| scenario_id,scenario_text,claim,label | |
| train_001,"A delivery route was optimized for shortest distance, but drivers now miss time windows during peak traffic.","The system shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_002,"A delivery route was optimized for shorter distance and still meets all time windows.","The system shows over-optimization.",0 | |
| train_003,"A model was tuned to maximize benchmark score, but performance dropped on real user prompts.","The system shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_004,"A model improved benchmark score and real user prompt performance also improved.","The system shows over-optimization.",0 | |
| train_005,"A warehouse minimized staffing costs so tightly that one absence now causes shipment failure.","The system shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_006,"A warehouse reduced staffing costs while preserving backup cover and shipment reliability.","The system shows over-optimization.",0 | |
| train_007,"A clinic maximized appointment volume by removing buffer time, causing delays after one complex case.","The clinic shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_008,"A clinic increased appointment volume while preserving buffer time for complex cases.","The clinic shows over-optimization.",0 | |
| train_009,"A server configuration maximized throughput but left no capacity for traffic spikes.","The server shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_010,"A server configuration improved throughput while preserving surge capacity.","The server shows over-optimization.",0 | |
| train_011,"A project plan removed all slack to meet the earliest possible deadline.","The project shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_012,"A project plan improved delivery time while preserving contingency buffer.","The project shows over-optimization.",0 | |
| train_013,"A finance team minimized cash reserves to improve reported capital use, then struggled with one delayed payment.","The organization shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_014,"A finance team improved capital use while preserving adequate reserves.","The organization shows over-optimization.",0 | |
| train_015,"A machine was tuned for maximum output and now overheats under normal variation.","The machine shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_016,"A machine increased output after cooling capacity was improved.","The machine shows over-optimization.",0 | |
| train_017,"A support team reduced average call time by scripting every response, but complex cases now escalate more often.","The support system shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_018,"A support team reduced average call time while complex-case resolution stayed stable.","The support system shows over-optimization.",0 | |
| train_019,"A school optimized test scores by teaching only likely exam items, and broader understanding declined.","The school shows over-optimization.",1 | |
| train_020,"A school improved test scores while broader assessment results stayed strong.","The school shows over-optimization.",0 |