{ "run": "ensemble_tfidf_modernbert", "split_scheme": "document", "alpha": 0.7, "alpha_meaning": "scores = alpha*tfidf + (1-alpha)*bert", "dev_macro_f1_at_best_alpha": 0.4745, "global_threshold": { "threshold": 0.2, "micro_f1": 0.4696, "macro_f1": 0.4504, "micro_precision": 0.3394, "micro_recall": 0.7618, "macro_precision": 0.3711, "macro_recall": 0.6685, "n_examples": 3635, "n_positive_labels": 911, "per_class": { "T1003.001": { "precision": 0.4048, "recall": 0.8095, "f1": 0.5397, "support": 21, "predicted": 42 }, "T1005": { "precision": 0.0563, "recall": 0.5, "f1": 0.1013, "support": 8, "predicted": 71 }, "T1012": { "precision": 0.1875, "recall": 0.75, "f1": 0.3, "support": 4, "predicted": 16 }, "T1016": { "precision": 0.2778, "recall": 0.4545, "f1": 0.3448, "support": 11, "predicted": 18 }, "T1021.001": { "precision": 0.3077, "recall": 1.0, "f1": 0.4706, "support": 12, "predicted": 39 }, "T1027": { "precision": 0.2917, "recall": 0.8235, "f1": 0.4308, "support": 102, "predicted": 288 }, "T1033": { "precision": 0.5, "recall": 0.9231, "f1": 0.6486, "support": 13, "predicted": 24 }, "T1036.005": { "precision": 0.2308, "recall": 0.6, "f1": 0.3333, "support": 10, "predicted": 26 }, "T1041": { "precision": 0.2105, "recall": 0.7059, "f1": 0.3243, "support": 17, "predicted": 57 }, "T1047": { "precision": 0.6579, "recall": 0.8929, "f1": 0.7576, "support": 28, "predicted": 38 }, "T1053.005": { "precision": 0.5319, "recall": 0.9615, "f1": 0.6849, "support": 26, "predicted": 47 }, "T1055": { "precision": 0.4459, "recall": 0.825, "f1": 0.5789, "support": 40, "predicted": 74 }, "T1056.001": { "precision": 0.7143, "recall": 1.0, "f1": 0.8333, "support": 15, "predicted": 21 }, "T1057": { "precision": 0.3448, "recall": 0.6667, "f1": 0.4545, "support": 15, "predicted": 29 }, "T1059.003": { "precision": 0.3154, "recall": 0.8039, "f1": 0.453, "support": 51, "predicted": 130 }, "T1068": { "precision": 1.0, "recall": 0.3333, "f1": 0.5, "support": 3, "predicted": 1 }, "T1070.004": { "precision": 0.3103, "recall": 0.75, "f1": 0.439, "support": 12, "predicted": 29 }, "T1071.001": { "precision": 0.2466, "recall": 0.8571, "f1": 0.383, "support": 21, "predicted": 73 }, "T1072": { "precision": 0.0, "recall": 0.0, "f1": 0.0, "support": 3, "predicted": 0 }, "T1074.001": { "precision": 0.1333, "recall": 0.6667, "f1": 0.2222, "support": 3, "predicted": 15 }, "T1078": { "precision": 0.1619, "recall": 0.7391, "f1": 0.2656, "support": 23, "predicted": 105 }, "T1082": { "precision": 0.2203, "recall": 0.5417, "f1": 0.3133, "support": 24, "predicted": 59 }, "T1083": { "precision": 0.2128, "recall": 0.6667, "f1": 0.3226, "support": 15, "predicted": 47 }, "T1090": { "precision": 0.3261, "recall": 0.6522, "f1": 0.4348, "support": 23, "predicted": 46 }, "T1095": { "precision": 0.3333, "recall": 0.3333, "f1": 0.3333, "support": 3, "predicted": 3 }, "T1105": { "precision": 0.3, "recall": 0.7895, "f1": 0.4348, "support": 57, "predicted": 150 }, "T1106": { "precision": 0.375, "recall": 0.7059, "f1": 0.4898, "support": 34, "predicted": 64 }, "T1110": { "precision": 0.5517, "recall": 0.8421, "f1": 0.6667, "support": 19, "predicted": 29 }, "T1112": { "precision": 0.2553, "recall": 0.8571, "f1": 0.3934, "support": 14, "predicted": 47 }, "T1113": { "precision": 0.4737, "recall": 1.0, "f1": 0.6429, "support": 9, "predicted": 19 }, "T1140": { "precision": 0.5328, "recall": 0.9559, "f1": 0.6842, "support": 68, "predicted": 122 }, "T1190": { "precision": 0.2903, "recall": 0.6, "f1": 0.3913, "support": 15, "predicted": 31 }, "T1204.002": { "precision": 0.3, "recall": 0.6, "f1": 0.4, "support": 15, "predicted": 30 }, "T1210": { "precision": 0.0, "recall": 0.0, "f1": 0.0, "support": 2, "predicted": 2 }, "T1218.011": { "precision": 0.6, "recall": 0.6429, "f1": 0.6207, "support": 14, "predicted": 15 }, "T1219": { "precision": 0.4375, "recall": 0.3684, "f1": 0.4, "support": 19, "predicted": 16 }, "T1484.001": { "precision": 0.5, "recall": 0.4, "f1": 0.4444, "support": 5, "predicted": 4 }, "T1518.001": { "precision": 0.2857, "recall": 0.5714, "f1": 0.381, "support": 7, "predicted": 14 }, "T1543.003": { "precision": 0.6667, "recall": 0.7692, "f1": 0.7143, "support": 13, "predicted": 15 }, "T1547.001": { "precision": 0.4333, "recall": 0.8125, "f1": 0.5652, "support": 16, "predicted": 30 }, "T1548.002": { "precision": 0.6667, "recall": 1.0, "f1": 0.8, "support": 2, "predicted": 3 }, "T1552.001": { "precision": 0.1667, "recall": 0.25, "f1": 0.2, "support": 4, "predicted": 6 }, "T1562.001": { "precision": 0.6176, "recall": 0.8077, "f1": 0.7, "support": 26, "predicted": 34 }, "T1564.001": { "precision": 0.5, "recall": 0.6667, "f1": 0.5714, "support": 3, "predicted": 4 }, "T1566.001": { "precision": 0.24, "recall": 0.4615, "f1": 0.3158, "support": 13, "predicted": 25 }, "T1569.002": { "precision": 0.2, "recall": 0.2, "f1": 0.2, "support": 5, "predicted": 5 }, "T1570": { "precision": 0.1333, "recall": 0.6667, "f1": 0.2222, "support": 6, "predicted": 30 }, "T1573.001": { "precision": 0.4783, "recall": 0.6875, "f1": 0.5641, "support": 16, "predicted": 23 }, "T1574.002": { "precision": 0.7586, "recall": 0.8462, "f1": 0.8, "support": 26, "predicted": 29 } } }, "per_class_threshold": { "thresholds": { "T1003.001": 0.7, "T1005": 0.7, "T1012": 0.2, "T1016": 0.25, "T1021.001": 0.55, "T1027": 0.4, "T1033": 0.35, "T1036.005": 0.15, "T1041": 0.5, "T1047": 0.15, "T1053.005": 0.4, "T1055": 0.55, "T1056.001": 0.35, "T1057": 0.5, "T1059.003": 0.7, "T1068": 0.2, "T1070.004": 0.2, "T1071.001": 0.6, "T1072": 0.05, "T1074.001": 0.05, "T1078": 0.4, "T1082": 0.8, "T1083": 0.35, "T1090": 0.3, "T1095": 0.2, "T1105": 0.65, "T1106": 0.5, "T1110": 0.3, "T1112": 0.9, "T1113": 0.1, "T1140": 0.45, "T1190": 0.3, "T1204.002": 0.3, "T1210": 0.05, "T1218.011": 0.15, "T1219": 0.15, "T1484.001": 0.1, "T1518.001": 0.2, "T1543.003": 0.4, "T1547.001": 0.55, "T1548.002": 0.1, "T1552.001": 0.05, "T1562.001": 0.4, "T1564.001": 0.2, "T1566.001": 0.4, "T1569.002": 0.1, "T1570": 0.65, "T1573.001": 0.2, "T1574.002": 0.2 }, "micro_f1": 0.5243, "macro_f1": 0.4965, "micro_precision": 0.45, "micro_recall": 0.6279, "macro_precision": 0.4821, "macro_recall": 0.6089, "n_examples": 3635, "n_positive_labels": 911, "per_class": { "T1003.001": { "precision": 0.7143, "recall": 0.7143, "f1": 0.7143, "support": 21, "predicted": 21 }, "T1005": { "precision": 0.375, "recall": 0.375, "f1": 0.375, "support": 8, "predicted": 8 }, "T1012": { "precision": 0.1875, "recall": 0.75, "f1": 0.3, "support": 4, "predicted": 16 }, "T1016": { "precision": 0.3571, "recall": 0.4545, "f1": 0.4, "support": 11, "predicted": 14 }, "T1021.001": { "precision": 0.5263, "recall": 0.8333, "f1": 0.6452, "support": 12, "predicted": 19 }, "T1027": { "precision": 0.4438, "recall": 0.6961, "f1": 0.542, "support": 102, "predicted": 160 }, "T1033": { "precision": 0.625, "recall": 0.7692, "f1": 0.6897, "support": 13, "predicted": 16 }, "T1036.005": { "precision": 0.1579, "recall": 0.6, "f1": 0.25, "support": 10, "predicted": 38 }, "T1041": { "precision": 0.28, "recall": 0.4118, "f1": 0.3333, "support": 17, "predicted": 25 }, "T1047": { "precision": 0.6098, "recall": 0.8929, "f1": 0.7246, "support": 28, "predicted": 41 }, "T1053.005": { "precision": 0.625, "recall": 0.9615, "f1": 0.7576, "support": 26, "predicted": 40 }, "T1055": { "precision": 0.6136, "recall": 0.675, "f1": 0.6429, "support": 40, "predicted": 44 }, "T1056.001": { "precision": 0.7778, "recall": 0.9333, "f1": 0.8485, "support": 15, "predicted": 18 }, "T1057": { "precision": 0.8182, "recall": 0.6, "f1": 0.6923, "support": 15, "predicted": 11 }, "T1059.003": { "precision": 0.6667, "recall": 0.3922, "f1": 0.4938, "support": 51, "predicted": 30 }, "T1068": { "precision": 1.0, "recall": 0.3333, "f1": 0.5, "support": 3, "predicted": 1 }, "T1070.004": { "precision": 0.3103, "recall": 0.75, "f1": 0.439, "support": 12, "predicted": 29 }, "T1071.001": { "precision": 0.4118, "recall": 0.6667, "f1": 0.5091, "support": 21, "predicted": 34 }, "T1072": { "precision": 0.0, "recall": 0.0, "f1": 0.0, "support": 3, "predicted": 0 }, "T1074.001": { "precision": 0.0303, "recall": 0.6667, "f1": 0.058, "support": 3, "predicted": 66 }, "T1078": { "precision": 0.25, "recall": 0.5652, "f1": 0.3467, "support": 23, "predicted": 52 }, "T1082": { "precision": 0.8, "recall": 0.3333, "f1": 0.4706, "support": 24, "predicted": 10 }, "T1083": { "precision": 0.3333, "recall": 0.6667, "f1": 0.4444, "support": 15, "predicted": 30 }, "T1090": { "precision": 0.4333, "recall": 0.5652, "f1": 0.4906, "support": 23, "predicted": 30 }, "T1095": { "precision": 0.3333, "recall": 0.3333, "f1": 0.3333, "support": 3, "predicted": 3 }, "T1105": { "precision": 0.6364, "recall": 0.3684, "f1": 0.4667, "support": 57, "predicted": 33 }, "T1106": { "precision": 0.5556, "recall": 0.4412, "f1": 0.4918, "support": 34, "predicted": 27 }, "T1110": { "precision": 0.6364, "recall": 0.7368, "f1": 0.6829, "support": 19, "predicted": 22 }, "T1112": { "precision": 0.6667, "recall": 0.2857, "f1": 0.4, "support": 14, "predicted": 6 }, "T1113": { "precision": 0.36, "recall": 1.0, "f1": 0.5294, "support": 9, "predicted": 25 }, "T1140": { "precision": 0.7143, "recall": 0.8824, "f1": 0.7895, "support": 68, "predicted": 84 }, "T1190": { "precision": 0.3684, "recall": 0.4667, "f1": 0.4118, "support": 15, "predicted": 19 }, "T1204.002": { "precision": 0.375, "recall": 0.6, "f1": 0.4615, "support": 15, "predicted": 24 }, "T1210": { "precision": 0.0227, "recall": 0.5, "f1": 0.0435, "support": 2, "predicted": 44 }, "T1218.011": { "precision": 0.5882, "recall": 0.7143, "f1": 0.6452, "support": 14, "predicted": 17 }, "T1219": { "precision": 0.4211, "recall": 0.4211, "f1": 0.4211, "support": 19, "predicted": 19 }, "T1484.001": { "precision": 0.4167, "recall": 1.0, "f1": 0.5882, "support": 5, "predicted": 12 }, "T1518.001": { "precision": 0.2857, "recall": 0.5714, "f1": 0.381, "support": 7, "predicted": 14 }, "T1543.003": { "precision": 0.8333, "recall": 0.3846, "f1": 0.5263, "support": 13, "predicted": 6 }, "T1547.001": { "precision": 0.7857, "recall": 0.6875, "f1": 0.7333, "support": 16, "predicted": 14 }, "T1548.002": { "precision": 0.6667, "recall": 1.0, "f1": 0.8, "support": 2, "predicted": 3 }, "T1552.001": { "precision": 0.0606, "recall": 0.5, "f1": 0.1081, "support": 4, "predicted": 33 }, "T1562.001": { "precision": 0.7917, "recall": 0.7308, "f1": 0.76, "support": 26, "predicted": 24 }, "T1564.001": { "precision": 0.5, "recall": 0.6667, "f1": 0.5714, "support": 3, "predicted": 4 }, "T1566.001": { "precision": 0.25, "recall": 0.3077, "f1": 0.2759, "support": 13, "predicted": 16 }, "T1569.002": { "precision": 0.2727, "recall": 0.6, "f1": 0.375, "support": 5, "predicted": 11 }, "T1570": { "precision": 0.5, "recall": 0.5, "f1": 0.5, "support": 6, "predicted": 6 }, "T1573.001": { "precision": 0.4783, "recall": 0.6875, "f1": 0.5641, "support": 16, "predicted": 23 }, "T1574.002": { "precision": 0.7586, "recall": 0.8462, "f1": 0.8, "support": 26, "predicted": 29 } } }, "components_test_macro_f1": { "tfidf_lr": { "global": 0.4492, "per_class": 0.4536 }, "modernbert": { "global": 0.4253, "per_class": 0.4454 } } }