#!/usr/bin/env python3 """ Generate radar charts for evaluation results across different scenarios. Creates one PDF radar chart per subfolder showing all models' performance. """ import pandas as pd import numpy as np from pathlib import Path import math try: import matplotlib.pyplot as plt import matplotlib as mpl from matplotlib.patches import Circle mpl.rcParams["font.family"] = "Times New Roman" except ImportError: plt = None mpl = None Circle = None # Metrics to plot METRICS = [ "exact_match", "any_order_match", "precision", "recall", "retry_rate", "pass_rate", ] # Color palette for different models - professional academic colors (Tableau 10 style) MODEL_COLORS = { "GPT-5": "#1f77b4", # Blue "GPT-4o-mini": "#ff7f0e", # Orange "DeepSeek-V3-1": "#2ca02c", # Green "DeepSeek-R1": "#d62728", # Red "Gemini-2.5-flash": "#9467bd", # Purple "Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking": "#8c564b", # Brown "Qwen3-235b": "#e377c2", # Pink } MODEL_CATEGORY = { "GPT-5": "closed", "GPT-4o-mini": "closed", "DeepSeek-V3-1": "open", "DeepSeek-R1": "open", "Gemini-2.5-flash": "closed", "Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking": "closed", "Qwen3-235b": "open", } def df_to_markdown(df): """Convert a DataFrame to a simple markdown table without external deps.""" headers = list(df.columns) lines = [] lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |") for _, row in df.iterrows(): values = [] for val in row: if isinstance(val, float): values.append(f"{val:.2f}") else: values.append(str(val)) lines.append("| " + " | ".join(values) + " |") return "\n".join(lines) def metric_display_name(metric, base_project, gt_projects): if metric == "pass_rate" and gt_projects and base_project in gt_projects: return "average_score" return metric def series_metric_headers(series_name, gt_projects): rate_label = ( "average_score" if gt_projects and series_name in gt_projects else "pass_rate" ) return [(rate_label if m == "pass_rate" else m) for m in METRICS] def generate_model_pair_comparison( model_a, model_b, data_dict, comparison_name, gt_projects=None ): """Generate comparison table between two models across all scenarios.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# {comparison_name}\n\n") # Group scenarios by base project name (remove -A2A, -A2A_mix, -MCP suffixes) project_series = {} for scenario_name in data_dict.keys(): # Extract base project name base_name = scenario_name for suffix in ["-A2A_mix", "-A2A", "-MCP"]: if scenario_name.endswith(suffix): base_name = scenario_name[: -len(suffix)] break if base_name not in project_series: project_series[base_name] = [] project_series[base_name].append(scenario_name) # Calculate averaged metrics for each project series series_data = {} for base_name, scenarios in project_series.items(): series_data[base_name] = {model_a: {}, model_b: {}} for metric in METRICS: vals_a = [] vals_b = [] for scenario_name in scenarios: scenario_data = data_dict[scenario_name] if model_a in scenario_data and model_b in scenario_data: vals_a.append(scenario_data[model_a].get(metric, 0)) vals_b.append(scenario_data[model_b].get(metric, 0)) if vals_a and vals_b: series_data[base_name][model_a][metric] = np.mean(vals_a) series_data[base_name][model_b][metric] = np.mean(vals_b) # Calculate overall averages overall_avgs = { metric: {"a": [], "b": []} for metric in METRICS if metric != "pass_rate" } overall_rate_avgs = { "gt": {"a": [], "b": []}, "non_gt": {"a": [], "b": []}, } for base_name in series_data.keys(): for metric in METRICS: if ( metric not in series_data[base_name][model_a] or metric not in series_data[base_name][model_b] ): continue if metric == "pass_rate": bucket = "gt" if gt_projects and base_name in gt_projects else "non_gt" overall_rate_avgs[bucket]["a"].append( series_data[base_name][model_a][metric] ) overall_rate_avgs[bucket]["b"].append( series_data[base_name][model_b][metric] ) continue overall_avgs[metric]["a"].append(series_data[base_name][model_a][metric]) overall_avgs[metric]["b"].append(series_data[base_name][model_b][metric]) # Add overall summary section lines.append("## Overall Summary (Averaged Across All Project Series)\n\n") lines.append(f"| Metric | {model_a} | {model_b} | Diff (A-B) |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for metric in METRICS: if metric == "pass_rate": if overall_rate_avgs["gt"]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(overall_rate_avgs["gt"]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(overall_rate_avgs["gt"]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b lines.append( f"| average_score | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) if overall_rate_avgs["non_gt"]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(overall_rate_avgs["non_gt"]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(overall_rate_avgs["non_gt"]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b lines.append( f"| pass_rate | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) continue if overall_avgs[metric]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(overall_avgs[metric]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(overall_avgs[metric]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b lines.append(f"| {metric} | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n") lines.append("\n---\n\n") # Add per-series comparisons headers = ["Project Series", f"{model_a}", f"{model_b}", "Diff (A-B)"] for metric in METRICS: if metric != "pass_rate": lines.append(f"## {metric}\n\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for base_name in sorted(series_data.keys()): if ( metric in series_data[base_name][model_a] and metric in series_data[base_name][model_b] ): val_a = series_data[base_name][model_a][metric] val_b = series_data[base_name][model_b][metric] diff = val_a - val_b lines.append( f"| {base_name} | {val_a:.2f} | {val_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n") continue lines.append("## average_score\n\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for base_name in sorted(series_data.keys()): if gt_projects and base_name not in gt_projects: continue if ( metric in series_data[base_name][model_a] and metric in series_data[base_name][model_b] ): val_a = series_data[base_name][model_a][metric] val_b = series_data[base_name][model_b][metric] diff = val_a - val_b lines.append( f"| {base_name} | {val_a:.2f} | {val_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n") lines.append("## pass_rate\n\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for base_name in sorted(series_data.keys()): if gt_projects and base_name in gt_projects: continue if ( metric in series_data[base_name][model_a] and metric in series_data[base_name][model_b] ): val_a = series_data[base_name][model_a][metric] val_b = series_data[base_name][model_b][metric] diff = val_a - val_b lines.append( f"| {base_name} | {val_a:.2f} | {val_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_mcp_comparison(base_project, scenario_data_dict, gt_projects=None): """Generate comparison between MCP and hardcoded versions for a project.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# {base_project}: MCP vs Hardcoded\n\n") mcp_scenario = f"{base_project}-MCP" hardcoded_scenario = base_project if ( mcp_scenario not in scenario_data_dict or hardcoded_scenario not in scenario_data_dict ): lines.append(f"_Data not available for comparison_\n\n") return "".join(lines) mcp_data = scenario_data_dict[mcp_scenario] hardcoded_data = scenario_data_dict[hardcoded_scenario] all_models = set(mcp_data.keys()) | set(hardcoded_data.keys()) # Calculate overall averages first overall_avgs = {metric: {"mcp": [], "hard": []} for metric in METRICS} for model in all_models: for metric in METRICS: mcp_val = mcp_data.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) hard_val = hardcoded_data.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) overall_avgs[metric]["mcp"].append(mcp_val) overall_avgs[metric]["hard"].append(hard_val) # Add overall summary section lines.append("## Overall Summary (Averaged Across All Models)\n\n") lines.append("| Metric | MCP | Hardcoded | Diff (MCP-Hardcoded) |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for metric in METRICS: if overall_avgs[metric]["mcp"]: avg_mcp = np.mean(overall_avgs[metric]["mcp"]) avg_hard = np.mean(overall_avgs[metric]["hard"]) diff = avg_mcp - avg_hard display_metric = metric_display_name(metric, base_project, gt_projects) lines.append( f"| {display_metric} | {avg_mcp:.2f} | {avg_hard:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n---\n\n") for metric in METRICS: display_metric = metric_display_name(metric, base_project, gt_projects) lines.append(f"## {display_metric}\n\n") headers = ["Model", "MCP", "Hardcoded", "Diff (MCP-Hardcoded)"] lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for model in sorted(all_models): mcp_val = mcp_data.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) hard_val = hardcoded_data.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) diff = mcp_val - hard_val lines.append( f"| {model} | {mcp_val:.2f} | {hard_val:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_mcp_overall_comparison(projects, scenario_data_dict, gt_projects=None): """Generate overall comparison across all MCP vs hardcoded projects.""" lines = [] lines.append("# Overall MCP vs Hardcoded Comparison\n\n") lines.append( "Averaged across all projects: MarkdownValidator, GameBuilder, EmailResponder\n\n" ) # Collect data from all projects overall_data = {} framework_data = { metric: {"mcp": [], "hard": []} for metric in METRICS if metric != "pass_rate" } framework_rate_data = { "gt": {"mcp": [], "hard": []}, "non_gt": {"mcp": [], "hard": []}, } overall_rate_data = {} for project in projects: mcp_scenario = f"{project}-MCP" hardcoded_scenario = project if ( mcp_scenario not in scenario_data_dict or hardcoded_scenario not in scenario_data_dict ): continue mcp_data = scenario_data_dict[mcp_scenario] hardcoded_data = scenario_data_dict[hardcoded_scenario] all_models = set(mcp_data.keys()) | set(hardcoded_data.keys()) project_bucket = "gt" if gt_projects and project in gt_projects else "non_gt" for model in all_models: if model not in overall_data: overall_data[model] = { metric: {"mcp": [], "hard": []} for metric in METRICS if metric != "pass_rate" } if model not in overall_rate_data: overall_rate_data[model] = { "gt": {"mcp": [], "hard": []}, "non_gt": {"mcp": [], "hard": []}, } for metric in METRICS: mcp_val = mcp_data.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) hard_val = hardcoded_data.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) if metric == "pass_rate": overall_rate_data[model][project_bucket]["mcp"].append(mcp_val) overall_rate_data[model][project_bucket]["hard"].append(hard_val) framework_rate_data[project_bucket]["mcp"].append(mcp_val) framework_rate_data[project_bucket]["hard"].append(hard_val) else: overall_data[model][metric]["mcp"].append(mcp_val) overall_data[model][metric]["hard"].append(hard_val) framework_data[metric]["mcp"].append(mcp_val) framework_data[metric]["hard"].append(hard_val) # Add framework-level comparison (all models averaged) lines.append("## Framework-Level Comparison (All Models Averaged)\n\n") lines.append("| Metric | MCP | Hardcoded | Diff (MCP-Hardcoded) |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for metric in METRICS: if metric == "pass_rate": if framework_rate_data["gt"]["mcp"]: avg_mcp = np.mean(framework_rate_data["gt"]["mcp"]) avg_hard = np.mean(framework_rate_data["gt"]["hard"]) diff = avg_mcp - avg_hard lines.append( f"| average_score | {avg_mcp:.2f} | {avg_hard:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) if framework_rate_data["non_gt"]["mcp"]: avg_mcp = np.mean(framework_rate_data["non_gt"]["mcp"]) avg_hard = np.mean(framework_rate_data["non_gt"]["hard"]) diff = avg_mcp - avg_hard lines.append( f"| pass_rate | {avg_mcp:.2f} | {avg_hard:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) continue if framework_data[metric]["mcp"]: avg_mcp = np.mean(framework_data[metric]["mcp"]) avg_hard = np.mean(framework_data[metric]["hard"]) diff = avg_mcp - avg_hard lines.append( f"| {metric} | {avg_mcp:.2f} | {avg_hard:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n---\n\n") # Generate per-model summary tables for metric in METRICS: if metric != "pass_rate": lines.append(f"## {metric}\n\n") headers = [ "Model", "MCP (Avg)", "Hardcoded (Avg)", "Diff (MCP-Hardcoded)", ] lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for model in sorted(overall_data.keys()): if overall_data[model][metric]["mcp"]: avg_mcp = np.mean(overall_data[model][metric]["mcp"]) avg_hard = np.mean(overall_data[model][metric]["hard"]) diff = avg_mcp - avg_hard lines.append( f"| {model} | {avg_mcp:.2f} | {avg_hard:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n") continue lines.append("## average_score\n\n") headers = ["Model", "MCP (Avg)", "Hardcoded (Avg)", "Diff (MCP-Hardcoded)"] lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for model in sorted(overall_rate_data.keys()): if overall_rate_data[model]["gt"]["mcp"]: avg_mcp = np.mean(overall_rate_data[model]["gt"]["mcp"]) avg_hard = np.mean(overall_rate_data[model]["gt"]["hard"]) diff = avg_mcp - avg_hard lines.append( f"| {model} | {avg_mcp:.2f} | {avg_hard:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n") lines.append("## pass_rate\n\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for model in sorted(overall_rate_data.keys()): if overall_rate_data[model]["non_gt"]["mcp"]: avg_mcp = np.mean(overall_rate_data[model]["non_gt"]["mcp"]) avg_hard = np.mean(overall_rate_data[model]["non_gt"]["hard"]) diff = avg_mcp - avg_hard lines.append( f"| {model} | {avg_mcp:.2f} | {avg_hard:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n") lines.append("---\n\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_version_comparison( base_project, version_a_suffix, version_b_suffix, scenario_data_dict, version_a_name, version_b_name, gt_projects=None, ): """Generate comparison between two versions of a project.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# {base_project}: {version_a_name} vs {version_b_name}\n\n") scenario_a = f"{base_project}{version_a_suffix}" scenario_b = f"{base_project}{version_b_suffix}" if scenario_a not in scenario_data_dict or scenario_b not in scenario_data_dict: lines.append(f"_Data not available for comparison_\n\n") return "".join(lines) data_a = scenario_data_dict[scenario_a] data_b = scenario_data_dict[scenario_b] all_models = set(data_a.keys()) | set(data_b.keys()) # Calculate overall averages first overall_avgs = {metric: {"a": [], "b": []} for metric in METRICS} for model in all_models: for metric in METRICS: val_a = data_a.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) val_b = data_b.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) overall_avgs[metric]["a"].append(val_a) overall_avgs[metric]["b"].append(val_b) # Add overall summary section lines.append("## Overall Summary (Averaged Across All Models)\n\n") lines.append( f"| Metric | {version_a_name} | {version_b_name} | Diff ({version_a_name}-{version_b_name}) |\n" ) lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for metric in METRICS: if overall_avgs[metric]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(overall_avgs[metric]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(overall_avgs[metric]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b display_metric = metric_display_name(metric, base_project, gt_projects) lines.append( f"| {display_metric} | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n---\n\n") for metric in METRICS: display_metric = metric_display_name(metric, base_project, gt_projects) lines.append(f"## {display_metric}\n\n") headers = [ "Model", version_a_name, version_b_name, f"Diff ({version_a_name}-{version_b_name})", ] lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for model in sorted(all_models): val_a = data_a.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) val_b = data_b.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) diff = val_a - val_b lines.append(f"| {model} | {val_a:.2f} | {val_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n") lines.append("\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_version_overall_comparison( projects, version_a_suffix, version_b_suffix, scenario_data_dict, version_a_name, version_b_name, comparison_title, gt_projects=None, ): """Generate overall comparison across all projects for two versions.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# Overall {comparison_title}\n\n") lines.append(f"Averaged across all projects: {', '.join(projects)}\n\n") # Collect data from all projects overall_data = {} framework_data = { metric: {"a": [], "b": []} for metric in METRICS if metric != "pass_rate" } framework_rate_data = { "gt": {"a": [], "b": []}, "non_gt": {"a": [], "b": []}, } overall_rate_data = {} for project in projects: scenario_a = f"{project}{version_a_suffix}" scenario_b = f"{project}{version_b_suffix}" if scenario_a not in scenario_data_dict or scenario_b not in scenario_data_dict: continue data_a = scenario_data_dict[scenario_a] data_b = scenario_data_dict[scenario_b] all_models = set(data_a.keys()) | set(data_b.keys()) project_bucket = "gt" if gt_projects and project in gt_projects else "non_gt" for model in all_models: if model not in overall_data: overall_data[model] = { metric: {"a": [], "b": []} for metric in METRICS if metric != "pass_rate" } if model not in overall_rate_data: overall_rate_data[model] = { "gt": {"a": [], "b": []}, "non_gt": {"a": [], "b": []}, } for metric in METRICS: val_a = data_a.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) val_b = data_b.get(model, {}).get(metric, 0) if metric == "pass_rate": overall_rate_data[model][project_bucket]["a"].append(val_a) overall_rate_data[model][project_bucket]["b"].append(val_b) framework_rate_data[project_bucket]["a"].append(val_a) framework_rate_data[project_bucket]["b"].append(val_b) else: overall_data[model][metric]["a"].append(val_a) overall_data[model][metric]["b"].append(val_b) framework_data[metric]["a"].append(val_a) framework_data[metric]["b"].append(val_b) # Add framework-level comparison (all models averaged) lines.append("## Framework-Level Comparison (All Models Averaged)\n\n") lines.append( f"| Metric | {version_a_name} | {version_b_name} | Diff ({version_a_name}-{version_b_name}) |\n" ) lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for metric in METRICS: if metric == "pass_rate": if framework_rate_data["gt"]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(framework_rate_data["gt"]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(framework_rate_data["gt"]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b lines.append( f"| average_score | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) if framework_rate_data["non_gt"]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(framework_rate_data["non_gt"]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(framework_rate_data["non_gt"]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b lines.append( f"| pass_rate | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) continue if framework_data[metric]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(framework_data[metric]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(framework_data[metric]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b lines.append(f"| {metric} | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n") lines.append("\n---\n\n") # Generate per-model summary tables for metric in METRICS: headers = [ "Model", f"{version_a_name} (Avg)", f"{version_b_name} (Avg)", f"Diff ({version_a_name}-{version_b_name})", ] if metric != "pass_rate": lines.append(f"## {metric}\n\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for model in sorted(overall_data.keys()): if overall_data[model][metric]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(overall_data[model][metric]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(overall_data[model][metric]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b lines.append( f"| {model} | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n" ) lines.append("\n") continue lines.append("## average_score\n\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for model in sorted(overall_rate_data.keys()): if overall_rate_data[model]["gt"]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(overall_rate_data[model]["gt"]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(overall_rate_data[model]["gt"]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b lines.append(f"| {model} | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n") lines.append("\n") lines.append("## pass_rate\n\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(headers) + " |\n") lines.append("| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(headers)) + " |\n") for model in sorted(overall_rate_data.keys()): if overall_rate_data[model]["non_gt"]["a"]: avg_a = np.mean(overall_rate_data[model]["non_gt"]["a"]) avg_b = np.mean(overall_rate_data[model]["non_gt"]["b"]) diff = avg_a - avg_b lines.append(f"| {model} | {avg_a:.2f} | {avg_b:.2f} | {diff:+.2f} |\n") lines.append("\n") lines.append("---\n\n") return "".join(lines) def create_radar_chart(df, scenario_name, output_path, pass_rate_label="pass_rate"): """ Create a radar chart for a single scenario with all models. Args: df: DataFrame containing evaluation results scenario_name: Name of the scenario (subfolder name) output_path: Path to save the PDF file """ if plt is None: print( f" Warning: matplotlib not installed, skipping radar chart: {output_path}" ) return # Number of metrics num_vars = len(METRICS) # Compute angle for each axis angles = np.linspace(0, 2 * np.pi, num_vars, endpoint=False).tolist() angles += angles[:1] # Complete the circle # Create figure with polar projection - increase size to avoid overlap fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(12, 12), subplot_kw=dict(projection="polar")) # Set background color to light blue/grey similar to reference ax.set_facecolor("#cedbea") # slightly lighter blue background fig.patch.set_facecolor("white") # Plot data for each model for idx, row in df.iterrows(): model_name = row["model"] values = [row[metric] for metric in METRICS] values += values[:1] # Complete the circle color = MODEL_COLORS.get(model_name, f"C{idx}") # Plot the line and fill ax.plot( angles, values, "o-", linewidth=2, label=model_name, color=color, markersize=6, ) ax.fill(angles, values, alpha=0.15, color=color) # Set the labels for each axis so they sit just outside the outer circle metric_labels = [ (pass_rate_label if metric == "pass_rate" else metric) for metric in METRICS ] ax.set_xticks(angles[:-1]) # Remove default tick labels; we'll draw them manually at a fixed radius ax.set_xticklabels([]) label_radius = 1.3 # Place labels on the outer grid circle (radius=1.25) for angle, label in zip(angles[:-1], metric_labels): # Choose horizontal alignment based on angle for better spacing if 0 <= angle < np.pi / 2 or 3 * np.pi / 2 <= angle <= 2 * np.pi: ha = "left" elif np.pi / 2 < angle < 3 * np.pi / 2: ha = "right" else: ha = "center" ax.text( angle, label_radius, label, ha=ha, va="center", fontsize=30, fontweight="bold", ) # Set radial limits to 1.25; keep labels only up to 1.0 ax.set_ylim(0, 1.25) ax.set_yticks([0, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1.0, 1.25]) ax.set_yticklabels( ["0", "0.25", "0.5", "0.75", "1.0", ""], size=30, color="black", weight="bold", ) # Remove the outer spine (circular border) ax.spines["polar"].set_visible(False) # Add gridlines ax.xaxis.grid(True, linestyle="--", linewidth=3.0, alpha=1.0, color="white") ax.yaxis.grid(True, linestyle="-", linewidth=3.0, color="white", alpha=1.0) # Title removed per user request # Adjust layout plt.tight_layout() # Save the figure plt.savefig(output_path, format="pdf", dpi=300, bbox_inches="tight") plt.close() print(f" Created: {output_path}") def create_legend_pdf(output_path): if plt is None: print(f" Warning: matplotlib not installed, skipping legend PDF: {output_path}") return fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(4, 3)) ax.axis("off") handles = [] labels = [] for model_name, color in MODEL_COLORS.items(): (handle,) = ax.plot( [], [], "o-", linewidth=2, markersize=8, color=color, ) handles.append(handle) labels.append(model_name) ax.legend( handles, labels, loc="center", frameon=True, fancybox=True, shadow=False, prop={"size": 12, "weight": "bold"}, ) plt.tight_layout() plt.savefig(output_path, format="pdf", dpi=300, bbox_inches="tight") plt.close(fig) print(f" Legend PDF created: {output_path}") def create_legend_pdf_horizontal(output_path): if plt is None: print( f" Warning: matplotlib not installed, skipping horizontal legend PDF: {output_path}" ) return # Wide and very low-height figure to make the legend strip as "flat" as possible fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(12, 1.0)) ax.axis("off") handles = [] labels = [] for model_name, color in MODEL_COLORS.items(): (handle,) = ax.plot( [], [], "o-", linewidth=2, markersize=8, color=color, ) handles.append(handle) labels.append(model_name) ax.legend( handles, labels, loc="center", ncol=len(MODEL_COLORS), frameon=False, fancybox=False, shadow=False, borderaxespad=0.1, borderpad=0.3, handletextpad=0.4, labelspacing=0.2, prop={"size": 12, "weight": "bold"}, ) plt.tight_layout(pad=0.0) plt.savefig(output_path, format="pdf", dpi=300, bbox_inches="tight", pad_inches=0.0) plt.close(fig) print(f" Horizontal legend PDF created: {output_path}") def main(): """Main function to process all subfolders and generate radar charts.""" base_dir = Path("/Users/wzr/TOSEM-2025/RESULTS/RQ1") output_dir = base_dir / "RadarCharts" output_dir.mkdir(exist_ok=True) # Find all evaluation_results.csv files csv_files = list(base_dir.glob("*/evaluation_results.csv")) print(f"Found {len(csv_files)} evaluation_results.csv files") print("=" * 60) # Dictionary to accumulate data for overall average all_data = { model: {metric: [] for metric in METRICS} for model in MODEL_COLORS.keys() } series_data = {} combined_open_closed_lines = [] combined_series_avg_lines = [] scenario_data = {} gt_projects = set() # Process each subfolder for csv_file in sorted(csv_files): scenario_name = csv_file.parent.name series_name = scenario_name.split("-")[0] try: # Read the main evaluation results CSV file df = pd.read_csv(csv_file) # Read retry_summary.csv for error_rate retry_file = csv_file.parent / "retry_summary.csv" if retry_file.exists(): retry_df = pd.read_csv(retry_file) retry_rate_col = "Retry_Rate(%)" if ( retry_rate_col not in retry_df.columns and "Error_Rate(%)" in retry_df.columns ): retry_rate_col = "Error_Rate(%)" retry_df["retry_rate"] = retry_df[retry_rate_col] / 100.0 # Merge with main dataframe df = df.merge( retry_df[["Model", "retry_rate"]], left_on="model", right_on="Model", how="left", ) df = df.drop(columns=["Model"]) df["retry_rate"] = df["retry_rate"].fillna(0.0) else: print(f" Warning: retry_summary.csv not found for {scenario_name}") df["retry_rate"] = 0.0 # Read success_rate.csv for success_rate success_file = csv_file.parent / "success_rate.csv" if success_file.exists(): success_df = pd.read_csv(success_file) # Convert Success_Rate(%) to decimal pass_rate success_df["pass_rate"] = success_df["Success_Rate(%)"] / 100.0 # Merge with main dataframe df = df.merge( success_df[["Model", "pass_rate"]], left_on="model", right_on="Model", how="left", ) df = df.drop(columns=["Model"]) df["pass_rate"] = df["pass_rate"].fillna(0.0) else: print(f" Warning: success_rate.csv not found for {scenario_name}") df["pass_rate"] = 0.0 df["pass_rate_agg"] = df["pass_rate"] pass_rate_label = "pass_rate" score_file = csv_file.parent / "score_summary.csv" if score_file.exists(): score_df = pd.read_csv(score_file) score_df["average_score"] = score_df["Mean_Score"] / 100.0 df = df.merge( score_df[["Model", "average_score"]], left_on="model", right_on="Model", how="left", ) df["pass_rate"] = df["average_score"].fillna(df["pass_rate"]) df = df.drop(columns=["Model", "average_score"]) pass_rate_label = "average_score" gt_projects.add(series_name) # Check if all required metrics are present missing_metrics = [m for m in METRICS if m not in df.columns] if missing_metrics: print(f" Skipping {scenario_name}: missing metrics {missing_metrics}") continue # Store per-scenario data for comparisons scenario_data[scenario_name] = {} for idx, row in df.iterrows(): model_name = row["model"] scenario_data[scenario_name][model_name] = { metric: row[metric] for metric in METRICS } # Accumulate data for overall and series-level charts for idx, row in df.iterrows(): model_name = row["model"] if model_name in all_data: for metric in METRICS: value = row[metric] all_data[model_name][metric].append(value) series_models = series_data.setdefault(series_name, {}) if model_name not in series_models: series_models[model_name] = {m: [] for m in METRICS} series_models[model_name][metric].append(value) # Create output path (all PDFs go to RadarCharts, filenames unchanged) output_path = output_dir / f"{scenario_name}_radar.pdf" # Generate radar chart create_radar_chart( df, scenario_name, output_path, pass_rate_label=pass_rate_label, ) except Exception as e: print(f" Error processing {scenario_name}: {e}") print("=" * 60) print("All individual radar charts generated successfully!") print("=" * 60) # Generate overall average chart try: print("Generating overall average chart...") # Calculate averages for each model avg_data = [] for model_name, metrics_data in all_data.items(): row_data = {"model": model_name} for metric in METRICS: if metrics_data[metric]: # Check if there's data row_data[metric] = np.mean(metrics_data[metric]) else: row_data[metric] = 0 avg_data.append(row_data) # Create DataFrame avg_df = pd.DataFrame(avg_data) group_rows = [] for group_name in ["open", "closed"]: group_models = [ m for m, category in MODEL_CATEGORY.items() if category == group_name ] if not group_models: continue group_df = avg_df[avg_df["model"].isin(group_models)] if group_df.empty: continue row = {"group": group_name, "model_count": len(group_df)} for metric in METRICS: row[metric] = float(group_df[metric].mean()) group_rows.append(row) if group_rows: header_cols = ["Group", "Model Count"] + METRICS header_line = "| " + " | ".join(header_cols) + " |\n" separator_line = "| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(header_cols)) + " |\n" md_lines = [] md_lines.append("# Overall Open vs Closed Models\n\n") md_lines.append(header_line) md_lines.append(separator_line) for row in group_rows: row_vals = [ row["group"], str(row["model_count"]), ] for metric in METRICS: val = row[metric] row_vals.append(f"{val:.2f}") md_lines.append("| " + " | ".join(row_vals) + " |\n") combined_open_closed_lines.extend(md_lines) combined_open_closed_lines.append("\n") # First, calculate overall summary across all projects overall_models_data = {} for series_name, models_data in series_data.items(): for model_name, metrics_data in models_data.items(): if model_name not in overall_models_data: overall_models_data[model_name] = {m: [] for m in METRICS} for metric in METRICS: values = metrics_data.get(metric, []) overall_models_data[model_name][metric].extend(values) # Generate overall summary table if overall_models_data: overall_rows = [] for model_name, metrics_data in overall_models_data.items(): row_data = {"model": model_name} for metric in METRICS: values = metrics_data.get(metric, []) if values: row_data[metric] = float(np.mean(values)) else: row_data[metric] = 0 overall_rows.append(row_data) if overall_rows: overall_df = pd.DataFrame(overall_rows) combined_series_avg_lines.append("# Overall Summary (All Projects)\n\n") combined_series_avg_lines.append(df_to_markdown(overall_df) + "\n\n") for series_name, models_data in sorted(series_data.items()): series_avg_rows = [] for model_name, metrics_data in models_data.items(): row_data = {"model": model_name} for metric in METRICS: values = metrics_data.get(metric, []) if values: row_data[metric] = float(np.mean(values)) else: row_data[metric] = 0 series_avg_rows.append(row_data) if not series_avg_rows: continue series_df = pd.DataFrame(series_avg_rows) series_pdf_output = output_dir / f"{series_name}_Series_Average_radar.pdf" series_pass_rate_label = ( "average_score" if series_name in gt_projects else "pass_rate" ) create_radar_chart( series_df, f"{series_name} Series Average", series_pdf_output, pass_rate_label=series_pass_rate_label, ) combined_series_avg_lines.append(f"# {series_name} Series Average\n\n") if series_pass_rate_label != "pass_rate": combined_series_avg_lines.append( df_to_markdown( series_df.rename(columns={"pass_rate": series_pass_rate_label}) ) + "\n\n" ) else: combined_series_avg_lines.append(df_to_markdown(series_df) + "\n\n") group_rows = [] for group_name in ["open", "closed"]: group_models = [ m for m, category in MODEL_CATEGORY.items() if category == group_name ] if not group_models: continue group_df = series_df[series_df["model"].isin(group_models)] if group_df.empty: continue row = { "series": series_name, "group": group_name, "model_count": len(group_df), } for metric in METRICS: row[metric] = float(group_df[metric].mean()) group_rows.append(row) if group_rows: header_cols = [ "Series", "Group", "Model Count", ] + series_metric_headers(series_name, gt_projects) header_line = "| " + " | ".join(header_cols) + " |\n" separator_line = "| " + " | ".join(["---"] * len(header_cols)) + " |\n" md_lines = [] md_lines.append(f"# {series_name} Open vs Closed Models\n\n") md_lines.append(header_line) md_lines.append(separator_line) for row in group_rows: row_vals = [ row["series"], row["group"], str(row["model_count"]), ] for metric in METRICS: val = row[metric] row_vals.append(f"{val:.2f}") md_lines.append("| " + " | ".join(row_vals) + " |\n") combined_open_closed_lines.extend(md_lines) combined_open_closed_lines.append("\n") # Combine generated markdown files into a single markdown with titles if combined_open_closed_lines: combined_md_path = output_dir / "All_Open_vs_Closed_summaries.md" combined_md_path.write_text( "".join(combined_open_closed_lines), encoding="utf-8", ) print(f" Combined markdown created: {combined_md_path}") # Combine all Series_Average_radar.csv into a single markdown with titles if combined_series_avg_lines: combined_csv_md_path = output_dir / "All_Series_Average_tables.md" combined_csv_md_path.write_text( "".join(combined_series_avg_lines), encoding="utf-8", ) print(f" Combined Series Average markdown created: {combined_csv_md_path}") # Generate overall chart overall_output = output_dir / "Overall_Average_radar.pdf" create_radar_chart(avg_df, "Overall Average (All Scenarios)", overall_output) legend_output = output_dir / "Model_Legend.pdf" create_legend_pdf(legend_output) legend_horizontal_output = output_dir / "Model_Legend_horizontal.pdf" create_legend_pdf_horizontal(legend_horizontal_output) # Generate model comparison markdowns - split into 3 separate files # File 1: GPT-5 vs GPT-4o-mini (powerful vs lightweight) comparison1_lines = [] comparison1_lines.append( generate_model_pair_comparison( "GPT-5", "GPT-4o-mini", scenario_data, "GPT-5 vs GPT-4o-mini (Powerful vs Lightweight)", gt_projects=gt_projects, ) ) comparison1_md_path = output_dir / "Comparison_Powerful_vs_Lightweight.md" comparison1_md_path.write_text("".join(comparison1_lines), encoding="utf-8") print(f" Powerful vs Lightweight comparison created: {comparison1_md_path}") # File 2: Reasoning vs Non-Reasoning models comparison2_lines = [] comparison2_lines.append( generate_model_pair_comparison( "DeepSeek-R1", "DeepSeek-V3-1", scenario_data, "DeepSeek-R1 vs DeepSeek-V3-1 (Reasoning vs Non-Reasoning)", gt_projects=gt_projects, ) ) comparison2_lines.append("\n---\n\n") comparison2_lines.append( generate_model_pair_comparison( "Gemini-2.5-flash", "Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking", scenario_data, "Gemini-2.5-flash vs Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking (Reasoning vs Non-Reasoning)", gt_projects=gt_projects, ) ) comparison2_md_path = output_dir / "Comparison_Reasoning_vs_NonReasoning.md" comparison2_md_path.write_text("".join(comparison2_lines), encoding="utf-8") print(f" Reasoning vs Non-Reasoning comparison created: {comparison2_md_path}") # File 3: MCP vs Hardcoded comparisons comparison3_lines = [] projects = ["MarkdownValidator", "GameBuilder", "EmailResponder"] # Add overall summary first comparison3_lines.append( generate_mcp_overall_comparison( projects, scenario_data, gt_projects=gt_projects ) ) # Then add per-project comparisons for project in projects: comparison3_lines.append( generate_mcp_comparison(project, scenario_data, gt_projects=gt_projects) ) comparison3_md_path = output_dir / "Comparison_MCP_vs_Hardcoded.md" comparison3_md_path.write_text("".join(comparison3_lines), encoding="utf-8") print(f" MCP vs Hardcoded comparison created: {comparison3_md_path}") # File 4: MCP vs A2A comparisons comparison4_lines = [] version_projects = [ "SQL_assistant", "intelligent_recruitment_platform", "landing_page_generator", "self_evaluation_loop_flow", "write_a_book_with_flows", ] # Add overall summary first comparison4_lines.append( generate_version_overall_comparison( version_projects, "-MCP", "-A2A", scenario_data, "MCP", "A2A", "MCP vs A2A Comparison", gt_projects=gt_projects, ) ) # Then add per-project comparisons for project in version_projects: comparison4_lines.append( generate_version_comparison( project, "-MCP", "-A2A", scenario_data, "MCP", "A2A", gt_projects=gt_projects, ) ) comparison4_md_path = output_dir / "Comparison_MCP_vs_A2A.md" comparison4_md_path.write_text("".join(comparison4_lines), encoding="utf-8") print(f" MCP vs A2A comparison created: {comparison4_md_path}") # File 5: A2A vs A2A_mix comparisons comparison5_lines = [] # Add overall summary first comparison5_lines.append( generate_version_overall_comparison( version_projects, "-A2A", "-A2A_mix", scenario_data, "A2A", "A2A_mix", "A2A vs A2A_mix Comparison", gt_projects=gt_projects, ) ) # Then add per-project comparisons for project in version_projects: comparison5_lines.append( generate_version_comparison( project, "-A2A", "-A2A_mix", scenario_data, "A2A", "A2A_mix", gt_projects=gt_projects, ) ) comparison5_md_path = output_dir / "Comparison_A2A_vs_A2A_mix.md" comparison5_md_path.write_text("".join(comparison5_lines), encoding="utf-8") print(f" A2A vs A2A_mix comparison created: {comparison5_md_path}") print("=" * 60) print(f" Overall average chart created: {overall_output}") print(f" Legend PDF created: {legend_output}") print(f" Horizontal legend PDF created: {legend_horizontal_output}") except Exception as e: print(f" Error generating overall chart: {e}") print("=" * 60) print("All radar charts completed!") if __name__ == "__main__": main()