{
  "created_at": "2026-07-21T23:04:52+00:00",
  "sample_count": 12,
  "sample_selection": "stratified by year, series, language, and PDF size",
  "results": [
    {
      "report_id": "cr-2006-067",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/cr-2006-067.pdf",
      "page_count": 89,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 4.457,
        "detected_tables": 3,
        "characters": 236568,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 198076,
        "words": 36002,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 5,
        "markdown_table_rows": 26
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.079,
        "characters": 261472,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 200745,
        "words": 36600,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.591,
        "characters": 303146,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 200745,
        "words": 36564,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "cr-2009-141",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/cr-2009-141.pdf",
      "page_count": 4,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 0.109,
        "detected_tables": 0,
        "characters": 5763,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 4875,
        "words": 868,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.05,
        "characters": 6338,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 4769,
        "words": 868,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.019,
        "characters": 6174,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 4769,
        "words": 868,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "tar-2026-057",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/tar-2026-057.pdf",
      "page_count": 74,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 6.971,
        "detected_tables": 20,
        "characters": 200869,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 172738,
        "words": 29103,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 14,
        "markdown_table_rows": 248
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.108,
        "characters": 242463,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 160050,
        "words": 27474,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 72
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.456,
        "characters": 232443,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 160046,
        "words": 27465,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 72
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "tar-2026-058",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/tar-2026-058.pdf",
      "page_count": 10,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 0.511,
        "detected_tables": 0,
        "characters": 15660,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 13284,
        "words": 2183,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 5,
        "markdown_table_rows": 8
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.028,
        "characters": 19177,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 14451,
        "words": 2442,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 8
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.048,
        "characters": 18869,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 14451,
        "words": 2442,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 8
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "cr-2019-360",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/cr-2019-360.pdf",
      "page_count": 47,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 3.213,
        "detected_tables": 6,
        "characters": 123619,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 105159,
        "words": 18315,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 31,
        "markdown_table_rows": 77
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.123,
        "characters": 131209,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 102232,
        "words": 18159,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.295,
        "characters": 129428,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 102232,
        "words": 18158,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "cr-2023-446",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/cr-2023-446.pdf",
      "page_count": 11,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 0.746,
        "detected_tables": 3,
        "characters": 20820,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 17809,
        "words": 2972,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 6,
        "markdown_table_rows": 33
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.026,
        "characters": 23041,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 17506,
        "words": 2988,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.055,
        "characters": 22584,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 17506,
        "words": 2988,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "tar-2024-001",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/tar-2024-001.pdf",
      "page_count": 27,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 1.958,
        "detected_tables": 4,
        "characters": 34949,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 29504,
        "words": 5065,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 5,
        "markdown_table_rows": 56
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.049,
        "characters": 65186,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 40658,
        "words": 7712,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 25
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.135,
        "characters": 61653,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 40658,
        "words": 7712,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 25
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "tar-2025-036",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/tar-2025-036.pdf",
      "page_count": 32,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 2.336,
        "detected_tables": 21,
        "characters": 78623,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 66946,
        "words": 11663,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 15,
        "markdown_table_rows": 129
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.052,
        "characters": 89029,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 66721,
        "words": 11895,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 30
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.203,
        "characters": 89079,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 66717,
        "words": 11895,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 30
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "legacy-47122",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/legacy-47122.pdf",
      "page_count": 14,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 0.646,
        "detected_tables": 2,
        "characters": 27151,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 23132,
        "words": 4044,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 13,
        "markdown_table_rows": 14
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.028,
        "characters": 28433,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 21137,
        "words": 3783,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.066,
        "characters": 28074,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 21137,
        "words": 3783,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "legacy-48819",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/legacy-48819.pdf",
      "page_count": 59,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 4.221,
        "detected_tables": 2,
        "characters": 134439,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 113496,
        "words": 20301,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 23,
        "markdown_table_rows": 16
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.093,
        "characters": 191320,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 117692,
        "words": 21595,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.357,
        "characters": 180415,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 117692,
        "words": 21491,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "legacy-49486",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/legacy-49486.pdf",
      "page_count": 44,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 5.989,
        "detected_tables": 22,
        "characters": 122776,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 105595,
        "words": 20007,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 13,
        "markdown_table_rows": 309
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.069,
        "characters": 139170,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 89846,
        "words": 17389,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.284,
        "characters": 134950,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 89846,
        "words": 17380,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "report_id": "legacy-48586",
      "pdf_path": "data/raw/pdfs/legacy-48586.pdf",
      "page_count": 75,
      "pymupdf4llm": {
        "seconds": 4.349,
        "detected_tables": 15,
        "characters": 156709,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 133202,
        "words": 23640,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 50,
        "markdown_table_rows": 109
      },
      "pdftotext_layout": {
        "seconds": 0.098,
        "characters": 188182,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 128287,
        "words": 23265,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      },
      "pymupdf_text": {
        "seconds": 0.401,
        "characters": 187251,
        "non_whitespace_characters": 128287,
        "words": 23266,
        "replacement_characters": 0,
        "headings": 0,
        "markdown_table_rows": 0
      }
    }
  ],
  "aggregate": {
    "pymupdf4llm_detected_tables": 98,
    "median_layout_to_pdftotext_non_whitespace_ratio": 1.0222268819459006,
    "pymupdf4llm_seconds": 35.506,
    "pdftotext_seconds": 0.803
  },
  "selected_method": "pymupdf4llm+pymupdf-layout",
  "selection_rationale": "PyMuPDF4LLM with PyMuPDF Layout preserves page boundaries, headings, reading order, detected tables, and visual regions. pdftotext -layout is retained as an independent coverage baseline, not as the canonical format.",
  "limitation": "The benchmark compares structural and coverage diagnostics without a human-transcribed ground truth; downstream extraction remains unreviewed."
}