| { |
| "utc": "2026-10-21T01:19:09.758641+00:00", |
| "timing": "specified during inference, before full cross-arm analysis or scientific content scoring", |
| "primary_arms": [ |
| "qwen_base", |
| "qwen_final", |
| "gemma_base", |
| "gemma_final" |
| ], |
| "contrasts": [ |
| { |
| "name": "qwen_finetuning", |
| "left": "qwen_base", |
| "right": "qwen_final" |
| }, |
| { |
| "name": "gemma_finetuning", |
| "left": "gemma_base", |
| "right": "gemma_final" |
| }, |
| { |
| "name": "base_cross_model", |
| "left": "qwen_base", |
| "right": "gemma_base" |
| }, |
| { |
| "name": "final_cross_model", |
| "left": "qwen_final", |
| "right": "gemma_final" |
| } |
| ], |
| "secondary_generation_contrasts": [ |
| { |
| "name": "qwen_domain_adaptation", |
| "left": "qwen_base", |
| "right": "qwen_domain" |
| }, |
| { |
| "name": "gemma_domain_adaptation", |
| "left": "gemma_base", |
| "right": "gemma_domain" |
| }, |
| { |
| "name": "qwen_semantic_stage", |
| "left": "qwen_domain", |
| "right": "qwen_final" |
| }, |
| { |
| "name": "gemma_semantic_stage", |
| "left": "gemma_domain", |
| "right": "gemma_final" |
| } |
| ], |
| "difference": "right minus left", |
| "generation_metrics": { |
| "json": [ |
| "json_valid", |
| "reference_top_level_keys_present", |
| "exact_json_reference_match" |
| ], |
| "tool": [ |
| "tool_schema_valid", |
| "tool_names_match_reference", |
| "tool_arguments_match_reference" |
| ], |
| "text": [ |
| "nonempty" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "source_metrics": { |
| "source_card": [ |
| "json_valid", |
| "identifiers_match", |
| "schema_fields_present", |
| "all_nonempty_spans_supported", |
| "numeric_literals_exact", |
| "mechanical_grounding_pass" |
| ], |
| "quote_locator": [ |
| "json_valid", |
| "identifiers_match", |
| "quote_match", |
| "interval_matches_source", |
| "exact_reference_position", |
| "mechanical_grounding_pass" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "workflow_primary_endpoints": { |
| "delivery_complete": "原生终态同时具有非占位实验计划与待审报告，并覆盖材料/工艺/性能能力/安全/综合评价/实验规划角色；人工批准不自动执行。", |
| "scientifically_usable_delivery": "delivery_complete且有两个实质不同方向、原文经典对照、可检验假设、对应目标的实验测量与样品身份绑定；未识别实质事实/数值/条件/引用错误，且没有阻止执行的未解决身份或方法缺口。正确声明输入不足、未计算、未实验可接受。", |
| "scientific_content_score": "来源蕴含、身份数值条件、假设与对照、测量设计、执行与能力边界5维，各0/1/2；0为错误或完全缺失，1为部分或未解决，2为明确满足。对最终可交付内容评分，未交付记0并保留原稿诊断。" |
| }, |
| "workflow_review": { |
| "assessor": "本助手的自动/人工阅读式审查，非领域专家", |
| "blinding": "打乱案例和臂顺序并生成无模型/协调标签的原答与最终状态文本；运行轨迹仅在内容评分锁定后核验。执行者已知研究设计，不能声称完全双盲。", |
| "expert_review_completed": false, |
| "expert_decision": null, |
| "rule": "每项实质问题给出输入来源和模型原文定位；格式失败不自动等同科学判断全错；未审项null。" |
| }, |
| "bootstrap": { |
| "replicates": 10000, |
| "seed": 20261018, |
| "confidence": 0.95, |
| "method": "paired cluster percentile; resample original case-group connected components for generation, DOI for source/workflow; numerator/denominator aggregated within each resample", |
| "single_cluster": "report paired point difference without confidence interval" |
| }, |
| "workflow_binary_tests": "two-sided exact McNemar on12 DOI pairs; Holm correction across four primary contrasts times two binary endpoints", |
| "generation_source_tests": "paired cluster confidence intervals and effect sizes; no independent assistant-turn binomial test", |
| "workflow_science_score": "five dimensions each0/1/2, sum0..10; missing final delivery scored0 per inherited rubric; partial raw-content diagnostics reviewed separately", |
| "incomplete_policy": "missing/unexecuted remains null, no complete comparison until expected paired cohort and integrity records are present", |
| "content_review": "blinded output IDs, original task and sources, final result and unmodified generated content except terminal EOS; metadata labels hidden; assessor knows study design, not fully double blind; lock scores before unblinding", |
| "expert_review_completed": false, |
| "timing_cost_policy": "record native token counts and elapsed costs; historical reused time includes decoding/scoring while fresh generation time ends before decoding/scoring. Show origin and timing scope; no high-precision speed superiority claim across these scopes." |
| } |
|
|
