aiflow-math-ink-06-intermediate / reports /behavior_exact_gate_3seed.json
cwLeeDev's picture
Add 3-seed formula-domain generalization study
4a3cd2f verified
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
69.6 kB
{
"experiment": "R-MATH-INK-06-BEHAVIOR-EXACT-GATE-001",
"generated_at": "2026-07-23T20:53:17.837992+00:00",
"split_contract": "CROHME trainData writer-validation threshold; testDataGT one-shot",
"scope": "truth symbol grouping conditional; c/C, x/X/times, z/Z only",
"seeds": [
{
"adapter": "research\\runs\\math_ink_06_online_casecontext_refined_seed17_20260723\\skeleton_adapter.pt",
"behavior_head": "research\\runs\\math_ink_06_behavior_role_seed17_20260724\\behavior_role_head.pt",
"selected_threshold": 0.54,
"validation_selected": {
"threshold": 0.54,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 340,
"abstained": 127,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
"validation_sweep": [
{
"threshold": 0.0,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.02,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.04,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.06,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.08,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.1,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.12,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.14,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.16,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.18,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.2,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.22,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.24,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.26,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.28,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.3,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.32,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.34,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.36,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.38,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.4,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.42,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.44,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.46,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.48,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 341,
"abstained": 126,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.5,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 340,
"abstained": 127,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.52,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 340,
"abstained": 127,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.54,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.715203426124197,
"gain_pp": 35.76017130620985,
"rewrites": 340,
"abstained": 127,
"beneficial": 170,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9826589595375722
},
{
"threshold": 0.56,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7130620985010707,
"gain_pp": 35.54603854389722,
"rewrites": 339,
"abstained": 128,
"beneficial": 169,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9825581395348837
},
{
"threshold": 0.58,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7130620985010707,
"gain_pp": 35.54603854389722,
"rewrites": 339,
"abstained": 128,
"beneficial": 169,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9825581395348837
},
{
"threshold": 0.6,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7130620985010707,
"gain_pp": 35.54603854389722,
"rewrites": 338,
"abstained": 129,
"beneficial": 169,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9825581395348837
},
{
"threshold": 0.62,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7130620985010707,
"gain_pp": 35.54603854389722,
"rewrites": 338,
"abstained": 129,
"beneficial": 169,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9825581395348837
},
{
"threshold": 0.64,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7130620985010707,
"gain_pp": 35.54603854389722,
"rewrites": 338,
"abstained": 129,
"beneficial": 169,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9825581395348837
},
{
"threshold": 0.66,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7130620985010707,
"gain_pp": 35.54603854389722,
"rewrites": 338,
"abstained": 129,
"beneficial": 169,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9825581395348837
},
{
"threshold": 0.68,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7109207708779444,
"gain_pp": 35.33190578158458,
"rewrites": 337,
"abstained": 130,
"beneficial": 168,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9824561403508771
},
{
"threshold": 0.7,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7066381156316917,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 335,
"abstained": 132,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9822485207100592
},
{
"threshold": 0.72,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7066381156316917,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 335,
"abstained": 132,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9822485207100592
},
{
"threshold": 0.74,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7066381156316917,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 335,
"abstained": 132,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9822485207100592
},
{
"threshold": 0.76,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7066381156316917,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 335,
"abstained": 132,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9822485207100592
},
{
"threshold": 0.78,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7066381156316917,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 334,
"abstained": 133,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9822485207100592
},
{
"threshold": 0.8,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7066381156316917,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 334,
"abstained": 133,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 3,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9822485207100592
},
{
"threshold": 0.82,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7066381156316917,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 332,
"abstained": 135,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880239520958084
},
{
"threshold": 0.84,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.7066381156316917,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 330,
"abstained": 137,
"beneficial": 164,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9939393939393939
},
{
"threshold": 0.86,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.6980728051391863,
"gain_pp": 34.04710920770878,
"rewrites": 326,
"abstained": 141,
"beneficial": 160,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9937888198757764
},
{
"threshold": 0.88,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.69593147751606,
"gain_pp": 33.83297644539615,
"rewrites": 322,
"abstained": 145,
"beneficial": 158,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.9,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.6937901498929336,
"gain_pp": 33.61884368308351,
"rewrites": 319,
"abstained": 148,
"beneficial": 157,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.92,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.6895074946466809,
"gain_pp": 33.190578158458244,
"rewrites": 317,
"abstained": 150,
"beneficial": 155,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.94,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.6873661670235546,
"gain_pp": 32.97644539614561,
"rewrites": 315,
"abstained": 152,
"beneficial": 154,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.96,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.6873661670235546,
"gain_pp": 32.97644539614561,
"rewrites": 313,
"abstained": 154,
"beneficial": 154,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.98,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.3576017130620985,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.7301927194860813,
"final_exact": 0.6638115631691649,
"gain_pp": 30.620985010706637,
"rewrites": 293,
"abstained": 174,
"beneficial": 143,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
}
],
"official_test": {
"threshold": 0.54,
"samples": 635,
"teacher_exact": 0.4519685039370079,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.6425196850393701,
"final_exact": 0.584251968503937,
"gain_pp": 13.228346456692913,
"rewrites": 399,
"abstained": 236,
"beneficial": 108,
"harmful": 24,
"rewrite_precision": 0.8181818181818182
}
},
{
"adapter": "research\\runs\\math_ink_06_online_casecontext_refined_seed31_20260723\\skeleton_adapter.pt",
"behavior_head": "research\\runs\\math_ink_06_behavior_role_seed31_20260724\\behavior_role_head.pt",
"selected_threshold": 0.9,
"validation_selected": {
"threshold": 0.9,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5438972162740899,
"gain_pp": 35.33190578158458,
"rewrites": 250,
"abstained": 217,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
"validation_sweep": [
{
"threshold": 0.0,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.02,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.04,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.06,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.08,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.1,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.12,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.14,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.16,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.18,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.2,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.22,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.24,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.26,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.28,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.3,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.32,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.34,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.36,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.38,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.4,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.42,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.44,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.46,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.48,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.5,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 255,
"abstained": 212,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.52,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 254,
"abstained": 213,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.54,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 254,
"abstained": 213,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.56,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 254,
"abstained": 213,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.58,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 254,
"abstained": 213,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.6,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 254,
"abstained": 213,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.62,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 254,
"abstained": 213,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.64,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 254,
"abstained": 213,
"beneficial": 166,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880952380952381
},
{
"threshold": 0.66,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5396145610278372,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 253,
"abstained": 214,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880239520958084
},
{
"threshold": 0.68,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5396145610278372,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 253,
"abstained": 214,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880239520958084
},
{
"threshold": 0.7,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5396145610278372,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 252,
"abstained": 215,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9880239520958084
},
{
"threshold": 0.72,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 251,
"abstained": 216,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9939759036144579
},
{
"threshold": 0.74,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 251,
"abstained": 216,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9939759036144579
},
{
"threshold": 0.76,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 251,
"abstained": 216,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9939759036144579
},
{
"threshold": 0.78,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 251,
"abstained": 216,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9939759036144579
},
{
"threshold": 0.8,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 251,
"abstained": 216,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9939759036144579
},
{
"threshold": 0.82,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5438972162740899,
"gain_pp": 35.33190578158458,
"rewrites": 250,
"abstained": 217,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.84,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5438972162740899,
"gain_pp": 35.33190578158458,
"rewrites": 250,
"abstained": 217,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.86,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5438972162740899,
"gain_pp": 35.33190578158458,
"rewrites": 250,
"abstained": 217,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.88,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5438972162740899,
"gain_pp": 35.33190578158458,
"rewrites": 250,
"abstained": 217,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.9,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5438972162740899,
"gain_pp": 35.33190578158458,
"rewrites": 250,
"abstained": 217,
"beneficial": 165,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.92,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 35.11777301927195,
"rewrites": 249,
"abstained": 218,
"beneficial": 164,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.94,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5396145610278372,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 246,
"abstained": 221,
"beneficial": 163,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.96,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5396145610278372,
"gain_pp": 34.903640256959314,
"rewrites": 246,
"abstained": 221,
"beneficial": 163,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.98,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.1905781584582441,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5481798715203426,
"final_exact": 0.5289079229122056,
"gain_pp": 33.83297644539615,
"rewrites": 238,
"abstained": 229,
"beneficial": 158,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
}
],
"official_test": {
"threshold": 0.9,
"samples": 635,
"teacher_exact": 0.27086614173228346,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.44724409448818897,
"final_exact": 0.3937007874015748,
"gain_pp": 12.283464566929133,
"rewrites": 270,
"abstained": 365,
"beneficial": 104,
"harmful": 26,
"rewrite_precision": 0.8
}
},
{
"adapter": "research\\runs\\math_ink_06_online_casecontext_refined_seed47_20260723\\skeleton_adapter.pt",
"behavior_head": "research\\runs\\math_ink_06_behavior_role_seed47_20260724\\behavior_role_head.pt",
"selected_threshold": 0.72,
"validation_selected": {
"threshold": 0.72,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 272,
"abstained": 195,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9938271604938271
},
"validation_sweep": [
{
"threshold": 0.0,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.02,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.04,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.06,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.08,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.1,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.12,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.14,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.16,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.18,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.2,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.22,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.24,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.26,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.28,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.3,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.32,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.34,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.36,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.38,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.4,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.42,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.44,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.46,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.48,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 278,
"abstained": 189,
"beneficial": 162,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9878048780487805
},
{
"threshold": 0.5,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5845824411134903,
"gain_pp": 34.04710920770878,
"rewrites": 277,
"abstained": 190,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9877300613496932
},
{
"threshold": 0.52,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5845824411134903,
"gain_pp": 34.04710920770878,
"rewrites": 277,
"abstained": 190,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9877300613496932
},
{
"threshold": 0.54,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5845824411134903,
"gain_pp": 34.04710920770878,
"rewrites": 276,
"abstained": 191,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9877300613496932
},
{
"threshold": 0.56,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5845824411134903,
"gain_pp": 34.04710920770878,
"rewrites": 274,
"abstained": 193,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9877300613496932
},
{
"threshold": 0.58,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5845824411134903,
"gain_pp": 34.04710920770878,
"rewrites": 274,
"abstained": 193,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 2,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9877300613496932
},
{
"threshold": 0.6,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 273,
"abstained": 194,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9938271604938271
},
{
"threshold": 0.62,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 273,
"abstained": 194,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9938271604938271
},
{
"threshold": 0.64,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 273,
"abstained": 194,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9938271604938271
},
{
"threshold": 0.66,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 273,
"abstained": 194,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9938271604938271
},
{
"threshold": 0.68,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 272,
"abstained": 195,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9938271604938271
},
{
"threshold": 0.7,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 272,
"abstained": 195,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9938271604938271
},
{
"threshold": 0.72,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5867237687366167,
"gain_pp": 34.261241970021416,
"rewrites": 272,
"abstained": 195,
"beneficial": 161,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9938271604938271
},
{
"threshold": 0.74,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5845824411134903,
"gain_pp": 34.04710920770878,
"rewrites": 271,
"abstained": 196,
"beneficial": 160,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9937888198757764
},
{
"threshold": 0.76,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5845824411134903,
"gain_pp": 34.04710920770878,
"rewrites": 270,
"abstained": 197,
"beneficial": 160,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9937888198757764
},
{
"threshold": 0.78,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.582441113490364,
"gain_pp": 33.83297644539615,
"rewrites": 269,
"abstained": 198,
"beneficial": 159,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.99375
},
{
"threshold": 0.8,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5802997858672377,
"gain_pp": 33.61884368308351,
"rewrites": 268,
"abstained": 199,
"beneficial": 158,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9937106918238994
},
{
"threshold": 0.82,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5802997858672377,
"gain_pp": 33.61884368308351,
"rewrites": 268,
"abstained": 199,
"beneficial": 158,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9937106918238994
},
{
"threshold": 0.84,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5802997858672377,
"gain_pp": 33.61884368308351,
"rewrites": 268,
"abstained": 199,
"beneficial": 158,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9937106918238994
},
{
"threshold": 0.86,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5802997858672377,
"gain_pp": 33.61884368308351,
"rewrites": 267,
"abstained": 200,
"beneficial": 158,
"harmful": 1,
"rewrite_precision": 0.9937106918238994
},
{
"threshold": 0.88,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.576017130620985,
"gain_pp": 33.190578158458244,
"rewrites": 263,
"abstained": 204,
"beneficial": 155,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.9,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5717344753747323,
"gain_pp": 32.76231263383298,
"rewrites": 261,
"abstained": 206,
"beneficial": 153,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.92,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5653104925053534,
"gain_pp": 32.11991434689507,
"rewrites": 256,
"abstained": 211,
"beneficial": 150,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.94,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5610278372591007,
"gain_pp": 31.69164882226981,
"rewrites": 253,
"abstained": 214,
"beneficial": 148,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.96,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5546038543897216,
"gain_pp": 31.049250535331907,
"rewrites": 250,
"abstained": 217,
"beneficial": 145,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
},
{
"threshold": 0.98,
"samples": 467,
"teacher_exact": 0.24411134903640258,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5952890792291221,
"final_exact": 0.5417558886509636,
"gain_pp": 29.764453961456102,
"rewrites": 238,
"abstained": 229,
"beneficial": 139,
"harmful": 0,
"rewrite_precision": 1.0
}
],
"official_test": {
"threshold": 0.72,
"samples": 635,
"teacher_exact": 0.2866141732283465,
"teacher_visual_family": 0.5007874015748032,
"final_exact": 0.4409448818897638,
"gain_pp": 15.433070866141732,
"rewrites": 307,
"abstained": 328,
"beneficial": 125,
"harmful": 27,
"rewrite_precision": 0.8223684210526315
}
}
],
"official_test_summary": {
"teacher_exact": {
"values": [
0.4519685039370079,
0.27086614173228346,
0.2866141732283465
],
"mean": 0.33648293963254594
},
"teacher_visual_family": {
"values": [
0.6425196850393701,
0.44724409448818897,
0.5007874015748032
],
"mean": 0.5301837270341206
},
"final_exact": {
"values": [
0.584251968503937,
0.3937007874015748,
0.4409448818897638
],
"mean": 0.47296587926509187
},
"gain_pp": {
"values": [
13.228346456692913,
12.283464566929133,
15.433070866141732
],
"mean": 13.648293963254593
},
"rewrite_precision": {
"values": [
0.8181818181818182,
0.8,
0.8223684210526315
],
"mean": 0.8135167464114832
}
},
"track": "R_noncommercial_only",
"product_validation": false,
"distillation_allowed": false
}