File size: 16,738 Bytes
d574a3d | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 | # Phase 3 Plan: Multi-Round Conflict Resolution Tracking
## Overview
**Goal**: Track how conflicts evolve across multiple debate rounds, measure resolution effectiveness, and build data for conflict-resolution strategies.
**Why Phase 3?**: Phase 1 detected conflicts (single round), Phase 2 learned which adapters performed best. Phase 3 closes the loop: measure if conflicts are *actually resolved* and which agents/strategies work best.
**Scope**: Medium (3-4 hours implementation + testing)
---
## Architecture: Multi-Round Conflict Tracking
### Current State (Phase 1-2)
- **Round 0**: Detect conflicts (70 detected)
- **Round 1**: Debate → Store conflicts in memory
- **End of cycle**: No tracking of conflict *evolution*
### Phase 3: Conflict Evolution Tracking
```
Round 0: Detect conflicts
├─ conflictA: Newton vs Quantum (emphasis, strength=0.15)
├─ conflictB: Philosophy vs DaVinci (framework, strength=0.12)
└─ ...
↓
Round 1: Debate responses
├─ Did agents address conflictA? (addressing yes/no)
├─ Did positions soften? (softening yes/no)
└─ Did conflict persist/worsen? (new_strength=0.10)
↓
Round 2: Follow-up analysis
├─ conflictA: NEW strength=0.08 (RESOLVED: 46% improvement)
├─ conflictB: NEW strength=0.14 (WORSENED: +17%)
└─ ...
↓
Metrics per conflict:
- resolution_path: [R0: 0.15, R1: 0.10, R2: 0.08] (improving)
- resolution_rate: (0.15 - 0.08) / 0.15 = 46%
- resolution_type: "soft_consensus" vs "hard_victory" vs "unresolved"
- agent_contribution: Which agents moved positions?
```
---
## Implementation Components
### 1. ConflictEvolution Dataclass (NEW)
**Path**: `reasoning_forge/conflict_engine.py`
```python
@dataclass
class ConflictEvolution:
"""Track how a conflict changes across debate rounds."""
original_conflict: Conflict # From Round 0
round_trajectories: Dict[int, Dict] # {round: {strength, agents, addressing_score, softening_score}}
resolution_rate: float # (initial - final) / initial
resolution_type: str # "hard_victory" | "soft_consensus" | "stalled" | "worsened"
resolved_in_round: int # Which round did it resolve? (-1 if not resolved)
adaptive_suggestions: List[str] # "Try adapter X", "Reframe as Y", etc.
def __post_init__(self):
if not self.round_trajectories:
self.round_trajectories = {}
if self.resolution_rate == 0.0:
self.resolution_rate = self._compute_resolution_rate()
def _compute_resolution_rate(self) -> float:
"""Calculate (initial - final) / initial."""
if not self.round_trajectories or 0 not in self.round_trajectories:
return 0.0
initial_strength = self.round_trajectories[0].get("strength", 0)
final_strength = min(self.round_trajectories.values(),
key=lambda x: x.get("strength", float('inf'))).get("strength", 0)
if initial_strength == 0:
return 0.0
return (initial_strength - final_strength) / initial_strength
```
### 2. ConflictTracker Class (NEW)
**Path**: `reasoning_forge/conflict_engine.py` (add to existing file)
```python
class ConflictTracker:
"""Track conflicts across multiple debate rounds."""
def __init__(self, conflict_engine):
self.conflict_engine = conflict_engine
self.evolution_data: Dict[str, ConflictEvolution] = {} # key: conflict anchor
def track_round(self, round_num: int, agent_analyses: Dict[str, str],
previous_round_conflicts: List[Conflict]) -> List[ConflictEvolution]:
"""
Track how previous round's conflicts evolved in this round.
Returns:
List of ConflictEvolution objects with updated metrics
"""
# Detect conflicts in current round
current_round_conflicts = self.conflict_engine.detect_conflicts(agent_analyses)
evolutions = []
for prev_conflict in previous_round_conflicts:
# Find matching conflict in current round (by agents and claim overlap)
matches = self._find_matching_conflicts(prev_conflict, current_round_conflicts)
if matches:
# Conflict still exists (may have changed strength)
current_conflict = matches[0]
evolution = self._compute_evolution(
prev_conflict, current_conflict, round_num, agent_analyses
)
else:
# Conflict resolved (no longer detected)
evolution = self._mark_resolved(prev_conflict, round_num)
evolutions.append(evolution)
# Track any new conflicts introduced this round
new_conflicts = self._find_new_conflicts(previous_round_conflicts, current_round_conflicts)
for new_conflict in new_conflicts:
evolution = ConflictEvolution(
original_conflict=new_conflict,
round_trajectories={round_num: {
"strength": new_conflict.conflict_strength,
"addressing_score": 0.0,
"softening_score": 0.0,
}},
resolution_rate=0.0,
resolution_type="new",
resolved_in_round=-1,
)
evolutions.append(evolution)
return evolutions
def _find_matching_conflicts(self, conflict: Conflict,
candidates: List[Conflict]) -> List[Conflict]:
"""Find conflicts from previous round that likely match current round conflicts."""
matches = []
for candidate in candidates:
# Match if same agent pair + similar claims
if ((conflict.agent_a == candidate.agent_a and conflict.agent_b == candidate.agent_b) or
(conflict.agent_a == candidate.agent_b and conflict.agent_b == candidate.agent_a)):
# Compute claim similarity
overlap = self.conflict_engine._compute_semantic_overlap(
conflict.claim_a, candidate.claim_a
)
if overlap > 0.5: # Threshold for "same conflict"
matches.append(candidate)
return matches
def _compute_evolution(self, prev_conflict: Conflict, current_conflict: Conflict,
round_num: int, agent_analyses: Dict[str, str]) -> ConflictEvolution:
"""Compute how conflict evolved."""
# Check if agents addressed each other's claims
addressing_a = self.conflict_engine._is_claim_addressed(
prev_conflict.claim_b, agent_analyses.get(current_conflict.agent_a, "")
)
addressing_b = self.conflict_engine._is_claim_addressed(
prev_conflict.claim_a, agent_analyses.get(current_conflict.agent_b, "")
)
addressing_score = (addressing_a + addressing_b) / 2.0
# Check if agents softened positions
softening_a = self.conflict_engine._is_claim_softened(
prev_conflict.claim_a, agent_analyses.get(current_conflict.agent_a, "")
)
softening_b = self.conflict_engine._is_claim_softened(
prev_conflict.claim_b, agent_analyses.get(current_conflict.agent_b, "")
)
softening_score = (softening_a + softening_b) / 2.0
# Determine resolution type
strength_delta = prev_conflict.conflict_strength - current_conflict.conflict_strength
if strength_delta > prev_conflict.conflict_strength * 0.5:
resolution_type = "hard_victory" # Strength dropped >50%
elif strength_delta > 0.1:
resolution_type = "soft_consensus" # Strength decreased
elif abs(strength_delta) < 0.05:
resolution_type = "stalled" # No change
else:
resolution_type = "worsened" # Strength increased
# Accumulate trajectory
key = prev_conflict.agent_a + "_vs_" + prev_conflict.agent_b
if key not in self.evolution_data:
self.evolution_data[key] = ConflictEvolution(
original_conflict=prev_conflict,
round_trajectories={0: {
"strength": prev_conflict.conflict_strength,
"addressing_score": 0.0,
"softening_score": 0.0,
}},
resolution_rate=0.0,
resolution_type="new",
resolved_in_round=-1,
)
self.evolution_data[key].round_trajectories[round_num] = {
"strength": current_conflict.conflict_strength,
"addressing_score": addressing_score,
"softening_score": softening_score,
"agents": [current_conflict.agent_a, current_conflict.agent_b],
}
self.evolution_data[key].resolution_rate = self.evolution_data[key]._compute_resolution_rate()
self.evolution_data[key].resolution_type = resolution_type
return self.evolution_data[key]
def _mark_resolved(self, conflict: Conflict, round_num: int) -> ConflictEvolution:
"""Mark a conflict as resolved (no longer appears in current round)."""
key = conflict.agent_a + "_vs_" + conflict.agent_b
if key not in self.evolution_data:
self.evolution_data[key] = ConflictEvolution(
original_conflict=conflict,
round_trajectories={0: {
"strength": conflict.conflict_strength,
"addressing_score": 0.0,
"softening_score": 0.0,
}},
resolution_rate=1.0,
resolution_type="resolved",
resolved_in_round=round_num,
)
# Add final round with 0 strength
self.evolution_data[key].round_trajectories[round_num] = {
"strength": 0.0,
"addressing_score": 1.0,
"softening_score": 1.0,
}
return self.evolution_data[key]
def _find_new_conflicts(self, previous: List[Conflict],
current: List[Conflict]) -> List[Conflict]:
"""Find conflicts that are new (not in previous round)."""
prev_pairs = {(c.agent_a, c.agent_b) for c in previous}
new = []
for conflict in current:
pair = (conflict.agent_a, conflict.agent_b)
if pair not in prev_pairs:
new.append(conflict)
return new
def get_summary(self) -> Dict:
"""Get summary of all conflict evolutions."""
resolved = [e for e in self.evolution_data.values() if e.resolution_type == "resolved"]
improving = [e for e in self.evolution_data.values() if e.resolution_type in ["hard_victory", "soft_consensus"]]
worsened = [e for e in self.evolution_data.values() if e.resolution_type == "worsened"]
avg_resolution = sum(e.resolution_rate for e in self.evolution_data.values()) / max(len(self.evolution_data), 1)
return {
"total_conflicts_tracked": len(self.evolution_data),
"resolved": len(resolved),
"improving": len(improving),
"worsened": len(worsened),
"avg_resolution_rate": avg_resolution,
"resolution_types": {
"resolved": len(resolved),
"hard_victory": len([e for e in self.evolution_data.values() if e.resolution_type == "hard_victory"]),
"soft_consensus": len([e for e in self.evolution_data.values() if e.resolution_type == "soft_consensus"]),
"stalled": len([e for e in self.evolution_data.values() if e.resolution_type == "stalled"]),
"worsened": len(worsened),
},
}
```
### 3. Integration into ForgeEngine (MODIFY)
**Path**: `reasoning_forge/forge_engine.py`
Modify `forge_with_debate()` to support multi-round tracking:
```python
def forge_with_debate(self, concept: str, debate_rounds: int = 2) -> dict:
"""Run forge with multi-turn agent debate and conflict tracking."""
# ... existing code ...
# NEW Phase 3: Initialize conflict tracker
tracker = ConflictTracker(self.conflict_engine)
# Round 0: Initial analyses + conflict detection
conflicts_round_0 = self.conflict_engine.detect_conflicts(analyses)
tracker.track_round(0, analyses, []) # Track R0 conflicts
# ... existing code ...
# Multi-round debate loop (now can handle 2+ rounds)
round_conflicts = conflicts_round_0
for round_num in range(1, min(debate_rounds + 1, 4)): # Cap at 3 rounds for now
# ... agent debate code ...
# NEW: Track conflicts for this round
round_evolutions = tracker.track_round(round_num, analyses, round_conflicts)
# Store evolution data
debate_log.append({
"round": round_num,
"type": "debate",
"conflict_evolutions": [
{
"agents": f"{e.original_conflict.agent_a}_vs_{e.original_conflict.agent_b}",
"initial_strength": e.original_conflict.conflict_strength,
"current_strength": e.round_trajectories[round_num]["strength"],
"resolution_type": e.resolution_type,
"resolution_rate": e.resolution_rate,
}
for e in round_evolutions
],
})
# Update for next round
round_conflicts = self.conflict_engine.detect_conflicts(analyses)
# Return with Phase 3 metrics
return {
"messages": [...],
"metadata": {
... # existing metadata ...
"phase_3_metrics": tracker.get_summary(),
"evolution_data": [
{
"agents": key,
"resolved_in_round": e.resolved_in_round,
"resolution_rate": e.resolution_rate,
"trajectory": e.round_trajectories,
}
for key, e in tracker.evolution_data.items()
],
}
}
```
---
## Testing Plan
### Unit Tests
1. ConflictEvolution dataclass creation
2. ConflictTracker.track_round() with mock conflicts
3. Resolution rate computation
4. Evolution type classification (hard_victory vs soft_consensus, etc.)
### E2E Test
1. Run forge_with_debate() with 3 rounds
2. Verify conflicts tracked across all rounds
3. Check resolution_rate computed correctly
4. Validate evolved conflicts stored in memory
---
## Expected Outputs
**Per-Conflict Evolution**:
```
Conflict: Newton vs Quantum (emphasis)
Round 0: strength = 0.15
Round 1: strength = 0.12 (addressing=0.8, softening=0.6) → soft_consensus
Round 2: strength = 0.08 (addressing=0.9, softening=0.9) → hard_victory
Resolution: 46% (0.15→0.08)
Type: hard_victory (>50% strength reduction)
Resolved: ✓ Round 2
```
**Summary Metrics**:
```
Total conflicts tracked: 70
Resolved: 18 (26%)
Hard victory: 15 (21%)
Soft consensus: 22 (31%)
Stalled: 10 (14%)
Worsened: 5 (7%)
Average resolution rate: 0.32 (32% improvement)
```
---
## Success Criteria
- [x] ConflictEvolution dataclass stores trajectory
- [x] ConflictTracker tracks conflicts across rounds
- [x] Resolution types classified correctly
- [x] Multi-round debate runs without errors
- [x] Evolution data stored in memory with performance metrics
- [x] Metrics returned in metadata
- [x] E2E test passes with 3-round debate
---
## Timeline
- **Part 1** (30 min): Implement ConflictEvolution + ConflictTracker
- **Part 2** (20 min): Integrate into ForgeEngine
- **Part 3** (20 min): Write unit + E2E tests
- **Part 4** (10 min): Update PHASE3_SUMMARY.md
**Total**: ~80 minutes
---
## What This Enables for Phase 4+
1. **Adaptive Conflict Resolution**: Choose debate strategy based on conflict type (hard contradictions need X, soft emphases need Y)
2. **Agent Specialization**: Identify which agents resolve which conflict types best
3. **Conflict Weighting**: Prioritize resolving high-impact conflicts first
4. **Predictive Resolution**: Train classifier to predict which conflicts will resolve in how many rounds
5. **Recursive Convergence Boost**: Feed evolution data back into RC+xi coherence/tension metrics
|