Beicicc's picture
ProbeShift reproducibility bundle: code + results + paper + figures
592942b verified
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
7.91 kB
"""A-priori, label-free probe-stability predictors evaluated by ProbeShift (G2).
Every predictor maps IID training activations (+ labels, + optional augmentation
activations) to a scalar where **higher = predicted more OOD-stable**, so all can be
correlated against (negated) OOD drop under one convention. All are computed WITHOUT any
OOD data and WITHOUT new annotation, except `whitened_cosine_upper` which is flagged as an
OOD-using upper-bound reference (Truthfulness-Spectrum style).
Implemented (each a verified competitor — see PRIOR_ART.md §四):
sip_eigengap SIP (2511.16288) — LDA eigengap / Fisher error
raptor_stability RAPTOR (2602.00158) — bootstrap direction mean|cos| (= dispersion)
fragility Fragility (2606.11375) — critical isotropic-noise collapse sigma
augmentation_robustness Probing-the-Probes — direction consistency under augmentation
xie_feature_dispersion Xie 2023 (2303.15488) — inter-class feature dispersion
pac ours (G3) — composite of dispersion + augmentation
whitened_cosine_upper Truth-Spectrum style — ID/OOD-whitened cosine (upper-bound ref)
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import numpy as np
from scipy import linalg
from config import STABILITY
from probes import make_probe
from metrics import accuracy
from stability_score import dispersion, augmentation_consistency, combine
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# SIP — spectral identifiability (eigengap of the task-relevant LDA subspace)
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
def sip_eigengap(X: np.ndarray, y: np.ndarray, num_labels: int, ridge: float = 1e-3, **_):
X = np.asarray(X, dtype=np.float64)
classes = np.unique(y)
mu = X.mean(0)
Sb = np.zeros((X.shape[1], X.shape[1]))
Sw = np.zeros_like(Sb)
for c in classes:
Xc = X[y == c]
d = (Xc.mean(0) - mu)[:, None]
Sb += len(Xc) * (d @ d.T)
Sw += np.cov(Xc, rowvar=False) * (len(Xc) - 1)
Sw += ridge * np.eye(X.shape[1])
# generalised eigenvalues of (Sb, Sw); top (num_labels-1) span the relevant subspace
eig = np.sort(linalg.eigvalsh(Sb, Sw))[::-1]
k = max(1, num_labels - 1)
if len(eig) <= k:
return float("nan")
gap = eig[k - 1] - eig[k] # gap after the relevant subspace
fisher_err = np.sqrt(X.shape[1] / len(X)) # ~ estimation error scale
return float(gap / (eig[0] + 1e-12) / (fisher_err + 1e-12))
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# RAPTOR-style directional stability == 1 - dispersion
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
def raptor_stability(X, y, num_labels, probe_kind="logreg", seed=0, **kw):
disp = dispersion(np.asarray(X, np.float32), np.asarray(y), num_labels,
probe_kind=probe_kind, k=STABILITY.k_bootstrap, seed=seed, **kw)
return float(1.0 - disp)
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Fragility — critical isotropic-noise collapse level
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
def fragility(X, y, num_labels, probe_kind="logreg", seed=0,
sigmas=(0.0, 0.25, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 3.0), **kw):
X = np.asarray(X, dtype=np.float32)
rng = np.random.default_rng(seed)
p = make_probe(probe_kind, num_labels=num_labels, seed=seed, **kw).fit(X, y)
iid_acc = accuracy(y, p.predict(X))
chance = 1.0 / num_labels
thresh = chance + 0.5 * (iid_acc - chance) # halfway from chance to IID
scale = X.std()
critical = sigmas[-1]
for s in sigmas:
Xn = X + s * scale * rng.standard_normal(X.shape).astype(np.float32)
if accuracy(y, p.predict(Xn)) < thresh:
critical = s
break
return float(critical) # higher = more robust = more stable
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# augmentation-robustness == augmentation_consistency component
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
def augmentation_robustness(X, y, aug_X_list, num_labels, probe_kind="logreg", seed=0, **kw):
return float(augmentation_consistency(
np.asarray(X, np.float32), np.asarray(y), [np.asarray(a, np.float32) for a in aug_X_list],
num_labels, probe_kind=probe_kind, seed=seed, **kw))
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Xie 2023 — inter-class feature dispersion (predicts overall acc, mechanism contrast)
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
def xie_feature_dispersion(X, y, num_labels, **_):
X = np.asarray(X, dtype=np.float64)
classes = np.unique(y)
mus = np.stack([X[y == c].mean(0) for c in classes]) # [C,H]
inter = np.mean([np.linalg.norm(mus[i] - mus[j])
for i in range(len(mus)) for j in range(i + 1, len(mus))])
return float(inter / (X.std() + 1e-12))
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# PAC (ours, G3) — composite of dispersion + augmentation-consistency (IID-only)
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
def pac(X, y, aug_X_list, num_labels, probe_kind="logreg", seed=0, **kw):
disp = dispersion(np.asarray(X, np.float32), np.asarray(y), num_labels,
probe_kind=probe_kind, k=STABILITY.k_bootstrap, seed=seed, **kw)
aug = augmentation_consistency(
np.asarray(X, np.float32), np.asarray(y),
[np.asarray(a, np.float32) for a in aug_X_list], num_labels,
probe_kind=probe_kind, seed=seed, **kw)
return float(combine(disp, aug, STABILITY))
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Whitened-cosine upper bound (Truth-Spectrum style) — uses covariance; flagged.
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
def whitened_cosine_upper(X, y, num_labels, probe_kind="logreg", seed=0, cov=None, **kw):
"""If `cov` (e.g. OOD covariance) is supplied, this becomes the OOD-using upper bound;
with cov=None it whitens by ID covariance (the metric-ablation variant)."""
X = np.asarray(X, dtype=np.float64)
C = np.cov(X, rowvar=False) if cov is None else np.asarray(cov, np.float64)
C += 1e-3 * np.eye(C.shape[0])
W = linalg.fractional_matrix_power(C, -0.5).real
return raptor_stability((X @ W).astype(np.float32), y, num_labels,
probe_kind=probe_kind, seed=seed, **kw)
# Registry: name -> (callable, needs_aug). All are higher = more stable.
PREDICTORS = {
"sip_eigengap": (sip_eigengap, False),
"raptor_stability": (raptor_stability, False),
"fragility": (fragility, False),
"augmentation_robustness": (augmentation_robustness, True),
"xie_feature_dispersion": (xie_feature_dispersion, False),
"pac": (pac, True),
"whitened_cosine_id": (whitened_cosine_upper, False),
}
def compute_all(X_iid, y_iid, aug_X_list, num_labels, probe_kind="logreg", seed=0) -> dict:
out = {}
for name, (fn, needs_aug) in PREDICTORS.items():
try:
out[name] = fn(X_iid, y_iid, aug_X_list, num_labels, probe_kind=probe_kind, seed=seed) \
if needs_aug else fn(X_iid, y_iid, num_labels, probe_kind=probe_kind, seed=seed)
except Exception as e: # keep the grid going; record the failure
out[name] = float("nan")
out[name + "__error"] = str(e)
return out