review
stringlengths
5
16.6k
score
stringclasses
5 values
area
stringclasses
12 values
text
stringlengths
31
5.65k
This paper looks at the approximation capabilities of a DBN with 2 layers in which the first layer is a has binary states (both hidden and visible) and the second layer has continuous visible state. Further, it is assumed that the conditional distributions for the last layer all come from the same parental distribution...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper looks at the approximation capabilities of a DBN with 2 layers in which the first layer is a has binary states (both hidden and visible) and the second layer has continuous visible state. Further, it is assumed that the conditional distributions for the last layer all come from the same parental dist...
This submission analyzes and extends previous invariant risk minimization (IRM) formulations to a multi-objective optimization scheme, named as PAreto Invariant Risk minimization (PAIR) for finding models generalizing well and with good OOD performance. The authors motivated the work by analyzing how IRM may fail to ac...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This submission analyzes and extends previous invariant risk minimization (IRM) formulations to a multi-objective optimization scheme, named as PAreto Invariant Risk minimization (PAIR) for finding models generalizing well and with good OOD performance. The authors motivated the work by analyzing how IRM may fa...
This paper claims that it proves that fairness and trustworthy are undecidable for binary classification. The authors frame this as a first-order logic problem to guide their proof. I am not entirely sure what the point of this paper is, unfortunately. The introduction makes claims about fairness and trustworthiness no...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper claims that it proves that fairness and trustworthy are undecidable for binary classification. The authors frame this as a first-order logic problem to guide their proof. I am not entirely sure what the point of this paper is, unfortunately. The introduction makes claims about fairness and trustworth...
This paper proposes a method to narrow the performance gap between SGD with momentum and AdamW when evaluating on the downstream tasks. The authors find that for the models where AdamW outperforms SGD, the gradients of the first layer are much larger than the gradients of the other layers. Therefore, they try to freeze...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a method to narrow the performance gap between SGD with momentum and AdamW when evaluating on the downstream tasks. The authors find that for the models where AdamW outperforms SGD, the gradients of the first layer are much larger than the gradients of the other layers. Therefore, they try t...
The paper proposes GReaT (Generation of Realistic Tabular Data), a large language model fine-tuned to generate samples for tabular datasets. First, GReaT encodes examples in a tabular dataset into sequences of text, then GReaT fine tunes a large pretrained language model using the textual representation of the tabular ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Generative models
Review: The paper proposes GReaT (Generation of Realistic Tabular Data), a large language model fine-tuned to generate samples for tabular datasets. First, GReaT encodes examples in a tabular dataset into sequences of text, then GReaT fine tunes a large pretrained language model using the textual representation of the ...
The paper proposes a new algorithm named FOSTER for out-of-distribution (OoD) detection in the federated setting. Since there may be no OoD sample in the federated setting, the paper proposes to use samples from the other classes that do not exist in the current client as OoD samples for local training. Since the raw d...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes a new algorithm named FOSTER for out-of-distribution (OoD) detection in the federated setting. Since there may be no OoD sample in the federated setting, the paper proposes to use samples from the other classes that do not exist in the current client as OoD samples for local training. Since t...
This paper proposes a novel method for continuous unconstrained black-box optimization problems, called Optformer. It is claimed that the Optformer is inspired by the similarity between Transformer and EA. Six simple benchmark functions and a real-world problem are used to verify the performance of Optformer. In genera...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a novel method for continuous unconstrained black-box optimization problems, called Optformer. It is claimed that the Optformer is inspired by the similarity between Transformer and EA. Six simple benchmark functions and a real-world problem are used to verify the performance of Optformer. I...
This paper presents a novel method for zero-shot multi-label classification where the model is trained on seen classes and tested on unseen classes without further model tuning. The strategy uses min-max zer-sum game between the maximizer and the minimizer with minimum cost graph cuts. The proposed method has four add...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper presents a novel method for zero-shot multi-label classification where the model is trained on seen classes and tested on unseen classes without further model tuning. The strategy uses min-max zer-sum game between the maximizer and the minimizer with minimum cost graph cuts. The proposed method has ...
This paper examines the perspective of interpreting masked language models (MLMs) as a generative model, where the unmasking procedure corresponds to predicting unary conditionals. The paper notes that the different unmasked tokens are predicted in a conditionally independent way, and focuses previous attempts that ins...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper examines the perspective of interpreting masked language models (MLMs) as a generative model, where the unmasking procedure corresponds to predicting unary conditionals. The paper notes that the different unmasked tokens are predicted in a conditionally independent way, and focuses previous attempts ...
- This works address two majors challenges in continual learning: catastrophic forgetting and knowledge transfer (KT) across tasks applied to NLP tasks. - In doing so, the approach is based on sub-networks, and computes task similaity via gradients and mask importance where catastrophic forgetting is controlled using ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: - This works address two majors challenges in continual learning: catastrophic forgetting and knowledge transfer (KT) across tasks applied to NLP tasks. - In doing so, the approach is based on sub-networks, and computes task similaity via gradients and mask importance where catastrophic forgetting is controlle...
**Update after rebuttal** The authors added an important control experiment (fluid in-polarity) which shows that the main improvements result from transferring a favorable initial set of weights, whereas actually freezing the polarity (which is *the* main NI inspiration) has a a marginal effect (and it is conceivable t...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Neuroscience and Cognitive Science (e.g., neural coding, brain-computer interfaces)
Review: **Update after rebuttal** The authors added an important control experiment (fluid in-polarity) which shows that the main improvements result from transferring a favorable initial set of weights, whereas actually freezing the polarity (which is *the* main NI inspiration) has a a marginal effect (and it is conce...
This paper proposes a new keypoint representation learning method through novel losses inspired by information theory. One of the losses encourages the keypoints to represent the scene without information loss, and the other guides the keypoints to represent well the dynamics of the video through conditional entropy an...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This paper proposes a new keypoint representation learning method through novel losses inspired by information theory. One of the losses encourages the keypoints to represent the scene without information loss, and the other guides the keypoints to represent well the dynamics of the video through conditional en...
This paper addresses the generalization ability of language-instructed agents of gSCAN. Based on the Meta-Sequence-to-Sequence learning approach and meta-seq2seq architecture of Lake 2019, they issue the statistical action-bias of gSCAN split-H and extend the Meta-Sequence-to-Sequence learning approach to the specially...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper addresses the generalization ability of language-instructed agents of gSCAN. Based on the Meta-Sequence-to-Sequence learning approach and meta-seq2seq architecture of Lake 2019, they issue the statistical action-bias of gSCAN split-H and extend the Meta-Sequence-to-Sequence learning approach to the s...
In this paper, the authors present an energy saving approach that replaces dot product operations with an equivalent add-shift-add operation. In the context of neural networks with integer weights, the authors demonstrate how such a technique can save significant amounts of energy while controlling for the accuracy deg...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: In this paper, the authors present an energy saving approach that replaces dot product operations with an equivalent add-shift-add operation. In the context of neural networks with integer weights, the authors demonstrate how such a technique can save significant amounts of energy while controlling for the accu...
The authors introduce a new class of stochastic processes that they think of as a generalization of diffusion models to infinite-dimensional inputs. - **Strength:** Any attempt to mary the pragmatism, effectiveness and scalability of deep learning with the "principledness" of Bayesian nonparametrics is always laudabl...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: The authors introduce a new class of stochastic processes that they think of as a generalization of diffusion models to infinite-dimensional inputs. - **Strength:** Any attempt to mary the pragmatism, effectiveness and scalability of deep learning with the "principledness" of Bayesian nonparametrics is always...
Existing diffusion-based cross-modal generation methods mainly establish the cross-modal relationships by incorporating the cross-modal prior model into the variational lower bound of the diffusion model. However, the authors claim that this method may lead to the loss of the cross-modal correspondence in the denoising...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: Existing diffusion-based cross-modal generation methods mainly establish the cross-modal relationships by incorporating the cross-modal prior model into the variational lower bound of the diffusion model. However, the authors claim that this method may lead to the loss of the cross-modal correspondence in the d...
Authors build upon the mitigation of back-propagation and aim at reaching higher accuracies. They first highlight these limits of BP. They then make very strong claims about soft Hebb, an algorithm capable of notably learn in a self-supervised manner or without feedback signals. They evaluate their algorithms or standa...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Neuroscience and Cognitive Science (e.g., neural coding, brain-computer interfaces)
Review: Authors build upon the mitigation of back-propagation and aim at reaching higher accuracies. They first highlight these limits of BP. They then make very strong claims about soft Hebb, an algorithm capable of notably learn in a self-supervised manner or without feedback signals. They evaluate their algorithms o...
This paper proposes a straightforward hyper-parameter-free approach to embed discrete solvers as differentiable layers into neural networks. In detail, during the backward pass, the Jacobian $\frac{\partial y(\omega)}{\partial \omega}$ is simply treated as a negative identity matrix and a theoretical justification is p...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a straightforward hyper-parameter-free approach to embed discrete solvers as differentiable layers into neural networks. In detail, during the backward pass, the Jacobian $\frac{\partial y(\omega)}{\partial \omega}$ is simply treated as a negative identity matrix and a theoretical justificat...
This paper introduces a method (B-DISTILL) to distill an (expensive) trained model into an ensemble of weak learners. These learners are meant to provide efficient inference, with progressively better results as the ensemble size increases: this allows for a straightforward way to trade off accuracy and compute at infe...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper introduces a method (B-DISTILL) to distill an (expensive) trained model into an ensemble of weak learners. These learners are meant to provide efficient inference, with progressively better results as the ensemble size increases: this allows for a straightforward way to trade off accuracy and compute...
This paper proposes an animal-pose estimation method which can be applied to multiple animal species. Firstly the proposed method divides a set of animal keypoints into several groups. The keypoints in one group are supposed to have close relation, i.e. intra-group keypoints may provide a localization cue to each other...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes an animal-pose estimation method which can be applied to multiple animal species. Firstly the proposed method divides a set of animal keypoints into several groups. The keypoints in one group are supposed to have close relation, i.e. intra-group keypoints may provide a localization cue to ea...
This paper provides a representation view of latent variable models in linear MDPs, and further propose a computationally efficient algorithm to implement it for both online and offline RL. The authors also theoretically and empirically demonstrate the proposed approach. **Strength:** + The paper is well organised and...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper provides a representation view of latent variable models in linear MDPs, and further propose a computationally efficient algorithm to implement it for both online and offline RL. The authors also theoretically and empirically demonstrate the proposed approach. **Strength:** + The paper is well organ...
This paper targets the problem of Class-Incremental-Learning with two major contributions. First, the authors propose to evaluate previous methods with aligned memory budgets to fairly compare exampler-based and model-based approaches. Second, the authors conduct empirical observations on the effect of different layers...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper targets the problem of Class-Incremental-Learning with two major contributions. First, the authors propose to evaluate previous methods with aligned memory budgets to fairly compare exampler-based and model-based approaches. Second, the authors conduct empirical observations on the effect of differen...
The authors propose a more realistic multi-agent communication setup and provide a corresponding experimental environment. The authors also propose a corresponding learning framework based on MI to solve the corresponding communication problem, and the experiments show that their approach has significant advantages. St...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The authors propose a more realistic multi-agent communication setup and provide a corresponding experimental environment. The authors also propose a corresponding learning framework based on MI to solve the corresponding communication problem, and the experiments show that their approach has significant advant...
This work proposes an interactive segmentation framework that leverages a pre-trained ViT model to perform semi-supervised segmentation tasks on otherwise challenging images. Due to the nature of the proposed framework and ambiguity in evaluation for interactive segmentation framework, no baseline is provided or compar...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This work proposes an interactive segmentation framework that leverages a pre-trained ViT model to perform semi-supervised segmentation tasks on otherwise challenging images. Due to the nature of the proposed framework and ambiguity in evaluation for interactive segmentation framework, no baseline is provided o...
This work discusses how regularizing the representations of deep neural networks can help improve model generalization when the dataset is noisy. In particular, the authors first discuss how limiting the capacity of a neural network can help improve generalization in noisy data settings. This is achieved via the regula...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This work discusses how regularizing the representations of deep neural networks can help improve model generalization when the dataset is noisy. In particular, the authors first discuss how limiting the capacity of a neural network can help improve generalization in noisy data settings. This is achieved via th...
The submission proposed the hidden Markov based GPFR mixture model (HM-GPFR) by describing the time series data from the perspective of both fine and coarse level. The time series data at fine level is characterized by Gaussian process model and and that at coarse level is characterized by a hidden Markov process. To a...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: The submission proposed the hidden Markov based GPFR mixture model (HM-GPFR) by describing the time series data from the perspective of both fine and coarse level. The time series data at fine level is characterized by Gaussian process model and and that at coarse level is characterized by a hidden Markov proce...
This work conducts an analysis of expressive power of geometric graph neural networks. Analogous to WL test for generic GNNs, this work proposes Geometric WL (GWL) test and its constraint version IGWL for geometric graphs. It characterizes an expressive-power gap between GWL and IGWL, which is then accordingly extended...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This work conducts an analysis of expressive power of geometric graph neural networks. Analogous to WL test for generic GNNs, this work proposes Geometric WL (GWL) test and its constraint version IGWL for geometric graphs. It characterizes an expressive-power gap between GWL and IGWL, which is then accordingly ...
1. The paper tackles the problem of client drift (locally) in federated learning (FL) due to heterogeneous client data distributions. Besides, they target the period drift (globally), which is the inter-communication heterogeneity of data distributions. 2. They propose a learning based parameterized aggregator called F...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: 1. The paper tackles the problem of client drift (locally) in federated learning (FL) due to heterogeneous client data distributions. Besides, they target the period drift (globally), which is the inter-communication heterogeneity of data distributions. 2. They propose a learning based parameterized aggregator ...
In this paper authors proposed a variational information pursuit for interpretable classification model / estimation scheme. Authors idea is motivated by generative variant that they denote G-IP. Authors propose a complete framework with model defintions explanation of the training scheme and proof that loss does what ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: In this paper authors proposed a variational information pursuit for interpretable classification model / estimation scheme. Authors idea is motivated by generative variant that they denote G-IP. Authors propose a complete framework with model defintions explanation of the training scheme and proof that loss do...
This paper studies the problem of the heterogeneity of local data distributions in federated learning. The authors argued that the distribution overlaps are not consistent but scattered in local clients. They proposed to infer the local data manifolds to learn from the informative overlaps and estimate the data density...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper studies the problem of the heterogeneity of local data distributions in federated learning. The authors argued that the distribution overlaps are not consistent but scattered in local clients. They proposed to infer the local data manifolds to learn from the informative overlaps and estimate the data...
The paper proposes a new routing strategy, Routing Entropy Minimization (REM), for capsule networks. The core idea of REM is to minimize the entropy of capsule parse trees by pruning so that the activated connections between capsules are stronger and fewer, which will improve the interpretability of the capsule network...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes a new routing strategy, Routing Entropy Minimization (REM), for capsule networks. The core idea of REM is to minimize the entropy of capsule parse trees by pruning so that the activated connections between capsules are stronger and fewer, which will improve the interpretability of the capsule...
The paper proposes speculative decoding, a decoding scheme for conditional NLG that aims to achieve the quality of traditional autoregressive approaches while retaining the speedup improvements of non-autoregressive approaches. The proposed framework combines a non-autoregressive transformer (NAT) to generate "draft" s...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: The paper proposes speculative decoding, a decoding scheme for conditional NLG that aims to achieve the quality of traditional autoregressive approaches while retaining the speedup improvements of non-autoregressive approaches. The proposed framework combines a non-autoregressive transformer (NAT) to generate "...
This paper is about improving the expressivity of large scale probabilistic circuits (PCs). Finding a good starting point for EM based learning of these large latent variable models is problematic and the authors propose one such solution to this problem. The main idea is to obtain semantic-aware assignments (called s...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: This paper is about improving the expressivity of large scale probabilistic circuits (PCs). Finding a good starting point for EM based learning of these large latent variable models is problematic and the authors propose one such solution to this problem. The main idea is to obtain semantic-aware assignments (...
In order to train GNN efficiently on large graphs with a single machine and external storage, this paper proposes a locality-aware training scheme to reduce the data movement time. First, it partitions the graph using METIS. The main idea is to save a mega-batch, which is randomly sampled from partitions in the main me...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: In order to train GNN efficiently on large graphs with a single machine and external storage, this paper proposes a locality-aware training scheme to reduce the data movement time. First, it partitions the graph using METIS. The main idea is to save a mega-batch, which is randomly sampled from partitions in the...
The paper proposes MultiMix which is a variant of the Mixup data augmentation technique. While Mixup creates augmented data by only considering interpolation between two data points, MultiMix considers the interpolation between $m$ data samples. In greater detail, MultiMix creates $n$ new augmented samples from $m$ dat...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes MultiMix which is a variant of the Mixup data augmentation technique. While Mixup creates augmented data by only considering interpolation between two data points, MultiMix considers the interpolation between $m$ data samples. In greater detail, MultiMix creates $n$ new augmented samples from...
The paper start from an interesting empirical finding that a transformer trained with ERM outperforms CNN trained with domain generalization (DG) algorithms on DG task. They show some experiments and math to prove that. They propose a new GMoE and show its superiority on DG. The paper focus on an interesting aspect an...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper start from an interesting empirical finding that a transformer trained with ERM outperforms CNN trained with domain generalization (DG) algorithms on DG task. They show some experiments and math to prove that. They propose a new GMoE and show its superiority on DG. The paper focus on an interesting a...
The paper introduces an asymmetric loss called Softmax MSE to address the overestimation issue in value-based off-policy learning. Instead of taking a minimum of an ensemble of Q-functions, as was proposed in TD3, the authors propose penalizing overestimation in TD learning. # Strength 1. The idea is exciting and novel...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper introduces an asymmetric loss called Softmax MSE to address the overestimation issue in value-based off-policy learning. Instead of taking a minimum of an ensemble of Q-functions, as was proposed in TD3, the authors propose penalizing overestimation in TD learning. # Strength 1. The idea is exciting a...
The paper introduces Implicit Value Regularization (IVR) framework, provides some interesting theoretical results that might help better understand offline methods such as CQL and IQL, and then under this framework, a new offline RL method called Sparse Q-learning (SQL) is proposed. Empirical results from D4RL benchm...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper introduces Implicit Value Regularization (IVR) framework, provides some interesting theoretical results that might help better understand offline methods such as CQL and IQL, and then under this framework, a new offline RL method called Sparse Q-learning (SQL) is proposed. Empirical results from D4R...
This paper may most accurately be summarized as giving polynomial-time algorithms that obtain sublinear regret in linear contextual MDPs when the transition and Q-functions are linear in the state-action features and the context, and that only need to re-solve the MDP logarithmically many times w.r.t. the number of tas...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper may most accurately be summarized as giving polynomial-time algorithms that obtain sublinear regret in linear contextual MDPs when the transition and Q-functions are linear in the state-action features and the context, and that only need to re-solve the MDP logarithmically many times w.r.t. the numbe...
Test-time model adaptation updates model parameters during inference in order to reduce generalization error on shifted data. Continual test-time adaptation, the setting of this work, does so for varying shifts without knowledge of when the shift itself changes over time. The purpose of this work is to improve the effi...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: Test-time model adaptation updates model parameters during inference in order to reduce generalization error on shifted data. Continual test-time adaptation, the setting of this work, does so for varying shifts without knowledge of when the shift itself changes over time. The purpose of this work is to improve ...
This paper proposes to continue adapting the language model to new domains without forgetting the previous domains. The main method first calculates the important neurons based on general language knowledge. Then it uses a KL divergence loss to to continued adaptation to other tasks and domains. 1. the general ideal of...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This paper proposes to continue adapting the language model to new domains without forgetting the previous domains. The main method first calculates the important neurons based on general language knowledge. Then it uses a KL divergence loss to to continued adaptation to other tasks and domains. 1. the general ...
This paper presents an automatic learning approach for constructing training samples of data augmentation. For this purpose, a framework with three candidate operations is built and a grid search algorithm is used for finding the optimal Delta (for the intensity of DA). Experiments show limited accuracy gain on image c...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper presents an automatic learning approach for constructing training samples of data augmentation. For this purpose, a framework with three candidate operations is built and a grid search algorithm is used for finding the optimal Delta (for the intensity of DA). Experiments show limited accuracy gain on...
This paper compares three network architectures for multi-task learning. The experiment uses the MNIST dataset for two binary classification tasks. The authors categorized the output activation of each layer according to their input number to show their (un)correlation with the task. The authors also analyzed the struc...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper compares three network architectures for multi-task learning. The experiment uses the MNIST dataset for two binary classification tasks. The authors categorized the output activation of each layer according to their input number to show their (un)correlation with the task. The authors also analyzed t...
The paper explores the use of diffusion models for novel view synthesis. The authors introduce a geometry-free image-to-image model, dubbed X-UNet, based on a new stochastic conditioning sampling algorithm. They compare their work with state-of-the-art baselines on SRN ShapeNet dataset, apparently, achieving better qua...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Generative models
Review: The paper explores the use of diffusion models for novel view synthesis. The authors introduce a geometry-free image-to-image model, dubbed X-UNet, based on a new stochastic conditioning sampling algorithm. They compare their work with state-of-the-art baselines on SRN ShapeNet dataset, apparently, achieving be...
EDIT: I have upgraded my overall score (6 to 8), as well as my correctness score (2 to 4). This paper proposes the use of the bidirectional transformer BERT to model intracranial EEG (iEEG) recordings collected from human patients while watching movie stimuli. They transform the iEEG data into spectrograms and use an ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Neuroscience and Cognitive Science (e.g., neural coding, brain-computer interfaces)
Review: EDIT: I have upgraded my overall score (6 to 8), as well as my correctness score (2 to 4). This paper proposes the use of the bidirectional transformer BERT to model intracranial EEG (iEEG) recordings collected from human patients while watching movie stimuli. They transform the iEEG data into spectrograms and...
The paper "MULTIWAVE: MULTIRESOLUTION DEEP ARCHITECTURES THROUGH WAVELET DECOMPOSITION FOR MULTIVARIATE TIME SERIES FORECASTING AND PREDICTION" proposes to fuse time series data with different sampling rates via concatenation of transformed features at matching scales in the wavelet domain. After motivating and explain...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper "MULTIWAVE: MULTIRESOLUTION DEEP ARCHITECTURES THROUGH WAVELET DECOMPOSITION FOR MULTIVARIATE TIME SERIES FORECASTING AND PREDICTION" proposes to fuse time series data with different sampling rates via concatenation of transformed features at matching scales in the wavelet domain. After motivating and...
This paper illustrates a method for how to train a neural network to predict 3D conformers of small molecules starting from their 2D structures. Building on previous works such as CVGAE, the authors propose a few tweaks which are meant to improve the models’ performance: 1) use a single tensor to represent both atom an...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Generative models
Review: This paper illustrates a method for how to train a neural network to predict 3D conformers of small molecules starting from their 2D structures. Building on previous works such as CVGAE, the authors propose a few tweaks which are meant to improve the models’ performance: 1) use a single tensor to represent both...
The authors of this study make the crucial point that by understanding how variations in the underlying rewards impact optimal behavior, several discussed issues on imitation learning and inverse reinforcement learning may be resolved. This amount can be approximated locally by the Bellman score, which is the gradient ...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The authors of this study make the crucial point that by understanding how variations in the underlying rewards impact optimal behavior, several discussed issues on imitation learning and inverse reinforcement learning may be resolved. This amount can be approximated locally by the Bellman score, which is the g...
The paper applies SNNs to text dataset tasks. It proposes a method of converting a pre-trained standard ANN into an SNN. This improves on current methods by allowing the model to handle large vocabularies. (strengths) Well-written and organized. Extends viability of SNNs to large vocabularies. A wide array of examp...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: The paper applies SNNs to text dataset tasks. It proposes a method of converting a pre-trained standard ANN into an SNN. This improves on current methods by allowing the model to handle large vocabularies. (strengths) Well-written and organized. Extends viability of SNNs to large vocabularies. A wide array ...
This paper shows fine-tuning a (contiguous) subset of layers matches or outperforms commonly used fine-tuning approaches including full fine-tuning or fine-tuning the last few layers. The authors evaluated the performance of surgical fine-tuning diverse layers of choice on 7 different distribution shift scenarios (inpu...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper shows fine-tuning a (contiguous) subset of layers matches or outperforms commonly used fine-tuning approaches including full fine-tuning or fine-tuning the last few layers. The authors evaluated the performance of surgical fine-tuning diverse layers of choice on 7 different distribution shift scenari...
This paper proposes a framework for converting any non-Mini-Batch-Consistent (non-MBC) models to an MBC model. Specifically, for any non-MBC set function, $f^\star$, we can convert it to an MBC function by plugging in an MBC function before it. This framework also enables incorporating uncertainty estimation methods, s...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a framework for converting any non-Mini-Batch-Consistent (non-MBC) models to an MBC model. Specifically, for any non-MBC set function, $f^\star$, we can convert it to an MBC function by plugging in an MBC function before it. This framework also enables incorporating uncertainty estimation me...
The paper proposes an unsupervised skill discovery algorithm based on state clustering in a latent space. Specifically, assuming that exploratory data are given (either by an offline dataset or by a separate exploratory policy), their proposed method learns a latent world model and clusters the latent states into $N$ d...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper proposes an unsupervised skill discovery algorithm based on state clustering in a latent space. Specifically, assuming that exploratory data are given (either by an offline dataset or by a separate exploratory policy), their proposed method learns a latent world model and clusters the latent states in...
The paper proposes a text classification method that adds three regularization constraints. The first is a contrastive term between labeled samples depending on whether pairs of inputs have the same labels. The second is a consistency constraint using K-L divergency on back-translated transformation of the data samples...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: The paper proposes a text classification method that adds three regularization constraints. The first is a contrastive term between labeled samples depending on whether pairs of inputs have the same labels. The second is a consistency constraint using K-L divergency on back-translated transformation of the data...
This paper generalizes the classical multidimensional scaling approach for unsupervised manifold alignment. This enables the mapping of , datasets from two different domains, without requiring correspondences across the datasets, to a common low-dimensional Euclidean space. This approach generalizes approaches based o...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This paper generalizes the classical multidimensional scaling approach for unsupervised manifold alignment. This enables the mapping of , datasets from two different domains, without requiring correspondences across the datasets, to a common low-dimensional Euclidean space. This approach generalizes approaches...
This paper studies off-policy evaluation and learning, under unknown propensities, which is pretty common for most complicated systems. The paper proposes a novel Uncertainty-aware Inverse Propensity Score estimator, which builds upon the original IPS estimator by adding an additional weight to reflect the uncertainty ...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper studies off-policy evaluation and learning, under unknown propensities, which is pretty common for most complicated systems. The paper proposes a novel Uncertainty-aware Inverse Propensity Score estimator, which builds upon the original IPS estimator by adding an additional weight to reflect the unce...
This paper applied the sampling-importance resampling methods to offline learning to conduct in-sample learning. The methods in this paper fit well into the line of in-sample offline RL learning. Strength: The method is very clear and makes sense for in-sample offline learning. The paper contains several solid th...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper applied the sampling-importance resampling methods to offline learning to conduct in-sample learning. The methods in this paper fit well into the line of in-sample offline RL learning. Strength: The method is very clear and makes sense for in-sample offline learning. The paper contains several ...
This paper tackles the problem of how to design structural/topological augmentations for graphs, which can be used by graph contrastive learning. The authors aim to find a principled way for topology augmentations by exploring the invariance of graphs from the spectral perspective. This paper proposes to generate topol...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This paper tackles the problem of how to design structural/topological augmentations for graphs, which can be used by graph contrastive learning. The authors aim to find a principled way for topology augmentations by exploring the invariance of graphs from the spectral perspective. This paper proposes to genera...
This paper presents a semantic image synthesis method by generating edge as an intermediate state to guide the following generation. Meanwhile, a semantic preserving module is designed to selectively choose class-dependent feature maps. One contrastive learning strategy by considering different layout inputs is propose...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper presents a semantic image synthesis method by generating edge as an intermediate state to guide the following generation. Meanwhile, a semantic preserving module is designed to selectively choose class-dependent feature maps. One contrastive learning strategy by considering different layout inputs is...
This paper considers a multi-agent reinforcement learning setup and takes an information-theoretic approach to the joint policy gradient method. The first observation is that the joint policy gradient maximizes the mutual information (MI) between the agents -- an observation that follows by definition of MI. The author...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper considers a multi-agent reinforcement learning setup and takes an information-theoretic approach to the joint policy gradient method. The first observation is that the joint policy gradient maximizes the mutual information (MI) between the agents -- an observation that follows by definition of MI. Th...
This paper proposes a state-dependent causal learning framework for multivariate time series. The goal seems to learn a state-dependent causal graph between multivariate time series. Since causal structures can change dynamically in practice, the targeted task is practically useful if the state is automatically inferre...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: This paper proposes a state-dependent causal learning framework for multivariate time series. The goal seems to learn a state-dependent causal graph between multivariate time series. Since causal structures can change dynamically in practice, the targeted task is practically useful if the state is automatically...
This paper proposes a general module that alleviates the over-smoothing problem and allows the design of deep GNNs. The theoretical results are useful. Strength: - The paper proposes reasonably theoretical results. Weakness: - The proposed method is not well motivated. The paper shows that "However, it is reasonable t...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a general module that alleviates the over-smoothing problem and allows the design of deep GNNs. The theoretical results are useful. Strength: - The paper proposes reasonably theoretical results. Weakness: - The proposed method is not well motivated. The paper shows that "However, it is reas...
This paper formulates a very interesting and novel problem (IDA, induced domain adapatation) in transfer learning. Consider the supervised classification setting where one usually trains a classifier $h : X \mapsto Y$ from samples $\{(X, Y)\}$ drawn from some distribution $\sim \mathcal D$. Oftentimes, when the data a...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper formulates a very interesting and novel problem (IDA, induced domain adapatation) in transfer learning. Consider the supervised classification setting where one usually trains a classifier $h : X \mapsto Y$ from samples $\{(X, Y)\}$ drawn from some distribution $\sim \mathcal D$. Oftentimes, when th...
The paper proposes an efficient way of fine-tuning diffusion models on new datasets. Instead of training the entire network or training from scratch, the authors add a attention non-linear block which is the only learnable part which is learned during fine-tuning. The attention non-linear block is a cross attention lay...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Generative models
Review: The paper proposes an efficient way of fine-tuning diffusion models on new datasets. Instead of training the entire network or training from scratch, the authors add a attention non-linear block which is the only learnable part which is learned during fine-tuning. The attention non-linear block is a cross atten...
The authors propose an SNN model with one timestep only. The key to the model is the use of the Hoyer extremum as a spiking threshold. The Hoyer regularization is a technique previously used for DNN regularization. The proposed SNN corresponds to a DNN with binary activation functions. The backprop pipeline includes th...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Neuroscience and Cognitive Science (e.g., neural coding, brain-computer interfaces)
Review: The authors propose an SNN model with one timestep only. The key to the model is the use of the Hoyer extremum as a spiking threshold. The Hoyer regularization is a technique previously used for DNN regularization. The proposed SNN corresponds to a DNN with binary activation functions. The backprop pipeline inc...
In the paper, the author provided some theoretical and experimental results on the so-called "sum of logits" approximation of empirical neural tangent kernel (eNTK) having multiple output units. The proposed approach consists in approximating the eNTK by a block diagonal matrix as the Kronecker product between some pse...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: In the paper, the author provided some theoretical and experimental results on the so-called "sum of logits" approximation of empirical neural tangent kernel (eNTK) having multiple output units. The proposed approach consists in approximating the eNTK by a block diagonal matrix as the Kronecker product between ...
The authors propose to use stochastic orders, more precisely, the Choquet order, instead of the commonly used integral probability metrics, to provide a differentiable measurement of the distance between distributions. Then this Choquet order can be applied to probability density estimation. By applying the proposed Ch...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: The authors propose to use stochastic orders, more precisely, the Choquet order, instead of the commonly used integral probability metrics, to provide a differentiable measurement of the distance between distributions. Then this Choquet order can be applied to probability density estimation. By applying the pro...
This paper studies the question of whether neural collapse is solely dependent on the output labels as suggested in prior work, or if it still contains information about the input distribution. To answer this question, the authors train models on Cifar10 and Cifar100 using coarse-grained and fine-grained labels, and me...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper studies the question of whether neural collapse is solely dependent on the output labels as suggested in prior work, or if it still contains information about the input distribution. To answer this question, the authors train models on Cifar10 and Cifar100 using coarse-grained and fine-grained labels...
This paper focuses on the problem of learning the intensity functions for temporal point processes (TPP) to model the occurrence of events in irregular time intervals. Specifically, the authors consider the representation of the intensity functions as parameterized by an exponentiated weighted sum of kernels switched b...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: This paper focuses on the problem of learning the intensity functions for temporal point processes (TPP) to model the occurrence of events in irregular time intervals. Specifically, the authors consider the representation of the intensity functions as parameterized by an exponentiated weighted sum of kernels sw...
This paper explores the spurious correlation problem, a common problem in current LMs that learns dependency relations between two unconditional entities. The authors take "date", "place", and "gender" as examples and analyze the spurious correlation between gender and date (or place). The authors also provide an uncer...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: This paper explores the spurious correlation problem, a common problem in current LMs that learns dependency relations between two unconditional entities. The authors take "date", "place", and "gender" as examples and analyze the spurious correlation between gender and date (or place). The authors also provide ...
This paper proposes to address the transition mismatch problem in GCHRL using (1) more readily reusable abstract subgoals, and (2) manually injecting stochasticity into the low-level policy as a form of regularization. Both of these contributions are ultimately proposed to improve generalization on unseen tasks where t...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper proposes to address the transition mismatch problem in GCHRL using (1) more readily reusable abstract subgoals, and (2) manually injecting stochasticity into the low-level policy as a form of regularization. Both of these contributions are ultimately proposed to improve generalization on unseen tasks...
This paper proposes two privacy-preserved (i.e., DP Guaranteed) versions of existing offline RL algorithms (i.e., APVI and VAPVI) proposed in previous works . DP-APVI is for tabular settings and DP-VAPVI for the case with linear function approximation (under linear MDP assumption). The authors provide theoretical an...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper proposes two privacy-preserved (i.e., DP Guaranteed) versions of existing offline RL algorithms (i.e., APVI and VAPVI) proposed in previous works . DP-APVI is for tabular settings and DP-VAPVI for the case with linear function approximation (under linear MDP assumption). The authors provide theore...
This paper proposes conformal prediction method for multivariate multistep TS forecasting. ## Strength - develop more efficient conformal prediction method with the simple yet effective idea of Coupla. - clear motivation and idea - extensive experiments are done ## Weakness - multivariate parts that author claim to ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: This paper proposes conformal prediction method for multivariate multistep TS forecasting. ## Strength - develop more efficient conformal prediction method with the simple yet effective idea of Coupla. - clear motivation and idea - extensive experiments are done ## Weakness - multivariate parts that author c...
The paper derives upper and lower bounds on the excess risk of last iterate of SGD in small dimensions with "standard" step-size schedules. They provide two main results: a lower bound of $\Omega\left(\frac{\log{d}}{\sqrt{T}}\right)$ on excess risk for convex Lipschitz functions (which is also extended to strongly conv...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Optimization (eg, convex and non-convex optimization)
Review: The paper derives upper and lower bounds on the excess risk of last iterate of SGD in small dimensions with "standard" step-size schedules. They provide two main results: a lower bound of $\Omega\left(\frac{\log{d}}{\sqrt{T}}\right)$ on excess risk for convex Lipschitz functions (which is also extended to stron...
The paper proposes an approach using meta-learning to learn to weight multiple auxiliary losses for any given target task. They first define a space of auxiliary losses that contains popular self-supervised methods like BERT and XLNet as special cases. Then they propose to learn the weighting over a given space of such...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: The paper proposes an approach using meta-learning to learn to weight multiple auxiliary losses for any given target task. They first define a space of auxiliary losses that contains popular self-supervised methods like BERT and XLNet as special cases. Then they propose to learn the weighting over a given space...
**Update after rebuttal** After reading the other reviews and the authors' responses I remain in favor of accepting the paper. I think wPfU, jy1a raise some very valid issues, but some of the issues raised concern the viability of the approach/research field of mechanistic interpretability in general, rather than the c...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: **Update after rebuttal** After reading the other reviews and the authors' responses I remain in favor of accepting the paper. I think wPfU, jy1a raise some very valid issues, but some of the issues raised concern the viability of the approach/research field of mechanistic interpretability in general, rather th...
This paper presents an exploration of the combination of curriculum learning for on-line reinforcement learning problems by application to two related combinatoric optimization problems. Central to the approach is to solve for a mixture $w_m$ of MDP models called a "Latent Markov Decision Process (LMDP) (Kwon et al., ...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper presents an exploration of the combination of curriculum learning for on-line reinforcement learning problems by application to two related combinatoric optimization problems. Central to the approach is to solve for a mixture $w_m$ of MDP models called a "Latent Markov Decision Process (LMDP) (Kwon ...
This paper considers the fusion algorithm to aggregate different neural network models trained locally. The Wasserstein/Gromov-Wasserstein barycenter is the main technique used in the construction. Extensive numerical experiments demonstrate the good performance of the proposed fusion algorithm, and provide empirical e...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper considers the fusion algorithm to aggregate different neural network models trained locally. The Wasserstein/Gromov-Wasserstein barycenter is the main technique used in the construction. Extensive numerical experiments demonstrate the good performance of the proposed fusion algorithm, and provide emp...
This paper introduces TabMWP - a dataset containing open-domain grade-level problems that require mathematical reasoning on both textual and tabular data. It evaluates a number of models and methods on this dataset and finds that chain-of-thought prompting on GPT-3 is the strongest baseline. Inspired by the sensitivity...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper introduces TabMWP - a dataset containing open-domain grade-level problems that require mathematical reasoning on both textual and tabular data. It evaluates a number of models and methods on this dataset and finds that chain-of-thought prompting on GPT-3 is the strongest baseline. Inspired by the sen...
The authors propose a method to compute embeddings suitable for fast and exact prediction of shortest path distances in a large graph. Strengths: - the empirical results look promising Weaknesses - it is unclear how the training paths ('random sp walk') are constructed from the random walks - it remains unclear how th...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The authors propose a method to compute embeddings suitable for fast and exact prediction of shortest path distances in a large graph. Strengths: - the empirical results look promising Weaknesses - it is unclear how the training paths ('random sp walk') are constructed from the random walks - it remains unclea...
This paper examines behaviors of large language models in causal and moral judgment tasks drawn from cognitive science literature studying human judgments in these domains. They first test on simple cloze tasks using stories and prompts that human participants responded to, and identify model preferences for continuati...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Neuroscience and Cognitive Science (e.g., neural coding, brain-computer interfaces)
Review: This paper examines behaviors of large language models in causal and moral judgment tasks drawn from cognitive science literature studying human judgments in these domains. They first test on simple cloze tasks using stories and prompts that human participants responded to, and identify model preferences for co...
This paper proposes an approach to perform meta-learning without task boundaries. **Strengths** - the paper is globally clear and well writen - the topic is interesting to the ICLR community **Weaknesses** - absence of any theoretical justification I am puzzled with this submission as I cannot find anything to comment...
Recommendation: 1: strong reject
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes an approach to perform meta-learning without task boundaries. **Strengths** - the paper is globally clear and well writen - the topic is interesting to the ICLR community **Weaknesses** - absence of any theoretical justification I am puzzled with this submission as I cannot find anything to...
The paper proposes a brain-inspired algorithm for continual learning and disentangled representations. However, the contributions are generally not clear. The paper is somewhat well-written. The results may show the effectiveness of proposed method. Weakness: 1、 The connection between brain mechanisms such as thalam...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: The paper proposes a brain-inspired algorithm for continual learning and disentangled representations. However, the contributions are generally not clear. The paper is somewhat well-written. The results may show the effectiveness of proposed method. Weakness: 1、 The connection between brain mechanisms such a...
This paper studies the application of EigenGame formulation to solve the Generalized Eigenvalue Problem (GEPs). The previous work had defined the implementation $\alpha$ and $\mu$ - EigenGame, while this one defines the $\delta$- EigenGame version. EigenGame is a reduction of the problem to compute eigenvalues to the p...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Optimization (eg, convex and non-convex optimization)
Review: This paper studies the application of EigenGame formulation to solve the Generalized Eigenvalue Problem (GEPs). The previous work had defined the implementation $\alpha$ and $\mu$ - EigenGame, while this one defines the $\delta$- EigenGame version. EigenGame is a reduction of the problem to compute eigenvalues ...
The paper tackles the problem of limited availability of labelled datasets for reinforcement learning tasks. The paper proposes to circumvent this challenge by combining large but sparsely-annotated datasets from a target environment of interest (without densely annotated large scale datasets) with fully annotated data...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper tackles the problem of limited availability of labelled datasets for reinforcement learning tasks. The paper proposes to circumvent this challenge by combining large but sparsely-annotated datasets from a target environment of interest (without densely annotated large scale datasets) with fully annota...
In contrast to the computer vision (CV) domain where the first-order projected gradient descent (PGD) is used as the benchmark approach to generate adversarial examples for robustness evaluation, there lacks a principled first-order gradient-based robustness evaluation framework in NLP. To bridge the gap, this paper pr...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: In contrast to the computer vision (CV) domain where the first-order projected gradient descent (PGD) is used as the benchmark approach to generate adversarial examples for robustness evaluation, there lacks a principled first-order gradient-based robustness evaluation framework in NLP. To bridge the gap, this ...
The paper proposes a MAML-like approach for neural operators aimed at transferring learning across slightly varying physical systems. It builds on recent work on implicit Fourier neural operators and proposes a meta-learning method that uses MAML for the (first) lifting layer, while the remaining layers (including the ...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: The paper proposes a MAML-like approach for neural operators aimed at transferring learning across slightly varying physical systems. It builds on recent work on implicit Fourier neural operators and proposes a meta-learning method that uses MAML for the (first) lifting layer, while the remaining layers (includ...
This paper presents comparative studies on various facets of two widely used self-supervised learning methods - contrastive learning and masked image modeling. The studies show opposing properties of the two methods: image information (image-level vs. token-level), features representations (low- and high-frequency) and...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This paper presents comparative studies on various facets of two widely used self-supervised learning methods - contrastive learning and masked image modeling. The studies show opposing properties of the two methods: image information (image-level vs. token-level), features representations (low- and high-freque...
This paper proposes a new talking head generation method with memory compensation. The proposed method is novel with good experiment performances. The claimed implicitly scale condition is confusing, however, it could be addressed by editing the paper. Strength: - The proposed method is novel in terms of using the meta...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper proposes a new talking head generation method with memory compensation. The proposed method is novel with good experiment performances. The claimed implicitly scale condition is confusing, however, it could be addressed by editing the paper. Strength: - The proposed method is novel in terms of using ...
This paper introduces Time-Transformer AAE. The proposed method is an adversarial autoencoder approach, and the Time-Transformer is a component of the decoder. Each Time-Transformer block is comprised of (1) two parallel modules: a TCN block and a transformer block, and (2) a bi-directional cross-attention. The experim...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Generative models
Review: This paper introduces Time-Transformer AAE. The proposed method is an adversarial autoencoder approach, and the Time-Transformer is a component of the decoder. Each Time-Transformer block is comprised of (1) two parallel modules: a TCN block and a transformer block, and (2) a bi-directional cross-attention. The...
This manuscript proposes a method to model non-stationary spatio-temporal events in the framework of hawkes process. The specific method is to construct a more refined kernel function. Strength: 1. The idea of using deep non-stationary kernel in the point process to model spatial-temporal data is interesting and somewh...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This manuscript proposes a method to model non-stationary spatio-temporal events in the framework of hawkes process. The specific method is to construct a more refined kernel function. Strength: 1. The idea of using deep non-stationary kernel in the point process to model spatial-temporal data is interesting an...
This paper asks the question of whether the Q-Fair Federated Learning (Q-FFL) algorithm can help or obviate personalization. This federated learning algorithm attempts to instill fairness by weighting losses more heavily for clients with large losses, controlled via an exponential weighting parameter q. By equalizing t...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Optimization (eg, convex and non-convex optimization)
Review: This paper asks the question of whether the Q-Fair Federated Learning (Q-FFL) algorithm can help or obviate personalization. This federated learning algorithm attempts to instill fairness by weighting losses more heavily for clients with large losses, controlled via an exponential weighting parameter q. By equa...
In this paper, the author propose a novel model-based method to attack the team performance in cooperative Multi-agent reinforcement learning. By changing the input state of the victim agent, the goal is to reduce the reward function of the whole team. In addition, the authors also propose a victim-agent selection str...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: In this paper, the author propose a novel model-based method to attack the team performance in cooperative Multi-agent reinforcement learning. By changing the input state of the victim agent, the goal is to reduce the reward function of the whole team. In addition, the authors also propose a victim-agent selec...
This paper develops a new algorithm for adversarially robust few-shot MAML. The interesting part is that the adversarial robustness transfers across domains. Experiments are conducted on multiple datasets and against multiple baseline methods. In my opinion, the strength here is the transferability of robustness acro...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper develops a new algorithm for adversarially robust few-shot MAML. The interesting part is that the adversarial robustness transfers across domains. Experiments are conducted on multiple datasets and against multiple baseline methods. In my opinion, the strength here is the transferability of robustn...
The paper proposes using a state abstractions defined as subgoals to improve efficiency by doing planning on the background while learning action-value estimates. Given a set of subgoals, which is a many-to-one mapping of states to abstract states, the proposed method runs dynamic programming to plan in the abstract sp...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper proposes using a state abstractions defined as subgoals to improve efficiency by doing planning on the background while learning action-value estimates. Given a set of subgoals, which is a many-to-one mapping of states to abstract states, the proposed method runs dynamic programming to plan in the abs...
The goal of the paper is the provide counterfactual explanations (CFs) for neural classification models. The paper makes the point that existing methods for generating CFs are posthoc -- so they are not aware of the decision boundary of the model. As a result, the approximations taken by these models lead to subpar CFs...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: The goal of the paper is the provide counterfactual explanations (CFs) for neural classification models. The paper makes the point that existing methods for generating CFs are posthoc -- so they are not aware of the decision boundary of the model. As a result, the approximations taken by these models lead to su...
This paper proposes DAR, an approach of Neural Algorithmic Reasoning following the FordFulkerson algorithm for calculating maximum flow. The key idea is to simultaneously learn the primal and the dual problem which is max-flow and min-cut in this case. This should produce a similar advantage to multi-task training. Exp...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes DAR, an approach of Neural Algorithmic Reasoning following the FordFulkerson algorithm for calculating maximum flow. The key idea is to simultaneously learn the primal and the dual problem which is max-flow and min-cut in this case. This should produce a similar advantage to multi-task train...
This paper presents an investigation into large-language models' (LLMs) abilities to learn algorithms for in-context linear regression given only sample problems consisting of inputs and linearly related outputs, but no information about the true (linear) hypothesis class underlying these relationships. The authors p...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper presents an investigation into large-language models' (LLMs) abilities to learn algorithms for in-context linear regression given only sample problems consisting of inputs and linearly related outputs, but no information about the true (linear) hypothesis class underlying these relationships. The a...
This paper considers joint human-algorithm system in multi-armed bandits. The authors explore multiple possible frameworks for human objectives and provide theoretical regret bounds. They also give experimental results which show how regret varies with the human decision-maker’s objective and the number of arms. Streng...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper considers joint human-algorithm system in multi-armed bandits. The authors explore multiple possible frameworks for human objectives and provide theoretical regret bounds. They also give experimental results which show how regret varies with the human decision-maker’s objective and the number of arms...
This work proposes a hierarchical VAE-based end-to-end TTS model. EfficientTTS 2 replaces the flow-based prior in VITS with convolution-based hierarchical VAE priors and introduces a fully differentiable aligner for duration modeling. EFTS 2 shows a comparable result to VITS and Your-TTS with faster inference speed. St...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This work proposes a hierarchical VAE-based end-to-end TTS model. EfficientTTS 2 replaces the flow-based prior in VITS with convolution-based hierarchical VAE priors and introduces a fully differentiable aligner for duration modeling. EFTS 2 shows a comparable result to VITS and Your-TTS with faster inference s...
This paper proposes a metric to measure generalization ability for transformer models that is not data-dependent. Their proposed metric is based entirely on a spectral analysis of the weight matrices, and the authors seek to show that this metric correlates directly with test accuracy (as a proxy for model generalizati...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a metric to measure generalization ability for transformer models that is not data-dependent. Their proposed metric is based entirely on a spectral analysis of the weight matrices, and the authors seek to show that this metric correlates directly with test accuracy (as a proxy for model gene...