Ouaill commited on
Commit
343bbb9
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): b05b030

Upload external_comparison.json with huggingface_hub

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. external_comparison.json +437 -0
external_comparison.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,437 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ [
2
+ {
3
+ "name": "shared_bpe_8000",
4
+ "source": "ours",
5
+ "algorithm": "bpe",
6
+ "architecture": "shared",
7
+ "vocab_size": 8000,
8
+ "fertility_ar": 1.4755656463463651,
9
+ "fertility_az": 1.7595859759130557,
10
+ "fertility_overall": 1.5744684296670828,
11
+ "disparity": 0.16141315823985886,
12
+ "cpt_ar": 3.812953050264278,
13
+ "cpt_az": 3.0042165735724513,
14
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9990480507706255,
15
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9992363821483116
16
+ },
17
+ {
18
+ "name": "concat_bpe_8000",
19
+ "source": "ours",
20
+ "algorithm": "bpe",
21
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
22
+ "vocab_size": 8000,
23
+ "fertility_ar": 1.677255929872786,
24
+ "fertility_az": 1.5274486975717831,
25
+ "fertility_overall": 1.625089409755206,
26
+ "disparity": 0.0893168595399542,
27
+ "cpt_ar": 3.3745329363977343,
28
+ "cpt_az": 3.4826508889784487,
29
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9989120580235721,
30
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9964364500254539
31
+ },
32
+ {
33
+ "name": "shared_unigram_8000",
34
+ "source": "ours",
35
+ "algorithm": "unigram",
36
+ "architecture": "shared",
37
+ "vocab_size": 8000,
38
+ "fertility_ar": 1.5098217608254827,
39
+ "fertility_az": 1.7286510868870875,
40
+ "fertility_overall": 1.5860234519252308,
41
+ "disparity": 0.12658964421540223,
42
+ "cpt_ar": 3.7495598617218993,
43
+ "cpt_az": 3.072876133532698,
44
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9990480507706255,
45
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9992363821483116
46
+ },
47
+ {
48
+ "name": "concat_unigram_8000",
49
+ "source": "ours",
50
+ "algorithm": "unigram",
51
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
52
+ "vocab_size": 8000,
53
+ "fertility_ar": 1.6828221737842166,
54
+ "fertility_az": 1.5327330595500248,
55
+ "fertility_overall": 1.630557495524919,
56
+ "disparity": 0.08918893307465849,
57
+ "cpt_ar": 3.3890978047599254,
58
+ "cpt_az": 3.4939403000980764,
59
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9989120580235721,
60
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9964364500254539
61
+ },
62
+ {
63
+ "name": "shared_wordpiece_8000",
64
+ "source": "ours",
65
+ "algorithm": "wordpiece",
66
+ "architecture": "shared",
67
+ "vocab_size": 8000,
68
+ "fertility_ar": 1.4715587661386824,
69
+ "fertility_az": 1.7600376405371791,
70
+ "fertility_overall": 1.5720141231575526,
71
+ "disparity": 0.16390494598197936,
72
+ "cpt_ar": 3.819823570325556,
73
+ "cpt_az": 3.001677181426908,
74
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.0,
75
+ "exact_match_az": 0.0
76
+ },
77
+ {
78
+ "name": "concat_wordpiece_8000",
79
+ "source": "ours",
80
+ "algorithm": "wordpiece",
81
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
82
+ "vocab_size": 8000,
83
+ "fertility_ar": 1.679880351462672,
84
+ "fertility_az": 1.5381307082241507,
85
+ "fertility_overall": 1.6305196797375283,
86
+ "disparity": 0.08438079718897826,
87
+ "cpt_ar": 3.366673383613362,
88
+ "cpt_az": 3.4556741357085015,
89
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.0,
90
+ "exact_match_az": 0.0
91
+ },
92
+ {
93
+ "name": "shared_bbpe_8000",
94
+ "source": "ours",
95
+ "algorithm": "bbpe",
96
+ "architecture": "shared",
97
+ "vocab_size": 8000,
98
+ "fertility_ar": 1.5432842580927282,
99
+ "fertility_az": 2.037850131276259,
100
+ "fertility_overall": 1.7155041180862605,
101
+ "disparity": 0.24269001218151182,
102
+ "cpt_ar": 3.6389791874263038,
103
+ "cpt_az": 2.5723083391604016,
104
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9994106980961015,
105
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9994909214322077
106
+ },
107
+ {
108
+ "name": "concat_bbpe_8000",
109
+ "source": "ours",
110
+ "algorithm": "bbpe",
111
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
112
+ "vocab_size": 8000,
113
+ "fertility_ar": 1.733122664722859,
114
+ "fertility_az": 1.8376823362685084,
115
+ "fertility_overall": 1.7695328842122233,
116
+ "disparity": 0.056897576627940066,
117
+ "cpt_ar": 3.268439481034545,
118
+ "cpt_az": 2.872055574482044,
119
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.999909338168631,
120
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9997454607161038
121
+ },
122
+ {
123
+ "name": "shared_bpe_16000",
124
+ "source": "ours",
125
+ "algorithm": "bpe",
126
+ "architecture": "shared",
127
+ "vocab_size": 16000,
128
+ "fertility_ar": 1.3322457895485136,
129
+ "fertility_az": 1.545385811386613,
130
+ "fertility_overall": 1.406466326610023,
131
+ "disparity": 0.13792026577936378,
132
+ "cpt_ar": 4.211736441809671,
133
+ "cpt_az": 3.426166367193676,
134
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9990480507706255,
135
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9992363821483116
136
+ },
137
+ {
138
+ "name": "concat_bpe_16000",
139
+ "source": "ours",
140
+ "algorithm": "bpe",
141
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
142
+ "vocab_size": 16000,
143
+ "fertility_ar": 1.4863282848922221,
144
+ "fertility_az": 1.3611285082800872,
145
+ "fertility_overall": 1.4427306790554728,
146
+ "disparity": 0.08423426902705648,
147
+ "cpt_ar": 3.806560946253488,
148
+ "cpt_az": 3.9116836675170874,
149
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9989120580235721,
150
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9964364500254539
151
+ },
152
+ {
153
+ "name": "shared_unigram_16000",
154
+ "source": "ours",
155
+ "algorithm": "unigram",
156
+ "architecture": "shared",
157
+ "vocab_size": 16000,
158
+ "fertility_ar": 1.383798509647741,
159
+ "fertility_az": 1.542776425502961,
160
+ "fertility_overall": 1.43915848471923,
161
+ "disparity": 0.10304663282846806,
162
+ "cpt_ar": 4.074326867754011,
163
+ "cpt_az": 3.4475943366681565,
164
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9990480507706255,
165
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9992363821483116
166
+ },
167
+ {
168
+ "name": "concat_unigram_16000",
169
+ "source": "ours",
170
+ "algorithm": "unigram",
171
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
172
+ "vocab_size": 16000,
173
+ "fertility_ar": 1.5133852390561142,
174
+ "fertility_az": 1.3859550062802124,
175
+ "fertility_overall": 1.4690109341605053,
176
+ "disparity": 0.08420211158883709,
177
+ "cpt_ar": 3.7636569223952008,
178
+ "cpt_az": 3.865353143030446,
179
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9989120580235721,
180
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9964364500254539
181
+ },
182
+ {
183
+ "name": "shared_wordpiece_16000",
184
+ "source": "ours",
185
+ "algorithm": "wordpiece",
186
+ "architecture": "shared",
187
+ "vocab_size": 16000,
188
+ "fertility_ar": 1.3278822099406427,
189
+ "fertility_az": 1.5399298737530456,
190
+ "fertility_overall": 1.4017223613822598,
191
+ "disparity": 0.1376995585491242,
192
+ "cpt_ar": 4.223103615213092,
193
+ "cpt_az": 3.43676962420351,
194
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.0,
195
+ "exact_match_az": 0.0
196
+ },
197
+ {
198
+ "name": "concat_wordpiece_16000",
199
+ "source": "ours",
200
+ "algorithm": "wordpiece",
201
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
202
+ "vocab_size": 16000,
203
+ "fertility_ar": 1.4835885687430344,
204
+ "fertility_az": 1.3635334584201908,
205
+ "fertility_overall": 1.441782460775622,
206
+ "disparity": 0.08092210526032824,
207
+ "cpt_ar": 3.81082194270718,
208
+ "cpt_az": 3.9034221417934196,
209
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.0,
210
+ "exact_match_az": 0.0
211
+ },
212
+ {
213
+ "name": "shared_bbpe_16000",
214
+ "source": "ours",
215
+ "algorithm": "bbpe",
216
+ "architecture": "shared",
217
+ "vocab_size": 16000,
218
+ "fertility_ar": 1.407745203379972,
219
+ "fertility_az": 1.8543152757754426,
220
+ "fertility_overall": 1.563251758755881,
221
+ "disparity": 0.24082747860054313,
222
+ "cpt_ar": 3.9802348152214964,
223
+ "cpt_az": 2.8299292509695566,
224
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9994106980961015,
225
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9994909214322077
226
+ },
227
+ {
228
+ "name": "concat_bbpe_16000",
229
+ "source": "ours",
230
+ "algorithm": "bbpe",
231
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
232
+ "vocab_size": 16000,
233
+ "fertility_ar": 1.5508741409303313,
234
+ "fertility_az": 1.7047474509939684,
235
+ "fertility_overall": 1.6044565681716603,
236
+ "disparity": 0.09026164548532975,
237
+ "cpt_ar": 3.653251881231358,
238
+ "cpt_az": 3.0920455646111016,
239
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.999909338168631,
240
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9997454607161038
241
+ },
242
+ {
243
+ "name": "shared_bpe_32000",
244
+ "source": "ours",
245
+ "algorithm": "bpe",
246
+ "architecture": "shared",
247
+ "vocab_size": 32000,
248
+ "fertility_ar": 1.2326026481342502,
249
+ "fertility_az": 1.3678412557544855,
250
+ "fertility_overall": 1.2796960189731112,
251
+ "disparity": 0.09887010429849855,
252
+ "cpt_ar": 4.537455476649384,
253
+ "cpt_az": 3.8681871063030555,
254
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9990480507706255,
255
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9992363821483116
256
+ },
257
+ {
258
+ "name": "concat_bpe_32000",
259
+ "source": "ours",
260
+ "algorithm": "bpe",
261
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
262
+ "vocab_size": 32000,
263
+ "fertility_ar": 1.3077466165859795,
264
+ "fertility_az": 1.1981161479838143,
265
+ "fertility_overall": 1.2695706222898995,
266
+ "disparity": 0.08383158267185423,
267
+ "cpt_ar": 4.388664556275568,
268
+ "cpt_az": 4.487021365858093,
269
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.0,
270
+ "exact_match_az": 0.0
271
+ },
272
+ {
273
+ "name": "shared_unigram_32000",
274
+ "source": "ours",
275
+ "algorithm": "unigram",
276
+ "architecture": "shared",
277
+ "vocab_size": 32000,
278
+ "fertility_ar": 1.3027084505800648,
279
+ "fertility_az": 1.3926146506382522,
280
+ "fertility_overall": 1.3340159750699838,
281
+ "disparity": 0.06455928064305677,
282
+ "cpt_ar": 4.308287618942264,
283
+ "cpt_az": 3.8153634896854167,
284
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9990480507706255,
285
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9992363821483116
286
+ },
287
+ {
288
+ "name": "concat_unigram_32000",
289
+ "source": "ours",
290
+ "algorithm": "unigram",
291
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
292
+ "vocab_size": 32000,
293
+ "fertility_ar": 1.392269196943319,
294
+ "fertility_az": 1.2705202940282205,
295
+ "fertility_overall": 1.3498732692189985,
296
+ "disparity": 0.08744638119007023,
297
+ "cpt_ar": 4.071549633983907,
298
+ "cpt_az": 4.204670213900507,
299
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9989120580235721,
300
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9964364500254539
301
+ },
302
+ {
303
+ "name": "shared_wordpiece_32000",
304
+ "source": "ours",
305
+ "algorithm": "wordpiece",
306
+ "architecture": "shared",
307
+ "vocab_size": 32000,
308
+ "fertility_ar": 1.2274699882356,
309
+ "fertility_az": 1.3618102283002589,
310
+ "fertility_overall": 1.2742505256521945,
311
+ "disparity": 0.0986482824646834,
312
+ "cpt_ar": 4.553239284995183,
313
+ "cpt_az": 3.883101533084343,
314
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.0,
315
+ "exact_match_az": 0.0
316
+ },
317
+ {
318
+ "name": "concat_wordpiece_32000",
319
+ "source": "ours",
320
+ "algorithm": "wordpiece",
321
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
322
+ "vocab_size": 32000,
323
+ "fertility_ar": 1.3416327230816638,
324
+ "fertility_az": 1.2307158917884393,
325
+ "fertility_overall": 1.303008786024938,
326
+ "disparity": 0.08267302174804893,
327
+ "cpt_ar": 4.201360994624003,
328
+ "cpt_az": 4.313461511548837,
329
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.001042611060743427,
330
+ "exact_match_az": 0.00033938571186153065
331
+ },
332
+ {
333
+ "name": "shared_bbpe_32000",
334
+ "source": "ours",
335
+ "algorithm": "bbpe",
336
+ "architecture": "shared",
337
+ "vocab_size": 32000,
338
+ "fertility_ar": 1.317581832517785,
339
+ "fertility_az": 1.7086120162163183,
340
+ "fertility_overall": 1.4537480484685892,
341
+ "disparity": 0.22885838328847793,
342
+ "cpt_ar": 4.240919303648946,
343
+ "cpt_az": 3.0730455542376744,
344
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9994106980961015,
345
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9994909214322077
346
+ },
347
+ {
348
+ "name": "concat_bbpe_32000",
349
+ "source": "ours",
350
+ "algorithm": "bbpe",
351
+ "architecture": "concatenated",
352
+ "vocab_size": 32000,
353
+ "fertility_ar": 1.3463628334026025,
354
+ "fertility_az": 1.2326871301490916,
355
+ "fertility_overall": 1.306778190060823,
356
+ "disparity": 0.08443170030639024,
357
+ "cpt_ar": 4.190301018162676,
358
+ "cpt_az": 4.3094384241989285,
359
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9989120580235721,
360
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9964364500254539
361
+ },
362
+ {
363
+ "name": "CaMeLBERT-MSA",
364
+ "source": "external_msa",
365
+ "algorithm": "WordPiece",
366
+ "architecture": "shared",
367
+ "vocab_size": 30000,
368
+ "fertility_ar": 1.816901627794181,
369
+ "fertility_az": 3.173471216645639,
370
+ "fertility_overall": 2.2892921369888652,
371
+ "disparity": 0.42747184273672184,
372
+ "cpt_ar": 3.1140517054288748,
373
+ "cpt_az": 1.6388977943422216,
374
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.2987307343608341,
375
+ "exact_match_az": 0.3885117936534872
376
+ },
377
+ {
378
+ "name": "Asafaya-BERT",
379
+ "source": "external_msa",
380
+ "algorithm": "WordPiece",
381
+ "architecture": "shared",
382
+ "vocab_size": 32000,
383
+ "fertility_ar": 1.7951679730188856,
384
+ "fertility_az": 2.794867411003224,
385
+ "fertility_overall": 2.143287620128837,
386
+ "disparity": 0.35769118565288,
387
+ "cpt_ar": 3.1312619206100933,
388
+ "cpt_az": 1.8618984630783484,
389
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.19895738893925657,
390
+ "exact_match_az": 0.15238418462582726
391
+ },
392
+ {
393
+ "name": "Aranizer-SP-86k",
394
+ "source": "external_msa",
395
+ "algorithm": "SentencePiece",
396
+ "architecture": "shared",
397
+ "vocab_size": 86000,
398
+ "fertility_ar": 1.5940707675919776,
399
+ "fertility_az": 2.5232344233957935,
400
+ "fertility_overall": 1.9176281406140119,
401
+ "disparity": 0.3682430959202508,
402
+ "cpt_ar": 3.532878084819776,
403
+ "cpt_az": 2.06546468780593,
404
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.9976881233000907,
405
+ "exact_match_az": 0.9955031393178347
406
+ },
407
+ {
408
+ "name": "DarijaBERT-ar",
409
+ "source": "external_darija",
410
+ "algorithm": "WordPiece",
411
+ "architecture": "shared",
412
+ "vocab_size": 80000,
413
+ "fertility_ar": 1.4174523931345464,
414
+ "fertility_az": 2.4040608107988306,
415
+ "fertility_overall": 1.7610134287249042,
416
+ "disparity": 0.41039245481334147,
417
+ "cpt_ar": 3.9815436288421893,
418
+ "cpt_az": 2.170223436755666,
419
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.13721668177697188,
420
+ "exact_match_az": 0.07984048871542508
421
+ },
422
+ {
423
+ "name": "DarijaBERT-az",
424
+ "source": "external_darija",
425
+ "algorithm": "WordPiece",
426
+ "architecture": "shared",
427
+ "vocab_size": 110000,
428
+ "fertility_ar": 1.6053190877519825,
429
+ "fertility_az": 1.5171613637119812,
430
+ "fertility_overall": 1.5746204251172413,
431
+ "disparity": 0.05491601309210961,
432
+ "cpt_ar": 3.476952784741954,
433
+ "cpt_az": 3.451281188374697,
434
+ "exact_match_ar": 0.14777878513145964,
435
+ "exact_match_az": 0.07984048871542508
436
+ }
437
+ ]