[mismatch4]: The overall scene does not appear calmer and more subdued; it maintains its natural ruggedness.


[mismatch1]: The woman in the image is wearing a black blazer and pinstripe pants, not a red blazer.

[mismatch2]: The walls in the image are green, not yellow.

[mismatch2]: The background in the image shows a blurred, artistic, and somewhat abstract scene with multiple figures and objects, which does not match the caption's description of a busy laboratory with bright overhead lighting and yellow-painted walls.

[mismatch2]: The background in the image shows a blurred figure in motion, which is not mentioned in the caption.

[mismatch1]: The caption mentions a woman in a red blazer and pinstripe pants, but the image shows a man in a white shirt and dark pants.

[mismatch2]: The caption describes a woman standing confidently in the foreground, but the image shows a man in the foreground.

[mismatch3]: The caption mentions a woman facing the camera, but the man in the image is not facing the camera.

[mismatch4]: The caption describes a busy laboratory with no people behind the woman, but the image shows a man behind the woman.

[caption mentions a woman, but the image shows a man]:[edit the caption to describe the person as a man]

[caption describes the person as wearing a red blazer and pinstripe pants, but the image shows a red blazer without pinstripe pants]:[edit the caption to remove the mention of pinstripe pants].

Remove the people in the white lab coat on the left

Replace the green wall with a yellow wall