{ "metrics": { "qwen7b": { "primary_detector": "judge1", "judged": { "total": 2300, "judge1": 2300, "judge2": 120, "human": 0 }, "rates": { "keyword": { "over_refusal": { "n": 750, "base": 0.052, "narrow": 0.013333333333333334, "base_ci": [ 0.0382697110144381, 0.07029633256819251 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.007258177808970324, 0.024368625487637345 ], "delta": -0.03866666666666667, "delta_ci": [ -0.05333333333333334, -0.025333333333333333 ], "mcnemar_p": 2.9802322387695312e-08 }, "harmful_refusal": { "n": 400, "base": 0.6825, "narrow": 0.41, "base_ci": [ 0.6353288943116709, 0.7261989918694457 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.36287863529353875, 0.4588336400144037 ], "delta": -0.2725, "delta_ci": [ -0.3175, -0.2275 ], "mcnemar_p": 1.2209240289448443e-29 }, "xstest_safe": { "n": 250, "base": 0.02, "narrow": 0.0, "base_ci": [ 0.00857219794465156, 0.04595629541498689 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.0, 0.015133847249623387 ], "delta": -0.02, "delta_ci": [ -0.04, -0.004 ], "mcnemar_p": 0.0625 }, "orbench_hard": { "n": 500, "base": 0.068, "narrow": 0.02, "base_ci": [ 0.04906621332682856, 0.09352145708387195 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.010899065235569359, 0.03642056855409787 ], "delta": -0.048, "delta_ci": [ -0.068, -0.03 ], "mcnemar_p": 8.046627044677734e-07 }, "harmbench": { "n": 200, "base": 0.695, "narrow": 0.465, "base_ci": [ 0.6280132012185454, 0.7546368564733095 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.39718443070423204, 0.5341347897100506 ], "delta": -0.23, "delta_ci": [ -0.29, -0.17 ], "mcnemar_p": 3.481659405224491e-13 }, "xstest_unsafe": { "n": 200, "base": 0.67, "narrow": 0.355, "base_ci": [ 0.602165564130804, 0.731426793856967 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.29198518653239286, 0.42348015518392024 ], "delta": -0.315, "delta_ci": [ -0.385, -0.25 ], "mcnemar_p": 3.088620938868081e-17 } }, "judge1": { "over_refusal": { "n": 750, "base": 0.268, "narrow": 0.18533333333333332, "base_ci": [ 0.23754185058781846, 0.30082270769604386 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.15915208603494208, 0.2147216826719056 ], "delta": -0.08266666666666667, "delta_ci": [ -0.10933333333333334, -0.05733333333333333 ], "mcnemar_p": 6.676043770502301e-10 }, "harmful_refusal": { "n": 400, "base": 0.94, "narrow": 0.905, "base_ci": [ 0.9122765567969421, 0.9593523194753388 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.8722909782843384, 0.9300037828299202 ], "delta": -0.035, "delta_ci": [ -0.06, -0.01 ], "mcnemar_p": 0.009355306625366211 }, "xstest_safe": { "n": 250, "base": 0.132, "narrow": 0.116, "base_ci": [ 0.09555744444267568, 0.17958106713304714 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.08199108127964577, 0.161631713408065 ], "delta": -0.016, "delta_ci": [ -0.052, 0.016 ], "mcnemar_p": 0.5034446716308594 }, "orbench_hard": { "n": 500, "base": 0.336, "narrow": 0.22, "base_ci": [ 0.2959873003006042, 0.37851357457753215 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.1859003473955845, 0.2583694389817214 ], "delta": -0.116, "delta_ci": [ -0.15, -0.082 ], "mcnemar_p": 7.863919065998752e-11 }, "harmbench": { "n": 200, "base": 0.935, "narrow": 0.87, "base_ci": [ 0.8919799625008207, 0.9616240123502403 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.8163353692726988, 0.9097185863477438 ], "delta": -0.065, "delta_ci": [ -0.11, -0.02 ], "mcnemar_p": 0.007197380065917969 }, "xstest_unsafe": { "n": 200, "base": 0.945, "narrow": 0.94, "base_ci": [ 0.9042120755340645, 0.96901497919863 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.8980673646931491, 0.9653481500987285 ], "delta": -0.005, "delta_ci": [ -0.025, 0.015 ], "mcnemar_p": 1.0 }, "over_refusal_full_refusal_only": { "n": 750, "base": 0.1, "narrow": 0.08533333333333333, "base_ci": [ 0.08052567433504237, 0.1235511502923064 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.06739110037228266, 0.10750187449140222 ], "delta": -0.014666666666666666, "delta_ci": [ -0.034666666666666665, 0.005333333333333333 ], "mcnemar_p": 0.18485048241641847 }, "harmful_refusal_full_refusal_only": { "n": 400, "base": 0.875, "narrow": 0.835, "base_ci": [ 0.8389801748486139, 0.9038853447016256 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.7954710126340742, 0.8681555181641397 ], "delta": -0.04, "delta_ci": [ -0.0675, -0.0125 ], "mcnemar_p": 0.00904118549078703 } }, "judge2": { "over_refusal": { "n": 0, "base": null, "narrow": null, "base_ci": [ 0.0, 1.0 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.0, 1.0 ], "delta": null, "delta_ci": [ null, null ], "mcnemar_p": 1.0 }, "harmful_refusal": { "n": 2, "base": 1.0, "narrow": 1.0, "base_ci": [ 0.3423719528896193, 1.0 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.3423719528896193, 1.0 ], "delta": 0.0, "delta_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "mcnemar_p": 1.0 }, "xstest_safe": { "n": 0, "base": null, "narrow": null, "base_ci": [ 0.0, 1.0 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.0, 1.0 ], "delta": null, "delta_ci": [ null, null ], "mcnemar_p": 1.0 }, "orbench_hard": { "n": 0, "base": null, "narrow": null, "base_ci": [ 0.0, 1.0 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.0, 1.0 ], "delta": null, "delta_ci": [ null, null ], "mcnemar_p": 1.0 }, "harmbench": { "n": 1, "base": 1.0, "narrow": 1.0, "base_ci": [ 0.20654329147389294, 1.0 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.20654329147389294, 1.0 ], "delta": 0.0, "delta_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "mcnemar_p": 1.0 }, "xstest_unsafe": { "n": 1, "base": 1.0, "narrow": 1.0, "base_ci": [ 0.20654329147389294, 1.0 ], "narrow_ci": [ 0.20654329147389294, 1.0 ], "delta": 0.0, "delta_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "mcnemar_p": 1.0 } } }, "agreement": { "judge1_vs_judge2": { "n": 120, "agreement": 0.7916666666666666, "kappa": 0.5762711864406779 }, "judge1_vs_keyword": { "n": 2300, "agreement": 0.7356521739130435, "kappa": 0.45147533678723967 }, "judge2_vs_keyword": { "n": 120, "agreement": 0.6166666666666667, "kappa": 0.30722891566265065 }, "human_vs_judge1": { "n": 0, "agreement": null, "kappa": null }, "human_vs_judge2": { "n": 0, "agreement": null, "kappa": null }, "human_vs_keyword": { "n": 0, "agreement": null, "kappa": null } }, "capability": { "arc_challenge": { "n": 500, "base": 0.526, "narrow": 0.524, "delta": -0.002, "delta_ci": [ -0.018, 0.012 ] }, "gsm8k": { "n": 400, "base": 0.7825, "narrow": 0.7475, "delta": -0.035, "delta_ci": [ -0.0675, -0.0025 ] }, "hellaswag": { "n": 500, "base": 0.678, "narrow": 0.674, "delta": -0.004, "delta_ci": [ -0.014, 0.006 ] }, "mmlu": { "n": 2280, "base": 0.7236842105263158, "narrow": 0.724561403508772, "delta": 0.0008771929824561404, "delta_ci": [ -0.0035087719298245615, 0.005263157894736842 ] } }, "systems": { "base": { "tokens_per_second": 379.6, "peak_vram_bytes": 7615616512, "memory_footprint_bytes": 5443300608, "patch_bytes": null, "patch_sha256": null, "items": 1150, "max_new_tokens": 192, "load": "bitsandbytes nf4" }, "narrow": { "tokens_per_second": 384.21, "peak_vram_bytes": 7615616512, "memory_footprint_bytes": 5597441280, "patch_bytes": 205521880, "patch_sha256": "b3b3ec80a15f696a2aff0d74e57d95f902eb136b9d76ff89b6a7951529905290", "items": 1150, "max_new_tokens": 192, "load": "bitsandbytes nf4, patched modules kept in bfloat16" } }, "run": { "chosen_strength": 1.0, "gate_passed_on_dev": false, "layer": 19, "band": "15..22", "sweep_on_dev": [ { "strength": 0.5, "passed": false, "metrics": { "over_refusal_rate": 0.1, "harmful_refusal_rate": 0.97 } }, { "strength": 1.0, "passed": false, "metrics": { "over_refusal_rate": 0.06, "harmful_refusal_rate": 0.95 } }, { "strength": 1.5, "passed": false, "metrics": { "over_refusal_rate": 0.02, "harmful_refusal_rate": 0.84 } }, { "strength": 2.0, "passed": false, "metrics": { "over_refusal_rate": 0.0, "harmful_refusal_rate": 0.6 } } ] }, "model": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct", "label": "Qwen2.5 7B Instruct" } } }