A dimly lit, messy bedroom. Batman, wearing his grey and black suit, cowl, and yellow utility belt, is lying in a queen-sized bed under a blue comforter, propped up on two pillows. He is smiling softly and looking to his right. Next to him is Big Bird, the large yellow bird with orange legs, also lying in the bed, snuggling into Batman's side. Big Bird is smiling serenely. A bedside table with a lamp and a glass of water is on Batman's side of the bed. The room is messy, with clothes strewn on the floor and books piled on the bedside table. The scene is heartwarming and humorous, highlighting the unlikely friendship between the two characters.

The enhanced image successfully implements the major changes requested in the prompt: Batman and Big Bird are now in a queen-sized bed, under a blue comforter, with a bedside table, lamp, and glass of water present. The background is changed from a cityscape to a bedroom, as required. Both characters are smiling and the scene is heartwarming and humorous, matching the prompt's tone. However, there are several notable discrepancies: (1) The room is not messy as specified—there are no clothes on the floor and the overall impression is tidy. (2) The lighting is not dim; the room is well-lit by the lamp. (3) Batman's gaze is not to his right (towards Big Bird), but rather towards the viewer. (4) Big Bird is not explicitly snuggling into Batman's side, just lying parallel. These are moderate deviations from the prompt, but the core concept and most visual elements are present. There are no unrequested changes outside the scope of the prompt, and the visual consistency is maintained. Therefore, the image is mostly faithful to the prompt but misses some key details, warranting a score of 0.7.


A dramatic, wide-angle shot of a lightning bolt striking Batman as he flies over a nighttime cityscape, with Big Bird flying next to him. Batman is in a grey and black suit with a yellow utility belt, cape billowing behind him, and a determined expression. Big Bird, the large yellow bird with orange and pink striped legs, looks startled and slightly singed. The lightning bolt is a bright, jagged line connecting the sky to Batman, with sparks and energy crackling around him. The cityscape below is dark, with twinkling lights, creating a sense of scale and danger. The overall mood is chaotic and humorous, blending the dark, serious tone of Batman with the whimsical presence of Big Bird.

The generated image closely follows the prompt in most respects: it depicts Batman and Big Bird flying over a nighttime cityscape, with Batman in the correct suit and pose, and Big Bird with the correct coloration and expression. The cityscape, mood, and overall composition are accurate, and the addition of the lightning bolt is present, adding the requested drama and chaos. However, there are a few notable discrepancies: (1) Big Bird is supposed to look 'slightly singed,' but there are no visual cues of singeing; (2) the lightning bolt is very close to Batman but does not clearly make contact or 'strike' him as specified; (3) Batman's expression is focused but not explicitly 'determined' as described in the prompt. There are no unwarranted changes to faces or the background, and the image remains visually consistent and faithful to the original outside the modified regions. These issues are relatively minor but do prevent a perfect score, as two key prompt details (the singeing and the direct lightning strike) are not fully realized.


A dynamic, wide-angle shot of Batman diving through the night sky to catch Big Bird, who is falling from the top of a skyscraper. Big Bird, the large yellow bird with pink eyebrows, is flailing with a terrified expression. Batman, in his classic dark grey and black suit with a flowing cape, swoops heroically towards Big Bird, arms outstretched. The backdrop is a sprawling cityscape at night, with twinkling lights and towering buildings. The scene is dramatic and humorous, playing on the contrast between the gritty superhero and the innocent children's character.

The generated image closely follows the prompt: it features a dynamic, wide-angle shot of Batman diving through the night sky to catch Big Bird, who is falling above a sprawling cityscape at night. Batman is depicted in his classic suit, swooping heroically with arms outstretched, and Big Bird is airborne, flailing with a distressed expression. The cityscape is visually consistent with the prompt, with twinkling lights and towering buildings. However, there are minor discrepancies: Big Bird's expression is more distressed or surprised than explicitly terrified, his flailing is somewhat stiff, and the image does not make it explicit that he is falling from the top of a skyscraper—he is simply airborne above the city. There are also slight changes to Big Bird's facial features and the spatial relationship to the background, but these are in service of the prompt's action and do not constitute major unrequested edits. Overall, the image is highly faithful to the prompt, with only minor deviations in expression nuance and pose dynamism.


A gritty, noir-style close-up shot of Big Bird from Sesame Street, sitting at a wooden table covered in hot dogs slathered in ketchup. Big Bird, with his signature yellow feathers and wide, innocent eyes, stares intently at a small, toy pistol lying amidst the ketchup-covered hot dogs. His expression is one of deep contemplation, a furrow in his brow suggesting a weighty decision. The lighting is dim, casting long shadows across the table and emphasizing the gravity of the scene. The background is blurred, focusing all attention on Big Bird and the pistol. The overall tone is a darkly humorous juxtaposition of childhood innocence and adult themes.

The generated image follows the prompt in several key aspects: it adopts a gritty, noir style with dim lighting and deep shadows, focuses attention on Big Bird and the pistol, and creates a darkly humorous juxtaposition by placing Big Bird in a serious, adult-themed scenario with hot dogs and a gun. The background is blurred and dark, as requested, and the table is covered in ketchup-slathered hot dogs. However, there are notable deviations from the prompt: (1) Big Bird's expression is not as specified—his eyes are half-closed and droopy, lacking the 'wide, innocent eyes' and 'deep contemplation' with a furrowed brow; (2) the pistol appears to be a realistic semi-automatic rather than a toy, which changes the tone; (3) Big Bird's gaze is not intently focused on the pistol as described. While the noir mood and overall composition are well executed, these discrepancies, especially regarding Big Bird's expression and the type of pistol, are significant. The background, while more minimal than described, still serves the prompt's focus. There are no major unrequested changes outside the specified modifications, but the missed details in expression and prop accuracy prevent a perfect score.


Big Bird, the large yellow bird-like Muppet with orange striped legs, is standing in a messy room holding a sign that reads "I'll be fine." In the new image, Big Bird is sitting at a table covered in half-eaten chili dogs. He is holding a chili dog in his hand, about to take a bite, with chili sauce smeared all over his face. He has a manic, unhinged look in his eyes. The sign that he was holding in the original image is now lying on the table, covered in chili sauce.

The generated image follows the prompt exactly: Big Bird is now sitting at a table covered in half-eaten chili dogs, holding a chili dog, with chili sauce smeared on his face, and displaying a manic, unhinged look. The sign from the original image is now on the table, covered in chili sauce, as requested. The background remains consistent with the original messy room, with only minor changes due to the new composition (Big Bird sitting at a table instead of standing). There are no unrequested changes or omissions, and all requested changes are present and accurately depicted. Visual consistency and realism are maintained within the context of the prompt.


A surreal scene in a heavenly realm. Michael Jackson, with his signature black curly hair, fair skin, and wearing a white button-down shirt with red armbands and black pants with a chain, is standing and looking down with concern. Jesus, with long brown hair and a beard, wearing a white robe, is also looking down with compassion. Both of their hands are gently placed on the shoulders of a frail, elderly man with sunken eyes and thin hair, who is seated and looking up with hope. Oprah Winfrey, a Black woman with short hair, wearing a bright, colorful dress, stands beside Michael Jackson, holding a microphone and beaming at the camera, ready to interview the man about his miraculous transformation. The background is bathed in a warm, golden light, emphasizing the divine and hopeful atmosphere.

The enhanced image fails to follow several core instructions from the prompt. Most critically, the frail, elderly man—who is the emotional and narrative focus of the scene—is entirely missing. Michael Jackson and Jesus are not interacting with this man as described; instead, Jesus is seated and interacting with Oprah, and Michael Jackson is not showing concern or touching anyone. Oprah is interviewing Jesus, not the elderly man. The expressions and poses of Michael Jackson and Jesus are altered in ways that contradict the prompt (aloof/confident and annoyed/bewildered, rather than concerned and compassionate). The background loses the intended depth and celestial atmosphere, becoming a flat yellow. While the characters' basic appearances and Oprah's likeness are somewhat preserved, the scene's composition, emotional tone, and narrative are fundamentally changed. There are also unwarranted facial and background changes. Given these significant deviations, but with some visual elements (character identities, some clothing) still present, the image is only partially relevant and coherent, but misses the main point of the prompt.


A wide shot of a wedding ceremony at sunset. The bride is a young, slender white woman with long auburn hair, wearing a white strapless wedding dress. She is looking up at her groom, who is Godzilla, wearing a black tuxedo with a bow tie. They are holding hands. The officiant is a middle-aged white man with glasses, wearing a white robe with a gold cross. He is holding a book and looking at the couple. A crowd of yellow Minions in tuxedos and bow ties are in the background, cheering and throwing rice.

The generated image closely follows the prompt: Godzilla as the groom in a tuxedo, the bride as a young white woman in a strapless dress, the officiant as a middle-aged white man in a white robe with a gold cross, and a crowd of Minions in tuxedos in the background. The Minions are depicted with some variety in expression, but not all are overtly cheering as specified; some look neutral or surprised. The image includes white specks resembling rice, fulfilling the 'throwing rice' instruction. The only unrequested change is the addition of bokeh lights in the background, which is minor and does not detract from the main scene. All other elements are preserved and visually consistent. The only significant shortcoming is that not all Minions are clearly 'cheering,' but the rest of the prompt is met with high fidelity and no unwarranted edits to the main subjects.


A portrait of a Caucasian man with long, wavy graying hair and a beard, wearing a tan robe and a gray shirt, staring intensely forward. He now has a lit cigarette in his mouth, smoke curling upwards. The lighting is dramatic, emphasizing his facial features and the smoke.

The enhanced image precisely matches the prompt: the man is depicted with the correct hair, beard, and clothing, and is staring intensely forward. The addition of the lit cigarette and curling smoke is executed as requested, with the smoke and cigarette rendered realistically and dramatically. The lighting remains dramatic and consistent with the original, emphasizing both the man's features and the smoke, as specified. There are no unrequested changes to the man's face, clothing, or background, aside from the natural adjustments needed to accommodate the cigarette. The background remains faithful to the original, with the only new element being the smoke, which is directly prompted. All instructions are followed, and no unnecessary alterations are made.


A surreal scene bathed in golden light. On the left, Michael Jackson, with his signature black curly hair, fair skin, and wearing a white button-down shirt with red armbands and black pants with a chain, is looking down with concern. Next to him, Jesus, with long brown hair and a beard, wearing a white robe, also looks down with compassion. Both have their hands gently placed on a frail, elderly man with sunken eyes and visible ribs, wrapped in a white cloth. Emerging from behind Jesus, Shrek, the green ogre from the animated movie, with his signature green skin, large ears, and brown vest, is also placing a large, comforting hand on the elderly man's shoulder, his face a mixture of confusion and empathy. The background is a soft, diffused golden glow, emphasizing the divine and unexpected nature of the scene. The composition is dramatic, highlighting the contrast between the iconic figures and the vulnerable man, with Shrek's presence adding a layer of absurd humor.

The enhanced image closely follows the prompt: Michael Jackson, Jesus, and the frail elderly man are all depicted as described, with correct poses, attire, and expressions. Shrek is added in the correct position, with his signature features and a brown vest. The background remains a soft, diffused golden glow, as requested. The only discrepancies are minor: Shrek's facial expression is more empathetic and sad rather than a mix of confusion and empathy, and he is wearing a white shirt under his vest, which was not specified in the prompt but is not a significant deviation. There are no unwarranted changes to the other characters or the background. These are small issues that do not significantly detract from the overall fidelity to the prompt, but they do prevent a perfect score.


A surreal, dreamlike sky scene, bathed in shades of blue and cyan, with soft, out-of-focus light flares creating a sense of ethereal wonder. In the midst of this heavenly scene, add a depiction of Jesus Christ, with long brown hair and a beard, wearing traditional white robes. He should be standing with his arms outstretched in a gesture of blessing, his face radiating serenity and compassion. The overall effect should be a blend of the abstract and the divine, creating a powerful and moving image.

The generated image closely follows the prompt in most respects: it features a depiction of Jesus Christ with long brown hair, a beard, and white robes, standing with arms outstretched in a gesture of blessing, and his face radiates serenity and compassion. The background is bathed in blue and cyan tones with soft, out-of-focus light flares, maintaining the ethereal, dreamlike quality. However, the main discrepancy is that the background, instead of remaining abstract and purely composed of gradients and bokeh effects as in the original, now includes distinct, fluffy white clouds. This makes the scene more literal (a sky with clouds) and less abstract than the prompt's request for a "blend of the abstract and the divine." While this is a minor deviation, it does shift the image away from the fully abstract, surreal base that was specified. There are no unwarranted changes to Jesus' depiction, and the overall effect remains powerful and moving, as requested. The only notable issue is the reduced abstraction in the background, which is a moderate but not severe deviation from the prompt.


Kim Kardashian, with long black hair and a black corset dress, Oprah, with her signature glasses and afro, Beyonce, with long blonde hair and a blue dress, and Rihanna, with long black hair and a gold dress, all stand shoulder to shoulder on a red carpet, giving a synchronized, unimpressed side-eye to the camera, as if they just heard the worst joke ever. The background is a swarm of paparazzi flashes. High fashion meets meme-worthy disdain.

The enhanced image fails to follow several key instructions from the prompt. Most notably, Rihanna is entirely omitted and replaced by a second Kim Kardashian, which is a major error in subject identity. The facial expressions do not match the prompt's request for a synchronized, unimpressed side-eye; instead, the women look directly forward with neutral or serious expressions, missing the meme-worthy disdain. There are also unrequested changes, such as Beyoncé's skin tone being lightened and the addition of hand-holding between two subjects, which was not specified. The background is mostly accurate, with a red carpet and paparazzi flashes, though it includes more detail than requested. While the setting and some fashion elements are correct, the major errors in subject identity and expression, as well as the unrequested changes, significantly reduce the image's accuracy. The image is coherent and relevant to the prompt's theme, but it falls short in faithfully executing the specific instructions and preserving the correct identities and expressions.


A wide shot of a confused-looking Black man in a tuxedo and bow tie, with a clean-shaven head, and a goatee. He is surrounded by a crowd of clowns in red suits with white collars and colorful wigs. The clowns are throwing rubber chickens in the air. The man no longer has a crown on his head.

The generated image follows the prompt closely: the Black man (Shaquille O'Neal) is present, in a tuxedo and bow tie, with a clean-shaven head and goatee, and the crown has been removed as requested. The crowd of clowns in red suits with white collars and colorful wigs is present, and the clowns are now throwing yellow, chicken-shaped objects, which aligns with the prompt's request for 'rubber chickens.' The setting and lighting remain consistent. However, there are some minor unwarranted changes: the man's facial features are subtly softened, losing some angularity and detail, and the blue cone-shaped objects originally being thrown by the clowns have been removed, even though the prompt did not specify their removal. These changes are relatively minor and do not significantly detract from the overall fidelity to the prompt, but they do prevent a perfect score.


A photo of Simon Cowell, a white man with short dark hair, wearing a white shirt and black suit jacket, sitting at a desk with a microphone in front of him. He is smirking and pointing at a large red button on the desk in front of him. Change the text on the button to read "not him". Do not change anything else about the image. Keep it exactly the same.

The prompt specifically requested only one change: to alter the text on the red button to read 'not him' and to keep everything else in the image exactly the same. According to the vivid description, the enhanced image made this exact change: the button's text was changed from 'CUM' to 'not him' in white, sans-serif lowercase letters. All other aspects of the image—including Simon Cowell's appearance, pose, facial expression, attire, the microphone, the desk, and the background—remained unchanged and faithful to the original. There were no unwarranted changes or discrepancies. The generation perfectly matches the prompt's requirements and constraints.


A photo of Simon Cowell, a middle-aged white man with short dark hair, wearing a white shirt and black suit jacket, sitting at a desk with a microphone in front of him, with a crowd of people in the background. He is leaning forward, with his right index finger pointing at a large red button on the desk in front of him. Change the text on the button to read "not him". Do not change anything else about the image. Keep it exactly the same.

The prompt requested only one change: to alter the text on the red button to read "not him" and to keep everything else in the image exactly the same. According to the vivid description, the enhanced image fulfills this request precisely. The button text is now "NOT HIM" in white capital letters, and all other aspects of the image—including Simon Cowell's appearance, pose, facial expression, the microphone, and the background—remain unchanged. There are no unwarranted edits or discrepancies. The generation is visually faithful to the original image outside the modified region and implements the requested change exactly as specified.


A photo of Simon Cowell, a middle-aged white man wearing a black suit and white shirt, sitting at a desk with a microphone in front of him. He is smirking and pointing at a large red button on the desk. The button should now have the text "not him" on it. The background is dark and out of focus, with indistinct figures visible. The lighting is bright and focused on Simon Cowell and the button. The overall style is realistic and slightly humorous.

The prompt specifically requested that the button display the text "not him". In the generated image, the button instead displays two lines: "not" on the upper line and "not him" on the lower line, introducing an extra "not" that was not specified. All other aspects of the image—Simon's appearance, pose, clothing, the desk, microphone, background, and lighting—are accurate and unchanged from the original, as requested. The only deviation is the extra word on the button. This is a minor but clear inaccuracy, as the prompt was explicit about the button text. However, the error is limited in scope and does not affect the rest of the image, which remains faithful to the prompt and original. Therefore, the image is very close to perfect, but not exact.


A surreal image of Chuck Norris in a kitchen, but instead of a normal background, the kitchen is engulfed in flames. Chuck Norris, a middle-aged white man with a beard, is wearing a black t-shirt and pointing directly at the viewer with a serious expression. He is wearing a large ring on his finger. The kitchen around him is filled with levitating cookware, fruit, and a sentient piece of toast with googly eyes running on the stove. The background is now a raging inferno, with flames licking at the edges of the frame, but Chuck Norris remains untouched by the fire. The overall tone is humorous and over-the-top, playing on Chuck Norris's invincible persona.

The generated image captures several key elements from the prompt: Chuck Norris is present, with a serious expression, black t-shirt, and a large ring, pointing at the viewer. The humorous, over-the-top tone is maintained, and the sentient toast with googly eyes is still running. The kitchen is depicted as engulfed in flames, and some levitating cookware and fruit are present. However, there are notable discrepancies: (1) The kitchen structure (cabinets, counters, appliances) is missing, replaced by a wall of fire, whereas the prompt implies the kitchen should still be visible but on fire. (2) The number of levitating items is reduced, so the kitchen is not as 'filled' as described. (3) There are minor, unwarranted changes to Chuck Norris's facial features, making him look slightly younger and less intense. These issues mean the image does not fully meet the prompt's requirements, but it is still clearly based on the prompt and mostly faithful to the intended scene and tone. The changes are significant but not so severe as to make the image irrelevant or incoherent. Therefore, a score of 0.7 is appropriate.


A photo of Chuck Norris, a middle-aged white man with a beard, wearing a black t-shirt and a gold ring, pointing directly at the viewer, but he is standing in the middle of a chaotic, cartoonish kitchen. Pots and pans are flying everywhere, a blender is exploding with fruit smoothie, and a sentient loaf of bread is running away in terror. Chuck Norris's expression is stern and unwavering amidst the chaos, as if he is the only force holding the kitchen together. The scene is brightly lit and hyper-detailed, with a sense of comedic urgency.

The generated image closely follows the prompt: Chuck Norris is accurately depicted (middle-aged, white, beard, black t-shirt, gold ring, stern expression, pointing at the viewer). The chaotic, cartoonish kitchen is present, with flying pots and pans, a blender with fruit smoothie splashing out, and a sentient loaf of bread running. The scene is brightly lit and hyper-detailed, with a comedic sense of urgency. The only notable discrepancies are that the blender's 'explosion' is more of a vigorous spill, and the bread's expression is not one of terror but rather a smile or bewilderment. There are no unwarranted changes to Chuck Norris or the background. These are minor deviations from the prompt, but the overall fidelity is very high. Therefore, a small deduction is warranted, but the image is otherwise excellent.


In a post-apocalyptic wasteland, reimagine the wedding scene. Godzilla, still in his black tuxedo, now holds a makeshift weapon, like a rusty pipe, and has a grim, determined expression. The Caucasian woman in the white wedding dress now wears tattered clothing and holds a scavenged weapon, her face showing a mix of fear and resolve. The Caucasian priest, still in his robes, clutches his bible tightly, looking warily around at the ruined cityscape. The background features crumbling buildings, plumes of smoke, and a tense, overcast sky, with debris scattered around their feet. The overall lighting is dark and moody, emphasizing the survival mood.

The generated image follows the prompt closely in terms of setting, mood, and the transformation of the main characters. Godzilla is in a tuxedo, holding a makeshift weapon, and has a grim, determined expression. The woman is in tattered clothing, holding scavenged weapons, and the background is a ruined cityscape with dark, moody lighting and debris, all as requested. However, there are notable issues: the priest is completely missing, which is a significant omission since the prompt explicitly required his presence and specific actions. Godzilla's weapon is not clearly a 'rusty pipe' as suggested, and the woman's expression is more fear/shock than a 'mix of fear and resolve.' There are also some unwarranted changes to facial features, making them more intense than described. Despite these issues, the image is highly faithful to the prompt in most respects, especially the setting and overall mood, but the absence of the priest is a major flaw. This warrants a significant deduction, but not a failing score, as the core scene and transformation are otherwise well executed.


A wide-angle shot of a man with brown hair, a beard, and wearing a white robe with a red sash, now with a comical expression of shock and disbelief, staring at a plate piled high with a mountain of nachos in a modern kitchen. The nachos are overflowing with melted cheese, jalapeños, guacamole, sour cream, and black olives. The kitchen background includes stainless steel appliances and light wood cabinets. The lighting is bright and slightly overexposed, emphasizing the absurdity of the situation. The overall scene is comedic and exaggerated, playing on the man's reaction to the unexpected and indulgent snack.

The generated image closely follows the prompt in most respects: the man is in a modern kitchen with stainless steel appliances and light wood cabinets, the lighting is bright, and the scene is comedic and exaggerated. The plate of nachos is accurately depicted with all the specified toppings. The man's expression is comically shocked and exaggerated, matching the prompt's request for a 'comical expression of shock and disbelief.' The only significant deviation is the absence of the red sash, which is explicitly requested in the prompt but missing in the generated image. There are no unwarranted changes to the background or other elements. The facial expression, while more exaggerated than the original, aligns with the prompt's intent. The missing red sash is a notable but singular omission, so the image is very close to perfect but not fully accurate.


A full shot of Godzilla, the iconic monster, sitting on a standard white toilet in a tiled bathroom. His blue denim pants are bunched around his ankles. His face is contorted in a grimace of pain and discomfort. His large, clawed hands are clenched on his stomach. The scene is lit with bright, sterile bathroom lighting, emphasizing the absurdity and discomfort of the situation. The style is a blend of hyperrealism and cartoonish exaggeration, creating a humorous and slightly disturbing image.

The enhanced image follows the prompt closely in most respects: Godzilla is seated on a standard white toilet in a tiled, brightly lit bathroom, with blue denim pants around his ankles, and his hands are clenched on his stomach. The style is a blend of hyperrealism and cartoonish exaggeration, as requested. The main discrepancies are: (1) the facial expression is more exaggerated than the prompt's 'grimace of pain and discomfort,' instead showing an over-the-top scream or roar, which, while cartoonish, may go beyond the intended discomfort to outright agony; (2) the toilet paper holder and roll are missing from the background, which, while not specified in the prompt, is an unrequested change from the original image. These issues are relatively minor: the exaggeration of the facial expression arguably fits the 'cartoonish exaggeration' part of the prompt, though it may be a bit too extreme, and the missing toilet paper is a small background detail. The rest of the image is faithful to the prompt and original outside the modified regions. Therefore, the image is very close to perfect, with only minor deviations.


A wide shot of a Black man in a tuxedo and bow tie standing in front of a crowd of clowns. The man has a slightly confused expression on his face. The man is no longer wearing the crown. The clowns are wearing red suits and have colorful wigs and makeup. Some of the clowns are throwing rubber chickens in the air. The background is a dark red color. The lighting is bright and theatrical. The image should be humorous and slightly surreal.

The enhanced image successfully implements some key elements of the prompt: the Black man is no longer wearing the crown, he is in a tuxedo and bow tie, and the background is filled with clowns in red suits with colorful wigs and makeup. The background color and lighting are also consistent with the prompt's request for a dark red, theatrical, and surreal atmosphere. However, there are notable shortcomings: the man's facial expression is not 'slightly confused' as requested, but rather neutral or slightly annoyed, which is a significant deviation from the prompt. Additionally, while more objects are being thrown in the air and they are more elongated, they are still not clearly identifiable as rubber chickens, which was a specific instruction. There are also minor unwarranted changes, such as the alteration of the blue conical object held by a clown. Despite these issues, the image remains largely faithful to the prompt in terms of composition, setting, and overall mood, but misses some important details and introduces minor unrequested changes.


A wide-angle shot of a Black man, wearing a tuxedo with a bow tie, his eyes wide with disbelief, staring directly at the camera as he is being crowned the new CEO of a failing clown college. The background is a chaotic graduation ceremony filled with clowns juggling rubber chickens and honking horns. The scene is lit with bright, theatrical lighting, emphasizing the man's bewildered expression. The image should have a surreal, comedic tone, reminiscent of a Terry Gilliam film.

The generated image follows the prompt in several key ways: it is a wide-angle shot, features a Black man in a tuxedo with a bow tie, and captures his wide-eyed, bewildered expression. The background is chaotic and filled with clowns, and the lighting is bright and theatrical, matching the surreal, comedic tone reminiscent of a Terry Gilliam film. However, there are notable discrepancies: the man is already wearing a crown rather than being actively crowned, which misses a central action from the prompt. The background, while chaotic and clown-filled, lacks the specific details of clowns juggling rubber chickens and honking horns—these are not clearly depicted. The atmosphere does not visually suggest a 'failing' clown college, as the scene appears vibrant and well-lit. There are also minor, unwarranted changes to the man's facial features (slightly rounder face, smoother skin, less pronounced wrinkles) and the addition of a blue party hat in the background, which was not requested. Despite these issues, the image is largely faithful to the prompt's main elements and tone, but misses some important specifics and introduces minor unrequested changes.


A medium shot of a Black man, formerly the President of the United States, with short graying hair, pointing directly at the viewer with an open mouth. He is wearing a large, gaudy gold chain around his neck and no shirt. The background is a dark, solid color. The image is high-resolution and humorous.

The generated image closely follows the prompt: it shows a Black man resembling Barack Obama, shirtless, wearing large gold chains, pointing at the viewer with an open mouth, and set against a solid dark background. All major prompt requirements are met. However, there are some unwarranted changes to the facial features and hair: the hair is much shorter and lighter than described, the eyes are more exaggerated, and the skin tone is lighter and smoother. These changes, while not requested, do not fundamentally alter the subject's identity or the humorous intent, but they do detract from perfect fidelity to the original and prompt. The background is accurate, and the overall composition is consistent with the instructions. Given that the main elements are present and the changes are mostly subtle (though noticeable), a small deduction is warranted.


A medium shot of a furious Barack Obama, an African American man with short grey hair, wearing a dark suit and blue tie, pointing directly at the viewer with a stern expression. He is standing in a dimly lit room with a red curtain in the background. The scene is dramatically lit, emphasizing the intensity of his gaze. The background is now a chaotic scene of a messy kitchen with overflowing trash cans, dirty dishes piled high, and food splattered everywhere. Obama is pointing at the mess with an expression of utter disbelief and exasperation. The overall tone is humorous and exaggerated, playing on the contrast between Obama's composed demeanor and the chaotic environment.

The generated image successfully implements the major requested change: transforming the background into a chaotic, messy kitchen with overflowing trash cans, dirty dishes, and food splatters, as described in the prompt. The overall composition, Obama's pose, and his attire (dark suit, blue tie, American flag pin) are preserved, and he is pointing at the mess, which aligns with the prompt. However, there are two significant shortcomings: (1) Obama's facial expression does not fully convey the 'utter disbelief and exasperation' or 'furious' tone requested, instead remaining merely stern and slightly annoyed; (2) the lighting in the scene is not 'dramatic' as specified, but rather flat and bright, which diminishes the intended intensity and humor. Additionally, Obama's face is subtly smoothed and less textured, losing some of the original's realism and intensity, though his overall appearance is still recognizable. These issues mean the image is coherent and relevant, and most major prompt elements are present, but the emotional tone and lighting are not fully accurate, and there are some minor unrequested changes to facial detail. This places the image between a perfect (1.0) and a partial (0.5) score, but since the main elements are present and the errors are significant but not overwhelming, a score of 0.7 is appropriate.


A courtroom scene with Barack Obama, an African American man wearing a black judge's robe and a blue tie, standing behind a wooden bench, wielding an enormous, cartoonishly oversized wooden mallet, slamming it down with exaggerated force. The courtroom is packed with bewildered onlookers, some wearing "Make America Great Again" hats, all staring in disbelief. The scene is lit dramatically, with a spotlight on Obama and the giant mallet. The overall tone is satirical and humorous, reminiscent of a scene from a Terry Gilliam movie.

The enhanced image follows the prompt closely in several key areas: Barack Obama is depicted as an African American man in a judge's robe with a blue tie, standing behind a wooden bench, wielding a cartoonishly oversized gavel. The scene is satirical and humorous, with dramatic spotlighting reminiscent of a Terry Gilliam movie. The addition of bewildered onlookers, some wearing MAGA hats, aligns with the prompt's request for a packed courtroom of shocked spectators. The lighting and overall tone are also consistent with the prompt's instructions.

However, there are some discrepancies. The most notable is that Obama is not shown actively slamming the gavel down with exaggerated force, as specified in the prompt; instead, he is holding it out in front of him. The courtroom, while containing onlookers, is not visibly 'packed'—there is only a single row of onlookers, not a full crowd. There are also some unrequested changes: Obama's facial structure is subtly altered, his skin tone is slightly lighter, and the background is more elaborate than in the original image. These changes, however, generally serve to enhance the satirical and dramatic effect requested by the prompt, rather than detract from it.

Overall, the image implements most of the requested changes and maintains the intended tone, but falls short in the specific action of the gavel and the fullness of the courtroom. The unrequested changes are minor and do not significantly detract from prompt fidelity. Therefore, a score of 0.8 is appropriate.


A courtroom scene with Barack Obama, an African American man wearing a black judge's robe and a blue tie, standing behind a wooden bench, wielding an absolutely gigantic, comically oversized wooden mallet. His face is contorted in a comical expression of exaggerated exertion as he brings the mallet down with full force. The courtroom is packed with onlookers, their faces a mix of shock, amusement, and disbelief. The scene is lit with bright, theatrical lighting, emphasizing the absurdity of the situation. The style is hyperrealistic with a touch of cartoonish exaggeration.

The generated image closely follows the prompt: Barack Obama is depicted in a black judge's robe and blue tie, standing behind a wooden bench, wielding a gigantic, comically oversized mallet. His facial expression is exaggerated as requested, and the courtroom is packed with onlookers whose faces show shock, amusement, and disbelief. The lighting is bright and theatrical, and the style is hyperrealistic with cartoonish exaggeration. The only notable discrepancies are that the cartoonish exaggeration is more pronounced than the 'touch' specified in the prompt, and there are some subtle, unwarranted changes to Obama's facial features (slightly lighter skin tone, broader face, slightly altered hairline). However, these changes are relatively minor and do not significantly detract from the overall fidelity to the prompt. There are no unwarranted changes to the background, and all major prompt elements are present and well-executed. Given these factors, the image is highly accurate with only minor deviations.


A courtroom scene featuring Barack Obama, an African American man, dressed in a black judge's robe and a blue tie, standing behind a wooden bench. He is swinging an absurdly oversized wooden mallet with both hands, his face contorted in a comical expression of exaggerated effort. The courtroom is filled with cartoonishly terrified jurors and lawyers, all cowering under their desks. The scene is lit with dramatic, theatrical lighting, emphasizing the absurdity of the situation. The style is a blend of photorealism and cartoonish exaggeration, aiming for a humorous and surreal effect.

The generated image follows the prompt in several key ways: Barack Obama is depicted as a judge in a courtroom, wearing the correct attire, and holding an absurdly oversized mallet. The courtroom is filled with cartoonishly terrified jurors and lawyers, and the lighting is dramatic and theatrical, emphasizing the absurdity. The style is a blend of photorealism and cartoonish exaggeration, as requested. However, there are notable discrepancies: (1) Obama is holding the mallet above his head, poised to strike, rather than actively swinging it as the prompt specifies. (2) Not all jurors and lawyers are cowering under their desks as the prompt requests; many are simply reacting with fear from their seats. (3) The facial features of Obama are more exaggerated and caricatured than the prompt's blend of photorealism and cartoonish exaggeration might suggest, losing some of the original's realism. (4) The background is more ornate and populated than the original, but this aligns with the prompt's request for a filled courtroom. Overall, the image captures the spirit and most details of the prompt, but misses on some specific actions and over-exaggerates the facial features, moving away from the photorealistic aspect. There are also some unrequested changes in facial structure and background complexity, but these are not egregious. The image is visually coherent and relevant, but falls short of full fidelity to the prompt.


Here is your prompt:

A high-resolution, comical image of Barack Obama, an African-American man with short hair, wearing a navy blue suit with an American flag pin and a light blue tie, standing against a stark white background. He is pointing directly at the viewer with a serious expression, but now he's standing in a courtroom, dressed as a judge in a black robe, holding a comically oversized gavel. The gavel is mid-swing, about to slam down on a stack of pancakes on the judge's bench. The pancakes are dripping with syrup and have a pat of butter melting on top. The scene is brightly lit with a surreal, dreamlike quality, emphasizing the absurdity of the situation.

The generated image follows the main instructions of the prompt: Barack Obama is depicted as a judge in a courtroom, wearing a black robe, holding a comically oversized gavel, and about to slam it onto a stack of pancakes with syrup and butter. The courtroom setting is accurate, and the absurdity of the situation is present due to the oversized gavel and pancakes. However, there are notable shortcomings: (1) The prompt specifically requests a 'surreal, dreamlike quality' to the lighting and scene, but the generated image is described as more realistic and dramatically lit, lacking the intended surrealism. (2) There are several subtle but clear inaccuracies in Obama's facial features—his hair is less grey, his face is fuller, his nose and lips are altered, his eyes are smaller and further apart, and his skin tone is lighter. These changes make the likeness less accurate and do not preserve the original unmentioned elements as well as they should. Despite these issues, the image is still clearly relevant, coherent, and implements the core requested changes, with no major unrequested background alterations. Therefore, the score should reflect that the image is mostly faithful but falls short in visual fidelity and style.


A full shot of Barack Obama, an African-American man with short black hair, wearing a navy blue suit with an American flag pin, and a light blue tie, pointing directly at the viewer, now holding a rubber chicken like a pistol, his expression comically serious, set against a stark white background. The scene is lit with a dramatic, high-contrast lighting scheme, reminiscent of a film noir, emphasizing the absurdity of the situation.

The generated image follows the prompt very closely: Barack Obama is depicted in a navy blue suit with an American flag pin and a light blue tie, holding a rubber chicken like a pistol, with a comically serious expression, against a stark white background with dramatic, high-contrast lighting. All major elements from the prompt are present and executed as described. The only unwarranted changes are minor facial adjustments—slightly smoothed forehead lines, marginally wider eyes, a fuller upper lip, and a slightly softened jawline. These changes are subtle and do not significantly detract from the overall fidelity to the prompt or the original image. No unrequested changes were made to the background or clothing. The image is visually consistent and realistic, maintaining the intended absurdity and style. Given the minor nature of the facial changes, a small deduction is warranted, but overall, the image is highly accurate.


A dramatic, low-angle shot of Barack Obama, a middle-aged Black man with short hair, wearing a dark suit with an American flag pin and a light blue tie, pointing directly at the viewer with a serious expression. Behind him, looming like colossal guardians, are Shaquille O'Neal, a gigantic Black man in a basketball jersey, and Neil deGrasse Tyson, a Black astrophysicist in a tweed jacket, both looking intensely at the viewer. The background is a stark white, emphasizing the imposing figures behind Obama. The scene is lit dramatically, casting long shadows and highlighting the intensity of the moment.

The generated image closely follows the prompt in terms of character selection, attire, expressions, and background. Barack Obama is depicted as described, with accurate facial features, clothing, and pose (pointing at the viewer with a serious expression). Shaquille O'Neal and Neil deGrasse Tyson are both present, accurately rendered, and positioned behind Obama, with appropriate attire and expressions. The background remains stark white as requested. However, there are two notable shortcomings: (1) The 'dramatic, low-angle shot' is not convincingly achieved—the perspective does not make the background figures appear as 'colossal guardians' looming over Obama, but rather as large portraits behind him. (2) The lighting does not fully deliver the 'dramatic' effect with 'long shadows' as specified; instead, it remains mostly bright and even. Despite these, there are no unrequested edits or unwarranted changes to the characters or background. The main issues are with the degree of drama and perspective, not with the core content or fidelity. These shortcomings are significant but do not fundamentally undermine the prompt's intent, so a score of 0.8 is appropriate.


A wide-angle shot from above of a massive crowd of protestors holding signs in a city street, viewed through a metal railing. Add 20-30 dinosaurs of varying species and sizes into the crowd. Some dinosaurs should be wearing protest signs around their necks, others should be playfully interacting with the human protestors, and one should be comically trying to eat a protest sign. The dinosaurs should be seamlessly integrated into the crowd, maintaining the original lighting and perspective. The overall tone should be humorous and surreal, as if this is a perfectly normal occurrence.

The generated image closely follows the prompt in several key aspects: it maintains the original wide-angle, high-angle perspective of a massive protest crowd in a city street, viewed through a metal railing. The addition of 20-30 dinosaurs of varying species and sizes is well executed, with dinosaurs of different colors and types scattered throughout the crowd. Some dinosaurs are wearing protest signs around their necks, and there is at least one instance of a human interacting with a dinosaur (sitting on its back). The lighting, perspective, and background are all preserved, and the overall tone is humorous and surreal, as requested. However, there are two notable shortcomings: (1) the prompt specifically asked for dinosaurs to be 'playfully interacting' with human protestors, which is only minimally depicted (one human on a dinosaur's back, but not widespread playful interaction), and (2) the prompt requested that one dinosaur be 'comically trying to eat a protest sign,' which is not present in the generated image. Despite these omissions, the image is otherwise highly faithful to the prompt and original image, with no unwarranted changes. These two missing prompt-specific actions prevent a perfect score, but the image is otherwise excellent.


A wide shot of three smiling Asian women taking a selfie at a fair at night. The woman on the left is wearing a white top, ripped jeans, and a black cardigan. She is holding a small brown dog. The woman in the middle is wearing a blue button-up shirt and a black New York Yankees baseball cap. The woman on the right is wearing a black crop top. Behind them is a crowded fair with a Ferris wheel and other rides lit up with colorful lights. In the sky above the fair, hundreds of light-up drones are arranged to spell out "Zedd" in large, glowing letters.

The enhanced image perfectly matches the prompt: all three women are accurately depicted with their clothing, poses, and accessories as described. The background remains faithful to the original, with the fair, Ferris wheel, and crowds intact. The only change is the addition of 'Zedd' spelled out by light-up drones in the sky, which is exactly what the prompt requested. There are no unrequested edits or alterations to faces, clothing, or the background. Visual consistency and realism are maintained throughout. This is a textbook example of a precise, prompt-aligned image generation.


Three happy Asian women are standing outside a bakery, taking a selfie. The woman in the front is wearing a black sweater and has sunglasses on her head. The woman to the left is wearing glasses and a white tank top. The woman in the back is wearing a black sweater. All three women are now wearing giant, fluffy teddy bear headbands, and they are all laughing hysterically, pointing at each other. The pastries on the table are now also wearing tiny teddy bear headbands. The background remains the same. The scene is lit with bright, cheerful sunlight.

The generated image follows the prompt very closely in most respects: all three women are present, their clothing and positions are correct, and they are all wearing giant, fluffy teddy bear headbands as requested. Their expressions have been changed to 'laughing hysterically' and they are pointing at each other, which matches the prompt. The background remains unchanged except for the lighting, which is now bright and cheerful as specified. The only significant discrepancy is that the pastries on the table are not wearing tiny teddy bear headbands, which was an explicit part of the prompt. There are no unwarranted changes to the women's facial features or the background. Because the only missed element is the teddy bear headbands on the pastries, and all other aspects are accurate, this is a minor but clear omission. Therefore, the image is very close to perfect but not fully complete.


A 2003 thriller movie poster featuring a young, light-skinned black man with curly hair, a goatee, and sunglasses, wearing a black Gucci t-shirt and silver watch. He is standing on a rooftop with a chain-link fence behind him, adjusting his sunglasses. The title of the movie is "The Algorithm," in bold, distressed font. The tagline reads: "Some secrets are better left unwritten." The background is a dark, ominous cityscape with rain and lightning. The overall tone is gritty, suspenseful, and mysterious.

The generated image perfectly matches the prompt in all key aspects. The subject's appearance, pose, clothing, and accessories are all accurately preserved from the original image, with no unwarranted changes to his facial features or attire. The background has been transformed exactly as requested, from a bright rooftop to a dark, stormy cityscape with rain and lightning, which fits the thriller movie poster aesthetic. The title and tagline are present in the correct font style and placement. The overall tone is gritty, suspenseful, and mysterious, as specified. There are no unrequested edits or deviations from the prompt, and all changes are justified and executed with visual consistency. Therefore, the image fully satisfies the criteria for a perfect score.


A surreal scene at a bustling international airport. The focus is on a young, fair-skinned man with short brown hair, standing confidently in the middle of the terminal. He's wearing a bright blue speedo, a matching blue backpack, and white sneakers. His expression is neutral, almost as if he's unaware of the chaos around him. The airport is filled with travelers of all kinds, some looking bewildered, others rushing to their gates, and a few staring in disbelief at the man in the speedo. Luggage is scattered haphazardly, and the departure boards display a mix of destinations and delays. The overall atmosphere is one of organized chaos, with a touch of absurdity due to the man's unexpected attire. The lighting is bright and fluorescent, typical of an airport, enhancing the surreal quality of the scene.

The generated image closely follows the prompt: the man is placed in a bustling international airport, wearing a bright blue speedo, matching backpack, and white sneakers. The lighting and background details (departure boards, travelers, scattered luggage) are consistent with the prompt. The overall atmosphere is bright and busy, as requested. Minor discrepancies include: (1) the man's hair is lighter and straighter than in the original, and his face is clean-shaven with less defined eyebrows, which are subtle but not specified in the prompt; (2) the man's chest and abdomen are hairless, whereas the original had prominent body hair—again, not specified in the prompt, but a notable change; (3) the expression is neutral, but the man looks directly at the camera, which slightly undermines the 'unaware' aspect; (4) the background travelers do not strongly convey 'organized chaos' or 'absurdity' as some are not reacting to the man as described. However, these are relatively minor issues. The major requested changes are implemented, and there are no significant unrequested edits outside of the subject's minor facial and body hair changes. Visual consistency and realism are maintained. Overall, the image is highly faithful to the prompt, with only small deviations.


A surreal scene: A young, hairy-chested man with fair skin, wearing a bright blue speedo, a blue backpack, and white sneakers, stands in the middle of a bustling airport terminal. He has a slightly confused expression on his face. People in business suits rush past him, pulling suitcases. Overhead, departure and arrival screens flash flight information. The overall atmosphere is one of chaotic travel, contrasting sharply with the man's casual attire and bewildered demeanor. The lighting is bright and fluorescent, typical of an airport, emphasizing the absurdity of the situation.

The generated image follows the prompt in several key ways: the man is in an airport terminal, wearing a bright blue speedo, blue backpack, and now white sneakers (as requested). The setting includes people in business suits, suitcases, and overhead screens, with bright fluorescent lighting. However, there are notable shortcomings: the man's facial expression does not clearly convey 'slightly confused' as specified, instead appearing more blank or vacant. The atmosphere is not as chaotic or bustling as described; people are present but not rushing or creating a sense of chaos. The flight information screens are blurry and not 'flashing' as described. Additionally, there are unwarranted changes to the man's facial structure, making his face rounder and less mature than in the original. Despite these issues, the core elements of the prompt are present, and the image is coherent and relevant, but it falls short of full fidelity to the prompt and original image. These issues are significant but not overwhelming, so a score of 0.7 is appropriate.


A full shot of a Caucasian male standing in a forest with a blue backpack, wearing a gray hoodie, light blue jeans, and gray sneakers. He is now wearing a tiny blue speedo and has a comically large amount of chest hair. The forest background remains the same.

The generated image follows the prompt exactly: the subject is now wearing a tiny blue speedo and has a comically large amount of chest hair, as requested. The blue backpack, gray sneakers, and the forest background are all preserved from the original image, with no unrequested changes to the face or background. The only changes made are those explicitly described in the prompt, and all other elements remain faithful to the original. There are no discrepancies or unwarranted edits. Therefore, the image fully meets the criteria for a perfect score.


A full shot of a young, white male standing in a forest clearing. He has brown hair and is wearing a grey hoodie, light blue jeans, a blue backpack, and grey sneakers. The man is now wearing a tiny, patriotic-themed speedo and has an absurd amount of chest hair that is escaping the confines of his swimwear. He is flexing his muscles and looking intensely at the camera. The forest background remains the same. The scene is lit dramatically, emphasizing the absurdity of the situation.

The generated image follows the main instructions of the prompt: the man is now wearing a tiny, patriotic-themed speedo, has an absurd amount of chest hair, is flexing his muscles, and is looking intensely at the camera. The dramatic lighting is also present, emphasizing the absurdity of the situation. However, there are notable deviations: the man's facial features are significantly altered, making him look older and more chiseled, and the original mole is missing. The background, while still a forest, is not identical to the original as requested; the arrangement and density of foliage have changed, and there is more green foliage introduced. The chest hair, while abundant, does not literally escape the confines of the speedo as described in the prompt. These changes, especially the unnecessary facial transformation and the altered background, detract from prompt fidelity, but the core absurd scenario and main visual elements are present and clear.


A surreal scene in heaven. A Caucasian man wearing a backwards baseball cap, a gray sweatshirt, jeans, and brown shoes is floating horizontally in the clouds. Next to him floats a golden harp with white wings. A cherub with a mischievous grin is playfully tugging on the man's sweatshirt, trying to pull him closer to the harp. The scene is bathed in golden light.

The generated image closely follows the prompt: the Caucasian man is floating in the clouds, wearing the correct clothing and pose, and the golden harp with white wings is present. The cherub is added as requested, with a playful expression and is tugging on the man's sweatshirt. The background and lighting are accurate and unchanged from the original, maintaining visual consistency. However, there are two minor deviations: (1) the cherub's expression is a wide, open-mouthed smile rather than a 'mischievous grin,' which is a subtle but notable difference in the intended mood; (2) the cherub's tugging action is not clearly directed toward pulling the man closer to the harp, as specified in the prompt. Additionally, there is an unwarranted detail of small brown debris falling from the cherub's feet, which was not requested. These issues are minor and do not significantly detract from the overall fidelity to the prompt, but they prevent a perfect score.


A surreal scene in Heaven, where a man in a tan shirt, jeans, and a baseball cap floats on his back through fluffy clouds, eyes closed and arms outstretched. Above him floats a bottle of beer and a golden harp with angel wings. A cherubic baby angel with curly hair, rosy cheeks, and tiny wings is now floating next to the man, offering him a tiny bottle of baby formula with a concerned expression. The scene is bathed in golden light, creating a humorous and ironic take on the afterlife.

The generated image closely follows the prompt in most respects: the man is floating in heaven with the correct attire and pose, the beer bottle and golden harp with angel wings are present, and the background is a radiant, golden, cloud-filled heaven. The main requested change—a cherubic baby angel offering a bottle of baby formula with a concerned expression—was implemented, but with two deviations: (1) there are two baby angels instead of one, and (2) the angel's expression is gentle or attentive rather than clearly concerned. The addition of a second angel is a minor but clear deviation from the prompt, and the lack of a distinctly concerned expression slightly weakens the humor/irony intended. However, all other elements are preserved, and there are no unwarranted changes to the man or the background. The image is visually consistent and faithful to the original outside the modified region. These issues are minor but prevent a perfect score.


A surreal image of a Caucasian man wearing a baseball cap, a gray sweatshirt, and jeans, floating on his back in the clouds with a golden harp with angel wings next to him. Add a floating beer bottle next to the man. The man should be reaching for the beer bottle with a look of relief on his face. The scene is bathed in golden light, creating a heavenly yet humorous atmosphere.

The enhanced image closely follows the prompt in several key aspects: the man is floating on his back in the clouds, wearing the correct clothing, with a golden harp with angel wings next to him, and a floating beer bottle has been added. The man is reaching for the beer bottle, and the overall scene maintains the golden, heavenly, and humorous atmosphere as described. However, there are two notable discrepancies: (1) The man's facial expression is not clearly one of relief as requested, since his face is mostly obscured and no specific emotion is discernible. (2) An extra, unrequested golden harp-like object (possibly a harp stand) is present, which was not mentioned in the prompt. Despite these issues, the image is otherwise faithful to the prompt and does not introduce unwarranted changes to the background or other elements. The main shortcomings are the lack of a clear 'relief' expression and the presence of an extra object, which are significant but do not fundamentally undermine the prompt's intent. Therefore, a score of 0.7 is appropriate, reflecting that most instructions were followed with some moderate deviations.


A surreal and humorous scene in the clouds, bathed in golden light. A Caucasian man with a baseball cap, wearing a gray sweatshirt and jeans, floats horizontally, arms outstretched, as if ascending to heaven. Next to him floats a golden harp with white angel wings. Add a group of chubby cherubs with rosy cheeks, curly hair, and tiny wings, surrounding the man and the harp. Some are playing miniature harps, others are blowing trumpets, and one is holding a sign that says "Wrong Way!". The cherubs should be comically exasperated and gesturing wildly at the man. The overall style should be a blend of classical painting and internet meme aesthetics, with exaggerated expressions and vibrant colors.

The generated image closely follows the prompt in most respects: the Caucasian man with a baseball cap, gray sweatshirt, and jeans floats horizontally in the clouds, arms outstretched, with a golden harp with white wings beside him. The scene is bathed in golden light, and a large group of cherubs with rosy cheeks, curly hair, and tiny wings surround the man and harp. The cherubs are depicted with exaggerated, comically exasperated expressions, and one holds a 'WRONG WAY!' sign as requested. The overall style blends classical painting and meme aesthetics, with vibrant colors and ornate details.

However, there are two notable discrepancies: (1) While many cherubs are blowing trumpets, none are playing miniature harps, which is a direct omission of a specific prompt detail. (2) The addition of ornate golden architectural elements in the background, while consistent with the classical painting style, was not explicitly requested and represents a minor unrequested change.

Despite these issues, the image is highly faithful to the prompt in terms of composition, style, and humor, with only a single clear omission (cherubs playing harps) and a minor background embellishment. These issues are not severe enough to warrant a major deduction, but they do prevent a perfect score.


A surreal, heavenly scene with a middle-aged Caucasian man wearing a backwards baseball cap, a gray sweatshirt, and jeans, floating horizontally through the clouds with his arms outstretched. Next to him floats a golden harp with white angel wings. The scene is bathed in golden light. Add a group of mischievous cherubs with rosy cheeks and tiny wings, playfully tugging at the man's sweatshirt and trying to steal the harp. The cherubs should have a variety of expressions, from gleeful to frustrated, as they attempt their heist. The background should remain a bright, ethereal expanse of clouds and golden light.

The generated image closely follows the prompt in terms of composition, characters, and setting. The man, his attire, pose, and the golden harp with angel wings are all accurately depicted. The background remains faithful to the prompt, with no unwarranted changes. The main requested addition—the group of cherubs—is present, and some are interacting with the man and the harp. However, the prompt specifically asks for the cherubs to be 'playfully tugging at the man's sweatshirt and trying to steal the harp,' with a 'variety of expressions, from gleeful to frustrated.' In the generated image, while cherubs are tugging at the man's clothing and one is reaching for the harp, their actions do not strongly convey an active 'heist' or attempt to steal the harp. Additionally, their expressions are mostly neutral or mildly mischievous, lacking the full range of emotions described in the prompt. Despite this, all other elements are accurate, and there are no unrequested changes. The main shortcoming is the insufficient expressiveness and narrative clarity in the cherubs' actions and faces, which prevents a perfect score.


A surreal, humorous, over-the-top image of a man floating in the clouds, as if he's ascended to heaven. The man, wearing a baseball cap, a gray sweatshirt, and jeans, is lying horizontally, arms outstretched, with a serene expression. Next to him floats a golden harp with white angel wings. Add a group of chubby cherubs with rosy cheeks and tiny wings, dressed in white togas, playfully tugging at the man's clothes, trying to pull him further up into the heavens. The background should remain a bright, ethereal sky with golden light streaming through fluffy white clouds. The overall tone should be lighthearted and comical, as if the cherubs are causing a bit of heavenly mischief.

The generated image follows the prompt in several key ways: it maintains the surreal, humorous, and over-the-top tone; the man is floating in the clouds, horizontally, with cherubs playfully tugging at his clothes, and the background is a bright, ethereal sky with golden light and fluffy clouds. The cherubs are accurately depicted as chubby, rosy-cheeked, and mischievous, dressed in white togas. However, there are notable discrepancies: (1) The golden harp is much larger than described, stands upright instead of floating horizontally, and lacks the explicitly requested white angel wings. (2) The man's expression is not serene as requested, but rather surprised or strained. (3) The man's shirt is more like a collared or utility shirt than a gray sweatshirt. Despite these issues, the overall composition, tone, and most elements are faithful to the prompt, and there are no unwarranted changes to the background. The main issues are with the harp's features and the man's expression/clothing, which are significant but do not fundamentally undermine the scene. Therefore, a score of 0.7 is appropriate, reflecting good but not perfect adherence to the prompt.


A surreal scene in the clouds under a Miller Lite neon sign. A young man with fair skin, wearing a black baseball cap, gray sweatshirt, and jeans, is passed out on a cloud. To the left, a woman with long brown hair looks on with concern. Behind the man's head, a man with short brown hair stares blankly. To the right, a man with a mustache looks on disapprovingly. To the far right, a man with curly brown hair points an accusing finger. Six cherubic babies with wings and diapers are flying around the passed-out man, holding tiny Miller Lite bottles and trying to pour them into his mouth. The scene is lit with a heavenly glow.

There is no vivid description of the generated image or the differences between the original and generated images provided. Without this information, I cannot evaluate how well the generated image matches the prompt or whether it made any unrequested changes. According to the instructions, if I do not have access to either the prompt or the vivid description, the score should be 0.


A surreal, wide-angle shot of a Caucasian man, wearing a backwards baseball cap, a gray fleece jacket, and jeans, floating horizontally in a sea of fluffy, white clouds. He is still slumped over as if he is asleep at the bar, with his head resting on an invisible surface and one arm dangling down. His facial expression is peaceful and serene, contrasting with the absurdity of his situation. In the background, the other bar patrons, including a smiling woman and a man pointing, are also floating among the clouds, looking confused and amused. The scene is bathed in soft, ethereal light, creating a dreamlike atmosphere. The Miller Lite sign from the bar is now a neon sign in the sky.

The generated image closely follows the prompt: the main subject (Caucasian man in backwards cap, gray fleece, jeans) is floating horizontally in clouds, maintaining his slumped, peaceful pose. The Miller Lite sign is now a neon sign in the sky, and the scene is bathed in soft, ethereal light, creating the dreamlike atmosphere requested. The other bar patrons are present and floating among the clouds, with the man on the right pointing and the woman on the left smiling. However, there are some minor deviations: the expressions of the background patrons are less explicitly 'confused and amused' than described in the prompt, with some appearing neutral. The wide-angle effect is not as pronounced as specified. Additionally, the smiling woman's expression is more subdued than in the original, and the pointing man's face is slightly altered. These are relatively minor issues and do not significantly detract from the overall fidelity to the prompt. There are no unwarranted changes to the background or main subject. Thus, the image is highly accurate, with only small shortcomings in expression and lens effect.


A surrealist painting of a young, fair-skinned man with a baseball cap, blue shirt, and grey fleece jacket, passed out on a bar stool. His head rests on the bar, and his arm hangs limply. He is ascending into a vibrant, swirling vortex of clouds, each cloud resembling a different type of alcoholic beverage: beer steins, wine glasses, and martini shakers. The clouds are illuminated with neon colors, reminiscent of bar signs, creating a dreamlike, intoxicating atmosphere. The man's expression is peaceful, as if he's found his ultimate happy place in the sky. The background should evoke a sense of both humor and awe, capturing the essence of a night out gone wonderfully, absurdly right.

The generated image diverges significantly from the prompt in several key areas. The prompt requests a fair-skinned young man, visibly passed out on a bar stool with his head on the bar and a peaceful expression, wearing a baseball cap, blue shirt, and grey fleece jacket. Instead, the generated image shows a blue-hooded figure floating upright with arms crossed, face obscured, and no visible bar stool or passed-out posture. The clothing is generic and does not match the prompt. The facial features and peaceful expression are missing due to the hood. The background, while vibrant and swirling with neon-lit alcoholic beverages, does not depict clouds shaped like beverages as requested, but rather distinct bottles and glasses. The overall mood is more mystical and awe-inspiring than humorous, missing the 'night out gone wonderfully, absurdly right' vibe. There are also unwarranted changes, such as the complete obscuring of the face and the transformation of clouds into objects. However, some elements from the prompt are present: the surreal, vibrant, neon-lit vortex and the inclusion of alcoholic beverage imagery. Given these partial alignments but major deviations, the image is only partially faithful to the prompt.


A young, fair-skinned man wearing a backwards baseball cap, blue shirt, tan fleece, and jeans, is passed out at a bar, his head resting on the bar top and his arm dangling off the side of his stool. He is now ascending to heaven, surrounded by fluffy white clouds, golden light, and cherubic angels playing harps. The bar scene fades away as he rises, but his pose and clothing remain the same. The woman and man in the background are now angels, smiling and waving him on.

The generated image does capture the overall concept of the prompt: the man is now in a heavenly scene, surrounded by clouds, golden light, and angels playing harps, with the bar scene faded away. However, there are several significant deviations from the prompt's explicit instructions: (1) The man's pose is not preserved—he is upright and conscious instead of slumped and unconscious as in the original; (2) his jeans are now much darker, not matching the original blue; (3) the background people (the woman and man) are not transformed into angels as requested, but replaced by generic cherubic angels; (4) the angels are playing harps, not waving him on as specified. There are also unwarranted changes to the man's facial expression and the loss of the original background characters' features. While the overall theme and some visual elements are correct, the image fails to follow several key, specific instructions and introduces unnecessary changes.


In a dimly lit bar, a young, fair-skinned man wearing a gray zip-up sweater, blue jeans, and a baseball cap sleeps, slumped over the bar on a stool. A fair-skinned woman with dark hair smiles behind him, and a fair-skinned man with dark hair points. Replace the bartender with the Grim Reaper, who wears a black hooded cloak, and is leaning over the bar, offering the sleeping man a shot glass filled with a glowing green liquid. The Grim Reaper has a skeletal face and bony hands. The bar is still dimly lit, with a neon "Lite" sign in the background.

The generated image follows the main instructions of the prompt very well: the bartender is replaced by the Grim Reaper, who is accurately depicted with a skeletal face, bony hands, and a black hooded cloak, offering a glowing green shot glass to the sleeping man. The setting remains a dimly lit bar with the neon 'Lite' sign and American flag in the background, as specified. The three main characters are present and their general positions are correct. However, there are some minor but notable deviations: the sleeping man's pose is altered (both hands under his head instead of one arm dangling), the woman's smile is less broad and her eyes less defined, and the man who was supposed to be pointing now has an open-mouthed reaction and less distinct facial features. These changes, while not major, do affect the fidelity to the prompt, especially since the prompt specifically asked for the man to be pointing and the woman to be smiling. No unwarranted changes were made to the background. Overall, the image is highly faithful to the prompt with only minor character expression and pose inaccuracies.


A surreal photo of a young, Caucasian man in a bar, passed out on a bar stool with his head on the bar. The man is wearing a grey zip-up jacket, blue jeans, and a backwards baseball cap. Hovering above him is a translucent, ghostly version of himself, wearing the same clothes, looking down at his sleeping body with a mixture of amusement and concern. The ghostly figure is reaching out a hand, as if to try and wake up his physical form. In the background, a woman with dark hair and a man with shaggy hair are looking on with expressions of amusement and disbelief. The bar is dimly lit, with a neon "Lite" sign in the background, adding to the surreal atmosphere. The overall scene is humorous and slightly melancholic, capturing the moment of out-of-body experience in a comical way.

The generated image fails to deliver the most critical surreal element requested in the prompt: a translucent, ghostly version of the passed-out man hovering above him. Instead, it introduces a second, fully physical man seated next to the original, with a different face and expression, which is a major deviation from the prompt. The ghostly figure is not only not ghostly or translucent, but also not hovering, and his expression is one of shock rather than the specified mixture of amusement and concern. The background characters also do not match the prompt: the woman is depicted as shocked or yelling rather than amused, and the shaggy-haired man is missing or obscured. There are also unwarranted changes to facial features and the overall lighting, making the scene darker and less visually consistent with the original. While the bar setting and some clothing details are preserved, the core surreal and humorous out-of-body experience is not achieved, and several unrequested changes are present. The image is partially relevant but misses the main conceptual and emotional beats of the prompt.


A surreal photo in a dimly lit bar. A young, fair-skinned man wearing a backwards baseball cap, blue t-shirt, grey sweatshirt, and jeans is slumped over the bar, seemingly asleep. Hovering a foot above him is a translucent, glowing version of himself, wearing the same clothes, but with a blissful expression. The translucent version is reaching towards a bright, inviting light source just out of frame. In the background, a woman with dark hair is laughing, and a man with dark hair is pointing and smirking, both seemingly oblivious to the spectral event. A Miller Lite sign hangs above the bar, casting a neon glow. The style is reminiscent of a whimsical, slightly dark fantasy film.

The generated image closely follows the prompt in most respects: the setting, characters, clothing, and overall composition are accurate. The main requested surreal element—a glowing, hovering version of the slumped man with a blissful expression reaching toward a bright light—is present. The background characters and the Miller Lite sign are also faithfully rendered. However, there are a few notable discrepancies: (1) The prompt specifies the hovering figure should be 'translucent,' but in the image, he is glowing and nearly opaque, not semi-transparent. (2) The prompt says the light source should be 'just out of frame,' but in the image, it is clearly visible within the frame. (3) The background characters' obliviousness is not overtly emphasized, though their expressions are consistent with the original. There are no significant unwarranted changes to the background or the unmodified characters. These issues are relatively minor and do not fundamentally alter the intent or impact of the image, but they do prevent a perfect score. The image is visually consistent, the changes are applied only where requested, and the unmentioned elements are preserved. Therefore, a score of 0.9 is appropriate.


A surreal photo of a dimly lit bar with a neon "Lite" sign. A Caucasian man wearing a gray zip-up sweater, blue jeans, and a baseball cap is slumped over the bar, asleep on the bar top. Hovering above him is a translucent, ghostly version of himself, wearing the same clothes, but with a surprised expression, looking down at his sleeping body. In the background, a woman with dark hair is laughing and pointing at the sleeping man, while another man with shaggy hair looks on with amusement. The ghostly figure is connected to the sleeping man by a thin, shimmering cord of light. The overall tone is humorous and slightly eerie.

The generated image successfully implements the main surreal elements requested in the prompt: the sleeping man, the ghostly version of himself with a surprised expression, the cord of light connecting them, and the humorous, slightly eerie tone. The background characters (the laughing woman and amused man) are present and their actions are mostly consistent with the prompt, though the woman's pose is more exaggerated than described. However, there are several notable discrepancies: the ghostly figure's pose is more leaning than hovering, the cord of light is rendered as white lines rather than shimmering and ethereal, and the specific 'Lite' neon sign is missing or unclear, with the neon colors and text altered. There are also minor, unrequested changes to facial features and background clarity, and the bar counter color is slightly different. These issues, while not catastrophic, mean the image does not fully meet the prompt's specificity and makes some unnecessary changes. However, the core concept and most details are present and recognizable, so the image is more than halfway accurate but not perfect.


In a dimly lit bar, a young, fair-skinned man wearing a backwards baseball cap, a gray fleece jacket, and blue jeans is passed out on the bar, slumped over the counter. A middle-aged woman with dark hair is smiling in the background, and a young man with dark hair is pointing at the passed-out man. Jesus Christ, with a kind, concerned expression, is standing next to the passed-out man, gently placing his hand on his back as if to comfort him. Jesus is wearing his traditional robes. The bar is crowded, with other patrons visible in the background. A neon "Miller" sign glows above the bar. The overall scene should evoke a sense of compassion and divine intervention in a mundane, slightly humorous setting.

The generated image closely follows the prompt: the passed-out man, the woman smiling, the man pointing, the crowded bar, and the prominent 'Miller' neon sign are all present. Jesus Christ is depicted in traditional robes, with a kind, concerned expression, standing next to the passed-out man and reaching toward his back. The only notable deviation is that Jesus's hand is hovering just above the man's back rather than making actual contact as specified in the prompt. There are minor, mostly cosmetic changes to the woman's facial expression, the man's jawline, the bar counter's color, and the overall warmth of the lighting. These are subtle and do not significantly alter the scene or its intent. The change from 'Miller Lite' to 'Miller' aligns with the prompt. Overall, the image is highly faithful to the prompt, with only a very minor deviation regarding Jesus's hand placement and some slight, non-disruptive visual refinements.