#!/usr/bin/env python3 """ Agent-Level Time Comparison Analysis Script This script analyzes agent time data from Part2 directories, comparing: - MCP vs Hardcoded - MCP vs A2A - A2A vs A2A_mix For each comparison, it shows: - Agent time proportions (percentage of total time) - Actual agent times (mean time per occurrence) - Differences in both absolute and percentage terms """ import csv import re from pathlib import Path from collections import defaultdict from typing import Dict, List, Tuple, Optional import logging # Setup logging logging.basicConfig( level=logging.INFO, format="%(asctime)s - %(levelname)s - %(message)s", ) logger = logging.getLogger(__name__) def parse_agent_map(agent_map_path: Path) -> Dict[str, str]: """ Parse agent_map.md file to extract agent name mappings. Format example: --agent-map "Expert SQL Query Generator:SQL Query Generator" Returns: Dict mapping original name -> standardized name """ agent_map = {} if not agent_map_path.exists(): logger.warning(f"Agent map not found: {agent_map_path}") return agent_map try: with open(agent_map_path, "r", encoding="utf-8") as f: content = f.read() # Pattern to match --agent-map "Original Name:Standardized Name" pattern = r'--agent-map\s+"([^:]+):([^"]+)"' matches = re.findall(pattern, content) for original, standardized in matches: agent_map[original.strip()] = standardized.strip() logger.info(f"Loaded {len(agent_map)} agent mappings from {agent_map_path}") except Exception as e: logger.error(f"Failed to parse agent map {agent_map_path}: {e}") return agent_map def load_agent_time_data( csv_path: Path, agent_map: Dict[str, str] ) -> Dict[str, Dict[str, float]]: """ Load agent time data from agent_llm_tool_breakdown_by_model.csv. Returns: Dict[model][agent] = { 'mean_time': mean time per occurrence in seconds, 'total_time': total time in seconds, 'occurrences': number of occurrences } """ agent_data = defaultdict(lambda: defaultdict(dict)) if not csv_path.exists(): logger.warning(f"CSV file not found: {csv_path}") return agent_data try: with open(csv_path, "r", encoding="utf-8") as f: reader = csv.DictReader(f) for row in reader: model = row["model"] agent_name = row["agent_name"] # Apply agent name mapping if available standardized_name = agent_map.get(agent_name, agent_name) occurrences = int(row["occurrences"]) total_time_ms = float(row["total_agent_llm_tool_time_ms"]) total_time_s = total_time_ms / 1000.0 # Convert to seconds mean_time = total_time_s / occurrences if occurrences > 0 else 0 agent_data[model][standardized_name] = { "mean_time": mean_time, "total_time": total_time_s, "occurrences": occurrences, } logger.info(f"Loaded agent data from {csv_path}") except Exception as e: logger.error(f"Failed to load agent data from {csv_path}: {e}") return agent_data def calculate_agent_proportions( agent_data: Dict[str, Dict[str, float]], ) -> Dict[str, Dict[str, float]]: """ Calculate what proportion of total time each agent takes per model. Returns: Dict[model][agent] = proportion (0-1) """ proportions = defaultdict(dict) for model, agents in agent_data.items(): # Calculate total time across all agents for this model total_time = sum(data["total_time"] for data in agents.values()) if total_time > 0: for agent, data in agents.items(): proportions[model][agent] = data["total_time"] / total_time else: for agent in agents.keys(): proportions[model][agent] = 0.0 return proportions def generate_project_comparison( project_name: str, version_a_suffix: str, version_b_suffix: str, part2_dir: Path, version_a_name: str, version_b_name: str, ) -> str: """Generate agent-level comparison for a single project, organized by agent.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# {project_name}: {version_a_name} vs {version_b_name}\n\n") # Get paths scenario_a = f"{project_name}{version_a_suffix}" scenario_b = f"{project_name}{version_b_suffix}" dir_a = part2_dir / scenario_a dir_b = part2_dir / scenario_b if not dir_a.exists() or not dir_b.exists(): lines.append("_Data not available for comparison_\n\n") return "".join(lines) # Load agent maps map_a = parse_agent_map(dir_a / "agent_map.md") map_b = parse_agent_map(dir_b / "agent_map.md") # Load agent data data_a = load_agent_time_data( dir_a / "agent_llm_tool_breakdown_by_model.csv", map_a ) data_b = load_agent_time_data( dir_b / "agent_llm_tool_breakdown_by_model.csv", map_b ) if not data_a or not data_b: lines.append("_No agent data available_\n\n") return "".join(lines) # Calculate proportions prop_a = calculate_agent_proportions(data_a) prop_b = calculate_agent_proportions(data_b) # Get all models and agents all_models = sorted(set(data_a.keys()) | set(data_b.keys())) # Get all unique agents across all models all_agents = set() for model in all_models: all_agents.update(data_a.get(model, {}).keys()) all_agents.update(data_b.get(model, {}).keys()) all_agents = sorted(all_agents) # Organize by agent for agent in all_agents: lines.append(f"## Agent: {agent}\n\n") # Per-model comparison for this agent lines.append(f"### Per-Model Comparison\n\n") lines.append( f"| Model | {version_a_name} Time (s) | {version_b_name} Time (s) | Time Diff | " ) lines.append(f"{version_a_name} % | {version_b_name} % | Proportion Diff |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") # Collect data for overall average overall_time_a = [] overall_time_b = [] overall_prop_a = [] overall_prop_b = [] for model in all_models: data_a_agent = data_a.get(model, {}).get( agent, {"mean_time": 0, "total_time": 0} ) data_b_agent = data_b.get(model, {}).get( agent, {"mean_time": 0, "total_time": 0} ) time_a = data_a_agent["mean_time"] time_b = data_b_agent["mean_time"] # Skip if both are 0 (agent not present in this model) if time_a == 0 and time_b == 0: continue prop_a_val = prop_a.get(model, {}).get(agent, 0) * 100 prop_b_val = prop_b.get(model, {}).get(agent, 0) * 100 time_diff = time_a - time_b time_pct = (time_diff / time_b * 100) if time_b > 0 else 0 prop_diff = prop_a_val - prop_b_val lines.append( f"| {model} | {time_a:.2f} | {time_b:.2f} | " f"{time_diff:+.2f}s ({time_pct:+.1f}%) | " f"{prop_a_val:.1f}% | {prop_b_val:.1f}% | " f"{prop_diff:+.1f}pp |\n" ) # Collect for average if time_a > 0: overall_time_a.append(time_a) overall_prop_a.append(prop_a_val) if time_b > 0: overall_time_b.append(time_b) overall_prop_b.append(prop_b_val) lines.append("\n") # Overall average for this agent across all models if overall_time_a or overall_time_b: lines.append(f"### Overall Average Across All Models\n\n") lines.append( f"| Metric | {version_a_name} | {version_b_name} | Difference |\n" ) lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") avg_time_a = ( sum(overall_time_a) / len(overall_time_a) if overall_time_a else 0 ) avg_time_b = ( sum(overall_time_b) / len(overall_time_b) if overall_time_b else 0 ) avg_prop_a = ( sum(overall_prop_a) / len(overall_prop_a) if overall_prop_a else 0 ) avg_prop_b = ( sum(overall_prop_b) / len(overall_prop_b) if overall_prop_b else 0 ) time_diff_avg = avg_time_a - avg_time_b time_pct_avg = (time_diff_avg / avg_time_b * 100) if avg_time_b > 0 else 0 prop_diff_avg = avg_prop_a - avg_prop_b lines.append( f"| Mean Time (s) | {avg_time_a:.2f} | {avg_time_b:.2f} | " f"{time_diff_avg:+.2f}s ({time_pct_avg:+.1f}%) |\n" ) lines.append( f"| Time Proportion (%) | {avg_prop_a:.1f}% | {avg_prop_b:.1f}% | " f"{prop_diff_avg:+.1f}pp |\n" ) lines.append("\n") lines.append("---\n\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_overall_comparison( projects: List[str], version_a_suffix: str, version_b_suffix: str, part2_dir: Path, version_a_name: str, version_b_name: str, comparison_title: str, ) -> str: """Generate overall agent-level comparison across multiple projects.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# Overall {comparison_title}\n\n") lines.append(f"Averaged across all projects: {', '.join(projects)}\n\n") # Collect data from all projects overall_data_a = defaultdict( lambda: defaultdict(lambda: {"total_time": 0, "count": 0}) ) overall_data_b = defaultdict( lambda: defaultdict(lambda: {"total_time": 0, "count": 0}) ) for project in projects: scenario_a = f"{project}{version_a_suffix}" scenario_b = f"{project}{version_b_suffix}" dir_a = part2_dir / scenario_a dir_b = part2_dir / scenario_b if not dir_a.exists() or not dir_b.exists(): continue # Load agent maps map_a = parse_agent_map(dir_a / "agent_map.md") map_b = parse_agent_map(dir_b / "agent_map.md") # Load agent data data_a = load_agent_time_data( dir_a / "agent_llm_tool_breakdown_by_model.csv", map_a ) data_b = load_agent_time_data( dir_b / "agent_llm_tool_breakdown_by_model.csv", map_b ) # Calculate proportions prop_a = calculate_agent_proportions(data_a) prop_b = calculate_agent_proportions(data_b) # Aggregate data for model, agents in data_a.items(): for agent, agent_data in agents.items(): overall_data_a[model][agent]["total_time"] += agent_data["total_time"] overall_data_a[model][agent]["count"] += agent_data["occurrences"] for model, agents in data_b.items(): for agent, agent_data in agents.items(): overall_data_b[model][agent]["total_time"] += agent_data["total_time"] overall_data_b[model][agent]["count"] += agent_data["occurrences"] # Calculate overall proportions and means all_models = sorted(set(overall_data_a.keys()) | set(overall_data_b.keys())) for model in all_models: lines.append(f"## {model}\n\n") agents_a = set(overall_data_a[model].keys()) agents_b = set(overall_data_b[model].keys()) all_agents = sorted(agents_a | agents_b) if not all_agents: lines.append("_No agent data for this model_\n\n") continue # Calculate total time for proportions total_time_a = sum(d["total_time"] for d in overall_data_a[model].values()) total_time_b = sum(d["total_time"] for d in overall_data_b[model].values()) # Table header lines.append( f"| Agent | {version_a_name} Mean (s) | {version_b_name} Mean (s) | Time Diff | " ) lines.append(f"{version_a_name} % | {version_b_name} % | Proportion Diff |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for agent in all_agents: data_a = overall_data_a[model][agent] data_b = overall_data_b[model][agent] mean_a = ( data_a["total_time"] / data_a["count"] if data_a["count"] > 0 else 0 ) mean_b = ( data_b["total_time"] / data_b["count"] if data_b["count"] > 0 else 0 ) prop_a = ( (data_a["total_time"] / total_time_a * 100) if total_time_a > 0 else 0 ) prop_b = ( (data_b["total_time"] / total_time_b * 100) if total_time_b > 0 else 0 ) time_diff = mean_a - mean_b time_pct = (time_diff / mean_b * 100) if mean_b > 0 else 0 prop_diff = prop_a - prop_b lines.append( f"| {agent} | {mean_a:.2f} | {mean_b:.2f} | " f"{time_diff:+.2f}s ({time_pct:+.1f}%) | " f"{prop_a:.1f}% | {prop_b:.1f}% | " f"{prop_diff:+.1f}pp |\n" ) return "".join(lines) def generate_overall_summary( projects: List[str], version_a_suffix: str, version_b_suffix: str, part2_dir: Path, version_a_name: str, version_b_name: str, ) -> str: """Generate overall summary across all projects and models.""" lines = [] lines.append("## Overall Summary (All Projects, All Models)\n\n") # Collect data from all projects overall_data_a = defaultdict(lambda: {"total_time": 0, "count": 0}) overall_data_b = defaultdict(lambda: {"total_time": 0, "count": 0}) for project in projects: scenario_a = f"{project}{version_a_suffix}" scenario_b = f"{project}{version_b_suffix}" dir_a = part2_dir / scenario_a dir_b = part2_dir / scenario_b if not dir_a.exists() or not dir_b.exists(): continue # Load agent maps map_a = parse_agent_map(dir_a / "agent_map.md") map_b = parse_agent_map(dir_b / "agent_map.md") # Load agent data data_a = load_agent_time_data( dir_a / "agent_llm_tool_breakdown_by_model.csv", map_a ) data_b = load_agent_time_data( dir_b / "agent_llm_tool_breakdown_by_model.csv", map_b ) # Aggregate data across all models for model, agents in data_a.items(): for agent, agent_data in agents.items(): overall_data_a[agent]["total_time"] += agent_data["total_time"] overall_data_a[agent]["count"] += agent_data["occurrences"] for model, agents in data_b.items(): for agent, agent_data in agents.items(): overall_data_b[agent]["total_time"] += agent_data["total_time"] overall_data_b[agent]["count"] += agent_data["occurrences"] # Get all agents all_agents = sorted(set(overall_data_a.keys()) | set(overall_data_b.keys())) if not all_agents: lines.append("_No data available_\n\n") return "".join(lines) # Calculate total time for proportions total_time_a = sum(d["total_time"] for d in overall_data_a.values()) total_time_b = sum(d["total_time"] for d in overall_data_b.values()) # Table header lines.append( f"| Agent | {version_a_name} Mean (s) | {version_b_name} Mean (s) | Time Diff | " ) lines.append(f"{version_a_name} % | {version_b_name} % | Proportion Diff |\n") lines.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |\n") for agent in all_agents: data_a = overall_data_a[agent] data_b = overall_data_b[agent] mean_a = data_a["total_time"] / data_a["count"] if data_a["count"] > 0 else 0 mean_b = data_b["total_time"] / data_b["count"] if data_b["count"] > 0 else 0 prop_a = (data_a["total_time"] / total_time_a * 100) if total_time_a > 0 else 0 prop_b = (data_b["total_time"] / total_time_b * 100) if total_time_b > 0 else 0 time_diff = mean_a - mean_b time_pct = (time_diff / mean_b * 100) if mean_b > 0 else 0 prop_diff = prop_a - prop_b lines.append( f"| {agent} | {mean_a:.2f} | {mean_b:.2f} | " f"{time_diff:+.2f}s ({time_pct:+.1f}%) | " f"{prop_a:.1f}% | {prop_b:.1f}% | " f"{prop_diff:+.1f}pp |\n" ) lines.append("\n---\n\n") return "".join(lines) def generate_comparisons_for_projects( projects: List[str], version_a_suffix: str, version_b_suffix: str, part2_dir: Path, version_a_name: str, version_b_name: str, comparison_title: str, ) -> str: """Generate project-by-project agent-level comparisons.""" lines = [] lines.append(f"# {comparison_title}\n\n") lines.append(f"Projects included: {', '.join(projects)}\n\n") lines.append("---\n\n") # Add overall summary first overall_summary = generate_overall_summary( projects, version_a_suffix, version_b_suffix, part2_dir, version_a_name, version_b_name, ) lines.append(overall_summary) # Generate comparison for each project for project in projects: project_comparison = generate_project_comparison( project, version_a_suffix, version_b_suffix, part2_dir, version_a_name, version_b_name, ) lines.append(project_comparison) return "".join(lines) def main(): """Main execution function""" part2_dir = Path("/Users/wzr/TOSEM-2025/RESULTS/RQ2") output_dir = Path("/Users/wzr/TOSEM-2025/RESULTS/RQ3/agent_time_reports") output_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) logger.info("Starting agent-level time comparison analysis...") # 1. MCP vs Hardcoded comparisons logger.info("Generating MCP vs Hardcoded comparisons...") mcp_hardcoded_projects = [ "MarkdownValidator", "GameBuilder", "EmailResponder", ] comparison_content = generate_comparisons_for_projects( mcp_hardcoded_projects, "-MCP", "", part2_dir, "MCP", "Hardcoded", "MCP vs Hardcoded Agent-Level Comparison", ) output_path = output_dir / "Agent_Time_Comparison_MCP_vs_Hardcoded.md" output_path.write_text(comparison_content, encoding="utf-8") logger.info(f"Created: {output_path}") # 2. MCP vs A2A comparisons logger.info("Generating MCP vs A2A comparisons...") version_projects = [ "SQL_assistant", "intelligent_recruitment_platform", "landing_page_generator", "self_evaluation_loop_flow", "write_a_book_with_flows", ] comparison_content = generate_comparisons_for_projects( version_projects, "-MCP", "-A2A", part2_dir, "MCP", "A2A", "MCP vs A2A Agent-Level Comparison", ) output_path = output_dir / "Agent_Time_Comparison_MCP_vs_A2A.md" output_path.write_text(comparison_content, encoding="utf-8") logger.info(f"Created: {output_path}") # 3. A2A vs A2A_mix comparisons logger.info("Generating A2A vs A2A_mix comparisons...") comparison_content = generate_comparisons_for_projects( version_projects, "-A2A", "-A2A_mix", part2_dir, "A2A", "A2A_mix", "A2A vs A2A_mix Agent-Level Comparison", ) output_path = output_dir / "Agent_Time_Comparison_A2A_vs_A2A_mix.md" output_path.write_text(comparison_content, encoding="utf-8") logger.info(f"Created: {output_path}") logger.info("Agent-level time comparison analysis complete!") if __name__ == "__main__": main()