#!/usr/bin/env python3 """ Analyze RETRY patterns in the BookWriter-H_A2A project. This script computes: - error locations - retry counts - retry rates Special focus: - BUSINESS-RETRY: [BUSINESS-RETRY] - orchestrator retry: (retry N) / [RETRYN] """ import os import re from pathlib import Path from collections import defaultdict import json import csv # Base directory and model list BASE_DIR = Path("/Users/wzr/TOSEM-2025/RESULTS") MODELS = [ "DeepSeek-R1", "DeepSeek-V3-1", "GPT-4o-mini", "GPT-5", "Gemini-2.5-flash", "Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking", "Qwen3-235b", ] PROJECT_NAME = "BookWriter-H_A2A" def extract_error_info(line: str) -> dict: """Extract error information from a line containing an error marker. Returns: {'has_error': bool, 'node_type': str, 'node_name': str, 'error_msg': str} """ # Strip tree drawing characters (including ─) clean = re.sub(r"^[│├└─\-\s]+", "", line).strip() # Check for the error marker if "❌" not in clean: return {"has_error": False} # Remove the error marker clean = clean.split("❌", 1)[1].lstrip() # Extract node type and name node_match = re.match( r"\[(SPAN|Chain|AGENT|Tool|LLM)\]\s+([^\[\]]+?)(?:\s+\[ERROR:(.*))?$", clean, ) if not node_match: return { "has_error": True, "node_type": "Unknown", "node_name": "Unknown", "error_msg": "", } node_type = node_match.group(1) node_name = node_match.group(2).strip() error_msg = node_match.group(3).strip() if node_match.group(3) else "" # Normalize node names if node_type == "AGENT": node_name = re.sub(r"\._execute_core$", "", node_name) elif node_type == "Tool": node_name = re.sub(r"\._use$", "", node_name) elif node_type == "Chain": node_name = re.sub(r"Crew_[a-f0-9\-]+\.kickoff", "Crew***.kickoff", node_name) return { "has_error": True, "node_type": node_type, "node_name": node_name, "error_msg": error_msg, } def extract_retry_info(line: str) -> dict: """Extract retry information from a line (including BUSINESS-RETRY). Returns: { 'is_retry': bool, 'retry_type': str ('orchestrator' or 'business_logic'), 'retry_number': int (only for orchestrator retries), 'node_type': str, 'node_name': str, 'batch_info': str (BATCH info, if any) } """ # Strip tree drawing characters (including ─) clean = re.sub(r"^[│├└─\-\s]+", "", line).strip() # Check BUSINESS-RETRY: [BUSINESS-RETRY] has_business_retry = "[BUSINESS-RETRY]" in clean # Check orchestrator retry: (retry N) or [RETRYN] orchestrator_retry_match = re.search(r"\(retry\s+(\d+)\)", clean) if not orchestrator_retry_match: orchestrator_retry_match = re.search(r"\[RETRY(\d+)\]", clean) # If neither retry marker exists, return False if not has_business_retry and not orchestrator_retry_match: return {"is_retry": False} # Determine retry type if orchestrator_retry_match: retry_type = "orchestrator" retry_number = int(orchestrator_retry_match.group(1)) else: retry_type = "business_logic" retry_number = 0 # BUSINESS-RETRY has no numeric index # Extract node type and name node_match = re.match( r"(?:❌\s*)?\[(SPAN|Chain|AGENT)\]\s+([^\[\]]+?)(?:\s+\[.*)?$", clean, ) if not node_match: return { "is_retry": True, "retry_type": retry_type, "retry_number": retry_number, "node_type": "Unknown", "node_name": "Unknown", "batch_info": "", } node_type = node_match.group(1) node_name = node_match.group(2).strip() # Extract BATCH info (e.g., 📚BATCH1) batch_match = re.search(r"📚BATCH(\d+)", clean) batch_info = f"BATCH{batch_match.group(1)}" if batch_match else "" # Extract chapter title (content inside the trailing parentheses) chapter_match = re.search(r"\(([^)]+)\)\s*$", clean) if chapter_match: chapter_title = chapter_match.group(1) batch_info = f"{batch_info} ({chapter_title})" if batch_info else chapter_title return { "is_retry": True, "retry_type": retry_type, "retry_number": retry_number, "node_type": node_type, "node_name": node_name, "batch_info": batch_info, } def analyze_session(md_file: str) -> dict: """Analyze a single session's `execution_path.md`. Returns: { 'has_error': bool, 'has_retry': bool, 'has_orchestrator_retry': bool, 'has_business_retry': bool, 'max_retry_number': int, 'total_orchestrator_retries': int, 'total_business_retries': int, 'errors': [{'node_type': str, 'node_name': str, 'error_msg': str}, ...], 'retries': [{ 'retry_type': str, 'retry_number': int, 'node_type': str, 'node_name': str, 'batch_info': str }, ...] } """ if not os.path.exists(md_file): return None with open(md_file, "r", encoding="utf-8") as f: content = f.read() # Extract the "Execution Path Tree" section tree_match = re.search( r"## Execution Path Tree.*?```\n(.*?)```", content, re.DOTALL ) if not tree_match: return None tree_content = tree_match.group(1) errors = [] retries = [] for line in tree_content.split("\n"): if not line.strip(): continue # Check for errors error_info = extract_error_info(line) if error_info["has_error"]: errors.append( { "node_type": error_info.get("node_type", "Unknown"), "node_name": error_info.get("node_name", "Unknown"), "error_msg": error_info.get("error_msg", ""), } ) # Check for retries (including BUSINESS-RETRY) retry_info = extract_retry_info(line) if retry_info["is_retry"]: retries.append( { "retry_type": retry_info["retry_type"], "retry_number": retry_info["retry_number"], "node_type": retry_info["node_type"], "node_name": retry_info["node_name"], "batch_info": retry_info["batch_info"], } ) # Aggregate retry types orchestrator_retries = [r for r in retries if r["retry_type"] == "orchestrator"] business_retries = [r for r in retries if r["retry_type"] == "business_logic"] max_retry = ( max([r["retry_number"] for r in orchestrator_retries]) if orchestrator_retries else 0 ) return { "has_error": len(errors) > 0, "has_retry": len(retries) > 0, "has_orchestrator_retry": len(orchestrator_retries) > 0, "has_business_retry": len(business_retries) > 0, "max_retry_number": max_retry, "total_orchestrator_retries": len(orchestrator_retries), "total_business_retries": len(business_retries), "errors": errors, "retries": retries, } def collect_model_stats(model_name: str) -> dict: """Collect retry statistics for a single model. Returns: { 'model': str, 'total_sessions': int, 'sessions_with_error': int, 'sessions_with_retry': int, 'sessions_with_orchestrator_retry': int, 'sessions_with_business_retry': int, 'total_orchestrator_retry_attempts': int, 'total_business_retry_attempts': int, 'error_by_agent': {agent_name: count}, 'error_types': {error_msg: count}, 'max_retry_number': int, 'business_retry_chapters': {chapter_info: count}, 'session_details': [...] } """ test_results_dir = BASE_DIR / model_name / PROJECT_NAME / "test_results" if not test_results_dir.exists(): return None stats = { "model": model_name, "total_sessions": 0, "sessions_with_error": 0, "sessions_with_retry": 0, "sessions_with_orchestrator_retry": 0, "sessions_with_business_retry": 0, "sessions_with_only_orchestrator_retry": 0, "sessions_with_only_business_retry": 0, "sessions_with_both_retries": 0, "total_orchestrator_retry_attempts": 0, "total_business_retry_attempts": 0, "error_by_agent": defaultdict(int), "error_by_node_type": defaultdict(int), "error_types": defaultdict(int), "max_retry_number": 0, "business_retry_chapters": defaultdict(int), "session_details": [], } for session_dir in sorted(test_results_dir.iterdir()): if not session_dir.is_dir(): continue exec_path_file = session_dir / "execution_path.md" if not exec_path_file.exists(): continue stats["total_sessions"] += 1 analysis = analyze_session(str(exec_path_file)) if not analysis: continue # Count errors and retries if analysis["has_error"]: stats["sessions_with_error"] += 1 if analysis["has_retry"]: stats["sessions_with_retry"] += 1 if analysis["has_orchestrator_retry"]: stats["sessions_with_orchestrator_retry"] += 1 stats["total_orchestrator_retry_attempts"] += analysis[ "total_orchestrator_retries" ] stats["max_retry_number"] = max( stats["max_retry_number"], analysis["max_retry_number"] ) if analysis["has_business_retry"]: stats["sessions_with_business_retry"] += 1 stats["total_business_retry_attempts"] += analysis["total_business_retries"] # Track cases with only one retry type vs. both if analysis["has_orchestrator_retry"] and not analysis["has_business_retry"]: stats["sessions_with_only_orchestrator_retry"] += 1 elif analysis["has_business_retry"] and not analysis["has_orchestrator_retry"]: stats["sessions_with_only_business_retry"] += 1 elif analysis["has_orchestrator_retry"] and analysis["has_business_retry"]: stats["sessions_with_both_retries"] += 1 # Aggregate error locations for error in analysis["errors"]: if error["node_type"] == "AGENT": stats["error_by_agent"][error["node_name"]] += 1 stats["error_by_node_type"][error["node_type"]] += 1 # Use a short prefix of the error message as the error type key error_msg = error["error_msg"] if error_msg: # Take the first 100 characters as the identifier error_type = ( error_msg[:100] if len(error_msg) <= 100 else error_msg[:100] + "..." ) stats["error_types"][error_type] += 1 # Aggregate BUSINESS-RETRY chapters for retry in analysis["retries"]: if retry["retry_type"] == "business_logic" and retry["batch_info"]: stats["business_retry_chapters"][retry["batch_info"]] += 1 # Store session-level details stats["session_details"].append( { "session": session_dir.name, "has_error": analysis["has_error"], "has_retry": analysis["has_retry"], "has_orchestrator_retry": analysis["has_orchestrator_retry"], "has_business_retry": analysis["has_business_retry"], "orchestrator_retry_count": analysis["total_orchestrator_retries"], "business_retry_count": analysis["total_business_retries"], "errors": analysis["errors"], "retries": analysis["retries"], } ) # Compute rates total = stats["total_sessions"] stats["retry_rate"] = ( (stats["sessions_with_retry"] / total * 100) if total > 0 else 0 ) stats["orchestrator_retry_rate"] = ( (stats["sessions_with_orchestrator_retry"] / total * 100) if total > 0 else 0 ) stats["business_retry_rate"] = ( (stats["sessions_with_business_retry"] / total * 100) if total > 0 else 0 ) stats["error_rate"] = ( (stats["sessions_with_error"] / total * 100) if total > 0 else 0 ) # Convert defaultdict to dict for JSON serialization stats["error_by_agent"] = dict(stats["error_by_agent"]) stats["error_by_node_type"] = dict(stats["error_by_node_type"]) stats["error_types"] = dict(stats["error_types"]) stats["business_retry_chapters"] = dict(stats["business_retry_chapters"]) return stats def print_summary(all_stats): """Print summary statistics.""" print("\n" + "=" * 120) print(f"RETRY pattern analysis summary - {PROJECT_NAME}") print("=" * 120 + "\n") # Overall summary table print("## Model summary\n") header = f"{'Model':<30} {'Total':<10} {'Error(%)':<10} {'Retry(%)':<10} {'OrchRetry(%)':<12} {'Business(%)':<12} {'OrchCnt':<12} {'BusinessCnt':<12}" print(header) print("-" * 120) for stats in all_stats: if stats: print( f"{stats['model']:<30} {stats['total_sessions']:<10} " f"{stats['error_rate']:>8.1f}% {stats['retry_rate']:>8.1f}% " f"{stats['orchestrator_retry_rate']:>10.1f}% {stats['business_retry_rate']:>10.1f}% " f"{stats['total_orchestrator_retry_attempts']:<12} {stats['total_business_retry_attempts']:<12}" ) print("\n" + "=" * 120) # Per-model details for stats in all_stats: if not stats: continue print(f"\n### 📊 {stats['model']}\n") print(f"- **Total sessions**: {stats['total_sessions']}") print( f"- **Sessions with errors**: {stats['sessions_with_error']} ({stats['error_rate']:.1f}%)" ) print( f"- **Sessions with retries**: {stats['sessions_with_retry']} ({stats['retry_rate']:.1f}%)" ) print( f" - Orchestrator retry: {stats['sessions_with_orchestrator_retry']} ({stats['orchestrator_retry_rate']:.1f}%) " f"[only-orchestrator: {stats['sessions_with_only_orchestrator_retry']}]" ) print( f" - BUSINESS-RETRY: {stats['sessions_with_business_retry']} ({stats['business_retry_rate']:.1f}%) " f"[only-business: {stats['sessions_with_only_business_retry']}]" ) print(f" - Both retry types: {stats['sessions_with_both_retries']}") print("- **Total retry attempts**:") print(f" - Orchestrator retry: {stats['total_orchestrator_retry_attempts']}") print(f" - BUSINESS-RETRY: {stats['total_business_retry_attempts']}") print(f"- **Max orchestrator retry index**: {stats['max_retry_number']}") if stats["error_by_agent"]: print("\n**Top agents with errors**:") for agent, count in sorted( stats["error_by_agent"].items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True )[:5]: print(f" - {agent}: {count}") if stats["business_retry_chapters"]: print("\n**BUSINESS-RETRY chapters (top 10)**:") for chapter, count in sorted( stats["business_retry_chapters"].items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True, )[:10]: print(f" - [{count}] {chapter}") if stats["error_types"]: print("\n**Top error types (top 3)**:") for error_type, count in sorted( stats["error_types"].items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True )[:3]: print(f" - [{count}] {error_type}") print("\n" + "-" * 120) def save_results(all_stats): """Save results to files.""" output_dir = Path(__file__).parent # Save detailed JSON json_file = output_dir / "retry_analysis.json" json_data = [] for stats in all_stats: if stats: json_data.append(stats) with open(json_file, "w", encoding="utf-8") as f: json.dump(json_data, f, indent=2, ensure_ascii=False) print(f"\n✅ Detailed JSON saved: {json_file}") # Save CSV summary csv_file = output_dir / "retry_summary.csv" with open(csv_file, "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as f: writer = csv.writer(f) writer.writerow( [ "Model", "Total_Sessions", "Sessions_With_Error", "Error_Rate(%)", "Sessions_With_Retry", "Retry_Rate(%)", "Orchestrator_Retry_Sessions", "Orchestrator_Retry_Rate(%)", "Only_Orchestrator_Retry_Sessions", "Business_Retry_Sessions", "Business_Retry_Rate(%)", "Only_Business_Retry_Sessions", "Both_Retries_Sessions", "Total_Orchestrator_Retries", "Total_Business_Retries", "Max_Retry_Number", ] ) for stats in all_stats: if stats: writer.writerow( [ stats["model"], stats["total_sessions"], stats["sessions_with_error"], f"{stats['error_rate']:.2f}", stats["sessions_with_retry"], f"{stats['retry_rate']:.2f}", stats["sessions_with_orchestrator_retry"], f"{stats['orchestrator_retry_rate']:.2f}", stats["sessions_with_only_orchestrator_retry"], stats["sessions_with_business_retry"], f"{stats['business_retry_rate']:.2f}", stats["sessions_with_only_business_retry"], stats["sessions_with_both_retries"], stats["total_orchestrator_retry_attempts"], stats["total_business_retry_attempts"], stats["max_retry_number"], ] ) print(f"✅ CSV summary saved: {csv_file}") # Save error location stats (by agent) error_csv_file = output_dir / "error_by_agent.csv" with open(error_csv_file, "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as f: writer = csv.writer(f) writer.writerow(["Model", "Agent_Name", "Error_Count"]) for stats in all_stats: if stats and stats["error_by_agent"]: for agent, count in sorted( stats["error_by_agent"].items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True ): writer.writerow([stats["model"], agent, count]) print(f"✅ Error location stats (by agent) saved: {error_csv_file}") # Save BUSINESS-RETRY chapter stats chapter_csv_file = output_dir / "business_retry_chapters.csv" with open(chapter_csv_file, "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as f: writer = csv.writer(f) writer.writerow(["Model", "Chapter_Info", "Retry_Count"]) for stats in all_stats: if stats and stats["business_retry_chapters"]: for chapter, count in sorted( stats["business_retry_chapters"].items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True, ): writer.writerow([stats["model"], chapter, count]) print(f"✅ BUSINESS-RETRY chapter stats saved: {chapter_csv_file}") if __name__ == "__main__": print(f"Starting RETRY pattern analysis - {PROJECT_NAME}...") print("Retry types:") print(" 1. Orchestrator retry: (retry N) or [RETRYN]") print(" 2. BUSINESS-RETRY: [BUSINESS-RETRY]\n") all_stats = [] for model in MODELS: print(f"\n📊 Analyzing model: {model}") stats = collect_model_stats(model) if stats: all_stats.append(stats) print( f" ✅ Done: {stats['total_sessions']} sessions, " f"{stats['sessions_with_error']} errors, " f"{stats['sessions_with_orchestrator_retry']} orch-retries, " f"{stats['sessions_with_business_retry']} business-retries" ) else: print(" ⚠️ Skipped (directory not found)") print_summary(all_stats) save_results(all_stats) print("\n" + "=" * 120) print("✅ Done!") print("=" * 120)