BurnyCoder's picture
Update website data
3d89fac verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
33.7 kB
{
"task.n_train": {
"value": 3830,
"fmt": "int"
},
"task.n_test": {
"value": 8939,
"fmt": "int"
},
"model.n_params": {
"value": 226816,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.key_freqs": {
"value": [
14,
35,
41,
42,
52
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"paper.t1": {
"value": 1567,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.t2": {
"value": 9301,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.t3": {
"value": 14001,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.t_grok": {
"value": 10601,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.restricted_drop_step": {
"value": 8101,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.test_drop_step": {
"value": 9701,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.loss40k_test": {
"value": 3.020125351316832e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R1": {
"value": 2.4122036965068944e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R2": {
"value": [
14,
35,
41,
42,
52
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R3": {
"value": 6,
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R4": {
"value": 0.005517078026515645,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R5": {
"value": 433,
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R6": {
"value": 44,
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R7": {
"value": 0.9635024080877127,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R8a": {
"value": 0.9613936842607974,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R8b": {
"value": 4.395112268126091e-08,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R9a": {
"value": 7.236198885132666e-08,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R9b": {
"value": 2.3766781750970298e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R9c": {
"value": 4.803951687362972,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R10a": {
"value": 2.482283676047179e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R10b": {
"value": 1.1212911021588694e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R11a": {
"value": 8.877300462328061e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R11b": {
"value": 7.24762972238341e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R11c": {
"value": 24.265471858863485,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R11d": {
"value": 1.0857271391194963,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R12": {
"value": [
0.00441777946420025,
0.001110644391768238,
0.004426720978782286,
0.001176727781378655
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R13a": {
"value": 0.9755725703445727,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R13b": {
"value": 2.1243161764958313e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R14": {
"value": [
35,
42,
52,
42
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R16": {
"value": [
0.00028202131589974145,
0.000633184287549272,
0.0016104677273914593,
0.07195004405297278,
0.032879199431613555
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R17": {
"value": [
44,
93,
145,
87,
64,
79
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R18": {
"value": [
0.9658959216089269,
0.8493635482282237
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R19a": {
"value": 5.547423110818639e-08,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"rc.R19b": {
"value": [
2.482283676047179e-07,
1.1790889481140824e-06
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R15": {
"value": [
3372.6148721243153,
2001.321472415883,
995.4816327816668
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R20a": {
"value": [
955.4492306368651,
941.8498192688169
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rc.R20b": {
"value": [
[
0.00441777946420025,
0.001110644391768238,
0.004426720978782286,
0.001176727781378655
],
[
0.11331604747965958,
0.0008201511074644619,
0.09146357488130168,
0.0008718142579934113
]
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"rchecks.rows": {
"value": [
{
"id": "R1",
"quantity": "loss at epoch 40k (all 12,769 pairs, 113-way)",
"paper": 2.41e-07,
"ours": 2.4122036965068944e-07,
"match": true,
"source": "p.6\u20137",
"note": "The paper calls it test loss; it matches the all-pairs loss (test-only is 3.02e-7)."
},
{
"id": "R2",
"quantity": "key frequencies",
"paper": [
14,
35,
41,
42,
52
],
"ours": [
14,
35,
41,
42,
52
],
"match": true,
"source": "p.4",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R3",
"quantity": "non-negligible W_E frequencies",
"paper": 6,
"ours": 6,
"match": true,
"source": "p.4",
"note": "threshold 10 % of max; the 6th is k=31"
},
{
"id": "R4",
"quantity": "W_L residual after 10-direction approximation",
"paper": "<0.55 %",
"ours": 0.005517078026515645,
"match": true,
"source": "p.6",
"note": "norm ratio 0.0743; the paper's '<0.55 %' matches the squared-norm ratio"
},
{
"id": "R5",
"quantity": "neurons with >85 % FVE at one frequency",
"paper": 433,
"ours": 433,
"match": true,
"source": "p.6",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R6",
"quantity": "neurons in the k=14 cluster",
"paper": 44,
"ours": 44,
"match": true,
"source": "p.7",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R7",
"quantity": "Table 1 FVE of u_k/v_k read-offs (mean of 10)",
"paper": 0.9624,
"ours": 0.9635024080877127,
"match": true,
"source": "p.6 Table 1",
"note": "paper's ten values average 96.24 %; per-row values in details.table1"
},
{
"id": "R8a",
"quantity": "logit fit \u03a3\u03b1_k cos(w_k(a+b\u2212c)) FVE",
"paper": 0.95,
"ours": 0.9613936842607974,
"match": true,
"source": "p.6",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R8b",
"quantity": "loss of the fitted logits",
"paper": 4.7e-08,
"ours": 4.395112268126091e-08,
"match": true,
"source": "p.6",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R9a",
"quantity": "loss keeping only the 40 key 2D components",
"paper": 7.24e-08,
"ours": 7.236198885132666e-08,
"match": true,
"source": "p.7",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R9b",
"quantity": "MLP projected onto 10 W_L directions",
"paper": 1.19e-07,
"ours": 2.3766781750970298e-07,
"match": false,
"source": "p.8",
"note": "closest variant shown; all variants in details.wl_projection"
},
{
"id": "R9c",
"quantity": "MLP projected onto the nullspace",
"paper": 5.27,
"ours": 4.803951687362972,
"match": false,
"source": "p.8",
"note": "closest variant (MLP-only, bias-corrected) shown"
},
{
"id": "R10a",
"quantity": "clustered neurons replaced by degree-2 polynomial",
"paper": 2.48e-07,
"ours": 2.482283676047179e-07,
"match": true,
"source": "p.7",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R10b",
"quantity": "neurons restricted to cos/sin(w_k(a+b)) terms",
"paper": 5.54e-08,
"ours": 1.1212911021588694e-07,
"match": false,
"source": "p.7",
"note": "per-neuron restriction gives this value; the paper's 5.54e-8 equals the restricted-LOGITS loss (R19a), so the paper likely restricted logits"
},
{
"id": "R11a",
"quantity": "MLP skip connection zero-ablated",
"paper": 9.12e-07,
"ours": 8.877300462328061e-07,
"match": true,
"source": "p.13",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R11b",
"quantity": "MLP skip connection mean-ablated",
"paper": 7.25e-07,
"ours": 7.24762972238341e-07,
"match": true,
"source": "p.13",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R11c",
"quantity": "attention heads zero-ablated",
"paper": 24.3,
"ours": 24.265471858863485,
"match": true,
"source": "p.13",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R11d",
"quantity": "skip around attention zero-ablated",
"paper": 19.1,
"ours": 1.0857271391194963,
"match": false,
"source": "p.13",
"note": "not reproduced: our ablation sets resid_mid = attention output (the paper does not specify its hook)"
},
{
"id": "R12",
"quantity": "mean attention from '=' to '=' (per head)",
"paper": "0.1\u20130.4 %",
"ours": [
0.00441777946420025,
0.001110644391768238,
0.004426720978782286,
0.001176727781378655
],
"match": true,
"source": "p.13",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R13a",
"quantity": "linear fit of the attention softmax (variance explained)",
"paper": 0.975,
"ours": 0.9755725703445727,
"match": true,
"source": "p.16",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R13b",
"quantity": "loss with softmax replaced by its linear fit",
"paper": 2.12e-07,
"ours": 2.1243161764958313e-07,
"match": true,
"source": "p.16",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R14",
"quantity": "head frequencies (Table 2)",
"paper": [
35,
42,
52,
42
],
"ours": [
35,
42,
52,
42
],
"match": true,
"source": "p.15 Table 2",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R16",
"quantity": "ARENA excluded loss per key freq",
"paper": [
0.000282,
0.000633,
0.00161,
0.07195,
0.03288
],
"ours": [
0.00028202131589974145,
0.000633184287549272,
0.0016104677273914593,
0.07195004405297278,
0.032879199431613555
],
"match": true,
"source": "ARENA tests.test_excl_loss",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R17",
"quantity": "ARENA cluster sizes 14/35/41/42/52/always",
"paper": [
44,
93,
145,
87,
64,
79
],
"ours": [
44,
93,
145,
87,
64,
79
],
"match": true,
"source": "ARENA 2-circuit-and-feature-analysis",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R18",
"quantity": "ARENA ReLU regression r\u00b2 (with / without quadratic)",
"paper": [
0.966,
0.849
],
"ours": [
0.9658959216089269,
0.8493635482282237
],
"match": true,
"source": "ARENA",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R19a",
"quantity": "ARENA trig-only (restricted) logits loss",
"paper": 5.5474e-08,
"ours": 5.547423110818639e-08,
"match": true,
"source": "ARENA",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R19b",
"quantity": "ARENA key-frequency neuron projection loss (with / without always-firing)",
"paper": [
2.482e-07,
1.179e-06
],
"ours": [
2.482283676047179e-07,
1.1790889481140824e-06
],
"match": true,
"source": "ARENA",
"note": ""
},
{
"id": "R15",
"quantity": "SSW at the paper's phase boundaries 1.4k / 9.4k / 14k (Fig. 7)",
"paper": "falls; steepest in cleanup",
"ours": [
3372.6148721243153,
2001.321472415883,
995.4816327816668
],
"match": true,
"source": "p.9 Fig. 7",
"note": "qualitative; fall per step 0.171 (circuit formation) vs 0.219 (cleanup)"
},
{
"id": "R20a",
"quantity": "total SSW at epoch 40k and at the end of training",
"paper": [
955,
942
],
"ours": [
955.4492306368651,
941.8498192688169
],
"match": true,
"source": "ARENA bonus (training dynamics)",
"note": "last checkpoint: step 49901"
},
{
"id": "R20b",
"quantity": "heads attending to '=' again after ~43k (attention at 40k \u2192 45k)",
"paper": "2 heads",
"ours": [
[
0.00441777946420025,
0.001110644391768238,
0.004426720978782286,
0.001176727781378655
],
[
0.11331604747965958,
0.0008201511074644619,
0.09146357488130168,
0.0008718142579934113
]
],
"match": true,
"source": "ARENA bonus (training dynamics)",
"note": "2 heads rise \u22655\u00d7 to >5 %"
}
],
"fmt": "str"
},
"rchecks.n_rows": {
"value": 30,
"fmt": "int"
},
"rchecks.n_match": {
"value": 26,
"fmt": "int"
},
"rchecks.n_miss": {
"value": 4,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.attn_eq_pct": {
"value": "0.44 %, 0.11 %, 0.44 %, 0.12 %",
"fmt": "str"
},
"paper.attn_eq_45k": {
"value": "11.3 %, 0.1 %, 9.1 %, 0.1 %",
"fmt": "str"
},
"paper.pos_norm0": {
"value": 0.1249291261500958,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.pos_norm1": {
"value": 0.12339678026142388,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.pos_norm2": {
"value": 2.7570561254253096,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.we_norm_mean": {
"value": 1.1777175285710453,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.pos_cos01": {
"value": 0.6173164425628147,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.we_top6": {
"value": [
14,
31,
35,
41,
42,
52
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"paper.gini_we": {
"value": 0.7356851086774049,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.gini_we_init": {
"value": 0.03520597622481869,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.cluster_sizes": {
"value": "k = 14: 44, k = 35: 93, k = 41: 145, k = 42: 87, k = 52: 64",
"fmt": "str"
},
"paper.always_firing": {
"value": 79,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.neurons_085": {
"value": 433,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.table1_fve_mean": {
"value": 0.9635024080877127,
"fmt": "pct"
},
"paper.table1_fve_range": {
"value": "93.2\u201398.2 %",
"fmt": "str"
},
"paper.head_freqs": {
"value": [
35,
42,
52,
42
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"paper.linear_fve": {
"value": 0.9755725703445727,
"fmt": "pct"
},
"paper.linearised_loss": {
"value": 2.1243161764958313e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"paper.logit_fve": {
"value": 0.9613936842607974,
"fmt": "pct"
},
"paper.logit_fit_loss": {
"value": 4.395112268126091e-08,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"paper.logit_alpha": {
"value": [
5.87,
5.96,
5.94,
9.6,
8.96
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"paper.wl_resid_sq": {
"value": 0.005517078026515645,
"fmt": "pct"
},
"paper.wl_resid_norm": {
"value": 0.07427703566053,
"fmt": "pct"
},
"paper.key_ablation_ratio_range": {
"value": "4,315\u00d7 to 315,210\u00d7",
"fmt": "str"
},
"paper.nonkey_ablation_max_ratio": {
"value": "1.09\u00d7",
"fmt": "str"
},
"paper.only_key_kept": {
"value": 7.236198885132666e-08,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"paper.all_key_removed": {
"value": 6.399452137925104,
"fmt": ".1f"
},
"paper.random5_min": {
"value": 1.84309785157996e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"paper.random5_max": {
"value": 2.654067974937735e-07,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"paper.patch_key": {
"value": 0.9970471900304149,
"fmt": ".3f"
},
"paper.patch_key_lo": {
"value": 0.9944736099408823,
"fmt": ".3f"
},
"paper.patch_key_hi": {
"value": 0.9995747144662669,
"fmt": ".3f"
},
"paper.patch_random": {
"value": 0.06151412756702074,
"fmt": ".3f"
},
"paper.patch_complement": {
"value": 0.0024557092225769156,
"fmt": ".3f"
},
"paper.relu_r2_full": {
"value": 0.9658959216089269,
"fmt": ".3f"
},
"paper.relu_r2_lin": {
"value": 0.8493635482282237,
"fmt": ".3f"
},
"paper.restricted_5k": {
"value": 1.4035709211453171,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.excluded_t1": {
"value": 6.937301958475235e-05,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"paper.excluded_t2": {
"value": 8.102498306019667,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.ssw_peak": {
"value": 3658.414966760416,
"fmt": ",.0f"
},
"paper.ssw_peak_step": {
"value": 901,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.ssw_t3": {
"value": 995.4816327816668,
"fmt": ",.0f"
},
"paper.mid_step": {
"value": 5401,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.cos_tt_start": {
"value": 0.7983190945708337,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.cos_tt_mid": {
"value": -0.2687966264579594,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.cos_tt_40k": {
"value": 0.3259630355783611,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"paper.cos_gw_40k": {
"value": -0.9958547424943925,
"fmt": ".3f"
},
"hypotheses.verdict": {
"value": {
"H1": {
"successes": 11,
"n": 11,
"p": 0.00048828125,
"threshold": 0.0125,
"p_holm": 0.001953125,
"reject": true,
"supported": true
},
"H2": {
"successes": 11,
"n": 11,
"p": 0.00048828125,
"threshold": 0.016666666666666666,
"p_holm": 0.001953125,
"reject": true,
"supported": true
},
"H3": {
"successes": 11,
"n": 11,
"p": 0.00048828125,
"threshold": 0.025,
"p_holm": 0.001953125,
"reject": true,
"supported": true
},
"H4": {
"successes": 6,
"n": 11,
"p": 0.5,
"threshold": 0.05,
"p_holm": 0.5,
"reject": false,
"supported": false
},
"H5": {
"wd1_grokked": 11,
"wd1_n": 11,
"wd0_grokked": 0,
"wd0_n": 5,
"p": 0.00022893772893772894,
"threshold": 0.01,
"p_holm": 0.0011446886446886447,
"reject": true,
"supported": true
}
},
"fmt": "json"
},
"hypotheses.per_run": {
"value": {
"wd1_s0": {
"t1": 1561,
"t2": 9600,
"t_test_drop": 9900,
"t_restricted_drop": 8300,
"H1_delta": 1600,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 133422.90012575238,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 3911.8713662378464,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.0695375593306105,
"H4_keep_ratio": 0.19081884445148678,
"H4_ok": true,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s1": {
"t1": 1562,
"t2": 9600,
"t_test_drop": 9900,
"t_restricted_drop": 9000,
"H1_delta": 900,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 487227.24491970486,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 5.919525368096768,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.2795748452213564,
"H4_keep_ratio": 0.9064272092642571,
"H4_ok": false,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s10": {
"t1": 1570,
"t2": 6900,
"t_test_drop": 7200,
"t_restricted_drop": 5600,
"H1_delta": 1600,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 5294.346184481961,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 55348.88413434843,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.8375855871722213,
"H4_keep_ratio": 1.6383775694485083,
"H4_ok": false,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s2": {
"t1": 1597,
"t2": 3900,
"t_test_drop": 4000,
"t_restricted_drop": 3200,
"H1_delta": 800,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 12.610611017222835,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 5629.935356981427,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.0456136537134881,
"H4_keep_ratio": 0.3438592821721323,
"H4_ok": true,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s3": {
"t1": 1572,
"t2": 7400,
"t_test_drop": 7600,
"t_restricted_drop": 6300,
"H1_delta": 1300,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 100729.20374910862,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 135041.84807155145,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.1289923795332457,
"H4_keep_ratio": 0.3939088107617958,
"H4_ok": true,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s4": {
"t1": 1578,
"t2": 6500,
"t_test_drop": 6700,
"t_restricted_drop": 5900,
"H1_delta": 800,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 48523.38152053423,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 233329.39489534724,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.0600557335131036,
"H4_keep_ratio": 2.7831531079973093,
"H4_ok": false,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s5": {
"t1": 1570,
"t2": 9200,
"t_test_drop": 9500,
"t_restricted_drop": 8600,
"H1_delta": 900,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 726130.5229599801,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 158531.33590537417,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.0019895504332275,
"H4_keep_ratio": 0.4024025850681291,
"H4_ok": true,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s6": {
"t1": 1563,
"t2": 9800,
"t_test_drop": 10000,
"t_restricted_drop": 8700,
"H1_delta": 1300,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 789449.3381529738,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 29046.77081513179,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.1539969996518311,
"H4_keep_ratio": 0.15613157793682142,
"H4_ok": true,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s7": {
"t1": 1586,
"t2": 4900,
"t_test_drop": 5100,
"t_restricted_drop": 3800,
"H1_delta": 1300,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 38.70196512870858,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 629.6312411320996,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.039661908031676,
"H4_keep_ratio": 0.2638522229523373,
"H4_ok": true,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s8": {
"t1": 1576,
"t2": 9900,
"t_test_drop": 10200,
"t_restricted_drop": 8100,
"H1_delta": 2100,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 115292.22117710457,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 70.38414300424814,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.0088093259749362,
"H4_keep_ratio": 0.062192467621088474,
"H4_ok": false,
"grokked": true
},
"wd1_s9": {
"t1": 1604,
"t2": 4200,
"t_test_drop": 4300,
"t_restricted_drop": 3600,
"H1_delta": 700,
"H1_ok": true,
"H2_ratio": 548.1522873825262,
"H2_ok": true,
"H3_ok": true,
"H4_key_min_ratio": 5390557.73212924,
"H4_nonkey_max_ratio": 1.0426553815128075,
"H4_keep_ratio": 1.9856414334462698,
"H4_ok": false,
"grokked": true
}
},
"fmt": "json"
},
"hypotheses.controls": {
"value": {
"rand_s0": {
"group": "rand",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 0.008837677592571876,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 4.755813121795654,
"gini_we": 0.08614800802331168,
"gini_wl": 0.07524616099906378,
"gini_we_init": 0.03520597620118737,
"gini_wl_init": 0.034458793437783575,
"key_freqs": [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41,
42,
43,
44,
45,
46,
47,
48,
49,
50,
51,
52,
53,
54,
55,
56
]
},
"rand_s1": {
"group": "rand",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 0.008725808255957042,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 4.758819103240967,
"gini_we": 0.09138536328613667,
"gini_wl": 0.08376880125503894,
"gini_we_init": 0.03690570460990228,
"gini_wl_init": 0.0394419735478444,
"key_freqs": [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41,
42,
43,
44,
45,
46,
47,
48,
49,
50,
51,
52,
53,
54,
55,
56
]
},
"rand_s2": {
"group": "rand",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 0.00839020024611254,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 4.7436909675598145,
"gini_we": 0.07908244383064023,
"gini_wl": 0.07851805262319544,
"gini_we_init": 0.03567157378568453,
"gini_wl_init": 0.03831196672783832,
"key_freqs": [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41,
42,
43,
44,
45,
46,
47,
48,
49,
50,
51,
52,
53,
54,
55,
56
]
},
"split0_init100": {
"group": "split0",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 1.0,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 5.4674201011657715,
"gini_we": 0.6843425266877394,
"gini_wl": 0.772677703796671,
"gini_we_init": 0.03364421530886319,
"gini_wl_init": 0.03756925070132966,
"key_freqs": [
2,
14,
27,
30,
37,
52
]
},
"split0_init101": {
"group": "split0",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 1.0,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 4.769634246826172,
"gini_we": 0.7163510545296281,
"gini_wl": 0.8394175536208605,
"gini_we_init": 0.03142269495076455,
"gini_wl_init": 0.03752133393165913,
"key_freqs": [
9,
14,
15,
27
]
},
"split0_init102": {
"group": "split0",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 1.0,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 8.831543922424316,
"gini_we": 0.6264363501729125,
"gini_wl": 0.7448949412925703,
"gini_we_init": 0.03426876954972058,
"gini_wl_init": 0.03456259085687319,
"key_freqs": [
7,
38,
49,
53
]
},
"wd0_s0": {
"group": "wd0",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 0.06007383376216579,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 4.755288600921631,
"gini_we": 0.06744272514642702,
"gini_wl": 0.07103440522393945,
"gini_we_init": 0.03520597620118737,
"gini_wl_init": 0.034458793437783575,
"key_freqs": [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41,
42,
43,
44,
45,
46,
47,
48,
49,
50,
51,
52,
53,
54,
55,
56
]
},
"wd0_s1": {
"group": "wd0",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 0.018794048551292093,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 4.769203186035156,
"gini_we": 0.06705836888349725,
"gini_wl": 0.07760427065954956,
"gini_we_init": 0.03690570460990228,
"gini_wl_init": 0.0394419735478444,
"key_freqs": [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41,
42,
43,
44,
45,
46,
47,
48,
49,
50,
51,
52,
53,
54,
55,
56
]
},
"wd0_s2": {
"group": "wd0",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 0.08099339970913973,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 4.748889446258545,
"gini_we": 0.07759488727957886,
"gini_wl": 0.0967013544851727,
"gini_we_init": 0.03567157378568453,
"gini_wl_init": 0.03831196672783832,
"key_freqs": [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41,
42,
43,
44,
45,
46,
47,
48,
49,
50,
51,
52,
53,
54,
55,
56
]
},
"wd0_s3": {
"group": "wd0",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 0.21467725696386622,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 4.761351108551025,
"gini_we": 0.07121806854142942,
"gini_wl": 0.08866172623669799,
"gini_we_init": 0.032033777395853,
"gini_wl_init": 0.04248594606512257,
"key_freqs": [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41,
42,
43,
44,
45,
46,
47,
48,
49,
50,
51,
52,
53,
54,
55,
56
]
},
"wd0_s4": {
"group": "wd0",
"final_train_acc": 1.0,
"final_test_acc": 0.16187493008166462,
"max_excluded_loss_K_free_peak": 4.763060092926025,
"gini_we": 0.07394684094968496,
"gini_wl": 0.08642104428458652,
"gini_we_init": 0.03394181242552419,
"gini_wl_init": 0.04096392429269691,
"key_freqs": [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41,
42,
43,
44,
45,
46,
47,
48,
49,
50,
51,
52,
53,
54,
55,
56
]
}
},
"fmt": "json"
},
"seeds.t1_ci": {
"value": "1,576 [1,567, 1,586]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.t2_ci": {
"value": "7,445 [5,874, 9,017]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.tgrok_ci": {
"value": "8,455 [6,816, 10,093]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.nkey_ci": {
"value": "4.364 [3.743, 4.985]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.neurons085_ci": {
"value": "80.2 % [75.3 %, 85.2 %]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.logitfve_ci": {
"value": "96.5 % [95.3 %, 97.7 %]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.patch_key_ci": {
"value": "0.997 [0.995, 0.998]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.patch_random_ci": {
"value": "0.058 [0.049, 0.067]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"hyp.summary": {
"value": "**H1** supported (11/11 seeds; Holm-adjusted p = 0.002); **H2** supported (11/11 seeds; Holm-adjusted p = 0.002); **H3** supported (11/11 seeds; Holm-adjusted p = 0.002); **H4** not supported (6/11 seeds; Holm-adjusted p = 0.5); **H5** supported (11/11 weight-decay runs vs 0/5 without grokked; Holm-adjusted p = 0.0011).",
"fmt": "str"
},
"hyp.h4_key_ok": {
"value": "9/11",
"fmt": "str"
},
"hyp.h4_nonkey_ok": {
"value": "11/11",
"fmt": "str"
},
"hyp.h4_keep_ok": {
"value": "8/11",
"fmt": "str"
},
"hyp.h4_key_min": {
"value": 5.919525368096768,
"fmt": ".1f"
},
"hyp.h4_nonkey_max": {
"value": 1.8375855871722213,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"hyp.h4_keep_max": {
"value": 2.7831531079973093,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"controls.wd0": {
"value": "final train accuracy 100 %, 100 %, 100 %, 100 %, 100 %, final test accuracy 6.0 %, 1.9 %, 8.1 %, 21.5 %, 16.2 %; Gini of the embedding spectrum 0.07, 0.07, 0.08, 0.07, 0.07 (initially \u2248 0.03)",
"fmt": "str"
},
"controls.rand": {
"value": "final train accuracy 100 %, 100 %, 100 %, final test accuracy 0.9 %, 0.9 %, 0.8 %; Gini of the embedding spectrum 0.09, 0.09, 0.08 (initially \u2248 0.04)",
"fmt": "str"
},
"controls.split0": {
"value": "final test accuracy 100.0 %, 100.0 %, 100.0 %; key frequencies split0_init100: [2, 14, 27, 30, 37, 52]; split0_init101: [9, 14, 15, 27]; split0_init102: [7, 38, 49, 53] (the paper's run: {14, 35, 41, 42, 52})",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.same_init_diff": {
"value": 2.9802322387695312e-08,
"fmt": "sci"
},
"seeds.same_init_cos40k": {
"value": 0.7352586156787267,
"fmt": ".2f"
},
"seeds.same_init_keys": {
"value": [
14,
35,
41,
42,
52
],
"fmt": "g"
},
"seeds.same_init_keys_equal": {
"value": "the same",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.same_init_loss_steps": {
"value": 52,
"fmt": "int"
},
"seeds.spikes": {
"value": "split0_init102 (6 spikes; test loss up to 0.64, test accuracy down to 87 %); wd1_s4 (4 spikes; test loss up to 0.25, test accuracy down to 93 %)",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.spike_n": {
"value": 2,
"fmt": "int"
},
"paper.neuron_linear_share": {
"value": 0.7618141461388657,
"fmt": "pct"
},
"paper.logit_linear_share": {
"value": 0.009948816856354528,
"fmt": "pct"
},
"paper.logit_key_product_share": {
"value": 0.9696048452014524,
"fmt": "pct"
},
"seeds.adam_ratio_end_ci": {
"value": "0.992 [0.972, 1.004]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.adam_cos_w_end_ci": {
"value": "-0.991 [-1.000, -0.976]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.cos_gw_end_ci": {
"value": "-0.814 [-0.965, -0.625]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.cos_tt_mid_ci": {
"value": "-0.251 [-0.305, -0.199]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.cos_tt_neg_ci": {
"value": "97.9 % [96.0 %, 99.6 %]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.dynamics_n": {
"value": 11,
"fmt": "int"
},
"seeds.cos_gw_end_range": {
"value": "-0.996 to -0.157",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.adam_dip_ci": {
"value": "0.906 [0.897, 0.914]",
"fmt": "str"
},
"seeds.adam_dip_near_grok": {
"value": "10 of 11",
"fmt": "str"
}
}