| ==Phrack Magazine== | |
| Volume Four, Issue Forty-Four, File 12 of 27 | |
| **************************************************************************** | |
| Sarah Gordon's Response | |
| Greetz and Salutations :) | |
| Thank you for giving me the opportunity to contribute to Phrack. While | |
| we may not agree on everything, I appreciate the chance to speak for | |
| myself. In the past, as many people now know, I have not | |
| had the opportunity to do so. My philosophies and ideals are quite similar | |
| to your own, and I hope that my response to this "Article" will help shine | |
| a bit of light on what is really going on here. | |
| I don't really want to spend too much time on it, because it is, as you | |
| said, obviously a personal attack. But, on the other hand, such nonsense | |
| can grow to the point where it has an effect. Perhaps a backlash on the | |
| programmers and hackers in Bulgaria, which of course will spread to the | |
| United States. They have suffered a lot of persecution because of the past | |
| malicious and irresponsible acts of some of their virus writers. Since Dark | |
| Avenger stopped writing viruses, their reputation has improved somewhat. | |
| David Briscoe recently wrote: | |
| "Computer hackers in former communist countries, including an elusive Bulgarian | |
| known as the Dark Avenger, are creating mischievous and sometimes costly viruses | |
| that threaten computers around the world". | |
| Following a recent interview I conducted with Dark Avenger, I was chastised for | |
| not making his identity known so he could be 'made to pay'. | |
| In "Discover" Magazine, writers Paul Mungo and Brian Clough | |
| are quoted from their book 'Approaching Zero' "the Mutating Engine...the | |
| most dangerous virus ever produced". This is so stupid, especially | |
| considering the thing does not replicate. It's a tool that can be used | |
| to perform encryption. Well, decryption too, but explanation of how it | |
| works aren't the point here, suffice to say it's not "the most dangerous | |
| virus ever produced". | |
| If people are going to rely on the media as an information resource, the | |
| media owes it to us to provide us with accurate information. However, | |
| this is simply not always the case. | |
| If you consider the actual viruses commonly found -in the wild- (that is, | |
| by computer users such as those from universities, corporations, etc.), | |
| the number of Bulgarian viruses -directly- impacting the users is a very | |
| insignificant number. For some reason, the media likes to play up | |
| Bulgaria as the big force behind the destruction of data! | |
| I personally don't have an interest in the economy of Bulgaria or any | |
| other country, but the media sure likes to use this kind of | |
| "information" to sell their own particular brand of fear. | |
| No more fear. Fear is a bad thing. It is one of the things that leads us | |
| to have government intervention into areas of our lives where it is | |
| definitely not desired. | |
| Sara(h?) Gordon AND THE DARK AVENGER SCAM. | |
| By K$hntark | |
| In one of my many online conversations with Sara Gordon | |
| I once asked her about the validity of the VNI interviews and | |
| her real relationship with the alleged dark avenger; after | |
| logging into her VFR BBS and seeing a #2 (hers being #1) | |
| account named after him. | |
| Of course his (Dark Avenger) name was #2 there. I put it there for him. His last | |
| call to my BBS was July 31, 1993 at 1:55 p.m. However, this was not the start of this | |
| business with Kohntark. He had been mailing me for about one month. From | |
| an account using the address of cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu. Keep this address | |
| in mind. It will come in handy later. | |
| I am not exactly sure of the date of the first message, but I think about one | |
| month. He had been reasonable enough at first, but he became | |
| increasingly agitated. Since he felt it was appropriate to include | |
| personal mail from Dark Avenger to him here, I think I can go ahead and | |
| illustrate for you some of his "hacking" :) (well, if you can call it | |
| hacking. you decide). (OH GOD, LOWER CASE...LeTZ SeE...) | |
| I proceeded to leave a message for the dark avenger there, | |
| claiming that the whole account was bogus as it is highly | |
| improbable that this person might call all the way from | |
| Bulgaria and log into a mediocre BBS just to chat with her, | |
| considering the expense of such long distance call , the | |
| economic situation in Eastern Europe and a fact that | |
| would learn later: Sara(h) Gordon has an account on the | |
| Bulgarian DIGSYS unix server, locally accessible by phone | |
| from there! | |
| This guy doesn't seem to know much about the "economic situation in | |
| Eastern Europe". At least, about Dark Avenger's personal economic | |
| state:) or mine. Maybe Dark Avenger could call digsys, but I | |
| certainly couldn't when I first started talking to him. I didn't have | |
| any internet account. All I had was my mediocre BBS. He couldn't get to | |
| my BBS any way but to call me, directly. | |
| Yes, I have an account there -now-, but I don't and didn't use it to chat with | |
| Dark Avenger. He did not want the sysadmin to monitor our chats. And, I | |
| didn't -have- that account until after I had talked to Dark Avenger for | |
| a long time, so I could hardly have used that server to talk to him | |
| early on I didn't have an account there then :) In fact, neither did he, | |
| at that time, because there was no digsys.bg as far as I know. He called | |
| Danbo BBS for years. It was not on the internet. He did later use it later, | |
| once it actually got onto the internet, to occasionally mail me, but not much. | |
| He used it more to come to IRC. | |
| In fact, a couple people you know talked to him there, with me. They didn't | |
| like him much; found him rude and arrogant. He can be. | |
| However, he most certainly did call me here. Does Kohntark think he is | |
| the only one who can make long distance telephone calls? Dark Avenger | |
| called me frequently, and not always from Bulgaria. I don't know how or | |
| if he paid for the calls, all I know is that since I couldn't afford | |
| to call, and didn't know any number for him, he called me. | |
| As for my "mediocre" BBS, it serves its purpose:) I think giving out | |
| virus free anti-virus products, and products that don't cost the users a | |
| small fortune, and that actually WORK is quite a good purpose. I don't | |
| see any reason for people to be exploited by some a-v companies, who | |
| are promoted by various magazines, which in turn rate them highly | |
| because they are doing their advertising. | |
| As it was expected, Sara(h) quickly 'noticed' my personal | |
| message to the dark avenger and replied to my questioning in | |
| a public post in FIDONET, (I don't read FIDONET posts and she | |
| knows I have no access to them!!!! ) | |
| Kohntark called my BBS, at my invitation, on July 13, 1993 at 23:19. | |
| There's no other way he could have left any mail because its an invite | |
| only system. It's not like it was any big shock to me that he called. | |
| He asked me to make him an account and I did. | |
| Dark Avenger was a regular caller to my BBS, and read his message, I | |
| imagine, since he fwded it to me. I don't know what access Kohntark | |
| has or doesn't have, as far as what networks he uses, (as far as what | |
| networks he reads mail from, that is) as I explained to | |
| him. I mailed him there because of the mail he left to Dark Avenger (which | |
| he forwarded to me) on MY system, and because I received a very nasty message | |
| from Kohntark, using the address kohntark@rot.in.hell.com, if I remember | |
| correctly. I sent the message, and did include answers to his questions | |
| because I wanted to continue talking with him. The message had the headers | |
| included from, guess where? cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu.... | |
| She claimed that the dark avenger was fully aware of how much | |
| money she made out of the VNI interviews and that she was in | |
| touch with him, etc.etc. | |
| This is the truth. In case anyone is curious, the amount of money I made | |
| from this article was less than the amount of my PC Pursuit Bill from | |
| calling to do chats and talks with him. At that time he had accesses via | |
| various networks, and we talked on a regular basis. Additionally, Dark | |
| Avenger had full control over taking out or editing any of his comments | |
| in the interview. It is a policy of mine. If you wish to confirm it, I | |
| can put you in touch with other virus writers. I can in fact do it any | |
| time probably, as they are usually around where we are. Let me know if | |
| you want me to do it. Dark Avenger was even a bit obsessive about how | |
| much money I would make. | |
| I also "sold" the story to PCWorld, where it has been published, in | |
| part. I have not received any compensation for this yet. More later on why I | |
| did the interview. | |
| Maybe the problem is I didn't interview Kohntark... | |
| Afterward, I questioned her again about the whole affair | |
| and demanded a proof, or some sort of direct contact from the | |
| dark avenger to my anonymous internet account. | |
| First, I do not have to "prove" my contact with this man to anyone. It | |
| has been well enough observed and documented every step of the way. Ever | |
| hear of the dedicated virus? It is the demo virus that came with the | |
| Mutation Engine. It contains "We dedicate this little virus to sara | |
| gordon who wanted to have a virus named after her". (At this point, Dark | |
| Avenger did not really know me, we were just establishing our contact; | |
| he still used the spelling Sara for my name :) | |
| I provided Kohntark with an address with Dark Avengers permission. | |
| Actually, the account Dark Avenger had at digsys which he used to get to | |
| me on chats or IRC (2 years after initial contact) was not | |
| under the name Dark Avenger OR dav, but under another name which would | |
| draw less attention to itself if someone happened to finger us during | |
| one of our chats. The system adminstrator made the additional account | |
| later, since he knew quite well it -was- Dark Avenger, having had an | |
| ongoing battle with him for years. | |
| Kohntark wrote to Dark Avenger there, just like he said he did. At least | |
| this much is true. And, I did receive copies of the mail. Actually Dark | |
| Avenger did not want to even answer the mail, but I asked him to please | |
| do it so that the guy would leave me alone. | |
| Someone using the same mail headers had already sent a message to WIRED, | |
| telling them "The DA is old news, he hasn't made a virus in 2 years, | |
| you should interview ME". Wonder who that might have been...... | |
| Does the header cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu ring any bells? | |
| At that point, Kohntark forged mail to WIRED magazine, this time posing | |
| as Dark Avenger. I would never have known this, but Dark Avenger fwd back | |
| a very strange reply message from WIRED and asked me what in the hell was | |
| going on. In that message, WIRED had included part of the message they | |
| had received. It clearly displayed the cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu headers, | |
| indicating that the mail had been sent from someone there! Someone who | |
| told WIRED "I don't want to talk to you" (paraphrased). Even WIRED told | |
| me "That mail did not sound like Dark Avenger..it was just all wrong" | |
| (paraphrased). I pointed out the headers to them later. It was a bad | |
| hack on Kohntark's part. Anyone doubts, it mail the sysadmin at | |
| digsys.bg. | |
| Here is a copy of that mail, with "compromising" parts xxxxed out. | |
| First, Dark Avenger's legitimate fwd to me: | |
| From dav@digsys.bg Sat Jul 24 20:36:12 1993 | |
| Return-Path: <dav@digsys.bg> | |
| Received: from mcsun.EU.net by mail.netcom.com (5.65/SMI-4.1/Netcom) | |
| id AA04202; Sat, 24 Jul 93 20:34:29 -0700 | |
| Received: from danbo.UUCP by mcsun.EU.net with UUCP | |
| id AA18612 (5.65b/CWI-2.220); Sun, 25 Jul 1993 05:35:36 +0200 | |
| Received: by danbo.digsys.bg (5.67/1.37) via EUnet | |
| id AA06614; Sun, 25 Jul 93 05:33:30 +0300 | |
| From: dav@digsys.bg (Dark Avenger) | |
| Message-Id: <9307250233.AA06614@danbo.digsys.bg> | |
| Subject: Re: FWD>None (fwd) | |
| To: vfr@netcom.com | |
| Date: Sun, 25 Jul 93 5:33:29 EET DST | |
| X-Mailer: ELM [version 2.3 PL11] | |
| Status: OR | |
| Then, the message from xxxxxxxxxxx at WIRED: | |
| Forwarded message: | |
| >From xxxxxx!wired.com!xxxxx Sat Jul 24 01:34:30 1993 | |
| Message-Id: <9307232129.AA02102@wired.com> | |
| Date: 23 Jul 1993 14:27:42 -0800 | |
| From: "xxxxxxxxxxx" <xxxxx@wired.com> | |
| Subject: Re: FWD>None | |
| To: dav@digsys.bg | |
| Reply to: RE>FWD>None | |
| *Some mail from WIRED guy replying to the message*** | |
| And now, the mail that prompted xxxxxxx's reply. I guess Kohntark didn't | |
| realize that the mail would receive a reply. Or, didn't realize the | |
| reply would include the mail headers: | |
| -------------------------------------- | |
| Date: 7/23/93 12:35 AM | |
| To: xxxxxxxxxxx | |
| From: xxxx | |
| Received: by xx.wired.com with SMTP;22 Jul 1993 05:38:19 -0800 | |
| Received: from anon.penet.fi by wired.com via SMTP (920330.SGI/911001.SGI) | |
| for xxxxx@xx.wired.com id AA00423; Thu, 22 Jul 93 05:35:20 -0700 | |
| Received: from cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu by anon.penet.fi (5.67/1.35) | |
| ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ | |
| id AA21218; Thu, 22 Jul 93 15:24:44 +0300 | |
| Date: Thu, 22 Jul 93 15:24:44 +0300 | |
| From: dav@digsys.bg | |
| Message-Id: <9307221224.AA21218@anon.penet.fi> | |
| Return-Path:<dav@digsys.bg> | |
| Date: Fri 13, 66 00:00:00 EST | |
| To:<xxxxxxx@wired.com> | |
| Subject:Not interest. | |
| Status:RO | |
| I read in VIRUS-L that some idiot (atman@rahut.net) wants to do | |
| interview with me face to face. | |
| I am not interested in being in your magazine. | |
| I am not interested in being interviewed, even if you offer me $1000. | |
| or more. | |
| I am not interested. so tell your friend to stop mentioning me in | |
| VIRUS-L, i have NO interest. | |
| Please don't bother to reply. I have no time for stupidity. | |
| <dav> | |
| --------- | |
| Interesting use of the anonymous mailer port 25, eh? (clue: try helo) | |
| Since this was the first time anyone had ever questioned the | |
| validity of her relationship with the DA, she took this to | |
| heart and shortly after, I received 3 short messages | |
| originating from <dav@danbo.digsys.bg> an Internet connected | |
| UNIX system in Bulgaria. | |
| HAHAHA. This has been questioned many times. Do you think the ACM, or | |
| any magazine would risk printing this without adequate proof? My contacts early | |
| on with the virus writer were well documented. I had to prove myself to | |
| everyone from Vesselin Bontchev (who did not believe me until he had | |
| seen the source code to Commander Bomber, which is a virus; the source | |
| code has never been made available to anyone). Here: | |
| From bontchev@informatik.uni-hamburg.de Tue Oct 12 02:34:53 1993 | |
| Return-Path: <bontchev@informatik.uni-hamburg.de> | |
| Received: from deneb.dfn.de by mail.netcom.com (5.65/SMI-4.1/Netcom) | |
| id AA09608; Tue, 12 Oct 93 02:34:34 -0700 | |
| Received: from fbihh.informatik.uni-hamburg.de by deneb.dfn.de (4.1/SMI-4.2) | |
| id AA05014; Tue, 12 Oct 93 10:33:30 +0100 | |
| From: bontchev@informatik.uni-hamburg.de (Vesselin Bontchev) | |
| Message-Id: <9310120933.AA22605@fbihh.informatik.uni-hamburg.de> | |
| Received: by fbihh.informatik.uni-hamburg.de (5.65+/FBIHH-1.21); | |
| id AA22605; Tue, 12 Oct 93 10:33:45 +0100 | |
| Subject: Re: urgent | |
| To: vfr@netcom.com | |
| Date: Tue, 12 Oct 1993 10:33:42 +0100 (MET) | |
| In-Reply-To: <9310120331.AA01134@netcom4.netcom.com> from "sara" at | |
| Oct 11, 93 08:31:48 pm | |
| X-Mailer: ELM [version 2.4 PL23] | |
| Content-Type: text | |
| Content-Length: 2211 | |
| Status: OR | |
| ....blah blah..(deleted) | |
| So, here is my official statement. | |
| I hereby confirm that when I met Sarah S. Gordon in March 1993 in New | |
| York, she showed me the original source of the Commander Bomber virus. | |
| It was obviously a source and not a disassembly, and it was very | |
| similar to a couple of other sources of Dark Avenger's programs that I | |
| have seen. When I say "similar" I mean such things like label names, | |
| commenting style, layout of the text and so on. Of course, this is not | |
| a proof that it has been really produced by the Dark Avenger, but this | |
| is very probable. Sarah didn't give me a copy of it and I didn't | |
| insist, because she told me that she has promised to Dark Avenger not | |
| to give this source to anybody. To my knowledge, nobody else has the | |
| source. | |
| Regards, | |
| Vesselin | |
| - -- | |
| Vesselin Vladimirov Bontchev Virus Test Center, University of Hamburg | |
| Tel.:+49-40-54715-224, Fax: +49-40-54715-226 Fachbereich Informatik - AGN | |
| < PGP 2.3 public key available on request. > Vogt-Koelln-Strasse 30, rm. 107 C | |
| e-mail: bontchev@fbihh.informatik.uni-hamburg.de 22527 Hamburg, Germany | |
| Keep in mind, Vesselin is not a product developer and has no affiliation | |
| with any developers. He is a Doctoral Student who has himself been | |
| accused of being the Dark Avenger. | |
| The Bulgarian Secret Police seemed to believe my | |
| contact was legitimate enough. I received an "invitation" to meet with | |
| them. I declined this "invitation" because I am not interested in the terrorist | |
| tactics of a desperate government to blame a hacker and virus writer for | |
| the problems of the country in general. | |
| I had to prove my contact lots of ways, just to get the article in | |
| print. Why did I want this article in print? One simple reason. To show | |
| this virus writer as not some evil sinister monster from Hell waiting to | |
| destroy the earth's supercomputer. Just as a person like the rest of us. | |
| Did it accomplish it? I think it did, from the response I got from most | |
| people. Did -I- personally 'benefit' from it? In some ways, I did. | |
| This reminds me, a certain ex-virus exchange sysop told me that he was | |
| going to make me expose the Dark Avenger; that he was going to find out | |
| his true identity, where no one else could; that he would make up some | |
| story, any story, to force Dark Avenger out into the open. Well, I don't | |
| narc on my friends. I am sure you can appreciate that. | |
| Here they are: | |
| (Private, compromising parts are X'd out) | |
| 1st Message: | |
| -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
| - | |
| >From daemon@digsys.bg Wed Jul 14 19:07 EDT 1993 | |
| Received: from danbo.digsys.bg by XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX; Wed, 14 Jul 93 19:07:3 | |
| 4 -0400 | |
| Return-Path: <dav@danbo.digsys.bg> | |
| Received: by XXXXXXXXXXXXXX (5.67/1.35) | |
| id AA12850; Thu, 15 Jul 93 02:04:46 +0300 | |
| Message-Id: <9307142304.AA12850@XXXXXXXXXXXX> | |
| To: XXXXXXX | |
| From: dav@danbo.digsys.bg | |
| Date: Wed, 14 Jul 93 23:41:36 +0300 | |
| Subject: No subject | |
| Status: RO | |
| kohntark- | |
| i just talked to a friend of mine who said you dont like her user | |
| log. why shouldnt i call her from bulgaria? i call whoever i want | |
| to, and this is not your problem. | |
| by the way, she sent me your mail. for your information, i do | |
| know how much money she made of that interview. and i also think | |
| that this is none of your business. | |
| also, maybe it would be good for you to know, that by offending | |
| her, you are offending me, too. keep this in mind. | |
| <dav> | |
| Second Message: | |
| ------------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
| >My mail with her is none of your business either. | |
| i dont think so, dude. | |
| maybe you need to read the next few lines again, | |
| in case you missed them. | |
| >> | |
| >> also, maybe it would be good for you to know, that by offending | |
| >> her, you are offending me, too. keep this in mind. | |
| >> | |
| >> <dav> | |
| > | |
| >HA HA! and you expect me to believe that you are the DA! | |
| >send me a proof: an email address from bulgaria or tell me | |
| >how many addressing modes does the MTE have? | |
| > | |
| >nice try. | |
| well, what do you think the domain .bg in my email address stands for? | |
| maybe you think its kameroon? | |
| as for the mte, im not giving you any info. | |
| i need not prove anything to anybody, and certainly dont plan to waste more | |
| of my time talking to you. you have been warned. | |
| <dav> | |
| Third Message: | |
| ------------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
| oh, yeah. sure it did. | |
| only you will not know where something else came from, when it knocks on your | |
| door. i have nothing more to say. | |
| ------------------------------------------------------------------------- | |
| Odd. He did not include the mail he forged using the address I gave him | |
| in good faith to WIRED magazine. | |
| He also did not include the mail he forged to Anthony Naggs, | |
| an engineer, in which he made the following statements: | |
| > > From @gate.demon.co.uk,@anon.penet.fi:darkavenger@sofia.somewhere.bg Fri | |
| Sep 17 18:16:32 1993 | |
| > > Received: from post.demon.co.uk by ubik.demon.co.uk with SMTP | |
| > > id AA4544 ; Fri, 17 Sep 93 18:16:22 GMT | |
| > > Received: from post.demon.co.uk via puntmail for amn@ubik.demon.co.uk; | |
| > > Fri Sep 17 14:49:12 BST 1993 | |
| > > Received: from gate.demon.co.uk by post.demon.co.uk id gk03845; | |
| > > 17 Sep 93 14:09 BST | |
| > > Received: from anon.penet.fi by gate.demon.co.uk id aa01230; | |
| > > 17 Sep 93 6:07 GMT-60:00 | |
| > > Received: from cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu by anon.penet.fi (5.67/1.35) | |
| ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^see originating mail location? | |
| > > id AA15730; Fri, 17 Sep 93 07:58:28 +0300 | |
| > > From: DarkAvenger@sofia.somewhere.bg | |
| > > Message-Id: <9309170458.AA15730@anon.penet.fi> | |
| > > Return-Path: <DarkAvenger@sofia.somewhere.bg> | |
| > > Date: Thursday, 16 Sept 93 22:02:54 | |
| > > To: amn@ubik.demon.co.uk | |
| > > MMDF-Warning: Parse error in original version of preceding line at gate. | |
| demon.co.uk | |
| > > Subject: NO i am NOT | |
| > > Status: RO | |
| > | |
| > NO , I have not found "more interesting thigs to do"! | |
| > If you don't know it yet, I am still active and will release | |
| > work at the end of the year. | |
| > Also in case you don't know the VNI interview was mostly made up. | |
| > I haven't talked to Sara in almost a year, and I will never again. | |
| > She betrayed me. | |
| > She will deny this and try to exploit my name more. | |
| > Until the end of year. | |
| > | |
| > Then again.. what do you know? you are like the weasel: another | |
| > stupid engineer.. you know nothing about viruses! | |
| > | |
| > UNtil then.. | |
| > | |
| > | |
| > | |
| > | |
| ------- | |
| Dark Avenger spells my name with an "h" :) And, he doesn't mail people | |
| from cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu :) And, I think this pretty clearly illustrates the | |
| motivations and methods of Kohntark. | |
| In my ignorance, I blindly trusted the three cryptic replies | |
| to be true, even thought whoever replied refused to give out | |
| trivial information such as the number of addressing modes | |
| for a 2 year old encryption engine (MTE) and spelled Cameroon | |
| with a 'k' (Check out Sara Gordon's spelling of URUGUAY in | |
| VIRUS-L Volume 6 Issue 120 -v06i120) | |
| Shortly after other unrelated discussions and a CUD post from | |
| Sara(h) in which I was mentioned (unnamed), someone warned me | |
| of several posts in NUKENET by an alleged dark avenger and | |
| Todor Todorov from an account belonging to the last, | |
| mentioning me and Aristotle. | |
| Sheesh. Kameroon with a -K- is the German spelling. It is also the most | |
| common spelling a European would use. The "correct" spelling, for anyone | |
| who cares, is Cameroun, because it is mainly a French speaking colony; A | |
| small portion of it is English-speaking and uses Cameroon. Most likely, | |
| An American would use Cameroon. Consult your nearest linguist or historical | |
| specialist for verification. Talk to discman about my linguistic aptitude. | |
| Do not attempt this at home. | |
| Kohntark spelled SKISM incorrectly in one of his messages to me. He must be the | |
| Dark Avenger. No, wait..he onlys -wants- to be... | |
| Those messages in the NukeNet were prompted by the virus exchange sysop | |
| mentioned earlier asking Todor Todorov to contact Dark Avenger and ask | |
| him if he had really talked to me. Todor -is- a friend of mine. He | |
| assisted me in my study of virus exchange bbs and their impact on end | |
| users. Todor put the mail on some Bulgarian BBS, and Dark Avenger | |
| answered it. Apparently, his answer was not liked very well by this | |
| Aristotle and others people, because an amateur linguistic analysis followed, | |
| detailing how much like me the Dark Avenger appeared to be. | |
| I employed the services of a professional linguist, who stated that | |
| indeed there are striking similarities. This can be attributed to the | |
| fact that Dark Avenger and I have spent many hours together. | |
| And, I usually type in lower case, in E-Mail messages, etc. Come to | |
| think of it, most of the hackers I know must be the Dark Avenger if | |
| this is the qualification :) | |
| In those messages I was referred to as 'hotshot,' a word that | |
| Sara Gordon had used on me several times on our personal | |
| email exchange; It was then that I became highly suspicious | |
| of the whole matter. | |
| Yes, I used this word. I use it all the time. So does Dark Avenger. It | |
| is a word we use to refer to certain people. It is a commonly used word | |
| in Bulgaria. It is not so common here, but it is there. They watch a lot | |
| of American television, and use a lot of words like this as well as a | |
| lot of profanity. Movies. Motherfucker and Asshole are two other words | |
| used a lot by Bulgarian hackers and virus writers. In fact, the word | |
| "motherfucker", which "proved" it was NOT a Bulgarian that posted as | |
| <dav> :) in the NuKeNet (since, as they said, NO Bulgarian would EVER | |
| use -this- word), was found in a virus of Bulgarian origin a very long | |
| time ago. Perhaps they should learn to disassemble the damned things | |
| before trying to say what's in them. In defense of NuKe (and believe me, | |
| there has been no love lost between some of those people and myself in | |
| the past), I think a lot of people were baited and led on by certain people. | |
| I called Virginia's Virus Research Institute's sysop and | |
| owner, Aristotle to find out more about the posts and he | |
| bought to my attention the particular writing style of | |
| Sara(h) Gordon: She NEVER uses capital letters and | |
| apostrophes on her personal email, and always signs her name | |
| on the lower left hand corner. (She seldom signs her posts | |
| Virginia Virus Research Institute is (was) The Black Axis BBS. The place | |
| that sold viruses for one hundred dollars per collection. Pretty | |
| enterprising, eh? Only, a lot of them were junk. The sysop is the same | |
| one who told me he was going to get the Dark Avenger to come forth, to | |
| 'Save my Name' or something like that. He also told me that if a new | |
| virus appeared, bearing the name 'Dark Avenger', people would want to | |
| 'catch' the virus writer again. And, guess what? Such a virus did | |
| appear. A crude hack of the Burma virus, with a text string included: | |
| DARKAVENGER :). And, it was this very sysop that uploaded it to a | |
| certain well known virus exchange BBS. Slick, huh? But definitely not the | |
| work of Dark Avenger. | |
| However, this will not make me identify the Dark Avenger, assuming I did | |
| know the path to his door. | |
| This same sysop also told me (when he closed his system) that he had | |
| intentionally tried to incite people, and had made some mistakes along | |
| the way in doing this. We all make mistakes. Unfortunately, Kohntark is | |
| making a really big mistake here. | |
| Yes, I use lower case ALL THE TIME. And, like Dark Avenger, I sometimes | |
| do and sometimes do not use correct punctuation. Apparently Kohntark has | |
| not been around in the early days of <dav> postings on Fidonet. Oh, | |
| that's right. He does not read it. Well, if he had, he would have seen | |
| Dark Avenger had this 'style' a long time before I ever heard of | |
| computer viruses. | |
| I am using upper case in this article (mostly) because when I write for | |
| a readership (as opposed to private mail, and online chats, etc.), I use | |
| correct form. Well, as correct form as I can. | |
| nowadays and changes her user name in her vfr@netcom.com | |
| account every week!; for further proof of her writing style, | |
| please refer to public posts in VIRUS-L Volume 6 #120; I also | |
| have over 100K of personal email exchange to prove this | |
| fact!) | |
| Shame on me. I change my user name :) I am so El33t.... | |
| I'm too hexy for my shirt, too hexy for my shirt...blah blah | |
| It was then that we realized that she was passing herself as | |
| Todor Todorov and the dark avenger (who could possibly verify | |
| their online identity?) and had infiltrated NUKENET.. | |
| HAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAAHHA oops, excuse me..hahahahahaha | |
| This is ridiculous, as anyone who has checked will know. Todorov is happy to | |
| take calls from people about this matter; eminent | |
| publicly (not anonymous) figures in the field know that I wrote | |
| the truth, and there really is nothing further to be said about this | |
| nonsense. | |
| The writing style described corresponds exactly to the one on | |
| the posts I received from the 'dark avenger.' | |
| Shortly afterward the <dav@danbo.digsys.bg> account was | |
| cancelled and I learned the whole truth: | |
| Oh my. My writing style corresponds exactly to Dark Avengers. It | |
| certainly does, when I want it to, or when I have been writing to him a | |
| lot. And, it does when I write e-mail. So what? So does the style of a | |
| of people :) We are all Dark Avenger. If you counted the names of | |
| everyone who writes in lower case, makes spelling areas, and signs their | |
| mail in the lower left hand corner of messages, how many people do you | |
| think you would find? | |
| About the account: Yes, it was cancelled. After Kohntark forged mail from | |
| that site, prompting a response from WIRED, I asked the system administrator | |
| to cancel the account so that no more such trickery could take place, | |
| requiring me to spend time trying to straighten it out. He | |
| was happy to do it. He had more than a few problems with Dark | |
| Avenger ftping files in excess, and had only retained the account as a | |
| personal favor to me. <dav> (yes, that IS how he signs personal mail, | |
| e-mail and some of his viruses) did not exactly be a nice boy on that | |
| system. | |
| The danbo.digsys.bg Bulgarian site belongs to Daniel Kalchev, | |
| another self appointed AV researcher whose best claims to | |
| fame are submitting various Bulgarian viruses to Patricia | |
| Hoffman's VSUM!! | |
| Self-appointed? He is the administrator of the Internet there. I think | |
| Kohntark is not fully aware of just who Mr. Kalchev is. | |
| (You can check this by doing a search on 'Kalchev' on the | |
| current VSUMs or you can contact him thru: | |
| <daniel@danbo.sigsys.bg> ) | |
| No. The best address is daniel@digsys.bg. Mr. and Mrs. Kalchev both have | |
| accounts there, and you can reach them best if you use this address. | |
| And please do feel free to contact him. He will tell you that he has | |
| talked to Dark Avenger for a very long time. Long before digsys was on | |
| the internet, and long before I met either of them. | |
| He is a very close friend of Sara(h) Gordon and he has an | |
| account in her VFR BBS (you can check this by logging into | |
| her system and checking the user list) and SHE has an | |
| account in digsys.bg under <sarah@danbo.digsys.bg> (this | |
| account is still valid as far as I know; notice the H after | |
| her name!) | |
| Of course he is a very close friend of mine. He has visited me here, and | |
| has been a great help to me in my work. Yes, I do have an account there. | |
| It has been there since I was invited by the Bulgarian ACM to present my | |
| work on Computer Viruses at their International Computer Virus | |
| Conference. It was nice of Daniel to do this for me, to make it | |
| convenient for me to access my mail, as I could have it forwarded there. | |
| We never did remove the account, as Bulgarian's prefer to mail in their | |
| own country for some reason. The H after my name is very simple: My name | |
| is Sarah Gordon. On the nets, I use Sara. When I am friends with | |
| someone, I use my given name. I do not like my given "familiar" name to | |
| be used in my articles or in e-mail from people I don't know. It is a | |
| quirk, I guess. My papers are presented using the Sara variant :) | |
| What I concluded is that is the DA would never get an account | |
| in such system as he HATES Daniel Kalchev!!!! | |
| Another wrong conclusion. | |
| The DA might not, but then the District Attorney usually doesn't :) | |
| Wrong. and Right. He certainly did get an account there. Call Daniel | |
| Kalchev or mail him to ask him. He has had many conversations with Dark | |
| Avenger there. He does sure hate Daniel. In this one thing, Kohntark is | |
| correct. He hates him violently. And, he's been on his BBS for years. | |
| Where do you think he used to post messages FROM? | |
| I tried repeatedly to act as intermediary between Dark Avenger and | |
| Kalchev, because they both have been very good to me. There was just no | |
| way to do it. Dark Avenger thinks Kalchev is (in his own words) "asshole | |
| hotshot with big company and lots of money, he can afford to give free | |
| accounts...". And yes, he used the word HOTSHOT. JUST LIKE ME. | |
| This is what really happened: Sara(h) Gordon in her | |
| desperation to prove that she was in touch with the dark | |
| avenger, told her pal Daniel Kalchev to make an account under | |
| the dark avenger's name (<dav> this is how she always refers | |
| to him, even though he never signs his name that way (check | |
| the source code for his 'Dark Avenger' virus or the | |
| 'Commander Bomber' virus message name: [DAME]) | |
| No one has the source code for Commander Bomber that I know of except | |
| myself and Dark Avenger, as I previously noted. He has signed his name | |
| this way for a very long time, in his e-mail. You can verify this easily | |
| enough by asking Todor, Daniel, Bontchev, or anyone who used to read his | |
| old posts. Sometimes he does, sometimes he doesn't, just like me. | |
| From there she could email me messages that would come from | |
| Bulgaria and would be untraceable since she would log into | |
| her account in digsys.bg and log into the <dav> account | |
| internally from the same site in Bulgaria. (You can check | |
| where and when most of the people log from in most internet | |
| unix and vax sites) | |
| :). If I wanted to mail Kohntark untraceable messages, I would not have | |
| to go to this extreme, as you well know :) | |
| As it is expected from her, she has denied any of this. | |
| Some of her ridiculous explanations include things like | |
| "hotshot is a very common English word in Bulgaria" !!! | |
| You might ask yourself what is the deal with the h? is it | |
| sara or sarah?? | |
| Well, I asked her the same question when I noticed this in | |
| one of the VNI interviews, where her name is spelled as | |
| Sarah. | |
| She replied that this was a mistake of the publisher. | |
| Mistake? well not really, it was another lie, meant to throw | |
| off any information and truth seekers, for example you can | |
| check her account in Daniel Kalchev's system: | |
| I explained this previously. It was a mistake. VNI is not supposed to | |
| use my given entire familiar name. In fact, they did mess up. They did | |
| not use it in the Dark Avenger interview, despite I had put it there as | |
| "Sarah". I told Dark Avenger I would do this for him. He asked me to do | |
| it, but for some reason they did not. Later, they -did- use my given | |
| name in a totally different situation. I can't account for their errors. | |
| <saraH@danbo.digsys.bg> , spelled with an H, | |
| another 'mistake of the publisher?' | |
| :) | |
| Other countless Sara Gordon lies are told in NUKE Info- | |
| Journal # 6. | |
| In the last NuKe Journal, the authors posted some private mail of mine, | |
| and said "Look how nice she knows this public mail will be read"..at the | |
| same time, the posted some public mail, from my BBS, which I had | |
| forwarded to one of them as a reply, and said "Look how nasty she is | |
| when she thinks no one can see". All in all, their response to both | |
| letters prompted a lot of people to think I had -joined- NuKe. For the | |
| record, nope. | |
| This behavior puts in question the validity of the VNI | |
| interviews and the reputation of Sara(h) Gordon as a serious | |
| (self appointed) 'virus researcher' | |
| :) | |
| IMHO the VNI interviews are a complete fabrication, meant | |
| only to boost her validity as a 'journalist', and to make her | |
| lots of money, charging for further 'interviews' to other | |
| magazines. (She has offered her paid 'interviewing' services | |
| to various other publications.) | |
| :) Lots of money? Well, first off, I told you how the Dark Avenger | |
| interview profited me. It didn't. Secondly, yes, I do write for | |
| magazines and I sell the articles. Some, I give away. I don't do any of | |
| this for the money. As for other interviewing, I recently interviewed | |
| two virus writers (one who has stopped, one who has not), and they are | |
| quite pleased with the articles. I'll ask them to contact you personally | |
| to tell you as the article is not yet in print. Keep in mind, I have | |
| literally no control over commentary by editors, omissions, etc. | |
| To the best of my knowledge the information I present here | |
| is true and can be checked. | |
| Yes, it can be checked, and I hope you check it and print what you find | |
| along with this commentary. | |
| I chose to publish this information, despite threats against | |
| my well being and countless lies about me propagated by | |
| Sara(h) Gordon. | |
| Now, about threats and lies. Here is the sort of mail I have received | |
| from Kohntark. In the interest of space, I will send you the headers, | |
| etc., so that you can see them and include here only the sort of | |
| diatribe he has been so vehemently sending me. | |
| I contacted his system administrator after this continued for such | |
| a long time. I'm not a Cori. I don't take every "hey, wanna have phone | |
| sex" message as a potential threat, I don't call people's probation | |
| officers for the hell of it, I don't ring up sysadmins at the drop of a | |
| hat to accuse innocent people of causing trouble. And, I discussed this | |
| situation with a lot of people, hackers and virus writers, friends and | |
| foes, prior to taking this action. There's no way to know over the nets if | |
| someone is really a maniac or if they are just playing around. In this case, | |
| considering the nature of the mail, I did contact them. | |
| First, the apology after he had gotten particularly nasty. | |
| Organization: Anonymous contact service | |
| Reply-To: xxxxxx@anon.penet.fi | |
| Subject: Apology | |
| Date: Fri, 30 Jul 93 8:08:45 EDT | |
| Status: OR | |
| Sara: | |
| I want to apologize for everything that I have said that you might | |
| have found offensive. | |
| I drop all accusations I have made against you. | |
| again, I am sorry. | |
| I have no desire in creating any animosity, and / or bad publicity | |
| to my name or yours. | |
| Sorry things got this silly and out of hand. | |
| Please accept my apologies and let's drop the whole thing OK? | |
| Thank you. | |
| ------------ | |
| Followed almost immediately by a forgery. What Kohntark did not realize | |
| is that I am in contact with Simon. In fact, I arranged for him to come | |
| to a virus conference, with all of his expenses paid. I am writing an | |
| article for 40-HEX, and I immediately called Simon to ask what in the hell was | |
| this about. After he told me, I went back and checked the mail headers. | |
| Guess what I found? | |
| From simon@skism.login.qc.ca Sat Jul 31 07:44:26 1993 | |
| Received: from anon.penet.fi by mail.netcom.com (5.65/SMI-4.1/Netcom) | |
| id AA17333; Sat, 31 Jul 93 07:44:19 -0700 | |
| Received: from cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu by anon.penet.fi (5.67/1.35) | |
| ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ | |
| id AA21213; Sat, 31 Jul 93 17:40:54 +0300 | |
| From: simon@skism.login.qc.ca | |
| Message-Id: <9307311440.AA21213@anon.penet.fi> | |
| Return-Path: <simon@sklism.login.ca> | |
| ****Notice: He misspelled skism. Maybe -he- is the Dark Avenger. | |
| I mean, if spelling counts..*** | |
| Date: Fri, 30 Jul 93 12:01:02 EST | |
| Subject: get real! | |
| Apparently-To: <vfr@netcom.com> | |
| Status: OR | |
| to vfr@netcom.com.... (Nobody) | |
| what is the matter? everyone knows you are sara gordon, are you afraid | |
| to sign you own name now?? | |
| Yes sara gordon, i heard rumours that you are passing yourself | |
| as the dark avenger. It wouldn't surprise me since you are | |
| even afraid to sign your own postings. | |
| -------- | |
| Ha. Actually he signed the above message at the bottom left:) He must be | |
| me in Real Life.... As we all have seen by now, if you sign the bottom | |
| left of your mail, you are Sara Gordon. | |
| Then, here he tells me how he has proved yet another self-appointed | |
| virus researcher wrong. Of course, the researcher in question is not | |
| wrong. He is Vesselin Bontchev, a rather pedantic but technically | |
| brilliant anti-virus Doctoral student at the University of Hamburg. | |
| Kohntark seems obsessed with proving anti-virus researchers wrong. It | |
| would make more sense to me to learn from the researchers. I am not | |
| talking about product developers or sales people, but researchers. | |
| ME=Sara | |
| HIM=Kohntark | |
| ME: dont you get it? im sorry, i am not going to respond to all of this | |
| nonsense. maybe you can get vesselin to respond to you again, but | |
| i doubt it considering his opinion of your 'knowledge'... | |
| HIM: I don't give a damn about what he thinks, I have shown the self appointed | |
| virus expert is wrong.That is all. | |
| --------- | |
| and, here (i'm reverting to UNIX lower case now, i must be the dark | |
| avenger..), he begins his harassment again. | |
| HIM: you don't have any children do you? It shows | |
| Then, after he tell me he knows all about me, he proceeds to mail me to | |
| taunt me with addresses referring to my child. | |
| From kohntark@youhavea10yearoldson.com Sun Aug 29 10:55:45 1993 | |
| Return-Path: <kohntark@youhavea10yearoldson.com> | |
| Received: from [193.64.138.3] by mail.netcom.com (5.65/SMI-4.1/Netcom) | |
| id AA07061; Sun, 29 Aug 93 10:55:39 -0700 | |
| Received: from cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu by anon.penet.fi (5.67/1.35) | |
| ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ | |
| id AA22796; Sun, 29 Aug 93 20:50:35 +0300 | |
| ME: am tired of your threats. the only danger you are to me | |
| is to waste my time with this nonsense. | |
| HIM: we will see. | |
| HIM: Never underestimate the power of hate. | |
| HIM: The end is coming. | |
| HIM: Also: you said 'oh my name is spelled SARA, VNI misspelled it! | |
| yeah right ! you idiot! | |
| you forgot who you are dealing here ha ha! not a fool like you!!! | |
| stupid tricks like changing your name can't defend you from thy mighty | |
| Kohntark! | |
| prepare yourself!! | |
| the end is near! | |
| Obviously i have overestimated your intelligence.. | |
| My dog has a higher IQ.. | |
| "who is anthony naggs?.." DUHH! | |
| Thanx for making my job easier he he. | |
| You think you got me? sure.. go ahead.. fry that guy's account, you will | |
| be doing me a favour he he! | |
| AH, and start looking for a new job.. you will need it soon after i am done | |
| with you | |
| you idiot! | |
| ------ | |
| He likes me to know he is watching me. Only, for a supreme UNIX hacker, | |
| he has not mastered the skills quite yet..note the paths again.. | |
| (baby copperfield is one of the names i used. i have red hair, and its a | |
| long story; someone asked me if i had read dickens and i replied 'yes, | |
| I've read baby copperfield'. CHFN followed :) | |
| But this was a bit eerie mail. Love him? | |
| From babycopperfield@haha.com Sun Sep 12 17:39:50 1993 | |
| Received: from anon.penet.fi by mail.netcom.com (5.65/SMI-4.1/Netcom) | |
| id AA22703; Sun, 12 Sep 93 17:39:42 -0700 | |
| Received: from cxxxxx.ic.xxxxxx.edu by anon.penet.fi (5.67/1.35) | |
| ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ | |
| id AA24832; Mon, 13 Sep 93 03:39:00 +0300 | |
| From: babycopperfield@haha.com | |
| Message-Id: <9309130039.AA24832@anon.penet.fi> | |
| Return-Path: <babycopperfield@haha.com> | |
| Date: Fri 13 Dec 66 00:00:00 | |
| To: <vfr@netcom.com> (Sara) | |
| Subject: I know you are on... | |
| Status: OR | |
| hi! | |
| i know you are logged on now... | |
| shame we cannot talk,, you know friendly discussions ha ha.. | |
| i might call to your bbs.. can i upload your gif picture?? | |
| yes? | |
| if i like you you might just get lucky ... | |
| Love me. | |
| ------ | |
| More of his article.. | |
| I am doing this to stop the lies and corruption fostered by | |
| the Anti-Virus industry. | |
| --------- | |
| What do you think? Is he doing -this- to stop the lies and | |
| corruption? It seems to me that the anti-virus industry would benefit | |
| from the Dark Avenger coming back onto the scene. They could sell more | |
| software, get the whole hacking community attacked by people who are | |
| afraid enough already. Why we could get a whole entire Legion of Virus | |
| Fighters up in arms, eh? | |
| If Kohntark wanted to do this 'stopping of lies and corruption', he would | |
| not be helping to recreate the myth of the Dark Avenger. He would not be | |
| impersonating him, harassing me, and telling people (impersonating Dark Avenger) | |
| that he will still release viruses into the wild. I also do not like lies and | |
| corruption, and work very hard to stop it. I do not profit from it in any | |
| substantial way. | |
| I run a free BBS: I distribute anti-virus software for free, and | |
| encourage people to choose software that will work for them in their | |
| situation. I don't go for the big scare tactics used by some companies, | |
| and I don't recommend those products. Not only because I don't like | |
| their marketing, but because their products are not as | |
| efficient/accurate as other products. I don't like that we have to have | |
| these products, but we do. It's a fact of life. If we can educate people | |
| on the real situation with viruses, we can stop a lot of this "Let's get | |
| those bad virus writers" before it's too late. We don't need another | |
| Dark Avenger. We don't need laws that will infringe on our freedoms. | |
| If anyone takes this "Sara and the Dark Avenger scam" even half-way | |
| seriously, they can email me, and ask me whatever specific questions | |
| they like. I also have a suggestion here, one that might even lead to | |
| some sort of agreement between this Kohntark and the rest of the hacker | |
| community that does not support lies and harassment. You call Todorov, | |
| e-mail or call Bontchev. Ask them. I'll come to HoHoCon (if someone buys | |
| me a ticket; although Kohntark thinks I had better look for a job, the | |
| fact is I don't have a real job), and compile the bomber source code | |
| and MtE Source (not the pitiful disassemblies that appear on a lot of | |
| BBS, but the REAL source, supplied to me by <dav> when I questioned HIM | |
| to make sure he was the "Real Thing". I'll show you step by step how it | |
| compiles flawlessly and works. If after you confirm that to the best of | |
| your knowledge, what I am saying is true, then I think Kohntark owes me | |
| an apology. And, an apology to the rest of the virus writers and hackers | |
| who do not need or deserve to be portrayed as evil demented creatures | |
| who are waiting to "Destroy the World". | |