{
  "status": "selected_for_fresh_qualification",
  "selected_batch": 2,
  "selected_source_root": "work/mlx-native-q3-v1",
  "weights_unchanged": true,
  "selection_data": "Exposed AMI IS1000a only; reserved11 results not reused for selection",
  "cases": [
    {
      "batch": 4,
      "report": "/Users/Ajab/conductor/workspaces/visualears/experiments/audio8-ternary/reports/mlx-native-q3-stream-v1/verification.json",
      "report_sha256": "0d9e39bf29670fd54631b693e51a0cd8873105989a47239b588d0273a53255cc",
      "generated_ids_sha256": "72f994120072e2b864ea8de08e44195efe481d10a74dedf2e78bd4a1a5eea4b3",
      "word_errors": {
        "hits": 303,
        "substitutions": 39,
        "deletions": 136,
        "insertions": 4,
        "reference_units": 478,
        "hypothesis_units": 346,
        "errors": 179,
        "error_rate": 0.37447698744769875
      },
      "matched_word_timing": {
        "measured": true,
        "actual_arrival_paced": true,
        "timing_basis": "Independent host receipt of flushed JSONL since paced20ms producer start; all source words retained",
        "correctly_matched_units": 303,
        "ambiguous_matched_units": 9,
        "ambiguity_method": "all minimum unit-cost Levenshtein paths, without timing-based selection",
        "unambiguous_matched_units": 294,
        "unambiguous_maximum_seconds": 5.586898207997422,
        "unmatched_reference_units": 175,
        "matched_reference_fraction": 0.6338912133891214,
        "min_seconds": -2.193736457971383,
        "p50_seconds": 0.6946411670209045,
        "p95_seconds": 0.8736333750304794,
        "maximum_seconds": 5.586898207997422,
        "matched_units_above_one_second": 4,
        "all_matched_units_within_one_second": null,
        "whole_release_pass": false,
        "limitation": "Lag summaries use one deterministic text alignment and are descriptive when alternative optimal alignments exist. Only unambiguous matches can support per-word timing claims. Omissions/substitutions remain errors, never zero-latency successes. Published reference timing uncertainty and overlapping-speaker word order are not independently corrected."
      },
      "causal_timing_audit": {
        "count": 293,
        "p95_seconds": 0.8712869580299412,
        "max_seconds": 1.1078053750237586,
        "above_one_second": 2
      },
      "cross_reset_matches": 1,
      "mature_work_rtf": 0.7764502045640678
    },
    {
      "batch": 2,
      "report": "/Users/Ajab/conductor/workspaces/visualears/experiments/audio8-ternary/reports/mlx-native-q3-b2-exposed-v1/run.json",
      "report_sha256": "789a6658c508b70aba1060c3cdd0412b87bd7b35e4793d47f8cb45e4c46c61e5",
      "generated_ids_sha256": "3d3130b78aad7aa764dfbf1aeae3591847f84f89379f03fb6eab9a072cb6d18c",
      "word_errors": {
        "hits": 302,
        "substitutions": 39,
        "deletions": 137,
        "insertions": 3,
        "reference_units": 478,
        "hypothesis_units": 344,
        "errors": 179,
        "error_rate": 0.37447698744769875
      },
      "matched_word_timing": {
        "measured": true,
        "actual_arrival_paced": true,
        "timing_basis": "Independent host receipt of flushed JSONL since paced20ms producer start; all source words retained",
        "correctly_matched_units": 302,
        "ambiguous_matched_units": 8,
        "ambiguity_method": "all minimum unit-cost Levenshtein paths, without timing-based selection",
        "unambiguous_matched_units": 294,
        "unambiguous_maximum_seconds": 5.489463750023845,
        "unmatched_reference_units": 176,
        "matched_reference_fraction": 0.6317991631799164,
        "min_seconds": -2.2680539579666146,
        "p50_seconds": 0.5616992500261517,
        "p95_seconds": 0.7167164999945186,
        "maximum_seconds": 5.489463750023845,
        "matched_units_above_one_second": 1,
        "all_matched_units_within_one_second": null,
        "whole_release_pass": false,
        "limitation": "Lag summaries use one deterministic text alignment and are descriptive when alternative optimal alignments exist. Only unambiguous matches can support per-word timing claims. Omissions/substitutions remain errors, never zero-latency successes. Published reference timing uncertainty and overlapping-speaker word order are not independently corrected."
      },
      "causal_timing_audit": {
        "count": 293,
        "p95_seconds": 0.7042127919802397,
        "max_seconds": 0.9364958749921044,
        "above_one_second": 0
      },
      "cross_reset_matches": 1,
      "mature_work_rtf": 0.8644507736555196
    },
    {
      "batch": 3,
      "report": "/Users/Ajab/conductor/workspaces/visualears/experiments/audio8-ternary/reports/mlx-native-q3-b3-exposed-v2/run.json",
      "report_sha256": "ac20ccdcf5eb13b28227de3428465c6caac31f1e21032b2037b16308f43e5cd3",
      "generated_ids_sha256": "3d3130b78aad7aa764dfbf1aeae3591847f84f89379f03fb6eab9a072cb6d18c",
      "word_errors": {
        "hits": 302,
        "substitutions": 39,
        "deletions": 137,
        "insertions": 3,
        "reference_units": 478,
        "hypothesis_units": 344,
        "errors": 179,
        "error_rate": 0.37447698744769875
      },
      "matched_word_timing": {
        "measured": true,
        "actual_arrival_paced": true,
        "timing_basis": "Independent host receipt of flushed JSONL since paced20ms producer start; all source words retained",
        "correctly_matched_units": 302,
        "ambiguous_matched_units": 8,
        "ambiguity_method": "all minimum unit-cost Levenshtein paths, without timing-based selection",
        "unambiguous_matched_units": 294,
        "unambiguous_maximum_seconds": 5.515487207956596,
        "unmatched_reference_units": 176,
        "matched_reference_fraction": 0.6317991631799164,
        "min_seconds": -2.1270811670180336,
        "p50_seconds": 0.6239733329950923,
        "p95_seconds": 0.7859231659909938,
        "maximum_seconds": 5.515487207956596,
        "matched_units_above_one_second": 4,
        "all_matched_units_within_one_second": null,
        "whole_release_pass": false,
        "limitation": "Lag summaries use one deterministic text alignment and are descriptive when alternative optimal alignments exist. Only unambiguous matches can support per-word timing claims. Omissions/substitutions remain errors, never zero-latency successes. Published reference timing uncertainty and overlapping-speaker word order are not independently corrected."
      },
      "causal_timing_audit": {
        "count": 293,
        "p95_seconds": 0.7846965410071789,
        "max_seconds": 1.0496153329871731,
        "above_one_second": 2
      },
      "cross_reset_matches": 1,
      "mature_work_rtf": 0.8001077809603885
    }
  ],
  "reason": "Batch2 and batch3 have identical tokens. All three batches have179/478 errors, but batch2/3 have one more deletion and one fewer insertion than batch4. Batch2 has the lowest delay and no >1 second same-session unambiguous match in this exposed diagnostic while mature RTF remains below1. Cross-reset textual matches remain unresolved recognition evidence, not latency successes. No universal pass inferred.",
  "new_inputs": [
    "data/continuous-v3/manifest.json",
    "data/heldout-zh-v3/manifest.json"
  ],
  "selector_sha256": "7ba7cbed4125fd7834a57ba909ca464b4d970e39487b551b567e0b4b9265acd0",
  "production_ready": false
}