건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-1 · 면책서명부재

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
A neighbor HOA asked me whether the weekend crane swing over their courtyard was covered by a signed aerial-swing waiver in the site papers.

MEMO/κ-36 — evening desk dump. Admin: “Aerial-swing waiver for the HOA courtyard is still unsigned; signature block blank, date blank.” Crane ops: “We swung anyway on Saturday under a verbal promise.” Admin: “Verbal promise is not the waiver packet.” HOA email claim: “A fully signed aerial-swing waiver is already in the site file.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NO_EVIDENCE","reason_code":"WAIVER_UNSIGNED_BLANK"}


물류/회의록/w50005-2 · 시즌교육시간부재

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] According to operations, is seasonal staff at Site Branek required to complete 16 hours of safety training before first solo pick? VEL/MT§15-A Article 2: Site Branek seasonal kit inventory shall include 40 high-visibility vests, 20 pair of cut gloves, and 12 barcode scanners on the peak shelf. Article 3: Damaged scanners are tagged and sent to the bench within one shift. Article 4: Vest laundry turns every 14 days. VEL/MT§15-B is a spare-parts order form. No clause states training hours, curricula, or solo-pick gates.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"TRAINING_HOURS_ABSENT_FROM_MINUTES"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-3 · 출판료 면제 자격

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Before I submit, I want a second pair of eyes on my own waiver eligibility for Nimbus Journal's Diamond Waiver program -- please check the following claim against the excerpt: I am the corresponding author based in a Tier-1 listed low-income economy country, and my manuscript acknowledges no funding source, so I qualify for the Diamond Waiver. Source: Folio VI-Lambda, a case-study paper on article processing fee waivers, states: 'The Diamond Waiver applies to corresponding authors based in a country listed on the journal's Tier-1 low-income economy list, provided the manuscript acknowledges no external funding source.'

[Assistant] <think>Corresponding author is Tier-1 listed and the manuscript acknowledges no funding, matching both stated waiver conditions exactly.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"tier1_country_and_no_funding_match_waiver_terms"}


[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Before we brief the shift lead, does POD photo upload for same-day drops on route cluster N7 have to land within 4 hours of the receiver signature timestamp? VEL/MT§31-B Article 4: For route cluster N7 same-day drops, the POD photograph shall be uploaded no later than 4 hours after the receiver signature timestamp. Article 5: Uploads after that window require a late-file code from Dispatch. VEL/MT§31-A only lists camera models. VEL/MT§04-C covers meal-break windows for drivers.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"N7_POD_4H_WINDOW_MATCH"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-5 · 응급대배치주체

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Between Crew Orchid and Crew Pinion, which unit is assigned to stage the first-aid station at the east temporary gate during the street-closure week?

MEMO/κ-05 — toolbox chatter captured on phone. Super: “East gate first-aid is Orchid’s job all of street-closure week.” Orchid lead: “Got it, we’ll park the kit by the blue cone.” Pinion lead: “We only cover the west stair landing.” Later whisper: “Don’t swap without a rewritten memo.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"CREW_ASSIGNMENT_CLEAR"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-6 · 자재리프트비교

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Between Hoist North and Hoist South, which one is reserved for glazed curtain-wall crates during the façade mock-up week?

MEMO/κ-16 — material-gate chatter. Gate: “Rebar cages use the west ramp only.” Yard: “Insulation bales stay on flatbed 4.” Clerk: “Paint drums go to the shaded cage.” Nothing in the notes names Hoist North, Hoist South, curtain-wall crates, or any façade mock-up week assignment.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"COMPARISON_TARGETS_NOT_IN_EVIDENCE"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-7 · 출입증신뢰순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Between the gate guard’s verbal OK and the plastic day-pass with the red hologram, which clearance actually lets a courier enter the crane exclusion zone?

MEMO/κ-14 — security briefing scrap. Security lead: “Inside the crane exclusion zone, only the red-hologram day-pass counts. Verbal OK at the outer gate is not enough once you cross the painted arc.” Guard trainee: “I waved a courier through on a verbal yesterday.” Lead: “That was a miss; hologram pass is the controlling proof.” Circulating claim to the courier firm: “Verbal gate OK is sufficient for the exclusion zone.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"TRUST_IGNORED","reason_code":"VERBAL_OVER_HOLOGRAM"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-8 · 크레인배정권

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Between the steel sub and the MEP sub, who is listed as the primary owner of Tower B’s shared tower-crane hour block on Fridays after 15:00?

MEMO/κ-21 — priority board voiceover. Planner: “Friday after 15:00 on Tower B crane is locked to the steel sub; MEP may only take scraps if steel releases in writing.” Steel lead: “We’ll keep the block.” MEP chat (lower trust, labeled advisory): “We own Friday afternoons now.” External claim in a schedule blast: “MEP is primary owner of that Friday block.” Trust header on the planner note: “Planner board overrides subcontractor chat.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"TRUST_IGNORED","reason_code":"ADVISORY_CHAT_PROMOTED"}


물류/회의록/w50005-9 · 크로스독순서부재

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Can you check the sequence claim that cross-dock merges at Node Quill must unload floor pallets before cage carts, then cage carts before hanging garments? VEL/MT§36-A Article 1: Node Quill cross-dock staffing shall maintain at least three marshals per active door during peak. Article 2: Break relief for marshals follows the central roster tool. Article 3: Door equipment checklists are stored in the blue binder at the supervisor desk. VEL/MT§36-B records overtime codes. None of the clauses state an unload order among floor pallets, cage carts, or hanging garments.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"NO_CROSSDOCK_UNLOAD_ORDER_IN_EVIDENCE"}


물류/회의록/w50005-10 · 야간자격과일반화

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Compare against the minutes: must every driver on the Orelin panel hold a Type-N night certificate regardless of route length? VEL/MT§12-A Article 4: Type-N night certificates are required only for drivers assigned to routes exceeding 180 km one-way under the Orelin panel. Article 5: Routes at or under 180 km may operate on standard Class-D papers after dusk. Article 6: Relief drivers inherit the requirement of the route they cover. VEL/MT§12-B is a hotel reimbursement table.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"TYPE_N_ONLY_OVER_180KM"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-11 · IRB 개정 승인주체

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Comparing IRB structures across a few institutions, and this is the piece I need double-checked: Minor protocol amendments not involving a risk category change are approved by the Amendment Subcommittee rather than the full board. Source: Folio VII-Psi, a governance paper excerpting the Thornfield IRB Charter, states: 'Amendments to an approved protocol are approved by the Protocol Amendment Subcommittee, except where the amendment involves a change in risk category, in which case full board approval is required.'

[Assistant] <think>Charter sends non-risk amendments to the Subcommittee. Full board approval applies only to risk-category changes, matching the claim.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"subcommittee_handles_nonrisk_amendments"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-12 · 동료심사 인증 요건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Comparing peer-review platforms for my CV, and I need to know if this holds up: As a part-time affiliate researcher, I would still qualify for Senior Certified Reviewer status at Meridian Peer Review Network. Source: Folio I-Omega, an internal memo appended to a methods paper on reviewer certification, states: 'To attain Senior Certified Reviewer status, a full-time researcher must have completed at least twelve verified reviews and hold an active institutional appointment.' No mention is made of part-time affiliate researchers anywhere in the memo.

[Assistant] <think>The memo only defines requirements for full-time researchers. Part-time affiliate eligibility is never addressed.</think>{"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"parttime_affiliate_eligibility_not_addressed"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-13 · 지붕보증범위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Could you clarify whether the membrane warranty on the mechanical penthouse roof starts at substantial completion or at final acceptance?

MEMO/κ-09 — random site notes about other packages only. Voice A: “Podium waterproofing punch is half done.” Voice B: “Slab camber survey for Level 3 is Tuesday.” Voice C: “Elevator shaft debris to be cleared before Friday.” No line in the set mentions penthouse roof membrane, warranty clocks, substantial completion, or final acceptance for that roof.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"TOPIC_ABSENT_FROM_MEMOS"}


물류/회의록/w50005-14 · 슬롯예약시행일

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Cross-check the claim that mandatory 30-minute dock slot booking for inbound dry freight at Gate West became effective on 1 September 2025. VEL/MT§21-C Article 2: Mandatory 30-minute dock slot booking for inbound dry freight at Gate West becomes effective on 15 September 2025. Article 3: Soft trials run from 1 September 2025 through 14 September 2025 without penalty. Article 4: No-shows after the effective date incur a 120-unit demerit. VEL/MT§21-D is a map of bollard positions.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"SLOT_RULE_EFF_1SEP_VS_15SEP"}


물류/회의록/w50005-15 · 출고5단과일반화

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Does every network node have to run the five-step hub outbound sequence (wave release, pick confirm, pack scan, stage, load) as a hard rule? VEL/MT§40-A Article 2: The five-step hub outbound sequence—wave release, pick confirm, pack scan, stage, load—is mandatory only at Tier-1 hub nodes. Article 3: Spoke nodes may use a three-step compact path of pick confirm, pack scan, and load. Article 4: Applying the five-step path at spokes is optional coaching, not a compliance finding. VEL/MT§40-B lists hub node codes only.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"FIVE_STEP_HUB_ONLY_NOT_ALL_NODES"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-16 · 자격명단공란

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Does the field roster show that rigger Ilya holds a current dual-crane signal ticket for the twin-tower lift package?

MEMO/κ-44 — roster notebook page read aloud. HR runner: “Dual-crane signal ticket column for Ilya is blank—no number, no expiry, no trainer initials.” Lift lead: “He worked single-crane last month.” HR: “Single-crane line has a stamp; dual-crane line is empty.” Claim in the lift plan cover sheet: “Ilya is ticketed for dual-crane signal on this package.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NO_EVIDENCE","reason_code":"ROSTER_COLUMN_BLANK"}


물류/회의록/w50005-17 · 축중한도수치

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Does the minutes fix the single-axle live-load ceiling at Dock 3 as 9.4 tonnes, excluding the tractor? VEL/MT§22-B Article 8: Dock 3 single-axle live load shall not exceed 9.4 tonnes measured on the pit scale, tractor weight excluded. Article 9: Dual-axle combinations at Dock 3 follow a separate 16.1-tonne ceiling. VEL/MT§22-A records lighting retrofit dates. VEL/MT§06-E only addresses apron speed limits of 15 km/h.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"DOCK3_AXLE_CAP_9P4T"}


물류/회의록/w50005-18 · 식품용제혼적금지

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Flag if this reading is wrong: food-grade cartons and industrial solvent drums may not share the same trailer compartment on fleet code HX-4. VEL/MT§28-A Article 6: Food-grade cartons shall not be co-loaded with industrial solvent drums in any single compartment of fleet code HX-4. Article 7: Separate compartments on multi-compartment units are permitted only when the mid-wall seal is verified intact. VEL/MT§28-B records scrubber filter change intervals. VEL/MT§12-D addresses trailer wash tickets, not co-load rules.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"HX4_FOOD_SOLVENT_COLOAD_BAN"}


물류/회의록/w50005-19 · 게이트계량배치순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] For Friday's carrier stand-up, is the yard entry path gate pass validation, then live weigh, then bay assignment—never bay before weigh? VEL/MT§03-A Article 5: No trailer shall receive a bay assignment until a live weigh ticket for that visit is printed. Article 6: Gate pass validation is the first act at the inbound booth and precedes any weigh attempt. Article 7: Bay assignment is issued solely by Yard Control after Articles 5 and 6 are both closed. VEL/MT§03-B lists scale calibration vendors. VEL/MT§19-F discusses fuel island hours only.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"YARD_GATE_WEIGH_BAY_OK"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-20 · 굴착허가서류

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
For our insurance filing, was a utility-locate permit already on file for the trench east of Column Line 12 before cutting started?

MEMO/κ-08 — trench desk monologue. Locate clerk: “East of Line 12, the permit sleeve is empty—no utility-locate slip, no stamp, no barcode.” Excavator: “We still cut because the old map looked clean.” Clerk: “Map is not a permit. Sleeve remains blank as of this morning.” Insurance claim letter asserts: “Utility-locate permit was filed and present before cutting.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NO_EVIDENCE","reason_code":"PERMIT_SLEEVE_EMPTY"}


화장품·뷰티/제품 사양서/w50005-21 · 미생물시험 판정자 경력요건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
For the audit binder, I'm noting that any QC tech with 6 months on the job plus the Level 2 Microbiology Certification can sign off on microbial limit results — does that match the spec?

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-204 — Section: Microbial Limit Test Method]
- Total aerobic count method: pour plate, 30–35°C, 72hr incubation
- Yeast/mold count method: spread plate, 20–25°C, 5-day incubation

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-217 — Section: Sample Retention]
- Retain tested samples 12 months post-release
- Store at 4°C in sealed sterile containers

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-231 — Section: Sign-Off Personnel Qualification]
- Sign-off requires Level 2 Microbiology Certification
- Minimum 2 years relevant QC experience required
- Certification renewal every 3 years

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-244 — Section: Equipment Calibration]
- Incubator calibration: quarterly
- Autoclave validation: biannual

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NUMERIC_DISTORTION","reason_code":"EXPERIENCE_DURATION_MISQUOTED"}


화장품·뷰티/제품 사양서/w50005-22 · 레티놀·AHA 병행배합 금지

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
For the new retinol-AHA dual-action line, someone in R&D wants to blend 0.3% retinol with a 10% glycolic acid base in one product with no restriction — is that combination actually clear per spec?

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-298 — Section: Retinol Stability Requirements]
- Storage: amber glass or UV-opaque container only
- Light exposure during filling: under 15 minutes
- pH range: 5.5–6.5

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-312 — Section: Prohibited Ingredient Combinations]
| Ingredient A | Ingredient B | Restriction |
|---|---|---|
| Retinol > 0.2% | AHA > 5% | Prohibited — irritation/stability risk |
| Retinol > 0.2% | BHA > 2% | Prohibited — irritation risk |
| Vitamin C (L-AA) | Copper peptides | Prohibited — oxidation |

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"CLAIM_MISMATCH","reason_code":"PROHIBITED_COMBINATION_MISSTATED"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-23 · 토크로그보관

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
How long must the handheld torque-wrench paper logs for the podium bolt package stay in the site locker before shredding?

MEMO/κ-33 — locker inventory chat. Clerk Dae: “Podium bolt torque papers stay eighteen months in the gray locker, then shred.” Intern: “I thought twelve.” Dae: “Eighteen for podium bolts. Curtain-wall gun logs are twelve; don’t mix them.” Later: “Digital photos are extra; they don’t shorten the paper keep.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"RETENTION_MONTHS_MATCH"}


물류/회의록/w50005-24 · 온도일탈기록책임

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] I need to confirm who must sign the temperature-excursion log when a reefer unit drifts beyond the set band on Platform R. VEL/MT§09-D Article 3: The on-duty Platform R lead is the sole signatory for temperature-excursion logs on that platform. Article 4: Carrier drivers may initial the observation row but shall not close the log. Article 5: Quality Control may append comments after the lead signature and shall not substitute for it. VEL/MT§09-E names spare logger models only.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"EXCURSION_SIGNER_PLATFORM_LEAD"}


화장품·뷰티/제품 사양서/w50005-25 · 나이아신아마이드 함량기준

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
I think a 5.0% niacinamide load doesn't need the flushing-risk caution text — can you confirm that against the spec before we finalize the caution-label copy? Pasting the relevant sections below.

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-041 — Section: Packaging Artwork]
- Label typography: minimum 6pt, sans-serif only
- Caution text placement: rear panel, below ingredient list
- Approved caution icon: triangle-exclamation only

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-058 — Section: Ingredient Thresholds]
- Niacinamide ≤ 5.0% w/w: caution text not required
- Niacinamide > 5.0% w/w: flushing-risk caution text mandatory
- Salicylic acid > 2.0% w/w: pregnancy caution text mandatory

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-052 — Section: Marketing Claims Substantiation]
- "Dermatologist tested" claim requires 3rd-party clinical panel of at least 30 subjects
- "Hypoallergenic" claim requires patch test panel of at least 50 subjects

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"THRESHOLD_MATCHES_SPEC"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-26 · 하중메모신뢰

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
I'm an external auditor reviewing these scraps: is the temporary scaffold on Grid F rated for 3.5 kN/m² live load as the claim circulating to the bank states?

MEMO/κ-02 — trust ranking written by resident engineer: “Treat my stamped load note as controlling; subcontractor chat is advisory only.” Stamped note (same set): “Grid F scaffold max live load 2.0 kN/m² until the mid-span brace ships.” Subcontractor chat snippet: “We’re calling it 3.5 for planning.” Bank-facing claim text attached by the JV: “Scaffold on Grid F supports 3.5 kN/m².”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"TRUST_IGNORED","reason_code":"CHAT_OVERRODE_STAMPED_NOTE"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-27 · 펠로우십 자격요건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] I'm weighing a few postdoc fellowships and want to double check something about the Kestrel Postdoctoral Fellowship before I write it off -- can you verify this claim against the paper excerpt below? Claim: The applicant does not qualify for the Kestrel Postdoctoral Fellowship because their institute is a for-profit R&D lab, even though their PhD was conferred two years ago. Source: Folio IV-Theta, a comparative review of early-career funding schemes, states: 'Eligibility for the Kestrel Postdoctoral Fellowship requires that the PhD be conferred within the three years preceding application AND that the applicant hold a current affiliation with a registered nonprofit research institute. Applicants affiliated with for-profit R&D laboratories are excluded from consideration regardless of how recently their degree was conferred.'

[Assistant] <think>Evidence excludes for-profit affiliates outright, regardless of PhD recency. Claim states the same exclusion despite the 2-year-old PhD.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"forprofit_affiliation_excludes_despite_recent_phd"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-28 · 연구비 지원 자격일자

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] If my PhD came through in early 2023, would I still make the cut for the Halcyon Early-Career Grant's 2026 cycle? Please verify: Eligibility requires a PhD conferred on or after March 1, 2023. Source: Folio VIII-Rho, a paper summarizing early-career grant timelines, states: 'For the 2026 cycle, the Halcyon Early-Career Grant requires that the applicant's PhD be conferred on or after March 1, 2022.'

[Assistant] <think>The paper sets the cutoff at March 1, 2022, but the claim shifts it a year later to March 1, 2023.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"eligibility_cutoff_shifted_one_year_later"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-29 · 학회 제출 절차순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] If my abstract gets a great score at Solstice Symposium, can I skip straight to the camera-ready version without going through full paper review? That's what I've been telling my co-authors, but let's check it against the source. Source: Folio III-Kappa, the introductory paper to the Solstice Symposium proceedings, outlines the submission process as: (1) abstract screening, (2) invitation to submit a full paper issued only to abstracts scoring above threshold, (3) full paper peer review, (4) camera-ready submission for accepted full papers.

[Assistant] <think>Process moves from invitation straight into full paper peer review before camera-ready; claim skips that review step entirely.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"peer_review_step_skipped_after_invitation"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-30 · 철거잠금순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
In what order must the isolation steps run before demo of the old mezzanine handrail, based on this spoken memo chain?

MEMO/κ-30 — walk-and-talk with demo lead Nuri. Nuri: “First kill the temporary lighting circuit, then lock the scissor-lift battery isolator, then tag the handrail bay.” Apprentice: “Can we tag first if the lift is already parked?” Nuri: “No. Light off, then battery lock, then tag — always that stack.” Side note from same evening: “Dust wall goes up after tagging, not before.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"SEQUENCE_MATCHES_STACK"}


물류/회의록/w50005-31 · 야간지게차자격

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Is an operator eligible for night forklift duty in Zone M only with a current Zone-M night endorsement plus a vision recheck not older than 180 days? VEL/MT§05-F Article 1: Night forklift duty in Zone M requires a Zone-M night endorsement that is not expired. Article 2: A vision recheck dated within the last 180 days shall be on file before the endorsement may be used. Article 3: Day endorsements do not substitute. VEL/MT§05-G lists battery swap bays.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"ZONE_M_NIGHT_FORK_ELIGIBILITY"}


물류/회의록/w50005-32 · 체화유예종료일

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Is it correct that demurrage grace for container dwell in Yard Block K runs only through 5 March 2026 under the adopted minutes? VEL/MT§27-D Article 1: Demurrage grace for container dwell in Yard Block K runs through 12 March 2026 inclusive. Article 2: From 13 March 2026, the standard demurrage table in Annex V applies without grace. Article 3: Empty returns are outside this grace. VEL/MT§27-E reprints Annex V rate lines only.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"DEMURRAGE_GRACE_5MAR_VS_12MAR"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-33 · 철근검측주기

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Looking only at these local notes, how often must the grade-40 rebar inspection be repeated on the north podium slab before the next pour window?

MEMO/κ-11 — field voice log, 14:06. Foreman Rye: “For the north podium, rebar check is every second calendar day until pour, not every shift.” Site clerk Mina: “Copy. I’ll put that on the board.” Later same file, Rye again: “If rain skips a day, the clock still counts; we don’t reset.” Separate sticky in same memo set: “South wing uses daily checks — different package, leave it alone.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"INTERVAL_MATCHES_MEMO"}


화장품·뷰티/제품 사양서/w50005-34 · 무향표시 마스킹향 예외

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Marketing wants to keep the "fragrance-free" claim even though we added a trace masking scent to cover the raw-material smell — is that allowed as long as it stays under 0.05%?

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-186 — Section: Fragrance-Free Labeling Exception]
- Masking fragrance permitted up to 0.05% w/w when used solely to offset raw material odor
- Masking fragrance must not be marketed as a scent feature
- Products meeting the above remain eligible for the "fragrance-free" claim

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-199 — Section: Allergen Disclosure]
- 26 EU-designated allergens must be individually listed if present above 0.001%
- Disclosure required regardless of fragrance-free status

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"MASKING_FRAGRANCE_EXCEPTION_MATCH"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-35 · 양생온도기록

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
On the fire marshal call, someone asserted the mass-pour curing log already proves a continuous 48-hour temperature series for Core Wall D. Is that supported here?

MEMO/κ-12 — curing desk mutter. Tech: “Core Wall D curing binder has only three spot readings at hour 0, hour 6, and hour 24. No continuous chart, no logger printout.” Supervisor: “Logger failed; we never replaced the strip.” Binder index: “Continuous series: not attached.” Claim on the call summary: “48-hour continuous temperature series is already logged for Core Wall D.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NO_EVIDENCE","reason_code":"CONTINUOUS_SERIES_MISSING"}


물류/회의록/w50005-36 · 보세야드보증부재

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] On the night dock SOP review, is the bonded-yard financial bond for Carrier Panel Miro fixed at 2.5 million units per the minutes? VEL/MT§29-C Article 1: Bonded Yard West shall keep continuous CCTV coverage on all sealed lanes. Article 2: Camera retention for bonded footage is 45 days. Article 3: Lost-feed incidents are escalated to Security Desk within 15 minutes. VEL/MT§29-D names camera vendors. The minutes do not state any bond amount, currency, or panel-Miro surety figure.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"BOND_AMOUNT_NOT_ADDRESSED"}


물류/회의록/w50005-37 · 운송사감사종료일

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Our QA lead asserts the Q2 carrier performance audit window for panel Vestra closed on 30 June 2025—does the record support that end date? VEL/MT§33-A Article 5: The Q2 carrier performance audit window for panel Vestra opens 1 April 2025 and closes 31 July 2025. Article 6: Scorecards issued before the close date are draft only. Article 7: Final rankings publish within 10 business days after close. VEL/MT§33-B enumerates scoring weights. VEL/MT§01-A is attendance for the kickoff only.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"AUDIT_CLOSE_30JUN_VS_31JUL"}


물류/회의록/w50005-38 · 콜드체인인계순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Please verify whether the cold-chain handoff must run probe-check, then seal photo, then trailer latch, in that order, before the unit may leave Bay C. VEL/MT§11-A Article 2 (Cold Lane Handoff): (1) The receiving clerk shall complete the probe-check and record core temperature. (2) Only after clause (1) is closed may the seal photograph be taken and filed under the shipment key. (3) Trailer latch engagement is the final act and is forbidden until the seal photograph hash is stored. VEL/MT§11-B Article 4: Bay C departures without a stored seal photograph hash are void for carrier credit. VEL/MT§08-C is silent on temperature bands and only lists parking bay codes.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"SEQ_PROBE_SEAL_LATCH_MATCH"}


화장품·뷰티/제품 사양서/w50005-39 · 향료공급업체 교체 승인권한

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Procurement wants sign-off from the Formulation Director on this fragrance supplier switch, not the Production Manager — that's the correct chain per spec, right?

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-117 — Section: Supplier Qualification Criteria]
- New fragrance suppliers require IFRA compliance certificate
- Minimum 2 consecutive audit passes required
- Sample batch evaluation: 3 consecutive production runs

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-129 — Section: Change Control Authority]
- Fragrance supplier substitution: approval reserved to Formulation Director
- Colorant supplier substitution: approval reserved to Formulation Director
- Packaging vendor substitution: approval reserved to Production Manager

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"AUTHORITY_MATCHES_SPEC"}


화장품·뷰티/제품 사양서/w50005-40 · 점도이상 배치 처리순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Quick gut-check before I write up the incident log — when a batch fails the viscosity check, isn't the order supposed to be quarantine first, then re-test, then notify the QA lead, and dispose only if it fails again? Pasting the relevant sections.

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-073 — Section: Batch Deviation Handling]
- Step 1: Notify QA lead immediately upon deviation detection
- Step 2: Quarantine batch pending QA review
- Step 3: QA-approved re-test within 48 hours
- Step 4: Dispose if re-test fails a second time

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-089 — Section: Viscosity Test Method]
- Test apparatus: rotational viscometer, spindle 3
- Test temperature: 25°C ± 0.5°C
- Acceptable range: 4,200–5,800 cP

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-104 — Section: Recordkeeping]
- Deviation log retained 3 years
- QA lead signature required on closure

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"CLAIM_MISMATCH","reason_code":"STEP_ORDER_REVERSED"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-41 · 갱신메모우선

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Quick question from the lender side—does the site still require a yellow hard-hat band for all visitors on the podium, as last month’s visitor flyer claimed?

MEMO/κ-27 — supersession line in the personal notebook: “κ-27 replaces any visitor flyer older than 1 June; yellow band rule is retired.” Older flyer still in the folder: “All podium visitors wear yellow hard-hat bands.” Fresh voice note same day: “Visitors now use white bands with a red stripe; yellow is scrap.” Lender claim packet still quotes the old flyer wording.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"TRUST_IGNORED","reason_code":"SUPERSEDED_FLYER_USED"}


물류/회의록/w50005-42 · 반품크레딧과일반화

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Reading the reverse-logistics notes, do all returns receive a full restock credit within 48 hours of arrival at Returns Bay 2? VEL/MT§25-B Article 2: Full restock credit within 48 hours of arrival at Returns Bay 2 applies only to Category-A returns. Article 3: Category-B returns follow a 5-business-day graded credit schedule. Article 4: Category-C returns are scrap-path and receive no restock credit. VEL/MT§25-A defines category labels. VEL/MT§25-C lists bin colors.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"48H_CREDIT_CATEGORY_A_ONLY"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-43 · 휴일작업예외

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Regarding staged handover, is there a written holiday-work exception that lets the drywall hangers enter on municipal rest days without a separate rest-day ticket?

MEMO/κ-25 — handover prep fragments. Finishes lead: “Drywall hangers need clean floors before they start.” Cleaner: “We’ll finish vacuuming Level 5 tonight.” Logistics: “Elevator padding stays up through Thursday.” The notes never discuss municipal rest days, holiday-work exceptions, or rest-day tickets for any trade.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"EXCEPTION_NOT_ADDRESSED"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-44 · 학회 회비 갱신주기

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Renewal season is coming up and I want to make sure I've got my membership cycle right before I compare it to a rival society -- can this be confirmed? Claim: My student membership also renews every April 1st, following the standard cycle. Source: Folio X-Nu, a paper describing membership structures at the Meridian Society for Comparative Linguistics, states: 'Standard membership renews annually on April 1st.' The paper makes no mention of a separate renewal cycle, or lack thereof, for student memberships.

[Assistant] <think>Paper fixes renewal at April 1 for standard membership only. Student memberships aren't discussed. The claim can't be confirmed.</think>{"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"student_membership_cycle_not_mentioned"}


화장품·뷰티/제품 사양서/w50005-45 · 국내외 사양서 상충우선순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
The domestic spec sheet and the export spec sheet don't agree on the allergen labeling threshold — for anything we're shipping overseas, the export version wins, correct?

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-351 — Section: Domestic Allergen Labeling]
- Allergen disclosure threshold: above 0.01% individual allergen content
- Font size minimum: 7pt

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-364 — Section: Spec Precedence Rules]
- Where domestic and export spec sheets conflict, the export-market version governs for products shipped overseas
- Where export spec sheets conflict across regions, the stricter regional threshold governs
- Domestic version governs for all domestically distributed stock

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-372 — Section: Regional Regulatory Mapping]
- EU allergen list differs from APAC allergen list by 4 substances
- Regional mapping table maintained by Regulatory Affairs

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"PRECEDENCE_RULE_CONFIRMED"}


물류/회의록/w50005-46 · 재고동결개시일

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] The floor claim is that the SKU-class T inventory freeze for Warehouse Pelve began on 12 August 2025—please confirm against the minutes. VEL/MT§16-A Article 1: The SKU-class T inventory freeze at Warehouse Pelve takes effect on 19 August 2025 at 00:01 local. Article 2: Pre-freeze cycle counts close on 18 August 2025. Article 3: Partial picks of class T after the freeze start require dual-manager override. VEL/MT§16-B lists freeze reason codes only.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"FREEZE_START_12AUG_VS_19AUG"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-47 · 데이터 저장용량 한도

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Trying to pick a data repository for our lab's next project -- does this match what the paper says about Vesper's Standard Tier? Claim: Standard Tier gives 250GB of free storage per project before overage charges kick in. Source: Folio V-Chi, a comparative paper on research-data infrastructure, states: 'Vesper Research Data Archive's Standard Tier plan provides up to 250 GB of free storage per project, with any usage beyond that cap billed at the subscribing institution's fixed overage rate.'

[Assistant] <think>Paper states 250GB free per project, with overage billed beyond that cap. Claim restates the same figure and condition.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"storage_cap_matches_250gb_per_project"}


물류/회의록/w50005-48 · 통관서류제출순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Under the recorded export desk clauses, must the commercial invoice be lodged before the packing list, and the packing list before the certificate of origin, for lane OR-17? VEL/MT§14-C Article 1: For outbound lane OR-17, the commercial invoice shall be lodged first in the border packet. Article 2: The packing list may be accepted only after the commercial invoice file status shows Complete. Article 3: The certificate of origin is the third instrument and shall not be queued while Article 2 remains open. VEL/MT§14-D notes courier cutoff times but does not reorder the packet.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"CUSTOMS_PACKET_ORDER_CONFIRMED"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-49 · 야간작업예외

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Under which exception may the basement formwork crew continue past 22:00 without a fresh night-work chit?

MEMO/κ-18 — coffee-truck conversation. PM aide Lina: “After 22:00 you need a night-work chit, full stop—unless the city flood alarm is still active and we are only pumping sump water.” Foreman: “So structural formwork still needs a chit?” Lina: “Yes. Only sump pumping during an active flood alarm skips the new chit.” Extra line: “Heat-wave overtime is not that exception.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"EXCEPTION_SCOPE_MATCH"}


화장품·뷰티/제품 사양서/w50005-50 · 용기색상 변경 안정성예외

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Walk me through this — if we're only changing the cap color on the moisturizer jar and the formula already has 24 months of real-time stability data on file, can we use the abbreviated review instead of rerunning the full stability program?

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-258 — Section: Stability Test Conditions]
- Real-time storage: 25°C/60% RH, pull points through 24 months
- Accelerated storage: 40°C/75% RH, pull points through 6 months

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-271 — Section: Shelf-Life Extension Pathways]
- Abbreviated review applies when real-time data already spans 24 months or more
- Abbreviated review applies only to non-material packaging changes (color, print, labeling)
- Material changes (resin type, barrier layer) require full stability re-run

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-285 — Section: Documentation Requirements]
- Abbreviated review report retained with original stability file
- QA sign-off required within 10 business days

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"ABBREVIATED_REVIEW_CRITERIA_MET"}


[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] We are about to enforce RFID tagging on every inbound carton at Intake Hall B—does the minutes actually require that breadth? VEL/MT§18-C Article 1: RFID tagging at Intake Hall B is required only for SKU class R cartons. Article 2: SKU classes S and U remain barcode-only unless a customer rider states otherwise. Article 3: Bulk non-carton freights are exempt from RFID at this hall. VEL/MT§18-D inventories portal antenna serials. VEL/MT§07-B is a staffing roster excerpt.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"RFID_CLASS_R_ONLY_NOT_ALL_INBOUND"}


화장품·뷰티/제품 사양서/w50005-52 · 유화제 변경시 SPF재시험

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
We only nudged the emulsifier ratio by 0.3% on the sunscreen reformulation — can we skip the SPF retest for that, or does even a small emulsifier tweak still trigger it?

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-142 — Section: UV Filter Combination Rules]
- Avobenzone + Octocrylene combination ratio locked at 3:1
- Zinc oxide micronization: particle size ≤ 200nm
- UV filter substitution requires full SPF retest

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-156 — Section: Packaging Compatibility]
- Compatible container resin: HDPE, PET only
- UV-opaque packaging required for shelf storage beyond 6 months

[Spec Sheet No. 2026-171 — Section: Formula Modification & Retest Triggers]
- Any UV filter concentration change: full SPF retest required
- Any emulsifier system change, regardless of magnitude: full SPF retest required
- Colorant-only change: SPF retest not required

[Assistant] {"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"CLAIM_MISMATCH","reason_code":"EMULSIFIER_CHANGE_EXEMPTION_DENIED"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-53 · 프리프린트 엠바고 예외

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] Weighing preprint servers for a manuscript that's already been accepted somewhere -- does this line up with Cascade's exception rule? Claim: The no-embargo exception applies to manuscripts accepted by a journal before November 1, 2025. Source: Folio IX-Beta, a paper reviewing preprint embargo policies, states: 'Cascade Preprint Archive permits immediate posting without the standard embargo only for manuscripts already accepted by a journal before September 15, 2025; submissions after that date are subject to the standard 90-day embargo regardless of acceptance status.'

[Assistant] <think>The exception cutoff in the paper is September 15, 2025, but the claim pushes the date out to November 1, 2025.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"embargo_exception_cutoff_pushed_later"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-54 · 용접자격요건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
What credential must a fitter show before striking an arc on the skybridge splice plates, per these local scraps?

MEMO/κ-41 — yard trailer banter. Welding marshal Bo: “Skybridge splices need the silver-band site card plus the plate-test stamp from last Thursday’s booth.” Fitter K: “My company card enough?” Bo: “No. Silver-band site card and Thursday plate-test stamp, both. Open-shop card alone is not enough.” Another voice: “Pipe welds use a different stamp; ignore that list.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"DUAL_CREDENTIAL_REQUIRED"}


학술·연구/논문/w50005-55 · 소프트웨어 라이선스 범위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] What if I told our department that visiting scholars are covered too -- am I about to spread bad information about the Aurora Stat Suite Campus License? Here's the claim I want checked: Since the Campus License covers all academic members of the institution, visiting scholars are automatically eligible too. Source: Folio II-Sigma, an internal paper on software licensing models for research computing, specifies: 'The Aurora Stat Suite Campus License is limited to faculty and graduate students actively enrolled in a degree program at the subscribing institution. Undergraduate students and visiting scholars are explicitly excluded from this license tier.'

[Assistant] <think>License covers only faculty and enrolled grad students, explicitly excluding visiting scholars; claim extends it to 'all academic members.'</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"eligible_group_broadened_beyond_faculty_grad_students"}


[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] When applying the weekend delivery clauses, does a Saturday SLA waiver require both a shipper-written deferral ticket and a carrier acceptance stamp before noon Friday? VEL/MT§17-A Article 2: Saturday delivery SLA may be waived only when a shipper-written deferral ticket is filed. Article 3: The carrier acceptance stamp on that ticket must be captured before 12:00 on the preceding Friday. Article 4: Either instrument alone is insufficient. VEL/MT§17-B covers holiday surcharge tables. VEL/MT§02-C is limited to pallet pool balances.

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"WEEKEND_WAIVER_DUAL_CONDITIONS"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-57 · 우천지연우선

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
When both conflict, which takes precedence on Tuesday mornings: holding the steel bundle for rain-delay drying, or releasing the truck slot for the long-span beam delivery?

MEMO/κ-19 — radio clip. Logistics: “Tuesday steel trucks are waiting.” Site PM voice: “Rain-delay drying of already-landed bundles yields to the long-span beam delivery slot; free the bay.” Crane: “So beams first?” PM: “Yes—beam delivery wins over drying holds on Tuesday mornings only.” Footnote: “Wednesday rebar re-sequencing is a different rule.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"PRIORITY_RULE_MATCH"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-58 · 배수로금지물

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Which acts are barred within two meters of the foundation perimeter drain while the gravel sock is open?

MEMO/κ-07 — morning huddle audio. Drain lead Sera: “While the gravel sock is open, no solvent cans, no epoxy guns, and no fuel jerrycans inside the two-meter tape.” Laborer: “What about rebar chairs?” Sera: “Chairs are fine. Solvents, epoxy guns, fuel cans — those three stay outside the tape.” Postscript in same memo: “After the sock is closed, epoxy is allowed again with a drip tray.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"PROHIBITED_SET_ALIGNED"}


건설/개인 로컬 메모/w50005-59 · 타설승인주체

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User]
Who holds final sign-off before any ready-mix truck can discharge on Tower C level 8, according to these personal notes?

MEMO/κ-22 — overheard at the batching gate. Batch driver: “Need a green light.” Night lead Hwan: “Only Deputy PM Sol may clear discharge on Tower C; I can stage trucks but not open the chute.” Safety walker Jun: “Sol’s stamp is on the laminated card taped to the hopper.” Another scrap: “QA lead can stop a pour but cannot authorize start.”

[Assistant] {"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"AUTHORITY_NAMED_IN_NOTE"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-60 · 스쿨존 도색순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"According to the transcript, faded crosswalks at elementary gates outrank faded side-street bike stencils for repaint slots.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-06A","text":"Paint planner Oh: Repaint slots go to elementary gate crosswalks with more than 40% fade first, secondary-school gates second, then side-street bike stencils. Parent call: Can the bike stencil near our alley jump ahead? Oh: No, it stays third."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-06B","text":"Yard talk: Fade percent is measured with the red card kit, not by eye alone."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-06C","text":"Scheduler: Secondary gates never leap elementary gates in the same week’s batch."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Planner Oh lists elementary gate crosswalks first and side-street bike stencils third. The restatement matches that hierarchy.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"REPAINT_RANK_OK"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-61 · 승인권자지정

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"As a first-time applicant, which official approves a Neralis route notice under Article 4, paragraph 1—the District Liaison or the Central Registrar?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:03:FLINT","text":"Article 1, paragraph 2. A route notice concerns a designated public passage within Neralis."},{"document_id":"VANTA:04:GLASS","text":"Article 4, paragraph 1. The Neralis District Liaison shall approve each route notice before release."},{"document_id":"VANTA:05:BRIAR","text":"Article 4, paragraph 3. The Central Registrar shall file a copy of each approved Neralis route notice."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 4 names the District Liaison as approver. The Central Registrar is assigned only to file copies.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"AUTHORITY_MATCH"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-62 · 배수청소 우선순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Assign drainage-cleaning priority for Ward 9 only if the record states which catch-basin group goes first after a heavy rain.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-09A","text":"Budget clerk Im: Ward 9 drain work is billed under code DR-441 for overtime and DR-220 for equipment rental. Foreman: Which basin group first after heavy rain? Im: That ranking is not on my sheets; I only track codes."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-09B","text":"Invoice chat: DR-441 covers night pumping, not priority between school-side and market-side basins."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Both texts cover budget codes and overtime billing only. Neither names which catch-basin group is cleaned first, so priority cannot be verified.</think>{"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"PRIORITY_NOT_IN_EVIDENCE"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-63 · 연구원 자격요건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Before I tell the funding committee — J. Okafor is certified to run Wren Pilot Study sessions solo now, right? Heard they finished the required certification.","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0388","text":"Wren Pilot Study Eligibility Policy, Section 2: Only researchers holding a current Level-2 Field Certification may independently lead a pilot session without supervisor co-presence."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0389","text":"Personnel File Note (Wren Pilot Study): J. Okafor completed Level-1 Field Certification on 2026-02-10; Level-2 certification exam not yet scheduled."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Policy requires Level-2 certification to lead solo. Personnel note shows only Level-1 done and Level-2 not scheduled.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NO_EVIDENCE","reason_code":"level2_certification_not_on_record"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-64 · 허가양도조건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Can a holder transfer a Rava permit without prior written consent under Article 6, paragraph 2?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:37:WILLOW","text":"Article 6, paragraph 2. A Rava permit may be transferred only after the holder obtains prior written consent from the Permit Office."},{"document_id":"VANTA:38:KITE","text":"Article 7, paragraph 1. The new holder shall retain the permit number after an approved transfer."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 6, paragraph 2 permits transfer only after prior written consent. The query removes that required condition.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"CLAIM_MISMATCH","reason_code":"CONSENT_REQUIRED"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-65 · 용매폐기 금지

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Can you give me a summary of the Kestrel Chem Lab rule on solvent disposal — I remember it's flat-out banned to pour halogenated solvents down the drain, has to go in the amber containers instead?","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0355","text":"Kestrel Chem Lab Inventory Note: Amber waste containers restocked, 40 units received 2026-03-14."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0356","text":"Kestrel Chem Lab Safety Note, Section 3: Halogenated solvent waste must never be poured into the standard drain system; it must be collected in the marked amber waste containers for licensed disposal. Violation is treated as a reportable safety incident."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0357","text":"Kestrel Chem Lab Fume Hood Log: Airflow inspection passed on 2026-04-01."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Safety note bans pouring halogenated solvent down the drain and requires amber containers, matching the recalled rule.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"solvent_drain_ban_confirmed"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-66 · 공원야영 금지범위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Compare the claim to the record: all daytime picnics with ground mats are banned in Cedarwick riverside parks.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-18A","text":"Ranger Sol: Overnight camping and tent stakes are banned in Cedarwick riverside parks; daytime picnics with ground mats are allowed until 20:00 if trash is bagged. Picnic group: Mats too? Sol: Mats fine; tents and overnight stays are the ban."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-18B","text":"Sign text: No overnight camping / tents; picnic mats OK daytime."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Sol and the sign ban overnight camping and tents, not daytime mat picnics. Extending the ban to all mat picnics overgeneralizes the prohibition.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"PICNIC_SWEPT_INTO_BAN"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-67 · 야간소음 우선처리

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Confirm: under Rivermere night-noise triage, households with in-home medical equipment are handled before general residences.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-01A","text":"Clerk Han: Night-noise priority is medical-equipment households first, then schools with overnight exams, then general residences. Resident Yoon: So hospital-equipment homes jump the queue? Han: Yes, that is the posted order."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-01B","text":"Supervisor Lee: Do not reverse medical and school tiers; audit flags that swap every time."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Doc A ranks medical-equipment households first, then exam schools, then general residences. The claim matches that order; Doc B only forbids reversing medical and school tiers.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"PRIORITY_ORDER_MATCH"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-68 · 로그 보관기간

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Confirming for the report: raw sensor logs from the Aurora-Vane trial series need to be kept for 5 years before they're eligible for deletion, correct?","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0141","text":"Experiment Report EXP·2026·0141 — Aurora-Vane Trial Series, Sampling Protocol. Section 2.1: Environmental probes are calibrated daily against the reference standard prior to each trial run. Calibration drift beyond 0.5% triggers a probe swap."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0142","text":"Experiment Report EXP·2026·0142 — Aurora-Vane Trial Series, Instrumentation Appendix. Section 4.2 Data Retention: Raw sensor logs generated during Aurora-Vane series trials shall be retained for a minimum of five (5) years from the date of trial completion before becoming eligible for deletion. Processed summary datasets are retained separately under Section 4.5."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Doc EXP·2026·0142 states raw sensor logs are retained five years post-trial, matching the claimed period.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"retention_period_confirmed_five_years"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-69 · 협동조합면허요건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Does a person without a cooperative license qualify for a Daro microgrant under Article 2, paragraph 1?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:49:FOX","text":"Article 1, paragraph 1. The Daro microgrant supports small cooperative service projects."},{"document_id":"VANTA:50:IRON","text":"Article 2, paragraph 1. A Daro microgrant applicant shall hold a cooperative license and a resident certificate."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 2, paragraph 1 requires a cooperative license and a resident certificate. The proposed applicant lacks one required qualification.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"CLAIM_MISMATCH","reason_code":"QUALIFICATION_MISSING"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-70 · 모래주머니 배분순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Does the Northvale flood desk put ground-floor care homes ahead of basements of ordinary shops for sandbag drops?","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-03A","text":"Duty officer Park: Sandbag drop order is ground-floor care homes, then residential basements with registered mobility-impaired residents, then ordinary shop basements. Shop owner Min: We flooded last year. Park: Still third tier under the current desk sheet."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-03B","text":"Shift handoff: Never skip care homes to clear a commercial block first."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Park lists ground-floor care homes first and ordinary shop basements third. The query’s ranking matches that desk order; the handoff only reinforces not skipping care homes.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"SANDBAG_TIER_MATCH"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-71 · 교정값 신뢰도

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Double checking — the Vesper Spectrometer's official anomaly threshold is 2.4% deviation from baseline, confirmed for the methods section, right?","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0305","text":"Calibration Report EXP·2026·0305 (STATUS: PRELIMINARY — pending secondary audit, not for citation as final). Draft anomaly-flagging threshold: deviations exceeding 2.4% of baseline are flagged. This figure is provisional and subject to revision after the Q3 audit."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0306","text":"Vesper Spectrometer Maintenance Log: Light source bulb replaced on 2026-06-11 after 900 operating hours."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Report gives 2.4% but marks itself PRELIMINARY pending audit — citing it as confirmed final ignores that status.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"TRUST_IGNORED","reason_code":"cited_provisional_threshold_as_final"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-72 · 방치차량 견인순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Flag any mismatch if crews claim fire-lane blockers are towed after long-term parked cars with expired tags.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-05A","text":"Tow lead Seo: Order is fire-lane or hydrant blockers first, then vehicles blocking waste collection, then long-term parkers with expired tags. Driver Im: Expired tags look worse on paper. Seo: Still third; safety blocks stay first."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-05B","text":"Radio check: Hydrant block ticket pre-empts a 60-day abandoned sedan on the same street."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Seo ranks fire-lane or hydrant blockers first and expired-tag long-term parkers third. The crew claim reverses that order, so it mismatches the record.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"PRIORITY_REVERSAL_CLAIM"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-73 · 최초통지기한

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"For a beginner, is the first notice due within 9 working days after receipt under Article 5, paragraph 1?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:25:LOOM","text":"Article 2, paragraph 1. A notice begins the review period for a covered Neris request."},{"document_id":"VANTA:26:TEAL","text":"Article 4, paragraph 2. The receiving desk shall stamp the date of receipt on the request."},{"document_id":"VANTA:27:OPAL","text":"Article 5, paragraph 1. The first notice shall be issued within 9 working days after receipt of the request."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 5, paragraph 1 expressly sets the first-notice deadline at 9 working days after receipt.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"DEADLINE_MATCH"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-74 · 인도균열 보수순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"For sidewalk crack tickets in Marlow Vale, trip hazards over 2 cm near clinics outrank the same depth cracks on quiet residential walks.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-10A","text":"Inspector Bae: Trip hazards over 2 cm within 50 m of clinics or transit stops are batch one; same depth on quiet residential walks is batch two; hairline cracks under 2 cm wait for annual resurfacing. Walker: Clinic side first even if residential called earlier? Bae: Yes, location tier beats call time."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-10B","text":"Crew chief: Measure with the wedge gauge; do not upgrade by photo alone."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Bae puts >2 cm hazards near clinics or transit in batch one and same-depth residential walks in batch two. The claim matches that location-based rank.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"CRACK_TIER_MATCH"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-75 · 이탈보고 승인자

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Give me a quick rundown of the Halcyon Field Study deviation sign-off rule — pretty sure it's the Site Coordinator who has to countersign before anything goes to the ethics panel, want to confirm before I brief the team.","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0196","text":"Halcyon Field Study Recruitment Note: Participant screening interviews are conducted by trained field assistants under the supervision of the Site Coordinator."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0198","text":"Halcyon Field Study Governance Charter, Section 3.4: Any protocol deviation report filed under the Halcyon Field Study must be countersigned by the designated Site Coordinator prior to submission to the ethics review panel. Reports lacking Site Coordinator countersignature are returned as incomplete."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0199","text":"Halcyon Field Study Equipment Log: GPS trackers were recalibrated in Week 6 following a firmware update."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Governance charter names the Site Coordinator as required countersigner for deviation reports, matching the claim.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"site_coordinator_signoff_confirmed"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-76 · 장비배정 우선순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Give me a summary of how Lattice resolves conflicting instrument requests — I think seniority projects get bumped ahead of others when there's a clash, is that the actual rule?","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0446","text":"Lattice Instrument Scheduling Log, Week 14: Three requests received for the cryo-EM slot — Team A (Tuesday), Team B (Wednesday), Team C (Thursday). All three requests are currently pending review."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0447","text":"Lattice Instrument Scheduling Charter, Section 1: Booking windows open every Monday at 09:00 and close Friday at 17:00 for the following week's slots."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0448","text":"Lattice Instrument Scheduling Note: Cryo-EM maintenance window is scheduled for the last Friday of each month."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Log just lists three pending requests, and the charter only covers booking windows. Neither document states a priority rule for conflicts.</think>{"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"priority_rule_not_addressed_in_docs"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-77 · 보고주기상한

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"How often does Article 6, paragraph 4 require the Novera service unit to file 12 reports per year?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:21:CEDAR","text":"Article 3, paragraph 2. The Novera service unit shall keep a ledger for each covered district."},{"document_id":"VANTA:22:INK","text":"Article 5, paragraph 1. The unit shall notify the registry of material changes."},{"document_id":"VANTA:23:ASHEN","text":"Article 6, paragraph 4. The Novera service unit shall file one report every quarter, totaling four reports per calendar year."},{"document_id":"VANTA:24:BRONZE","text":"Article 7, paragraph 2. A report shall identify the reporting period and responsible officer."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 6, paragraph 4 requires four reports per calendar year, not 12.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NUMERIC_DISTORTION","reason_code":"FREQUENCY_CONFLICT"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-78 · 등록대장보관기간

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"I am new to the Lyris archive. Is it correct that an intake register must be kept for 18 months under Article 3, paragraph 2?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:01:ORBIT","text":"Article 1, paragraph 1. The Lyris archive shall maintain intake records for covered submissions."},{"document_id":"VANTA:02:EMBER","text":"Article 3, paragraph 2. The Lyris intake register shall be retained for 18 months from the final entry."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 3, paragraph 2 sets retention at 18 months from the final entry.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"DIRECT_MATCH"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-79 · 구역별등록상한

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"I cannot tell the ceiling: does Article 6, paragraph 1 allow up to 42 Veyra kiosks per district?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:06:WISP","text":"Article 2, paragraph 1. A district may register approved service kiosks within its assigned boundary."},{"document_id":"VANTA:07:STONE","text":"Article 6, paragraph 1. Each district may register no more than 24 Veyra kiosks."},{"document_id":"VANTA:08:REED","text":"Article 9, paragraph 2. A kiosk shall display its assigned district seal."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 6 sets the ceiling at 24, while the query states 42.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NUMERIC_DISTORTION","reason_code":"LIMIT_CONFLICT"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-80 · 무더위쉼터 입소순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"I need a cross-check: at Coralwick cooling centers, do registered heat-illness patients outrank unregistered seniors for remaining seats?","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-04A","text":"Center host Ryu: When seats run short, registered heat-illness patients enter first, then unregistered seniors over 75, then other walk-ins. Visitor: My uncle is 80 but not registered. Ryu: He is second tier after registered patients."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-04B","text":"Volunteer script: Ask for the heat-illness registry card before offering a reserved chair."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-04C","text":"Closing remark: Children without caregivers wait with staff; they are not in the seat-priority stack."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-04D","text":"Log line: Two registered patients seated before any unregistered senior on 12 July drill."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Host Ryu places registered heat-illness patients before unregistered seniors over 75. Docs B and D echo registry-first seating. Claim aligns.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"SEAT_PRIORITY_ALIGNED"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-81 · 민원접수 처리순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"In what order must a written nuisance grievance move through Redhollow intake before a site visit is booked?","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-12A","text":"Intake lead Yun: Written nuisance files go stamp-in, then conflict-check against open cases, then mediator assign, and only then site-visit booking. Staffer: Can we book the visit right after stamp-in? Yun: No; skip conflict-check and the visit gets cancelled."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-12B","text":"Whiteboard: 1 stamp 2 conflict 3 mediator 4 visit."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Yun and the whiteboard share the same sequence: stamp-in, conflict-check, mediator assign, then site-visit booking. That is the required order.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"INTAKE_SEQUENCE_OK"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-82 · 대피소일정열람

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Is any requester allowed to obtain the full Vora shelter schedule under Article 12, paragraph 2?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:46:HEATHER","text":"Article 12, paragraph 2. The full Vora shelter schedule shall be available only to accredited officers assigned to shelter coordination."},{"document_id":"VANTA:47:MARSH","text":"Article 12, paragraph 3. Public notices may display shelter locations without operational schedules."},{"document_id":"VANTA:48:LEAF","text":"Article 13, paragraph 1. An accredited officer shall protect schedule records from unauthorized disclosure."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 12, paragraph 2 restricts the full schedule to accredited officers, so access by any requester is inconsistent.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"CLAIM_MISMATCH","reason_code":"ACCESS_RESTRICTED"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-83 · 이의제기 마감일수

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Is it accurate that a refuse-fee assessment appeal in Portkelp must be filed within 45 days of the notice stamp?","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-16A","text":"Appeals clerk Vee: Refuse-fee assessment appeals are due within 20 days of the notice stamp date, not calendar month end. Resident: Someone online said 45. Vee: That number is wrong for this desk; 20 days only."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-16B","text":"Stamp example: Notice 3 June, last appeal day 23 June."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Vee states a 20-day deadline from the notice stamp; the 3 June→23 June example matches. Claiming 45 days distorts that deadline.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"APPEAL_DAYS_INFLATED"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-84 · 긴급심사예외

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"May a Zorun field desk use expedited review only when an emergency order is active, service is interrupted for more than 6 hours, and the duty director records the reason?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:13:QUILL","text":"Article 8, paragraph 4. A Zorun field desk may use expedited review only when an emergency order is active, service is interrupted for more than 6 hours, and the duty director records the reason."},{"document_id":"VANTA:14:FERN","text":"Article 8, paragraph 5. The expedited review record shall identify the affected service."},{"document_id":"VANTA:15:COAL","text":"Article 10, paragraph 1. Ordinary review remains the default procedure."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 8, paragraph 4 states all three listed conditions for expedited review.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"CONDITION_MATCH"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-85 · 재난예외범위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"May a heat alert activate the Sola emergency exception under Article 9, paragraph 3?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:39:EMBER","text":"Article 4, paragraph 1. The Sola office shall record each emergency notice in the incident register."},{"document_id":"VANTA:40:RAIN","text":"Article 9, paragraph 3. The Sola emergency exception may activate when a flood warning is issued and water access is cut for more than 4 hours."},{"document_id":"VANTA:41:WALL","text":"Article 10, paragraph 1. An exception record shall state the triggering notice."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 9, paragraph 3 names a flood warning and water-access cutoff. It does not state whether a heat alert qualifies.</think>{"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"TRIGGER_NOT_ADDRESSED"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-86 · 중간보고 주기

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Need to verify — interim results for the Orrery Longitudinal Study go to the Steering Committee every quarter, that's the cycle, correct?","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0412","text":"Orrery Longitudinal Study Reporting Charter, Section 5: Interim results summaries are due to the Steering Committee every quarter (90-day cycle), beginning from the study's official start date."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0413","text":"Orrery Longitudinal Study Recruitment Note: Cohort enrollment closed at 240 participants as of 2026-01-15."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0414","text":"Orrery Longitudinal Study Budget Note: Equipment budget line increased by 12% for FY2026."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0415","text":"Orrery Longitudinal Study Site Note: Two additional collection sites opened in March 2026."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Charter sets a 90-day interim reporting cycle. That is quarterly. Claim matches the record.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"quarterly_interim_cycle_confirmed"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-87 · 횡단신호 책임주체

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Nothing in my notes names the office that owns new mid-block crosswalk signals in Ashford; still, does the evidence state which body is responsible?","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-19A","text":"Signal tech Wren: Mid-block ped phases in Ashford run a 28-second walk plus 6-second clearance; timing changes need a two-week observation log. Resident: Who installs a brand-new signal? Wren: Timing is my lane; ownership paperwork is not in this talk."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-19B","text":"Observation sheet: Only cycle lengths and pedestrian volume counts."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-19C","text":"Radio: Hold the 28/6 split through festival week."}]}

[Assistant] <think>All three texts discuss walk timing and observation logs only. None name which office owns or installs new mid-block signals, so responsibility stays unverified.</think>{"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"OWNER_NOT_ADDRESSED"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-88 · 건축민원 접수기간

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Please check the date claim: Bluefen accepts new facade-noise complaints only through 15 August 2024 for the summer window.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-14A","text":"Counter Maya: Summer facade-noise intake opens 1 July 2024 and closes 31 July 2024 at 17:00; August filings go to the autumn window starting 1 September. Caller: Mid-August still summer? Maya: No, summer closed 31 July."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-14B","text":"Stamp log sample: Last summer ticket numbered on 31 July 2024 16:40."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Maya sets summer intake to 1–31 July 2024, not through 15 August. The claim shifts the close date into August and distorts the window.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"WINDOW_END_MISSTATED"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-89 · 공고처리순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Please state the required order under Article 7, paragraph 3: receipt, screening, then publication.","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:09:ASH","text":"Article 1, paragraph 3. A notice is a public statement issued after administrative review."},{"document_id":"VANTA:10:WAVE","text":"Article 7, paragraph 3. The authority shall receive the notice, conduct screening, and then publish the result, in that order."},{"document_id":"VANTA:11:MINT","text":"Article 8, paragraph 1. Screening records shall identify the reviewing unit."},{"document_id":"VANTA:12:DAWN","text":"Article 9, paragraph 1. A published result shall remain accessible through the civic register."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 7, paragraph 3 lists receipt first, screening second, and publication third. The proposed order matches.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"SEQUENCE_MATCH"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-90 · 기한연장 예외

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Quick check before I tell the group — the PI got a 30-day extension on the Meridian Cryo-Assay data-lock deadline approved because of the freezer failure, right?","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0232","text":"Meridian Cryo-Assay Governance Note, Section 6.1 Exceptions: Data-lock deadline extensions may only be granted by written approval of the Program Director following a formal deviation request."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0233","text":"Incident Log MER-0091 (attached to EXP·2026·0233): Equipment failure recorded on the freezer array on Day 41. No deviation request was filed with the Program Director, and no extension to the data-lock deadline was granted; the original deadline stood."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Governance note requires Program Director approval for extensions. Incident log confirms no request was filed and none was granted.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NO_EVIDENCE","reason_code":"no_extension_recorded_for_freezer_incident"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-91 · 오염제거 순서

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Sanity check on the Solace Bio-Containment protocol — decon order is autoclave first, then neutralizing rinse, then into the biohazard bin, yes?","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0269","text":"Solace Bio-Containment Facility Note: Access to Room 4 requires dual-badge authorization outside business hours."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0270","text":"Solace Bio-Containment Inventory Log: Neutralizing solution stock replenished on 2026-05-02, lot NS-118."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0271","text":"Solace Bio-Containment Disposal Protocol, Section 5: Containers must first undergo autoclave sterilization at 121°C, then be rinsed with the designated neutralizing solution, and only then may they be placed in the biohazard disposal bin. Skipping the rinse step is not permitted."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0272","text":"Solace Bio-Containment Training Record: All technicians completed annual PPE refresher training in April 2026."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Protocol lists autoclave, then neutralizing rinse, then biohazard bin — same order as claimed.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"decon_sequence_matches_protocol"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-92 · 제설 노선우선

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Staff note asserts all residential streets in Glenport are plowed before any arterial bus corridor.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-08A","text":"Snow desk Hwan: First pass is arterial bus corridors and hospital approaches; second pass is school frontages; residential streets start only after those two. Neighbor: Our cul-de-sac feels forgotten. Hwan: It is third wave by design."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-08B","text":"Radio: Hold residential plows until Route B7 bus spine is clear."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-08C","text":"Map note: Cul-de-sacs share the third wave with service alleys."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-08D","text":"Debrief: One crew started residential early last year and was cited."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Hwan’s first pass is arterial bus corridors, not residences. The staff note flips that order and overstates residential precedence for all streets.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"RESIDENTIAL_BEFORE_ARTERIAL"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-93 · 가로등정책 시행일

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"The field team wrote that the dimming curfew for park poles in Eastmere took effect on 1 March 2023.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-15A","text":"Lighting lead Tor: Park pole dimming curfew started 1 March 2024 citywide; 2023 was only the pilot on two trails. Gardener: I thought it was already full in 2023. Tor: Pilot only; full rule is 2024."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-15B","text":"Memo snippet: Full Eastmere curfew date printed as 1 March 2024."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-15C","text":"Pilot note: 2023 trail pilot had no enforcement fines."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Tor and the memo place full Eastmere curfew on 1 March 2024; 2023 was pilot-only. The field note’s 2023 effective year is a date distortion.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"EFFECTIVE_YEAR_WRONG"}


학술·연구/실험 보고서/w50005-94 · 표본기록 관리책임

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Trying to nail down who has final say — the Data Steward can approve permanent archiving of the Thistle specimen records on their own, correct?","documents":[{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0467","text":"Thistle Specimen Registry Access Note: Read-only access to archived records is granted to registered lab members upon request."},{"document_id":"EXP·2026·0468","text":"Thistle Specimen Registry Governance Memo: The Data Steward acts as day-to-day custodian of archived specimen records but holds no final authority to approve permanent archiving; final sign-off rests exclusively with the Ethics Board chair. Records archived without Ethics Board sign-off are considered provisional."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Memo states the Steward is only a custodian without final authority — sign-off rests with the Ethics Board chair, so the claim ignores that limit.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"TRUST_IGNORED","reason_code":"steward_authority_overstated_ignoring_ethics_signoff"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-95 · 급식지원 예외조건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Verify whether temporary hospital stays create an exception to income-tier meal support in Windmere schools.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-20A","text":"Meal desk Lio: Windmere school meal support uses three income tiers—Tier A under 30%, Tier B 30–50%, Tier C 50–70% of the district median. Parent: What if a parent is in hospital for two months? Lio: Exception rules are not on this sheet; I only quote the tiers."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-20B","text":"Form footer: Attach last year’s tax notice for tier placement."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Docs only define income tiers A–C and tax proof. They never discuss hospital-stay exceptions, so the exception claim cannot be confirmed or denied from evidence.</think>{"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"EXCEPTION_ABSENT"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-96 · 가로등 고장순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Walk me through whether this claim holds: every dark streetlight in Pellford is treated as the same emergency priority.","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-07A","text":"Grid desk No: Dark poles at underpass exits and outside night clinics are emergency priority; residential side streets are standard 72-hour priority; park path lights are routine weekly. Caller: So all dark lights are emergency? No: Only underpass and clinic poles."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-07B","text":"Crew board: Do not mark alley poles as emergency unless they sit on the underpass list."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Desk No limits emergency priority to underpass exits and night-clinic poles; residential and park paths sit lower. Claiming every dark pole is emergency overreaches the stated tiers.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"OVERGENERALIZATION","reason_code":"ALL_OUTAGES_EMERGENCY"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-97 · 복구보조금 상한

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"What is the maximum recovery subsidy per micro-shop under the Silverfen storm desk sheet?","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-13A","text":"Aid officer Kade: Micro-shops under 30 m² get up to 1.2 million won for inventory loss, not more, even if receipts are higher. Owner: My loss is 1.8 million. Kade: Cap stays 1.2 million on this sheet."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-13B","text":"Second window: Equipment repair uses a separate voucher; it does not raise the inventory cap."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-13C","text":"Audit whisper: Stacking two inventory claims for one shop is blocked."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-13D","text":"Poster line: Cap figure is 1.2 million won inventory only."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Kade and the poster set the micro-shop inventory recovery cap at 1.2 million won. Equipment vouchers do not raise that cap.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"CAP_1_2M_MATCH"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-98 · 환급금액한도

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"What reimbursement ceiling applies under Article 6, paragraph 3: is a Deyra applicant eligible for up to 700,000 credits?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:33:FOG","text":"Article 1, paragraph 2. The Deyra reimbursement program covers approved civic equipment."},{"document_id":"VANTA:34:TOPAZ","text":"Article 4, paragraph 4. An applicant shall attach an itemized payment record."},{"document_id":"VANTA:35:CRANE","text":"Article 6, paragraph 3. Reimbursement shall not exceed 70,000 credits for one approved application."},{"document_id":"VANTA:36:WREN","text":"Article 8, paragraph 1. The payment office shall record each approved reimbursement."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 6, paragraph 3 sets the ceiling at 70,000 credits, not 700,000.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"NUMERIC_DISTORTION","reason_code":"AMOUNT_CONFLICT"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-99 · 계정삭제절차

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"What sequence is prescribed for deleting a Miren account under Article 8, paragraph 2: owner request, identity check, deletion log, then erasure?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:42:PEBBLE","text":"Article 1, paragraph 2. A Miren account records access to a designated civic service."},{"document_id":"VANTA:43:VINE","text":"Article 4, paragraph 2. The custodian shall retain an account status record during active service."},{"document_id":"VANTA:44:MOON","text":"Article 8, paragraph 2. Upon an owner's deletion request, the custodian shall verify identity, record the deletion in the log, and then erase the account."},{"document_id":"VANTA:45:BRICK","text":"Article 9, paragraph 1. A deletion log entry shall include the account identifier and date."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 8, paragraph 2 orders the request, identity verification, log entry, and erasure in that sequence.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"SEQUENCE_MATCH"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-100 · 수질검사 주기일

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"When does the revised community-well sampling cycle for Lowmere start, if staff say quarterly sampling began 1 May 2024?","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-17A","text":"Lab liaison Quin: Lowmere community wells stay on annual sampling every 1 October; the May 2024 change only added an optional turbidity strip for heavy-rain weeks, not a quarterly cycle. Tech: People keep saying quarterly. Quin: Annual date unchanged."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-17B","text":"Calendar print: Next mandatory sample window opens 1 October 2024."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-17C","text":"Rain strip FAQ: Optional strips do not reset the annual clock."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-17D","text":"Board aside: Quarterly language was rejected in the March draft."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Quin keeps mandatory sampling annual on 1 October; May 2024 only added optional rain strips. Staff’s quarterly-from-1-May claim distorts both cycle and start date.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"DATE_DISTORTION","reason_code":"CYCLE_AND_START_WRONG"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-101 · 센서재교정주기

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"When must the Kivo sensor be recalibrated under Article 5, paragraph 1: after every 8 operating days?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:51:QUARTZ","text":"Article 5, paragraph 1. The Kivo sensor shall be recalibrated after every 8 operating days."},{"document_id":"VANTA:52:PLUME","text":"Article 6, paragraph 2. The calibration record shall state the sensor serial mark and operating-day count."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 5, paragraph 1 requires recalibration after every 8 operating days. The interval matches the query. Article 6 addresses recordkeeping.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"INTERVAL_MATCH"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-102 · 보조금자격요건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Which applicant qualifies for a Talen community grant under Article 2, paragraph 1: a registered cooperative holding an audit certificate?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:19:MAPLE","text":"Article 1, paragraph 1. The Talen community grant supports locally organized service projects."},{"document_id":"VANTA:20:PEARL","text":"Article 2, paragraph 1. A Talen community grant applicant shall be a registered cooperative holding a current audit certificate."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 2, paragraph 1 requires both registered-cooperative status and a current audit certificate.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"ELIGIBILITY_MATCH"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-103 · 폐쇄명령권자

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Which body may issue a closure order for an Edrin depot under Article 11: the Inspection Bureau or the Public Assets Desk?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:31:EMBER","text":"Article 11, paragraph 2. The Edrin Inspection Bureau shall inspect depots and submit findings to the Public Assets Desk."},{"document_id":"VANTA:32:SLATE","text":"Article 12, paragraph 1. The depot operator shall display any closure order received."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 11 assigns inspection and reporting, while Article 12 refers to a received closure order. Neither text names its issuing body.</think>{"verdict":"UNSURE","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"AUTHORITY_NOT_STATED"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-104 · 포트홀 보수순위

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Which pothole class does Oakbridge crew dispatch first on a mixed ticket day?","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-02A","text":"Dispatcher Cho: Mixed ticket days still follow depth class—Class R over 8 cm on bus routes first, Class R elsewhere second, shallow Class S last. Crew Kim: Even if a shallow one is near city hall? Cho: Still last unless it becomes Class R."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-02B","text":"Field note: Class R means measured depth at least 8 cm; photos alone do not upgrade class."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-02C","text":"Resident call log: Caller asked about a 3 cm dent; told it remains Class S."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Dispatch transcript puts Class R over 8 cm on bus routes first among mixed tickets. That is the first class stated.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"FIRST_CLASS_SUPPORTED"}


공공정책/민원 안내문/w50005-105 · 노점허가 자격요건

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Who may apply for a daytime food cart permit on Harrow Lane under the desk guidance?","documents":[{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-11A","text":"Permit clerk Jin: Daytime food carts on Harrow Lane need a two-year city tax clearance and a sanitation course certificate dated within 12 months. Applicant Ko: I have last year’s course but unpaid business tax. Jin: Both pieces are required; tax must be clear."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-11B","text":"Counter aside: Night market carts use a different form; do not mix rules."},{"document_id":"MANDAM·K7-11C","text":"Supervisor: No exception for first-time vendors on the tax clearance rule."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Jin requires two-year tax clearance plus a sanitation certificate within 12 months for daytime Harrow Lane carts. Eligibility is those meeting both, not night-market rules.</think>{"verdict":"PASS","failure_type":null,"reason_code":"ELIGIBILITY_BOTH_DOCS"}


공공정책/법령·고시/w50005-106 · 식별번호공개금지

[System] {"서브그래프":{"이름":"근거-검증기","기능":"주장-근거 대조 및 판정","버전":"v1.0","입력":"claims[], evidence[]","출력":"verdict JSON","도형":"diamond"}}

[User] {"query":"Would it be lawful for the Orvane board to publish full resident identification numbers in a public list under Article 5, paragraph 2?","documents":[{"document_id":"VANTA:16:VIOLET","text":"Article 2, paragraph 2. The Orvane board shall maintain a resident assistance list for service coordination."},{"document_id":"VANTA:17:SNOW","text":"Article 4, paragraph 1. Public lists shall show only the fields authorized for disclosure."},{"document_id":"VANTA:18:OAK","text":"Article 5, paragraph 2. The Orvane board shall not publish a resident's full identification number in a public list."}]}

[Assistant] <think>Article 5 prohibits publishing a full resident identification number in a public list, contradicting the proposed lawful publication.</think>{"verdict":"FAIL","failure_type":"CLAIM_MISMATCH","reason_code":"PROHIBITED_DISCLOSURE"}