#!/usr/bin/env python3 import csv from collections import defaultdict from pathlib import Path from typing import Dict, List import matplotlib.pyplot as plt import numpy as np # Use Times New Roman for all text to match other figures plt.rcParams["font.family"] = "Times New Roman" # Fixed model order (must match the names used in the CSV files) MODEL_ORDER: List[str] = [ "GPT-5", "GPT-4o-mini", "DeepSeek-V3-1", "DeepSeek-R1", "Gemini-2.5-flash", "Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking", "Qwen3-235b", ] # Display labels (can be slightly pretty-printed) MODEL_LABELS: Dict[str, str] = { "GPT-5": "GPT-5", "GPT-4o-mini": "GPT-4o-mini", "DeepSeek-V3-1": "DeepSeek-V3.1", "DeepSeek-R1": "DeepSeek-R1", "Gemini-2.5-flash": "Gemini-2.5", "Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking": "Gemini-2.5-NT", "Qwen3-235b": "Qwen3-235b", } # Color palette for different models - professional academic colors (Tableau 10 style) MODEL_COLORS: Dict[str, str] = { "GPT-5": "#1f77b4", # Blue "GPT-4o-mini": "#ff7f0e", # Orange "DeepSeek-V3-1": "#2ca02c", # Green "DeepSeek-R1": "#d62728", # Red "Gemini-2.5-flash": "#9467bd", # Purple "Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking": "#8c564b", # Brown "Qwen3-235b": "#e377c2", # Pink } def load_total_classified(csv_path: Path) -> Dict[str, List[float]]: """Load total_classified values per model from a CSV file. Returns: data[model] = sorted list of total_classified values (floats). """ by_model: Dict[str, List[float]] = defaultdict(list) with csv_path.open("r", encoding="utf-8", newline="") as f: reader = csv.DictReader(f) for row in reader: model = (row.get("model") or "").strip() if not model: continue if model not in MODEL_ORDER: # Ignore unknown models so that colors/order stay consistent continue val_raw = row.get("total_classified") if val_raw is None or val_raw == "": continue try: # total_classified is in milliseconds in existing CSVs val = float(val_raw) except ValueError: continue by_model[model].append(val) # Sort values for ECDF computation for m in list(by_model.keys()): by_model[m].sort() return by_model def compute_ecdf(values: List[float]): """Return x, y for the empirical CDF of a 1D sample. x: sorted values y: ECDF in [0, 1] """ if not values: return np.array([]), np.array([]) x = np.asarray(values, dtype=float) n = x.size # Standard ECDF: y_i = i / n for sorted x_i y = np.arange(1, n + 1, dtype=float) / float(n) return x, y def compute_weighted_ecdf(values: List[float], weights: List[float]): if not values or not weights or len(values) != len(weights): return np.array([]), np.array([]) x = np.asarray(values, dtype=float) w = np.asarray(weights, dtype=float) if np.all(w <= 0.0): return np.array([]), np.array([]) order = np.argsort(x) x_sorted = x[order] w_sorted = w[order] cum_w = np.cumsum(w_sorted) total_w = cum_w[-1] if total_w <= 0.0: return np.array([]), np.array([]) y = cum_w / float(total_w) return x_sorted, y def create_legend_pdf_horizontal(output_path: Path) -> None: fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(12, 1.0)) ax.axis("off") handles = [] labels = [] for model in MODEL_ORDER: color = MODEL_COLORS.get(model, "black") (handle,) = ax.plot([], [], "-", linewidth=2, color=color) handles.append(handle) labels.append(MODEL_LABELS.get(model, model)) ax.legend( handles, labels, loc="center", ncol=len(handles), frameon=False, fancybox=False, shadow=False, borderaxespad=0.1, borderpad=0.3, handletextpad=0.4, labelspacing=0.2, prop={"size": 14}, ) fig.tight_layout(pad=0.0) fig.savefig( output_path, format="pdf", dpi=300, bbox_inches="tight", pad_inches=0.0, ) plt.close(fig) print(f"saved horizontal legend: {output_path}") def plot_overall_ecdf( overall_values_by_model: Dict[str, List[float]], overall_weights_by_model: Dict[str, List[float]], out_dir: Path, ) -> None: fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(6, 4)) any_line = False for model in MODEL_ORDER: values = overall_values_by_model.get(model) weights = overall_weights_by_model.get(model) if not values or not weights or len(values) != len(weights): continue x, y = compute_weighted_ecdf(values, weights) if x.size == 0: continue x_plot = x / 1_000_000.0 color = MODEL_COLORS.get(model, "black") label = MODEL_LABELS.get(model, model) ax.plot(x_plot, y, label=label, color=color, linewidth=2.0) any_line = True if not any_line: plt.close(fig) print("no ECDF lines drawn for overall, skip figure") return ax.set_xlabel("Trace duration [10^3 s]", fontsize=18) ax.set_ylabel("", fontsize=18) ax.set_ylim(0.0, 1.0) ax.grid(True, which="both", axis="both", linestyle="-", linewidth=0.5, alpha=0.4) ax.tick_params(axis="both", labelsize=14) ax.margins(x=0.01) fig.tight_layout(pad=0.0) out_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) out_file = out_dir / "ecdf_overall_time_weighted.pdf" fig.savefig(out_file, dpi=200, bbox_inches="tight", pad_inches=0.02) plt.close(fig) print(f"saved ECDF figure: {out_file}") def compute_time_statistics(values: List[float]) -> Dict[str, float]: """Compute time statistics for a list of values (in milliseconds). Returns: Dictionary with mean, median, and total in seconds. """ if not values: return {"mean": 0.0, "median": 0.0, "total": 0.0, "count": 0} # Convert from milliseconds to seconds values_sec = [v / 1000.0 for v in values] return { "mean": np.mean(values_sec), "median": np.median(values_sec), "total": np.sum(values_sec), "count": len(values), } def generate_mcp_vs_hardcoded_comparison( base_project: str, scenario_time_data: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[float]]] ) -> str: """Generate comparison between MCP and hardcoded versions for a project.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# {base_project}: MCP vs Hardcoded\n\n") mcp_scenario = f"{base_project}-MCP" hardcoded_scenario = base_project if ( mcp_scenario not in scenario_time_data or hardcoded_scenario not in scenario_time_data ): lines.append("_Data not available for comparison_\n\n") return "".join(lines) mcp_data = scenario_time_data[mcp_scenario] hardcoded_data = scenario_time_data[hardcoded_scenario] all_models = sorted(set(mcp_data.keys()) | set(hardcoded_data.keys())) # Calculate overall averages first overall_stats = { "mcp": {"total": 0.0, "count": 0}, "hard": {"total": 0.0, "count": 0}, } for model in all_models: mcp_stats = compute_time_statistics(mcp_data.get(model, [])) hard_stats = compute_time_statistics(hardcoded_data.get(model, [])) overall_stats["mcp"]["total"] += mcp_stats["total"] overall_stats["mcp"]["count"] += mcp_stats["count"] overall_stats["hard"]["total"] += hard_stats["total"] overall_stats["hard"]["count"] += hard_stats["count"] # Add overall summary section lines.append("## Overall Summary (Averaged Across All Models)\n\n") lines.append("| MCP Mean (s) | Hardcoded Mean (s) | Diff (MCP-Hard) |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- |\n") if overall_stats["mcp"]["count"] > 0 and overall_stats["hard"]["count"] > 0: avg_mcp = overall_stats["mcp"]["total"] / overall_stats["mcp"]["count"] avg_hard = overall_stats["hard"]["total"] / overall_stats["hard"]["count"] diff = avg_mcp - avg_hard pct = (diff / avg_hard * 100) if avg_hard > 0 else 0 lines.append( f"| {avg_mcp:.2f} | {avg_hard:.2f} | {diff:+.2f}s ({pct:+.1f}%) |\n" ) lines.append("\n---\n\n") # Per-model comparison lines.append("## Per-Model Comparison\n\n") lines.append("| Model | MCP Mean (s) | Hardcoded Mean (s) | Diff (MCP-Hard) |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for model in all_models: mcp_stats = compute_time_statistics(mcp_data.get(model, [])) hard_stats = compute_time_statistics(hardcoded_data.get(model, [])) mean_diff = mcp_stats["mean"] - hard_stats["mean"] mean_pct = ( (mean_diff / hard_stats["mean"] * 100) if hard_stats["mean"] > 0 else 0 ) lines.append( f"| {model} | {mcp_stats['mean']:.2f} | {hard_stats['mean']:.2f} | " f"{mean_diff:+.2f}s ({mean_pct:+.1f}%) |\n" ) lines.append("\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_mcp_vs_hardcoded_overall_comparison( projects: List[str], scenario_time_data: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[float]]] ) -> str: """Generate overall comparison across all MCP vs hardcoded projects.""" lines = [] lines.append("# Overall MCP vs Hardcoded Comparison\n\n") lines.append(f"Averaged across all projects: {', '.join(projects)}\n\n") # Collect data from all projects overall_data = {} framework_stats = { "mcp": {"total": 0.0, "count": 0}, "hard": {"total": 0.0, "count": 0}, } for project in projects: mcp_scenario = f"{project}-MCP" hardcoded_scenario = project if ( mcp_scenario not in scenario_time_data or hardcoded_scenario not in scenario_time_data ): continue mcp_data = scenario_time_data[mcp_scenario] hardcoded_data = scenario_time_data[hardcoded_scenario] all_models = set(mcp_data.keys()) | set(hardcoded_data.keys()) for model in all_models: if model not in overall_data: overall_data[model] = {"mcp": [], "hard": []} mcp_vals = mcp_data.get(model, []) hard_vals = hardcoded_data.get(model, []) overall_data[model]["mcp"].extend(mcp_vals) overall_data[model]["hard"].extend(hard_vals) # Add to framework-level stats mcp_stats = compute_time_statistics(mcp_vals) hard_stats = compute_time_statistics(hard_vals) framework_stats["mcp"]["total"] += mcp_stats["total"] framework_stats["mcp"]["count"] += mcp_stats["count"] framework_stats["hard"]["total"] += hard_stats["total"] framework_stats["hard"]["count"] += hard_stats["count"] # Add framework-level comparison lines.append("## Framework-Level Comparison (All Models Averaged)\n\n") lines.append("| MCP Mean (s) | Hardcoded Mean (s) | Diff (MCP-Hard) |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- |\n") if framework_stats["mcp"]["count"] > 0 and framework_stats["hard"]["count"] > 0: avg_mcp = framework_stats["mcp"]["total"] / framework_stats["mcp"]["count"] avg_hard = framework_stats["hard"]["total"] / framework_stats["hard"]["count"] diff = avg_mcp - avg_hard pct = (diff / avg_hard * 100) if avg_hard > 0 else 0 lines.append( f"| {avg_mcp:.2f} | {avg_hard:.2f} | {diff:+.2f}s ({pct:+.1f}%) |\n" ) lines.append("\n---\n\n") # Per-model summary lines.append("## Per-Model Summary\n\n") lines.append("| Model | MCP Mean (s) | Hard Mean (s) | Diff (MCP-Hard) |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for model in sorted(overall_data.keys()): mcp_stats = compute_time_statistics(overall_data[model]["mcp"]) hard_stats = compute_time_statistics(overall_data[model]["hard"]) mean_diff = mcp_stats["mean"] - hard_stats["mean"] mean_pct = ( (mean_diff / hard_stats["mean"] * 100) if hard_stats["mean"] > 0 else 0 ) lines.append( f"| {model} | {mcp_stats['mean']:.2f} | {hard_stats['mean']:.2f} | " f"{mean_diff:+.2f}s ({mean_pct:+.1f}%) |\n" ) lines.append("\n---\n\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_version_comparison( base_project: str, version_a_suffix: str, version_b_suffix: str, scenario_time_data: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[float]]], version_a_name: str, version_b_name: str, ) -> str: """Generate comparison between two versions of a project.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# {base_project}: {version_a_name} vs {version_b_name}\n\n") scenario_a = f"{base_project}{version_a_suffix}" scenario_b = f"{base_project}{version_b_suffix}" if scenario_a not in scenario_time_data or scenario_b not in scenario_time_data: lines.append("_Data not available for comparison_\n\n") return "".join(lines) data_a = scenario_time_data[scenario_a] data_b = scenario_time_data[scenario_b] all_models = sorted(set(data_a.keys()) | set(data_b.keys())) # Calculate overall averages first overall_stats = {"a": {"total": 0.0, "count": 0}, "b": {"total": 0.0, "count": 0}} for model in all_models: stats_a = compute_time_statistics(data_a.get(model, [])) stats_b = compute_time_statistics(data_b.get(model, [])) overall_stats["a"]["total"] += stats_a["total"] overall_stats["a"]["count"] += stats_a["count"] overall_stats["b"]["total"] += stats_b["total"] overall_stats["b"]["count"] += stats_b["count"] # Add overall summary section lines.append("## Overall Summary (Averaged Across All Models)\n\n") lines.append( f"| {version_a_name} Mean (s) | {version_b_name} Mean (s) | Diff ({version_a_name}-{version_b_name}) |\n" ) lines.append("| --- | --- | --- |\n") if overall_stats["a"]["count"] > 0 and overall_stats["b"]["count"] > 0: avg_a = overall_stats["a"]["total"] / overall_stats["a"]["count"] avg_b = overall_stats["b"]["total"] / overall_stats["b"]["count"] diff = avg_a - avg_b pct = (diff / avg_b * 100) if avg_b > 0 else 0 lines.append(f"| {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f}s ({pct:+.1f}%) |\n") lines.append("\n---\n\n") # Per-model comparison lines.append("## Per-Model Comparison\n\n") lines.append( f"| Model | {version_a_name} Mean (s) | {version_b_name} Mean (s) | Diff ({version_a_name}-{version_b_name}) |\n" ) lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for model in all_models: stats_a = compute_time_statistics(data_a.get(model, [])) stats_b = compute_time_statistics(data_b.get(model, [])) mean_diff = stats_a["mean"] - stats_b["mean"] mean_pct = (mean_diff / stats_b["mean"] * 100) if stats_b["mean"] > 0 else 0 lines.append( f"| {model} | {stats_a['mean']:.2f} | {stats_b['mean']:.2f} | " f"{mean_diff:+.2f}s ({mean_pct:+.1f}%) |\n" ) lines.append("\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_version_overall_comparison( projects: List[str], version_a_suffix: str, version_b_suffix: str, scenario_time_data: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[float]]], version_a_name: str, version_b_name: str, comparison_title: str, ) -> str: """Generate overall comparison across all projects for two versions.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# Overall {comparison_title}\n\n") lines.append(f"Averaged across all projects: {', '.join(projects)}\n\n") # Collect data from all projects overall_data = {} framework_stats = {"a": {"total": 0.0, "count": 0}, "b": {"total": 0.0, "count": 0}} for project in projects: scenario_a = f"{project}{version_a_suffix}" scenario_b = f"{project}{version_b_suffix}" if scenario_a not in scenario_time_data or scenario_b not in scenario_time_data: continue data_a = scenario_time_data[scenario_a] data_b = scenario_time_data[scenario_b] all_models = set(data_a.keys()) | set(data_b.keys()) for model in all_models: if model not in overall_data: overall_data[model] = {"a": [], "b": []} vals_a = data_a.get(model, []) vals_b = data_b.get(model, []) overall_data[model]["a"].extend(vals_a) overall_data[model]["b"].extend(vals_b) # Add to framework-level stats stats_a = compute_time_statistics(vals_a) stats_b = compute_time_statistics(vals_b) framework_stats["a"]["total"] += stats_a["total"] framework_stats["a"]["count"] += stats_a["count"] framework_stats["b"]["total"] += stats_b["total"] framework_stats["b"]["count"] += stats_b["count"] # Add framework-level comparison lines.append("## Framework-Level Comparison (All Models Averaged)\n\n") lines.append( f"| {version_a_name} Mean (s) | {version_b_name} Mean (s) | Diff ({version_a_name}-{version_b_name}) |\n" ) lines.append("| --- | --- | --- |\n") if framework_stats["a"]["count"] > 0 and framework_stats["b"]["count"] > 0: avg_a = framework_stats["a"]["total"] / framework_stats["a"]["count"] avg_b = framework_stats["b"]["total"] / framework_stats["b"]["count"] diff = avg_a - avg_b pct = (diff / avg_b * 100) if avg_b > 0 else 0 lines.append(f"| {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f}s ({pct:+.1f}%) |\n") lines.append("\n---\n\n") # Per-model summary lines.append("## Per-Model Summary\n\n") lines.append( f"| Model | {version_a_name} Mean (s) | {version_b_name} Mean (s) | Diff ({version_a_name}-{version_b_name}) |\n" ) lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for model in sorted(overall_data.keys()): stats_a = compute_time_statistics(overall_data[model]["a"]) stats_b = compute_time_statistics(overall_data[model]["b"]) mean_diff = stats_a["mean"] - stats_b["mean"] mean_pct = (mean_diff / stats_b["mean"] * 100) if stats_b["mean"] > 0 else 0 lines.append( f"| {model} | {stats_a['mean']:.2f} | {stats_b['mean']:.2f} | " f"{mean_diff:+.2f}s ({mean_pct:+.1f}%) |\n" ) lines.append("\n---\n\n") return "".join(lines) def get_base_project_name(scenario: str) -> str: if scenario.endswith("-H_A2A"): return scenario[: -len("-H_A2A")] if scenario.endswith("-A2A"): return scenario[: -len("-A2A")] if scenario.endswith("-MCP"): return scenario[: -len("-MCP")] return scenario def generate_overall_model_comparison( scenario_time_data: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[float]]], ) -> str: """Generate an all-projects summary comparing models across every scenario.""" lines: List[str] = [] lines.append("## All Projects Combined (Summary Across All Projects, by Model)\n\n") # Aggregate all total_classified samples per model across every project scenario aggregated: Dict[str, List[float]] = defaultdict(list) for project_data in scenario_time_data.values(): for model, vals in project_data.items(): aggregated[model].extend(vals) if not aggregated: lines.append("_No data available across projects_\n\n") return "".join(lines) # Respect fixed display order, then any remaining models alphabetically ordered_models: List[str] = [ m for m in MODEL_ORDER if m in aggregated and aggregated[m] ] remaining_models = sorted( m for m in aggregated.keys() if m not in ordered_models and aggregated[m] ) all_models = ordered_models + remaining_models # Compute statistics for each model model_stats: Dict[str, Dict[str, float]] = {} for model in all_models: model_stats[model] = compute_time_statistics(aggregated[model]) # Summary table lines.append("### Model Statistics Summary\n\n") lines.append("| Model | Mean (s) |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- |\n") for model in all_models: stats = model_stats[model] lines.append(f"| {model} | {stats['mean']:.2f} |\n") # Relative performance vs fastest (only if at least two models with data) positive_models = [m for m in all_models if model_stats[m]["mean"] > 0] if len(positive_models) > 1: fastest_model = min(positive_models, key=lambda m: model_stats[m]["mean"]) fastest_mean = model_stats[fastest_model]["mean"] lines.append("\n### Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)\n\n") lines.append( f"Baseline (fastest): **{fastest_model}** ({fastest_mean:.2f}s mean)\n\n" ) lines.append("| Model | Mean (s) | Slowdown vs Baseline |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- |\n") for model in all_models: stats = model_stats[model] if stats["mean"] > 0 and fastest_mean > 0: slowdown = (stats["mean"] - fastest_mean) / fastest_mean * 100 lines.append(f"| {model} | {stats['mean']:.2f} | {slowdown:+.1f}% |\n") else: lines.append(f"| {model} | {stats['mean']:.2f} | N/A |\n") # Add slowest model summary slowest_model = max( positive_models, key=lambda m: model_stats[m]["mean"] if model_stats[m]["mean"] > 0 else 0, ) slowest_mean = model_stats[slowest_model]["mean"] if fastest_mean > 0 and slowest_mean > 0: slowest_slowdown = (slowest_mean - fastest_mean) / fastest_mean * 100 lines.append( f"\n**Slowest model:** {slowest_model} ({slowest_mean:.2f}s mean, " f"{slowest_slowdown:+.1f}% slower than baseline {fastest_model})\n" ) lines.append("\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_project_model_comparison( project_name: str, scenario_time_data: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[float]]] ) -> str: """Generate model-to-model comparison for a single project. Compares all models within the same project scenario. """ lines = [] lines.append(f"# {project_name}: Model Comparison\n\n") if project_name not in scenario_time_data: lines.append("_Data not available for this project_\n\n") return "".join(lines) project_data = scenario_time_data[project_name] all_models = sorted(project_data.keys()) if not all_models: lines.append("_No model data available_\n\n") return "".join(lines) # Compute statistics for each model model_stats = {} for model in all_models: vals = project_data.get(model, []) model_stats[model] = compute_time_statistics(vals) # Summary table lines.append("## Model Statistics Summary\n\n") lines.append("| Model | Mean (s) |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- |\n") for model in all_models: stats = model_stats[model] lines.append(f"| {model} | {stats['mean']:.2f} |\n") # Pairwise comparison: compare each model against the fastest one if len(all_models) > 1: lines.append("\n## Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)\n\n") # Find fastest model by mean fastest_model = min( all_models, key=lambda m: ( model_stats[m]["mean"] if model_stats[m]["mean"] > 0 else float("inf") ), ) fastest_mean = model_stats[fastest_model]["mean"] # Find slowest model by mean slowest_model = max( all_models, key=lambda m: model_stats[m]["mean"] if model_stats[m]["mean"] > 0 else 0, ) slowest_mean = model_stats[slowest_model]["mean"] lines.append( f"Baseline (fastest): **{fastest_model}** ({fastest_mean:.2f}s mean)\n\n" ) lines.append("| Model | Mean (s) | Slowdown vs Baseline |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- |\n") for model in all_models: stats = model_stats[model] if stats["mean"] > 0 and fastest_mean > 0: slowdown = (stats["mean"] - fastest_mean) / fastest_mean * 100 lines.append(f"| {model} | {stats['mean']:.2f} | {slowdown:+.1f}% |\n") else: lines.append(f"| {model} | {stats['mean']:.2f} | N/A |\n") # Add slowest model summary if fastest_mean > 0 and slowest_mean > 0: slowest_slowdown = (slowest_mean - fastest_mean) / fastest_mean * 100 lines.append( f"\n**Slowest model:** {slowest_model} ({slowest_mean:.2f}s mean, " f"{slowest_slowdown:+.1f}% slower than baseline {fastest_model})\n" ) lines.append("\n") return "".join(lines) def plot_ecdf_for_project( project_dir: Path, csv_path: Path, out_dir: Path, x_max_ms: float ) -> None: """Plot ECDF of total_classified for all models in one project. One figure per project, up to 7 lines (one per model present in the CSV). """ data_by_model = load_total_classified(csv_path) if not data_by_model: print(f"no total_classified data in {csv_path}, skip") return # If no global series maximum was provided, fall back to this project's # own maximum so that the function remains usable in isolation. if x_max_ms <= 0.0: local_max = 0.0 for vals in data_by_model.values(): if vals: v_max = max(vals) if v_max > local_max: local_max = v_max x_max_ms = local_max fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(6, 4)) # For a consistent legend order, iterate in fixed MODEL_ORDER any_line = False for model in MODEL_ORDER: values = data_by_model.get(model) if not values: continue x, y = compute_ecdf(values) if x.size == 0: continue # Plot in units of 10^3 s so that the 1e3 scaling factor is # explicitly captured in the axis label rather than as a separate # offset text. x_plot = x / 1_000_000.0 color = MODEL_COLORS.get(model, "black") label = MODEL_LABELS.get(model, model) ax.plot(x_plot, y, label=label, color=color, linewidth=2.0) any_line = True if not any_line: plt.close(fig) print(f"no ECDF lines drawn for {csv_path}, skip figure") return # Use a shared x-axis upper bound (in milliseconds) for all scenarios in # the same project series so that their ECDFs are directly comparable. x_max_plot = x_max_ms / 1_000_000.0 if x_max_plot > 0.0: ax.set_xlim(0.0, x_max_plot) # Show axis units directly in terms of 10^3 s using plain text (no LaTeX). ax.set_xlabel("Trace duration [10^3 s]", fontsize=18) # No explicit y-axis label (ECDF) to keep the figure clean. ax.set_ylabel("", fontsize=18) ax.set_ylim(0.0, 1.0) # Add light grid similar to typical ECDF examples ax.grid(True, which="both", axis="both", linestyle="-", linewidth=0.5, alpha=0.4) ax.tick_params(axis="both", labelsize=14) # Slightly reduce margins so curves fill the axes area; no in-figure legend or title ax.margins(x=0.01) fig.tight_layout(pad=0.0) out_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) out_file = out_dir / f"ecdf_{project_dir.name}.pdf" # Use a tiny padding so the right axis spine is fully preserved while # keeping extra whitespace visually negligible. fig.savefig(out_file, dpi=200, bbox_inches="tight", pad_inches=0.02) plt.close(fig) print(f"saved ECDF figure: {out_file}") def main() -> None: # Assume this script is placed in Part2 directory part2_dir = Path(__file__).resolve().parent # Output directory for ECDF figures out_dir = part2_dir / "ECDFs" overall_values_by_model: Dict[str, List[float]] = defaultdict(list) overall_weights_by_model: Dict[str, List[float]] = defaultdict(list) # Dictionary to store time data per scenario for comparisons scenario_time_data: Dict[str, Dict[str, List[float]]] = {} # Per-series maximum of total_classified (in milliseconds) so that # scenarios sharing the same base project name use a common x-axis range. series_x_max_ms: Dict[str, float] = {} # First pass: load data, build overall ECDF inputs, and compute per-series maxima. for sub in sorted(p for p in part2_dir.iterdir() if p.is_dir()): if sub.name.startswith("z_"): # Skip output directories continue csv_path = sub / "performance_breakdown_summary.csv" if not csv_path.exists(): continue data_by_model = load_total_classified(csv_path) # Store scenario data for comparisons scenario_time_data[sub.name] = data_by_model # Update weights used for the overall ECDF for model, vals in data_by_model.items(): if not vals: continue total_time = float(sum(vals)) count = len(vals) if total_time <= 0.0 or count <= 0: continue weight_per_sample = total_time / float(count) for v in vals: overall_values_by_model[model].append(v) overall_weights_by_model[model].append(weight_per_sample) # Track the maximum total_classified for this scenario and propagate it # to the corresponding project series. scenario_max = 0.0 for vals in data_by_model.values(): if vals: v_max = max(vals) if v_max > scenario_max: scenario_max = v_max if scenario_max > 0.0: base_name = get_base_project_name(sub.name) prev_max = series_x_max_ms.get(base_name, 0.0) if scenario_max > prev_max: series_x_max_ms[base_name] = scenario_max # Second pass: draw ECDF for each scenario using the shared x-axis maximum # per project series. for sub in sorted(p for p in part2_dir.iterdir() if p.is_dir()): if sub.name.startswith("z_"): continue csv_path = sub / "performance_breakdown_summary.csv" if not csv_path.exists(): continue base_name = get_base_project_name(sub.name) x_max_ms = series_x_max_ms.get(base_name, 0.0) print(f"processing {csv_path}") try: plot_ecdf_for_project(sub, csv_path, out_dir, x_max_ms) except Exception as exc: # pragma: no cover - defensive print(f" error while plotting {csv_path}: {exc}") if overall_values_by_model: plot_overall_ecdf(overall_values_by_model, overall_weights_by_model, out_dir) # Also create a standalone horizontal legend PDF (one per script run) legend_path = out_dir / "ECDF_Model_Legend_horizontal.pdf" create_legend_pdf_horizontal(legend_path) # Generate time comparison markdown files print("\n" + "=" * 60) print("Generating time comparison summaries...") print("=" * 60) mcp_hardcoded_projects = [ "MarkdownValidator", "GameBuilder", "EmailResponder", ] version_projects = [ "SQLAssistant", "RecruitmentAssistant", "LandingPageGenerator", "SocialMediaManager", "BookWriter", ] # 1. MCP vs Hardcoded comparisons comparison_lines = [] comparison_lines.append( generate_mcp_vs_hardcoded_overall_comparison( mcp_hardcoded_projects, scenario_time_data ) ) for project in mcp_hardcoded_projects: comparison_lines.append( generate_mcp_vs_hardcoded_comparison(project, scenario_time_data) ) comparison_md_path = out_dir / "Time_Comparison_MCP_vs_Hardcoded.md" comparison_md_path.write_text("".join(comparison_lines), encoding="utf-8") print(f"Created: {comparison_md_path}") # 2. MCP vs A2A comparisons comparison_lines = [] comparison_lines.append( generate_version_overall_comparison( version_projects, "-MCP", "-A2A", scenario_time_data, "MCP", "A2A", "MCP vs A2A Time Comparison", ) ) for project in version_projects: comparison_lines.append( generate_version_comparison( project, "-MCP", "-A2A", scenario_time_data, "MCP", "A2A" ) ) comparison_md_path = out_dir / "Time_Comparison_MCP_vs_A2A.md" comparison_md_path.write_text("".join(comparison_lines), encoding="utf-8") print(f"Created: {comparison_md_path}") # 3. A2A vs H_A2A comparisons comparison_lines = [] comparison_lines.append( generate_version_overall_comparison( version_projects, "-A2A", "-H_A2A", scenario_time_data, "A2A", "H_A2A", "A2A vs H_A2A Time Comparison", ) ) for project in version_projects: comparison_lines.append( generate_version_comparison( project, "-A2A", "-H_A2A", scenario_time_data, "A2A", "H_A2A" ) ) comparison_md_path = out_dir / "Time_Comparison_A2A_vs_H_A2A.md" comparison_md_path.write_text("".join(comparison_lines), encoding="utf-8") print(f"Created: {comparison_md_path}") # 4. Generate detailed A2A vs H_A2A comparison for each project print("\nGenerating detailed A2A vs H_A2A per-project comparisons...") a2a_mix_comparison_lines = [] a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append( "# A2A vs H_A2A: Detailed Per-Project Comparison\n\n" ) a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append( "This document compares A2A and H_A2A architectures for each project, " ) a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append( "showing both per-model and overall statistics.\n\n" ) a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append("---\n\n") # Aggregators for cross-project summary global_all_models = sorted( set().union(*[set(d.keys()) for d in scenario_time_data.values()]) ) overall_deltas: List[Dict[str, float]] = [] per_model_global: Dict[str, Dict[str, float]] = defaultdict( lambda: {"a2a_sum": 0.0, "a2a_cnt": 0, "mix_sum": 0.0, "mix_cnt": 0} ) for project in version_projects: scenario_a2a = f"{project}-A2A" scenario_a2a_mix = f"{project}-H_A2A" if ( scenario_a2a not in scenario_time_data or scenario_a2a_mix not in scenario_time_data ): continue a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append(f"## {project}\n\n") a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append("### Project-Level Summary\n\n") data_a2a = scenario_time_data[scenario_a2a] data_a2a_mix = scenario_time_data[scenario_a2a_mix] all_models = sorted(set(data_a2a.keys()) | set(data_a2a_mix.keys())) # Overall comparison overall_a2a_total = 0.0 overall_a2a_count = 0 overall_a2a_mix_total = 0.0 overall_a2a_mix_count = 0 for model in all_models: stats_a2a = compute_time_statistics(data_a2a.get(model, [])) stats_a2a_mix = compute_time_statistics(data_a2a_mix.get(model, [])) overall_a2a_total += stats_a2a["total"] overall_a2a_count += stats_a2a["count"] overall_a2a_mix_total += stats_a2a_mix["total"] overall_a2a_mix_count += stats_a2a_mix["count"] # accumulate for global per-model summary per_model_global[model]["a2a_sum"] += stats_a2a["total"] per_model_global[model]["a2a_cnt"] += stats_a2a["count"] per_model_global[model]["mix_sum"] += stats_a2a_mix["total"] per_model_global[model]["mix_cnt"] += stats_a2a_mix["count"] if overall_a2a_count > 0 and overall_a2a_mix_count > 0: avg_a2a = overall_a2a_total / overall_a2a_count avg_a2a_mix = overall_a2a_mix_total / overall_a2a_mix_count diff = avg_a2a_mix - avg_a2a pct = (diff / avg_a2a * 100) if avg_a2a > 0 else 0 a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append("### Overall Summary\n\n") a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append( "| A2A Mean (s) | H_A2A Mean (s) | Diff (H_A2A - A2A) |\n" ) a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append("| --- | --- | --- |\n") a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append( f"| {avg_a2a:.2f} | {avg_a2a_mix:.2f} | {diff:+.2f}s ({pct:+.1f}%) |\n\n" ) overall_deltas.append( { "project": project, "a2a": avg_a2a, "mix": avg_a2a_mix, "diff": diff, "pct": pct, } ) # Per-model comparison a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append("### Per-Model Comparison\n\n") a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append( "| Model | A2A Mean (s) | H_A2A Mean (s) | Diff (H_A2A - A2A) |\n" ) a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for model in all_models: stats_a2a = compute_time_statistics(data_a2a.get(model, [])) stats_a2a_mix = compute_time_statistics(data_a2a_mix.get(model, [])) mean_diff = stats_a2a_mix["mean"] - stats_a2a["mean"] mean_pct = ( (mean_diff / stats_a2a["mean"] * 100) if stats_a2a["mean"] > 0 else 0 ) a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append( f"| {model} | {stats_a2a['mean']:.2f} | {stats_a2a_mix['mean']:.2f} | " f"{mean_diff:+.2f}s ({mean_pct:+.1f}%) |\n" ) a2a_mix_comparison_lines.append("\n---\n\n") # Global cross-project summaries (coarse) if overall_deltas: a2a_mix_comparison_lines.insert( 4, "## Overall (All Projects)\n\n" "| Project | A2A Mean (s) | H_A2A Mean (s) | Diff (H_A2A - A2A) |\n" "| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n" + "".join( f"| {d['project']} | {d['a2a']:.2f} | {d['mix']:.2f} | {d['diff']:+.2f}s ({d['pct']:+.1f}%) |\n" for d in overall_deltas ) + "\n", ) if per_model_global: per_model_lines = [] per_model_lines.append("## All Projects Combined (Per-Model)\n\n") per_model_lines.append( "| Model | A2A Mean (s) | H_A2A Mean (s) | Diff (H_A2A - A2A) |\n" ) per_model_lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for model in MODEL_ORDER: stats = per_model_global.get(model) if not stats: continue a2a_cnt = stats["a2a_cnt"] mix_cnt = stats["mix_cnt"] if a2a_cnt <= 0 or mix_cnt <= 0: continue avg_a2a = stats["a2a_sum"] / a2a_cnt avg_mix = stats["mix_sum"] / mix_cnt diff = avg_mix - avg_a2a pct = (diff / avg_a2a * 100) if avg_a2a > 0 else 0 per_model_lines.append( f"| {model} | {avg_a2a:.2f} | {avg_mix:.2f} | {diff:+.2f}s ({pct:+.1f}%) |\n" ) per_model_lines.append("\n---\n\n") # insert after top intro (after first 4 elements added earlier) a2a_mix_comparison_lines[5:5] = per_model_lines a2a_mix_md_path = out_dir / "A2A_vs_H_A2A_Detailed_Comparison.md" a2a_mix_md_path.write_text("".join(a2a_mix_comparison_lines), encoding="utf-8") print(f"Created: {a2a_mix_md_path}") # 5. Generate per-project model comparison for all 21 projects print("\nGenerating per-project model comparisons (21 projects)...") all_project_names = sorted(scenario_time_data.keys()) model_comparison_lines = [] model_comparison_lines.append("# Per-Project Model Performance Comparison\n\n") model_comparison_lines.append( f"This document compares model performance within each of the {len(all_project_names)} projects.\n\n" ) model_comparison_lines.append("Each project shows:\n") model_comparison_lines.append("- Model statistics (mean)\n") model_comparison_lines.append( "- Relative performance compared to the fastest model\n\n" ) # Add global summary across all projects first model_comparison_lines.append("---\n\n") model_comparison_lines.append(generate_overall_model_comparison(scenario_time_data)) model_comparison_lines.append("---\n\n") for project_name in all_project_names: model_comparison_lines.append( generate_project_model_comparison(project_name, scenario_time_data) ) model_comparison_lines.append("---\n\n") model_comparison_md_path = out_dir / "Per_Project_Model_Comparison.md" model_comparison_md_path.write_text( "".join(model_comparison_lines), encoding="utf-8" ) print(f"Created: {model_comparison_md_path}") print("\n" + "=" * 60) print("All time comparison summaries generated!") print("=" * 60) if __name__ == "__main__": main()