{ "utc": "2026-10-21T05:11:22.492913+00:00", "scope": "question/reference audit independent of model answers; initial verified examples, not an exhaustive affected-case count", "input_sha256": "5944c73357362066a19d3697761df5be18069084f571a3362ab2321da19c2130", "examples": [ { "unit_id": "compare2-4f0507d5543cb2dc@assistant-2", "category": "原文数值比较", "payload": { "caption": "Measurement parameter for J200 LIBS instrument", "column_header_paths": [ [ "Laser wavelength (nm)" ], [ "266" ] ], "doi": "10.1007/s00216-024-05163-6", "footnotes": "", "left": { "cell_origins": [ [ 1, 0 ], [ 1, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Laser energy (mJ)", "3.2" ], "row_index": 1 }, "right": { "cell_origins": [ [ 2, 0 ], [ 2, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Laser spotsize (µm)", "100" ], "row_index": 2 }, "table": "Tab1" }, "reference": { "content": "{\"comparison_scope\": \"只比较原表可解析点值；保留表头与表注，不转成跨条件性能或因果结论\", \"comparisons\": [{\"column\": 1, \"header_path\": [\"266\"], \"left_raw\": \"3.2\", \"relation\": \"right_higher\", \"right_minus_left\": \"96.8\", \"right_raw\": \"100\"}], \"doi\": \"10.1007/s00216-024-05163-6\", \"left_label\": \"Laser energy (mJ)\", \"research_use\": \"有变化的列用于提出权衡或机制问题；数值高低不自动代表更好的PI或新的体系\", \"right_label\": \"Laser spotsize (µm)\", \"table\": \"Tab1\"}", "role": "assistant" }, "finding": "heterogeneous physical quantities and units appear in the same numerical column; mechanical arithmetic/reference matching must not be interpreted as a scientifically meaningful property comparison" }, { "unit_id": "compare2-6d2bb6919adb1b6a@assistant-2", "category": "原文数值比较", "payload": { "caption": "Measurement parameter for J200 LIBS instrument", "column_header_paths": [ [ "Laser wavelength (nm)" ], [ "266" ] ], "doi": "10.1007/s00216-024-05163-6", "footnotes": "", "left": { "cell_origins": [ [ 2, 0 ], [ 2, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Laser spotsize (µm)", "100" ], "row_index": 2 }, "right": { "cell_origins": [ [ 3, 0 ], [ 3, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Laser repetition rate (Hz)", "20" ], "row_index": 3 }, "table": "Tab1" }, "reference": { "content": "{\"comparison_scope\": \"只比较原表可解析点值；保留表头与表注，不转成跨条件性能或因果结论\", \"comparisons\": [{\"column\": 1, \"header_path\": [\"266\"], \"left_raw\": \"100\", \"relation\": \"left_higher\", \"right_minus_left\": \"-80\", \"right_raw\": \"20\"}], \"doi\": \"10.1007/s00216-024-05163-6\", \"left_label\": \"Laser spotsize (µm)\", \"research_use\": \"有变化的列用于提出权衡或机制问题；数值高低不自动代表更好的PI或新的体系\", \"right_label\": \"Laser repetition rate (Hz)\", \"table\": \"Tab1\"}", "role": "assistant" }, "finding": "heterogeneous physical quantities and units appear in the same numerical column; mechanical arithmetic/reference matching must not be interpreted as a scientifically meaningful property comparison" }, { "unit_id": "order2-d1f22b1c18079733@assistant-2", "category": "原表排序与筛选边界", "payload": { "column": 1, "doi": "10.1007/s00216-024-05163-6", "footnotes": "", "header_path": [ "266" ], "rows": [ { "cell_origins": [ [ 1, 0 ], [ 1, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Laser energy (mJ)", "3.2" ], "row_index": 1 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 2, 0 ], [ 2, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Laser spotsize (µm)", "100" ], "row_index": 2 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 3, 0 ], [ 3, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Laser repetition rate (Hz)", "20" ], "row_index": 3 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 4, 0 ], [ 4, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Laser beam geometry", "Circular" ], "row_index": 4 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 5, 0 ], [ 5, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Stage scan speed (mm/s)", "2" ], "row_index": 5 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 6, 0 ], [ 6, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Atmosphere", "Argon" ], "row_index": 6 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 7, 0 ], [ 7, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Spectrometer", "Czerny-Turner" ], "row_index": 7 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 8, 0 ], [ 8, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Detector", "6-channel CCD" ], "row_index": 8 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 9, 0 ], [ 9, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Gate delay (µs)", "0.3" ], "row_index": 9 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 10, 0 ], [ 10, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Gate width (ms)", "1.05" ], "row_index": 10 }, { "cell_origins": [ [ 11, 0 ], [ 11, 1 ] ], "cells": [ "Covered wavelength range (nm)", "188–1048" ], "row_index": 11 } ], "table": "Tab1" }, "reference": { "content": "{\"ascending_rows\": [{\"raw_value\": \"0.3\", \"row_index\": 9, \"row_label_literal\": \"Gate delay (µs)\"}, {\"raw_value\": \"1.05\", \"row_index\": 10, \"row_label_literal\": \"Gate width (ms)\"}, {\"raw_value\": \"2\", \"row_index\": 5, \"row_label_literal\": \"Stage scan speed (mm/s)\"}, {\"raw_value\": \"3.2\", \"row_index\": 1, \"row_label_literal\": \"Laser energy (mJ)\"}, {\"raw_value\": \"20\", \"row_index\": 3, \"row_label_literal\": \"Laser repetition rate (Hz)\"}, {\"raw_value\": \"100\", \"row_index\": 2, \"row_label_literal\": \"Laser spotsize (µm)\"}], \"column\": 1, \"doi\": \"10.1007/s00216-024-05163-6\", \"header_path\": [\"266\"], \"scope\": \"仅对指定原列的可解析点值排序，不宣称目标适用性、显著性或全局最优\", \"table\": \"Tab1\"}", "role": "assistant" }, "finding": "heterogeneous physical quantities and units appear in the same numerical column; mechanical arithmetic/reference matching must not be interpreted as a scientifically meaningful property comparison" } ], "reporting_rule": "retain all frozen primary mechanical scores; flag these items in the benchmark audit. In scientific reading, a correct refusal of dimensionally meaningless comparison is not a scientific error merely because it differs from the mechanical reference. Report item-level analysis separately and label any later stratification as post-launch audit.", "inference_prompts_or_scoring_modified": false }