# Full reference-trajectory configuration - SocialMediaManager-H_A2A # # Version: ported from SocialMediaManager-A2A and adapted to the A2A_mix hybrid architecture # Principle: keep business logic unchanged while adapting to the hybrid framework hierarchy (LangGraph + CrewAI + AutoGen) # # A2A_mix hybrid-architecture characteristics: # - Stage 1 (Topic Analysis): LangGraph # * Uses [Chain] LangGraph instead of CrewAI's Crew***.kickoff # * Uses a simplified AGENT name: "agent" (not the full role name) # * Tool calls appear under [Chain] tools, supporting batched execution # * LangGraph-specific chains: _should_continue and format_output # # - Stage 2 (Content Generation): CrewAI # * Keeps the standard [Chain] Crew***.kickoff structure # * Uses the full agent role name: "Shakespearean Bard._execute_core" # * Tool calls appear directly under AGENT (no intermediate Chain) # # - Stage 3 (Post Review): AutoGen # * AGENT pattern: create_agent + invoke_agent # * Ignore create_agent (excluded from evaluation) # * Focus on invoke_agent execution # * Tool prefix is "execute_tool" # * Filter all [SPAN] mcp client/operation and its children # # Dynamic reference-trajectory design (5-way dynamic composition): # 1. LangGraph tools batched-execution grouping (2 options): # - [1,1]: two Chain: tools, each containing 1 tool # - [2]: one Chain: tools containing 2 tools # # 2. LangGraph tools order (2! = 2 options): # - keyword_extractor → topic_complexity_analyzer # - topic_complexity_analyzer → keyword_extractor # # 3. AutoGen LLM/Tool insertion pattern (2^4 = 16 options): # Rule: must start and end with an LLM; between adjacent tools there may be 0 or 1 LLM # - 5 tools have 4 adjacency gaps → 2^4 = 16 combinations # - Example: LLM → Tool1 → Tool2 → Tool3 → Tool4 → Tool5 → LLM (no insertion) # LLM → Tool1 → LLM → Tool2 → LLM → Tool3 → LLM → Tool4 → LLM → Tool5 → LLM (insert everywhere) # # 4. AutoGen tools order (5! = 120 options): # - The 5 verification tools can appear in any order # - character_counter_tool, emoji_detector_tool, post_structure_validator, # shakespearean_style_detector, tone_analyzer # # 5. CrewAI tool order (5! = 120 options): # - Shakespearean Bard's 5 validation tools can appear in any order # - keyword_extractor must be the first tool (not permuted) # # Total combinations: 2 × 2 × 16 × 120 × 120 = 921,600 reference variants # # Evaluation strategy: for each sample, select the variant with the highest score: # exact_match×3 + in_order_match×2 + any_order_match×1 # Project name project_name: "SocialMediaManager-H_A2A" # Extraction types extract_types: - "SPAN" # multi-level SPAN structure - "Chain" # Chain nodes for LangGraph/CrewAI - "AGENT" # Agent nodes (AutoGen: only invoke_agent is extracted) - "LLM" # LLM calls - "Tool" # tool calls # ============================================================================ # Reference trajectory (Ground Truth) - A2A_mix hybrid architecture # ============================================================================ # # Visual structure (ideal execution path; example with batched tools execution): # # [SPAN] shakespeare_x_post_orchestrator # └─ [SPAN] crew_execution # ├─ [SPAN] analyze_topic (LangGraph) # │ └─ [SPAN] a2a_call_topic_analyzer # │ └─ [SPAN] topic_analyzer_server_execution # │ └─ [Chain] LangGraph # │ ├─ [AGENT] agent # │ │ ├─ [LLM] * # │ │ └─ [Chain] _should_continue # │ ├─ [Chain] tools (batched execution of 2 tools; possible groupings: 1+1, 2) # │ │ ├─ [Tool] keyword_extractor # │ │ └─ [Tool] topic_complexity_analyzer # │ ├─ [AGENT] agent # │ │ ├─ [LLM] * # │ │ └─ [Chain] _should_continue # │ └─ [Chain] format_output # └─ [SPAN] content_generation_loop # ├─ [SPAN] a2a_call_content_generator (CrewAI) # │ └─ [SPAN] content_generator_server_execution # │ └─ [Chain] Crew***.kickoff # │ └─ [AGENT] Shakespearean Bard # │ ├─ [LLM] * # │ ├─ [Tool] keyword_extractor # │ ├─ [LLM] * # │ ├─ [Tool] character_counter_tool # │ ├─ [LLM] * # │ ├─ [Tool] emoji_detector_tool # │ ├─ [LLM] * # │ ├─ [Tool] post_structure_validator # │ ├─ [LLM] * # │ ├─ [Tool] shakespearean_style_detector # │ ├─ [LLM] * # │ ├─ [Tool] tone_analyzer # │ └─ [LLM] * # └─ [SPAN] a2a_call_post_reviewer (AutoGen) # └─ [SPAN] post_reviewer_autogen_execution # └─ [AGENT] invoke_agent x_post_verifier # ├─ [LLM] * # ├─ [Tool] execute_tool character_counter_tool # ├─ [Tool] execute_tool emoji_detector_tool # ├─ [Tool] execute_tool post_structure_validator # ├─ [Tool] execute_tool shakespearean_style_detector # ├─ [Tool] execute_tool tone_analyzer # └─ [LLM] * # # Notes: # - Under LangGraph's [Chain] tools there may be batched calls (2 tools can be grouped as 1+1 or 2) # - AutoGen create_agent nodes are excluded from the reference trajectory # - AutoGen [SPAN] mcp client/operation and its children are excluded from the reference trajectory # - Between AutoGen tools there may be 0 or 1 LLM; the evaluator will generate all valid patterns # ============================================================================ # Default reference trajectory (compatibility): batched LangGraph tools, AutoGen compact mode reference_trajectory: # ===== Top-level SPAN ===== - "SPAN: shakespeare_x_post_orchestrator" # ===== Second-level SPAN (includes retry logic) ===== - "SPAN: crew_execution" # ===== Stage 1: Topic Analysis (LangGraph; 2 tools) ===== - "SPAN: analyze_topic" - "SPAN: a2a_call_topic_analyzer" - "SPAN: topic_analyzer_server_execution" - "Chain: LangGraph" - "AGENT: agent" - "LLM: *" - "Chain: _should_continue" - "Chain: tools" - "Tool: keyword_extractor" - "Tool: topic_complexity_analyzer" - "AGENT: agent" - "LLM: *" - "Chain: _should_continue" - "Chain: format_output" # ===== Stage 2: Content Generation (CrewAI) ===== - "SPAN: content_generation_loop" - "SPAN: a2a_call_content_generator" - "SPAN: content_generator_server_execution" - "Chain: Crew***.kickoff" - "AGENT: Shakespearean Bard" - "LLM: *" - "Tool: keyword_extractor" - "LLM: *" - "Tool: character_counter_tool" - "LLM: *" - "Tool: emoji_detector_tool" - "LLM: *" - "Tool: post_structure_validator" - "LLM: *" - "Tool: shakespearean_style_detector" - "LLM: *" - "Tool: tone_analyzer" - "LLM: *" # ===== Stage 3: Post Review (AutoGen) ===== - "SPAN: a2a_call_post_reviewer" - "SPAN: post_reviewer_autogen_execution" - "AGENT: invoke_agent x_post_verifier" - "LLM: *" - "Tool: execute_tool character_counter_tool" - "Tool: execute_tool emoji_detector_tool" - "Tool: execute_tool post_structure_validator" - "Tool: execute_tool shakespearean_style_detector" - "Tool: execute_tool tone_analyzer" - "LLM: *" # Target tool list (used for the single-tool use metric) target_tools: # Topic Analysis stage (LangGraph) - "Tool: keyword_extractor" - "Tool: topic_complexity_analyzer" # Content Generation stage (CrewAI) - "Tool: character_counter_tool" - "Tool: emoji_detector_tool" - "Tool: post_structure_validator" - "Tool: shakespearean_style_detector" - "Tool: tone_analyzer" # Post Review stage (AutoGen; note the execute_tool prefix) - "Tool: execute_tool character_counter_tool" - "Tool: execute_tool emoji_detector_tool" - "Tool: execute_tool post_structure_validator" - "Tool: execute_tool shakespearean_style_detector" - "Tool: execute_tool tone_analyzer" # Models to evaluate models: - "GPT-5" - "GPT-4o-mini" - "DeepSeek-V3-1" - "DeepSeek-R1" - "Gemini-2.5-flash" - "Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking" - "Qwen3-235b" # Permutable tool-group configuration (for dynamic tool-order matching) permutable_tool_groups: # Shakespearean Bard validation tools can be in any order (CrewAI part) # Note: keyword_extractor must be the first tool and is not permuted shakespearean_bard_validation_tools: - "Tool: character_counter_tool" - "Tool: emoji_detector_tool" - "Tool: post_structure_validator" - "Tool: shakespearean_style_detector" - "Tool: tone_analyzer" # ============================================================================ # Usage notes - A2A_mix hybrid architecture # ============================================================================ # # 1. Hybrid framework characteristics: # - Stage 1 (Topic Analysis): LangGraph # * Chain name: LangGraph (not Crew***.kickoff) # * Simplified AGENT name: agent (not a full role name) # * Batched tool execution: [Chain] tools may contain multiple Tool nodes # * Special chains: _should_continue and format_output # # - Stage 2 (Content Generation): CrewAI # * Standard CrewAI structure: Crew***.kickoff → AGENT → LLM/Tool # * Full AGENT name: Shakespearean Bard # * keyword_extractor must be the first tool; subsequent validation tools may be in any order # # - Stage 3 (Post Review): AutoGen # * Ignore create_agent (excluded from evaluation) # * Focus on invoke_agent x_post_verifier # * Tool prefix: execute_tool # * Filter all [SPAN] mcp client/operation and its children # # 2. LangGraph dynamic tool mode (grouping + order): # The evaluator automatically detects the tools grouping pattern and tool order in each sample, # and dynamically generates matching reference variants. # # Grouping patterns (2 options): # - [1,1]: 2 Chain: tools, each with 1 Tool # - [2]: 1 Chain: tools, with 2 Tools # # Tool order (2! = 2 options): # - keyword_extractor → topic_complexity_analyzer # - topic_complexity_analyzer → keyword_extractor # # 3. AutoGen dynamic mode (LLM insertion + tool order): # The evaluator automatically detects the LLM/Tool calling pattern and tool order in AutoGen, # and dynamically generates matching reference variants. # # LLM insertion patterns (2^4 = 16 options): # - Compact: LLM → Tool1 → Tool2 → Tool3 → Tool4 → Tool5 → LLM # (consecutive tool calls with no LLM between tools) # - Interleaved: LLM → Tool1 → LLM → Tool2 → ... → Tool5 → LLM # (LLM calls interleaved between tools) # - Mixed: LLM is inserted between some tools but not others (16 combinations) # # Tool order (5! = 120 options): # - The 5 verification tools can be in any order # - character_counter_tool, emoji_detector_tool, post_structure_validator, # shakespearean_style_detector, tone_analyzer # # Validation rules: # - Must start and end with an LLM # - Must contain all 5 target tools in the middle (order can vary) # - At most one LLM between adjacent tools # # 4. Dynamic reference selection strategy (5-way combination): # For each sample: # a) Detect the actual LangGraph tools grouping pattern # b) Enumerate LangGraph tool order (2! = 2) # c) Detect the actual AutoGen Post Review LLM/Tool pattern # d) Enumerate AutoGen tool order (5! = 120) # e) Enumerate CrewAI tool permutations (5! = 120) # f) Enumerate all combinations # - LangGraph grouping: 2 # - LangGraph order: 2 # - AutoGen LLM insertion: 16 # - AutoGen order: 120 # - CrewAI permutations: 120 # - Total variants: 2 × 2 × 16 × 120 × 120 = 921,600 # g) For each variant compute exact_match, in_order_match, any_order_match # h) Select the variant with the highest composite score # Composite score = exact_match×3 + in_order_match×2 + any_order_match×1 # # 5. Metric definitions (consistent with A2A): # - Exact Match: predicted trajectory matches the reference exactly # - In-order Match: reference is a subsequence of the predicted trajectory # - Any-order Match: all required steps are present (order ignored) # - Precision: fraction of predicted steps that are correct # - Recall: fraction of reference steps covered by prediction # - Single-tool Use: average usage rate of target tools # - unique_path_ratio: path diversity # - path_entropy: path entropy # # 6. Run command: # cd /Users/wzr/TOSEM-2025/RESULTS/RQ-Failure_Breakdown/SocialMediaManager-H_A2A # python3 evaluate_trajectory.py --config reference_trajectory.yaml # # 7. Key differences vs the A2A version: # - LangGraph-specific Chain node structure # - Simplified AGENT name (LangGraph uses "agent") # - AutoGen invoke_agent pattern # - Dynamic handling of LangGraph batched tools execution # - Dynamic handling of AutoGen LLM/Tool insertion patterns (new) # - AutoGen tool prefix: execute_tool (not CrewAI tool names) # - Filter AutoGen MCP client/operation SPAN nodes # - Triple dynamic matching across LangGraph, CrewAI, and AutoGen # # 8. Special filtering rules: # - Filter all [SPAN] mcp client/operation and its children (AutoGen noise) # - Filter [AGENT] create_agent (AutoGen initialization, not business logic) # - Keep [AGENT] invoke_agent (actual AutoGen execution) # # 9. Tool-order notes: # - LangGraph Topic Analysis: 2 tools can be in any order (2! = 2) # - CrewAI Shakespearean Bard: keyword_extractor must be first; the 5 validation tools can be permuted (5! = 120) # - AutoGen Post Review: the 5 verification tools can be in any order (5! = 120) #