"""Tier-1 re-analysis of cached results (no GPU, no refitting): reads results/*.jsonl and produces the breakdowns the paper needs. Safe to run alongside / after the grid. python analyze.py shift # per shift-type predictor ranking (paraphrase/domain/length) python analyze.py estimator # cross-estimator: do logreg-based predictors predict mass-mean rotation? python analyze.py fidelity # label-fidelity (NLI flip-rate) summary per dataset python analyze.py all """ from __future__ import annotations import sys import numpy as np import metrics from config import DATASETS from baselines import PREDICTORS from run_pipeline import _rot_mag, _mean_ood_drop, _read_results, _rank_predictors def _pred_index(preds): return {(p["model"], p["dataset"], p["seed"]): p["predictors"] for p in preds} def shift_breakdown(): evals = _read_results("eval") pidx = _pred_index(_read_results("predictors")) print("\n########## SHIFT-TYPE BREAKDOWN (rotation target per shift) ##########") for shift in ["paraphrase", "domain", "length"]: rows = [] for e in evals: if e.get("probe") != "logreg": continue key = (e["model"], e["dataset"], e["seed"]) if key not in pidx: continue mag = _rot_mag(e.get("dists", {}).get(shift, {}).get("rotation")) if mag != mag: continue rows.append({"concept": DATASETS[e["dataset"]].concept, "rot": mag, **pidx[key]}) if len(rows) < 8: print(f"\n[{shift}] only {len(rows)} configs — skipped") continue _rank_predictors(rows, "rot", f"rotation under {shift.upper()} (n={len(rows)})") def estimator_cross(): """Do logreg-derived predictors also forecast the MASS-MEAN probe's rotation? (S2 external validity).""" evals = _read_results("eval") pidx = _pred_index(_read_results("predictors")) print("\n########## ESTIMATOR EXTERNAL VALIDITY (predict mass-mean rotation) ##########") rows = [] for e in evals: if e.get("probe") != "mass_mean": continue key = (e["model"], e["dataset"], e["seed"]) if key not in pidx: continue rots = [_rot_mag(v.get("rotation")) for d, v in e.get("dists", {}).items() if d != "iid"] rots = [r for r in rots if r == r] if not rots: continue rows.append({"concept": DATASETS[e["dataset"]].concept, "rot": float(np.mean(rots)), **pidx[key]}) if len(rows) < 8: print(f"only {len(rows)} configs — skipped") return _rank_predictors(rows, "rot", f"mass-mean rotation (n={len(rows)})") def size_ladder(): """Tier 3: does predictability of rotation / excess change with model size? (C4 / inverse-scaling check). Per model, correlate key predictors vs paraphrase rotation and vs excess rotation across its (dataset x seed) configs. """ from config import MODELS evals = _read_results("eval") pidx = _pred_index(_read_results("predictors")) keypreds = ["raptor_stability", "augmentation_robustness", "pac"] # build per-model rows of (predictors, para_rot, excess) by_model = {} for e in evals: if e.get("probe") != "logreg": continue key = (e["model"], e["dataset"], e["seed"]) if key not in pidx: continue para = _rot_mag(e.get("dists", {}).get("paraphrase", {}).get("rotation")) iids = _rot_mag(e.get("iid_split_rotation")) if para != para: continue excess = para - iids if iids == iids else float("nan") by_model.setdefault(e["model"], []).append({"para": para, "excess": excess, **pidx[key]}) print("\n########## SIZE-LADDER: predictability vs model size ##########") print(f"{'model':16s}{'params_M':>9s} | rho(predictor, target) for para-rot / excess") for m in sorted(by_model, key=lambda x: MODELS[x].params_m if x in MODELS else 0): rows = by_model[m] pm = MODELS[m].params_m if m in MODELS else 0 cells = [] for tgt in ("para", "excess"): y = np.array([r[tgt] for r in rows], dtype=float) for kp in keypreds: s = np.array([r.get(kp, np.nan) for r in rows], dtype=float) ok = ~(np.isnan(s) | np.isnan(y)) rho = metrics.spearman(s[ok], -y[ok])[0] if ok.sum() >= 6 else float("nan") cells.append(f"{kp.split('_')[0][:4]}:{rho:+.2f}") cells.append("|") print(f"{m:16s}{pm:>9.0f} | {' '.join(cells)}") print("(target order: para-rot [raptor aug pac] | excess [raptor aug pac])") def _partial_spearman(x, y, z): """Partial Spearman of (x,y) controlling for z: rank-transform then residualise on z.""" from scipy.stats import rankdata ok = ~(np.isnan(x) | np.isnan(y) | np.isnan(z)) x, y, z = x[ok], y[ok], z[ok] if len(x) < 8: return float("nan"), 0 rx, ry, rz = rankdata(x), rankdata(y), rankdata(z) Z = np.c_[np.ones_like(rz), rz] res = lambda a: a - Z @ np.linalg.lstsq(Z, a, rcond=None)[0] ex, ey = res(rx), res(ry) return float(np.corrcoef(ex, ey)[0, 1]), len(x) def robust_circularity(): """Reviewer rebuttal (R2 difference-score artefact, R1 pseudo-replication): (a) PARTIAL Spearman of (signal, paraphrase-rotation | placebo) — does a signal predict shift-rotation BEYOND the sampling-noise floor, without the naive-minus-placebo subtraction? (b) CLUSTER bootstrap (resampling CONCEPTS, not cells) for Δρ[aug−raptor] on excess. """ evals = _read_results("eval") pidx = _pred_index(_read_results("predictors")) rows = [] for e in evals: if e.get("probe") != "logreg": continue k = (e["model"], e["dataset"], e["seed"]) if k not in pidx: continue para = _rot_mag(e.get("dists", {}).get("paraphrase", {}).get("rotation")) plac = _rot_mag(e.get("iid_split_rotation")) if para != para or plac != plac: continue rows.append({"concept": DATASETS[e["dataset"]].concept, "para": para, "plac": plac, "excess": para - plac, **pidx[k]}) print("\n########## ROBUST CIRCULARITY CHECK (reviewer R1/R2 rebuttal) ##########") print("PARTIAL Spearman rho(signal, paraphrase-rot | placebo) [the artefact-free version]") print(f"{'predictor':26s}{'partial-rho':>12s}{'naive-rho':>11s}{'excess-rho':>11s}") para = np.array([r["para"] for r in rows]); plac = np.array([r["plac"] for r in rows]) exc = np.array([r["excess"] for r in rows]) for name in PREDICTORS: s = np.array([r.get(name, np.nan) for r in rows], float) pr, n = _partial_spearman(s, para, plac) nr = metrics.spearman(s[~np.isnan(s)], -para[~np.isnan(s)])[0] if (~np.isnan(s)).sum() >= 8 else float("nan") er = metrics.spearman(s[~np.isnan(s)], -exc[~np.isnan(s)])[0] if (~np.isnan(s)).sum() >= 8 else float("nan") print(f"{name:26s}{-pr:>12.3f}{nr:>11.3f}{er:>11.3f}") print("(partial-rho>0 => signal predicts shift-rotation beyond the sampling floor, non-circular," " no difference-score subtraction)") # cluster bootstrap by concept for Delta rho[aug - raptor] on excess concepts = np.array([r["concept"] for r in rows]) uc = list(np.unique(concepts)) sa = np.array([r.get("augmentation_robustness", np.nan) for r in rows], float) sb = np.array([r.get("raptor_stability", np.nan) for r in rows], float) rng = np.random.default_rng(0) def drho(mask): m = mask & ~(np.isnan(sa) | np.isnan(sb) | np.isnan(exc)) if m.sum() < 8: return np.nan return metrics.spearman(sa[m], -exc[m])[0] - metrics.spearman(sb[m], -exc[m])[0] base = drho(np.ones(len(rows), bool)) boots = [] for _ in range(2000): pick = rng.choice(uc, len(uc), replace=True) mask = np.isin(concepts, pick) # build resampled arrays by concept blocks idx = np.concatenate([np.where(concepts == c)[0] for c in pick]) m = ~(np.isnan(sa[idx]) | np.isnan(sb[idx]) | np.isnan(exc[idx])) if m.sum() >= 8: boots.append(metrics.spearman(sa[idx][m], -exc[idx][m])[0] - metrics.spearman(sb[idx][m], -exc[idx][m])[0]) lo, hi = np.percentile(boots, [2.5, 97.5]) sig = "SIGNIFICANT" if lo > 0 else "n.s." print(f"\nCLUSTER bootstrap (resample {len(uc)} CONCEPTS): Δρ[aug−raptor] on EXCESS = {base:+.3f}" f" 95%CI [{lo:+.3f},{hi:+.3f}] -> {sig}") print("(this is the pseudo-replication-corrected version of the headline paired test)") def fidelity_summary(): audit = _read_results("audit") print("\n########## LABEL-FIDELITY (NLI flip-rate of paraphrase shift) ##########") by_ds = {} for a in audit: by_ds.setdefault(a["dataset"], []).append(a.get("flip_rate", float("nan"))) print(f"{'dataset':18s}{'mean flip-rate':>16s}{'pass-rate':>12s}") for ds in sorted(by_ds): fr = float(np.nanmean(by_ds[ds])) print(f"{ds:18s}{fr:>16.3f}{1 - fr:>12.3f}") allfr = [v for vs in by_ds.values() for v in vs if v == v] if allfr: print(f"{'OVERALL':18s}{np.mean(allfr):>16.3f}{1 - np.mean(allfr):>12.3f}") if __name__ == "__main__": mode = sys.argv[1] if len(sys.argv) > 1 else "all" if mode in ("shift", "all"): shift_breakdown() if mode in ("estimator", "all"): estimator_cross() if mode in ("size", "all"): size_ladder() if mode in ("robust", "all"): robust_circularity() if mode in ("fidelity", "all"): fidelity_summary()