AntonioJun commited on
Commit
1a4ba5a
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 1e6cfcc

code backup: analysis

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. analysis/preregistration.md +17 -1
analysis/preregistration.md CHANGED
@@ -93,10 +93,26 @@ All corruption arms run the extended protocol on ground-truth codes (chimera arm
93
  use both code sources by construction). The solver runs every arm as the zero-cost
94
  second reasoner.
95
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
96
  ## Analysis plan
97
 
98
  Every cross-harness delta: exact question-id intersection (analysis.compare), scene-
99
- clustered paired bootstrap with fixed seed (analysis.stats), 95% CIs. The primary
 
 
 
 
 
 
100
  family (H7, H21-H26) is Holm-Bonferroni corrected; supporting and exploratory results
101
  are reported with CIs but no corrected significance claims. Aggregate category scores
102
  use only the real, unmodified official VSI-Bench aggregator.
 
93
  use both code sources by construction). The solver runs every arm as the zero-cost
94
  second reasoner.
95
 
96
+ ## Robustness arm (scheduled)
97
+
98
+ Two single-surface-factor B re-runs on the corruption sample, qwen3.5-4b, extended
99
+ protocol, explicit format: (a) the paraphrased context line
100
+ (harness.B.prompts.PARAPHRASE_PRE_PROMPT), (b) YAML serialization of the identical
101
+ code dict (--serialization yaml; the context line's "JSON" wording swaps to "YAML"
102
+ automatically so no false description rides along). Prediction: B's headline effects
103
+ survive both -- a material change under either is reported as prompt-artifact
104
+ evidence.
105
+
106
  ## Analysis plan
107
 
108
  Every cross-harness delta: exact question-id intersection (analysis.compare), scene-
109
+ clustered paired bootstrap with fixed seed (analysis.stats), 95% CIs. H21's
110
+ prediction test compares the corruption curve against B RESTRICTED TO THE SAME
111
+ pre-registered sample question ids (a filter over B's full-run records) -- never
112
+ against B's full-benchmark aggregate, whose category mix differs from the balanced
113
+ sample. H6's conflict-question sets are built from the _perturbation.json sidecars
114
+ the single-object runs write per scene (the perturbed object's identity is also
115
+ recomputable from the frozen seed via corruption.run.single_object_info). The primary
116
  family (H7, H21-H26) is Holm-Bonferroni corrected; supporting and exploratory results
117
  are reported with CIs but no corrected significance claims. Aggregate category scores
118
  use only the real, unmodified official VSI-Bench aggregator.