mrshravan commited on
Commit
9aa46fc
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 68744ef

Upload benchmarks/discovery_results.json with huggingface_hub

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. benchmarks/discovery_results.json +1493 -697
benchmarks/discovery_results.json CHANGED
@@ -1,25 +1,19 @@
1
  {
2
  "model": {
3
- "path": "/root/anofy/dist/tcpfn/outputs/discovery/final.pt",
4
- "step": 100000,
5
- "config": {
6
- "max_time_steps": 200,
7
- "max_lag": 5,
8
- "d_model": 256,
9
- "n_heads": 4,
10
- "n_layers": 6
11
- },
12
- "size_mb": 0.9
13
  },
14
  "machine": {
15
- "hostname": "61c36f0ed717",
16
- "platform": "Linux-6.8.0-87-generic-x86_64-with-glibc2.39",
17
  "python": "3.12.13",
18
  "cpu": "x86_64",
19
- "gpu": "NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5080",
20
- "gpu_count": 4,
21
- "ram_gb": 270.3,
22
- "cpu_count": 128
23
  },
24
  "config": {
25
  "n_datasets": 50,
@@ -33,28 +27,28 @@
33
  "method": "TCPFN",
34
  "n_datasets": 50,
35
  "f1": {
36
- "mean": 0.2986291649451138,
37
- "std": 0.15559474264047013
38
  },
39
  "shd": {
40
- "mean": 37.14,
41
- "std": 5.2383585215217945
42
  },
43
  "auroc": {
44
- "mean": 0.5629769792757515,
45
- "std": 0.07555041936987411
46
  },
47
  "precision": {
48
- "mean": 0.4725594091111507,
49
- "std": 0.19215669588802106
50
  },
51
  "recall": {
52
- "mean": 0.2644720689542138,
53
- "std": 0.1811084353327902
54
  },
55
  "time_s": {
56
- "mean": 32.92481945515901,
57
- "std": 2.7318745112347416
58
  }
59
  },
60
  "Granger": {
@@ -81,8 +75,8 @@
81
  "std": 0.011166183018395231
82
  },
83
  "time_s": {
84
- "mean": 0.49674954622227235,
85
- "std": 0.02478016747338035
86
  }
87
  },
88
  "PCMCI": {
@@ -109,114 +103,114 @@
109
  "std": 0.04877330670079095
110
  },
111
  "time_s": {
112
- "mean": 1.9922658350790152,
113
- "std": 0.3556177872639759
114
  }
115
  }
116
  },
117
  "TENNESSEE EASTMAN": {
118
  "TCPFN": {
119
- "f1": 0.30769230769230765,
120
- "precision": 0.22784810126582278,
121
- "recall": 0.47368421052631576,
122
- "shd": 81,
123
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
124
- "n_pred_edges": 79,
125
  "n_true_edges": 38,
126
- "time_s": 1001.6724438759848,
127
  "best_threshold": 0.6,
128
- "best_f1": 0.3076923076923077,
129
- "best_precision": 0.3,
130
- "best_recall": 0.3157894736842105,
131
  "threshold_sweep": {
132
  "0.01": {
133
  "f1": 0.02825278810408922,
134
  "precision": 0.014328808446455505,
135
  "recall": 1.0,
136
  "shd": 2614,
137
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
138
  "n_pred_edges": 2652,
139
  "n_true_edges": 38
140
  },
141
  "0.02": {
142
- "f1": 0.029699101211410707,
143
- "precision": 0.01507338357794526,
144
  "recall": 1.0,
145
- "shd": 2483,
146
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
147
- "n_pred_edges": 2521,
148
  "n_true_edges": 38
149
  },
150
  "0.05": {
151
- "f1": 0.03655603655603655,
152
- "precision": 0.018618324350808426,
153
  "recall": 1.0,
154
- "shd": 2003,
155
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
156
- "n_pred_edges": 2041,
157
  "n_true_edges": 38
158
  },
159
  "0.1": {
160
- "f1": 0.04878048780487806,
161
- "precision": 0.025,
162
  "recall": 1.0,
163
- "shd": 1482,
164
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
165
- "n_pred_edges": 1520,
166
  "n_true_edges": 38
167
  },
168
  "0.15": {
169
- "f1": 0.0636042402826855,
170
- "precision": 0.03290676416819013,
171
  "recall": 0.9473684210526315,
172
- "shd": 1060,
173
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
174
- "n_pred_edges": 1094,
175
  "n_true_edges": 38
176
  },
177
  "0.2": {
178
- "f1": 0.07901234567901234,
179
- "precision": 0.04145077720207254,
180
  "recall": 0.8421052631578947,
181
- "shd": 746,
182
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
183
- "n_pred_edges": 772,
184
  "n_true_edges": 38
185
  },
186
  "0.3": {
187
- "f1": 0.14500000000000002,
188
- "precision": 0.08011049723756906,
189
  "recall": 0.7631578947368421,
190
- "shd": 342,
191
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
192
- "n_pred_edges": 362,
193
  "n_true_edges": 38
194
  },
195
  "0.4": {
196
- "f1": 0.23364485981308414,
197
- "precision": 0.14204545454545456,
198
  "recall": 0.6578947368421053,
199
- "shd": 164,
200
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
201
- "n_pred_edges": 176,
202
  "n_true_edges": 38
203
  },
204
  "0.5": {
205
- "f1": 0.30769230769230765,
206
- "precision": 0.22784810126582278,
207
- "recall": 0.47368421052631576,
208
- "shd": 81,
209
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
210
- "n_pred_edges": 79,
211
  "n_true_edges": 38
212
  },
213
  "0.6": {
214
- "f1": 0.3076923076923077,
215
- "precision": 0.3,
216
- "recall": 0.3157894736842105,
217
- "shd": 54,
218
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
219
- "n_pred_edges": 40,
220
  "n_true_edges": 38
221
  },
222
  "0.7": {
@@ -224,26 +218,26 @@
224
  "precision": 0.2916666666666667,
225
  "recall": 0.18421052631578946,
226
  "shd": 48,
227
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
228
  "n_pred_edges": 24,
229
  "n_true_edges": 38
230
  },
231
  "0.8": {
232
- "f1": 0.23529411764705882,
233
- "precision": 0.46153846153846156,
234
- "recall": 0.15789473684210525,
235
- "shd": 39,
236
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
237
  "n_pred_edges": 13,
238
  "n_true_edges": 38
239
  },
240
  "0.9": {
241
- "f1": 0.2222222222222222,
242
- "precision": 0.7142857142857143,
243
  "recall": 0.13157894736842105,
244
- "shd": 35,
245
- "auroc": 0.9032839366971369,
246
- "n_pred_edges": 7,
247
  "n_true_edges": 38
248
  }
249
  }
@@ -256,7 +250,7 @@
256
  "auroc": 0.9976291628075544,
257
  "n_pred_edges": 1897,
258
  "n_true_edges": 38,
259
- "time_s": 16.681262108992087,
260
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
261
  "best_f1": 0.12603648424543948,
262
  "best_precision": 0.06725663716814159,
@@ -389,7 +383,7 @@
389
  "auroc": 1.0,
390
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
391
  "n_true_edges": 38,
392
- "time_s": 31.044114629010437,
393
  "best_threshold": 0.15,
394
  "best_f1": 1.0,
395
  "best_precision": 1.0,
@@ -518,25 +512,25 @@
518
  "CAUSEME": {
519
  "VAR-5": {
520
  "TCPFN": {
521
- "f1": 0.5,
522
- "precision": 0.42857142857142855,
523
- "recall": 0.6,
524
- "shd": 6,
525
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
526
- "n_pred_edges": 7,
527
  "n_true_edges": 5,
528
- "time_s": 14.438594213017495,
529
- "best_threshold": 0.5,
530
  "best_f1": 0.5,
531
- "best_precision": 0.42857142857142855,
532
- "best_recall": 0.6,
533
  "threshold_sweep": {
534
  "0.01": {
535
  "f1": 0.4,
536
  "precision": 0.25,
537
  "recall": 1.0,
538
  "shd": 15,
539
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
540
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
541
  "n_true_edges": 5
542
  },
@@ -545,7 +539,7 @@
545
  "precision": 0.25,
546
  "recall": 1.0,
547
  "shd": 15,
548
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
549
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
550
  "n_true_edges": 5
551
  },
@@ -554,7 +548,7 @@
554
  "precision": 0.25,
555
  "recall": 1.0,
556
  "shd": 15,
557
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
558
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
559
  "n_true_edges": 5
560
  },
@@ -563,71 +557,71 @@
563
  "precision": 0.25,
564
  "recall": 1.0,
565
  "shd": 15,
566
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
567
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
568
  "n_true_edges": 5
569
  },
570
  "0.15": {
571
- "f1": 0.4166666666666667,
572
- "precision": 0.2631578947368421,
573
  "recall": 1.0,
574
- "shd": 14,
575
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
576
- "n_pred_edges": 19,
577
  "n_true_edges": 5
578
  },
579
  "0.2": {
580
- "f1": 0.45454545454545453,
581
- "precision": 0.29411764705882354,
582
- "recall": 1.0,
583
- "shd": 12,
584
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
585
- "n_pred_edges": 17,
586
  "n_true_edges": 5
587
  },
588
  "0.3": {
589
- "f1": 0.4444444444444444,
590
- "precision": 0.3076923076923077,
591
- "recall": 0.8,
592
- "shd": 10,
593
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
594
  "n_pred_edges": 13,
595
  "n_true_edges": 5
596
  },
597
  "0.4": {
598
- "f1": 0.4615384615384615,
599
- "precision": 0.375,
600
  "recall": 0.6,
601
- "shd": 7,
602
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
603
- "n_pred_edges": 8,
604
  "n_true_edges": 5
605
  },
606
  "0.5": {
607
- "f1": 0.5,
608
- "precision": 0.42857142857142855,
609
- "recall": 0.6,
610
- "shd": 6,
611
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
612
- "n_pred_edges": 7,
613
  "n_true_edges": 5
614
  },
615
  "0.6": {
616
- "f1": 0.4000000000000001,
617
- "precision": 0.4,
618
  "recall": 0.4,
619
- "shd": 6,
620
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
621
- "n_pred_edges": 5,
622
  "n_true_edges": 5
623
  },
624
  "0.7": {
625
- "f1": 0.5,
626
- "precision": 0.6666666666666666,
627
  "recall": 0.4,
628
- "shd": 4,
629
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
630
- "n_pred_edges": 3,
631
  "n_true_edges": 5
632
  },
633
  "0.8": {
@@ -635,7 +629,7 @@
635
  "precision": 0.6666666666666666,
636
  "recall": 0.4,
637
  "shd": 4,
638
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
639
  "n_pred_edges": 3,
640
  "n_true_edges": 5
641
  },
@@ -644,7 +638,7 @@
644
  "precision": 0.5,
645
  "recall": 0.2,
646
  "shd": 5,
647
- "auroc": 0.7466666666666667,
648
  "n_pred_edges": 2,
649
  "n_true_edges": 5
650
  }
@@ -658,7 +652,7 @@
658
  "auroc": 1.0,
659
  "n_pred_edges": 18,
660
  "n_true_edges": 5,
661
- "time_s": 0.1311069279909134,
662
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
663
  "best_f1": 0.7142857142857143,
664
  "best_precision": 0.5555555555555556,
@@ -791,7 +785,7 @@
791
  "auroc": 1.0,
792
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
793
  "n_true_edges": 5,
794
- "time_s": 0.22336580898263492,
795
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
796
  "best_f1": 1.0,
797
  "best_precision": 1.0,
@@ -919,17 +913,17 @@
919
  },
920
  "VAR-10": {
921
  "TCPFN": {
922
- "f1": 0.39999999999999997,
923
- "precision": 0.5294117647058824,
924
- "recall": 0.32142857142857145,
925
- "shd": 27,
926
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
927
- "n_pred_edges": 17,
928
  "n_true_edges": 28,
929
- "time_s": 30.636591791990213,
930
  "best_threshold": 0.2,
931
- "best_f1": 0.5365853658536585,
932
- "best_precision": 0.4074074074074074,
933
  "best_recall": 0.7857142857142857,
934
  "threshold_sweep": {
935
  "0.01": {
@@ -937,7 +931,7 @@
937
  "precision": 0.3111111111111111,
938
  "recall": 1.0,
939
  "shd": 62,
940
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
941
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
942
  "n_true_edges": 28
943
  },
@@ -946,7 +940,7 @@
946
  "precision": 0.3111111111111111,
947
  "recall": 1.0,
948
  "shd": 62,
949
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
950
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
951
  "n_true_edges": 28
952
  },
@@ -955,17 +949,17 @@
955
  "precision": 0.3111111111111111,
956
  "recall": 1.0,
957
  "shd": 62,
958
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
959
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
960
  "n_true_edges": 28
961
  },
962
  "0.1": {
963
- "f1": 0.47619047619047616,
964
- "precision": 0.3246753246753247,
965
- "recall": 0.8928571428571429,
966
- "shd": 55,
967
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
968
- "n_pred_edges": 77,
969
  "n_true_edges": 28
970
  },
971
  "0.15": {
@@ -973,71 +967,71 @@
973
  "precision": 0.35384615384615387,
974
  "recall": 0.8214285714285714,
975
  "shd": 47,
976
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
977
  "n_pred_edges": 65,
978
  "n_true_edges": 28
979
  },
980
  "0.2": {
981
- "f1": 0.5365853658536585,
982
- "precision": 0.4074074074074074,
983
  "recall": 0.7857142857142857,
984
- "shd": 38,
985
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
986
- "n_pred_edges": 54,
987
  "n_true_edges": 28
988
  },
989
  "0.3": {
990
- "f1": 0.5230769230769231,
991
- "precision": 0.4594594594594595,
992
- "recall": 0.6071428571428571,
993
- "shd": 31,
994
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
995
- "n_pred_edges": 37,
996
  "n_true_edges": 28
997
  },
998
  "0.4": {
999
- "f1": 0.5283018867924528,
1000
- "precision": 0.56,
1001
- "recall": 0.5,
1002
- "shd": 25,
1003
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
1004
- "n_pred_edges": 25,
1005
  "n_true_edges": 28
1006
  },
1007
  "0.5": {
1008
- "f1": 0.39999999999999997,
1009
- "precision": 0.5294117647058824,
1010
- "recall": 0.32142857142857145,
1011
- "shd": 27,
1012
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
1013
- "n_pred_edges": 17,
1014
  "n_true_edges": 28
1015
  },
1016
  "0.6": {
1017
- "f1": 0.21052631578947364,
1018
- "precision": 0.4,
1019
- "recall": 0.14285714285714285,
1020
- "shd": 30,
1021
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
1022
- "n_pred_edges": 10,
1023
  "n_true_edges": 28
1024
  },
1025
  "0.7": {
1026
- "f1": 0.16216216216216214,
1027
  "precision": 0.3333333333333333,
1028
- "recall": 0.10714285714285714,
1029
- "shd": 31,
1030
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
1031
- "n_pred_edges": 9,
1032
  "n_true_edges": 28
1033
  },
1034
  "0.8": {
1035
- "f1": 0.125,
1036
- "precision": 0.5,
1037
  "recall": 0.07142857142857142,
1038
- "shd": 28,
1039
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
1040
- "n_pred_edges": 4,
1041
  "n_true_edges": 28
1042
  },
1043
  "0.9": {
@@ -1045,7 +1039,7 @@
1045
  "precision": 0.5,
1046
  "recall": 0.07142857142857142,
1047
  "shd": 28,
1048
- "auroc": 0.6751152073732719,
1049
  "n_pred_edges": 4,
1050
  "n_true_edges": 28
1051
  }
@@ -1059,7 +1053,7 @@
1059
  "auroc": 0.8582949308755761,
1060
  "n_pred_edges": 80,
1061
  "n_true_edges": 28,
1062
- "time_s": 0.5876666490221396,
1063
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
1064
  "best_f1": 0.5617977528089887,
1065
  "best_precision": 0.4098360655737705,
@@ -1192,7 +1186,7 @@
1192
  "auroc": 0.9441244239631337,
1193
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
1194
  "n_true_edges": 28,
1195
- "time_s": 1.3846248999761883,
1196
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
1197
  "best_f1": 0.9433962264150945,
1198
  "best_precision": 1.0,
@@ -1320,125 +1314,125 @@
1320
  },
1321
  "VAR-20": {
1322
  "TCPFN": {
1323
- "f1": 0.14492753623188406,
1324
- "precision": 0.3448275862068966,
1325
- "recall": 0.09174311926605505,
1326
- "shd": 118,
1327
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1328
- "n_pred_edges": 29,
1329
  "n_true_edges": 109,
1330
- "time_s": 137.46085193098406,
1331
- "best_threshold": 0.05,
1332
- "best_f1": 0.45023696682464454,
1333
- "best_precision": 0.3035143769968051,
1334
- "best_recall": 0.8715596330275229,
1335
  "threshold_sweep": {
1336
  "0.01": {
1337
- "f1": 0.4426229508196722,
1338
- "precision": 0.2849604221635884,
1339
- "recall": 0.9908256880733946,
1340
- "shd": 272,
1341
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1342
- "n_pred_edges": 379,
1343
  "n_true_edges": 109
1344
  },
1345
  "0.02": {
1346
- "f1": 0.45000000000000007,
1347
- "precision": 0.29110512129380056,
1348
- "recall": 0.9908256880733946,
1349
- "shd": 264,
1350
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1351
  "n_pred_edges": 371,
1352
  "n_true_edges": 109
1353
  },
1354
  "0.05": {
1355
- "f1": 0.45023696682464454,
1356
- "precision": 0.3035143769968051,
1357
- "recall": 0.8715596330275229,
1358
- "shd": 232,
1359
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1360
- "n_pred_edges": 313,
1361
  "n_true_edges": 109
1362
  },
1363
  "0.1": {
1364
- "f1": 0.3964497041420118,
1365
- "precision": 0.2925764192139738,
1366
- "recall": 0.6146788990825688,
1367
- "shd": 204,
1368
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1369
- "n_pred_edges": 229,
1370
  "n_true_edges": 109
1371
  },
1372
  "0.15": {
1373
- "f1": 0.3680555555555556,
1374
- "precision": 0.29608938547486036,
1375
- "recall": 0.48623853211009177,
1376
- "shd": 182,
1377
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1378
- "n_pred_edges": 179,
1379
  "n_true_edges": 109
1380
  },
1381
  "0.2": {
1382
- "f1": 0.33599999999999997,
1383
- "precision": 0.2978723404255319,
1384
- "recall": 0.3853211009174312,
1385
- "shd": 166,
1386
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1387
- "n_pred_edges": 141,
1388
  "n_true_edges": 109
1389
  },
1390
  "0.3": {
1391
- "f1": 0.2828282828282829,
1392
- "precision": 0.3146067415730337,
1393
- "recall": 0.25688073394495414,
1394
- "shd": 142,
1395
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1396
- "n_pred_edges": 89,
1397
  "n_true_edges": 109
1398
  },
1399
  "0.4": {
1400
- "f1": 0.18292682926829268,
1401
- "precision": 0.2727272727272727,
1402
- "recall": 0.13761467889908258,
1403
- "shd": 134,
1404
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1405
- "n_pred_edges": 55,
1406
  "n_true_edges": 109
1407
  },
1408
  "0.5": {
1409
- "f1": 0.14492753623188406,
1410
- "precision": 0.3448275862068966,
1411
- "recall": 0.09174311926605505,
1412
- "shd": 118,
1413
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1414
- "n_pred_edges": 29,
1415
  "n_true_edges": 109
1416
  },
1417
  "0.6": {
1418
- "f1": 0.06666666666666667,
1419
- "precision": 0.36363636363636365,
1420
  "recall": 0.03669724770642202,
1421
- "shd": 112,
1422
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1423
- "n_pred_edges": 11,
1424
  "n_true_edges": 109
1425
  },
1426
  "0.7": {
1427
- "f1": 0.017543859649122806,
1428
- "precision": 0.2,
1429
- "recall": 0.009174311926605505,
1430
- "shd": 112,
1431
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1432
- "n_pred_edges": 5,
1433
  "n_true_edges": 109
1434
  },
1435
  "0.8": {
1436
- "f1": 0.0,
1437
- "precision": 0.0,
1438
- "recall": 0.0,
1439
- "shd": 110,
1440
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1441
- "n_pred_edges": 1,
1442
  "n_true_edges": 109
1443
  },
1444
  "0.9": {
@@ -1446,7 +1440,7 @@
1446
  "precision": 0.0,
1447
  "recall": 0.0,
1448
  "shd": 110,
1449
- "auroc": 0.5240529469514879,
1450
  "n_pred_edges": 1,
1451
  "n_true_edges": 109
1452
  }
@@ -1460,7 +1454,7 @@
1460
  "auroc": 0.5092250922509225,
1461
  "n_pred_edges": 380,
1462
  "n_true_edges": 109,
1463
- "time_s": 3.392255473008845,
1464
  "best_threshold": 0.01,
1465
  "best_f1": 0.4458077709611452,
1466
  "best_precision": 0.2868421052631579,
@@ -1593,7 +1587,7 @@
1593
  "auroc": 0.9575137953214394,
1594
  "n_pred_edges": 2,
1595
  "n_true_edges": 109,
1596
- "time_s": 18.785499755002093,
1597
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
1598
  "best_f1": 0.8761904761904762,
1599
  "best_precision": 0.9108910891089109,
@@ -1721,15 +1715,15 @@
1721
  },
1722
  "NVAR-5": {
1723
  "TCPFN": {
1724
- "f1": 0.8,
1725
- "precision": 1.0,
1726
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1727
- "shd": 1,
1728
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1729
- "n_pred_edges": 2,
1730
  "n_true_edges": 3,
1731
- "time_s": 13.954447253985563,
1732
- "best_threshold": 0.5,
1733
  "best_f1": 0.8,
1734
  "best_precision": 1.0,
1735
  "best_recall": 0.6666666666666666,
@@ -1739,7 +1733,7 @@
1739
  "precision": 0.15,
1740
  "recall": 1.0,
1741
  "shd": 17,
1742
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1743
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
1744
  "n_true_edges": 3
1745
  },
@@ -1748,7 +1742,7 @@
1748
  "precision": 0.15,
1749
  "recall": 1.0,
1750
  "shd": 17,
1751
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1752
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
1753
  "n_true_edges": 3
1754
  },
@@ -1757,62 +1751,62 @@
1757
  "precision": 0.15,
1758
  "recall": 1.0,
1759
  "shd": 17,
1760
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1761
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
1762
  "n_true_edges": 3
1763
  },
1764
  "0.1": {
1765
- "f1": 0.1904761904761905,
1766
- "precision": 0.1111111111111111,
1767
- "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1768
- "shd": 17,
1769
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1770
- "n_pred_edges": 18,
1771
  "n_true_edges": 3
1772
  },
1773
  "0.15": {
1774
- "f1": 0.25,
1775
- "precision": 0.15384615384615385,
1776
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1777
- "shd": 12,
1778
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1779
- "n_pred_edges": 13,
1780
  "n_true_edges": 3
1781
  },
1782
  "0.2": {
1783
- "f1": 0.30769230769230765,
1784
- "precision": 0.2,
1785
- "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1786
- "shd": 9,
1787
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1788
- "n_pred_edges": 10,
1789
- "n_true_edges": 3
1790
- },
1791
- "0.3": {
1792
  "f1": 0.36363636363636365,
1793
  "precision": 0.25,
1794
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1795
  "shd": 7,
1796
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1797
  "n_pred_edges": 8,
1798
  "n_true_edges": 3
1799
  },
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1800
  "0.4": {
1801
- "f1": 0.5714285714285715,
1802
- "precision": 0.5,
1803
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1804
- "shd": 3,
1805
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1806
- "n_pred_edges": 4,
1807
  "n_true_edges": 3
1808
  },
1809
  "0.5": {
1810
- "f1": 0.8,
1811
- "precision": 1.0,
1812
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1813
- "shd": 1,
1814
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1815
- "n_pred_edges": 2,
1816
  "n_true_edges": 3
1817
  },
1818
  "0.6": {
@@ -1820,7 +1814,7 @@
1820
  "precision": 1.0,
1821
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1822
  "shd": 1,
1823
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1824
  "n_pred_edges": 2,
1825
  "n_true_edges": 3
1826
  },
@@ -1829,7 +1823,7 @@
1829
  "precision": 1.0,
1830
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1831
  "shd": 1,
1832
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1833
  "n_pred_edges": 2,
1834
  "n_true_edges": 3
1835
  },
@@ -1838,7 +1832,7 @@
1838
  "precision": 1.0,
1839
  "recall": 0.3333333333333333,
1840
  "shd": 2,
1841
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1842
  "n_pred_edges": 1,
1843
  "n_true_edges": 3
1844
  },
@@ -1847,7 +1841,7 @@
1847
  "precision": 1.0,
1848
  "recall": 0.3333333333333333,
1849
  "shd": 2,
1850
- "auroc": 0.6666666666666666,
1851
  "n_pred_edges": 1,
1852
  "n_true_edges": 3
1853
  }
@@ -1861,7 +1855,7 @@
1861
  "auroc": 0.9803921568627451,
1862
  "n_pred_edges": 14,
1863
  "n_true_edges": 3,
1864
- "time_s": 0.1324127630214207,
1865
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
1866
  "best_f1": 0.6666666666666666,
1867
  "best_precision": 0.5,
@@ -1994,7 +1988,7 @@
1994
  "auroc": 1.0,
1995
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
1996
  "n_true_edges": 3,
1997
- "time_s": 0.1916731619858183,
1998
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
1999
  "best_f1": 0.8,
2000
  "best_precision": 1.0,
@@ -2122,25 +2116,25 @@
2122
  },
2123
  "NVAR-10": {
2124
  "TCPFN": {
2125
- "f1": 0.39999999999999997,
2126
- "precision": 0.47058823529411764,
2127
- "recall": 0.34782608695652173,
2128
- "shd": 24,
2129
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2130
- "n_pred_edges": 17,
2131
  "n_true_edges": 23,
2132
- "time_s": 32.40212181198876,
2133
- "best_threshold": 0.4,
2134
- "best_f1": 0.41666666666666663,
2135
- "best_precision": 0.4,
2136
- "best_recall": 0.43478260869565216,
2137
  "threshold_sweep": {
2138
  "0.01": {
2139
  "f1": 0.4070796460176991,
2140
  "precision": 0.25555555555555554,
2141
  "recall": 1.0,
2142
  "shd": 67,
2143
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2144
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2145
  "n_true_edges": 23
2146
  },
@@ -2149,7 +2143,7 @@
2149
  "precision": 0.25555555555555554,
2150
  "recall": 1.0,
2151
  "shd": 67,
2152
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2153
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2154
  "n_true_edges": 23
2155
  },
@@ -2158,98 +2152,98 @@
2158
  "precision": 0.25555555555555554,
2159
  "recall": 1.0,
2160
  "shd": 67,
2161
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2162
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2163
  "n_true_edges": 23
2164
  },
2165
  "0.1": {
2166
- "f1": 0.41509433962264153,
2167
- "precision": 0.26506024096385544,
2168
- "recall": 0.9565217391304348,
2169
- "shd": 62,
2170
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2171
- "n_pred_edges": 83,
2172
  "n_true_edges": 23
2173
  },
2174
  "0.15": {
2175
- "f1": 0.39080459770114945,
2176
- "precision": 0.265625,
2177
- "recall": 0.7391304347826086,
2178
- "shd": 53,
2179
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2180
- "n_pred_edges": 64,
2181
  "n_true_edges": 23
2182
  },
2183
  "0.2": {
2184
- "f1": 0.3561643835616438,
2185
- "precision": 0.26,
2186
- "recall": 0.5652173913043478,
2187
- "shd": 47,
2188
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2189
- "n_pred_edges": 50,
2190
  "n_true_edges": 23
2191
  },
2192
  "0.3": {
2193
- "f1": 0.3793103448275862,
2194
- "precision": 0.3142857142857143,
2195
- "recall": 0.4782608695652174,
2196
- "shd": 36,
2197
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2198
- "n_pred_edges": 35,
2199
  "n_true_edges": 23
2200
  },
2201
  "0.4": {
2202
- "f1": 0.41666666666666663,
2203
- "precision": 0.4,
2204
- "recall": 0.43478260869565216,
2205
- "shd": 28,
2206
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2207
- "n_pred_edges": 25,
2208
  "n_true_edges": 23
2209
  },
2210
  "0.5": {
2211
- "f1": 0.39999999999999997,
2212
- "precision": 0.47058823529411764,
2213
- "recall": 0.34782608695652173,
2214
- "shd": 24,
2215
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2216
- "n_pred_edges": 17,
2217
  "n_true_edges": 23
2218
  },
2219
  "0.6": {
2220
- "f1": 0.2857142857142857,
2221
- "precision": 0.4166666666666667,
2222
- "recall": 0.21739130434782608,
2223
  "shd": 25,
2224
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2225
- "n_pred_edges": 12,
2226
  "n_true_edges": 23
2227
  },
2228
  "0.7": {
2229
- "f1": 0.25806451612903225,
2230
- "precision": 0.5,
2231
  "recall": 0.17391304347826086,
2232
- "shd": 23,
2233
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2234
- "n_pred_edges": 8,
2235
  "n_true_edges": 23
2236
  },
2237
  "0.8": {
2238
- "f1": 0.22222222222222218,
2239
- "precision": 0.75,
2240
- "recall": 0.13043478260869565,
2241
- "shd": 21,
2242
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2243
- "n_pred_edges": 4,
2244
  "n_true_edges": 23
2245
  },
2246
  "0.9": {
2247
- "f1": 0.16,
2248
  "precision": 1.0,
2249
- "recall": 0.08695652173913043,
2250
- "shd": 21,
2251
- "auroc": 0.5807916937053861,
2252
- "n_pred_edges": 2,
2253
  "n_true_edges": 23
2254
  }
2255
  }
@@ -2262,7 +2256,7 @@
2262
  "auroc": 0.9188838416612588,
2263
  "n_pred_edges": 83,
2264
  "n_true_edges": 23,
2265
- "time_s": 0.6003497519996017,
2266
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
2267
  "best_f1": 0.5316455696202531,
2268
  "best_precision": 0.375,
@@ -2395,7 +2389,7 @@
2395
  "auroc": 0.9682024659312136,
2396
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
2397
  "n_true_edges": 23,
2398
- "time_s": 1.4121810299984645,
2399
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
2400
  "best_f1": 0.9302325581395349,
2401
  "best_precision": 1.0,
@@ -2527,84 +2521,84 @@
2527
  "precision": 0.4827586206896552,
2528
  "recall": 0.12389380530973451,
2529
  "shd": 114,
2530
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2531
  "n_pred_edges": 29,
2532
  "n_true_edges": 113,
2533
- "time_s": 139.27770364499884,
2534
- "best_threshold": 0.02,
2535
- "best_f1": 0.4609053497942387,
2536
- "best_precision": 0.3002680965147453,
2537
- "best_recall": 0.9911504424778761,
2538
  "threshold_sweep": {
2539
  "0.01": {
2540
  "f1": 0.45841784989858014,
2541
  "precision": 0.29736842105263156,
2542
  "recall": 1.0,
2543
  "shd": 267,
2544
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2545
  "n_pred_edges": 380,
2546
  "n_true_edges": 113
2547
  },
2548
  "0.02": {
2549
- "f1": 0.4609053497942387,
2550
- "precision": 0.3002680965147453,
2551
- "recall": 0.9911504424778761,
2552
- "shd": 262,
2553
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2554
- "n_pred_edges": 373,
2555
  "n_true_edges": 113
2556
  },
2557
  "0.05": {
2558
- "f1": 0.45098039215686275,
2559
- "precision": 0.31186440677966104,
2560
- "recall": 0.8141592920353983,
2561
- "shd": 224,
2562
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2563
- "n_pred_edges": 295,
2564
  "n_true_edges": 113
2565
  },
2566
  "0.1": {
2567
- "f1": 0.43613707165109034,
2568
- "precision": 0.33653846153846156,
2569
- "recall": 0.6194690265486725,
2570
- "shd": 181,
2571
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2572
- "n_pred_edges": 208,
2573
  "n_true_edges": 113
2574
  },
2575
  "0.15": {
2576
- "f1": 0.42519685039370086,
2577
- "precision": 0.3829787234042553,
2578
- "recall": 0.4778761061946903,
2579
- "shd": 146,
2580
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2581
- "n_pred_edges": 141,
2582
  "n_true_edges": 113
2583
  },
2584
  "0.2": {
2585
- "f1": 0.34449760765550236,
2586
- "precision": 0.375,
2587
- "recall": 0.3185840707964602,
2588
- "shd": 137,
2589
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2590
- "n_pred_edges": 96,
2591
  "n_true_edges": 113
2592
  },
2593
  "0.3": {
2594
- "f1": 0.26436781609195403,
2595
- "precision": 0.3770491803278688,
2596
  "recall": 0.20353982300884957,
2597
- "shd": 128,
2598
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2599
- "n_pred_edges": 61,
2600
  "n_true_edges": 113
2601
  },
2602
  "0.4": {
2603
- "f1": 0.23376623376623376,
2604
- "precision": 0.43902439024390244,
2605
- "recall": 0.1592920353982301,
2606
- "shd": 118,
2607
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2608
  "n_pred_edges": 41,
2609
  "n_true_edges": 113
2610
  },
@@ -2613,44 +2607,44 @@
2613
  "precision": 0.4827586206896552,
2614
  "recall": 0.12389380530973451,
2615
  "shd": 114,
2616
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2617
  "n_pred_edges": 29,
2618
  "n_true_edges": 113
2619
  },
2620
  "0.6": {
2621
- "f1": 0.16176470588235292,
2622
- "precision": 0.4782608695652174,
2623
- "recall": 0.09734513274336283,
2624
- "shd": 114,
2625
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2626
  "n_pred_edges": 23,
2627
  "n_true_edges": 113
2628
  },
2629
  "0.7": {
2630
- "f1": 0.13953488372093023,
2631
- "precision": 0.5625,
2632
- "recall": 0.07964601769911504,
2633
- "shd": 111,
2634
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2635
  "n_pred_edges": 16,
2636
  "n_true_edges": 113
2637
  },
2638
  "0.8": {
2639
- "f1": 0.09917355371900827,
2640
- "precision": 0.75,
2641
- "recall": 0.05309734513274336,
2642
- "shd": 109,
2643
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2644
- "n_pred_edges": 8,
2645
  "n_true_edges": 113
2646
  },
2647
  "0.9": {
2648
- "f1": 0.05128205128205128,
2649
- "precision": 0.75,
2650
- "recall": 0.02654867256637168,
2651
- "shd": 111,
2652
- "auroc": 0.586622916045209,
2653
- "n_pred_edges": 4,
2654
  "n_true_edges": 113
2655
  }
2656
  }
@@ -2663,7 +2657,7 @@
2663
  "auroc": 0.7275198037850916,
2664
  "n_pred_edges": 379,
2665
  "n_true_edges": 113,
2666
- "time_s": 3.3989179150084965,
2667
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
2668
  "best_f1": 0.47379454926624737,
2669
  "best_precision": 0.31043956043956045,
@@ -2796,7 +2790,7 @@
2796
  "auroc": 0.9580060322826556,
2797
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
2798
  "n_true_edges": 113,
2799
- "time_s": 15.669835932989372,
2800
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
2801
  "best_f1": 0.909952606635071,
2802
  "best_precision": 0.9795918367346939,
@@ -2924,14 +2918,14 @@
2924
  },
2925
  "Lorenz96-10": {
2926
  "TCPFN": {
2927
- "f1": 0.31746031746031744,
2928
- "precision": 0.38461538461538464,
2929
  "recall": 0.2702702702702703,
2930
- "shd": 43,
2931
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
2932
- "n_pred_edges": 26,
2933
  "n_true_edges": 37,
2934
- "time_s": 34.32434367900714,
2935
  "best_threshold": 0.01,
2936
  "best_f1": 0.5826771653543308,
2937
  "best_precision": 0.4111111111111111,
@@ -2942,7 +2936,7 @@
2942
  "precision": 0.4111111111111111,
2943
  "recall": 1.0,
2944
  "shd": 53,
2945
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
2946
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2947
  "n_true_edges": 37
2948
  },
@@ -2951,53 +2945,53 @@
2951
  "precision": 0.4111111111111111,
2952
  "recall": 1.0,
2953
  "shd": 53,
2954
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
2955
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2956
  "n_true_edges": 37
2957
  },
2958
  "0.05": {
2959
- "f1": 0.559322033898305,
2960
- "precision": 0.4074074074074074,
2961
  "recall": 0.8918918918918919,
2962
- "shd": 52,
2963
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
2964
- "n_pred_edges": 81,
2965
  "n_true_edges": 37
2966
  },
2967
  "0.1": {
2968
- "f1": 0.5185185185185185,
2969
- "precision": 0.39436619718309857,
2970
- "recall": 0.7567567567567568,
2971
- "shd": 52,
2972
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
2973
- "n_pred_edges": 71,
2974
  "n_true_edges": 37
2975
  },
2976
  "0.15": {
2977
- "f1": 0.5098039215686274,
2978
- "precision": 0.4,
2979
  "recall": 0.7027027027027027,
2980
- "shd": 50,
2981
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
2982
- "n_pred_edges": 65,
2983
  "n_true_edges": 37
2984
  },
2985
  "0.2": {
2986
- "f1": 0.49462365591397844,
2987
- "precision": 0.4107142857142857,
2988
  "recall": 0.6216216216216216,
2989
- "shd": 47,
2990
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
2991
- "n_pred_edges": 56,
2992
  "n_true_edges": 37
2993
  },
2994
  "0.3": {
2995
- "f1": 0.4761904761904763,
2996
- "precision": 0.425531914893617,
2997
- "recall": 0.5405405405405406,
2998
- "shd": 44,
2999
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
3000
- "n_pred_edges": 47,
3001
  "n_true_edges": 37
3002
  },
3003
  "0.4": {
@@ -3005,44 +2999,44 @@
3005
  "precision": 0.3888888888888889,
3006
  "recall": 0.3783783783783784,
3007
  "shd": 45,
3008
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
3009
  "n_pred_edges": 36,
3010
  "n_true_edges": 37
3011
  },
3012
  "0.5": {
3013
- "f1": 0.31746031746031744,
3014
- "precision": 0.38461538461538464,
3015
  "recall": 0.2702702702702703,
3016
- "shd": 43,
3017
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
3018
- "n_pred_edges": 26,
3019
  "n_true_edges": 37
3020
  },
3021
  "0.6": {
3022
- "f1": 0.2181818181818182,
3023
- "precision": 0.3333333333333333,
3024
- "recall": 0.16216216216216217,
3025
- "shd": 43,
3026
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
3027
- "n_pred_edges": 18,
3028
  "n_true_edges": 37
3029
  },
3030
  "0.7": {
3031
- "f1": 0.09090909090909091,
3032
- "precision": 0.2857142857142857,
3033
- "recall": 0.05405405405405406,
3034
- "shd": 40,
3035
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
3036
- "n_pred_edges": 7,
3037
  "n_true_edges": 37
3038
  },
3039
  "0.8": {
3040
  "f1": 0.0,
3041
  "precision": 0.0,
3042
  "recall": 0.0,
3043
- "shd": 40,
3044
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
3045
- "n_pred_edges": 3,
3046
  "n_true_edges": 37
3047
  },
3048
  "0.9": {
@@ -3050,7 +3044,7 @@
3050
  "precision": 0.0,
3051
  "recall": 0.0,
3052
  "shd": 38,
3053
- "auroc": 0.4722080571137175,
3054
  "n_pred_edges": 1,
3055
  "n_true_edges": 37
3056
  }
@@ -3064,7 +3058,7 @@
3064
  "auroc": 0.5800611932687405,
3065
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
3066
  "n_true_edges": 37,
3067
- "time_s": 0.8085818090185057,
3068
  "best_threshold": 0.8,
3069
  "best_f1": 0.5873015873015873,
3070
  "best_precision": 0.4157303370786517,
@@ -3197,7 +3191,7 @@
3197
  "auroc": 0.8500764915859255,
3198
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
3199
  "n_true_edges": 37,
3200
- "time_s": 4.598472089011921,
3201
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
3202
  "best_f1": 0.7123287671232876,
3203
  "best_precision": 0.7222222222222222,
@@ -3325,14 +3319,14 @@
3325
  },
3326
  "Lorenz96-20": {
3327
  "TCPFN": {
3328
- "f1": 0.2222222222222222,
3329
- "precision": 0.2833333333333333,
3330
- "recall": 0.1827956989247312,
3331
- "shd": 119,
3332
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3333
- "n_pred_edges": 60,
3334
  "n_true_edges": 93,
3335
- "time_s": 143.05683296200004,
3336
  "best_threshold": 0.01,
3337
  "best_f1": 0.39323467230443976,
3338
  "best_precision": 0.24473684210526317,
@@ -3343,7 +3337,7 @@
3343
  "precision": 0.24473684210526317,
3344
  "recall": 1.0,
3345
  "shd": 287,
3346
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3347
  "n_pred_edges": 380,
3348
  "n_true_edges": 93
3349
  },
@@ -3352,107 +3346,107 @@
3352
  "precision": 0.24473684210526317,
3353
  "recall": 1.0,
3354
  "shd": 287,
3355
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3356
  "n_pred_edges": 380,
3357
  "n_true_edges": 93
3358
  },
3359
  "0.05": {
3360
- "f1": 0.3847874720357942,
3361
- "precision": 0.24293785310734464,
3362
- "recall": 0.9247311827956989,
3363
- "shd": 275,
3364
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3365
- "n_pred_edges": 354,
3366
  "n_true_edges": 93
3367
  },
3368
  "0.1": {
3369
- "f1": 0.3609022556390977,
3370
- "precision": 0.23529411764705882,
3371
- "recall": 0.7741935483870968,
3372
- "shd": 255,
3373
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3374
- "n_pred_edges": 306,
3375
  "n_true_edges": 93
3376
  },
3377
  "0.15": {
3378
- "f1": 0.3788300835654596,
3379
- "precision": 0.2556390977443609,
3380
- "recall": 0.7311827956989247,
3381
  "shd": 223,
3382
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3383
- "n_pred_edges": 266,
3384
  "n_true_edges": 93
3385
  },
3386
  "0.2": {
3387
- "f1": 0.3788819875776398,
3388
- "precision": 0.2663755458515284,
3389
- "recall": 0.6559139784946236,
3390
- "shd": 200,
3391
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3392
- "n_pred_edges": 229,
3393
  "n_true_edges": 93
3394
  },
3395
  "0.3": {
3396
- "f1": 0.328125,
3397
- "precision": 0.25766871165644173,
3398
- "recall": 0.45161290322580644,
3399
- "shd": 172,
3400
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3401
  "n_pred_edges": 163,
3402
  "n_true_edges": 93
3403
  },
3404
  "0.4": {
3405
- "f1": 0.2755102040816326,
3406
- "precision": 0.2621359223300971,
3407
- "recall": 0.2903225806451613,
3408
- "shd": 142,
3409
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3410
- "n_pred_edges": 103,
3411
  "n_true_edges": 93
3412
  },
3413
  "0.5": {
3414
- "f1": 0.2222222222222222,
3415
- "precision": 0.2833333333333333,
3416
- "recall": 0.1827956989247312,
3417
- "shd": 119,
3418
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3419
- "n_pred_edges": 60,
3420
  "n_true_edges": 93
3421
  },
3422
  "0.6": {
3423
- "f1": 0.16923076923076927,
3424
- "precision": 0.2972972972972973,
3425
  "recall": 0.11827956989247312,
3426
- "shd": 108,
3427
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3428
- "n_pred_edges": 37,
3429
  "n_true_edges": 93
3430
  },
3431
  "0.7": {
3432
- "f1": 0.13913043478260867,
3433
- "precision": 0.36363636363636365,
3434
- "recall": 0.08602150537634409,
3435
- "shd": 99,
3436
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3437
- "n_pred_edges": 22,
3438
  "n_true_edges": 93
3439
  },
3440
  "0.8": {
3441
- "f1": 0.07920792079207922,
3442
- "precision": 0.5,
3443
- "recall": 0.043010752688172046,
3444
- "shd": 93,
3445
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3446
  "n_pred_edges": 8,
3447
  "n_true_edges": 93
3448
  },
3449
  "0.9": {
3450
- "f1": 0.04166666666666667,
3451
- "precision": 0.6666666666666666,
3452
  "recall": 0.021505376344086023,
3453
- "shd": 92,
3454
- "auroc": 0.5205499981267093,
3455
- "n_pred_edges": 3,
3456
  "n_true_edges": 93
3457
  }
3458
  }
@@ -3465,7 +3459,7 @@
3465
  "auroc": 0.8101045296167249,
3466
  "n_pred_edges": 349,
3467
  "n_true_edges": 93,
3468
- "time_s": 3.382360035000602,
3469
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
3470
  "best_f1": 0.48022598870056493,
3471
  "best_precision": 0.32567049808429116,
@@ -3598,7 +3592,7 @@
3598
  "auroc": 0.7790266381926492,
3599
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
3600
  "n_true_edges": 93,
3601
- "time_s": 12.206421765004052,
3602
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
3603
  "best_f1": 0.6193548387096774,
3604
  "best_precision": 0.7741935483870968,
@@ -3727,25 +3721,25 @@
3727
  },
3728
  "SACHS": {
3729
  "TCPFN": {
3730
- "f1": 0.3421052631578947,
3731
- "precision": 0.22033898305084745,
3732
- "recall": 0.7647058823529411,
3733
- "shd": 50,
3734
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3735
- "n_pred_edges": 59,
3736
  "n_true_edges": 17,
3737
- "time_s": 42.790291861019796,
3738
- "best_threshold": 0.7,
3739
- "best_f1": 0.41860465116279066,
3740
- "best_precision": 0.34615384615384615,
3741
- "best_recall": 0.5294117647058824,
3742
  "threshold_sweep": {
3743
  "0.01": {
3744
  "f1": 0.26771653543307083,
3745
  "precision": 0.15454545454545454,
3746
  "recall": 1.0,
3747
  "shd": 93,
3748
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3749
  "n_pred_edges": 110,
3750
  "n_true_edges": 17
3751
  },
@@ -3754,7 +3748,7 @@
3754
  "precision": 0.15454545454545454,
3755
  "recall": 1.0,
3756
  "shd": 93,
3757
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3758
  "n_pred_edges": 110,
3759
  "n_true_edges": 17
3760
  },
@@ -3763,98 +3757,98 @@
3763
  "precision": 0.15454545454545454,
3764
  "recall": 1.0,
3765
  "shd": 93,
3766
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3767
  "n_pred_edges": 110,
3768
  "n_true_edges": 17
3769
  },
3770
  "0.1": {
3771
- "f1": 0.2764227642276422,
3772
- "precision": 0.16037735849056603,
3773
  "recall": 1.0,
3774
- "shd": 89,
3775
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3776
- "n_pred_edges": 106,
3777
  "n_true_edges": 17
3778
  },
3779
  "0.15": {
3780
- "f1": 0.288135593220339,
3781
- "precision": 0.16831683168316833,
3782
  "recall": 1.0,
3783
- "shd": 84,
3784
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3785
- "n_pred_edges": 101,
3786
  "n_true_edges": 17
3787
  },
3788
  "0.2": {
3789
- "f1": 0.30357142857142855,
3790
- "precision": 0.17894736842105263,
3791
  "recall": 1.0,
3792
- "shd": 78,
3793
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3794
- "n_pred_edges": 95,
3795
  "n_true_edges": 17
3796
  },
3797
  "0.3": {
3798
- "f1": 0.30927835051546393,
3799
- "precision": 0.1875,
3800
- "recall": 0.8823529411764706,
3801
  "shd": 67,
3802
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3803
- "n_pred_edges": 80,
3804
  "n_true_edges": 17
3805
  },
3806
  "0.4": {
3807
- "f1": 0.3333333333333333,
3808
- "precision": 0.2054794520547945,
3809
  "recall": 0.8823529411764706,
3810
- "shd": 60,
3811
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3812
- "n_pred_edges": 73,
3813
  "n_true_edges": 17
3814
  },
3815
  "0.5": {
3816
- "f1": 0.3421052631578947,
3817
- "precision": 0.22033898305084745,
3818
- "recall": 0.7647058823529411,
3819
- "shd": 50,
3820
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3821
- "n_pred_edges": 59,
3822
  "n_true_edges": 17
3823
  },
3824
  "0.6": {
3825
- "f1": 0.3793103448275862,
3826
- "precision": 0.2682926829268293,
3827
- "recall": 0.6470588235294118,
3828
- "shd": 36,
3829
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3830
- "n_pred_edges": 41,
3831
  "n_true_edges": 17
3832
  },
3833
  "0.7": {
3834
- "f1": 0.41860465116279066,
3835
- "precision": 0.34615384615384615,
3836
- "recall": 0.5294117647058824,
3837
- "shd": 25,
3838
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3839
- "n_pred_edges": 26,
3840
  "n_true_edges": 17
3841
  },
3842
  "0.8": {
3843
- "f1": 0.3888888888888889,
3844
- "precision": 0.3684210526315789,
3845
- "recall": 0.4117647058823529,
3846
- "shd": 22,
3847
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3848
- "n_pred_edges": 19,
3849
  "n_true_edges": 17
3850
  },
3851
  "0.9": {
3852
- "f1": 0.19047619047619047,
3853
- "precision": 0.5,
3854
- "recall": 0.11764705882352941,
3855
- "shd": 17,
3856
- "auroc": 0.7166350411132194,
3857
- "n_pred_edges": 4,
3858
  "n_true_edges": 17
3859
  }
3860
  }
@@ -3867,7 +3861,7 @@
3867
  "auroc": 0.6211258697027198,
3868
  "n_pred_edges": 86,
3869
  "n_true_edges": 17,
3870
- "time_s": 0.682047195994528,
3871
  "best_threshold": 0.8,
3872
  "best_f1": 0.31884057971014496,
3873
  "best_precision": 0.21153846153846154,
@@ -4000,7 +3994,7 @@
4000
  "auroc": 0.6008855154965211,
4001
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
4002
  "n_true_edges": 17,
4003
- "time_s": 0.912862290017074,
4004
  "best_threshold": 0.01,
4005
  "best_f1": 0.26771653543307083,
4006
  "best_precision": 0.15454545454545454,
@@ -4125,5 +4119,807 @@
4125
  }
4126
  }
4127
  }
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
4128
  }
4129
  }
 
1
  {
2
  "model": {
3
+ "path": "/root/anofy/dist/tcpfn/outputs/temporal/final.pt",
4
+ "step": 200000,
5
+ "config": {},
6
+ "size_mb": 259.0
 
 
 
 
 
 
7
  },
8
  "machine": {
9
+ "hostname": "656d0957efe5",
10
+ "platform": "Linux-5.15.0-173-generic-x86_64-with-glibc2.39",
11
  "python": "3.12.13",
12
  "cpu": "x86_64",
13
+ "gpu": "NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090",
14
+ "gpu_count": 1,
15
+ "ram_gb": 540.8,
16
+ "cpu_count": 192
17
  },
18
  "config": {
19
  "n_datasets": 50,
 
27
  "method": "TCPFN",
28
  "n_datasets": 50,
29
  "f1": {
30
+ "mean": 0.2989125934987405,
31
+ "std": 0.1435712782917347
32
  },
33
  "shd": {
34
+ "mean": 37.7,
35
+ "std": 5.142956348249516
36
  },
37
  "auroc": {
38
+ "mean": 0.5605962305319522,
39
+ "std": 0.07788191474750997
40
  },
41
  "precision": {
42
+ "mean": 0.45871396313321744,
43
+ "std": 0.16906860369146257
44
  },
45
  "recall": {
46
+ "mean": 0.26641676360011685,
47
+ "std": 0.1755913489230663
48
  },
49
  "time_s": {
50
+ "mean": 31.185446181157605,
51
+ "std": 2.41096888176201
52
  }
53
  },
54
  "Granger": {
 
75
  "std": 0.011166183018395231
76
  },
77
  "time_s": {
78
+ "mean": 0.34120664981659504,
79
+ "std": 0.01605172193878427
80
  }
81
  },
82
  "PCMCI": {
 
103
  "std": 0.04877330670079095
104
  },
105
  "time_s": {
106
+ "mean": 1.370767328743823,
107
+ "std": 0.21038910360625637
108
  }
109
  }
110
  },
111
  "TENNESSEE EASTMAN": {
112
  "TCPFN": {
113
+ "f1": 0.3140495867768595,
114
+ "precision": 0.2289156626506024,
115
+ "recall": 0.5,
116
+ "shd": 83,
117
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
118
+ "n_pred_edges": 83,
119
  "n_true_edges": 38,
120
+ "time_s": 962.837620805949,
121
  "best_threshold": 0.6,
122
+ "best_f1": 0.32098765432098764,
123
+ "best_precision": 0.3023255813953488,
124
+ "best_recall": 0.34210526315789475,
125
  "threshold_sweep": {
126
  "0.01": {
127
  "f1": 0.02825278810408922,
128
  "precision": 0.014328808446455505,
129
  "recall": 1.0,
130
  "shd": 2614,
131
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
132
  "n_pred_edges": 2652,
133
  "n_true_edges": 38
134
  },
135
  "0.02": {
136
+ "f1": 0.02998027613412229,
137
+ "precision": 0.015218261914297157,
138
  "recall": 1.0,
139
+ "shd": 2459,
140
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
141
+ "n_pred_edges": 2497,
142
  "n_true_edges": 38
143
  },
144
  "0.05": {
145
+ "f1": 0.03669724770642201,
146
+ "precision": 0.018691588785046728,
147
  "recall": 1.0,
148
+ "shd": 1995,
149
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
150
+ "n_pred_edges": 2033,
151
  "n_true_edges": 38
152
  },
153
  "0.1": {
154
+ "f1": 0.04856230031948883,
155
+ "precision": 0.024885396201702686,
156
  "recall": 1.0,
157
+ "shd": 1489,
158
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
159
+ "n_pred_edges": 1527,
160
  "n_true_edges": 38
161
  },
162
  "0.15": {
163
+ "f1": 0.06282722513089005,
164
+ "precision": 0.032490974729241874,
165
  "recall": 0.9473684210526315,
166
+ "shd": 1074,
167
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
168
+ "n_pred_edges": 1108,
169
  "n_true_edges": 38
170
  },
171
  "0.2": {
172
+ "f1": 0.07911001236093942,
173
+ "precision": 0.041504539559014265,
174
  "recall": 0.8421052631578947,
175
+ "shd": 745,
176
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
177
+ "n_pred_edges": 771,
178
  "n_true_edges": 38
179
  },
180
  "0.3": {
181
+ "f1": 0.15025906735751296,
182
+ "precision": 0.08333333333333333,
183
  "recall": 0.7631578947368421,
184
+ "shd": 328,
185
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
186
+ "n_pred_edges": 348,
187
  "n_true_edges": 38
188
  },
189
  "0.4": {
190
+ "f1": 0.23255813953488372,
191
+ "precision": 0.14124293785310735,
192
  "recall": 0.6578947368421053,
193
+ "shd": 165,
194
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
195
+ "n_pred_edges": 177,
196
  "n_true_edges": 38
197
  },
198
  "0.5": {
199
+ "f1": 0.3140495867768595,
200
+ "precision": 0.2289156626506024,
201
+ "recall": 0.5,
202
+ "shd": 83,
203
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
204
+ "n_pred_edges": 83,
205
  "n_true_edges": 38
206
  },
207
  "0.6": {
208
+ "f1": 0.32098765432098764,
209
+ "precision": 0.3023255813953488,
210
+ "recall": 0.34210526315789475,
211
+ "shd": 55,
212
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
213
+ "n_pred_edges": 43,
214
  "n_true_edges": 38
215
  },
216
  "0.7": {
 
218
  "precision": 0.2916666666666667,
219
  "recall": 0.18421052631578946,
220
  "shd": 48,
221
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
222
  "n_pred_edges": 24,
223
  "n_true_edges": 38
224
  },
225
  "0.8": {
226
+ "f1": 0.2745098039215686,
227
+ "precision": 0.5384615384615384,
228
+ "recall": 0.18421052631578946,
229
+ "shd": 37,
230
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
231
  "n_pred_edges": 13,
232
  "n_true_edges": 38
233
  },
234
  "0.9": {
235
+ "f1": 0.22727272727272727,
236
+ "precision": 0.8333333333333334,
237
  "recall": 0.13157894736842105,
238
+ "shd": 34,
239
+ "auroc": 0.9035960214231065,
240
+ "n_pred_edges": 6,
241
  "n_true_edges": 38
242
  }
243
  }
 
250
  "auroc": 0.9976291628075544,
251
  "n_pred_edges": 1897,
252
  "n_true_edges": 38,
253
+ "time_s": 11.888438255991787,
254
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
255
  "best_f1": 0.12603648424543948,
256
  "best_precision": 0.06725663716814159,
 
383
  "auroc": 1.0,
384
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
385
  "n_true_edges": 38,
386
+ "time_s": 22.083945223130286,
387
  "best_threshold": 0.15,
388
  "best_f1": 1.0,
389
  "best_precision": 1.0,
 
512
  "CAUSEME": {
513
  "VAR-5": {
514
  "TCPFN": {
515
+ "f1": 0.3076923076923077,
516
+ "precision": 0.25,
517
+ "recall": 0.4,
518
+ "shd": 9,
519
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
520
+ "n_pred_edges": 8,
521
  "n_true_edges": 5,
522
+ "time_s": 6.940148788038641,
523
+ "best_threshold": 0.8,
524
  "best_f1": 0.5,
525
+ "best_precision": 0.6666666666666666,
526
+ "best_recall": 0.4,
527
  "threshold_sweep": {
528
  "0.01": {
529
  "f1": 0.4,
530
  "precision": 0.25,
531
  "recall": 1.0,
532
  "shd": 15,
533
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
534
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
535
  "n_true_edges": 5
536
  },
 
539
  "precision": 0.25,
540
  "recall": 1.0,
541
  "shd": 15,
542
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
543
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
544
  "n_true_edges": 5
545
  },
 
548
  "precision": 0.25,
549
  "recall": 1.0,
550
  "shd": 15,
551
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
552
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
553
  "n_true_edges": 5
554
  },
 
557
  "precision": 0.25,
558
  "recall": 1.0,
559
  "shd": 15,
560
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
561
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
562
  "n_true_edges": 5
563
  },
564
  "0.15": {
565
+ "f1": 0.4,
566
+ "precision": 0.25,
567
  "recall": 1.0,
568
+ "shd": 15,
569
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
570
+ "n_pred_edges": 20,
571
  "n_true_edges": 5
572
  },
573
  "0.2": {
574
+ "f1": 0.3333333333333333,
575
+ "precision": 0.21052631578947367,
576
+ "recall": 0.8,
577
+ "shd": 16,
578
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
579
+ "n_pred_edges": 19,
580
  "n_true_edges": 5
581
  },
582
  "0.3": {
583
+ "f1": 0.33333333333333337,
584
+ "precision": 0.23076923076923078,
585
+ "recall": 0.6,
586
+ "shd": 12,
587
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
588
  "n_pred_edges": 13,
589
  "n_true_edges": 5
590
  },
591
  "0.4": {
592
+ "f1": 0.37499999999999994,
593
+ "precision": 0.2727272727272727,
594
  "recall": 0.6,
595
+ "shd": 10,
596
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
597
+ "n_pred_edges": 11,
598
  "n_true_edges": 5
599
  },
600
  "0.5": {
601
+ "f1": 0.3076923076923077,
602
+ "precision": 0.25,
603
+ "recall": 0.4,
604
+ "shd": 9,
605
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
606
+ "n_pred_edges": 8,
607
  "n_true_edges": 5
608
  },
609
  "0.6": {
610
+ "f1": 0.3333333333333333,
611
+ "precision": 0.2857142857142857,
612
  "recall": 0.4,
613
+ "shd": 8,
614
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
615
+ "n_pred_edges": 7,
616
  "n_true_edges": 5
617
  },
618
  "0.7": {
619
+ "f1": 0.4000000000000001,
620
+ "precision": 0.4,
621
  "recall": 0.4,
622
+ "shd": 6,
623
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
624
+ "n_pred_edges": 5,
625
  "n_true_edges": 5
626
  },
627
  "0.8": {
 
629
  "precision": 0.6666666666666666,
630
  "recall": 0.4,
631
  "shd": 4,
632
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
633
  "n_pred_edges": 3,
634
  "n_true_edges": 5
635
  },
 
638
  "precision": 0.5,
639
  "recall": 0.2,
640
  "shd": 5,
641
+ "auroc": 0.4666666666666667,
642
  "n_pred_edges": 2,
643
  "n_true_edges": 5
644
  }
 
652
  "auroc": 1.0,
653
  "n_pred_edges": 18,
654
  "n_true_edges": 5,
655
+ "time_s": 0.09317358396947384,
656
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
657
  "best_f1": 0.7142857142857143,
658
  "best_precision": 0.5555555555555556,
 
785
  "auroc": 1.0,
786
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
787
  "n_true_edges": 5,
788
+ "time_s": 0.15940325194969773,
789
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
790
  "best_f1": 1.0,
791
  "best_precision": 1.0,
 
913
  },
914
  "VAR-10": {
915
  "TCPFN": {
916
+ "f1": 0.22727272727272727,
917
+ "precision": 0.3125,
918
+ "recall": 0.17857142857142858,
919
+ "shd": 34,
920
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
921
+ "n_pred_edges": 16,
922
  "n_true_edges": 28,
923
+ "time_s": 33.02883345284499,
924
  "best_threshold": 0.2,
925
+ "best_f1": 0.5176470588235293,
926
+ "best_precision": 0.38596491228070173,
927
  "best_recall": 0.7857142857142857,
928
  "threshold_sweep": {
929
  "0.01": {
 
931
  "precision": 0.3111111111111111,
932
  "recall": 1.0,
933
  "shd": 62,
934
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
935
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
936
  "n_true_edges": 28
937
  },
 
940
  "precision": 0.3111111111111111,
941
  "recall": 1.0,
942
  "shd": 62,
943
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
944
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
945
  "n_true_edges": 28
946
  },
 
949
  "precision": 0.3111111111111111,
950
  "recall": 1.0,
951
  "shd": 62,
952
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
953
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
954
  "n_true_edges": 28
955
  },
956
  "0.1": {
957
+ "f1": 0.5,
958
+ "precision": 0.3375,
959
+ "recall": 0.9642857142857143,
960
+ "shd": 54,
961
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
962
+ "n_pred_edges": 80,
963
  "n_true_edges": 28
964
  },
965
  "0.15": {
 
967
  "precision": 0.35384615384615387,
968
  "recall": 0.8214285714285714,
969
  "shd": 47,
970
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
971
  "n_pred_edges": 65,
972
  "n_true_edges": 28
973
  },
974
  "0.2": {
975
+ "f1": 0.5176470588235293,
976
+ "precision": 0.38596491228070173,
977
  "recall": 0.7857142857142857,
978
+ "shd": 41,
979
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
980
+ "n_pred_edges": 57,
981
  "n_true_edges": 28
982
  },
983
  "0.3": {
984
+ "f1": 0.463768115942029,
985
+ "precision": 0.3902439024390244,
986
+ "recall": 0.5714285714285714,
987
+ "shd": 37,
988
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
989
+ "n_pred_edges": 41,
990
  "n_true_edges": 28
991
  },
992
  "0.4": {
993
+ "f1": 0.39999999999999997,
994
+ "precision": 0.4074074074074074,
995
+ "recall": 0.39285714285714285,
996
+ "shd": 33,
997
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
998
+ "n_pred_edges": 27,
999
  "n_true_edges": 28
1000
  },
1001
  "0.5": {
1002
+ "f1": 0.22727272727272727,
1003
+ "precision": 0.3125,
1004
+ "recall": 0.17857142857142858,
1005
+ "shd": 34,
1006
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
1007
+ "n_pred_edges": 16,
1008
  "n_true_edges": 28
1009
  },
1010
  "0.6": {
1011
+ "f1": 0.10810810810810811,
1012
+ "precision": 0.2222222222222222,
1013
+ "recall": 0.07142857142857142,
1014
+ "shd": 33,
1015
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
1016
+ "n_pred_edges": 9,
1017
  "n_true_edges": 28
1018
  },
1019
  "0.7": {
1020
+ "f1": 0.11764705882352941,
1021
  "precision": 0.3333333333333333,
1022
+ "recall": 0.07142857142857142,
1023
+ "shd": 30,
1024
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
1025
+ "n_pred_edges": 6,
1026
  "n_true_edges": 28
1027
  },
1028
  "0.8": {
1029
+ "f1": 0.11764705882352941,
1030
+ "precision": 0.3333333333333333,
1031
  "recall": 0.07142857142857142,
1032
+ "shd": 30,
1033
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
1034
+ "n_pred_edges": 6,
1035
  "n_true_edges": 28
1036
  },
1037
  "0.9": {
 
1039
  "precision": 0.5,
1040
  "recall": 0.07142857142857142,
1041
  "shd": 28,
1042
+ "auroc": 0.6192396313364055,
1043
  "n_pred_edges": 4,
1044
  "n_true_edges": 28
1045
  }
 
1053
  "auroc": 0.8582949308755761,
1054
  "n_pred_edges": 80,
1055
  "n_true_edges": 28,
1056
+ "time_s": 0.4130916290450841,
1057
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
1058
  "best_f1": 0.5617977528089887,
1059
  "best_precision": 0.4098360655737705,
 
1186
  "auroc": 0.9441244239631337,
1187
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
1188
  "n_true_edges": 28,
1189
+ "time_s": 0.967412305995822,
1190
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
1191
  "best_f1": 0.9433962264150945,
1192
  "best_precision": 1.0,
 
1314
  },
1315
  "VAR-20": {
1316
  "TCPFN": {
1317
+ "f1": 0.09090909090909091,
1318
+ "precision": 0.2608695652173913,
1319
+ "recall": 0.05504587155963303,
1320
+ "shd": 120,
1321
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1322
+ "n_pred_edges": 23,
1323
  "n_true_edges": 109,
1324
+ "time_s": 137.4862743311096,
1325
+ "best_threshold": 0.02,
1326
+ "best_f1": 0.4458333333333333,
1327
+ "best_precision": 0.2884097035040431,
1328
+ "best_recall": 0.981651376146789,
1329
  "threshold_sweep": {
1330
  "0.01": {
1331
+ "f1": 0.4458077709611452,
1332
+ "precision": 0.2868421052631579,
1333
+ "recall": 1.0,
1334
+ "shd": 271,
1335
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1336
+ "n_pred_edges": 380,
1337
  "n_true_edges": 109
1338
  },
1339
  "0.02": {
1340
+ "f1": 0.4458333333333333,
1341
+ "precision": 0.2884097035040431,
1342
+ "recall": 0.981651376146789,
1343
+ "shd": 266,
1344
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1345
  "n_pred_edges": 371,
1346
  "n_true_edges": 109
1347
  },
1348
  "0.05": {
1349
+ "f1": 0.4309927360774818,
1350
+ "precision": 0.29276315789473684,
1351
+ "recall": 0.8165137614678899,
1352
+ "shd": 235,
1353
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1354
+ "n_pred_edges": 304,
1355
  "n_true_edges": 109
1356
  },
1357
  "0.1": {
1358
+ "f1": 0.37689969604863216,
1359
+ "precision": 0.2818181818181818,
1360
+ "recall": 0.5688073394495413,
1361
+ "shd": 205,
1362
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1363
+ "n_pred_edges": 220,
1364
  "n_true_edges": 109
1365
  },
1366
  "0.15": {
1367
+ "f1": 0.3597122302158273,
1368
+ "precision": 0.2958579881656805,
1369
+ "recall": 0.45871559633027525,
1370
+ "shd": 178,
1371
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1372
+ "n_pred_edges": 169,
1373
  "n_true_edges": 109
1374
  },
1375
  "0.2": {
1376
+ "f1": 0.3305084745762712,
1377
+ "precision": 0.30708661417322836,
1378
+ "recall": 0.3577981651376147,
1379
+ "shd": 158,
1380
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1381
+ "n_pred_edges": 127,
1382
  "n_true_edges": 109
1383
  },
1384
  "0.3": {
1385
+ "f1": 0.2594594594594595,
1386
+ "precision": 0.3157894736842105,
1387
+ "recall": 0.22018348623853212,
1388
+ "shd": 137,
1389
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1390
+ "n_pred_edges": 76,
1391
  "n_true_edges": 109
1392
  },
1393
  "0.4": {
1394
+ "f1": 0.14379084967320263,
1395
+ "precision": 0.25,
1396
+ "recall": 0.10091743119266056,
1397
+ "shd": 131,
1398
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1399
+ "n_pred_edges": 44,
1400
  "n_true_edges": 109
1401
  },
1402
  "0.5": {
1403
+ "f1": 0.09090909090909091,
1404
+ "precision": 0.2608695652173913,
1405
+ "recall": 0.05504587155963303,
1406
+ "shd": 120,
1407
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1408
+ "n_pred_edges": 23,
1409
  "n_true_edges": 109
1410
  },
1411
  "0.6": {
1412
+ "f1": 0.06611570247933884,
1413
+ "precision": 0.3333333333333333,
1414
  "recall": 0.03669724770642202,
1415
+ "shd": 113,
1416
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1417
+ "n_pred_edges": 12,
1418
  "n_true_edges": 109
1419
  },
1420
  "0.7": {
1421
+ "f1": 0.034782608695652174,
1422
+ "precision": 0.3333333333333333,
1423
+ "recall": 0.01834862385321101,
1424
+ "shd": 111,
1425
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1426
+ "n_pred_edges": 6,
1427
  "n_true_edges": 109
1428
  },
1429
  "0.8": {
1430
+ "f1": 0.01801801801801802,
1431
+ "precision": 0.5,
1432
+ "recall": 0.009174311926605505,
1433
+ "shd": 109,
1434
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1435
+ "n_pred_edges": 2,
1436
  "n_true_edges": 109
1437
  },
1438
  "0.9": {
 
1440
  "precision": 0.0,
1441
  "recall": 0.0,
1442
  "shd": 110,
1443
+ "auroc": 0.5102745522868073,
1444
  "n_pred_edges": 1,
1445
  "n_true_edges": 109
1446
  }
 
1454
  "auroc": 0.5092250922509225,
1455
  "n_pred_edges": 380,
1456
  "n_true_edges": 109,
1457
+ "time_s": 2.3641056939959526,
1458
  "best_threshold": 0.01,
1459
  "best_f1": 0.4458077709611452,
1460
  "best_precision": 0.2868421052631579,
 
1587
  "auroc": 0.9575137953214394,
1588
  "n_pred_edges": 2,
1589
  "n_true_edges": 109,
1590
+ "time_s": 11.973680943017825,
1591
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
1592
  "best_f1": 0.8761904761904762,
1593
  "best_precision": 0.9108910891089109,
 
1715
  },
1716
  "NVAR-5": {
1717
  "TCPFN": {
1718
+ "f1": 0.5714285714285715,
1719
+ "precision": 0.5,
1720
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1721
+ "shd": 3,
1722
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1723
+ "n_pred_edges": 4,
1724
  "n_true_edges": 3,
1725
+ "time_s": 6.926997279981151,
1726
+ "best_threshold": 0.6,
1727
  "best_f1": 0.8,
1728
  "best_precision": 1.0,
1729
  "best_recall": 0.6666666666666666,
 
1733
  "precision": 0.15,
1734
  "recall": 1.0,
1735
  "shd": 17,
1736
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1737
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
1738
  "n_true_edges": 3
1739
  },
 
1742
  "precision": 0.15,
1743
  "recall": 1.0,
1744
  "shd": 17,
1745
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1746
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
1747
  "n_true_edges": 3
1748
  },
 
1751
  "precision": 0.15,
1752
  "recall": 1.0,
1753
  "shd": 17,
1754
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1755
  "n_pred_edges": 20,
1756
  "n_true_edges": 3
1757
  },
1758
  "0.1": {
1759
+ "f1": 0.2727272727272727,
1760
+ "precision": 0.15789473684210525,
1761
+ "recall": 1.0,
1762
+ "shd": 16,
1763
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1764
+ "n_pred_edges": 19,
1765
  "n_true_edges": 3
1766
  },
1767
  "0.15": {
1768
+ "f1": 0.23529411764705882,
1769
+ "precision": 0.14285714285714285,
1770
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1771
+ "shd": 13,
1772
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1773
+ "n_pred_edges": 14,
1774
  "n_true_edges": 3
1775
  },
1776
  "0.2": {
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1777
  "f1": 0.36363636363636365,
1778
  "precision": 0.25,
1779
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1780
  "shd": 7,
1781
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1782
  "n_pred_edges": 8,
1783
  "n_true_edges": 3
1784
  },
1785
+ "0.3": {
1786
+ "f1": 0.4,
1787
+ "precision": 0.2857142857142857,
1788
+ "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1789
+ "shd": 6,
1790
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1791
+ "n_pred_edges": 7,
1792
+ "n_true_edges": 3
1793
+ },
1794
  "0.4": {
1795
+ "f1": 0.4444444444444444,
1796
+ "precision": 0.3333333333333333,
1797
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1798
+ "shd": 5,
1799
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1800
+ "n_pred_edges": 6,
1801
  "n_true_edges": 3
1802
  },
1803
  "0.5": {
1804
+ "f1": 0.5714285714285715,
1805
+ "precision": 0.5,
1806
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1807
+ "shd": 3,
1808
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1809
+ "n_pred_edges": 4,
1810
  "n_true_edges": 3
1811
  },
1812
  "0.6": {
 
1814
  "precision": 1.0,
1815
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1816
  "shd": 1,
1817
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1818
  "n_pred_edges": 2,
1819
  "n_true_edges": 3
1820
  },
 
1823
  "precision": 1.0,
1824
  "recall": 0.6666666666666666,
1825
  "shd": 1,
1826
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1827
  "n_pred_edges": 2,
1828
  "n_true_edges": 3
1829
  },
 
1832
  "precision": 1.0,
1833
  "recall": 0.3333333333333333,
1834
  "shd": 2,
1835
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1836
  "n_pred_edges": 1,
1837
  "n_true_edges": 3
1838
  },
 
1841
  "precision": 1.0,
1842
  "recall": 0.3333333333333333,
1843
  "shd": 2,
1844
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
1845
  "n_pred_edges": 1,
1846
  "n_true_edges": 3
1847
  }
 
1855
  "auroc": 0.9803921568627451,
1856
  "n_pred_edges": 14,
1857
  "n_true_edges": 3,
1858
+ "time_s": 0.09350674296729267,
1859
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
1860
  "best_f1": 0.6666666666666666,
1861
  "best_precision": 0.5,
 
1988
  "auroc": 1.0,
1989
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
1990
  "n_true_edges": 3,
1991
+ "time_s": 0.13613249082118273,
1992
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
1993
  "best_f1": 0.8,
1994
  "best_precision": 1.0,
 
2116
  },
2117
  "NVAR-10": {
2118
  "TCPFN": {
2119
+ "f1": 0.4390243902439025,
2120
+ "precision": 0.5,
2121
+ "recall": 0.391304347826087,
2122
+ "shd": 23,
2123
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2124
+ "n_pred_edges": 18,
2125
  "n_true_edges": 23,
2126
+ "time_s": 32.78371823602356,
2127
+ "best_threshold": 0.5,
2128
+ "best_f1": 0.4390243902439025,
2129
+ "best_precision": 0.5,
2130
+ "best_recall": 0.391304347826087,
2131
  "threshold_sweep": {
2132
  "0.01": {
2133
  "f1": 0.4070796460176991,
2134
  "precision": 0.25555555555555554,
2135
  "recall": 1.0,
2136
  "shd": 67,
2137
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2138
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2139
  "n_true_edges": 23
2140
  },
 
2143
  "precision": 0.25555555555555554,
2144
  "recall": 1.0,
2145
  "shd": 67,
2146
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2147
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2148
  "n_true_edges": 23
2149
  },
 
2152
  "precision": 0.25555555555555554,
2153
  "recall": 1.0,
2154
  "shd": 67,
2155
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2156
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2157
  "n_true_edges": 23
2158
  },
2159
  "0.1": {
2160
+ "f1": 0.4181818181818182,
2161
+ "precision": 0.26436781609195403,
2162
+ "recall": 1.0,
2163
+ "shd": 64,
2164
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2165
+ "n_pred_edges": 87,
2166
  "n_true_edges": 23
2167
  },
2168
  "0.15": {
2169
+ "f1": 0.4375,
2170
+ "precision": 0.2876712328767123,
2171
+ "recall": 0.9130434782608695,
2172
+ "shd": 54,
2173
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2174
+ "n_pred_edges": 73,
2175
  "n_true_edges": 23
2176
  },
2177
  "0.2": {
2178
+ "f1": 0.3902439024390244,
2179
+ "precision": 0.2711864406779661,
2180
+ "recall": 0.6956521739130435,
2181
+ "shd": 50,
2182
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2183
+ "n_pred_edges": 59,
2184
  "n_true_edges": 23
2185
  },
2186
  "0.3": {
2187
+ "f1": 0.39393939393939387,
2188
+ "precision": 0.3023255813953488,
2189
+ "recall": 0.5652173913043478,
2190
+ "shd": 40,
2191
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2192
+ "n_pred_edges": 43,
2193
  "n_true_edges": 23
2194
  },
2195
  "0.4": {
2196
+ "f1": 0.4230769230769231,
2197
+ "precision": 0.3793103448275862,
2198
+ "recall": 0.4782608695652174,
2199
+ "shd": 30,
2200
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2201
+ "n_pred_edges": 29,
2202
  "n_true_edges": 23
2203
  },
2204
  "0.5": {
2205
+ "f1": 0.4390243902439025,
2206
+ "precision": 0.5,
2207
+ "recall": 0.391304347826087,
2208
+ "shd": 23,
2209
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2210
+ "n_pred_edges": 18,
2211
  "n_true_edges": 23
2212
  },
2213
  "0.6": {
2214
+ "f1": 0.24242424242424243,
2215
+ "precision": 0.4,
2216
+ "recall": 0.17391304347826086,
2217
  "shd": 25,
2218
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2219
+ "n_pred_edges": 10,
2220
  "n_true_edges": 23
2221
  },
2222
  "0.7": {
2223
+ "f1": 0.27586206896551724,
2224
+ "precision": 0.6666666666666666,
2225
  "recall": 0.17391304347826086,
2226
+ "shd": 21,
2227
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2228
+ "n_pred_edges": 6,
2229
  "n_true_edges": 23
2230
  },
2231
  "0.8": {
2232
+ "f1": 0.2857142857142857,
2233
+ "precision": 0.8,
2234
+ "recall": 0.17391304347826086,
2235
+ "shd": 20,
2236
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2237
+ "n_pred_edges": 5,
2238
  "n_true_edges": 23
2239
  },
2240
  "0.9": {
2241
+ "f1": 0.08333333333333333,
2242
  "precision": 1.0,
2243
+ "recall": 0.043478260869565216,
2244
+ "shd": 22,
2245
+ "auroc": 0.6281635301752109,
2246
+ "n_pred_edges": 1,
2247
  "n_true_edges": 23
2248
  }
2249
  }
 
2256
  "auroc": 0.9188838416612588,
2257
  "n_pred_edges": 83,
2258
  "n_true_edges": 23,
2259
+ "time_s": 0.41245319601148367,
2260
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
2261
  "best_f1": 0.5316455696202531,
2262
  "best_precision": 0.375,
 
2389
  "auroc": 0.9682024659312136,
2390
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
2391
  "n_true_edges": 23,
2392
+ "time_s": 0.9857114581391215,
2393
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
2394
  "best_f1": 0.9302325581395349,
2395
  "best_precision": 1.0,
 
2521
  "precision": 0.4827586206896552,
2522
  "recall": 0.12389380530973451,
2523
  "shd": 114,
2524
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2525
  "n_pred_edges": 29,
2526
  "n_true_edges": 113,
2527
+ "time_s": 138.3603924238123,
2528
+ "best_threshold": 0.05,
2529
+ "best_f1": 0.4674698795180723,
2530
+ "best_precision": 0.3211920529801324,
2531
+ "best_recall": 0.8584070796460177,
2532
  "threshold_sweep": {
2533
  "0.01": {
2534
  "f1": 0.45841784989858014,
2535
  "precision": 0.29736842105263156,
2536
  "recall": 1.0,
2537
  "shd": 267,
2538
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2539
  "n_pred_edges": 380,
2540
  "n_true_edges": 113
2541
  },
2542
  "0.02": {
2543
+ "f1": 0.465979381443299,
2544
+ "precision": 0.30376344086021506,
2545
+ "recall": 1.0,
2546
+ "shd": 259,
2547
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2548
+ "n_pred_edges": 372,
2549
  "n_true_edges": 113
2550
  },
2551
  "0.05": {
2552
+ "f1": 0.4674698795180723,
2553
+ "precision": 0.3211920529801324,
2554
+ "recall": 0.8584070796460177,
2555
+ "shd": 221,
2556
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2557
+ "n_pred_edges": 302,
2558
  "n_true_edges": 113
2559
  },
2560
  "0.1": {
2561
+ "f1": 0.45592705167173253,
2562
+ "precision": 0.3472222222222222,
2563
+ "recall": 0.6637168141592921,
2564
+ "shd": 179,
2565
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2566
+ "n_pred_edges": 216,
2567
  "n_true_edges": 113
2568
  },
2569
  "0.15": {
2570
+ "f1": 0.44688644688644685,
2571
+ "precision": 0.38125,
2572
+ "recall": 0.5398230088495575,
2573
+ "shd": 151,
2574
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2575
+ "n_pred_edges": 160,
2576
  "n_true_edges": 113
2577
  },
2578
  "0.2": {
2579
+ "f1": 0.3710407239819005,
2580
+ "precision": 0.37962962962962965,
2581
+ "recall": 0.36283185840707965,
2582
+ "shd": 139,
2583
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2584
+ "n_pred_edges": 108,
2585
  "n_true_edges": 113
2586
  },
2587
  "0.3": {
2588
+ "f1": 0.2658959537572254,
2589
+ "precision": 0.38333333333333336,
2590
  "recall": 0.20353982300884957,
2591
+ "shd": 127,
2592
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2593
+ "n_pred_edges": 60,
2594
  "n_true_edges": 113
2595
  },
2596
  "0.4": {
2597
+ "f1": 0.24675324675324675,
2598
+ "precision": 0.4634146341463415,
2599
+ "recall": 0.168141592920354,
2600
+ "shd": 116,
2601
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2602
  "n_pred_edges": 41,
2603
  "n_true_edges": 113
2604
  },
 
2607
  "precision": 0.4827586206896552,
2608
  "recall": 0.12389380530973451,
2609
  "shd": 114,
2610
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2611
  "n_pred_edges": 29,
2612
  "n_true_edges": 113
2613
  },
2614
  "0.6": {
2615
+ "f1": 0.1764705882352941,
2616
+ "precision": 0.5217391304347826,
2617
+ "recall": 0.10619469026548672,
2618
+ "shd": 112,
2619
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2620
  "n_pred_edges": 23,
2621
  "n_true_edges": 113
2622
  },
2623
  "0.7": {
2624
+ "f1": 0.15503875968992248,
2625
+ "precision": 0.625,
2626
+ "recall": 0.08849557522123894,
2627
+ "shd": 109,
2628
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2629
  "n_pred_edges": 16,
2630
  "n_true_edges": 113
2631
  },
2632
  "0.8": {
2633
+ "f1": 0.11475409836065573,
2634
+ "precision": 0.7777777777777778,
2635
+ "recall": 0.061946902654867256,
2636
+ "shd": 108,
2637
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2638
+ "n_pred_edges": 9,
2639
  "n_true_edges": 113
2640
  },
2641
  "0.9": {
2642
+ "f1": 0.06779661016949151,
2643
+ "precision": 0.8,
2644
+ "recall": 0.035398230088495575,
2645
+ "shd": 110,
2646
+ "auroc": 0.5980245931523649,
2647
+ "n_pred_edges": 5,
2648
  "n_true_edges": 113
2649
  }
2650
  }
 
2657
  "auroc": 0.7275198037850916,
2658
  "n_pred_edges": 379,
2659
  "n_true_edges": 113,
2660
+ "time_s": 2.3700400500092655,
2661
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
2662
  "best_f1": 0.47379454926624737,
2663
  "best_precision": 0.31043956043956045,
 
2790
  "auroc": 0.9580060322826556,
2791
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
2792
  "n_true_edges": 113,
2793
+ "time_s": 10.411002143053338,
2794
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
2795
  "best_f1": 0.909952606635071,
2796
  "best_precision": 0.9795918367346939,
 
2918
  },
2919
  "Lorenz96-10": {
2920
  "TCPFN": {
2921
+ "f1": 0.3125,
2922
+ "precision": 0.37037037037037035,
2923
  "recall": 0.2702702702702703,
2924
+ "shd": 44,
2925
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
2926
+ "n_pred_edges": 27,
2927
  "n_true_edges": 37,
2928
+ "time_s": 33.02998321107589,
2929
  "best_threshold": 0.01,
2930
  "best_f1": 0.5826771653543308,
2931
  "best_precision": 0.4111111111111111,
 
2936
  "precision": 0.4111111111111111,
2937
  "recall": 1.0,
2938
  "shd": 53,
2939
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
2940
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2941
  "n_true_edges": 37
2942
  },
 
2945
  "precision": 0.4111111111111111,
2946
  "recall": 1.0,
2947
  "shd": 53,
2948
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
2949
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
2950
  "n_true_edges": 37
2951
  },
2952
  "0.05": {
2953
+ "f1": 0.5409836065573771,
2954
+ "precision": 0.38823529411764707,
2955
  "recall": 0.8918918918918919,
2956
+ "shd": 56,
2957
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
2958
+ "n_pred_edges": 85,
2959
  "n_true_edges": 37
2960
  },
2961
  "0.1": {
2962
+ "f1": 0.5454545454545454,
2963
+ "precision": 0.410958904109589,
2964
+ "recall": 0.8108108108108109,
2965
+ "shd": 50,
2966
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
2967
+ "n_pred_edges": 73,
2968
  "n_true_edges": 37
2969
  },
2970
  "0.15": {
2971
+ "f1": 0.52,
2972
+ "precision": 0.4126984126984127,
2973
  "recall": 0.7027027027027027,
2974
+ "shd": 48,
2975
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
2976
+ "n_pred_edges": 63,
2977
  "n_true_edges": 37
2978
  },
2979
  "0.2": {
2980
+ "f1": 0.4893617021276595,
2981
+ "precision": 0.40350877192982454,
2982
  "recall": 0.6216216216216216,
2983
+ "shd": 48,
2984
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
2985
+ "n_pred_edges": 57,
2986
  "n_true_edges": 37
2987
  },
2988
  "0.3": {
2989
+ "f1": 0.39506172839506176,
2990
+ "precision": 0.36363636363636365,
2991
+ "recall": 0.43243243243243246,
2992
+ "shd": 49,
2993
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
2994
+ "n_pred_edges": 44,
2995
  "n_true_edges": 37
2996
  },
2997
  "0.4": {
 
2999
  "precision": 0.3888888888888889,
3000
  "recall": 0.3783783783783784,
3001
  "shd": 45,
3002
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
3003
  "n_pred_edges": 36,
3004
  "n_true_edges": 37
3005
  },
3006
  "0.5": {
3007
+ "f1": 0.3125,
3008
+ "precision": 0.37037037037037035,
3009
  "recall": 0.2702702702702703,
3010
+ "shd": 44,
3011
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
3012
+ "n_pred_edges": 27,
3013
  "n_true_edges": 37
3014
  },
3015
  "0.6": {
3016
+ "f1": 0.25,
3017
+ "precision": 0.3684210526315789,
3018
+ "recall": 0.1891891891891892,
3019
+ "shd": 42,
3020
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
3021
+ "n_pred_edges": 19,
3022
  "n_true_edges": 37
3023
  },
3024
  "0.7": {
3025
+ "f1": 0.125,
3026
+ "precision": 0.2727272727272727,
3027
+ "recall": 0.08108108108108109,
3028
+ "shd": 42,
3029
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
3030
+ "n_pred_edges": 11,
3031
  "n_true_edges": 37
3032
  },
3033
  "0.8": {
3034
  "f1": 0.0,
3035
  "precision": 0.0,
3036
  "recall": 0.0,
3037
+ "shd": 38,
3038
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
3039
+ "n_pred_edges": 1,
3040
  "n_true_edges": 37
3041
  },
3042
  "0.9": {
 
3044
  "precision": 0.0,
3045
  "recall": 0.0,
3046
  "shd": 38,
3047
+ "auroc": 0.453850076491586,
3048
  "n_pred_edges": 1,
3049
  "n_true_edges": 37
3050
  }
 
3058
  "auroc": 0.5800611932687405,
3059
  "n_pred_edges": 90,
3060
  "n_true_edges": 37,
3061
+ "time_s": 0.5657367659732699,
3062
  "best_threshold": 0.8,
3063
  "best_f1": 0.5873015873015873,
3064
  "best_precision": 0.4157303370786517,
 
3191
  "auroc": 0.8500764915859255,
3192
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
3193
  "n_true_edges": 37,
3194
+ "time_s": 2.8821691600605845,
3195
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
3196
  "best_f1": 0.7123287671232876,
3197
  "best_precision": 0.7222222222222222,
 
3319
  },
3320
  "Lorenz96-20": {
3321
  "TCPFN": {
3322
+ "f1": 0.2547770700636942,
3323
+ "precision": 0.3125,
3324
+ "recall": 0.21505376344086022,
3325
+ "shd": 117,
3326
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3327
+ "n_pred_edges": 64,
3328
  "n_true_edges": 93,
3329
+ "time_s": 138.39342237496749,
3330
  "best_threshold": 0.01,
3331
  "best_f1": 0.39323467230443976,
3332
  "best_precision": 0.24473684210526317,
 
3337
  "precision": 0.24473684210526317,
3338
  "recall": 1.0,
3339
  "shd": 287,
3340
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3341
  "n_pred_edges": 380,
3342
  "n_true_edges": 93
3343
  },
 
3346
  "precision": 0.24473684210526317,
3347
  "recall": 1.0,
3348
  "shd": 287,
3349
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3350
  "n_pred_edges": 380,
3351
  "n_true_edges": 93
3352
  },
3353
  "0.05": {
3354
+ "f1": 0.3824175824175824,
3355
+ "precision": 0.24033149171270718,
3356
+ "recall": 0.9354838709677419,
3357
+ "shd": 281,
3358
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3359
+ "n_pred_edges": 362,
3360
  "n_true_edges": 93
3361
  },
3362
  "0.1": {
3363
+ "f1": 0.3890274314214464,
3364
+ "precision": 0.2532467532467532,
3365
+ "recall": 0.8387096774193549,
3366
+ "shd": 245,
3367
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3368
+ "n_pred_edges": 308,
3369
  "n_true_edges": 93
3370
  },
3371
  "0.15": {
3372
+ "f1": 0.3753501400560224,
3373
+ "precision": 0.2537878787878788,
3374
+ "recall": 0.7204301075268817,
3375
  "shd": 223,
3376
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3377
+ "n_pred_edges": 264,
3378
  "n_true_edges": 93
3379
  },
3380
  "0.2": {
3381
+ "f1": 0.37341772151898733,
3382
+ "precision": 0.2645739910313901,
3383
+ "recall": 0.6344086021505376,
3384
+ "shd": 198,
3385
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3386
+ "n_pred_edges": 223,
3387
  "n_true_edges": 93
3388
  },
3389
  "0.3": {
3390
+ "f1": 0.35156250000000006,
3391
+ "precision": 0.27607361963190186,
3392
+ "recall": 0.4838709677419355,
3393
+ "shd": 166,
3394
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3395
  "n_pred_edges": 163,
3396
  "n_true_edges": 93
3397
  },
3398
  "0.4": {
3399
+ "f1": 0.3069306930693069,
3400
+ "precision": 0.28440366972477066,
3401
+ "recall": 0.3333333333333333,
3402
+ "shd": 140,
3403
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3404
+ "n_pred_edges": 109,
3405
  "n_true_edges": 93
3406
  },
3407
  "0.5": {
3408
+ "f1": 0.2547770700636942,
3409
+ "precision": 0.3125,
3410
+ "recall": 0.21505376344086022,
3411
+ "shd": 117,
3412
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3413
+ "n_pred_edges": 64,
3414
  "n_true_edges": 93
3415
  },
3416
  "0.6": {
3417
+ "f1": 0.16541353383458648,
3418
+ "precision": 0.275,
3419
  "recall": 0.11827956989247312,
3420
+ "shd": 111,
3421
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3422
+ "n_pred_edges": 40,
3423
  "n_true_edges": 93
3424
  },
3425
  "0.7": {
3426
+ "f1": 0.1206896551724138,
3427
+ "precision": 0.30434782608695654,
3428
+ "recall": 0.07526881720430108,
3429
+ "shd": 102,
3430
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3431
+ "n_pred_edges": 23,
3432
  "n_true_edges": 93
3433
  },
3434
  "0.8": {
3435
+ "f1": 0.09900990099009901,
3436
+ "precision": 0.625,
3437
+ "recall": 0.053763440860215055,
3438
+ "shd": 91,
3439
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3440
  "n_pred_edges": 8,
3441
  "n_true_edges": 93
3442
  },
3443
  "0.9": {
3444
+ "f1": 0.04210526315789474,
3445
+ "precision": 1.0,
3446
  "recall": 0.021505376344086023,
3447
+ "shd": 91,
3448
+ "auroc": 0.5384211906635196,
3449
+ "n_pred_edges": 2,
3450
  "n_true_edges": 93
3451
  }
3452
  }
 
3459
  "auroc": 0.8101045296167249,
3460
  "n_pred_edges": 349,
3461
  "n_true_edges": 93,
3462
+ "time_s": 2.3884899020195007,
3463
  "best_threshold": 0.9,
3464
  "best_f1": 0.48022598870056493,
3465
  "best_precision": 0.32567049808429116,
 
3592
  "auroc": 0.7790266381926492,
3593
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
3594
  "n_true_edges": 93,
3595
+ "time_s": 8.319127733120695,
3596
  "best_threshold": 0.1,
3597
  "best_f1": 0.6193548387096774,
3598
  "best_precision": 0.7741935483870968,
 
3721
  },
3722
  "SACHS": {
3723
  "TCPFN": {
3724
+ "f1": 0.4117647058823529,
3725
+ "precision": 0.27450980392156865,
3726
+ "recall": 0.8235294117647058,
3727
+ "shd": 40,
3728
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3729
+ "n_pred_edges": 51,
3730
  "n_true_edges": 17,
3731
+ "time_s": 40.968244003131986,
3732
+ "best_threshold": 0.5,
3733
+ "best_f1": 0.4117647058823529,
3734
+ "best_precision": 0.27450980392156865,
3735
+ "best_recall": 0.8235294117647058,
3736
  "threshold_sweep": {
3737
  "0.01": {
3738
  "f1": 0.26771653543307083,
3739
  "precision": 0.15454545454545454,
3740
  "recall": 1.0,
3741
  "shd": 93,
3742
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3743
  "n_pred_edges": 110,
3744
  "n_true_edges": 17
3745
  },
 
3748
  "precision": 0.15454545454545454,
3749
  "recall": 1.0,
3750
  "shd": 93,
3751
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3752
  "n_pred_edges": 110,
3753
  "n_true_edges": 17
3754
  },
 
3757
  "precision": 0.15454545454545454,
3758
  "recall": 1.0,
3759
  "shd": 93,
3760
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3761
  "n_pred_edges": 110,
3762
  "n_true_edges": 17
3763
  },
3764
  "0.1": {
3765
+ "f1": 0.2809917355371901,
3766
+ "precision": 0.16346153846153846,
3767
  "recall": 1.0,
3768
+ "shd": 87,
3769
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3770
+ "n_pred_edges": 104,
3771
  "n_true_edges": 17
3772
  },
3773
  "0.15": {
3774
+ "f1": 0.3119266055045872,
3775
+ "precision": 0.18478260869565216,
3776
  "recall": 1.0,
3777
+ "shd": 75,
3778
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3779
+ "n_pred_edges": 92,
3780
  "n_true_edges": 17
3781
  },
3782
  "0.2": {
3783
+ "f1": 0.32075471698113206,
3784
+ "precision": 0.19101123595505617,
3785
  "recall": 1.0,
3786
+ "shd": 72,
3787
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3788
+ "n_pred_edges": 89,
3789
  "n_true_edges": 17
3790
  },
3791
  "0.3": {
3792
+ "f1": 0.32323232323232326,
3793
+ "precision": 0.1951219512195122,
3794
+ "recall": 0.9411764705882353,
3795
  "shd": 67,
3796
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3797
+ "n_pred_edges": 82,
3798
  "n_true_edges": 17
3799
  },
3800
  "0.4": {
3801
+ "f1": 0.3614457831325301,
3802
+ "precision": 0.22727272727272727,
3803
  "recall": 0.8823529411764706,
3804
+ "shd": 53,
3805
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3806
+ "n_pred_edges": 66,
3807
  "n_true_edges": 17
3808
  },
3809
  "0.5": {
3810
+ "f1": 0.4117647058823529,
3811
+ "precision": 0.27450980392156865,
3812
+ "recall": 0.8235294117647058,
3813
+ "shd": 40,
3814
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3815
+ "n_pred_edges": 51,
3816
  "n_true_edges": 17
3817
  },
3818
  "0.6": {
3819
+ "f1": 0.391304347826087,
3820
+ "precision": 0.3103448275862069,
3821
+ "recall": 0.5294117647058824,
3822
+ "shd": 28,
3823
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3824
+ "n_pred_edges": 29,
3825
  "n_true_edges": 17
3826
  },
3827
  "0.7": {
3828
+ "f1": 0.2580645161290323,
3829
+ "precision": 0.2857142857142857,
3830
+ "recall": 0.23529411764705882,
3831
+ "shd": 23,
3832
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3833
+ "n_pred_edges": 14,
3834
  "n_true_edges": 17
3835
  },
3836
  "0.8": {
3837
+ "f1": 0.2,
3838
+ "precision": 0.6666666666666666,
3839
+ "recall": 0.11764705882352941,
3840
+ "shd": 16,
3841
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3842
+ "n_pred_edges": 3,
3843
  "n_true_edges": 17
3844
  },
3845
  "0.9": {
3846
+ "f1": 0.1111111111111111,
3847
+ "precision": 1.0,
3848
+ "recall": 0.058823529411764705,
3849
+ "shd": 16,
3850
+ "auroc": 0.7254901960784313,
3851
+ "n_pred_edges": 1,
3852
  "n_true_edges": 17
3853
  }
3854
  }
 
3861
  "auroc": 0.6211258697027198,
3862
  "n_pred_edges": 86,
3863
  "n_true_edges": 17,
3864
+ "time_s": 0.4789543580263853,
3865
  "best_threshold": 0.8,
3866
  "best_f1": 0.31884057971014496,
3867
  "best_precision": 0.21153846153846154,
 
3994
  "auroc": 0.6008855154965211,
3995
  "n_pred_edges": 0,
3996
  "n_true_edges": 17,
3997
+ "time_s": 0.6475036679767072,
3998
  "best_threshold": 0.01,
3999
  "best_f1": 0.26771653543307083,
4000
  "best_precision": 0.15454545454545454,
 
4119
  }
4120
  }
4121
  }
4122
+ },
4123
+ "SWAT": {
4124
+ "TCPFN": {
4125
+ "f1": 0.2649006622516556,
4126
+ "precision": 0.20833333333333334,
4127
+ "recall": 0.36363636363636365,
4128
+ "shd": 111,
4129
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4130
+ "n_pred_edges": 96,
4131
+ "n_true_edges": 55,
4132
+ "time_s": 1085.5645980471745,
4133
+ "best_threshold": 0.5,
4134
+ "best_f1": 0.2649006622516556,
4135
+ "best_precision": 0.20833333333333334,
4136
+ "best_recall": 0.36363636363636365,
4137
+ "threshold_sweep": {
4138
+ "0.01": {
4139
+ "f1": 0.036375661375661374,
4140
+ "precision": 0.018524755810037048,
4141
+ "recall": 1.0,
4142
+ "shd": 2914,
4143
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4144
+ "n_pred_edges": 2969,
4145
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4146
+ },
4147
+ "0.02": {
4148
+ "f1": 0.039384174722520586,
4149
+ "precision": 0.02008765522279036,
4150
+ "recall": 1.0,
4151
+ "shd": 2683,
4152
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4153
+ "n_pred_edges": 2738,
4154
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4155
+ },
4156
+ "0.05": {
4157
+ "f1": 0.04545454545454545,
4158
+ "precision": 0.02328705776981639,
4159
+ "recall": 0.9454545454545454,
4160
+ "shd": 2184,
4161
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4162
+ "n_pred_edges": 2233,
4163
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4164
+ },
4165
+ "0.1": {
4166
+ "f1": 0.06261510128913443,
4167
+ "precision": 0.032401524777636595,
4168
+ "recall": 0.9272727272727272,
4169
+ "shd": 1527,
4170
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4171
+ "n_pred_edges": 1574,
4172
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4173
+ },
4174
+ "0.15": {
4175
+ "f1": 0.08602150537634409,
4176
+ "precision": 0.04524033930254477,
4177
+ "recall": 0.8727272727272727,
4178
+ "shd": 1020,
4179
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4180
+ "n_pred_edges": 1061,
4181
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4182
+ },
4183
+ "0.2": {
4184
+ "f1": 0.11466666666666667,
4185
+ "precision": 0.0618705035971223,
4186
+ "recall": 0.7818181818181819,
4187
+ "shd": 664,
4188
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4189
+ "n_pred_edges": 695,
4190
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4191
+ },
4192
+ "0.3": {
4193
+ "f1": 0.193717277486911,
4194
+ "precision": 0.11314984709480122,
4195
+ "recall": 0.6727272727272727,
4196
+ "shd": 308,
4197
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4198
+ "n_pred_edges": 327,
4199
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4200
+ },
4201
+ "0.4": {
4202
+ "f1": 0.22641509433962262,
4203
+ "precision": 0.15286624203821655,
4204
+ "recall": 0.43636363636363634,
4205
+ "shd": 164,
4206
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4207
+ "n_pred_edges": 157,
4208
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4209
+ },
4210
+ "0.5": {
4211
+ "f1": 0.2649006622516556,
4212
+ "precision": 0.20833333333333334,
4213
+ "recall": 0.36363636363636365,
4214
+ "shd": 111,
4215
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4216
+ "n_pred_edges": 96,
4217
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4218
+ },
4219
+ "0.6": {
4220
+ "f1": 0.24299065420560748,
4221
+ "precision": 0.25,
4222
+ "recall": 0.23636363636363636,
4223
+ "shd": 81,
4224
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4225
+ "n_pred_edges": 52,
4226
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4227
+ },
4228
+ "0.7": {
4229
+ "f1": 0.19512195121951217,
4230
+ "precision": 0.2962962962962963,
4231
+ "recall": 0.14545454545454545,
4232
+ "shd": 66,
4233
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4234
+ "n_pred_edges": 27,
4235
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4236
+ },
4237
+ "0.8": {
4238
+ "f1": 0.1176470588235294,
4239
+ "precision": 0.3076923076923077,
4240
+ "recall": 0.07272727272727272,
4241
+ "shd": 60,
4242
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4243
+ "n_pred_edges": 13,
4244
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4245
+ },
4246
+ "0.9": {
4247
+ "f1": 0.06451612903225805,
4248
+ "precision": 0.2857142857142857,
4249
+ "recall": 0.03636363636363636,
4250
+ "shd": 58,
4251
+ "auroc": 0.8590924684235147,
4252
+ "n_pred_edges": 7,
4253
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4254
+ }
4255
+ }
4256
+ },
4257
+ "Granger": {
4258
+ "f1": 0.05004549590536852,
4259
+ "precision": 0.025664955669622024,
4260
+ "recall": 1.0,
4261
+ "shd": 2088,
4262
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4263
+ "n_pred_edges": 2143,
4264
+ "n_true_edges": 55,
4265
+ "time_s": 13.190947315189987,
4266
+ "best_threshold": 0.9,
4267
+ "best_f1": 0.14341590612777053,
4268
+ "best_precision": 0.07724719101123595,
4269
+ "best_recall": 1.0,
4270
+ "threshold_sweep": {
4271
+ "0.01": {
4272
+ "f1": 0.03636363636363636,
4273
+ "precision": 0.018518518518518517,
4274
+ "recall": 1.0,
4275
+ "shd": 2915,
4276
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4277
+ "n_pred_edges": 2970,
4278
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4279
+ },
4280
+ "0.02": {
4281
+ "f1": 0.036411784177424696,
4282
+ "precision": 0.018543492919757248,
4283
+ "recall": 1.0,
4284
+ "shd": 2911,
4285
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4286
+ "n_pred_edges": 2966,
4287
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4288
+ },
4289
+ "0.05": {
4290
+ "f1": 0.036556995679627786,
4291
+ "precision": 0.018618821936357482,
4292
+ "recall": 1.0,
4293
+ "shd": 2899,
4294
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4295
+ "n_pred_edges": 2954,
4296
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4297
+ },
4298
+ "0.1": {
4299
+ "f1": 0.03699966363942146,
4300
+ "precision": 0.018848526387936944,
4301
+ "recall": 1.0,
4302
+ "shd": 2863,
4303
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4304
+ "n_pred_edges": 2918,
4305
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4306
+ },
4307
+ "0.15": {
4308
+ "f1": 0.03767123287671233,
4309
+ "precision": 0.019197207678883072,
4310
+ "recall": 1.0,
4311
+ "shd": 2810,
4312
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4313
+ "n_pred_edges": 2865,
4314
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4315
+ },
4316
+ "0.2": {
4317
+ "f1": 0.03859649122807018,
4318
+ "precision": 0.01967799642218247,
4319
+ "recall": 1.0,
4320
+ "shd": 2740,
4321
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4322
+ "n_pred_edges": 2795,
4323
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4324
+ },
4325
+ "0.3": {
4326
+ "f1": 0.040740740740740744,
4327
+ "precision": 0.020793950850661626,
4328
+ "recall": 1.0,
4329
+ "shd": 2590,
4330
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4331
+ "n_pred_edges": 2645,
4332
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4333
+ },
4334
+ "0.4": {
4335
+ "f1": 0.044390637610976585,
4336
+ "precision": 0.02269913330581923,
4337
+ "recall": 1.0,
4338
+ "shd": 2368,
4339
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4340
+ "n_pred_edges": 2423,
4341
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4342
+ },
4343
+ "0.5": {
4344
+ "f1": 0.05004549590536852,
4345
+ "precision": 0.025664955669622024,
4346
+ "recall": 1.0,
4347
+ "shd": 2088,
4348
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4349
+ "n_pred_edges": 2143,
4350
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4351
+ },
4352
+ "0.6": {
4353
+ "f1": 0.05804749340369393,
4354
+ "precision": 0.029891304347826088,
4355
+ "recall": 1.0,
4356
+ "shd": 1785,
4357
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4358
+ "n_pred_edges": 1840,
4359
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4360
+ },
4361
+ "0.7": {
4362
+ "f1": 0.07033248081841433,
4363
+ "precision": 0.03644797879390325,
4364
+ "recall": 1.0,
4365
+ "shd": 1454,
4366
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4367
+ "n_pred_edges": 1509,
4368
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4369
+ },
4370
+ "0.8": {
4371
+ "f1": 0.09166666666666667,
4372
+ "precision": 0.048034934497816595,
4373
+ "recall": 1.0,
4374
+ "shd": 1090,
4375
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4376
+ "n_pred_edges": 1145,
4377
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4378
+ },
4379
+ "0.9": {
4380
+ "f1": 0.14341590612777053,
4381
+ "precision": 0.07724719101123595,
4382
+ "recall": 1.0,
4383
+ "shd": 657,
4384
+ "auroc": 0.997405270544207,
4385
+ "n_pred_edges": 712,
4386
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4387
+ }
4388
+ }
4389
+ },
4390
+ "PCMCI": {
4391
+ "f1": 0.0,
4392
+ "precision": 0.0,
4393
+ "recall": 0.0,
4394
+ "shd": 55,
4395
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4396
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4397
+ "n_true_edges": 55,
4398
+ "time_s": 24.643292143009603,
4399
+ "best_threshold": 0.15,
4400
+ "best_f1": 1.0,
4401
+ "best_precision": 1.0,
4402
+ "best_recall": 1.0,
4403
+ "threshold_sweep": {
4404
+ "0.01": {
4405
+ "f1": 0.036826247070639445,
4406
+ "precision": 0.018758526603001365,
4407
+ "recall": 1.0,
4408
+ "shd": 2877,
4409
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4410
+ "n_pred_edges": 2932,
4411
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4412
+ },
4413
+ "0.02": {
4414
+ "f1": 0.040160642570281124,
4415
+ "precision": 0.020491803278688523,
4416
+ "recall": 1.0,
4417
+ "shd": 2629,
4418
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4419
+ "n_pred_edges": 2684,
4420
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4421
+ },
4422
+ "0.05": {
4423
+ "f1": 0.102803738317757,
4424
+ "precision": 0.054187192118226604,
4425
+ "recall": 1.0,
4426
+ "shd": 960,
4427
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4428
+ "n_pred_edges": 1015,
4429
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4430
+ },
4431
+ "0.1": {
4432
+ "f1": 0.8396946564885496,
4433
+ "precision": 0.7236842105263158,
4434
+ "recall": 1.0,
4435
+ "shd": 21,
4436
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4437
+ "n_pred_edges": 76,
4438
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4439
+ },
4440
+ "0.15": {
4441
+ "f1": 1.0,
4442
+ "precision": 1.0,
4443
+ "recall": 1.0,
4444
+ "shd": 0,
4445
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4446
+ "n_pred_edges": 55,
4447
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4448
+ },
4449
+ "0.2": {
4450
+ "f1": 0.9,
4451
+ "precision": 1.0,
4452
+ "recall": 0.8181818181818182,
4453
+ "shd": 10,
4454
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4455
+ "n_pred_edges": 45,
4456
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4457
+ },
4458
+ "0.3": {
4459
+ "f1": 0.03571428571428572,
4460
+ "precision": 1.0,
4461
+ "recall": 0.01818181818181818,
4462
+ "shd": 54,
4463
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4464
+ "n_pred_edges": 1,
4465
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4466
+ },
4467
+ "0.4": {
4468
+ "f1": 0.0,
4469
+ "precision": 0.0,
4470
+ "recall": 0.0,
4471
+ "shd": 55,
4472
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4473
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4474
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4475
+ },
4476
+ "0.5": {
4477
+ "f1": 0.0,
4478
+ "precision": 0.0,
4479
+ "recall": 0.0,
4480
+ "shd": 55,
4481
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4482
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4483
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4484
+ },
4485
+ "0.6": {
4486
+ "f1": 0.0,
4487
+ "precision": 0.0,
4488
+ "recall": 0.0,
4489
+ "shd": 55,
4490
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4491
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4492
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4493
+ },
4494
+ "0.7": {
4495
+ "f1": 0.0,
4496
+ "precision": 0.0,
4497
+ "recall": 0.0,
4498
+ "shd": 55,
4499
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4500
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4501
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4502
+ },
4503
+ "0.8": {
4504
+ "f1": 0.0,
4505
+ "precision": 0.0,
4506
+ "recall": 0.0,
4507
+ "shd": 55,
4508
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4509
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4510
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4511
+ },
4512
+ "0.9": {
4513
+ "f1": 0.0,
4514
+ "precision": 0.0,
4515
+ "recall": 0.0,
4516
+ "shd": 55,
4517
+ "auroc": 1.0,
4518
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4519
+ "n_true_edges": 55
4520
+ }
4521
+ }
4522
+ }
4523
+ },
4524
+ "CAUSAL_RIVERS": {
4525
+ "TCPFN": {
4526
+ "f1": 0.3188405797101449,
4527
+ "precision": 0.19213973799126638,
4528
+ "recall": 0.9361702127659575,
4529
+ "shd": 188,
4530
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4531
+ "n_pred_edges": 229,
4532
+ "n_true_edges": 47,
4533
+ "time_s": 839.9077468570322,
4534
+ "best_threshold": 0.8,
4535
+ "best_f1": 0.42857142857142855,
4536
+ "best_precision": 0.4117647058823529,
4537
+ "best_recall": 0.44680851063829785,
4538
+ "threshold_sweep": {
4539
+ "0.01": {
4540
+ "f1": 0.041246160596752963,
4541
+ "precision": 0.021057347670250897,
4542
+ "recall": 1.0,
4543
+ "shd": 2185,
4544
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4545
+ "n_pred_edges": 2232,
4546
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4547
+ },
4548
+ "0.02": {
4549
+ "f1": 0.043438077634011085,
4550
+ "precision": 0.022201228153046763,
4551
+ "recall": 1.0,
4552
+ "shd": 2070,
4553
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4554
+ "n_pred_edges": 2117,
4555
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4556
+ },
4557
+ "0.05": {
4558
+ "f1": 0.04867944070429829,
4559
+ "precision": 0.024946921443736732,
4560
+ "recall": 1.0,
4561
+ "shd": 1837,
4562
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4563
+ "n_pred_edges": 1884,
4564
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4565
+ },
4566
+ "0.1": {
4567
+ "f1": 0.05905006418485237,
4568
+ "precision": 0.03044341495698213,
4569
+ "recall": 0.9787234042553191,
4570
+ "shd": 1466,
4571
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4572
+ "n_pred_edges": 1511,
4573
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4574
+ },
4575
+ "0.15": {
4576
+ "f1": 0.07261247040252565,
4577
+ "precision": 0.03770491803278689,
4578
+ "recall": 0.9787234042553191,
4579
+ "shd": 1175,
4580
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4581
+ "n_pred_edges": 1220,
4582
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4583
+ },
4584
+ "0.2": {
4585
+ "f1": 0.09099901088031652,
4586
+ "precision": 0.04771784232365145,
4587
+ "recall": 0.9787234042553191,
4588
+ "shd": 919,
4589
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4590
+ "n_pred_edges": 964,
4591
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4592
+ },
4593
+ "0.3": {
4594
+ "f1": 0.1361573373676248,
4595
+ "precision": 0.0732899022801303,
4596
+ "recall": 0.9574468085106383,
4597
+ "shd": 571,
4598
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4599
+ "n_pred_edges": 614,
4600
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4601
+ },
4602
+ "0.4": {
4603
+ "f1": 0.2137767220902613,
4604
+ "precision": 0.12032085561497326,
4605
+ "recall": 0.9574468085106383,
4606
+ "shd": 331,
4607
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4608
+ "n_pred_edges": 374,
4609
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4610
+ },
4611
+ "0.5": {
4612
+ "f1": 0.3188405797101449,
4613
+ "precision": 0.19213973799126638,
4614
+ "recall": 0.9361702127659575,
4615
+ "shd": 188,
4616
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4617
+ "n_pred_edges": 229,
4618
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4619
+ },
4620
+ "0.6": {
4621
+ "f1": 0.40201005025125625,
4622
+ "precision": 0.2631578947368421,
4623
+ "recall": 0.851063829787234,
4624
+ "shd": 119,
4625
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4626
+ "n_pred_edges": 152,
4627
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4628
+ },
4629
+ "0.7": {
4630
+ "f1": 0.42028985507246375,
4631
+ "precision": 0.31868131868131866,
4632
+ "recall": 0.6170212765957447,
4633
+ "shd": 80,
4634
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4635
+ "n_pred_edges": 91,
4636
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4637
+ },
4638
+ "0.8": {
4639
+ "f1": 0.42857142857142855,
4640
+ "precision": 0.4117647058823529,
4641
+ "recall": 0.44680851063829785,
4642
+ "shd": 56,
4643
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4644
+ "n_pred_edges": 51,
4645
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4646
+ },
4647
+ "0.9": {
4648
+ "f1": 0.28125,
4649
+ "precision": 0.5294117647058824,
4650
+ "recall": 0.19148936170212766,
4651
+ "shd": 46,
4652
+ "auroc": 0.9551640773239071,
4653
+ "n_pred_edges": 17,
4654
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4655
+ }
4656
+ }
4657
+ },
4658
+ "Granger": {
4659
+ "f1": 0.04676616915422886,
4660
+ "precision": 0.023942944472745798,
4661
+ "recall": 1.0,
4662
+ "shd": 1916,
4663
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4664
+ "n_pred_edges": 1963,
4665
+ "n_true_edges": 47,
4666
+ "time_s": 10.070944402134046,
4667
+ "best_threshold": 0.9,
4668
+ "best_f1": 0.07442596991290579,
4669
+ "best_precision": 0.038651315789473686,
4670
+ "best_recall": 1.0,
4671
+ "threshold_sweep": {
4672
+ "0.01": {
4673
+ "f1": 0.04081632653061225,
4674
+ "precision": 0.020833333333333332,
4675
+ "recall": 1.0,
4676
+ "shd": 2209,
4677
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4678
+ "n_pred_edges": 2256,
4679
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4680
+ },
4681
+ "0.02": {
4682
+ "f1": 0.04081632653061225,
4683
+ "precision": 0.020833333333333332,
4684
+ "recall": 1.0,
4685
+ "shd": 2209,
4686
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4687
+ "n_pred_edges": 2256,
4688
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4689
+ },
4690
+ "0.05": {
4691
+ "f1": 0.040905134899912966,
4692
+ "precision": 0.02087960906263883,
4693
+ "recall": 1.0,
4694
+ "shd": 2204,
4695
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4696
+ "n_pred_edges": 2251,
4697
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4698
+ },
4699
+ "0.1": {
4700
+ "f1": 0.04108391608391609,
4701
+ "precision": 0.020972780008924587,
4702
+ "recall": 1.0,
4703
+ "shd": 2194,
4704
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4705
+ "n_pred_edges": 2241,
4706
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4707
+ },
4708
+ "0.15": {
4709
+ "f1": 0.04135503739551254,
4710
+ "precision": 0.021114106019766397,
4711
+ "recall": 1.0,
4712
+ "shd": 2179,
4713
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4714
+ "n_pred_edges": 2226,
4715
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4716
+ },
4717
+ "0.2": {
4718
+ "f1": 0.0417036379769299,
4719
+ "precision": 0.021295876755777075,
4720
+ "recall": 1.0,
4721
+ "shd": 2160,
4722
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4723
+ "n_pred_edges": 2207,
4724
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4725
+ },
4726
+ "0.3": {
4727
+ "f1": 0.042766151046405826,
4728
+ "precision": 0.02185030218503022,
4729
+ "recall": 1.0,
4730
+ "shd": 2104,
4731
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4732
+ "n_pred_edges": 2151,
4733
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4734
+ },
4735
+ "0.4": {
4736
+ "f1": 0.04446546830652791,
4737
+ "precision": 0.022738268021286888,
4738
+ "recall": 1.0,
4739
+ "shd": 2020,
4740
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4741
+ "n_pred_edges": 2067,
4742
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4743
+ },
4744
+ "0.5": {
4745
+ "f1": 0.04676616915422886,
4746
+ "precision": 0.023942944472745798,
4747
+ "recall": 1.0,
4748
+ "shd": 1916,
4749
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4750
+ "n_pred_edges": 1963,
4751
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4752
+ },
4753
+ "0.6": {
4754
+ "f1": 0.04994686503719447,
4755
+ "precision": 0.02561307901907357,
4756
+ "recall": 1.0,
4757
+ "shd": 1788,
4758
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4759
+ "n_pred_edges": 1835,
4760
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4761
+ },
4762
+ "0.7": {
4763
+ "f1": 0.05468295520651542,
4764
+ "precision": 0.028110047846889953,
4765
+ "recall": 1.0,
4766
+ "shd": 1625,
4767
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4768
+ "n_pred_edges": 1672,
4769
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4770
+ },
4771
+ "0.8": {
4772
+ "f1": 0.06064516129032259,
4773
+ "precision": 0.03127079174983367,
4774
+ "recall": 1.0,
4775
+ "shd": 1456,
4776
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4777
+ "n_pred_edges": 1503,
4778
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4779
+ },
4780
+ "0.9": {
4781
+ "f1": 0.07442596991290579,
4782
+ "precision": 0.038651315789473686,
4783
+ "recall": 1.0,
4784
+ "shd": 1169,
4785
+ "auroc": 0.9376197952284177,
4786
+ "n_pred_edges": 1216,
4787
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4788
+ }
4789
+ }
4790
+ },
4791
+ "PCMCI": {
4792
+ "f1": 0.0,
4793
+ "precision": 0.0,
4794
+ "recall": 0.0,
4795
+ "shd": 47,
4796
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4797
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4798
+ "n_true_edges": 47,
4799
+ "time_s": 21.8234854710754,
4800
+ "best_threshold": 0.15,
4801
+ "best_f1": 0.9555555555555556,
4802
+ "best_precision": 1.0,
4803
+ "best_recall": 0.9148936170212766,
4804
+ "threshold_sweep": {
4805
+ "0.01": {
4806
+ "f1": 0.04130052724077329,
4807
+ "precision": 0.021085688649618663,
4808
+ "recall": 1.0,
4809
+ "shd": 2182,
4810
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4811
+ "n_pred_edges": 2229,
4812
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4813
+ },
4814
+ "0.02": {
4815
+ "f1": 0.045105566218809984,
4816
+ "precision": 0.023073146784486992,
4817
+ "recall": 1.0,
4818
+ "shd": 1990,
4819
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4820
+ "n_pred_edges": 2037,
4821
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4822
+ },
4823
+ "0.05": {
4824
+ "f1": 0.10693970420932879,
4825
+ "precision": 0.056490384615384616,
4826
+ "recall": 1.0,
4827
+ "shd": 785,
4828
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4829
+ "n_pred_edges": 832,
4830
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4831
+ },
4832
+ "0.1": {
4833
+ "f1": 0.8035714285714286,
4834
+ "precision": 0.6923076923076923,
4835
+ "recall": 0.9574468085106383,
4836
+ "shd": 22,
4837
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4838
+ "n_pred_edges": 65,
4839
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4840
+ },
4841
+ "0.15": {
4842
+ "f1": 0.9555555555555556,
4843
+ "precision": 1.0,
4844
+ "recall": 0.9148936170212766,
4845
+ "shd": 4,
4846
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4847
+ "n_pred_edges": 43,
4848
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4849
+ },
4850
+ "0.2": {
4851
+ "f1": 0.8941176470588235,
4852
+ "precision": 1.0,
4853
+ "recall": 0.8085106382978723,
4854
+ "shd": 9,
4855
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4856
+ "n_pred_edges": 38,
4857
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4858
+ },
4859
+ "0.3": {
4860
+ "f1": 0.25925925925925924,
4861
+ "precision": 1.0,
4862
+ "recall": 0.14893617021276595,
4863
+ "shd": 40,
4864
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4865
+ "n_pred_edges": 7,
4866
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4867
+ },
4868
+ "0.4": {
4869
+ "f1": 0.0,
4870
+ "precision": 0.0,
4871
+ "recall": 0.0,
4872
+ "shd": 47,
4873
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4874
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4875
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4876
+ },
4877
+ "0.5": {
4878
+ "f1": 0.0,
4879
+ "precision": 0.0,
4880
+ "recall": 0.0,
4881
+ "shd": 47,
4882
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4883
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4884
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4885
+ },
4886
+ "0.6": {
4887
+ "f1": 0.0,
4888
+ "precision": 0.0,
4889
+ "recall": 0.0,
4890
+ "shd": 47,
4891
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4892
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4893
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4894
+ },
4895
+ "0.7": {
4896
+ "f1": 0.0,
4897
+ "precision": 0.0,
4898
+ "recall": 0.0,
4899
+ "shd": 47,
4900
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4901
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4902
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4903
+ },
4904
+ "0.8": {
4905
+ "f1": 0.0,
4906
+ "precision": 0.0,
4907
+ "recall": 0.0,
4908
+ "shd": 47,
4909
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4910
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4911
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4912
+ },
4913
+ "0.9": {
4914
+ "f1": 0.0,
4915
+ "precision": 0.0,
4916
+ "recall": 0.0,
4917
+ "shd": 47,
4918
+ "auroc": 0.9963784517881394,
4919
+ "n_pred_edges": 0,
4920
+ "n_true_edges": 47
4921
+ }
4922
+ }
4923
+ }
4924
  }
4925
  }