diff --git "a/validated/passed_pairs.jsonl" "b/validated/passed_pairs.jsonl" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/validated/passed_pairs.jsonl" @@ -0,0 +1,418 @@ +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d0a2e465853ba39c76c32e6038f9817cdb1e88b8dd7f79996c992590a2b9b124", "request_id": "08de7ccb09e5365be5c9ffe71c5ac1e6", "response_sha256": "405a49dff6b7ced772a9231e5c5cc955336619453586b642d6bb1ba3cb304cdc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "14929538b3c1e182547e9063580cc79465667a878a6d16f272229cdb7494edeb", "request_id": "a9e6f15baf16d3c7249353313aa1b7c9", "response_sha256": "0b925b8daf0e2a95a767ab6e05e3b2a1be1b4bc54fad89a45ff40fcce87b9971", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "1cd215c10af6773daecc985fb377e4f4", "candidate_priority_rank": 22812, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6284516ccc80b6be:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6284516ccc80b6be:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6284516ccc80b6be:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6284516ccc80b6be:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "white<->yellow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "yellow"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->yellow", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 383, "image_id": "2373002", "image_sha256": "ab83c2ca45d68a134140f9adb3b29aafd9fe7c38f88f924d9cde1fb11b7065dc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2373002.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2373002.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2382263", "image_sha256": "375f708ddf9b765b3855a649f0a2e60b0842de2ebce8f8e635a474ff7be67c3f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382263.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382263.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6284516ccc80b6be", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "yellow", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "yellow"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blond", "blue", "brown", "gray", "green", "red", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bdf93fc8de8aef492cb262e887148f8867cea50bce76d56a29ba3e3d51d881f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11134096", "text": "What is on the white wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["yellow"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yellow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "838cf1b2b924049eb95a0268bb9f8b363f910e936b923c3885cf0a37b1817109"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "081010453", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 22812, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 20, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "selected_component": "yellow", "selected_source_question_id": "081010453", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the yellow wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "grass", "full_answer": "The grass is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the white wall?", "question_id": "11134096", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (3729975)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1957807)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "mirror", "full_answer": "The mirror is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the yellow wall?", "question_id": "081010453", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1329840)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "yellow", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1329839)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1694764", "1698484", "1698488", "1701538", "1752804", "1752805", "1758783", "1777248", "1939228", "1939229", "1957807", "1966596", "1968458", "2080189", "2153909", "2179986", "2193864", "2276558", "2303888", "2412898", "2557109", "2681915", "2683508", "3729976", "3729977", "3729978", "3729979", "3729980", "3851909", "3851910"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 30, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["grass"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "1957807", "query_target_entity_name": "grass", "relation_object_entity_id": "3729975", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1957807", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3729975", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3729975"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1329827", "1329828", "1329829", "1329830", "1329831", "1329832", "1329833", "1329834", "1329835", "1329836", "1329837", "1329838", "1329839", "1329841", "1329843", "1329844", "1329845", "1329846", "1329847", "1329848", "1329849", "1329850"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mirror"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "reflective"], "query_target_entity_id": "1329839", "query_target_entity_name": "mirror", "relation_object_entity_id": "1329840", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1329839", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1329840", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1329840"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:1cd215c10af6773daecc985fb377e4f4", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ab83c2ca45d68a134140f9adb3b29aafd9fe7c38f88f924d9cde1fb11b7065dc", "image_sha256_b": "375f708ddf9b765b3855a649f0a2e60b0842de2ebce8f8e635a474ff7be67c3f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4e3e5c0703dafb8c72f8b004c13973a90a8dfc23e779e0e2a04ec0b75410f9a7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8c3c5f0e83c00afe54025b76383d41e9", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2d1a1174e8441de0a94132588218e28528b054697973d841793dc75940df0722"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "39ab959e99451e2c52aa4783966282a36ee394f380af50397583e2daabf5d5b1", "request_id": "c8ad07717f9f2872d3245e8ba0e7b848", "response_sha256": "7814909ec2894668752156e7d00d1268fed4450ae2ec0c78267b0d2dcdc3c1bf", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8801f181663d42c0679325921008e5bed8d4ca61084c38cddc017c3d5b6c4c89", "request_id": "400b431c65c0364ea3822b11eedce7c3", "response_sha256": "bff1a10efcc9650e2eb1d3d36aef8596733f0b9a3e0a68517e44bc2d49d5296b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "000e09037d37a63bdfb55015ea77d32e", "candidate_priority_rank": 22841, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26f0031548a37de6:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26f0031548a37de6:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26f0031548a37de6:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26f0031548a37de6:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "metal<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "metal", "B": "wood"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "metal<->wood", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2357050", "image_sha256": "44ac21645a5af8e793533b5ea11c69cf842b5866ef9f251ac26d13e9459c6b1a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2357050.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2357050.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 353, "image_id": "2407370", "image_sha256": "3f3238a8bd516924bc3c3ed4965ddf5f8e85061a6ce89597d2d86eca945ea965", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407370.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407370.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26f0031548a37de6", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "metal", "diff_b": "wood", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "metal", "component_b": "wood"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal"], "detected_components": ["metal"], "masked_program_sha256": "59392c85a17477ede3fb91c9e60cc3b97a8b68d70d3b72c93129a65043e5385e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "metal", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6df5669bbef84f31d134ca15736380a5b6740d7ca2d1baac0455500eec1747b4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08658577", "text": "What is on the metal pole?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "59392c85a17477ede3fb91c9e60cc3b97a8b68d70d3b72c93129a65043e5385e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "37a02374ffd20b99c515c818fc38d31daa5cd1123ceed9bdf51df64ef6825964"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0857797", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 22841, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "42ddc8bdd41752add4b2e91c1a278ef100fb336df0617470e0f3001e4003140c", "selected_component": "wood", "selected_source_question_id": "0857797", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the wood pole?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pole", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the pole?", "program_group_hash": "42ddc8bdd41752add4b2e91c1a278ef100fb336df0617470e0f3001e4003140c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pole"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pole", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the pole?", "program_group_hash": "42ddc8bdd41752add4b2e91c1a278ef100fb336df0617470e0f3001e4003140c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pole"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "street sign", "full_answer": "The street sign is on the pole.", "question": "What is on the metal pole?", "question_id": "08658577", "semantic": [{"argument": "pole (2485247)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "metal", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2358357)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stop sign", "full_answer": "The stop sign is on the pole.", "question": "What is on the wood pole?", "question_id": "0857797", "semantic": [{"argument": "pole (280808)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (280807)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1803782", "1870062", "2011713", "2090751", "2151977", "2189025", "2195742", "2242109", "2242112", "2325511", "2341326", "2358357", "2370033", "2370035", "2470139", "2519326", "3557172", "3557176", "3557177"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["street sign"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2358357", "query_target_entity_name": "street sign", "relation_object_entity_id": "2485247", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2358357", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2485247", "selected_entity_name": "pole"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2485247"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["280807", "280809", "280810", "280812", "280815", "280817"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stop sign"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["octagonal", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "280807", "query_target_entity_name": "stop sign", "relation_object_entity_id": "280808", "relation_subject_entity_id": "280807", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "280808", "selected_entity_name": "pole"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["280808"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:000e09037d37a63bdfb55015ea77d32e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "44ac21645a5af8e793533b5ea11c69cf842b5866ef9f251ac26d13e9459c6b1a", "image_sha256_b": "3f3238a8bd516924bc3c3ed4965ddf5f8e85061a6ce89597d2d86eca945ea965", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "dcd84d9047fe8aec2c8826a1f2692019f5a56db52cb3ea5560900247b4c86f44", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b57458a832f67feebcce5f59dd4fb876", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6e25ad17853ce4601f1744b7317c19f8bb6cf35ac32d922827cad758aa06fa5e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5a81ac73961422a590429a43807be5561a968ac27b52fa87d19578398114f644", "request_id": "8be2fe1c2d625f6c7890a3a308655ce1", "response_sha256": "42ef0ba95d8137a6aef69da93ecc4606d48f7b324646e6bd3feb1780df57548f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bebea5bc992ae8b9489d84ec528ecbeaef3136c195aba05d72514146752fd871", "request_id": "589733969152a8816508501cc54a550e", "response_sha256": "3f1b77f933b8310738fa7dba735430171759766613ff813f6837a43807030652", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "f08fb59d1284bd13dd5706908b418a78", "candidate_priority_rank": 22889, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb056a96c25d5ff1:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb056a96c25d5ff1:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb056a96c25d5ff1:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb056a96c25d5ff1:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "glass<->plastic", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "glass", "B": "plastic"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "glass<->plastic", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2315538", "image_sha256": "4e7bf89e764cdcaee3da7f4691dc19184191ca4ba76c302e129ec368820a6065", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2315538.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2315538.jpg", "width": 325}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2410110", "image_sha256": "74ad3dd221d8d9cad5ec5e08371956a4fa05d2939a6f19d3613f9d0a176c4962", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410110.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410110.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb056a96c25d5ff1", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "glass", "diff_b": "plastic", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "glass", "component_b": "plastic"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["glass", "wood"], "detected_components": ["glass"], "masked_program_sha256": "e7b34d4b7a17aad39e759ccf326515c7aae3fbc26723ac9c08d048368305c8bc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "glass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ad0117c639033a217bfc28526f6d898282021cc9ba41d7473fb7a646d0ae5735"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07335153", "text": "What is in the glass bottle?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["glass", "plastic", "stainless steel", "steel"], "detected_components": ["plastic"], "masked_program_sha256": "e7b34d4b7a17aad39e759ccf326515c7aae3fbc26723ac9c08d048368305c8bc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "plastic", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1c37cc1536c3c9d6565968e7f526401e18d75134755602e279c87d23726a3b14"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10460663", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 22889, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "42696ed2c673354105535e4692bb3283f9dae0616f3cb9186a5619feb624a2e2", "selected_component": "plastic", "selected_source_question_id": "10460663", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the plastic bottle?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bottle", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bottle?", "program_group_hash": "42696ed2c673354105535e4692bb3283f9dae0616f3cb9186a5619feb624a2e2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bottle"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bottle", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bottle?", "program_group_hash": "42696ed2c673354105535e4692bb3283f9dae0616f3cb9186a5619feb624a2e2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bottle"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "plant", "full_answer": "The plant is in the bottle.", "question": "What is in the glass bottle?", "question_id": "07335153", "semantic": [{"argument": "bottle (1055713)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "glass", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (1055712)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "soap", "full_answer": "The soap is in the bottle.", "question": "What is in the plastic bottle?", "question_id": "10460663", "semantic": [{"argument": "bottle (225643)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "plastic", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (225642)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1055712", "1055714", "1055717", "1055718", "1055720", "1055728"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["plant"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "1055712", "query_target_entity_name": "plant", "relation_object_entity_id": "1055713", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1055712", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1055713", "selected_entity_name": "bottle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1055713"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "plastic", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["225639", "225641", "225642", "225644", "225645", "225646", "225648", "225649", "225650", "225651", "225652", "225653", "225654", "225656", "225658", "225659", "225662", "225663", "225666", "225667", "225669", "225670", "225671", "225674"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 24, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["soap"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "225642", "query_target_entity_name": "soap", "relation_object_entity_id": "225643", "relation_subject_entity_id": "225642", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "225643", "selected_entity_name": "bottle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "plastic", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["225643"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:f08fb59d1284bd13dd5706908b418a78", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4e7bf89e764cdcaee3da7f4691dc19184191ca4ba76c302e129ec368820a6065", "image_sha256_b": "74ad3dd221d8d9cad5ec5e08371956a4fa05d2939a6f19d3613f9d0a176c4962", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c6f7b1d5ebab1dcb9693b046eeb897340161bb2e8b585e412f625b4ffd8cd6f2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0dfbc3d72659dbbd581421d54db79176", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3a887d88ebc25ad559b86c3c6fa615d41726243b13f4e0ca8094e49ea78c78c0"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7b6f6aed7dd35b67fc454b02c92d160054d47fa84ca32a09bb3fc95d58bf1e58", "request_id": "7ac9ede5242e3dfbfd8a1d90c6b344cb", "response_sha256": "2aece78809f6ab663e149cf2f43afda2af3f0b01495ac9741112c1cf04207c98", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "01adf7fc9e553817454e67ae5ad155a7ef84bcb5d8082114ea03eaa98bdc096e", "request_id": "31672dacb657f0fbb9af14bb0085dfb6", "response_sha256": "3077646e5cb5be94b67eaa9a18f7eefa77e6d6dde4113ca32de8074335c0e437", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "4fff2384514d019d40a2c30330b1dbc5", "candidate_priority_rank": 23023, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8046ce2cedb5c011:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8046ce2cedb5c011:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8046ce2cedb5c011:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8046ce2cedb5c011:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "skiing<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "skiing", "B": "surfing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "skiing<->surfing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2407404", "image_sha256": "a3fddce855d6397ba4a783c54b660fc811f55032a6741c89ceeffc1e67329a48", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407404.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407404.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2323042", "image_sha256": "30dc29d6357ebca36e076f6febae0e381ce8c27d7a57067ddb42924720aad016", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2323042.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2323042.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8046ce2cedb5c011", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "skiing", "diff_b": "surfing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "skiing", "component_b": "surfing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["skiing"], "detected_components": ["skiing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "skiing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b1b7723f85271e4c736be74c6accbbe92c5aa9ae0b19f0f01bbcc9b1872fbb6d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01218831", "text": "What is the person that is skiing wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e60cb519061f9a7757db8551ae37f1c8e776ec4ce8929871b7d33b1bf739a866"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10928113", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 23023, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 30, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "selected_component": "surfing", "selected_source_question_id": "10928113", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "helmet", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a helmet.", "question": "What is the person that is skiing wearing?", "question_id": "01218831", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (280180)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "skiing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (3810652)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "suit", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a suit.", "question": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?", "question_id": "10928113", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (2952877)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (2744401)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["280182", "280184", "280187", "280188", "280189", "280190", "280192", "280193", "3810645", "3810646", "3810652"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["helmet"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "3810652", "query_target_entity_name": "helmet", "relation_object_entity_id": "3810652", "relation_subject_entity_id": "280180", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "280180", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["280180"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2744401", "2857307", "3287113"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["suit"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "2744401", "query_target_entity_name": "suit", "relation_object_entity_id": "2744401", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2952877", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2952877", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2952877"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:4fff2384514d019d40a2c30330b1dbc5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a3fddce855d6397ba4a783c54b660fc811f55032a6741c89ceeffc1e67329a48", "image_sha256_b": "30dc29d6357ebca36e076f6febae0e381ce8c27d7a57067ddb42924720aad016", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b94fac553f988dfc93f785b6b4c7c489784f7aef580691cfa82fca30c5870e6f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a6fde414297f8b5f6c4f804a32673b9a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "26df18205cc78894dc1d1e2bba5331b902ef126a477d254bc8f88972249fcb90"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a9fb95fee0be6bd2d4d4d3f11e1e59eb0fa2f70ded43edce74943cb90455ec4f", "request_id": "e34d4121798d55051f8f7dc63425ca41", "response_sha256": "5ccd33fdbdd6e3670738ef91e5da23b0eb3cd5f68becf9889643258d66455c93", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c9e52934f42af3069747a49519f87e9363d928e4df56b95807cce2354a8b9de5", "request_id": "e0e2b1716457389c3d7c08c8db230598", "response_sha256": "ef2622e4a325f7f291f1c43204d3b87032aca7877da98af9c193fa9dc075c236", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "c918ccc38cee5ec507bdb6b51dfce400", "candidate_priority_rank": 23128, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ad1ee35db5e1e7ef:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ad1ee35db5e1e7ef:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ad1ee35db5e1e7ef:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ad1ee35db5e1e7ef:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "standing<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "standing", "B": "walking"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "standing<->walking", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 240, "image_id": "2407061", "image_sha256": "6153a7ff7c539fa136e09e3b96b38eab747dafe6af51f0f4e5229289132549dc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407061.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407061.jpg", "width": 320}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2407317", "image_sha256": "0cefda710184caa7e706dd1a72693f405456e569d825460389653d24ed37b543", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407317.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407317.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ad1ee35db5e1e7ef", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "standing", "diff_b": "walking", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "standing", "component_b": "walking"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "96086a768acf017a0d95aedaedb87e98cd8beee03f0c32ca3a33b0cd2136d91b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01734818", "text": "What is the person that is standing holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2bf1c30a22a7f5dcded4e434fbc083ba3c8d0eb4cddab68a2635546cc49940bc"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01213212", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 23128, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "selected_component": "walking", "selected_source_question_id": "01213212", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is walking holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "frisbee", "full_answer": "The man is holding the frisbee.", "question": "What is the person that is standing holding?", "question_id": "01734818", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (286165)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (286178)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "frisbee", "full_answer": "The man is holding the frisbee.", "question": "What is the person that is walking holding?", "question_id": "01213212", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (281863)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (281864)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["286160", "286164", "286166", "286167", "286168", "286169", "286170", "286171", "286172", "286174", "286178", "286180"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["frisbee"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "286178", "query_target_entity_name": "frisbee", "relation_object_entity_id": "286178", "relation_subject_entity_id": "286165", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "286165", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["286165"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["281864", "281865", "281866", "281867", "281868", "281869", "281870", "281871", "281872", "281873", "281874", "281876", "281878", "281879", "281880", "281881", "281882", "281883", "281884"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["frisbee"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blurry", "red"], "query_target_entity_id": "281864", "query_target_entity_name": "frisbee", "relation_object_entity_id": "281864", "relation_subject_entity_id": "281863", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "281863", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["281863"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:c918ccc38cee5ec507bdb6b51dfce400", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6153a7ff7c539fa136e09e3b96b38eab747dafe6af51f0f4e5229289132549dc", "image_sha256_b": "0cefda710184caa7e706dd1a72693f405456e569d825460389653d24ed37b543", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "64aa40901ffbd3da5bd6202b4f331facfd23491e367e1d71517d0989753c6cec", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c3f41e0f72d77aa1320db23f38781130", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1ed79d9a47e372f85f318abdc8ceef851246dc244d84ddd459c0e2187482d77d"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8a550dabd1919b2451520abca212f8957fefe6530b6fd9912dad8eef97541f7e", "request_id": "1df9887244753853ebcb665b2bf12a85", "response_sha256": "6f1762e398078ca80a722c9f7e1e2c28c8a1ffe693b5de1c170c7da0f255111f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3116fb123190e210aec16b4d113c339510a38e937aca817b327d51d9dc6dcb48", "request_id": "1dec9c0e3aee52f79abcd0bac9998d92", "response_sha256": "e5d92abe6a13cf9655f2111ac0e8f32631b57672835cf351acd7470960a9f535", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "571b10cf33bd33d0b21d4702ac8a4b22", "candidate_priority_rank": 23152, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-90c99d9eda06e06f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-90c99d9eda06e06f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-90c99d9eda06e06f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-90c99d9eda06e06f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->silver", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "silver"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->silver", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2326448", "image_sha256": "cbe0162f02c368d95e77fbbf3fb1c8551dbfb4c7acc816e271fa9d4aadbbf4cc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326448.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326448.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2396943", "image_sha256": "e30b872137d53892b1325ab504d23318bf44d82a527c30ed92634aee1807e0d4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396943.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396943.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-90c99d9eda06e06f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "silver", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "silver"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "purple", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "2b13bae9746f8d924638e292c11678aead06729ce480bbec713f42f619798cb3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "76fa991ad41f0c5acda6d1035b4d0f5d1e955cec1416665b0c922de3c38d3377"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12605389", "text": "What does the black device hang from?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "gray", "orange", "pink", "purple", "red", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["silver"], "masked_program_sha256": "2b13bae9746f8d924638e292c11678aead06729ce480bbec713f42f619798cb3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "silver", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "836964cd9e81abf8a5d2a38c6b4d6855851bb5a9e20dd1aaa6a4b654d16bed9f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17259384", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 23152, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f3683580c4365f62120c29cdd20e88987cab149676aed2c10ca35cbb99e4d151", "selected_component": "silver", "selected_source_question_id": "17259384", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What does the silver device hang from?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "device", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging from,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what does the device hang from?", "program_group_hash": "f3683580c4365f62120c29cdd20e88987cab149676aed2c10ca35cbb99e4d151", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hanging from", "select_category": "device"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "device", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging from,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what does the device hang from?", "program_group_hash": "f3683580c4365f62120c29cdd20e88987cab149676aed2c10ca35cbb99e4d151", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hanging from", "select_category": "device"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "ceiling", "full_answer": "The television hangs from the ceiling.", "question": "What does the black device hang from?", "question_id": "12605389", "semantic": [{"argument": "device (4134844)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging from,o (4134804)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "ceiling", "full_answer": "The projector hangs from the ceiling.", "question": "What does the silver device hang from?", "question_id": "17259384", "semantic": [{"argument": "device (439079)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "silver", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging from,o (439080)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4134789", "4134790", "4134794", "4134796", "4134804", "4134808", "4134809", "4134815", "4134820", "4134824", "4134833", "4134836", "4134837", "4134838", "4134843", "4134846"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ceiling"], "predicate": "hanging from", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4134804", "query_target_entity_name": "ceiling", "relation_object_entity_id": "4134804", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4134844", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "4134844", "selected_entity_name": "television"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4134844"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["439065", "439066", "439067", "439068", "439069", "439070", "439071", "439072", "439073", "439075", "439076", "439077", "439078", "439080", "439082", "439083", "439084", "439085", "439086", "439087", "439088", "439089"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ceiling"], "predicate": "hanging from", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "439080", "query_target_entity_name": "ceiling", "relation_object_entity_id": "439080", "relation_subject_entity_id": "439079", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "439079", "selected_entity_name": "projector"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["439079"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:571b10cf33bd33d0b21d4702ac8a4b22", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "cbe0162f02c368d95e77fbbf3fb1c8551dbfb4c7acc816e271fa9d4aadbbf4cc", "image_sha256_b": "e30b872137d53892b1325ab504d23318bf44d82a527c30ed92634aee1807e0d4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c79fd52925ab9ff1fec0f8acd97a0d2aebd3de2fadfc5ae8f6096ce4fe6a3c92", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "09b138d4e3d7718bb7b07a2f07403f8b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6c984464f89c24b2222029b0d9e06b8b6410c455b9b85a79d28b841d441b5fce"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a62a06003865dc5f8e3c80003bf2688d77686dec23a3270c54c318b9fb2ff78a", "request_id": "3a14f7a9e26bfb8a431eeaecbb361c1e", "response_sha256": "80bc54801cc896ba2b76377875fd4dbe7665fc5942b629e60c43e08eefac99e9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7cc87938f9e35c0de767378b4040c5348a525b6bb67d6c53a2af11d19abf5135", "request_id": "8d5b45f1b29bd823fbbf4b2639bcedbd", "response_sha256": "badb89ecc4f5ca2a0b6df4576ebf455b431aefbd903c7f48a0e99c46451f77d5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "dac137c4efa0801ca14dafc33253be4e", "candidate_priority_rank": 23153, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fa16fc379e3ecc01:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fa16fc379e3ecc01:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fa16fc379e3ecc01:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fa16fc379e3ecc01:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "standing<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "standing", "B": "walking"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "standing<->walking", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 401, "image_id": "2405653", "image_sha256": "07731bfb32559b17d14be5020162520e05f26df734e6219a43244e1c0b67c3ac", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405653.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405653.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2404919", "image_sha256": "988dfd93cb8b32700865e89e04b46cad8042656c7ae4d7ebb102f0365b69da25", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404919.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404919.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fa16fc379e3ecc01", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "standing", "diff_b": "walking", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "standing", "component_b": "walking"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "3eafefa1f150106ecb0f6ac9d4f2a101a7bef14f0cf770523ae085376fa163c7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e28d39eaf0b51772839cf848d5d3a6ddad024b35983dd61f5c3e840e3c47979e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09755172", "text": "What is the person that is standing carrying?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "3eafefa1f150106ecb0f6ac9d4f2a101a7bef14f0cf770523ae085376fa163c7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "aa7c7006aa8cb0446d7628663df50887837d1c0e4f6d66aaadb1a38546e7dee9"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13799390", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 23153, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "74fbf935582792afa8d9a7dadb0eb2d773e980ca6ef4ccefd7454dfa745b7414", "selected_component": "walking", "selected_source_question_id": "13799390", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is walking carrying?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is carrying?", "program_group_hash": "74fbf935582792afa8d9a7dadb0eb2d773e980ca6ef4ccefd7454dfa745b7414", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "carrying", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is carrying?", "program_group_hash": "74fbf935582792afa8d9a7dadb0eb2d773e980ca6ef4ccefd7454dfa745b7414", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "carrying", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "umbrella", "full_answer": "The woman is carrying an umbrella.", "question": "What is the person that is standing carrying?", "question_id": "09755172", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1106869)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o (1106868)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "luggage", "full_answer": "The man is carrying luggage.", "question": "What is the person that is walking carrying?", "question_id": "13799390", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (336565)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o (336564)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1106868", "1106872", "1106874", "1106875", "1106876", "1106877", "1106878", "1106881", "1106882", "1106884", "1106885", "1106886", "1106887", "1106888"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["umbrella"], "predicate": "carrying", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "tilted"], "query_target_entity_id": "1106868", "query_target_entity_name": "umbrella", "relation_object_entity_id": "1106868", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1106869", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1106869", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1106869"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["336563", "336564", "336566", "336567", "336568", "336569", "336573", "336574", "336575", "336576", "336577", "336580", "336583", "336584", "336586", "336587", "336588", "336589"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["luggage"], "predicate": "carrying", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "336564", "query_target_entity_name": "luggage", "relation_object_entity_id": "336564", "relation_subject_entity_id": "336565", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "336565", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["336565"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:dac137c4efa0801ca14dafc33253be4e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "07731bfb32559b17d14be5020162520e05f26df734e6219a43244e1c0b67c3ac", "image_sha256_b": "988dfd93cb8b32700865e89e04b46cad8042656c7ae4d7ebb102f0365b69da25", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "389e40ac2ae42ec457878444e0314c89645fd5d0b98880fe4e2c178cce6de2bb", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "99cbee8af3f0b7a75beb4c29390aa19b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0df244b696d14e3cc36fbf10ef739eb8bee231e25a6c9b770dce4c34e08d3c52"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "45701ec8fab09b73e4ed979d377ffc6a5fb47cfdab1caab42733098b9e46c852", "request_id": "59835e906fc111f881f2ad5433f7e9c8", "response_sha256": "45b759e1bcea678ad62923a38ac022a0de60712a6f5eef8b95846ae728fb4c4a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dbca8b8e6425ee3f8834be766d07d738a362baef6eb3598945adcadd8eb310d5", "request_id": "3d32767411319c933d9423bd65077308", "response_sha256": "938ebccf3548c2c0c4bc083fc69dc72ef783f53758f65720cfd641775e8f5ff8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "6b3f7eb2b920357a547fb46019875231", "candidate_priority_rank": 23355, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63b5e6eae766fab8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63b5e6eae766fab8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63b5e6eae766fab8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63b5e6eae766fab8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "red<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "red", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "red<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2387610", "image_sha256": "efdabdb071f1f5177348e681b302fd1c691f7845f0d06d21a306aa65e7d08a42", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387610.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387610.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2369285", "image_sha256": "78400c57c16c4c918b73a7d7710c758b5618b93db1eec20a441f3d3f90f4e042", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369285.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369285.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63b5e6eae766fab8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "red", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "red", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "61e67986c6d6f2138a522c56b642600dc3a5082a53383467fd7ae19d6a22bae6"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "17692379", "text": "What do you think is on the red wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "green", "orange", "pink", "purple", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e408a1d527706876e705fbc732b69c4fe6847aa683020a40227272f423f080a5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0227885", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 23355, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "7a913e7e431b3413fe9981bca87663c184b7bc86b33fe4dc39ab27f81eaad6a1", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "0227885", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What do you think is on the white wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what do you think is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "7a913e7e431b3413fe9981bca87663c184b7bc86b33fe4dc39ab27f81eaad6a1", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what do you think is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "7a913e7e431b3413fe9981bca87663c184b7bc86b33fe4dc39ab27f81eaad6a1", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "light switch", "full_answer": "The light switch is on the wall.", "question": "What do you think is on the red wall?", "question_id": "17692379", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1274497)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1274488)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "picture", "full_answer": "The picture is on the wall.", "question": "What do you think is on the white wall?", "question_id": "0227885", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (612616)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (612615)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1274484", "1274485", "1274486", "1274487", "1274488", "1274489", "1274490", "1274491", "1274492", "1274493", "1274494", "1274495", "1274496", "1274498", "1274499", "1274502", "1274503", "1274506"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["light switch"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1274488", "query_target_entity_name": "light switch", "relation_object_entity_id": "1274497", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1274488", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1274497", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1274497"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["612611", "612612", "612613", "612614", "612615", "612617", "612618", "612619"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["picture"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["pink", "rainbow colored"], "query_target_entity_id": "612615", "query_target_entity_name": "picture", "relation_object_entity_id": "612616", "relation_subject_entity_id": "612615", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "612616", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["612616"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:6b3f7eb2b920357a547fb46019875231", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "efdabdb071f1f5177348e681b302fd1c691f7845f0d06d21a306aa65e7d08a42", "image_sha256_b": "78400c57c16c4c918b73a7d7710c758b5618b93db1eec20a441f3d3f90f4e042", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d267d7bf46ebc8db3e0b8ce8fc7d28651550d669f3c86bb3d683f2e91eaf2f7a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f713867630baf8712dc347d427036b53", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2c732875ca133a2a4362ae7ca9abc6993371dad3ed9783effb94281965fe3b75"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f26f4b2b471dd8a59bf5b8de26043f109ff36e896eeffc92f7532700fee8dc4b", "request_id": "6af8e5019470212cdc52230415844d03", "response_sha256": "0f2453fec5df170fd4ac8b55c2427d7022c5a4412743498babbc55c85b26eb1a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ee25c5ffdfbfed3171c13775234ffd443c16d626bf7f8380543be47552005609", "request_id": "3d19279c96c6cf591955ef790a831c0b", "response_sha256": "410c78f223a919aedb54e73f6c3193166cd2318b7c0588dc3c65e22dd1367448", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "3bdd35aeeb8dec8fa4e6a40e4ac7d9e3", "candidate_priority_rank": 23747, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0d46940e08858f4a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0d46940e08858f4a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0d46940e08858f4a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0d46940e08858f4a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2391328", "image_sha256": "0a029a4e71792a9b8b8450b174f76d1e56f5c70b97fe0041b62cf4d526add6d9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2391328.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2391328.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 300, "image_id": "2355304", "image_sha256": "fc06be816a714656f09272e1eb61d88b43604b972604fc507522080c21ec9ba5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2355304.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2355304.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0d46940e08858f4a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae38aedb7502c9cd77e2de2390f29daef1462110eb6334fffbd2550be42e47f3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3eea2fd858b83dbca1fda9c39527ae2ab95877ab497ef85a5f34d74d4604c338"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05160759", "text": "What is the black dog wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae38aedb7502c9cd77e2de2390f29daef1462110eb6334fffbd2550be42e47f3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dc656aeef42ef5d0064b9aaa0a63c40d47c1b56128a24254fec1d461ec45bf56"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "011022333", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 23747, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "07e92c91a5921a19afab2633db5a9695a8b644cdccf4d22197117af2f67e1125", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "011022333", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the brown dog wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "dog", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the dog wearing?", "program_group_hash": "07e92c91a5921a19afab2633db5a9695a8b644cdccf4d22197117af2f67e1125", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "dog", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the dog wearing?", "program_group_hash": "07e92c91a5921a19afab2633db5a9695a8b644cdccf4d22197117af2f67e1125", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "goggles", "full_answer": "The dog is wearing goggles.", "question": "What is the black dog wearing?", "question_id": "05160759", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (1241496)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (1241495)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "collar", "full_answer": "The dog is wearing a collar.", "question": "What is the brown dog wearing?", "question_id": "011022333", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (830842)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (830843)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1241474", "1241475", "1241476", "1241477", "1241481", "1241490", "1241491", "1241492", "1241493", "1241494", "1241495", "1241500", "1241501", "1241502", "1241504"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["goggles"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1241495", "query_target_entity_name": "goggles", "relation_object_entity_id": "1241495", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1241496", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1241496", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1241496"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["830837", "830839", "830840", "830841", "830842", "830843", "830844", "830845", "830849", "830850", "830851", "830859"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["830858"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["830837", "830839", "830840", "830841", "830843", "830844", "830845", "830849", "830850", "830851", "830858", "830859"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["collar"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "830843", "query_target_entity_name": "collar", "relation_object_entity_id": "830843", "relation_subject_entity_id": "830842", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "830842", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["830842"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:3bdd35aeeb8dec8fa4e6a40e4ac7d9e3", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "0a029a4e71792a9b8b8450b174f76d1e56f5c70b97fe0041b62cf4d526add6d9", "image_sha256_b": "fc06be816a714656f09272e1eb61d88b43604b972604fc507522080c21ec9ba5", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "15ba1db07645f23fb14a5e0a0bba7560a0bed0984943951e8720d8ce26fe1b50", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "cf35124c21001afeb65876469a834bd3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2f02a1a2fd04e48f8c67a4bba21b929c6302618a5d39e45b0c5d07fd8c6251c3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2882cd073c44f1e616bbee52b5e5644d3dae606d5fa306c0a8854c968b60fb17", "request_id": "3f5cc6707c45ba780130f603ede2fdc5", "response_sha256": "b5dcb127ef570e2ac853acf0ba163604fc7605e7983874c18004f1d811ed70d7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f6c9837bac18b2a5ca8179abdaface953dac8cab72fa14baa1cc37634c5e09ff", "request_id": "5541dddbe35f7fbdfad823f129a6e656", "response_sha256": "6eee938e73ccc69fc4d3877f06887701053def04d8faac2c1bd4dfabe4c44e96", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "3ba13f4b4ad9df1643b8a15d63785fb1", "candidate_priority_rank": 23874, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b99da6d39c3f8fc8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b99da6d39c3f8fc8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b99da6d39c3f8fc8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b99da6d39c3f8fc8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 679, "image_id": "498298", "image_sha256": "a30bbf64880ed470be9e098cb157a5d19b374bbfab2d45e8b59acd807c186d2f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/498298.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/498298.jpg", "width": 1024}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2381512", "image_sha256": "4913a2eaf58a549368fc03865ecbf3cad85cf02f5be4f7a212eb1a1a1d602643", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2381512.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2381512.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b99da6d39c3f8fc8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "dark brown", "gold", "gray"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "91f00bce9c7094e94c95a0750aa28dc92f33521bd003f1bd6bf9bcdfe335e358", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bc25df3f4d909e4ff44d6663e8fe570c0342dfd24767fd028c0031dde1268f0a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14983199", "text": "What is the blue food covered in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "91f00bce9c7094e94c95a0750aa28dc92f33521bd003f1bd6bf9bcdfe335e358", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8e704ef5435b060cedf22d1d2987161039b63295ee499cd145a44943a013cb95"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00379079", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 23874, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "201d4d1e5adbf380c95f1a8fea553f598a4bddeebdaf4aa7fa2144c9b405bf04", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "00379079", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the brown food covered in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "food", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,covered in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food covered in?", "program_group_hash": "201d4d1e5adbf380c95f1a8fea553f598a4bddeebdaf4aa7fa2144c9b405bf04", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "covered in", "select_category": "food"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "food", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,covered in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food covered in?", "program_group_hash": "201d4d1e5adbf380c95f1a8fea553f598a4bddeebdaf4aa7fa2144c9b405bf04", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "covered in", "select_category": "food"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "frosting", "full_answer": "The donut is covered in frosting.", "question": "What is the blue food covered in?", "question_id": "14983199", "semantic": [{"argument": "food (1575397)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,covered in,o (1575398)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "sprinkles", "full_answer": "The donut is covered in sprinkles.", "question": "What is the brown food covered in?", "question_id": "00379079", "semantic": [{"argument": "food (704155)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,covered in,o (704156)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1575349", "1575353", "1575356", "1575357", "1575359", "1575360", "1575362", "1575365", "1575368", "1575372", "1575373", "1575374", "1575375", "1575376", "1575377", "1575378", "1575379", "1575380", "1575394", "1575398", "1575399", "1575403", "1575404", "1575405", "1575409", "3789853"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 26, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["frosting"], "predicate": "covered in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1575398", "query_target_entity_name": "frosting", "relation_object_entity_id": "1575398", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1575397", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1575397", "selected_entity_name": "donut"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1575397"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["704152", "704153", "704154", "704156", "704157", "704158", "704162", "704163", "704164", "704165", "704166", "704168", "704169", "704171", "704172", "704173", "704174", "704175", "704176", "704177", "704178", "704179", "704180", "704181", "704183", "704184", "704185", "704186", "704189", "704190"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 30, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sprinkles"], "predicate": "covered in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["colorful"], "query_target_entity_id": "704156", "query_target_entity_name": "sprinkles", "relation_object_entity_id": "704156", "relation_subject_entity_id": "704155", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "704155", "selected_entity_name": "donut"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["704155"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:3ba13f4b4ad9df1643b8a15d63785fb1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a30bbf64880ed470be9e098cb157a5d19b374bbfab2d45e8b59acd807c186d2f", "image_sha256_b": "4913a2eaf58a549368fc03865ecbf3cad85cf02f5be4f7a212eb1a1a1d602643", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c841d580c99b0db1e9cd33307e09b816013770a3b71a8976c97fb0cb904132a1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "323e19ebabd57d16159f6b4966f9f4ea", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "48f026794f20b7464769ac4d5caef8120d56f76e1f4036c64c381b3f38537de7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "30952970f3b8c75e022b8c354cd7146784136a5b38f007e368abc8675ebf46a9", "request_id": "08541f67429216352184a5a50e9600db", "response_sha256": "79f5daa7c0befc47e9e1b331467e2ef8a2a8df2b1cc2675f02ebb131fc81596d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "98af2a53e1020232f46bff56dcc03592a797a92b2245f96222b1dde119b1457f", "request_id": "59f7d657b5c664b07949e702ef27d834", "response_sha256": "c4a66146b316a2eff0651dea689f77588fe2af184fd13d17b1dcb58a4d9650ea", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "2194348760db702291e3d39c62c175bc", "candidate_priority_rank": 24084, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3b3570eaec627d5f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3b3570eaec627d5f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3b3570eaec627d5f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3b3570eaec627d5f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "standing<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "walking", "B": "standing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "walking<->standing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2394406", "image_sha256": "5ff4e44a0704689bb21a040da11469bd01ec014160ba8d2b6db45960b70b1acf", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2394406.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2394406.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2346869", "image_sha256": "554e7f7f825382d11975fb361dab0a192ed9ee4ccf4b8e30615250c5e3508027", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2346869.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2346869.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3b3570eaec627d5f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "walking", "diff_b": "standing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "walking", "component_b": "standing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "d4e6e2e730fca3d5b69619cb1c80fbb72b5855b9b3f1d4ffb55a25b1a68cff14", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3a2176f4960f7330adda654b27acb7ed13b0f01e0f28d6618bfc069a422ee932"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16245339", "text": "What is the person that is walking wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["jumping", "standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "d4e6e2e730fca3d5b69619cb1c80fbb72b5855b9b3f1d4ffb55a25b1a68cff14", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b5e27dc43696e64571db4448e8955d0cbff3aff3df50549ca7b73803484ba013"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10222397", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 24084, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 58, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "07b46cf9cc4149f16a010b44e86bb0cba93829f7aca1fc3cea87c4880c68fdc0", "selected_component": "standing", "selected_source_question_id": "10222397", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is standing wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "07b46cf9cc4149f16a010b44e86bb0cba93829f7aca1fc3cea87c4880c68fdc0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "07b46cf9cc4149f16a010b44e86bb0cba93829f7aca1fc3cea87c4880c68fdc0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "helmet", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a helmet.", "question": "What is the person that is walking wearing?", "question_id": "16245339", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (666894)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (666900)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hat", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a hat.", "question": "What is the person that is standing wearing?", "question_id": "10222397", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (895810)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (895811)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["666893", "666895", "666900", "666905", "666906", "666907", "666909", "666910"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["helmet"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "666900", "query_target_entity_name": "helmet", "relation_object_entity_id": "666900", "relation_subject_entity_id": "666894", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "666894", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["666894"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["895808", "895809", "895811", "895812"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hat"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "895811", "query_target_entity_name": "hat", "relation_object_entity_id": "895811", "relation_subject_entity_id": "895810", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "895810", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["895810"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:2194348760db702291e3d39c62c175bc", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5ff4e44a0704689bb21a040da11469bd01ec014160ba8d2b6db45960b70b1acf", "image_sha256_b": "554e7f7f825382d11975fb361dab0a192ed9ee4ccf4b8e30615250c5e3508027", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "97a545e4118ec5087bd9a5f326d1e59d7853edffd6d122d7bd6fd460847abaef", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "87824e119d1e6da0190a7ab36ea1bdf8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2abeefcc5948292f60d0c5c156a56ec500d9eb838b2da6c86d5ce1cc11c833ba"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c2f372bf705e7220b6b4fd66c2b1324b6dbe1451508a2b2d76c98e2879e7a61b", "request_id": "e72467a7d55995a092e0f119e4d071dd", "response_sha256": "09d88df73b45e6c0217afbac0984fb2d9c60a2253bf321bbb6580e5f2504af15", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5472fea329c1d59ca2215d22adb431d123efef378191e86cd521d2ede1e39ae6", "request_id": "ea34dcf65e365635a9dc005f8bb99056", "response_sha256": "877eeada4720a1b67d78a4b60af71485637561769ef1924018ef930f01bff0c5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "afcb02427a78b154a73576c798f02b3d", "candidate_priority_rank": 24560, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-76d0c9a52f3c6643:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-76d0c9a52f3c6643:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-76d0c9a52f3c6643:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-76d0c9a52f3c6643:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "skiing<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "surfing", "B": "skiing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "surfing<->skiing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2369333", "image_sha256": "a82d915dfa73eb569d42c88ae374f2968a836082c890dff32f0dfd8a2f4b7a29", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369333.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369333.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2380665", "image_sha256": "12d38bba3ee0db205f8f4c18605bcc95f08507380c8735f263177f44c6777a7e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2380665.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2380665.jpg", "width": 314}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-76d0c9a52f3c6643", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "surfing", "diff_b": "skiing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "surfing", "component_b": "skiing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e60cb519061f9a7757db8551ae37f1c8e776ec4ce8929871b7d33b1bf739a866"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06881372", "text": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["skiing"], "detected_components": ["skiing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "skiing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b1b7723f85271e4c736be74c6accbbe92c5aa9ae0b19f0f01bbcc9b1872fbb6d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08207431", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 24560, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 17, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "selected_component": "skiing", "selected_source_question_id": "08207431", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is skiing wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "wetsuit", "full_answer": "The surfer is wearing a wetsuit.", "question": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?", "question_id": "06881372", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (612205)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (612213)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hat", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a hat.", "question": "What is the person that is skiing wearing?", "question_id": "08207431", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1343943)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "skiing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (1343945)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["612206", "612207", "612208", "612213", "612214", "612215", "612216"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wetsuit"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "612213", "query_target_entity_name": "wetsuit", "relation_object_entity_id": "612213", "relation_subject_entity_id": "612205", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "612205", "selected_entity_name": "surfer"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["612205"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1343945", "1343946", "1343949", "1343950", "1343951", "1343952", "1343953", "1343954", "1343956", "1343957", "1343958"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hat"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "1343945", "query_target_entity_name": "hat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1343945", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1343943", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1343943", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1343943"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:afcb02427a78b154a73576c798f02b3d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a82d915dfa73eb569d42c88ae374f2968a836082c890dff32f0dfd8a2f4b7a29", "image_sha256_b": "12d38bba3ee0db205f8f4c18605bcc95f08507380c8735f263177f44c6777a7e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "6c7208cdef8eb4f7a1f86a302b0a79956da584fc160139b56a40f75c4e2bb0f2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e50e256f852185240da978b523e61125", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d16930bbbe9aa2add94aafda354b663941f494618769b9752665d25dde92f07a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2562c249e4c7a85ac7a9c27f3f5e767257e264aec02c658664c910f7fb5e2b3a", "request_id": "1cf711fe2d20667d1811c5f903d4e670", "response_sha256": "a8437203c772da37492aa231ceaabb5ebc56ca57700fee0b14b280c8269234f4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "526f205450f246e1e3058e7daea65662f14f65cd08552d75b82c3a5eb9257e45", "request_id": "086ae42eb973bc30a83e16785f47941b", "response_sha256": "557b5e13f6599138bb3d713918e241e6ad2f59f7c35c76565f10430365d29f43", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "5720f9c8cc9bdcfbf0ad8b63b1e0c843", "candidate_priority_rank": 24824, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e1e5447d68d2a66:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e1e5447d68d2a66:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e1e5447d68d2a66:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e1e5447d68d2a66:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2379256", "image_sha256": "bb7e5e01e45c3e56750032bf3ff938961b2c13852e17e9f7bddd10a9e93de2a4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2379256.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2379256.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2403169", "image_sha256": "a2118724fdb43852860af1ed69f3aac970741d950c1c2c15bb3a61b88cdfae5e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2403169.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2403169.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e1e5447d68d2a66", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blond", "blue", "brown", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "45692036505c4a342ecd717b54649c2a244b1b7a1b17b6851d1d92504c30c2c3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["roof"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["roof"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "60abe9cff0e5877cb49987621d984ac792942a1c94095213215e05e833d64073"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0396443", "text": "What is on the blue roof?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "dark", "gray", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "45692036505c4a342ecd717b54649c2a244b1b7a1b17b6851d1d92504c30c2c3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["roof"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["roof"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8c30da000ed042dd7d4873596c55bce0bbbabde1d36c9fcedeac3f5f25359708"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19357282", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 24824, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b83cabe76bd2831ffd5f4365fab091df346c03fa6b338b6837469bcaf6aee4e5", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "19357282", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the brown roof?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "roof", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the roof?", "program_group_hash": "b83cabe76bd2831ffd5f4365fab091df346c03fa6b338b6837469bcaf6aee4e5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "roof"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "roof", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the roof?", "program_group_hash": "b83cabe76bd2831ffd5f4365fab091df346c03fa6b338b6837469bcaf6aee4e5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "roof"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "antenna", "full_answer": "The antenna is on the roof.", "question": "What is on the blue roof?", "question_id": "0396443", "semantic": [{"argument": "roof (1359218)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1359230)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "american flag", "full_answer": "The American flag is on the roof.", "question": "What is on the brown roof?", "question_id": "19357282", "semantic": [{"argument": "roof (355958)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (355953)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1359208", "1359209", "1359211", "1359212", "1359213", "1359214", "1359216", "1359217", "1359219", "1359220", "1359221", "1359222", "1359223", "1359224", "1359225", "1359226", "1359227", "1359228", "1359230", "1359231", "1359232", "1359233", "1359235", "1359236", "1359237", "1359239", "1359240", "1359241", "1359242"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 29, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["antenna"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1359230", "query_target_entity_name": "antenna", "relation_object_entity_id": "1359218", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1359230", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1359218", "selected_entity_name": "roof"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1359218"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["355953", "355954", "355955", "355956", "355959", "355960", "355961", "355962", "355964", "355965", "355966", "355968"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["american flag"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "355953", "query_target_entity_name": "american flag", "relation_object_entity_id": "355958", "relation_subject_entity_id": "355953", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "355958", "selected_entity_name": "roof"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["355958"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:5720f9c8cc9bdcfbf0ad8b63b1e0c843", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bb7e5e01e45c3e56750032bf3ff938961b2c13852e17e9f7bddd10a9e93de2a4", "image_sha256_b": "a2118724fdb43852860af1ed69f3aac970741d950c1c2c15bb3a61b88cdfae5e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7fc9b76e62e5c069e7a16a29146a3cbc3043aecb9256b10976ccf8f0e8abcd6e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "876ee833d7e4b9681c64ad82991220ff", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "23885659c20ab7c4f10add29c49ca669a101b56ecbcf83a3edfe431b47bcc16f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "01adb84082a18569b79823a6d743f31de5510a716803211e796c97c0aa1cdfbd", "request_id": "22b67ed344b62a7f89724e1768982eb6", "response_sha256": "5b917cf5ea9c40c2336a811e30b1ed941b22c16d6d5f5ad72d713e815216963c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "394be4b43762c6bc94cf48b1ffbe075c53e03826da7b06d81faaa9a83365bcad", "request_id": "58a6420f64a517e8a95738dd4144d457", "response_sha256": "7a21bb6d224f972851ded6b31bef1c51437b93334300f6b8dec507426a3c2e4e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "417b859dbf57ad84d47c9e0911870b35", "candidate_priority_rank": 24832, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f375a6c74ae4035b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f375a6c74ae4035b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f375a6c74ae4035b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f375a6c74ae4035b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gray", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gray<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2337137", "image_sha256": "8ca58874ee2a163b077f34d218c7a78fa493f93a0da82d300446fc0d143c2184", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2337137.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2337137.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2342105", "image_sha256": "89704b61ff4aed46b29c20a6e9bf9e54296257346acae6ba769f44021ad24d16", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342105.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342105.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f375a6c74ae4035b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gray", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gray", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "d550a97ca6fd928e10610c856497e45c1c0255c7874e3132ce9667ff72e11725", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sky"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sky"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1c3bf1038ada5ba07dca35fc71856a9fe54bbddc4bcab83a44d46de1a15f125c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02257552", "text": "What is the gray sky full of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "green", "orange", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "d550a97ca6fd928e10610c856497e45c1c0255c7874e3132ce9667ff72e11725", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sky"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sky"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ea72500346aeac8db5d460814c83c21c2b2691daad90997bbe5826035a31fde6"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10726733", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 24832, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2689c7ae9c78ed109882f0c01bb1b4bf8c90fd75fb33d400e86fe6a3fc2d613d", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "10726733", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the blue sky full of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "sky", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,full of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the sky full of?", "program_group_hash": "2689c7ae9c78ed109882f0c01bb1b4bf8c90fd75fb33d400e86fe6a3fc2d613d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "full of", "select_category": "sky"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "sky", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,full of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the sky full of?", "program_group_hash": "2689c7ae9c78ed109882f0c01bb1b4bf8c90fd75fb33d400e86fe6a3fc2d613d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "full of", "select_category": "sky"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "fog", "full_answer": "The sky is full of fog.", "question": "What is the gray sky full of?", "question_id": "02257552", "semantic": [{"argument": "sky (2690920)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,full of,o (3709672)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "kites", "full_answer": "The sky is full of kites.", "question": "What is the blue sky full of?", "question_id": "10726733", "semantic": [{"argument": "sky (937211)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,full of,o (937212)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2028556", "2076050", "2084082", "2195664", "2281836", "2281837", "2423819", "2480183", "2624065", "2634959", "2722326", "2915389", "3016004", "3016005", "3130520", "3138862", "3138863", "3183158", "3183159", "3316418", "3351381", "3478617", "3654785", "3709672"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 24, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fog"], "predicate": "full of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3709672", "query_target_entity_name": "fog", "relation_object_entity_id": "3709672", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2690920", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2690920", "selected_entity_name": "sky"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2690920"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["937212", "937214", "937215", "937217", "937218", "937219", "937221", "937223", "937224", "937225", "937226", "937227", "937228", "937229", "937230", "937232", "937234", "937235", "937236", "937238"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["kites"], "predicate": "full of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["colorful"], "query_target_entity_id": "937212", "query_target_entity_name": "kites", "relation_object_entity_id": "937212", "relation_subject_entity_id": "937211", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "937211", "selected_entity_name": "sky"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["937211"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:417b859dbf57ad84d47c9e0911870b35", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8ca58874ee2a163b077f34d218c7a78fa493f93a0da82d300446fc0d143c2184", "image_sha256_b": "89704b61ff4aed46b29c20a6e9bf9e54296257346acae6ba769f44021ad24d16", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d210ab48532c86339163d60e1a62560e7680dc9993bcd0895bcd2790be31c54c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "51518c6dcbfb6ef1842e0e698f741740", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "8eb628bfc2b747845c03e31a50e645395b0c490c9112da62b201a9ec3a953f88"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "34bc30bdaf9b3a85745278b241af86b1bedd4518a6add14382e207fe3181a666", "request_id": "9af54b7f3e25342489f8d6e4454db71a", "response_sha256": "ff06e194e7c42a46e9e9279624f0034819dbed28b27b2daa86e42e714f039fa0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "48143af5768bd337a8a06f8119dc0191724005556927e32f19720bc82c049f54", "request_id": "da0240098937e8c810b5510164d0c2df", "response_sha256": "32d67bed367ad5deeb873235063ce48e3b64c9c23da2d96af3fe022588265329", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "844e6a217e90fb674ccbc83e2922b359", "candidate_priority_rank": 25142, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b08f29e262d9069c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b08f29e262d9069c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b08f29e262d9069c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b08f29e262d9069c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "red<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "red"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->red", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2322640", "image_sha256": "1f217bc9e2d00b2794f1690f161919899d764340717904c94a4ab9248569a96f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2322640.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2322640.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2373583", "image_sha256": "4f5753777658d96cfe6dff56c9a17f860be015947580785de65228d0b1961ab3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2373583.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2373583.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b08f29e262d9069c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "red", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "red"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "red", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "d2bad4d44d3b2665388b8585499b8269d6dd5666955b7d503ee4f02bd8646e8c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "24bc995d78a9f4b2cb689adf7157ffbb8f3f15fd64bf1ad7300596bde75d7e91"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02545074", "text": "What is in the white basket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "green", "red", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "d2bad4d44d3b2665388b8585499b8269d6dd5666955b7d503ee4f02bd8646e8c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f97e61e4d21ee245bc15582995a07dec8983ad4a5f4b2d0b5a93ef4c0dd12929"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10330351", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25142, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "01384b5c473638f180ddd2cc1ccb19aff335750a5bf907cd2e9ccf43a55e095d", "selected_component": "red", "selected_source_question_id": "10330351", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the red basket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "basket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the basket?", "program_group_hash": "01384b5c473638f180ddd2cc1ccb19aff335750a5bf907cd2e9ccf43a55e095d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "basket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "basket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the basket?", "program_group_hash": "01384b5c473638f180ddd2cc1ccb19aff335750a5bf907cd2e9ccf43a55e095d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "basket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bananas", "full_answer": "The bananas are in the basket.", "question": "What is in the white basket?", "question_id": "02545074", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (990972)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (990983)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chains", "full_answer": "The chains are in the basket.", "question": "What is in the red basket?", "question_id": "10330351", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (588477)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (588489)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["990968", "990969", "990970", "990971", "990973", "990974", "990975", "990976", "990977", "990979", "990980", "990981", "990982", "990983", "990984", "990985", "990986", "990987", "990988", "990989", "990990", "990992"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bananas"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "990983", "query_target_entity_name": "bananas", "relation_object_entity_id": "990972", "relation_subject_entity_id": "990983", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "990972", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["990972"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["588459", "588460", "588461", "588462", "588463", "588464", "588465", "588466", "588467", "588468", "588469", "588471", "588472", "588473", "588474", "588475", "588476", "588478", "588480", "588481", "588482", "588485", "588487", "588489", "588490", "588492", "588494", "588495"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 28, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chains"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "588489", "query_target_entity_name": "chains", "relation_object_entity_id": "588477", "relation_subject_entity_id": "588489", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "588477", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["588477"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:844e6a217e90fb674ccbc83e2922b359", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1f217bc9e2d00b2794f1690f161919899d764340717904c94a4ab9248569a96f", "image_sha256_b": "4f5753777658d96cfe6dff56c9a17f860be015947580785de65228d0b1961ab3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "787cf49543022e63254d254b8760616d4d92b0b9d77c6d9988c3dae790b83947", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a72a12d12e637e6df1165aa9efbab0fa", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "cf349ff3ab6f8ce6755736d2ac421286ef880cc81e736b053f2ecc021b384d60"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "518eedce484b10013088bc0f47e877c5b62480cbd3088a945682c0864eb8b053", "request_id": "793e6dfbb935fa1a2934e9e547dbecb6", "response_sha256": "6c7530a8472b377b1c98c2f6e9d7c8a3bf4ae17c3a591421fbe47ac00cae3979", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "215bfe0d0c396091742ae39b7468e1070abc4c4f5d9b7dfc8717e36f04ccd405", "request_id": "a488b347e0ce7f5be1d048dc89f21b3c", "response_sha256": "10daf1bfd1de9e0bf7213136fdc78fd4cfed024ea62c2b5e5749892d0fb86706", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "a680a2696aab2762b766a6ffbf5847a2", "candidate_priority_rank": 25156, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89807269dff2a3c6:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89807269dff2a3c6:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89807269dff2a3c6:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89807269dff2a3c6:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2412269", "image_sha256": "2462eada40505074578fa66fd5b80a2f1fcb28588dd01a34b4ab719f2225d53a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412269.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412269.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2400012", "image_sha256": "ddf61510893af5df3cf81b864e0442f2b22af9ec8c488a2b49b1be683daeaf8e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400012.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400012.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89807269dff2a3c6", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beige", "black", "blue", "brown", "dark", "pink", "red", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "7ac0fbabad5128a7627845d7716e2ad8a330eae03e59cc6020a2d65ec21afeb1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pot"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pot"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "efea86ea6817439af6534b36e54cde6d18f13389617b7a271f603fd85d4441a4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13312672", "text": "What is in the brown pot?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "pink", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "7ac0fbabad5128a7627845d7716e2ad8a330eae03e59cc6020a2d65ec21afeb1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pot"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pot"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ad45105a4cf9a78eaedc8b0798d48a17d291839d2ac971e64360795fabf28675"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03909573", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25156, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "618b7dc1972d94f8ce6c4588b1f3c1502a421011ffeaa1782fcd7a5270a305ae", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "03909573", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the white pot?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pot", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the pot?", "program_group_hash": "618b7dc1972d94f8ce6c4588b1f3c1502a421011ffeaa1782fcd7a5270a305ae", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "pot"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pot", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the pot?", "program_group_hash": "618b7dc1972d94f8ce6c4588b1f3c1502a421011ffeaa1782fcd7a5270a305ae", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "pot"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cactus", "full_answer": "The cactus is in the pot.", "question": "What is in the brown pot?", "question_id": "13312672", "semantic": [{"argument": "pot (198702)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (198701)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "flowers", "full_answer": "The flowers are in the pot.", "question": "What is in the white pot?", "question_id": "03909573", "semantic": [{"argument": "pot (4295623)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (4295622)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["198676", "198677", "198678", "198679", "198680", "198682", "198683", "198684", "198685", "198686", "198687", "198688", "198689", "198690", "198691", "198692", "198693", "198694", "198695", "198696", "198697", "198698", "198699", "198700", "198701"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 25, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cactus"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "198701", "query_target_entity_name": "cactus", "relation_object_entity_id": "198702", "relation_subject_entity_id": "198701", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "198702", "selected_entity_name": "pot"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["198702"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4295598", "4295605", "4295612", "4295617", "4295619", "4295622", "4295625", "4295629", "4295630", "4295634", "4295641"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["flowers"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4295622", "query_target_entity_name": "flowers", "relation_object_entity_id": "4295623", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4295622", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4295623", "selected_entity_name": "pot"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4295623"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:a680a2696aab2762b766a6ffbf5847a2", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2462eada40505074578fa66fd5b80a2f1fcb28588dd01a34b4ab719f2225d53a", "image_sha256_b": "ddf61510893af5df3cf81b864e0442f2b22af9ec8c488a2b49b1be683daeaf8e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f599ec03f028989da34225988d0e2e4defb605f750eb45eaff19795f09511543", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a041fac528b4636609a316e45514b238", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f82a5a68b9ca97102de38c41189125a1683a216f6d184b99737e8be6a9facde5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ae5b2a8d8d06af92a3d5e99c7b54c2bc1751cdb37ed08552dfde286450ea9608", "request_id": "123347811cb530e0ba38d40ed3aae315", "response_sha256": "e8db6f1e1d5737ce2813d02bc121b2fd994dea1c92d15b698edb242d07091304", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9df0b1f4579435af80447ed51e4a3ea8b3e7750b39dc6448401791c24a71fbd3", "request_id": "0bc6f84184d5ed75fed72bf43a73dbce", "response_sha256": "5652bdc0f733336f4340e39a0f1239000f84a7743193424e87f93a3fa8e830f3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "1ca7ceb92cd855dc801fbb0dcf73e697", "candidate_priority_rank": 25347, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9fdb307073241bb7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9fdb307073241bb7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9fdb307073241bb7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9fdb307073241bb7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "silver<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "silver"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->silver", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2318089", "image_sha256": "a819c5df44dcdaabf268f85f8f9734acce128830dcb3c1e54b31d8b61d6988aa", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2318089.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2318089.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2389682", "image_sha256": "18f2bf75b183b8d404d84e31a480b455f58205ebce91a67270d23b95656c446e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389682.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389682.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9fdb307073241bb7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "silver", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "silver"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beige", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "53b527c386fb718e3afdfb3a1d1f89073b0bd01710876e889d9ca0437d4f1856", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "299e93e97a190f167c2ada9903d3412329874d24440806cd5a30cface2d516cd"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14527655", "text": "What is in the white bowl?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blond", "blue", "brown", "pink", "silver"], "detected_components": ["silver"], "masked_program_sha256": "53b527c386fb718e3afdfb3a1d1f89073b0bd01710876e889d9ca0437d4f1856", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "silver", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c1ad959af9b82824aa1bc2b61f7a818f771f6832831c8a533f2b980a3ec36faf"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1944537", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25347, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "56a905337fd3ba9c5d8b80e4ab730c875e10489cd0ea04eedc65471cbb12eb6d", "selected_component": "silver", "selected_source_question_id": "1944537", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the silver bowl?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bowl", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bowl?", "program_group_hash": "56a905337fd3ba9c5d8b80e4ab730c875e10489cd0ea04eedc65471cbb12eb6d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bowl", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bowl?", "program_group_hash": "56a905337fd3ba9c5d8b80e4ab730c875e10489cd0ea04eedc65471cbb12eb6d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "balls", "full_answer": "The balls are in the bowl.", "question": "What is in the white bowl?", "question_id": "14527655", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (1014214)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (1014215)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "salad", "full_answer": "The salad is in the bowl.", "question": "What is in the silver bowl?", "question_id": "1944537", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (503303)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "silver", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (503304)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1014205", "1014206", "1014207", "1014210", "1014211", "1014215", "1014216", "1014217", "1014218", "1014219", "1014223", "1014224", "1014226", "1014227", "1014228", "1014229"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["balls"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["decorative"], "query_target_entity_id": "1014215", "query_target_entity_name": "balls", "relation_object_entity_id": "1014214", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1014215", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1014214", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1014214"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["503288", "503289", "503290", "503291", "503293", "503294", "503295", "503296", "503298", "503299", "503300", "503301", "503302", "503304", "503305"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["salad"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "503304", "query_target_entity_name": "salad", "relation_object_entity_id": "503303", "relation_subject_entity_id": "503304", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "503303", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["503303"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:1ca7ceb92cd855dc801fbb0dcf73e697", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a819c5df44dcdaabf268f85f8f9734acce128830dcb3c1e54b31d8b61d6988aa", "image_sha256_b": "18f2bf75b183b8d404d84e31a480b455f58205ebce91a67270d23b95656c446e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "01d4c2bd506983fb28112f3eb78245701f1b348e4b039d57a72ca572affb0d75", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b337a52d14d208801e01d27fb1bdb14b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "26b12dfd513f686168b38ea04b66a13dcb193a4f2bfacb564517d9cb9960f259"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4d6389571f51e17e7bf3f0b81cd9ca1647e335acba6d798d76790a52a9f14f74", "request_id": "2a473b1b4c5b5e4ae88f70f15ee92f77", "response_sha256": "df8de45f2a3afc71a2e754f5c25a1b1a211e392f95b36c6e39a64ea877aa58b3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c0ca71964da6c66ce472599e48eab1bfc59be108c5c7d9ebec2ec79e34dee6e5", "request_id": "16ee34c0cc8a36a2d87cc176bb21128c", "response_sha256": "d75dbf39b03f5cc84cc4b6efb6be3821f888b547d299f72946fa46d671e6724b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "c40e525fd4a8af4658e885656b1e976b", "candidate_priority_rank": 25614, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c435a43eb62d8c82:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c435a43eb62d8c82:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c435a43eb62d8c82:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c435a43eb62d8c82:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2402809", "image_sha256": "5623ee2278f0c2fa08da648d0d0dd884b931dcc6556c15e3a026eb5b40f455ad", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402809.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402809.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 472, "image_id": "2386795", "image_sha256": "9d0670e8e6b561545c7e29f44723707fb28aba563a791050dd36f5ec020ed119", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386795.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386795.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c435a43eb62d8c82", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "00e1f1aa4f90b8eff97f0be484af7220e4114326b429edf2700d46f8dce53334", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a89697f50020288535f07471ba60944f40ddd5badc4f302a356556e8c561c7a0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "15526528", "text": "What is the brown animal wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "pink", "red", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "00e1f1aa4f90b8eff97f0be484af7220e4114326b429edf2700d46f8dce53334", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "da0a32598db0ba66d7fd858d1830de0ffad566614d7592b11bb2226176801899"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04687908", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25614, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 13, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9b59952d4e37e30e62fd799bae04a7ca60fb28b9d7859b2f9c5e4d91faa128bd", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "04687908", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the white animal wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal wearing?", "program_group_hash": "9b59952d4e37e30e62fd799bae04a7ca60fb28b9d7859b2f9c5e4d91faa128bd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal wearing?", "program_group_hash": "9b59952d4e37e30e62fd799bae04a7ca60fb28b9d7859b2f9c5e4d91faa128bd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "scarf", "full_answer": "The bear is wearing a scarf.", "question": "What is the brown animal wearing?", "question_id": "15526528", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1131457)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (1131468)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bandana", "full_answer": "The dog is wearing a bandana.", "question": "What is the white animal wearing?", "question_id": "04687908", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (516759)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (516779)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1131458", "1131460", "1131463", "1131465", "1131467", "1131468", "1131469", "1131470", "1131471", "1131473"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["scarf"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1131468", "query_target_entity_name": "scarf", "relation_object_entity_id": "1131468", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1131457", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1131457", "selected_entity_name": "bear"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1131457"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["516760", "516762", "516763", "516766", "516767", "516770", "516771", "516772", "516773", "516774", "516775", "516777", "516778", "516779", "516783", "516784", "516785", "516786", "516787", "516788", "516792", "516793", "516794"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 23, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bandana"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "516779", "query_target_entity_name": "bandana", "relation_object_entity_id": "516779", "relation_subject_entity_id": "516759", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "516759", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["516759"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:c40e525fd4a8af4658e885656b1e976b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5623ee2278f0c2fa08da648d0d0dd884b931dcc6556c15e3a026eb5b40f455ad", "image_sha256_b": "9d0670e8e6b561545c7e29f44723707fb28aba563a791050dd36f5ec020ed119", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e8c20680aaf9b98f3cbf205f9759f25cb6951f4f7b1625c550b12a8edaf88272", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "caa93a34856566418a219a83d607a6fa", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1e24568a40416b5086ec8405c660c79eb5e9897a2d9558bd4835e44403954c9d"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6439a25a4060b0e1ef771ce5b8bfb7b7ca20b5c97d78aa899d1586048010a72b", "request_id": "9a29e38ed68a26f59b5bb83fbea1d0a9", "response_sha256": "c75d0b80a5b0dc2282c4abbced3df895cd0cfaa278865f6f7e259a271e44ded6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d077a72d36e3f754532c562a329059f1e0e558851ee0fe09dd324815cb4e2ac0", "request_id": "96af698c93bab26689dcbbb7d36e5e99", "response_sha256": "858f80dc4eb559ce31663cbba57c69b40d7566295c27e6d3307c583dae879aa1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "32293701369f1f7667f7a06901f112bd", "candidate_priority_rank": 25633, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e15033148deb5ced:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e15033148deb5ced:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e15033148deb5ced:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e15033148deb5ced:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "snowboarding<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "surfing", "B": "snowboarding"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "surfing<->snowboarding", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 265, "image_id": "2386784", "image_sha256": "0fcd51925f14a94a84b4ff493ba79b0b6cacca3b071b83facf0280ea3f3d9985", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386784.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386784.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2367350", "image_sha256": "568096eefb93f15a47a72efca0c200c8aa414fc9afec82402928919e11885b3a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367350.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367350.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e15033148deb5ced", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "surfing", "diff_b": "snowboarding", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "surfing", "component_b": "snowboarding"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "6ec7ffb45bdfe07ddb7def04e16c6887295e9fdbedf55ef844158601067b52dd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d4d8d25a1490290ad712f421458a02f991ea9716a015d91a4bb93251031a2b30"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07639648", "text": "What is the person that is surfing standing on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["snowboarding"], "detected_components": ["snowboarding"], "masked_program_sha256": "6ec7ffb45bdfe07ddb7def04e16c6887295e9fdbedf55ef844158601067b52dd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "snowboarding", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "caddb3318e18d92c7562c7ef3834055026c38a5a1021cbf7aef18ac1a4b07e9e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0873631", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25633, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "144fb240cf38cab91748b7bfbc080637beb8d38a6fb12843b264a9528ffb9557", "selected_component": "snowboarding", "selected_source_question_id": "0873631", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is snowboarding standing on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is standing on?", "program_group_hash": "144fb240cf38cab91748b7bfbc080637beb8d38a6fb12843b264a9528ffb9557", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is standing on?", "program_group_hash": "144fb240cf38cab91748b7bfbc080637beb8d38a6fb12843b264a9528ffb9557", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "surfboard", "full_answer": "The person is standing on the surfboard.", "question": "What is the person that is surfing standing on?", "question_id": "07639648", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1282485)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (1282486)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "snowboard", "full_answer": "The person is standing on the snowboard.", "question": "What is the person that is snowboarding standing on?", "question_id": "0873631", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (623099)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "snowboarding", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (623103)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1282486", "1282487", "1282489", "1282493", "1282494", "1282500", "1282501", "1282502", "1282503", "1282504", "1282505", "1282506"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["surfboard"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["splashing", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1282486", "query_target_entity_name": "surfboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "1282486", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1282485", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1282485", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1282485"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "snowboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["623100", "623101", "623102", "623103", "623104", "623105", "623106", "623107", "623108", "623109", "623110", "623111", "623112", "623113", "623114"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["snowboard"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "623103", "query_target_entity_name": "snowboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "623103", "relation_subject_entity_id": "623099", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "623099", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "snowboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["623099"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:32293701369f1f7667f7a06901f112bd", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "0fcd51925f14a94a84b4ff493ba79b0b6cacca3b071b83facf0280ea3f3d9985", "image_sha256_b": "568096eefb93f15a47a72efca0c200c8aa414fc9afec82402928919e11885b3a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0d3e5508ddcdceedf7c9a9d6f8c6542749bfb215fc1862b5dd273d5026d5b8e4", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1dc91d1eff534213d8447ff8f11a94a8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1dc326875e591e95d02bbe73a12e6856bf6e4043e5263012d815b9456cdaec7f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "80020918872d500297c9dc4f716e9c6c6f9f1fb8ab25b9fcbf85fa10dfbedaaa", "request_id": "19c2f3b94904dcf95d94d32168c1d6d4", "response_sha256": "376c68123b0a6b3163c3fa8a6385430ac39ef2c38bb0aa6c18e2371303dc7661", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e47cae0bcbfbbcaa58f96977985cac128aa858f258a0941b5ac2608a31e14e07", "request_id": "01d6e807ae811ee928da795df14f14d0", "response_sha256": "9a38ab819cc326b6f0f641bad5aeb0a7179e05d97c250886775707a98a1d51f6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "dbcc6325d554f6b5f42d31b707d2fb78", "candidate_priority_rank": 25768, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-40968ce62563c6c3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-40968ce62563c6c3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-40968ce62563c6c3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-40968ce62563c6c3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "concrete<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "concrete", "B": "wood"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "concrete<->wood", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2384158", "image_sha256": "f0f623073d750436d2c37fe62032f8f5d042ac05923b33a062cf94b99034c492", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384158.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384158.jpg", "width": 363}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2394367", "image_sha256": "bdee3ed45c74a38ef502b8f9c7a8912b59e46aa787adb21f41e2c75813a925d3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2394367.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2394367.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-40968ce62563c6c3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "concrete", "diff_b": "wood", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "concrete", "component_b": "wood"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["concrete"], "detected_components": ["concrete"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "concrete", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "262cff1081c91bcaa8deb9e9d368c06e9aa6c9c98c6aa0bf77879bd5d9ed5dcf"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1292541", "text": "What is on the concrete wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["porcelain", "wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d3466c0c725f80ac5fb4642b5a74d9ba2c40cb5757e8780bbff19b1cd827febf"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11713979", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25768, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 26, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2bef5906f241b03de4a71550f0a90863677e1dfbf3df580f7d6977acbeba0222", "selected_component": "wood", "selected_source_question_id": "11713979", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the wood wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "2bef5906f241b03de4a71550f0a90863677e1dfbf3df580f7d6977acbeba0222", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "2bef5906f241b03de4a71550f0a90863677e1dfbf3df580f7d6977acbeba0222", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "graffiti", "full_answer": "The graffiti is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the concrete wall?", "question_id": "1292541", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (528222)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "concrete", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (528221)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "light switch", "full_answer": "The switch is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the wood wall?", "question_id": "11713979", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (464825)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (464824)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["528207", "528208", "528210", "528211", "528212", "528213", "528215", "528218", "528220", "528221", "528225", "528226", "528227", "528230", "528232", "528235", "528237", "528239", "528241", "528244", "528245", "528247", "528249"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 23, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["graffiti"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "528221", "query_target_entity_name": "graffiti", "relation_object_entity_id": "528222", "relation_subject_entity_id": "528221", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "528222", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "concrete", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["528222"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "concrete", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["464805", "464806", "464807", "464808", "464809", "464811", "464813", "464814", "464815", "464816", "464817", "464819", "464821", "464822", "464823", "464824", "464827", "464829", "464831", "464832", "464833", "464838"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["light switch"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["silver", "square"], "query_target_entity_id": "464824", "query_target_entity_name": "light switch", "relation_object_entity_id": "464825", "relation_subject_entity_id": "464824", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "464825", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["464825"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:dbcc6325d554f6b5f42d31b707d2fb78", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f0f623073d750436d2c37fe62032f8f5d042ac05923b33a062cf94b99034c492", "image_sha256_b": "bdee3ed45c74a38ef502b8f9c7a8912b59e46aa787adb21f41e2c75813a925d3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "bd6542c940d02be2e99c9732189c359db1c9105cd32dc701f5cffcd7d0eeab2a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "feaa9c48ed31987a6cfca1956e80e7c0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "46e38d9c74b6937aadfd69ceac782608625851a5502db2bd05d835e0c612d5db"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bfe3ec2c32a25d0668c38042f0ff8779658480650b3cc9fb6ef39c95edea3bf2", "request_id": "60da942868e02d5ddefbb3de897b9ac7", "response_sha256": "ab3ed057735ccb5bc086fac1283b0fd04aea757ee3cbe3bf56650942e795d378", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "38ae8c3c4cc9512318f9079efefc9e24ac6f72207d28ea86bf62abcd996500b3", "request_id": "532f5e32965a814cc35e65a2571871c3", "response_sha256": "d9be202afae7efa3aa73115a8a19867f294465c6207986623a89b0ab31fd9716", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "335bf9f6097885adf0c2506f2be560af", "candidate_priority_rank": 26040, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f2e5b89ebe2108:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f2e5b89ebe2108:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f2e5b89ebe2108:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f2e5b89ebe2108:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2368734", "image_sha256": "7c7679bae9309191fcb00b4299e5f36661c795fc94b16c16ef7c58e2a052adc7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2368734.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2368734.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2351290", "image_sha256": "873167f46c21c28fa2cfad0d0ca0be77cf28998866393751510c94bbe2633f1b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2351290.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2351290.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f2e5b89ebe2108", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "green", "purple", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "2973084cd525afcfd5c247a73c9c2a039844f0cc431963cf2dc47154209285b4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8cc82700fb285b6684b44a6dd92b7c3e7e525686aa1a732703f757ee24ddfe0f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12966296", "text": "What is on the green pole?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "green", "silver", "tan"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "2973084cd525afcfd5c247a73c9c2a039844f0cc431963cf2dc47154209285b4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f9ed55d69889bac21de592ec808a3cab9b60699e0880b769a8ed020d03c80093"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19169710", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26040, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 59, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "476cbbc136ee064c2fd7ac2cad33873eeee8b6e378c20fb3af17bd6a7108bc09", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "19169710", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the blue pole?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pole", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the pole?", "program_group_hash": "476cbbc136ee064c2fd7ac2cad33873eeee8b6e378c20fb3af17bd6a7108bc09", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pole"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pole", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the pole?", "program_group_hash": "476cbbc136ee064c2fd7ac2cad33873eeee8b6e378c20fb3af17bd6a7108bc09", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pole"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bicycle", "full_answer": "The bicycle is on the pole.", "question": "What is on the green pole?", "question_id": "12966296", "semantic": [{"argument": "pole (3867299)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2319141)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "poster", "full_answer": "The poster is on the pole.", "question": "What is on the blue pole?", "question_id": "19169710", "semantic": [{"argument": "pole (2285646)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2285645)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1765445", "1777857", "1839086", "1865218", "1898503", "1898504", "1905686", "1966755", "2132250", "2133163", "2312203", "2319141", "2356615", "2427900", "2427901", "2504772", "2570991", "2612006", "3867295", "3867296", "3867297", "3867298"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bicycle"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "2319141", "query_target_entity_name": "bicycle", "relation_object_entity_id": "3867299", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2319141", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3867299", "selected_entity_name": "pole"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3867299"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1720044", "1720046", "1720047", "1805418", "1824933", "1900228", "1941798", "1989261", "2078325", "2285645", "2383114", "2397976", "2582119", "2582120", "2582121", "2582122", "2582123", "2624910", "2630855", "2630856", "2637640", "2673184", "3589772", "3897847"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 24, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["poster"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2285645", "query_target_entity_name": "poster", "relation_object_entity_id": "2285646", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2285645", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2285646", "selected_entity_name": "pole"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2285646"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:335bf9f6097885adf0c2506f2be560af", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7c7679bae9309191fcb00b4299e5f36661c795fc94b16c16ef7c58e2a052adc7", "image_sha256_b": "873167f46c21c28fa2cfad0d0ca0be77cf28998866393751510c94bbe2633f1b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "08890260be4365d94062199906a0af3c70eaa4c401aacb9e07185a0bee9de4a1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5d74d187b328f1eee96b49a977e8e836", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3002c6f1b4cd6657978209624d270c08c1fbe27167b8e1f71c5fe1ecc2d2f211"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0f906134a15c44a1c356c360a135adfe4db07dd7cc4b98f56b28e86fbc331791", "request_id": "b45b86d854adaed4332b9816280fb32b", "response_sha256": "4a3214fdd3d9e0945cad0d33df4cf02b3172b8f4dbc15b2f7d3335839204cf73", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7df4b4601290360bbd26e6fee64b204aa33c9edc03c502e0e5e862a284207470", "request_id": "eb9df04cf07e4c0bf71bec30f8bc2bef", "response_sha256": "2625219c5d41aa384c9eae2e6fa69a4b74cea1a6b1d1d12ca74b0115673b4c27", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "bfd8604596bb6d24eeb32462ce5d0221", "candidate_priority_rank": 26168, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-06968f8360a9d8cf:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-06968f8360a9d8cf:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-06968f8360a9d8cf:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-06968f8360a9d8cf:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "playing<->posing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "posing", "B": "playing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "posing<->playing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2404977", "image_sha256": "c56b4f29d566daa70d7d8211640c98fa97577a3e08440577cda6e749c067205f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404977.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404977.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2409448", "image_sha256": "b2b771d003c5acae4b501fcd769f23b55df3ce89c9b22cabbb9992142b316261", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2409448.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2409448.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-06968f8360a9d8cf", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "posing", "diff_b": "playing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "posing", "component_b": "playing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["looking down", "posing"], "detected_components": ["posing"], "masked_program_sha256": "dffce669263f3a6e3572dfce5216d65140aa0cf67f6c319010b54777cbc6eff8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "posing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d5fbb1d04e9a6a118c05ed5342cee582942a40e4a7965512d07eea07afd2b258"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11164334", "text": "What does the person that is posing hold?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["playing"], "detected_components": ["playing"], "masked_program_sha256": "dffce669263f3a6e3572dfce5216d65140aa0cf67f6c319010b54777cbc6eff8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "playing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "33e656d6d66b6ab6b2d8e74e35c760e8d10ee981c7a325a07d60f3ae1f7e2c0a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10696045", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26168, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6bba309926dff9563c5a323fe47563de8522cf2ed0563317a2ad58fd0dc2a057", "selected_component": "playing", "selected_source_question_id": "10696045", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What does the person that is playing hold?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what does the person that is hold?", "program_group_hash": "6bba309926dff9563c5a323fe47563de8522cf2ed0563317a2ad58fd0dc2a057", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what does the person that is hold?", "program_group_hash": "6bba309926dff9563c5a323fe47563de8522cf2ed0563317a2ad58fd0dc2a057", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "hat", "full_answer": "The man holds the hat.", "question": "What does the person that is posing hold?", "question_id": "11164334", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (374973)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "posing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (374976)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "frisbee", "full_answer": "The man holds the frisbee.", "question": "What does the person that is playing hold?", "question_id": "10696045", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1088591)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "playing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (1088592)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["374974", "374975", "374976", "374977", "374978", "374979", "374980", "374981", "374983", "374986", "374987", "374991", "374992", "374993", "374994", "374997", "374998"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hat"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "374976", "query_target_entity_name": "hat", "relation_object_entity_id": "374976", "relation_subject_entity_id": "374973", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "374973", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "posing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["374973"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "posing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1088592", "1088593", "1088594", "1088596", "1088599", "1088600", "1088601", "1088602", "1088604", "1088606"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["frisbee"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["round", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1088592", "query_target_entity_name": "frisbee", "relation_object_entity_id": "1088592", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1088591", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1088591", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1088591"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:bfd8604596bb6d24eeb32462ce5d0221", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c56b4f29d566daa70d7d8211640c98fa97577a3e08440577cda6e749c067205f", "image_sha256_b": "b2b771d003c5acae4b501fcd769f23b55df3ce89c9b22cabbb9992142b316261", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "803b238ee2ec3c7b9033b6b8cdc48d0819e56e60feabdd81d4459e78614b2940", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b438b81a8cb567a243e8c5bea59854dc", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3497f6f601e48e49ee34cd86e1c67721925b4afed592951d274cd4a5086a4fc0"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "23b8d79b22dbc83af1ddcba36e488014e4a7fe47cfb9e0d331cb76886f484a42", "request_id": "7e60533134727e04d112b313235aebd2", "response_sha256": "b83707f031ec9e2276997eb0d9d67c333da99651765b6b1258d78bbb1fa2cbc2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "214bb2fe432fbb8f8d20e3c425ee0c9db0a43786660c652188ff4f531bf05a24", "request_id": "fff6ca59b7300b78bfebb474f845ceeb", "response_sha256": "31af4c1cd0866bf953884101bdec1bd0be310cf526cd932df3171b3f31b6fe50", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "85cdcc646cacd70fca30c3f74af03ae3", "candidate_priority_rank": 26230, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e75dda1f3940ab95:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e75dda1f3940ab95:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e75dda1f3940ab95:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e75dda1f3940ab95:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 377, "image_id": "2402484", "image_sha256": "b937057dc7af2dd8c20a4b7ec89dbc041f80c6ea3099e1ee1b1a3662b3ffbf14", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402484.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402484.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2335162", "image_sha256": "2c73323e2144ccd157a916c188017ef1df4d1c13467b3d5893d429542c9b0fc4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2335162.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2335162.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e75dda1f3940ab95", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["green", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "30ce1fb59b0d9b513a8f0600deba9519abe6257f2ca46010d2e87ad2f4739c5f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4bee598623b74cbbc9ff7142700127a433a76c713f9a5d040cc82be9c355c79d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1495189", "text": "What kind of animal is on the green grass?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "green", "pink", "red"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "30ce1fb59b0d9b513a8f0600deba9519abe6257f2ca46010d2e87ad2f4739c5f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9102c0c0c66a10fb898d1eb7162fbc8b6fedb2383636cd0b71ae9fee5857775b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16681330", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26230, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "39c76a6a1b528702b4ba881c3003e1e426d2768e8455cdd72cce20355b6ef0af", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "16681330", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of animal is on the brown grass?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "grass", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is on the grass?", "program_group_hash": "39c76a6a1b528702b4ba881c3003e1e426d2768e8455cdd72cce20355b6ef0af", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "grass"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "grass", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is on the grass?", "program_group_hash": "39c76a6a1b528702b4ba881c3003e1e426d2768e8455cdd72cce20355b6ef0af", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "grass"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The animal is a horse.", "question": "What kind of animal is on the green grass?", "question_id": "1495189", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (389261)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (389260)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The animal is a horse.", "question": "What kind of animal is on the brown grass?", "question_id": "16681330", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (4634927)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (4634918)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["389260"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "389260", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "389261", "relation_subject_entity_id": "389260", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "389261", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["389261"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4634918"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "4634918", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "4634927", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4634918", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4634927", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4634927"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:85cdcc646cacd70fca30c3f74af03ae3", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b937057dc7af2dd8c20a4b7ec89dbc041f80c6ea3099e1ee1b1a3662b3ffbf14", "image_sha256_b": "2c73323e2144ccd157a916c188017ef1df4d1c13467b3d5893d429542c9b0fc4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "98d3f66a4ca30a373107b431c09a98532750b4ff70973a36530ad6617cd89ed7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b0bae82fc6b3022c3a74c768bd5e48bd", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ab16868e752a669fa7b0196d410671f34840f21c849a0c638b090f937d9add77"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c195da27d0f7b96f0ab3b1d698950fe8dea9e25957ac4670433d5dae5973f104", "request_id": "c6c47c2fae86a3ed73290fdecde36783", "response_sha256": "46cd6286d44f499530d828922d8bcb5a0651a7954f992ff3e75c22ba37154708", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e3825549cb176f3272684f1884635cd9749fc998466460912f914a35c68671df", "request_id": "b04d94fb31f674cb6f20a9444d54dd21", "response_sha256": "1fc57847aea2460876611e57659a0606067d9fa0e9634e1a4409da32b51d83d0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "5dfaf6b6d4980899f08d71a11e464d0a", "candidate_priority_rank": 26271, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb81c252e125882d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb81c252e125882d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb81c252e125882d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb81c252e125882d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->red", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "red", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "red<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2410335", "image_sha256": "69e05115c51cf6d8fd4796b490f4f185bda0a51af15de193fb830b367c4cc3ba", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410335.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410335.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2385395", "image_sha256": "98130f9771f25877b7e4c6a14e4dcfd76e9ff99ab3ea16838f75455b6233af26", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2385395.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2385395.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bb81c252e125882d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "red", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "red", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "gray", "green", "purple", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "25e3c4a5fa69b3bed8a9ba26f83bb0b63a80d8955177fd6aa512c0fbb1ab0574", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bike"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bike"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "24f9b9131b9a5b1b1446d16549058e314b50d5c6f6d2e87a519eb91ac5547c22"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "17758586", "text": "What is on the red bike?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "green", "orange", "pink", "red"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "25e3c4a5fa69b3bed8a9ba26f83bb0b63a80d8955177fd6aa512c0fbb1ab0574", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bike"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bike"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c6cfc7e244eb457890e871c5e529a50cad68fc9c50c18163da62fc3aa96390fb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1926203", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26271, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ed70e51aabef44303b5e58a1f379f7d87196eb39dcce8e37741a190a7321285d", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "1926203", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the blue bike?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bike", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the bike?", "program_group_hash": "ed70e51aabef44303b5e58a1f379f7d87196eb39dcce8e37741a190a7321285d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "bike"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bike", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the bike?", "program_group_hash": "ed70e51aabef44303b5e58a1f379f7d87196eb39dcce8e37741a190a7321285d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "bike"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "leaves", "full_answer": "The leaves are on the bike.", "question": "What is on the red bike?", "question_id": "17758586", "semantic": [{"argument": "bike (220243)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (220238)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "seat", "full_answer": "The seat is on the bike.", "question": "What is on the blue bike?", "question_id": "1926203", "semantic": [{"argument": "bike (1297361)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1297357)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["220235", "220236", "220237", "220238", "220239", "220240", "220241", "220242", "220244", "220245", "220246", "220247", "220251"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["leaves"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "220238", "query_target_entity_name": "leaves", "relation_object_entity_id": "220243", "relation_subject_entity_id": "220238", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "220243", "selected_entity_name": "bike"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["220243"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1297356", "1297357", "1297358", "1297359", "1297360", "1297362", "1297363", "1297364", "1297365", "1297366", "1297367", "1297368", "1297369", "1297370", "1297371", "1297372", "1297373", "1297374", "1297375", "1297376", "1297377", "1297378", "1297379", "1297380", "1297381", "1297384", "1297385", "1297388", "1297389", "1297390", "1297391", "1297392", "1297393", "1297394", "1297395"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 35, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["seat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "1297357", "query_target_entity_name": "seat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1297361", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1297357", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1297361", "selected_entity_name": "bike"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1297361"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:5dfaf6b6d4980899f08d71a11e464d0a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "69e05115c51cf6d8fd4796b490f4f185bda0a51af15de193fb830b367c4cc3ba", "image_sha256_b": "98130f9771f25877b7e4c6a14e4dcfd76e9ff99ab3ea16838f75455b6233af26", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ae6b79a1d0eed4da23728ca185b862109a6931d223c6851f691885d27f9b997b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d50778d035d60afb3568d1cd745473d3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4ae35d19e42e7a0169bb66a60a9598709a04bb7d8c70a62c052ef443c7f67690"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cf46e0391ae93f14f7f652abc311e5d162eb5ac664348984ba80a3684c32284a", "request_id": "e37adbe922b231cfdcd2be9148bebc9e", "response_sha256": "31a6476190f7218e2b5a8262f03180160852309ba6d1f0a2ef23614cf3f7322e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "29797f8c612865dc083b24b6fa043109773f150b86d7211a67bd063093395e05", "request_id": "c6e3dd2d43617fda6a9f0c0e01f45290", "response_sha256": "f2f65c1459462a014bef37e9faf17f55777fbe6b14b55e195e76ffb3549739cb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "0bdf22fe2708025ae1e5b33764eebacf", "candidate_priority_rank": 26171, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-396ed46c51082a22:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-396ed46c51082a22:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-396ed46c51082a22:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-396ed46c51082a22:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "snowboarding<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "surfing", "B": "snowboarding"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "surfing<->snowboarding", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2321486", "image_sha256": "67c7f3a2020504c99950911884322c75bfc69322a1b582c0171806a78cdefb90", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2321486.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2321486.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 294, "image_id": "2395476", "image_sha256": "583bcb430420b31af2170b1669a3840c6ca73bcf1e94c7942bb1ae2da9bf90de", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395476.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395476.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-396ed46c51082a22", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "surfing", "diff_b": "snowboarding", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "surfing", "component_b": "snowboarding"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e60cb519061f9a7757db8551ae37f1c8e776ec4ce8929871b7d33b1bf739a866"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06661643", "text": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["skiing", "snowboarding"], "detected_components": ["snowboarding"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "snowboarding", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "96047646741ecffbdfc61a6e745ab0478e428710c1af3b6cdc438b4e31c1fbfd"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11890552", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26171, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 37, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "selected_component": "snowboarding", "selected_source_question_id": "11890552", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is snowboarding wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "wetsuit", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a wet suit.", "question": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?", "question_id": "06661643", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1047811)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (1047816)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pants", "full_answer": "The person is wearing pants.", "question": "What is the person that is snowboarding wearing?", "question_id": "11890552", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1204991)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "snowboarding", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (1204996)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1047810", "1047812", "1047814", "1047815", "1047816", "1047818", "1047819", "1047821"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wetsuit"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1047816", "query_target_entity_name": "wetsuit", "relation_object_entity_id": "1047816", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1047811", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1047811", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1047811"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "snowboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1204992", "1204994", "1204995", "1204996", "1204998", "1204999", "1205000", "1205005", "1205006", "1205007", "3823091", "3823092"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pants"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1204996", "query_target_entity_name": "pants", "relation_object_entity_id": "1204996", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1204991", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1204991", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "snowboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1204991"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:0bdf22fe2708025ae1e5b33764eebacf", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "67c7f3a2020504c99950911884322c75bfc69322a1b582c0171806a78cdefb90", "image_sha256_b": "583bcb430420b31af2170b1669a3840c6ca73bcf1e94c7942bb1ae2da9bf90de", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5a342ea79b5e08efee890401d4f2de84e3eea6814ee251a6e45c65c6115f8bc4", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7e07f284f9a919593a24c07cd6327d50", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b2566f7406f1e19cc92e0057f53a9a9461752af94be090d3c31a2aeae337d46a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "33c385d4c6e0cd13438049745773cec4b93ed07a49bf769b542ffcefc3c5c0d2", "request_id": "1b3139cbdcdffcf88d041f823ce21d10", "response_sha256": "25fd502684d0d11a54915416137f44eb8d6d038130d8482abfa3128ebe8cbca6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8dd7aec7dc38ade39e9d7be4c522a4cfb036f16c3b9524a40ea757f34bafa112", "request_id": "fb5ae5c1038ec78be18eb4778fa5d4c8", "response_sha256": "8fe987c5570fb72270ad171b2b5117fa6ba3d939d3c5ff7db8d18c88046f0e0b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "d771f4e6d8415eacc28279b5ded2d04b", "candidate_priority_rank": 15276, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3fcff451e665b72c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3fcff451e665b72c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3fcff451e665b72c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3fcff451e665b72c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "standing<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "walking", "B": "standing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "walking<->standing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2353264", "image_sha256": "29f5acff64b60c688954ce55d0b2eb150237491e49112a9ce7ab9025d4c7da36", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2353264.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2353264.jpg", "width": 407}, "B": {"height": 384, "image_id": "2411857", "image_sha256": "1a97fcaedd1ee4974a5ab4578e488c862db13a95504976986feec9dde08274a4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2411857.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2411857.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3fcff451e665b72c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "walking", "diff_b": "standing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "walking", "component_b": "standing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2bf1c30a22a7f5dcded4e434fbc083ba3c8d0eb4cddab68a2635546cc49940bc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "17401540", "text": "What is the person that is walking holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "96086a768acf017a0d95aedaedb87e98cd8beee03f0c32ca3a33b0cd2136d91b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01628038", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15276, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "selected_component": "standing", "selected_source_question_id": "01628038", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is standing holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "umbrella", "full_answer": "The person is holding the umbrella.", "question": "What is the person that is walking holding?", "question_id": "17401540", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (847814)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (847818)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "paddle", "full_answer": "The person is holding the paddle.", "question": "What is the person that is standing holding?", "question_id": "01628038", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (208292)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (208297)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["847816", "847817", "847818", "847820", "847821", "847822", "847823", "847825", "847826", "847827", "847828", "847832", "847833"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["umbrella"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue", "bright"], "query_target_entity_id": "847818", "query_target_entity_name": "umbrella", "relation_object_entity_id": "847818", "relation_subject_entity_id": "847814", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "847814", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["847814"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["208293", "208294", "208296", "208297", "208298", "208299", "208300", "208301", "208302", "208303", "208304"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["paddle"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "208297", "query_target_entity_name": "paddle", "relation_object_entity_id": "208297", "relation_subject_entity_id": "208292", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "208292", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["208292"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:d771f4e6d8415eacc28279b5ded2d04b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "29f5acff64b60c688954ce55d0b2eb150237491e49112a9ce7ab9025d4c7da36", "image_sha256_b": "1a97fcaedd1ee4974a5ab4578e488c862db13a95504976986feec9dde08274a4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "6c0ca55451d869ba39d6a5a99302de019766642cc03fd783f50569d372ae5825", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e0dcfd5a26cf2363e3ee7ece88a5a4e4", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "794381a87018b414d45a872ec0879804c30e2706433a08a20ec0c0841ac1afc4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0f016a4063a8ab72aa770345c0b41e8a49e1386802a373c2f3414ef8f09663c7", "request_id": "2f2df010f45a343f6e7a17dbfb273411", "response_sha256": "5829b4150ab511f3188f23b970ab57c678a088ec496d23dca2321ff31a2297b5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "658f4dbf130adbaf0072f0ca1ff726fb8077abc8c1a851ef288b20a7fe1fa4cf", "request_id": "5e9f800a2ed0f9e34ce4e86e74e0a0ec", "response_sha256": "1a49e25fa7751f970e8de36525e77a43acf59dd423975fd6a6b829522219f8d0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "097403ddc150ecdfaebe40681f5a13be", "candidate_priority_rank": 15294, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b6e5f5b5614ece7c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b6e5f5b5614ece7c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b6e5f5b5614ece7c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b6e5f5b5614ece7c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->dark", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "dark"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->dark", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2404960", "image_sha256": "6cd4a472c6a7737e7cfc635a5dae14dd54ae6ac1ed3a5ad6be63af69985ba2d0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404960.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404960.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2342898", "image_sha256": "afa67824af043980a8e0be89e8e73ef99ef9eb101a167035b3504ca2d97317de", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342898.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342898.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b6e5f5b5614ece7c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "dark", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "dark"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "dark blue", "orange"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "482105bdca9937f70687e09ec07fc524c03c0e5fb3ce88dea2648ed091c7374d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2153a9e40105bb0f5995b2cf06496b947a96b39fc9ce5e460d24cb6397fb3a0c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07189147", "text": "What is in the water that looks blue?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "dark", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["dark"], "masked_program_sha256": "482105bdca9937f70687e09ec07fc524c03c0e5fb3ce88dea2648ed091c7374d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dark", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "aa04dd5a82fdc7841ab988a3d9a927ad7cc8846a5beb8fd81d8b7d24b746cbe8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19612400", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15294, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6847820184a8472db0fb25de2d9ca450f17fed3c4090bc8325619ce9595ef266", "selected_component": "dark", "selected_source_question_id": "19612400", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the water that looks dark?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the water that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "6847820184a8472db0fb25de2d9ca450f17fed3c4090bc8325619ce9595ef266", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the water that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "6847820184a8472db0fb25de2d9ca450f17fed3c4090bc8325619ce9595ef266", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "surfboard", "full_answer": "The surf board is in the water.", "question": "What is in the water that looks blue?", "question_id": "07189147", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (4167818)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (4167806)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "boat", "full_answer": "The boat is in the water.", "question": "What is in the water that looks dark?", "question_id": "19612400", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (2690495)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dark", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (2508219)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4167757", "4167758", "4167785", "4167790", "4167794", "4167798", "4167802", "4167806", "4167820", "4167824", "4167831", "4268044", "4268106"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["surfboard"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "4167806", "query_target_entity_name": "surfboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "4167818", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4167806", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4167818", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4167818"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2038909", "2062313", "2063959", "2110979", "2372539", "2398849", "2508219", "2587784", "2616010", "2632795", "2678594", "3643999"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["boat"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2508219", "query_target_entity_name": "boat", "relation_object_entity_id": "2690495", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2508219", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2690495", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2690495"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:097403ddc150ecdfaebe40681f5a13be", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6cd4a472c6a7737e7cfc635a5dae14dd54ae6ac1ed3a5ad6be63af69985ba2d0", "image_sha256_b": "afa67824af043980a8e0be89e8e73ef99ef9eb101a167035b3504ca2d97317de", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "525eb34b7d4279f7667d74279da10f889755a8d82f77aedaa37fd55e35697433", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a541e24f19754dcee9a2dca586d9b91e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "005c4989da05c00d853b269d54582309474dbb85fb2a9cc443f4ba30180149f4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "602782c143a10b4a94704689e009cf7b9ae26d60a591feee6556dbb9d02943a7", "request_id": "f3b403a88f0e8814cc3a1a4ee0966125", "response_sha256": "86691cb85c280021b37c4a33e86b8ccf6c364b4def39ce8d67be2169c3d61beb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "149a9163cade5dbc1c59b21e1a75268eb0c29a321406022f810e46a41e807f6d", "request_id": "f919647a3e16cada815a257bc6fe06b9", "response_sha256": "0af52746716722eea1d033070d2de8d068846465a1120ad15998a467d3b5208c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "eb6fe2a5887607153f3bc63979464b9a", "candidate_priority_rank": 15378, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280ad6d7aeccc364:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280ad6d7aeccc364:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280ad6d7aeccc364:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280ad6d7aeccc364:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "metal<->wicker", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "metal", "B": "wicker"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "metal<->wicker", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2402280", "image_sha256": "d0ae5bae71c2effa09c105de2c1d7f401ff76a9c0daa7b14d690c797fe5e4249", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402280.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402280.jpg", "width": 334}, "B": {"height": 323, "image_id": "2374376", "image_sha256": "cb61a138738aa5ddfd9823f173b229062c7e2089b0217d914037a8ea737cee1d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2374376.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2374376.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280ad6d7aeccc364", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "metal", "diff_b": "wicker", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "metal", "component_b": "wicker"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal", "plastic"], "detected_components": ["metal"], "masked_program_sha256": "5c4a219f21b438ccfe3c22ed7de06a68bb1bb650bc42f8ecb146c0882ae2a4dd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "metal", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ba8cb8eafaade83d1694a71299671f6cb34341636cf52b125465a128a27b67b4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16797727", "text": "What is in the metal basket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wicker", "wood"], "detected_components": ["wicker"], "masked_program_sha256": "5c4a219f21b438ccfe3c22ed7de06a68bb1bb650bc42f8ecb146c0882ae2a4dd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wicker", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a22e6c4b4ddd1dd206464d1580777323f7b04504c686f7757a99f0780120cd20"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17846945", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15378, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e7a1af3282c265f4b33eee38613a39f01c0fe86d629df7b55399d1d33a23e89c", "selected_component": "wicker", "selected_source_question_id": "17846945", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the wicker basket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "basket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the basket?", "program_group_hash": "e7a1af3282c265f4b33eee38613a39f01c0fe86d629df7b55399d1d33a23e89c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "basket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "basket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the basket?", "program_group_hash": "e7a1af3282c265f4b33eee38613a39f01c0fe86d629df7b55399d1d33a23e89c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "basket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bananas", "full_answer": "The bananas are in the basket.", "question": "What is in the metal basket?", "question_id": "16797727", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (1138168)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "metal", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (1138155)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "plants", "full_answer": "The plants are in the basket.", "question": "What is in the wicker basket?", "question_id": "17846945", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (727237)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wicker", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (727238)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1138155", "1138156", "1138158", "1138159", "1138161", "1138162", "1138163", "1138165", "1138169", "1138170", "1138173", "1138174", "1138175", "1138176", "1138177", "1138178", "1138179", "1138180", "1138181", "1138182", "1138183", "1138184", "1138185", "1138186", "1138187"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 25, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bananas"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1138155", "query_target_entity_name": "bananas", "relation_object_entity_id": "1138168", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1138155", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1138168", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1138168"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wicker", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["727235", "727236", "727238", "727239", "727240", "727241", "727244", "727245", "727246", "727247", "727248", "727249", "727251", "727252", "727254", "727255", "727257", "727259", "727260", "727262", "727263", "727265", "727266", "727267", "727269", "727270", "727271"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 27, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["plants"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "727238", "query_target_entity_name": "plants", "relation_object_entity_id": "727237", "relation_subject_entity_id": "727238", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "727237", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wicker", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["727237"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:eb6fe2a5887607153f3bc63979464b9a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d0ae5bae71c2effa09c105de2c1d7f401ff76a9c0daa7b14d690c797fe5e4249", "image_sha256_b": "cb61a138738aa5ddfd9823f173b229062c7e2089b0217d914037a8ea737cee1d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3b36ddb1db314b317a1634be809acdb25c4ba53e56ebec52b12252baa9298e73", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f15f9796a970a5bb70c857cb9d2531cd", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "8ab6f88c21523f5086c9a8e11bc8459479cbe9e553164efb5a0bd8ac076c4cc2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5df6782ad0aeabc6f4eca255e0496419c024c4de7e859d38f2bf6fb9e0cf6e2c", "request_id": "1a7c3e360d318ad4cb01ef831efe70bc", "response_sha256": "c9321fde22aecd9558c2a5978d679845b9c44383877753193dffd1cdbcfac5a6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "525934d318bb77eab609bdb26f8c8520c158ca0570d8b8e90b25909bd84b6a7c", "request_id": "742739a8f3519e1dae04695b90474a4b", "response_sha256": "f15fde4882203ab33d773ee5fb7a8c72bf90b86dd90408e6c1781d7f24c62a2f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "af0facda5a68c54e9b73370e42f38118", "candidate_priority_rank": 15417, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5a26e234db90312:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5a26e234db90312:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5a26e234db90312:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5a26e234db90312:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "metal<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "wood", "B": "metal"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wood<->metal", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2362611", "image_sha256": "c0ec9d8bb941b2d066459054b9f6f41db36dd3cf4afc6e0efc5ca29a49346f54", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2362611.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2362611.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2387051", "image_sha256": "ad2d2d8cfa071c1a13c6b3279ba64f84492dee34b4099ba65fff26b77ecdf815", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387051.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387051.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5a26e234db90312", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wood", "diff_b": "metal", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wood", "component_b": "metal"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal", "wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "59392c85a17477ede3fb91c9e60cc3b97a8b68d70d3b72c93129a65043e5385e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7a6392af26cd4d3d394ed02bbb7e3538fd56ada07206012b48a2085e0ebcc660"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06748159", "text": "What is on the pole made of wood?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brick", "metal", "steel", "wood"], "detected_components": ["metal"], "masked_program_sha256": "59392c85a17477ede3fb91c9e60cc3b97a8b68d70d3b72c93129a65043e5385e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "metal", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "894648a2829d9e304351f70e6d013e03e19db7b152b24ac76cde88bf9b46aa74"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12756592", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15417, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "832878dfc770342535b875b8ff8cd0ce10da7e18cdafe053d802701e11043b91", "selected_component": "metal", "selected_source_question_id": "12756592", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the pole made of metal?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pole", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the pole made of ?", "program_group_hash": "832878dfc770342535b875b8ff8cd0ce10da7e18cdafe053d802701e11043b91", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pole"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pole", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the pole made of ?", "program_group_hash": "832878dfc770342535b875b8ff8cd0ce10da7e18cdafe053d802701e11043b91", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pole"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sign", "full_answer": "The sign is on the pole.", "question": "What is on the pole made of wood?", "question_id": "06748159", "semantic": [{"argument": "pole (772798)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (772794)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is on the pole.", "question": "What is on the pole made of metal?", "question_id": "12756592", "semantic": [{"argument": "pole (1279913)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "metal", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1279911)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["772793", "772794", "772795", "772799", "772800", "772802", "772803", "772804", "772805", "772806", "772811"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sign"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["dirty", "rectangular", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "772794", "query_target_entity_name": "sign", "relation_object_entity_id": "772798", "relation_subject_entity_id": "772794", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "772798", "selected_entity_name": "pole"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["772798"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1279910", "1279911", "1279912", "1279915", "1279916", "1279917", "1279918", "1279919", "1279920", "1279921"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "metal"], "query_target_entity_id": "1279911", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "1279913", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1279911", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1279913", "selected_entity_name": "pole"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1279913"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:af0facda5a68c54e9b73370e42f38118", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c0ec9d8bb941b2d066459054b9f6f41db36dd3cf4afc6e0efc5ca29a49346f54", "image_sha256_b": "ad2d2d8cfa071c1a13c6b3279ba64f84492dee34b4099ba65fff26b77ecdf815", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "168d5b7eb44f1c011a2a4c97e11bc623b88beef6c3e4e36d7c4816ab0d52c747", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "104b8a2834a1b4dd3954b976284eeb6b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f849e982de668b2ef54912ba599711750b433e73fcb7608d3f92f04323cd2f0a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5b47031bcc5f283fb9da1b5c931004e8c3ebe85d06afa8e230ccd5c1244fb0fc", "request_id": "7c956ee2013e1eec39da958f55bd4071", "response_sha256": "8ed330d241c4f16f2385a1adb3c2f0ff96ae133b76f8ba16f7f3708bbef36209", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "16bc31c5fc716f64b5fccdf655fa8768fe6a6afa5d492fb0f76b80b84634ccfb", "request_id": "69b742a02f1f477c880fe29d00a5cae7", "response_sha256": "f18e5dd6a14f4d16d179f32e62509a0006ac720f4b653b8b06d5e7bcb2273d35", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "cd154672fb7c8a5a7dcb0abd7f970255", "candidate_priority_rank": 15557, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b55a7c1dc2dc94c3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b55a7c1dc2dc94c3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b55a7c1dc2dc94c3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b55a7c1dc2dc94c3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "green<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "green"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->green", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2408364", "image_sha256": "1cdca920170fd1ef9b9e701406be7d95b6ff93386c4d18e49ba20bf719928614", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408364.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408364.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2417365", "image_sha256": "df99d61b68ac22817b26238d88e962ef96d1f61dd0299ef7298d098e3d968e3e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2417365.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2417365.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b55a7c1dc2dc94c3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "green", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "green"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "gray", "pink", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "0dee32591b4283638a4a4c4f8e9989d90023e77a23e66b71202b4507c7150aa3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2e2eab208e280708ca423b937b107455f5f75125616b993dea6d78a23f422826"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12774996", "text": "What is on the white food?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "0dee32591b4283638a4a4c4f8e9989d90023e77a23e66b71202b4507c7150aa3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d1261fa43c16ed7ad8d03ce377f567ff4aad6bd479d22c8e031606c690486f28"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10207058", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15557, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f0e777482888f1e4ebd49118e47ba7b3d329abebeec1c3816daaaa7c2d1a52cd", "selected_component": "green", "selected_source_question_id": "10207058", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the green food?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "food", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the food?", "program_group_hash": "f0e777482888f1e4ebd49118e47ba7b3d329abebeec1c3816daaaa7c2d1a52cd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "food"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "food", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the food?", "program_group_hash": "f0e777482888f1e4ebd49118e47ba7b3d329abebeec1c3816daaaa7c2d1a52cd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "food"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "paper", "full_answer": "The paper is on the doughnut.", "question": "What is on the white food?", "question_id": "12774996", "semantic": [{"argument": "food (365331)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1093549)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "icing", "full_answer": "The icing is on the doughnut.", "question": "What is on the green food?", "question_id": "10207058", "semantic": [{"argument": "food (2833321)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (3330340)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1093548", "1093549", "1093551", "1093552", "1093553", "1093555", "1093556", "365329", "365330"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["paper"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1093549", "query_target_entity_name": "paper", "relation_object_entity_id": "365331", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1093549", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "365331", "selected_entity_name": "donut"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["365331"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2712327", "2770202", "2770204", "3227676", "3303299", "3330340", "3387977", "3445365", "3556393"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["icing"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "3330340", "query_target_entity_name": "icing", "relation_object_entity_id": "2833321", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3330340", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2833321", "selected_entity_name": "donut"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2833321"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:cd154672fb7c8a5a7dcb0abd7f970255", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1cdca920170fd1ef9b9e701406be7d95b6ff93386c4d18e49ba20bf719928614", "image_sha256_b": "df99d61b68ac22817b26238d88e962ef96d1f61dd0299ef7298d098e3d968e3e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d1444a84b8edba4f370c9b2fd255e13200e3e9f67f16dcb7bf665bc4f9207106", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "899b5f5d97f0dd1f702d21e14ce257af", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1ca54cd5246e390d14aaf409ba951d8b5df7c94dcb73e115f67c82e898c8efc4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "88c3811c3eba4fe59a97d3ef0267a6521bdb03790aed218fffd3619685d829d2", "request_id": "c86b980b1f70d043fb4e25eeb83fc6b6", "response_sha256": "1e3d4427b93a0e29a1d92fc2ac7dc19aeeab5e6cd9060ad730029746ec3e7004", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fcc4df52e40435d4f3699e3fed97fe58b9f7ac2dea5d2c3ab16b6e4d4cfddb01", "request_id": "46921febe52f8193d485bb9f167c3cd3", "response_sha256": "edb4ecd8d4777a4b56373e19cf60874892cbd2397ab21b91835638e772bef11d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "174268e522a69271568c100975706e31", "candidate_priority_rank": 15629, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-016993ec61ece0d3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-016993ec61ece0d3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-016993ec61ece0d3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-016993ec61ece0d3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "playing<->talking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "playing", "B": "talking"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "playing<->talking", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2364814", "image_sha256": "63f33f487adba1a86189ee075bc28df4ac69680a6efadfe84942432476eca1d6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364814.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364814.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2391241", "image_sha256": "723e227751c332acc4ef535dbe6dfc9034d0c1eccf7198e4fafd4bf4b735fff1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2391241.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2391241.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-016993ec61ece0d3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "playing", "diff_b": "talking", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "playing", "component_b": "talking"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["playing"], "detected_components": ["playing"], "masked_program_sha256": "dffce669263f3a6e3572dfce5216d65140aa0cf67f6c319010b54777cbc6eff8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "playing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b420120dc50a3a8723584535f780717bccf943b4a831fd2a3c7e3f08aef66c53"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "041003463", "text": "What is the person that is playing holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["talking"], "detected_components": ["talking"], "masked_program_sha256": "dffce669263f3a6e3572dfce5216d65140aa0cf67f6c319010b54777cbc6eff8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "talking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bb3f78279247ab32e0df47ba3264bbe87b40e1e901a564d5653c39d2aa6326a1"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10311722", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15629, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "51003c3f0e3f6afd77dcb7234c97b8985ebaf361a3f9e8e5a10179aa71d0cd1e", "selected_component": "talking", "selected_source_question_id": "10311722", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is talking holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "51003c3f0e3f6afd77dcb7234c97b8985ebaf361a3f9e8e5a10179aa71d0cd1e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "51003c3f0e3f6afd77dcb7234c97b8985ebaf361a3f9e8e5a10179aa71d0cd1e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "racket", "full_answer": "The man is holding the racket.", "question": "What is the person that is playing holding?", "question_id": "041003463", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (758556)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "playing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (758558)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cell phone", "full_answer": "The woman is holding the mobile phone.", "question": "What is the person that is talking holding?", "question_id": "10311722", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (490518)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "talking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (490519)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["758557", "758558", "758559", "758561", "758562"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["racket"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "758558", "query_target_entity_name": "racket", "relation_object_entity_id": "758558", "relation_subject_entity_id": "758556", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "758556", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["758556"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "talking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["490513", "490514", "490516", "490517", "490519", "490520", "490521", "490522", "490524", "490525", "490527", "490528"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cell phone"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "490519", "query_target_entity_name": "cell phone", "relation_object_entity_id": "490519", "relation_subject_entity_id": "490518", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "490518", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "talking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["490518"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:174268e522a69271568c100975706e31", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "63f33f487adba1a86189ee075bc28df4ac69680a6efadfe84942432476eca1d6", "image_sha256_b": "723e227751c332acc4ef535dbe6dfc9034d0c1eccf7198e4fafd4bf4b735fff1", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1cb4c3b7267807d9eac220b0106e22668104b83d20dfc2dcfd2a414307f1adb1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "49ae5345a178ba970e520657ffed2c61", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "83f2ca66bb999f8e1481094469e82144627ae34f761afb82dd3ef4df503db730"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cc0e1ebd36c6094b051a68ebfc3ea1a6ee935494dc2a8f9d339d130a597dfe58", "request_id": "3bd601d44addfdb78776e017259100a5", "response_sha256": "1e798c25a25ee3ba081934c528dadf6107be9331aff798c15457e4af81306814", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "318ca2e0e3c2fbb2b65674f9e5aaa007917c12687a27f21138f69aa42d2e2d29", "request_id": "b10a4328da4584b3a10a6f2c4a9d557b", "response_sha256": "d361a85a95debbe23a62dbb35b2bd54dce086733b9575f24ccdf9ff37414fa53", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "b1378b2413e32e6314277563da8ee9e8", "candidate_priority_rank": 15701, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-add9e598ef4ffaef:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-add9e598ef4ffaef:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-add9e598ef4ffaef:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-add9e598ef4ffaef:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "white<->yellow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "yellow"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->yellow", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 768, "image_id": "1592219", "image_sha256": "6e0df63ad07cb6883fa5c4c0a83e6f939c2a9e654a39ecb1cf63952f41382ec3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/1592219.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/1592219.jpg", "width": 1024}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2399294", "image_sha256": "e26fcb9ffd8e8cf901bb809388e3d86d2602016e82abe50f7cbe5ebb14cd935e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399294.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399294.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-add9e598ef4ffaef", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "yellow", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "yellow"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "orange", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "ea685bfa4acb35e25b1a243228e5bb7265e1bc97dc826da33ea441b1aa1d4858", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["van"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["van"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1acef71a4c0464e32c4427126cae5e615fe16faa76ea59802d9a63ca57caa2ac"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05428543", "text": "What is in front of the white van?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["green", "tan", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["yellow"], "masked_program_sha256": "ea685bfa4acb35e25b1a243228e5bb7265e1bc97dc826da33ea441b1aa1d4858", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["van"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yellow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["van"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "33c78a319477f0241be62415ee1cf4f68e2c2689b3457f8375293be32b153cef"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04498868", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15701, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6126a8bfc77c155ae9671a035f4560f31b22af8886914bc7fdb177f7c6f7eb51", "selected_component": "yellow", "selected_source_question_id": "04498868", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the yellow van?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "van", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the van?", "program_group_hash": "6126a8bfc77c155ae9671a035f4560f31b22af8886914bc7fdb177f7c6f7eb51", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "van"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "van", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the van?", "program_group_hash": "6126a8bfc77c155ae9671a035f4560f31b22af8886914bc7fdb177f7c6f7eb51", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "van"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "fence", "full_answer": "The fence is in front of the van.", "question": "What is in front of the white van?", "question_id": "05428543", "semantic": [{"argument": "van (1607565)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (1607566)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "trailer", "full_answer": "The trailer is in front of the van.", "question": "What is in front of the yellow van?", "question_id": "04498868", "semantic": [{"argument": "van (3472969)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "yellow", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (2469393)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1607523", "1607526", "1607530", "1607531", "1607532", "1607534", "1607535", "1607538", "1607539", "1607542", "1607543", "1607544", "1607545", "1607547", "1607549", "1607550", "1607551", "1607552", "1607554", "1607555", "1607556", "1607557", "1607558", "1607560", "1607561", "1607562", "1607563", "1607564", "1607566", "1607567", "1607568", "1607569", "3611572"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 33, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fence"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1607566", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "1607565", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1607566", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1607565", "selected_entity_name": "van"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1607565"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1811839", "2079849", "2469392", "2469393", "2514888", "2514889", "2641900", "2944734", "3146435", "3152264", "3409675", "3568748", "3568750", "3568752"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trailer"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2469393", "query_target_entity_name": "trailer", "relation_object_entity_id": "3472969", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2469393", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3472969", "selected_entity_name": "van"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3472969"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b1378b2413e32e6314277563da8ee9e8", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6e0df63ad07cb6883fa5c4c0a83e6f939c2a9e654a39ecb1cf63952f41382ec3", "image_sha256_b": "e26fcb9ffd8e8cf901bb809388e3d86d2602016e82abe50f7cbe5ebb14cd935e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "408a5a7efa9dc23f641a12647c81143e9102ddda3ed78af5095aca7b91f064ae", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "44e422f2b9970765cf863e8d59ea75b0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "94fb450cf369d9d6ef7be0fd1d30e4995bf66846eec59ea0cd2ea0c16fef17c9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "382327782fef157a58779deb898124b57120603fdecf09c99f9331032a63cbd0", "request_id": "858d8a33065919d1bfde7b73b5e939ab", "response_sha256": "6c32e57b611ec6d8ed233a2d67affc344a4cb7b4f38ee8a95b6bbf211b93cd39", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "31a93aad81910b49b916889c22d36905bfca8573c915cc916cbaa299341d55d3", "request_id": "284e91203c9af750e280de4781475721", "response_sha256": "6675db11acd88523a73f685cf19becacc4e340a1035e2e8f99a00d5a3aa438f2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "81c11219738db8be9cf6daecb69cb766", "candidate_priority_rank": 15783, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6fb8a4e5dbb4b369:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6fb8a4e5dbb4b369:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6fb8a4e5dbb4b369:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6fb8a4e5dbb4b369:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brick<->concrete", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "concrete", "B": "brick"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "concrete<->brick", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 371, "image_id": "2392577", "image_sha256": "3ea025023321eb652e0b331c1e45e3df3ed693d6509680bf0f6c65d8c481b579", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392577.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392577.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2327939", "image_sha256": "7ba581ac5904e630b4c07c4ca4acfd6c6241f48d4726fb5ba9e8e28c018231f1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2327939.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2327939.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6fb8a4e5dbb4b369", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "concrete", "diff_b": "brick", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "concrete", "component_b": "brick"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["concrete", "metal"], "detected_components": ["concrete"], "masked_program_sha256": "5164c907fdcb051180f7f72caa856555234326acb7f485eb87e10b8f565b2842", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "concrete", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "13ffe7f596947165f4b5bb8e0a72f9fe0e0b1f9559c7e36d1badd17ea4478e0c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14832628", "text": "What is in front of the concrete building?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brick", "rubber"], "detected_components": ["brick"], "masked_program_sha256": "5164c907fdcb051180f7f72caa856555234326acb7f485eb87e10b8f565b2842", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brick", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3a0a8620c68be1ad1c1e211b98a2cef77403584608df1850b0a0ce9b2784a370"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16415619", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15783, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 26, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d41015e9165c8e377344136072c1edd3236b33f218acbf2326d847f1c403ed67", "selected_component": "brick", "selected_source_question_id": "16415619", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the brick building?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "building", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the building?", "program_group_hash": "d41015e9165c8e377344136072c1edd3236b33f218acbf2326d847f1c403ed67", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "building"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "building", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the building?", "program_group_hash": "d41015e9165c8e377344136072c1edd3236b33f218acbf2326d847f1c403ed67", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "building"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dumpster", "full_answer": "The dumpster is in front of the building.", "question": "What is in front of the concrete building?", "question_id": "14832628", "semantic": [{"argument": "building (1228353)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "concrete", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (1228346)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "school bus", "full_answer": "The school bus is in front of the building.", "question": "What is in front of the brick building?", "question_id": "16415619", "semantic": [{"argument": "building (3964588)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brick", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (4125481)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1228339", "1228340", "1228341", "1228342", "1228343", "1228344", "1228345", "1228346", "1228347", "1228350", "1228355", "1228357", "1228359", "1228360", "1228361", "3825705"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dumpster"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "metal"], "query_target_entity_id": "1228346", "query_target_entity_name": "dumpster", "relation_object_entity_id": "1228353", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1228346", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1228353", "selected_entity_name": "building"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "concrete", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1228353"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "concrete", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3964591", "3964595", "3964597", "3964603", "3964612", "3964618", "4125473", "4125475", "4125481", "4125482", "4125487", "4125491", "4125493", "4125499", "4125501", "4125504", "4125509", "4125518", "4682166", "4682167", "4682171", "4682173"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["school bus"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "4125481", "query_target_entity_name": "school bus", "relation_object_entity_id": "3964588", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4125481", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3964588", "selected_entity_name": "building"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3964588"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:81c11219738db8be9cf6daecb69cb766", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3ea025023321eb652e0b331c1e45e3df3ed693d6509680bf0f6c65d8c481b579", "image_sha256_b": "7ba581ac5904e630b4c07c4ca4acfd6c6241f48d4726fb5ba9e8e28c018231f1", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3d20a41231b6e9c5f80a2a8532d28eeb32703a87a8f9602cc32d0d7ae890b2f1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a06b4ce9baa39e9a1b1132ce742d86b0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1c6e88c1810e4b40ca4394ae8672e6c47d90b5c3ae84f74f6bd04011794d21b2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "42455862a9b4f88a103bc75dc55c9e673c6ce3b90a91e5157efd2db61a1bca9a", "request_id": "f482ac78e2c4e2e332a98ed30497e79c", "response_sha256": "4e2c86a6e8a731784bc4d727a72d6c62195302b375da72f7dcf43bf4857f2ff9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "98be709f40eebc3332ebe9886e192c8de7f9cae6f0692252d9e751b3e6207348", "request_id": "f2b112e43979d0e2d257963874a7fc1c", "response_sha256": "219b84a15caa4c1bf0c390e9863be22729d5461d600966f14b8e46f199ea4169", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "4b9068cf94d56e464ee93da3dbb87671", "candidate_priority_rank": 15857, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5446723f892ab3a7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5446723f892ab3a7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5446723f892ab3a7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5446723f892ab3a7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "running<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "walking", "B": "running"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "walking<->running", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2413973", "image_sha256": "fd97263f1911fec542bf4af4df96cb74fd0f1993cd8d357bcb0dfbf9a9437298", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2413973.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2413973.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 278, "image_id": "2349624", "image_sha256": "a912513f2b231393cf41ca1d194a976d42d10e92cf9c2ad48b31050e2f692aa9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2349624.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2349624.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5446723f892ab3a7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "walking", "diff_b": "running", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "walking", "component_b": "running"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2bf1c30a22a7f5dcded4e434fbc083ba3c8d0eb4cddab68a2635546cc49940bc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11184174", "text": "What is the person that is walking holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["running"], "detected_components": ["running"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "running", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ebfa35cd00683fa16f537cbc0e37f0615ab8508a04a3ec615bc23be0ad1a1e45"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17530682", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15857, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 23, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "selected_component": "running", "selected_source_question_id": "17530682", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is running holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "rope", "full_answer": "The man is holding the rope.", "question": "What is the person that is walking holding?", "question_id": "11184174", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (162340)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (162348)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "racket", "full_answer": "The person is holding the tennis racket.", "question": "What is the person that is running holding?", "question_id": "17530682", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (873287)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "running", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (873305)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["162338", "162339", "162341", "162342", "162344", "162348", "162349", "162351", "162352", "162353", "162354", "162355", "162356", "162357"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["rope"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "162348", "query_target_entity_name": "rope", "relation_object_entity_id": "162348", "relation_subject_entity_id": "162340", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "162340", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["162340"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "running", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["873286", "873294", "873296", "873298", "873299", "873301", "873302", "873305", "873307", "873308", "873320", "873321", "873322", "873323", "873324", "873325", "873326", "873327", "873328", "873329"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["racket"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blurry"], "query_target_entity_id": "873305", "query_target_entity_name": "racket", "relation_object_entity_id": "873305", "relation_subject_entity_id": "873287", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "873287", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "running", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["873287"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:4b9068cf94d56e464ee93da3dbb87671", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "fd97263f1911fec542bf4af4df96cb74fd0f1993cd8d357bcb0dfbf9a9437298", "image_sha256_b": "a912513f2b231393cf41ca1d194a976d42d10e92cf9c2ad48b31050e2f692aa9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "883dd2e320ffd910ae3b2a65a0cc51b62eeda06e4b5df944f0c8fdced8f91ee1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "aac500f9834968a147436c5a6c8814d6", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "dab8a21e5f4ddd5b38e959a3fb5194f546d884e8a8f6abf5c310d882d28e2ef7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1e9e79dc00ed2f29c0816cf93711795d55bda4229bd6f8300cd2c6baafc512bf", "request_id": "f4ca1024cbb3e5f032486070ad9c4700", "response_sha256": "66ced80dcf960d5786dc494342329e85fba718afbce60c107d9fc31a3019d193", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "76a307f2a6a78c7403a511291b8c962acf48f76bf36cfc248517b91e9c54623e", "request_id": "45c2ba7fd5732054ae80eddcd528570c", "response_sha256": "e155db6376d57aab66f1ff63773bbb057ef24acf0d5eda74703209f6c4cc7173", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "11afea026cc6c6ad5922a73a8071b391", "candidate_priority_rank": 15894, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7fa7be4f65865556:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7fa7be4f65865556:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7fa7be4f65865556:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7fa7be4f65865556:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "jumping<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "walking", "B": "jumping"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "walking<->jumping", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2407317", "image_sha256": "0cefda710184caa7e706dd1a72693f405456e569d825460389653d24ed37b543", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407317.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407317.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2398358", "image_sha256": "e7703632aee6527f797e29cec63a6aa64012328cdc150290739de594ba4efb38", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398358.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398358.jpg", "width": 335}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7fa7be4f65865556", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "walking", "diff_b": "jumping", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "walking", "component_b": "jumping"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2bf1c30a22a7f5dcded4e434fbc083ba3c8d0eb4cddab68a2635546cc49940bc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01213212", "text": "What is the person that is walking holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["jumping"], "detected_components": ["jumping"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "jumping", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "02b5ba820826ea8cb181dc7738a1bdeb7b2b5b84c3cb6409c4b2a724757c94b1"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12966715", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15894, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "selected_component": "jumping", "selected_source_question_id": "12966715", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is jumping holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "frisbee", "full_answer": "The man is holding the frisbee.", "question": "What is the person that is walking holding?", "question_id": "01213212", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (281863)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (281864)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "snowboard", "full_answer": "The person is holding the snowboard.", "question": "What is the person that is jumping holding?", "question_id": "12966715", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1180581)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "jumping", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (1180577)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["281864", "281865", "281866", "281867", "281868", "281869", "281870", "281871", "281872", "281873", "281874", "281876", "281878", "281879", "281880", "281881", "281882", "281883", "281884"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["frisbee"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blurry", "red"], "query_target_entity_id": "281864", "query_target_entity_name": "frisbee", "relation_object_entity_id": "281864", "relation_subject_entity_id": "281863", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "281863", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["281863"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "jumping", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1180572", "1180574", "1180575", "1180577", "1180578", "1180580", "1180582", "1180583", "1180585", "1180587", "1180589", "1180591", "1180592", "1180594"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["snowboard"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1180577", "query_target_entity_name": "snowboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "1180577", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1180581", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1180581", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "jumping", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1180581"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:11afea026cc6c6ad5922a73a8071b391", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "0cefda710184caa7e706dd1a72693f405456e569d825460389653d24ed37b543", "image_sha256_b": "e7703632aee6527f797e29cec63a6aa64012328cdc150290739de594ba4efb38", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8faca1a6381396449a8f658e964cec2998586bd922386c9b6981fdf0c2e67176", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7029d47b3cf400cd03fd73471f825815", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "755f86c11e0c2490ab9b71a3a69004a25fa3a4fb29e929e8a3813aa4a7405ece"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4ae9420f780d788941459bd03b13b5459fd023740932dd16d58001e6f11be8d4", "request_id": "f2bb78da57fd53895a7a5c63ee2c8415", "response_sha256": "70140fdb9cd10675018cbf277af8fd7d66525e6963c3f7cacacd749aa5201198", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f2110e7656fce2a808af2a2aecfa0c8231bf3a39251b9b70afb4086455b333d9", "request_id": "3b037191c569eb8f64c2ed7eeba47859", "response_sha256": "7610cab1214f658deef3613e4dbf22bd0dab92f0879b632d655dcacfffb30c2f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "38da36ca5bf0cd58d2dcc8aee3a13642", "candidate_priority_rank": 16035, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d020d57aa2ca7949:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d020d57aa2ca7949:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d020d57aa2ca7949:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d020d57aa2ca7949:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "baseball<->tennis", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "baseball", "B": "tennis"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "baseball<->tennis", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 331, "image_id": "2326839", "image_sha256": "96a2d20221742a68f75f0175c0f56264dda16c07ab4edb320bb317a254574e7e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326839.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326839.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2375455", "image_sha256": "2acde5232e9dd81c012d6e0314f733985f603c95d7d482d5a52e4191daa00bae", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2375455.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2375455.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d020d57aa2ca7949", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "baseball", "diff_b": "tennis", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "baseball", "component_b": "tennis"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["baseball"], "detected_components": ["baseball"], "masked_program_sha256": "b3f17fd88d5b787600026edab7ab16d2406b5423c97a377856b8486e612fad07", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["player"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "baseball", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["player"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7e79ada35f321b6247858172af502b98db8c72e3b7d0a6dcd1f4d60b134e9ed3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04362321", "text": "What is the baseball player holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["tennis"], "detected_components": ["tennis"], "masked_program_sha256": "b3f17fd88d5b787600026edab7ab16d2406b5423c97a377856b8486e612fad07", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["player"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tennis", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["player"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c67ca6c3e857c5b0f8cdfbd4a9ccdd6aa6e5443939aa4f44c233667f3a20c24e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03495495", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16035, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ab3f9d5ff89ac340744222fdc1f3576c3946c29cdd58ff4facf4028f05a63a6f", "selected_component": "tennis", "selected_source_question_id": "03495495", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the tennis player holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sport", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "player", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sport"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the player holding?", "program_group_hash": "ab3f9d5ff89ac340744222fdc1f3576c3946c29cdd58ff4facf4028f05a63a6f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "player"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sport", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "player", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sport"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the player holding?", "program_group_hash": "ab3f9d5ff89ac340744222fdc1f3576c3946c29cdd58ff4facf4028f05a63a6f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "player"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bat", "full_answer": "The player is holding the bat.", "question": "What is the baseball player holding?", "question_id": "04362321", "semantic": [{"argument": "player (4131300)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baseball", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sport"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (3977569)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "racket", "full_answer": "The player is holding the tennis racket.", "question": "What is the tennis player holding?", "question_id": "03495495", "semantic": [{"argument": "player (582284)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "tennis", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sport"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (582290)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3977567", "3977569", "3977570", "3977574", "3977577", "3977578", "3977580", "3977584", "3977585", "3977586", "3977588", "3977589", "3977590", "4131277", "4131278", "4131280", "4131281", "4131284", "4131291", "4131292", "4131293", "4131294", "4131295", "4131296", "4131301"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 25, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bat"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "3977569", "query_target_entity_name": "bat", "relation_object_entity_id": "3977569", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4131300", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4131300", "selected_entity_name": "player"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "baseball", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4131300"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tennis", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "baseball", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["582282", "582285", "582286", "582287", "582288", "582289", "582290", "582294", "582295", "582296", "582297", "582298", "582299", "582300", "582301", "582302", "582303"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["racket"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "582290", "query_target_entity_name": "racket", "relation_object_entity_id": "582290", "relation_subject_entity_id": "582284", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "582284", "selected_entity_name": "player"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tennis", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["582284"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:38da36ca5bf0cd58d2dcc8aee3a13642", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "96a2d20221742a68f75f0175c0f56264dda16c07ab4edb320bb317a254574e7e", "image_sha256_b": "2acde5232e9dd81c012d6e0314f733985f603c95d7d482d5a52e4191daa00bae", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b6b97831260e2725c62fae97a892bc63cc9de25c50ddd51e72721ed2246406db", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e34e96dcf76ab31b9d996681b9bd4b81", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "58b020b956ed00f658f6ed2ae1a3c4c7cdf73430c545ada2203e39dc1db6f442"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "97c68801cfdfea1a2b735e1ffce832c766d1661d451db964caa378627432b9d4", "request_id": "88717a01631a306284ba762b7773e043", "response_sha256": "6e6b31637703e27158b68dc46dc15d4765959229ae80d2949bd02c94f2e1cef7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1e6139b4a59c7dc3cc810e741896c699af60e1c77217d8be7534502480080ee8", "request_id": "c9d017cb3c56f8a86a66ab3ecc51099b", "response_sha256": "f7e8c01619015da99744150d6615c5e2def0cfb65af49638b839350a65126ac9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "be8f532cafa1c690b99999433438ee03", "candidate_priority_rank": 16291, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5b21cab97397b1d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5b21cab97397b1d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5b21cab97397b1d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5b21cab97397b1d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "looking down<->playing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "playing", "B": "looking down"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "playing<->looking down", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2374898", "image_sha256": "57d1903817356a0631b8949c3e89479b79d10f37e01515c53077824234f4ae9c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2374898.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2374898.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2357894", "image_sha256": "6cb730ad69d946a089289b28b82b6b72007ce6a6a7eb4a1f0352049bbb6494fa", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2357894.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2357894.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d5b21cab97397b1d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "playing", "diff_b": "looking down", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "playing", "component_b": "looking down"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["playing"], "detected_components": ["playing"], "masked_program_sha256": "9216734cce87512096015463885f997aaef0ad7bf7e9bd133e3201cb3fd37c33", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "playing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c51fdc8a350abdf7650d079c19c64252bfc4daee68a6fc6c331def2f420242ab"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0713181", "text": "What kind of device is the person that is playing holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["looking down"], "detected_components": ["looking down"], "masked_program_sha256": "9216734cce87512096015463885f997aaef0ad7bf7e9bd133e3201cb3fd37c33", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "looking down", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "724f14da3c5a9e0cc6208ddc8b8a75d09bf82ecc1ec264212ed8e8b3f710ad13"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05933612", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16291, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d841add9c068a7c50dc0aa3dfa6681162f32e4702f3d842e5b88e37bfea5be0e", "selected_component": "looking down", "selected_source_question_id": "05933612", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of device is the person that is looking down holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "device,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of device is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "d841add9c068a7c50dc0aa3dfa6681162f32e4702f3d842e5b88e37bfea5be0e", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "device,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of device is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "d841add9c068a7c50dc0aa3dfa6681162f32e4702f3d842e5b88e37bfea5be0e", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "controllers", "full_answer": "The woman is holding the controllers.", "question": "What kind of device is the person that is playing holding?", "question_id": "0713181", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (724481)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "playing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "device,holding,o (724480)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cell phone", "full_answer": "The boy is holding the mobile phone.", "question": "What kind of device is the person that is looking down holding?", "question_id": "05933612", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (807784)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "looking down", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "device,holding,o (807777)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["724480"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["controllers"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "724480", "query_target_entity_name": "controllers", "relation_object_entity_id": "724480", "relation_subject_entity_id": "724481", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "724481", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["724481"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "looking down", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["807777"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cell phone"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "807777", "query_target_entity_name": "cell phone", "relation_object_entity_id": "807777", "relation_subject_entity_id": "807784", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "807784", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "looking down", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["807784"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:be8f532cafa1c690b99999433438ee03", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "57d1903817356a0631b8949c3e89479b79d10f37e01515c53077824234f4ae9c", "image_sha256_b": "6cb730ad69d946a089289b28b82b6b72007ce6a6a7eb4a1f0352049bbb6494fa", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1586a5d53e51d1c2098f8afcedcf6b3cb347409e943f28dc966c524a6c00676f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ca76e35d6ed46f886f465b5534107e70", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "802ebb16b77d2f0f5dddbed12c3d959a0e0e869325af410f4ea912341a1e5220"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fb2f4bb215d9a0161187aeede3ddf34ef29ac824e85b7a971b8970e2f3e9189c", "request_id": "2a6348a524f5af9d77901f6f62ff8aa3", "response_sha256": "eacfdc8eb0bff3ee6d112ab6ff9d537b5ad4eec2961560945259e6c8d2a8385b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4632550a88fe881c334eedd34ad4a1d6301f4fdbd1840968ec00d35f123874a5", "request_id": "b824dfdf910ca69df9d7b6a97a60c0e5", "response_sha256": "11d256a0172b5c8d8cfa8499185eb9369619800e38159b5c0f975861b5e7b0ef", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "997670011a1f2f8aa60891c938787567", "candidate_priority_rank": 16440, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7debc679d3e739dc:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7debc679d3e739dc:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7debc679d3e739dc:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7debc679d3e739dc:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "gray<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2403455", "image_sha256": "c97ae7b841738205aff3f176b994cbcc443bcf438cb0c5dda22fa2b6017b2631", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2403455.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2403455.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2398519", "image_sha256": "aff4b40f5cefcc3e7d852c0d94afc11859b70e0fc238592d787e2d49ab8a6f87", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398519.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398519.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7debc679d3e739dc", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "green"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "1f98f4d1c58a3d2e7c374d955f32aa57f51075aa58c0a7100bc476c43a9cef64", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0a6e7d2e690fb22a3ed0d8a31d95f0197210b53a176106c15beb40db65964971"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09875068", "text": "What is on the water that looks green?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "gray", "green"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "1f98f4d1c58a3d2e7c374d955f32aa57f51075aa58c0a7100bc476c43a9cef64", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2bd9050528687eb057a1fab54fa854966130648df7c9fe027c3722d2607a0bc7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08389943", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16440, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "7ca8b04837154767288fa0aeddfd3e2311059d4cde66a2ba6abfee48d73510a4", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "08389943", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the water that looks gray?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the water that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "7ca8b04837154767288fa0aeddfd3e2311059d4cde66a2ba6abfee48d73510a4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the water that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "7ca8b04837154767288fa0aeddfd3e2311059d4cde66a2ba6abfee48d73510a4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "surfboard", "full_answer": "The surfboard is on the water.", "question": "What is on the water that looks green?", "question_id": "09875068", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (381469)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (381462)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "boats", "full_answer": "The boats are on the water.", "question": "What is on the water that looks gray?", "question_id": "08389943", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (1179055)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1179058)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["381459", "381462", "381467", "381472", "381476", "381479", "381481", "381483", "381484", "381491", "381492", "381494", "381495", "381496"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["surfboard"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "381462", "query_target_entity_name": "surfboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "381469", "relation_subject_entity_id": "381462", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "381469", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["381469"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1179052", "1179053", "1179054", "1179056", "1179057", "1179058", "1179059", "1179061", "1179064", "1179071", "1179072", "1179073"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["boats"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1179058", "query_target_entity_name": "boats", "relation_object_entity_id": "1179055", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1179058", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1179055", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1179055"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:997670011a1f2f8aa60891c938787567", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c97ae7b841738205aff3f176b994cbcc443bcf438cb0c5dda22fa2b6017b2631", "image_sha256_b": "aff4b40f5cefcc3e7d852c0d94afc11859b70e0fc238592d787e2d49ab8a6f87", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e5ae56a802e7d0c81b65b4b86bc142f1a174f3ab6e9f77a96135d2500df35611", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ff39a01bed3d56485c234f9a2b7d8638", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6389145525df2e39ad9e2a601e9a5d6f90d16c73daf4c55dbc730ef8255dd011"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a79d6244dadcf01622eb2edcf0d240e85217bfbcef0d9dc4c7b1949cd1ca07a7", "request_id": "1b29a7597d6631058ca88b3a614ffb9e", "response_sha256": "0289993403d32b5cba451ec398e78ae9a5e542f2206c53dd4e9f19bf77ef9557", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1d76bdba343d1fb08c86f096f842d1da34f496116d0992d386ee8805907df709", "request_id": "e7ee6ab8e5018875d72c6b46468aa3e4", "response_sha256": "7932cccbff9c14dabbd7747e59be95caa83c3a9922de3d74be8cdd3264dde45f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "4136b84fd274da6995dbee7ec2ff35a0", "candidate_priority_rank": 16542, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7479a280bb2584d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7479a280bb2584d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7479a280bb2584d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7479a280bb2584d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->dark", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "dark", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dark<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2343473", "image_sha256": "2ed392bc0b166ec3acbd5426ecd4176dfff512e4f96745d56882b873f1315a42", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343473.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343473.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2317402", "image_sha256": "af5cda20d02647e469a29b1e19267b78837aa1942894dd98dd5386a4f60fc7bb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317402.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317402.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7479a280bb2584d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dark", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dark", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "dark"], "detected_components": ["dark"], "masked_program_sha256": "f77866058976e1ed9d98de9678b87aa69d364648c6c238f45da0ea05ffb22421", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dark", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6ed3bb965e54127deff072ad64f72474088ba957c24f4a188aefd41ab1f36509"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08723851", "text": "What animal is in the dark water?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "f77866058976e1ed9d98de9678b87aa69d364648c6c238f45da0ea05ffb22421", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7089e06965bcb008974d49b20d15254495e9f1a33112156a2d5a013e054be55d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08596015", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16542, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 15, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "93210a12cf36543bece01548c784b435020767279533f29bcf736cb98743aac7", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "08596015", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in the blue water?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in the water?", "program_group_hash": "93210a12cf36543bece01548c784b435020767279533f29bcf736cb98743aac7", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in the water?", "program_group_hash": "93210a12cf36543bece01548c784b435020767279533f29bcf736cb98743aac7", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bear", "full_answer": "The bear is in the water.", "question": "What animal is in the dark water?", "question_id": "08723851", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (923286)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dark", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (923279)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "birds", "full_answer": "The birds are in the water.", "question": "What animal is in the blue water?", "question_id": "08596015", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (3428789)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (3428788)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["923279"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bear"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "furry", "large", "wet"], "query_target_entity_id": "923279", "query_target_entity_name": "bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "923286", "relation_subject_entity_id": "923279", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "923286", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["923286"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2712109", "2712111", "2712113", "2712115", "2712117", "2712119", "2712121", "2756311", "2786441", "2800323", "2843192", "2843193", "2843194", "2843196", "2876045", "2923109", "2925792", "2962137", "2962138", "2962139", "2962140", "2962141", "2984592", "3030871", "3030873", "3030874", "3061514", "3147534", "3222882", "3269047", "3335883", "3335884", "3336340", "3395304", "3428788", "3484205", "3484206", "3484207", "3484208", "3501471", "3708241", "3708242", "3708243", "3708244", "3708245"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 45, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["birds"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "3428788", "query_target_entity_name": "birds", "relation_object_entity_id": "3428789", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3428788", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3428789", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3428789"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:4136b84fd274da6995dbee7ec2ff35a0", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2ed392bc0b166ec3acbd5426ecd4176dfff512e4f96745d56882b873f1315a42", "image_sha256_b": "af5cda20d02647e469a29b1e19267b78837aa1942894dd98dd5386a4f60fc7bb", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "dff6d7c5ecc2938892a1234cb46d87f15a1b42daa6b924e5f89308f1f9545480", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f1379c4b29bf529a0fcb013d98ed1edf", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "07e894174e55b2420d913f1bda4646a2e928604f8a25278627d64ccdff78a91b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5c8f371109aa37de34493ed12faa33a49ce36914947627660018c19bb5cf3bc8", "request_id": "3854a59febdaba62416cfb53903fa648", "response_sha256": "025cb87397e28c124fa7072962e41e891fa1525333c416ef7f620bdc88ae8834", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bb76888424054252c1fcc55f6fc681604d23218dacfe50b366735c891f437e30", "request_id": "520bef794434c5b4a84debb42ec21985", "response_sha256": "4279b819eb4f605035173e714bfafeac6fd986942544306904fd7a7b5fa5b8de", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "bd3685ed7c7e1df6de85c7f5e60207d5", "candidate_priority_rank": 16651, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4e3192736fc7b955:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4e3192736fc7b955:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4e3192736fc7b955:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4e3192736fc7b955:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "red<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "red"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->red", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 600, "image_id": "1669", "image_sha256": "d8949e23d9dcb20e493d3049043ef0a4c55b691930a627df45eb85374df7b38b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/1669.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/1669.jpg", "width": 800}, "B": {"height": 683, "image_id": "1160136", "image_sha256": "7ec91236dd4f63c97cb16f6c36bf86a37e24b3148f955bd1502d70a80966aba8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/1160136.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/1160136.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4e3192736fc7b955", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "red", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "red"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bdf93fc8de8aef492cb262e887148f8867cea50bce76d56a29ba3e3d51d881f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02802276", "text": "What is on the white wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "517153e7cfd70729d177e9c1c825be56bbc4802f2c3d08293249f1401f0edf22"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01711858", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16651, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 39, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "selected_component": "red", "selected_source_question_id": "01711858", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the red wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the white wall?", "question_id": "02802276", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (4314716)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (4314715)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "painting", "full_answer": "The painting is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the red wall?", "question_id": "01711858", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1040057)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1040061)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4314658", "4314671", "4314673", "4314677", "4314679", "4314683", "4314685", "4314688", "4314694", "4314699", "4314703", "4314713", "4314715", "4314718", "4314720", "4314734", "4530027", "4530029", "4530031", "4530032"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "4314715", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "4314716", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4314715", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4314716", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4314716"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1040051", "1040052", "1040053", "1040054", "1040055", "1040058", "1040060", "1040061", "1040062", "1040067", "1040069", "1040070", "1040071", "1040072", "1040074", "1040076", "1040077", "3790382"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["painting"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["framed"], "query_target_entity_id": "1040061", "query_target_entity_name": "painting", "relation_object_entity_id": "1040057", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1040061", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1040057", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1040057"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:bd3685ed7c7e1df6de85c7f5e60207d5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d8949e23d9dcb20e493d3049043ef0a4c55b691930a627df45eb85374df7b38b", "image_sha256_b": "7ec91236dd4f63c97cb16f6c36bf86a37e24b3148f955bd1502d70a80966aba8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "93e172d321a21df1012f68ed5f8beee01ae4147346978f84d0d8328ec42dce77", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0c7ebe263faca6afeb83b96085c0c548", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e0b2cb684f288b31e7177429e8fc684ab92f01b7293e902342b2fa40e356eee1"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e2e323b204a77e768878f0fdf41845d4839497c195c02873738f3085e9064a0b", "request_id": "e00f3ee46c43d504960bda8a1a424f99", "response_sha256": "45637328ee5454e7ad2f519f05927eefe615535c8f8b8972002ec5660c18b354", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "17c8568f7c48f0f020c847ffad1380dac94526cf9976412681bee542a03c50f6", "request_id": "c3cd3c1e413321cb5b55e1f4508d67a7", "response_sha256": "19480f53501d12959fbdb13903b2b60bac25c0537108c00ee186be5cb805dc18", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "3061b858fb34c17f5a89ba52f381700f", "candidate_priority_rank": 16866, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4220b2a3713cb88f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4220b2a3713cb88f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4220b2a3713cb88f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4220b2a3713cb88f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "standing<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "walking", "B": "standing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "walking<->standing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 342, "image_id": "2404443", "image_sha256": "091962c21533fa2520768b20c697280d7965040a195490dbb31ad1474e9e9f61", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404443.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404443.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2318861", "image_sha256": "66a4a9089a22c1c06499e80170199492a98eefe8af379eabd3a95f6989f0f657", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2318861.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2318861.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4220b2a3713cb88f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "walking", "diff_b": "standing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "walking", "component_b": "standing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "d4e6e2e730fca3d5b69619cb1c80fbb72b5855b9b3f1d4ffb55a25b1a68cff14", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3a2176f4960f7330adda654b27acb7ed13b0f01e0f28d6618bfc069a422ee932"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01720907", "text": "What is the person that is walking wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["sitting", "standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "d4e6e2e730fca3d5b69619cb1c80fbb72b5855b9b3f1d4ffb55a25b1a68cff14", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b5e27dc43696e64571db4448e8955d0cbff3aff3df50549ca7b73803484ba013"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12217336", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16866, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "07b46cf9cc4149f16a010b44e86bb0cba93829f7aca1fc3cea87c4880c68fdc0", "selected_component": "standing", "selected_source_question_id": "12217336", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is standing wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "07b46cf9cc4149f16a010b44e86bb0cba93829f7aca1fc3cea87c4880c68fdc0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "07b46cf9cc4149f16a010b44e86bb0cba93829f7aca1fc3cea87c4880c68fdc0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "shorts", "full_answer": "The man is wearing shorts.", "question": "What is the person that is walking wearing?", "question_id": "01720907", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (342604)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (342626)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "suit", "full_answer": "The person is wearing a suit.", "question": "What is the person that is standing wearing?", "question_id": "12217336", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1006527)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (1006530)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["342605", "342606", "342607", "342608", "342609", "342610", "342615", "342617", "342618", "342619", "342620", "342625", "342626"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["shorts"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "342626", "query_target_entity_name": "shorts", "relation_object_entity_id": "342626", "relation_subject_entity_id": "342604", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "342604", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["342604"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1006519", "1006520", "1006521", "1006523", "1006530", "1006531", "1006532", "1006533", "1006535", "1006536", "1006537", "1006538"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["suit"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1006530", "query_target_entity_name": "suit", "relation_object_entity_id": "1006530", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1006527", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1006527", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1006527"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:3061b858fb34c17f5a89ba52f381700f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "091962c21533fa2520768b20c697280d7965040a195490dbb31ad1474e9e9f61", "image_sha256_b": "66a4a9089a22c1c06499e80170199492a98eefe8af379eabd3a95f6989f0f657", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "77be8edc179af25dcf3211d1773e199ba0894466670d3af06b52e7d38e79bcf9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "13b90095bd847836239a1b279141c5b0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "be2fb25d0bc110c502a2821c5621f0d9088ad2de1ee4e493cfb5edf5076913bf"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c07377508def79d08a90d9092a1c367b1cd3dcc3c72ecaf2def4b9ed858ffdaf", "request_id": "58794e551d3d59fa6c543026996c349b", "response_sha256": "52dfab968f106863477ed0490d1ec1f4e1d28a57ad8fbfb99d719de00371eeb1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6ba81e09af3638473b5ab1402cdcf7ab2faaaa1c77cb29bbf670d2930375858c", "request_id": "eaddb89eac2d08af1fb0c80cc515d40b", "response_sha256": "335f56841e7ce6e7c82ac2686005cfc27e05419fa6cb88887a60eee62b967bbe", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "0ee091b8183fe5f7bc2f3bd1d7585639", "candidate_priority_rank": 16876, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-945cdd752b40d951:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-945cdd752b40d951:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-945cdd752b40d951:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-945cdd752b40d951:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->silver", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "silver"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->silver", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2344692", "image_sha256": "ffa9e821ea13ab39ab145683c3d03774aad743ceda1d6546123ee499056a6217", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2344692.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2344692.jpg", "width": 374}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2341419", "image_sha256": "ceeec1f6700ecda6b84ab327604b64d0336e3491459bd53966ff8c4ff4b24f29", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2341419.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2341419.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-945cdd752b40d951", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "silver", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "silver"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "76a2816b3d2a6742c92494011f312686f0d59f265e0cf5f5c7fa71afd4f7ca3c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b56f921831f59641dd5c855da885eedd5278d8f7bb4faf053a8032751c4d4f2d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04851408", "text": "What is on the utensil that looks black?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["silver"], "masked_program_sha256": "76a2816b3d2a6742c92494011f312686f0d59f265e0cf5f5c7fa71afd4f7ca3c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "silver", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "39d40d1d97cd845681308b21bbd64be1a5a56cf5278b5ba5f1cf2ac42e4bb8aa"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "141015631", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16876, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8936939686906df8d11736299a1f11051b85f2123878d99da2586edee972e93b", "selected_component": "silver", "selected_source_question_id": "141015631", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the utensil that looks silver?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "utensil", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the utensil that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "8936939686906df8d11736299a1f11051b85f2123878d99da2586edee972e93b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "utensil"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "utensil", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the utensil that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "8936939686906df8d11736299a1f11051b85f2123878d99da2586edee972e93b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "utensil"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "label", "full_answer": "The label is on the knife.", "question": "What is on the utensil that looks black?", "question_id": "04851408", "semantic": [{"argument": "utensil (2314458)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2460981)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "crumbs", "full_answer": "The crumbs are on the fork.", "question": "What is on the utensil that looks silver?", "question_id": "141015631", "semantic": [{"argument": "utensil (2687129)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "silver", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2035445)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2181755", "2217053", "2440151", "2460981", "2696007", "2820306", "2949502", "3116521", "3467539", "3562373", "3630126", "3914238"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["label"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2460981", "query_target_entity_name": "label", "relation_object_entity_id": "2314458", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2460981", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2314458", "selected_entity_name": "knife"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2314458"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2035445", "2236804", "2582428", "3402690"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["crumbs"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2035445", "query_target_entity_name": "crumbs", "relation_object_entity_id": "2687129", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2035445", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2687129", "selected_entity_name": "fork"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2687129"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:0ee091b8183fe5f7bc2f3bd1d7585639", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ffa9e821ea13ab39ab145683c3d03774aad743ceda1d6546123ee499056a6217", "image_sha256_b": "ceeec1f6700ecda6b84ab327604b64d0336e3491459bd53966ff8c4ff4b24f29", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e2d3f8194b3a80ff1af15edd4bfa7e684e339e94bc347ec8ed38ee066c199dd3", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8a7ed6b2cc0a3913d78dcca66b58e66a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "baa3f03a3abf2c674f363ba08566f60da3e4659c45592dedd412a11a2e23db0b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4767f9afe54db145dc2ad3b8a0a6bc84e6584ea16a42c1fba4a754d2e6943e7d", "request_id": "ad2a6293c37ea33f93011c94cf698ed9", "response_sha256": "9468eadf94af7596d567ddbad3c1c230dcf3f54cd03315fe0b3778383fa6867b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d880871baac2e458891d30e9b39487f4fbdfc1fc237843b69ed9e5e8130f5897", "request_id": "396753bbf352e21030c1b0a51eef8e8d", "response_sha256": "9db84ebe8af8285272472f9400f80eb71e5e99a49615e63a00d23f1fc677eaff", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "652f451c0da40ac98795afb3006dc3e3", "candidate_priority_rank": 17227, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e501ce181508e41f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e501ce181508e41f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e501ce181508e41f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e501ce181508e41f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "jumping<->standing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "jumping", "B": "standing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "jumping<->standing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2377593", "image_sha256": "94a9ec73559281c82875e9f121d344b60ee54b18c8b8afa9779029e60b0d7b3e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2377593.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2377593.jpg", "width": 334}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2413388", "image_sha256": "75e5845b53e950fd74e19766cf2f7c6f077fc48698c39a8fd29f16cef88a8d6b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2413388.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2413388.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e501ce181508e41f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "jumping", "diff_b": "standing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "jumping", "component_b": "standing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["jumping"], "detected_components": ["jumping"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "jumping", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "02b5ba820826ea8cb181dc7738a1bdeb7b2b5b84c3cb6409c4b2a724757c94b1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11392501", "text": "What is the person that is jumping holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "96086a768acf017a0d95aedaedb87e98cd8beee03f0c32ca3a33b0cd2136d91b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0910286", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 17227, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "selected_component": "standing", "selected_source_question_id": "0910286", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is standing holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "skateboard", "full_answer": "The man is holding the skateboard.", "question": "What is the person that is jumping holding?", "question_id": "11392501", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (564632)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "jumping", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (564633)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "umbrella", "full_answer": "The woman is holding the umbrella.", "question": "What is the person that is standing holding?", "question_id": "0910286", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (174555)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (174557)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["564633", "564635", "564636", "564638", "564641", "564642", "564644", "564646", "564648", "564649", "564650", "564651", "564652", "564653", "564654", "564655", "564658", "564660", "564661", "564662", "564668", "564669", "564673", "564675"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 24, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["skateboard"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "564633", "query_target_entity_name": "skateboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "564633", "relation_subject_entity_id": "564632", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "564632", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "jumping", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["564632"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "jumping", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["174556", "174557", "174558", "174559", "174560", "174562", "174563", "174565", "174566"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["umbrella"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "174557", "query_target_entity_name": "umbrella", "relation_object_entity_id": "174557", "relation_subject_entity_id": "174555", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "174555", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["174555"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:652f451c0da40ac98795afb3006dc3e3", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "94a9ec73559281c82875e9f121d344b60ee54b18c8b8afa9779029e60b0d7b3e", "image_sha256_b": "75e5845b53e950fd74e19766cf2f7c6f077fc48698c39a8fd29f16cef88a8d6b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c65ba986c0469cfb9b2bf75a4cca8c608bba4557108cdac7d999d570842ada9c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d00e55024318f7f7011b387429daf54e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "84a77ca3d973866daa8cab7d0d2a9fcf6657e337f0c42a6e03d72ee635c88b8f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6dc8fbef8a47c9a8feb7536ea0033c9bf4895b3df88ba878272125e9e632318d", "request_id": "7537e82d95bc35a16ba865a0a6797338", "response_sha256": "ec6bb99106980aa3546811cbd130487a554d37182dd5ffdc342a318639e9cdbd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "089d13b905a3a6cb39e701e1232fbf83f1dc78e3a6c692bfd5ce5ec343f5221b", "request_id": "bef0b9fe8786a12054311fc98e877c9e", "response_sha256": "3ea1986d2985227fdaa5c25b583dfe3918bedc3a10ff0445ed377d1ca0e93e8f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "f17d519bdcb010435142841e516caa30", "candidate_priority_rank": 15459, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bcb3f73799346f36:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bcb3f73799346f36:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bcb3f73799346f36:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bcb3f73799346f36:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 345, "image_id": "2371075", "image_sha256": "9c1bcc87262768e0e543b38b41ecad3733ab405062f63bc07fd053817e2d7b0d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371075.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371075.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2346899", "image_sha256": "7749e5c275fa7505aaad0b39aac44a2ed7c4c07c62463162d1282caedb0e5d9d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2346899.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2346899.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bcb3f73799346f36", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "red", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "bdbd54fcc50b4d98a8de87a8298ca0797bfbf7c4d79218929e3b0907687d6cf4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9505533f0bd48baea810f5f158b95b0cb160db2224990989916d28c4f8a66ee1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14250465", "text": "What is the black bag sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "gray", "green", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "bdbd54fcc50b4d98a8de87a8298ca0797bfbf7c4d79218929e3b0907687d6cf4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "cc033901efcf0d609f854e397f3be1219691bd945559f15ccaffb890e43b8921"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13701189", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 15459, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5a699e8bb8b6a5e909dfc304e95a2f748c624018e46ed2ec7e8a314d8ecff8bd", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "13701189", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the brown bag sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bag", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bag sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "5a699e8bb8b6a5e909dfc304e95a2f748c624018e46ed2ec7e8a314d8ecff8bd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "bag"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bag", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bag sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "5a699e8bb8b6a5e909dfc304e95a2f748c624018e46ed2ec7e8a314d8ecff8bd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "bag"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The bag is sitting on the chair.", "question": "What is the black bag sitting on?", "question_id": "14250465", "semantic": [{"argument": "bag (2826252)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (2826253)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The purse is sitting on the chair.", "question": "What is the brown bag sitting on?", "question_id": "13701189", "semantic": [{"argument": "bag (895571)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (895572)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1904379", "1916230", "2083590", "2092652", "2155480", "2211404", "2239450", "2262798", "2447898", "2480663", "2498648", "2504449", "2717619", "2769627", "2826253", "3086889", "3118174", "3146483", "3236492", "3314412", "3314413", "3352386", "3356081", "3394430", "3475829", "3475830", "3784787", "3855251"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 28, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2826253", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "2826253", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2826252", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2826252", "selected_entity_name": "bag"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2826252"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["895563", "895564", "895565", "895566", "895568", "895569", "895570", "895572", "895573", "895574", "895575", "895576", "895577", "895578", "895579", "895580", "895581", "895582", "895583", "895584", "895585", "895586", "895587"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 23, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["plastic", "red"], "query_target_entity_id": "895572", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "895572", "relation_subject_entity_id": "895571", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "895571", "selected_entity_name": "purse"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["895571"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:f17d519bdcb010435142841e516caa30", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9c1bcc87262768e0e543b38b41ecad3733ab405062f63bc07fd053817e2d7b0d", "image_sha256_b": "7749e5c275fa7505aaad0b39aac44a2ed7c4c07c62463162d1282caedb0e5d9d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "55f116a5cedc2b0ead5f687339119eeb401fd22528080ec0f3ef07f374eedb0f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "67b57539630d1ce412422b151ece88c6", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6e4a8e83006d8541f97fecf763ea562b1d7e39dda012eb81b0a33b3928fc1e9e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fdc0d07799153a1e0165134ab588741455f05eae3c42b29df86b2e4bceaaa049", "request_id": "8005579ef50ac811d07c9825a6bc1274", "response_sha256": "81ce567238613083193e80a1763b7d55d9a228b8ffb22d291d8cf9b1e226a542", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "555a9a45f638abb1eb681b84d592bfaff0ed48836d0e0e41a1a84e92588ae5a4", "request_id": "c11918b3dbc1509d02759a10446923e4", "response_sha256": "bb940632227d4a0d132b6c035246668931a6358de739e64f20a1831649f67fd8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "81c81ea13c942ce4f3cfaae6a11b7827", "candidate_priority_rank": 16311, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7bf4aae2ba24c190:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7bf4aae2ba24c190:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7bf4aae2ba24c190:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7bf4aae2ba24c190:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "skateboarding<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "skateboarding", "B": "surfing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "skateboarding<->surfing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2367943", "image_sha256": "fcabd866c218bf1b89b436be9cd921a344804d4d85893934176f9aa4116a511b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367943.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367943.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2369333", "image_sha256": "a82d915dfa73eb569d42c88ae374f2968a836082c890dff32f0dfd8a2f4b7a29", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369333.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369333.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7bf4aae2ba24c190", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "skateboarding", "diff_b": "surfing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "skateboarding", "component_b": "surfing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["skateboarding"], "detected_components": ["skateboarding"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "skateboarding", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b80a162ad123aa7a820faf467bf1332f67f2bf209dc8d0efc97884e19e280775"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12377226", "text": "What is the person that is skateboarding wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e60cb519061f9a7757db8551ae37f1c8e776ec4ce8929871b7d33b1bf739a866"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06881372", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16311, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 35, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "selected_component": "surfing", "selected_source_question_id": "06881372", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "helmet", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a helmet.", "question": "What is the person that is skateboarding wearing?", "question_id": "12377226", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (619844)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "skateboarding", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (619857)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "wetsuit", "full_answer": "The surfer is wearing a wetsuit.", "question": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?", "question_id": "06881372", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (612205)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (612213)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["619845", "619846", "619847", "619848", "619849", "619850", "619855", "619856", "619857", "619858", "619859", "619861", "619863", "619864", "619865", "619867", "619868"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["helmet"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "619857", "query_target_entity_name": "helmet", "relation_object_entity_id": "619857", "relation_subject_entity_id": "619844", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "619844", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skateboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["619844"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skateboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["612206", "612207", "612208", "612213", "612214", "612215", "612216"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wetsuit"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "612213", "query_target_entity_name": "wetsuit", "relation_object_entity_id": "612213", "relation_subject_entity_id": "612205", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "612205", "selected_entity_name": "surfer"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["612205"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:81c81ea13c942ce4f3cfaae6a11b7827", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "fcabd866c218bf1b89b436be9cd921a344804d4d85893934176f9aa4116a511b", "image_sha256_b": "a82d915dfa73eb569d42c88ae374f2968a836082c890dff32f0dfd8a2f4b7a29", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4fe1b17ea6b45b34eb82df0a361bf95f35a48b8f906476de45d229781cd23606", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7aab2e9f2a4dc7f3b9a8054dd607faca", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "bef7af7ee1920a07614a086afe5a0290e0d28d9c1449ee87135ed7701904aa4f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9ddd5c600c5f8c74bdbea051f1250728c2407c93a52696f6fa55330402285cad", "request_id": "e124115e2c3221570abb0e7f12787d7e", "response_sha256": "dbb7e00d762bea0c48061bf2bc499bb6a7f06ff6c1f6a00a89044d600ddf2795", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3b59d7da53648f14f3462ce802ee55246994be2628e64717a2230859a7c5859b", "request_id": "7844547cd401873b12c8f8dc7fe200bc", "response_sha256": "8a9cf7b405cc2db4e84fc5cfc52ba8dc0a94d392164cc4c562d9b87f82c209de", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "1c10e04cc38f7ddc4a972c01411c6d7c", "candidate_priority_rank": 16864, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ba901e0c0b6d6f84:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ba901e0c0b6d6f84:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ba901e0c0b6d6f84:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ba901e0c0b6d6f84:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->red", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "red"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->red", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2414452", "image_sha256": "c42075ed6a16d13742485298723b88e3c3bbac62e93225948be9c2d7b5b27c80", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2414452.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2414452.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 325, "image_id": "2408753", "image_sha256": "0fd13ae86fdc9ce264a9c0416a0e2699368bcb69a21a9b407006744ff4de5178", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408753.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408753.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ba901e0c0b6d6f84", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "red", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "red"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "45692036505c4a342ecd717b54649c2a244b1b7a1b17b6851d1d92504c30c2c3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["roof"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["roof"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "60abe9cff0e5877cb49987621d984ac792942a1c94095213215e05e833d64073"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13286081", "text": "What is on the blue roof?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "45692036505c4a342ecd717b54649c2a244b1b7a1b17b6851d1d92504c30c2c3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["roof"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["roof"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "623cfff557066b6bd416d1f34d84fe8edc00b985c04b86ab34833a9797ed5e33"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08980178", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16864, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b83cabe76bd2831ffd5f4365fab091df346c03fa6b338b6837469bcaf6aee4e5", "selected_component": "red", "selected_source_question_id": "08980178", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the red roof?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "roof", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the roof?", "program_group_hash": "b83cabe76bd2831ffd5f4365fab091df346c03fa6b338b6837469bcaf6aee4e5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "roof"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "roof", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the roof?", "program_group_hash": "b83cabe76bd2831ffd5f4365fab091df346c03fa6b338b6837469bcaf6aee4e5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "roof"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "graffiti", "full_answer": "The graffiti is on the roof.", "question": "What is on the blue roof?", "question_id": "13286081", "semantic": [{"argument": "roof (321163)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (321146)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "snow", "full_answer": "The snow is on the roof.", "question": "What is on the red roof?", "question_id": "08980178", "semantic": [{"argument": "roof (255694)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (255693)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["321144", "321145", "321146", "321149", "321150", "321153", "321154", "321155", "321156", "321159", "321160", "321161", "321164", "321167", "321168", "321171", "321172", "321174"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["graffiti"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "321146", "query_target_entity_name": "graffiti", "relation_object_entity_id": "321163", "relation_subject_entity_id": "321146", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "321163", "selected_entity_name": "roof"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["321163"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1620511", "1620516", "255674", "255675", "255676", "255678", "255679", "255681", "255685", "255686", "255687", "255688", "255690", "255691", "255692", "255693", "255695"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["snow"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "255693", "query_target_entity_name": "snow", "relation_object_entity_id": "255694", "relation_subject_entity_id": "255693", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "255694", "selected_entity_name": "roof"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["255694"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:1c10e04cc38f7ddc4a972c01411c6d7c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c42075ed6a16d13742485298723b88e3c3bbac62e93225948be9c2d7b5b27c80", "image_sha256_b": "0fd13ae86fdc9ce264a9c0416a0e2699368bcb69a21a9b407006744ff4de5178", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "29944a8ed661ddd1210e5fd9641c2a76ce572366ee85e3783d393a7c912fc3ab", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f99fb288a0528deffb9059462c92ff74", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "064f9bc008045e6f94eb7c515c39c11872495e0ea7a6d4458cabb55e2e13a85c"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0c68983e2b65c5460e2ffa996bfde81237d656bac9b468a3b838a42d2f624180", "request_id": "db8997da3dfe815b078a3d6aa8bace1f", "response_sha256": "6b35a3ab08cc7e7ac68915d9e7db73bacb02c9f585267859b6eae7e8470533a0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "390fa429d508bb8309d62843c5b6573be73e97a744ae6ccb6d251a773f13b395", "request_id": "aea8aff2f6359d598f37c277ffa03e33", "response_sha256": "d20f067bbd452efad4858ccecc1686776d61309d6f32bd87e6b27e068f5cab1e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "2e7353372d8ddebbbe6c8a6f98add8a3", "candidate_priority_rank": 17669, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-330e7435ab047df5:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-330e7435ab047df5:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-330e7435ab047df5:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-330e7435ab047df5:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "running<->standing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "running", "B": "standing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "running<->standing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2410919", "image_sha256": "0a5b48a784250ba6574e16f6bbb13cdca8ed03ee281b5cee2b06d5429fd881ab", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410919.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410919.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2380913", "image_sha256": "74673be7a5d0e344296ba716be665c4f46903003d7589bc7b7b9122c99b43263", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2380913.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2380913.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-330e7435ab047df5", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "running", "diff_b": "standing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "running", "component_b": "standing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["running"], "detected_components": ["running"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "running", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ebfa35cd00683fa16f537cbc0e37f0615ab8508a04a3ec615bc23be0ad1a1e45"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02228445", "text": "What is the person that is running holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "96086a768acf017a0d95aedaedb87e98cd8beee03f0c32ca3a33b0cd2136d91b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02333141", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 17669, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 36, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "selected_component": "standing", "selected_source_question_id": "02333141", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is standing holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bat", "full_answer": "The batter is holding the bat.", "question": "What is the person that is running holding?", "question_id": "02228445", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (318913)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "running", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (318923)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "kite", "full_answer": "The man is holding the kite.", "question": "What is the person that is standing holding?", "question_id": "02333141", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (708444)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (708456)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["318914", "318915", "318917", "318920", "318922", "318923", "318924", "318925", "318928", "318929", "318930", "318932", "318933", "318934", "318935", "318936", "318937", "318938"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bat"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "318923", "query_target_entity_name": "bat", "relation_object_entity_id": "318923", "relation_subject_entity_id": "318913", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "318913", "selected_entity_name": "batter"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "running", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["318913"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "running", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["708446", "708448", "708449", "708450", "708451", "708452", "708454", "708455", "708456", "708457", "708458", "708460", "708461"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["kite"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["colorful"], "query_target_entity_id": "708456", "query_target_entity_name": "kite", "relation_object_entity_id": "708456", "relation_subject_entity_id": "708444", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "708444", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["708444"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:2e7353372d8ddebbbe6c8a6f98add8a3", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "0a5b48a784250ba6574e16f6bbb13cdca8ed03ee281b5cee2b06d5429fd881ab", "image_sha256_b": "74673be7a5d0e344296ba716be665c4f46903003d7589bc7b7b9122c99b43263", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "6eda363af5172ffabc1ea12da96d583e1370c91e5d58b34f5ec73bd60ee9209f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f806bd48559c41ea5913d3af93702bc8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9971a001d96930161b73f32c69bb74f8939dd814a5d7202bb8a27a2b21be923c"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8e85411dea001595fd123aa596e9a0c4ac5e97bd55cae9b14fc0d5e0c264e088", "request_id": "a04dc5b24a499415e1f0aa18ecdd7829", "response_sha256": "4ed33f0567a7bd42dbcd9c84fd17ae502630e7ae278b38dccae168ff8096b121", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a566c55fe195cf4cfee2697700e9c4856c5bc57f6cf2df3a21948aacc16fd225", "request_id": "d6251f241a7bf70269d4fdd196797dd8", "response_sha256": "7ee2e4b4618af8880ad5055850904b66a2ab027b7a624bf284db79f6c34aef3d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "b593453a585cb562232f38b163692f38", "candidate_priority_rank": 17983, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-576255b84715fd55:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-576255b84715fd55:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-576255b84715fd55:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-576255b84715fd55:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "white<->yellow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "yellow", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "yellow<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 331, "image_id": "2399761", "image_sha256": "08f2158b05a31895c7f7ce132a390b1f40c6c2adb5b1d12e550bbe6525d51652", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399761.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399761.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2411586", "image_sha256": "e36b042cf3a70f94fe278442c90838816a57f487defe6412fa9df171504fcb18", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2411586.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2411586.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-576255b84715fd55", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "yellow", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "yellow", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "green", "orange", "purple", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["yellow"], "masked_program_sha256": "e73974fbbb1e95347b10ac44e012fd3e618f10f3533121a1296e672eaef142ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yellow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3473aacb24c06d617cbba5be818686c6f9ca9121e782f64a6a85a125c03839c2"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11843189", "text": "What is on the yellow table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "green", "purple", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "e73974fbbb1e95347b10ac44e012fd3e618f10f3533121a1296e672eaef142ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "68b6270601dd4e47977535e1aaf60b3e29dcbe2a8536b6ccb5cb95b11efa6bb3"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06775275", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 17983, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e9930c4e445b6f97ba358331196fc75b70857cebf6e3179882feefaa6f5341f5", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "06775275", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the white table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "e9930c4e445b6f97ba358331196fc75b70857cebf6e3179882feefaa6f5341f5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "e9930c4e445b6f97ba358331196fc75b70857cebf6e3179882feefaa6f5341f5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "plant", "full_answer": "The plant is on the table.", "question": "What is on the yellow table?", "question_id": "11843189", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (413948)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "yellow", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (413934)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dish", "full_answer": "The dish is on the table.", "question": "What is on the white table?", "question_id": "06775275", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (309727)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (309719)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["413933", "413934", "413935", "413940", "413941", "413942", "413943", "413945", "413946", "413947", "413950", "413951", "413952", "413953", "413955", "413956", "413957"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["plant"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green", "potted"], "query_target_entity_id": "413934", "query_target_entity_name": "plant", "relation_object_entity_id": "413948", "relation_subject_entity_id": "413934", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "413948", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["413948"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["309713", "309714", "309715", "309718", "309719", "309720", "309721", "309722", "309723", "309724", "309725", "309726", "309728", "309729", "309730", "309733", "309734", "309735", "309736"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dish"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["ridged", "small", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "309719", "query_target_entity_name": "dish", "relation_object_entity_id": "309727", "relation_subject_entity_id": "309719", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "309727", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["309727"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b593453a585cb562232f38b163692f38", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "08f2158b05a31895c7f7ce132a390b1f40c6c2adb5b1d12e550bbe6525d51652", "image_sha256_b": "e36b042cf3a70f94fe278442c90838816a57f487defe6412fa9df171504fcb18", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d151a99eaf9eb3cdcd5b85a41d9a25b9fd9b23ad190317da565dfda9723d7e83", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ba29d6c2fb1dac4ed6924f278e957550", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "11ce31ac7a41676625d78b20d3a40c0ad4d933434449f3f29dd5e63ffd621522"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "95663f35fb2a2489ace23c7d4f0513adad8a2cc64f0c5081527b93a43a75df05", "request_id": "7ebaab970a4aaa60902110bc59255265", "response_sha256": "6d03d8f89d8d13ecf85603ff782eada165861abfb9e108746318627134fc07ea", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9c24a69d6cb4dddb1a7525f90a84f2465548b87ca91a6415c78d2d23cf5a7cb0", "request_id": "6c68b7e672dc15ea50e60b5f21a8db09", "response_sha256": "8a3036445ed01c47a435464db7c119914c30118cd14c584676c7b280ff21d65b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "4070000f0da62e9e942e6b6509edac3c", "candidate_priority_rank": 18084, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d1478e36a1b2577c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d1478e36a1b2577c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d1478e36a1b2577c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d1478e36a1b2577c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->blue", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 370, "image_id": "2404663", "image_sha256": "b7970d7f8d9fc3cb7a6b5c52f40f3bc5c8dad073d54d2837cfc6c2f41ec69bab", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404663.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404663.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2350406", "image_sha256": "b224d80e70b9f460f2ad256f1ade81ddbc5f41e3e8e512bf71ba778b5e660fe0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2350406.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2350406.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d1478e36a1b2577c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "tan", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "de66aef07411df154654dc0fec3ced85fc2bbb411ae2a5d6fe4f38cb6611214d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0adeff779bc08e7a17b166e49b5245eea1e07489e1ff266427b11cc1c7a0407b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1751585", "text": "What is lying on the blue table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray", "green", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "de66aef07411df154654dc0fec3ced85fc2bbb411ae2a5d6fe4f38cb6611214d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bc7084cc6a54cd0c6c356aba289768a8194c3f44c66c4ad548594d2f4c6e0ce8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10297878", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 18084, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "740ea82b4385a5a9e80d98e3d7ea7923832d9842bf5211574a9e30ff83ea8fc3", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "10297878", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is lying on the black table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is lying on the table?", "program_group_hash": "740ea82b4385a5a9e80d98e3d7ea7923832d9842bf5211574a9e30ff83ea8fc3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is lying on the table?", "program_group_hash": "740ea82b4385a5a9e80d98e3d7ea7923832d9842bf5211574a9e30ff83ea8fc3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "papers", "full_answer": "The papers are lying on the table.", "question": "What is lying on the blue table?", "question_id": "1751585", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (1113997)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,s (1113996)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cell phone", "full_answer": "The mobile phone is lying on the table.", "question": "What is lying on the black table?", "question_id": "10297878", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (868211)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,s (868215)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1113985", "1113989", "1113994", "1113995", "1113996", "1113999", "1114000", "1114003", "1114004", "1114005", "1114007", "1114008", "1114009", "1114010", "1114011", "1114012", "1114013", "1114015", "1114016", "1114018", "1114019", "1114020"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["papers"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1113996", "query_target_entity_name": "papers", "relation_object_entity_id": "1113997", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1113996", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1113997", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1113997"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["868199", "868200", "868201", "868202", "868203", "868204", "868205", "868206", "868207", "868208", "868209", "868210", "868212", "868213", "868214", "868215", "868216", "868217", "868218", "868219", "868220", "868221", "868222", "868223", "868224", "868225"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 26, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cell phone"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "868215", "query_target_entity_name": "cell phone", "relation_object_entity_id": "868211", "relation_subject_entity_id": "868215", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "868211", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["868211"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:4070000f0da62e9e942e6b6509edac3c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b7970d7f8d9fc3cb7a6b5c52f40f3bc5c8dad073d54d2837cfc6c2f41ec69bab", "image_sha256_b": "b224d80e70b9f460f2ad256f1ade81ddbc5f41e3e8e512bf71ba778b5e660fe0", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4cb9cdeda3bf035ce8d8db0b375e8898fcce7a8e2307538a7c8bc36fba593806", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0e3ea3e98dc5bbe6599f28f9dfa48b7e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "793d138bbd39f004ff736f3394167c619bdc54821a188ff332d3c812eb9abc59"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e65de2fd99e6ed9d142051b8f947e94b3ef8d84560016791d99d866aac457b0e", "request_id": "d953013c6f76954ccd12e83508579179", "response_sha256": "e10876d2f732d94ad31e99a366ea90d512b282f3d9aee63ffdb2cfb4656aa697", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0e8394de18eec5b1d4848e8d22744dbc71cfbe6932d265cc52c9dd5c92901050", "request_id": "dff184b4415374c9201aa32e384d5271", "response_sha256": "f0ab171b67183894d6b235be973cea33b3766cc6d095a122fbf3ccb56f891f1f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "dca7d1f127ac177813a665d292a88ae8", "candidate_priority_rank": 18089, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-74a02c396f463de0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-74a02c396f463de0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-74a02c396f463de0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-74a02c396f463de0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "metal<->stone", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "metal", "B": "stone"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "metal<->stone", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2415964", "image_sha256": "57480eeb38c0553a4982f065678a3b46531f07815428b43889038b90320cd89d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2415964.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2415964.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2370640", "image_sha256": "28ce76469eb91c87584cebcc953a970b71628bf696d34aa1952911e1d0ab2094", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2370640.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2370640.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-74a02c396f463de0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "metal", "diff_b": "stone", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "metal", "component_b": "stone"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal"], "detected_components": ["metal"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "metal", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5ce1e7ffa9a445d92d8ab77e5b51aec0369e1cb47f782ea2dfdb89aba189e5ab"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19967536", "text": "What animal is in front of the fence that is made of metal?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal", "rock", "stone"], "detected_components": ["stone"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stone", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "51ae79d76a90203a08f4f637b27c06a8dc9382b3486702c098e65ddbd2f5a890"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1235255", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 18089, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1081aa0a41fe489f36a70ac3861ce1a4d5d9444b4d8c671111342dd8d42c9493", "selected_component": "stone", "selected_source_question_id": "1235255", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in front of the fence that is made of stone?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the fence that is made of ?", "program_group_hash": "1081aa0a41fe489f36a70ac3861ce1a4d5d9444b4d8c671111342dd8d42c9493", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the fence that is made of ?", "program_group_hash": "1081aa0a41fe489f36a70ac3861ce1a4d5d9444b4d8c671111342dd8d42c9493", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sheep", "full_answer": "The sheep is in front of the fence.", "question": "What animal is in front of the fence that is made of metal?", "question_id": "19967536", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (3402845)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "metal", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (3651639)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The giraffe is in front of the fence.", "question": "What animal is in front of the fence that is made of stone?", "question_id": "1235255", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (2177641)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "stone", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (2177643)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3064080", "3480197", "3544359", "3651639"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sheep"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3651639", "query_target_entity_name": "sheep", "relation_object_entity_id": "3402845", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3651639", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3402845", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3402845"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2177643", "2292670"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2177643", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "2177641", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2177643", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2177641", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2177641"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:dca7d1f127ac177813a665d292a88ae8", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "57480eeb38c0553a4982f065678a3b46531f07815428b43889038b90320cd89d", "image_sha256_b": "28ce76469eb91c87584cebcc953a970b71628bf696d34aa1952911e1d0ab2094", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "130d3c71eff72a39203f55190bb14a62df91573fa62bba9bae89b70258ebdb28", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8418c034aeca383a57afd09697352e46", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "8effc1c774c6a6e8dbab0c8bc2b77216aa08f5c5830cd8224404b4cb34122524"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b15a9448aa0716dd42594791eef0e2cd86d4ffd035a49a94999c0050c79771e3", "request_id": "99f1a69aff0c31920a6d327c2d891b70", "response_sha256": "d9e9fd9ad7aace5a596fb6f607d04e75b25d9ec2f8adaa289efbfff58cc84188", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "71a2ab19d67cd2993cbf95aa083282b13fb0e39e639eb4d67eed255a4b85c611", "request_id": "6bc7120151d5fe9f101df46a313e0218", "response_sha256": "cb422d4a9a081b355de12e864ffade7eaf5f1006236c9aefdffae6bde14410cb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "4346bc4962e3175f0a1ba8a24bd7f4f4", "candidate_priority_rank": 18633, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-beca85aeeb824f83:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-beca85aeeb824f83:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-beca85aeeb824f83:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-beca85aeeb824f83:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2402713", "image_sha256": "fa8d7a4075729c87598c0f859ab7383dabb025865fb663bcf693a19d615faf85", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402713.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402713.jpg", "width": 379}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2379259", "image_sha256": "cad5d8854204130c70cf30d35cc4714333cd13506869da9fcebaf133245f9479", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2379259.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2379259.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-beca85aeeb824f83", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "green", "orange", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "b5b75fe7b823fede5bf369b63aacafaf900e47223ba24ac0d367fc600263dacf", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["post"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["post"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5d9c0663184dfd5f7be0b79570041ad982166e493a3fa20037c732a61d0960ed"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16514737", "text": "What is on the green post?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "b5b75fe7b823fede5bf369b63aacafaf900e47223ba24ac0d367fc600263dacf", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["post"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["post"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4af793a445ebfc2df6112dea4b62ec3bb6d1dcfc78dc05ab8c80fbdd252a9921"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1012085", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 18633, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4ddac6ee33ada0560e52647d751063318680b49abbea613e87ed9738918aef08", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "1012085", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the black post?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "post", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the post?", "program_group_hash": "4ddac6ee33ada0560e52647d751063318680b49abbea613e87ed9738918aef08", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "post"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "post", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the post?", "program_group_hash": "4ddac6ee33ada0560e52647d751063318680b49abbea613e87ed9738918aef08", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "post"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is on the post.", "question": "What is on the green post?", "question_id": "16514737", "semantic": [{"argument": "post (1132490)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1132489)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stop sign", "full_answer": "The stop sign is on the post.", "question": "What is on the black post?", "question_id": "1012085", "semantic": [{"argument": "post (1359156)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1359153)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1132471", "1132472", "1132475", "1132476", "1132477", "1132478", "1132479", "1132481", "1132482", "1132483", "1132484", "1132486", "1132489", "1132492", "1132493", "1132494", "1132495", "1132496", "1132497", "387280"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1132489", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "1132490", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1132489", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1132490", "selected_entity_name": "post"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1132490"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1132471", "1132472", "1132475", "1132476", "1132477", "1132478", "1132479", "1132481", "1132482", "1132483", "1132484", "1132486", "1132489", "1132490", "1132492", "1132493", "1132494", "1132496", "1132497", "387280"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1132495"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1359153", "1359154", "1359157", "1359160", "1359161", "1359167", "1359168", "1359169", "1359170"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stop sign"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "octagonal", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1359153", "query_target_entity_name": "stop sign", "relation_object_entity_id": "1359156", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1359153", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1359156", "selected_entity_name": "post"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1359156"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:4346bc4962e3175f0a1ba8a24bd7f4f4", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "fa8d7a4075729c87598c0f859ab7383dabb025865fb663bcf693a19d615faf85", "image_sha256_b": "cad5d8854204130c70cf30d35cc4714333cd13506869da9fcebaf133245f9479", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "34016cbfe80a2ac4d47acd477f4e5c24c24c3dc7073d849390c3b01da5e4caff", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5e5db11c5a2ac75f9ee1a72b6e353e95", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e38edcf6dfcc0e585313967448df8d65acbe591174f0a3d6fa81ae3dc13549ef"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f86b8ab9a5ea1ad7c73b253a3c0c954a99b1901e7c79548eacbed18ed0b137fe", "request_id": "f1d9c3fe0dd670b29e629bcc88a64222", "response_sha256": "d4cc784fd0c17af2cab9efc37560c78eef25b8df3c1021c9edf22d91cd3f24c5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a9bfc947a9935523816135288ece75f6e80c68a73d93c19fe31a25cad8193ccd", "request_id": "36a3e07399ab9be01355014917d91603", "response_sha256": "aff751889a2910ec967df8e5eeb4f4225fb7ee423a2c046550222794f16f6681", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "3e50ab4230d11b970bc143dc22d45216", "candidate_priority_rank": 7803, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d08591321aa6f86d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d08591321aa6f86d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d08591321aa6f86d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d08591321aa6f86d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "green<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2407233", "image_sha256": "7f4ee8f19dcf59c9e94efa681dcb78e6bbe4f6a03f80d10e452b241a93bba62f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407233.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407233.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2359955", "image_sha256": "e24d9999b33fe5338ad2c4e173eae4b10c5155521dd13270967cf1a9735624be", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2359955.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2359955.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d08591321aa6f86d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "cream colored", "green", "orange", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a7ea1c1f326e2bec451090d5a6cfe60814722ead9fdb2ef496517a6037b5a716"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19832552", "text": "What is on the green wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bdf93fc8de8aef492cb262e887148f8867cea50bce76d56a29ba3e3d51d881f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16861797", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 7803, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 42, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "16861797", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the white wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "picture", "full_answer": "The picture is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the green wall?", "question_id": "19832552", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (283351)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (283350)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "flowers", "full_answer": "The flowers are on the wall.", "question": "What is on the white wall?", "question_id": "16861797", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1932881)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1753883)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["283350", "283352", "283353", "283354", "283356", "283357", "283358", "283359", "283360", "283361", "283362", "283363", "283364"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["picture"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["flowered", "green", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "283350", "query_target_entity_name": "picture", "relation_object_entity_id": "283351", "relation_subject_entity_id": "283350", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "283351", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["283351"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1753883", "1960367", "1984360", "1984361", "1984362", "1984364", "2314989", "2350291", "2417291", "2577550", "2823133", "3119801", "3207604", "3207605", "3207606", "3207607", "3207608", "3536469", "3536473"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["flowers"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1753883", "query_target_entity_name": "flowers", "relation_object_entity_id": "1932881", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1753883", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1932881", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1932881"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:3e50ab4230d11b970bc143dc22d45216", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7f4ee8f19dcf59c9e94efa681dcb78e6bbe4f6a03f80d10e452b241a93bba62f", "image_sha256_b": "e24d9999b33fe5338ad2c4e173eae4b10c5155521dd13270967cf1a9735624be", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "bd472dcc3bea1bfa139b6edd51fef9f04788adca9b84f1902098660295fe194a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "67981017d56105894cfb3a82d783073d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b8019b595069f1493a03864bd222a5f09bac5ca4a132ef7770554042405b4d6f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "712386981dcc3665d5239916c8b9bf498139aebc97923e1717d955f8223189e8", "request_id": "c9d7d3444248ebefc6451319c1553972", "response_sha256": "7ec37e46bf799cbd4aa6ce8e9b81a5bce6cd347efa55e82f353da71f4efb97a2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f1b155b950cb2e6b75cba155e4ce740d872964430cac0ef36c43a02c1f110f5f", "request_id": "15c7f09a769446430e89991e659959d7", "response_sha256": "6c4d58f0c849e79e72cc0bafbd070406afc7cfe54f59385c9f6123765aaf2b4a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "b7d0ed944f090a1f40580f3870b57461", "candidate_priority_rank": 7917, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-950bf9f3a13e0f20:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-950bf9f3a13e0f20:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-950bf9f3a13e0f20:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-950bf9f3a13e0f20:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "red<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "red"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->red", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2325292", "image_sha256": "9a278364f1f8222b4944aa558c237ffe3cf2f4e19c19469d51a4f94e349a7099", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2325292.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2325292.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2354043", "image_sha256": "b499cd688345c241b6b032831a67574873afe81449d363b6f43af65e987955ea", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2354043.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2354043.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-950bf9f3a13e0f20", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "red", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "red"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "67818916c77171ab4bdb886e0c1b22a4046ad75ce0cee796e6cbebe5034d7e6e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a13cdf67363ff1a15ddf7f5cc1e1388c5b51aa83778a9b8ef06f4aa6f4ea2284"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10512974", "text": "What is in front of the white vehicle?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "green", "red"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "67818916c77171ab4bdb886e0c1b22a4046ad75ce0cee796e6cbebe5034d7e6e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0ff7f761c1ac0c7bd6f90f0d2a590dd782e24ade09ecf3cdee4e1665cd5a533a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1259780", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 7917, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 13, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f86a61c469f10abb956cee1c5f2035cdef5fff8d06421b4cdb042677a67cb120", "selected_component": "red", "selected_source_question_id": "1259780", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the red vehicle?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "vehicle", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the vehicle?", "program_group_hash": "f86a61c469f10abb956cee1c5f2035cdef5fff8d06421b4cdb042677a67cb120", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "vehicle"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "vehicle", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the vehicle?", "program_group_hash": "f86a61c469f10abb956cee1c5f2035cdef5fff8d06421b4cdb042677a67cb120", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "vehicle"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bicycle", "full_answer": "The bicycle is in front of the bus.", "question": "What is in front of the white vehicle?", "question_id": "10512974", "semantic": [{"argument": "vehicle (3170238)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (3113827)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "fence", "full_answer": "The fence is in front of the truck.", "question": "What is in front of the red vehicle?", "question_id": "1259780", "semantic": [{"argument": "vehicle (2235909)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (2235910)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2741872", "2775512", "2912698", "2913655", "2917040", "2922089", "3054005", "3059029", "3064044", "3090069", "3113827", "3124651", "3494946", "3941808", "3941809"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bicycle"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3113827", "query_target_entity_name": "bicycle", "relation_object_entity_id": "3170238", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3113827", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "3170238", "selected_entity_name": "bus"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3170238"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1734768", "1917275", "1917276", "1917277", "1917278", "2095131", "2235910", "2271860", "2271861", "2279967", "2401292", "2659308", "2664759", "2666843", "2683854", "3575272", "3778406", "3895134"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fence"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["chain-link"], "query_target_entity_id": "2235910", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "2235909", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2235910", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2235909", "selected_entity_name": "truck"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2235909"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b7d0ed944f090a1f40580f3870b57461", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9a278364f1f8222b4944aa558c237ffe3cf2f4e19c19469d51a4f94e349a7099", "image_sha256_b": "b499cd688345c241b6b032831a67574873afe81449d363b6f43af65e987955ea", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "93279efd62d553729c127b4de1aa09bef5af285836c2facdbcb52411c92b51e7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "72028b7423d309714028408bd15eb6ed", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0dc0fba7721268a55a8250570293d432fd81b1fc66fc892afb9c72157bcffd25"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1d3fe9d2d2df761edefc8b74692e94be03c2e84742e62c86cd6d090f88e76b46", "request_id": "b337ab8a7e8b17dcf656516dafcc37ee", "response_sha256": "cd1ca1a83e51475be1af0b09c61af8663bd6956be90bba12dc96ad2c573015c4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "da6889be0ca03bfffbdf9aa76a74024df887b98b7be4106904ce3cccc8630d92", "request_id": "f42472411b0ae9d822ee64ff616dccfb", "response_sha256": "b0ab8a53c9f80111133a846945d769c50cbf89e4c60c261e402a32a225c9211d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "013c38e608ce22dfc730e2efe6d20f83", "candidate_priority_rank": 7987, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c77d62378d2a3f92:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c77d62378d2a3f92:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c77d62378d2a3f92:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c77d62378d2a3f92:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brick<->stone", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brick", "B": "stone"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brick<->stone", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2390216", "image_sha256": "bbffdfb355fd662ecf9cf35182df7f28e40ebb756c532ac503fac3ff98ca4abc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390216.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390216.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2412985", "image_sha256": "27c2fd758f8190bf04dba8a8072167ac688acfac3724b91a6e9abecf159c7476", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412985.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412985.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c77d62378d2a3f92", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brick", "diff_b": "stone", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brick", "component_b": "stone"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brick"], "detected_components": ["brick"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brick", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1416b44662f9a3a1e88f9c2cf8864749654867b13c3dfb91ebdfd072550e5815"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19417840", "text": "What is on the wall made of brick?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal", "stone"], "detected_components": ["stone"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stone", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e54ba93766d84cd441c86a6c54cdc5e77df5c2bad179776b2b99120ea0041d2a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05358565", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 7987, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 15, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "73321a13d93b81b16835c08883a18828f7d31153422e699ba9d4f79970700f9e", "selected_component": "stone", "selected_source_question_id": "05358565", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the wall made of stone?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "73321a13d93b81b16835c08883a18828f7d31153422e699ba9d4f79970700f9e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "73321a13d93b81b16835c08883a18828f7d31153422e699ba9d4f79970700f9e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "graffiti", "full_answer": "The graffiti is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the wall made of brick?", "question_id": "19417840", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (4467517)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brick", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (4467521)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "moss", "full_answer": "The moss is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the wall made of stone?", "question_id": "05358565", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (182714)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "stone", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (182715)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4467519", "4467520", "4467521", "4467533", "4467534", "4467535", "4467536", "4467537", "4467538", "4467539", "4467541", "4467543", "4467544", "4467545", "4467546"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["graffiti"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4467521", "query_target_entity_name": "graffiti", "relation_object_entity_id": "4467517", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4467521", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4467517", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4467517"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["182710", "182711", "182715", "182716", "182717", "182718", "182723", "182728", "182729", "182730", "182731", "182736"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["moss"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green", "wet"], "query_target_entity_id": "182715", "query_target_entity_name": "moss", "relation_object_entity_id": "182714", "relation_subject_entity_id": "182715", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "182714", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["182714"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:013c38e608ce22dfc730e2efe6d20f83", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bbffdfb355fd662ecf9cf35182df7f28e40ebb756c532ac503fac3ff98ca4abc", "image_sha256_b": "27c2fd758f8190bf04dba8a8072167ac688acfac3724b91a6e9abecf159c7476", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8e951d690e566a1b51ef26526f153ed017b1999031a8ad73627ec1d5db13c437", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f21d6f5c0aff2efdfb95c6ed208dfcb8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7e13ef9555494ec3facf7229452f2df96ecc34bdbe6ef02fe061664e01467c58"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7a4da54499082f22b721cf14cd2782c23e28c18791a67d34ecf467e8753334e3", "request_id": "d48db6bbde6a6639fdf7b5e7a03760e6", "response_sha256": "5b59b04cb497b64e6b236f1cfe3f92c792449b7e99786d3d9c18fed94038bc2d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "80e88f49033c6595d66a5bcb71c313e96ae3b58362ccb76188f6bd05375f6cf5", "request_id": "34ef7b1e2e113f0c4387bbe8b0d7e0b1", "response_sha256": "04608e34e55637057ba10fc66726bef47022effe0f50c14dc8979f5cca4246d7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "a6928db46be36d6401c2cb8ba903bb09", "candidate_priority_rank": 7997, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-32cd9f9cb144f015:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-32cd9f9cb144f015:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-32cd9f9cb144f015:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-32cd9f9cb144f015:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "playing<->waiting", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "waiting", "B": "playing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "waiting<->playing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 307, "image_id": "2384174", "image_sha256": "38e7ce9571c2056213e701a4b618637e193932ecc0c1cc6565d39dacd200db16", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384174.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384174.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2346647", "image_sha256": "d49d8376ae462bd5c8cb639f0f9da0022b555be47ed992db5c303b997b3fdcda", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2346647.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2346647.jpg", "width": 332}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-32cd9f9cb144f015", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "waiting", "diff_b": "playing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "waiting", "component_b": "playing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["waiting"], "detected_components": ["waiting"], "masked_program_sha256": "c29262c7fcb698da82ae7d9f54178cfdc022d6e0a16f5620cebd2b15139505d7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "waiting", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a6592ff81310e7f97c63f998a29f3db36c59395556ce98e4afbdbb5cffd9da84"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19987868", "text": "What is the man that is waiting wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["playing"], "detected_components": ["playing"], "masked_program_sha256": "c29262c7fcb698da82ae7d9f54178cfdc022d6e0a16f5620cebd2b15139505d7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "playing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0647ddceaf23b6660af1015028ec3d657f48c7ffd6e3556735a40e84e99fcc5b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05786379", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 7997, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a08e43be71a18382fd122ab257409c11e866c30745cb9a2f054f92f7234fc0b6", "selected_component": "playing", "selected_source_question_id": "05786379", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the man that is playing wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "man", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the man that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "a08e43be71a18382fd122ab257409c11e866c30745cb9a2f054f92f7234fc0b6", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "man", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the man that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "a08e43be71a18382fd122ab257409c11e866c30745cb9a2f054f92f7234fc0b6", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "wetsuit", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a wetsuit.", "question": "What is the man that is waiting wearing?", "question_id": "19987868", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1312474)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "waiting", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (1312475)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hat", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a hat.", "question": "What is the man that is playing wearing?", "question_id": "05786379", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (897520)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "playing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (897523)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1312472", "1312473", "1312475", "1312476", "1312477", "1312481", "1312482", "1312483"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wetsuit"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1312475", "query_target_entity_name": "wetsuit", "relation_object_entity_id": "1312475", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1312474", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1312474", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "waiting", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1312474"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "waiting", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["897516", "897517", "897518", "897522", "897523", "897524", "897525", "897526", "897527", "897528", "897532", "897533", "897534", "897535", "897536"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hat"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "897523", "query_target_entity_name": "hat", "relation_object_entity_id": "897523", "relation_subject_entity_id": "897520", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "897520", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["897520"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:a6928db46be36d6401c2cb8ba903bb09", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "38e7ce9571c2056213e701a4b618637e193932ecc0c1cc6565d39dacd200db16", "image_sha256_b": "d49d8376ae462bd5c8cb639f0f9da0022b555be47ed992db5c303b997b3fdcda", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3fc4fffee2afedb684781a294279fef924013aca707a52cb2a32778f2d50768e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "98042756b0f84a74b69c3ab19c6d2ae3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6563d0f05f86c8829cb46b05451a08a57ded38a67eba397b2f391fd50b3aaf8a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "02451b928651e21f656ba30de7244a039e9777acf9092387791579b18623ea49", "request_id": "4c32f1598430906e224ad2c779b8143c", "response_sha256": "dfad23579030168b53e8fd8dc52941f480d3ceb41d50aac66064ca4d1b0edd8e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9e9aaffdae893f684537beee5e5f09054cd4b385503e48c805a345d847893ffb", "request_id": "e02250d630b6666d102cbf587a4bc5e3", "response_sha256": "de6960c752db7c02ea31fe6f611e39ccbda69f926bcdf12750a0877ec77cca0c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "b2d8bf0e51d28dca78297f139f1276a8", "candidate_priority_rank": 8012, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a122c52ef27ac31a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a122c52ef27ac31a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a122c52ef27ac31a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a122c52ef27ac31a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->purple", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "purple", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "purple<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2398414", "image_sha256": "9e070bb5a31a09d46c2d51a32c6c843a74303bedf754adcc391c1d2ea9fed9ad", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398414.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398414.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2342966", "image_sha256": "7e1f2e54255d7671daed439a06b114e34a3440a8f9dd03d367e24ed41dd91321", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342966.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342966.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a122c52ef27ac31a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "purple", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "purple", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blond", "blue", "brown", "green", "orange", "purple", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["purple"], "masked_program_sha256": "673c20ebba5fc47a1a7dec1bb99008e0b1dadb00be4e7f75cd4d47e4fb129339", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "purple", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "434bca27201704cfbeb438b0da32bdb48da17343cb69a0ac97aa1b63c8d0c071"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19817268", "text": "What is on the plate that looks purple?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "light brown", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "673c20ebba5fc47a1a7dec1bb99008e0b1dadb00be4e7f75cd4d47e4fb129339", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4799e0d1cdd1efa6753d385b7ec27ad2825b25dc57159cedab78e4d89b4c821f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19499386", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8012, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "838c6c898fcde171982424463bed1dd68e54eb6a4e746be36158f54c565c3d2a", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "19499386", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the plate that looks brown?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the plate that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "838c6c898fcde171982424463bed1dd68e54eb6a4e746be36158f54c565c3d2a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the plate that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "838c6c898fcde171982424463bed1dd68e54eb6a4e746be36158f54c565c3d2a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The pizza is on the plate.", "question": "What is on the plate that looks purple?", "question_id": "19817268", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (1180113)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "purple", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1180114)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The pizza is on the plate.", "question": "What is on the plate that looks brown?", "question_id": "19499386", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (2939111)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2196473)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1180105", "1180106", "1180108", "1180110", "1180112", "1180114", "1180116", "1180117", "1180118", "1180119", "1180121", "1180122", "1180123", "1180124", "1180125", "1180128"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1180114", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "1180113", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1180114", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1180113", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "purple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1180113"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "purple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2158327", "2196473", "2303740", "2401544", "2418074", "2516902", "2760080", "2817683", "3052207", "3073358", "3151582", "3185645", "3363197", "3475730", "3643504", "3643512"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["round"], "query_target_entity_id": "2196473", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "2939111", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2196473", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2939111", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2939111"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b2d8bf0e51d28dca78297f139f1276a8", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9e070bb5a31a09d46c2d51a32c6c843a74303bedf754adcc391c1d2ea9fed9ad", "image_sha256_b": "7e1f2e54255d7671daed439a06b114e34a3440a8f9dd03d367e24ed41dd91321", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0d53019e57d62395d0520e1b7a004ea329c52521bfd1fd73c4f211222e9317f6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d6018c9fd01d092b312f8614f0a5064f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1360c2899d7441567a4f5ee6fc58edc819e89cc514a428f99d3ace1488cc9c7d"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "768e49761efafd15626d5216e1061487b301a24a1756d5b11921f83118f9c6d9", "request_id": "e39d62f96a23faf5d860968e45a7d9dc", "response_sha256": "e441cb6769dd4519fb5ee9315fdebbca718f3991beb8b06d2c112928ee5a5400", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "401108a5f9f2f2daf21f562c52bb004162dd7c4b7495bcdf64c28bf777d69a46", "request_id": "55083453e353b32c12f3f5833ddcd89e", "response_sha256": "67d7fc5ffb83508be10252f84a69007e16c1b68cea04da09dc0d4aaa3f7e35b4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "d1fe61588199162a97492e36697f0b1c", "candidate_priority_rank": 8016, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-27a29da1a1f9880d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-27a29da1a1f9880d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-27a29da1a1f9880d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-27a29da1a1f9880d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->red", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "red"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->red", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2381908", "image_sha256": "8fccb0d4b261a8bd15c41ca6b3ca4cfa87272dddf30dc660dccab34767844183", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2381908.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2381908.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2373583", "image_sha256": "4f5753777658d96cfe6dff56c9a17f860be015947580785de65228d0b1961ab3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2373583.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2373583.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-27a29da1a1f9880d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "red", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "red"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "green", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "d2bad4d44d3b2665388b8585499b8269d6dd5666955b7d503ee4f02bd8646e8c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "185f7c1ddfb7059a6c2d2b5b46a36c3fbf044ddac2caf02c25369e7ee0b7c48e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "061044602", "text": "What is in the brown basket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "green", "red", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "d2bad4d44d3b2665388b8585499b8269d6dd5666955b7d503ee4f02bd8646e8c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f97e61e4d21ee245bc15582995a07dec8983ad4a5f4b2d0b5a93ef4c0dd12929"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10330351", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8016, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "01384b5c473638f180ddd2cc1ccb19aff335750a5bf907cd2e9ccf43a55e095d", "selected_component": "red", "selected_source_question_id": "10330351", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the red basket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "basket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the basket?", "program_group_hash": "01384b5c473638f180ddd2cc1ccb19aff335750a5bf907cd2e9ccf43a55e095d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "basket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "basket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the basket?", "program_group_hash": "01384b5c473638f180ddd2cc1ccb19aff335750a5bf907cd2e9ccf43a55e095d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "basket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "mango", "full_answer": "The mango is in the basket.", "question": "What is in the brown basket?", "question_id": "061044602", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (700891)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (700894)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chains", "full_answer": "The chains are in the basket.", "question": "What is in the red basket?", "question_id": "10330351", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (588477)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (588489)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["700893", "700894", "700895", "700897", "700898", "700899", "700900"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mango"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "700894", "query_target_entity_name": "mango", "relation_object_entity_id": "700891", "relation_subject_entity_id": "700894", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "700891", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["700891"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["588459", "588460", "588461", "588462", "588463", "588464", "588465", "588466", "588467", "588468", "588469", "588471", "588472", "588473", "588474", "588475", "588476", "588478", "588480", "588481", "588482", "588485", "588487", "588489", "588490", "588492", "588494", "588495"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 28, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chains"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "588489", "query_target_entity_name": "chains", "relation_object_entity_id": "588477", "relation_subject_entity_id": "588489", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "588477", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["588477"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:d1fe61588199162a97492e36697f0b1c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8fccb0d4b261a8bd15c41ca6b3ca4cfa87272dddf30dc660dccab34767844183", "image_sha256_b": "4f5753777658d96cfe6dff56c9a17f860be015947580785de65228d0b1961ab3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ca9e3bf8df5cfe21128d8bfc0223a4d68d856af02ccedf2e3dac7f84399c9397", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5996c68387bd2d9b7d4a94e81651754f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "bb9d75bb7a8aba98012110c6490e4daaed24f871fa6031f82ca283d16935f634"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "31fccb1bf30bfe9247e261911dc5922c68b88144adfb1ef260c5a93c23ab03de", "request_id": "f45575b9e7f0a4f80f72bdf16f26c072", "response_sha256": "a89db9e2a66dcd242d5c2237724155f873d59db89e296f59d70a86006a86c862", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cecb14f87edf3bf4b2493e957de6f652bf8cbb0363b49c7b9d543a6472d915c4", "request_id": "e8692cd66fe6dc04b35cd4c2536b0a59", "response_sha256": "6285bfde7f2d2a61627fefe93e9321ee1f0b3d5ab1969303165517f5cb1251df", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "ffa2c3d464e9c50ed9f34397d22bb334", "candidate_priority_rank": 8105, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-796b4eeaae3be277:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-796b4eeaae3be277:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-796b4eeaae3be277:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-796b4eeaae3be277:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 353, "image_id": "2408709", "image_sha256": "51ac896bef555bb5c09da8b23a918a005bf74f051ab8712ea5477beb4a53d77c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408709.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408709.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2342201", "image_sha256": "4b7987c1cf8c2cab7506a02a124573de1a2efc74da0b6a26f6e3c9a1413c0cc7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342201.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342201.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-796b4eeaae3be277", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "dark", "silver"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "d7b1a9cc714c458dd779a4238233bd22a98e66933f2d8f406f9812ed20f1172f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0a11de7e09392ce2b2be5154dc9473c27c4c0385b34632c190c4b8712c41678b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19407122", "text": "What is the brown bird standing on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "dark"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "d7b1a9cc714c458dd779a4238233bd22a98e66933f2d8f406f9812ed20f1172f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "12d3f37f40e3eff6a25b7547e811bf855c803fe0c5d437d592af609945279aee"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11478917", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8105, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "14933fd742c41af710a9d9c5bc3562e026e40960491c124b05f4eb54d1acaeaa", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "11478917", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the black bird standing on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird standing on?", "program_group_hash": "14933fd742c41af710a9d9c5bc3562e026e40960491c124b05f4eb54d1acaeaa", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "bird"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird standing on?", "program_group_hash": "14933fd742c41af710a9d9c5bc3562e026e40960491c124b05f4eb54d1acaeaa", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "bird"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "glove", "full_answer": "The bird is standing on the glove.", "question": "What is the brown bird standing on?", "question_id": "19407122", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (256457)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (256482)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "rock", "full_answer": "The bird is standing on the rock.", "question": "What is the black bird standing on?", "question_id": "11478917", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (2667943)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (2078449)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["256461", "256463", "256464", "256465", "256466", "256467", "256468", "256469", "256470", "256471", "256474", "256475", "256476", "256477", "256478", "256479", "256480", "256481", "256482", "256483"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["glove"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["huge", "leather"], "query_target_entity_id": "256482", "query_target_entity_name": "glove", "relation_object_entity_id": "256482", "relation_subject_entity_id": "256457", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "256457", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["256457"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2078449", "2257176", "2309593", "2636982", "3649661", "3649662", "3649673"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["rock"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["dark", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "2078449", "query_target_entity_name": "rock", "relation_object_entity_id": "2078449", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2667943", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2667943", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2667943"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:ffa2c3d464e9c50ed9f34397d22bb334", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "51ac896bef555bb5c09da8b23a918a005bf74f051ab8712ea5477beb4a53d77c", "image_sha256_b": "4b7987c1cf8c2cab7506a02a124573de1a2efc74da0b6a26f6e3c9a1413c0cc7", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "bb92b6e1ccd2fdf6b476fd630edef6caaca0651d2f014a00ca9d02941fe2bf02", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "071e4659f491d3871f995273196a690e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "df13803a487356cac5ebfdbfb3a4279f6d140b90424ffa1641fad44a0d180f4f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7ab6370b5fbfec258b2ab49e0dfe175e6a4ab1f3d50b4ed194ae274885b478e0", "request_id": "7df2a46f94fe1585cdf3ef30e01fe4fc", "response_sha256": "8ca098296c0e07e73fcfced815847d0d414b2584246fcc7c0cb96fc282757c63", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "82a5bc6c0640b7048d05ee2e89949a56ba360824eda076ed5c4138f3c2a814b9", "request_id": "7a78ab3ce449b8cb97357f45cf340ef7", "response_sha256": "0c20402b41505be64d189d437375370a426e966601c95cd44bed0b8e35240f64", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "da9ae4478ecdf000abeced64a76b542b", "candidate_priority_rank": 8309, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00734557b1b7a419:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00734557b1b7a419:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00734557b1b7a419:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00734557b1b7a419:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "red<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "red", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "red<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 683, "image_id": "1160136", "image_sha256": "7ec91236dd4f63c97cb16f6c36bf86a37e24b3148f955bd1502d70a80966aba8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/1160136.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/1160136.jpg", "width": 1024}, "B": {"height": 286, "image_id": "2382344", "image_sha256": "e7983afafc28b862507c14c0d7b99b01f6c8f04ca84de89276ff798e0f1673be", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382344.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382344.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00734557b1b7a419", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "red", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "red", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "517153e7cfd70729d177e9c1c825be56bbc4802f2c3d08293249f1401f0edf22"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01711858", "text": "What is on the red wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beige", "black", "gray", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bdf93fc8de8aef492cb262e887148f8867cea50bce76d56a29ba3e3d51d881f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0386835", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8309, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 36, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "0386835", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the white wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "painting", "full_answer": "The painting is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the red wall?", "question_id": "01711858", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1040057)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1040061)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "picture", "full_answer": "The picture is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the white wall?", "question_id": "0386835", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1329388)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1329387)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1040051", "1040052", "1040053", "1040054", "1040055", "1040058", "1040060", "1040061", "1040062", "1040067", "1040069", "1040070", "1040071", "1040072", "1040074", "1040076", "1040077", "3790382"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["painting"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["framed"], "query_target_entity_id": "1040061", "query_target_entity_name": "painting", "relation_object_entity_id": "1040057", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1040061", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1040057", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1040057"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1329384", "1329385", "1329386", "1329387", "1329389", "1329390", "1329391", "1329393", "1329394", "1329395", "1329396", "1329397", "1329398", "1329399", "1329400", "1329401"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["picture"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["colorful"], "query_target_entity_id": "1329387", "query_target_entity_name": "picture", "relation_object_entity_id": "1329388", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1329387", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1329388", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1329388"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:da9ae4478ecdf000abeced64a76b542b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7ec91236dd4f63c97cb16f6c36bf86a37e24b3148f955bd1502d70a80966aba8", "image_sha256_b": "e7983afafc28b862507c14c0d7b99b01f6c8f04ca84de89276ff798e0f1673be", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c94b73efd4bc9a2c768ee9483490db4db1a154ae9832eb9d2b728a7a93f0195f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "025e62fbd08b82986b9137f66bfde999", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ffb6977e8e7adef06b3ec3e438bbcbbe7838224d901b72f9eaaf0f9d62d08d90"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "00bfab0d924aeedc92735faa6d856beb90fe043c0c87a9c72e23d6769e808f06", "request_id": "c96939028b81f7c857a06ec562b58512", "response_sha256": "3f2c2a6f7f1c2152231ba421320972e8c5c7f49a262eecef956a156f92cd965f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cc849c43b91c2345c69e321e998988d8afdcffb448ae6c229f47191a4dedddfd", "request_id": "8c4c8886a9ff459de4fc86cd9009de00", "response_sha256": "3907ad5ad1b1fc821f0ba8cc5b22af4303d8fb43ce4c46bce151ed96ec92dfa4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "f176da7ff61fdb1645d9480cee5e75c2", "candidate_priority_rank": 8352, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b3c61ba4565227b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b3c61ba4565227b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b3c61ba4565227b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b3c61ba4565227b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "glass<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "glass", "B": "wood"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "glass<->wood", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2328810", "image_sha256": "ff8f4fbb370e7e068f06f619974b3953a340e8c42c850e63a23e6154b6da9a3e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2328810.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2328810.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2367927", "image_sha256": "0fcc58996fce6176a9391bda9537f5659d25b080c1a8a7d8074b0f1cc3111820", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367927.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367927.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b3c61ba4565227b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "glass", "diff_b": "wood", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "glass", "component_b": "wood"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["glass"], "detected_components": ["glass"], "masked_program_sha256": "42946fbb314ed2cf5b2588ccff4eb458aae7346b15eef86c13b4a35d2beda519", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "glass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bf3b6d0a3dc92f049426cc76d47f8ff54c11585c030c07650228a5378800af71"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09194550", "text": "What is on the glass table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "42946fbb314ed2cf5b2588ccff4eb458aae7346b15eef86c13b4a35d2beda519", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4623ec72f4a746497ab5312326cab864cb494496eca94234a5452ae1008da849"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08325031", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8352, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 34, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ce329daae8c0d867fc2956d17060b12142940fc7be236cb12db3e1a2a1869694", "selected_component": "wood", "selected_source_question_id": "08325031", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the wood table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "ce329daae8c0d867fc2956d17060b12142940fc7be236cb12db3e1a2a1869694", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "ce329daae8c0d867fc2956d17060b12142940fc7be236cb12db3e1a2a1869694", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pots", "full_answer": "The pots are on the table.", "question": "What is on the glass table?", "question_id": "09194550", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (3731663)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "glass", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (3330953)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "glass", "full_answer": "The glass is on the table.", "question": "What is on the wood table?", "question_id": "08325031", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (749375)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (749367)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2746655", "2749164", "2749165", "2789877", "2798248", "2833070", "2932991", "2961054", "2961056", "3078342", "3127011", "3127012", "3204468", "3204469", "3214123", "3214124", "3261277", "3307399", "3330953", "3411667", "3491288", "3731664"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pots"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3330953", "query_target_entity_name": "pots", "relation_object_entity_id": "3731663", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3330953", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3731663", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3731663"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["749354", "749356", "749357", "749358", "749359", "749360", "749362", "749364", "749365", "749366", "749367", "749368", "749369", "749370", "749374", "749376", "749377", "749378"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["glass"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "749367", "query_target_entity_name": "glass", "relation_object_entity_id": "749375", "relation_subject_entity_id": "749367", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "749375", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["749375"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:f176da7ff61fdb1645d9480cee5e75c2", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ff8f4fbb370e7e068f06f619974b3953a340e8c42c850e63a23e6154b6da9a3e", "image_sha256_b": "0fcc58996fce6176a9391bda9537f5659d25b080c1a8a7d8074b0f1cc3111820", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7cfdc9cca4e30e9dc03839cd12671243b0d9e8ce0fa90115642eb7a8fbfb68be", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3909dd7834df8809210bd92a0caa8927", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c23eb73fc8b21cfffeccd0e117404e5770d1eaa094f3871c94c1d4b90e2db2e3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bd8f8f2c34a0292360def8c0c2ccc059e6f50b7fa601f8a4bb52d97908144261", "request_id": "f293ec7038cce3bb7ebe1cf1fcf1817f", "response_sha256": "d58f4f6b9298d976004aa82e10bc40c341e628e8bb8bed452824d5da58883184", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1539ac04fcc4cecf31425a2d33045704a258d58b3333d91527d095e568cfbc4c", "request_id": "d28fc668652ad9ed952e32aa4a966053", "response_sha256": "d95a97383228386d2e892c8e1ac6950d107a1e6ce795a7480b6222c5cc3c3304", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "537a96274c7b24d8d6c28495dbf2f493", "candidate_priority_rank": 8368, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aa4995035a21adf3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aa4995035a21adf3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aa4995035a21adf3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aa4995035a21adf3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->yellow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "yellow", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "yellow<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2406018", "image_sha256": "59b2b89eadbc75678b8eac852332f4a21371d7a8b791b93ca5dc7844e3834ee6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2406018.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2406018.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2365388", "image_sha256": "16089a875c7d9b83d21e994f4e848e49bdb28633ed5a70b4f8fea3bf449898dc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365388.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365388.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aa4995035a21adf3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "yellow", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "yellow", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "tan", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["yellow"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yellow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "838cf1b2b924049eb95a0268bb9f8b363f910e936b923c3885cf0a37b1817109"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02563665", "text": "What is on the yellow wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b51b2a9689025e61c9f03a658ba1a1fa591dac00ae9036a8c8761d1ebfd601f6"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03315607", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8368, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 40, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "03315607", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the blue wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "shelf", "full_answer": "The shelf is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the yellow wall?", "question_id": "02563665", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (327039)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "yellow", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (327029)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "towel", "full_answer": "The towel is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the blue wall?", "question_id": "03315607", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (634605)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (634604)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["327015", "327017", "327019", "327022", "327024", "327025", "327026", "327027", "327028", "327029", "327031", "327032", "327034", "327036", "327038", "327046", "327051", "327052", "327055", "327061", "327062"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["shelf"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "327029", "query_target_entity_name": "shelf", "relation_object_entity_id": "327039", "relation_subject_entity_id": "327029", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "327039", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["327039"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["634598", "634599", "634600", "634601", "634603", "634604", "634606"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["towel"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["hanging"], "query_target_entity_id": "634604", "query_target_entity_name": "towel", "relation_object_entity_id": "634605", "relation_subject_entity_id": "634604", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "634605", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["634605"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:537a96274c7b24d8d6c28495dbf2f493", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "59b2b89eadbc75678b8eac852332f4a21371d7a8b791b93ca5dc7844e3834ee6", "image_sha256_b": "16089a875c7d9b83d21e994f4e848e49bdb28633ed5a70b4f8fea3bf449898dc", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5d756543e59ba443319b54f0dd09d8e377b721eff9a0ced4f97a15adc7860b8f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "842dce5824bfc132732d29d517919150", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9581bd1fa7a062aaa950b39c8614702286144410a560d18166be8b6f0c8562a8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "badce112f1dba66dc6e6aeadd4ad8eff201cf94d34261dc67fee7bd1b044cea4", "request_id": "c7a71be96bb44d0b4abf8d6cff337485", "response_sha256": "558822d592b8df201c08d0be7dcbb6d381e8f51bbe9cfe1205985e8aa8b39eb4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "953df17a376446db3f58a8a79d66dc469429d8c9fcf5b1aad72f4f19ef0a7f35", "request_id": "1f3a5d4281ad49c31d867a92685a22c8", "response_sha256": "c7850de6c7edc6e6a5eea5351ce66210d4190615b92d8ae3c464001298dfe47b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "190ddf0f9394292533e4eaf745e624f3", "candidate_priority_rank": 8469, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fbf46f8c98a16169:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fbf46f8c98a16169:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fbf46f8c98a16169:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fbf46f8c98a16169:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "green"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->green", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 313, "image_id": "2398768", "image_sha256": "ad20bf2159756765f881beeefb7a5b5d9136297bd45ea41dc7e08174847692d8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398768.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398768.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2320545", "image_sha256": "7ed7d9e8fa53a0dbd375c891dd5e49f585630955e3f35f5c7cf1d22cb7391b40", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2320545.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2320545.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fbf46f8c98a16169", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "green", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "green"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "orange"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "8d6781728c476073c969cb45e8f888df5ba0a05469452a4d84b91db972b63676", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7dad1ffb0905899334691de280ab06db4fed97b0a09a70919249065ed49415fe"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "121026940", "text": "What does the black bird sit on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "gray", "green", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "8d6781728c476073c969cb45e8f888df5ba0a05469452a4d84b91db972b63676", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "83f1e57c16d9ac3df4b21b3fc76f766e7faf394f4b98b2d530a266770077e87d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02770630", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8469, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "bf2b703f14bb109d6e52fa4a324a8e374c11b182e00ebdec3c93aa219a379200", "selected_component": "green", "selected_source_question_id": "02770630", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What does the green bird sit on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what does the bird sit on?", "program_group_hash": "bf2b703f14bb109d6e52fa4a324a8e374c11b182e00ebdec3c93aa219a379200", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "bird"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what does the bird sit on?", "program_group_hash": "bf2b703f14bb109d6e52fa4a324a8e374c11b182e00ebdec3c93aa219a379200", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "bird"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "post", "full_answer": "The bird sits on the post.", "question": "What does the black bird sit on?", "question_id": "121026940", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (1176141)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (1176142)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "trunk", "full_answer": "The bird sits on the trunk.", "question": "What does the green bird sit on?", "question_id": "02770630", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (4472658)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (4472652)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1176140", "1176142", "1176143", "1176146", "1176148", "1176154"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["post"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1176142", "query_target_entity_name": "post", "relation_object_entity_id": "1176142", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1176141", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1176141", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1176141"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4031893", "4031894", "4031895", "4031896", "4031992", "4231531", "4231552", "4231554", "4231561", "4231564", "4231571", "4231577", "4231583", "4231587", "4231589", "4472620", "4472630", "4472634", "4472635", "4472638", "4472639", "4472652", "4472657", "4472662", "4472664", "4492748"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 26, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trunk"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4472652", "query_target_entity_name": "trunk", "relation_object_entity_id": "4472652", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4472658", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4472658", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4472658"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:190ddf0f9394292533e4eaf745e624f3", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ad20bf2159756765f881beeefb7a5b5d9136297bd45ea41dc7e08174847692d8", "image_sha256_b": "7ed7d9e8fa53a0dbd375c891dd5e49f585630955e3f35f5c7cf1d22cb7391b40", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "aa991f8888c5afeee70978b86bee773f82ec1d50b7026cb2391443e954b14ca3", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8f68d9df37fcb4714ccd3363e85fc8c5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e4fe49d8b23ce411df72ee7a6692375da4f886b9531baeb197113e7899251e44"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2f32a23df870b9cca9dd3dd245779113f89454549fc4e645c337f814daad30d7", "request_id": "005d04d487ec4a50a7ee8e02dfce59db", "response_sha256": "b86f32183d5b9f536ce0f91c1cca6b51eb8f5cf954356aeb8fecb3e142004e4c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b19a1a140a462828cdd3909fab114979ee80e55cd532b2c8da923ea902734073", "request_id": "33cb2fb7e49035637a0539cd52d1c3f6", "response_sha256": "45c9afe3a6513fd88e41b10b773275daffa239b845984c64e90d63cd464b7ce6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "274863d5ddcb91d04b92f4f68921cc6c", "candidate_priority_rank": 8584, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-08a79d9d8421b7ad:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-08a79d9d8421b7ad:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-08a79d9d8421b7ad:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-08a79d9d8421b7ad:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "baseball<->tennis", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "baseball", "B": "tennis"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "baseball<->tennis", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2390991", "image_sha256": "e593a6cd492b31bdfbde1f544634836b2485e5f64f146aae8a6344fb9dba2c23", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390991.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390991.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2316558", "image_sha256": "2cd2bfc52bdcafcb12f99e072af1389aafd1f069a17938fa01ad9db5a1aea84b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2316558.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2316558.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-08a79d9d8421b7ad", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "baseball", "diff_b": "tennis", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "baseball", "component_b": "tennis"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["baseball"], "detected_components": ["baseball"], "masked_program_sha256": "b3f17fd88d5b787600026edab7ab16d2406b5423c97a377856b8486e612fad07", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["player"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "baseball", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["player"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7e79ada35f321b6247858172af502b98db8c72e3b7d0a6dcd1f4d60b134e9ed3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12421562", "text": "What is the baseball player holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["tennis"], "detected_components": ["tennis"], "masked_program_sha256": "b3f17fd88d5b787600026edab7ab16d2406b5423c97a377856b8486e612fad07", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["player"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tennis", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["player"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c67ca6c3e857c5b0f8cdfbd4a9ccdd6aa6e5443939aa4f44c233667f3a20c24e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08627620", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8584, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ab3f9d5ff89ac340744222fdc1f3576c3946c29cdd58ff4facf4028f05a63a6f", "selected_component": "tennis", "selected_source_question_id": "08627620", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the tennis player holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sport", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "player", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sport"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the player holding?", "program_group_hash": "ab3f9d5ff89ac340744222fdc1f3576c3946c29cdd58ff4facf4028f05a63a6f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "player"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sport", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "player", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sport"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the player holding?", "program_group_hash": "ab3f9d5ff89ac340744222fdc1f3576c3946c29cdd58ff4facf4028f05a63a6f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "player"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "baseball bat", "full_answer": "The player is holding the baseball bat.", "question": "What is the baseball player holding?", "question_id": "12421562", "semantic": [{"argument": "player (1245144)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baseball", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sport"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (1245146)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "racket", "full_answer": "The player is holding the tennis racket.", "question": "What is the tennis player holding?", "question_id": "08627620", "semantic": [{"argument": "player (1053072)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "tennis", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sport"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (1053074)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1245145", "1245146", "1245148", "1245151", "1245152", "1245153", "1245154", "1245155", "1245157", "1245158", "1245159", "1245160", "1245161", "1245162", "1245163", "1245165"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["baseball bat"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1245146", "query_target_entity_name": "baseball bat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1245146", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1245144", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1245144", "selected_entity_name": "player"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "baseball", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1245144"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tennis", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "baseball", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1053073", "1053074", "1053075", "1053076", "1053077", "1053079", "1053080", "1053082", "1053083", "1053084", "1053086"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["racket"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1053074", "query_target_entity_name": "racket", "relation_object_entity_id": "1053074", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1053072", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1053072", "selected_entity_name": "player"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tennis", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1053072"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:274863d5ddcb91d04b92f4f68921cc6c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e593a6cd492b31bdfbde1f544634836b2485e5f64f146aae8a6344fb9dba2c23", "image_sha256_b": "2cd2bfc52bdcafcb12f99e072af1389aafd1f069a17938fa01ad9db5a1aea84b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "2adb2e3087fa8dc0d3ce57b89b66a4f306c6504ea45ad02b18ec3bf42c358522", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "faf33a6d89fb3b5e9936d966f4d770b2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "21fd2017bdd08972f864591ff9d9b963d5a667809932e3c824195ee0916d616e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e62f7827c5f780a23bd8746023492ff8d0f6a721997dc346e5e25c624970f842", "request_id": "3008a70e8af44ff7d7b7845e5ac3d0d4", "response_sha256": "32d6943075b8733b9bb06f16e2659ff3b3b96a22a285fb526ece7425d11b3124", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1dd27f38ea71a528abf940f0be634615604195d91f5da22f33bb631ae894ee82", "request_id": "f4a5c407223cd4553f7751a5573816dc", "response_sha256": "27e2a5ffb42c2cc2a6e7a23758f9e0177d4db1e7cac00a4bc0c6e76691444d19", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "0faf71e31d5de82e0e09b92ba687d5ba", "candidate_priority_rank": 8626, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d58f13c70fdcd193:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d58f13c70fdcd193:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d58f13c70fdcd193:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d58f13c70fdcd193:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "gold<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gold", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gold<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 230, "image_id": "2321443", "image_sha256": "876c5e44cc7a922316f3ba01c60b767b2b290f58c20288edd7f917623e1eba7b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2321443.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2321443.jpg", "width": 343}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2392337", "image_sha256": "4565eea9ee22fc4a03888917b8ef8588b6c363b4d46dbc7421c4561abfeb7e93", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392337.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392337.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d58f13c70fdcd193", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gold", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gold", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "gold", "gray", "green", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["gold"], "masked_program_sha256": "a3653cb1a029bcb9c99c6db419aa3fe84e0a775eed4b6f815a097b757ea08cdb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gold", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e4789aee69a81f83ec89fcb80fa1cad4d41ca7561ed1cd9a47d6024bb0effddd"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01388297", "text": "What is hanging on the gold wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "dark brown", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "a3653cb1a029bcb9c99c6db419aa3fe84e0a775eed4b6f815a097b757ea08cdb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6b74698daf71c4b5124ac37c24706d94497c0300f38d310c996526b47f898cb9"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18332001", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8626, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "48c44fdf983249048795808e3b2c60cc579826db48de57cd94d134ba3f78a81f", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "18332001", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is hanging on the white wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is hanging on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "48c44fdf983249048795808e3b2c60cc579826db48de57cd94d134ba3f78a81f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is hanging on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "48c44fdf983249048795808e3b2c60cc579826db48de57cd94d134ba3f78a81f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "frame", "full_answer": "The frame is hanging on the wall.", "question": "What is hanging on the gold wall?", "question_id": "01388297", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (3364349)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gold", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s (3130790)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hose", "full_answer": "The water hose is hanging on the wall.", "question": "What is hanging on the white wall?", "question_id": "18332001", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1231292)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s (1231288)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2751247", "2765237", "2778637", "2819281", "2819282", "2913000", "2957603", "2983476", "3026920", "3093136", "3093137", "3130790", "3160312", "3197224", "3201473", "3277656", "3314894", "3364350", "3364351", "3364353", "3370259", "3397314", "3402749", "3402750", "3476098", "3476099", "3516413", "3586947", "3586948", "3591326"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 30, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["frame"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3130790", "query_target_entity_name": "frame", "relation_object_entity_id": "3364349", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3130790", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3364349", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gold", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3364349"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gold", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1231286", "1231287", "1231288", "1231293", "1231295", "1231296", "1231300", "1231303"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hose"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["long", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1231288", "query_target_entity_name": "hose", "relation_object_entity_id": "1231292", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1231288", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1231292", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1231292"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:0faf71e31d5de82e0e09b92ba687d5ba", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "876c5e44cc7a922316f3ba01c60b767b2b290f58c20288edd7f917623e1eba7b", "image_sha256_b": "4565eea9ee22fc4a03888917b8ef8588b6c363b4d46dbc7421c4561abfeb7e93", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "355c9b2c3821df9ab1dbe88242f882fc717cddd940656ab8849f34dab03cf304", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2bc31dda8524bb9ca4aef0cb64257516", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a49411e28f72471b315d272f8a4c10c021ac500617a3903250453c8bec8985b4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7d43323c18e1590d65b805fdb94d599586e49d47504d5511897793d2ced9c8ec", "request_id": "46bfd755062b11e9a8781a4413f2ff82", "response_sha256": "4585653c6b0aa9065cdef64ce06fd13326b50203befabb296cf62d1e4356bc06", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ea8cf1c74744e2271cfd2930673870eb255656cb6b385ee2acbd21369fe58d5e", "request_id": "0256fb90d50a9c7ee1c00f2dc5352cab", "response_sha256": "72041a4f1b54d5f6952f3605ade34628175944f7715216074989b24da4381528", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "b7ca97366cdbe83ce5bbf0440cdccbbe", "candidate_priority_rank": 8650, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7842178c6ea02d8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7842178c6ea02d8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7842178c6ea02d8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7842178c6ea02d8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 351, "image_id": "2402810", "image_sha256": "b2e4ff4129efb6ab8a6ba23db0d9bbf5636e91509d92d0752363a859312f390d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402810.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402810.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 315, "image_id": "2410936", "image_sha256": "c3563103fb320a903e587f68d4278354df2419b9008cc295ab834085aedc61f7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410936.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410936.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7842178c6ea02d8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray", "purple", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "f68c9a6f1ceddd8016443e94d17f23ee334aa9224c5b77326cb882d32c9b9633", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "983722f021e575aaff4e57107ebd1cd90b67e97a327d538a408c5134a5acdb39"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12544998", "text": "What is underneath the brown cat?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "pink", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "f68c9a6f1ceddd8016443e94d17f23ee334aa9224c5b77326cb882d32c9b9633", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f332a87279337b7e933d2b4fe9bed5aa5bc2dcebcfa9b0540a413c3d90fff75e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13151446", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8650, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0ff9cfe70dc9b3e599d49c107a769996a20fcc102b21783fa19989ee3c37891e", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "13151446", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is underneath the black cat?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "cat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is underneath the cat?", "program_group_hash": "0ff9cfe70dc9b3e599d49c107a769996a20fcc102b21783fa19989ee3c37891e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "underneath", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "cat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is underneath the cat?", "program_group_hash": "0ff9cfe70dc9b3e599d49c107a769996a20fcc102b21783fa19989ee3c37891e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "underneath", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pen", "full_answer": "The pen is underneath the cat.", "question": "What is underneath the brown cat?", "question_id": "12544998", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (1131435)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s (1131438)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The chair is underneath the cat.", "question": "What is underneath the black cat?", "question_id": "13151446", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (318691)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s (318701)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1131436", "1131437", "1131438", "1131439", "1131442", "1131443", "1131444", "1131446", "1131447", "1131448", "1131449", "1131453", "1131456"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pen"], "predicate": "underneath", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "1131438", "query_target_entity_name": "pen", "relation_object_entity_id": "1131435", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1131438", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1131435", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1131435"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["318686", "318687", "318688", "318689", "318690", "318692", "318693", "318696", "318697", "318698", "318701", "318702", "318704", "318705", "318706", "318707", "318708", "318710", "318712"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "underneath", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "318701", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "318691", "relation_subject_entity_id": "318701", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "318691", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["318691"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b7ca97366cdbe83ce5bbf0440cdccbbe", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b2e4ff4129efb6ab8a6ba23db0d9bbf5636e91509d92d0752363a859312f390d", "image_sha256_b": "c3563103fb320a903e587f68d4278354df2419b9008cc295ab834085aedc61f7", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "97861c366ee33b83b1f4f38beb5713747f7f872e942b795109e55cfe72c72c69", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "db15cc7e07b74d9d02d3ab57015883e2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0008c58d52f08a4313da66f4504ce5c04e0c3aebcc97691e5db4135b97870dd7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7f7b02f749d09a280fe88081ff59a09ddf0936c7c2ae40431815d33f7e3455c1", "request_id": "79d38bfb2c6469a19f373c22f72e9791", "response_sha256": "ed25c9d77cd6d696d818062a92c2180a26a7efbb262c41dace2908771c9cf365", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e67c75760e04f11bc722a3c319e6fcf8cc04b20dbd7ba3088479ab99ebd3d34a", "request_id": "ebda60b65da4a63ba1cdcd8f894a6aad", "response_sha256": "692fb0b45f54254e3cc534a20093d728339e9eba487844c8a33f71f68fdcbea3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "d53c7731f2a01c4083bc7092f52f9c29", "candidate_priority_rank": 8726, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-55c9f86965fa7033:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-55c9f86965fa7033:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-55c9f86965fa7033:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-55c9f86965fa7033:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "rock<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "wood", "B": "rock"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wood<->rock", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2322438", "image_sha256": "1700e31bba711d979a45991afd6b5810e132329d139a01a892f1b2d67e92c039", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2322438.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2322438.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 384, "image_id": "2317209", "image_sha256": "f2acbfcbe34cccc8dce4d1cf78151ca8a95959cd62f07a68c30e496ac415a9e1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317209.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317209.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-55c9f86965fa7033", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wood", "diff_b": "rock", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wood", "component_b": "rock"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "3380d654d8d649bff9a7f1e3f52414ad45b4da0a41b2189867cd6b8a936b5d44", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b840b83dc813939066112b79b9b020438237873415f0054794311b523215e66e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12977439", "text": "What is in front of the wood wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal", "rock"], "detected_components": ["rock"], "masked_program_sha256": "3380d654d8d649bff9a7f1e3f52414ad45b4da0a41b2189867cd6b8a936b5d44", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "rock", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4c3739b32effb2f050ae5bb88b9f6c3c5de331a6479d774733c8f27b355ec55e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05417042", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8726, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "df14529b800911ac3dea0026a482e0a0bdb6d4b0eae06db989c90a6086a69b9e", "selected_component": "rock", "selected_source_question_id": "05417042", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the rock wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "df14529b800911ac3dea0026a482e0a0bdb6d4b0eae06db989c90a6086a69b9e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "df14529b800911ac3dea0026a482e0a0bdb6d4b0eae06db989c90a6086a69b9e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The bed is in front of the wall.", "question": "What is in front of the wood wall?", "question_id": "12977439", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (991912)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (991904)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "fire hydrant", "full_answer": "The fire hydrant is in front of the wall.", "question": "What is in front of the rock wall?", "question_id": "05417042", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1022711)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "rock", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (1022715)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["991898", "991899", "991900", "991901", "991902", "991903", "991904", "991905", "991906", "991907", "991908", "991909", "991913", "991914", "991915"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large"], "query_target_entity_id": "991904", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "991912", "relation_subject_entity_id": "991904", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "991912", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["991912"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "rock", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1022710", "1022713", "1022714", "1022715", "1022716", "1022717", "1022718", "1022719", "1022720", "1022722", "1022723", "1022724", "1022726", "1022727", "1022728"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fire hydrant"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["old", "outdoors", "red"], "query_target_entity_id": "1022715", "query_target_entity_name": "fire hydrant", "relation_object_entity_id": "1022711", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1022715", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1022711", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "rock", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1022711"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:d53c7731f2a01c4083bc7092f52f9c29", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1700e31bba711d979a45991afd6b5810e132329d139a01a892f1b2d67e92c039", "image_sha256_b": "f2acbfcbe34cccc8dce4d1cf78151ca8a95959cd62f07a68c30e496ac415a9e1", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "9621075de2a6256c928d93142a3bf047ef122b0ba0be381650200e4eef882abe", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ad5364c29ce6cd04b06a7890cbd5cd0e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ca83af9571133d8c4f13c3bfaf82311dab4ba873bc9aeadf908038fd53206abd"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8084d1921c5ed9319eac13e31c1add831b0feff3f2dccec554d4cab6bc274f8c", "request_id": "eb08abc57ee41c67986fb44bee1a180e", "response_sha256": "61a2790fa13e2a5ccabb445aba715c7d304d90d26c42ad4de994dd68ae317084", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3586f087dbddd40757b2dab9d99fd180633712955173f9eb0767f4538d22f863", "request_id": "77ad30d1d490ab08bc7102eac11f9205", "response_sha256": "8ba6a439e74a11fe6d57c56d140f6c95078e30c0a9e2f71d6467f44dcd5f2c7b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "057308053476cd68c3c61330758e3fbe", "candidate_priority_rank": 8732, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-03025798e3bfe0c9:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-03025798e3bfe0c9:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-03025798e3bfe0c9:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-03025798e3bfe0c9:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "skiing<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "surfing", "B": "skiing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "surfing<->skiing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2412009", "image_sha256": "b2e79b7a8169479b34828d01d901472a362571250c8a9e99d5dad95a03463cbf", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412009.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412009.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2397945", "image_sha256": "7dc58d75c3b9b62bb42403caefa1f8a0803783e1bc1033e78808683e93157914", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397945.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397945.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-03025798e3bfe0c9", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "surfing", "diff_b": "skiing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "surfing", "component_b": "skiing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e60cb519061f9a7757db8551ae37f1c8e776ec4ce8929871b7d33b1bf739a866"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02806288", "text": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["skiing"], "detected_components": ["skiing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "skiing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b1b7723f85271e4c736be74c6accbbe92c5aa9ae0b19f0f01bbcc9b1872fbb6d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08182416", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8732, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 36, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "selected_component": "skiing", "selected_source_question_id": "08182416", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is skiing wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1486f740c85be38190ae5df6d6c68e864a8ff67fd028789f644eb8d29dfe12c3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "trunks", "full_answer": "The guy is wearing trunks.", "question": "What is the person that is surfing wearing?", "question_id": "02806288", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (204826)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (204838)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pants", "full_answer": "The person is wearing pants.", "question": "What is the person that is skiing wearing?", "question_id": "08182416", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (429402)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "skiing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (429405)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["204830", "204833", "204838", "204840", "204846"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trunks"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "204838", "query_target_entity_name": "trunks", "relation_object_entity_id": "204838", "relation_subject_entity_id": "204826", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "204826", "selected_entity_name": "guy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["204826"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["429404", "429405", "429408", "429409", "429410", "429411", "429415", "429420", "429424", "429426", "429428"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pants"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "429405", "query_target_entity_name": "pants", "relation_object_entity_id": "429405", "relation_subject_entity_id": "429402", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "429402", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["429402"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:057308053476cd68c3c61330758e3fbe", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b2e79b7a8169479b34828d01d901472a362571250c8a9e99d5dad95a03463cbf", "image_sha256_b": "7dc58d75c3b9b62bb42403caefa1f8a0803783e1bc1033e78808683e93157914", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "647498f396d424d5cf5110a9a86ee3f5d0fcb97ca599afddeb8d72121e91ea38", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c7fca102002948c0443ed79c424e7841", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ed71df55a575da4369f31e0d49e32cc6ffdcddb05ffc36667b4a55f49af971e7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "66951f46ec6bd937cde3e81f2a6abb3ddc1ad732de04a2926611a2f7c0701402", "request_id": "80d3a85ae7ddbfe0aac94962d8ff3dd9", "response_sha256": "8de5eb87c424272d11d2d2653dd72e1eb5af387035295ae4947bcb9c619a7c79", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "98ac3be56f6c7d75958a4ccb5836d81fbf8a7f5569cd8f51b5ef26724e5cba78", "request_id": "d8f2f57541fbfde5fff4870ce81e75d3", "response_sha256": "2d4a90f29a55da00dd5b123d736cfb6911432356ec3fefe801c73d8fff668951", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "3d64b463f9dce3416a1fae123d375be5", "candidate_priority_rank": 8776, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0297b96a90c7a16e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0297b96a90c7a16e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0297b96a90c7a16e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0297b96a90c7a16e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2355019", "image_sha256": "1b8e108ede5522bab039ef38de65d37700e06b15540e8ea881491d06f59fd1d0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2355019.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2355019.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2316174", "image_sha256": "1cc798e8fa0e894049795288146dce2a6369968e3ac69ec2e14cf921f9ad57d7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2316174.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2316174.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0297b96a90c7a16e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "gray", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "8cc09a7a0f8b8945960ff8df9b1b8d00a83f305471f2f7823422390eb1a0c4ab", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a74632786b87ee23249495c333f9df812fabd4a402d6f55d8bf131b1be16ac90"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01854975", "text": "What is in the brown boat?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "orange", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "8cc09a7a0f8b8945960ff8df9b1b8d00a83f305471f2f7823422390eb1a0c4ab", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "db59a72942c7aedae1acfcbb2413dc01b61d4193a646924faefde0df440026cb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09437006", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8776, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e2deefd457d12e6dcf8d879a4e89c235a62559c7d5638d17018192efac113c0d", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "09437006", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the black boat?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "boat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the boat?", "program_group_hash": "e2deefd457d12e6dcf8d879a4e89c235a62559c7d5638d17018192efac113c0d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "boat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "boat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the boat?", "program_group_hash": "e2deefd457d12e6dcf8d879a4e89c235a62559c7d5638d17018192efac113c0d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "boat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bananas", "full_answer": "The bananas are in the boat.", "question": "What is in the brown boat?", "question_id": "01854975", "semantic": [{"argument": "boat (833571)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (833570)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cooler", "full_answer": "The cooler is in the boat.", "question": "What is in the black boat?", "question_id": "09437006", "semantic": [{"argument": "boat (2915163)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (3632526)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["833570", "833573", "833574", "833575", "833576", "833577", "833578", "833579", "833581", "833582", "833583", "833584"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bananas"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["bunched", "yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "833570", "query_target_entity_name": "bananas", "relation_object_entity_id": "833571", "relation_subject_entity_id": "833570", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "833571", "selected_entity_name": "boat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["833571"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2731833", "2731834", "2790123", "2975774", "3056594", "3056595", "3118620", "3153525", "3222901", "3314076", "3350176", "3384922", "3457943", "3479997", "3528585", "3632526", "3632544", "3632545", "3632546", "3632555", "3963035", "3963037"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cooler"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "3632526", "query_target_entity_name": "cooler", "relation_object_entity_id": "2915163", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3632526", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2915163", "selected_entity_name": "boat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2915163"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:3d64b463f9dce3416a1fae123d375be5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1b8e108ede5522bab039ef38de65d37700e06b15540e8ea881491d06f59fd1d0", "image_sha256_b": "1cc798e8fa0e894049795288146dce2a6369968e3ac69ec2e14cf921f9ad57d7", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "acb8421f22f20d180bbb7e18685876f37b4e617ac79df7793835ca70186f200f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0243a36ca4a0ca8996bc65464a35f9ea", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "40d4a195b86dfd4515b4b1a828713f985425380ecb67fb1bde5cf9267123b2dd"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4136648e9bd1faebdde9f8f2cdb054987f67fabfc15512c2b2b7201ed8436a1c", "request_id": "0f36b5dbc54c3ac8b9f4fd8c2122d9ed", "response_sha256": "3cc9c683a3b63801567e6bea6c7c58b53d2bcde4d561a4feb5b61aa1145b17d4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3d2ef1f20590461e29a1b1e45c03c2a7b98b8b4736e711085e0fdf5cdbf70c9f", "request_id": "bbfc71cb8df7549befebcb1d787fd5df", "response_sha256": "86e6826f16ff5ce324a1b8af6af6f32ee697430c851061e65c97b69cc8205bbe", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "7f5710fceccf8112828823d4bd7f8cde", "candidate_priority_rank": 8800, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3e850d25d1f6c375:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3e850d25d1f6c375:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3e850d25d1f6c375:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3e850d25d1f6c375:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "round<->square", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "round", "B": "square"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "round<->square", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 612, "image_id": "61562", "image_sha256": "ebf46cdfa5ab0eb1f3a69d9b96eea55d959b35a05a5279aa79109bb5d51cad28", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/61562.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/61562.jpg", "width": 1024}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2318494", "image_sha256": "5e275d9f73bee6e0c40c919fd056da3a6f33889fd9a1a83ecacfe823fb2b2ea6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2318494.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2318494.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3e850d25d1f6c375", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "round", "diff_b": "square", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "round", "component_b": "square"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["round"], "detected_components": ["round"], "masked_program_sha256": "7ae3f1fe4f79c81afd265f8c3903cbac456342a60add9232b33f1aa599d1d415", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "round", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5a0cb15a524e1be894900120156d8b86d2a58f10366df51a5960911da3211125"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16820039", "text": "What is sitting on the round table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["rectangular", "round", "square"], "detected_components": ["square"], "masked_program_sha256": "7ae3f1fe4f79c81afd265f8c3903cbac456342a60add9232b33f1aa599d1d415", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "square", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1ca2a5e5b0dfe93bd20bfda550e7dc5526d0d60ac3e3064ebb36f9aa1109cf59"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00157280", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8800, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f61497bad98bd822f0f3e76bc9fdc813f4e960894b75ab7921d9e4bb35bed098", "selected_component": "square", "selected_source_question_id": "00157280", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is sitting on the square table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "shape", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is sitting on the table?", "program_group_hash": "f61497bad98bd822f0f3e76bc9fdc813f4e960894b75ab7921d9e4bb35bed098", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "shape", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is sitting on the table?", "program_group_hash": "f61497bad98bd822f0f3e76bc9fdc813f4e960894b75ab7921d9e4bb35bed098", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "book", "full_answer": "The book is sitting on the table.", "question": "What is sitting on the round table?", "question_id": "16820039", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (1073171)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "round", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,s (1073177)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "lamp", "full_answer": "The lamp is sitting on the table.", "question": "What is sitting on the square table?", "question_id": "00157280", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (1010125)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "square", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,s (1010133)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1073166", "1073167", "1073168", "1073169", "1073172", "1073173", "1073174", "1073175", "1073176", "1073177", "1073178", "1073179", "1073182", "1073183"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["book"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1073177", "query_target_entity_name": "book", "relation_object_entity_id": "1073171", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1073177", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1073171", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "round", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1073171"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "square", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1010115", "1010116", "1010117", "1010118", "1010119", "1010121", "1010122", "1010124", "1010125", "1010126", "1010127", "1010129", "1010130", "1010131", "1010132", "1010133", "1010134", "1010135", "1010136", "1010137", "1010138", "1010139", "1010140", "1010141", "1010142"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 25, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "round", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1010128"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1010115", "1010116", "1010117", "1010118", "1010119", "1010121", "1010122", "1010124", "1010126", "1010127", "1010128", "1010129", "1010130", "1010131", "1010132", "1010133", "1010134", "1010135", "1010136", "1010137", "1010138", "1010139", "1010140", "1010141", "1010142"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 25, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["lamp"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["bronze", "gold"], "query_target_entity_id": "1010133", "query_target_entity_name": "lamp", "relation_object_entity_id": "1010125", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1010133", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1010125", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "square", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1010125"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:7f5710fceccf8112828823d4bd7f8cde", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ebf46cdfa5ab0eb1f3a69d9b96eea55d959b35a05a5279aa79109bb5d51cad28", "image_sha256_b": "5e275d9f73bee6e0c40c919fd056da3a6f33889fd9a1a83ecacfe823fb2b2ea6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "837e7180dc3bfd848616e013db01bfe0f9fe10a4e3daa236c688de091c2af4d2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3e8cda7900a7accb8399a4c8f4c7f6c3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1fec07840c99a44bc7972a16724f92c57923b0d7650d2f467174257faf7a6df9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "388d4235e196b71502d26624ebdb13a954f55e6292e210ea8652fa2ecb928b89", "request_id": "afa914801a53170b11ccb517d02dbca8", "response_sha256": "7f9997413e920297faea0217308925512936ee40cf57f85ff858e33388c43bdf", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "767fcd514418827cee17d0ad6118db5b8645d48643c9358e92a96bd3e68594f2", "request_id": "ff7de231716e28e9911fcb98f50d8fde", "response_sha256": "6a003b6cd6020d83aac1a6abb12b31b9554a1f6928e4a920defee07e78fde245", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "87f9ecb01421b61f74dd01d20c319ee5", "candidate_priority_rank": 8812, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5a1bcf846c90236c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5a1bcf846c90236c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5a1bcf846c90236c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5a1bcf846c90236c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2412258", "image_sha256": "3a344d37c248aa1619c4dc3c81a24d32a2136d16f556dc8ad79617cac71bb71a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412258.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412258.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 440, "image_id": "2357310", "image_sha256": "f4e0d1e9cbcfa9cffd7344c8ef41ab74c2c38c07d46c4777fd8ece64899d2c3f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2357310.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2357310.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5a1bcf846c90236c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "orange", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "e73974fbbb1e95347b10ac44e012fd3e618f10f3533121a1296e672eaef142ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d69d0f7d705277de745561dec08977e46f90ec746aa9b1d7342440857e3b3e00"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16350215", "text": "What is on the black table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "dark", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "e73974fbbb1e95347b10ac44e012fd3e618f10f3533121a1296e672eaef142ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "68b6270601dd4e47977535e1aaf60b3e29dcbe2a8536b6ccb5cb95b11efa6bb3"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08968713", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8812, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 32, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e9930c4e445b6f97ba358331196fc75b70857cebf6e3179882feefaa6f5341f5", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "08968713", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the white table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "e9930c4e445b6f97ba358331196fc75b70857cebf6e3179882feefaa6f5341f5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "e9930c4e445b6f97ba358331196fc75b70857cebf6e3179882feefaa6f5341f5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "rubber duck", "full_answer": "The rubber duck is on the table.", "question": "What is on the black table?", "question_id": "16350215", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (199066)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (199053)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "laptop", "full_answer": "The laptop computer is on the table.", "question": "What is on the white table?", "question_id": "08968713", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (3555006)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2257315)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["199039", "199042", "199043", "199044", "199045", "199046", "199047", "199048", "199049", "199050", "199051", "199052", "199053", "199054", "199055", "199056", "199058", "199059", "199062", "199063", "199064", "199065", "199067", "199068", "199069", "199070"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 26, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["rubber duck"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["little", "plastic", "yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "199053", "query_target_entity_name": "rubber duck", "relation_object_entity_id": "199066", "relation_subject_entity_id": "199053", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "199066", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["199066"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1798601", "1806125", "1806126", "1846069", "2019758", "2084619", "2200298", "2257315", "2269638", "2379080", "2471827", "2501483", "2501487", "2501488", "2589487", "2668067", "2699546", "3555000"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["laptop"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2257315", "query_target_entity_name": "laptop", "relation_object_entity_id": "3555006", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2257315", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3555006", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3555006"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:87f9ecb01421b61f74dd01d20c319ee5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3a344d37c248aa1619c4dc3c81a24d32a2136d16f556dc8ad79617cac71bb71a", "image_sha256_b": "f4e0d1e9cbcfa9cffd7344c8ef41ab74c2c38c07d46c4777fd8ece64899d2c3f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "6f18e83613e90673b929b3e37df60428fb537514dca851dce67a80ef05e7f5f8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0eacb26b0b4f8563a2d03cbb6a168b16", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "39f38c0af89ac59f4961f7ca5911341ae072953a3a9b0438e31acc4e9a17d356"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2d486ac7a0c50aeac268bd82c3cc9108bd0e2fa4c66fee2d6a87e0c7388455c2", "request_id": "1050e69ddbe05a53b0778990aefb9567", "response_sha256": "1908c634d907db6ca4a5096e27246f8516408c40ed885eb0f978f5deb0ec589a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e33fe2fa2970ea1fba2110a3f5dae2fb4c5c8bfb80a9fe05055ba3bc8718c516", "request_id": "6b4104555dc7f488e2a16344c1a1aa45", "response_sha256": "b7d002c66087679d9c880f76a1bf695e0268a7fc6115784f059947422d4537e0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "9767a861cd73fd7e1bd2d4a82814f402", "candidate_priority_rank": 8825, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f008977e602bb952:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f008977e602bb952:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f008977e602bb952:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f008977e602bb952:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "standing<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "walking", "B": "standing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "walking<->standing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2414438", "image_sha256": "35c402374bd3f9dcb70fdfa5a895a75e628888c2b4f804907d35a49c69f245e6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2414438.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2414438.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2392556", "image_sha256": "bd52e0f42210b013eddaedfdb2f77495e23ce0e223f3b2064237c75126f9a18f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392556.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392556.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f008977e602bb952", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "walking", "diff_b": "standing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "walking", "component_b": "standing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2bf1c30a22a7f5dcded4e434fbc083ba3c8d0eb4cddab68a2635546cc49940bc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10729957", "text": "What is the person that is walking holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "96086a768acf017a0d95aedaedb87e98cd8beee03f0c32ca3a33b0cd2136d91b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07810144", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 8825, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 36, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "selected_component": "standing", "selected_source_question_id": "07810144", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is standing holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "umbrella", "full_answer": "The man is holding the umbrella.", "question": "What is the person that is walking holding?", "question_id": "10729957", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (295300)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (295301)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "skateboard", "full_answer": "The man is holding the skateboard.", "question": "What is the person that is standing holding?", "question_id": "07810144", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (479076)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (479095)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["295297", "295298", "295299", "295301", "295302", "295304", "295305", "295306", "295310", "295311", "295312", "295316", "295319", "295321", "295322"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["umbrella"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["dark", "open"], "query_target_entity_id": "295301", "query_target_entity_name": "umbrella", "relation_object_entity_id": "295301", "relation_subject_entity_id": "295300", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "295300", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["295300"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["479077", "479078", "479079", "479080", "479084", "479085", "479086", "479090", "479093", "479094", "479095", "479097", "479098"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["skateboard"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "479095", "query_target_entity_name": "skateboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "479095", "relation_subject_entity_id": "479076", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "479076", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["479076"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:9767a861cd73fd7e1bd2d4a82814f402", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "35c402374bd3f9dcb70fdfa5a895a75e628888c2b4f804907d35a49c69f245e6", "image_sha256_b": "bd52e0f42210b013eddaedfdb2f77495e23ce0e223f3b2064237c75126f9a18f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "678634e335af39acb53c052b7d9340e43c2b179ac1c3bf1c2ec0721ad1c890d9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9210bfa369760a9c74b77519f743ba10", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "13501b3220dc4f88cdce0f2a53343ef76550a580940fcf761d1b13c6d7d0478f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "94353d3080fc8b8044a035651389c8c290a9f114432f872820bc6049680a9933", "request_id": "aa9ab23b5edaf9e556f15ced9f73fda2", "response_sha256": "14a1456e50db730ecd7c375d72d267ab66f4e3e377cb7fd1ba0fdec0d92c871f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1975bc0709edd1214c47991e8d370055b8ee25c9726e233649da8a86397cb54c", "request_id": "fed44e9676c7fdb4fe33b3ed70720ca6", "response_sha256": "08aea5d2a32953ca2e01b4d2e1318a0b0ef58d648d1cf2d25aef608319877490", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "c87e326eb4788b2c4f9b93f37b320b95", "candidate_priority_rank": 9168, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e144cdc9e2d2253:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e144cdc9e2d2253:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e144cdc9e2d2253:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e144cdc9e2d2253:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "running<->standing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "running", "B": "standing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "running<->standing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2376305", "image_sha256": "6fcf48a88808f17b5ad733e907a26e9c550aa496fd1b21725536b33b4e82cae2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376305.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376305.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2413388", "image_sha256": "75e5845b53e950fd74e19766cf2f7c6f077fc48698c39a8fd29f16cef88a8d6b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2413388.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2413388.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6e144cdc9e2d2253", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "running", "diff_b": "standing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "running", "component_b": "standing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["running"], "detected_components": ["running"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "running", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ebfa35cd00683fa16f537cbc0e37f0615ab8508a04a3ec615bc23be0ad1a1e45"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10125827", "text": "What is the person that is running holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "b0053646b24209446e2218e8bf580726262b595dbf7e367eef66da7344022feb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "96086a768acf017a0d95aedaedb87e98cd8beee03f0c32ca3a33b0cd2136d91b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0910286", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9168, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 13, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "selected_component": "standing", "selected_source_question_id": "0910286", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is standing holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "a922fadb843d9b9f7468034080465e851ba6e5c53d5c9d18bf5f6fbe4b8591b4", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "briefcase", "full_answer": "The man is holding the brief case.", "question": "What is the person that is running holding?", "question_id": "10125827", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (574038)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "running", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (574040)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "umbrella", "full_answer": "The woman is holding the umbrella.", "question": "What is the person that is standing holding?", "question_id": "0910286", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (174555)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (174557)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["574039", "574040", "574041", "574042", "574043", "574046", "574047", "574049", "574050", "574052", "574053", "574054", "574056", "574058", "574059", "574060", "574061", "574062", "574063"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["briefcase"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "574040", "query_target_entity_name": "briefcase", "relation_object_entity_id": "574040", "relation_subject_entity_id": "574038", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "574038", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "running", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["574038"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "running", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["174556", "174557", "174558", "174559", "174560", "174562", "174563", "174565", "174566"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["umbrella"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "174557", "query_target_entity_name": "umbrella", "relation_object_entity_id": "174557", "relation_subject_entity_id": "174555", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "174555", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["174555"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:c87e326eb4788b2c4f9b93f37b320b95", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6fcf48a88808f17b5ad733e907a26e9c550aa496fd1b21725536b33b4e82cae2", "image_sha256_b": "75e5845b53e950fd74e19766cf2f7c6f077fc48698c39a8fd29f16cef88a8d6b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8ff88b0f703536af4a71f788b7c7c6b3c13b8007c061237185602e944bb1f5b5", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d3b5708b05b20b83280b6700a1fba4a0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b2d6d8366e5baa62a513606f0931d840fdd31014e8836b93b72f4447e40372f3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "32ea0d03a62aa0464a9ab84c2bffe19bdf18afa27d18fc6db8f4c02d2324be99", "request_id": "cfa9b36b737dd41c7fbf758a484ed2a4", "response_sha256": "06a7d9bb89167f66df93798e9d4290bfa63c7de0466385d8fb564093b286691d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b59fb0f8c6ccd3c7dfbb8baf4dc579b2fdd16133c8b2c2efe8576f6812eca8d6", "request_id": "277f25c77062789d94cdc4091cf5bc51", "response_sha256": "a76d60808fea3c67175465ae3613a7ed7a522914ea4f84cfba05465c5c04df6e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "601ace5a2d013d2ab07be56e9a35eb0d", "candidate_priority_rank": 9337, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-77f1dc0f3cd6ec1a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-77f1dc0f3cd6ec1a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-77f1dc0f3cd6ec1a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-77f1dc0f3cd6ec1a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "metal<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "wood", "B": "metal"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wood<->metal", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2382760", "image_sha256": "1db2a2d3cc0d5c042ce34735e500fb0d530710c2c0f1592d1b52be9469b37626", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382760.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382760.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2369173", "image_sha256": "7bfacf000ec9320020f80b278d22b3643bff715c6d99ea4ce4d74ed384943c02", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369173.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369173.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-77f1dc0f3cd6ec1a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wood", "diff_b": "metal", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wood", "component_b": "metal"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e64865925468f92af8582732f82e4e78bf43a83ed0cc2f41e34758f5b24ef488"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04445342", "text": "What animal is in front of the wood fence?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal"], "detected_components": ["metal"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "metal", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ba1714f151480d51c4324e43fb2d8364794995de7753462541b01c326a84af05"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11947920", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9337, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f53242e18568f2edc2ec84c9d4ac5a0859e612b605182eee6035c3256d15ec2e", "selected_component": "metal", "selected_source_question_id": "11947920", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in front of the metal fence?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the fence?", "program_group_hash": "f53242e18568f2edc2ec84c9d4ac5a0859e612b605182eee6035c3256d15ec2e", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the fence?", "program_group_hash": "f53242e18568f2edc2ec84c9d4ac5a0859e612b605182eee6035c3256d15ec2e", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The elephant is in front of the fence.", "question": "What animal is in front of the wood fence?", "question_id": "04445342", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (537376)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (537363)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The giraffe is in front of the fence.", "question": "What animal is in front of the metal fence?", "question_id": "11947920", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (3390208)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "metal", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (1998607)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["537363"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "537363", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "537376", "relation_subject_entity_id": "537363", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "537376", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["537376"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1998607"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "tall"], "query_target_entity_id": "1998607", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "3390208", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1998607", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3390208", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3390208"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:601ace5a2d013d2ab07be56e9a35eb0d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1db2a2d3cc0d5c042ce34735e500fb0d530710c2c0f1592d1b52be9469b37626", "image_sha256_b": "7bfacf000ec9320020f80b278d22b3643bff715c6d99ea4ce4d74ed384943c02", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4bc9a4cfdb4a1b14d05d709ebf0d7c9b6398cdfc3c38d4dfa7a661eb057301c6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "73d2870ec5462d0ba38f1f0c569c85f2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ffa40203b2f8693dc3922d8769e6eaa50762d6e4020a5a1f0b66d89217aa223e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "29424731ebd788d2f7ac40c2188ef4edbfd389a69a89cd683dcefb5157f5d437", "request_id": "da08200e92e561adc923410c8b625129", "response_sha256": "5b598afa31a48e39fda78f1a78d5570e3cb80752d51e76766766b5540c12343c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "78b1047488538a9ad5dd2032ed82f23e1a05c862aa8792ae123d2d778519dad8", "request_id": "15990191d5088974a442160a300bb2a3", "response_sha256": "1c371cb25e074a077d4ab30961e44a34053adba0010a38e3d67a1466e56898ab", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "a2e215a1caf0ca865f5f097b24bcdb38", "candidate_priority_rank": 9395, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7ace59772da0f16:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7ace59772da0f16:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7ace59772da0f16:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7ace59772da0f16:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gray", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gray<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 361, "image_id": "2368162", "image_sha256": "58b95b76e23f1ae561a4696a88b5cccb225b33deef91170f3aee666671ef030c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2368162.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2368162.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2326334", "image_sha256": "b01a96f8f82a4b08993a83395789fbf1466c5d955277965da5ed28fa78d16c78", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326334.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326334.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d7ace59772da0f16", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gray", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gray", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f8092f3fd39d2cd506a56347d3cefd4b8e26e1e4c0970a0295a116f440a65fe", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "99d6f9d8d3df2bc2f47ed56af136d55b40e770db8a1a4e773266872b7c330fc3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0772325", "text": "What animal is in front of the gray water?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f8092f3fd39d2cd506a56347d3cefd4b8e26e1e4c0970a0295a116f440a65fe", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f300fff870309fbe4a46bcc3fe3c3ad14b3a37d8a01f34549a66c5e4968b3ac3"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03912660", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9395, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5a40e49966ba1de55ac6ed94a7f041e33c03f8cbef1659384fbb116525deba00", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "03912660", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in front of the brown water?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the water?", "program_group_hash": "5a40e49966ba1de55ac6ed94a7f041e33c03f8cbef1659384fbb116525deba00", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the water?", "program_group_hash": "5a40e49966ba1de55ac6ed94a7f041e33c03f8cbef1659384fbb116525deba00", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is in front of the water.", "question": "What animal is in front of the gray water?", "question_id": "0772325", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (747717)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (747714)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The elephant is in front of the water.", "question": "What animal is in front of the brown water?", "question_id": "03912660", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (982546)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (982537)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["747714"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "large", "running"], "query_target_entity_id": "747714", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "747717", "relation_subject_entity_id": "747714", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "747717", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["747717"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["982537"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["baby", "brown", "dirty", "heavy", "huge", "large", "wrinkled"], "query_target_entity_id": "982537", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "982546", "relation_subject_entity_id": "982537", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "982546", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["982546"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:a2e215a1caf0ca865f5f097b24bcdb38", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "58b95b76e23f1ae561a4696a88b5cccb225b33deef91170f3aee666671ef030c", "image_sha256_b": "b01a96f8f82a4b08993a83395789fbf1466c5d955277965da5ed28fa78d16c78", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "341fc9fc746f2d3c81d03f07c8c12b11693dc9210198d0fa2b76ca8c4ccc6ef9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "11c37eb6690d140022df4fefdcb91413", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1b77fb2ef29f7d6d74b3fc01acf6cd40d3c07df54757250311d154058f0ca184"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0668d85edde34ca0747c5a67d656ef03499548760feefdf28fbaf8fd5a22ff05", "request_id": "a6df525f4dd94dd6e0f4d9f308ab0122", "response_sha256": "5dc7f4e4bcf29b042ecd935e7f47abf7ecb1a8ad1c93e41263791c733dbfd8a5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a96ab394e29012dfde08b615ce34f2eccfc9b9351085feb34e413674682d507f", "request_id": "3572a3aa684cc2e58a7410c2c0088a82", "response_sha256": "67a08e96abb0cc78ce8f1fa9344ff34b57b27f56e8a68ae3d1e99fdab7cb7d4d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "2652c981ce0f2a19b31dd909acf30fb9", "candidate_priority_rank": 9407, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f8743b221cf8b483:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f8743b221cf8b483:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f8743b221cf8b483:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f8743b221cf8b483:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "sitting<->standing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "sitting", "B": "standing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sitting<->standing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2402434", "image_sha256": "f668fa8ce3a115feb81cdcc841c34e3bc29e39251b9c2e5af2d880d1efd3bb97", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402434.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402434.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 556, "image_id": "4229", "image_sha256": "39d2e562cb9fa9fe59c104b5e971b4cf3da6d9ba475d84111571d33082b057ce", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/4229.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/4229.jpg", "width": 712}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f8743b221cf8b483", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sitting", "diff_b": "standing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sitting", "component_b": "standing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["sitting", "standing"], "detected_components": ["sitting"], "masked_program_sha256": "bf136c2765f8ab6be8f7951450a96b121589b8ae1f688ba22b7254768eb176e4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sitting", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f8becb10747bc058e9d53aa8922651df529fc9233ff2324821eb99fbe61a17d0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13314776", "text": "What is the man that is sitting wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "bf136c2765f8ab6be8f7951450a96b121589b8ae1f688ba22b7254768eb176e4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fcfe92aee5897377d7ac9ba7fd951d24f7a8d57266992e0cb1fa3d42e67856d5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06583609", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9407, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 24, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "88aa822ac25ddf78178fed9bbaed1e511b2d7317eca447a124ad522570dbdeda", "selected_component": "standing", "selected_source_question_id": "06583609", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the man that is standing wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "man", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the man that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "88aa822ac25ddf78178fed9bbaed1e511b2d7317eca447a124ad522570dbdeda", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "man", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the man that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "88aa822ac25ddf78178fed9bbaed1e511b2d7317eca447a124ad522570dbdeda", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "hat", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a hat.", "question": "What is the man that is sitting wearing?", "question_id": "13314776", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1136234)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sitting", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (1136233)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "jacket", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a jacket.", "question": "What is the man that is standing wearing?", "question_id": "06583609", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (4365854)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (4365855)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1136229", "1136232", "1136233", "1136235", "1136236", "1136237", "1136238", "1136239", "1136240", "1136241", "1136243", "1136244", "1136245", "1136246", "1136247", "1136248", "1136249", "1136250"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hat"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1136233", "query_target_entity_name": "hat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1136233", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1136234", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1136234", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "sitting", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1136234"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "sitting", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3993045", "4365835", "4365837", "4365838", "4365845", "4365846", "4365847", "4365850", "4365851", "4365852", "4365853", "4365855", "4365856", "4365859", "4365860", "4365861", "4501697", "4501699", "4501701", "4502000"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["jacket"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "4365855", "query_target_entity_name": "jacket", "relation_object_entity_id": "4365855", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4365854", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4365854", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4365854"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:2652c981ce0f2a19b31dd909acf30fb9", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f668fa8ce3a115feb81cdcc841c34e3bc29e39251b9c2e5af2d880d1efd3bb97", "image_sha256_b": "39d2e562cb9fa9fe59c104b5e971b4cf3da6d9ba475d84111571d33082b057ce", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8d76da4c276d38a9e0ba6d4b81637f0fbe9633088326018dd9a8bd43c2aaf297", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "738ba67e15507e3bd58832e507fca66d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f27411b5253d40b7c1b314d5a5ad7afd5895edd114ad19760688f8fbfe5a43d3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4a5386b245bcac49b708deef5ec5bcbba635053ae40fa6d32739b4b3e7a43109", "request_id": "3220b91e828bebe643de07e8b1a064e4", "response_sha256": "3cbb43dfa5761cc33670064495f4b3e123f68f90d2a8c36b1350731b82b5c90b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5c697dad112e55c3dfc12adb09a781aeffa27e0670a1e9973d364b21ba078ab0", "request_id": "4a7b538d7e2e19968b4777bf3c018bbb", "response_sha256": "5f375cf6332f20f003889c1f742971972ca8b61dd33445d9e2fcfb17c011a97e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "f874b388d0df50431748669218879983", "candidate_priority_rank": 9462, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c02b06903178eca6:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c02b06903178eca6:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c02b06903178eca6:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c02b06903178eca6:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "gray<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 335, "image_id": "2387477", "image_sha256": "bc20923720e68da6b24853a10ab19a0290a6beb732ada64590a500f16e529319", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387477.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387477.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2372911", "image_sha256": "8d047a847321a620e0fbc2a759d32c0865fce6ed88ec4a99efc067112fad9731", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2372911.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2372911.jpg", "width": 331}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c02b06903178eca6", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "gray", "green", "purple", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "c213c8883348807e7ffd46db2e4c79810fbd6a29f02e8aea807e948f99293bf6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["helmet"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["helmet"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bae1f8ba5672a4805e19df9df3a4f6585aec58b800063763333d23b3f62afbbe"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18653012", "text": "What is on the green helmet?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "green", "pink", "purple", "red"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "c213c8883348807e7ffd46db2e4c79810fbd6a29f02e8aea807e948f99293bf6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["helmet"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["helmet"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f7fc41286991493ece54fe8855428f530c5daea887820b620e42505353e734d9"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04282470", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9462, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e77ebf7fe3065fc4587b3a687bf80f5a71efa1bb558a8f26e0c51dfeef5ed83e", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "04282470", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the gray helmet?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "helmet", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the helmet?", "program_group_hash": "e77ebf7fe3065fc4587b3a687bf80f5a71efa1bb558a8f26e0c51dfeef5ed83e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "helmet"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "helmet", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the helmet?", "program_group_hash": "e77ebf7fe3065fc4587b3a687bf80f5a71efa1bb558a8f26e0c51dfeef5ed83e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "helmet"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "goggles", "full_answer": "The goggles are on the helmet.", "question": "What is on the green helmet?", "question_id": "18653012", "semantic": [{"argument": "helmet (1275645)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1275659)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "goggles", "full_answer": "The goggles are on the helmet.", "question": "What is on the gray helmet?", "question_id": "04282470", "semantic": [{"argument": "helmet (2634650)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2178505)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1275646", "1275647", "1275648", "1275649", "1275651", "1275652", "1275654", "1275655", "1275656", "1275657", "1275658", "1275659", "1275660", "1275661", "1275662", "1275663", "1275664", "1275665", "1275666", "1275667", "1275668", "1275669", "1275670", "1275671", "1275673", "1275675", "1275676"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 27, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["goggles"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "1275659", "query_target_entity_name": "goggles", "relation_object_entity_id": "1275645", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1275659", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1275645", "selected_entity_name": "helmet"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1275645"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1713888", "1806789", "2081222", "2081224", "2083497", "2125711", "2178505", "2221094", "2293677", "2472039", "3730514", "3730515", "3730520", "3730524", "3730525", "3730526", "3730529", "3730532"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["goggles"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2178505", "query_target_entity_name": "goggles", "relation_object_entity_id": "2634650", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2178505", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2634650", "selected_entity_name": "helmet"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2634650"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:f874b388d0df50431748669218879983", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bc20923720e68da6b24853a10ab19a0290a6beb732ada64590a500f16e529319", "image_sha256_b": "8d047a847321a620e0fbc2a759d32c0865fce6ed88ec4a99efc067112fad9731", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "dbdfdf8556a6c84fadb076f4d9f25341fe9fb753a95403af6f530b9e8581240e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ab1f9d273be7105f2d6530c5a435f68c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5c5b852a26338e8001bcc242314005f02487ca440a9df478744ccf1cf67e4cbc"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d22c89f974f64f8846f874824dbebf5c2e8e8bf43496b69c308e2a72e1ea519a", "request_id": "8cd1e782b55ef6c76b572899551bcd98", "response_sha256": "a4cd82261c1782f2a72131818c7966598dee7a8bcef6d90a404aac88fb86b0ec", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fe5fb0b0e849c0a7c1833c7ba7fd73d21d134bcff81fb24399588055e21e51e9", "request_id": "e70bf713d2e045e4fd4f78af88487c42", "response_sha256": "30725cc480dd594804a074d7a05398b358f844ff0512b95846ec11f4cabc57b0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "64a44e350635619b5e54f22bde0f1e4f", "candidate_priority_rank": 9579, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7ad401cb49a8d1f8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7ad401cb49a8d1f8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7ad401cb49a8d1f8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7ad401cb49a8d1f8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "lying<->sitting", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "sitting", "B": "lying"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sitting<->lying", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 453, "image_id": "2337218", "image_sha256": "7514e9d9b979e5cc5dab32735e715325c832ec74c90a00a8ffd4e1deb504f8f2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2337218.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2337218.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2382760", "image_sha256": "1db2a2d3cc0d5c042ce34735e500fb0d530710c2c0f1592d1b52be9469b37626", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382760.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382760.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7ad401cb49a8d1f8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sitting", "diff_b": "lying", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sitting", "component_b": "lying"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["sitting"], "detected_components": ["sitting"], "masked_program_sha256": "bf136c2765f8ab6be8f7951450a96b121589b8ae1f688ba22b7254768eb176e4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sitting", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f8becb10747bc058e9d53aa8922651df529fc9233ff2324821eb99fbe61a17d0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19660046", "text": "What is the man that is sitting wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["lying", "standing"], "detected_components": ["lying"], "masked_program_sha256": "bf136c2765f8ab6be8f7951450a96b121589b8ae1f688ba22b7254768eb176e4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "lying", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "067d81f1e44011a78b28dd50ba9340f4c820ea5ad933e29b815541504c33e980"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04445195", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9579, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 30, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "88aa822ac25ddf78178fed9bbaed1e511b2d7317eca447a124ad522570dbdeda", "selected_component": "lying", "selected_source_question_id": "04445195", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the man that is lying wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "man", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the man that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "88aa822ac25ddf78178fed9bbaed1e511b2d7317eca447a124ad522570dbdeda", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "man", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the man that is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "88aa822ac25ddf78178fed9bbaed1e511b2d7317eca447a124ad522570dbdeda", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "shirt", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a shirt.", "question": "What is the man that is sitting wearing?", "question_id": "19660046", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (958698)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sitting", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (958700)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "t-shirt", "full_answer": "The man is wearing a tshirt.", "question": "What is the man that is lying wearing?", "question_id": "04445195", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (537364)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "lying", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (537377)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["958692", "958694", "958695", "958696", "958699", "958700", "958703", "958704", "958705", "958706", "958707", "958710", "958711"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["shirt"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "958700", "query_target_entity_name": "shirt", "relation_object_entity_id": "958700", "relation_subject_entity_id": "958698", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "958698", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "sitting", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["958698"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "lying", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "sitting", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["537363", "537365", "537366", "537367", "537368", "537369", "537370", "537371", "537372", "537373", "537374", "537376", "537377", "537378", "537380", "537382", "537383"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["t-shirt"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "537377", "query_target_entity_name": "t-shirt", "relation_object_entity_id": "537377", "relation_subject_entity_id": "537364", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "537364", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "lying", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["537364"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:64a44e350635619b5e54f22bde0f1e4f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7514e9d9b979e5cc5dab32735e715325c832ec74c90a00a8ffd4e1deb504f8f2", "image_sha256_b": "1db2a2d3cc0d5c042ce34735e500fb0d530710c2c0f1592d1b52be9469b37626", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "646b2d29db36ae8313849cb27cabf1ca3af28f77b59b7a62b09bc1b5ea00b489", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0768669dfc9f44b8bce2811c7651186f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0162f7cadc9dcbc684194e66a79b554978895e0d4e6990f1de0938575d86ca5a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "899d01bc60e7eb9c1d2123e42fb652282dc6acf63500a011463f8cab0fcf3eda", "request_id": "09af5f62dface1d3506641a86a8673e8", "response_sha256": "6d5c3f8b2c8615d3b40b0f7de1c97f142857c1ef3f3abe80dd46953095a17e40", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d0caa53795b76ca450704d4f63ccad7c8556c7332ce90399d89d34ad5fbfef2b", "request_id": "2f1f95f7e67984a608e475da9987485f", "response_sha256": "891dee128384b7fce2b14fa80f07f6e73cdd0d6c7ccf207ba9a9451eb6dac046", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "fb526d9cdd8ea9932c3f48cd83299fab", "candidate_priority_rank": 9655, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d4bb57486a53987f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d4bb57486a53987f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d4bb57486a53987f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d4bb57486a53987f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2326227", "image_sha256": "fce5ce49c1b38ea24d80fbf0c056207673d95bcd81798d538b7d05ac09559b33", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326227.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326227.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2414165", "image_sha256": "33402f4bf1ddfde731415b7ddcbbeb3754956e9b1dff91084e2ec4ba7c08efe8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2414165.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2414165.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d4bb57486a53987f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "green", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "e917dbf432ece18f67fb22e525dea2843341d86156ef2e9120d0844041681891", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c80fa4dfc25471dcf10de3a3b6e6f7d5c547b08407f668884b0bf6ccd6463b8e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12560241", "text": "What is the blue bird perched on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "e917dbf432ece18f67fb22e525dea2843341d86156ef2e9120d0844041681891", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9ff14f1b81a30054951918867b2400612476d73e7fab12b217c26c9b2f4454c6"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02885606", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9655, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2f7af46444de8fea1d3203d07b3b940ebfc03c3f973d6e74dc6f17f7c4f410ed", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "02885606", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the gray bird perched on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,perched on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird perched on?", "program_group_hash": "2f7af46444de8fea1d3203d07b3b940ebfc03c3f973d6e74dc6f17f7c4f410ed", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "perched on", "select_category": "bird"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,perched on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird perched on?", "program_group_hash": "2f7af46444de8fea1d3203d07b3b940ebfc03c3f973d6e74dc6f17f7c4f410ed", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "perched on", "select_category": "bird"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pole", "full_answer": "The bird is perched on the pole.", "question": "What is the blue bird perched on?", "question_id": "12560241", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (3987534)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,perched on,o (3987545)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bush", "full_answer": "The bird is perched on the shrub.", "question": "What is the gray bird perched on?", "question_id": "02885606", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (158638)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,perched on,o (158640)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3987535", "3987543", "3987545", "3987549", "3987552", "3987553", "3987555", "3987557", "3987568", "3987581", "3987584", "3987585", "3987588", "3987595", "3987598", "3987599", "3987600", "3987601", "3987602"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pole"], "predicate": "perched on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3987545", "query_target_entity_name": "pole", "relation_object_entity_id": "3987545", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3987534", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3987534", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3987534"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["158640", "158643", "158646", "158648", "158649", "158651", "158652"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bush"], "predicate": "perched on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "dry"], "query_target_entity_id": "158640", "query_target_entity_name": "bush", "relation_object_entity_id": "158640", "relation_subject_entity_id": "158638", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "158638", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["158638"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:fb526d9cdd8ea9932c3f48cd83299fab", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "fce5ce49c1b38ea24d80fbf0c056207673d95bcd81798d538b7d05ac09559b33", "image_sha256_b": "33402f4bf1ddfde731415b7ddcbbeb3754956e9b1dff91084e2ec4ba7c08efe8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "fe9557642ca5fab86e64c68ee130096e13ef06046e4437d3ed5d561e5fea251b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "dd05d266bb2bd8ada55f7c40d173ac57", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "77db69fc02b6b980c30cca9897b0547706cc285cec8ea9c6cc58312927ba1d92"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "677523fdeb891edf51923aa813d4e080d1443510166949aed0133259f7782ec5", "request_id": "345b0ccfe418b8081af6a35d74decfab", "response_sha256": "61b4dc633914805acd56a747137c05c5fe6e7dff8cb33cff74794915e7e2579d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "47c4c471c76b35101d91f7f7426148a62478c5a12ecc72feef18c39637877be4", "request_id": "b0d2e8a249c55fb4bcb61aa9f07cbf60", "response_sha256": "12d2351ced78fda92629c897f8879debed658ffff6388ef9b5fcaddc6d9bd450", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "495ed677419bea267b4a8ec492b8cc0c", "candidate_priority_rank": 9732, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f82ee51dd6b83684:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f82ee51dd6b83684:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f82ee51dd6b83684:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f82ee51dd6b83684:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "stone<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "stone", "B": "wood"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "stone<->wood", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2400618", "image_sha256": "1907f67202a380091ad44c930137cd7dfe3a24b1b99baab7311802502d0186df", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400618.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400618.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 331, "image_id": "2384323", "image_sha256": "c75a81e357f3138f1dcd2bf42c52d42bd2e258d35219961a8b09ba24f33475f8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384323.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384323.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f82ee51dd6b83684", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "stone", "diff_b": "wood", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "stone", "component_b": "wood"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["clay", "stone"], "detected_components": ["stone"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stone", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4696104486cde7b78143d30a8379c12b421cb5e9fb8a1b1a104e65bd91f067d3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05768145", "text": "What is on the stone wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d3466c0c725f80ac5fb4642b5a74d9ba2c40cb5757e8780bbff19b1cd827febf"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07622289", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9732, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2bef5906f241b03de4a71550f0a90863677e1dfbf3df580f7d6977acbeba0222", "selected_component": "wood", "selected_source_question_id": "07622289", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the wood wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "2bef5906f241b03de4a71550f0a90863677e1dfbf3df580f7d6977acbeba0222", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "2bef5906f241b03de4a71550f0a90863677e1dfbf3df580f7d6977acbeba0222", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "plants", "full_answer": "The plants are on the wall.", "question": "What is on the stone wall?", "question_id": "05768145", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (407249)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "stone", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (407251)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "paper", "full_answer": "The paper is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the wood wall?", "question_id": "07622289", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1310837)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1310836)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["407242", "407243", "407246", "407247", "407250", "407251", "407252", "407253", "407254", "407255", "407256", "407258", "407259", "407260", "407261", "407262", "407263", "407264", "407265", "407266", "407267", "407268", "407269", "407270", "407271", "407272", "407275", "407276", "407277", "407278", "407279", "407280", "407281", "407282"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 34, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["plants"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "407251", "query_target_entity_name": "plants", "relation_object_entity_id": "407249", "relation_subject_entity_id": "407251", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "407249", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["407249"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1310830", "1310831", "1310832", "1310833", "1310835", "1310836", "1310839", "1310841", "1310842", "1310844", "1310845", "1310847", "1310848", "1310850", "1310851", "1310852"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["paper"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1310836", "query_target_entity_name": "paper", "relation_object_entity_id": "1310837", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1310836", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1310837", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1310837"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:495ed677419bea267b4a8ec492b8cc0c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1907f67202a380091ad44c930137cd7dfe3a24b1b99baab7311802502d0186df", "image_sha256_b": "c75a81e357f3138f1dcd2bf42c52d42bd2e258d35219961a8b09ba24f33475f8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "94b57b6d21739e3015cf176b241a199c3f952b8b70f9ed263a4988d149b1ada4", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "15faf3b3fb668fd68cd4081bedc5afa3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ee38abdef125ba49321f206202ea71c01392878a9e63dd6877753fc06c56e211"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c7c6aa8c665708614955d04cf21d9ad28da54c734220e21da71ffc362365aaf9", "request_id": "b7ebf90d17e2bfed6e64f8f79fd4e93a", "response_sha256": "016b1040f9b7f33b40194c886da486e42d19537990cd629a349bea17aa2059a9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6a025533aa922d55ae14aabc274fea5432a73b345dd3ee44ae473c2fd4263bc7", "request_id": "46a9fd3be3dc1c357556aadecc10d08a", "response_sha256": "9415d0e35af6d5898cf7f8c7aa6a0f0b7f64a82c58a00b01324db633c670c8fa", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "46908a126e42d66eab538a8a78395087", "candidate_priority_rank": 9747, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-939d560d9affeebe:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-939d560d9affeebe:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-939d560d9affeebe:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-939d560d9affeebe:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "snowboarding<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "surfing", "B": "snowboarding"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "surfing<->snowboarding", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2355318", "image_sha256": "57d9df9b85940ca82cee852e17f8beede8621f2823818b82ae4a1a2e38ddb0bc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2355318.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2355318.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2390404", "image_sha256": "4d2ed3c3434149bb78ff342b00453ffcafd6cd6ccaae06dc851ab86cd31445e5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390404.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390404.jpg", "width": 334}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-939d560d9affeebe", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "surfing", "diff_b": "snowboarding", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "surfing", "component_b": "snowboarding"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "b3d81a104fad68ce7e634e262a734daa47bf66faa75fa51875b2699789a31491", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "24461432a8e6f0517146d6da6e9dc5e8957ec71aaff32cbc06859f88276c37d2"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "17956275", "text": "What is the person that is surfing riding on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["snowboarding"], "detected_components": ["snowboarding"], "masked_program_sha256": "b3d81a104fad68ce7e634e262a734daa47bf66faa75fa51875b2699789a31491", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "snowboarding", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c7955da83e9175ad36bb5d778f4c80d5a3dfa15d701aa502eb804910dd6fdc04"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19530482", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9747, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 11, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "25a169db68be174f4f8916d178703bdb7b2bf914373577f70e9b7a15103879eb", "selected_component": "snowboarding", "selected_source_question_id": "19530482", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is snowboarding riding on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,riding on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is riding on?", "program_group_hash": "25a169db68be174f4f8916d178703bdb7b2bf914373577f70e9b7a15103879eb", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "riding on", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,riding on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is riding on?", "program_group_hash": "25a169db68be174f4f8916d178703bdb7b2bf914373577f70e9b7a15103879eb", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "riding on", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "surfboard", "full_answer": "The person is riding on the surfboard.", "question": "What is the person that is surfing riding on?", "question_id": "17956275", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (830720)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,riding on,o (830723)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "snowboard", "full_answer": "The person is riding on the snowboard.", "question": "What is the person that is snowboarding riding on?", "question_id": "19530482", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1250744)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "snowboarding", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,riding on,o (1250743)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["830721", "830723", "830724", "830725", "830726", "830727", "830728", "830729", "830730"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["surfboard"], "predicate": "riding on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "830723", "query_target_entity_name": "surfboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "830723", "relation_subject_entity_id": "830720", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "830720", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["830720"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "snowboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1250743", "1250745", "1250746", "1250747", "1250749", "1250752", "1250753", "1250754", "3828044", "3828045"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["snowboard"], "predicate": "riding on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["red", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "1250743", "query_target_entity_name": "snowboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "1250743", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1250744", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1250744", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "snowboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1250744"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:46908a126e42d66eab538a8a78395087", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "57d9df9b85940ca82cee852e17f8beede8621f2823818b82ae4a1a2e38ddb0bc", "image_sha256_b": "4d2ed3c3434149bb78ff342b00453ffcafd6cd6ccaae06dc851ab86cd31445e5", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a3f75163fa167bc5560dae729103e5c6cc8f23f91c3e7d529745e5c81ac8d522", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "edea6706ac44b9507a50aeb95e4f6ad1", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "141cfc64729c579df5689dec9c8af8de4d489ffcc7447f2b82fcad2c7ebd0e88"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "69b681ea0a64212fb40df46ae8534ee0666fbe07816e3ea173b7d475180b8119", "request_id": "5cd7daff8f7e5464bf6f5342cd2362f7", "response_sha256": "ef34a71f9f3d89aa2c8d0cdd3ec0d9f3fc4c36530464515f6a7b267008098c7a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "69e85d81ec88ca15b8bcfcd87dbbe5e4ca7487993501ae692bc628f4ca7b2b73", "request_id": "334b568abae33c32801865791f5d7046", "response_sha256": "b12b5f6f4fa2677fb1c0c729c59e41286723c0f3029eb352674ac93c0ee6b8cb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "6efbb3e312f9c8fc4c50be445752f96a", "candidate_priority_rank": 9756, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2de6b0af1a403e79:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2de6b0af1a403e79:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2de6b0af1a403e79:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2de6b0af1a403e79:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "orange<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "orange"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->orange", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2383653", "image_sha256": "32691cff4cc75361411ef24a12f5ee9b117f4ce05cdf8d42ea816554a0961170", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2383653.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2383653.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2400436", "image_sha256": "e2f9dc4b6a4b4348239c3f8e12cb314fdc0be59992c71290cfb42f788f1af75d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400436.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400436.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2de6b0af1a403e79", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "orange", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "orange"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "cream colored", "light blue", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "09fdf851e6b9893f1cc7cc7044d69b9944e6e4f23de278806d33d0ae5027e27d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7865a1085721f4f41fc2022aee17d6f71ccb38633b00ddf2a36b7db6e7d7a1f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0490069", "text": "What is the white towel hanging on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "orange"], "detected_components": ["orange"], "masked_program_sha256": "09fdf851e6b9893f1cc7cc7044d69b9944e6e4f23de278806d33d0ae5027e27d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "orange", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7803d0ac311a775a02c5b82459ada7d8951a198bd8f8bb0b5fbc0b425239dce8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19346099", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9756, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b00665a9834b3d19bee92e230bdf23f55e016bf2bcc6d1a9f6555884145f27a6", "selected_component": "orange", "selected_source_question_id": "19346099", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the orange towel hanging on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "towel", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the towel hanging on?", "program_group_hash": "b00665a9834b3d19bee92e230bdf23f55e016bf2bcc6d1a9f6555884145f27a6", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "towel"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "towel", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the towel hanging on?", "program_group_hash": "b00665a9834b3d19bee92e230bdf23f55e016bf2bcc6d1a9f6555884145f27a6", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "towel"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bathtub", "full_answer": "The towel is hanging on the tub.", "question": "What is the white towel hanging on?", "question_id": "0490069", "semantic": [{"argument": "towel (1318728)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,o (1318726)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stove", "full_answer": "The towel is hanging on the stove.", "question": "What is the orange towel hanging on?", "question_id": "19346099", "semantic": [{"argument": "towel (1159048)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "orange", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,o (1159043)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1318726", "1318727", "1318730", "1318731", "1318733", "1318734", "1318735", "1318736", "1318737", "1318738", "1318741", "1318742", "1318743", "1318745"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bathtub"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["clean", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1318726", "query_target_entity_name": "bathtub", "relation_object_entity_id": "1318726", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1318728", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1318728", "selected_entity_name": "towel"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1318728"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "orange", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1159038", "1159040", "1159041", "1159043", "1159044", "1159045", "1159046", "1159047", "1159050", "1159054", "1159055", "1159056", "1159058", "1159059", "1159060", "1159062", "1159065", "1159066", "1159067"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stove"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1159043", "query_target_entity_name": "stove", "relation_object_entity_id": "1159043", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1159048", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1159048", "selected_entity_name": "towel"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "orange", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1159048"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:6efbb3e312f9c8fc4c50be445752f96a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "32691cff4cc75361411ef24a12f5ee9b117f4ce05cdf8d42ea816554a0961170", "image_sha256_b": "e2f9dc4b6a4b4348239c3f8e12cb314fdc0be59992c71290cfb42f788f1af75d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7c4828e7f6676dd2ba9f2612b5c9b0c77363d1a97716ec10938944c07aecd133", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "72f3c39316af4f10d61e56649db5920c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a5622c1fe5e2537303effdfc5ff401c802ba67830d75fed39755bb7d6ae68af9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "43c93c47cfa814dbf4b30a75eb55829b5208d9f768b69d7640fc208842621d67", "request_id": "c967fa333cbff91a9d3b1dedd59559ca", "response_sha256": "79c9ab4887f31f5629ac378fd57aea8267d9aae3f12c15213630a8e3e0ae929a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "24cf787f77765b33c3eb57ac4feb89c1f6785d0259f3e3a44d34efcd671f020e", "request_id": "bbeaf2489c1d8b524d3db28f1ac95d39", "response_sha256": "743b48ed7f7239e784c366d2884c502d1936fdca2029b4fa39d398b2359c1a18", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "d6ed44b49d863f446105eb940c1ea068", "candidate_priority_rank": 9773, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-1d3280a3cffae68a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-1d3280a3cffae68a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-1d3280a3cffae68a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-1d3280a3cffae68a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "skiing<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "surfing", "B": "skiing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "surfing<->skiing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2370746", "image_sha256": "9bccfde935dcf1046fd5a4e31ce153d45d7f6992c958b004739040c5ca2f0ce4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2370746.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2370746.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 328, "image_id": "2409675", "image_sha256": "2e2b8581a0d8cb2500a2d119c97098b04bd489c50e907d0e18190201acf9c537", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2409675.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2409675.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-1d3280a3cffae68a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "surfing", "diff_b": "skiing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "surfing", "component_b": "skiing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9e727753e7cf4a9b525c37ad5257d9550f27e81735566e624b56f11be1942ef4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01367109", "text": "What does the person that is surfing wear?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["skiing"], "detected_components": ["skiing"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f88cab29aa90dbbd84c7c3c76aa82b1ecad2774b4c9f007bd1eb094aeffd3c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "skiing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b92d3f506c0c277f68dfbb51112299325a3d3e68dad91a7f2cf31b3dce2f482b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11329727", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9773, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "de78827ed1131f5538bd0264ddba7f0bea5f7c4964b07df4a7a69a6322e2ac1f", "selected_component": "skiing", "selected_source_question_id": "11329727", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What does the person that is skiing wear?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what does the person that is wear?", "program_group_hash": "de78827ed1131f5538bd0264ddba7f0bea5f7c4964b07df4a7a69a6322e2ac1f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what does the person that is wear?", "program_group_hash": "de78827ed1131f5538bd0264ddba7f0bea5f7c4964b07df4a7a69a6322e2ac1f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "wetsuit", "full_answer": "The man wears a wetsuit.", "question": "What does the person that is surfing wear?", "question_id": "01367109", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (2027638)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (2631852)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "jacket", "full_answer": "The person wears a jacket.", "question": "What does the person that is skiing wear?", "question_id": "11329727", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (236445)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "skiing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (236451)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1740339", "1740406", "1841438", "2325921", "2328745", "2328747", "2328748", "2328749", "2383473", "2455908", "2612603", "2627875", "2631852", "2702974", "3856956", "3856957"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wetsuit"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "2631852", "query_target_entity_name": "wetsuit", "relation_object_entity_id": "2631852", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2027638", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2027638", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2027638"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["236448", "236451", "236454", "236457", "236458", "236460", "236462", "236463", "236464", "236465", "236466", "236468", "236473", "3807634"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["jacket"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "236451", "query_target_entity_name": "jacket", "relation_object_entity_id": "236451", "relation_subject_entity_id": "236445", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "236445", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["236445"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:d6ed44b49d863f446105eb940c1ea068", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9bccfde935dcf1046fd5a4e31ce153d45d7f6992c958b004739040c5ca2f0ce4", "image_sha256_b": "2e2b8581a0d8cb2500a2d119c97098b04bd489c50e907d0e18190201acf9c537", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "cd97825e8836cb386f730ccb67f0571682c83143d1c9eb308354dcbffcaa739d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "108bc38871cd05cb939a948c6acbf054", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "8e69be545a7a4ae1dff51ad5639605d75311ae8f5fe18b1baba0ddbeacbf4248"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3f96e375656012b55aebed0a1095a87e97c1498ed0a7cf0c045177ec7c006622", "request_id": "80769a91f268b16e015c55e350e5de37", "response_sha256": "64b9344594847cef8bd11b31656192e450beebb9ebfd4aad9310bf3c2a2925da", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cecb14f87edf3bf4b2493e957de6f652bf8cbb0363b49c7b9d543a6472d915c4", "request_id": "3e15fd03dbe15781efa298177911c98a", "response_sha256": "5904a733df1f05970126e3dd7c19984aa3918aecd3b66a10a154bffe5147418b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "3abab0855fa7f6d62bf0d1bac5289420", "candidate_priority_rank": 9787, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26259a9486f2076d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26259a9486f2076d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26259a9486f2076d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26259a9486f2076d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 426, "image_id": "2390864", "image_sha256": "e93414a2dd5f9a10a9eb70006ce0a79ac1c39436182cfd78d9c9797e411a171e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390864.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390864.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2398817", "image_sha256": "e027bb6cfcc1930e3726307d8a6c7da2a677bec251bf5ca74c1a56250083be34", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398817.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398817.jpg", "width": 332}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-26259a9486f2076d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "green"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "d7b1a9cc714c458dd779a4238233bd22a98e66933f2d8f406f9812ed20f1172f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0a11de7e09392ce2b2be5154dc9473c27c4c0385b34632c190c4b8712c41678b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13342030", "text": "What is the brown bird standing on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray", "green", "pink"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "d7b1a9cc714c458dd779a4238233bd22a98e66933f2d8f406f9812ed20f1172f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "12d3f37f40e3eff6a25b7547e811bf855c803fe0c5d437d592af609945279aee"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06165572", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9787, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "14933fd742c41af710a9d9c5bc3562e026e40960491c124b05f4eb54d1acaeaa", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "06165572", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the black bird standing on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird standing on?", "program_group_hash": "14933fd742c41af710a9d9c5bc3562e026e40960491c124b05f4eb54d1acaeaa", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "bird"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird standing on?", "program_group_hash": "14933fd742c41af710a9d9c5bc3562e026e40960491c124b05f4eb54d1acaeaa", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "bird"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "branch", "full_answer": "The bird is standing on the branch.", "question": "What is the brown bird standing on?", "question_id": "13342030", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (1246309)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (1246319)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "rock", "full_answer": "The bird is standing on the rock.", "question": "What is the black bird standing on?", "question_id": "06165572", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (421791)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (421792)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1246310", "1246311", "1246312", "1246313", "1246314", "1246315", "1246316", "1246317", "1246318", "1246319", "1246320", "1246321", "1246322", "1246323", "1246324"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["branch"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "shiny", "wet"], "query_target_entity_id": "1246319", "query_target_entity_name": "branch", "relation_object_entity_id": "1246319", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1246309", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1246309", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1246309"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["421792", "421793", "421794", "421795", "421796", "421797", "421798", "421800", "421801", "421802", "421803", "421805", "421806", "421808"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["rock"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "421792", "query_target_entity_name": "rock", "relation_object_entity_id": "421792", "relation_subject_entity_id": "421791", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "421791", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["421791"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:3abab0855fa7f6d62bf0d1bac5289420", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e93414a2dd5f9a10a9eb70006ce0a79ac1c39436182cfd78d9c9797e411a171e", "image_sha256_b": "e027bb6cfcc1930e3726307d8a6c7da2a677bec251bf5ca74c1a56250083be34", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "943b10f541f09f4784735ea9f1410817dca6512b828bc376b6782988691ed29b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "250ec4302fe782931d6e34d4b4bcf7f3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b9fc6be9d71c1b920ec075fc96d10f5c608ebd61c1e2bbc3a92a46f74b29bd51"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6c111a58de5f6545340d3a8049fc649b315e8682d13fdb9ab0f540b47b77462f", "request_id": "c52b63f77e7bd2d05568af01232acf30", "response_sha256": "3a805d894b95d4b739ada87f7de9eb704aebe790cbf28a6aae555a79f63aa3ad", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "aaa0a53959f806b40f96c9a9c799ae55a16c5f806765f9afd602b8e16cdb4884", "request_id": "3c14da3d52d9821fec21bdd6d18de9f8", "response_sha256": "c31725ffa8cfa0e25c69c0e4e4e037e6fcda38031bc0c6e2e5c594396a5c189c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "d6579d461b42e0034f1c0271a08eafba", "candidate_priority_rank": 9805, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-741fbc18f18b8078:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-741fbc18f18b8078:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-741fbc18f18b8078:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-741fbc18f18b8078:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "standing<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "standing", "B": "walking"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "standing<->walking", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 401, "image_id": "2405653", "image_sha256": "07731bfb32559b17d14be5020162520e05f26df734e6219a43244e1c0b67c3ac", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405653.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405653.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2403302", "image_sha256": "c89281858641fc5e5971ac802cf125233a3661807c644072d886f3dc497f257c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2403302.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2403302.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-741fbc18f18b8078", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "standing", "diff_b": "walking", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "standing", "component_b": "walking"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "3eafefa1f150106ecb0f6ac9d4f2a101a7bef14f0cf770523ae085376fa163c7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e28d39eaf0b51772839cf848d5d3a6ddad024b35983dd61f5c3e840e3c47979e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09755172", "text": "What is the person that is standing carrying?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "3eafefa1f150106ecb0f6ac9d4f2a101a7bef14f0cf770523ae085376fa163c7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "aa7c7006aa8cb0446d7628663df50887837d1c0e4f6d66aaadb1a38546e7dee9"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11789168", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9805, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "74fbf935582792afa8d9a7dadb0eb2d773e980ca6ef4ccefd7454dfa745b7414", "selected_component": "walking", "selected_source_question_id": "11789168", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is walking carrying?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is carrying?", "program_group_hash": "74fbf935582792afa8d9a7dadb0eb2d773e980ca6ef4ccefd7454dfa745b7414", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "carrying", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is carrying?", "program_group_hash": "74fbf935582792afa8d9a7dadb0eb2d773e980ca6ef4ccefd7454dfa745b7414", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "carrying", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "umbrella", "full_answer": "The woman is carrying an umbrella.", "question": "What is the person that is standing carrying?", "question_id": "09755172", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1106869)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o (1106868)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stick", "full_answer": "The person is carrying a stick.", "question": "What is the person that is walking carrying?", "question_id": "11789168", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1126118)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o (1126119)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1106868", "1106872", "1106874", "1106875", "1106876", "1106877", "1106878", "1106881", "1106882", "1106884", "1106885", "1106886", "1106887", "1106888"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["umbrella"], "predicate": "carrying", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "tilted"], "query_target_entity_id": "1106868", "query_target_entity_name": "umbrella", "relation_object_entity_id": "1106868", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1106869", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1106869", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1106869"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1126111", "1126112", "1126114", "1126115", "1126117", "1126119", "1126121", "1126122", "1126123", "1126124", "1126125", "1126126", "1126127", "1126129", "1126130", "1126134"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stick"], "predicate": "carrying", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1126119", "query_target_entity_name": "stick", "relation_object_entity_id": "1126119", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1126118", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1126118", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1126118"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:d6579d461b42e0034f1c0271a08eafba", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "07731bfb32559b17d14be5020162520e05f26df734e6219a43244e1c0b67c3ac", "image_sha256_b": "c89281858641fc5e5971ac802cf125233a3661807c644072d886f3dc497f257c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7ea9f56a80c224f4d329183b7e7ea8261fc6e5c2845dd3bddf79615e272c6177", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "cc4fb35203239e875226151dd33e8dd2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "8554d27c522dc32c6fa76afddc64314ee85a8f46fa8a635f0389d1d8211cdf66"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f8e0fb94677188edc5ca5e2575bcf5046ba7ca367b2d46ec92fee6cb64800f13", "request_id": "44caf31481654e20e2f6f2232b267fa2", "response_sha256": "7d5d3ea0fa41941f3f64fe522cde3512824df028532aacccaf6f21e0f8f19220", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f9357d5c1a0191078ba8248dc109528fcf00ee3ecd005376d0dde8b935af4abb", "request_id": "c43e5911ef41157b3582ae2595428278", "response_sha256": "fa8c3ccce2e8b0093abb580196ac259daa4bd93b98bb0bbe0f335bd89a04e48a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "714b21e1f1100dde5ba341919ee8bd1b", "candidate_priority_rank": 10064, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-62a5ac6f5721b9b5:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-62a5ac6f5721b9b5:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-62a5ac6f5721b9b5:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-62a5ac6f5721b9b5:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->yellow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "yellow"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->yellow", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 438, "image_id": "2334053", "image_sha256": "3de27106fcebf596e98cb85d524852c4418a069590a9b4563fd2357b74e15fa0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2334053.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2334053.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2340448", "image_sha256": "7a5726e2fcc554c171c4db9cae74893bb62115fc0ccd4a65a9452ead4645b749", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2340448.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2340448.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-62a5ac6f5721b9b5", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "yellow", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "yellow"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "209d6ab539b608547c8edd044c8b8d31b7ffc2acbee08bcf370043a3a86d9d3d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["container", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["container", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "23ff4fd8229808c90fdf0229212771d5b192ebfe15cb1f96c939fc453ac6ffea"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11844882", "text": "What is the piece of furniture that the black container is sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "pink", "purple", "red", "silver", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["yellow"], "masked_program_sha256": "209d6ab539b608547c8edd044c8b8d31b7ffc2acbee08bcf370043a3a86d9d3d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["container", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yellow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["container", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3808517724cc25a6edd9acf7889fdad8b93eae4b9d7890c143464289cba51141"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05894175", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 10064, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c451ef17526d8d05f0708be81e6e05aca7ab4505070b3414043f3dfa4086f71b", "selected_component": "yellow", "selected_source_question_id": "05894175", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the piece of furniture that the yellow container is sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "container", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that the container is sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "c451ef17526d8d05f0708be81e6e05aca7ab4505070b3414043f3dfa4086f71b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "container"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "container", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that the container is sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "c451ef17526d8d05f0708be81e6e05aca7ab4505070b3414043f3dfa4086f71b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "container"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dresser", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a dresser.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that the black container is sitting on?", "question_id": "11844882", "semantic": [{"argument": "container (3194907)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (3186976)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a table.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that the yellow container is sitting on?", "question_id": "05894175", "semantic": [{"argument": "container (3421743)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "yellow", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (3388568)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2875660", "3186976"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dresser"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "3186976", "query_target_entity_name": "dresser", "relation_object_entity_id": "3186976", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3194907", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "3194907", "selected_entity_name": "box"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3194907"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3388568"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "3388568", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "3388568", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3421743", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3421743", "selected_entity_name": "container"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3421743"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:714b21e1f1100dde5ba341919ee8bd1b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3de27106fcebf596e98cb85d524852c4418a069590a9b4563fd2357b74e15fa0", "image_sha256_b": "7a5726e2fcc554c171c4db9cae74893bb62115fc0ccd4a65a9452ead4645b749", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "bc0078aaf0fe120dd4aca2f40b32cb73250e2768e4ef4a2d5814f28498c27b8b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "eafa1c51e49548c5a1a169add7729f58", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7fa33491d83682df65b4b3a02199e992bcf02e5ae06af0996be824eacacb34c9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "23a88c6f06a88d698ad6f340a7c7a8665b71bee8e16d22e987fe387721081a45", "request_id": "33149e0d4df74a9bacfd67d22b0e009e", "response_sha256": "fc1542ab4bdda6d5d2785acba6c838eba24df02db2e961c6a11c1fcc9f8957bc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "edd147643d87b22b875659c396529cd16cdeede5ec1c8412961ba477219f6f82", "request_id": "f764189731b5a01482bcdc11ac201782", "response_sha256": "9dd7323962d3901a1b45fad8b8a633190281b439ee40a3745dd1e74c9759b040", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "7e04bee2ceb7a1578906d0a0b848a421", "candidate_priority_rank": 10065, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-58366257a3ed0755:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-58366257a3ed0755:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-58366257a3ed0755:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-58366257a3ed0755:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "green<->yellow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "yellow"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->yellow", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2385442", "image_sha256": "a5e12faeef874afa86f02b8c6c97d8540a1b3003e83df28fa505cd0e67cb479f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2385442.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2385442.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 768, "image_id": "498184", "image_sha256": "12e94f1643fa1586c65562efca2e7fb98a8c366971c5da1439da2aeaeb162b32", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/498184.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/498184.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-58366257a3ed0755", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "yellow", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "yellow"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "dark", "green", "red", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "2973084cd525afcfd5c247a73c9c2a039844f0cc431963cf2dc47154209285b4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8cc82700fb285b6684b44a6dd92b7c3e7e525686aa1a732703f757ee24ddfe0f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03290912", "text": "What is on the green pole?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "red", "silver", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["yellow"], "masked_program_sha256": "2973084cd525afcfd5c247a73c9c2a039844f0cc431963cf2dc47154209285b4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yellow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d7655540b14116704dc96ca320bf5d5f4a1f7b6f0fcbade405b5391c4ece59f0"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02347929", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 10065, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 55, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "476cbbc136ee064c2fd7ac2cad33873eeee8b6e378c20fb3af17bd6a7108bc09", "selected_component": "yellow", "selected_source_question_id": "02347929", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the yellow pole?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pole", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the pole?", "program_group_hash": "476cbbc136ee064c2fd7ac2cad33873eeee8b6e378c20fb3af17bd6a7108bc09", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pole"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "pole", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the pole?", "program_group_hash": "476cbbc136ee064c2fd7ac2cad33873eeee8b6e378c20fb3af17bd6a7108bc09", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pole"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "street sign", "full_answer": "The street sign is on the pole.", "question": "What is on the green pole?", "question_id": "03290912", "semantic": [{"argument": "pole (1296770)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1296760)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "umbrella", "full_answer": "The umbrella is on the pole.", "question": "What is on the yellow pole?", "question_id": "02347929", "semantic": [{"argument": "pole (4421937)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "yellow", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (4421936)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1296760", "1296761", "1296762", "1296764", "1296765", "1296766", "1296767", "1296768", "1296769", "1296771", "1296772", "1296773", "1296774", "1296775", "1296778", "1296780", "1296781", "1296782", "1296783"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["street sign"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["dark"], "query_target_entity_id": "1296760", "query_target_entity_name": "street sign", "relation_object_entity_id": "1296770", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1296760", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1296770", "selected_entity_name": "pole"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1296770"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4421909", "4421921", "4421926", "4421927", "4421928", "4421931", "4421934", "4421935", "4421936", "4421938", "4421942", "4421946", "4421948", "4421950", "4421951", "4421952", "4421955", "4421959", "4421969"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["umbrella"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["colorful", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "4421936", "query_target_entity_name": "umbrella", "relation_object_entity_id": "4421937", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4421936", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4421937", "selected_entity_name": "pole"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4421937"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:7e04bee2ceb7a1578906d0a0b848a421", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a5e12faeef874afa86f02b8c6c97d8540a1b3003e83df28fa505cd0e67cb479f", "image_sha256_b": "12e94f1643fa1586c65562efca2e7fb98a8c366971c5da1439da2aeaeb162b32", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "72b4207173942d7de1e8c87181d18aab486bfce21ece9e3a0b17151b2cdf95a8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "05eb044422117a8b45b97cf0607ee9f2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0f2d00405e33f431cb2bc7e703b777538a003ed0dee5418e3fb70de2b373df0b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "aec0800a781c610c7a52c1f8d6af1c746052fb124617f8801fe5f64764bddea4", "request_id": "2165fc34744dc1142a5cd77520603afe", "response_sha256": "907be78b5f40c83b1ae93e9b97bb0a6d9ae2222c9de72412c104b2a318166fe8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f5011b166e8ffba590a36c4d8c3618489356eedac7b55daf7ff1087aeb256481", "request_id": "d1ed4ec2cccff74218fbf86bf55c291e", "response_sha256": "29c4f93b2b0dd442f26e64c7068c4649a0b25cd261912400a599e548ba265980", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "19442f68b3760bcb25968c41c71ae702", "candidate_priority_rank": 10117, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d31d9f53dfddb0bb:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d31d9f53dfddb0bb:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d31d9f53dfddb0bb:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d31d9f53dfddb0bb:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "white<->yellow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "yellow", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "yellow<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 354, "image_id": "2343966", "image_sha256": "4c028232ea60016699aac2e2477287714151be9c35906e5c38c9d100c2cbd96e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343966.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343966.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "4848", "image_sha256": "13791d708e0867d0601e68a5c500fbf8f7ea4e49d8576ab72b46e1964ce5bde2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/4848.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/4848.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d31d9f53dfddb0bb", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "yellow", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "yellow", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["light brown", "red", "silver", "tan", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["yellow"], "masked_program_sha256": "53b527c386fb718e3afdfb3a1d1f89073b0bd01710876e889d9ca0437d4f1856", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yellow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "750d5f71d6d80b30741259fc5eca041a5e90c2d14832a91692d5affddd6f4ac5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19694538", "text": "What is in the yellow bowl?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "53b527c386fb718e3afdfb3a1d1f89073b0bd01710876e889d9ca0437d4f1856", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "299e93e97a190f167c2ada9903d3412329874d24440806cd5a30cface2d516cd"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17694000", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 10117, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 31, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "56a905337fd3ba9c5d8b80e4ab730c875e10489cd0ea04eedc65471cbb12eb6d", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "17694000", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the white bowl?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bowl", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bowl?", "program_group_hash": "56a905337fd3ba9c5d8b80e4ab730c875e10489cd0ea04eedc65471cbb12eb6d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bowl", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bowl?", "program_group_hash": "56a905337fd3ba9c5d8b80e4ab730c875e10489cd0ea04eedc65471cbb12eb6d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bananas", "full_answer": "The bananas are in the bowl.", "question": "What is in the yellow bowl?", "question_id": "19694538", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (3495578)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "yellow", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (2541644)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "utensil", "full_answer": "The utensil is in the bowl.", "question": "What is in the white bowl?", "question_id": "17694000", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (1563551)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (1563581)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2311780", "2465419", "2499771", "2513776", "2541644", "2558842", "2928525", "3023921", "3065881", "3073936", "3108664", "3206664", "3412353", "3444008", "3634795", "3634796"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bananas"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["ripe", "yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "2541644", "query_target_entity_name": "bananas", "relation_object_entity_id": "3495578", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2541644", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3495578", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3495578"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1563548", "1563550", "1563552", "1563553", "1563556", "1563571", "1563573", "1563576", "1563578", "1563579", "1563581", "1563582", "1563583", "1563584", "1563585", "1563587", "1563588", "1563600", "1563609", "1563614", "1563615", "1563619", "1563621"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 23, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["utensil"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1563581", "query_target_entity_name": "utensil", "relation_object_entity_id": "1563551", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1563581", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1563551", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1563551"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:19442f68b3760bcb25968c41c71ae702", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4c028232ea60016699aac2e2477287714151be9c35906e5c38c9d100c2cbd96e", "image_sha256_b": "13791d708e0867d0601e68a5c500fbf8f7ea4e49d8576ab72b46e1964ce5bde2", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f70ac2696990a132b8efa3c778dd8d7318a3bce27e25f8f1c4b1b46cc4317961", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "51d659f1f18363830e30f1fe86538d28", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6f2e1b6113e9c3648e13db78868cd350f7109c266a4cd6948c882914a0b520b2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c92bc7a09ea22f19b948a34b236734e6f9526a94adb095fd5c34bc138de418ed", "request_id": "c24e42f8d0b6de02811e9818300f7668", "response_sha256": "b73fb4884bcd25d91e741c8458c2ca80e0d2efe738ceb957afaf5f50dc594db1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4b89ea251a99efbf4861efbbe7242e76ab5e2892ba551163db4c4ab0b33f8e64", "request_id": "e5d7d850e5aa7f9a843f9865bd44f3f0", "response_sha256": "063274a40e0df1572d0a8ec979461ebec2b94dd0d600612c1290093ee10a8e73", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "0fb26088b18e134a62362857ccffd9d0", "candidate_priority_rank": 7798, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-85278f8839229d05:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-85278f8839229d05:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-85278f8839229d05:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-85278f8839229d05:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dark<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "dark", "B": "green"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dark<->green", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2412250", "image_sha256": "d80db705ff6e68f8c0d296290cd40b8c3366a54f1a1f0f4e95b561cfb6993f02", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412250.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412250.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2380482", "image_sha256": "ed0860289c0664b1c305a0d29a534595ae220a7148430e0a2d43a98a145a5b48", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2380482.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2380482.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-85278f8839229d05", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dark", "diff_b": "green", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dark", "component_b": "green"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "dark", "gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["dark"], "masked_program_sha256": "8d6781728c476073c969cb45e8f888df5ba0a05469452a4d84b91db972b63676", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dark", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "83a28efdba2a967065854100af750b1e342761960d0fa99d945f743ef9dc2731"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06347770", "text": "What is the dark bird sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "gray", "green", "orange", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "8d6781728c476073c969cb45e8f888df5ba0a05469452a4d84b91db972b63676", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d9dc6eee8589d81cbe8fff39e4cd65c37e13a5928d3d55063d35f810aa820375"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16274798", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 7798, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6814cd36a0323009d5d777e18afac13365277e71d445e54c1692a47278b62659", "selected_component": "green", "selected_source_question_id": "16274798", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the green bird sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "6814cd36a0323009d5d777e18afac13365277e71d445e54c1692a47278b62659", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "bird"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "6814cd36a0323009d5d777e18afac13365277e71d445e54c1692a47278b62659", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "bird"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "wall", "full_answer": "The bird is sitting on the wall.", "question": "What is the dark bird sitting on?", "question_id": "06347770", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (199276)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dark", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (199294)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "laptop", "full_answer": "The bird is sitting on the laptop computer.", "question": "What is the green bird sitting on?", "question_id": "16274798", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (710432)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (710438)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["199274", "199275", "199277", "199278", "199280", "199281", "199282", "199284", "199285", "199286", "199287", "199290", "199291", "199292", "199294"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wall"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "199294", "query_target_entity_name": "wall", "relation_object_entity_id": "199294", "relation_subject_entity_id": "199276", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "199276", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["199276"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["710433", "710434", "710435", "710436", "710437", "710438", "710439", "710440", "710441", "710444", "710445", "710448", "710450"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["laptop"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "710438", "query_target_entity_name": "laptop", "relation_object_entity_id": "710438", "relation_subject_entity_id": "710432", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "710432", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["710432"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:0fb26088b18e134a62362857ccffd9d0", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d80db705ff6e68f8c0d296290cd40b8c3366a54f1a1f0f4e95b561cfb6993f02", "image_sha256_b": "ed0860289c0664b1c305a0d29a534595ae220a7148430e0a2d43a98a145a5b48", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b2e3a95d72e94ef9f169a9a9b0635f09bb9d61ca5f0f1a1e31aae21aaacc25a3", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "de8a7de306c39cfebecb6f5234787ab9", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f39ad28ac00674fafd53b786a2afd325e5b4aa4f38d15ee4a7f8aadcc2328036"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a1e3c8d9a2e186c34618abc56456cb33e3635a191ffe34953796dbe45e63f042", "request_id": "d20d14e6c46431a95b6fac9e0b99e652", "response_sha256": "8376b3e200ffe18ae9b68ab17a93d3930a10a7c75ad7754c8eba8cb23c3c79c3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "befd86d301abb25392713b1c190009b7a9ad63320a6ca855ba8af58be2093ba9", "request_id": "f0771814f6cc6182308e70de21c34177", "response_sha256": "75662df716bd1305990169063bd9a4aa562e9ad77ef3bbc5026d0d9c29e0a4b8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "41b8749e44d5094f9831efa4682db134", "candidate_priority_rank": 0, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c2f8b9361c755aa1:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c2f8b9361c755aa1:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c2f8b9361c755aa1:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c2f8b9361c755aa1:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "gold<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gold", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gold<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2399232", "image_sha256": "ccc31695a5d757cd632fbe2fa64dd6004597814154ec09d788f741d4e5582875", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399232.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399232.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2399921", "image_sha256": "f98d02d6fb1fb1f76872a9c0b045514a22148d42d6a659aa05999b57487881a9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399921.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399921.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c2f8b9361c755aa1", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gold", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gold", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "gold", "green", "red"], "detected_components": ["gold"], "masked_program_sha256": "6119ff0fca6fe375306c7f08fb3378707e4d6bdc3c7f848bf6667367e8a560bf", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gold", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5174c716afa6006f7b173e1e7dc470704b0f4b247cc6c87298cd6ed7d26594a6"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06717944", "text": "What is under the gold plate?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "6119ff0fca6fe375306c7f08fb3378707e4d6bdc3c7f848bf6667367e8a560bf", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "79cb36997f14272ea9b8a6e00451be2ed8c598e29ad613a372088061f27db76a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17656789", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 0, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "63e9816af684ebb26fdc83dd6eeb26285bae4f9d9da7205d0235250d069e022a", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "17656789", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is under the white plate?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is under the plate?", "program_group_hash": "63e9816af684ebb26fdc83dd6eeb26285bae4f9d9da7205d0235250d069e022a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is under the plate?", "program_group_hash": "63e9816af684ebb26fdc83dd6eeb26285bae4f9d9da7205d0235250d069e022a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "plate"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The table is under the plate.", "question": "What is under the gold plate?", "question_id": "06717944", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (418064)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gold", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,under,s (418065)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The table is under the plate.", "question": "What is under the white plate?", "question_id": "17656789", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (1164774)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,under,s (1164780)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["418059", "418065", "418069", "418071", "418076", "418079", "418082", "418083", "418085", "418086", "418091", "418092", "418093", "418099", "418101", "418104", "418105"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["fancy"], "query_target_entity_id": "418065", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "418064", "relation_subject_entity_id": "418065", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "418064", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gold", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["418064"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gold", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1164773", "1164775", "1164776", "1164777", "1164779", "1164780", "1164781"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1164780", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "1164774", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1164780", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1164774", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1164774"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:41b8749e44d5094f9831efa4682db134", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ccc31695a5d757cd632fbe2fa64dd6004597814154ec09d788f741d4e5582875", "image_sha256_b": "f98d02d6fb1fb1f76872a9c0b045514a22148d42d6a659aa05999b57487881a9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e0910a763fb3f2667d2fbf40933c8c5557d8430ea2bffbabe0d03aa04dcc8af4", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "735a1d185279dcaf5837d0fdb4714a4c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "757041b5060ca0d508d1795c6788ef76abe4ad22cfb771561ed3d0ca0759eb30"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6a5448fd79fdc6072bc01b1eb0e5320a85736b42cfbf30c905efc802dc19a9bd", "request_id": "1bbb660de4b3c985dba88cd04dc9b078", "response_sha256": "a286bc2033065e917a1bc026721c49b8c8d230c8c3c0d4cbf851052796b8d10a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "798c8a1101647bad8be7cb69f7fe262eb3d5d275dfde10e30763a90699a5ebf5", "request_id": "09fb2ce54f75859ba44422d0c00f4f5d", "response_sha256": "7a19ecd155d0df0a1a4c49ed841eb5b8e57a7062b31cc522ce61bbe03698648d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "3928af5ddada5004e08a25ce78760f12", "candidate_priority_rank": 7, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5097f5ebb66ff546:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5097f5ebb66ff546:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5097f5ebb66ff546:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5097f5ebb66ff546:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2382159", "image_sha256": "1c8af7d29345bf5977fb668f34c99d6beb246cebc265311908cb08ca47b98b62", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382159.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382159.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2407968", "image_sha256": "5722d4c963be0feafc0e924d213f5d3a60c7cd3854b93088520d1ab2ddb7052e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407968.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407968.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5097f5ebb66ff546", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "dark", "red"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7a0994aa1383bc7f1c7329a5d805dffd1939235482f9eb08d3d80d44e66ef59c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19708194", "text": "What is the brown animal lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "615094ad419cb47e1862fb93711dae5d33609fe4ef76e418024f4e7facf281ff"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14984383", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 7, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "14984383", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the white animal lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "ground", "full_answer": "The giraffe is lying on the ground.", "question": "What is the brown animal lying on?", "question_id": "19708194", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (698806)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (698816)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "ground", "full_answer": "The animal is lying on the ground.", "question": "What is the white animal lying on?", "question_id": "14984383", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (650339)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (650337)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["698805", "698807", "698808", "698809", "698810", "698811", "698812", "698813", "698814", "698815", "698816", "698817", "698818", "698819", "698820", "698821", "698822", "698823", "698824", "698825", "698826", "698828", "698829", "698832", "698839"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 25, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ground"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "698816", "query_target_entity_name": "ground", "relation_object_entity_id": "698816", "relation_subject_entity_id": "698806", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "698806", "selected_entity_name": "giraffe"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["698806"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["650331", "650332", "650333", "650334", "650335", "650336", "650337", "650338", "650341", "650342", "650344"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ground"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["rocky"], "query_target_entity_id": "650337", "query_target_entity_name": "ground", "relation_object_entity_id": "650337", "relation_subject_entity_id": "650339", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "650339", "selected_entity_name": "animal"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["650339"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:3928af5ddada5004e08a25ce78760f12", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1c8af7d29345bf5977fb668f34c99d6beb246cebc265311908cb08ca47b98b62", "image_sha256_b": "5722d4c963be0feafc0e924d213f5d3a60c7cd3854b93088520d1ab2ddb7052e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d04688d120cbc96e63a11debab04f27242832e9ab1d86ac0fe628ad0d5ec8fc5", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "bf955ae7e8dbc7bf72d0c19dc19cb14a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2af835cca2e6e390bbcbc15861f112182ecdbfd225d7a7f349444a02842b8daf"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8d004bde868938e8b4cc84ac7532e6d54bba495a28d941748f4560921ee3e229", "request_id": "dda739ac6812b8bcfe919a55022cde01", "response_sha256": "95b48e9cbfc76ac8ec29ba2f999090acf5944a65a09a14b2b85adacb9a7639d0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cb62ac11e66cfae4978c55eae42a442ba5763c18a8161f82dc47615adbc2d4c5", "request_id": "f730819b0bda7b55b231eef21c761984", "response_sha256": "61ddf045c9b7eb84c38802bcc92292da58bad96348893a6abb541da79c5285b3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a583f1c0bab41a168cfff120fce3469e", "candidate_priority_rank": 11, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9233bd231a027867:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9233bd231a027867:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9233bd231a027867:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9233bd231a027867:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "gray<->red", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "red", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "red<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2345391", "image_sha256": "5f71f4d05bcf8bd7ce81ff6e475d49c544e66419843987deec9039312e0c8953", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345391.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345391.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2329464", "image_sha256": "439862a81431c83a57024d84d864c4772a89dda7d64e1ef51f86f5ae8f650dff", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2329464.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2329464.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9233bd231a027867", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "red", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "red", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["orange", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "5b049cdc7c2ba3cd12526d188cb39b014edbe1d7443300f7393f98fd43b290c4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "cd658345b3fd4406f97fa6b3ff5c08ff0f351ed83cd01d6e7d71eacee7d8daa7"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02468100", "text": "What animal is in the red bag?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["gray"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "5b049cdc7c2ba3cd12526d188cb39b014edbe1d7443300f7393f98fd43b290c4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dd8b9a76341c38e5d2525e3854d096865b3b714784177adaad3cdaec6929fd31"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03608521", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 11, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a33616df8a943b1d8cc6bb36848421eb9c918d556851ed8f3c0d613ec3e78133", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "03608521", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in the gray bag?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bag", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in the bag?", "program_group_hash": "a33616df8a943b1d8cc6bb36848421eb9c918d556851ed8f3c0d613ec3e78133", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bag"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bag", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in the bag?", "program_group_hash": "a33616df8a943b1d8cc6bb36848421eb9c918d556851ed8f3c0d613ec3e78133", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bag"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is in the bag.", "question": "What animal is in the red bag?", "question_id": "02468100", "semantic": [{"argument": "bag (2322756)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (2300053)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is in the bag.", "question": "What animal is in the gray bag?", "question_id": "03608521", "semantic": [{"argument": "bag (3083657)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (3111474)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2300053"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2300053", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "2322756", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2300053", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2322756", "selected_entity_name": "bag"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2322756"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3111474"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3111474", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "3083657", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3111474", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3083657", "selected_entity_name": "bag"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3083657"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:a583f1c0bab41a168cfff120fce3469e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5f71f4d05bcf8bd7ce81ff6e475d49c544e66419843987deec9039312e0c8953", "image_sha256_b": "439862a81431c83a57024d84d864c4772a89dda7d64e1ef51f86f5ae8f650dff", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "914f4f84ac2c5c005b3a8552859fbe1cc8cd615aabfbf14403f670b957c13f94", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "6f65b2cf0e82b43e72e18f117627c7fe", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7655e72ca446b1c6464a7ba7cc3e763a6d8ccd0de6379c7056b480a61545718f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e9a53930974d64a4115a741f0b98928b926a46ad8c6684e423cdd537ff31c52c", "request_id": "c8f94f21c1ca034b8b8c74c2a8c5c676", "response_sha256": "6f830933da61f734d9c01b15f50168cc755696dbae15a6f0a6c895dc1a059655", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fae57edcb0138f106d5a9ec68a0bef52552ea56d620d1fda1c5d0a3c3a7ee9f1", "request_id": "7f054d7c084378b5cc95b5d570e11a03", "response_sha256": "1701d1978d8575fc1fd112d6fc65bcbd9eba48e5283e668084430c9c720e0c1a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "1f0429db483dd25658cda5f882c3dc72", "candidate_priority_rank": 13, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c39573b24ac7bc6d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c39573b24ac7bc6d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c39573b24ac7bc6d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c39573b24ac7bc6d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "round<->square", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "square", "B": "round"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "square<->round", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2370832", "image_sha256": "322ac729da842f559b976c17278a2ef372c09e3b0cf1c164633f95c7d222641c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2370832.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2370832.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2409955", "image_sha256": "8738feb57b0a4895ae0413078f4b8a88b29a877b2a863db1d29766d09c68d97d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2409955.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2409955.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c39573b24ac7bc6d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "square", "diff_b": "round", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "square", "component_b": "round"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["square"], "detected_components": ["square"], "masked_program_sha256": "5686fad8c72f449e482a79e83e574d90e1d11e448d8261b8d88ad5f4f6468820", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "square", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "75da7a124f6d7e97515a8d9953bf1b457f6f899a3cf7ee9769aa511b514bcc4b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06521501", "text": "What is on the square plate?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["round"], "detected_components": ["round"], "masked_program_sha256": "5686fad8c72f449e482a79e83e574d90e1d11e448d8261b8d88ad5f4f6468820", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "round", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "61414e21d730500cb98ec881f2183ecd03fd6f5e90a4e3004e3aefceca22dcef"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05872295", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "98750e4c5875a22daf1536bbec77f08d94ac55d48e1af87a2f664ce41376160c", "selected_component": "round", "selected_source_question_id": "05872295", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the round plate?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "shape", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the plate?", "program_group_hash": "98750e4c5875a22daf1536bbec77f08d94ac55d48e1af87a2f664ce41376160c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "shape", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the plate?", "program_group_hash": "98750e4c5875a22daf1536bbec77f08d94ac55d48e1af87a2f664ce41376160c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bread", "full_answer": "The bread is on the plate.", "question": "What is on the square plate?", "question_id": "06521501", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (3498986)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "square", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (3414198)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pancakes", "full_answer": "The pancakes are on the plate.", "question": "What is on the round plate?", "question_id": "05872295", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (229463)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "round", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (229471)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2143120", "2440894", "2891097", "2891098", "2891099", "3024087", "3107155", "3414198"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bread"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["huge", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "3414198", "query_target_entity_name": "bread", "relation_object_entity_id": "3498986", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3414198", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3498986", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "square", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3498986"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "round", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "square", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["229464", "229466", "229468", "229469", "229470", "229471", "229472", "229473", "229476", "229477", "229478", "229479", "229480", "229481", "229484"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pancakes"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["crispy"], "query_target_entity_id": "229471", "query_target_entity_name": "pancakes", "relation_object_entity_id": "229463", "relation_subject_entity_id": "229471", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "229463", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "round", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["229463"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:1f0429db483dd25658cda5f882c3dc72", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "322ac729da842f559b976c17278a2ef372c09e3b0cf1c164633f95c7d222641c", "image_sha256_b": "8738feb57b0a4895ae0413078f4b8a88b29a877b2a863db1d29766d09c68d97d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "cd8afe90c029469e96e1963e2b2b3c3b5ca86ff227d41195ebc3e4c8c5d8d91e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "054f8a3a65b17c4c87b08344f4b7a495", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "efd9bfee9db37db5a803c81014c6c605d28fd04b9f6f23a9753bdb94f709c12d"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4fa3a8700df8c0acff9a95269cc648062e3c362110accc567e72790f10a10ec8", "request_id": "49ef78be6161bafe99d3be91206ec2c7", "response_sha256": "03d7a244dd75bb09271443bc8dbd0b2af22b1d476bce00e2e8c62d14b793d975", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9f77bcc749fdcbc93d7e88f1d01b04627c4f9fe840e6eac5d5d13237ade54853", "request_id": "04a6a9f569ed45014272c7aa040e91b6", "response_sha256": "eccb9524948591cc50cda2911f08d745775159c869cad409b80453bab2e4faea", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "8931ef30ba40d7cdf7f259637077bd4c", "candidate_priority_rank": 14, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cf5bba8feff3d90f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cf5bba8feff3d90f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cf5bba8feff3d90f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cf5bba8feff3d90f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2395302", "image_sha256": "7cd07d359f49eccd1b9e957ca2ab58e566c5e19cb5e2925c5c3f8d34a6a8a275", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395302.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395302.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2316441", "image_sha256": "0ac320a54fba32dc824e339113fd5200e124c1e2b78512649e14b3f347816f98", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2316441.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2316441.jpg", "width": 326}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cf5bba8feff3d90f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "3751b18b6157581377ba49eb16a0b47577a0ca8a56361fcfdbd884795a04de2a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ef59332642b17f7cab53955d567cb80737b20a06f03bba45a3a38035b3f8dec5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10154220", "text": "What is the brown animal sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "3751b18b6157581377ba49eb16a0b47577a0ca8a56361fcfdbd884795a04de2a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fcf6d46549293df34afc3cccffea78c11dc134303cd8864d37cb69c1e852121f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02388951", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 14, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "295f904424fd112b34a4650858cb7c79040a98774f47ad61acc13d568accc777", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "02388951", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the white animal sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "295f904424fd112b34a4650858cb7c79040a98774f47ad61acc13d568accc777", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "295f904424fd112b34a4650858cb7c79040a98774f47ad61acc13d568accc777", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "ground", "full_answer": "The bear is sitting on the ground.", "question": "What is the brown animal sitting on?", "question_id": "10154220", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (456001)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (456002)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "porch", "full_answer": "The dog is sitting on the porch.", "question": "What is the white animal sitting on?", "question_id": "02388951", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (4073763)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (4073760)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["456002", "456003", "456004", "456006", "456007", "456008", "456010", "456012", "456013", "456022"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ground"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "456002", "query_target_entity_name": "ground", "relation_object_entity_id": "456002", "relation_subject_entity_id": "456001", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "456001", "selected_entity_name": "bear"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["456001"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4073682", "4073687", "4073688", "4073690", "4073695", "4073723", "4073724", "4073727", "4073732", "4073760", "4073771", "4464581", "4486746", "4486749", "4486754", "4486758", "4486760", "4486761", "4486774", "4486781", "4486785", "4486786"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["porch"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4073760", "query_target_entity_name": "porch", "relation_object_entity_id": "4073760", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4073763", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "4073763", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4073763"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:8931ef30ba40d7cdf7f259637077bd4c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7cd07d359f49eccd1b9e957ca2ab58e566c5e19cb5e2925c5c3f8d34a6a8a275", "image_sha256_b": "0ac320a54fba32dc824e339113fd5200e124c1e2b78512649e14b3f347816f98", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3c9a10f956a595563eb388a279112a43712301a23a9bccc8f5c7a976c03610c8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "70f0ad8845c1137c573d43a4fbe98186", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c7982e6048c2ec8db6c116a74043f028724fd5aaa3741da0456e5c7c52a21741"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "65e0173e0f28689bf44a0dacf02e6f4908760fa4f37760ba113697a6343cceb4", "request_id": "e69b02796e349bf730a4815281d814a8", "response_sha256": "76d441c823e1188414739f477f4c22c65f19bfce4606fbfc8c69d1f30ee78892", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "30dcfb063d6cf9260a757b719cd98b82bdefa3c80eca6810919c0fee40c7827e", "request_id": "335cd8f615431117a5da25031c50aa75", "response_sha256": "eae8396d67449df0052a74a34b04c08dc2bb1dec1faf083fd078ee595f4316d3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "74c022f2ca2e6b7803aaaa964bc5384c", "candidate_priority_rank": 20, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ae758bc67797c79a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ae758bc67797c79a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ae758bc67797c79a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ae758bc67797c79a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2390745", "image_sha256": "3ba5f8f891aee41276b015cefa573b8468c8d4091e766466d74dd7e0ffe99f1f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390745.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390745.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 392, "image_id": "2319764", "image_sha256": "0f3643211a8dc18a1892bdc804294e17d3f5286a6eec467fb436e15f2c605cec", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2319764.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2319764.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-ae758bc67797c79a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7a0994aa1383bc7f1c7329a5d805dffd1939235482f9eb08d3d80d44e66ef59c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18962208", "text": "What is the brown animal lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "dark", "green", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "615094ad419cb47e1862fb93711dae5d33609fe4ef76e418024f4e7facf281ff"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10965272", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 20, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "10965272", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the white animal lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the bed.", "question": "What is the brown animal lying on?", "question_id": "18962208", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1247498)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (1247505)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "grass", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the grass.", "question": "What is the white animal lying on?", "question_id": "10965272", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (998981)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (998988)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1247502", "1247503", "1247504", "1247505", "1247506", "1247507", "1247509", "1247510", "1247511", "1247512", "1247513", "1247515"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1247505", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "1247505", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1247498", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1247498", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1247498"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["998982", "998983", "998984", "998986", "998988", "998989", "998990", "998994", "998995", "998996", "998997", "998998", "999000", "999001"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["grass"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "998988", "query_target_entity_name": "grass", "relation_object_entity_id": "998988", "relation_subject_entity_id": "998981", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "998981", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["998981"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:74c022f2ca2e6b7803aaaa964bc5384c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3ba5f8f891aee41276b015cefa573b8468c8d4091e766466d74dd7e0ffe99f1f", "image_sha256_b": "0f3643211a8dc18a1892bdc804294e17d3f5286a6eec467fb436e15f2c605cec", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "cfb0ff74127a1e5dd908c2066c583d24b3057d879f952caa80dc8193c0d55ff6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3b2a313596313573d728a53b92248847", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1c5ecae77d7dbf69fbac1d944af53b602574797298f7504d67fa69c77243845e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c4747bf7ac620fa4830f2bf7488accedcf578db5f1ecaa014e77adfd1e14d1f8", "request_id": "748a7cce90eb3e227f52aed41c170a7a", "response_sha256": "72731fbe349178832f95715a405bd665ad4778419f7b10156af9a512d6374957", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "34da9fdc621e14010ce0024a553e10dd5339c2e9a91b724d97943a0f6c0f1d64", "request_id": "60cfe499c7009f2d3f986e541076a557", "response_sha256": "af6db13c4c5cc5429871625119b0e9bc169923dd93d87e84686b10cdb423b4eb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ee807493c42474bc77e37f26cd018b50", "candidate_priority_rank": 26, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cc0dfe4fab921627:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cc0dfe4fab921627:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cc0dfe4fab921627:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cc0dfe4fab921627:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gray", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gray<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2381672", "image_sha256": "0fc26f7e4a160d517639bf625fda4a82058c09c2669cd3058a5840a9c49c5429", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2381672.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2381672.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2356701", "image_sha256": "14b6393379d0dcacb1f205ad38543e0a4dc15c645dae6ff327810dc2a68b9a1a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2356701.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2356701.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cc0dfe4fab921627", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gray", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gray", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["gray", "green", "silver", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "9fa31164193b7ae511ddd8e01571534350ccddf1b9b8c6612e6133160c42e70a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "65b37ab7ff59779d0e0549483885567bcc7f49ebf6b308ee8284dc52a80aa5f9"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "181058292", "text": "What is in front of the gray animal?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "orange", "pink"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "9fa31164193b7ae511ddd8e01571534350ccddf1b9b8c6612e6133160c42e70a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "590034034fd93988a664ea96b339058c95084708853744c577be4267da1d5d9d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13509386", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3f985ccf4bb7c968b3f509a62f52119aa0b5343ad6821aca50e1bd72bfc45b19", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "13509386", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the brown animal?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the animal?", "program_group_hash": "3f985ccf4bb7c968b3f509a62f52119aa0b5343ad6821aca50e1bd72bfc45b19", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the animal?", "program_group_hash": "3f985ccf4bb7c968b3f509a62f52119aa0b5343ad6821aca50e1bd72bfc45b19", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "fence", "full_answer": "The fence is in front of the elephant.", "question": "What is in front of the gray animal?", "question_id": "181058292", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1334842)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (1334844)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "lid", "full_answer": "The lid is in front of the dog.", "question": "What is in front of the brown animal?", "question_id": "13509386", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (817992)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (818000)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1334839", "1334840", "1334841", "1334843", "1334844", "1334845", "1334846", "1334847", "1334848", "1334850", "1334851", "1334852", "1334853", "1334854", "1334855", "1334856", "1334857", "1334858", "1334859", "1334861", "1334862"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fence"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "1334844", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "1334842", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1334844", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1334842", "selected_entity_name": "elephant"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1334842"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["817993", "817994", "817996", "817998", "817999", "818000", "818020", "818021"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["lid"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["metal", "pink", "round"], "query_target_entity_id": "818000", "query_target_entity_name": "lid", "relation_object_entity_id": "817992", "relation_subject_entity_id": "818000", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "817992", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["817992"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:ee807493c42474bc77e37f26cd018b50", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "0fc26f7e4a160d517639bf625fda4a82058c09c2669cd3058a5840a9c49c5429", "image_sha256_b": "14b6393379d0dcacb1f205ad38543e0a4dc15c645dae6ff327810dc2a68b9a1a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "2972cbd08d61ffc32266330897ed634f35148d120a7ca15e614a090e7e271222", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1ce9ca072c599e5a58c576b6aefb939b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d2f7d1538fffe633febd80c3f13ec1c19fef2286f30746b6c35bbed5cca1c415"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4e4700ac86e3856c9b1cc269a20355f0ef96c5d40e1a871e6636b149b2d8d9d1", "request_id": "bab222bf7803d4856b647b7e3afa5382", "response_sha256": "79ea511cc35b7bb657647bf5c1a231f8cb24ffaf165c0ba756db755826005f94", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a85a23ada4b956d7840176474aa64ec048d8307f72b3089e195d8cc1fa13d502", "request_id": "e01fb33fc491c5e566a76cec88591fd1", "response_sha256": "f32e00b9cca563cded353184c9313452ceba3880930425a8001334c6b5049305", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "166c00549886f748b6599956195f8bc7", "candidate_priority_rank": 36, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e6b818ec5ac995cc:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e6b818ec5ac995cc:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e6b818ec5ac995cc:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e6b818ec5ac995cc:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2398076", "image_sha256": "64e068bf1e923d8e34f37841c0125a2d4aa2e909a91c42edad34ddbc14a1907e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398076.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398076.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2395146", "image_sha256": "8f49bb17469ee6cdb38d072400b4c806feb3c8e2cece3bd7e4682c3f8202c77f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395146.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395146.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e6b818ec5ac995cc", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["green", "orange", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "e73974fbbb1e95347b10ac44e012fd3e618f10f3533121a1296e672eaef142ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "68b6270601dd4e47977535e1aaf60b3e29dcbe2a8536b6ccb5cb95b11efa6bb3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02380847", "text": "What is on the white table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "e73974fbbb1e95347b10ac44e012fd3e618f10f3533121a1296e672eaef142ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "643c6b31517c9696db9dd7850fbe7c856596b2f4a9eeab27bb00d5535eb16474"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19224945", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 36, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 35, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e9930c4e445b6f97ba358331196fc75b70857cebf6e3179882feefaa6f5341f5", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "19224945", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the brown table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "e9930c4e445b6f97ba358331196fc75b70857cebf6e3179882feefaa6f5341f5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "e9930c4e445b6f97ba358331196fc75b70857cebf6e3179882feefaa6f5341f5", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bowl", "full_answer": "The bowl is on the table.", "question": "What is on the white table?", "question_id": "02380847", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (1183101)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (3820589)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "glasses", "full_answer": "The glasses are on the table.", "question": "What is on the brown table?", "question_id": "19224945", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (4391023)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (4391022)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1183100", "1183102", "3820581", "3820587", "3820589", "3820590"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bowl"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3820589", "query_target_entity_name": "bowl", "relation_object_entity_id": "1183101", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3820589", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1183101", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1183101"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4391018", "4391022", "4391027", "4391028", "4391029", "4391032", "4391033", "4391035", "4391036"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["glasses"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4391022", "query_target_entity_name": "glasses", "relation_object_entity_id": "4391023", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4391022", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4391023", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4391023"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:166c00549886f748b6599956195f8bc7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "64e068bf1e923d8e34f37841c0125a2d4aa2e909a91c42edad34ddbc14a1907e", "image_sha256_b": "8f49bb17469ee6cdb38d072400b4c806feb3c8e2cece3bd7e4682c3f8202c77f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "be1efe60384a1e6a6cf15c58c3bbe13fd654c4cfbf88341ebc8e302e837a43de", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f2b691d95feccd4dee6b95c77da01467", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6c459cfc23d3e74a4d8f00724701e0b0dc5caa23af5e52eeb824135bb7c360e7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c63526fb6538d07df85b508ddcd7e8eea787c2633e2d4c7eed0f349dea0d0fca", "request_id": "973cd64186ec00b7289180add177421c", "response_sha256": "1369a2388bbe9ebc3b72ed876a41a65bae6963eb86fe3411b4c49c8941cc14c4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dbece97022cf62ee4f00034b3fbfdb1bb33de41111fdd9a83aa095a60b06f3fe", "request_id": "981056e33bae091be6abd8993cfbcea9", "response_sha256": "de99f41eb7ac02116eec95ad5f6d8c5a95038691d0e4cce301bc1fceeb670aaa", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "f77b4f49c17a32568aa6ed7047b64849", "candidate_priority_rank": 73, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7f18c3d6a1937e14:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7f18c3d6a1937e14:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7f18c3d6a1937e14:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7f18c3d6a1937e14:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->purple", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "purple", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "purple<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2357733", "image_sha256": "802f4dd85fd18b2973523226748665d93162c0b59aff24d29a508a3118df0dcc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2357733.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2357733.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2410153", "image_sha256": "1a4831cdca750d0a7569478c63136f069c7778dfb450d547bc449ac2853e2742", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410153.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410153.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7f18c3d6a1937e14", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "purple", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "purple", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["green", "purple", "white"], "detected_components": ["purple"], "masked_program_sha256": "f572b01f3ebb6b0c5951502bc96b7722a4fe4b820205ef1b08e257cdd53634b5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "purple", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bbc3dae96d8cd7c61f9b8cf71cb26e0c9bd1f76d05999e8eab7a47b91b8f7c42"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11536084", "text": "What animal is on the purple blanket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "pink", "tan", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "f572b01f3ebb6b0c5951502bc96b7722a4fe4b820205ef1b08e257cdd53634b5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "78e68ede8813dcd6f032335ca08beb200abca6a8d09de8da3ed00babf72577ab"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16755955", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 73, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "41dc7246992025a8000a3ebe71de6cf238ff86d5fae0fddd2f64caf6948d49b1", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "16755955", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is on the blue blanket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "blanket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the blanket?", "program_group_hash": "41dc7246992025a8000a3ebe71de6cf238ff86d5fae0fddd2f64caf6948d49b1", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "blanket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "blanket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the blanket?", "program_group_hash": "41dc7246992025a8000a3ebe71de6cf238ff86d5fae0fddd2f64caf6948d49b1", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "blanket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is on the blanket.", "question": "What animal is on the purple blanket?", "question_id": "11536084", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (809263)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "purple", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (809262)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is on the blanket.", "question": "What animal is on the blue blanket?", "question_id": "16755955", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (224827)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (224815)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["809262"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "809262", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "809263", "relation_subject_entity_id": "809262", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "809263", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "purple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["809263"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "purple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["224815"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["calico", "lying", "sitting", "sleeping", "striped"], "query_target_entity_id": "224815", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "224827", "relation_subject_entity_id": "224815", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "224827", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["224827"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:f77b4f49c17a32568aa6ed7047b64849", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "802f4dd85fd18b2973523226748665d93162c0b59aff24d29a508a3118df0dcc", "image_sha256_b": "1a4831cdca750d0a7569478c63136f069c7778dfb450d547bc449ac2853e2742", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "acec696d4529491546fff057d3728ada7ecbc3f1d15c341560e0b1ea2bce0971", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "92d76c8c5df423abd90306e5e41759c5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a972d8eebca2692324b6348ece6167d7d2f48bc342a16e3a7c74d47934daa285"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cd435d9ef08cdd183fb308fb849523c294f84199b51c2a812a2e02ef83252ced", "request_id": "f352d890902f938b1bc226d932f88292", "response_sha256": "020e1d7c0cea7e9437650ddda41a8c430320c85b7d2699bb8b5d655f389af8aa", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bd5196deb938d83d49bd828f6841e22281739439b854df5e454ad4226803be9a", "request_id": "44c3adf7915ad9956e5bc8650785b98e", "response_sha256": "570b82cba1b68a134715fa7cc312fef2a84a1023c101d09931bc2378440a1845", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "6f9ff50b903d28a3244ea8fa856f3720", "candidate_priority_rank": 91, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dfc8c4a1f2ea5b43:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dfc8c4a1f2ea5b43:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dfc8c4a1f2ea5b43:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dfc8c4a1f2ea5b43:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->orange", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "orange", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "orange<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2367088", "image_sha256": "09230abcb3e8d1d46fd1005ea4c4b6e289cdf10764d5f5997e5fd7f3957a0cd3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367088.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367088.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2345547", "image_sha256": "e0cfdc40dbe82a7506aa67577655b008eb440b3689795ff429e238e7b9a43bab", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345547.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345547.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dfc8c4a1f2ea5b43", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "orange", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "orange", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "gold", "green", "orange", "purple", "white"], "detected_components": ["orange"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "orange", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2dc7ed273e3455850e04c34a9756749295062c0cb7c455a80f1c12c5f5fa1815"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1236635", "text": "What is on the orange wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blond", "brown", "dark", "gray", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b32448496bf250042d44c530e2a2a298fbd1508a0018fae8f1a8917b24015bdf"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1795804", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 91, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 27, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "1795804", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the brown wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the orange wall?", "question_id": "1236635", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (624557)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "orange", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (624536)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "mirror", "full_answer": "The mirror is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the brown wall?", "question_id": "1795804", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (907168)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (907153)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["624529", "624530", "624531", "624532", "624534", "624536", "624538", "624539", "624543", "624544", "624545", "624549", "624552", "624553", "624554", "624555", "624556"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "624536", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "624557", "relation_subject_entity_id": "624536", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "624557", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "orange", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["624557"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "orange", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["907140", "907141", "907142", "907143", "907144", "907145", "907146", "907149", "907152", "907153", "907154", "907155", "907156", "907157", "907158", "907166", "907167"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mirror"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "907153", "query_target_entity_name": "mirror", "relation_object_entity_id": "907168", "relation_subject_entity_id": "907153", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "907168", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["907168"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:6f9ff50b903d28a3244ea8fa856f3720", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "09230abcb3e8d1d46fd1005ea4c4b6e289cdf10764d5f5997e5fd7f3957a0cd3", "image_sha256_b": "e0cfdc40dbe82a7506aa67577655b008eb440b3689795ff429e238e7b9a43bab", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3e379a5e3457d1a44760c8854669f09f3880f24cdf0ec4a15c11fd63c0451ddd", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "62b4117bd83e73c1ee2263142aeaba0e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b687befe9fe7503f81d8a78f8ae05c3c10328f53def808fdbc5b0beb2f01baae"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8d7169b4dec5a4b85503fc6b59bf6e64474f377774b4d6c2533ca08089d3a4a1", "request_id": "47715ae3f2c8ad80d2eee1b49446981c", "response_sha256": "1cdc7866050254077d80c75b4d133fd495646349598d54dd06b3156af9064caf", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "89bbafe7415f1043c5b1aa526015f6bbe4ffeff957dc80f4f0bd08188dd5071d", "request_id": "307e59e734a1f360fd830a4a3a7bb0cf", "response_sha256": "f9de088e93d9dce9443a523cc44e2ad09ad03009450236c608aae7c397078c33", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "20b77f9800b75b2a7a3601b44b3b66ba", "candidate_priority_rank": 103, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-07e0c3db70d5ea4f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-07e0c3db70d5ea4f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-07e0c3db70d5ea4f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-07e0c3db70d5ea4f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2400946", "image_sha256": "5fb5880c3a040dc809ee3bb66cce3b0289c7826c960cf1c9ac29cc03be18490e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400946.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400946.jpg", "width": 374}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2325715", "image_sha256": "2017ded79417e4abc663e53f21d38b828516d8aa8eae7fdbfe0079a29306d799", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2325715.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2325715.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-07e0c3db70d5ea4f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "silver", "tan", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "615094ad419cb47e1862fb93711dae5d33609fe4ef76e418024f4e7facf281ff"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13777591", "text": "What is the white animal lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "green", "purple", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ff142e4e037216a78a86f28f47ec9c34264783cfcbdba45906bb44cd21680abb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01149684", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 103, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 20, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "01149684", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the black animal lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dish", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the dish.", "question": "What is the white animal lying on?", "question_id": "13777591", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1153378)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (1153379)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "suitcase", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the suitcase.", "question": "What is the black animal lying on?", "question_id": "01149684", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (985342)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (985345)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1153379", "1153380", "1153381", "1153383", "1153384", "1153385", "1153386", "1153387", "1153388", "1153389", "1153391", "1153392"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dish"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1153379", "query_target_entity_name": "dish", "relation_object_entity_id": "1153379", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1153378", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1153378", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1153378"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["985343", "985344", "985345", "985346", "985348", "985349", "985350", "985351", "985354", "985355", "985356", "985357"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["suitcase"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["empty", "open", "purple"], "query_target_entity_id": "985345", "query_target_entity_name": "suitcase", "relation_object_entity_id": "985345", "relation_subject_entity_id": "985342", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "985342", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["985342"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:20b77f9800b75b2a7a3601b44b3b66ba", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5fb5880c3a040dc809ee3bb66cce3b0289c7826c960cf1c9ac29cc03be18490e", "image_sha256_b": "2017ded79417e4abc663e53f21d38b828516d8aa8eae7fdbfe0079a29306d799", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b866b84cbf8480777ba6861475c8bdb9d33d586330b668199d03678a2e4cc811", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7497b0a5c2d90081a8bb382df82fb460", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "061101f47e405a4cb9aace3f6892a63637daaf56fea11747cd1a233adf5051b1"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e9b0244889a02da77f28dfb767e8d3fc67f2eace4c80dd86eaa73ce0f4f6547d", "request_id": "7ef4e8a55994ef721dc352cea7d3dd2d", "response_sha256": "4e2299b208abbc242cd74dd49a75a3cbe394ed03adfbbe6d3e5a32816780490e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cdf956b831b15396b59e60337289b5b7ebba5554563f17f8c5bb9375d1f6853a", "request_id": "79e31b539b3a72d0d3198453172fdba0", "response_sha256": "462071a299caf16986a35998c8f59e6c407b28efde0f98ba1ac627f18ffa4683", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "04348a7ba2511199210f11e0f2cbd1e7", "candidate_priority_rank": 120, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280cf5b1098068e2:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280cf5b1098068e2:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280cf5b1098068e2:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280cf5b1098068e2:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dark blue<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "dark blue", "B": "green"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dark blue<->green", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 346, "image_id": "2334108", "image_sha256": "69f0c113b03e0960cba466d06ac7982d43e7705989ea94736ea5be028ca8d9aa", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2334108.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2334108.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 357, "image_id": "2352073", "image_sha256": "6932b6a60b28d4f37e64877b9e164fcb88b83d385db0cde1c9ae6b09ef8497ee", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2352073.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2352073.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-280cf5b1098068e2", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dark blue", "diff_b": "green", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dark blue", "component_b": "green"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "dark blue"], "detected_components": ["dark blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "f77866058976e1ed9d98de9678b87aa69d364648c6c238f45da0ea05ffb22421", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dark blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "588aa333ab110d5924075704d548eb4e8502365b193a63e324d78b21187fece7"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12526364", "text": "What animal is in the dark blue water?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "green"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "f77866058976e1ed9d98de9678b87aa69d364648c6c238f45da0ea05ffb22421", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0daade2b058653d6ddabe03b15d159b1cc2b33bb5e72ee407dff3e9bf6e3c258"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09245499", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 120, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "93210a12cf36543bece01548c784b435020767279533f29bcf736cb98743aac7", "selected_component": "green", "selected_source_question_id": "09245499", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in the green water?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in the water?", "program_group_hash": "93210a12cf36543bece01548c784b435020767279533f29bcf736cb98743aac7", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in the water?", "program_group_hash": "93210a12cf36543bece01548c784b435020767279533f29bcf736cb98743aac7", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The animal is an elephant.", "question": "What animal is in the dark blue water?", "question_id": "12526364", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (3071244)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dark blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (3136599)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bear", "full_answer": "The bear is in the water.", "question": "What animal is in the green water?", "question_id": "09245499", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (2373281)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (1770154)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3136599"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3136599", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "3071244", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3136599", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3071244", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3071244"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1770154"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bear"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "1770154", "query_target_entity_name": "bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "2373281", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1770154", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2373281", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2373281"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:04348a7ba2511199210f11e0f2cbd1e7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "69f0c113b03e0960cba466d06ac7982d43e7705989ea94736ea5be028ca8d9aa", "image_sha256_b": "6932b6a60b28d4f37e64877b9e164fcb88b83d385db0cde1c9ae6b09ef8497ee", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d1a6a8be0b1c9a0f8692e813ccd2d5e14cd80f6edf4713965212146d7f1d5d5a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2b63b281e1ee333decad1f34f2fa7878", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1da61f2189a95093a4055cf3aa15448df7d28e3f73615c07a1f7a550d4050fd0"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d0f94bad214d803ef507f1a2d45c4116c29e617bfbf3ca634c20e9b490617d98", "request_id": "126a9b7a4fde89d3c5b71a489ef26853", "response_sha256": "257320cf71d8a39cf68a32f0db92663ea2e7d785273cb8f7550ce8f744ae4491", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a2f273c5f3af6d36776d092ab1b331f7257d87a75af6b3e1f50ab4710d314223", "request_id": "4b762b3a3efdb028e2139c0cdc4f41c6", "response_sha256": "32b8f8eea8fec3c5f5bc7b26a0d794c8a08ab200847005eba487d2f263ef987f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "f3be3bfbfd14f85d2b319f0868a89eb0", "candidate_priority_rank": 126, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00fabecab8141e64:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00fabecab8141e64:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00fabecab8141e64:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00fabecab8141e64:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gray", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gray<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2370845", "image_sha256": "b65d55d8674231ab270ae281167585c2872cb941c8fbb8cf0a04d85a2a7794e7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2370845.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2370845.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2317229", "image_sha256": "51f0263a54475badcd59d6758a1261d4a9439bb613de95b6e62cd704f31ae637", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317229.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317229.jpg", "width": 332}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-00fabecab8141e64", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gray", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gray", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "dark", "gray", "pink"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "f77866058976e1ed9d98de9678b87aa69d364648c6c238f45da0ea05ffb22421", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6ee8c98e1af7b2dd1460036d30a659e7aa7808bacc86f4fe8afbfeed0b9182ba"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02568875", "text": "What is the animal in the gray water?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "f77866058976e1ed9d98de9678b87aa69d364648c6c238f45da0ea05ffb22421", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9e686dd989a29c48a3dbfe6f8ba775b6d92d9433e8105240137fc2dd01072d46"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18275313", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 126, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "674e6682319b5ea2e547644e2190c78256f2223014dd0f62ba093f4645353b11", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "18275313", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal in the blue water?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal in the water?", "program_group_hash": "674e6682319b5ea2e547644e2190c78256f2223014dd0f62ba093f4645353b11", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal in the water?", "program_group_hash": "674e6682319b5ea2e547644e2190c78256f2223014dd0f62ba093f4645353b11", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The animal is a dog.", "question": "What is the animal in the gray water?", "question_id": "02568875", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (601327)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (601326)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "polar bear", "full_answer": "The animal is a polar bear.", "question": "What is the animal in the blue water?", "question_id": "18275313", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (4067588)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (4067561)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["601326"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "small", "surfing", "wet"], "query_target_entity_id": "601326", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "601327", "relation_subject_entity_id": "601326", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "601327", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["601327"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4067561"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["polar bear"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white", "young"], "query_target_entity_id": "4067561", "query_target_entity_name": "polar bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "4067588", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4067561", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4067588", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4067588"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:f3be3bfbfd14f85d2b319f0868a89eb0", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b65d55d8674231ab270ae281167585c2872cb941c8fbb8cf0a04d85a2a7794e7", "image_sha256_b": "51f0263a54475badcd59d6758a1261d4a9439bb613de95b6e62cd704f31ae637", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f8edc687d9e2488e523d8fda59b1bc445d9e1f28db025bce9d678f135c7a4228", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1b0e73b862250aa81df2743a39178e41", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b5190b2e207616bc4a72eb75dfcff30de509aed9c199bfbdb6b84bc6f548007b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "33d49b492437a9cdb2968d115156fef1afb973932ee98fbea03588f1f11e7516", "request_id": "f4489acbfcf113acd391a7de3de1b477", "response_sha256": "933f6d3089ca28c44a52cad111f6f4fe4cf80dd47c51e634ee3af130fb75c1ae", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a2db91693eab4242849ad743b94ede49955fbe42aa0c31a282adf2eba569b7c8", "request_id": "bef0e462c82c030e839fe47a4b754e3d", "response_sha256": "51852a0de20675383cb4c98655d74e2546075d238240e6ac489f25d701fc161b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a0914aaefa04c1378cb29db5ca44d895", "candidate_priority_rank": 131, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5720d581038aca19:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5720d581038aca19:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5720d581038aca19:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5720d581038aca19:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "green<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2316629", "image_sha256": "86589b25e2625e5889df55443fb42dbdb9d59241461ea21a853586a4b33e5daa", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2316629.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2316629.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2370353", "image_sha256": "2445ab91800b26eabdb4b038591afd2eab9280de5df9b22d3a342bd71e4fa6f0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2370353.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2370353.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-5720d581038aca19", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["green", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "53b527c386fb718e3afdfb3a1d1f89073b0bd01710876e889d9ca0437d4f1856", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c77630d013cb4c27a65ff7f79770c6bdaa07a3419fb0244d1eb04f332df1a766"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10906298", "text": "What is in the green bowl?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "53b527c386fb718e3afdfb3a1d1f89073b0bd01710876e889d9ca0437d4f1856", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "299e93e97a190f167c2ada9903d3412329874d24440806cd5a30cface2d516cd"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03175145", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 131, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "56a905337fd3ba9c5d8b80e4ab730c875e10489cd0ea04eedc65471cbb12eb6d", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "03175145", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the white bowl?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bowl", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bowl?", "program_group_hash": "56a905337fd3ba9c5d8b80e4ab730c875e10489cd0ea04eedc65471cbb12eb6d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bowl", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bowl?", "program_group_hash": "56a905337fd3ba9c5d8b80e4ab730c875e10489cd0ea04eedc65471cbb12eb6d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "soup", "full_answer": "The soup is in the bowl.", "question": "What is in the green bowl?", "question_id": "10906298", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (3478348)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (3155712)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "soup", "full_answer": "The soup is in the bowl.", "question": "What is in the white bowl?", "question_id": "03175145", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (604790)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (3859043)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2760736", "2905227", "2970284", "3139959", "3155712", "3205351", "3321522", "3353618", "3356342", "3447378", "3954536"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["soup"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3155712", "query_target_entity_name": "soup", "relation_object_entity_id": "3478348", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3155712", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3478348", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3478348"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3859043", "604792", "604793", "604794", "604796", "604797", "604798", "604799"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["soup"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3859043", "query_target_entity_name": "soup", "relation_object_entity_id": "604790", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3859043", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "604790", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["604790"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:a0914aaefa04c1378cb29db5ca44d895", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "86589b25e2625e5889df55443fb42dbdb9d59241461ea21a853586a4b33e5daa", "image_sha256_b": "2445ab91800b26eabdb4b038591afd2eab9280de5df9b22d3a342bd71e4fa6f0", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c6d8879a909fdc11a20d2456c97034e8e88311151bfb697c15bcfcad0770b9ca", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f4dcee6bd5b217b0b500c7f6783058e5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "dc82d0b1544f300a6a6209c521132b6b0b75860687172be2c73b4c19b4f539fb"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3294257b5afce00363ada013d3c3e1b4b7dcb6b746ec0a39ee3c53bba0bfc6dc", "request_id": "ac226b307568169af7b639331b3a06cb", "response_sha256": "efc74615daf207c4fcb2ba89b2650f7dda371829ca8d2c0d9d8f4d5a52a03b1e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "779f6b89a4716482f0eaa5a734d784ef5f52a8e24521c83fc98cc97391c9baad", "request_id": "adce93987af4b97d777599eb60fb4fa8", "response_sha256": "e2c43195dda83e5014b6aaed83cffb092640a216f1d2b1b19ba7bb9d1210c99a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "86e611e437a27bf0ad9a3e45231c0a4c", "candidate_priority_rank": 150, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8885d2d0f9c88feb:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8885d2d0f9c88feb:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8885d2d0f9c88feb:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8885d2d0f9c88feb:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 331, "image_id": "2417203", "image_sha256": "193ef521cacecf10fc726aa2a75ec1803725ef42f4492d04ebaaabae87cada36", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2417203.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2417203.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 420, "image_id": "2325695", "image_sha256": "336ccf5b1cd6677b74b04964117a34aba8c15819695c1f85bd72e88837344f80", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2325695.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2325695.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-8885d2d0f9c88feb", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "deef7ed1655ba236d52b862428d379a1d56223c5f512ef63ab33bb49ffe519de", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1351e9ee3adc5b3e27d1aac74a9fd4dbd8e6518b482c58b305947232c4288da0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05798858", "text": "What animal is on the brown table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "silver", "tan", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "deef7ed1655ba236d52b862428d379a1d56223c5f512ef63ab33bb49ffe519de", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a8df109e33756ede2e05c305447264343ded02bf074114b57b4a75a7f4a0c847"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00979991", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 150, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f47e6cde1702dd72a2c19b7ba27b90f3e438e6f7c5885320e803ca82a356bc9b", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "00979991", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is on the black table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "f47e6cde1702dd72a2c19b7ba27b90f3e438e6f7c5885320e803ca82a356bc9b", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the table?", "program_group_hash": "f47e6cde1702dd72a2c19b7ba27b90f3e438e6f7c5885320e803ca82a356bc9b", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is on the table.", "question": "What animal is on the brown table?", "question_id": "05798858", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (3122892)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (3188656)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is on the table.", "question": "What animal is on the black table?", "question_id": "00979991", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (2965719)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (3940933)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3188656"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3188656", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "3122892", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3188656", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3122892", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3122892"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3940933"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3940933", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "2965719", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3940933", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2965719", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2965719"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:86e611e437a27bf0ad9a3e45231c0a4c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "193ef521cacecf10fc726aa2a75ec1803725ef42f4492d04ebaaabae87cada36", "image_sha256_b": "336ccf5b1cd6677b74b04964117a34aba8c15819695c1f85bd72e88837344f80", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8a7e47822768abb4202ca2f45d67eda130ccbf9a4d4155ff5316bf297e8d0dac", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "254574856cd20e115f5c2add586ebde5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5ba55a017ed8af440b57c000378882b2f454f299f4c915dda0c37415abfedd5b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "545048fbd43f32a5ff66a7ce76536a129c7481d557c6347a3b8df3b792386606", "request_id": "e52d0421c85e623e6b3d8523078a4d3d", "response_sha256": "14bc4373ecb56fd1b8dee5bea80bd020e314f4910e7e92e609ef0093bfc573a0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "acbfe7f5d15d4d000ca4ffb83e706295619516d319e9953bc76b5e107339e173", "request_id": "eeffbe5856be42cfce059be4632d1204", "response_sha256": "2e870ef4153d133d78c7062c79d1bf1d13e717eeb2da47f1355ed11e4c0c0b2c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "b425f52c43b19fe2f3a11de04b7405c7", "candidate_priority_rank": 151, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f6c79ffa3c64ae63:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f6c79ffa3c64ae63:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f6c79ffa3c64ae63:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f6c79ffa3c64ae63:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "green<->silver", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "silver", "B": "green"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "silver<->green", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2378920", "image_sha256": "602bf671aa5275a00a6bce6722a1c443f219e2e5cfca23ef7b2e330732edde04", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2378920.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2378920.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 377, "image_id": "2363282", "image_sha256": "029015fee16351aae6f883c433e0e6b633c22cfa685b6660f6a17b69bb6ae407", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2363282.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2363282.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f6c79ffa3c64ae63", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "silver", "diff_b": "green", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "silver", "component_b": "green"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "gray", "green", "red", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["silver"], "masked_program_sha256": "05ae84f5c0d9b6a6b43189f170e4cc0fe9fb79ab04f8a0da0ad1c23cff2ce625", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "silver", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "742a137a31d79c4711f94d7f9dee83c26e95d6f1f1f0b18248fbd57cb355efe9"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13925086", "text": "What type of fast food is on the silver tray?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["green", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "05ae84f5c0d9b6a6b43189f170e4cc0fe9fb79ab04f8a0da0ad1c23cff2ce625", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3dac4890d8e9962976c6e39797e1a1f3bfd0d0aa564f185501ef769d5ddffb25"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05111534", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 151, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "20b26cbea18b8c077b607ae1bf146542912f79027a08526d204843c25170e871", "selected_component": "green", "selected_source_question_id": "05111534", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of fast food is on the green tray?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "tray", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "fast food,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of fast food is on the tray?", "program_group_hash": "20b26cbea18b8c077b607ae1bf146542912f79027a08526d204843c25170e871", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "tray"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "tray", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "fast food,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of fast food is on the tray?", "program_group_hash": "20b26cbea18b8c077b607ae1bf146542912f79027a08526d204843c25170e871", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "tray"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The food is a pizza.", "question": "What type of fast food is on the silver tray?", "question_id": "13925086", "semantic": [{"argument": "tray (556534)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "silver", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "fast food,on,s (556533)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The food is a pizza.", "question": "What type of fast food is on the green tray?", "question_id": "05111534", "semantic": [{"argument": "tray (2537905)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "fast food,on,s (2537903)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["556533"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["cut", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "556533", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "556534", "relation_subject_entity_id": "556533", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "556534", "selected_entity_name": "tray"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["556534"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2537903", "2591947"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2537903", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "2537905", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2537903", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2537905", "selected_entity_name": "tray"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2537905"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b425f52c43b19fe2f3a11de04b7405c7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "602bf671aa5275a00a6bce6722a1c443f219e2e5cfca23ef7b2e330732edde04", "image_sha256_b": "029015fee16351aae6f883c433e0e6b633c22cfa685b6660f6a17b69bb6ae407", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1044a263f05a5c0feeffd48572a612e9a61ef5562213241b4c1b18ee72401b9c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a55f653fa08fe9c8ce4da12246956c6e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "19cf0420d3540b5764f65145e319d4dde8ffda2006649b987a6af1ae2c42a892"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "61dcdee572e305f0c93d63713eff1f4003121661ee86d0d93f51b2dc5af0560c", "request_id": "0e35da98583a074aa62b16cc45b1b9d2", "response_sha256": "63af2b5b77ab3d836c41c652d83fd7bdbf14a7706c9db00d867f458739e0ca72", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f84d181a5759a47f8abe52851d1750a1fc65d9300de1c6487aa4e964fd82f388", "request_id": "e6c855acf6bf70459f159a723df82c40", "response_sha256": "f64a013e2bf633433f8fbf50d8cfbe523852afd2469ed2d1b167484d5d2ce300", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ce25de7405ee4f2edc86ded8b691392f", "candidate_priority_rank": 171, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-eaaa8c33eb006b49:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-eaaa8c33eb006b49:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-eaaa8c33eb006b49:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-eaaa8c33eb006b49:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2404639", "image_sha256": "03694054136a440f2b65a5c4e23c16c1fe213bce6acbe9f8eda8a1d753509c83", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404639.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404639.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2409067", "image_sha256": "4239ddbddeddf31b491b20fd3a15f464aa7e805c8996fb15b96ae75dff3e871b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2409067.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2409067.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-eaaa8c33eb006b49", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "tan", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "455582afd61e34072e8d4315650ea23843fd2c1379f34329335d76a09d624f4b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "302c68ba77585b94eb65b9f9b8ff756a6d5a2100920365873b2f349589051cda"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1425136", "text": "What is the item of furniture in front of the blue wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "455582afd61e34072e8d4315650ea23843fd2c1379f34329335d76a09d624f4b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d479f27a665b2d0561ff1ff7b5a00fecc190ff7755da6ac59d67ce65c8f2e9ec"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16414116", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 171, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c15efeb2740a88be6c7d620e2251dd1319afe8b28d2da0171d68a2e53dd8cde6", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "16414116", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the item of furniture in front of the white wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "c15efeb2740a88be6c7d620e2251dd1319afe8b28d2da0171d68a2e53dd8cde6", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "c15efeb2740a88be6c7d620e2251dd1319afe8b28d2da0171d68a2e53dd8cde6", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a chair.", "question": "What is the item of furniture in front of the blue wall?", "question_id": "1425136", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (340097)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s (340095)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a couch.", "question": "What is the item of furniture in front of the white wall?", "question_id": "16414116", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (363860)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s (363877)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["340095", "340096"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["tan", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "340095", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "340097", "relation_subject_entity_id": "340095", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "340097", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["340097"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["363877"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "dark colored", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "363877", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "363860", "relation_subject_entity_id": "363877", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "363860", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["363860"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:ce25de7405ee4f2edc86ded8b691392f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "03694054136a440f2b65a5c4e23c16c1fe213bce6acbe9f8eda8a1d753509c83", "image_sha256_b": "4239ddbddeddf31b491b20fd3a15f464aa7e805c8996fb15b96ae75dff3e871b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "2f3184bbd7814c00691bc48cfd30ac4d177706e0a9c6d4440c50f57ce2bd69fb", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b8e6ffff9115c87ca9fc8a94166a2522", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "59dd172d6db8ee8b0aef49c6b3e21efd7b37540dca619fa867260388cec0944b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8133158d972c61588bf87f9b9b6ef4f6a59e6707dfafe7eb1a166e954e3090da", "request_id": "da84ec379b3c732fd5a665db0f2e1cd4", "response_sha256": "eed1dc2e3dac13bca0ff47b735c0a06e660a4e3c1b24f52d69106dffaec3389b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cd3eef6449cb4a3cd4bb912b63c4c07d3eb2e29cbf15f1d75b35f7a11fd08035", "request_id": "cae7ae6bd33dfb34e5fa6b7deea6f573", "response_sha256": "1f600a7d760339a521498a6d57d5ed3597651730b038f4d63600188b41b7ac39", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "3850f7a5d1a0d5ab0db49201c67d7455", "candidate_priority_rank": 184, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6326e2d34e5a19bd:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6326e2d34e5a19bd:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6326e2d34e5a19bd:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6326e2d34e5a19bd:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brick<->glass", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "glass", "B": "brick"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "glass<->brick", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2338552", "image_sha256": "aa3c7737e4b9f9368ff66bbbefd4c6834295bf16c8bb853b8de07e5d37f9558c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2338552.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2338552.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2400323", "image_sha256": "79c0477d497e6d73086ce97696dde31f51707409065e77c536ba1c44d4d3d90b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400323.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400323.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6326e2d34e5a19bd", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "glass", "diff_b": "brick", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "glass", "component_b": "brick"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["glass", "wood"], "detected_components": ["glass"], "masked_program_sha256": "3380d654d8d649bff9a7f1e3f52414ad45b4da0a41b2189867cd6b8a936b5d44", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "glass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ff7a9a521f590c1bb5d0034148056ebc1616fff50687a28eee48f0edab86c95f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12802346", "text": "What is in front of the wall made of glass?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brick"], "detected_components": ["brick"], "masked_program_sha256": "3380d654d8d649bff9a7f1e3f52414ad45b4da0a41b2189867cd6b8a936b5d44", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brick", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d479a575883de79134ace9dfe7141d62be95fa99ac4abab32fa6222cbde340f2"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1286033", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 184, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a5893cfa359f88cdc559c041131d63282491e8ff3960aa2d21d0c57352948c09", "selected_component": "brick", "selected_source_question_id": "1286033", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the wall made of brick?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "a5893cfa359f88cdc559c041131d63282491e8ff3960aa2d21d0c57352948c09", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "a5893cfa359f88cdc559c041131d63282491e8ff3960aa2d21d0c57352948c09", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bench", "full_answer": "The bench is in front of the wall.", "question": "What is in front of the wall made of glass?", "question_id": "12802346", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (953788)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "glass", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (953772)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bus", "full_answer": "The bus is in front of the wall.", "question": "What is in front of the wall made of brick?", "question_id": "1286033", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1160359)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brick", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (1160356)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["953772", "953773", "953774", "953775", "953776", "953778", "953779", "953780", "953782", "953783", "953784", "953787"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bench"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "953772", "query_target_entity_name": "bench", "relation_object_entity_id": "953788", "relation_subject_entity_id": "953772", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "953788", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["953788"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1160356", "1160357", "1160358"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bus"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "long", "parked", "yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "1160356", "query_target_entity_name": "bus", "relation_object_entity_id": "1160359", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1160356", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1160359", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1160359"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:3850f7a5d1a0d5ab0db49201c67d7455", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "aa3c7737e4b9f9368ff66bbbefd4c6834295bf16c8bb853b8de07e5d37f9558c", "image_sha256_b": "79c0477d497e6d73086ce97696dde31f51707409065e77c536ba1c44d4d3d90b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b37b10a7c78d32abb0399543a3ae6d21130793e795806498febc00baedf375bc", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8831728cac146ff78e735912d0efeaf3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f67394d42a306cbd3cd61ef38183e0d18a0028a5fe26f7b17edfe511ec72b9dd"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "03bbde88841644e3f2457cbee570ff3ca14f69ff69608cd98511503be6689e64", "request_id": "f826398d5d90953bbb593516501cffe5", "response_sha256": "f2b0a773548fbcb242eee3b56dcb8bb691c3f8d2a9b54a3ca608f60db3309b12", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "da55dcfe7c2a984bcf556895dc42a205e4443a5ca3f18f0ae3709d75eb3627fc", "request_id": "9bca07782d14f4257092afba5d37761f", "response_sha256": "bfb32dacd297bae4cb4a03d10f241da1e9b4c4158ad180f08bc4d080066495c4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "1c44282aa04e776cd148493aa2674f61", "candidate_priority_rank": 185, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2a5b39d082373c41:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2a5b39d082373c41:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2a5b39d082373c41:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2a5b39d082373c41:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gray", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gray<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 384, "image_id": "2392445", "image_sha256": "5acebb91ad8380a0a39625ac86bb2c7644791f50ce438d577a7435b04d7a4874", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392445.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392445.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 307, "image_id": "2387562", "image_sha256": "cec0cc2250b7299ab32046db10c46f13e73a7b715483c66fe30adac6e98628e8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387562.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387562.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2a5b39d082373c41", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gray", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gray", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "gray", "green", "pink", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "16a1ded188a72cf7479d3ed2816c88dc73a7e41d7a3712ba67ee49f081f97039", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e36c5fb40e900d3c7de81c10c1d7a2477acacf788dc39ae656eceb121831f322"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00456184", "text": "What animal is lying on the gray blanket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "orange", "pink", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "16a1ded188a72cf7479d3ed2816c88dc73a7e41d7a3712ba67ee49f081f97039", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "132a5cf765f5c7fe22681cbb1afef3e55ba7f326af653332776977b8dcae43be"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00873486", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 185, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8e5ca54fcd84dbe2fab750ab1900647c9928b6abf5785ad0442d4388a18cce64", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "00873486", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is lying on the blue blanket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "blanket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is lying on the blanket?", "program_group_hash": "8e5ca54fcd84dbe2fab750ab1900647c9928b6abf5785ad0442d4388a18cce64", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "blanket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "blanket", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is lying on the blanket?", "program_group_hash": "8e5ca54fcd84dbe2fab750ab1900647c9928b6abf5785ad0442d4388a18cce64", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "blanket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the blanket.", "question": "What animal is lying on the gray blanket?", "question_id": "00456184", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (1230016)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (3825935)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What animal is lying on the blue blanket?", "question_id": "00873486", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (1274903)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (1274902)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3825935"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "furry", "soft"], "query_target_entity_id": "3825935", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1230016", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3825935", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1230016", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1230016"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1274902"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "1274902", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1274903", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1274902", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1274903", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1274903"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:1c44282aa04e776cd148493aa2674f61", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5acebb91ad8380a0a39625ac86bb2c7644791f50ce438d577a7435b04d7a4874", "image_sha256_b": "cec0cc2250b7299ab32046db10c46f13e73a7b715483c66fe30adac6e98628e8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "28cda8516a703348b899ed2305ff60042a468252f83e296199b352c04e867518", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e3b7a52d01f8b227c311490b1fdef23e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "659858fed32dfe8c8a1c0d615181b1d1bab1bbdaefeb552e5b851ddfd4d6d695"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "92ec39392275a77d83de2e6f41d897977a14ffcb44232f4c41bbc61e3577169f", "request_id": "aaf9853d452e7062fdc56a10add07397", "response_sha256": "9379c109acd95856413034b011e13f26380ce8e508ebac271d66300aa4888f0a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3079489c7a6d1550ed69931c3cf0b839682cae8e0c43e7cf3c3c3dbf4cd7b498", "request_id": "75a8d5c335061221c88fab6d465b15f8", "response_sha256": "52014a9b8ce25d6a224f66c1f4c77ac91be119399a030a25373ce44f42b4ccdf", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "0635ef9c595801be75c58a81f62b8624", "candidate_priority_rank": 194, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7c230acee7bc0f34:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7c230acee7bc0f34:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7c230acee7bc0f34:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7c230acee7bc0f34:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2400498", "image_sha256": "d627d75680d8eff6eec282c4a37257a39965c0c0526b3c76871a4dc3a59e4835", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400498.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400498.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2390030", "image_sha256": "6197451702de35418240944fca83bde550488f8467c1f13e8209034859ae790d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390030.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390030.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7c230acee7bc0f34", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "6a8d926d2f2c2f3c55ec78bfaf4df2dbc1352c6dad90f18af68768b40754819f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "04a54f5999c0d3927963a39bbbc8fd5f6264f0eaac20a86da8d5ae88e90e8614"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0294074", "text": "What is in front of the brown wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "red", "tan", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "6a8d926d2f2c2f3c55ec78bfaf4df2dbc1352c6dad90f18af68768b40754819f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e9a47fd1060dcb309022a00f353f11b885b45ee8dde0261178d455a9ef9c59b2"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11973050", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 194, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 47, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ecd51a50678dba47703a79b3485008a8ce79a7bc0b5644fe9dfb9a3fcc065e8d", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "11973050", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the white wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "ecd51a50678dba47703a79b3485008a8ce79a7bc0b5644fe9dfb9a3fcc065e8d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "ecd51a50678dba47703a79b3485008a8ce79a7bc0b5644fe9dfb9a3fcc065e8d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The bed is in front of the wall.", "question": "What is in front of the brown wall?", "question_id": "0294074", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1158265)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (1158272)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "suitcase", "full_answer": "The suitcase is in front of the wall.", "question": "What is in front of the white wall?", "question_id": "11973050", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1254727)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (1254715)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1158261", "1158262", "1158263", "1158264", "1158266", "1158268", "1158269", "1158270", "1158271", "1158272", "1158273", "1158274", "1158276", "1158277", "1158279", "3818076", "3818079", "3818082"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1158272", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "1158265", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1158272", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1158265", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1158265"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1254715", "1254716", "1254717", "1254721", "1254722", "1254723", "1254731", "1254732", "1254734", "1254736", "1254739", "1254740", "1254741"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["suitcase"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["bright", "large", "red"], "query_target_entity_id": "1254715", "query_target_entity_name": "suitcase", "relation_object_entity_id": "1254727", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1254715", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1254727", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1254727"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:0635ef9c595801be75c58a81f62b8624", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d627d75680d8eff6eec282c4a37257a39965c0c0526b3c76871a4dc3a59e4835", "image_sha256_b": "6197451702de35418240944fca83bde550488f8467c1f13e8209034859ae790d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "24e3d71033943863f209c8c9f570b732e1cc4e5b691d5bf2ee36d204a346b55a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "44e70604005d930e366f5a9c6be29214", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c0f1e5a52ebe8efe925ba453e9aa667ddfda5becbb25bc713c7f57c7a7e6e6cf"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6caaaf7c6ee71c75512bafc73dbe10aa483c0515826ed1ce12de4df438763b1b", "request_id": "e30ea12580931cbda1eb1fb43732e355", "response_sha256": "4824d428c862aac4cd4299068992fd2d4ee6dc5f162fed42dcf7c2077616b4a8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5e91784c40b660566c6f288d1a1e4979db195983a1762678bf22969a0b1888e9", "request_id": "97ec0379b5f57fd968365a27cf509cf6", "response_sha256": "7bfafdaf46dcf84bcf585c6a10b4eb557f58a6f575fe6d0deefa0ad88758de63", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a4575b98b38b7a1e615877b25185bf9c", "candidate_priority_rank": 215, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0a0021fcec2c19ea:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0a0021fcec2c19ea:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0a0021fcec2c19ea:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0a0021fcec2c19ea:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "looking down<->posing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "looking down", "B": "posing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "looking down<->posing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2402637", "image_sha256": "616f8ccd97043d86f7b65bc4889ccfcded9f04f55c3fd5010ea9285b2cd96a8a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402637.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402637.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2388810", "image_sha256": "dc00a3b50c973863ec29a0d8df7f38b8efcbbc426f437c1f2ea6a8a21927d12f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388810.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388810.jpg", "width": 332}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-0a0021fcec2c19ea", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "looking down", "diff_b": "posing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "looking down", "component_b": "posing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["looking down"], "detected_components": ["looking down"], "masked_program_sha256": "0d76f91a9b0d6aa78cb7d2645f6fa00693e592fdb34be36dedbf2758064d8751", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "looking down", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f052480c75c9252e7f8afd80524d6e7a62b893cf896f3ed37bf960aa78947b4c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13635047", "text": "What is the person that is looking down sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["posing"], "detected_components": ["posing"], "masked_program_sha256": "0d76f91a9b0d6aa78cb7d2645f6fa00693e592fdb34be36dedbf2758064d8751", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "posing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c39f0e7e2ed25a0be6bb94be24b5b9dd313fcf4b35178766dce273c9aefb172d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08341139", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 215, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "06366c365debf17650e46a8f9e9c42f5d6719695c3a9472bdb8e743e4f1d22c0", "selected_component": "posing", "selected_source_question_id": "08341139", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is posing sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "06366c365debf17650e46a8f9e9c42f5d6719695c3a9472bdb8e743e4f1d22c0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "06366c365debf17650e46a8f9e9c42f5d6719695c3a9472bdb8e743e4f1d22c0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The boy is sitting on the chair.", "question": "What is the person that is looking down sitting on?", "question_id": "13635047", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (387933)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "looking down", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (1133430)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "motorcycle", "full_answer": "The man is sitting on the motorcycle.", "question": "What is the person that is posing sitting on?", "question_id": "08341139", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (670494)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "posing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (670495)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1133409", "1133410", "1133411", "1133412", "1133414", "1133415", "1133416", "1133417", "1133421", "1133423", "1133424", "1133425", "1133426", "1133427", "1133428", "1133429", "1133430", "1133431", "387931", "387932"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1133430", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "1133430", "relation_subject_entity_id": "387933", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "387933", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "looking down", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["387933"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "posing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "looking down", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["670495", "670496", "670500", "670501", "670502", "670503", "670506", "670507", "670510", "670511", "670512", "670513", "670514", "670516", "670519", "670520", "670521", "670522", "670524", "670525"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["motorcycle"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "670495", "query_target_entity_name": "motorcycle", "relation_object_entity_id": "670495", "relation_subject_entity_id": "670494", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "670494", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "posing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["670494"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:a4575b98b38b7a1e615877b25185bf9c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "616f8ccd97043d86f7b65bc4889ccfcded9f04f55c3fd5010ea9285b2cd96a8a", "image_sha256_b": "dc00a3b50c973863ec29a0d8df7f38b8efcbbc426f437c1f2ea6a8a21927d12f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a0af7e09632643cd43258a5255d8b4273876f7f627bcb6c0636c84bfd279057f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0462c482eaf974dc887af13c978917f8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "10cb7420827d445301d8fc38ab3ceda6fbfd9ce8357efe628a30f3800b24e2b6"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7d64846225edf7d10049bddb64da7abede663eda44ba2a24eda1ae33860bea6b", "request_id": "291808e0378d2348ae6a75166844ef1a", "response_sha256": "632eee7b0522e2049588b618b742d906d02497561fa8b589375f0f264f95bf9a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8b9ea66f81cbab0b1a21d95a8685ed2e7b7fd2ebd2ccba919a2fc8b0611e15c4", "request_id": "4bcd39716e761e22a7c1a09012c02d46", "response_sha256": "36c560ecaac41892e4d4360bc1e316871ec120e6cfe8d920a5a6a035bdbb8a92", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "b49ff9d3889fb831902fa6eabe60729f", "candidate_priority_rank": 221, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-83918bf9fed98bc4:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-83918bf9fed98bc4:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-83918bf9fed98bc4:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-83918bf9fed98bc4:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "metal<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "wood", "B": "metal"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wood<->metal", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 363, "image_id": "2360243", "image_sha256": "e04b85b3bfe6ac9a2d0fa579f044636e8a0ec9d2cdada2bfb9bd79aaf05d6860", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2360243.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2360243.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2376336", "image_sha256": "b2ba7fc446147d4455719dedf0824e53eb3cd737fe3ffb4f2903aa46c908b18d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376336.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376336.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-83918bf9fed98bc4", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wood", "diff_b": "metal", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wood", "component_b": "metal"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b0421c754df9e11551e2273c97a0147114f38bddb47c854a5069072eb85630fd"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05706707", "text": "What is the animal in front of the fence made of wood?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal"], "detected_components": ["metal"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "metal", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a02dbb49c6aa383dc968283733ba974fedd61df2af8bdfbe9da881770595e432"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01942161", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 221, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "22640cbadd1ed05ad87f80bcdc4727b509ee7859bb1ba5f2a200bf4621f4f2ff", "selected_component": "metal", "selected_source_question_id": "01942161", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal in front of the fence made of metal?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal in front of the fence made of ?", "program_group_hash": "22640cbadd1ed05ad87f80bcdc4727b509ee7859bb1ba5f2a200bf4621f4f2ff", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal in front of the fence made of ?", "program_group_hash": "22640cbadd1ed05ad87f80bcdc4727b509ee7859bb1ba5f2a200bf4621f4f2ff", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What is the animal in front of the fence made of wood?", "question_id": "05706707", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (2690246)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (2698328)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "zebra", "full_answer": "The animal is a zebra.", "question": "What is the animal in front of the fence made of metal?", "question_id": "01942161", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (573770)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "metal", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (573765)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2698328"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2698328", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "2690246", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2698328", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2690246", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2690246"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["573765"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["zebra"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["adult", "black", "eating", "furry", "grazing"], "query_target_entity_id": "573765", "query_target_entity_name": "zebra", "relation_object_entity_id": "573770", "relation_subject_entity_id": "573765", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "573770", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["573770"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b49ff9d3889fb831902fa6eabe60729f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e04b85b3bfe6ac9a2d0fa579f044636e8a0ec9d2cdada2bfb9bd79aaf05d6860", "image_sha256_b": "b2ba7fc446147d4455719dedf0824e53eb3cd737fe3ffb4f2903aa46c908b18d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "16b8a62d71810db4be35ea1e25775c28b2bb74dba664890dc571b5b4067f5c85", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f1a49f18aa9d8e97c162c87ed638df35", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "17aea0002cb2954884bf9c347c25a42efcf747eb91396bd0a6fdbc59c4478aea"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "05b842e87de0ea255f9ee2a494b6b9e93979432b59930b5c505dc51cf25773dd", "request_id": "1b7aebaffea19b67e617ac8b9fadc119", "response_sha256": "0a7374191291275d78a4f6876aa8cd281a3c2984bf1e22bcaafe69e3c0e229ac", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "20a228f14b568879e61749da46b786dfe3e00b687dc2b0cbb6446d29bb9c83ac", "request_id": "6ca65cecdf5b54fccf2f0f7096870460", "response_sha256": "d11f81637c19a74a26bf0fa546a7f9713635f7429b84a60e06f1af933a5f64e4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "82f8d47c6f6d92f8887cefb87e617b27", "candidate_priority_rank": 227, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e0d88b8e21ffd5ab:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e0d88b8e21ffd5ab:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e0d88b8e21ffd5ab:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e0d88b8e21ffd5ab:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "red<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "red", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "red<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2376662", "image_sha256": "20dc08b5f1e919523cd5cf45c04d3bcd272b44d422a4ff9fcefdd9167670d158", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376662.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376662.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2387340", "image_sha256": "5d4828c1e0027a45a25e5770ba3c9d3eb4237782f81a27050edb8509e209bf5b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387340.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387340.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e0d88b8e21ffd5ab", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "red", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "red", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["red", "white"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "39e919c532d47da282fe2282e85b897ca511e1d3dcb521e37de43204f46ed7af", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2886a84180ecc1a90cacb93eaab66ca3b63b0e676543b1fb6018700c9b439aab"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11521535", "text": "What is located on top of the red table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "39e919c532d47da282fe2282e85b897ca511e1d3dcb521e37de43204f46ed7af", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4779166347dff53d60ac98d86212a8f5b34d5c4166a1b2d49c5d94717b48f9ed"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04419196", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 227, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 17, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c68c47f65dea5fa04ab22087c585ae5b808f7d427b445690ae8de019f05a3504", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "04419196", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is located on top of the white table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is located on top of the table?", "program_group_hash": "c68c47f65dea5fa04ab22087c585ae5b808f7d427b445690ae8de019f05a3504", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is located on top of the table?", "program_group_hash": "c68c47f65dea5fa04ab22087c585ae5b808f7d427b445690ae8de019f05a3504", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "hot dogs", "full_answer": "The hot dogs are on top of the table.", "question": "What is located on top of the red table?", "question_id": "11521535", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (570928)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on top of,s (570924)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "vase", "full_answer": "The vase is on top of the table.", "question": "What is located on top of the white table?", "question_id": "04419196", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (678170)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on top of,s (678169)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["570924", "570927", "570929", "570931", "570932", "570935", "570936", "570937", "570938"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hot dogs"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "570924", "query_target_entity_name": "hot dogs", "relation_object_entity_id": "570928", "relation_subject_entity_id": "570924", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "570928", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["570928"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["678168", "678169", "678172", "678174", "678175", "678183", "678184", "678185", "678186", "678188", "678189", "678190"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["vase"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["ceramic", "porcelain", "round", "shiny", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "678169", "query_target_entity_name": "vase", "relation_object_entity_id": "678170", "relation_subject_entity_id": "678169", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "678170", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["678170"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:82f8d47c6f6d92f8887cefb87e617b27", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "20dc08b5f1e919523cd5cf45c04d3bcd272b44d422a4ff9fcefdd9167670d158", "image_sha256_b": "5d4828c1e0027a45a25e5770ba3c9d3eb4237782f81a27050edb8509e209bf5b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "9de8d15b578a73b1b6d7d96a074a42eec60b1ebfda53a25b8cd6af4574dd06fa", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f93f209f96283bed7bc79027d3c91098", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c2c208d3f68a3c76c12dba9044841f5079838710dde163722514720bc8a2f0ef"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "48b02d4ad7c4993c8c1b528c1e80b7585d107600ce6dcc6cd4ef908c17b60256", "request_id": "69feb68630881026a477f7267189908e", "response_sha256": "7502908a54484b1cedc13e313f7cc6bf09907161c5516c7f3aa89ba33fdc3d0b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f215ffde6dc868276f38706b8c60eefc8b3ce19461ec3ad6d0e13a3c57d8a5c2", "request_id": "4b3e00f2cf921b20252900f004bc1a9f", "response_sha256": "582b4f3cf94bb91984983cfbd3bb35eea07e71b337fefe9aa4c6c58ca8bc5be5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "32223dfeffe2dc28280cc8ecbfcafd66", "candidate_priority_rank": 247, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aadc0dd20094c72d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aadc0dd20094c72d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aadc0dd20094c72d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aadc0dd20094c72d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "wire<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "wood", "B": "wire"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wood<->wire", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2353868", "image_sha256": "d1054dd701d8cfebee8c1b1f16068f5e00d1a385f76dc901b73ddf267a81bbc4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2353868.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2353868.jpg", "width": 434}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2359046", "image_sha256": "cad00ded7907900e618baaad81324ed19965a215a7d8e5dea31886c512954cf1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2359046.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2359046.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-aadc0dd20094c72d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wood", "diff_b": "wire", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wood", "component_b": "wire"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e64865925468f92af8582732f82e4e78bf43a83ed0cc2f41e34758f5b24ef488"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16471254", "text": "What animal is in front of the wood fence?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["concrete", "metal", "wire"], "detected_components": ["wire"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wire", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e70641aa927e1eae7d14e12c9c6943a847f92965ae164ccecfa7afa65aadadab"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16878010", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 247, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f53242e18568f2edc2ec84c9d4ac5a0859e612b605182eee6035c3256d15ec2e", "selected_component": "wire", "selected_source_question_id": "16878010", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in front of the wire fence?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the fence?", "program_group_hash": "f53242e18568f2edc2ec84c9d4ac5a0859e612b605182eee6035c3256d15ec2e", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the fence?", "program_group_hash": "f53242e18568f2edc2ec84c9d4ac5a0859e612b605182eee6035c3256d15ec2e", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The animal is a horse.", "question": "What animal is in front of the wood fence?", "question_id": "16471254", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (2078630)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (2078631)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The elephant is in front of the fence.", "question": "What animal is in front of the wire fence?", "question_id": "16878010", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (796637)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wire", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (796634)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2078631"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "2078631", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "2078630", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2078631", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2078630", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2078630"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wire", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["796634"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "796634", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "796637", "relation_subject_entity_id": "796634", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "796637", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wire", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["796637"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:32223dfeffe2dc28280cc8ecbfcafd66", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d1054dd701d8cfebee8c1b1f16068f5e00d1a385f76dc901b73ddf267a81bbc4", "image_sha256_b": "cad00ded7907900e618baaad81324ed19965a215a7d8e5dea31886c512954cf1", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7c4b7482319eff7ee23188f9fa5388dfbaab83c3fcbbb3a6c5fcf3cf8030c706", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f244c8676243aa06d46c98b4f43f1288", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f76f699584ec5c5091835d8cfc7c4cfcb75048b7608d22de0a10aeccea21afd1"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "15e310ddd7ebdf231b3f2c69ce93d60e77ca3df2f51109791f303025af63942c", "request_id": "5d41adf430e888dc0723eda093d47a0e", "response_sha256": "c9b67e653965d4f98a9e3e4808a1cecae1d8e7833d19edd29a4eb98f214e9975", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1e98c994856ebc80466f14c73ddde5a633c56eba5e6af96dd35982c3396ea37b", "request_id": "3338ec16c052b2946427c32e8b3816ff", "response_sha256": "f6f94bff6e5a41947b0aed345dcc414b443b80a16383c127397e42501cc27b1a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "9a57a4b82c6d66ac97e7a2f765595f07", "candidate_priority_rank": 248, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bebbc5ae1d674768:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bebbc5ae1d674768:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bebbc5ae1d674768:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bebbc5ae1d674768:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "metal<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "wood", "B": "metal"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wood<->metal", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2353868", "image_sha256": "d1054dd701d8cfebee8c1b1f16068f5e00d1a385f76dc901b73ddf267a81bbc4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2353868.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2353868.jpg", "width": 434}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2345476", "image_sha256": "d76c8622b40d7065fd500450455111239cc0eedf115af44cc51834982de1b943", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345476.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345476.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-bebbc5ae1d674768", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wood", "diff_b": "metal", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wood", "component_b": "metal"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f42b2b5c5b15efa385c21e00b4b71660404c39e676446babd810416f9bbda4d9"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16471252", "text": "What animal is in front of the fence made of wood?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal"], "detected_components": ["metal"], "masked_program_sha256": "cdf1a8a655d9bcfc1a80ee49d197a8d3fa9915b3d049631fbfd02e0f5922ed69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "metal", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c0c0fc083391f27c58b039aff42a0a4bb3fdf6bf20d2064bdded316b06dff860"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03453754", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 248, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8b9e79fcbc37e9919926e9eed4948821c2a42cad2e80825aecc83103b0aa3816", "selected_component": "metal", "selected_source_question_id": "03453754", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in front of the fence made of metal?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the fence made of ?", "program_group_hash": "8b9e79fcbc37e9919926e9eed4948821c2a42cad2e80825aecc83103b0aa3816", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "fence", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the fence made of ?", "program_group_hash": "8b9e79fcbc37e9919926e9eed4948821c2a42cad2e80825aecc83103b0aa3816", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The horse is in front of the fence.", "question": "What animal is in front of the fence made of wood?", "question_id": "16471252", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (2078630)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (2078631)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The animal is a giraffe.", "question": "What animal is in front of the fence made of metal?", "question_id": "03453754", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (2370128)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "metal", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (2997969)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2078631"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "2078631", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "2078630", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2078631", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2078630", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2078630"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2997969"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "eating"], "query_target_entity_id": "2997969", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "2370128", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2997969", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2370128", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2370128"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:9a57a4b82c6d66ac97e7a2f765595f07", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d1054dd701d8cfebee8c1b1f16068f5e00d1a385f76dc901b73ddf267a81bbc4", "image_sha256_b": "d76c8622b40d7065fd500450455111239cc0eedf115af44cc51834982de1b943", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c2419bfc6fb5c321ab484babb30645ff89c455a8f83812d4899375a58f1b490d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d252f0cc2f61fbb26a9ec54d0574a5fc", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "09f7ebc3958c27ce80c76593cf7d59a3645f3cd65cec92f14528941c2df2dded"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dfb02bf0a27886bef856b8178548936fc42da1ae095a01833028fcf41240d316", "request_id": "25ba159f37eb2a770f32cc30639d2b37", "response_sha256": "cbbdcbe25d3fd1924b14ced36a523c4fc9f15cb9fc8589561cfb7c1d69fc5e0a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e6203af87105facad6fed9c50fb62094b11aa2ce419997d5ad2cf32b20bd8358", "request_id": "4ae5641d4d265f52fd2493827a3ffa4e", "response_sha256": "aad40b31488367b610cac85f47d11275b649875b26a41e050699f593a641222b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "34b61b4789e7d4d0dbda85ab3fc94068", "candidate_priority_rank": 251, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a4ef4f4c257316bb:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a4ef4f4c257316bb:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a4ef4f4c257316bb:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a4ef4f4c257316bb:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brick<->stone", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "stone", "B": "brick"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "stone<->brick", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2378794", "image_sha256": "e274bb86bbb54e4d9291e7e4e6d6cf368bbc5fafb040f202f536c876aed2d3f3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2378794.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2378794.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2390401", "image_sha256": "cf7f1cd57d452cb84245ab795ed3e6257191d583383c95e65b0f4d501bb81e3f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390401.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390401.jpg", "width": 281}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a4ef4f4c257316bb", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "stone", "diff_b": "brick", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "stone", "component_b": "brick"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["stone", "wood"], "detected_components": ["stone"], "masked_program_sha256": "7d9ca6553e75137f5e372cb7451776bb30ff27a90401eeab34301d5782a32b73", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["building", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stone", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["building", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1e99c15898101e4f127a3e28864f7d542c30929fa5372a70f5281d2535395652"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14968739", "text": "What animal is in front of the stone building?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brick", "metal", "wire"], "detected_components": ["brick"], "masked_program_sha256": "7d9ca6553e75137f5e372cb7451776bb30ff27a90401eeab34301d5782a32b73", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["building", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brick", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["building", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "812b5fa1f2dc6ac0c98fad1fc01e02af5e60971777bd0232b64a638f8ce9120e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19530985", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 251, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1238516117208fb709af5d88bf7847924d5765ff507b9b0311cefaf3ece3d860", "selected_component": "brick", "selected_source_question_id": "19530985", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in front of the brick building?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "building", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the building?", "program_group_hash": "1238516117208fb709af5d88bf7847924d5765ff507b9b0311cefaf3ece3d860", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "building"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "building", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the building?", "program_group_hash": "1238516117208fb709af5d88bf7847924d5765ff507b9b0311cefaf3ece3d860", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "building"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The elephant is in front of the building.", "question": "What animal is in front of the stone building?", "question_id": "14968739", "semantic": [{"argument": "building (1364597)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "stone", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (1364593)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The giraffe is in front of the building.", "question": "What animal is in front of the brick building?", "question_id": "19530985", "semantic": [{"argument": "building (4461742)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brick", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (4461705)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1364593"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["baby", "brown", "dirty", "eating", "large", "walking", "young"], "query_target_entity_id": "1364593", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "1364597", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1364593", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1364597", "selected_entity_name": "building"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1364597"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4461705"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4461705", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "4461742", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4461705", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4461742", "selected_entity_name": "building"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4461742"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:34b61b4789e7d4d0dbda85ab3fc94068", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e274bb86bbb54e4d9291e7e4e6d6cf368bbc5fafb040f202f536c876aed2d3f3", "image_sha256_b": "cf7f1cd57d452cb84245ab795ed3e6257191d583383c95e65b0f4d501bb81e3f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "820dab1c3805cb7067ae880cc54e8b3e1364c80bb19fa9c56cfa3f8c4a3da9c6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ccafd86efe2968fc6aec1bd7c368e4b5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "47ae25f77e82220303cf4f74313a740db1e934e050f6657bd098c67e8bd81814"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9b97f9ebd13b8be1f0d480b231b794fbd2d9601cae759bf2ec384b0793fa94ae", "request_id": "39c9d6b06d839da7e1249861a47e7bee", "response_sha256": "de62679aa517d69ddfb9aa82674444f443a2c5d04fe6c879691672cb9afa2cf4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e61fd85897a8ae3369238cbc7c7c6368df0c446dc58c3a59c60a19aea5ef751f", "request_id": "10488c676e293511c74616c3665eebbe", "response_sha256": "dbd5b0cb5b358c557e0135ab69ce04ae7c62813099048bbbaa2813eccfc929e9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "e2667497f9e33878d0d16da020b921c6", "candidate_priority_rank": 260, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-072d2f047d1d915d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-072d2f047d1d915d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-072d2f047d1d915d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-072d2f047d1d915d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2394957", "image_sha256": "038a8aaea55588088f231945c5576f5d648954b1e4a2ccbe447234a650e2a340", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2394957.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2394957.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 352, "image_id": "2399015", "image_sha256": "cd19e9985eeb5f88f9b5447b2c40da753f24d9e9234f92f0179e5fdde900e299", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399015.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399015.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-072d2f047d1d915d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "orange", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "e917dbf432ece18f67fb22e525dea2843341d86156ef2e9120d0844041681891", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c80fa4dfc25471dcf10de3a3b6e6f7d5c547b08407f668884b0bf6ccd6463b8e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0494579", "text": "What is the blue bird perched on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "gray", "green", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "e917dbf432ece18f67fb22e525dea2843341d86156ef2e9120d0844041681891", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9ff14f1b81a30054951918867b2400612476d73e7fab12b217c26c9b2f4454c6"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09455622", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 260, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2f7af46444de8fea1d3203d07b3b940ebfc03c3f973d6e74dc6f17f7c4f410ed", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "09455622", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the gray bird perched on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,perched on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird perched on?", "program_group_hash": "2f7af46444de8fea1d3203d07b3b940ebfc03c3f973d6e74dc6f17f7c4f410ed", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "perched on", "select_category": "bird"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bird", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,perched on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the bird perched on?", "program_group_hash": "2f7af46444de8fea1d3203d07b3b940ebfc03c3f973d6e74dc6f17f7c4f410ed", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "perched on", "select_category": "bird"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dish", "full_answer": "The bird is perched on the dish.", "question": "What is the blue bird perched on?", "question_id": "0494579", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (1209099)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,perched on,o (1209101)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "tree", "full_answer": "The bird is perched on the tree.", "question": "What is the gray bird perched on?", "question_id": "09455622", "semantic": [{"argument": "bird (419940)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,perched on,o (419937)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1209100", "1209101", "1209102", "1209103", "1209104", "1209106", "1209108", "1209111", "1209112"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dish"], "predicate": "perched on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1209101", "query_target_entity_name": "dish", "relation_object_entity_id": "1209101", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1209099", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1209099", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1209099"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["419935", "419936", "419937", "419938", "419939", "419941", "419942", "419943", "419944", "419945", "419946", "419948", "419949", "419950"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["tree"], "predicate": "perched on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "419937", "query_target_entity_name": "tree", "relation_object_entity_id": "419937", "relation_subject_entity_id": "419940", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "419940", "selected_entity_name": "bird"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["419940"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:e2667497f9e33878d0d16da020b921c6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "038a8aaea55588088f231945c5576f5d648954b1e4a2ccbe447234a650e2a340", "image_sha256_b": "cd19e9985eeb5f88f9b5447b2c40da753f24d9e9234f92f0179e5fdde900e299", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ab3cdda56febab17c339b7e7adc3598cbe757a31aa0c33660f16675146d682f9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "151a9513123330ac315e2f409d6684d7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "692b6db72332c60bbfbae74cf40959a8d5064f075ce77c05f34ee5058616b80a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d8104dad3c21f192ba04f598eecf85e342bbd729920c61493637ca293299db3d", "request_id": "89c1e469c6b91e3b7aabe8e08c83ff57", "response_sha256": "52818c105a93ef3cf6bf23b2a693e464ece10e5abc59c04e0a29db1cb32afb66", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2dd985c51939f7b0233f92ea8a8d9b157d91e49463e80b226e66819a9a8da1e3", "request_id": "26a7a9dee0b7695b9f8f76f8f761b428", "response_sha256": "874f927d8ad1fd9407de9a8e5e612b24eb6b63ed900adf92e0a1c8e2c5f2516b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "560224ebbd1d055415f66f0cef973a69", "candidate_priority_rank": 262, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-04dd262d7affa2e3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-04dd262d7affa2e3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-04dd262d7affa2e3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-04dd262d7affa2e3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 371, "image_id": "2347340", "image_sha256": "799c636ed7c1868c8de31cc384a788d396b3843728f32ee8caea8475370aaa8e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2347340.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2347340.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2388487", "image_sha256": "cf32f26f4040493d64d292c91c436d2933c31518225eb26804dbb0cd43bb4347", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388487.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388487.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-04dd262d7affa2e3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beige", "black", "brown", "dark", "green", "red"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fce90db3284ddcb5f05f8ef42b81cb43b44d9315fb98dd371c5cba26dba8484a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00235547", "text": "What do you think is the brown animal lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7e4705d67bfe9ebb5ec05af45a7891d879fb0b7eb7ca189f2f6a404e56f724bb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00633880", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 262, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "fb1eca96ac5b89149de37df94802193b2b75caf3490a2bbda915da6d456fffe0", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "00633880", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What do you think is the gray animal lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what do you think is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "fb1eca96ac5b89149de37df94802193b2b75caf3490a2bbda915da6d456fffe0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what do you think is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "fb1eca96ac5b89149de37df94802193b2b75caf3490a2bbda915da6d456fffe0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the chair.", "question": "What do you think is the brown animal lying on?", "question_id": "00235547", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (2914023)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (2914024)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "carpet", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the carpet.", "question": "What do you think is the gray animal lying on?", "question_id": "00633880", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1268545)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (1268546)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1693253", "1899566", "2103233", "2240034", "2442664", "2532671", "2562562", "2724342", "2756561", "2767143", "2914024", "2941385", "3072482", "3168324", "3233226", "3289767", "3434383", "3611884", "3611886", "3611889"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "2914024", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "2914024", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2914023", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2914023", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2914023"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1268546", "1268547", "1268548", "1268549", "1268551", "1268552", "1268554"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["carpet"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "shaggy"], "query_target_entity_id": "1268546", "query_target_entity_name": "carpet", "relation_object_entity_id": "1268546", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1268545", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1268545", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1268545"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:560224ebbd1d055415f66f0cef973a69", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "799c636ed7c1868c8de31cc384a788d396b3843728f32ee8caea8475370aaa8e", "image_sha256_b": "cf32f26f4040493d64d292c91c436d2933c31518225eb26804dbb0cd43bb4347", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "262989ed3503ec2723fbf8e64b6880573b11af9d04053b72c062346fcc6d375d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b3d0f513f276293ed1678d9837160dc2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a12b14859f2fb8252f7bbb965d5cb0448cb5deef3e1d0140587550144bdb3a4a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bec3025379dd0692c7861ba99ad9dd2bb7229d5ce262a8b7944cdfb68f943d54", "request_id": "3e0ed1a2bd9e960474c9db7a4199b169", "response_sha256": "13c500318d80b54dcb86a22ef6025830a5028e10c91b6462f43f09bf8bcd1a58", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ba5b3bd9a16522f045a556c1c837137637037aada475694e0ba7e4441d61e4d6", "request_id": "757bd485b0eebd6a9976a6af62773857", "response_sha256": "103666e8765aef038726398e5906d096d5e0b6ba9595666ed48e444f055e19da", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a8d107ee0c47ab8be2341b7166904bae", "candidate_priority_rank": 278, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d06738cc50803e4d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d06738cc50803e4d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d06738cc50803e4d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d06738cc50803e4d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "tan<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "tan", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "tan<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2357667", "image_sha256": "40373f683fea97231d17ac844c4f81b2320b88ebc85766b0bb09f3c4e1c5163b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2357667.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2357667.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2398747", "image_sha256": "ca35435649f548856bdb58c78fd82ae236e44494c8150d728dcc75f0bb17ba59", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398747.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398747.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d06738cc50803e4d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "tan", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "tan", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "tan", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["tan"], "masked_program_sha256": "00e1f1aa4f90b8eff97f0be484af7220e4114326b429edf2700d46f8dce53334", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tan", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "70696bd9d4a7f15b00ae65c2c82e255fcff17beab79f0e1287c8c190efe8321e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07845853", "text": "What is the animal that looks tan wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "00e1f1aa4f90b8eff97f0be484af7220e4114326b429edf2700d46f8dce53334", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ea2860f229fb5ccfa9430629324d16dd7f12963bc028852eff893727004075f5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04113080", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 278, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0135f32ec17cc30da8b66c872415833c7f8e407f13e8ab352c23d2a59805fc3a", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "04113080", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal that looks white wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that looks wearing?", "program_group_hash": "0135f32ec17cc30da8b66c872415833c7f8e407f13e8ab352c23d2a59805fc3a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that looks wearing?", "program_group_hash": "0135f32ec17cc30da8b66c872415833c7f8e407f13e8ab352c23d2a59805fc3a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "tie", "full_answer": "The dog is wearing a necktie.", "question": "What is the animal that looks tan wearing?", "question_id": "07845853", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (810055)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "tan", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (810053)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hat", "full_answer": "The bear is wearing a hat.", "question": "What is the animal that looks white wearing?", "question_id": "04113080", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1176468)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,wearing,o (1176469)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3769731", "3769732", "810053", "810054", "810056", "810057", "810058", "810059", "810061", "810062"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["tie"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "810053", "query_target_entity_name": "tie", "relation_object_entity_id": "810053", "relation_subject_entity_id": "810055", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "810055", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["810055"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1176467", "1176469", "1176470", "1176471", "1176473", "1176477", "1176478", "1176479", "1176480", "1176481"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hat"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1176469", "query_target_entity_name": "hat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1176469", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1176468", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1176468", "selected_entity_name": "bear"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1176468"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:a8d107ee0c47ab8be2341b7166904bae", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "40373f683fea97231d17ac844c4f81b2320b88ebc85766b0bb09f3c4e1c5163b", "image_sha256_b": "ca35435649f548856bdb58c78fd82ae236e44494c8150d728dcc75f0bb17ba59", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a4f3d3fe5de704e779b27617aa6c143b2eb314e864a9e95d174ea0def99296d1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7973777a21fbd991bb8255e8fb02f626", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4b81f2bbd84da9067a85a311201abdbb1ba85a57ee6df41c16eb954de7c9c112"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "917a0d9458b095bf9a633009c91d14976d5fb3192116682ff595f1b5abfc7181", "request_id": "a0e2e12355796c589dabe5e01bbb36bd", "response_sha256": "3618ab63890465bde90030a3142c08363a413f14822240c897957d09d5270b4c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4666c6c8bc370302201b819006047af0ddefa1ea2184f901e7cc3436d8401b9a", "request_id": "c625e827385232a65ae49fcb33440817", "response_sha256": "046ca1a618f6695c76911848916b4b9c634b3743596b068fe156906d16a07718", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "b4a45a47be677ea5fd97702c52e7d9dc", "candidate_priority_rank": 288, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-833c56f42f747284:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-833c56f42f747284:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-833c56f42f747284:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-833c56f42f747284:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "green"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->green", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 330, "image_id": "2361232", "image_sha256": "85d12724bc31c16b5dc1fdb27b378648e5757d5a770985b866fae10a6ae81793", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2361232.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2361232.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2320950", "image_sha256": "0fe2fb9ad024452822389a0b8175fbc2e21f9f29d9444640222db1875bd578e3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2320950.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2320950.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-833c56f42f747284", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "green", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "green"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "gray", "purple"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "eed4576252574841a1cacafff454766e450e444b6559fda8d782d5db715b351a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["couch", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["couch", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "27c56268afec447a0b6ab67ed2df4a8120d9f7065e4f9d754ee7bf1b971176b0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06738853", "text": "What animal is on the brown couch?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "eed4576252574841a1cacafff454766e450e444b6559fda8d782d5db715b351a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["couch", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["couch", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c338217853aa09c8e397fe58f3251d70f35691b13c1efcefacbb67547d72186d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02831689", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 288, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0f0c28aece76e589a2ff0d149447c34ab04af884b02dbae77ba775270c8ae1b0", "selected_component": "green", "selected_source_question_id": "02831689", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is on the green couch?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "couch", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the couch?", "program_group_hash": "0f0c28aece76e589a2ff0d149447c34ab04af884b02dbae77ba775270c8ae1b0", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "couch"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "couch", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the couch?", "program_group_hash": "0f0c28aece76e589a2ff0d149447c34ab04af884b02dbae77ba775270c8ae1b0", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "couch"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is on the couch.", "question": "What animal is on the brown couch?", "question_id": "06738853", "semantic": [{"argument": "couch (2202430)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (1776273)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is on the couch.", "question": "What animal is on the green couch?", "question_id": "02831689", "semantic": [{"argument": "couch (4219363)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (4219358)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1776273"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1776273", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "2202430", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1776273", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2202430", "selected_entity_name": "couch"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2202430"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4219358"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "4219358", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "4219363", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4219358", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4219363", "selected_entity_name": "couch"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4219363"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b4a45a47be677ea5fd97702c52e7d9dc", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "85d12724bc31c16b5dc1fdb27b378648e5757d5a770985b866fae10a6ae81793", "image_sha256_b": "0fe2fb9ad024452822389a0b8175fbc2e21f9f29d9444640222db1875bd578e3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "008b73153aa22cd6b97f2db4562f799cdc86ee50c2b7b3325becbd5794e424dd", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b27caab76e50afbfe786c2d5b91135f8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0eb02d7b9fc84d531c5feecf6b269f3b3287e259d6fa0f803c7c553c2de4a8f8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "08a8b1ee9136301b0bb430edb76b702cfb1759596d3eee78216edf1d1ddfd800", "request_id": "fade6d7a8a9232e6f9431758a9bfd569", "response_sha256": "120c57f291bcf3e656bdc2db222716828fa38ff570ae49120245114ca29d9cc3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f1b47d8ecc5c461428b6e8b8c3b2e61a8a788e8c0ffa2d83a04b9b5d70ef00b1", "request_id": "7f02e536ddd736e3bb6a8a80d7918e5a", "response_sha256": "8aa7e39537610fe0b4daa0d3c48060c587ed18f6c1ca02c5cf37c50a8989ab30", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "386ec254359cbb74f80f211032d13ae2", "candidate_priority_rank": 296, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-24de95799dde886c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-24de95799dde886c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-24de95799dde886c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-24de95799dde886c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2402906", "image_sha256": "b6740a4ba7b3b956131afa306300a23d4c86356ef0a6f07e9d486641dd9df06a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402906.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402906.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 329, "image_id": "2330184", "image_sha256": "1fe87ab0955dc3f38acbe73869f823dc07d62f10123580901e8047ccd51932b8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2330184.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2330184.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-24de95799dde886c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "purple"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "06832819f96cb5c71344cabe21f712ab3832178a9110e5e4606f5c4d51cdd6fa", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fb1fd52de5008e506d9cd4c3479c3a69035e1bd2105645fc98f1332bd980b857"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18471291", "text": "What is the brown dog lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "06832819f96cb5c71344cabe21f712ab3832178a9110e5e4606f5c4d51cdd6fa", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "49f5f6ea260696c03518a968b7bf39b898ad02911ce10f875ebc45c99e8c367c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16262646", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 296, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e3fffb41500624ed6480f889a68ff4e596698d3dc8bc6ba30e0bc6257d26bb32", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "16262646", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the black dog lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "dog", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the dog lying on?", "program_group_hash": "e3fffb41500624ed6480f889a68ff4e596698d3dc8bc6ba30e0bc6257d26bb32", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "dog", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the dog lying on?", "program_group_hash": "e3fffb41500624ed6480f889a68ff4e596698d3dc8bc6ba30e0bc6257d26bb32", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "book", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the book.", "question": "What is the brown dog lying on?", "question_id": "18471291", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (385148)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (385150)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "blanket", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the blanket.", "question": "What is the black dog lying on?", "question_id": "16262646", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (3202327)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (2815224)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["385150", "385151", "385152", "385155", "385158", "385160", "385162"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["book"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "385150", "query_target_entity_name": "book", "relation_object_entity_id": "385150", "relation_subject_entity_id": "385148", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "385148", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["385148"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2716782", "2799758", "2799759", "2815224", "2847936", "2847937", "3093649", "3093650", "3093651", "3093652", "3460329", "3512535", "3512536"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blanket"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2815224", "query_target_entity_name": "blanket", "relation_object_entity_id": "2815224", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3202327", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3202327", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3202327"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:386ec254359cbb74f80f211032d13ae2", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b6740a4ba7b3b956131afa306300a23d4c86356ef0a6f07e9d486641dd9df06a", "image_sha256_b": "1fe87ab0955dc3f38acbe73869f823dc07d62f10123580901e8047ccd51932b8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1a1909ae733b13806ea24b8010aaeb0742ecc0ed90ae949221995df46ca867be", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "72145b38ff5b6b1d30985dc06a3c4bc1", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "70ffda4fd50c007d7f6c59d9e6bee59570d897e9d0d3d0b33d3063711f0a2a02"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d3fd0fab05751d97ad75a8c1d1278e5f5128eb21823af5f74bced0b3dab4970c", "request_id": "7b0dd2a281e0dbe0eddf826d6bb0edaa", "response_sha256": "507cd805f699084ef18069ff43877f4f4233ff523083b20fbc66f027ef40abf8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "20a692d77756773c3501c478a64a4e0c8379dacdf727ee40f4b583073280a593", "request_id": "f81775b86b460b7857980ca0fafd572d", "response_sha256": "2457085acfd5325bf76e7565456f278c57c5b045d269ab0958047b0684ee16fc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "cf791bf4d4d6623a68c22cd6251bf401", "candidate_priority_rank": 298, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-69168f0f0ee8afe0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-69168f0f0ee8afe0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-69168f0f0ee8afe0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-69168f0f0ee8afe0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2384080", "image_sha256": "19a8a5a234710114f5a7af463aad54c781c0bb107855fa99da2dd43a1c3a9f6e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384080.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384080.jpg", "width": 357}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2384666", "image_sha256": "0109e06fbfa9170593824d131cc2ba6d07ac564b3753ebd02c75ce3fbbe524ce", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384666.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384666.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-69168f0f0ee8afe0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["green", "orange", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "84f01fc904b2816f82a783ae92b5d24b4044c57431bd3ef7726bc8f903d87b19", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3915a5579daccf10240edde6c7cf582a7502ddcd0b8217c33cfa981d7e432162"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14666229", "text": "What animal is standing in the green field?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "84f01fc904b2816f82a783ae92b5d24b4044c57431bd3ef7726bc8f903d87b19", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "efea48998cc0979f9309e78003bdeba1932415c5f841f8471428466ed6744a48"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12686551", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 298, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "eb4e4e0d4b7293ea38b9dc1383906269e2f5bdb9935bfc37f9028c8b41cdb417", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "12686551", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is standing in the brown field?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "field", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,standing in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is standing in the field?", "program_group_hash": "eb4e4e0d4b7293ea38b9dc1383906269e2f5bdb9935bfc37f9028c8b41cdb417", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "standing in", "select_category": "field"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "field", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,standing in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is standing in the field?", "program_group_hash": "eb4e4e0d4b7293ea38b9dc1383906269e2f5bdb9935bfc37f9028c8b41cdb417", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "standing in", "select_category": "field"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The horse is standing in the field.", "question": "What animal is standing in the green field?", "question_id": "14666229", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (1313618)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,standing in,s (1313615)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The giraffe is standing in the field.", "question": "What animal is standing in the brown field?", "question_id": "12686551", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (525213)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,standing in,s (525212)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1313615"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "standing in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "standing", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1313615", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "1313618", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1313615", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1313618", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1313618"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["525212"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "standing in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "525212", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "525213", "relation_subject_entity_id": "525212", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "525213", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["525213"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:cf791bf4d4d6623a68c22cd6251bf401", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "19a8a5a234710114f5a7af463aad54c781c0bb107855fa99da2dd43a1c3a9f6e", "image_sha256_b": "0109e06fbfa9170593824d131cc2ba6d07ac564b3753ebd02c75ce3fbbe524ce", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "de3f83206ad32000678dcbf8c5502ed1ce282f43dd13523257359ab25b58e5dd", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "05c0194ed3f5d1bbeb7c8aa52aeea93f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d43fbaf7ff6acf7dbb449e81e53aedb8283e27ad14727e079946b11a8b4f0ce5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3c2c81204fd0c82ce3e2ce0d87d2cb551ea49e9c8a7e7bafb84505a26f997044", "request_id": "4dedd8dd51ff605a1506aba6ba9e908f", "response_sha256": "36dc37dd9c24fee6e7c7c22bd5a839077393abadc7f916674b56d9008789bab2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0145ad14966050f5f64aa5817607c3dd1db7d7d864e940211466a03564dc06b2", "request_id": "d64e06f5442001bdc8684b0b832bc924", "response_sha256": "7d5dfb47b013c771269067e3c8c84b56855a7ed55b6224708134714c68da5e2c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "75fe02929a274a5207798c8bdd60fb1b", "candidate_priority_rank": 364, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f4629c361ce0ee0e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f4629c361ce0ee0e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f4629c361ce0ee0e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f4629c361ce0ee0e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2354453", "image_sha256": "93a2d513ce0ca033a0b6d05b7ff738f402d729c6cde17a9566dfa8a133293319", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2354453.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2354453.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 240, "image_id": "2343619", "image_sha256": "74b78c3e410135b949660833fd98c3b3c463c3745aa7d76a80fdb5cea8f67925", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343619.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343619.jpg", "width": 320}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-f4629c361ce0ee0e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "615094ad419cb47e1862fb93711dae5d33609fe4ef76e418024f4e7facf281ff"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07119909", "text": "What is the white animal lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "pink"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7a0994aa1383bc7f1c7329a5d805dffd1939235482f9eb08d3d80d44e66ef59c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18373308", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 364, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "18373308", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the brown animal lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "log", "full_answer": "The bear is lying on the log.", "question": "What is the white animal lying on?", "question_id": "07119909", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (838218)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (838219)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "blanket", "full_answer": "The puppy is lying on the blanket.", "question": "What is the brown animal lying on?", "question_id": "18373308", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (921608)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (921611)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["838219", "838220", "838221", "838223", "838224", "838225", "838226", "838227", "838228", "838230", "838232"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["log"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "large", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "838219", "query_target_entity_name": "log", "relation_object_entity_id": "838219", "relation_subject_entity_id": "838218", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "838218", "selected_entity_name": "bear"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["838218"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["921609", "921610", "921611", "921613", "921614", "921615", "921616", "921617"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blanket"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "patterned", "soft", "wrinkled"], "query_target_entity_id": "921611", "query_target_entity_name": "blanket", "relation_object_entity_id": "921611", "relation_subject_entity_id": "921608", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "921608", "selected_entity_name": "puppy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["921608"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:75fe02929a274a5207798c8bdd60fb1b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "93a2d513ce0ca033a0b6d05b7ff738f402d729c6cde17a9566dfa8a133293319", "image_sha256_b": "74b78c3e410135b949660833fd98c3b3c463c3745aa7d76a80fdb5cea8f67925", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f40fdcc20cd6aa370fd869faef73da93e031516664b2a1ade933aeba3165f0b5", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d60a749984d51d5e1dac53d855925efd", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "099e4a197d3d2f07be3b9bc3f21d6e15232debc189cff485c4a12126a3595749"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5b0cf56b26c336f836e812eeab5504d03185ec566ac37f908227379ff3c49875", "request_id": "f800c49c4e35a71c9adcb855c422b8ef", "response_sha256": "4894f2a5aaec83879b0f81904e68db036555d51f8828f2537845494b3eebf1d1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cb48345fd2b21f67b06a3acb9c47d22337d55736914bb274f10c98f396772417", "request_id": "4765db61d5fb578d47d48605494f7157", "response_sha256": "78e5fc9148055b7e3af30ad927174247da87fad3a1b393aa4fa253437db801c3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "8bbd6188c4f9c8e507cb647833f36626", "candidate_priority_rank": 385, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6aa303d1d8ca1088:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6aa303d1d8ca1088:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6aa303d1d8ca1088:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6aa303d1d8ca1088:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "stone<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "stone", "B": "wood"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "stone<->wood", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2323081", "image_sha256": "fb8039de413ba505a515ed69476ac4d98fa98eeba144eee78246cf4133c02cd0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2323081.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2323081.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2348545", "image_sha256": "1ac3693fbccd5b75f0e39479f2498173a949c7d4553ec796b1c4c81f5c13df85", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2348545.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2348545.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6aa303d1d8ca1088", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "stone", "diff_b": "wood", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "stone", "component_b": "wood"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["stone"], "detected_components": ["stone"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stone", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e54ba93766d84cd441c86a6c54cdc5e77df5c2bad179776b2b99120ea0041d2a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03288060", "text": "What is on the wall made of stone?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["plastic", "wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "da61d57627c5f1592b17596195dcbf31c8538dd6ae148a35b65a9c4f88ed5c26"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13673969", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 385, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "73321a13d93b81b16835c08883a18828f7d31153422e699ba9d4f79970700f9e", "selected_component": "wood", "selected_source_question_id": "13673969", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the wall made of wood?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "73321a13d93b81b16835c08883a18828f7d31153422e699ba9d4f79970700f9e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "73321a13d93b81b16835c08883a18828f7d31153422e699ba9d4f79970700f9e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the wall made of stone?", "question_id": "03288060", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (3500264)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "stone", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2808184)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the wall made of wood?", "question_id": "13673969", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (881401)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (881400)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2736299", "2808184", "2989876", "2995278", "3153598", "3324941", "3544524", "3604584"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large"], "query_target_entity_id": "2808184", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "3500264", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2808184", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3500264", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3500264"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "stone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["881400", "881403", "881404", "881405", "881407", "881408", "881414", "881416", "881417", "881418", "881419", "881420", "881421", "881422", "881423", "881424", "881425", "881426", "881427", "881428", "881429"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "round", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "881400", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "881401", "relation_subject_entity_id": "881400", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "881401", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["881401"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:8bbd6188c4f9c8e507cb647833f36626", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "fb8039de413ba505a515ed69476ac4d98fa98eeba144eee78246cf4133c02cd0", "image_sha256_b": "1ac3693fbccd5b75f0e39479f2498173a949c7d4553ec796b1c4c81f5c13df85", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0e97455a6bf257ab8cb48cd79ef9de944b8364579ea8091636b21eecd4d2980c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ac65ce8fc0a6f18028842ef936eb6e22", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7877102a5d13319b21fcc2d79552938c092e487755a2ac1f67e5550ebb549875"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7932cd7b54f7cd1fafae153dd9c590fed0501b967eee9cfa0af5e95575311233", "request_id": "e44ae2afcf5b26283884e7ee3f97dd6e", "response_sha256": "eabe595183484e30e8857d42b2f2df16e849874e46649a2d68cfb663f8f0dc7f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2d2a280a28a19a3b7cf4b15f590676229208fcb6f205eeedf55974386db23a88", "request_id": "522f88bd92ffe6bd1830455fae3788e9", "response_sha256": "f1d724a905f0a4a2a14d57b44ef8d2fddff7427237f1a4838c01d79098d39a5a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "07e1785538c8342ae8eec7a583121aac", "candidate_priority_rank": 407, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d747b5c0cd0e57b6:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d747b5c0cd0e57b6:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d747b5c0cd0e57b6:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d747b5c0cd0e57b6:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2382757", "image_sha256": "791215d2dd4cdf518ec9a054fb9854a5abbbb6996f558e0d051652a8870679c5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382757.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382757.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 322, "image_id": "2404811", "image_sha256": "f89cd665d9b5f0520b9fdd06a5c76d422044a4b0bab3d00a79d68e2d7f5177e9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404811.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404811.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d747b5c0cd0e57b6", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "green", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "3751b18b6157581377ba49eb16a0b47577a0ca8a56361fcfdbd884795a04de2a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1699a9e18f826ed06f3c105f5e5fcab1363d8e8eada94720f5d9d2f1f8e8c2b4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12932374", "text": "What is the black animal sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray", "purple"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "3751b18b6157581377ba49eb16a0b47577a0ca8a56361fcfdbd884795a04de2a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "56cda2c8c61b853b688764acb6ab11cd8c714dd83ecf3a3fe26cde061b8a69c8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04193737", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 407, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "295f904424fd112b34a4650858cb7c79040a98774f47ad61acc13d568accc777", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "04193737", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the gray animal sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "295f904424fd112b34a4650858cb7c79040a98774f47ad61acc13d568accc777", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "295f904424fd112b34a4650858cb7c79040a98774f47ad61acc13d568accc777", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "blanket", "full_answer": "The cat is sitting on the blanket.", "question": "What is the black animal sitting on?", "question_id": "12932374", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1326378)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (1326387)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "seat", "full_answer": "The cat is sitting on the seat.", "question": "What is the gray animal sitting on?", "question_id": "04193737", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (337623)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (337624)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1326379", "1326380", "1326381", "1326382", "1326383", "1326385", "1326386", "1326387", "1326389", "1326390"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blanket"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["colorful"], "query_target_entity_id": "1326387", "query_target_entity_name": "blanket", "relation_object_entity_id": "1326387", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1326378", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1326378", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1326378"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["337624", "337627", "337628", "337634", "337635", "337636", "337638", "337639"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["seat"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["cloth", "purple"], "query_target_entity_id": "337624", "query_target_entity_name": "seat", "relation_object_entity_id": "337624", "relation_subject_entity_id": "337623", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "337623", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["337623"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:07e1785538c8342ae8eec7a583121aac", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "791215d2dd4cdf518ec9a054fb9854a5abbbb6996f558e0d051652a8870679c5", "image_sha256_b": "f89cd665d9b5f0520b9fdd06a5c76d422044a4b0bab3d00a79d68e2d7f5177e9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "91a068ffeaf61b488d2f83bec9f753e6ab17bce1dd4d3f4eeadc8c49c694f1a0", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e1364c1438d8ab040651924eed8ca94e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a79135d9cc6db8eb7b8b0ed61594124dbc21aa9e7a5f062f5189537afe2c36d4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e7a00760f01d65de617a572637a1d845ab3518318f7e5cc26b505d0eeab09d17", "request_id": "8793e5a1d767328e855920edd1e296fc", "response_sha256": "39be83dc4f5981840b8605ca8d65cf41e1b6fa451e00764a29a5ebc40d02c166", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9668615c510eba3156b2ec3316e4ca58722fbe4a2419f9879d3f37093d33fa9d", "request_id": "6b2d17178fcd7f50161b465600b8ce02", "response_sha256": "8bf845217f3afda8ed761d6fc324b93786cb2d6557fd5d7b377add452f610abe", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "463bd3898167007434eeab079e53ff0e", "candidate_priority_rank": 422, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4c2a1ffaee353896:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4c2a1ffaee353896:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4c2a1ffaee353896:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4c2a1ffaee353896:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "orange<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "orange"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->orange", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2393278", "image_sha256": "a00b18ba5b230babfd666043082ed1cd9fa93b72b6a7585e7d78d9ddb65217ca", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2393278.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2393278.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2402662", "image_sha256": "3e04e8aa406e6ca53cae245ebca9c1a956b97057c4f3f209ea4381f986c1fe8d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402662.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402662.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-4c2a1ffaee353896", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "orange", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "orange"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "orange", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "3a9e3bcab6cf893723b3ea8cca447b8e40537a91f1d59d82223697d3d549fa34", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ee13579b5c9d06f84acd910e9a419266971ff93343378792079f64885141b8ed"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1169424", "text": "What is under the white food?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "orange", "silver"], "detected_components": ["orange"], "masked_program_sha256": "3a9e3bcab6cf893723b3ea8cca447b8e40537a91f1d59d82223697d3d549fa34", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "orange", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fcdb078b1df94ec2e5c246da6525404e24d2266b9a1a425c1cc8c410b9570228"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02822837", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 422, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0f00a6391590942da1051f2aed1d03eef45b89315dbb8b768baac33c82c5dc3f", "selected_component": "orange", "selected_source_question_id": "02822837", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is under the orange food?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "food", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is under the food?", "program_group_hash": "0f00a6391590942da1051f2aed1d03eef45b89315dbb8b768baac33c82c5dc3f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "food"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "food", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is under the food?", "program_group_hash": "0f00a6391590942da1051f2aed1d03eef45b89315dbb8b768baac33c82c5dc3f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "food"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "plate", "full_answer": "The plate is under the rice.", "question": "What is under the white food?", "question_id": "1169424", "semantic": [{"argument": "food (1221406)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,under,s (1221404)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "liquid", "full_answer": "The liquid is under the food.", "question": "What is under the orange food?", "question_id": "02822837", "semantic": [{"argument": "food (387746)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "orange", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,under,s (387750)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1221403", "1221404", "1221405", "1221407", "1221408", "1221409", "1221410"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["plate"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1221404", "query_target_entity_name": "plate", "relation_object_entity_id": "1221406", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1221404", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1221406", "selected_entity_name": "rice"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1221406"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "orange", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["387747", "387748", "387750", "387767"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["liquid"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "387750", "query_target_entity_name": "liquid", "relation_object_entity_id": "387746", "relation_subject_entity_id": "387750", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "387746", "selected_entity_name": "food"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "orange", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["387746"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:463bd3898167007434eeab079e53ff0e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a00b18ba5b230babfd666043082ed1cd9fa93b72b6a7585e7d78d9ddb65217ca", "image_sha256_b": "3e04e8aa406e6ca53cae245ebca9c1a956b97057c4f3f209ea4381f986c1fe8d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "488e3e9f3d374712da1f169dda8cfb8cd0ab53f84cfaa0906d81a8a36c47b57b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b41ddc8e324fcad3e8e440bb337ab376", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c1e8cd997a07b98e2e7b87561e489e8c8308671175b07e85a6c5b1fe35b67404"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d3fa99b031cd30bfcd0bd0e8c5b14944175e8f29b6ff7c6faf33d8f28820e151", "request_id": "f6c05264c6d35deccbd20ab4ce306ab5", "response_sha256": "d557d69410b4d6191fa167a35d7e2b027807a266d0335cf452c3a63b4df01469", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "39e6572391a8ebf208bb1bfcd16ff23cf986a7f86a20981eb947a77d59013e93", "request_id": "fce8531432581340f74cc0dca3bfad25", "response_sha256": "11b319fcde3a5a419a1c78386b88e23a14d12fcb2fde833fc029dc0971001131", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "113139770261fb50b9c934071701477a", "candidate_priority_rank": 425, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dbb164131b6f96d5:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dbb164131b6f96d5:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dbb164131b6f96d5:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dbb164131b6f96d5:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "rectangular<->round", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "round", "B": "rectangular"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "round<->rectangular", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2389434", "image_sha256": "9525c536deaa4787908e38a6799c4d22c419dc1a5a797a62749c95be7635340d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389434.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389434.jpg", "width": 419}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2386560", "image_sha256": "c090b91276a1aba450022ace0c17df1b4a8338b75df616a893fd3d4cd18fc89c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386560.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386560.jpg", "width": 281}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-dbb164131b6f96d5", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "round", "diff_b": "rectangular", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "round", "component_b": "rectangular"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["round"], "detected_components": ["round"], "masked_program_sha256": "5c430c43c56e9412a55327658a343168f8cd986af58f6b31c22fef363a1dbfbd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "round", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5c323b5518e0c7a54c4a30600964f8a2ea7ff96420de95538e4acdb08557d3dd"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12643950", "text": "What is the food on the round plate?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["rectangular"], "detected_components": ["rectangular"], "masked_program_sha256": "5c430c43c56e9412a55327658a343168f8cd986af58f6b31c22fef363a1dbfbd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "rectangular", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2866c27f3bc7780aab68ad4666408d639ec7b0e90655d492b5f063e2d6a20c02"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19979793", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 425, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c7047595cf8c3aaa15df0d56b56e0d669dad4b826d9dfddbe9a8baf25610763f", "selected_component": "rectangular", "selected_source_question_id": "19979793", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the food on the rectangular plate?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "shape", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food on the plate?", "program_group_hash": "c7047595cf8c3aaa15df0d56b56e0d669dad4b826d9dfddbe9a8baf25610763f", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "shape", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food on the plate?", "program_group_hash": "c7047595cf8c3aaa15df0d56b56e0d669dad4b826d9dfddbe9a8baf25610763f", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "donut", "full_answer": "The food is a donut.", "question": "What is the food on the round plate?", "question_id": "12643950", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (1260937)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "round", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s (1260948)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pie", "full_answer": "The food is a pie.", "question": "What is the food on the rectangular plate?", "question_id": "19979793", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (1284819)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "rectangular", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter shape"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s (3844371)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1260948"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["donut"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1260948", "query_target_entity_name": "donut", "relation_object_entity_id": "1260937", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1260948", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1260937", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "round", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1260937"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "rectangular", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "round", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3844371"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pie"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3844371", "query_target_entity_name": "pie", "relation_object_entity_id": "1284819", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3844371", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1284819", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "rectangular", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1284819"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:113139770261fb50b9c934071701477a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9525c536deaa4787908e38a6799c4d22c419dc1a5a797a62749c95be7635340d", "image_sha256_b": "c090b91276a1aba450022ace0c17df1b4a8338b75df616a893fd3d4cd18fc89c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "06084c1bce6626835a5a31e0c865afb32edc95b67ef07487bf4929b209cacd34", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8fd0f4a6b571bfbd489629fb92daeb6b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b0057c74865733ceeefb5e373b5c962d78c70ba791981b290f431d3964d4a0d4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "37c33714e373a5a36e1121bfef014eb6a0ceb292f81999a506d61a1057b6c5b9", "request_id": "3ad5f5eb2a511669d6cb7d83d86ca63a", "response_sha256": "7c373f1351606268e6bcf82dd29b858c40777f091f4fdb0b12f212806cb673dc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d4071479f4190521be626ba3e9f3c77d07cb688aaa28225f102e4f3b5501722d", "request_id": "c52ccb45f3ce4e1c1beec78030176a88", "response_sha256": "7ac58711d798ec5e19361c4461a078e408eb24186c7ce6ef3cb31f6e34d329c6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "63f5fd951a010e5cb9de88dc60050d33", "candidate_priority_rank": 457, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d69d22374e610a5c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d69d22374e610a5c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d69d22374e610a5c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d69d22374e610a5c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brick<->concrete", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brick", "B": "concrete"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brick<->concrete", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2401539", "image_sha256": "4f41309f0fe3ede1827175fa5b8f6f04a1aa684779b0cf9bbf82cb7c058231f4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401539.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401539.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2353959", "image_sha256": "3cb4e377937f293c761dba23a9b3b9e62e9a527b8d917dc4bbce78028abea916", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2353959.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2353959.jpg", "width": 277}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d69d22374e610a5c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brick", "diff_b": "concrete", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brick", "component_b": "concrete"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brick"], "detected_components": ["brick"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brick", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "85411a57905d3567da6279fdc40d3659c47f524aa773ad180e0e8f9c3d952d5b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1674579", "text": "What is on the brick wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["concrete"], "detected_components": ["concrete"], "masked_program_sha256": "da357ffba3da99efe70ffd252351b4e53f56e368d21162d53cec424c79f90160", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "concrete", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "262cff1081c91bcaa8deb9e9d368c06e9aa6c9c98c6aa0bf77879bd5d9ed5dcf"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "093514", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 457, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 29, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2bef5906f241b03de4a71550f0a90863677e1dfbf3df580f7d6977acbeba0222", "selected_component": "concrete", "selected_source_question_id": "093514", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the concrete wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "2bef5906f241b03de4a71550f0a90863677e1dfbf3df580f7d6977acbeba0222", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "2bef5906f241b03de4a71550f0a90863677e1dfbf3df580f7d6977acbeba0222", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the brick wall?", "question_id": "1674579", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (398402)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brick", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (398398)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "graffiti", "full_answer": "The graffiti is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the concrete wall?", "question_id": "093514", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (3778647)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "concrete", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (842083)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["398398", "398400", "398401", "398405", "398406", "398412", "398420"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["decorative", "gold", "ornate", "square"], "query_target_entity_id": "398398", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "398402", "relation_subject_entity_id": "398398", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "398402", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["398402"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "concrete", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3778634", "3778635", "3778641", "3778643", "842081", "842082", "842083", "842085", "842086", "842087", "842093", "842094"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["graffiti"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "842083", "query_target_entity_name": "graffiti", "relation_object_entity_id": "3778647", "relation_subject_entity_id": "842083", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3778647", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "concrete", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3778647"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:63f5fd951a010e5cb9de88dc60050d33", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4f41309f0fe3ede1827175fa5b8f6f04a1aa684779b0cf9bbf82cb7c058231f4", "image_sha256_b": "3cb4e377937f293c761dba23a9b3b9e62e9a527b8d917dc4bbce78028abea916", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1d44a7210dbeee8c2db9bb31684bba6ddd3cf6a68f110d53e91b47b827c9125d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1cc305a42d26cefd64ddb857b049ad79", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ee8f50b7ee9f590d0764e1ccda3e96faede7fd6fc134ae42073d2c644af0c065"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7486188c5f5b15744aeb45f927b71bec8f0bacfc032ce41b37c5f5fbfcc1f557", "request_id": "86e297a464ed1164e8de416957ee2ad1", "response_sha256": "9c0ab5e4a1f8bc66fc564c7ae35d1e08ee3ee623bf92a8b3ead22ead9a01ad2e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2012edc3c240bf3b87e0f14dc95cdb7dc7ec4a331c81fd07afbcd7cdcb4ec4f0", "request_id": "f889534b5c80fe0aa821046aa077d69d", "response_sha256": "ddc95d4040da03078e15186401fa295eb121613b744cdf5dea4b0e78a9a7cf67", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "b2fbccf88c1c1638ac969e56d8fb32ba", "candidate_priority_rank": 458, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-66296a24eb7e23de:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-66296a24eb7e23de:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-66296a24eb7e23de:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-66296a24eb7e23de:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2346049", "image_sha256": "bdd6253f7d6c18d2b9b923c93ad65c5faf146971553e260dd76822449d2d5e06", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2346049.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2346049.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2403766", "image_sha256": "12a4768b1d2609ca93bb2ce8c2fd24ba18dd51aef07707530fe9acd4e2a5c263", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2403766.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2403766.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-66296a24eb7e23de", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["gray", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "6b568b1812431ce4d60a7c5e1acc91f24777a1335fa385a7b8c9fc14dfb2aeb0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["trees"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["trees"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e487523ba2e92a368e20d8288b9bd59fdbd57079e7888fbe6f95fa89cbd9a1b6"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "011017283", "text": "What is in front of the green trees?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "6b568b1812431ce4d60a7c5e1acc91f24777a1335fa385a7b8c9fc14dfb2aeb0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["trees"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["trees"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9c4800dec28efc73b1e77e1094883d8fff1d4b681ebc735820c467b76a2fcb2d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "101018606", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 458, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 25, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8fab900ee8e1dd536d9331d7ecc762e88ac8d24f148be8762d9773ce42861e56", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "101018606", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the brown trees?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "trees", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the trees?", "program_group_hash": "8fab900ee8e1dd536d9331d7ecc762e88ac8d24f148be8762d9773ce42861e56", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "trees"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "trees", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the trees?", "program_group_hash": "8fab900ee8e1dd536d9331d7ecc762e88ac8d24f148be8762d9773ce42861e56", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "trees"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "fence", "full_answer": "The fence is in front of the trees.", "question": "What is in front of the green trees?", "question_id": "011017283", "semantic": [{"argument": "trees (2615603)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (2442933)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "snow", "full_answer": "The snow is in front of the trees.", "question": "What is in front of the brown trees?", "question_id": "101018606", "semantic": [{"argument": "trees (1121726)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (1121720)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1759671", "1838119", "2442933", "2841194", "3187577", "3360875", "3397361", "3619945", "3911015"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fence"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2442933", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "2615603", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2442933", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2615603", "selected_entity_name": "trees"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2615603"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1121714", "1121716", "1121717", "1121719", "1121720", "1121721", "1121722", "1121724", "1121725", "1121727", "1121728", "1121729"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["snow"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1121720", "query_target_entity_name": "snow", "relation_object_entity_id": "1121726", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1121720", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1121726", "selected_entity_name": "trees"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1121726"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b2fbccf88c1c1638ac969e56d8fb32ba", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bdd6253f7d6c18d2b9b923c93ad65c5faf146971553e260dd76822449d2d5e06", "image_sha256_b": "12a4768b1d2609ca93bb2ce8c2fd24ba18dd51aef07707530fe9acd4e2a5c263", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "80299fd2673a5a28b60995273bb7343024384162321f9202d343189e32bda3f2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2f6545ac84cd7dd6a14d059ec2b166d0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5951cb24871fb8328ffd4420ae132724a7c6e1b97b2cd33d73b65dc33b9d7857"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "02769ab3cb73b5cd2182597f49b5ba992f5ad7f03789df2773393b235e93d2f2", "request_id": "07df477df333445ee5ae42382ef83049", "response_sha256": "3d705893c7fac0a37ce1f53f68bcda9607c6b94e98cc3a22bb2a436f0828a7bb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a9ab9b2d721f0b083b24a701df5b711135126cbbb32af2b7adb6d3fae847d757", "request_id": "41a5bdcc93a6b4376f7e932e308fabb5", "response_sha256": "ffcc7bd79c25400489e70c1e551fadc92354aa5aa6044c861ecf1a4cbaaf87e8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "172c072c55ae1d03cc84849997855bbf", "candidate_priority_rank": 502, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-900b7d8e78bdd708:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-900b7d8e78bdd708:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-900b7d8e78bdd708:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-900b7d8e78bdd708:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brick<->concrete", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brick", "B": "concrete"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brick<->concrete", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2344930", "image_sha256": "921c23249f6e09bc40f2a27c0fdcb8762dd3b687ea657d0513872eedc8fd5ee3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2344930.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2344930.jpg", "width": 380}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2342503", "image_sha256": "a225e3a9973178888f1a24b91dda7ce91fa22f2cae2eed878feb46d99df54f48", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342503.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342503.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-900b7d8e78bdd708", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brick", "diff_b": "concrete", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brick", "component_b": "concrete"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brick"], "detected_components": ["brick"], "masked_program_sha256": "3fb640f4e3c5302fcc88056b11cfd2cce938788a668fc8a1ad55612a35b0341a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brick", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "12a14d96cf332a910c7c2375be60cafbd0d82a672d8208a80704d0cce6a1fbd3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05702279", "text": "What animal is in front of the brick wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["concrete", "metal", "stainless steel"], "detected_components": ["concrete"], "masked_program_sha256": "3fb640f4e3c5302fcc88056b11cfd2cce938788a668fc8a1ad55612a35b0341a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "concrete", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c1ac7749066736f04d9bfea566df3ff0c7401acb43eaf0f2b4076142f8123812"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01695588", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 502, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2fc798b9c308e8042023636403d3feedbc27c70dd5fbfad5c2f9801c5c7d3a6f", "selected_component": "concrete", "selected_source_question_id": "01695588", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in front of the concrete wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "2fc798b9c308e8042023636403d3feedbc27c70dd5fbfad5c2f9801c5c7d3a6f", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "2fc798b9c308e8042023636403d3feedbc27c70dd5fbfad5c2f9801c5c7d3a6f", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is in front of the wall.", "question": "What animal is in front of the brick wall?", "question_id": "05702279", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (2657659)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brick", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (3913670)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The giraffe is in front of the wall.", "question": "What animal is in front of the concrete wall?", "question_id": "01695588", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (2213928)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "concrete", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (3056199)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2300298", "3913670"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3913670", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "2657659", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3913670", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2657659", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2657659"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "concrete", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3056199"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3056199", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "2213928", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3056199", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2213928", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "concrete", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2213928"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:172c072c55ae1d03cc84849997855bbf", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "921c23249f6e09bc40f2a27c0fdcb8762dd3b687ea657d0513872eedc8fd5ee3", "image_sha256_b": "a225e3a9973178888f1a24b91dda7ce91fa22f2cae2eed878feb46d99df54f48", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "81462af8bc60886b9b778d3ae0b1f34cf79fdb6439dbccff754399054c90d206", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "32e5a3302abb407ba42438cd61cc829e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "db9605eae87767b4031eaa07a6214a788f7ea551435b5e8f78d21f3f4b9688c7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0bd057a01725d41e50d04d987a5efa830dbd7c0eb02a7c86d67efb13465cf17d", "request_id": "38227332734fcd955e0d8e98e0b6f4d5", "response_sha256": "864d13545388df45db6806cf5c74ed390178c3b958f3f3130e47362e4831e47d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "766c966696705e68989bc537722689444a6ce7b0b6bfe782568a5508f28719f2", "request_id": "461d3150a093f91bd077f4f9c25adbc7", "response_sha256": "fdc32a00029f1f90050d9ffee3a09a54c2f8139cd8c0b616992101396d694593", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "7d11f839c8f2b90767cd5f28ad2dc2e3", "candidate_priority_rank": 520, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8ea521f69ba225c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8ea521f69ba225c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8ea521f69ba225c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8ea521f69ba225c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->blue", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2374500", "image_sha256": "1ba87a7730f111fb2d138bb3b214d0d12b8dc54eb566d34e06dc6f17cd42150f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2374500.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2374500.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2353125", "image_sha256": "e2855e262c0580f6590b028bbf43e7944c6fc9c7a4bb94211b60b8b3d900f92d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2353125.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2353125.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8ea521f69ba225c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "gray", "green", "red", "tan", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "8a74541076b3c6c36c39c867a1e3c73db8132d9a6b84e02debfda861ac336426", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["car", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["car", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f4f66778a0f85d79680eda634b60a2e28d2e911b7fff5697273acfc0e2cec9ad"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09769723", "text": "What animal is on the blue car?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray", "green"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "8a74541076b3c6c36c39c867a1e3c73db8132d9a6b84e02debfda861ac336426", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["car", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["car", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0d034014f0d8e6de613d1830e9df873cf1e645c9952d3629e7aa13583e7a482a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16424457", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 520, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b29bdbc2218ed08944fbdc2ea26fccfd3a12b91f2af4fa4aa80e2f33d52648e5", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "16424457", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is on the black car?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "car", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the car?", "program_group_hash": "b29bdbc2218ed08944fbdc2ea26fccfd3a12b91f2af4fa4aa80e2f33d52648e5", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "car"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "car", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the car?", "program_group_hash": "b29bdbc2218ed08944fbdc2ea26fccfd3a12b91f2af4fa4aa80e2f33d52648e5", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "car"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is on the car.", "question": "What animal is on the blue car?", "question_id": "09769723", "semantic": [{"argument": "car (726443)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (726442)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is on the car.", "question": "What animal is on the black car?", "question_id": "16424457", "semantic": [{"argument": "car (849139)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (849137)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["726442"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "looking down", "staring"], "query_target_entity_id": "726442", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "726443", "relation_subject_entity_id": "726442", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "726443", "selected_entity_name": "car"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["726443"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["849137"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "striped"], "query_target_entity_id": "849137", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "849139", "relation_subject_entity_id": "849137", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "849139", "selected_entity_name": "car"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["849139"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:7d11f839c8f2b90767cd5f28ad2dc2e3", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1ba87a7730f111fb2d138bb3b214d0d12b8dc54eb566d34e06dc6f17cd42150f", "image_sha256_b": "e2855e262c0580f6590b028bbf43e7944c6fc9c7a4bb94211b60b8b3d900f92d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5ba79aff498c4e3292b1e74c002e71599445a0739dedd9c4db2b8942e07ab108", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "36228e84a0f617b14ced20a948a9cf4f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d46e8b78e68d03d7b3bcfb9f71a93f897260ef229d71029c64357a86e331ead2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7e99b1d72a5ef0d4af580caff99dcfa0048e85398ee2b78e971d879c2a51581c", "request_id": "56e0c0726c58eb611083877f787904b4", "response_sha256": "bd390d844989c42471563c08ed106bcbed0291b315d2c8c679921667784a53ca", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e77734ce094a3b5022b974f086ddc1f280c4d71e10d6be5670d26dd2c0001706", "request_id": "472230dbe858e7cdd845b1e0a6b6b1df", "response_sha256": "bd073b29b6a4ec1e411ab19b604876941404e3a3bb8fca6732bb16032286479b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a333cd5211f5d55dee232a28c0787165", "candidate_priority_rank": 532, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a1c7a3831024f6dd:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a1c7a3831024f6dd:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a1c7a3831024f6dd:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a1c7a3831024f6dd:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "green<->yellow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "yellow"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->yellow", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 354, "image_id": "2411872", "image_sha256": "b26e33a6854a319585fde3276cf1775f7b6c5f18041b9634e1f807111df72815", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2411872.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2411872.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2344996", "image_sha256": "11096fed95a86b93899a329d0d5d5db632478236c82372d7f9205bf4a07a8c89", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2344996.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2344996.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-a1c7a3831024f6dd", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "yellow", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "yellow"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blond", "blue", "brown", "dark blue", "green", "silver"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "455582afd61e34072e8d4315650ea23843fd2c1379f34329335d76a09d624f4b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7f4166add81364af492810c58bc0bc030a3a4a6244525da9dfe5409721db2eea"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06954204", "text": "What kind of furniture is in front of the green wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "dark", "orange", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["yellow"], "masked_program_sha256": "455582afd61e34072e8d4315650ea23843fd2c1379f34329335d76a09d624f4b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yellow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "60a1590671a9d62999e82a3547e68d3797e44215af3c5dd8d2e83515da6c8c87"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08362177", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 532, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "eee44b7d417e830475a0b1e49a58289d21c4c91da464bb58bf77936509db3b75", "selected_component": "yellow", "selected_source_question_id": "08362177", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of furniture is in front of the yellow wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture is in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "eee44b7d417e830475a0b1e49a58289d21c4c91da464bb58bf77936509db3b75", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture is in front of the wall?", "program_group_hash": "eee44b7d417e830475a0b1e49a58289d21c4c91da464bb58bf77936509db3b75", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sofa", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a sofa.", "question": "What kind of furniture is in front of the green wall?", "question_id": "06954204", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (208046)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s (208048)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What kind of furniture is in front of the yellow wall?", "question_id": "08362177", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (2067983)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "yellow", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s (3628100)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["208048"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sofa"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "208048", "query_target_entity_name": "sofa", "relation_object_entity_id": "208046", "relation_subject_entity_id": "208048", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "208046", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["208046"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2595462", "2673664", "3628100", "3628105", "3628106"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3628100", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "2067983", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3628100", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2067983", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "yellow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2067983"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:a333cd5211f5d55dee232a28c0787165", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b26e33a6854a319585fde3276cf1775f7b6c5f18041b9634e1f807111df72815", "image_sha256_b": "11096fed95a86b93899a329d0d5d5db632478236c82372d7f9205bf4a07a8c89", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "713373419dde135ffb7b409e0221c6724f3f386b4031c72f6ae0a15cdaa466b6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "db61a5f7a03b78e4d6739ed32a03fd33", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0fe9b0c86bb092a56736428bad9cf2d8205a2ac0bcb158b27d1895071e8bf10e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "85a150f6e76ac7eaea6dd889ee45018a18a280b0230c151b46e19eb7efc3f4a4", "request_id": "0a71dfa7be38007e445ecd6631703eed", "response_sha256": "8672b7b5815f2922740fcda9f87ac1c7afc45cf497d4e9353778c2898d256a83", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6de7a7655697c4e12f664272beb5213f209af830dbfe9176e01df958ab722f3f", "request_id": "4a8093102499de1edc2324c529ba141b", "response_sha256": "436a4f7e5bc437c9bedb7476cc36cfcc16cd4c2c6d41c2f42ad628220869894d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "160084ca94af23529b3d2ab29361718f", "candidate_priority_rank": 591, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-01beef6006f90ef3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-01beef6006f90ef3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-01beef6006f90ef3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-01beef6006f90ef3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "glass<->metal", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "metal", "B": "glass"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "metal<->glass", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 382, "image_id": "2399896", "image_sha256": "09da7e7aee3e4b80f5f4389a6f76c29837e3e9696ad8adf599077d0f85b69e83", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399896.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399896.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2409200", "image_sha256": "4ef1d424ab96f636ea774240ec701aa4bf4c20e030e5b11122b27bb9a7fe2a5f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2409200.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2409200.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-01beef6006f90ef3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "metal", "diff_b": "glass", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "metal", "component_b": "glass"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal"], "detected_components": ["metal"], "masked_program_sha256": "90cda5614ed04073f85eace61812ed0870e14eb5844098d466cedbda69f92214", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "metal", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "505e4b9686406bea0c73159b9ac915e3fa73d04468ea297fd896835549f81c7f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06811089", "text": "What is inside the appliance made of metal?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["glass", "plastic"], "detected_components": ["glass"], "masked_program_sha256": "90cda5614ed04073f85eace61812ed0870e14eb5844098d466cedbda69f92214", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "glass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e9576f8559aa2604bd9c3dc9b108407c7713c67f21dcca2bbca8b917882ba11b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0979702", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 591, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "bac22562217a09a7e7b45cabd59b443613fda63f290b8f027617386a7ae6c92a", "selected_component": "glass", "selected_source_question_id": "0979702", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is inside the appliance made of glass?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "appliance", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is inside the appliance made of ?", "program_group_hash": "bac22562217a09a7e7b45cabd59b443613fda63f290b8f027617386a7ae6c92a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "appliance"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "appliance", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is inside the appliance made of ?", "program_group_hash": "bac22562217a09a7e7b45cabd59b443613fda63f290b8f027617386a7ae6c92a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "appliance"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dish", "full_answer": "The dish is inside the oven.", "question": "What is inside the appliance made of metal?", "question_id": "06811089", "semantic": [{"argument": "appliance (661261)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "metal", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,inside,s (661259)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "liquid", "full_answer": "The liquid is inside the blender.", "question": "What is inside the appliance made of glass?", "question_id": "0979702", "semantic": [{"argument": "appliance (246843)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "glass", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,inside,s (246842)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["661259", "661260", "661270", "661275", "661276", "661278"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dish"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue", "ceramic"], "query_target_entity_id": "661259", "query_target_entity_name": "dish", "relation_object_entity_id": "661261", "relation_subject_entity_id": "661259", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "661261", "selected_entity_name": "oven"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["661261"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "metal", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["246842", "246845", "246846", "246847", "246849"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["liquid"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "246842", "query_target_entity_name": "liquid", "relation_object_entity_id": "246843", "relation_subject_entity_id": "246842", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "246843", "selected_entity_name": "blender"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["246843"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:160084ca94af23529b3d2ab29361718f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "09da7e7aee3e4b80f5f4389a6f76c29837e3e9696ad8adf599077d0f85b69e83", "image_sha256_b": "4ef1d424ab96f636ea774240ec701aa4bf4c20e030e5b11122b27bb9a7fe2a5f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4e60a79628d562d185c0804d82f06d3caa71822bcdadeb4d01e90891cf5eacbb", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "16a64a5254a6a9fce7adc38f4b3c32f4", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b72628f892c6519f34f6048b63aa81402009eaff89ed1a02331b378b1373311e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a9f28b36ebfa1bc182489344c3cfae1a651d4c452f38ecdbebe11324f1bfc567", "request_id": "6fee88efbc17f7e502a48fb0c7604522", "response_sha256": "12a8cd3846bdca1513a5e7de0125bbdd1058b4d25d74df0b4a12dc3924e89ede", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e032219709d20509a3e5c1642b6ed7af3d281f89200044daa29ec45d520ce1d5", "request_id": "ccc7e047f4442fcf54465052cd05e1e2", "response_sha256": "35775fdcce88253eaf5efa551f5160776b6150b1ef3662d715ede599e8a8d11a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "37017cb0c88332d5c001ed9668a614d7", "candidate_priority_rank": 608, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b037a1e59d2a6653:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b037a1e59d2a6653:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b037a1e59d2a6653:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b037a1e59d2a6653:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dark<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "dark"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->dark", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2399454", "image_sha256": "8ad60253199ecd0cf650fc2f10bf85cca92137618a5137c44ef344ac2ce53e41", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399454.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399454.jpg", "width": 374}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2365253", "image_sha256": "8740563c0121ee830e4f3ef0b3b8c9edaa25e99b7f5ca5869f33c5093fa482b0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365253.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365253.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-b037a1e59d2a6653", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "dark", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "dark"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gold", "purple", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "6d1f21837850e133bba99d1bd922487a87e32ca03cf50e307f09f62daa77d93d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "baked good"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "baked good"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "97ab756ccb9050b07d3110f9e5bd07cec2c7141bde876810be628d74b41493ad"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "15738511", "text": "What kind of baked good is on the white plate?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["dark", "silver", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["dark"], "masked_program_sha256": "6d1f21837850e133bba99d1bd922487a87e32ca03cf50e307f09f62daa77d93d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "baked good"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dark", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "baked good"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "34230a6ceaddc9083665c07d42a4d43e6a4d6a3207b29465a5455d8a0dd78408"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "111027406", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 608, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0afb2e33f7c942ee265d15a00182b4339df5123fcfaf66120eab638d0fbd517f", "selected_component": "dark", "selected_source_question_id": "111027406", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of baked good is on the dark plate?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of baked good is on the plate?", "program_group_hash": "0afb2e33f7c942ee265d15a00182b4339df5123fcfaf66120eab638d0fbd517f", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of baked good is on the plate?", "program_group_hash": "0afb2e33f7c942ee265d15a00182b4339df5123fcfaf66120eab638d0fbd517f", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "donuts", "full_answer": "The food is donuts.", "question": "What kind of baked good is on the white plate?", "question_id": "15738511", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (1169554)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s (1169553)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "waffle", "full_answer": "The food is a waffle.", "question": "What kind of baked good is on the dark plate?", "question_id": "111027406", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (635585)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dark", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s (635589)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1169553"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["donuts"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["glazed", "round"], "query_target_entity_id": "1169553", "query_target_entity_name": "donuts", "relation_object_entity_id": "1169554", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1169553", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1169554", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1169554"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["635589"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["waffle"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "635589", "query_target_entity_name": "waffle", "relation_object_entity_id": "635585", "relation_subject_entity_id": "635589", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "635585", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["635585"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:37017cb0c88332d5c001ed9668a614d7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8ad60253199ecd0cf650fc2f10bf85cca92137618a5137c44ef344ac2ce53e41", "image_sha256_b": "8740563c0121ee830e4f3ef0b3b8c9edaa25e99b7f5ca5869f33c5093fa482b0", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "58fe952e750c783d3967d3142d0e682307c6e2ae988dc13f4c62d8f4727d1ce4", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "852cbe537dfec489cd9c0d22d64a0fb3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7bbc6b42f0dbec96644c77799e6ec6cf8f78bbe7e2caf18bcfc8bca4e3708e18"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c6e5cb800c4c92821ac4341079c90ef79b04fb20f7847c4d26c354b4739f32ac", "request_id": "20546f9ebc732bae0a06264efb7bc3b6", "response_sha256": "85e8cdb7dfdd4be8aaf30f770da9a2e7428905357dab4d8c3fb678e7ba889b3a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c0a69672eddcfd9d011bca1dc7ddf8549e0e2b2854a5b32634dcc89389002469", "request_id": "a22772c6090f34427c8b6f43007b1a93", "response_sha256": "788284bd36e148604e4764ff415dc7be436fc8109a115043de1907a6942932f4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "5fa8ee222a86e669b4915bb1ed138869", "candidate_priority_rank": 664, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9bdafe028741eeea:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9bdafe028741eeea:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9bdafe028741eeea:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9bdafe028741eeea:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "paper<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "wood", "B": "paper"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wood<->paper", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2402146", "image_sha256": "91c1524fbe45632ae7cfbc5fbd253b1b0cda10bb1864a48e64c2c46fbd748c86", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402146.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402146.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2382541", "image_sha256": "ee9eb956efcaef9c332098931665b356e38defb4ecda63df710663d9f4a6b855", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382541.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382541.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9bdafe028741eeea", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wood", "diff_b": "paper", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wood", "component_b": "paper"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["metal", "wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "21f5ffef2b5ae0afdad7587b416bb4648a46bae7ec3307e224c1b12bc73b3106", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0619fbcf4d111328cfe740535528e6132c26443ec76735bedfc06df694a07b4b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00629477", "text": "What is located on top of the wood plate?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["paper", "wood"], "detected_components": ["paper"], "masked_program_sha256": "21f5ffef2b5ae0afdad7587b416bb4648a46bae7ec3307e224c1b12bc73b3106", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "paper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a128c21ce9a24c22644beeabbc36d7a5271179422cb5d6a3cd2556c570e9f832"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "001026243", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 664, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "eb846915062a9c227cdc0439b6b2cc5748d9865901ecf254285fa630fc6b4162", "selected_component": "paper", "selected_source_question_id": "001026243", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is located on top of the paper plate?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is located on top of the plate?", "program_group_hash": "eb846915062a9c227cdc0439b6b2cc5748d9865901ecf254285fa630fc6b4162", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "plate", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is located on top of the plate?", "program_group_hash": "eb846915062a9c227cdc0439b6b2cc5748d9865901ecf254285fa630fc6b4162", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "plate"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The pizza is on top of the plate.", "question": "What is located on top of the wood plate?", "question_id": "00629477", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (1139797)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on top of,s (1139798)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The pizza is on top of the plate.", "question": "What is located on top of the paper plate?", "question_id": "001026243", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (1327939)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "paper", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,on top of,s (1327938)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1139798", "1139799", "1139800", "1139802", "1139805", "1139807", "1139809", "1139810"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1139798", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "1139797", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1139798", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1139797", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1139797"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1327938", "1327942", "1327943", "1327944", "1327945", "1327946", "1327947", "1327948", "1327949", "1327951", "1327953", "1327954", "1327957"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["cooked"], "query_target_entity_id": "1327938", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "1327939", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1327938", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1327939", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1327939"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:5fa8ee222a86e669b4915bb1ed138869", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "91c1524fbe45632ae7cfbc5fbd253b1b0cda10bb1864a48e64c2c46fbd748c86", "image_sha256_b": "ee9eb956efcaef9c332098931665b356e38defb4ecda63df710663d9f4a6b855", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1131182e809fb3ce384747ed7d86c10ded44fa5f6f22c7b0d7153b26c46db025", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "12218ca64517e067fab96fb0682d848d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "628091c6ac9153ff2b1c16e9a268e6f94a6bb76c6b9489ceb08d8c56552fb62e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a4d9d807c44424323f322640efb2b76b9c1350d4c08ef6293c295faf1dfd9e19", "request_id": "87d0e9d1eba7298725110a662ac32d7d", "response_sha256": "6359680ab717b7d09ddfdc6387085a4dd19e9a3b6ffd64bbf6320d8f823abdf2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7eefcb4c6ad77c1df8a7201a42e89731b8ba16c40d8f774a6783f80c9d28b02f", "request_id": "a1936d1b27c881b703793c64a3662997", "response_sha256": "6c760fea326ec351705a9e829d6ee19529a3e348cb89da5749a7f0bb381dd847", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "98a9df00883234634b11e7ee0948962b", "candidate_priority_rank": 695, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3001ee4d4ab00baa:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3001ee4d4ab00baa:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3001ee4d4ab00baa:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3001ee4d4ab00baa:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "standing<->walking", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "standing", "B": "walking"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "standing<->walking", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 401, "image_id": "2405653", "image_sha256": "07731bfb32559b17d14be5020162520e05f26df734e6219a43244e1c0b67c3ac", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405653.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405653.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2406191", "image_sha256": "5a29f38d5a9cad1db81ad47293bff119beb3c4ff36c1aaeb1e3768640a3770ec", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2406191.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2406191.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3001ee4d4ab00baa", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "standing", "diff_b": "walking", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "standing", "component_b": "walking"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["standing"], "detected_components": ["standing"], "masked_program_sha256": "3eafefa1f150106ecb0f6ac9d4f2a101a7bef14f0cf770523ae085376fa163c7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "standing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e28d39eaf0b51772839cf848d5d3a6ddad024b35983dd61f5c3e840e3c47979e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09755172", "text": "What is the person that is standing carrying?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["walking"], "detected_components": ["walking"], "masked_program_sha256": "3eafefa1f150106ecb0f6ac9d4f2a101a7bef14f0cf770523ae085376fa163c7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "walking", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "aa7c7006aa8cb0446d7628663df50887837d1c0e4f6d66aaadb1a38546e7dee9"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03952718", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 695, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "74fbf935582792afa8d9a7dadb0eb2d773e980ca6ef4ccefd7454dfa745b7414", "selected_component": "walking", "selected_source_question_id": "03952718", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is walking carrying?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is carrying?", "program_group_hash": "74fbf935582792afa8d9a7dadb0eb2d773e980ca6ef4ccefd7454dfa745b7414", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "carrying", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "pose", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is carrying?", "program_group_hash": "74fbf935582792afa8d9a7dadb0eb2d773e980ca6ef4ccefd7454dfa745b7414", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "carrying", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "umbrella", "full_answer": "The woman is carrying an umbrella.", "question": "What is the person that is standing carrying?", "question_id": "09755172", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1106869)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "standing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o (1106868)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "umbrella", "full_answer": "The woman is carrying an umbrella.", "question": "What is the person that is walking carrying?", "question_id": "03952718", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (325921)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "walking", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter pose"}, {"argument": "_,carrying,o (325923)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1106868", "1106872", "1106874", "1106875", "1106876", "1106877", "1106878", "1106881", "1106882", "1106884", "1106885", "1106886", "1106887", "1106888"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["umbrella"], "predicate": "carrying", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "tilted"], "query_target_entity_id": "1106868", "query_target_entity_name": "umbrella", "relation_object_entity_id": "1106868", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1106869", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1106869", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1106869"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "standing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["325919", "325920", "325922", "325923", "325924", "325925", "325927", "325928", "325931", "325932", "325933", "325934", "325937", "325939"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["umbrella"], "predicate": "carrying", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["dark"], "query_target_entity_id": "325923", "query_target_entity_name": "umbrella", "relation_object_entity_id": "325923", "relation_subject_entity_id": "325921", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "325921", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "walking", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["325921"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:98a9df00883234634b11e7ee0948962b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "07731bfb32559b17d14be5020162520e05f26df734e6219a43244e1c0b67c3ac", "image_sha256_b": "5a29f38d5a9cad1db81ad47293bff119beb3c4ff36c1aaeb1e3768640a3770ec", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "92dfb36404630165ee1a4e4cdae12e3e18e92d5481b75dbace54536cf5df6e12", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e09c3889022f9deac549bc8cabfed512", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4a14375fccf2763a7915b5485392698690d8dc44d215838062b631af870154bf"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0997f9f7f00664339e67b8e8ccf6f7857bff2a03fa15defd2c8578d5aad7f744", "request_id": "dd72298997b5128c127c469350b09052", "response_sha256": "d597d736b98fa5f400f972cfb58bcb84a45d2f03a8af93af7959b3990cae9b72", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "488ceb3d34490f2be7a9fea21fe7e532fdd9ea2f935509a3db64f6ff0fab899e", "request_id": "fbb389a58e71f348e79f27212740ae13", "response_sha256": "a697d7bf0bd2d4ba5ecc7d0634fc7e449ae97fc289bb6591cca30b81431b829f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "86b7637915b73ba13d4e46f08540ed24", "candidate_priority_rank": 697, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d65c408fc3914492:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d65c408fc3914492:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d65c408fc3914492:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d65c408fc3914492:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gray", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gray<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 393, "image_id": "2407477", "image_sha256": "ad984ef8a59ca9fa2aa166dadfea75727beba87e41e9043a7a45462660d82425", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407477.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407477.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 370, "image_id": "2404663", "image_sha256": "b7970d7f8d9fc3cb7a6b5c52f40f3bc5c8dad073d54d2837cfc6c2f41ec69bab", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404663.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404663.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d65c408fc3914492", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gray", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gray", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["gray", "red", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "de66aef07411df154654dc0fec3ced85fc2bbb411ae2a5d6fe4f38cb6611214d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "263e2db97297c0d8a5ca1712e66c6905c7e6166bc273d791293b0dd07834ec9d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03622473", "text": "What is lying on the gray table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "tan", "white"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "de66aef07411df154654dc0fec3ced85fc2bbb411ae2a5d6fe4f38cb6611214d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0adeff779bc08e7a17b166e49b5245eea1e07489e1ff266427b11cc1c7a0407b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1751585", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 697, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "740ea82b4385a5a9e80d98e3d7ea7923832d9842bf5211574a9e30ff83ea8fc3", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "1751585", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is lying on the blue table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is lying on the table?", "program_group_hash": "740ea82b4385a5a9e80d98e3d7ea7923832d9842bf5211574a9e30ff83ea8fc3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is lying on the table?", "program_group_hash": "740ea82b4385a5a9e80d98e3d7ea7923832d9842bf5211574a9e30ff83ea8fc3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "soda bottle", "full_answer": "The soda bottle is lying on the table.", "question": "What is lying on the gray table?", "question_id": "03622473", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (278735)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,s (278734)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "papers", "full_answer": "The papers are lying on the table.", "question": "What is lying on the blue table?", "question_id": "1751585", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (1113997)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,s (1113996)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["278734", "278736", "278746", "278747", "278748", "278749", "278751", "278755", "278759"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["soda bottle"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "278734", "query_target_entity_name": "soda bottle", "relation_object_entity_id": "278735", "relation_subject_entity_id": "278734", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "278735", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["278735"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1113985", "1113989", "1113994", "1113995", "1113996", "1113999", "1114000", "1114003", "1114004", "1114005", "1114007", "1114008", "1114009", "1114010", "1114011", "1114012", "1114013", "1114015", "1114016", "1114018", "1114019", "1114020"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["papers"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1113996", "query_target_entity_name": "papers", "relation_object_entity_id": "1113997", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1113996", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1113997", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1113997"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:86b7637915b73ba13d4e46f08540ed24", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ad984ef8a59ca9fa2aa166dadfea75727beba87e41e9043a7a45462660d82425", "image_sha256_b": "b7970d7f8d9fc3cb7a6b5c52f40f3bc5c8dad073d54d2837cfc6c2f41ec69bab", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4af6f24a616d76a6d0970b0acd57080d713dd004da5f86381a5f22547bd2021f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "07dad3a0873a262c80490c5c561134fd", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0c4b2d6817d79f3b543ccdf051d0827d035b96610d411ca2177133df22b1ab83"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2c1d4ee42ef8ce222fffabf408adbc6bae7fe582ec6ccb7437249f653d6c6bd2", "request_id": "39f0b18e3364bb8f409813107b8be968", "response_sha256": "19c010a9e96bda033efcb2662fdace5cb02b845e120697ae9807a2aa956b62bf", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4da2e5e2871f1d1ebe07cba7780829be44eb989b8557233279ca5885155a3382", "request_id": "b54280ba729df8645b5cc6f9b2d9c5a4", "response_sha256": "f4da48652a8a2d9d372c801a14f975845e7744de668a266abdf62c13222ec71d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "f4413bb1930020561c7dab542cbabcfd", "candidate_priority_rank": 735, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9b90a6ba830d7fe6:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9b90a6ba830d7fe6:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9b90a6ba830d7fe6:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9b90a6ba830d7fe6:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2404075", "image_sha256": "b09b08c0ea0e2d82f19d2b2aa7a7e1fd895ceb5112ce0235a61cf4fe4f406b80", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404075.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404075.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2320806", "image_sha256": "fb6d355c31e5871348a73efa21adf0f37ed7d928e1cb1eb39a8600078b9beb77", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2320806.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2320806.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9b90a6ba830d7fe6", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "purple", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7a0994aa1383bc7f1c7329a5d805dffd1939235482f9eb08d3d80d44e66ef59c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "17627412", "text": "What is the brown animal lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "cream colored", "gray", "pink", "tan", "white"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "91d1592f7bf0089742152e74ccb0a3959ee75e28c571161ff9adc73e06296a93", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "25b2ebf5450ab8f6832a88e335951651cfc0d4167e9358a98f694987cb350da8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14973653", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 735, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 27, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "14973653", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the gray animal lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal lying on?", "program_group_hash": "f6060cdb92a364624819007ee71d0b6e684c4db7c876c7663e4e2eef109b0b1b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "blanket", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the blanket.", "question": "What is the brown animal lying on?", "question_id": "17627412", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1119040)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (1119044)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the couch.", "question": "What is the gray animal lying on?", "question_id": "14973653", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (2876102)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (3123629)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1119041", "1119042", "1119043", "1119044", "1119045", "1119046", "1119047", "1119048", "1119055", "1119056", "1119057", "1119058", "1119059", "1119060"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blanket"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1119044", "query_target_entity_name": "blanket", "relation_object_entity_id": "1119044", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1119040", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1119040", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1119040"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2751373", "2819371", "2928982", "2959983", "2959984", "3015553", "3068634", "3086582", "3110805", "3123629", "3143906", "3151690", "3186445", "3195995", "3443759", "3443760", "3533886"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3123629", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "3123629", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2876102", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2876102", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2876102"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:f4413bb1930020561c7dab542cbabcfd", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b09b08c0ea0e2d82f19d2b2aa7a7e1fd895ceb5112ce0235a61cf4fe4f406b80", "image_sha256_b": "fb6d355c31e5871348a73efa21adf0f37ed7d928e1cb1eb39a8600078b9beb77", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d669a621e5e8118dd4de2f4b431d2948b0459ad9dc03c06c332ea5b4fb02657d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c2d17d7f3639d0d7981857bf7ef9ca86", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d2d3ddd66a857e679d5c1de97557d35a7f60019164bb39052685abcff38511cd"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "250bc7c8aa5f7b170ef4a155a4604238fd39d4c8a172568dbbf60594027c519e", "request_id": "a38d493db2e993db9b0a218244ed69be", "response_sha256": "ba64c409a46f3d8a92074ec6190bd13e0e1695643bc6c865923d4ec308a60ced", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5bfb342eafdeb228d9ac1fd29e53e2b3e1f8da56aaeabeafe6500c99de17e5db", "request_id": "2b0e3fbba31110bd71d9c8d8a9f1ab52", "response_sha256": "841b5343f2b618dc25d9bc5973b2c797de61475c1409a3937d2900fdfd4508e5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "30e55c77cfccbb155ca6330d2b1fae8e", "candidate_priority_rank": 756, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8cdadd61c2793b1:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8cdadd61c2793b1:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8cdadd61c2793b1:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8cdadd61c2793b1:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gray", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gray<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 430, "image_id": "2372551", "image_sha256": "76dd75c4426a9aef84e7d39798846b13d83b73eb61906bd259b78f84c2778913", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2372551.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2372551.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2399218", "image_sha256": "b861624decedc7e3d24a9e841d2a3a843d68b8c6b1780dd3536bc3aded036bb9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399218.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399218.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e8cdadd61c2793b1", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gray", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gray", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "gray", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "c924a8633adaaec6ef087896af479678764a59bdf7f6670125b0df352179b6d8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f65d1ad690aebb5c7fa51054dd887c19cece71d797c9d881e1ea2cc2d2f1710e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00460853", "text": "What is the gray animal sitting on top of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "maroon", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "c924a8633adaaec6ef087896af479678764a59bdf7f6670125b0df352179b6d8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b6e3a8a2cf4ba0f11c35085fed3e4e1e9fd56bd476648e04700aac95a44ed072"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1496916", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 756, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f71d7a9b660b50c648694d61cffb68ba8b273fab09db7a20110660a4fd67a637", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "1496916", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the brown animal sitting on top of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on top of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal sitting on top of?", "program_group_hash": "f71d7a9b660b50c648694d61cffb68ba8b273fab09db7a20110660a4fd67a637", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on top of", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on top of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal sitting on top of?", "program_group_hash": "f71d7a9b660b50c648694d61cffb68ba8b273fab09db7a20110660a4fd67a637", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on top of", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The cat is sitting on top of the table.", "question": "What is the gray animal sitting on top of?", "question_id": "00460853", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (591378)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on top of,o (591380)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The dog is sitting on top of the couch.", "question": "What is the brown animal sitting on top of?", "question_id": "1496916", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1040628)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on top of,o (1040629)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["591379", "591380", "591382", "591386", "591393", "591400", "591401", "591402", "591403", "591404", "591405", "591406", "591407", "591408", "591409", "591410", "591411", "591412", "591417", "591418"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "sitting on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "591380", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "591380", "relation_subject_entity_id": "591378", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "591378", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["591378"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1040629", "1040630", "1040634", "1040635", "1040636", "1040638", "1040640", "1040641", "1040642", "1040644", "1040645", "1040646", "1040647", "1040648", "1040649", "1040650", "1040651", "1040652", "1040653"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "sitting on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["maroon"], "query_target_entity_id": "1040629", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "1040629", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1040628", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1040628", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1040628"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:30e55c77cfccbb155ca6330d2b1fae8e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "76dd75c4426a9aef84e7d39798846b13d83b73eb61906bd259b78f84c2778913", "image_sha256_b": "b861624decedc7e3d24a9e841d2a3a843d68b8c6b1780dd3536bc3aded036bb9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "501c4ca804c52f68e6ae198dbfd502348260e730b5d3f15b7c98badcc0289abf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7ce361877cd10dea22fbad4d3b37fdd9", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "eb36b61c6e980b2594465960c23e857932b9515f372666f6df9a02fd819d6def"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3cf3b965c65ab34b455376edf4fae341b44caa1857fee0ef70f2664b5eee7735", "request_id": "d7481fc0c253b8954e98622d1e412acc", "response_sha256": "0c2c68b6075994ffe451bd37908119c3653a4a1d448fd98a2f4a461821312eb4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f0147674a3e41c9acbd85b8eac5e5257077fcc25c308e8d799590f8d6cb0c9aa", "request_id": "0bb3f581e2377a8885d9ce73c120143c", "response_sha256": "7df2ee9f421e3a0d1d1e7304b3d17bd1f637c486142f22fe81c0665b356bbab5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "b2c2618daaea9be8c543ad7a6c118221", "candidate_priority_rank": 776, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6dce041e2350925d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6dce041e2350925d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6dce041e2350925d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6dce041e2350925d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dark<->green", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "dark", "B": "green"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dark<->green", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2417792", "image_sha256": "b21379769622b06f39fb39135c1782c0edec062e76eac7e1ca66c7ab50f23507", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2417792.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2417792.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2336148", "image_sha256": "4b08816baed4552e43f86369c0df442f25de49c566d45463a97e8d60ba9d7b73", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2336148.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2336148.jpg", "width": 414}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6dce041e2350925d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dark", "diff_b": "green", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dark", "component_b": "green"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "dark", "green", "orange", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["dark"], "masked_program_sha256": "f77866058976e1ed9d98de9678b87aa69d364648c6c238f45da0ea05ffb22421", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dark", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f25616ad6f3afce10104baba0358b19677312dbe94ee908cae7b240a75bebf86"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10474891", "text": "What is the animal in the dark water?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["green"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "f77866058976e1ed9d98de9678b87aa69d364648c6c238f45da0ea05ffb22421", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3b0791d6807665198cacd21906f2883620acf82c33f69efcdf3a976fd437d162"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0739058", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 776, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "674e6682319b5ea2e547644e2190c78256f2223014dd0f62ba093f4645353b11", "selected_component": "green", "selected_source_question_id": "0739058", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal in the green water?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal in the water?", "program_group_hash": "674e6682319b5ea2e547644e2190c78256f2223014dd0f62ba093f4645353b11", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal in the water?", "program_group_hash": "674e6682319b5ea2e547644e2190c78256f2223014dd0f62ba093f4645353b11", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "duck", "full_answer": "The animal is a duck.", "question": "What is the animal in the dark water?", "question_id": "10474891", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (1058167)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dark", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (1058168)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The animal is an elephant.", "question": "What is the animal in the green water?", "question_id": "0739058", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (1045271)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (1045270)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1058168"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["duck"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "swimming"], "query_target_entity_id": "1058168", "query_target_entity_name": "duck", "relation_object_entity_id": "1058167", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1058168", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1058167", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1058167"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "dark", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1045270"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1045270", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "1045271", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1045270", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1045271", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1045271"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:b2c2618daaea9be8c543ad7a6c118221", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b21379769622b06f39fb39135c1782c0edec062e76eac7e1ca66c7ab50f23507", "image_sha256_b": "4b08816baed4552e43f86369c0df442f25de49c566d45463a97e8d60ba9d7b73", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "46eeaaef1d17690308742016c8489a8d8c9dc7b5f77da01644694ba305a0bfd8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2ab2d849f43ffeaf8e509171514627d0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0147d6c869b71438b8e7fba80580b70fea15da608b3cabe3dfc9a84d21e2aa58"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4fe84a011c28e6b5a18c25101ce6cdd60f1bf90947243d464c4ad3b323899c24", "request_id": "f004051c17fcd98d9f66cafb1ff19ac3", "response_sha256": "8df6b98e503bb6388d4fe0d91d1a5a64bd053f298a855faba81c112f258478f5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "60a366a9c4f6efa28c1917a81ec4fb5a693df460379683d292128699abcd06c5", "request_id": "01b7fff923d65f61fc06f7bd66d3c1e6", "response_sha256": "0b317d770c551bb9def947e7f67157fec92f325e8f62b5def38e1e4bdc81cbb9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "0d0dec11b9814e6616332f667d175999", "candidate_priority_rank": 779, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7386ca27700f9d7b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7386ca27700f9d7b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7386ca27700f9d7b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7386ca27700f9d7b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gray", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gray<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2385325", "image_sha256": "55afb9220d65c4054ff6dbf3e4afdead41464f067b3097c9698e7718448d1152", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2385325.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2385325.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2377574", "image_sha256": "4670f78a2a3f6c016d588618a9e2f0f5f483ff8e72187738d93f107cea9e228a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2377574.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2377574.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7386ca27700f9d7b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gray", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gray", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "dark", "gray", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "fb844caa3f8dcf3bdbe34ef11b7d33b1028a8a5e8e3370cb637f9ab1962c40dd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b97d6650d4d31af2f36420d0ca8368739a385b0cd47291813f7d9b710c333f7a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18807887", "text": "What is the gray cat sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "fb844caa3f8dcf3bdbe34ef11b7d33b1028a8a5e8e3370cb637f9ab1962c40dd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0a0bc61bf2fef63580c37f64e3cd2c8084f0bac0dcd681bde77636dd7cf07a64"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1751015", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 779, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "cace96b12a25882fe64823b05a6a109ce3f28be16854ea205bf704c7439c768c", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "1751015", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the black cat sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "cat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cat sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "cace96b12a25882fe64823b05a6a109ce3f28be16854ea205bf704c7439c768c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "cat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cat sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "cace96b12a25882fe64823b05a6a109ce3f28be16854ea205bf704c7439c768c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dining table", "full_answer": "The cat is sitting on the dining table.", "question": "What is the gray cat sitting on?", "question_id": "18807887", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (1298333)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (1298334)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "laptop", "full_answer": "The cat is sitting on the laptop computer.", "question": "What is the black cat sitting on?", "question_id": "1751015", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (717430)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (717432)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1298334", "1298335", "1298336", "1298337", "1298338", "1298339", "1298340", "1298341", "1298342", "1298343", "1298344", "1298345", "1298346", "1298347", "1298348", "1298349", "1298350", "1298351", "1298352", "1298353", "1298354", "1298355", "1298356", "1298357", "1298363", "1298364", "1298365", "1298366", "1298367", "1298368", "1298370", "1298371", "1298372", "1298374", "1298375", "1298376", "1298377", "1298378", "1298379", "1298380", "1298381", "1298382", "1298383"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 43, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dining table"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1298334", "query_target_entity_name": "dining table", "relation_object_entity_id": "1298334", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1298333", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1298333", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1298333"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["717431", "717432", "717433", "717435", "717436", "717437", "717438", "717439", "717440", "717442", "717443", "717445", "717446"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["laptop"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "717432", "query_target_entity_name": "laptop", "relation_object_entity_id": "717432", "relation_subject_entity_id": "717430", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "717430", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["717430"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:0d0dec11b9814e6616332f667d175999", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "55afb9220d65c4054ff6dbf3e4afdead41464f067b3097c9698e7718448d1152", "image_sha256_b": "4670f78a2a3f6c016d588618a9e2f0f5f483ff8e72187738d93f107cea9e228a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f1919f30e6c503e2836e31c06202536e8d223f69ea7d4885b7e63c25a89974ba", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "dbdfc272878dc7383fe08b7c34a65869", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "edb81ad395e6b8e014931bab050d86739f3e4858baa8fd9ab14378b9addd71fe"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "399cb2cedc85a34b85910656d05d5df03d47882318929671daaaa1aa94933a93", "request_id": "380874ee6a0aa3ae3318bdd440b8851d", "response_sha256": "f9fd7d788993bf6d3e4696505722c612a710dbba5e2b47a18f9aa0a525d1f9cd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c1178144836975ffc67f305ea7cc8f3c390d1df682b2c37ae1bc481808e6fe09", "request_id": "5761ff14c6d669253c7140497d3028cc", "response_sha256": "08b75cfb70e1dea857ca750f9141083fe489b295c168b40267a7f1f53bc9ea52", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "6bbca9c3c16fa7c2155c3150a982a44b", "candidate_priority_rank": 797, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d46fcf391729084f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d46fcf391729084f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d46fcf391729084f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d46fcf391729084f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "snowboarding<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "surfing", "B": "snowboarding"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "surfing<->snowboarding", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 358, "image_id": "2363805", "image_sha256": "475ee8338194f8786e7746e1f6ef9b71636475c27058fa53df6213c50a4bed15", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2363805.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2363805.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2367350", "image_sha256": "568096eefb93f15a47a72efca0c200c8aa414fc9afec82402928919e11885b3a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367350.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367350.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d46fcf391729084f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "surfing", "diff_b": "snowboarding", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "surfing", "component_b": "snowboarding"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "6ec7ffb45bdfe07ddb7def04e16c6887295e9fdbedf55ef844158601067b52dd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d4d8d25a1490290ad712f421458a02f991ea9716a015d91a4bb93251031a2b30"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01667105", "text": "What is the person that is surfing standing on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["snowboarding"], "detected_components": ["snowboarding"], "masked_program_sha256": "6ec7ffb45bdfe07ddb7def04e16c6887295e9fdbedf55ef844158601067b52dd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "snowboarding", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "caddb3318e18d92c7562c7ef3834055026c38a5a1021cbf7aef18ac1a4b07e9e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0873631", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 797, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "144fb240cf38cab91748b7bfbc080637beb8d38a6fb12843b264a9528ffb9557", "selected_component": "snowboarding", "selected_source_question_id": "0873631", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is snowboarding standing on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is standing on?", "program_group_hash": "144fb240cf38cab91748b7bfbc080637beb8d38a6fb12843b264a9528ffb9557", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is standing on?", "program_group_hash": "144fb240cf38cab91748b7bfbc080637beb8d38a6fb12843b264a9528ffb9557", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "surfboard", "full_answer": "The man is standing on the surfboard.", "question": "What is the person that is surfing standing on?", "question_id": "01667105", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (761979)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (761981)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "snowboard", "full_answer": "The person is standing on the snowboard.", "question": "What is the person that is snowboarding standing on?", "question_id": "0873631", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (623099)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "snowboarding", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (623103)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["761980", "761981", "761984", "761987", "761988", "761989"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["surfboard"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "761981", "query_target_entity_name": "surfboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "761981", "relation_subject_entity_id": "761979", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "761979", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["761979"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "snowboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["623100", "623101", "623102", "623103", "623104", "623105", "623106", "623107", "623108", "623109", "623110", "623111", "623112", "623113", "623114"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["snowboard"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "623103", "query_target_entity_name": "snowboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "623103", "relation_subject_entity_id": "623099", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "623099", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "snowboarding", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["623099"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:6bbca9c3c16fa7c2155c3150a982a44b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "475ee8338194f8786e7746e1f6ef9b71636475c27058fa53df6213c50a4bed15", "image_sha256_b": "568096eefb93f15a47a72efca0c200c8aa414fc9afec82402928919e11885b3a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1d0dd3b792b6a3c2ca54556a2852050b9d72464c837ea5e27edcca56c1c62112", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "bf8cadfaadafe42d64fb6c6d3ffe54e6", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6dc91b417c328c6d26ae49d0e52c79688837aa233b19ba6eae2fbb6d3304e9f1"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "35af5c65fbfaf4d022be961a4485db7a2c597538a117d25388774269a8f05cf4", "request_id": "cc0ef1cf47eeabf9ebc710e9d4220579", "response_sha256": "63d687fc7eba7c10dbb1a46b011dcdde2e1f981776b4db7047472ece919ba21c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "81199f24f9a7053eefe8a79c3277c9bb2b8f8a1b4bcd603e3d0bb439d3210a09", "request_id": "6003fab5ff7d123280fa119459c4ae92", "response_sha256": "cab190248118a7e63fda7563906ec3ad9e7a0098d5c9c2bdebd349e8ade6adf6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "3afb0fbaa4e44fdbc109729fa044e658", "candidate_priority_rank": 808, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7f19f7f3f2da04f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7f19f7f3f2da04f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7f19f7f3f2da04f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7f19f7f3f2da04f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "green<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "green", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "green<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2370075", "image_sha256": "90646f5dd3c80bd838ee8b23883daecce6adc66ca0a98d9ecd27ecb7f9f4b89b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2370075.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2370075.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 225, "image_id": "2405390", "image_sha256": "6a218ebb92688e333f4cd0526e5abee7447d05deef6c531902b9ff0aa04a39b9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405390.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405390.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-e7f19f7f3f2da04f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "green", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "green", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beige", "black", "brown", "dark", "gold", "green", "silver"], "detected_components": ["green"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "green", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a7ea1c1f326e2bec451090d5a6cfe60814722ead9fdb2ef496517a6037b5a716"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03999838", "text": "What is on the green wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bdf93fc8de8aef492cb262e887148f8867cea50bce76d56a29ba3e3d51d881f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06713799", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 808, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 20, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "06713799", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the white wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "mirror", "full_answer": "The mirror is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the green wall?", "question_id": "03999838", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (606580)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "green", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (606574)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "radiator", "full_answer": "The radiator is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the white wall?", "question_id": "06713799", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (373416)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (373447)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["606570", "606571", "606573", "606574", "606576", "606577", "606579", "606582"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mirror"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large"], "query_target_entity_id": "606574", "query_target_entity_name": "mirror", "relation_object_entity_id": "606580", "relation_subject_entity_id": "606574", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "606580", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["606580"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "green", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["373415", "373417", "373418", "373420", "373424", "373429", "373430", "373431", "373435", "373438", "373444", "373447"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["radiator"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "373447", "query_target_entity_name": "radiator", "relation_object_entity_id": "373416", "relation_subject_entity_id": "373447", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "373416", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["373416"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:3afb0fbaa4e44fdbc109729fa044e658", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "90646f5dd3c80bd838ee8b23883daecce6adc66ca0a98d9ecd27ecb7f9f4b89b", "image_sha256_b": "6a218ebb92688e333f4cd0526e5abee7447d05deef6c531902b9ff0aa04a39b9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "97c27b2d80e3763c41f108f082833f6446dd060859825e1ec97f4050957531bf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "041dae613c54b96bedfe61b3935df3f8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a2ee66909a31e3ac0fc00036f5812ab5f9787f2d9c4ee66332750185563fdc38"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c5f1362551283b5354fa3903b1050d37a516a419e8ed0357e859fe3bba3ba76f", "request_id": "ab5c6b335c6c68cc29e479ef11aead4f", "response_sha256": "4b8fdc63c215b3ab3711f05029a24c6047824eeedbe0e3a3c4e3dac777062743", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "619a44e38b0de74a901a0d55306db54492df060fe9de0d9525a584a5912e8d57", "request_id": "06f38587168ef2a3f8c49403720b4cbf", "response_sha256": "384e026f182e5f81672a6f17df834a499dbb7c29725c61e3248fb25bcd844f5f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "002d50dc1686b4c408b721609c08cd0e", "candidate_priority_rank": 820, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cadf2340bc79fab8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cadf2340bc79fab8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cadf2340bc79fab8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cadf2340bc79fab8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brown<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brown", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brown<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2320086", "image_sha256": "d896516f1031cb5388f6a0b12730889e03bb84fa83aeea27aa872353039a0cab", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2320086.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2320086.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2380065", "image_sha256": "b27ba5138f3a0a65decf3807279618c89efabbdace1dfe3f2d231bb0fcdd1a55", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2380065.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2380065.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cadf2340bc79fab8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brown", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brown", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "e73974fbbb1e95347b10ac44e012fd3e618f10f3533121a1296e672eaef142ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2acba0d1994896c544c301d723759d8200959d10f64c3c4ab748a917693da3be"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16523188", "text": "What is on the table that looks brown?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "e73974fbbb1e95347b10ac44e012fd3e618f10f3533121a1296e672eaef142ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "34d35e74af4812a785417e4336112edb8ee5a78bc129ce9bae47a9582b310a01"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05233534", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 820, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f1d3888d20c2d10d13949b72bf7f84abded3daad28b02bbc4d9f937e0d792e70", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "05233534", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the table that looks gray?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "f1d3888d20c2d10d13949b72bf7f84abded3daad28b02bbc4d9f937e0d792e70", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "table", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the table that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "f1d3888d20c2d10d13949b72bf7f84abded3daad28b02bbc4d9f937e0d792e70", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "wine glasses", "full_answer": "The wine glasses are on the table.", "question": "What is on the table that looks brown?", "question_id": "16523188", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (2719127)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2943682)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "robot", "full_answer": "The robot is on the table.", "question": "What is on the table that looks gray?", "question_id": "05233534", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (548102)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (548096)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2943682", "3090300", "3360878", "3415867", "3943871"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wine glasses"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2943682", "query_target_entity_name": "wine glasses", "relation_object_entity_id": "2719127", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2943682", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2719127", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2719127"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["548090", "548091", "548092", "548093", "548095", "548096", "548097", "548098", "548099", "548100", "548101"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["robot"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["small", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "548096", "query_target_entity_name": "robot", "relation_object_entity_id": "548102", "relation_subject_entity_id": "548096", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "548102", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["548102"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:002d50dc1686b4c408b721609c08cd0e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d896516f1031cb5388f6a0b12730889e03bb84fa83aeea27aa872353039a0cab", "image_sha256_b": "b27ba5138f3a0a65decf3807279618c89efabbdace1dfe3f2d231bb0fcdd1a55", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "72efb61e41cca11f6d773779d9fa5dc17acb9b001a217de425fd7b21d942eebe", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "004d8e1dfce00cdd47779bf2b48a7bce", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ce90dfc8d23adc783164c4e28a42af2b426933c0c5a01a65f09ca08c5fef00b8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "83affc5ed00aab47f2abcfa5b355334861b823fb66a282563e39efd93fb5e218", "request_id": "c43d7b7a7e67ba1f2d717f74586b9541", "response_sha256": "5f35bc9204fc138593a89a010928f422b8dd13e6d0634c6db77c92c797393e59", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "24b113ad5e63625b4e674e97315c3caa74dd254052ca430e627726febcb0c297", "request_id": "f01f269dc1371b6528f51f62712c470d", "response_sha256": "11585baa5bf5d0a8d5dfb8b5c6f5b703d37b58e34a6356249be6b8cf9c569df0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "9324ed7e72cd78206ea636adbe8f2d3c", "candidate_priority_rank": 874, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fade19157bd110f6:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fade19157bd110f6:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fade19157bd110f6:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fade19157bd110f6:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "light blue<->red", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "light blue", "B": "red"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "light blue<->red", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2342945", "image_sha256": "6cbed3d55ac274b759fc5f372d797268c227306cbf189d57e33b25d4d1fe1cbf", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342945.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342945.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2407529", "image_sha256": "cb3cc7d0d7413f08ea3b68ee5dfd67be8f652503f697da7af81a77470820a8cb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407529.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407529.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-fade19157bd110f6", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "light blue", "diff_b": "red", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "light blue", "component_b": "red"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "dark blue", "gray", "light blue", "light brown", "white"], "detected_components": ["light blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "6a8d926d2f2c2f3c55ec78bfaf4df2dbc1352c6dad90f18af68768b40754819f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "light blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "645608e0910c9e73a5aa492c641d9b2a6ea94343a0e1522fe26d34b13ae28fa4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07383108", "text": "What is in front of the wall that looks light blue?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "green", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "6a8d926d2f2c2f3c55ec78bfaf4df2dbc1352c6dad90f18af68768b40754819f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d49d6bdf9332fca9f29876b86edafc16576e69853e86d0b10d1dbecea3312c13"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0271292", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 874, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a4fa416279659a4747db3f82540cceb72ce4c4bf7d4e78966342da7c637bb370", "selected_component": "red", "selected_source_question_id": "0271292", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the wall that looks red?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the wall that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "a4fa416279659a4747db3f82540cceb72ce4c4bf7d4e78966342da7c637bb370", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the wall that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "a4fa416279659a4747db3f82540cceb72ce4c4bf7d4e78966342da7c637bb370", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "desk", "full_answer": "The desk is in front of the wall.", "question": "What is in front of the wall that looks light blue?", "question_id": "07383108", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (929159)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "light blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (929150)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "fence", "full_answer": "The fence is in front of the wall.", "question": "What is in front of the wall that looks red?", "question_id": "0271292", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1097058)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (1097059)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["929146", "929147", "929150", "929151", "929152", "929153", "929154", "929156", "929157", "929158", "929161", "929162", "929163", "929164", "929165", "929166", "929167", "929168", "929170"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["desk"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "929150", "query_target_entity_name": "desk", "relation_object_entity_id": "929159", "relation_subject_entity_id": "929150", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "929159", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "light blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["929159"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "light blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1097055", "1097057", "1097059", "366759", "366760"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fence"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["green", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "1097059", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "1097058", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1097059", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1097058", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1097058"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:9324ed7e72cd78206ea636adbe8f2d3c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6cbed3d55ac274b759fc5f372d797268c227306cbf189d57e33b25d4d1fe1cbf", "image_sha256_b": "cb3cc7d0d7413f08ea3b68ee5dfd67be8f652503f697da7af81a77470820a8cb", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "75849d18da7d2f53fec9e37dab87713669e1f1fa8a65d736b363f8389da30389", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d465c589116265b73dbc7521a90d36c4", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f94ac0f1dca45c5db9d0c6a1afaf874b2b8d6cf1310dcbf72956528b605d4c7a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fc75947c2dcf59db3a8313aada18d8cd5b2af3a7496a3f79e3a5260c5ea11fd5", "request_id": "72c2ddff149fd842e8a93b7fb87a7c05", "response_sha256": "0f7637bc53e416df36f23139f339f14bc667a31d8f7d07a7e262222f56c77d4e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ac0c328591893b89c5deb08c4f1ddd320541ae9386b49410fb70c265d2984207", "request_id": "29dee59e99e541ef45be2e63fe363f6f", "response_sha256": "6a75a060bf03342371cfa8705e6162f2bdf63a9e59b22e346fb88d3842b2b30f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "25d11de5776cbd72bf5c47bca5221b51", "candidate_priority_rank": 912, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b9bf4d3ed242c63:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b9bf4d3ed242c63:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b9bf4d3ed242c63:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b9bf4d3ed242c63:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cardboard<->glass", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "cardboard", "B": "glass"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cardboard<->glass", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 338, "image_id": "2406675", "image_sha256": "b1bf3a687907e88a8bacee0e35be5f7ed3004862b60b699a7cbe63cbf7cf0159", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2406675.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2406675.jpg", "width": 450}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2342149", "image_sha256": "c0bc1a2e032e286760ac5deb5ffc988f60adf76822ff776d35a150bdb8f62534", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342149.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342149.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-2b9bf4d3ed242c63", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cardboard", "diff_b": "glass", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cardboard", "component_b": "glass"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cardboard"], "detected_components": ["cardboard"], "masked_program_sha256": "67746452aa6a7f34d10654803d748fb40340bec351059de7ac43c5874d793ed5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["container"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cardboard", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["container"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "52e97ceccf4e9522bafd82a5be290362e3d4a8cd62bb934e9a402faa579595fe"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14482080", "text": "What is in the container made of cardboard?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["glass", "metal"], "detected_components": ["glass"], "masked_program_sha256": "67746452aa6a7f34d10654803d748fb40340bec351059de7ac43c5874d793ed5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["container"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "glass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["container"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b4c75bfd4a9dab2ba32a14eb7ce16461d5dd23f9046e63ab0299c1743410c14f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15617816", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 912, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f3ab9ea2f43baf51bf99b02fff71c57d83976e844969c29a6cdb50ff5a1ff94b", "selected_component": "glass", "selected_source_question_id": "15617816", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the container made of glass?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "container", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the container made of ?", "program_group_hash": "f3ab9ea2f43baf51bf99b02fff71c57d83976e844969c29a6cdb50ff5a1ff94b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "container"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "container", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the container made of ?", "program_group_hash": "f3ab9ea2f43baf51bf99b02fff71c57d83976e844969c29a6cdb50ff5a1ff94b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "container"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The pizza is in the box.", "question": "What is in the container made of cardboard?", "question_id": "14482080", "semantic": [{"argument": "container (368356)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cardboard", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (368354)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "light bulb", "full_answer": "The bulb is in the container.", "question": "What is in the container made of glass?", "question_id": "15617816", "semantic": [{"argument": "container (936765)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "glass", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (936769)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["368353", "368354", "368355", "368357", "368358", "368359"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["burnt", "cooked", "fresh", "round", "small", "thick", "toasted", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "368354", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "368356", "relation_subject_entity_id": "368354", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "368356", "selected_entity_name": "box"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "cardboard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["368356"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "cardboard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["936760", "936761", "936762", "936763", "936768", "936769", "936770", "936771"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["light bulb"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["shiny", "upside down", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "936769", "query_target_entity_name": "light bulb", "relation_object_entity_id": "936765", "relation_subject_entity_id": "936769", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "936765", "selected_entity_name": "container"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["936765"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:25d11de5776cbd72bf5c47bca5221b51", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b1bf3a687907e88a8bacee0e35be5f7ed3004862b60b699a7cbe63cbf7cf0159", "image_sha256_b": "c0bc1a2e032e286760ac5deb5ffc988f60adf76822ff776d35a150bdb8f62534", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7034328aff18f1ba9e9a62495e1a5bdbcdacb84a452bccdb78562a6b9d333997", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ee2edc13f1d5d9869aba7dd382090a21", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9689e5f475064c1f3d93959c3b13e65464c1406f63a34543be7d34454614cc63"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a8b90c6723304cbc1a2f85d86ac5ccc28c57c5344a5bf726ff608430b240200a", "request_id": "f87d9b837fc7d45c4e32de5312e2ad84", "response_sha256": "7a32ad08923d7297a06560ed65612802d018caa4efdf25d8621cc716062bb4e2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "673dd870196cd503bb35639927d5d3d6d65078d1dd169b6ea48d982b2f469d5d", "request_id": "a0717afb22a66339e8489548c3793314", "response_sha256": "77d1eb66503bff60f3d57c77c941a534432deafd85bfdfff41e19cea117b928d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "9829741085fe4f41ae95154daee4ee85", "candidate_priority_rank": 946, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-259691b743a7c4b7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-259691b743a7c4b7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-259691b743a7c4b7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-259691b743a7c4b7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "4820", "image_sha256": "6757b32a32890403fb4ee633137875c7d159987018ae52b7d1dabb44c9311c83", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/4820.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/4820.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2378601", "image_sha256": "52e3a8ef7c992bed9e8cb4c84de93a867a5e04262bb35b40c9e53654459eade9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2378601.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2378601.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-259691b743a7c4b7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "53b527c386fb718e3afdfb3a1d1f89073b0bd01710876e889d9ca0437d4f1856", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6789ec60ce8306aa130da3b0a7af5f403ba28bb480cece3e96980ff58da5c6cc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1089242", "text": "What is in the bowl that looks black?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "green", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "53b527c386fb718e3afdfb3a1d1f89073b0bd01710876e889d9ca0437d4f1856", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "aafb0c830131bda10c6bdff55cffecb473c65b630f1454d549f1dbc0e54637ae"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17492326", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 946, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c1f03c9504ea5aedf83640d6d1caf46eece8c77acf462f0242d0686aa625d1f1", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "17492326", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the bowl that looks white?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bowl", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bowl that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "c1f03c9504ea5aedf83640d6d1caf46eece8c77acf462f0242d0686aa625d1f1", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "bowl", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the bowl that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "c1f03c9504ea5aedf83640d6d1caf46eece8c77acf462f0242d0686aa625d1f1", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "noodles", "full_answer": "The noodles are in the bowl.", "question": "What is in the bowl that looks black?", "question_id": "1089242", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (1563297)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (1563292)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "soup", "full_answer": "The soup is in the bowl.", "question": "What is in the bowl that looks white?", "question_id": "17492326", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (714003)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (714012)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1563287", "1563289", "1563290", "1563292", "1563294", "1563295", "1563296"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["noodles"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1563292", "query_target_entity_name": "noodles", "relation_object_entity_id": "1563297", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1563292", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1563297", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1563297"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["714006", "714009", "714010", "714011", "714012", "714015", "714016", "714017", "714018", "714019", "714020", "714021", "714023", "714024", "714025", "714026", "714027", "714028"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["soup"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "714012", "query_target_entity_name": "soup", "relation_object_entity_id": "714003", "relation_subject_entity_id": "714012", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "714003", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["714003"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:9829741085fe4f41ae95154daee4ee85", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6757b32a32890403fb4ee633137875c7d159987018ae52b7d1dabb44c9311c83", "image_sha256_b": "52e3a8ef7c992bed9e8cb4c84de93a867a5e04262bb35b40c9e53654459eade9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "07fdd12189f56afef58380c7858831b8bbe278aab64601e751dafe49f9503b49", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "93b57457fda86e7a3cdcbdcdc54e5132", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5e17372f4e6c1a84492dbe1ae319bd90a5b732ea2ab291e6555637dbbf530801"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b915b558677874a21bc2416f4d9dbd6ed8062260df09040ff573d0b019738322", "request_id": "ccd3fe4e1080d046ca523c4ddee92cdc", "response_sha256": "6e5c45a88ef4775b1a57d7f7a96906235f061bf6a75677cfd4ae6f14abe8df79", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0f357646df150dff6c33ecf5804240f1df9278eb477d5c4187f16e8860f46195", "request_id": "35395c5d40ed1d6bd91dfb3c2042083c", "response_sha256": "fb36916176bc2b761cc006d48933be6a5eab147200a958b9defc1d7dfa845960", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "5e4fe98622365fe3bec022a1cd8cd457", "candidate_priority_rank": 992, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6f6a73febaf2ba7e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6f6a73febaf2ba7e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6f6a73febaf2ba7e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6f6a73febaf2ba7e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2394773", "image_sha256": "710f0e133c7ca466a711561a335af45cd1b160528f36fbb6cf96a7d4108c0e47", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2394773.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2394773.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2338019", "image_sha256": "300c92cdd920751e26be9a90f1ea575d080ecdf8f11b79408faa2c99f307df8c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2338019.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2338019.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-6f6a73febaf2ba7e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "33b73430df8efe2201afa32fbc0d5f93d78a820a5a70fa52ec97c433fbca58b2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b9a73ad678364a6f30f27e87721fe24cb68d44f5393b542fdf05edb839896457"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "15360791", "text": "What type of furniture is the white animal sleeping on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "33b73430df8efe2201afa32fbc0d5f93d78a820a5a70fa52ec97c433fbca58b2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4457f87120af6feccb78cb37bf364504e72b4ea098abba036c1308d8ffaef549"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18661311", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 992, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3555b48eae4e30da916e89673896f387d48ae25c997cc921e214aa08eccd47f8", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "18661311", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of furniture is the black animal sleeping on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,sleeping on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of furniture is the animal sleeping on?", "program_group_hash": "3555b48eae4e30da916e89673896f387d48ae25c997cc921e214aa08eccd47f8", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sleeping on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,sleeping on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of furniture is the animal sleeping on?", "program_group_hash": "3555b48eae4e30da916e89673896f387d48ae25c997cc921e214aa08eccd47f8", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sleeping on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The cat is sleeping on the table.", "question": "What type of furniture is the white animal sleeping on?", "question_id": "15360791", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (461219)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,sleeping on,o (461222)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The cat is sleeping on the bed.", "question": "What type of furniture is the black animal sleeping on?", "question_id": "18661311", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (3084018)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "furniture,sleeping on,o (3172094)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["461222", "461224"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "sleeping on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "461222", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "461222", "relation_subject_entity_id": "461219", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "461219", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["461219"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2317941", "3172094"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "sleeping on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3172094", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "3172094", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3084018", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "3084018", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3084018"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:5e4fe98622365fe3bec022a1cd8cd457", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "710f0e133c7ca466a711561a335af45cd1b160528f36fbb6cf96a7d4108c0e47", "image_sha256_b": "300c92cdd920751e26be9a90f1ea575d080ecdf8f11b79408faa2c99f307df8c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a34fe4b7ef55b3daa89e66b705cc506667a6dfd59127e9354c9d5f7ef88548f9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "11632e895d1202bf38e534d9ab2908d8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "31d8aa36b937164e45d927483833077fdf512a207156a25ac0ff540914534bb6"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9d3be3a149918e9c945828328a8ad2138c09854dd4d7528b5ad55fb7ef63a48a", "request_id": "ee72a04ebc45af4e34f7bfaef781f25a", "response_sha256": "a91e5dd0455ead8c4d3f14279fe51dc54fc07a974176d321840bc1686aab0a75", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dd8536a9ac4b296eb4b3f457d63b7bab065e9a8939cad09e146a2f65a476e234", "request_id": "98d2c5b9a5823f95cf838d0cefd60d1c", "response_sha256": "b498bb78761f0ce48739a4a7b834023721c17901cd8b4993161768329d8c9bb1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "61179552e7c7d86d61bc71b10833af86", "candidate_priority_rank": 1012, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65f680046f966e7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65f680046f966e7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65f680046f966e7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65f680046f966e7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "eating<->playing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "playing", "B": "eating"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "playing<->eating", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2404461", "image_sha256": "f82efb949b16ce7c6eb6529b79529a6186175355ea3bc7f255e51cecada62573", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404461.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404461.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2382906", "image_sha256": "984dd3cf01e9685c21a9d29f40d3a9ab9d5980a96fec3b17c6877f22eb1f48b0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382906.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382906.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65f680046f966e7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "playing", "diff_b": "eating", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "playing", "component_b": "eating"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["playing"], "detected_components": ["playing"], "masked_program_sha256": "dffce669263f3a6e3572dfce5216d65140aa0cf67f6c319010b54777cbc6eff8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "playing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b420120dc50a3a8723584535f780717bccf943b4a831fd2a3c7e3f08aef66c53"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08661414", "text": "What is the person that is playing holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["eating"], "detected_components": ["eating"], "masked_program_sha256": "dffce669263f3a6e3572dfce5216d65140aa0cf67f6c319010b54777cbc6eff8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "eating", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f91cc7e2b359038183b385a169f3519bb979fc659d8b16613a18e26c63ea393f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "151023716", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1012, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 22, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "51003c3f0e3f6afd77dcb7234c97b8985ebaf361a3f9e8e5a10179aa71d0cd1e", "selected_component": "eating", "selected_source_question_id": "151023716", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is eating holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "51003c3f0e3f6afd77dcb7234c97b8985ebaf361a3f9e8e5a10179aa71d0cd1e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "51003c3f0e3f6afd77dcb7234c97b8985ebaf361a3f9e8e5a10179aa71d0cd1e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "racket", "full_answer": "The man is holding the tennis racket.", "question": "What is the person that is playing holding?", "question_id": "08661414", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (342469)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "playing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (342484)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chopsticks", "full_answer": "The girl is holding the chopsticks.", "question": "What is the person that is eating holding?", "question_id": "151023716", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1325144)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "eating", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (1325150)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["342468", "342471", "342474", "342476", "342477", "342478", "342479", "342480", "342484", "342485", "342486"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["racket"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "342484", "query_target_entity_name": "racket", "relation_object_entity_id": "342484", "relation_subject_entity_id": "342469", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "342469", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["342469"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "eating", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1325143", "1325145", "1325146", "1325148", "1325150", "1325151", "1325152", "1325153", "1325156", "1325157", "1325158", "1325159", "1325161"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chopsticks"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1325150", "query_target_entity_name": "chopsticks", "relation_object_entity_id": "1325150", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1325144", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1325144", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "eating", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1325144"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:61179552e7c7d86d61bc71b10833af86", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f82efb949b16ce7c6eb6529b79529a6186175355ea3bc7f255e51cecada62573", "image_sha256_b": "984dd3cf01e9685c21a9d29f40d3a9ab9d5980a96fec3b17c6877f22eb1f48b0", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "930e3c17ed4d977fc8b3d9d9052ef9248d6b60c7c7657dffd6a3ba7f010be6d1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2e8a388918093f8596ed5beff12ea0f7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7cde60ee35f9313f46ebd52ced92c1480586cb3aeddc561a273e8c8d29efe791"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6ba18888bd6973b87068c4f80575ef34cd3e463e4e04cdcd0ea57a9128cc35fb", "request_id": "f151a8bbbed7ff4de55d00c9bd2d59d8", "response_sha256": "137dbb015d129bee82deff1b8956c59043f14576dac27eda7e1be82b8fa718a6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2365a8f979a8090bf3a3c3b6c6d1e19c949dcceff8b7eb3bb7b6465f939aa115", "request_id": "9caf74f1c42240cc37b968b295f678d6", "response_sha256": "f34fea3e0c99c038f2ac58bdf410c9c0711d031c3a418e0e48597efa50b3eed9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "22ae5ebf145f6a93579cb2165634c19d", "candidate_priority_rank": 1017, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-098cd2bafc896b6f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-098cd2bafc896b6f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-098cd2bafc896b6f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-098cd2bafc896b6f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->gray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 198, "image_id": "2342226", "image_sha256": "56bee117ac3291e787b803985d8bf2300a324f700729c98bfc87e74f6dac84ca", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342226.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342226.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2402781", "image_sha256": "8c23c4ecc285c0c5881911315e95965bbaabf46d8b14edb8842ed8f69bb32231", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402781.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402781.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "location_endpoint", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-098cd2bafc896b6f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "location_endpoint", "question_prefix": "Where", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "10e5eee9a564f8af3c9ce4eca3e6ec686fac7bfc31f1eaaed0fb7968a90182f5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c09f5cdf97d1a39ede2fb4a3f22f2cecde583a350dd000384efa474b0ee56082"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "071002853", "text": "Where is the black animal lying?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "10e5eee9a564f8af3c9ce4eca3e6ec686fac7bfc31f1eaaed0fb7968a90182f5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "753b844874f75446707366564efc5ea49f8c10a8eed0719db1fc206b6da18144"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03131361", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1017, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a21b93a90e10754ada66f9c6ae7e2c4c76fd53d1bd2fa49ffe4a250d237c4673", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "03131361", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "Where is the gray animal lying?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "location_endpoint", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "where is the animal lying?", "program_group_hash": "a21b93a90e10754ada66f9c6ae7e2c4c76fd53d1bd2fa49ffe4a250d237c4673", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying in", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "location_endpoint", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "where is the animal lying?", "program_group_hash": "a21b93a90e10754ada66f9c6ae7e2c4c76fd53d1bd2fa49ffe4a250d237c4673", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying in", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The dog is lying in the bed.", "question": "Where is the black animal lying?", "question_id": "071002853", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (935890)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying in,o (935891)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "yard", "full_answer": "The bear is lying in the yard.", "question": "Where is the gray animal lying?", "question_id": "03131361", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (4257893)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying in,o (4257944)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["935891", "935892", "935893", "935894", "935895", "935896", "935897", "935898", "935899", "935900", "935901", "935902", "935903", "935904", "935905", "935907", "935908", "935909", "935910", "935911", "935912", "935913", "935915", "935917", "935919", "935920", "935921"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 27, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "935891", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "935891", "relation_subject_entity_id": "935890", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "935890", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["935890"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4257880", "4257884", "4257888", "4257910", "4257911", "4257912", "4257915", "4257923", "4257940", "4257942", "4257944", "4257946", "4257947", "4257951", "4257956"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["yard"], "predicate": "lying in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4257944", "query_target_entity_name": "yard", "relation_object_entity_id": "4257944", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4257893", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "4257893", "selected_entity_name": "bear"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4257893"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:22ae5ebf145f6a93579cb2165634c19d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "56bee117ac3291e787b803985d8bf2300a324f700729c98bfc87e74f6dac84ca", "image_sha256_b": "8c23c4ecc285c0c5881911315e95965bbaabf46d8b14edb8842ed8f69bb32231", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5de1ebd609416244145e55d0fa1a391dff2f87f1caac8cf5925f10bc3ece6bb8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d851e316ed8c4cb9d50ecdb247022e49", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "86a6f63700add49472dba361aabb4a9498fcb5e480947f32abdeeac93d6d7afe"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e64c903a7fa6df1d3801ddc8e8ced01fdc491fa269febde4932202a46cdc2796", "request_id": "be7941e5161c98302ec39673e1e7b6e0", "response_sha256": "3c42224cf96463dfa6d4381d500ba12bbaaf4ae92e560af35e49b72622a302f0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e826181a02fdff2165d2115e7b6e96fae8e80ad1e7f85e07309435d93d113d15", "request_id": "d1bc5368759d002c459451db15f12104", "response_sha256": "fdbb9f7560611a77485f8d43854ea409c71fd3a28c8b2f9e443c6f1a0f7a09fd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "04f9f8454e7fd4dd8bdd08c5fb99d1fb", "candidate_priority_rank": 1055, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3330b2cfc918242e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3330b2cfc918242e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3330b2cfc918242e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3330b2cfc918242e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 1024, "image_id": "1159417", "image_sha256": "8b88883c596d1083d5c3dad3c7a2a41bae68b609b40b2535d4346c0e6b90eb0a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/1159417.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/1159417.jpg", "width": 683}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2326177", "image_sha256": "e3714c0db577c0b14c2471f24e5dbfd7d1d51e6a17d14ddfdf7d90d01168d439", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326177.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326177.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-3330b2cfc918242e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "red", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "c37d97257ee9322c1b65b01b0aa7ac95b544ed1cf2ddfc81497ed26f523e673c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8ee554f01e9f286fc521a3022c5615914ef9ed9727ffa3edfe865aad6df97c0a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06593354", "text": "What is the black animal standing on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "dark", "green", "red"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "c37d97257ee9322c1b65b01b0aa7ac95b544ed1cf2ddfc81497ed26f523e673c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "da157a3ccd76a348434c595960073abe88011b28cca7534822778d6cc47caee3"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16163954", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1055, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "45b5ea3842828b35f8ab0af1dd49922c1a68d4ada8eb551de264bcbfbab7108e", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "16163954", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the brown animal standing on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal standing on?", "program_group_hash": "45b5ea3842828b35f8ab0af1dd49922c1a68d4ada8eb551de264bcbfbab7108e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal standing on?", "program_group_hash": "45b5ea3842828b35f8ab0af1dd49922c1a68d4ada8eb551de264bcbfbab7108e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "speaker", "full_answer": "The cat is standing on the speaker.", "question": "What is the black animal standing on?", "question_id": "06593354", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (4073662)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (4073652)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The horse is standing on the chair.", "question": "What is the brown animal standing on?", "question_id": "16163954", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (3988649)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,standing on,o (4136873)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4073638", "4073639", "4073642", "4073643", "4073645", "4073651", "4073652", "4073654", "4073655", "4073660", "4073661", "4073663", "4073669", "4073670", "4073672", "4073675"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["speaker"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4073652", "query_target_entity_name": "speaker", "relation_object_entity_id": "4073652", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4073662", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "4073662", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4073662"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3988637", "3988643", "3988646", "3988652", "3988665", "3988673", "3988675", "3988678", "3988680", "4136859", "4136863", "4136866", "4136869", "4136870", "4136871", "4136872", "4136873", "4136874", "4136880", "4136882", "4136885", "4136887", "4136888", "4136889", "4136892", "4136893", "4136896"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 27, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "red"], "query_target_entity_id": "4136873", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "4136873", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3988649", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "3988649", "selected_entity_name": "horse"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3988649"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:04f9f8454e7fd4dd8bdd08c5fb99d1fb", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8b88883c596d1083d5c3dad3c7a2a41bae68b609b40b2535d4346c0e6b90eb0a", "image_sha256_b": "e3714c0db577c0b14c2471f24e5dbfd7d1d51e6a17d14ddfdf7d90d01168d439", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5b80ceed75bd51553ba005101d89c9fecb2dd76df5c681ebb25bff4e0069a9f1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3e69da168b95de0a749a51a3c8cfc081", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7f93266b9c11a4ad2c20aa99a2e36991a38f65b6e91d2c154a8af3d0ca1baece"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f21128b0cc6e348eecd3625ea179cd7ffb9d21ea5f81b5236dda1d061485936e", "request_id": "706d370b5c3a4f766361b00b5a4bd341", "response_sha256": "5ca6c5e4ee6f28274777f55d86897a029b4a28101aed7d53ad159681c5ac070a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "73522aba23f43fee02e743d16f0e08f4fda41a51978392517e63d34ab092f98c", "request_id": "8744cb98121d68ab9266a770c1ea9fcb", "response_sha256": "20d47a7b03be85d366489282eedc8b762a5b2fc53a3ce137f0fb56bca6282e38", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "d7f3daeaaab5fcdb801be4623f405d28", "candidate_priority_rank": 1210, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7e61526f380debde:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7e61526f380debde:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7e61526f380debde:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7e61526f380debde:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "silver<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "silver", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "silver<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2348157", "image_sha256": "7cbcfcba1a87b54dec7d61ebf7754e4ee206452a75c90d1cadd7421612298088", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2348157.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2348157.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 320, "image_id": "2410239", "image_sha256": "c9c1facc8fde45f989a545755f83830f5604d076be1cb525038f2928e076070e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410239.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410239.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-7e61526f380debde", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "silver", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "silver", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["red", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["silver"], "masked_program_sha256": "17300dff4ef0471bac7df91d4124adc330892b2e9c6607c01c2e73e865cd15a7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "silver", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "752a8d6cfd152b98326e78a7980e9d115bab37c2aa82ade94732b400023f51e8"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08667034", "text": "What is the cooking utensil on the silver tray?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "orange", "pink", "silver", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "17300dff4ef0471bac7df91d4124adc330892b2e9c6607c01c2e73e865cd15a7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dc13b7ba9cd5fd02c1315d27d2633cbeefaa8ae738fbf4503664904776357670"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02196329", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1210, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6d6ee7f4b5b09f3298cc9510555bc52b6215d2a0c28f84511ac90c1bc5f4bdb0", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "02196329", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the cooking utensil on the white tray?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "tray", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cooking utensil on the tray?", "program_group_hash": "6d6ee7f4b5b09f3298cc9510555bc52b6215d2a0c28f84511ac90c1bc5f4bdb0", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "tray"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "tray", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cooking utensil on the tray?", "program_group_hash": "6d6ee7f4b5b09f3298cc9510555bc52b6215d2a0c28f84511ac90c1bc5f4bdb0", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "tray"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "spatula", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a spatula.", "question": "What is the cooking utensil on the silver tray?", "question_id": "08667034", "semantic": [{"argument": "tray (3906327)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "silver", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,s (3606989)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "coffee pot", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a coffee pot.", "question": "What is the cooking utensil on the white tray?", "question_id": "02196329", "semantic": [{"argument": "tray (222679)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,s (222682)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3606989"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["spatula"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["metal"], "query_target_entity_id": "3606989", "query_target_entity_name": "spatula", "relation_object_entity_id": "3906327", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3606989", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3906327", "selected_entity_name": "tray"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3906327"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "silver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["222682"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["coffee pot"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "222682", "query_target_entity_name": "coffee pot", "relation_object_entity_id": "222679", "relation_subject_entity_id": "222682", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "222679", "selected_entity_name": "tray"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["222679"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:d7f3daeaaab5fcdb801be4623f405d28", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7cbcfcba1a87b54dec7d61ebf7754e4ee206452a75c90d1cadd7421612298088", "image_sha256_b": "c9c1facc8fde45f989a545755f83830f5604d076be1cb525038f2928e076070e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5b16d186d871944943b15a944d257ee374e0751cbee18c52a6a0763f1eeb2226", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "acce913d94c10e65a982f762debe5127", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "096b6b1e946e3fb250a086743052df35aec6dec1b4778506a56966638b090f95"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4a2659a1e5cc723f78f444aa97765ba8a4b8069bacac36be552f6e5752baee2e", "request_id": "0a4467c24d51f8ba24fef7be21e0dfa9", "response_sha256": "30b115cf63fd894fb781fc7aa6390efe748300c378d537e91e0192684c69144c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "49c38633a20079010c7a4a217392866f6e58c792396aff375d6fb35de39e5dd6", "request_id": "2dedc011cf0fed505fcdaee79ebf026f", "response_sha256": "a03390c4cddbcbf7c9de7d51409bd475718247e289ba7c01505a27ec81fa4150", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "1225de3e3f0d70ac9efc9a0e4dfada0d", "candidate_priority_rank": 1270, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d120be073f7651cf:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d120be073f7651cf:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d120be073f7651cf:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d120be073f7651cf:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "calm<->wavy", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "wavy", "B": "calm"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wavy<->calm", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2379473", "image_sha256": "d902fb587845ac98fb2a7f358a430918122f3120656b557ab16b58270cd8fe3b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2379473.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2379473.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2387575", "image_sha256": "72969bde0da6186a3ff10b55617600bc750de7f56174dd7d88902e3a17422843", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387575.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387575.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-d120be073f7651cf", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wavy", "diff_b": "calm", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wavy", "component_b": "calm"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wavy"], "detected_components": ["wavy"], "masked_program_sha256": "6a060534a3afd36052cbabea625e835c595de2c0b0032a868af17e53213a87ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "watercraft"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wavy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "watercraft"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5a176e145a8284232444034838aa87f3d124d857825a3d7a0837971ab4e37e33"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09896565", "text": "What is the watercraft on the wavy water?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["calm"], "detected_components": ["calm"], "masked_program_sha256": "6a060534a3afd36052cbabea625e835c595de2c0b0032a868af17e53213a87ca", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "watercraft"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "calm", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "watercraft"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "61cd133098e4eb80a699cd8149e065605b5a06282ceaccf44bdc4d92ff16d046"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04221834", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1270, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "647f07476b175c85f3658c4b6cafa3a02dff825b1031c2ba1aabb2b77d4454c0", "selected_component": "calm", "selected_source_question_id": "04221834", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the watercraft on the calm water?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "state", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter state"}, {"argument": "watercraft,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the watercraft on the water?", "program_group_hash": "647f07476b175c85f3658c4b6cafa3a02dff825b1031c2ba1aabb2b77d4454c0", "queried_category": "watercraft", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "state", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter state"}, {"argument": "watercraft,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the watercraft on the water?", "program_group_hash": "647f07476b175c85f3658c4b6cafa3a02dff825b1031c2ba1aabb2b77d4454c0", "queried_category": "watercraft", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sailboat", "full_answer": "The watercraft is a sailboat.", "question": "What is the watercraft on the wavy water?", "question_id": "09896565", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (1357269)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wavy", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter state"}, {"argument": "watercraft,on,s (1357271)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "boat", "full_answer": "The watercraft is a boat.", "question": "What is the watercraft on the calm water?", "question_id": "04221834", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (4531379)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "calm", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter state"}, {"argument": "watercraft,on,s (4531378)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1357271", "1357279"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sailboat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["small", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1357271", "query_target_entity_name": "sailboat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1357269", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1357271", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1357269", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wavy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1357269"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "calm", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wavy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4531378"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["boat"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4531378", "query_target_entity_name": "boat", "relation_object_entity_id": "4531379", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4531378", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4531379", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "calm", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4531379"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:1225de3e3f0d70ac9efc9a0e4dfada0d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d902fb587845ac98fb2a7f358a430918122f3120656b557ab16b58270cd8fe3b", "image_sha256_b": "72969bde0da6186a3ff10b55617600bc750de7f56174dd7d88902e3a17422843", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "227446f13d7ce3dd901ba8808ecb258eb45a87f9e35164a643a21145a123e110", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "219f8e5fcde8ca398adf5b256087fa6b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b6e934b7dc826ff14effa165a00f30cb99e91a7b05f2f808963651e4677f1685"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "06e62fc496a890b520db417257e792db3f073e7b32acd038d1460bc605b28b79", "request_id": "6b766ed15340108a7bd7cdc4f6af619d", "response_sha256": "aeebc173bcad1b966b6c12d6700cf0e5ad757ce7cd4b19de0e39867e7addb4e2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "04959831707551507593aba511099b16e5bf0fdffbb785d4c04fc67ee2de4ee0", "request_id": "b88530c3024d84a1785743002039b75f", "response_sha256": "9f33054d2cfd152fd8dd0bc54cfcb0c06bed6640e06cbfd072f2a8adac04588a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "c688cb64ae8f34569ca15956fbd64186", "candidate_priority_rank": 1271, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9159eb4808a4ec8c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9159eb4808a4ec8c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9159eb4808a4ec8c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9159eb4808a4ec8c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "skiing<->surfing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "surfing", "B": "skiing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "surfing<->skiing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 358, "image_id": "2408389", "image_sha256": "5567fb6fe17c7fb559eb49e0fa9332c13a1c2972cabaadffefa7b39ddd9d2258", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408389.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408389.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 329, "image_id": "2411532", "image_sha256": "5d6e3ae620c5a9fe2aca098c354b13dd3a9a39eafb0a27fccf90b31b90e19ece", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2411532.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2411532.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-9159eb4808a4ec8c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "surfing", "diff_b": "skiing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "surfing", "component_b": "skiing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["surfing"], "detected_components": ["surfing"], "masked_program_sha256": "b3d81a104fad68ce7e634e262a734daa47bf66faa75fa51875b2699789a31491", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "surfing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "24461432a8e6f0517146d6da6e9dc5e8957ec71aaff32cbc06859f88276c37d2"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00811314", "text": "What is the person that is surfing riding on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["skiing"], "detected_components": ["skiing"], "masked_program_sha256": "b3d81a104fad68ce7e634e262a734daa47bf66faa75fa51875b2699789a31491", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "skiing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d5162ce2472e929d90bebfa3aada5f5bfc363ab1e7cc7060088187f1af68a711"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07107208", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1271, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "25a169db68be174f4f8916d178703bdb7b2bf914373577f70e9b7a15103879eb", "selected_component": "skiing", "selected_source_question_id": "07107208", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is skiing riding on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,riding on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is riding on?", "program_group_hash": "25a169db68be174f4f8916d178703bdb7b2bf914373577f70e9b7a15103879eb", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "riding on", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "sportactivity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportactivity"}, {"argument": "_,riding on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is riding on?", "program_group_hash": "25a169db68be174f4f8916d178703bdb7b2bf914373577f70e9b7a15103879eb", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "riding on", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "surfboard", "full_answer": "The boy is riding on the surfboard.", "question": "What is the person that is surfing riding on?", "question_id": "00811314", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1988819)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "surfing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,riding on,o (1740915)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "skis", "full_answer": "The girl is riding on the skis.", "question": "What is the person that is skiing riding on?", "question_id": "07107208", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1079165)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "skiing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter sportActivity"}, {"argument": "_,riding on,o (1079166)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1740915", "1860789", "1951075", "262664", "262665", "262670", "262674", "262675", "262676", "262677", "262678", "262679", "262680", "262681", "262682"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["surfboard"], "predicate": "riding on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1740915", "query_target_entity_name": "surfboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "1740915", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1988819", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1988819", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1988819"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "surfing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1079166", "1079167", "1079168", "1079169", "3813661"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["skis"], "predicate": "riding on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1079166", "query_target_entity_name": "skis", "relation_object_entity_id": "1079166", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1079165", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1079165", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "skiing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1079165"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:c688cb64ae8f34569ca15956fbd64186", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5567fb6fe17c7fb559eb49e0fa9332c13a1c2972cabaadffefa7b39ddd9d2258", "image_sha256_b": "5d6e3ae620c5a9fe2aca098c354b13dd3a9a39eafb0a27fccf90b31b90e19ece", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "640cbffdd4f49e46d9f435b7054cf279938073fc5a9bfaf41e42a483e0d77ef0", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "aa3c134dcfc249ce8c170b5efc77d3d8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "8480ecbb7bbfb378957c78acfe7e8aa6ca2703a1c244c6239cb6e9b5fb319710"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "322067f2d21c646651a95c2469d459816935fc4e37ef966f779138f7b752e091", "request_id": "af141f80cac4851a5d1d125f07159d79", "response_sha256": "f3e322c7a7509650466713136c0943e9ec81491f1131aa7ef37dd7932aca3d45", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ebd23b0ad7f0714d894fb971e6074076cdd7c9443b90953600b95b724ce10817", "request_id": "981636658032a36e7f0a955a0e7487c8", "response_sha256": "5c7402472247c91e05ed71e797a0ce4f1eb24a4a0761414df3b8a7348b8b7192", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "d9fa5ec3e90701730058d23090c366ee", "candidate_priority_rank": 1333, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65159ffa0aea030:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65159ffa0aea030:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65159ffa0aea030:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65159ffa0aea030:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "gray<->orange", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "orange", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "orange<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2413428", "image_sha256": "04043cde3120660fe1f9454f3816fc028cd03065d228657a682c31010d097a8b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2413428.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2413428.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2386515", "image_sha256": "9fc55871468827bb9f54b23993f037da53f8543461610f7fead2faf985a49875", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386515.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386515.jpg", "width": 362}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c65159ffa0aea030", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "orange", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "orange", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "dark", "green", "orange", "red", "white"], "detected_components": ["orange"], "masked_program_sha256": "2144cdf3a565459360b6b4688b6f1428732c6569036b05c74a91bf96402f77b3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "orange", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f39d54126e21acf5133dd1930a8b3a0b7de95b6a90b9442fcf4a91c90a77ee8d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06711427", "text": "What is the orange cat looking at?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray", "pink", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "2144cdf3a565459360b6b4688b6f1428732c6569036b05c74a91bf96402f77b3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "28755185543c511c41ea123a9ace18fa5605382da22625860ccd4d1f84ec7f8c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10436516", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1333, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5fef6ae7e9c93b47e58625183c5004af2f539e1bd5127b2439563fab15f4f9f0", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "10436516", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the gray cat looking at?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "cat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,looking at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cat looking at?", "program_group_hash": "5fef6ae7e9c93b47e58625183c5004af2f539e1bd5127b2439563fab15f4f9f0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking at", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "cat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,looking at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cat looking at?", "program_group_hash": "5fef6ae7e9c93b47e58625183c5004af2f539e1bd5127b2439563fab15f4f9f0", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking at", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "toilet", "full_answer": "The cat is looking at the toilet.", "question": "What is the orange cat looking at?", "question_id": "06711427", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (173748)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "orange", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,looking at,o (173749)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "television", "full_answer": "The cat is looking at the television.", "question": "What is the gray cat looking at?", "question_id": "10436516", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (518227)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,looking at,o (518228)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["173745", "173746", "173749", "173752", "173753", "173755", "173757", "173758", "173759", "173760", "173761", "173764", "173765", "173766", "173767", "173768"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["toilet"], "predicate": "looking at", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["open", "shiny", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "173749", "query_target_entity_name": "toilet", "relation_object_entity_id": "173749", "relation_subject_entity_id": "173748", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "173748", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "orange", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["173748"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "orange", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["518228", "518230", "518232", "518233", "518235", "518236", "518237", "518239", "518240", "518244", "518245", "518246", "518248"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["television"], "predicate": "looking at", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "framed", "on"], "query_target_entity_id": "518228", "query_target_entity_name": "television", "relation_object_entity_id": "518228", "relation_subject_entity_id": "518227", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "518227", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["518227"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:d9fa5ec3e90701730058d23090c366ee", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "04043cde3120660fe1f9454f3816fc028cd03065d228657a682c31010d097a8b", "image_sha256_b": "9fc55871468827bb9f54b23993f037da53f8543461610f7fead2faf985a49875", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "9216efa5df564e56d2216575a94c57c8664538a799eacdff8f0989063adb87bf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c32fc5987d5ec289f3082fb98d16ad7f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "043183455c19e046ace7ff458e0ed0976f458b627858c4502134304ffe23858c"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "49cb345abc35cab0f08c4eb72393a0a62e4fb57cbadcb99fa301bc88f6935a9a", "request_id": "994cb5e9a5c33244a0dfb7b9a9fd5cd8", "response_sha256": "5654a3651b3a64c7764e8feccdda8d18635740c4f9b07001258e899a2b5b628d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "eecc4c5e5ae3ac670aeb2e908ec045004ea297b322384c83cbf1a278d45ff396", "request_id": "092d27b3abab766e171b39f17470658b", "response_sha256": "c0c8c740a1cc68e80b1a69d75dea3b7a4e6cbf0ef39343a34a53c0edf3a329ae", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "27d9fe5250f38a2f46307b1f15793f78", "candidate_priority_rank": 1352, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f40e365a19294a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f40e365a19294a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f40e365a19294a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f40e365a19294a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "blue", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blue<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2403141", "image_sha256": "1c21ff026356422c67a7fa41cd49fd2cb39a7ae5564be134b235406e874df895", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2403141.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2403141.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2403232", "image_sha256": "ea380a9d417c1bcf9ef370cb2b48fd677fa7347520c6bb14bf16be9259db5417", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2403232.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2403232.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-95f40e365a19294a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blue", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blue", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beige", "blue", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "a3653cb1a029bcb9c99c6db419aa3fe84e0a775eed4b6f815a097b757ea08cdb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "576d64b9ad06eb4f826dd9e98abc9aee1d66617d6325f3647c405c14f7bf783e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12537522", "text": "What is hanging on the blue wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "a3653cb1a029bcb9c99c6db419aa3fe84e0a775eed4b6f815a097b757ea08cdb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "39af14ddbe9db77e7117628b3172a9fd9bec1508764723c588046d2cb4484486"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12712998", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1352, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 10, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "48c44fdf983249048795808e3b2c60cc579826db48de57cd94d134ba3f78a81f", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "12712998", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is hanging on the brown wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is hanging on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "48c44fdf983249048795808e3b2c60cc579826db48de57cd94d134ba3f78a81f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is hanging on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "48c44fdf983249048795808e3b2c60cc579826db48de57cd94d134ba3f78a81f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "mirror", "full_answer": "The mirror is hanging on the wall.", "question": "What is hanging on the blue wall?", "question_id": "12537522", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1127619)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s (1127618)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "mirror", "full_answer": "The mirror is hanging on the wall.", "question": "What is hanging on the brown wall?", "question_id": "12712998", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1126753)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s (1126751)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1127618", "1127620", "1127621", "1127622", "1127623", "1127624", "1127627", "1127629", "1127630", "1127631", "1127633"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mirror"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["apple", "glass", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "1127618", "query_target_entity_name": "mirror", "relation_object_entity_id": "1127619", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1127618", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1127619", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1127619"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1126750", "1126751", "1126752", "1126754", "1126755", "1126756", "1126759", "1126767"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mirror"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["framed", "reflective"], "query_target_entity_id": "1126751", "query_target_entity_name": "mirror", "relation_object_entity_id": "1126753", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1126751", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1126753", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1126753"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:27d9fe5250f38a2f46307b1f15793f78", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1c21ff026356422c67a7fa41cd49fd2cb39a7ae5564be134b235406e874df895", "image_sha256_b": "ea380a9d417c1bcf9ef370cb2b48fd677fa7347520c6bb14bf16be9259db5417", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b0aefe483cd396b5043e1662d12c6a56b2e2b3954cb36a7d60397337b501d3a4", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "38b9111e42df82a608bb3a3f8582b91e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "69e6cffdce9c055540a966a4f261c39f2ef2bc6cb510816f421bcd5aaeb6e03f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ec35ca41d547f11afc4f33eacb4a73911d1f36f943948328b1bfea054ab43a71", "request_id": "f6f18b05e55bd3db2007c689b4769c79", "response_sha256": "e604955da36beda56843a48c0d9e81b9b754c8d9517cf15f4b25a2a2e74631a4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d38d466a99b7427c1e602ca607dbbc0ad30aaabb87400ed3a9764910c7ae90ec", "request_id": "4d60b399725368cdaf4c794afabc0f26", "response_sha256": "9c62f8356c0f386bf2750edf5c68f504bed7960dcb0947dfc5366bc78b9abd04", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "f2309418d0abe2716b5120d4ff5818f4", "candidate_priority_rank": 1373, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-724f390fcead4f7a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-724f390fcead4f7a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-724f390fcead4f7a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-724f390fcead4f7a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "rock<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "wood", "B": "rock"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wood<->rock", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2347071", "image_sha256": "f4787519f4af025b5d1d0981df7f43090a5ff8b010e49ebbfae9e63c6b7446d7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2347071.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2347071.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2384309", "image_sha256": "e0c39cda7e0ed39ab92282294c08f6b66fd70113cb1f772c99921b559c840f8a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384309.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384309.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-724f390fcead4f7a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wood", "diff_b": "rock", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wood", "component_b": "rock"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "3fb640f4e3c5302fcc88056b11cfd2cce938788a668fc8a1ad55612a35b0341a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f385a119caedea794d4c9fa9aba81f2a90b4016abaf826156448e0390fa79d54"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "17490130", "text": "What animal is in front of the wall made of wood?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["rock"], "detected_components": ["rock"], "masked_program_sha256": "3fb640f4e3c5302fcc88056b11cfd2cce938788a668fc8a1ad55612a35b0341a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "rock", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b89a94ee24a751a6803cbcca1f1765d51cf8565e6897b44777237e23a3705c3e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11499251", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1373, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "20f790f332b337be0bfa6bf82ef8428df9bf142f83c3fe9ef2bb870514599629", "selected_component": "rock", "selected_source_question_id": "11499251", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in front of the wall made of rock?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "20f790f332b337be0bfa6bf82ef8428df9bf142f83c3fe9ef2bb870514599629", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "20f790f332b337be0bfa6bf82ef8428df9bf142f83c3fe9ef2bb870514599629", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is in front of the wall.", "question": "What animal is in front of the wall made of wood?", "question_id": "17490130", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (4446288)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (4321473)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephants", "full_answer": "The elephants are in front of the wall.", "question": "What animal is in front of the wall made of rock?", "question_id": "11499251", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (527463)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "rock", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (527459)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4321473"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["lying"], "query_target_entity_id": "4321473", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "4446288", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4321473", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4446288", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4446288"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "rock", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3847027", "527459"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "playing", "wrinkled", "young"], "query_target_entity_id": "527459", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "527463", "relation_subject_entity_id": "527459", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "527463", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "rock", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["527463"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:f2309418d0abe2716b5120d4ff5818f4", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f4787519f4af025b5d1d0981df7f43090a5ff8b010e49ebbfae9e63c6b7446d7", "image_sha256_b": "e0c39cda7e0ed39ab92282294c08f6b66fd70113cb1f772c99921b559c840f8a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7023894f171a7bd3a7ee83d892f82f614d4fa82e10c01351ef69d51976be0ab6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2b3ec66f2c477b0e325c7bb70e747e67", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "206a1e0722229bf7be555f9d9ad961a9239382f503eff74e536ddf8ceced6747"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d6391d1ace9e5352b06629a5886927061b469315f655a53824fed308602882c9", "request_id": "045df6afa9c0a2754864f47211a5e3ab", "response_sha256": "b88da7726d557e80baa4a6d7a442b18236927852b3105972b6b7196fa7389e4a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d85f2d0128ce5aba3a63ae48ec13f4c7b1a0c529572560f295e5901b7b45ae52", "request_id": "cdae4cd183ec1a5de44c59744321296d", "response_sha256": "14ec43040b6a88bbd928c563cff187d81cfd35c258b195b13c655c4656fe019f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "6cdc7b6c01b86d06c22b9466f25a3b53", "candidate_priority_rank": 1437, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-42d0c4f590d5c5aa:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-42d0c4f590d5c5aa:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-42d0c4f590d5c5aa:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-42d0c4f590d5c5aa:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "gray<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "white", "B": "gray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "white<->gray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2318849", "image_sha256": "1c03172bd2240fcd89c889a3dbeca7d9d5899444590643d3ef173a1af6024165", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2318849.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2318849.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2342361", "image_sha256": "6a9cae7b965c6342bb69d528bd7d4eb4b3baf01835cfd73ffe536616b884dc47", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342361.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342361.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-42d0c4f590d5c5aa", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "white", "diff_b": "gray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "white", "component_b": "gray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "c8c5b1b6acde7907b47d7d637a367d133401887f438337534f71c03c001a9149", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "63572617ed53b4bc16fad8fa503f6f36f5d912ac6a08473051c9532f134fc1fb"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07465467", "text": "What animal is on the white animal?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "gray", "green", "orange", "pink", "white"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "c8c5b1b6acde7907b47d7d637a367d133401887f438337534f71c03c001a9149", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "22ae0dbf04795c63488b3c7141f22ff2d57c4c2bc86afcbca45d8b194b029539"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19166686", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1437, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "11ed3a19543c4e0c5ac765b5d32cd61aac3a7dd0630a1f7bb7da12a75cd73a33", "selected_component": "gray", "selected_source_question_id": "19166686", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is on the gray animal?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the animal?", "program_group_hash": "11ed3a19543c4e0c5ac765b5d32cd61aac3a7dd0630a1f7bb7da12a75cd73a33", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is on the animal?", "program_group_hash": "11ed3a19543c4e0c5ac765b5d32cd61aac3a7dd0630a1f7bb7da12a75cd73a33", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is on the bunny.", "question": "What animal is on the white animal?", "question_id": "07465467", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (2717910)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (3492042)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "duck", "full_answer": "The duck is on the cat.", "question": "What animal is on the gray animal?", "question_id": "19166686", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (934748)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (934749)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3492042"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "3492042", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "2717910", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3492042", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2717910", "selected_entity_name": "bunny"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2717910"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["934749"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["duck"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["orange", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "934749", "query_target_entity_name": "duck", "relation_object_entity_id": "934748", "relation_subject_entity_id": "934749", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "934748", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["934748"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:6cdc7b6c01b86d06c22b9466f25a3b53", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1c03172bd2240fcd89c889a3dbeca7d9d5899444590643d3ef173a1af6024165", "image_sha256_b": "6a9cae7b965c6342bb69d528bd7d4eb4b3baf01835cfd73ffe536616b884dc47", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ab7526e5fb4f081493f80714a7d5f2c09b5ad2098124026841a2a16b83e30646", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "343ff545941c6fd4f7a9f6548214c3d5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "19ca9b2c735b10fdd811cd5e9cf82640296d4067225be0071fc88480dc05c230"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a7ff9caebfb25044b820595b6707ce59b4444cccb52a47c631f09452be05c768", "request_id": "8feb22171ff12211b0c6f814c620ec72", "response_sha256": "2e4c3a153b87a3cf292bfc0aec51935a9bdf192c4f7cf6bfb3262dc1605bb8a3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1c7028ee6097c9466c3a81dbf32313944101c646c438b6f9f79f8000663f418c", "request_id": "39587679665b9366d37b2865f297e851", "response_sha256": "1d3d81b3018b52f34ab57244e926fe8ac2836d0b7479b9c02d7f673be0992a68", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "5bfae46679eb0deaf505be9687a8e94b", "candidate_priority_rank": 1439, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cb646e343be20418:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cb646e343be20418:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cb646e343be20418:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cb646e343be20418:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blue<->red", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "red", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "red<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2354043", "image_sha256": "b499cd688345c241b6b032831a67574873afe81449d363b6f43af65e987955ea", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2354043.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2354043.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2410138", "image_sha256": "35ba0c9be18bffe26ab4645d841eb6b941627df48fad83c856a42e7c4771cffa", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410138.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410138.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-cb646e343be20418", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "red", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "red", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "green", "red"], "detected_components": ["red"], "masked_program_sha256": "67818916c77171ab4bdb886e0c1b22a4046ad75ce0cee796e6cbebe5034d7e6e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "red", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0ff7f761c1ac0c7bd6f90f0d2a590dd782e24ade09ecf3cdee4e1665cd5a533a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1259780", "text": "What is in front of the red vehicle?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "gray"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "67818916c77171ab4bdb886e0c1b22a4046ad75ce0cee796e6cbebe5034d7e6e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c7cd297c2a5cfe7b48ff22e09824b0f14fc3de5e863b73929cea82ae3ae77b26"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18333867", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1439, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f86a61c469f10abb956cee1c5f2035cdef5fff8d06421b4cdb042677a67cb120", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "18333867", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the blue vehicle?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "vehicle", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the vehicle?", "program_group_hash": "f86a61c469f10abb956cee1c5f2035cdef5fff8d06421b4cdb042677a67cb120", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "vehicle"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "vehicle", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the vehicle?", "program_group_hash": "f86a61c469f10abb956cee1c5f2035cdef5fff8d06421b4cdb042677a67cb120", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "vehicle"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "fence", "full_answer": "The fence is in front of the truck.", "question": "What is in front of the red vehicle?", "question_id": "1259780", "semantic": [{"argument": "vehicle (2235909)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "red", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (2235910)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "platform", "full_answer": "The platform is in front of the train.", "question": "What is in front of the blue vehicle?", "question_id": "18333867", "semantic": [{"argument": "vehicle (225110)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (225114)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1734768", "1917275", "1917276", "1917277", "1917278", "2095131", "2235910", "2271860", "2271861", "2279967", "2401292", "2659308", "2664759", "2666843", "2683854", "3575272", "3778406", "3895134"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fence"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["chain-link"], "query_target_entity_id": "2235910", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "2235909", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2235910", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "2235909", "selected_entity_name": "truck"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2235909"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "red", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["225114", "225120", "225122", "225124", "225125", "225126", "225127", "225128", "225129", "225130", "225131", "225132", "225138", "225139"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["platform"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "225114", "query_target_entity_name": "platform", "relation_object_entity_id": "225110", "relation_subject_entity_id": "225114", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "225110", "selected_entity_name": "train"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["225110"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:5bfae46679eb0deaf505be9687a8e94b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b499cd688345c241b6b032831a67574873afe81449d363b6f43af65e987955ea", "image_sha256_b": "35ba0c9be18bffe26ab4645d841eb6b941627df48fad83c856a42e7c4771cffa", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e95372074846914c8bb0277942953b644dad112656bea561da214beba16877ed", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7c9496e0ea1e31a567565c9e8a8111f0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9845a57497e9956cdbc81ea2a0f2451ad7810dd897042285124fac509f27010e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b3f3d3924f683db39b3ffb6d7224d4f31002e27cf3330800d3c73e5c334e5113", "request_id": "db1a79902461f836852b4fe3185b3540", "response_sha256": "5939d3a8639ebc1508a826749688b3c2a6a58ec4710a02a22887e3ff1a5732e6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8f150acc73b5dd83367bf52b5975b4a043844fc4dfec2550d0e7b3124859b50e", "request_id": "8b9d9690ba539c5ea6bc5dfdbb4d8e71", "response_sha256": "b643358effd8453374e22855859e427d653af93bb658f5ada2289bfe9e89c438", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a70667713050c0ec3218cc46c2eb4aac", "candidate_priority_rank": 1547, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89813c5ba4d1ff9a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89813c5ba4d1ff9a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89813c5ba4d1ff9a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89813c5ba4d1ff9a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "eating<->playing", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "eating", "B": "playing"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "eating<->playing", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2399302", "image_sha256": "2c7e4aba71515f19219feda095cf45964ae2aac3c6a27c5229ef49b8308b0a75", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399302.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399302.jpg", "width": 326}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2405536", "image_sha256": "c0e7ab647874cb2389207c7000511ecea7e4f1749a49e1f29aa0b23c675ec491", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405536.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405536.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89813c5ba4d1ff9a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "eating", "diff_b": "playing", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "eating", "component_b": "playing"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["eating"], "detected_components": ["eating"], "masked_program_sha256": "dffce669263f3a6e3572dfce5216d65140aa0cf67f6c319010b54777cbc6eff8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "eating", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f91cc7e2b359038183b385a169f3519bb979fc659d8b16613a18e26c63ea393f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07206792", "text": "What is the person that is eating holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["playing"], "detected_components": ["playing"], "masked_program_sha256": "dffce669263f3a6e3572dfce5216d65140aa0cf67f6c319010b54777cbc6eff8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "playing", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b420120dc50a3a8723584535f780717bccf943b4a831fd2a3c7e3f08aef66c53"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "001033752", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1547, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 11, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "51003c3f0e3f6afd77dcb7234c97b8985ebaf361a3f9e8e5a10179aa71d0cd1e", "selected_component": "playing", "selected_source_question_id": "001033752", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person that is playing holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "51003c3f0e3f6afd77dcb7234c97b8985ebaf361a3f9e8e5a10179aa71d0cd1e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "activity", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "person", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person that is holding?", "program_group_hash": "51003c3f0e3f6afd77dcb7234c97b8985ebaf361a3f9e8e5a10179aa71d0cd1e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sandwich", "full_answer": "The man is holding the sandwich.", "question": "What is the person that is eating holding?", "question_id": "07206792", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (417396)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "eating", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (417399)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bat", "full_answer": "The girl is holding the bat.", "question": "What is the person that is playing holding?", "question_id": "001033752", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (331292)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "playing", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter activity"}, {"argument": "_,holding,o (331297)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["417399", "417400", "417401", "417402", "417403", "417404", "417405", "417406", "417407", "417409", "417410", "417411", "417412"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sandwich"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "417399", "query_target_entity_name": "sandwich", "relation_object_entity_id": "417399", "relation_subject_entity_id": "417396", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "417396", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "eating", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["417396"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "eating", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["331291", "331293", "331294", "331295", "331297", "331300", "331302", "331304", "331306", "331307"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bat"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue", "metal"], "query_target_entity_id": "331297", "query_target_entity_name": "bat", "relation_object_entity_id": "331297", "relation_subject_entity_id": "331292", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "331292", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "playing", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["331292"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:a70667713050c0ec3218cc46c2eb4aac", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2c7e4aba71515f19219feda095cf45964ae2aac3c6a27c5229ef49b8308b0a75", "image_sha256_b": "c0e7ab647874cb2389207c7000511ecea7e4f1749a49e1f29aa0b23c675ec491", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "2f9d91bd68295b9c678aae8766df06b9326d04c5030b5bc782e4c25b60662107", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7cc10c263e31aff2065636a2b0ab031e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f1cc7f220a22b6cadb6f65ceb8830741d6d124528bddfab3372e3d7e70200330"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "61c815264ee6b1b1786eb517eae6e65fef53171f20f5a955e87eb4dd57057c6a", "request_id": "2e6837f6d959515791ca2304b82c3e28", "response_sha256": "66e52967e9a9eddd31a8a8bd524c85d4873107e913e9a16fed2664f6347f0fd9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "91cd60b566d1b792da68829fda744d6976f87ea6103573ac04f58b5562e2ac0b", "request_id": "d227418cba520588a326dfd67be92672", "response_sha256": "1ce75fd8cb49b6a30015de4f2afb51732d69da1381d8c01cf81bab06b9645168", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "102ee0f77a8763c96be161a2b6fba8f8", "candidate_priority_rank": 1581, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-753c30df50500776:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-753c30df50500776:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-753c30df50500776:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-753c30df50500776:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2345652", "image_sha256": "8b0a66e3f6679f41ab7d76ed0bef65664bd3935caa1d39f6f3c1e481d2d77836", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345652.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345652.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2359955", "image_sha256": "e24d9999b33fe5338ad2c4e173eae4b10c5155521dd13270967cf1a9735624be", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2359955.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2359955.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-753c30df50500776", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "brown", "green", "red", "white", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "954f92c9574c7cde07702deed180192445cf1db5d2d7771cd1c25009d7d49542"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08610216", "text": "What is on the black wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bdf93fc8de8aef492cb262e887148f8867cea50bce76d56a29ba3e3d51d881f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16861797", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1581, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "16861797", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the white wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "paper", "full_answer": "The paper is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the black wall?", "question_id": "08610216", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (906019)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (906018)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "flowers", "full_answer": "The flowers are on the wall.", "question": "What is on the white wall?", "question_id": "16861797", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1932881)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1753883)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["906012", "906014", "906015", "906016", "906017", "906018", "906020", "906021", "906022", "906023", "906025", "906026", "906027", "906028", "906029"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["paper"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["hanging"], "query_target_entity_id": "906018", "query_target_entity_name": "paper", "relation_object_entity_id": "906019", "relation_subject_entity_id": "906018", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "906019", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["906019"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1753883", "1960367", "1984360", "1984361", "1984362", "1984364", "2314989", "2350291", "2417291", "2577550", "2823133", "3119801", "3207604", "3207605", "3207606", "3207607", "3207608", "3536469", "3536473"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["flowers"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1753883", "query_target_entity_name": "flowers", "relation_object_entity_id": "1932881", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1753883", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1932881", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1932881"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:102ee0f77a8763c96be161a2b6fba8f8", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8b0a66e3f6679f41ab7d76ed0bef65664bd3935caa1d39f6f3c1e481d2d77836", "image_sha256_b": "e24d9999b33fe5338ad2c4e173eae4b10c5155521dd13270967cf1a9735624be", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c4f35f6615814a79a5f91e27d736e341348d8a610099d837fc2673579a7ee419", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "505e92502dfd7dc7109a343b22371b27", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f4ec892309300cd4252b660f1231e7dbef114ef3adce684cd1fa5d9b1d2a56a4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f86e8cd297b659cda3811035625f39677bc60f3f8cd7e43bbc585789b08b813f", "request_id": "e02f80454061eb21337981efebea6c14", "response_sha256": "01c74135fa0e17ba653f8e33f244eb3d29c1d5dd48d506bd2a618358b38cd37b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8c8afd932fcd0da848d473c0ccd6fead52ce45f19aa5e7fee76a4bc453f39138", "request_id": "7ae974f329b2c3feb0e14b6b66489589", "response_sha256": "2f6cef90396dd353c8058a52448f638f727d7ec94a0de68e8aa7e9162f95d492", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "8256a1aab18fcd57a9d24a9ef9f2e049", "candidate_priority_rank": 1635, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c300f7ea6dd8ca92:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c300f7ea6dd8ca92:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c300f7ea6dd8ca92:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c300f7ea6dd8ca92:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->blue", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "blue"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->blue", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 307, "image_id": "2382145", "image_sha256": "9263288ce8e345ce3744288834beb127f81455c89347795c39b883b6ca4f6eba", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382145.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382145.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 768, "image_id": "713694", "image_sha256": "a0d59a7e09093826a11f85bc4375c79b564de022bda9f1133204fe80b8c894c6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/713694.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/713694.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c300f7ea6dd8ca92", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "blue", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "blue"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.469, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.066, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.302734375, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": -0.0224609375, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0224609375, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 2}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "66a2adde5e5b8e99a9712e92414d4f8b4f4b33ce3304a8ffd20a7a0e2ef4b9b1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "604511def3a0e03d337c0de789ad5375f86c55f3b1d0db87f51f865858901707"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02668636", "text": "What is the vehicle to the left of the black vehicle?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "green", "yellow"], "detected_components": ["blue"], "masked_program_sha256": "66a2adde5e5b8e99a9712e92414d4f8b4f4b33ce3304a8ffd20a7a0e2ef4b9b1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blue", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "83a769b54306a4246d6923513c5a325acd22e09af9ef52d526a5742c6fd1eb32"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17602934", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1635, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6a96c7c221bc4cbf827f1778ab418f8f5858e97caf52147e56ae9522304359b3", "selected_component": "blue", "selected_source_question_id": "17602934", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the vehicle to the left of the blue vehicle?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "vehicle", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vehicle to the left of the vehicle?", "program_group_hash": "6a96c7c221bc4cbf827f1778ab418f8f5858e97caf52147e56ae9522304359b3", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "vehicle"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "vehicle", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vehicle to the left of the vehicle?", "program_group_hash": "6a96c7c221bc4cbf827f1778ab418f8f5858e97caf52147e56ae9522304359b3", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "vehicle"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "trailer", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a trailer.", "question": "What is the vehicle to the left of the black vehicle?", "question_id": "02668636", "semantic": [{"argument": "vehicle (1330618)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the left of,s (1330619)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bus", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a bus.", "question": "What is the vehicle to the left of the blue vehicle?", "question_id": "17602934", "semantic": [{"argument": "vehicle (1587601)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "blue", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the left of,s (1587646)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1330619"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trailer"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["small", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1330619", "query_target_entity_name": "trailer", "relation_object_entity_id": "1330618", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1330619", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1330618", "selected_entity_name": "truck"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1330618"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1587600", "1587646"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bus"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["green", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "1587646", "query_target_entity_name": "bus", "relation_object_entity_id": "1587601", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1587646", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1587601", "selected_entity_name": "taxi"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "blue", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1587601"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:8256a1aab18fcd57a9d24a9ef9f2e049", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9263288ce8e345ce3744288834beb127f81455c89347795c39b883b6ca4f6eba", "image_sha256_b": "a0d59a7e09093826a11f85bc4375c79b564de022bda9f1133204fe80b8c894c6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "2ee919afe343f3c1691ab4907bee2f7d8cfb63104c359bb070e483312e13b15c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e77c0638eb3abafb8138c63c0d630ab1", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0f7eb4631466adeca82459d81b04d8f424bdd10b4ed17768915da70d09882a9c"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1588cd877102152a727c8d2059955d4b5f7453c7c2edd04e31d268b40d198b11", "request_id": "b574e21d861d6cad72284de0c681cc43", "response_sha256": "d7831f20ef43826428753bf60f918f504bc5429d2fa7821b25ff66939c81548c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bcb576f2e3d8d26f4030d02619028269ac639f9e01e05a6bdd54dd3cd6a8f302", "request_id": "435d30f8fc78a97d546c7f00eb115e30", "response_sha256": "694fdb78b3d55baa4fc7b989b8c45c73e16f5e061ed7a9bfea05ae0f20c51c22", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "feea39fcb39f0c4fe0f20ffd4b2fafc7", "candidate_priority_rank": 1692, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63d6148026bd9484:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63d6148026bd9484:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63d6148026bd9484:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63d6148026bd9484:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "calm<->choppy", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "calm", "B": "choppy"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "calm<->choppy", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2369544", "image_sha256": "c42fb3929c0a73a975f52a38a455319217e82c4dad805e6a04814b533fdea3ca", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369544.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369544.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2396202", "image_sha256": "57abf87851809002e77b1ae61eea26d8ec8456f04090f810d939ae94b5e80e16", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396202.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396202.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-63d6148026bd9484", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "calm", "diff_b": "choppy", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "calm", "component_b": "choppy"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["calm", "still"], "detected_components": ["calm"], "masked_program_sha256": "0d732ce6be975b6fdbe128927a32b4e4d165598908555745c445d486ee81327e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "calm", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a6896fea5175fdb4bdfdbe6e0a15938718470b0b15b816d387e97ed076fa969f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14998964", "text": "What animal is in front of the calm water?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["choppy"], "detected_components": ["choppy"], "masked_program_sha256": "0d732ce6be975b6fdbe128927a32b4e4d165598908555745c445d486ee81327e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "choppy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f54bb9e7adad6a860c86d9eb6a5b57f6b8d71da1aecc88e91a909b14128ef373"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13481599", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1692, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "62c11a2dbce19a3e3463a2a3212aefe1f9376c4c6ec09f1794a85f329a9722b5", "selected_component": "choppy", "selected_source_question_id": "13481599", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is in front of the choppy water?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "state", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter state"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the water?", "program_group_hash": "62c11a2dbce19a3e3463a2a3212aefe1f9376c4c6ec09f1794a85f329a9722b5", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "state", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "water", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter state"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is in front of the water?", "program_group_hash": "62c11a2dbce19a3e3463a2a3212aefe1f9376c4c6ec09f1794a85f329a9722b5", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bears", "full_answer": "The bears are in front of the water.", "question": "What animal is in front of the calm water?", "question_id": "14998964", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (4000589)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "calm", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter state"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (4000590)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The horse is in front of the water.", "question": "What animal is in front of the choppy water?", "question_id": "13481599", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (447019)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "choppy", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter state"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (447018)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4000590", "4000602", "4000639"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bears"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "4000590", "query_target_entity_name": "bears", "relation_object_entity_id": "4000589", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4000590", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4000589", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "calm", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4000589"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "choppy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "calm", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["447018"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "large", "running"], "query_target_entity_id": "447018", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "447019", "relation_subject_entity_id": "447018", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "447019", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "choppy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["447019"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:feea39fcb39f0c4fe0f20ffd4b2fafc7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c42fb3929c0a73a975f52a38a455319217e82c4dad805e6a04814b533fdea3ca", "image_sha256_b": "57abf87851809002e77b1ae61eea26d8ec8456f04090f810d939ae94b5e80e16", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "12c106c2b8b62260e18366f261b53e4f7c07696e4aa65ba67fa542a0b392dc4f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9a5f79a2057c492205d19c1a199d4479", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "98abb4af0159f1e5ca366bea9637fc87eeab347a923fc8d4cfefc6711fe860f7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0202996fad30bbd1f5bdb94b339b55aaca10cb8e8be66efabd37ae1e699280d0", "request_id": "a38fae2881ac0eb7f59e9f18ed24f722", "response_sha256": "3d703eb2ec37f7dc68481528567341f206df53735108163b86bd54813e366eb6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0861f2b5ff0295be53981d2c916bd7c561d4f9c870fa5b0cb5151fe6d72db5bf", "request_id": "64fb3c464824370c2a8218641fb50722", "response_sha256": "4b1b5c8fe6573e73aae7928a5862c0646a95252747ddd4da6fcbe0e17133c2b1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "49401d51c7e3403f1f63df93a659164b", "candidate_priority_rank": 1876, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89a297dd49025b06:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89a297dd49025b06:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89a297dd49025b06:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89a297dd49025b06:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brick<->wood", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "brick", "B": "wood"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brick<->wood", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2378093", "image_sha256": "d17d4fe7c9d2a9fb8600e12ab5a559a5c2737bbf88bd196ef969ef4bf7b9784e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2378093.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2378093.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2348545", "image_sha256": "1ac3693fbccd5b75f0e39479f2498173a949c7d4553ec796b1c4c81f5c13df85", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2348545.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2348545.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-89a297dd49025b06", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brick", "diff_b": "wood", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brick", "component_b": "wood"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brick", "metal"], "detected_components": ["brick"], "masked_program_sha256": "d8f20b755b9c6a7ff36707985d176d3369501288086e6e7d07bee59cd5e98d40", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brick", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e21014e29346458994234b513204d7473463f2540f2de07eae71194bc74c1875"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00941636", "text": "What is hanging on the wall made of brick?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["plastic", "wood"], "detected_components": ["wood"], "masked_program_sha256": "d8f20b755b9c6a7ff36707985d176d3369501288086e6e7d07bee59cd5e98d40", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wood", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d46020b09fcad532bf7aaffa5e197f9a3ac7061a1112ca3a634684e46068eef6"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13673979", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1876, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5ac79a470b91fa6547a962b53a8c6612a3d2773c411c96c96818cdbd00d6e609", "selected_component": "wood", "selected_source_question_id": "13673979", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is hanging on the wall made of wood?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is hanging on the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "5ac79a470b91fa6547a962b53a8c6612a3d2773c411c96c96818cdbd00d6e609", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "material", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is hanging on the wall made of ?", "program_group_hash": "5ac79a470b91fa6547a962b53a8c6612a3d2773c411c96c96818cdbd00d6e609", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sign", "full_answer": "The sign is hanging on the wall.", "question": "What is hanging on the wall made of brick?", "question_id": "00941636", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1972976)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brick", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s (3672267)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is hanging on the wall.", "question": "What is hanging on the wall made of wood?", "question_id": "13673979", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (881401)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "wood", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter material"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,s (881400)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1712200", "1712201", "1733356", "1766777", "1766780", "1766781", "1766782", "1766783", "1780715", "1797474", "1908280", "1922939", "1945819", "2046500", "2107825", "2139010", "2263204", "2280941", "2433941", "2453502", "2492826", "2492828", "2569805", "2569806", "2609816", "3672267", "3672268", "3672270", "3672272", "3672273"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 30, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sign"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "3672267", "query_target_entity_name": "sign", "relation_object_entity_id": "1972976", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3672267", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1972976", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1972976"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["881400", "881403", "881404", "881405", "881407", "881408", "881414", "881416", "881417", "881418", "881419", "881420", "881421", "881422", "881423", "881424", "881425", "881426", "881427", "881428", "881429"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "round", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "881400", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "881401", "relation_subject_entity_id": "881400", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "881401", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "wood", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["881401"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:49401d51c7e3403f1f63df93a659164b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d17d4fe7c9d2a9fb8600e12ab5a559a5c2737bbf88bd196ef969ef4bf7b9784e", "image_sha256_b": "1ac3693fbccd5b75f0e39479f2498173a949c7d4553ec796b1c4c81f5c13df85", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "2771433a88cb370748575843132f7b000d3467ec5f9db54fa4f855ef2bd35336", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0bab6c3c0d0db6a6306a1eb6e6596ff9", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e2c3e510af754373c85510eb846742464be6dc598ac354cba5346853f0be2499"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "33efe9c03a763d5880062ba55ae9a338528b593537eb835c756cc16bc45b1f63", "request_id": "20b6c1dfad85e3524ec243828f547a62", "response_sha256": "ddd3431d36e54435d171e16797e0824dae3669e8d482eb6e7761f6a145ea7d44", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "16b9a9b971c4d10f728b8f68a57a65dc630b1b98cbe418d8ea6b6dc16bd396c5", "request_id": "929d228d19fe9ee2d8257423095e7de5", "response_sha256": "85ec385df7ab57b09a5f7bfb20eb79c03e17b6c5b4656d1c06e384d147cee57d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "cce993a61e6420ba65dd8f6a8dfefc27", "candidate_priority_rank": 321, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c05fe236d7155d8e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c05fe236d7155d8e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c05fe236d7155d8e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c05fe236d7155d8e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->gold", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gold", "B": "black"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gold<->black", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2358391", "image_sha256": "2a60da6b0a732531b6c8ec35caf4b67bbb868b9b72c57e68522833361dd7a6cd", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2358391.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2358391.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 324, "image_id": "2387285", "image_sha256": "25128a79f81f15bad7575a2b575f19cf7ce1c7f869beeee1c25e5b67afe554c3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387285.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387285.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-c05fe236d7155d8e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gold", "diff_b": "black", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gold", "component_b": "black"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["gold", "orange", "white"], "detected_components": ["gold"], "masked_program_sha256": "b8e9dbc573e38823ba05a18c9c8874ad9bf10e27aec2e1ad4390310cab6a7669", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gold", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9e918dbdb7f2d657d6486389a413db13a452397e5a7bfc488c701cef7e14b369"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18255994", "text": "What is the gold cat lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "white"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "b8e9dbc573e38823ba05a18c9c8874ad9bf10e27aec2e1ad4390310cab6a7669", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5f5aea5b5e4e4831211c79ab7e33797bd7eb78b506eab6efd9fd990a9448a027"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15236307", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 321, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "838bfdf917014c31eaa5da689a105b1a4c00a969ccfa8d98704655eb76e13c2b", "selected_component": "black", "selected_source_question_id": "15236307", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the black cat lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "cat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cat lying on?", "program_group_hash": "838bfdf917014c31eaa5da689a105b1a4c00a969ccfa8d98704655eb76e13c2b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "cat", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cat lying on?", "program_group_hash": "838bfdf917014c31eaa5da689a105b1a4c00a969ccfa8d98704655eb76e13c2b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bench", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the bench.", "question": "What is the gold cat lying on?", "question_id": "18255994", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (2469089)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gold", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (2012344)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the couch.", "question": "What is the black cat lying on?", "question_id": "15236307", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (1277430)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (1277431)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1712685", "1712798", "1975500", "2012344", "2393274", "2527544", "2694549", "2694550", "3545585", "3545586", "3545587", "3545591", "3545592", "3545596", "3545597", "3768554", "3768557"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bench"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "2012344", "query_target_entity_name": "bench", "relation_object_entity_id": "2012344", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2469089", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2469089", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gold", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2469089"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gold", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1277431", "1277432", "1277433", "1277434", "1277435", "1277436", "1277437", "1277438", "1277439", "1277440", "1277441", "1277442"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["colorful", "striped"], "query_target_entity_id": "1277431", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "1277431", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1277430", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1277430", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1277430"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:cce993a61e6420ba65dd8f6a8dfefc27", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2a60da6b0a732531b6c8ec35caf4b67bbb868b9b72c57e68522833361dd7a6cd", "image_sha256_b": "25128a79f81f15bad7575a2b575f19cf7ce1c7f869beeee1c25e5b67afe554c3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "13e577fac3bd158ec0e5ac800f2708c1cbaeb1c68d33f90aa20b87c7081ef6b6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "82dfabdf2cbed5c403d566e1f82bf169", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b72eca25a7ce44ec5b183e433b013488e9604125af08ab24a74168130f5ae16e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e696c386aaacb2b3e313b3b386f9b73bc6e1e092c71361ea478564f13251cd6d", "request_id": "1c25055a905de8541928d977f6467ba2", "response_sha256": "0907a9166cb56c1fc5223b0716895796f223a285df21b4de562117ad9eabd9de", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "08e6f593bcb5e711b839e2ede8ad31b036c19dfe3fea43f5418288b6f9d90fe7", "request_id": "9476d7bb88e169c810b4d747d659ee78", "response_sha256": "5a6d60a95eba81d05bd4996f19f42f14be5ec24536f2e36aad30b4f6ed507680", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "4918e611d2f720432bee9acf7d0e5343", "candidate_priority_rank": 1061, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-029046469bf74a45:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-029046469bf74a45:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-029046469bf74a45:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-029046469bf74a45:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "tan<->white", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "tan", "B": "white"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "tan<->white", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2401528", "image_sha256": "ea586234d3c10b119ed21c342345344a8766ab0df9a85bd5d5fd380f8209e788", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401528.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401528.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2374903", "image_sha256": "6d5e6654f188036212a65990132275d4b36cd6b180209edfdfb041eefd604f22", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2374903.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2374903.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-029046469bf74a45", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "tan", "diff_b": "white", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "tan", "component_b": "white"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "blue", "brown", "gray", "orange", "tan", "white"], "detected_components": ["tan"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tan", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1517ce75186689b9c39c7e5ac81934ebaa044d7cad8081a547d8693d955dafe0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "001054369", "text": "What is on the tan wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blue", "brown", "gray", "white"], "detected_components": ["white"], "masked_program_sha256": "80001675c10f164b63ffd0b437de9c2953f995ab4d7d83d3117c5a2ccf4f0b87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "white", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bdf93fc8de8aef492cb262e887148f8867cea50bce76d56a29ba3e3d51d881f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03870677", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1061, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 14, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "selected_component": "white", "selected_source_question_id": "03870677", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the white wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "wall", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the wall?", "program_group_hash": "66ef6b2feca3329fc8265821aa22712024448bf5131b18de4e1161e203249045", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "mirror", "full_answer": "The mirror is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the tan wall?", "question_id": "001054369", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1146884)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "tan", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1146883)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "television", "full_answer": "The TV is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the white wall?", "question_id": "03870677", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (724471)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "white", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (724454)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1146881", "1146882", "1146883", "1146885", "1146886", "1146887", "1146888", "1146889", "1146890", "1146891", "1146892", "1146893", "1146894", "1146895", "1146896", "1146897", "1146898", "1146899", "1146900", "1146901", "1146902", "1146903", "1146904", "1146905", "1146906", "1146909", "1146910"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 27, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mirror"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["rectangular"], "query_target_entity_id": "1146883", "query_target_entity_name": "mirror", "relation_object_entity_id": "1146884", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1146883", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1146884", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1146884"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1146881", "1146882", "1146883", "1146884", "1146885", "1146886", "1146887", "1146888", "1146889", "1146890", "1146891", "1146892", "1146893", "1146894", "1146895", "1146896", "1146897", "1146898", "1146899", "1146901", "1146902", "1146903", "1146904", "1146905", "1146906", "1146909", "1146910"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 27, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1146900"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["724451", "724452", "724453", "724454", "724455", "724456", "724457", "724458", "724460", "724462", "724463", "724464", "724465", "724466", "724467", "724468", "724469", "724472", "724473", "724475"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["television"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "724454", "query_target_entity_name": "television", "relation_object_entity_id": "724471", "relation_subject_entity_id": "724454", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "724471", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "white", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["724471"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:4918e611d2f720432bee9acf7d0e5343", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ea586234d3c10b119ed21c342345344a8766ab0df9a85bd5d5fd380f8209e788", "image_sha256_b": "6d5e6654f188036212a65990132275d4b36cd6b180209edfdfb041eefd604f22", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "960359ed7c31fe7a1d1daa8d7a098533f0f5c0b89956958e7dd32fb5279cb6b5", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c03b20e15cbfe2ba4ff051afbadb5dde", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6fc05fe098fca196c7168ed32016ea2377d002b104dad8b537453c13f1f1da06"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "14b01e550b14d7501a28cab7b35295ca73ae086c69709701790cad9b6f29f90e", "request_id": "c47e030becbc467dbd1597709889ce5a", "response_sha256": "fee0bb02091e2044b3cb30cbd5b7ffdb56eaef0f71583b61231e2ba267e6b2c6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2fab7b8f1d4e56cb2d6b60eeec71e099eb1f0e758493920da0729fe8a9512664", "request_id": "d29874f3ca7e3e3300897e64b1f4c789", "response_sha256": "52e83dcf1e43ca00bf020352d973993a15d45cc786da027b4a56453ca668325a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ca4cd57fcdbb4a4df0f7912b07aff9b5", "candidate_priority_rank": 1909, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-964ff1de6111a8a0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-964ff1de6111a8a0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-964ff1de6111a8a0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-964ff1de6111a8a0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "gray<->tan", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "gray", "B": "tan"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "gray<->tan", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2401202", "image_sha256": "c650533e9f02b2da36079baa3225f76b21fcfde84720a17bc45639751cde0a1b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401202.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401202.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2355317", "image_sha256": "5d09af781459cb74e265343d03e5edd3b8103eaea278d5dfc1d09c4f1c04a618", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2355317.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2355317.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-964ff1de6111a8a0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "gray", "diff_b": "tan", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "gray", "component_b": "tan"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gray"], "detected_components": ["gray"], "masked_program_sha256": "9393295f9b5aa8b5d10a4c214403fdc944834c32709c0440357e2214642fe420", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "gray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "208ef166e9f0a3cb9821671858bcf31018e7eae279b5304b303727d5f20df452"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04973009", "text": "What is in front of the building that looks gray?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "gold", "tan"], "detected_components": ["tan"], "masked_program_sha256": "9393295f9b5aa8b5d10a4c214403fdc944834c32709c0440357e2214642fe420", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tan", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2142a788f53639f4b5250092cfdcb939c3d32517f4518a53440c8a8c646df595"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17955767", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1909, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 10, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c52d4ca5d5f0afd1e372e270516e94a73a82a9baf54aefcd6b520b69ebd640f3", "selected_component": "tan", "selected_source_question_id": "17955767", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in front of the building that looks tan?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "building", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the building that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "c52d4ca5d5f0afd1e372e270516e94a73a82a9baf54aefcd6b520b69ebd640f3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "building"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "building", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in front of the building that looks ?", "program_group_hash": "c52d4ca5d5f0afd1e372e270516e94a73a82a9baf54aefcd6b520b69ebd640f3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "building"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "train", "full_answer": "The train is in front of the building.", "question": "What is in front of the building that looks gray?", "question_id": "04973009", "semantic": [{"argument": "building (401678)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "gray", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (401673)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "statue", "full_answer": "The statue is in front of the building.", "question": "What is in front of the building that looks tan?", "question_id": "17955767", "semantic": [{"argument": "building (830736)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "tan", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,in front of,s (830731)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["401673", "401675", "401680", "401681", "401682", "401684", "401685"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["train"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["antique", "black"], "query_target_entity_id": "401673", "query_target_entity_name": "train", "relation_object_entity_id": "401678", "relation_subject_entity_id": "401673", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "401678", "selected_entity_name": "building"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["401678"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "gray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["830731", "830732", "830733", "830734", "830737", "830738", "830739", "830740", "830741", "830742", "830743", "830744", "830745", "830746", "830747"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["statue"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gold"], "query_target_entity_id": "830731", "query_target_entity_name": "statue", "relation_object_entity_id": "830736", "relation_subject_entity_id": "830731", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "830736", "selected_entity_name": "building"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "tan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["830736"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:ca4cd57fcdbb4a4df0f7912b07aff9b5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c650533e9f02b2da36079baa3225f76b21fcfde84720a17bc45639751cde0a1b", "image_sha256_b": "5d09af781459cb74e265343d03e5edd3b8103eaea278d5dfc1d09c4f1c04a618", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5ffcb8bf090ec039732cc45ef651a6588c4aae18d94525c20d4ff8ac13b738ff", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ca9bf78ca0bd3b7179fa602b744edbfd", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "737230b885d9188facf87415012d6a9f9a1579ec1d1ba869d15579d67aa67c6a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0cbdd17c2a2559e7127d706cefc60f83577e712c82b1f40102c5e738401e0301", "request_id": "068193555bd6193eda6dd7ae84f06e18", "response_sha256": "ba297908cc77c5db3da9d2d705b843ef1c6977b986aa92d14ad4125bdd0df7d0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4c3af2357da3598f096e689be565b7f71dd90ebe380879f1c35f262b60baa1fe", "request_id": "9d794ba9b4c56ae01f1a238b58f90fc4", "response_sha256": "5c64bf0c5b0481e27bf0e73e141e81db4ecc6fc2f717cbd3d43b00682aa54635", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "13ccffcc57125c9bc276f24c0a39adaf", "candidate_priority_rank": 2085, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-290d090942d35808:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-290d090942d35808:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-290d090942d35808:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-290d090942d35808:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "black<->brown", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "components": {"A": "black", "B": "brown"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "black<->brown", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2402324", "image_sha256": "b1e958cecea0b810800d7baa39f404b37856ba9c270d42a112b0d2664ebea8e1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402324.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402324.jpg", "width": 371}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2407279", "image_sha256": "1a159ef5d1f5456cb7ce51889fd8c67d6236f5394cfd0f02fb8ed9c86b992004", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407279.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407279.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "location_endpoint", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-attribute-290d090942d35808", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "black", "diff_b": "brown", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "black", "component_b": "brown"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "location_endpoint", "question_prefix": "Where", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["black", "purple"], "detected_components": ["black"], "masked_program_sha256": "e8335c4d18655f614ece38f808d463dec527fa97bddac38f59d090ffe58324ea", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "black", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ee253696e16fe110cccfa3d18efd4a1722d451d41f558a4231cdbd87beacae9b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14261357", "text": "Where is the black animal walking?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brown", "gray", "green"], "detected_components": ["brown"], "masked_program_sha256": "e8335c4d18655f614ece38f808d463dec527fa97bddac38f59d090ffe58324ea", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brown", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "12716ce1bc2599fa6b956546881cbf8a756b6b17de19aebd921f9b62c2f5ab72"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14524295", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 2085, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5d2bfd1d8c01c8d5e6ff5a45da1b7a9b01c3054e481360c45bfc4ed12380d140", "selected_component": "brown", "selected_source_question_id": "14524295", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "Where is the brown animal walking?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "location_endpoint", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,walking on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "where is the animal walking?", "program_group_hash": "5d2bfd1d8c01c8d5e6ff5a45da1b7a9b01c3054e481360c45bfc4ed12380d140", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "animal"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": "color", "component_role": "referent_attribute_filter", "intent_family": "location_endpoint", "masked_program": [{"argument": "animal", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,walking on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "where is the animal walking?", "program_group_hash": "5d2bfd1d8c01c8d5e6ff5a45da1b7a9b01c3054e481360c45bfc4ed12380d140", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "animal"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "path", "full_answer": "The dog is walking on the path.", "question": "Where is the black animal walking?", "question_id": "14261357", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (1137607)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "black", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,walking on,o (1137609)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "log", "full_answer": "The bear is walking on the log.", "question": "Where is the brown animal walking?", "question_id": "14524295", "semantic": [{"argument": "animal (282395)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "brown", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "filter color"}, {"argument": "_,walking on,o (282396)", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [2], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1137609", "1137610", "1137611", "1137612", "1137613", "1137614"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["path"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["narrow"], "query_target_entity_id": "1137609", "query_target_entity_name": "path", "relation_object_entity_id": "1137609", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1137607", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "1137607", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1137607"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "black", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["282396", "282397", "282398", "282399", "282400", "282401", "282402", "282403", "282404", "282406", "282407", "282409", "282410", "282411", "282412", "282413", "282414", "282415", "282416", "282423", "282424"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["log"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "wide"], "query_target_entity_id": "282396", "query_target_entity_name": "log", "relation_object_entity_id": "282396", "relation_subject_entity_id": "282395", "selected_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "selected_entity_id": "282395", "selected_entity_name": "bear"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "attribute", "question_component": "brown", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["282395"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "attribute", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:attribute:13ccffcc57125c9bc276f24c0a39adaf", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b1e958cecea0b810800d7baa39f404b37856ba9c270d42a112b0d2664ebea8e1", "image_sha256_b": "1a159ef5d1f5456cb7ce51889fd8c67d6236f5394cfd0f02fb8ed9c86b992004", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "dc4b5ea4c218c0039f38a7f70c9f69d8b228c609bb7070db1f9d5be081ac5006", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "310a37838cc11b3e472bc692e833d39f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "489ec639c25541ac0550ffb81cff6137bb3061fc178955f59b7d4bb85b5417b0"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "24d5433404cd701d28d81967c10128691d01cde637ee14ea8b2ebf4c7f0c2e49", "request_id": "4d111f3f16f6506ff44b9afc818f839e", "response_sha256": "21b0ffdb049f2cfe961402678fe11a63c4ecfc1432105b8f8f7fa0c8c3720b78", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "69aa5ede9a5d8c44fb0ff652ddc1e8c40b9031511cbd49b09dca57803bb175ef", "request_id": "bb7e626b37524481627220de9a182f18", "response_sha256": "7a3c1100117944711425ee6bc14843521d8392eab9d0447ca3801767ffd1f09b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "f79dd67ee1ac95ef1373db17f7a36daa", "candidate_priority_rank": 37538, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2af41b7d5dcd2cc0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2af41b7d5dcd2cc0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2af41b7d5dcd2cc0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2af41b7d5dcd2cc0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "baby<->bottle", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "baby", "B": "bottle"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "baby<->bottle", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2354438", "image_sha256": "653b22641c834996da3b22c18bcf1e12d9c86e719df16a151149e26ebeec6cbe", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2354438.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2354438.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2372192", "image_sha256": "3cb67113985ddc8cdc4c98c7c2037b80aa92ff1f48c8e6f6f7f35855e77d3b3b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2372192.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2372192.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2af41b7d5dcd2cc0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "baby", "diff_b": "bottle", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "baby", "component_b": "bottle"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "baby", "bag", "bandana", "eyes", "head", "lady", "lips", "outfit", "people", "person", "pouch", "scarf", "shirt", "umbrella"], "detected_components": ["baby"], "masked_program_sha256": "48a5fa047f61fd8233e73f49b427616be30420659c9f516ec1434034e2c4fc87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby", "bag"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "baby", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby", "bag"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9679a6a30cb7ca154a20b59c8be5c7dbd0d20d3558accd76a2ea19ed31432b21"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00291875", "text": "What bag is the baby in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arms", "backpack", "bag", "bottle", "building", "bus", "bus stop", "ground", "hat", "pants", "pocket", "pole", "shoe", "shoes", "sign", "tire"], "detected_components": ["bottle"], "masked_program_sha256": "48a5fa047f61fd8233e73f49b427616be30420659c9f516ec1434034e2c4fc87", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle", "bag"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bottle", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle", "bag"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1d517ca66bb3c90b5eb86ba13ba80336d6453ab90d03fb241b4ccbcd0d9bc886"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16301216", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37538, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "7a405b3ed77e35b8df33268bbb8c1522066cf99ad0f9b53f36917d957634fe83", "selected_component": "bottle", "selected_source_question_id": "16301216", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What bag is the bottle in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bag,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what bag is the in?", "program_group_hash": "7a405b3ed77e35b8df33268bbb8c1522066cf99ad0f9b53f36917d957634fe83", "queried_category": "bag", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "baby"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bag,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what bag is the in?", "program_group_hash": "7a405b3ed77e35b8df33268bbb8c1522066cf99ad0f9b53f36917d957634fe83", "queried_category": "bag", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bottle"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pouch", "full_answer": "The baby is in the pouch.", "question": "What bag is the baby in?", "question_id": "00291875", "semantic": [{"argument": "baby (2942567)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bag,in,o (1742907)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "backpack", "full_answer": "The bottle is in the backpack.", "question": "What bag is the bottle in?", "question_id": "16301216", "semantic": [{"argument": "bottle (593405)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bag,in,o (593403)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1742907", "2942568"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pouch"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1742907", "query_target_entity_name": "pouch", "relation_object_entity_id": "1742907", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2942567", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2942567", "selected_entity_name": "baby"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2942567"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["593403", "593406", "593414", "593420"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["backpack"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "593403", "query_target_entity_name": "backpack", "relation_object_entity_id": "593403", "relation_subject_entity_id": "593405", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "593405", "selected_entity_name": "bottle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["593405"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f79dd67ee1ac95ef1373db17f7a36daa", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "653b22641c834996da3b22c18bcf1e12d9c86e719df16a151149e26ebeec6cbe", "image_sha256_b": "3cb67113985ddc8cdc4c98c7c2037b80aa92ff1f48c8e6f6f7f35855e77d3b3b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "199d9ab328b896a917f014e1a111290073f55b817537a7b74175a577df028c7c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8357750c0e659614fe66927b1e51408c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "033dbd6e0036bebdbd486dfd4b6b6ed83acbeefdaea33568a8f707ce3bf3464c"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ab4efc8fa76f84b5457285ee3fd11e782dbdf04846bc59ba65d4c46eacc3c353", "request_id": "1967a990436e7f48277bf6c42ebc4531", "response_sha256": "8faea0884b86385abc4ac841cadb8ec2f1286a68fc09f4a6acb4450edf4089a9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e4628f0f7db8e49025534ebaa90bc1a119ad1b84f4a6a902bf923e895c92d7d4", "request_id": "39042451daf16df79c1b2d490db9fad7", "response_sha256": "54526a6ec915926215538fa94e10ebfa780dd49929953b163f05214f80edce23", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "9288c6d3c3f22a5bbfea45b3d8ec2070", "candidate_priority_rank": 37555, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91a137021ea2fe58:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91a137021ea2fe58:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91a137021ea2fe58:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91a137021ea2fe58:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "charger<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "charger", "B": "woman"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "charger<->woman", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2330638", "image_sha256": "6234fda189db3b6e913d3b8a97f1830d3c46b1ed2f6e8ceb43259e0198f44b3a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2330638.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2330638.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2376122", "image_sha256": "13171929617f31d62578ccc0fe6f432e639ef40458d52f3fc28c9190a8ef2813", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376122.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376122.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91a137021ea2fe58", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "charger", "diff_b": "woman", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "charger", "component_b": "woman"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bikes", "book", "charger", "chicken", "container", "cord", "doorway", "drawings", "eye glasses", "girl", "grass", "laptop", "lid", "necklace", "phone", "shirt", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["charger"], "masked_program_sha256": "018379a36fbc4a353ad0b61adc5076e4a816534943fd8690a21f208a3626fa7b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["charger", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "charger", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["charger", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "92006ecb6c14d01ab5291c1b0d5406bf68a8895f9a1ad4fc74b8a700a74e5a59"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0269002", "text": "What is the item of furniture that the charger is lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "armchair", "bag", "bed", "book", "boy", "curtain", "eyes", "floor", "hand", "hat", "head", "headboard", "mouth", "pants", "shirt", "suitcase", "wall", "window", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "018379a36fbc4a353ad0b61adc5076e4a816534943fd8690a21f208a3626fa7b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8cd16a504b8442debb1ddc142a63a6777ccd0ac8360fcead06fba621e89a1ebb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07913557", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37555, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "630967e3baf7335bd03fe2a61fb78f18fb6d1b650c057ae8c69d61bff6ec09dc", "selected_component": "woman", "selected_source_question_id": "07913557", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the item of furniture that the woman is lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that the is lying on?", "program_group_hash": "630967e3baf7335bd03fe2a61fb78f18fb6d1b650c057ae8c69d61bff6ec09dc", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "charger"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that the is lying on?", "program_group_hash": "630967e3baf7335bd03fe2a61fb78f18fb6d1b650c057ae8c69d61bff6ec09dc", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "woman"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a table.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that the charger is lying on?", "question_id": "0269002", "semantic": [{"argument": "charger (972818)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o (972813)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that the woman is lying on?", "question_id": "07913557", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (576022)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o (576023)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["972813"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["outdoors", "red"], "query_target_entity_id": "972813", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "972813", "relation_subject_entity_id": "972818", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "972818", "selected_entity_name": "charger"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "charger", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["972818"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "charger", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["576023", "576032"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["large"], "query_target_entity_id": "576023", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "576023", "relation_subject_entity_id": "576022", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "576022", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["576022"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:9288c6d3c3f22a5bbfea45b3d8ec2070", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6234fda189db3b6e913d3b8a97f1830d3c46b1ed2f6e8ceb43259e0198f44b3a", "image_sha256_b": "13171929617f31d62578ccc0fe6f432e639ef40458d52f3fc28c9190a8ef2813", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "db2badd5e656ac067db802f418da6b329a3c2dc9ad544994c5f5f99633006d2b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7a9b8a1f9a06253637966dab64fd5463", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2995af797ab546b70885b985b3404d6f685722de658cdb8f55a686829141cd92"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b5b4ca941151f8fda3b2bc38e7e29aca4fb9f9259556b69baf2e65dfb04c3292", "request_id": "11f52da09d082640fa66d251c094a933", "response_sha256": "acb6f60b61e2d2880ae06e86070754be9e80357a8531b59bc8d9c7e0d2c2df08", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d7081dab03e472e02836cbebe94c726fb7f711987a4a33ee24819a66b583d288", "request_id": "005487509fc925481e30441317427701", "response_sha256": "87f5124ff5d8a36bbc5f07c46a72b9b2c88ebc144ee287b19a5766f4acda05ad", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "28061668b8e234eb85c15f1bf552bbec", "candidate_priority_rank": 37617, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df9e0b80607579e4:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df9e0b80607579e4:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df9e0b80607579e4:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df9e0b80607579e4:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "fence<->stick", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "stick", "B": "fence"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "stick<->fence", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2405047", "image_sha256": "6f886ab417ba968382b51677bbe300428721c4746c2a9a1b85188ac3cce4ba4b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405047.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405047.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2318591", "image_sha256": "f642469a6df0f7b1a3882171df4bfbc8d4a917398c1cc6c45277182b05c49550", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2318591.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2318591.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df9e0b80607579e4", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "stick", "diff_b": "fence", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "stick", "component_b": "fence"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boulders", "ear", "giraffe", "grass", "ground", "hair", "hose", "legs", "log", "neck", "rock", "rocks", "stick", "stone", "tail", "tree", "water"], "detected_components": ["stick"], "masked_program_sha256": "239ad30690062c7cab1e4ef583a5a06bdd9dc26ab5630b6ba9055103b3be38a0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["stick", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stick", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["stick", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fa6b9eb7adc853610ee28d54bfcccd88c155e0ee8cc2fdac1e3a6f2393e9baeb"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01100460", "text": "What animal is chewing the stick?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "face", "fence", "giraffe", "hair", "head", "horn", "leaves", "mouth", "neck", "nose", "pole", "skin"], "detected_components": ["fence"], "masked_program_sha256": "239ad30690062c7cab1e4ef583a5a06bdd9dc26ab5630b6ba9055103b3be38a0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "fence", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "11d14cb8ca0942932cae495151c8fa2c5f0adc0391350254d4774dce4726cb2e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16846324", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37617, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ee38da7d6daa80ecc4478a7393f6bfe2af2de40b94d58e85ac5b77f703eabb6c", "selected_component": "fence", "selected_source_question_id": "16846324", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is chewing the fence?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,chewing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is chewing the ?", "program_group_hash": "ee38da7d6daa80ecc4478a7393f6bfe2af2de40b94d58e85ac5b77f703eabb6c", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "chewing", "select_category": "stick"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,chewing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is chewing the ?", "program_group_hash": "ee38da7d6daa80ecc4478a7393f6bfe2af2de40b94d58e85ac5b77f703eabb6c", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "chewing", "select_category": "fence"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The animal is a giraffe.", "question": "What animal is chewing the stick?", "question_id": "01100460", "semantic": [{"argument": "stick (4165754)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,chewing,s (4165758)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The giraffe is chewing the fence.", "question": "What animal is chewing the fence?", "question_id": "16846324", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (1009263)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,chewing,s (1009262)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4165758"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "chewing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["tall", "tan"], "query_target_entity_id": "4165758", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "4165754", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4165758", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4165754", "selected_entity_name": "stick"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4165754"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stick", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1009262"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "chewing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1009262", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "1009263", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1009262", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1009263", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1009263"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:28061668b8e234eb85c15f1bf552bbec", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6f886ab417ba968382b51677bbe300428721c4746c2a9a1b85188ac3cce4ba4b", "image_sha256_b": "f642469a6df0f7b1a3882171df4bfbc8d4a917398c1cc6c45277182b05c49550", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d2af942ecb5ff794f0f453f019bbe0ed96fcc0197636453a7241033660f7cd2b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0b1f33072c819420563b3faf671f0bf6", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "09281f72a2e45665f8f9502ed5d1158fbf5e6eb58806088a01e41c50806921c2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7f421ec4af5b75b6e2891d5fdcd909167dd5bbc6bc7cc7473ac46441eeb5f5a7", "request_id": "64f4d55b5478c770d99a8611bfbb7786", "response_sha256": "8647068a4e220f510c2e96d5f25fae023eb1b20ff0602dff410839e904ee5bb0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1d9739e8e77fd27528fe54c793b1b515b8b70a60712979a14ef79383a16d91b0", "request_id": "48271d25ce6538496d72c996845f68ef", "response_sha256": "767bf7df8728b87d8fde72de69aaa4289dbb52207cca6704023fcaba92491394", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "ebb29734d91f0806d8ef9ff1f4db0921", "candidate_priority_rank": 37629, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba2132180ac5bdc:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba2132180ac5bdc:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba2132180ac5bdc:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba2132180ac5bdc:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->water", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "water"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->water", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2350150", "image_sha256": "019165e39f8199c5449f4f6f72b006e5468256d2af5249304d0faa7c957343df", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2350150.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2350150.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2371507", "image_sha256": "34f7382952a96b16f4040081b890e8a790220b173bf6c52bc7f8575c038544e8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371507.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371507.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba2132180ac5bdc", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "water", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "water"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bike", "bush", "dog", "feet", "field", "grass", "man", "oven door", "pants", "path", "sheep", "shirt", "shoe", "trees", "turbine"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "1102552f204312f2dbec2bbeb4c522aa8fd020a35e60a81fa50479889c004e68", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c70c2a76b684ae7f2bbbd5d85ac8d1599c1561ba318e89adc85c8e4c646573d9"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10881990", "text": "What animal is walking next to the man?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bear", "bush", "fence", "grass", "hill", "leaves", "log", "path", "plant", "rock", "trees", "water"], "detected_components": ["water"], "masked_program_sha256": "1102552f204312f2dbec2bbeb4c522aa8fd020a35e60a81fa50479889c004e68", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "water", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7bd942322e7064c94b683c6d475dfae35ad399486a316ca9b21cf250c4bfd136"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02315581", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37629, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "78880c46dcd803870a11bcdfb35d94d81930be1d1106cf3877fcb9ba86ff8eb6", "selected_component": "water", "selected_source_question_id": "02315581", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is walking next to the water?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking next to,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is walking next to the ?", "program_group_hash": "78880c46dcd803870a11bcdfb35d94d81930be1d1106cf3877fcb9ba86ff8eb6", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking next to", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking next to,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is walking next to the ?", "program_group_hash": "78880c46dcd803870a11bcdfb35d94d81930be1d1106cf3877fcb9ba86ff8eb6", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking next to", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is walking next to the man.", "question": "What animal is walking next to the man?", "question_id": "10881990", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (2987210)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking next to,s (3595008)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bear", "full_answer": "The bear is walking next to the water.", "question": "What animal is walking next to the water?", "question_id": "02315581", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (739315)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking next to,s (739312)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3243586", "3243587", "3243589", "3243590", "3275295", "3275296", "3595008"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "walking next to", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3595008", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "2987210", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3595008", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2987210", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2987210"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["739312"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bear"], "predicate": "walking next to", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "walking"], "query_target_entity_id": "739312", "query_target_entity_name": "bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "739315", "relation_subject_entity_id": "739312", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "739315", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["739315"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ebb29734d91f0806d8ef9ff1f4db0921", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "019165e39f8199c5449f4f6f72b006e5468256d2af5249304d0faa7c957343df", "image_sha256_b": "34f7382952a96b16f4040081b890e8a790220b173bf6c52bc7f8575c038544e8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d54e15101f5350bb144d50dd8b67915bf6e1ab646b4f8c79a1f1767ea4b43aee", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3f2b488280f2d978dc1422ecd364d6d7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "255ae8f744fb2b6bd8057e8ccc1b04b97737a606cc0870229ee77bd693c01784"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8a05902ce7876dce2833453ff8208e4efa4216365183ef769cbab95ae3d8a8ad", "request_id": "d805d72cf6486480318e200963ca6bbe", "response_sha256": "ac2d740c9d7e6708a7717c9cb3219bdd45b9fb398b678b3bdbf22d4f4e245a1e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cf7e2226d95bd9764e13f63c69ab8756a0e1fdc5a8d5c878542067a965d3745a", "request_id": "a9cb6afda63fa75aea6741e5dfac435b", "response_sha256": "674340ef8b09813c694d32d0b1ed99dc7f6fe2f5007bc237bc53a924ffef05f7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "30b718c30b6c708e81675941347c1292", "candidate_priority_rank": 37646, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fc6d160a2edfba68:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fc6d160a2edfba68:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fc6d160a2edfba68:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fc6d160a2edfba68:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "street<->yard", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "street", "B": "yard"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "street<->yard", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2400752", "image_sha256": "f112940c4f52c1f7dc56b211a713d18740a2f110166146d8bcdb89ed405a6f36", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400752.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400752.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2398775", "image_sha256": "708870d0b556c7c1700314f8e879da152dd98043d0690e73d09c3c979bdf7655", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398775.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398775.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fc6d160a2edfba68", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "street", "diff_b": "yard", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "street", "component_b": "yard"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "car", "cars", "clock", "pole", "sign", "sky", "street", "taxi", "window"], "detected_components": ["street"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4b65b82473a90961ecc11c0a56a11d033667b9903bc679a60e58cdb4254b191", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["street"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "street", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["street"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "220aca232cefbc0a09d99cc3395dd915be401faaa2eeed99d7fb06ce698769ed"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01763834", "text": "What vehicles are in the street?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "car", "cars", "ground", "numbers", "pole", "sand", "sign", "snow", "train", "trains", "trees", "windshield", "yard"], "detected_components": ["yard"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4b65b82473a90961ecc11c0a56a11d033667b9903bc679a60e58cdb4254b191", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["yard"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yard", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["yard"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1a6d6071b69cc04eaa22d25f2f5d5166c84b7b4ab0ad93148e47104782b5659a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16954759", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37646, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5583be64818fa26be3f10694e8954e65aabb262a7c6f3733f9ad8ec8f718c16e", "selected_component": "yard", "selected_source_question_id": "16954759", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What vehicles are in the yard?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicles are in the ?", "program_group_hash": "5583be64818fa26be3f10694e8954e65aabb262a7c6f3733f9ad8ec8f718c16e", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "street"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicles are in the ?", "program_group_hash": "5583be64818fa26be3f10694e8954e65aabb262a7c6f3733f9ad8ec8f718c16e", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "yard"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cars", "full_answer": "The vehicles are cars.", "question": "What vehicles are in the street?", "question_id": "01763834", "semantic": [{"argument": "street (405939)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s (405938)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "trains", "full_answer": "The vehicles are trains.", "question": "What vehicles are in the yard?", "question_id": "16954759", "semantic": [{"argument": "yard (422103)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s (422094)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["405938", "405942", "405944"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cars"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "405938", "query_target_entity_name": "cars", "relation_object_entity_id": "405939", "relation_subject_entity_id": "405938", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "405939", "selected_entity_name": "street"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "street", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["405939"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "yard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "street", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["422080", "422084", "422087", "422091", "422094", "422097"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trains"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "422094", "query_target_entity_name": "trains", "relation_object_entity_id": "422103", "relation_subject_entity_id": "422094", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "422103", "selected_entity_name": "yard"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "yard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["422103"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:30b718c30b6c708e81675941347c1292", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f112940c4f52c1f7dc56b211a713d18740a2f110166146d8bcdb89ed405a6f36", "image_sha256_b": "708870d0b556c7c1700314f8e879da152dd98043d0690e73d09c3c979bdf7655", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "959f414103e371ea02046cb3d3ad3d5e11dda1e6c4eed37b2c08281e2f0197af", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0a49e67e4a2d1e3a12c38662d2f11fe8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "bee59404b0ec3b97817bbc3eaea8575ab0eb66f1b1d7f1c8a6415c7ed8a72f68"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1b6b9ef3c7f913668966577e787cb601d68b6227fe0cb9aff98589a6313ef4b4", "request_id": "58b60c111bb8b2c221576fde4784e42b", "response_sha256": "f04b868d7a325fc9e4cd4401f399953dda2a531e66a734c45509b11aea1e6f0e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "448a38f4919caaaeb3a5c56060339daccf58a912116f39b74684895005f2ca09", "request_id": "67c339296a6b5bc705ba03cca88bff26", "response_sha256": "568f99ff1fa39159e27f672cceb8528f596daec1e2556b499dc031df9bf4700f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "f26e71821b547e3cfc325d853d38e455", "candidate_priority_rank": 37707, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf491065c42279d2:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf491065c42279d2:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf491065c42279d2:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf491065c42279d2:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "lady<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "lady", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "lady<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2344217", "image_sha256": "70112fc58bc796213fddf7ef273887192b5ee8a5feaabf6dab1fa2117c631aa4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2344217.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2344217.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2396042", "image_sha256": "e14ab76faedc79385346952001b2c1b98e5bf1a407ff48b13b91d28f1e64ccb1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396042.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396042.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf491065c42279d2", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "lady", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "lady", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ball", "box", "chair", "lady", "man", "net", "people", "person", "pole", "racket", "skirt", "vest", "words"], "detected_components": ["lady"], "masked_program_sha256": "980a30f67382967c57dc7b49d28835ae911c68feded11017ff727ff8cb985ac2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["lady", "vest"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "lady", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["lady", "vest"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "faca6d4a60040f7dcb7e5a8311dfde89a8550d488bf47cea68976ce4687a43b7"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05908570", "text": "What color is the vest the lady is wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bench", "boy", "car", "cloud", "hand", "hat", "jeans", "letters", "man", "mountains", "pants", "parking lot", "shirt", "shoe", "sidewalk", "skateboard", "sky", "trailer", "trash can", "vest", "water", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "980a30f67382967c57dc7b49d28835ae911c68feded11017ff727ff8cb985ac2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "vest"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "vest"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "26ba216aab9ac3c331dc99d04429e796ace0dc55cd5bab7605eddcee407ed5ef"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02254626", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37707, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "09c4488c937f1ce725b76c31e0f30272f2f6b1b013c72bdbdaf1a4eaaf73348d", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "02254626", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color is the vest the man is wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vest,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the vest the is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "09c4488c937f1ce725b76c31e0f30272f2f6b1b013c72bdbdaf1a4eaaf73348d", "queried_category": "vest", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "lady"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vest,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the vest the is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "09c4488c937f1ce725b76c31e0f30272f2f6b1b013c72bdbdaf1a4eaaf73348d", "queried_category": "vest", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "white", "full_answer": "The vest is white.", "question": "What color is the vest the lady is wearing?", "question_id": "05908570", "semantic": [{"argument": "lady (917104)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vest,wearing,o (917106)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "orange", "full_answer": "The vest is orange.", "question": "What color is the vest the man is wearing?", "question_id": "02254626", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1201091)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vest,wearing,o (1201118)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["917106"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["white"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "917106", "query_target_entity_name": "vest", "relation_object_entity_id": "917106", "relation_subject_entity_id": "917104", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "917104", "selected_entity_name": "lady"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lady", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["917104"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["917106"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["917111"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lady", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1201118"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["orange"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "1201118", "query_target_entity_name": "vest", "relation_object_entity_id": "1201118", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1201091", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1201091", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1201091"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f26e71821b547e3cfc325d853d38e455", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "70112fc58bc796213fddf7ef273887192b5ee8a5feaabf6dab1fa2117c631aa4", "image_sha256_b": "e14ab76faedc79385346952001b2c1b98e5bf1a407ff48b13b91d28f1e64ccb1", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e28ff48d0db9b7b3512ce60249bd70092242c627a4bb33cf9f20fae4669ff667", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "6a2b7ef6622d942a8909e21f964f58e3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2936f61b4dcbce9a5f095e6a38b1b9e61409efdb3a8cf73c88a647e040b4942b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3d7afaeeecfe308dea30859cb6b469d3811bf859bde5c082e39e8e8a4f7bb19b", "request_id": "c2fa2e7a24da8ff4bde99c6250c244c2", "response_sha256": "446de77a8fd51e0a5839304dba40ae9b0fad7f3119abcde874b32f11208212e7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "02a4acc7068af25a0843391f322cccea1f78c0a3f9b3fea7e8699aaacd1b16e2", "request_id": "56615792a48dbfa8e668b7b0e096ef92", "response_sha256": "919d3880c5ee7db4491ce16788406eee275f34e6b1a237714c25bba8026f30a1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "b89cd0eca85e2b04ab49bd38056dd1c7", "candidate_priority_rank": 37723, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-30e997d7fbecfa3c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-30e997d7fbecfa3c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-30e997d7fbecfa3c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-30e997d7fbecfa3c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dirt<->pepper", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dirt", "B": "pepper"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dirt<->pepper", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2406045", "image_sha256": "2b99d1d43f0ed52a77adbf4db509766611dda43802588fa752e2d895e1ab0750", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2406045.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2406045.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 674, "image_id": "285856", "image_sha256": "f26a79c5e2ed93ff00b13bc8c76de72c6b2b2b5c579e5cc9de682252bb36cbfb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/285856.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/285856.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-30e997d7fbecfa3c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dirt", "diff_b": "pepper", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dirt", "component_b": "pepper"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["broccoli", "dirt", "garlic", "leaf", "leaves", "sweet potato", "table", "vegetable"], "detected_components": ["dirt"], "masked_program_sha256": "7ac5fe75b3f491fa327ab81f59c1788d6c62853f7d9f8fc14cf9de520a0c6ee9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dirt", "vegetable"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dirt", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dirt", "vegetable"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5af52038f6014ccc47c68721e125ffde8674fed5e3a940cd3c38794963de826a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01228906", "text": "What is the vegetable that the dirt is on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bread", "cup", "dish", "egg", "food", "oil", "pepper", "sausage", "tomato"], "detected_components": ["pepper"], "masked_program_sha256": "7ac5fe75b3f491fa327ab81f59c1788d6c62853f7d9f8fc14cf9de520a0c6ee9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pepper", "vegetable"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pepper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pepper", "vegetable"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "17b5c948673134d43cabd63a1808454d51a8401f2444142cb3a77f38468f3f88"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08867506", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37723, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "37cadce6b24e3895aa2697933842af9576986ed3fe417f7baf3d0ec8b64e655d", "selected_component": "pepper", "selected_source_question_id": "08867506", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the vegetable that the pepper is on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vegetable that the is on?", "program_group_hash": "37cadce6b24e3895aa2697933842af9576986ed3fe417f7baf3d0ec8b64e655d", "queried_category": "vegetable", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "dirt"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vegetable that the is on?", "program_group_hash": "37cadce6b24e3895aa2697933842af9576986ed3fe417f7baf3d0ec8b64e655d", "queried_category": "vegetable", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pepper"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sweet potato", "full_answer": "The vegetable is a sweet potato.", "question": "What is the vegetable that the dirt is on?", "question_id": "01228906", "semantic": [{"argument": "dirt (326845)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on,o (326846)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "tomato", "full_answer": "The vegetable is a tomato.", "question": "What is the vegetable that the pepper is on?", "question_id": "08867506", "semantic": [{"argument": "pepper (4406497)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on,o (4406487)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["326846", "326854", "326858", "326867"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sweet potato"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["dirty", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "326846", "query_target_entity_name": "sweet potato", "relation_object_entity_id": "326846", "relation_subject_entity_id": "326845", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "326845", "selected_entity_name": "dirt"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["326845"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pepper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4406487"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["tomato"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["grilled"], "query_target_entity_id": "4406487", "query_target_entity_name": "tomato", "relation_object_entity_id": "4406487", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4406497", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4406497", "selected_entity_name": "pepper"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pepper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4406497"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b89cd0eca85e2b04ab49bd38056dd1c7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2b99d1d43f0ed52a77adbf4db509766611dda43802588fa752e2d895e1ab0750", "image_sha256_b": "f26a79c5e2ed93ff00b13bc8c76de72c6b2b2b5c579e5cc9de682252bb36cbfb", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "23aaf4ff1dc12edf1f2777f57c75e88e7029f2d61b29bd68331935d2023cfd99", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a46d0d83a1d6a915ab03e72e9c9b8e29", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "42dbb612ace4d9f17e93510c723ac692d05d1811fe848316e09294d09c82aa4a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0b3658b8be1b4f2c6c4703236bf3383c088c588e10c5f9de6696ec97ecbcc71a", "request_id": "48b877d66069c1e00740661d220460b9", "response_sha256": "2becc68025f76d7ccb7b16ff1c4b0359367ce06e6001a076790fac3d9bd74758", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5ef78c78c1e040f5b5bb5f8eeef731581c8feb4f155dc818fa34f5cbeafbae34", "request_id": "a31d54df30123bc2b5499435aae001f4", "response_sha256": "a5b2ea04043f33640839ae1fa1b8f79704d9799ac7efb64da89998842fdbe650", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "932c46a045b31d179137e71e783cde0b", "candidate_priority_rank": 37729, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-80e5d02ddb833267:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-80e5d02ddb833267:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-80e5d02ddb833267:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-80e5d02ddb833267:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "plate<->tray", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "plate", "B": "tray"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "plate<->tray", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2412701", "image_sha256": "b27b457e73333c59c10318ad1765b4393e0e7c53a712ce8f4cfe926e57a31e17", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412701.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412701.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2350303", "image_sha256": "22133cea8be12fd5d54709bdbe49b05b8863a949d76b627ae1b59b36d7e1bc2f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2350303.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2350303.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-80e5d02ddb833267", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "plate", "diff_b": "tray", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "plate", "component_b": "tray"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cake", "cherry", "chocolate", "floor", "hand", "ice cream", "plate", "spoon", "spots"], "detected_components": ["plate"], "masked_program_sha256": "3ca2a83dacb379871f80719ae05d1c25a3bffc8493cc5f0f8f9df12b185b73d9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "plate", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7d58fd8ea9f49c082642329286d3d49710f2b41c9d02e3fe0059294dc19b8ec8"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "075515", "text": "What is the food in the plate called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "bottle", "bread", "broccoli", "counter", "dirt", "egg", "eggplant", "eggs", "floor", "foil", "food", "head", "jar", "jars", "leaf", "leaves", "lid", "package", "plant", "tray"], "detected_components": ["tray"], "masked_program_sha256": "3ca2a83dacb379871f80719ae05d1c25a3bffc8493cc5f0f8f9df12b185b73d9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray", "food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8886925df6e1f5fb9a968e5e1097ba7d5732d900b6bed34dabbda319f7423551"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16999472", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37729, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "94fa29f2e816f16a60d85fa29d54ba325de824c6cd0c2b21d04fcfb51560b600", "selected_component": "tray", "selected_source_question_id": "16999472", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the food in the tray called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food in the called?", "program_group_hash": "94fa29f2e816f16a60d85fa29d54ba325de824c6cd0c2b21d04fcfb51560b600", "queried_category": "food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food in the called?", "program_group_hash": "94fa29f2e816f16a60d85fa29d54ba325de824c6cd0c2b21d04fcfb51560b600", "queried_category": "food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "tray"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chocolate", "full_answer": "The food is chocolate.", "question": "What is the food in the plate called?", "question_id": "075515", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (188653)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,in,s (188652)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "eggs", "full_answer": "The food is eggs.", "question": "What is the food in the tray called?", "question_id": "16999472", "semantic": [{"argument": "tray (868938)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,in,s (868923)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["188652"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chocolate"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "188652", "query_target_entity_name": "chocolate", "relation_object_entity_id": "188653", "relation_subject_entity_id": "188652", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "188653", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plate", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["188653"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plate", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["868923", "868926", "868930", "868937"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["eggs"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "868923", "query_target_entity_name": "eggs", "relation_object_entity_id": "868938", "relation_subject_entity_id": "868923", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "868938", "selected_entity_name": "tray"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["868938"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:932c46a045b31d179137e71e783cde0b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b27b457e73333c59c10318ad1765b4393e0e7c53a712ce8f4cfe926e57a31e17", "image_sha256_b": "22133cea8be12fd5d54709bdbe49b05b8863a949d76b627ae1b59b36d7e1bc2f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "caddef185ea40b8c62887ffd5b2a26ed4372f76ff1f1204a265b8dbcab853fed", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "efd237562c66de8712d4de041e7f3880", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e0e6f36adb41bfc850637846dcce0546afbcdbdc7ea5e8f2a54c51fc8a0cd9a2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c56ab7f462203aa36f7f372692d570ac62c6c550a94eab6c4fae0ae62ea31010", "request_id": "071ed589afc18586955a3423acba519e", "response_sha256": "653656d1a8b6d1851fbcc0eee9447d33b9c28ed1f596cd4f7d1c0f85c1266c72", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7dbbe165fa5d5962bcc8c5830d77e426b7a43e33fd608dda8fba1c8fdcecad6b", "request_id": "ad5c7908f22488907b340a86c4b9f9cb", "response_sha256": "516fd416b38c422727efdb5799d09fbb29131e4ae0d16cc5d78f46158103b157", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "4482c06e2c71e126e243d5e429c98359", "candidate_priority_rank": 37765, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35bb15b0e2ac7a62:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35bb15b0e2ac7a62:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35bb15b0e2ac7a62:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35bb15b0e2ac7a62:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "stove<->table", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "stove", "B": "table"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "stove<->table", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2367346", "image_sha256": "30f3410b1c38c24cf5b46b58e43a286e1af7e6a1751ac90316a45740149e96a4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367346.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367346.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2397994", "image_sha256": "9a41865ba3424237ebb5ffb23cd36f7e893363fcba739133404bbf4f7e7d0f2c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397994.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397994.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35bb15b0e2ac7a62", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "stove", "diff_b": "table", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "stove", "component_b": "table"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.3663663663663664, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.14414414414414414, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 2}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.208, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": -0.022, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.022, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["apron", "box", "bread", "counter", "egg", "eggs", "floor", "food", "hand", "kitchen", "lid", "liquid", "meat", "microwave", "outlet", "oven", "pan", "plate", "pot", "stove", "towel", "wall", "woman"], "detected_components": ["stove"], "masked_program_sha256": "21e0c06d38ce3ce78c7b6a7b5ed241f03245db0a049cca8107b1ed8404ec2d6f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["stove", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stove", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["stove", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6caa495586e9a93119fc2809709a0cb530dcbe319c173d336f7fd78dc27b5001"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04140786", "text": "What is the appliance to the right of the stove called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["apple", "bag", "box", "cabinet", "cabinets", "counter", "door", "ground", "kitchen", "light switch", "picture", "refrigerator", "room", "sign", "sink", "table", "television", "tray", "wall", "water bottles"], "detected_components": ["table"], "masked_program_sha256": "21e0c06d38ce3ce78c7b6a7b5ed241f03245db0a049cca8107b1ed8404ec2d6f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "table", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1163e2ae34ca4a4ebec24059e36b194473121008ef729e79f534fdaefc998964"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09493383", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37765, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1a8a60084f89215b58270aef079cbd46171163982f2bf12541af82bc34984708", "selected_component": "table", "selected_source_question_id": "09493383", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the appliance to the right of the table called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the appliance to the right of the called?", "program_group_hash": "1a8a60084f89215b58270aef079cbd46171163982f2bf12541af82bc34984708", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "stove"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the appliance to the right of the called?", "program_group_hash": "1a8a60084f89215b58270aef079cbd46171163982f2bf12541af82bc34984708", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "microwave", "full_answer": "The appliance is a microwave.", "question": "What is the appliance to the right of the stove called?", "question_id": "04140786", "semantic": [{"argument": "stove (2430155)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s (1987416)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "refrigerator", "full_answer": "The appliance is a refrigerator.", "question": "What is the appliance to the right of the table called?", "question_id": "09493383", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (1969401)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s (2145124)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1987416", "3051118"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["microwave"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1987416", "query_target_entity_name": "microwave", "relation_object_entity_id": "2430155", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1987416", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2430155", "selected_entity_name": "stove"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stove", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2430155"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stove", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2145124"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["refrigerator"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "2145124", "query_target_entity_name": "refrigerator", "relation_object_entity_id": "1969401", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2145124", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1969401", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1969401"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4482c06e2c71e126e243d5e429c98359", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "30f3410b1c38c24cf5b46b58e43a286e1af7e6a1751ac90316a45740149e96a4", "image_sha256_b": "9a41865ba3424237ebb5ffb23cd36f7e893363fcba739133404bbf4f7e7d0f2c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "16680f078cb7f82fb4be1cb08537a3a57c4d813f7f3935acece6ec7c49f79f2f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3236da9c47f15be582d8f49b4959e57c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c8443aafd9370262e2149c5b5014fc5befeb742efcac7bcec4c5594ae16e9b3b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3f56859800f89eec8daff2db4307c7e030969628862d011530c1ae59bc5a7460", "request_id": "8c1de43f03d82f5de7c5c2e1c30a355f", "response_sha256": "b8e8dd2b1102dc538b3083b6284180f766ee619ea02590da2d4a9ab74de9f7a4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "173a9e9a9e1b80c4e434725a4f9ea79ba05aacb601acd31d6c7ce2257b4881bb", "request_id": "5661510ad7a285164ff572344603ee98", "response_sha256": "e66bafd122af7df61d8678599f01f9038e0ff7adb5d5124054618438b483fe22", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "8e9a89238478c7a7286f90d1f372ed4c", "candidate_priority_rank": 37781, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1781b6dd8420d995:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1781b6dd8420d995:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1781b6dd8420d995:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1781b6dd8420d995:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "box<->field", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "field", "B": "box"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "field<->box", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2320386", "image_sha256": "dcf60e2c8e47cb49881b55b77088ea865e6f86be68d4006bf4d0a774ba59bb63", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2320386.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2320386.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2317877", "image_sha256": "64ca2c55e96e8a41b65381e7f2b120e61ba89cf926bab6c34427ad1ef762de0f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317877.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317877.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1781b6dd8420d995", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "field", "diff_b": "box", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "field", "component_b": "box"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "fence", "fence post", "field", "ground", "horse", "picture", "pole", "roof", "sky", "tree", "trees", "trunk"], "detected_components": ["field"], "masked_program_sha256": "5e84dfc0cd5ed52b4d1e0cd82b7797cbbe237a7245165106a20557622bd8a00d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "field", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e280b6480faef2c5e39610635d77207413a9054c8cc5050221c11d37ffff35f5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "101049116", "text": "What animal is eating from the field?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["animal", "box", "building", "door", "face", "giraffe", "head", "horn", "leg", "legs", "screen", "tail"], "detected_components": ["box"], "masked_program_sha256": "5e84dfc0cd5ed52b4d1e0cd82b7797cbbe237a7245165106a20557622bd8a00d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["box", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "box", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["box", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4e20404ad9842531655642160b291f2b96c3e539d3b5ae403d462fcc974c71fe"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09904995", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37781, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 15, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "030b88b2f6e8c897b6f30cde1263fa13a93b7a3928b60723109098a5eb968f10", "selected_component": "box", "selected_source_question_id": "09904995", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is eating from the box?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,eating from,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is eating from the ?", "program_group_hash": "030b88b2f6e8c897b6f30cde1263fa13a93b7a3928b60723109098a5eb968f10", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "eating from", "select_category": "field"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,eating from,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is eating from the ?", "program_group_hash": "030b88b2f6e8c897b6f30cde1263fa13a93b7a3928b60723109098a5eb968f10", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "eating from", "select_category": "box"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The animal is a horse.", "question": "What animal is eating from the field?", "question_id": "101049116", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (2898604)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,eating from,s (2829924)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The giraffe is eating from the box.", "question": "What animal is eating from the box?", "question_id": "09904995", "semantic": [{"argument": "box (3693864)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,eating from,s (3483114)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2705622", "2705626", "2705627", "2705629", "2829924", "2833438", "3233748"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "eating from", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2829924", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "2898604", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2829924", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2898604", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2898604"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "box", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2810760", "3161850", "3455346", "3483113", "3483114", "3483115"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "eating from", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3483114", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "3693864", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3483114", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3693864", "selected_entity_name": "box"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "box", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3693864"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:8e9a89238478c7a7286f90d1f372ed4c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "dcf60e2c8e47cb49881b55b77088ea865e6f86be68d4006bf4d0a774ba59bb63", "image_sha256_b": "64ca2c55e96e8a41b65381e7f2b120e61ba89cf926bab6c34427ad1ef762de0f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d14d10224f137febc6ad6199cd80c19e9326c795ed72547ab87301a7fbcd3eaf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "11584909ae131d9c58be58f857426dd6", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "413c92c6a82c5efb5c1ed82fc37c6279c763e66c7a48746af2189cec2f4ac7c6"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "236af12b4d19bc5bd65aca764ef2183c45031e1b6400c5a7e6f4bb1c25627808", "request_id": "5f3c7ddb12cf0291a7c40dec78265c6c", "response_sha256": "4611a51c1fde80d9fb71027abfa4513b5955f9e51a5da3b443775ec49a37207a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "613cd554af7aabb14633237722f9a7b2d02fff0b4cc8f28636b27bfd2d78885f", "request_id": "11a6feaad6429233859bf9c5a76e1ffb", "response_sha256": "6a5106b4f3cc6c5a0fefb1a7dad4ac8b8d56c3252c0c5192a8e4fc673370fa32", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "1b305ee6de6f4267aeb2410f2ce32d64", "candidate_priority_rank": 37789, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0af89afc0e58bade:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0af89afc0e58bade:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0af89afc0e58bade:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0af89afc0e58bade:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "airplane<->baby", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "baby", "B": "airplane"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "baby<->airplane", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2384085", "image_sha256": "079304fb86dde0e16cc65f170cc722e371f88a8be4dfc9ce875cac5759176472", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384085.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384085.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2374832", "image_sha256": "da7a22ddc8bfbeca276e9ddbf39e0a876fbf0bac4b80055db6a72bb33ee1673d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2374832.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2374832.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0af89afc0e58bade", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "baby", "diff_b": "airplane", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "baby", "component_b": "airplane"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["baby", "bed", "diaper", "eyes", "foot", "hair", "hand", "head", "headboard", "leg", "nose", "pillow", "toy", "truck"], "detected_components": ["baby"], "masked_program_sha256": "45d1ef0028f2e3abc88c02623ad6300fc892748aabeca2a90e1cc05347d9445e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "baby", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7181d1d1062984b1ae63415aab6a10935f04a9646ef1b50c8861fe2dc11aeacc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14665427", "text": "What vehicle is the baby holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["airplane", "cockpit", "door", "flag", "logo", "nose", "propeller", "shuttle", "sky", "tail", "windows", "wing"], "detected_components": ["airplane"], "masked_program_sha256": "45d1ef0028f2e3abc88c02623ad6300fc892748aabeca2a90e1cc05347d9445e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["airplane", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "airplane", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["airplane", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ce8f650639783286f9ae786aab2b79a34ee0aaeda2528638985224b8c3d9de8d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09577483", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37789, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e9368b5a14d2b8861a58fe5f284d6fee75c12800aed0e29b80550c7bf53abf53", "selected_component": "airplane", "selected_source_question_id": "09577483", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What vehicle is the airplane holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicle is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "e9368b5a14d2b8861a58fe5f284d6fee75c12800aed0e29b80550c7bf53abf53", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "baby"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicle is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "e9368b5a14d2b8861a58fe5f284d6fee75c12800aed0e29b80550c7bf53abf53", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "airplane"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "truck", "full_answer": "The baby is holding the truck.", "question": "What vehicle is the baby holding?", "question_id": "14665427", "semantic": [{"argument": "baby (1313555)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,holding,o (1313562)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "shuttle", "full_answer": "The plane is holding the shuttle.", "question": "What vehicle is the airplane holding?", "question_id": "09577483", "semantic": [{"argument": "airplane (585422)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,holding,o (585420)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1313562"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["truck"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1313562", "query_target_entity_name": "truck", "relation_object_entity_id": "1313562", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1313555", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1313555", "selected_entity_name": "baby"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1313555"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "airplane", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["585420"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["shuttle"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "585420", "query_target_entity_name": "shuttle", "relation_object_entity_id": "585420", "relation_subject_entity_id": "585422", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "585422", "selected_entity_name": "airplane"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "airplane", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["585422"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1b305ee6de6f4267aeb2410f2ce32d64", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "079304fb86dde0e16cc65f170cc722e371f88a8be4dfc9ce875cac5759176472", "image_sha256_b": "da7a22ddc8bfbeca276e9ddbf39e0a876fbf0bac4b80055db6a72bb33ee1673d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "12aa200f26788c0ad8fb79aa476192e510f4899c791e2b5c220092dd65ad101b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8d8a208b7c2b4bcb6e9c5503238ace41", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "43efb1cbac0dfceba3df19a3efce6b49f7dec4934d2bf28a8c948d1c2d400b33"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5c9eb3841f978fd0a169fb1431db997fdd0a8fbdb5bcee2862689ffaa3a82072", "request_id": "10325afbd52257383700a751e2276f77", "response_sha256": "da84dd35bd4b0bae3fc434fc650b2e6630f5554fd66e546f90465c2366b2e855", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9db4da87295c5021a210c4ba2a2d35a399ad96a4de8de7e12c41d28ffa5131c1", "request_id": "6351aeb15f2078872b18110712ef74d2", "response_sha256": "41fd62006c3cdbc2665a662b877d943a648533685874879bb1e68dd7a6721243", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "5b5e1ea3676ab283fcbde76de078843e", "candidate_priority_rank": 37793, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-118550d1f58ae28f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-118550d1f58ae28f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-118550d1f58ae28f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-118550d1f58ae28f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cabinet<->motorcycle", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "motorcycle", "B": "cabinet"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "motorcycle<->cabinet", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2357158", "image_sha256": "e60495efffb97f874937231a08cf1e2da649ef28cb7088628c1d960d0fae2148", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2357158.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2357158.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2412457", "image_sha256": "01bb524ce64b76d8094dc049ae1670cbb1d45917d921d626d613b2a6b10aa5a5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412457.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412457.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-118550d1f58ae28f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "motorcycle", "diff_b": "cabinet", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "motorcycle", "component_b": "cabinet"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.202, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.074, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.224, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.024, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bench", "bird", "building", "cloud", "gate", "ground", "leaves", "motorcycle", "neck", "park", "rocks", "sky", "tree", "walkway", "wall", "wheel", "wildflowers"], "detected_components": ["motorcycle"], "masked_program_sha256": "38a327df4428f51a910969942cd473a8270b955a62b78d8c0a7b9b212d2dd656", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["motorcycle", "bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "motorcycle", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["motorcycle", "bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "11bd97b72bc3919de84ad44be205025d6366642738fa859f3955a38388e9a8c3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08571835", "text": "What is the color of the bird to the right of the motorcycle?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "basket", "bathroom", "bathtub", "bird", "cabinet", "cabinet door", "clock", "counter", "curtain", "door", "floor", "frame", "kitchen", "outlet", "pan", "picture", "sink", "table", "toilet", "wall", "window", "wires"], "detected_components": ["cabinet"], "masked_program_sha256": "38a327df4428f51a910969942cd473a8270b955a62b78d8c0a7b9b212d2dd656", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cabinet", "bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cabinet", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cabinet", "bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4a56cd22c6e3791b83ce283555b49e97fd0847cd86d0fbe64ccbe0879defd59b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06757783", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37793, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3e3e326460663ea8a0bba3940087248912fdbd56e289e81718ab72a0e52592b9", "selected_component": "cabinet", "selected_source_question_id": "06757783", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the color of the bird to the right of the cabinet?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bird,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the color of the bird to the right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "3e3e326460663ea8a0bba3940087248912fdbd56e289e81718ab72a0e52592b9", "queried_category": "bird", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "motorcycle"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bird,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the color of the bird to the right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "3e3e326460663ea8a0bba3940087248912fdbd56e289e81718ab72a0e52592b9", "queried_category": "bird", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "cabinet"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "gray", "full_answer": "The bird is gray.", "question": "What is the color of the bird to the right of the motorcycle?", "question_id": "08571835", "semantic": [{"argument": "motorcycle (1743636)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bird,to the right of,s (2023339)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "black", "full_answer": "The bird is black.", "question": "What is the color of the bird to the right of the cabinet?", "question_id": "06757783", "semantic": [{"argument": "cabinet (3058673)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bird,to the right of,s (3804533)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2023339"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["gray", "grey"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "2023339", "query_target_entity_name": "bird", "relation_object_entity_id": "1743636", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2023339", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1743636", "selected_entity_name": "motorcycle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "motorcycle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1743636"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cabinet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "motorcycle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3804533"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["black"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "3804533", "query_target_entity_name": "bird", "relation_object_entity_id": "3058673", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3804533", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3058673", "selected_entity_name": "cabinet"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cabinet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3058673"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:5b5e1ea3676ab283fcbde76de078843e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e60495efffb97f874937231a08cf1e2da649ef28cb7088628c1d960d0fae2148", "image_sha256_b": "01bb524ce64b76d8094dc049ae1670cbb1d45917d921d626d613b2a6b10aa5a5", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c93dd143f5edfab3a7cb537b45e5b73e887c79e767ca32284fa79f3e00777795", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7132f2e9abce31ee1b3b4353736d616e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3fd806a8f37e49ac4261c1043769f9015f2790ec72726d8c22205691f4de0f1e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5af4551bd7f41dceacecd5034fb7dbd3ade5e17e58a0cf871eb9af63e42f53de", "request_id": "608808fdb8f4b24c1db1258625c6fce8", "response_sha256": "2d67bf00b2c805b4945ba3822dea43404ddc2c9cd60276a5908cd22e1603210d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5bed3954f6a35e5f35abfd49f1e4d998107313c7ec358ffcb66bda494014310b", "request_id": "e887b4ef7c987fcc1c6349b3731fc05e", "response_sha256": "af2007ba9e93e0fc66880046a9c601edd7be4284e00c779c2b9cdd1e3e3e0e4c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "ce214d5aecdeb21908401a0abc02b75e", "candidate_priority_rank": 37822, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c7937fb63cef604:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c7937fb63cef604:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c7937fb63cef604:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c7937fb63cef604:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "oranges<->people", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "oranges", "B": "people"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "oranges<->people", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2319393", "image_sha256": "c51e62d5e5adabb6a1c059bd65334d793e048906b3e4c568435e738e63ee1248", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2319393.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2319393.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2380908", "image_sha256": "8f915e1b588aecea839994259619a16903ed6a40144aab69e3988104bcef73e9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2380908.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2380908.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c7937fb63cef604", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "oranges", "diff_b": "people", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "oranges", "component_b": "people"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["gate", "numbers", "oranges", "pole", "trailer", "wires"], "detected_components": ["oranges"], "masked_program_sha256": "c50480a1d262d238b2062ba1b80068a91be181210aeb45a12c8de880564a4a1d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["oranges", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "oranges", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["oranges", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "55c53db9dbe62dc51025114a3e56562effe10cfd79b7fffab86d825c5ebcddb8"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12863598", "text": "What vehicle are the oranges in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "clouds", "door", "fence", "hat", "letters", "license plate", "logo", "mirrors", "people", "road", "sidewalk", "sky", "taxi", "tire", "tires", "truck", "wheels", "windows", "windshield"], "detected_components": ["people"], "masked_program_sha256": "c50480a1d262d238b2062ba1b80068a91be181210aeb45a12c8de880564a4a1d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["people", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "people", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["people", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "11f631df27c81aedc17604db03e8c45c955623b9f7d252d8db9a9f56c1d67c36"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06321113", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37822, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f8e158ec6895a1d2ed2dd76966a19b1c874d5416817334b86eba29d2db8717f4", "selected_component": "people", "selected_source_question_id": "06321113", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What vehicle are the people in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicle are the in?", "program_group_hash": "f8e158ec6895a1d2ed2dd76966a19b1c874d5416817334b86eba29d2db8717f4", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "oranges"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicle are the in?", "program_group_hash": "f8e158ec6895a1d2ed2dd76966a19b1c874d5416817334b86eba29d2db8717f4", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "people"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "trailer", "full_answer": "The oranges are in the trailer.", "question": "What vehicle are the oranges in?", "question_id": "12863598", "semantic": [{"argument": "oranges (1002362)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o (1002361)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "truck", "full_answer": "The people are in the truck.", "question": "What vehicle are the people in?", "question_id": "06321113", "semantic": [{"argument": "people (543101)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o (543100)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1002361"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trailer"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "metal"], "query_target_entity_id": "1002361", "query_target_entity_name": "trailer", "relation_object_entity_id": "1002361", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1002362", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1002362", "selected_entity_name": "oranges"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "oranges", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1002362"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "people", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "oranges", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["543100", "543113"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["truck"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["industrial", "large", "orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "543100", "query_target_entity_name": "truck", "relation_object_entity_id": "543100", "relation_subject_entity_id": "543101", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "543101", "selected_entity_name": "people"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "people", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["543101"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ce214d5aecdeb21908401a0abc02b75e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c51e62d5e5adabb6a1c059bd65334d793e048906b3e4c568435e738e63ee1248", "image_sha256_b": "8f915e1b588aecea839994259619a16903ed6a40144aab69e3988104bcef73e9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "35c18cfc26b93761f9a4907fa4dbf89a447853f874930da86fe0a87239c063b1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0440dd88bf93b35953d7b212cd08d433", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "bea3e2957edf8bee70d61a5e7e687e080fa555403fcc5e7429f1afababcc7abd"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "49ae639f07dc35bccf4f9aeeb22214db001e89ec6244416eed80a66b995d89ce", "request_id": "affaa3c167868c620f7ce8cb142f1e86", "response_sha256": "ef746a3dcd53e698ec896555cb44ca9a76dd06f9f7fc05e71b30c372c245bb75", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bf27011ac18b0727c1762e0b0ec9ff110f495e904062f28f828508b278d46ff8", "request_id": "d1b7a6bb07bf0dd95f93b068c46542bf", "response_sha256": "4173940771f3ee56e227e403ac97cc028a30370ec6f2c18a53351146b6ac5696", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "2403522a8c3f77f8f26aef1e6cfeccf4", "candidate_priority_rank": 37917, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3243d83533f87050:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3243d83533f87050:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3243d83533f87050:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3243d83533f87050:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cooking pot<->cup", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cooking pot", "B": "cup"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cooking pot<->cup", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2320757", "image_sha256": "de5b7fa7fa00a2bb6d75460a13c4f175e071aa64bfe6db090e91ad0596f4e1fb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2320757.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2320757.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2322789", "image_sha256": "4e39073c571c09174aa61e035305b9191f8140f7ee56cfa3c464c65ef4b94408", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2322789.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2322789.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3243d83533f87050", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cooking pot", "diff_b": "cup", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cooking pot", "component_b": "cup"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "bowl", "container", "cooking pot", "costume", "cup", "food", "glasses", "gravy", "hand", "hat", "jeans", "leaf", "lid", "necklace", "person", "ring", "shoe", "spoon", "table", "turkey"], "detected_components": ["cooking pot"], "masked_program_sha256": "2da8f4ab7de74e37a017edc6a04f62ea13454692d0fd7ac865e50bbb6e133538", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cooking pot", "sauce"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cooking pot", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cooking pot", "sauce"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1f75375997cdf41def3a188b1b9c5748c047192cd4a7b6b5154bf41fee889848"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14100344", "text": "What sauce is in the cooking pot?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cup", "dressing", "ham", "pineapple", "pizza", "salad"], "detected_components": ["cup"], "masked_program_sha256": "2da8f4ab7de74e37a017edc6a04f62ea13454692d0fd7ac865e50bbb6e133538", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cup", "sauce"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cup", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cup", "sauce"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "70dadbe61ce98c5c3572fa05300269981583594cedff4f147b9176d0f52111f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05865633", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37917, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 10, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9c537c96b3f3fe1240b000f681b97f5cf28015ab86fabb59a56f13b5debefc8e", "selected_component": "cup", "selected_source_question_id": "05865633", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What sauce is in the cup?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sauce,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what sauce is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "9c537c96b3f3fe1240b000f681b97f5cf28015ab86fabb59a56f13b5debefc8e", "queried_category": "sauce", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "cooking pot"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sauce,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what sauce is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "9c537c96b3f3fe1240b000f681b97f5cf28015ab86fabb59a56f13b5debefc8e", "queried_category": "sauce", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "cup"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "gravy", "full_answer": "The sauce is gravy.", "question": "What sauce is in the cooking pot?", "question_id": "14100344", "semantic": [{"argument": "cooking pot (4225763)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sauce,in,s (4225762)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dressing", "full_answer": "The sauce is a dressing.", "question": "What sauce is in the cup?", "question_id": "05865633", "semantic": [{"argument": "cup (3109528)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sauce,in,s (3109527)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4225762"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["gravy"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "4225762", "query_target_entity_name": "gravy", "relation_object_entity_id": "4225763", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4225762", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4225763", "selected_entity_name": "cooking pot"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cooking pot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4225763"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4225762"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cup", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4526305"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cooking pot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3109527"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dressing"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3109527", "query_target_entity_name": "dressing", "relation_object_entity_id": "3109528", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3109527", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3109528", "selected_entity_name": "cup"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cup", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3109528"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:2403522a8c3f77f8f26aef1e6cfeccf4", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "de5b7fa7fa00a2bb6d75460a13c4f175e071aa64bfe6db090e91ad0596f4e1fb", "image_sha256_b": "4e39073c571c09174aa61e035305b9191f8140f7ee56cfa3c464c65ef4b94408", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "66312e3420534ce161e214af65fb2499fcbf5fbf19ca30613375c95e17b50816", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5a5b3334376bb47a63c321497364d814", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4540fac86e5f5229eeb80deec957f35aa00f2fedcf8810a908770782ba74c1fb"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4f8912340805eb0c4c216b178923f1e7077a163d59375e140ff5ec930d9a1eb9", "request_id": "a0e83c15ef4d4f5bd109a0da9bd01da2", "response_sha256": "695e93a811e0cf002806b24c9f5adb8a893bb0f5d109f9f603791b29ef64c6cf", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f652ec9a624128358439893febe69562764a92d92419ac0aa1fff03fa3304cae", "request_id": "d683a99ceeea7768c1e1dc85824c293c", "response_sha256": "58aea7621bdbe7114ecf5f7962b295c9c4eb61f8436c39a56fdc1afbfd013d4d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "d7fd5f598338260a571dd8bbe6a73404", "candidate_priority_rank": 37927, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-279fb5e8ea7343d7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-279fb5e8ea7343d7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-279fb5e8ea7343d7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-279fb5e8ea7343d7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "tree<->vine", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "tree", "B": "vine"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "tree<->vine", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2414805", "image_sha256": "f2fc67bfabf0138d6562501a0ce1829bcc8db917d62625cf52c718f8b757d2fc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2414805.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2414805.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 313, "image_id": "2343088", "image_sha256": "eb9445166112e5573491357cacbb0bac1efb9270eb353c61f84ab20800c91f8b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343088.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343088.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-279fb5e8ea7343d7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "tree", "diff_b": "vine", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "tree", "component_b": "vine"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bananas", "building", "door", "flower", "leaves", "roof", "tiles", "tree", "trunk", "wall"], "detected_components": ["tree"], "masked_program_sha256": "4fd457542e82186eb0ae04b57c409543ad056bf428a715b139cf6baa353683de", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tree"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tree", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tree"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "31291cf023c3c050170b556c9cf776776d4bd1da3db25836e587e11485478c80"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1174727", "text": "What are the fruits on the tree?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["carrot", "cloud", "grape", "grapes", "grass", "leaf", "road", "sky", "stop sign", "tire", "vine"], "detected_components": ["vine"], "masked_program_sha256": "4fd457542e82186eb0ae04b57c409543ad056bf428a715b139cf6baa353683de", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["vine"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "vine", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["vine"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "88733f3c734c47408f33b7e5220af29e05fa5c9b2ad71804ef4a197885c3acfb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18185627", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37927, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8a7be861671d655488f7f7fbd62c99dcbc503be435d7713dd7ea566856662535", "selected_component": "vine", "selected_source_question_id": "18185627", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the fruits on the vine?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the fruits on the ?", "program_group_hash": "8a7be861671d655488f7f7fbd62c99dcbc503be435d7713dd7ea566856662535", "queried_category": "fruit", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "tree"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the fruits on the ?", "program_group_hash": "8a7be861671d655488f7f7fbd62c99dcbc503be435d7713dd7ea566856662535", "queried_category": "fruit", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "vine"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bananas", "full_answer": "The fruits are bananas.", "question": "What are the fruits on the tree?", "question_id": "1174727", "semantic": [{"argument": "tree (151575)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,on,s (151576)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "grapes", "full_answer": "The fruits are grapes.", "question": "What are the fruits on the vine?", "question_id": "18185627", "semantic": [{"argument": "vine (3642660)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,on,s (2917868)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["151576"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bananas"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["green", "hanging"], "query_target_entity_id": "151576", "query_target_entity_name": "bananas", "relation_object_entity_id": "151575", "relation_subject_entity_id": "151576", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "151575", "selected_entity_name": "tree"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tree", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["151575"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "vine", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tree", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2175424", "2585128", "2737583", "2917868", "3066500", "3080716", "3318144", "3318146", "3318148", "3642657", "3642659"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["grapes"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["red", "round"], "query_target_entity_id": "2917868", "query_target_entity_name": "grapes", "relation_object_entity_id": "3642660", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2917868", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3642660", "selected_entity_name": "vine"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "vine", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3642660"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:d7fd5f598338260a571dd8bbe6a73404", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f2fc67bfabf0138d6562501a0ce1829bcc8db917d62625cf52c718f8b757d2fc", "image_sha256_b": "eb9445166112e5573491357cacbb0bac1efb9270eb353c61f84ab20800c91f8b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "daefb2939a9fd5943a9dd426ddca9929c2cdc28b9587327ec90d224f55131b4f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f23bed656260fc292cfdaf2242d69eeb", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2dda1c800530ed51d6048038568491c5159da772417046bf770a1b609feb8d1f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4bd0a48e371da21ef09531b543be5e236bc0fa9891d2e85244bdbc5870c20daa", "request_id": "11cc7271f60c921d49e3b084137e0d7a", "response_sha256": "0b0213796b3cd58213240374fe9fb392f20862f08cb4f2f2c8e045de6410f2d5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e859239b91f8c6b1db08ea689b2b7a84f31d2d98e8e34a81ae879b8233a2fb8e", "request_id": "890c37eb912f1412f9359b1fc31b4438", "response_sha256": "9f34755f2c5313b5fc022ac8688546645d00765e955a678d4f27dfdbda0644aa", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "e14beb15fc46f2a08bcc5bb4a48a30c7", "candidate_priority_rank": 37937, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-32e3ee963fb55246:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-32e3ee963fb55246:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-32e3ee963fb55246:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-32e3ee963fb55246:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "stove<->toy", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "toy", "B": "stove"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "toy<->stove", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2363022", "image_sha256": "c024772553ad1c761862f442904ecb605e9d6fe56957a8a752d3121611ce821b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2363022.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2363022.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2337590", "image_sha256": "57154697bcca2feb82ea6c7100ae5fa5c96d09f76b28407722ffd697c6547cf9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2337590.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2337590.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-32e3ee963fb55246", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "toy", "diff_b": "stove", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "toy", "component_b": "stove"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.161, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.036, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.092, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": -0.006, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.006, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["brush", "candle", "container", "counter", "cup", "drawer", "faucet", "glass", "light switch", "outlet", "sink", "toaster", "toy", "tray", "wall"], "detected_components": ["toy"], "masked_program_sha256": "21e0c06d38ce3ce78c7b6a7b5ed241f03245db0a049cca8107b1ed8404ec2d6f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["toy", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "toy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["toy", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "912aa1d7773342470619259767b7f9a4627016778c26bbf09b5c562545ef1756"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "021056524", "text": "What appliance is right of the toy?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["chair", "chandelier", "door", "fire extinguisher", "microwave", "plant", "stove", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["stove"], "masked_program_sha256": "21e0c06d38ce3ce78c7b6a7b5ed241f03245db0a049cca8107b1ed8404ec2d6f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["stove", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stove", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["stove", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0177cf58bd46941367d18e4712d51c27d71be49e441352b10e6499147493a28d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11776072", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37937, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 15, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3f1ddf93e7b80917b3cb59c6da59197fa4e7c1a7818b8d8f37d8e52831d97d32", "selected_component": "stove", "selected_source_question_id": "11776072", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What appliance is right of the stove?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "3f1ddf93e7b80917b3cb59c6da59197fa4e7c1a7818b8d8f37d8e52831d97d32", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "toy"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "3f1ddf93e7b80917b3cb59c6da59197fa4e7c1a7818b8d8f37d8e52831d97d32", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "stove"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "toaster", "full_answer": "The appliance is a toaster.", "question": "What appliance is right of the toy?", "question_id": "021056524", "semantic": [{"argument": "toy (1041542)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s (1041537)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "microwave", "full_answer": "The appliance is a microwave.", "question": "What appliance is right of the stove?", "question_id": "11776072", "semantic": [{"argument": "stove (4228963)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s (4604268)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1041537"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["toaster"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1041537", "query_target_entity_name": "toaster", "relation_object_entity_id": "1041542", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1041537", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1041542", "selected_entity_name": "toy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "toy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1041542"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stove", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "toy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4604268"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["microwave"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "4604268", "query_target_entity_name": "microwave", "relation_object_entity_id": "4228963", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4604268", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4228963", "selected_entity_name": "stove"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stove", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4228963"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e14beb15fc46f2a08bcc5bb4a48a30c7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c024772553ad1c761862f442904ecb605e9d6fe56957a8a752d3121611ce821b", "image_sha256_b": "57154697bcca2feb82ea6c7100ae5fa5c96d09f76b28407722ffd697c6547cf9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "29634419a378b1f00a622b617e833b3e6356f837475e4cccf04eedd939948fb7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5326e13423a29f181e023216502876b6", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ee623e9534f6a014465365e5663ba4ae4b2b242598f11b511bd4c7b392ed1a3f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dac828a3e362657cdf68938f284b89d27155da9254dc0a5ecdbe66705b9e8cb4", "request_id": "e65043d9b050981752872d6e8b4a5c20", "response_sha256": "4132a107221c32ff05c272512d97dda9baa450261e8e3e003588038064287f04", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2c832560f293bfbb0f98d9508d5f864aec9dea5a4d25798059f4b7216d5cceb4", "request_id": "7f9d17613a1cb1c4dc602b05f9911f97", "response_sha256": "c7202b6348ec716a3fc0be72ecd37d42ba14668b89ad0f887e5eb0d636d6d17d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "3d32caf0c82a04b620ad33d520ef8612", "candidate_priority_rank": 37953, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6af399f58fa7289f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6af399f58fa7289f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6af399f58fa7289f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6af399f58fa7289f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bottle<->glass", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bottle", "B": "glass"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bottle<->glass", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2379505", "image_sha256": "e60eeea20aa4bcf8a4a5aee6cfa4590686e6003bb19fafd681d996b186934c6b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2379505.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2379505.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2388921", "image_sha256": "599bb1d69fcfc8e6823c9b5a8243050ab304c7254058f32522a869314fe424fd", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388921.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388921.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6af399f58fa7289f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bottle", "diff_b": "glass", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bottle", "component_b": "glass"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bag", "bottle", "cap", "cell phone", "chair", "coke", "cord", "couch", "ground", "laptop", "lid", "man", "pants", "rug", "sandal", "shirt", "shoe", "shoes", "stickers", "table", "wire", "woman"], "detected_components": ["bottle"], "masked_program_sha256": "4b186f4ade718aceeeb0508c7aa9f23014db87caca3c023cafef7206ce36e816", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle", "drink"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bottle", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle", "drink"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "916bcc849b32d40d092e7b1265bc49235b7f7c6ddaa53576343191db6a47599d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "15142316", "text": "What drink does the bottle contain?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "chair", "door", "face", "glass", "hand", "house", "lock", "necklace", "pizza slice", "porch", "watch", "window", "wine", "woman"], "detected_components": ["glass"], "masked_program_sha256": "4b186f4ade718aceeeb0508c7aa9f23014db87caca3c023cafef7206ce36e816", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["glass", "drink"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "glass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["glass", "drink"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "86409c9a3cd7b31c75b6fa790b3ce2304579f87537fd7c63bd89d22367a517d7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09322244", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37953, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0746a9e489fc1bf3c92789eec34a3326893264adc77e7626058d10598dfb74b5", "selected_component": "glass", "selected_source_question_id": "09322244", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What drink does the glass contain?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,contain,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what drink does the contain?", "program_group_hash": "0746a9e489fc1bf3c92789eec34a3326893264adc77e7626058d10598dfb74b5", "queried_category": "drink", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "contain", "select_category": "bottle"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,contain,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what drink does the contain?", "program_group_hash": "0746a9e489fc1bf3c92789eec34a3326893264adc77e7626058d10598dfb74b5", "queried_category": "drink", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "contain", "select_category": "glass"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "coke", "full_answer": "The bottle contains Coke.", "question": "What drink does the bottle contain?", "question_id": "15142316", "semantic": [{"argument": "bottle (1356976)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,contain,o (3834978)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "wine", "full_answer": "The glass contains wine.", "question": "What drink does the glass contain?", "question_id": "09322244", "semantic": [{"argument": "glass (669761)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,contain,o (669762)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3834978"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["coke"], "predicate": "contain", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3834978", "query_target_entity_name": "coke", "relation_object_entity_id": "3834978", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1356976", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1356976", "selected_entity_name": "bottle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1356976"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["669762"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wine"], "predicate": "contain", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "669762", "query_target_entity_name": "wine", "relation_object_entity_id": "669762", "relation_subject_entity_id": "669761", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "669761", "selected_entity_name": "glass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["669761"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:3d32caf0c82a04b620ad33d520ef8612", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e60eeea20aa4bcf8a4a5aee6cfa4590686e6003bb19fafd681d996b186934c6b", "image_sha256_b": "599bb1d69fcfc8e6823c9b5a8243050ab304c7254058f32522a869314fe424fd", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "550212c19188b6fcc1687a4c3cb53f2f800063d5030de1cd32705a62f3d9075e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "46b6ee1ca81ca5fc8fc940d7afb62c8b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "44031e5a63b4382203e4ab7def96b58d71b9be7f74a971fb74af5b14a43bc474"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3f518edb628433828382ca19e8d3532442ba10e75d522184ffc3914afa26101b", "request_id": "be46f083934a610d637e9994cab4c353", "response_sha256": "db385bc7dfcfefe514d622a6469c978cd78dbdff0fc30e055973e3c0a0aeef59", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b77cadf6354bda0921ec7779870777bf3d3f70ca760568f496b920c4539ec2b1", "request_id": "4bd97ac845465b947f09cfcef1d814d4", "response_sha256": "f48740647f75d2f101dabdd582aebe3c3fe27e7d7684a3c8537d7cb3a2c70515", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "b16f09232735025ceb1f923310a39277", "candidate_priority_rank": 38015, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d09079173b1a4666:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d09079173b1a4666:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d09079173b1a4666:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d09079173b1a4666:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "girl<->player", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "girl", "B": "player"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "girl<->player", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2345526", "image_sha256": "6f3ddb04ba420ff6580e50681e47acc3b302fb3b674762746068b1dc72afc94a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345526.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345526.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2345031", "image_sha256": "1b782717f0f62f2db93d7c2b4ed3b6571d3615ebd29a53e9c035cbd78ea6aa90", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345031.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345031.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d09079173b1a4666", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "girl", "diff_b": "player", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "girl", "component_b": "player"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arms", "backpack", "bag", "building", "foot", "girl", "hand", "jeans", "luggage", "man", "people", "platform", "scarf", "shirt", "shoes", "sidewalk", "skirt", "station", "suitcase", "wheels", "window", "woman"], "detected_components": ["girl"], "masked_program_sha256": "79de3d47fd5020261c39553f11657f5f8d84cf939b64741f0ebd33156d7be6f0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "shoes"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "girl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "shoes"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4619526f074c626ba83ff142776f67618e46ff6458a47e7ccd0f502dfd529bd5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19673289", "text": "What color are the shoes that the girl is wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["fence", "grass", "hair", "hands", "head", "logo", "net", "player", "racket", "shirt", "shoes", "shorts", "socks", "tennis ball"], "detected_components": ["player"], "masked_program_sha256": "79de3d47fd5020261c39553f11657f5f8d84cf939b64741f0ebd33156d7be6f0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["player", "shoes"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "player", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["player", "shoes"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d361414f1c223334403e1fadd5c9cedc061bfd714c4fd28ba4e1f47ebb49b951"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09530763", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38015, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "dbfb04a2c903aee736e141853509cf3e4d70f0ee03bedc7251fba51a67f54247", "selected_component": "player", "selected_source_question_id": "09530763", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color are the shoes that the player is wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "shoes,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color are the shoes that the is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "dbfb04a2c903aee736e141853509cf3e4d70f0ee03bedc7251fba51a67f54247", "queried_category": "shoes", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "girl"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "shoes,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color are the shoes that the is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "dbfb04a2c903aee736e141853509cf3e4d70f0ee03bedc7251fba51a67f54247", "queried_category": "shoes", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "player"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "black", "full_answer": "The shoes are black.", "question": "What color are the shoes that the girl is wearing?", "question_id": "19673289", "semantic": [{"argument": "girl (2220704)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "shoes,wearing,o (2066740)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "white", "full_answer": "The shoes are white.", "question": "What color are the shoes that the player is wearing?", "question_id": "09530763", "semantic": [{"argument": "player (911179)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "shoes,wearing,o (911180)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2066740", "2066741"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["black"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "2066740", "query_target_entity_name": "shoes", "relation_object_entity_id": "2066740", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2220704", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2220704", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2220704"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "player", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["911180"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["white"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "911180", "query_target_entity_name": "shoes", "relation_object_entity_id": "911180", "relation_subject_entity_id": "911179", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "911179", "selected_entity_name": "player"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "player", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["911179"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b16f09232735025ceb1f923310a39277", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6f3ddb04ba420ff6580e50681e47acc3b302fb3b674762746068b1dc72afc94a", "image_sha256_b": "1b782717f0f62f2db93d7c2b4ed3b6571d3615ebd29a53e9c035cbd78ea6aa90", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "577c0002894971a8f650d899892d0eaa1a7ca7fa5d2c5c3126895f4981ae046f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f5b88b95d3885711e0286eb4ba0dbc45", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "edc601cca9bb31678ff57d6f8b180f7314e8b2b714be7a66fcd25eccdb1e470a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3eb4f175779b93b0c9ee5d0f1dca7b0c885a3328ca734a4e5f5b85461bb273a9", "request_id": "07af2884a5fa117dcc43f80ec7189d1e", "response_sha256": "a903c54157229ead979d2affa029cf23f24f9e62f64b1be56439b348a36a0be1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d7876010ebc35d8e1593cf4a8972be0bd0bd94f8124db400986941bb5e4bd7ce", "request_id": "d914d87bf2f7f668befb1b2a5071adfc", "response_sha256": "c56b5862a0f66f18a667a37884f413de5ead2be4293d64779701b730ad2901f1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "04d85492291ea69a07c45eec08af25f6", "candidate_priority_rank": 38053, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c19eedf24f32771:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c19eedf24f32771:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c19eedf24f32771:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c19eedf24f32771:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "floor<->sidewalk", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sidewalk", "B": "floor"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sidewalk<->floor", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 396, "image_id": "2390512", "image_sha256": "6a76cbf9dbcb6dc801cf96547d3ff046d964587a1a64a796231bee342b9ebfd7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390512.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390512.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 480, "image_id": "4319", "image_sha256": "b2d301596b791526bab49e6b5eed4ee907fc18967621b2034eb7c82d56fadeae", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/4319.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/4319.jpg", "width": 640}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c19eedf24f32771", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sidewalk", "diff_b": "floor", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sidewalk", "component_b": "floor"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "car", "chain", "foot", "jacket", "neck", "piano", "shoe", "sidewalk", "sign", "street", "woman"], "detected_components": ["sidewalk"], "masked_program_sha256": "ec44cfc7b285a3048708d575c749665bcb006151337404fb6d58ff2cbfddbc0f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sidewalk", "instrument"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sidewalk", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sidewalk", "instrument"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "eddaf6787569c6bfea3f030c3a5463468fb4939f48c023e96dcf31761640a339"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03473262", "text": "What kind of instrument is on the sidewalk?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["artwork", "ceiling", "chair", "chandelier", "couch", "desk", "door", "drum", "floor", "flower", "lamp", "light fixture", "living room", "painting", "picture", "plant", "rug", "wall"], "detected_components": ["floor"], "masked_program_sha256": "ec44cfc7b285a3048708d575c749665bcb006151337404fb6d58ff2cbfddbc0f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["floor", "instrument"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "floor", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["floor", "instrument"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e8f82ba9a734e1ef29d3a1e4554ef5151bf67f0abc1bf0e095e9e237b3793768"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18622477", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38053, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "7ccc7236798c0bf9997d095aefe5f4f55111ff6d32c871f6275f301390358c32", "selected_component": "floor", "selected_source_question_id": "18622477", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of instrument is on the floor?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "instrument,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of instrument is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "7ccc7236798c0bf9997d095aefe5f4f55111ff6d32c871f6275f301390358c32", "queried_category": "instrument", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "sidewalk"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "instrument,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of instrument is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "7ccc7236798c0bf9997d095aefe5f4f55111ff6d32c871f6275f301390358c32", "queried_category": "instrument", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "floor"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "piano", "full_answer": "The instrument is a piano.", "question": "What kind of instrument is on the sidewalk?", "question_id": "03473262", "semantic": [{"argument": "sidewalk (1249593)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "instrument,on,s (1249594)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "drum", "full_answer": "The instrument is a drum.", "question": "What kind of instrument is on the floor?", "question_id": "18622477", "semantic": [{"argument": "floor (4369045)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "instrument,on,s (4369070)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1249594"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["piano"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "huge", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "1249594", "query_target_entity_name": "piano", "relation_object_entity_id": "1249593", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1249594", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1249593", "selected_entity_name": "sidewalk"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sidewalk", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1249593"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "floor", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sidewalk", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4369069", "4369070"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["drum"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["small"], "query_target_entity_id": "4369070", "query_target_entity_name": "drum", "relation_object_entity_id": "4369045", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4369070", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4369045", "selected_entity_name": "floor"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "floor", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4369045"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:04d85492291ea69a07c45eec08af25f6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6a76cbf9dbcb6dc801cf96547d3ff046d964587a1a64a796231bee342b9ebfd7", "image_sha256_b": "b2d301596b791526bab49e6b5eed4ee907fc18967621b2034eb7c82d56fadeae", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b8b04b66c0e549dcc6428e927e8c111ba6089c93ebfaf95f8079cc960aaec489", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7672bbbeba88c538b40a36bbad3619a7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "130434fb0161655a019d0fca318a2fdc25419102c4a12e597cc0e23c7d90e856"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9480dfdfc91a74fb3c8a30b3249734b67cbf63a7e65d3443d1d8129b552fc637", "request_id": "37f0e9022b7163ee463680c75e4b0969", "response_sha256": "40320d68086e27bf51d5cda8ec4371fa336a5db2da861b780adb727ad6b7a9f2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "76401be02493d325aed315ff73011417ee1d1289b6cf3e47ba4265236c390b14", "request_id": "613898c90d84f9b1b3f1db0505d6c56d", "response_sha256": "e00850e8b4076a8e54509363ae5c7114bb97649fdfa6877d07745824c7b71779", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "cb739c6eedf768381bc749f5fa599010", "candidate_priority_rank": 38073, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6ee7c8b34b8954a6:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6ee7c8b34b8954a6:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6ee7c8b34b8954a6:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6ee7c8b34b8954a6:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "basket<->boy", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "basket", "B": "boy"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "basket<->boy", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2333459", "image_sha256": "4eb5f25f1a836766a5cac1b7313797e0d0d6f7ac8246cfa0ed7036f669fb85df", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2333459.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2333459.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 331, "image_id": "2347323", "image_sha256": "e7d7f207e0e1315b5f4c2718c3f4517679f27b2cfb8a587528c742ee299abd22", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2347323.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2347323.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6ee7c8b34b8954a6", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "basket", "diff_b": "boy", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "basket", "component_b": "boy"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "bench", "bottle", "bun", "cash register", "countertop", "food", "fries", "girl", "hot dog", "pot", "rug", "scarf", "tree", "wall"], "detected_components": ["basket"], "masked_program_sha256": "68f941ffbf971e587047423945131dda2165acb8edcd677a8d8cf3ddd95a77be", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "basket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "91c4b51778bd899b6fedec8d5bc96b8871a33b34299095cbab5d3ee6f7af3b78"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06220228", "text": "What kind of fast food is the basket holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["balloon", "balloons", "bottles", "boy", "cup", "cups", "girl", "man", "men", "napkin", "pizza", "plate", "plates", "poster", "shirt", "table"], "detected_components": ["boy"], "masked_program_sha256": "68f941ffbf971e587047423945131dda2165acb8edcd677a8d8cf3ddd95a77be", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "boy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7ce58446bc62d3c3c9ad7c9611c1f5fa1239e675c49b9ac5338b6caf519631f6"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02860106", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38073, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "46d4aa501c7f58b614aa7bf54d97c1e65ac5b759c8a2d073258eb9aedec35e4e", "selected_component": "boy", "selected_source_question_id": "02860106", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of fast food is the boy holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "46d4aa501c7f58b614aa7bf54d97c1e65ac5b759c8a2d073258eb9aedec35e4e", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "basket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "46d4aa501c7f58b614aa7bf54d97c1e65ac5b759c8a2d073258eb9aedec35e4e", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "boy"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "hot dog", "full_answer": "The basket is holding the hot dog.", "question": "What kind of fast food is the basket holding?", "question_id": "06220228", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (3043634)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,holding,o (2905479)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The boy is holding the pizza.", "question": "What kind of fast food is the boy holding?", "question_id": "02860106", "semantic": [{"argument": "boy (891842)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,holding,o (891849)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2905479", "3016822", "3016823", "3016824", "3016825", "3016826"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hot dog"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2905479", "query_target_entity_name": "hot dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "2905479", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3043634", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3043634", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3043634"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["891849", "891854"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "891849", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "891849", "relation_subject_entity_id": "891842", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "891842", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["891842"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:cb739c6eedf768381bc749f5fa599010", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4eb5f25f1a836766a5cac1b7313797e0d0d6f7ac8246cfa0ed7036f669fb85df", "image_sha256_b": "e7d7f207e0e1315b5f4c2718c3f4517679f27b2cfb8a587528c742ee299abd22", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "658d898f3d0f5a86836f7decaf9c8a7420620beb997fad1bcdf5cad26627f496", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e10569a69e845e6aef87f29b304ec364", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7d4f6ed75d8e86211b38c2fb217d8cd01ac38ca26d416cf78b4a5be51fa10c42"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "45d6469b8b50ed4960382c1c014209ee2093e1dc71353d2c73294cffbf021166", "request_id": "845eb649af50535b9f6d435a86c2b003", "response_sha256": "1e264de8f108e64a1c5f7ed7638769cfe0df3d017c3746887fe10b8a2ef9fd17", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "89598b7671a8f78874a305c1de71543ce984e6d27051885316e93de9d1dcd04e", "request_id": "7b5ef04336d16e68e5100283014bfdcf", "response_sha256": "72adc5cca46f03c7782341c39f47eeef67f291ea7e674b19ac70988920ecebdf", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "a0ec9dfa2a9154e9be9223077216443d", "candidate_priority_rank": 38085, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-10c6995e3cfefa14:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-10c6995e3cfefa14:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-10c6995e3cfefa14:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-10c6995e3cfefa14:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "figurines<->spices", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "spices", "B": "figurines"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "spices<->figurines", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2378641", "image_sha256": "2c428cacd304980946a8b4f308f17879ddefe5e7f4af70b5e7d809b74009a5a5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2378641.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2378641.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 357, "image_id": "2396810", "image_sha256": "83a7c332d7dd3fb7c4088df6414410efc49832044ecdb5ebf6f582a75fd8033c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396810.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396810.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-10c6995e3cfefa14", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "spices", "diff_b": "figurines", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "spices", "component_b": "figurines"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["avocado", "bread", "computer monitor", "computer mouse", "food", "keyboard", "knife", "paper", "pepper", "plate", "spices", "table"], "detected_components": ["spices"], "masked_program_sha256": "7ac5fe75b3f491fa327ab81f59c1788d6c62853f7d9f8fc14cf9de520a0c6ee9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["spices", "vegetable"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "spices", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["spices", "vegetable"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dc7701ee1a3a5501f862bbb6718bc1c3987351ab3780f9c886aa6f20f2cf7e52"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14813191", "text": "What is the vegetable that the spices are on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "cauliflower", "figurines", "hand", "hat", "head", "headband", "jacket", "outfit", "pants", "shirt", "ski", "sky", "socks", "sweater"], "detected_components": ["figurines"], "masked_program_sha256": "7ac5fe75b3f491fa327ab81f59c1788d6c62853f7d9f8fc14cf9de520a0c6ee9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["figurines", "vegetable"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "figurines", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["figurines", "vegetable"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0baa9c500e9ca86756bd1648b4bf7b729eb4b6638767523906a8e7ee7b109308"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16466465", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38085, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c9246e81bca39a6fe66f84930113d917c1f3cd2fb0af03c9528dbaa8e6019938", "selected_component": "figurines", "selected_source_question_id": "16466465", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the vegetable that the figurines are on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vegetable that the are on?", "program_group_hash": "c9246e81bca39a6fe66f84930113d917c1f3cd2fb0af03c9528dbaa8e6019938", "queried_category": "vegetable", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "spices"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vegetable that the are on?", "program_group_hash": "c9246e81bca39a6fe66f84930113d917c1f3cd2fb0af03c9528dbaa8e6019938", "queried_category": "vegetable", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "figurines"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "avocado", "full_answer": "The vegetable is an avocado.", "question": "What is the vegetable that the spices are on?", "question_id": "14813191", "semantic": [{"argument": "spices (2637613)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on,o (2546817)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cauliflower", "full_answer": "The vegetable is cauliflower.", "question": "What is the vegetable that the figurines are on?", "question_id": "16466465", "semantic": [{"argument": "figurines (1194887)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on,o (1194892)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2377726", "2546817"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["avocado"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2546817", "query_target_entity_name": "avocado", "relation_object_entity_id": "2546817", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2637613", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2637613", "selected_entity_name": "spices"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "spices", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2637613"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "figurines", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "spices", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1194892"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cauliflower"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["fake", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1194892", "query_target_entity_name": "cauliflower", "relation_object_entity_id": "1194892", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1194887", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1194887", "selected_entity_name": "figurines"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "figurines", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1194887"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a0ec9dfa2a9154e9be9223077216443d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2c428cacd304980946a8b4f308f17879ddefe5e7f4af70b5e7d809b74009a5a5", "image_sha256_b": "83a7c332d7dd3fb7c4088df6414410efc49832044ecdb5ebf6f582a75fd8033c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "95f193b60a801091593d18894edf5b15f493e285bb06c318aed9af962ad3f0c5", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "cfb5c8279b04dc1c1d93a779b4332a79", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4042a7950255b0b8cb13dc6e5f921b74110f812333f6a5674b1b4dc6ae8cc48f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "794c5762ec45a4f5cee5e4903cce6dc9a7e75ceb27ad1e7cfe45995a635f68e7", "request_id": "dbef26c83784dfb23847fbb09846753d", "response_sha256": "528050d6671efb5a1e7d588b860ad0cd3bddffe081c930e35f70920241e7c749", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f12ef3bcf595a9f05130425dd368cac744eb09bc8233f312219cd194f2d6f0cf", "request_id": "86438ad4ebb6f3e4d3b1558f18169531", "response_sha256": "e5f98609ecbb5a5a5df8619d08f5a2e1d6e514a1c60d5ebee6cea3a76b0ac881", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "967889fd7d905f7b9bbd72e9e254d990", "candidate_priority_rank": 38100, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a458a5c0863cfb5:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a458a5c0863cfb5:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a458a5c0863cfb5:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a458a5c0863cfb5:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "counter<->wall", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "counter", "B": "wall"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "counter<->wall", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2390031", "image_sha256": "639434c0d9e7e3f2599f7273b2daa2165473e2da4b7b4d7b333095961b64ecee", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390031.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390031.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2401271", "image_sha256": "702c8e331093d9d391420d2cd60dfe167b176aec182f3b743dcd9aee7fe75ab3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401271.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401271.jpg", "width": 488}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a458a5c0863cfb5", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "counter", "diff_b": "wall", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "counter", "component_b": "wall"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "blender", "counter", "finger", "hand", "jeans", "olives", "person", "ring", "shirt", "thumb", "wall"], "detected_components": ["counter"], "masked_program_sha256": "165511abab08c9ceb65413b65b1dbf2dfc0d61be70b3ddebea3ab2dc80c164c3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["counter", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "counter", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["counter", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b3cb069dfe8f453b988381ed66c849691ed438934581f0d698b0481db25bf5d5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11973283", "text": "What is the appliance that is on the counter?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["chair", "dog", "eye", "floor", "frame", "head", "nose", "paw", "radiator", "tail", "tongue", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["wall"], "masked_program_sha256": "165511abab08c9ceb65413b65b1dbf2dfc0d61be70b3ddebea3ab2dc80c164c3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wall", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "edb088910382c07ee83ef9fd44dee63b89cfc401b19bb474675ca55d46b74658"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06315370", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38100, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b276d3247c1930cb9969a4ab3bc0428654b4b6f2af50286315360932b15ec742", "selected_component": "wall", "selected_source_question_id": "06315370", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the appliance that is on the wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the appliance that is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "b276d3247c1930cb9969a4ab3bc0428654b4b6f2af50286315360932b15ec742", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "counter"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the appliance that is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "b276d3247c1930cb9969a4ab3bc0428654b4b6f2af50286315360932b15ec742", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "blender", "full_answer": "The appliance is a blender.", "question": "What is the appliance that is on the counter?", "question_id": "11973283", "semantic": [{"argument": "counter (500858)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,s (500854)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "radiator", "full_answer": "The appliance is a radiator.", "question": "What is the appliance that is on the wall?", "question_id": "06315370", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1149439)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,s (1149427)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["500854"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blender"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["clear", "electric", "glass", "open"], "query_target_entity_id": "500854", "query_target_entity_name": "blender", "relation_object_entity_id": "500858", "relation_subject_entity_id": "500854", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "500858", "selected_entity_name": "counter"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "counter", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["500858"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["500854"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["500860"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "counter", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1149427"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["radiator"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1149427", "query_target_entity_name": "radiator", "relation_object_entity_id": "1149439", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1149427", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1149439", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1149439"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:967889fd7d905f7b9bbd72e9e254d990", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "639434c0d9e7e3f2599f7273b2daa2165473e2da4b7b4d7b333095961b64ecee", "image_sha256_b": "702c8e331093d9d391420d2cd60dfe167b176aec182f3b743dcd9aee7fe75ab3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "07c7c61ead831bc5ec5c48ec1d6e71fa70cfc1e569600d6a428820cde8491ad7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ee736c6d951b8ed33665f4d5fa8565bb", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "372d90ea0f4f3af647117d7aa88fed3dd2f74888a7470e5ff390407adbf6686a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "52687f4711786afa74cd522a53350e4f40a0a9798478527399e9980f19ab4d22", "request_id": "7f78079a6e76a8ce3019022c48d194be", "response_sha256": "77206bb4d4d11ec08ffd3d519fcc776c4fc2c052abf6096b567e678d44f12df2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4588a93464622fefb3018cad8f90090c47e734fb7716ae88cfa43ec6922d76e1", "request_id": "72e189387ac74bcebc986b6d1d806809", "response_sha256": "9e6d6fcb18f75ace0b22163b0e430a26b262bc5adbc039218224b11c1f962ae0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "770c63d651fac4a3752f46501f99a9b1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38170, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-79bf6558f0d0afb3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-79bf6558f0d0afb3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-79bf6558f0d0afb3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-79bf6558f0d0afb3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dirt<->ocean", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "ocean", "B": "dirt"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "ocean<->dirt", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2411305", "image_sha256": "c95aeca29fa3121317fd9063d41c6f303998dd73ff5a53904efd4ee7f45143b1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2411305.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2411305.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2407373", "image_sha256": "336c07d28b4d07526d41ddc145dad76b8850bfdefc192ff8811935f617d6a8b2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407373.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407373.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-79bf6558f0d0afb3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "ocean", "diff_b": "dirt", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "ocean", "component_b": "dirt"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beach", "bird", "birds", "boat", "cloud", "legs", "ocean", "seagull", "seagulls", "sky", "tail", "wing"], "detected_components": ["ocean"], "masked_program_sha256": "4f5a650cdcc6e0a060d4db888a2ccc0442a0c818aa6835cda98887c47b6bcda7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ocean"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ocean", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ocean"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "95eee608a6d528bd22c0307bdb07e9fcf49f2220e94ac8ad31011f743778d1c5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19269725", "text": "What is the name of the animals above the ocean?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boots", "bushes", "coat", "dirt", "ear", "elephant", "elephants", "feet", "hat", "man", "mountains", "outfit", "pants", "rock", "sky", "sweater", "tail", "trees"], "detected_components": ["dirt"], "masked_program_sha256": "4f5a650cdcc6e0a060d4db888a2ccc0442a0c818aa6835cda98887c47b6bcda7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dirt"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dirt", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dirt"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d50ebf6a8b083da0cd5abdf5ca00fb5d61a1a82adad9c48683efa2c4cbd66aa8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08346292", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38170, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "01db3908c7fa968431978b068c3d097f5036c0c7762b6de28844e42784d429a1", "selected_component": "dirt", "selected_source_question_id": "08346292", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the name of the animals above the dirt?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the name of the animals above the ?", "program_group_hash": "01db3908c7fa968431978b068c3d097f5036c0c7762b6de28844e42784d429a1", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "ocean"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the name of the animals above the ?", "program_group_hash": "01db3908c7fa968431978b068c3d097f5036c0c7762b6de28844e42784d429a1", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "dirt"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "birds", "full_answer": "The animals are birds.", "question": "What is the name of the animals above the ocean?", "question_id": "19269725", "semantic": [{"argument": "ocean (313696)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,above,s (313691)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephants", "full_answer": "The animals are elephants.", "question": "What is the name of the animals above the dirt?", "question_id": "08346292", "semantic": [{"argument": "dirt (280697)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,above,s (280694)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["313689", "313691", "313697", "313699", "313705", "313708", "313710", "313714", "313717"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["birds"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["flying"], "query_target_entity_id": "313691", "query_target_entity_name": "birds", "relation_object_entity_id": "313696", "relation_subject_entity_id": "313691", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "313696", "selected_entity_name": "ocean"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ocean", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["313696"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ocean", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["280694", "280712"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "tiny"], "query_target_entity_id": "280694", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "280697", "relation_subject_entity_id": "280694", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "280697", "selected_entity_name": "dirt"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["280697"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:770c63d651fac4a3752f46501f99a9b1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c95aeca29fa3121317fd9063d41c6f303998dd73ff5a53904efd4ee7f45143b1", "image_sha256_b": "336c07d28b4d07526d41ddc145dad76b8850bfdefc192ff8811935f617d6a8b2", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0a7684d7dfbcd3cb6d299d553e43e30ac4da0105c7bf25918e17f08390da76b1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f2b5f0c41cb7c05459e1aa359bf05d89", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "254d5818cc212dffcea61dfdcb2f56d0ec77f315c455ae1649af5b73127049a6"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "19a3a91d4ceefad941dee84d7778cc47ab62314e859887cbc63d3a1f32abea29", "request_id": "5785c865d3d9a0f0152fe837669d5701", "response_sha256": "479f9effca41ab759d06bc2d9f655727e974b3d7769658852a70c7272eaf68c8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b4db133ab64fdec6d8456e0106e50c217a128c46384cbc510ac9603b545cdc13", "request_id": "e3dae4f43539aa00a7117d15b7f22515", "response_sha256": "e03f5262edd224f8c300d016dbf1282f86562add2b5ac111bba9700dceccd170", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "6b31249d1551ab18c04ea2261124677a", "candidate_priority_rank": 38197, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-02aa8b9c8396dbee:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-02aa8b9c8396dbee:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-02aa8b9c8396dbee:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-02aa8b9c8396dbee:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "books<->papers", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "books", "B": "papers"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "books<->papers", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2352710", "image_sha256": "10b181930763fb863cefdafc57751dd5abfea508f5b69707ec918f806bc7356e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2352710.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2352710.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2325711", "image_sha256": "86cf24f512ee61a143f0c6ce97a0400504b9d4a751a0896f46458bfad1875d90", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2325711.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2325711.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-02aa8b9c8396dbee", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "books", "diff_b": "papers", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "books", "component_b": "papers"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["books", "chocolate", "donut", "hand", "mug", "plate", "shelf", "table", "windows"], "detected_components": ["books"], "masked_program_sha256": "0daf575b077a08727295a94c5d75a33ba86f0da0a2ce4e29070c39f428672504", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["books", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "books", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["books", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3abebcdb73fa904f53cbe08b863671ad5e1d31d8545e1dc88513d5b82a4efb2a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18361986", "text": "What kind of furniture are the books sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["desk", "keyboard", "laptop", "letters", "logo", "mouse pad", "papers", "table"], "detected_components": ["papers"], "masked_program_sha256": "0daf575b077a08727295a94c5d75a33ba86f0da0a2ce4e29070c39f428672504", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["papers", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "papers", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["papers", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e20729d3065ed26d0bf52c865d8f1e21b55c928704e9f3e0070709c542bfa1b0"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01148867", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38197, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "47861cf000ad8bc1117a37626f89e6640c04ec10f2dc3f2db3e7d8ee7bb3d2ae", "selected_component": "papers", "selected_source_question_id": "01148867", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of furniture are the papers sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture are the sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "47861cf000ad8bc1117a37626f89e6640c04ec10f2dc3f2db3e7d8ee7bb3d2ae", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "books"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture are the sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "47861cf000ad8bc1117a37626f89e6640c04ec10f2dc3f2db3e7d8ee7bb3d2ae", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "papers"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "shelf", "full_answer": "The books are sitting on the shelf.", "question": "What kind of furniture are the books sitting on?", "question_id": "18361986", "semantic": [{"argument": "books (852277)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (852276)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "desk", "full_answer": "The papers are sitting on the desk.", "question": "What kind of furniture are the papers sitting on?", "question_id": "01148867", "semantic": [{"argument": "papers (3998586)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (3998584)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["852275", "852276"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["shelf"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "852276", "query_target_entity_name": "shelf", "relation_object_entity_id": "852276", "relation_subject_entity_id": "852277", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "852277", "selected_entity_name": "books"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "books", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["852277"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "papers", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "books", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3998574", "3998584", "3998585", "3998603"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["desk"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3998584", "query_target_entity_name": "desk", "relation_object_entity_id": "3998584", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3998586", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3998586", "selected_entity_name": "papers"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "papers", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3998586"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:6b31249d1551ab18c04ea2261124677a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "10b181930763fb863cefdafc57751dd5abfea508f5b69707ec918f806bc7356e", "image_sha256_b": "86cf24f512ee61a143f0c6ce97a0400504b9d4a751a0896f46458bfad1875d90", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3b92d16fd781087b7bbea2f47dce574dd7148c7c3398155002b98ac0d309dd54", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e294e5b2898407c7398a1092f4ab67eb", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "81a3d9393677cfb5e676577cdaf37175ea9f4dba7b549418a875e9a918ca434b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2ff8e986a169625c5407998ace72e3abb880e92cc872c76de769805fa73de18b", "request_id": "5a4e5ab64da72b99795757e2787d9450", "response_sha256": "60e0412f308503112dcdebbfddae8d465cfa1125f92ea759cccd78f07b5c8835", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b1bd1a3fb445e214da6dad1696d82a00e4127a2c2905a52103e708e428f80856", "request_id": "b9dcfebef9dc6d702cb55d072d2e178c", "response_sha256": "a9b0a13b81a79d66daa629d6acb087733066644ed93becb8a4539d86d0149721", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "fe1c58a48f7ac4a428cf939089ef9837", "candidate_priority_rank": 38200, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7b07e73ae6372463:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7b07e73ae6372463:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7b07e73ae6372463:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7b07e73ae6372463:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "boy<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "boy"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->boy", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2376307", "image_sha256": "7bce162cd85e2d6b0693fd2fc44e65393b5d3dc68f29368b124ec81aed607ef2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376307.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376307.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2413335", "image_sha256": "135cf249ab272500f3f7fd69c2d7cc479cb7d26456d06b1cc7ba8c114b9d96a2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2413335.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2413335.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7b07e73ae6372463", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "boy", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "boy"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boot", "cap", "coat", "glasses", "glove", "hat", "jacket", "man", "pants", "person", "pole", "ski", "snow", "tag", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "c35d3d2436e5b4ec0650d28829c517ec69d8992214ef84a75a15ca57c7416329", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "hat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "hat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "60c68e7f038c968553dac6a3a03429b9fcbc241fb7f96970c61183a79bf0abea"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10125376", "text": "What color do you think the hat the woman is wearing is?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "ball", "boy", "fence", "grass", "ground", "hat", "net", "pole", "racket", "road", "shirt", "shoe", "shorts", "sneakers", "tattoos"], "detected_components": ["boy"], "masked_program_sha256": "c35d3d2436e5b4ec0650d28829c517ec69d8992214ef84a75a15ca57c7416329", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "hat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "boy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "hat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "be84c12d83f554fc3f0b059fc27c121b07b5dec1801834ebeed9ea2cec744f84"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04231137", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38200, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "10907079e786a98622ccb023c15ffb11268df5c76e74f56135f0de961ce4ddec", "selected_component": "boy", "selected_source_question_id": "04231137", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color do you think the hat the boy is wearing is?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "hat,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color do you think the hat the is wearing is?", "program_group_hash": "10907079e786a98622ccb023c15ffb11268df5c76e74f56135f0de961ce4ddec", "queried_category": "hat", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "hat,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color do you think the hat the is wearing is?", "program_group_hash": "10907079e786a98622ccb023c15ffb11268df5c76e74f56135f0de961ce4ddec", "queried_category": "hat", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "boy"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "green", "full_answer": "The hat is green.", "question": "What color do you think the hat the woman is wearing is?", "question_id": "10125376", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (720381)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "hat,wearing,o (720361)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "blue", "full_answer": "The hat is blue.", "question": "What color do you think the hat the boy is wearing is?", "question_id": "04231137", "semantic": [{"argument": "boy (3800780)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "hat,wearing,o (3091428)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["720361", "720363"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["green"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "720361", "query_target_entity_name": "hat", "relation_object_entity_id": "720361", "relation_subject_entity_id": "720381", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "720381", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["720381"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3091428"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blue"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "3091428", "query_target_entity_name": "hat", "relation_object_entity_id": "3091428", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3800780", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3800780", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3800780"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:fe1c58a48f7ac4a428cf939089ef9837", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7bce162cd85e2d6b0693fd2fc44e65393b5d3dc68f29368b124ec81aed607ef2", "image_sha256_b": "135cf249ab272500f3f7fd69c2d7cc479cb7d26456d06b1cc7ba8c114b9d96a2", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5af7b0938a3e7e6f7572ab2573c9141e5ca9ce72fcbe91194b3d8a324690ce73", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2d1bf9c43a3c2c621468f9f97e512f08", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "254282a56d49900206edfa2fb265a03db24900fcec3189be3eee24785dcb4d24"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "108a212b480152442fbcab73d99d5fd349481dc663e8f48ebd868b8647883ea3", "request_id": "f532da24ddfecb403dc0835c6b8f01a1", "response_sha256": "2f402a08a8b3a2d02b50abe79d83250436cd1ae48edf3cc9c4635b3652b7a214", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2bf72a13889f01a1fe10188d49fe72de950ca47c1b1e9815ff89b14a55df149d", "request_id": "70189329001a6d79cf587542a596cbb7", "response_sha256": "f439118c7432fb51cf6ff03b6cf5f0a1e364df7d084595291fa251ec45c0042a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "d0a915389439fe8eb9e2b866712d4eea", "candidate_priority_rank": 38317, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f7c9a71636bb199:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f7c9a71636bb199:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f7c9a71636bb199:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f7c9a71636bb199:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "airplane<->door", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "airplane", "B": "door"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "airplane<->door", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2343179", "image_sha256": "f0612daf9e23cb833339b6cc90e29b82f6cf8559cd3e376f3385f7b7a04d5748", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343179.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343179.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2386724", "image_sha256": "3dd803251077a0db1e5084371d6a179cc85b67ccd60965e2e4e179d20b3e5d77", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386724.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386724.jpg", "width": 342}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f7c9a71636bb199", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "airplane", "diff_b": "door", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "airplane", "component_b": "door"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["airplane", "building", "buildings", "clouds", "cockpit", "cone", "doors", "grass", "hat", "mat", "mountains", "nose", "person", "sky", "tire", "truck", "window", "windows", "wing"], "detected_components": ["airplane"], "masked_program_sha256": "2d09bd65679e1bb77d349b0dcba7a0ba602593a60562aa897b2ec76f2d8a90af", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["airplane", "mat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "airplane", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["airplane", "mat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1cbf993ad9dc2d05ada7fd30701f3c109d7b5227a1ba581388f56be30da20df7"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00571763", "text": "What color is the mat near the airplane?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bicycle", "box", "car", "clock", "door", "floor", "mat", "shelf", "skateboard", "tire", "truck", "wall", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["door"], "masked_program_sha256": "2d09bd65679e1bb77d349b0dcba7a0ba602593a60562aa897b2ec76f2d8a90af", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["door", "mat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "door", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["door", "mat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5f74d8ca4dc4b7bb9eb0cffb6bfcca0b52be0a183dbd70a886c90486062f35aa"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05265189", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38317, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "241ca50167e751e1ee04914fb4fe939bef4165cc8797ef9ab8efa16d2ac3ee3e", "selected_component": "door", "selected_source_question_id": "05265189", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color is the mat near the door?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "mat,near,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the mat near the ?", "program_group_hash": "241ca50167e751e1ee04914fb4fe939bef4165cc8797ef9ab8efa16d2ac3ee3e", "queried_category": "mat", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "near", "select_category": "airplane"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "mat,near,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the mat near the ?", "program_group_hash": "241ca50167e751e1ee04914fb4fe939bef4165cc8797ef9ab8efa16d2ac3ee3e", "queried_category": "mat", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "near", "select_category": "door"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "red", "full_answer": "The mat is red.", "question": "What color is the mat near the airplane?", "question_id": "00571763", "semantic": [{"argument": "airplane (926525)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "mat,near,s (926536)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "purple", "full_answer": "The mat is purple.", "question": "What color is the mat near the door?", "question_id": "05265189", "semantic": [{"argument": "door (1283140)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "mat,near,s (1283132)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["926536"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["red"], "predicate": "near", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "926536", "query_target_entity_name": "mat", "relation_object_entity_id": "926525", "relation_subject_entity_id": "926536", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "926525", "selected_entity_name": "airplane"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "airplane", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["926525"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "door", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "airplane", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1283132"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["purple"], "predicate": "near", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["purple"], "query_target_entity_id": "1283132", "query_target_entity_name": "mat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1283140", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1283132", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1283140", "selected_entity_name": "door"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "door", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1283140"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:d0a915389439fe8eb9e2b866712d4eea", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f0612daf9e23cb833339b6cc90e29b82f6cf8559cd3e376f3385f7b7a04d5748", "image_sha256_b": "3dd803251077a0db1e5084371d6a179cc85b67ccd60965e2e4e179d20b3e5d77", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c22624f4b01889ff96ca46ff29559506b24a0245818a41e44c568d0c49cd6cae", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "fce6d7ef2206741db22c37c611712aae", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "08fe2b1e47979bfdf000ac39150e242d9fd1283fce5999c7e188dbf5b9a6d3b0"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "15aa125cb6fd84635cc8c688d214ec97e66a8f46e5863b79a781dc1e96fdc3bb", "request_id": "e7568e45886abb0f2adfc3caecccdd8d", "response_sha256": "e92d4fd65ae3e147d61ac2bafa2d919038968c92c9a64e3f7b3a209c12b474de", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ee2d67d79aaa297712fb621b48c9e92935abff4157f4c4bd731595b4d5cc22fe", "request_id": "ec5ee8bb9cff469c165121436b4afb1a", "response_sha256": "ae5ba3e9cd2689b7337ae805d5b0a632607217a1d6b98f9b05e03e08ec2280c6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "03272805facd8ea19fd0af211ccb2bca", "candidate_priority_rank": 38381, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c665d1e13c8ae982:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c665d1e13c8ae982:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c665d1e13c8ae982:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c665d1e13c8ae982:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dirt<->sign", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sign", "B": "dirt"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sign<->dirt", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 247, "image_id": "2317568", "image_sha256": "8e6dc4cf3a4d33a85fe72680e8cb27590fa951edc4b3986ab7238193e404c0ba", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317568.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317568.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2381754", "image_sha256": "f7aac94376c46f2cd818186fb3666fb98c5486dae873561d9de369b3914400f4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2381754.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2381754.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c665d1e13c8ae982", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sign", "diff_b": "dirt", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sign", "component_b": "dirt"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arrow", "clouds", "cow", "hook", "owl", "plate", "roof", "sign", "sky", "trees"], "detected_components": ["sign"], "masked_program_sha256": "c261f61ca3f32e9c08718acb874cf3377546b4d58dc75579c60cfcf9039c8fd9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sign", "bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sign", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sign", "bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c38584ce59cd77f2c5c06a7fc96e4c26fd8cf3296dc756971125ffafe1306313"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02155688", "text": "What kind of bird is on the sign?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["dirt", "door", "ground", "head", "leg", "log", "owl", "rock"], "detected_components": ["dirt"], "masked_program_sha256": "c261f61ca3f32e9c08718acb874cf3377546b4d58dc75579c60cfcf9039c8fd9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dirt", "bird"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dirt", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dirt", "bird"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f5916e7a76d661479132958575f301ab9de4f086e5b3863a91e4d8079e1c3d57"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16294646", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38381, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "84f831e64eee59ca2bc8c99ab77585520cd42a2d55d598f7094c6e80dc8d38e4", "selected_component": "dirt", "selected_source_question_id": "16294646", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of bird is on the dirt?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bird,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of bird is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "84f831e64eee59ca2bc8c99ab77585520cd42a2d55d598f7094c6e80dc8d38e4", "queried_category": "bird", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "sign"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bird,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of bird is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "84f831e64eee59ca2bc8c99ab77585520cd42a2d55d598f7094c6e80dc8d38e4", "queried_category": "bird", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "dirt"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "owl", "full_answer": "The bird is an owl.", "question": "What kind of bird is on the sign?", "question_id": "02155688", "semantic": [{"argument": "sign (1019658)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bird,on,s (1019665)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "owl", "full_answer": "The bird is an owl.", "question": "What kind of bird is on the dirt?", "question_id": "16294646", "semantic": [{"argument": "dirt (3832104)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bird,on,s (702081)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1019665"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["owl"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1019665", "query_target_entity_name": "owl", "relation_object_entity_id": "1019658", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1019665", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1019658", "selected_entity_name": "sign"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sign", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1019658"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sign", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["702081"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["owl"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "standing"], "query_target_entity_id": "702081", "query_target_entity_name": "owl", "relation_object_entity_id": "3832104", "relation_subject_entity_id": "702081", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3832104", "selected_entity_name": "dirt"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3832104"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:03272805facd8ea19fd0af211ccb2bca", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8e6dc4cf3a4d33a85fe72680e8cb27590fa951edc4b3986ab7238193e404c0ba", "image_sha256_b": "f7aac94376c46f2cd818186fb3666fb98c5486dae873561d9de369b3914400f4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0c39677d46a5d50d73cc071501dd8f152cf7f09317c057ff8227ea8c09dd691a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "63575bfad033017060178abe6fb65344", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b1cbe333b76ac6236604c00dc7894d06221b82c089eceac0ea6f04f037a647e8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7450e945f363e255323db0087997933c1b369b405ead45ad9aae297f845272fb", "request_id": "549f63647f9038d68f0e507af598837b", "response_sha256": "a13772b60a6805a9531adcc2182a9e9ea091ce6f5c8150bbf5b313d99c06c186", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0dbb14a979b4a2c7c6928387b352368499927d6fbd00df0a796d41be184d36c1", "request_id": "1f5a025f8aeb4725ca4bdf1b4986824e", "response_sha256": "042c27945e29524e01fe903f700addd950c97cb001d2ba50df43188a7c4f3f97", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "0e8609d00c91f5400f1ee9d0dae4505f", "candidate_priority_rank": 38389, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-619420eb3091a277:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-619420eb3091a277:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-619420eb3091a277:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-619420eb3091a277:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "grass<->pavement", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "grass", "B": "pavement"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "grass<->pavement", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2383613", "image_sha256": "2c2c927e06e198700db67de1455ebdb6053a3cde40c750ddb7dd0a7634531fc2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2383613.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2383613.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2351225", "image_sha256": "00c71e61b34005e202f5071d041e03ad515d15d8e8b004339e1573aa103549af", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2351225.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2351225.jpg", "width": 390}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-619420eb3091a277", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "grass", "diff_b": "pavement", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "grass", "component_b": "pavement"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bench", "duck", "ducks", "grass", "park", "tree", "trees", "water"], "detected_components": ["grass"], "masked_program_sha256": "9d101c86b63c1693b6803bccde91431dc0f12d8f9bc1d7f08119d3d92ad9829f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "grass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "35ee139cb9bbc4dd8f859b34bf0f75ddecbc278eaf45e8ad0c24bc8a0588e25c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05404026", "text": "What animals are walking on the grass?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["buildings", "car", "cars", "elephants", "hat", "jacket", "man", "pavement", "people", "shirt", "sidewalk", "street", "suit", "trees", "water"], "detected_components": ["pavement"], "masked_program_sha256": "9d101c86b63c1693b6803bccde91431dc0f12d8f9bc1d7f08119d3d92ad9829f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pavement"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pavement", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pavement"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7f881cbf186ef881da5f27dc162f4d3985aa0d9d26848583019b05edf99b3efb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "041033336", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38389, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ee4d2717edb40810ce16ec24e97c23c77ab70629fbfd29b0f93dd152c9e9be49", "selected_component": "pavement", "selected_source_question_id": "041033336", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animals are walking on the pavement?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are walking on the ?", "program_group_hash": "ee4d2717edb40810ce16ec24e97c23c77ab70629fbfd29b0f93dd152c9e9be49", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "grass"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are walking on the ?", "program_group_hash": "ee4d2717edb40810ce16ec24e97c23c77ab70629fbfd29b0f93dd152c9e9be49", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "pavement"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "ducks", "full_answer": "The animals are ducks.", "question": "What animals are walking on the grass?", "question_id": "05404026", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (1319081)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s (1319082)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephants", "full_answer": "The animals are elephants.", "question": "What animals are walking on the pavement?", "question_id": "041033336", "semantic": [{"argument": "pavement (3590050)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s (2226009)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1319080", "1319082", "1319090", "1319091", "1319092", "1319093"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ducks"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1319082", "query_target_entity_name": "ducks", "relation_object_entity_id": "1319081", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1319082", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1319081", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1319081"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pavement", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2226009"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2226009", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "3590050", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2226009", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3590050", "selected_entity_name": "pavement"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pavement", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3590050"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0e8609d00c91f5400f1ee9d0dae4505f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2c2c927e06e198700db67de1455ebdb6053a3cde40c750ddb7dd0a7634531fc2", "image_sha256_b": "00c71e61b34005e202f5071d041e03ad515d15d8e8b004339e1573aa103549af", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d84467e8bb5ea5e0fd10664204d106b95862956e62d23d12d7d21a3b89a74dfc", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a05a934527adac5bcb1872f660952853", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "865e22e22cd767c0c94bc1d582a920a0172ed1e95e97f6cb31980034d925b755"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a291ba325c46e1279caf74e481943966f261ad4179ff890f7cae74b68b4c9a42", "request_id": "4a34b1edf89832005f339a6ca1ef1414", "response_sha256": "0a964f83a4fe5cbf8d8b658f41af3c5140e191a3398c303c6166d2eea69abdc3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f1e0407004203d2c095fbb25c4e766deff61a67ae8e036c48fd25ca2479ad041", "request_id": "166b1b4537c6d6180e531592e4c4089b", "response_sha256": "fe490ac14ad5118713f153a2eb9f6ac10d3c222549400433b2408d1e4721b4d8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "fa2f76a059716f9c43ec4b3a50d2dd2b", "candidate_priority_rank": 38586, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c66bdec5684963ed:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c66bdec5684963ed:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c66bdec5684963ed:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c66bdec5684963ed:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->cell phone", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cell phone", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cell phone<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 312, "image_id": "2353808", "image_sha256": "dc3bbc4967f6644d11fdb0db2c6af4cdaf35b5ace2b8b47918ee3d65ec0cfc95", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2353808.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2353808.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2376421", "image_sha256": "55ae39dbc190ce837da20bddd6537b8aceb4d283eefebbf1c5f480861c8148c8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376421.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376421.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c66bdec5684963ed", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cell phone", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cell phone", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cd", "cds", "cell phone", "computer mouse", "controller", "dvds", "floor", "keyboard", "laptop", "moon", "pizza", "platform", "remote control", "screen", "shelf", "shelves", "wall", "walls"], "detected_components": ["cell phone"], "masked_program_sha256": "fc03a964bf9484f8410f87bf83cfbc41572e881e892631a72b31a124c30317ee", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cell phone", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cell phone", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cell phone", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "18b7b970747a36b792a90840c6ccf75a5edcab82c9bd3a6c2970c89256385b3d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "15641920", "text": "What is the device that the cell phone is lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["book", "books", "cat", "cd", "desk", "envelope", "laptop", "legs", "paper", "phone", "screen"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "fc03a964bf9484f8410f87bf83cfbc41572e881e892631a72b31a124c30317ee", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4f518ddeddc3a943627662ec4ad3ef18f8426a2d09703f5cfc205d9c9ba7d5ac"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11396676", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38586, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d29bfcd2d2a29de9f7504c7bed7ff861bea16068c9caa32417e049f0dd2b975f", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "11396676", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the device that the cat is lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the device that the is lying on?", "program_group_hash": "d29bfcd2d2a29de9f7504c7bed7ff861bea16068c9caa32417e049f0dd2b975f", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "cell phone"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the device that the is lying on?", "program_group_hash": "d29bfcd2d2a29de9f7504c7bed7ff861bea16068c9caa32417e049f0dd2b975f", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "laptop", "full_answer": "The device is a laptop.", "question": "What is the device that the cell phone is lying on?", "question_id": "15641920", "semantic": [{"argument": "cell phone (3181408)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,lying on,o (2773246)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "laptop", "full_answer": "The device is a laptop.", "question": "What is the device that the cat is lying on?", "question_id": "11396676", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (1907673)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,lying on,o (2428247)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1857528", "1857529", "2118689", "2358739", "2441850", "2677192", "2773246", "2850427", "3181410", "3304897"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["laptop"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "2773246", "query_target_entity_name": "laptop", "relation_object_entity_id": "2773246", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3181408", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3181408", "selected_entity_name": "cell phone"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cell phone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3181408"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cell phone", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1768129", "2428247", "3840159"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["laptop"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "2428247", "query_target_entity_name": "laptop", "relation_object_entity_id": "2428247", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1907673", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1907673", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1907673"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:fa2f76a059716f9c43ec4b3a50d2dd2b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "dc3bbc4967f6644d11fdb0db2c6af4cdaf35b5ace2b8b47918ee3d65ec0cfc95", "image_sha256_b": "55ae39dbc190ce837da20bddd6537b8aceb4d283eefebbf1c5f480861c8148c8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "077787d7c3d5d32c61f09a6ecda1223f980092a3f12a0e40d6b9d565aa7aecbf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8bfae2f3a2311cd91570566428093ef0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "073f7ab5c58aecd5b31b69a876ddd8c3d473defd02067ec7147b1f9f6e76ac04"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "db320dda8c120643c9c7bb03831ccfd24891aa19c4cd0727fe9befb90fb43f6c", "request_id": "7c441e6625ea9baec5cc88892d6328c9", "response_sha256": "c09eff37e8fb5047c6eae86e47f07cbf46e6fd0662859ef2b8101dd50085d97c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7d94b0fa7a3cf0ebc7786c0e793e11106c667ec6cc8387a361dff0148f48ef78", "request_id": "18c44834564de18e9c32ab78b31439db", "response_sha256": "4a6d3d2e2b90b0ac683c06567f6fefaee0e58b8839cb3737fd4903f2a50b32b4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "e5c6b143314b41b255efa16ab184b5ed", "candidate_priority_rank": 38601, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e3785f20a43fc0ef:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e3785f20a43fc0ef:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e3785f20a43fc0ef:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e3785f20a43fc0ef:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "picture<->sink", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sink", "B": "picture"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sink<->picture", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2366815", "image_sha256": "2092b533f700981cd05e3d810cf66fe9d476fb582abe37c06d15a03571c9072b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2366815.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2366815.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2388691", "image_sha256": "4ae9944d8fa743e6b8f179c9dfd05215e0fef67ae12ead790e12643191e047f6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388691.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388691.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e3785f20a43fc0ef", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sink", "diff_b": "picture", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sink", "component_b": "picture"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "cabinets", "clock", "counter", "dishwasher", "door", "drawer", "faucet", "floor", "jar", "kitchen", "knives", "mat", "microwave", "oven", "refrigerator", "shelf", "shelves", "sink", "spices", "stove", "towels", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["sink"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sink", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "52be8fa2f8ecd4104645b682d2ab01af0a29c84be08f772d59c7ab4ea6b77f12"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "151032886", "text": "What type of furniture is below the sink?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bedspread", "bench", "canoe", "ceiling", "curtains", "fish", "floor", "headboard", "lamp", "nightstand", "picture", "pillows", "post", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["picture"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["picture", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "picture", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["picture", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "68e3a331682e3f165409b7a46774e2f96f51113dedcff68c930f0052def00e44"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1980064", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38601, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "196faa3d35f78151deb18d36fad9d14e955cc7106642438311f718c3654e383b", "selected_component": "picture", "selected_source_question_id": "1980064", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of furniture is below the picture?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "196faa3d35f78151deb18d36fad9d14e955cc7106642438311f718c3654e383b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "sink"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "196faa3d35f78151deb18d36fad9d14e955cc7106642438311f718c3654e383b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "picture"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cabinets", "full_answer": "The pieces of furniture are cabinets.", "question": "What type of furniture is below the sink?", "question_id": "151032886", "semantic": [{"argument": "sink (625807)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (625812)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What type of furniture is below the picture?", "question_id": "1980064", "semantic": [{"argument": "picture (671489)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (671486)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["625804", "625812", "625825", "625826", "625840", "625841", "625844"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cabinets"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "625812", "query_target_entity_name": "cabinets", "relation_object_entity_id": "625807", "relation_subject_entity_id": "625812", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "625807", "selected_entity_name": "sink"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["625807"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "picture", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["671486", "671500"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["dark", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "671486", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "671489", "relation_subject_entity_id": "671486", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "671489", "selected_entity_name": "picture"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "picture", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["671489"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e5c6b143314b41b255efa16ab184b5ed", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2092b533f700981cd05e3d810cf66fe9d476fb582abe37c06d15a03571c9072b", "image_sha256_b": "4ae9944d8fa743e6b8f179c9dfd05215e0fef67ae12ead790e12643191e047f6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "40c8dbe2d2b4611c4ae0df8eae4d38ef724b72a33df97a3f74b9ff010278768e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1fee9e1ade95e15595d379ee66306c5d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f379daa272b15ee7cbbf9f45f8fdc1c38a9b96c0d2c726a2b44af77afd19e748"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "210f3ea4dcedd66c585893f327b19c56537f107c823bb29a31a8a60fef077b1a", "request_id": "24c0921397f92170c34e2fb8edd3049d", "response_sha256": "e295aa203de4bf3a488e77d4d6bf15a486638b57a2089c1293aca4579576e8ff", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a89eecefffae9a951f10a40640fb2ad7165bbe6760cc6ea80480809552278d93", "request_id": "6dc79edfece0de7cb75dc7059e54280d", "response_sha256": "ff9531d9be8e12ec108701e78e0023aa7be8f125e48fc823d8d4351c32989c6e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "53620358d341baff4f3ae5776297f472", "candidate_priority_rank": 38692, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9cd8bf34e56a5486:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9cd8bf34e56a5486:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9cd8bf34e56a5486:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9cd8bf34e56a5486:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "girl<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "girl"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->girl", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2329526", "image_sha256": "18fcc42f9d1436d15bade3501d4982c7fad389cedfdb13ba392c3a9f4c6edf21", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2329526.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2329526.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 768, "image_id": "61545", "image_sha256": "e0e62bee6a4a8c46d0bb017696bd80ec999f5c550b09e7cfb50427a2757186df", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/61545.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/61545.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9cd8bf34e56a5486", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "girl", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "girl"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["american flag", "computer monitor", "desk", "door", "flag", "jacket", "man", "nose", "scissors", "star", "tie", "uniform", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "3f76532d9e7d234c512465cf5cad0f28906af4dd1da5341868d596bddff8e095", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "283c845a06f3fcf8cf83e4a5ff1544ffcca8d701433d34f936c09e6ecc07893d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06492759", "text": "What's the woman cutting?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boy", "chair", "collar", "ear", "face", "girl", "glasses", "guy", "hand", "mouth", "nose", "paper", "room", "scissors", "shirt", "table"], "detected_components": ["girl"], "masked_program_sha256": "3f76532d9e7d234c512465cf5cad0f28906af4dd1da5341868d596bddff8e095", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "girl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7d7d8cbf972f0b74c2b674d596c58c4a14ccc6d90a2a47d51b642f4fa0386c76"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04632192", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38692, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c8b5095741b6ac119bf7f53d1ef3b78922dab7271bda4ec08edefba5cafa0c20", "selected_component": "girl", "selected_source_question_id": "04632192", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's the girl cutting?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,cutting,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the cutting?", "program_group_hash": "c8b5095741b6ac119bf7f53d1ef3b78922dab7271bda4ec08edefba5cafa0c20", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "cutting", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,cutting,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the cutting?", "program_group_hash": "c8b5095741b6ac119bf7f53d1ef3b78922dab7271bda4ec08edefba5cafa0c20", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "cutting", "select_category": "girl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "tie", "full_answer": "The woman is cutting the tie.", "question": "What's the woman cutting?", "question_id": "06492759", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (4673485)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,cutting,o (4673496)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "paper", "full_answer": "The girl is cutting the paper.", "question": "What's the girl cutting?", "question_id": "04632192", "semantic": [{"argument": "girl (4388204)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,cutting,o (4388205)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4133916", "4666588", "4666589", "4673487", "4673493", "4673496", "4673498", "4673499", "4673504", "4673505", "4673510", "4673514", "4673516", "4673517"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["tie"], "predicate": "cutting", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "4673496", "query_target_entity_name": "tie", "relation_object_entity_id": "4673496", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4673485", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4673485", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4673485"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4075127", "4388164", "4388168", "4388174", "4388179", "4388192", "4388196", "4388197", "4388200", "4388205", "4388211", "4388213", "4388218", "4388220", "4388224", "4388225", "4388229", "4388239", "4388243"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["paper"], "predicate": "cutting", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4388205", "query_target_entity_name": "paper", "relation_object_entity_id": "4388205", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4388204", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4388204", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4388204"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:53620358d341baff4f3ae5776297f472", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "18fcc42f9d1436d15bade3501d4982c7fad389cedfdb13ba392c3a9f4c6edf21", "image_sha256_b": "e0e62bee6a4a8c46d0bb017696bd80ec999f5c550b09e7cfb50427a2757186df", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b172a4e979423979eaea8834381bb1265160ffcc0a4f7a5b3f936d1e81baee1c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "013742e9b3e8e8ab303ffb80b1e1c57b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "10ca730cd4b934d5afe3283f64e68feaea60c2dde9da73c75b9979515f99bd70"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0c33cdf6772865e0920b663eddff55c7a12ece53c90d0c601d66ed998e260353", "request_id": "a6c36225e629f0118068200286612024", "response_sha256": "0116b415aad66c293bb3c388d7fc99e6ca6a1f3002a4a2166afa1893c9c78889", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0794af78415bcc80c535f253dfe3d2d94961ef1e342e81fba293f2c410ff63eb", "request_id": "595aa81cbb9d1b375f2b746002a65f32", "response_sha256": "f9045b4c9493acd16df6619f5f469417b38779d3f91adffac9f83db93119a6e5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "bf3c2c8728035562ec78b69d0b311586", "candidate_priority_rank": 38729, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a44c5baa35702fda:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a44c5baa35702fda:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a44c5baa35702fda:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a44c5baa35702fda:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "candle<->lady", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "lady", "B": "candle"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "lady<->candle", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2317136", "image_sha256": "8e810c94308787258c7ca284ef0184a5a1eee39a92b69ba0114fbb0c35b430c4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317136.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317136.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2384212", "image_sha256": "23f16c15630302b48c59b38d8e2a5df67b54af6af93721fb63088fc8251bef1f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384212.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384212.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a44c5baa35702fda", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "lady", "diff_b": "candle", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "lady", "component_b": "candle"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["butter", "coffee", "coffee cup", "eye glasses", "fork", "glass", "hand", "lady", "magazine", "milk", "napkin", "plate", "room", "skirt", "sofa", "table"], "detected_components": ["lady"], "masked_program_sha256": "0daf575b077a08727295a94c5d75a33ba86f0da0a2ce4e29070c39f428672504", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["lady", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "lady", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["lady", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "103b91a56b688827a952f8b4fce771669a7a920c6d809da1dd4543d1f8159387"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09644181", "text": "What is the item of furniture that the lady is sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "cabinet door", "candle", "faucet", "floor", "flower", "frame", "jar", "mirror", "picture", "shelf", "sink", "toilet", "toilet bowl", "toilet seat", "wall", "waste basket"], "detected_components": ["candle"], "masked_program_sha256": "0daf575b077a08727295a94c5d75a33ba86f0da0a2ce4e29070c39f428672504", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["candle", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "candle", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["candle", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "20780fc6c4c49075deedfe6d6c6cc4cbbb59d2bada58be7fd4f5b2611965d734"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02286592", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38729, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "81fdee507e02b869cb91dccc811b9eaa988d64f34b7d88f6e338de5f00a34f2b", "selected_component": "candle", "selected_source_question_id": "02286592", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the item of furniture that the candle is sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that the is sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "81fdee507e02b869cb91dccc811b9eaa988d64f34b7d88f6e338de5f00a34f2b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "lady"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that the is sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "81fdee507e02b869cb91dccc811b9eaa988d64f34b7d88f6e338de5f00a34f2b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "candle"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sofa", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a sofa.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that the lady is sitting on?", "question_id": "09644181", "semantic": [{"argument": "lady (2999437)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (3952457)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "shelf", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a shelf.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that the candle is sitting on?", "question_id": "02286592", "semantic": [{"argument": "candle (1312086)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (1312079)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2720889", "3952457"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sofa"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3952457", "query_target_entity_name": "sofa", "relation_object_entity_id": "3952457", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2999437", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2999437", "selected_entity_name": "lady"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lady", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2999437"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "candle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lady", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1312064", "1312079"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["shelf"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["glass"], "query_target_entity_id": "1312079", "query_target_entity_name": "shelf", "relation_object_entity_id": "1312079", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1312086", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1312086", "selected_entity_name": "candle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "candle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1312086"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:bf3c2c8728035562ec78b69d0b311586", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8e810c94308787258c7ca284ef0184a5a1eee39a92b69ba0114fbb0c35b430c4", "image_sha256_b": "23f16c15630302b48c59b38d8e2a5df67b54af6af93721fb63088fc8251bef1f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7b39f5ab811706caa181d029ea02d325e4d07eec9e561be7c9af0625002ba0d1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0217bc5b92868243b9a31a6ca53ac82e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5b4f9bdfa9fe0d9197bb232436136dde7cc67a8fac273e709bfe36c489ae50b5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d65e5051dc845d4d35d6727ab4b9e7506db0e5b5716d9792c57985a0078b6ed7", "request_id": "3a8da452c5db7aafad663d11657fc59f", "response_sha256": "07fc8d252e2b9aea76c9828ac8cf43e588001c9e3dcd291b97c90fe971cc8764", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b528bcf3cf8713dca739a9423418cac93e168c4aabd5b722426ceef79f393d48", "request_id": "57666344c3313f57c05fd0c6e7bf4241", "response_sha256": "6b12a0b8da0f61ce9383a22a1c04ba6b626d35d51d0508c1c80c94fcb91c5df0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "ff313011f11d4e05205808f40f27fd07", "candidate_priority_rank": 38730, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73a84a680634b438:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73a84a680634b438:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73a84a680634b438:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73a84a680634b438:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bowl<->keyboard", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "keyboard", "B": "bowl"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "keyboard<->bowl", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 600, "image_id": "370", "image_sha256": "eb2186dbe98dd85608e53502e1f3961c6aa5761659b6224ce94ba9093efb20c5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/370.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/370.jpg", "width": 800}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2366570", "image_sha256": "2ddc39f0c4eb9f63e4ac591d06eada242d9dba807ef2e867e1c01aa83da04826", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2366570.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2366570.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73a84a680634b438", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "keyboard", "diff_b": "bowl", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "keyboard", "component_b": "bowl"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blinds", "bookshelf", "box", "chair", "computer", "cup", "desk", "fan", "keyboard", "man", "monitor", "mouse pad", "plant", "pot", "trash can", "window"], "detected_components": ["keyboard"], "masked_program_sha256": "b233d93a1511b023b4c57113d94565874b676dd2208b42b21054f7638a44e001", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["keyboard", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "keyboard", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["keyboard", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a09ca392f3b9c8c7792110c784545b700d494a57ea2538a097c8cb3049210904"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1883355", "text": "What is the device that the keyboard is in front of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["antenna", "books", "bowl", "controller", "door", "dvd player", "glass", "hand", "lamp", "mirror", "pen", "remote control", "rug", "shelf", "speaker", "table", "television", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["bowl"], "masked_program_sha256": "b233d93a1511b023b4c57113d94565874b676dd2208b42b21054f7638a44e001", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bowl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f71dac8aa896491db865074f3aa035a9daa6b4ceea656e7e9de30d60ddd6dad5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13401114", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38730, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "76fe189313367cd38fbf3c30c2a1e81b9e21ab7835d6869acb7a780ec70f033c", "selected_component": "bowl", "selected_source_question_id": "13401114", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the device that the bowl is in front of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,in front of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the device that the is in front of?", "program_group_hash": "76fe189313367cd38fbf3c30c2a1e81b9e21ab7835d6869acb7a780ec70f033c", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "keyboard"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,in front of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the device that the is in front of?", "program_group_hash": "76fe189313367cd38fbf3c30c2a1e81b9e21ab7835d6869acb7a780ec70f033c", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "bowl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "monitor", "full_answer": "The device is a monitor.", "question": "What is the device that the keyboard is in front of?", "question_id": "1883355", "semantic": [{"argument": "keyboard (1027332)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,in front of,o (1027328)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "television", "full_answer": "The device is a television.", "question": "What is the device that the bowl is in front of?", "question_id": "13401114", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (627601)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,in front of,o (627591)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1027328", "1027340"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["monitor"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1027328", "query_target_entity_name": "monitor", "relation_object_entity_id": "1027328", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1027332", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1027332", "selected_entity_name": "keyboard"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "keyboard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1027332"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "keyboard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["627591", "627592", "627593", "627594", "627598", "627600", "627603", "627604"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["television"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "on"], "query_target_entity_id": "627591", "query_target_entity_name": "television", "relation_object_entity_id": "627591", "relation_subject_entity_id": "627601", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "627601", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["627601"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ff313011f11d4e05205808f40f27fd07", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "eb2186dbe98dd85608e53502e1f3961c6aa5761659b6224ce94ba9093efb20c5", "image_sha256_b": "2ddc39f0c4eb9f63e4ac591d06eada242d9dba807ef2e867e1c01aa83da04826", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8e0c0ebb00dddd7ddd6221011f0aa3e6cc7739d1fc238df64afd5bf973e1bf14", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "07a72aaec634b8dc552a7eeb66a940a3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "55d3457dacff329308fb07a4a67f00375b272fa6f6fc6335392d12d97e52aaac"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cafa90c49a0a83fca155e09dc38eb03f725c313acabcad4363ba602344f4c576", "request_id": "d91e17c98e878cee0ed642c934b473a2", "response_sha256": "37a807d49852f551572f64a6c4458b2d7e9a728fdcb6b0992c114eacf95fc843", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b8633744b2523c7ae61302167b812e0cc4ecb6f7d0101c0bfb0b21accf8e4def", "request_id": "cc49a7ec068fcd1e5a432ba6ed0baba2", "response_sha256": "09afe5e7de7fb9cee7be9a0347f5e17746f054d102b849f72bdcd82f852e0934", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "a8f5052a0379bde56ab3e14a81b79c84", "candidate_priority_rank": 37544, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c97512d8e59fea0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c97512d8e59fea0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c97512d8e59fea0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c97512d8e59fea0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dream catcher<->towel", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dream catcher", "B": "towel"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dream catcher<->towel", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2317977", "image_sha256": "1c66fc801cd07ffc3ae6d0e51f3856c068d34955554d4f4f6157879205cdcfeb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317977.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317977.jpg", "width": 348}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2358241", "image_sha256": "d7ae2a1d573969a8e95683241bf59096b8dc9c2757d83dbe9f11baea33f41e83", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2358241.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2358241.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c97512d8e59fea0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dream catcher", "diff_b": "towel", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dream catcher", "component_b": "towel"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bedroom", "blanket", "cabinet", "comforter", "dream catcher", "floor", "lamp", "leg", "lock", "mat", "oven", "picture", "pillow", "plate", "shelf", "tiles", "wall"], "detected_components": ["dream catcher"], "masked_program_sha256": "d5e374b56baca5a28fee7009c841beb45163572e34c6ce313b3226d5ef487894", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dream catcher"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dream catcher", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dream catcher"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "efd3d2504ac056dabf72650d9b4825dde2070489b1238cf335826e1561ce735e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04348393", "text": "What is the dream catcher hung on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "cabinet", "cabinets", "carpet", "countertop", "cupboards", "dress", "floor", "girl", "hair", "kettle", "knife block", "oven", "person", "pot", "shirt", "stove", "towel", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["towel"], "masked_program_sha256": "d5e374b56baca5a28fee7009c841beb45163572e34c6ce313b3226d5ef487894", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "towel", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c89e6e3b089d5b8bb33a5371064edb64e355fdcbba4a48eec6b234b5bb90b6c8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1281092", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37544, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9861eaac2ea2ab6a69276d5aca60a287c14ddbd9872e8c9b2c2717f2e7e88732", "selected_component": "towel", "selected_source_question_id": "1281092", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the towel hung on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hung on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the hung on?", "program_group_hash": "9861eaac2ea2ab6a69276d5aca60a287c14ddbd9872e8c9b2c2717f2e7e88732", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hung on", "select_category": "dream catcher"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hung on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the hung on?", "program_group_hash": "9861eaac2ea2ab6a69276d5aca60a287c14ddbd9872e8c9b2c2717f2e7e88732", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hung on", "select_category": "towel"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "wall", "full_answer": "The dream catcher is hung on the wall.", "question": "What is the dream catcher hung on?", "question_id": "04348393", "semantic": [{"argument": "dream catcher (3072773)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hung on,o (3394782)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stove", "full_answer": "The towel is hung on the stove.", "question": "What is the towel hung on?", "question_id": "1281092", "semantic": [{"argument": "towel (804798)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hung on,o (804762)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2819965", "2827637", "2838864", "2891912", "2891913", "3017071", "3055015", "3059050", "3072774", "3093482", "3104997", "3105922", "3125806", "3315334", "3315335", "3322055", "3349511", "3394782", "3405816", "3405817", "3479088", "3949493", "3949500", "3949503", "3949505", "3949506"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 26, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wall"], "predicate": "hung on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3394782", "query_target_entity_name": "wall", "relation_object_entity_id": "3394782", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3072773", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3072773", "selected_entity_name": "dream catcher"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dream catcher", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3072773"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "towel", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dream catcher", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["804761", "804762", "804765", "804766", "804768", "804773", "804774", "804779", "804783", "804785", "804788", "804789", "804790", "804793", "804794", "804795", "804801", "804803", "804804"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stove"], "predicate": "hung on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "804762", "query_target_entity_name": "stove", "relation_object_entity_id": "804762", "relation_subject_entity_id": "804798", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "804798", "selected_entity_name": "towel"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "towel", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["804798"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a8f5052a0379bde56ab3e14a81b79c84", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1c66fc801cd07ffc3ae6d0e51f3856c068d34955554d4f4f6157879205cdcfeb", "image_sha256_b": "d7ae2a1d573969a8e95683241bf59096b8dc9c2757d83dbe9f11baea33f41e83", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "73317295bca7d111f7257013eb8723cf80dc0b55aee5a6175860257c7f96cadf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e159416dc922cf2ed74436b9124f506c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ed287966e0cf7afadd6850388540ecd9ce09bc01d3c1b9f26e860c9c827c6dd9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c8ebc9fec22c5121be7c4135f1f456bef90b06878702b231b4140e733097913a", "request_id": "983a1cd0ea6ae80943a7eca45c3f0e56", "response_sha256": "5aafb6072ca52dbeca4a77d7a6e934d4d3fe5c7de1e15b7b4cc475851a28ee48", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7db2378a67da670efeb1402edbbc3cd13debf6a088d170e1dd7da16eec63e548", "request_id": "4185c8a9dde0a5afd0acb18992ded85f", "response_sha256": "d7958a32973cc215bc19dcf0a786568fa56188cd1ec7c5ea200128dfe13714b5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "9cbbbb05a11d5acf0c7a9f9493534c66", "candidate_priority_rank": 37691, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a62dbe56a22ae3d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a62dbe56a22ae3d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a62dbe56a22ae3d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a62dbe56a22ae3d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "fans<->spectators", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "fans", "B": "spectators"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "fans<->spectators", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2327715", "image_sha256": "d99e7f33d278ec717b87d99e2b455751543fe2c2c030ecc8e5f7e8aced5e0427", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2327715.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2327715.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2376569", "image_sha256": "2de51e34b8f33adccaea3384360c9a52523f2179700a3e40fc0bcb482048c55b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376569.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376569.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a62dbe56a22ae3d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "fans", "diff_b": "spectators", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "fans", "component_b": "spectators"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "baseball bat", "bleachers", "cap", "crowd", "fans", "game", "gloves", "grass", "ground", "hand", "head", "helmet", "man", "number", "pants", "people", "shirt", "sign", "umpire", "wall"], "detected_components": ["fans"], "masked_program_sha256": "b952423ab86c43267686a791777dec20dbc1603cbb8957011404f72420019543", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fans"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "fans", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fans"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3e019f2a755e11775357a2b92208ad2c3f89c0b77bfae954f7fa81facfac0ddf"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02157506", "text": "What are the fans watching?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "cap", "ground", "leaves", "pants", "people", "roof", "shirt", "shorts", "sign", "skateboard", "sneakers", "spectators", "stairs", "t-shirt", "trees", "wheel", "wristwatch"], "detected_components": ["spectators"], "masked_program_sha256": "b952423ab86c43267686a791777dec20dbc1603cbb8957011404f72420019543", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["spectators"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "spectators", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["spectators"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d1b209bbc085509b73e5ddcd6f4403919581834bdb7b16cc43f954f3a9b71491"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07242501", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37691, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 13, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2948de1571adb248f96f299b91ac60d84c83d29bad3daf10458cdb79a4ff52cd", "selected_component": "spectators", "selected_source_question_id": "07242501", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the spectators watching?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,watching,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the watching?", "program_group_hash": "2948de1571adb248f96f299b91ac60d84c83d29bad3daf10458cdb79a4ff52cd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "watching", "select_category": "fans"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,watching,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the watching?", "program_group_hash": "2948de1571adb248f96f299b91ac60d84c83d29bad3daf10458cdb79a4ff52cd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "watching", "select_category": "spectators"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "game", "full_answer": "The fans are watching the game.", "question": "What are the fans watching?", "question_id": "02157506", "semantic": [{"argument": "fans (979621)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,watching,o (979622)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "skateboard", "full_answer": "The spectators are watching the skateboard.", "question": "What are the spectators watching?", "question_id": "07242501", "semantic": [{"argument": "spectators (571650)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,watching,o (571654)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["979610", "979613", "979614", "979615", "979616", "979617", "979619", "979620", "979622", "979623", "979627", "979628", "979632", "979635", "979643", "979645", "979646", "979647", "979648", "979649", "979652", "979654", "979655"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 23, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["game"], "predicate": "watching", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "979622", "query_target_entity_name": "game", "relation_object_entity_id": "979622", "relation_subject_entity_id": "979621", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "979621", "selected_entity_name": "fans"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fans", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["979621"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "spectators", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fans", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["571647", "571649", "571651", "571652", "571653", "571654", "571655", "571656", "571657", "571658", "571659", "571660", "571661", "571662", "571663", "571664", "571667", "571668"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["skateboard"], "predicate": "watching", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "571654", "query_target_entity_name": "skateboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "571654", "relation_subject_entity_id": "571650", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "571650", "selected_entity_name": "spectators"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "spectators", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["571650"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:9cbbbb05a11d5acf0c7a9f9493534c66", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d99e7f33d278ec717b87d99e2b455751543fe2c2c030ecc8e5f7e8aced5e0427", "image_sha256_b": "2de51e34b8f33adccaea3384360c9a52523f2179700a3e40fc0bcb482048c55b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d3accd1cda9d4581a650eaa4fab637f376a42af4fe658b490eb1e3d4d7478681", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b95ea9f267e835ddb6192beed5021941", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "8ee0e7bc0b171d145bb0682431824643c1b300a401f29fedf79f3277f2c0e1e9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8b674c8efaa7cb680b8b2636a059c3db6cf8539881e0e5cd1599c7ec24b5f8d2", "request_id": "b5b9c76c3718e604fa26750495e86856", "response_sha256": "a2f30c7f355b53bf1bfe14ff670bbaff127d2406ed75d34029d006432c6dd392", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "46e0feb7b8848ce3dd547bd5121cbb785eebceaa64136ddab96f7b78f03993de", "request_id": "4c522ec542cb19d2be36c7c27d2f2e78", "response_sha256": "4d6a90d1015b224be022caaabf3049aaea633260760bff1ddbf3c2fb05e761ec", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "df0b3d4a85a53f08890248ca15b09ee5", "candidate_priority_rank": 37878, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6150384da7fc4237:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6150384da7fc4237:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6150384da7fc4237:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6150384da7fc4237:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "curtain<->sign", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "curtain", "B": "sign"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "curtain<->sign", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2363793", "image_sha256": "6056bb7759168e99aa0506c9e17e9fda74a832f7091b956cf9ecee2a531a0b3b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2363793.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2363793.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 480, "image_id": "1592580", "image_sha256": "86fd2f626e8becd511cd770e78118bfc1e7ed6d68c05e1ec869e3ce707cb83f5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/1592580.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/1592580.jpg", "width": 640}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6150384da7fc4237", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "curtain", "diff_b": "sign", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "curtain", "component_b": "sign"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bathroom", "bathtub", "bed", "bedroom", "blanket", "curtain", "doorway", "floor", "garland", "headboard", "pillow", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["curtain"], "masked_program_sha256": "74403201cba99cb9d349f3170d4b1263c3a2b2b0a171ea153978d77c8cecd567", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["curtain"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "curtain", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["curtain"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7ae83924948aaba84309b848e956ed0d908f618399bf11bf820a5aae024d30e2"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03454899", "text": "What's the curtain hanging above?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["balls", "building", "door", "hair", "hat", "leg", "man", "person", "picture", "shirt", "sign", "waist", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["sign"], "masked_program_sha256": "74403201cba99cb9d349f3170d4b1263c3a2b2b0a171ea153978d77c8cecd567", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sign"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sign", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sign"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ca101ef50d0766a09d48ec1b3bb252264247155db91d13245ef6ddbaf6515e8c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14938042", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 37878, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "aea64db1c37c75d5e5fa75b6920b9a80a5a95b4671ca8a6692a8ab1a39af8f6d", "selected_component": "sign", "selected_source_question_id": "14938042", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's the sign hanging above?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging above,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the hanging above?", "program_group_hash": "aea64db1c37c75d5e5fa75b6920b9a80a5a95b4671ca8a6692a8ab1a39af8f6d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hanging above", "select_category": "curtain"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging above,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the hanging above?", "program_group_hash": "aea64db1c37c75d5e5fa75b6920b9a80a5a95b4671ca8a6692a8ab1a39af8f6d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hanging above", "select_category": "sign"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The curtain is hanging above the bed.", "question": "What's the curtain hanging above?", "question_id": "03454899", "semantic": [{"argument": "curtain (762129)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging above,o (762118)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "door", "full_answer": "The sign is hanging above the door.", "question": "What's the sign hanging above?", "question_id": "14938042", "semantic": [{"argument": "sign (4324473)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging above,o (4324486)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["762117", "762118", "762119", "762120", "762121", "762122", "762124", "762125", "762131", "762132", "762136", "762141", "762142"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "hanging above", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "762118", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "762118", "relation_subject_entity_id": "762129", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "762129", "selected_entity_name": "curtain"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "curtain", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["762129"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sign", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "curtain", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4139769", "4285536", "4285539", "4285561", "4324460", "4324486", "4324493", "4447109", "4447110", "4447118", "4447120", "4447121", "4447137", "4447138", "4447142", "4447143"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["door"], "predicate": "hanging above", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "4324486", "query_target_entity_name": "door", "relation_object_entity_id": "4324486", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4324473", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4324473", "selected_entity_name": "sign"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sign", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4324473"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:df0b3d4a85a53f08890248ca15b09ee5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6056bb7759168e99aa0506c9e17e9fda74a832f7091b956cf9ecee2a531a0b3b", "image_sha256_b": "86fd2f626e8becd511cd770e78118bfc1e7ed6d68c05e1ec869e3ce707cb83f5", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "198f0b938e8c319defde4e612400e42fb941f6fed26b03c3b311f31dfcf59e8f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "fd72237e1b05d63536143692ec0b38a0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d82c156f7f995e0b98053f0f39998d86dc1ea3251630596276147bf278192c6b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dd24f64dd7e02907c0f6c5032daa72a60666b544805dd9e066cc7273b20dbebd", "request_id": "a1ec06393597380c912ad471fcab8992", "response_sha256": "44355a19584c9d80161b2c8dfedddf14d8be3c7158b2f0ffece0c07f9b97f592", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dcf4aa6611461123512a4d8548c7c6f6d1613059975566e213a09185564464f9", "request_id": "ccdbce724b0cc82225d4598d60e517c5", "response_sha256": "4b92ac9038b637926d4b3cab5f8af158c69d329d3ccc83e9a8b491b8f16c8b90", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "e3bc3dd3913f933145cdf1b39c8333ad", "candidate_priority_rank": 38401, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73fda7b502dfe195:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73fda7b502dfe195:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73fda7b502dfe195:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73fda7b502dfe195:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bags<->ducks", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "ducks", "B": "bags"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "ducks<->bags", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 267, "image_id": "2317551", "image_sha256": "d16c2e6022017d74c69d2ced397e67547cacd3cc3b7fc28e0645c5b4faafb740", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317551.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317551.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2359606", "image_sha256": "defa44bab06ef70ea5c47b4b9d83beb764f01c1312b2354fa45fd62eb60a9d28", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2359606.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2359606.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73fda7b502dfe195", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "ducks", "diff_b": "bags", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "ducks", "component_b": "bags"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beak", "ducks", "eyes", "feathers", "grass", "head", "leg", "straw", "tail"], "detected_components": ["ducks"], "masked_program_sha256": "5e34dee98502ccb1b78004b7f1c1cf0107819167cc7eb1b0631d865ab498f230", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ducks"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ducks", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ducks"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9923f7437ccce36938d77e334992737710c6b34d979da369cc3ce9760e4b026e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04447734", "text": "What are these ducks on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bags", "bottle", "cup", "eye", "ground", "hair", "hand", "head", "hot dog", "man", "people", "plate", "shirt", "sky", "spoon", "table", "tank top", "trees", "woman"], "detected_components": ["bags"], "masked_program_sha256": "5e34dee98502ccb1b78004b7f1c1cf0107819167cc7eb1b0631d865ab498f230", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bags"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bags", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bags"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "434634929f9f0e15404d123f4cd4c7f218a0c7949b807d7bc1fbc3901ef44c12"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15208521", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38401, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a6b716ed742ad3ee92201675fa9e7d65886f52aa928fee62080926e79413430d", "selected_component": "bags", "selected_source_question_id": "15208521", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are these bags on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are these on?", "program_group_hash": "a6b716ed742ad3ee92201675fa9e7d65886f52aa928fee62080926e79413430d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "ducks"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are these on?", "program_group_hash": "a6b716ed742ad3ee92201675fa9e7d65886f52aa928fee62080926e79413430d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "bags"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "straw", "full_answer": "The ducks are on the straw.", "question": "What are these ducks on?", "question_id": "04447734", "semantic": [{"argument": "ducks (1019805)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,o (1019817)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The bags are on the table.", "question": "What are these bags on?", "question_id": "15208521", "semantic": [{"argument": "bags (1776984)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,o (3764846)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1019807", "1019808", "1019811", "1019814", "1019815", "1019816", "1019817", "1019819"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["straw"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["tan"], "query_target_entity_id": "1019817", "query_target_entity_name": "straw", "relation_object_entity_id": "1019817", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1019805", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1019805", "selected_entity_name": "ducks"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ducks", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1019805"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bags", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ducks", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1668227", "1668229", "1668230", "1723113", "1773475", "1904714", "1998710", "2030989", "2340847", "2340849", "2361179", "2386422", "2386491", "2544923", "2559604", "2609045", "3764837", "3764838", "3764844", "3764845", "3764846"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3764846", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "3764846", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1776984", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1776984", "selected_entity_name": "bags"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bags", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1776984"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e3bc3dd3913f933145cdf1b39c8333ad", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d16c2e6022017d74c69d2ced397e67547cacd3cc3b7fc28e0645c5b4faafb740", "image_sha256_b": "defa44bab06ef70ea5c47b4b9d83beb764f01c1312b2354fa45fd62eb60a9d28", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "610dd0bf61e7399bf35582ff8dd5e1a68f479a8d32995db82a4a888e3b5a16bf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5ac36c190d9723d86f8ef0f138e1e107", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9cd928a826264876bfa1d1ad308e74a88f1e62bb22f14c9787610488fa1d3156"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ef1fe16ca5542203eb30ac84359dcd6208b08c0fc3d7f756331c59135360595d", "request_id": "26984975771e3071a8fa5d7b3c48d3ee", "response_sha256": "d528641f5255c2d7af4dcd7eade2bc0320dc8bfe225892b355d38ffe49d759e7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3edb15265846554c4294695609069b109912d4f8507515ebcebbe835f862063b", "request_id": "fdfbf6698b9c0e1e20f138835b84437c", "response_sha256": "eef811d23953a7fe8d20e49c484b776e8570dd73836aca5e642b86730c39a075", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "2e55e23f309df074dacd6176ccdd7010", "candidate_priority_rank": 38432, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3ad8ca008591e09a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3ad8ca008591e09a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3ad8ca008591e09a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3ad8ca008591e09a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blanket<->counter", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "blanket", "B": "counter"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blanket<->counter", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2321488", "image_sha256": "85f384b92eaf1bfcad51b4c9610e5be72f94164daad8ee75af768d1e5342b120", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2321488.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2321488.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 750, "image_id": "150495", "image_sha256": "ad31d40263fa709d4903bccf5ebb578a37f36321137f9cc21c5e11c125c32a24", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/150495.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/150495.jpg", "width": 1000}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3ad8ca008591e09a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blanket", "diff_b": "counter", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blanket", "component_b": "counter"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bear", "blanket", "book", "camera", "cup", "foot", "girl", "grass", "ground", "hair", "hand", "kettle", "liquid", "shoe", "skirt", "tea kettle"], "detected_components": ["blanket"], "masked_program_sha256": "089b13badee45c4d13308ecabd28a40f008c86041825f53cd67afac59de79365", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blanket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4d6257c7bd62a9ac572a5b56027dd298fd019816c19c8f0eed24a6f67dd8d2df"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19635604", "text": "What is the device that is sitting on the blanket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bathtub", "counter", "door", "doorway", "floor", "hair dryer", "light fixture", "light switch", "man", "mirror", "picture", "robe", "rug", "shower door", "sink", "television", "tiles", "towel", "towels", "wall"], "detected_components": ["counter"], "masked_program_sha256": "089b13badee45c4d13308ecabd28a40f008c86041825f53cd67afac59de79365", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["counter", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "counter", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["counter", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "241c5f0a72b155fe8441321e7b591e558f0fbd576efd165854e59e57a0e8cbcd"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04485618", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38432, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1176d0bdcfd7fddaf6e37ccaa59727253be87474570096243b2ad2407be67be9", "selected_component": "counter", "selected_source_question_id": "04485618", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the device that is sitting on the counter?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,sitting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the device that is sitting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "1176d0bdcfd7fddaf6e37ccaa59727253be87474570096243b2ad2407be67be9", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "blanket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,sitting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the device that is sitting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "1176d0bdcfd7fddaf6e37ccaa59727253be87474570096243b2ad2407be67be9", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "counter"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "camera", "full_answer": "The device is a camera.", "question": "What is the device that is sitting on the blanket?", "question_id": "19635604", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (3467636)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,sitting on,s (3425647)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hair dryer", "full_answer": "The device is a hair dryer.", "question": "What is the device that is sitting on the counter?", "question_id": "04485618", "semantic": [{"argument": "counter (1038994)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,sitting on,s (1038993)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3425647"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["camera"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3425647", "query_target_entity_name": "camera", "relation_object_entity_id": "3467636", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3425647", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3467636", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3467636"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "counter", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1038990", "1038993"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hair dryer"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1038993", "query_target_entity_name": "hair dryer", "relation_object_entity_id": "1038994", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1038993", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1038994", "selected_entity_name": "counter"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "counter", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1038994"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:2e55e23f309df074dacd6176ccdd7010", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "85f384b92eaf1bfcad51b4c9610e5be72f94164daad8ee75af768d1e5342b120", "image_sha256_b": "ad31d40263fa709d4903bccf5ebb578a37f36321137f9cc21c5e11c125c32a24", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0c88376a311bc8511daf0f6ae89ab66c351d2e515281a66cf936cc8dba320396", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e6c537b2820824b0f5eb5da671091115", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "55cdfca3e10599b096d96457922e055923a82d89657741b18b6c22cacaafb66a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5861d22d52f6e7727179d97addf2c65c9b8701ace99c918458df4a7d548e808e", "request_id": "6180ffd05ba7169acaacc9d90d18a9e9", "response_sha256": "d1d673378354a824f68a36c6957b18a2b79241281bed4f7de6699331e9270f7b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "44b286fcb592e02723959ce78acaed27dd203943030a96f0099ef53d174abb98", "request_id": "336278fdfdb5113debd24a3910edbfd5", "response_sha256": "6642461aa1b9153206de8c4aef1713dfe11f66a31905b70184b837719430dc9f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "97f178982bb38660007904b67af3816a", "candidate_priority_rank": 38598, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-26ae32f2fe858316:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-26ae32f2fe858316:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-26ae32f2fe858316:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-26ae32f2fe858316:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "decorations<->papers", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "decorations", "B": "papers"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "decorations<->papers", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2412085", "image_sha256": "9590f66722e8a5fda7153513912790b95f0b2f8adc7f94bd1e1e2996293d40b1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412085.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412085.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2378237", "image_sha256": "c87902c2fcdbdca9a0369df9b6ae68bcc660b8c21ab073db960e57c8e79f3935", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2378237.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2378237.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-26ae32f2fe858316", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "decorations", "diff_b": "papers", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "decorations", "component_b": "papers"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["decorations", "door", "drink", "hair", "magnets", "microwave", "refrigerator", "shirt", "straw", "sweater", "woman"], "detected_components": ["decorations"], "masked_program_sha256": "2d39c02ec2aeefc125b14067a8f9036baee83528e7d65637ce92ee5602a5d1ae", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["decorations", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "decorations", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["decorations", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dfba783932e6edd63de7166fe05cd601c8cd6457b176a2a86e164d2747aa8e74"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00219065", "text": "What appliance are the decorations on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinets", "ceiling", "clock", "cooker", "door", "floor", "gas stove", "kitchen", "papers", "pipe", "refrigerator", "wall"], "detected_components": ["papers"], "masked_program_sha256": "2d39c02ec2aeefc125b14067a8f9036baee83528e7d65637ce92ee5602a5d1ae", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["papers", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "papers", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["papers", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3192281514b98b6f4bd5c49a5866860c60ff8dee3920a26f4cf8dfc39ddf7c3b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0962071", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38598, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ec2d2f4c8a4a93727a011ac8b026067f856c3b0c2ded2bd671d959e100431d44", "selected_component": "papers", "selected_source_question_id": "0962071", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What appliance are the papers on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance are the on?", "program_group_hash": "ec2d2f4c8a4a93727a011ac8b026067f856c3b0c2ded2bd671d959e100431d44", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "decorations"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance are the on?", "program_group_hash": "ec2d2f4c8a4a93727a011ac8b026067f856c3b0c2ded2bd671d959e100431d44", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "papers"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "refrigerator", "full_answer": "The decorations are on the fridge.", "question": "What appliance are the decorations on?", "question_id": "00219065", "semantic": [{"argument": "decorations (203174)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,o (203165)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "gas stove", "full_answer": "The papers are on the gas stove.", "question": "What appliance are the papers on?", "question_id": "0962071", "semantic": [{"argument": "papers (561061)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,o (561052)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["203165", "203171"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["refrigerator"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["cream colored"], "query_target_entity_id": "203165", "query_target_entity_name": "refrigerator", "relation_object_entity_id": "203165", "relation_subject_entity_id": "203174", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "203174", "selected_entity_name": "decorations"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "decorations", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["203174"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "papers", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "decorations", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["561052", "561063", "561069"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["gas stove"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "561052", "query_target_entity_name": "gas stove", "relation_object_entity_id": "561052", "relation_subject_entity_id": "561061", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "561061", "selected_entity_name": "papers"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "papers", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["561061"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:97f178982bb38660007904b67af3816a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9590f66722e8a5fda7153513912790b95f0b2f8adc7f94bd1e1e2996293d40b1", "image_sha256_b": "c87902c2fcdbdca9a0369df9b6ae68bcc660b8c21ab073db960e57c8e79f3935", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "459de395d0620ec711b436667e42702da9c5fac9477542a4fd8e2cdd3c05ba00", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2ae92fd50a12ec456d17c8c792e04981", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7775187cf0fb5a9131a71b540adaa4efc5a64a89704dd5a52b1bf1eb7e48d802"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9da5499ab2da05bffe0b1d8e6ed94c7569df65011a2f917d19f34ba96b349f12", "request_id": "b99284b7aa3c76cd9e65400906eef738", "response_sha256": "e214241f1f429a3c60454079a95761874b654dc53d571f8f1a62c68ae725dc42", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3dc10a5718dd4ba07bd7c897133b56634c0ae696caee23191e0686ccdb6beba8", "request_id": "40bebad18d0713bc9a7d7b4acf0fec7c", "response_sha256": "0d7386db9673b5338f3436918c54f0f6750cffde69dfea7ef57acd14102007ae", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "candidate_key": "058dfa3569027d1356f367f4df843ad2", "candidate_priority_rank": 38737, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35187a7c0d062c28:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35187a7c0d062c28:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35187a7c0d062c28:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35187a7c0d062c28:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "pizza<->sandwich", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sandwich", "B": "pizza"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sandwich<->pizza", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2398412", "image_sha256": "bb13341df53fae37aca755404da8a9edd2324d43a4c1b864c7d7126f4edf27d3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398412.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398412.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2401947", "image_sha256": "90cea708cc4460e586610fb40eac4ee7a205c5a9579b1e4edd2ded655272baff", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401947.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401947.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-35187a7c0d062c28", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sandwich", "diff_b": "pizza", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sandwich", "component_b": "pizza"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "bun", "cheese", "fries", "onions", "pepper", "sandwich", "tray"], "detected_components": ["sandwich"], "masked_program_sha256": "80dc5a5a4325ba9c69f078b41bce7f6066a89d90bd3db68966c6056d6ffed867", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sandwich"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sandwich", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sandwich"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fa9ba141c09c631e7ff5a2b4bd16c29b1562535d6a2ec7b769338c9047427663"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19816480", "text": "What vegetables are on top of the sandwich?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cheese", "cord", "cords", "crust", "foil", "onion", "onions", "pizza", "pizza cutter", "plate", "table", "tablecloth", "wires"], "detected_components": ["pizza"], "masked_program_sha256": "80dc5a5a4325ba9c69f078b41bce7f6066a89d90bd3db68966c6056d6ffed867", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pizza", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2c4755e8f6a877abf84a8663169b9ccc1ea6b1e60b916c91234871f6ac6c4585"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13593248", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 38737, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 10, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "033d001f8da7ff6bccd5e416a60a2a41207c5df48237266535b27788ae8a5ddf", "selected_component": "pizza", "selected_source_question_id": "13593248", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What vegetables are on top of the pizza?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vegetables are on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "033d001f8da7ff6bccd5e416a60a2a41207c5df48237266535b27788ae8a5ddf", "queried_category": "vegetable", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "sandwich"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vegetables are on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "033d001f8da7ff6bccd5e416a60a2a41207c5df48237266535b27788ae8a5ddf", "queried_category": "vegetable", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "pizza"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "onions", "full_answer": "The vegetables are onions.", "question": "What vegetables are on top of the sandwich?", "question_id": "19816480", "semantic": [{"argument": "sandwich (4319324)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on top of,s (4319323)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "onions", "full_answer": "The vegetables are onions.", "question": "What vegetables are on top of the pizza?", "question_id": "13593248", "semantic": [{"argument": "pizza (1142290)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vegetable,on top of,s (1142313)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4319323", "4319337"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["onions"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4319323", "query_target_entity_name": "onions", "relation_object_entity_id": "4319324", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4319323", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4319324", "selected_entity_name": "sandwich"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sandwich", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4319324"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sandwich", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1142291", "1142313"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["onions"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1142313", "query_target_entity_name": "onions", "relation_object_entity_id": "1142290", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1142313", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1142290", "selected_entity_name": "pizza"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1142290"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:058dfa3569027d1356f367f4df843ad2", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bb13341df53fae37aca755404da8a9edd2324d43a4c1b864c7d7126f4edf27d3", "image_sha256_b": "90cea708cc4460e586610fb40eac4ee7a205c5a9579b1e4edd2ded655272baff", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "53eed1096016120a8db91ee060d7efc853f18e3aa94cf4cbc8866c91c31ea9a8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c823cea850e554645de919a0f8c4b72f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f78104f6a3cf26412887412a624bc01cce8ae8ffea27e7d785f33dc82be796b3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "363d86a7deb6c112d8460538d00ae2a1d7c0fca9c8a756d1b1a925c8f7074f07", "request_id": "f1ddbd4c945abfd8a153a6a5e1d2e6d5", "response_sha256": "308763975a4e5af82c243fa7684965b3dec0027009a6a998470438f5e62008cd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5aacc96be7e168aab270d07efb718bcf925b00852d50f7a05deb463272e7411f", "request_id": "44970f532708e9c7d1001001d0e8b52c", "response_sha256": "b80521781f97f1931ab48c5b75991de9aefb10c0f5ca71cf416c1a5504f1be5d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "f486548bbe2943a73f1141f8279c53fe", "candidate_priority_rank": 25055, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a89044eceb3fed94:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a89044eceb3fed94:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a89044eceb3fed94:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a89044eceb3fed94:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "field<->parking lot", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "parking lot", "B": "field"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "parking lot<->field", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 337, "image_id": "2343856", "image_sha256": "ead3c0bf3d116945cdc898895af9865dcea4c6e2b20e8ab9405227c8f42e3c4e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343856.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343856.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 347, "image_id": "2369037", "image_sha256": "eb4b28c4cca3a6000a54cb6821ac6e636432f015029cf385bb3607ab22b3607e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369037.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369037.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a89044eceb3fed94", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "parking lot", "diff_b": "field", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "parking lot", "component_b": "field"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "cars", "clouds", "fence", "jet", "leaves", "license plate", "parking lot", "sky", "tail", "tire", "trees", "truck", "windows", "word"], "detected_components": ["parking lot"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4b65b82473a90961ecc11c0a56a11d033667b9903bc679a60e58cdb4254b191", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["parking lot"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "parking lot", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["parking lot"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a2a2d2a53a3555b097a177d39fa435795d23c0292c8db8e69f8dfc9ac3c90a0f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10287403", "text": "What vehicles are in the parking lot?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["face", "field", "grass", "ground", "hat", "head", "horse", "jewelry", "leg", "legs", "man", "mountains", "nose", "pants", "shirt", "sky", "tractors"], "detected_components": ["field"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4b65b82473a90961ecc11c0a56a11d033667b9903bc679a60e58cdb4254b191", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "field", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2648c4c03755f4330cc1c0d18e4b53939756c4a52f96e3608d036c240b05422e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07100627", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25055, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5583be64818fa26be3f10694e8954e65aabb262a7c6f3733f9ad8ec8f718c16e", "selected_component": "field", "selected_source_question_id": "07100627", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What vehicles are in the field?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicles are in the ?", "program_group_hash": "5583be64818fa26be3f10694e8954e65aabb262a7c6f3733f9ad8ec8f718c16e", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "parking lot"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicles are in the ?", "program_group_hash": "5583be64818fa26be3f10694e8954e65aabb262a7c6f3733f9ad8ec8f718c16e", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "field"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cars", "full_answer": "The vehicles are cars.", "question": "What vehicles are in the parking lot?", "question_id": "10287403", "semantic": [{"argument": "parking lot (919327)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s (919326)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "tractors", "full_answer": "The vehicles are tractors.", "question": "What vehicles are in the field?", "question_id": "07100627", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (2280131)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s (1664818)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["919315", "919319", "919321", "919326"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cars"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["parked"], "query_target_entity_id": "919326", "query_target_entity_name": "cars", "relation_object_entity_id": "919327", "relation_subject_entity_id": "919326", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "919327", "selected_entity_name": "parking lot"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "parking lot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["919327"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "parking lot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1664818"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["tractors"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1664818", "query_target_entity_name": "tractors", "relation_object_entity_id": "2280131", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1664818", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2280131", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2280131"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f486548bbe2943a73f1141f8279c53fe", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ead3c0bf3d116945cdc898895af9865dcea4c6e2b20e8ab9405227c8f42e3c4e", "image_sha256_b": "eb4b28c4cca3a6000a54cb6821ac6e636432f015029cf385bb3607ab22b3607e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7af57a24501a3ceb74d3d4387df385d75bba087576b59479e62e7b0b4016fc46", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ebc1cc2df9cc75931eee0b4461624712", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d6bb3ffa1ce4d8bb81256ef3224ad57231c3756b49223a080d4041a95f2a2966"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9dd2b58004b3a7ac8ef8db621a942fc6752c6ff73468ef4d98a2748d8ff637da", "request_id": "2cb73834ac8b535e6f35fae8e40bcad3", "response_sha256": "94760b990ea5198b5fbcf7b37ba85a2462423bbc96f2431e91641ea2dd9f4577", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "91e1f5e7a502972617a14c59f6011662d773c9b746d7bb2bf861e54bb4f18c6d", "request_id": "9c9df6ba355d39e630478f0b14f7460a", "response_sha256": "94040a7900019be7a756d0196854522630efa34fc5afb982f688ccf1e12bc7bd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "1de055750cf08970e9404473fa77fddd", "candidate_priority_rank": 25084, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fa9798e60e9ef6b3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fa9798e60e9ef6b3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fa9798e60e9ef6b3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fa9798e60e9ef6b3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "car<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "car"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->car", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2380647", "image_sha256": "932f54ba2581ecb3664a7ff0a10f0aedbf49d026f8cd71a95f4e8fe19ec52abe", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2380647.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2380647.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 318, "image_id": "2370790", "image_sha256": "ed7e7e97e5adb0154af3236e82ec86a5ea5675d931d47893db06587c7abdc950", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2370790.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2370790.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fa9798e60e9ef6b3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "car", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "car"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.338, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.094, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.334, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": -0.006, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.006, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 2}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "material", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:material", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["castle", "collar", "door", "feet", "fence", "ground", "hair", "hand", "head", "jeans", "leg", "man", "plants", "poster", "skateboard", "skateboarder", "skater"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "77c6db110ccc8cb9f4a4aaca23ec68100c478667c5266f16e69efbc3369b1473", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "fence"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "fence"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9cedbe2d3155f8164e75f94a8a0315da714beacddc4e3a5939dd2afcb1722b02"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "041047694", "text": "What is the fence to the right of the man made of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bicycle", "car", "cloud", "dirt", "fence", "hotel", "paint", "pole", "road", "rocks", "sign", "sky", "trailer", "window", "wire"], "detected_components": ["car"], "masked_program_sha256": "77c6db110ccc8cb9f4a4aaca23ec68100c478667c5266f16e69efbc3369b1473", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["car", "fence"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "car", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["car", "fence"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "68b431a28862821c81fa8f60a1fc35d5b293a6e8f22facf1d7074f672f550f56"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "003446", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25084, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "64a273eace03ba87016c7bf5857354910ed6c84b8c1e8749514678bd22ac1ffb", "selected_component": "car", "selected_source_question_id": "003446", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the fence to the right of the car made of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fence,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "material", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the fence to the right of the made of?", "program_group_hash": "64a273eace03ba87016c7bf5857354910ed6c84b8c1e8749514678bd22ac1ffb", "queried_category": "fence", "query_role": "material", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fence,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "material", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the fence to the right of the made of?", "program_group_hash": "64a273eace03ba87016c7bf5857354910ed6c84b8c1e8749514678bd22ac1ffb", "queried_category": "fence", "query_role": "material", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "car"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "metal", "full_answer": "The fence is made of metal.", "question": "What is the fence to the right of the man made of?", "question_id": "041047694", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1344168)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fence,to the right of,s (1344173)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "material", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "wood", "full_answer": "The fence is made of wood.", "question": "What is the fence to the right of the car made of?", "question_id": "003446", "semantic": [{"argument": "car (2383314)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fence,to the right of,s (3856691)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "material", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1344173"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["metal"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["metal"], "query_target_entity_id": "1344173", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "1344168", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1344173", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1344168", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1344168"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "car", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3856691", "3856698"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wood"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "3856691", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "2383314", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3856691", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2383314", "selected_entity_name": "car"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "car", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2383314"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1de055750cf08970e9404473fa77fddd", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "932f54ba2581ecb3664a7ff0a10f0aedbf49d026f8cd71a95f4e8fe19ec52abe", "image_sha256_b": "ed7e7e97e5adb0154af3236e82ec86a5ea5675d931d47893db06587c7abdc950", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "9ea86834cc5b691d39d64e3e6f48c29f706647f0a047ac170d32558d469bab27", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5e6fde55bd8a2abdc51a44ee223539a3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4807e5169864b02d7d305066614a027addff47d09f6bbdd25b790c64b6db2302"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7f379ec182360109c55e4998adc234f97b219291161d4be0c5a4b6fdc589d0c2", "request_id": "71f60f4e5ebeb1645540da9a441d4a68", "response_sha256": "c113da2d7b81319571a01a4d23b70ca357e3ec104f520d9457c88887505505f1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "06100d10953f95e63a3313986a35768d1d87e50cd3e15abcc0f6c84c71145c37", "request_id": "26dd1c60bf838dbd09dbb39380ab5980", "response_sha256": "7863dc52bb4dc46b97f25d445d1769fdc583a091a4b23e43826fe1046dbb9e84", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "83f4770131895a4f55cf6654d49ce497", "candidate_priority_rank": 25136, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b3d5fbb39d7ba214:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b3d5fbb39d7ba214:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b3d5fbb39d7ba214:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b3d5fbb39d7ba214:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "mustard<->spinach", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "spinach", "B": "mustard"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "spinach<->mustard", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2387609", "image_sha256": "ab7f51b790223a301a4c2509cf2ff78554149b76c2ccfb54f303076d6fa412b1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387609.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387609.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2332529", "image_sha256": "c57cdfe8f0bc8e63ae3a7fbc081bda08536f9626ea493c9e4466cb5559ea557c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2332529.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2332529.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b3d5fbb39d7ba214", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "spinach", "diff_b": "mustard", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "spinach", "component_b": "mustard"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bread", "cheese", "container", "crumbs", "crust", "hand", "lettuce", "sandwich", "spinach", "thumb", "tomato"], "detected_components": ["spinach"], "masked_program_sha256": "b273d5f11a7ab9717115658f7166755f2db682ad236578546f02744476d18cc5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["spinach", "food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "spinach", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["spinach", "food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "08688a1cb7b71bfff8802d05bce9f70c37185804372317f525892b25c150046b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13690124", "text": "What type of food is the spinach on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beard", "bread", "food", "glasses", "ketchup", "man", "mustard", "napkin", "sausage", "shirt", "street light", "woman"], "detected_components": ["mustard"], "masked_program_sha256": "b273d5f11a7ab9717115658f7166755f2db682ad236578546f02744476d18cc5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mustard", "food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mustard", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mustard", "food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dc974110dc509e904ce3c60b3f4aba0aaf4de656dce165c84a906c3300bd5134"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08803197", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25136, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3f6ae8b750a5e637a859f0c71bbb85946bb8da4ee6444f6446cb5d5203efe202", "selected_component": "mustard", "selected_source_question_id": "08803197", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of food is the mustard on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of food is the on?", "program_group_hash": "3f6ae8b750a5e637a859f0c71bbb85946bb8da4ee6444f6446cb5d5203efe202", "queried_category": "food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "spinach"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of food is the on?", "program_group_hash": "3f6ae8b750a5e637a859f0c71bbb85946bb8da4ee6444f6446cb5d5203efe202", "queried_category": "food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "mustard"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sandwich", "full_answer": "The spinach is on the sandwich.", "question": "What type of food is the spinach on?", "question_id": "13690124", "semantic": [{"argument": "spinach (1274510)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,on,o (1274508)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "sausage", "full_answer": "The mustard is on the sausage.", "question": "What type of food is the mustard on?", "question_id": "08803197", "semantic": [{"argument": "mustard (969312)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,on,o (969305)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1274508", "1274511", "1274517"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sandwich"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1274508", "query_target_entity_name": "sandwich", "relation_object_entity_id": "1274508", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1274510", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1274510", "selected_entity_name": "spinach"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "spinach", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1274510"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mustard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "spinach", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["969297", "969305", "969306"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sausage"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "long"], "query_target_entity_id": "969305", "query_target_entity_name": "sausage", "relation_object_entity_id": "969305", "relation_subject_entity_id": "969312", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "969312", "selected_entity_name": "mustard"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mustard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["969312"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:83f4770131895a4f55cf6654d49ce497", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ab7f51b790223a301a4c2509cf2ff78554149b76c2ccfb54f303076d6fa412b1", "image_sha256_b": "c57cdfe8f0bc8e63ae3a7fbc081bda08536f9626ea493c9e4466cb5559ea557c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "bf2e0911e39ff9b52505ee9f1f2b6a09f75f693a385433f945383d1d633fc6a8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "97e354446ce83e631d3651d8fc7d1b3c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0f175de8c00ac56d6030020cd7216e736e1ffc17690843fb403af9c23c293a9b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "be3ae88bc83c576871f9d5e601ed918a970f200c2d89d824e03f9108765adbf6", "request_id": "54bbc990e209c01a4b666632fff54a4f", "response_sha256": "50b24857b1de67a3405b8ae01ba707637d5e560a170061de0ce938256796ac7e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "90da6fd7539619058bf91a2dc0a89efeb37a605c44418fced1f07f1cbca55269", "request_id": "c2fae806dac8333d3e7b9444e6ab7907", "response_sha256": "101e32b071d756af3c2b4d9a4be751a54077cd8de24e3ef8f8c477ca738f7467", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "84ea0c242a01ebae074fab1c006f9a11", "candidate_priority_rank": 25192, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f90b3be3769d2a0c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f90b3be3769d2a0c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f90b3be3769d2a0c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f90b3be3769d2a0c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "collar<->mask", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "collar", "B": "mask"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "collar<->mask", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2363838", "image_sha256": "c396784c773999eebe49aff26d837e5d371ab0e3a28d6c17323e1989661da8b7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2363838.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2363838.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 308, "image_id": "2356080", "image_sha256": "ceae137681cbda176ecf2f5a4d53ad2969e6f9213c8202390f4dde0bb0173996", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2356080.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2356080.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f90b3be3769d2a0c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "collar", "diff_b": "mask", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "collar", "component_b": "mask"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bell", "cat", "collar", "ear", "eye", "floor", "head", "leg", "nose", "paw", "sofa", "stuffed bear", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["collar"], "masked_program_sha256": "aa1d6e6fc8139864b3f62c95e3e3b57c0499276a5543fd4475e22f59a0dc65bc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["collar", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "collar", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["collar", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "15e6ba21702e479fcd197ecbcbb44ead90ce2d4cbe5bee061535f3e011f9993a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09925098", "text": "What type of animal is wearing a collar?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ground", "head", "horse", "leg", "legs", "man", "mask", "people", "pole", "tail"], "detected_components": ["mask"], "masked_program_sha256": "aa1d6e6fc8139864b3f62c95e3e3b57c0499276a5543fd4475e22f59a0dc65bc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mask", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mask", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mask", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "407676d031c6fd83a3c345674b30f258876bb9f21a4c77993b0eeed6841a2c3c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02697842", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25192, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9fb84a3dc849ca5c057bee1e2cc696e9eeaadba61077e9949d75eaeaaf99f7be", "selected_component": "mask", "selected_source_question_id": "02697842", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of animal is wearing a mask?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,wearing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is wearing a ?", "program_group_hash": "9fb84a3dc849ca5c057bee1e2cc696e9eeaadba61077e9949d75eaeaaf99f7be", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "collar"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,wearing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is wearing a ?", "program_group_hash": "9fb84a3dc849ca5c057bee1e2cc696e9eeaadba61077e9949d75eaeaaf99f7be", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "mask"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What type of animal is wearing a collar?", "question_id": "09925098", "semantic": [{"argument": "collar (761689)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,wearing,s (761683)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The animal is a horse.", "question": "What type of animal is wearing a mask?", "question_id": "02697842", "semantic": [{"argument": "mask (823743)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,wearing,s (823742)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["761683"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "sitting", "turned"], "query_target_entity_id": "761683", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "761689", "relation_subject_entity_id": "761683", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "761689", "selected_entity_name": "collar"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "collar", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["761689"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mask", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "collar", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["823742", "823751"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["dark"], "query_target_entity_id": "823742", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "823743", "relation_subject_entity_id": "823742", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "823743", "selected_entity_name": "mask"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mask", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["823743"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:84ea0c242a01ebae074fab1c006f9a11", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c396784c773999eebe49aff26d837e5d371ab0e3a28d6c17323e1989661da8b7", "image_sha256_b": "ceae137681cbda176ecf2f5a4d53ad2969e6f9213c8202390f4dde0bb0173996", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8016642c731d8be0ecff5e330cd2d84db2b4bcbbe2f69ed91b12a89f6cc313c3", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "457f6c497a449a39e44ef65a4d450d08", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "52fe4c12065faacc872275919856b58efe954c5860abbab23298dd30dc92dc50"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3df17c49b959282c95f67f80e2808af50f385ce4484f3680092d104657c7843d", "request_id": "ee8d16676e3da11fffb6554db8ca30c6", "response_sha256": "0e66607df4dcf504f1d58159a2838d6ea05524f062001dd18a408e944d2d9374", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "14ad2e58adafb88659634a6a1a897087437e67cf09d46f0a0b5f1d69ef8d8837", "request_id": "931787521b1997e52faf7cdff7e9ded6", "response_sha256": "44fac431dbb8a17207d471c9ccdd7cbb2b2f68d2e890b6e2eed9a7fd25d4e4f4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "175b20f06fa8b374eb8b91238c5eb41e", "candidate_priority_rank": 25239, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ccf8c3332556698d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ccf8c3332556698d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ccf8c3332556698d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ccf8c3332556698d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "trees<->windows", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "windows", "B": "trees"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "windows<->trees", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2370507", "image_sha256": "aee6a93609cd91033a75129cf930a6834ebe5d1331e960953cf10f49678b85ea", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2370507.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2370507.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 335, "image_id": "2358636", "image_sha256": "b9d29e603cbd01def373cddb73523a2bbb5c82553ea1f5e6dc956c3f18d49042", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2358636.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2358636.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ccf8c3332556698d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "windows", "diff_b": "trees", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "windows", "component_b": "trees"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arms", "blinds", "curtain", "dress", "ear", "eye", "eyes", "face", "flower", "girl", "hair", "hand", "leaves", "lips", "mouth", "nose", "sofa", "wii controller", "windows"], "detected_components": ["windows"], "masked_program_sha256": "f0ac5f4c7e458380c526488af9758a361c7b8fafdb2c91a8abab09803e80f1fc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["windows"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "windows", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["windows"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1f25d2020f580b06c1762cd0aaa95be56b37506a40fefdbf4444dc6a38761a74"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00852452", "text": "What are the windows covered with?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boy", "branches", "child", "goggles", "hat", "head", "helmet", "jacket", "number", "ski", "skis", "snow", "trees"], "detected_components": ["trees"], "masked_program_sha256": "f0ac5f4c7e458380c526488af9758a361c7b8fafdb2c91a8abab09803e80f1fc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["trees"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "trees", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["trees"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0712be25b245b509b6d7f03a9f6674602d99c15b059db826d6d6f0dd0370b481"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08757222", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25239, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 10, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5365b967f431cbbc957b645eb8820e9e029ab56f5a497e556889042d5bbc608e", "selected_component": "trees", "selected_source_question_id": "08757222", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the trees covered with?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,covered with,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the covered with?", "program_group_hash": "5365b967f431cbbc957b645eb8820e9e029ab56f5a497e556889042d5bbc608e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "covered with", "select_category": "windows"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,covered with,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the covered with?", "program_group_hash": "5365b967f431cbbc957b645eb8820e9e029ab56f5a497e556889042d5bbc608e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "covered with", "select_category": "trees"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "blinds", "full_answer": "The windows are covered with blinds.", "question": "What are the windows covered with?", "question_id": "00852452", "semantic": [{"argument": "windows (603586)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,covered with,o (603585)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "snow", "full_answer": "The trees are covered with snow.", "question": "What are the trees covered with?", "question_id": "08757222", "semantic": [{"argument": "trees (2033088)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,covered with,o (3543586)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["603582", "603583", "603584", "603585", "603587", "603588", "603589", "603590", "603591", "603592", "603594", "603595", "603597", "603600", "603601", "603602", "603603", "603604"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blinds"], "predicate": "covered with", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["closed", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "603585", "query_target_entity_name": "blinds", "relation_object_entity_id": "603585", "relation_subject_entity_id": "603586", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "603586", "selected_entity_name": "windows"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "windows", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["603586"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "trees", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "windows", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1679232", "1695194", "1695195", "2039906", "2060152", "2241997", "2248315", "2248316", "2248317", "2278552", "2278553", "2349144", "2689587", "3543586", "3690272", "3768136", "3768138", "3768139"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["snow"], "predicate": "covered with", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3543586", "query_target_entity_name": "snow", "relation_object_entity_id": "3543586", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2033088", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2033088", "selected_entity_name": "trees"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "trees", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2033088"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:175b20f06fa8b374eb8b91238c5eb41e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "aee6a93609cd91033a75129cf930a6834ebe5d1331e960953cf10f49678b85ea", "image_sha256_b": "b9d29e603cbd01def373cddb73523a2bbb5c82553ea1f5e6dc956c3f18d49042", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1a2cb01e2c8af84657d6f97d8c226c7abc392454e8f74eb5bd5f6ada70529c5f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "dfaf68702fba517dda1be1437b76b067", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "73b64fea3adb9d22e2166fb15207bbc9ab8441f7a87e2d717faf1ca6b52e1248"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d712c6c33092b98f4e580a7f2b2305941d6886bb6847e876d7ea8d081bf4ef21", "request_id": "c2376b28b907a6cd5eef0bc2ec73b88b", "response_sha256": "41c1490047ebc3924f8af415bcb8f4d5573f06dfa43020921fdad5f253c6570c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a46ff63f9d0ba93c3c86b7d24a74c73e215d3cc12ba0b6faa75e3f6735767d13", "request_id": "29e23d45764e0953dacb418efd78159d", "response_sha256": "7ed42518a7531f16b9155074085e08dd31a831b6308705cdf64ea4a6c44775b6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "0526990ff22897494b365323616e7e1b", "candidate_priority_rank": 25331, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-055bb3dfb4cf9021:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-055bb3dfb4cf9021:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-055bb3dfb4cf9021:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-055bb3dfb4cf9021:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blinds<->drapes", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "blinds", "B": "drapes"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blinds<->drapes", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2376657", "image_sha256": "070d2617114755ecbdbe8115b6e25b2e0d9fbfa85a7499be286bc07f3301e692", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376657.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376657.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2386684", "image_sha256": "22398ffe1fee4997448984b4aea5e6eb8a1a38b28573f7dd00ee2c083b9bc207", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386684.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386684.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-055bb3dfb4cf9021", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blinds", "diff_b": "drapes", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blinds", "component_b": "drapes"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "blinds", "burner", "cabinet door", "counter", "cupboards", "cutting board", "dishwasher", "door", "drawer", "floor", "kitchen", "microwave", "paper towel", "refrigerator", "sink", "stove", "tag", "toaster", "towel", "wall"], "detected_components": ["blinds"], "masked_program_sha256": "84ba65943002901feedfb3abe8993d646991053ad7b6fb5566a14621994a7214", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blinds"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blinds", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blinds"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "269ff2191f9de214a7d61fc6485de0e360e38f00f7bab528b747978fce2ad025"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08477609", "text": "What are the blinds hanging on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["air conditioner", "bed", "chair", "desk", "drapes", "floor", "hotel room", "lamp", "mirror", "nightstand", "picture", "pillow", "remote control", "sheet", "shelf", "table", "television", "wall", "windows"], "detected_components": ["drapes"], "masked_program_sha256": "84ba65943002901feedfb3abe8993d646991053ad7b6fb5566a14621994a7214", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["drapes"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "drapes", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["drapes"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c245dcd1be53ed268c2c42761e371b45bd1eaa82bef9d4b98b00eb811d10a74a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10950197", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25331, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f97f55da569e0be8fef869ab44e650fc401726ba75b78732270eadee0f52c3d9", "selected_component": "drapes", "selected_source_question_id": "10950197", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the drapes hanging on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the hanging on?", "program_group_hash": "f97f55da569e0be8fef869ab44e650fc401726ba75b78732270eadee0f52c3d9", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "blinds"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the hanging on?", "program_group_hash": "f97f55da569e0be8fef869ab44e650fc401726ba75b78732270eadee0f52c3d9", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hanging on", "select_category": "drapes"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "door", "full_answer": "The blinds are hanging on the door.", "question": "What are the blinds hanging on?", "question_id": "08477609", "semantic": [{"argument": "blinds (570979)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,o (570976)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "windows", "full_answer": "The draperies are hanging on the windows.", "question": "What are the drapes hanging on?", "question_id": "10950197", "semantic": [{"argument": "drapes (1283641)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging on,o (1283642)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["570970", "570971", "570972", "570973", "570974", "570975", "570976", "570977", "570980", "570981", "570982", "570983", "570984", "570985", "570986", "570987", "570988", "570989", "570990", "570991", "570992", "570993", "570994", "570997", "570998", "571001", "571002", "571006", "571007", "571008", "571010", "571011"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 32, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["door"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "570976", "query_target_entity_name": "door", "relation_object_entity_id": "570976", "relation_subject_entity_id": "570979", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "570979", "selected_entity_name": "blinds"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blinds", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["570979"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "drapes", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blinds", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1283627", "1283628", "1283629", "1283630", "1283631", "1283632", "1283633", "1283634", "1283635", "1283636", "1283637", "1283638", "1283639", "1283640", "1283642", "1283643", "1283644", "1283645", "1283646", "1283647", "1283648"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["windows"], "predicate": "hanging on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1283642", "query_target_entity_name": "windows", "relation_object_entity_id": "1283642", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1283641", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1283641", "selected_entity_name": "drapes"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "drapes", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1283641"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0526990ff22897494b365323616e7e1b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "070d2617114755ecbdbe8115b6e25b2e0d9fbfa85a7499be286bc07f3301e692", "image_sha256_b": "22398ffe1fee4997448984b4aea5e6eb8a1a38b28573f7dd00ee2c083b9bc207", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1ea7174baf53fda1cde93726ca6c415fba10fce2ed3c875a4a46637b75ddf192", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "259bc5b3deeec84a80b694767a5d5735", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "bfb9b3e1a9f5ef847bf901ae2f6ee88a036a3a8f42743e14bf632cab8cf56fb8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b686364b69d55e82c6682be546c6c2d914d809586356ad61936defb529cc0368", "request_id": "a0ca2368fe7b7a95df8fe969d3ef4133", "response_sha256": "e9c62f10c8baa1a6694322be0393c89a4ce349d90420ddb5b958d2437ac89856", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8b1514789fa58de3c36afd48627080eaecb0a17c0ead5d437a4c71033e2a1c62", "request_id": "27984c7d2d8a4c34320c79adf1fc6686", "response_sha256": "5e269a0c2fe5c0e255cdc9f27050cbbf3d0e2d88aa88416802066182e7eb3c5d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "b729f794a35d37e0c16812bb9d44ec0b", "candidate_priority_rank": 25338, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73f2bbb102d03cd8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73f2bbb102d03cd8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73f2bbb102d03cd8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73f2bbb102d03cd8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "horse<->pole", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "pole", "B": "horse"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "pole<->horse", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2361825", "image_sha256": "bf7f7d95dabb91c40df0a1827aa50cf962f714046cc2591ce9c42ae2c065a23c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2361825.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2361825.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2405227", "image_sha256": "aa7709b099040fbb120a6669158bbb3db02e91e4c3ce9f24f51c71fdfbd8e5af", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405227.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405227.jpg", "width": 491}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-73f2bbb102d03cd8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "pole", "diff_b": "horse", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "pole", "component_b": "horse"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arrow", "branch", "broom", "building", "flag", "ground", "letter", "pole", "sign", "sticker", "tree", "wall", "window", "words"], "detected_components": ["pole"], "masked_program_sha256": "cb8024a5cbc866d1014dd3dae39651043feaee9f18441c5b1917efe35ec171b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pole", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pole"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2160b23214be2ca6322a2e198f3b98c7813f50ae21158b251e3f08542964b1f4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08132690", "text": "What is tied to the pole?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "ears", "fence", "ground", "hay", "horse", "leaves", "legs", "mountains", "nose", "palm tree", "rope", "sky", "spots", "tail", "tree", "trees"], "detected_components": ["horse"], "masked_program_sha256": "cb8024a5cbc866d1014dd3dae39651043feaee9f18441c5b1917efe35ec171b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["horse"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "horse", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["horse"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a9ed381b542d00854557626be8e8600f4bb761022a8b2eb4e89684b59c5d5620"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10130629", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25338, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e44b647c95fddd6c93e9245198af202fbfbcac9930e86797b206e02174aa71a2", "selected_component": "horse", "selected_source_question_id": "10130629", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is tied to the horse?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,tied to,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is tied to the ?", "program_group_hash": "e44b647c95fddd6c93e9245198af202fbfbcac9930e86797b206e02174aa71a2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "tied to", "select_category": "pole"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,tied to,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is tied to the ?", "program_group_hash": "e44b647c95fddd6c93e9245198af202fbfbcac9930e86797b206e02174aa71a2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "tied to", "select_category": "horse"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "flag", "full_answer": "The flag is tied to the pole.", "question": "What is tied to the pole?", "question_id": "08132690", "semantic": [{"argument": "pole (2310355)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,tied to,s (1699980)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "rope", "full_answer": "The rope is tied to the horse.", "question": "What is tied to the horse?", "question_id": "10130629", "semantic": [{"argument": "horse (1109648)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,tied to,s (1109656)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1699980", "1781111", "1781113", "1781114", "1827372", "1959164", "1989869", "1989870", "1989871", "1989872", "1989873", "2019761", "2225055", "2289714", "2291493", "2469171", "2611688", "2611689", "2611691", "3753201", "3753206", "3753207", "3753208", "3753211", "3753212"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 25, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["flag"], "predicate": "tied to", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1699980", "query_target_entity_name": "flag", "relation_object_entity_id": "2310355", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1699980", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2310355", "selected_entity_name": "pole"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pole", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2310355"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "horse", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pole", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1109650", "1109651", "1109652", "1109653", "1109654", "1109656", "1109657", "1109658", "1109659", "1109660", "1109661", "1109662", "1109663", "1109664", "1109666", "1109668", "1109669"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["rope"], "predicate": "tied to", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1109656", "query_target_entity_name": "rope", "relation_object_entity_id": "1109648", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1109656", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1109648", "selected_entity_name": "horse"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "horse", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1109648"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b729f794a35d37e0c16812bb9d44ec0b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bf7f7d95dabb91c40df0a1827aa50cf962f714046cc2591ce9c42ae2c065a23c", "image_sha256_b": "aa7709b099040fbb120a6669158bbb3db02e91e4c3ce9f24f51c71fdfbd8e5af", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1701e884a0e9ac99ec194b8cd7d9f549cd18415ebc35c75e45efaa38e2437ee8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f6241e3a3f8e7abe0be55347cbe61fa1", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "afdf3029940dabe12cfaa3492ffde7efaee580f0239b8c00ebe9bbdce0419fd1"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1fdc12117a179b143f3697139f98490150433bb2a6465f6764f33e64cba2d900", "request_id": "e1c85553984e2e7cb53a3808216f1df5", "response_sha256": "f1c01fb0d175e918993b10857f5afd57a8a9de7fcc3d03f387145ae6de6f06d6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a8be1551aa541667e0e12f6230eca4952fa630f0cd771867c815a8ec1321583f", "request_id": "8bd1c41fce2393ccbb35c49dbfd93261", "response_sha256": "3357d2143f876d7ff440da924bcfa3d7656ca310bb9e8c346b49adc33a8eff40", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "2700d4518357a9b23a36b76b6e055353", "candidate_priority_rank": 25397, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-888132c0e6056a09:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-888132c0e6056a09:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-888132c0e6056a09:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-888132c0e6056a09:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "children<->officers", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "children", "B": "officers"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "children<->officers", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2398103", "image_sha256": "4c785054b6e756e43d56935d3d07bb210f8c3f257b731646b26d4ce0a2b042b9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398103.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398103.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2319082", "image_sha256": "a7f22aa0c71293af8a07a6e6a1fe8802615c313ab7e8c258fd85a0657fbe5c79", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2319082.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2319082.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-888132c0e6056a09", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "children", "diff_b": "officers", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "children", "component_b": "officers"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "children", "crowd", "elephants", "hat", "leaves", "man", "pants", "people", "roof", "shirt", "tail", "trees", "wires"], "detected_components": ["children"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f0cd62d73f2d51060c3522e8973a56f92665ad2169bb3a615a99d47fa93c4e8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["children", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "children", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["children", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "38e79fd3e43dfe03f0d78cd09eaf6b9913edea2b76445f2586eff9e5e5e75ead"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16135349", "text": "What animal are the children sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bike", "building", "bus", "horses", "jacket", "lamp", "officers", "person", "pole", "sign", "street", "tire", "uniform", "window"], "detected_components": ["officers"], "masked_program_sha256": "2f0cd62d73f2d51060c3522e8973a56f92665ad2169bb3a615a99d47fa93c4e8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["officers", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "officers", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["officers", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e3f5e7cacf3ad0c9aef12de43abe22271aafd9b050056f22d72e71d51c2701e8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13889239", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25397, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "fe6d2ec168084d994c4df2fd58af6823756fbcb4203c65961627f16fb2206677", "selected_component": "officers", "selected_source_question_id": "13889239", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal are the officers sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal are the sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "fe6d2ec168084d994c4df2fd58af6823756fbcb4203c65961627f16fb2206677", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "children"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal are the sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "fe6d2ec168084d994c4df2fd58af6823756fbcb4203c65961627f16fb2206677", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "officers"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "elephants", "full_answer": "The children are sitting on the elephants.", "question": "What animal are the children sitting on?", "question_id": "16135349", "semantic": [{"argument": "children (1182740)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sitting on,o (1182718)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "horses", "full_answer": "The officers are sitting on the horses.", "question": "What animal are the officers sitting on?", "question_id": "13889239", "semantic": [{"argument": "officers (1004820)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sitting on,o (1004819)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1182718"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["decorated", "gray", "grey", "large", "walking"], "query_target_entity_id": "1182718", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "1182718", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1182740", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1182740", "selected_entity_name": "children"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "children", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1182740"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "officers", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "children", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1004819"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horses"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1004819", "query_target_entity_name": "horses", "relation_object_entity_id": "1004819", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1004820", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1004820", "selected_entity_name": "officers"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "officers", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1004820"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:2700d4518357a9b23a36b76b6e055353", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4c785054b6e756e43d56935d3d07bb210f8c3f257b731646b26d4ce0a2b042b9", "image_sha256_b": "a7f22aa0c71293af8a07a6e6a1fe8802615c313ab7e8c258fd85a0657fbe5c79", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8221679efa9c5a95a4d39d6913ea2f4b1979f771653e3209ff5037a8b6288aff", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2617cc5fde9c29c625aefa7eea5e2f2a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "929491c4e54c6fd8d343bda853aa9086aeb6b40534d3e86207d78cb166b03534"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "12b2b7ba0e191ac5ce65af4e7ef70a9b65ca72e62c8c987e3a62af9057d65f15", "request_id": "5d29e0a9d2a120d7088815164730577a", "response_sha256": "3b34a0cf7f23dcaa9d6a71de8a2e22f79de1fb7204da5ca9a5bd18ed12ce9e84", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bafa754b60dd4bbd200dce8bd4c200ff669d1c8a0a834f9de4771f2dafd2ff75", "request_id": "ea3252b3f76fd863ee43278a45c1cc1c", "response_sha256": "43a2357edf8d3a65f741889074646b8eece3deac4909605dbbc3100b0fa9b5cd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "02c18490c109a25e8cf77c276eeaa021", "candidate_priority_rank": 25408, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d83138d533e98098:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d83138d533e98098:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d83138d533e98098:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d83138d533e98098:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cheese<->fork", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "fork", "B": "cheese"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "fork<->cheese", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2360064", "image_sha256": "65943205d1d86f4e5d61d2dbc804b4e0455dfa6c9ffba60aee1a87edb4d77488", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2360064.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2360064.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2401869", "image_sha256": "462e98c82588b18361f4e8ecc37fcc790abeedf8eaa94a2bc65c2420ec1de1e9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401869.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401869.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d83138d533e98098", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "fork", "diff_b": "cheese", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "fork", "component_b": "cheese"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.328, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.178, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.234, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": -0.024, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.024, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["carrot", "chocolate", "cup", "fork", "glass", "gravy", "liquid", "meat", "pineapple", "plate", "sauce", "saucer", "spoon", "table"], "detected_components": ["fork"], "masked_program_sha256": "d3d50c738a62d56e4fa54ff3f9ae0321488668d1aafd33a4e42d44cf4ef9ba29", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fork", "meat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "fork", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fork", "meat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c625e9c055a2b5ba08deddb8ab0ee8ede97a6e1c2cd7468056e8f96bf3d91247"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07675487", "text": "What color is the meat to the left of the fork?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "cheese", "dish", "fork", "fruit", "grape", "grapes", "meat", "napkin", "paper", "sandwich", "table"], "detected_components": ["cheese"], "masked_program_sha256": "d3d50c738a62d56e4fa54ff3f9ae0321488668d1aafd33a4e42d44cf4ef9ba29", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cheese", "meat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cheese", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cheese", "meat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "95b947d804e2f0fccfc9ce52892a7f436519fbc170d0aa88d76b79b4df51b320"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03352698", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25408, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ea7b0fc1cad47ce08c60c2efedbbfeeda8315522ad496aca347abdb4371e3886", "selected_component": "cheese", "selected_source_question_id": "03352698", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color is the meat to the left of the cheese?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "meat,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the meat to the left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "ea7b0fc1cad47ce08c60c2efedbbfeeda8315522ad496aca347abdb4371e3886", "queried_category": "meat", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "fork"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "meat,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the meat to the left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "ea7b0fc1cad47ce08c60c2efedbbfeeda8315522ad496aca347abdb4371e3886", "queried_category": "meat", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "cheese"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dark brown", "full_answer": "The meat is dark brown.", "question": "What color is the meat to the left of the fork?", "question_id": "07675487", "semantic": [{"argument": "fork (789882)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "meat,to the left of,s (789875)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pink", "full_answer": "The meat is pink.", "question": "What color is the meat to the left of the cheese?", "question_id": "03352698", "semantic": [{"argument": "cheese (1143234)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "meat,to the left of,s (1143226)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["789875"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dark brown"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["dark brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "789875", "query_target_entity_name": "meat", "relation_object_entity_id": "789882", "relation_subject_entity_id": "789875", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "789882", "selected_entity_name": "fork"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fork", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["789882"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cheese", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1143226"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fork", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1143221"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1143226"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["folded", "pink"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["folded", "pink"], "query_target_entity_id": "1143226", "query_target_entity_name": "meat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1143234", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1143226", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1143234", "selected_entity_name": "cheese"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cheese", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1143234"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:02c18490c109a25e8cf77c276eeaa021", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "65943205d1d86f4e5d61d2dbc804b4e0455dfa6c9ffba60aee1a87edb4d77488", "image_sha256_b": "462e98c82588b18361f4e8ecc37fcc790abeedf8eaa94a2bc65c2420ec1de1e9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4c13795024029500de4485fd02c4d3882434f39f32754a3ba263d75f4324860a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2c53ba97c721763fd956506d1ea458bd", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5b091bfbf97260ec717aa4fcadca6bc185825a2165809a6464627878da22f210"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5c26bd000e2e4b1761aae5572460f75486eea68f31e518becc60412e5a142af3", "request_id": "514def1d0e318ae320c35ccaa4e559aa", "response_sha256": "57381b9c0686c2e261fda8e68c0536f2b9a1e89e34605045d8fed3b4fc515976", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e6eaf705ddf2c760cecec6d2777e66e3f72b8bdcbdf479d98d73226d2206a7f2", "request_id": "5dbd883ffc7e1b8c6e068145e6392c7b", "response_sha256": "273c103e8a54f3747b3e20ffd4038e9f43dab417a787dafed0025a93fecdf0a4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "18a03b6abda36d9d4f2a4bfe7907d19c", "candidate_priority_rank": 25635, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ae106f1d692dcfd:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ae106f1d692dcfd:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ae106f1d692dcfd:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ae106f1d692dcfd:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "foil<->lid", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "lid", "B": "foil"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "lid<->foil", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2365121", "image_sha256": "7d0167178230a5f5ff875a0bfce3467e7f4dda43872a36a4bc91e165a6cb9f4b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365121.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365121.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2343463", "image_sha256": "8e1e7bf73c8943cdba1f759381b7bced181d4508d09744b42ea6519bb693d66a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343463.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343463.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ae106f1d692dcfd", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "lid", "diff_b": "foil", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "lid", "component_b": "foil"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["baking pan", "burner", "cabinet", "door", "hook", "lid", "oven", "wall"], "detected_components": ["lid"], "masked_program_sha256": "7bfded0b6d2c9d7254979190210c051e0ec630213784ed5ed97e2c29b9c12c0f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["lid", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "lid", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["lid", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b711812350bf20c027e60cc80835ec39a50b6182dd6bf1a49f391f79646a8af8"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10249337", "text": "What cooking utensil is the lid covering?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "door", "foil", "food", "hair", "hand", "oven", "pan", "person", "stove", "symbol", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["foil"], "masked_program_sha256": "7bfded0b6d2c9d7254979190210c051e0ec630213784ed5ed97e2c29b9c12c0f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["foil", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "foil", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["foil", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1852255283a39f91d9f150168a4bd4d1a6e7fc37cd80d256114435865c733e2d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11957537", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25635, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9bcfff8c034ac07753c99dc70b2cd331554c7f173fbe12faddb78a1a24a58b7f", "selected_component": "foil", "selected_source_question_id": "11957537", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What cooking utensil is the foil covering?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,covering,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what cooking utensil is the covering?", "program_group_hash": "9bcfff8c034ac07753c99dc70b2cd331554c7f173fbe12faddb78a1a24a58b7f", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "covering", "select_category": "lid"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,covering,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what cooking utensil is the covering?", "program_group_hash": "9bcfff8c034ac07753c99dc70b2cd331554c7f173fbe12faddb78a1a24a58b7f", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "covering", "select_category": "foil"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "baking pan", "full_answer": "The lid is covering the baking pan.", "question": "What cooking utensil is the lid covering?", "question_id": "10249337", "semantic": [{"argument": "lid (3885989)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,covering,o (2443344)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pan", "full_answer": "The foil is covering the pan.", "question": "What cooking utensil is the foil covering?", "question_id": "11957537", "semantic": [{"argument": "foil (923392)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,covering,o (923400)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2443344"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["baking pan"], "predicate": "covering", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2443344", "query_target_entity_name": "baking pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "2443344", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3885989", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3885989", "selected_entity_name": "lid"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lid", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3885989"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "foil", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lid", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["923400"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pan"], "predicate": "covering", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["cooking"], "query_target_entity_id": "923400", "query_target_entity_name": "pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "923400", "relation_subject_entity_id": "923392", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "923392", "selected_entity_name": "foil"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "foil", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["923392"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:18a03b6abda36d9d4f2a4bfe7907d19c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7d0167178230a5f5ff875a0bfce3467e7f4dda43872a36a4bc91e165a6cb9f4b", "image_sha256_b": "8e1e7bf73c8943cdba1f759381b7bced181d4508d09744b42ea6519bb693d66a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "438ce0b0ffb07f0927cf668d3a032cd63477a9b6d55784fcd9d8fa3e56cd3dcc", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c26a7a9126f70973820f7ee4e4baa756", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c6ec7b4ad2e0cc4e99b4783bf8895c36607979fff36a48c031c8608caaef744b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6477182a3984cd426df22be390e4e7ffaf4e992377d9de7aaafc7ecdefacadd1", "request_id": "51838e53ab1c85d346208f8ecbf011ab", "response_sha256": "4e94b94fff56c9bea6c551d25427b129c2c4abb1c15aa3936a7f494635dac1fc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "79ea1399c4a3b9454de84ca4fc1574b5a3c5411f7d4affd7bff35845e3f1df40", "request_id": "94394eea718da45d7cd0faf4ce73b5da", "response_sha256": "5889c1b714717de6faecd0b7f44db23302778f87afc91a9bc36724e7dc7659eb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "0441b390da546ddd1ca8dcdd594158ae", "candidate_priority_rank": 25699, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3dc959949aa6d95:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3dc959949aa6d95:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3dc959949aa6d95:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3dc959949aa6d95:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bed<->refrigerator", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bed", "B": "refrigerator"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bed<->refrigerator", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2357139", "image_sha256": "91df1805f259f803cb7b4ec3ff29a21974be5465da0912f936182b968608e6c4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2357139.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2357139.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2365742", "image_sha256": "e9539886816f47450692696ce61036f3b88588b3806b2e529e9f53adbb52a81c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365742.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365742.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3dc959949aa6d95", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bed", "diff_b": "refrigerator", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bed", "component_b": "refrigerator"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bottle", "cap", "chair", "curtain", "desk", "desk lamp", "envelope", "glass", "hotel room", "notebook", "phone", "pillows", "remote control", "sheets", "table", "window"], "detected_components": ["bed"], "masked_program_sha256": "24e8169fc0ba53d75a30f447dbeb6ce3af9b2ea01c1f0cdf8cccfd41f1d45403", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bed", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c4f5b132681d460cf26e36c47defc89729de3bce253db477f4b30562c78a581b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01630956", "text": "What is stacked on the bed?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "bowl", "bowls", "cds", "chair", "end table", "floor", "fruits", "painting", "picture", "pillow", "refrigerator", "room", "rug", "sofa", "speaker", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["refrigerator"], "masked_program_sha256": "24e8169fc0ba53d75a30f447dbeb6ce3af9b2ea01c1f0cdf8cccfd41f1d45403", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["refrigerator"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "refrigerator", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["refrigerator"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0e3487ec7972bc7b474c22ea66637e90b7ea8710a2c64358a71fd58e16684341"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1928972", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25699, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 12, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "dc58e1297b92c41313685d6a03f2efd1f5330c7e1b9b9254dbebdf5ccc28d39e", "selected_component": "refrigerator", "selected_source_question_id": "1928972", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is stacked on the refrigerator?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,stacked on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is stacked on the ?", "program_group_hash": "dc58e1297b92c41313685d6a03f2efd1f5330c7e1b9b9254dbebdf5ccc28d39e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "stacked on", "select_category": "bed"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,stacked on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is stacked on the ?", "program_group_hash": "dc58e1297b92c41313685d6a03f2efd1f5330c7e1b9b9254dbebdf5ccc28d39e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "stacked on", "select_category": "refrigerator"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pillows", "full_answer": "The pillows are stacked on the bed.", "question": "What is stacked on the bed?", "question_id": "01630956", "semantic": [{"argument": "bed (814574)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,stacked on,s (814573)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bowls", "full_answer": "The bowls are stacked on the refrigerator.", "question": "What is stacked on the refrigerator?", "question_id": "1928972", "semantic": [{"argument": "refrigerator (632265)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,stacked on,s (632266)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3770741", "3770742", "3770743", "3770745", "814556", "814557", "814560", "814561", "814562", "814563", "814564", "814565", "814566", "814569", "814570", "814571", "814573", "814575"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pillows"], "predicate": "stacked on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "814573", "query_target_entity_name": "pillows", "relation_object_entity_id": "814574", "relation_subject_entity_id": "814573", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "814574", "selected_entity_name": "bed"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["814574"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "refrigerator", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["632258", "632259", "632260", "632261", "632262", "632263", "632264", "632266", "632267", "632268", "632269", "632270", "632272", "632275", "632276", "632277", "632278", "632279"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bowls"], "predicate": "stacked on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "632266", "query_target_entity_name": "bowls", "relation_object_entity_id": "632265", "relation_subject_entity_id": "632266", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "632265", "selected_entity_name": "refrigerator"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "refrigerator", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["632265"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0441b390da546ddd1ca8dcdd594158ae", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "91df1805f259f803cb7b4ec3ff29a21974be5465da0912f936182b968608e6c4", "image_sha256_b": "e9539886816f47450692696ce61036f3b88588b3806b2e529e9f53adbb52a81c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e125fa2f23bb33b7055656cd49944705990631f67056266758f25b232f7715e2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1189d7f2ac6e1595c0d153a8938bd310", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7e8816b05f7e736a8374ab96e362273f2c5c01eaedacfdf99754812fb65620b9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c41e15d163fc36a2cb9e3e1fbda78583614e6be03b87d7ea88687a3999d40198", "request_id": "01d330ad5efe4531da7401677f5f16a2", "response_sha256": "9287260891d3711b4a1d60963e43eb8055d1e7d1581851de77865f4f0c28d32a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bb22aa7ff77d43d3302409bbd9cb405e2cb698815e70523c5e5f33b6b69a8e1f", "request_id": "5d50a5fbafa7e785174773fef8c6aa6f", "response_sha256": "26ec6399792fcf2b1f88dfbd1e9245ecb530475552f724667959c5a0a6bee9b4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "69cfa55f5d164f092aa0a321cab16561", "candidate_priority_rank": 25708, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-080d732b3786e7db:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-080d732b3786e7db:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-080d732b3786e7db:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-080d732b3786e7db:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "boat<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "boat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->boat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 329, "image_id": "2375797", "image_sha256": "b3cfe5b9f25bfd9fd8e1d084c8a0638a9f114dfca499ca7da1c6699203fa508d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2375797.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2375797.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2343136", "image_sha256": "71e0ccd608fcc761f4e7a7e27476f09e6140db98a259945c9e4f85b7e21b05be", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343136.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343136.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-080d732b3786e7db", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "boat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "boat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "ground", "hair", "hand", "head", "legs", "man", "shirt", "surfboard", "water"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "8663e766efa40aac060f82ad7694427b0fe7d2f214177de64fae35f61c2c464e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "water"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "water"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d2d6863fe596d131367e2a5b502e641de843bb62b1d70afd7bc2706df3dfc955"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1198852", "text": "What is the color of the water the man is in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boat", "building", "crane", "ring", "rope", "sky", "water", "window"], "detected_components": ["boat"], "masked_program_sha256": "8663e766efa40aac060f82ad7694427b0fe7d2f214177de64fae35f61c2c464e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boat", "water"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "boat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boat", "water"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a32997f2b25714583aec0ba9661f4ecd11e1692310a88c99cb131b32e19e2fff"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05875620", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25708, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2aeba9981fe87506fcb117adad04124f74f4d531ddbf31def63941c2761e4186", "selected_component": "boat", "selected_source_question_id": "05875620", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the color of the water the boat is in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "water,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the color of the water the is in?", "program_group_hash": "2aeba9981fe87506fcb117adad04124f74f4d531ddbf31def63941c2761e4186", "queried_category": "water", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "water,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the color of the water the is in?", "program_group_hash": "2aeba9981fe87506fcb117adad04124f74f4d531ddbf31def63941c2761e4186", "queried_category": "water", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "boat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "brown", "full_answer": "The water is brown.", "question": "What is the color of the water the man is in?", "question_id": "1198852", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (3841422)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "water,in,o (3841421)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "brown", "full_answer": "The water is brown.", "question": "What is the color of the water the boat is in?", "question_id": "05875620", "semantic": [{"argument": "boat (926954)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "water,in,o (926952)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1774110", "1786719", "1953738", "3841421", "3841423"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["brown"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "3841421", "query_target_entity_name": "water", "relation_object_entity_id": "3841421", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3841422", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3841422", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3841422"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["926952"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["brown"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "926952", "query_target_entity_name": "water", "relation_object_entity_id": "926952", "relation_subject_entity_id": "926954", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "926954", "selected_entity_name": "boat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["926954"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:69cfa55f5d164f092aa0a321cab16561", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b3cfe5b9f25bfd9fd8e1d084c8a0638a9f114dfca499ca7da1c6699203fa508d", "image_sha256_b": "71e0ccd608fcc761f4e7a7e27476f09e6140db98a259945c9e4f85b7e21b05be", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "22569f7b75ab47d33597d3216906afa57d88bb18ee282e66ff1f7cb1f58b6084", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "464b580f541aef18766152854a0cd755", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4d9e0e715bce9fde38c32e53a4bcaf07d2253ededb43b4773ebfb0a9a5e29f95"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3ad068fbd794815cb3b6af7f732cda673d74c2b1cf0d0232075263beb15852c5", "request_id": "12e5fb3613ad22f3972b717701e3cdb4", "response_sha256": "61dc43e401904f88c8ea7535b6d717fc9d142a55a4934160cb3c0c9a70d346ed", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "594e845730e838c8cf92e40c3adebb32b2555deb64e8c51122bcae081c0a11fc", "request_id": "d8d03df1fc5ecad72c1415836e66602b", "response_sha256": "afd85d458b3c580c253c2d6af0aeb3285aadef35c1bd0f98d57f8ee0a81622f0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "a47b6781ab2a8a632a23dab02564e86c", "candidate_priority_rank": 25715, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-485bcab2c25ba96f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-485bcab2c25ba96f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-485bcab2c25ba96f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-485bcab2c25ba96f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "boy<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "boy", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "boy<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2351468", "image_sha256": "ab5c934f35042511c8c5a4ef4775d56a24c824e3650a5d907a0434872ecf47fa", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2351468.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2351468.jpg", "width": 335}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2377302", "image_sha256": "5b08141b5c6b30c896c69e880b97a56d160970a2b458474b9189df2ee21bd8d6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2377302.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2377302.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-485bcab2c25ba96f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "boy", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "boy", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "boy", "ear", "eye", "ground", "hand", "head", "net", "shirt", "shorts", "sneakers", "soccer ball", "sock"], "detected_components": ["boy"], "masked_program_sha256": "ab43683b3bf040eb9383d864afa81f266f2dedbd32ec70fb8274401e2877ebb7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "boy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b01f33aea4795be7e87b30d667b418dd97cb4566a2bf3f927a0c7f90d4997623"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "071008451", "text": "What is that boy kicking?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "field", "hair", "man", "shirt", "shoe", "shorts", "soccer ball", "sock", "trash can", "wall"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "ab43683b3bf040eb9383d864afa81f266f2dedbd32ec70fb8274401e2877ebb7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "77c9711cca42985e6a824043bef68c3d62daa9de7373f63e918c0c3c7f8f2522"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02108035", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25715, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e3749f6172800a1bb78197366a59ff43faf9f181b00b8eb094bb8fedf217d149", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "02108035", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is that man kicking?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,kicking,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is that kicking?", "program_group_hash": "e3749f6172800a1bb78197366a59ff43faf9f181b00b8eb094bb8fedf217d149", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "kicking", "select_category": "boy"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,kicking,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is that kicking?", "program_group_hash": "e3749f6172800a1bb78197366a59ff43faf9f181b00b8eb094bb8fedf217d149", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "kicking", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "soccer ball", "full_answer": "The boy is kicking the soccer ball.", "question": "What is that boy kicking?", "question_id": "071008451", "semantic": [{"argument": "boy (2937861)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,kicking,o (3588920)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "soccer ball", "full_answer": "The man is kicking the soccer ball.", "question": "What is that man kicking?", "question_id": "02108035", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (566508)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,kicking,o (566511)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1856066", "1893458", "2042547", "2052757", "2205138", "2857244", "2995467", "3007427", "3007428", "3099774", "3288542", "3420831", "3457684", "3588920", "3588925"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["soccer ball"], "predicate": "kicking", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3588920", "query_target_entity_name": "soccer ball", "relation_object_entity_id": "3588920", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2937861", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2937861", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2937861"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["566509", "566510", "566511", "566514", "566515", "566516", "566517", "566518", "566535", "566536", "566537", "566538", "566539"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["soccer ball"], "predicate": "kicking", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["flying", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "566511", "query_target_entity_name": "soccer ball", "relation_object_entity_id": "566511", "relation_subject_entity_id": "566508", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "566508", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["566508"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a47b6781ab2a8a632a23dab02564e86c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ab5c934f35042511c8c5a4ef4775d56a24c824e3650a5d907a0434872ecf47fa", "image_sha256_b": "5b08141b5c6b30c896c69e880b97a56d160970a2b458474b9189df2ee21bd8d6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "afc6481f37e413a872c7fd0e544c217a2ca8def3b58be914ab6fc40300ce1397", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "2b8f14425e167736fc93c00892e9b16a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1f8414ecdce232b9fba73a8bcc6a67048bb5a7550bd009bd677dd3d6c9ac27bd"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d24b36d01e56d61d592e8d243aae17a0a00b44b19db8db59122c8dcc50acdef4", "request_id": "b1ebdf646ef6c3dc723e01f9a998652f", "response_sha256": "3aec9957f0d7a7e7a3894bb015d2263addac503d1a8e6a8b457e91f04795650f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6cd2f03d6e43a84c307a1360a68074005b74ea3ed47242442394bac12822442d", "request_id": "c531157a8aa70d99525d4bd52c9f6c51", "response_sha256": "20e53019f9810308a8d968173ad24221fd71c4538806805b3e1ebc6db9abb77c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "cc3fdd748328ff83aba84364ac9d5312", "candidate_priority_rank": 25719, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-51173f388c15e781:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-51173f388c15e781:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-51173f388c15e781:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-51173f388c15e781:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "beer bottle<->cup", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "beer bottle", "B": "cup"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "beer bottle<->cup", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2364575", "image_sha256": "d455839ea9ba65405a8073586c5fed798d63e51e796e7dbf453ed7a1eb22a25a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364575.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364575.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2383547", "image_sha256": "0c07ce8949e2b3a1d5f4913ba6b41005f6dfd1ec0e473c6f9f863001c9c2eae6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2383547.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2383547.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-51173f388c15e781", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "beer bottle", "diff_b": "cup", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "beer bottle", "component_b": "cup"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "beer", "beer bottle", "book", "ceiling", "chairs", "chicken", "container", "fork", "glass", "glasses", "hands", "jacket", "people", "pitcher", "plate", "salad", "spices", "straw", "table", "tank top", "television", "tomato", "wall", "woman"], "detected_components": ["beer bottle"], "masked_program_sha256": "c488c7b3b6351e0a5c65c81c044b8de0367f9afeed9fcd5af64f8581a83ba14c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["beer bottle", "drink", "beer"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "beer bottle", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["beer bottle", "drink", "beer"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8e99c511f0cec39ee1e0d2e892a56cfe89bd8a69d0d339a845869e5aa6795176"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02773461", "text": "What type of drink is in the beer bottle?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "bottle", "box", "chair", "chocolate", "coffee", "cup", "donut", "donuts", "icing", "lobster", "paper", "sprinkles", "sugar", "table", "tissue", "vanilla"], "detected_components": ["cup"], "masked_program_sha256": "c488c7b3b6351e0a5c65c81c044b8de0367f9afeed9fcd5af64f8581a83ba14c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cup", "drink"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cup", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cup", "drink"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2db844c912ab8ac31108ffe05aba7a7644da542c73390cc049dacf2c54c06b1a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07116412", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25719, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b98add330855a5d8bc1d0ad4db5adb21f993406e2443ed94f2fb198020b37c52", "selected_component": "cup", "selected_source_question_id": "07116412", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of drink is in the cup?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of drink is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "b98add330855a5d8bc1d0ad4db5adb21f993406e2443ed94f2fb198020b37c52", "queried_category": "drink", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "beer bottle"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of drink is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "b98add330855a5d8bc1d0ad4db5adb21f993406e2443ed94f2fb198020b37c52", "queried_category": "drink", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "cup"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "beer", "full_answer": "The drink is beer.", "question": "What type of drink is in the beer bottle?", "question_id": "02773461", "semantic": [{"argument": "beer bottle (640324)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s (640300)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "coffee", "full_answer": "The drink is coffee.", "question": "What type of drink is in the cup?", "question_id": "07116412", "semantic": [{"argument": "cup (1319484)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s (1319485)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["640300"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["beer"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "640300", "query_target_entity_name": "beer", "relation_object_entity_id": "640324", "relation_subject_entity_id": "640300", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "640324", "selected_entity_name": "beer bottle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "beer bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["640324"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cup", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "beer bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1319485"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["coffee"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1319485", "query_target_entity_name": "coffee", "relation_object_entity_id": "1319484", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1319485", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1319484", "selected_entity_name": "cup"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cup", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1319484"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:cc3fdd748328ff83aba84364ac9d5312", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d455839ea9ba65405a8073586c5fed798d63e51e796e7dbf453ed7a1eb22a25a", "image_sha256_b": "0c07ce8949e2b3a1d5f4913ba6b41005f6dfd1ec0e473c6f9f863001c9c2eae6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "decb4d97215c80064708a3d083a3eadec7b8661c72e58f0de0b8897d188c4908", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "045773d93843ff7a40c617733fee9ab7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "48f6c212e95f0e14b5276cf56c508fdc9a05d01e10f5937bf31e2bfe6dd77894"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "64bc016fc3f2a41874b091e92c9a9b76e0f56ef9b4b8f237c7c5abdb2d668f06", "request_id": "41f7e22fbabc18d77fc801d301665385", "response_sha256": "c4a8677f511f09e3a7eb354be36b196b6d95a010e2a56e043d7b58a67767b8ff", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5db564ffcfdb3db02728eb829126b15d62426b0b60910300a40d3a840ac2b5d9", "request_id": "738a82f348fc5842446b2bd67d107d13", "response_sha256": "fab4056b860408477a5e449621221e658bcb1235d08f087197903e6fe5db4f5c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "e521c8be45652983e5c0eba1fa5f3fd3", "candidate_priority_rank": 25727, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2a9f0bfca0097c0f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2a9f0bfca0097c0f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2a9f0bfca0097c0f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2a9f0bfca0097c0f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "tray<->tree", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "tray", "B": "tree"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "tray<->tree", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2320575", "image_sha256": "c83bb611fdcf2065ac302c0f11f200e97e0b332fd89c46e4e57c7402d0c06c7b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2320575.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2320575.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2414805", "image_sha256": "f2fc67bfabf0138d6562501a0ce1829bcc8db917d62625cf52c718f8b757d2fc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2414805.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2414805.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2a9f0bfca0097c0f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "tray", "diff_b": "tree", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "tray", "component_b": "tree"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bananas", "bench", "ear", "earring", "eye", "hair", "hat", "head", "man", "mouth", "nose", "pants", "person", "picture", "shirt", "tray", "woman"], "detected_components": ["tray"], "masked_program_sha256": "4fd457542e82186eb0ae04b57c409543ad056bf428a715b139cf6baa353683de", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tray", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tray"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "75d647f063405506c7f9e2cda0b7ed25c2655dd46b172408b730fadd106100ea"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "111006084", "text": "What are the fruits on the tray?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bananas", "building", "door", "flower", "leaves", "roof", "tiles", "tree", "trunk", "wall"], "detected_components": ["tree"], "masked_program_sha256": "4fd457542e82186eb0ae04b57c409543ad056bf428a715b139cf6baa353683de", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tree"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tree", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tree"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "31291cf023c3c050170b556c9cf776776d4bd1da3db25836e587e11485478c80"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1174727", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25727, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8a7be861671d655488f7f7fbd62c99dcbc503be435d7713dd7ea566856662535", "selected_component": "tree", "selected_source_question_id": "1174727", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the fruits on the tree?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the fruits on the ?", "program_group_hash": "8a7be861671d655488f7f7fbd62c99dcbc503be435d7713dd7ea566856662535", "queried_category": "fruit", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "tray"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the fruits on the ?", "program_group_hash": "8a7be861671d655488f7f7fbd62c99dcbc503be435d7713dd7ea566856662535", "queried_category": "fruit", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "tree"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bananas", "full_answer": "The fruits are bananas.", "question": "What are the fruits on the tray?", "question_id": "111006084", "semantic": [{"argument": "tray (1049634)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,on,s (1049633)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bananas", "full_answer": "The fruits are bananas.", "question": "What are the fruits on the tree?", "question_id": "1174727", "semantic": [{"argument": "tree (151575)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,on,s (151576)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1049633"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bananas"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "1049633", "query_target_entity_name": "bananas", "relation_object_entity_id": "1049634", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1049633", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1049634", "selected_entity_name": "tray"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1049634"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tree", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tray", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["151576"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bananas"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["green", "hanging"], "query_target_entity_id": "151576", "query_target_entity_name": "bananas", "relation_object_entity_id": "151575", "relation_subject_entity_id": "151576", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "151575", "selected_entity_name": "tree"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tree", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["151575"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e521c8be45652983e5c0eba1fa5f3fd3", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c83bb611fdcf2065ac302c0f11f200e97e0b332fd89c46e4e57c7402d0c06c7b", "image_sha256_b": "f2fc67bfabf0138d6562501a0ce1829bcc8db917d62625cf52c718f8b757d2fc", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "32927577191b1a474ee7d043545ff70a30e36cabe31b160095f4bf801b4ff82e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5262e162cabdaa533f9c8824c61e8176", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ced1591ae18a289283b77c6604d948036a9caf92d1877633de3ac59131db7952"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "81450809530c27f76354d805922bb55613c27de11d5b14bf463462a7d09da8b8", "request_id": "de427d913b5c57bcb39f13f7f00528b6", "response_sha256": "521a81654d86698153bdab17dfcc490878b938d38cd467a0200c449b17bd7a91", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ccc9aa6f540bfa52cc2d6d31fee9e9e5e82382ea3e7ecd742865fd0532ecbb39", "request_id": "0e59a20150270e0493df8d2e8542423d", "response_sha256": "c31d1ff95b13912d59182bfae756a8356b718bdf659295729c52428fc02da5a5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "47efb6e06ffbc5de68d61c806e05f538", "candidate_priority_rank": 25782, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5fd4687dce4a0c59:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5fd4687dce4a0c59:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5fd4687dce4a0c59:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5fd4687dce4a0c59:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 320, "image_id": "2398225", "image_sha256": "b5ed58369db1a5c0d4f4e344b276a7e703b2750ac14fa49f47ea82d51c789181", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398225.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398225.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2387667", "image_sha256": "8f1ec7c2d448860511cd8a4c5709ed10d066cc9c0cb18c3dc711381f0beda50d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387667.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387667.jpg", "width": 400}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5fd4687dce4a0c59", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["hair", "hands", "hill", "legs", "mountains", "orange", "rope", "sky", "snow", "tree", "water", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "708f2486de870b169c55cdd35990f2dd86fcbba4f2cd9dd7955845f5b1c1fa69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "41d57a239d2892cdedc0b06c595ffe457ce06753e7709815ae44957d9f2734d4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00525460", "text": "What's pulling the woman?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "buildings", "buoy", "feet", "hand", "hat", "helmet", "kite", "man", "shirt", "shorts", "water"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "708f2486de870b169c55cdd35990f2dd86fcbba4f2cd9dd7955845f5b1c1fa69", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f9a89479655ee7c4f47711cd8a51bf57dd3493b6c25c002494b88cf1a584bfdd"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11566706", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25782, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "45e5e38ba2967ed37b01663e1c0021cec3a3d0fa8474139debed1dd66a5bee2d", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "11566706", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's pulling the man?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,pulling,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's pulling the ?", "program_group_hash": "45e5e38ba2967ed37b01663e1c0021cec3a3d0fa8474139debed1dd66a5bee2d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "pulling", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,pulling,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's pulling the ?", "program_group_hash": "45e5e38ba2967ed37b01663e1c0021cec3a3d0fa8474139debed1dd66a5bee2d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "pulling", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "rope", "full_answer": "The rope is pulling the woman.", "question": "What's pulling the woman?", "question_id": "00525460", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (1181468)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,pulling,s (1181480)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "kite", "full_answer": "The kite is pulling the man.", "question": "What's pulling the man?", "question_id": "11566706", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1273904)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,pulling,s (1273913)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1181471", "1181475", "1181476", "1181477", "1181480", "1181484", "1181486", "1181487", "1181489", "1181490", "1181491"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["rope"], "predicate": "pulling", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1181480", "query_target_entity_name": "rope", "relation_object_entity_id": "1181468", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1181480", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1181468", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1181468"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1273905", "1273906", "1273908", "1273909", "1273910", "1273911", "1273913", "1273915", "1273918", "1273920", "1273924", "1273925"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["kite"], "predicate": "pulling", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1273913", "query_target_entity_name": "kite", "relation_object_entity_id": "1273904", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1273913", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1273904", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1273904"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:47efb6e06ffbc5de68d61c806e05f538", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b5ed58369db1a5c0d4f4e344b276a7e703b2750ac14fa49f47ea82d51c789181", "image_sha256_b": "8f1ec7c2d448860511cd8a4c5709ed10d066cc9c0cb18c3dc711381f0beda50d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ff663858219df25ff2f464712022c350fb7a2e91652219bebc9c1e5d2a928df4", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f1abc74c8ca2357c5132ca1a72e97a88", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "29fab48deba5076f76bfd0d9fbee7edc04101beb6a19303a7cd864e3b079fbff"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c6c0c16c16bc302a3f5a5e7c6a6f92d8b7f924c005cb87a960cdea19fb2b038b", "request_id": "4aaff4cb054063bc06d56b2033ac3329", "response_sha256": "1bb34d071e51eb6645ab58ada7a88cbbeeeaf8213938f2dd18fdd371d3660405", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bd17584bfe5ea8e5379623009099c626475bf7eaa142f189bdec8a79576d7016", "request_id": "228307cf4aadf7088f2f2552541e9127", "response_sha256": "e6d9331ee6c08ab6f98abe12b4129560c71fcba51ef1e03277188312b019b5af", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "7ef2e196494f04bb14a31abf930502e1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25825, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93bfda59fd175e79:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93bfda59fd175e79:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93bfda59fd175e79:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93bfda59fd175e79:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bag<->cheese", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bag", "B": "cheese"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bag<->cheese", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2405754", "image_sha256": "9684a4a5777c3753117054b4fbba71710e6e2a03775415b1e585f3d669b75533", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405754.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405754.jpg", "width": 373}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2411258", "image_sha256": "ad155ac191427b89754de3b9342b88c6563b33ae159252c35b2bd1134d977bf3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2411258.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2411258.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93bfda59fd175e79", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bag", "diff_b": "cheese", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bag", "component_b": "cheese"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.19973190348525469, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.0938337801608579, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.417, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.234, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "bottle", "box", "boxes", "cabinet door", "cat", "face", "floor", "refrigerator", "table", "tail"], "detected_components": ["bag"], "masked_program_sha256": "69c0c05f377c7d2fa647551b4624e432961873f4b00621813b3f378d621ee409", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag", "bottle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bag", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag", "bottle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "00e3faff3bd7f539c2b8e30f3960614591fc74d006a0f81e2448b8bb8c7b3461"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08447345", "text": "What color does the bottle to the left of the bag have?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arms", "bottle", "candle", "cheese", "glass", "lettuce", "parmesan cheese", "plate", "salad", "table", "tomato", "wine", "woman"], "detected_components": ["cheese"], "masked_program_sha256": "69c0c05f377c7d2fa647551b4624e432961873f4b00621813b3f378d621ee409", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cheese", "bottle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cheese", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cheese", "bottle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5f72c9b7e553373d01865be315f93f5a97996534464bf4f5d6413c397063765e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1770048", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25825, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d4886e59cedfa7db4d639e818286053684611b4c2e5d83abe235f7133c26c5fe", "selected_component": "cheese", "selected_source_question_id": "1770048", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color does the bottle to the left of the cheese have?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bottle,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color does the bottle to the left of the have?", "program_group_hash": "d4886e59cedfa7db4d639e818286053684611b4c2e5d83abe235f7133c26c5fe", "queried_category": "bottle", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "bag"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bottle,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color does the bottle to the left of the have?", "program_group_hash": "d4886e59cedfa7db4d639e818286053684611b4c2e5d83abe235f7133c26c5fe", "queried_category": "bottle", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "cheese"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "brown", "full_answer": "The bottle has brown color.", "question": "What color does the bottle to the left of the bag have?", "question_id": "08447345", "semantic": [{"argument": "bag (4157720)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bottle,to the left of,s (4157721)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "green", "full_answer": "The bottle has green color.", "question": "What color does the bottle to the left of the cheese have?", "question_id": "1770048", "semantic": [{"argument": "cheese (314372)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "bottle,to the left of,s (314373)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4157721"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["brown"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "4157721", "query_target_entity_name": "bottle", "relation_object_entity_id": "4157720", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4157721", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4157720", "selected_entity_name": "bag"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bag", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4157720"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cheese", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bag", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["314373"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["empty", "green"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["empty", "green"], "query_target_entity_id": "314373", "query_target_entity_name": "bottle", "relation_object_entity_id": "314372", "relation_subject_entity_id": "314373", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "314372", "selected_entity_name": "cheese"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cheese", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["314372"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:7ef2e196494f04bb14a31abf930502e1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9684a4a5777c3753117054b4fbba71710e6e2a03775415b1e585f3d669b75533", "image_sha256_b": "ad155ac191427b89754de3b9342b88c6563b33ae159252c35b2bd1134d977bf3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e9420bc50f3a30b5ac2fac24a86b0469cc57fe5860a989ff0c41c41c93332c32", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0a2d52d56b3ffff15c12ebea3d6fd07b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "cf85b6ba0c423a3ac46acb17e4c695f8149eea79f2a7c184fcadb8783f6324f2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a58fe45f87b2b3bbc393a5af05e33d4f5094231d3c53007367cc8f6dedcc86bd", "request_id": "0b126da5d5c41a92eaa1e5acdf10c41f", "response_sha256": "fdc9b51b41e9fd410c1ca3638a0e6ff3fdcf5ef8cc87261bf396167c82bb7613", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "de04c9176c22015e15a614e41f7c036bb414561c2b21ce22834ac5639f231bbd", "request_id": "02d719139c7cb42a8ca1be7ac5fd1ee3", "response_sha256": "f505fdccf909965c521f5db22a21ecd2f6d7adb4db2ad8df46f0633137585dbe", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "95f86bc15be26d4a87db0165d9a91f2e", "candidate_priority_rank": 25877, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-57cded60bdd08aa2:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-57cded60bdd08aa2:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-57cded60bdd08aa2:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-57cded60bdd08aa2:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "mat<->stove", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "stove", "B": "mat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "stove<->mat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2350733", "image_sha256": "4460926bb5bf2e903f667ed61a11f1d5e27efac170c4c6323670cdb626f34b87", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2350733.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2350733.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2365498", "image_sha256": "1d14ae18be2256204995934d870eca61f608ee82e1fe065e67bec08240079c67", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365498.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365498.jpg", "width": 421}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-57cded60bdd08aa2", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "stove", "diff_b": "mat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "stove", "component_b": "mat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.434, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.176, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 2}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.3990498812351544, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.028503562945368172, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinets", "clock", "counter", "kettle", "knives", "microwave", "mixer", "oil", "pan", "shelves", "stove", "wall"], "detected_components": ["stove"], "masked_program_sha256": "81decf8b99167c854cb8fc9fb5aa72dd77ce7c5e258d8aafb2edaab9dbc2285e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["stove", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stove", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["stove", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0e6ee02961d7cc7cb7813f76c8cf7a4b5ffc28156277d803309abbff0c70f4cd"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18155233", "text": "What type of appliance is to the left of the stove?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["apron", "bottles", "cabinets", "cans", "counter", "dishwasher", "doors", "dress", "faucet", "glove", "heel", "mat", "scrub brush", "sink", "sponge", "woman"], "detected_components": ["mat"], "masked_program_sha256": "81decf8b99167c854cb8fc9fb5aa72dd77ce7c5e258d8aafb2edaab9dbc2285e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mat", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mat", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4462d6b271b0a225822b426b5681acc6c9d0dfee9f3628cc4222f3314d35d34c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13441877", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25877, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0f997d3f59253782c80f00f616cd5a585a047af09ff8641ea6d3e16a2341d2ba", "selected_component": "mat", "selected_source_question_id": "13441877", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of appliance is to the left of the mat?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of appliance is to the left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "0f997d3f59253782c80f00f616cd5a585a047af09ff8641ea6d3e16a2341d2ba", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "stove"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of appliance is to the left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "0f997d3f59253782c80f00f616cd5a585a047af09ff8641ea6d3e16a2341d2ba", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "mat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "mixer", "full_answer": "The appliance is a mixer.", "question": "What type of appliance is to the left of the stove?", "question_id": "18155233", "semantic": [{"argument": "stove (865820)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the left of,s (865825)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dishwasher", "full_answer": "The appliance is a dishwasher.", "question": "What type of appliance is to the left of the mat?", "question_id": "13441877", "semantic": [{"argument": "mat (1802907)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the left of,s (1665672)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["865815", "865825"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mixer"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "865825", "query_target_entity_name": "mixer", "relation_object_entity_id": "865820", "relation_subject_entity_id": "865825", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "865820", "selected_entity_name": "stove"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stove", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["865820"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stove", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1665672"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dishwasher"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1665672", "query_target_entity_name": "dishwasher", "relation_object_entity_id": "1802907", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1665672", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1802907", "selected_entity_name": "mat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1802907"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:95f86bc15be26d4a87db0165d9a91f2e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4460926bb5bf2e903f667ed61a11f1d5e27efac170c4c6323670cdb626f34b87", "image_sha256_b": "1d14ae18be2256204995934d870eca61f608ee82e1fe065e67bec08240079c67", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "19e3f786490c85a398127004fced03acb58ccb14ecbe2c14adc6f3401fec5fc1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3ccfe2f61f03fc8e6cf90b424a06c3df", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0a162fb4f680d49961d438d39f1aaac0b46720af8bcfe239a83cc671253426dc"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "197aa2eafbd9bf8b6855ddc8245632ab0e10f557b67d1ea9ce7719248229b201", "request_id": "081542e91917a02b7b22aeec16c26d6b", "response_sha256": "0912232360be81dc11becd3930bdf33daf9b7c80c82bcacf5c747aee943c2d43", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ac246b1e7004309ce54e8abcba9b8312d9514c29567b47a30316a21180d399c8", "request_id": "cfd1c55b8905d8af4cd486111eb24d07", "response_sha256": "5c162c18c0222a1e12297db09ecf344a34c94f8529d37cf6b6c55cbce95da320", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "0b58b15c32daa23bd75384c9b27b3015", "candidate_priority_rank": 25907, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-63846a3df85a7f50:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-63846a3df85a7f50:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-63846a3df85a7f50:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-63846a3df85a7f50:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "sink<->truck", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "truck", "B": "sink"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "truck<->sink", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2410842", "image_sha256": "9619e79400e6604783b51f8c7898f882d06c8b733a5f7aa04bd5a95f6cd003d3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410842.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410842.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 768, "image_id": "286061", "image_sha256": "2e6722895ef7c90300b30382dc95414e0cc8345fb10f2cda5a2755c88f8d910f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/286061.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/286061.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-63846a3df85a7f50", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "truck", "diff_b": "sink", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "truck", "component_b": "sink"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "grass", "ground", "house", "leaves", "man", "motorcycle", "roof", "sidewalk", "steps", "tire", "tires", "trailer", "tree", "trees", "truck"], "detected_components": ["truck"], "masked_program_sha256": "0706f1cf6c0889c2b9f4f9b8fad6ed9db921bc63a94ae23bc9e7dd5fb385f44b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["truck"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "truck", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["truck"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e0c930f4867a6e369d1092b6a0aaa5e6166e32aa94060c37b9e1de8ad738ba73"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03894840", "text": "What is hanging above the truck?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bathroom", "cabinet", "cabinet door", "counter", "door", "floor", "mirror", "seat", "sink", "tiles", "toilet", "wall", "walls"], "detected_components": ["sink"], "masked_program_sha256": "0706f1cf6c0889c2b9f4f9b8fad6ed9db921bc63a94ae23bc9e7dd5fb385f44b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sink", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "aa490920a63f3ccf9e489a3ae3baf7813a7475f4481c1d677e36ceb006efc5a4"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18861245", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25907, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 17, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "18e00e96686b777031111454aecc788ba0a3e71f10f12f1ed4ab01d8be626cda", "selected_component": "sink", "selected_source_question_id": "18861245", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is hanging above the sink?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is hanging above the ?", "program_group_hash": "18e00e96686b777031111454aecc788ba0a3e71f10f12f1ed4ab01d8be626cda", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "hanging above", "select_category": "truck"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is hanging above the ?", "program_group_hash": "18e00e96686b777031111454aecc788ba0a3e71f10f12f1ed4ab01d8be626cda", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "hanging above", "select_category": "sink"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "leaves", "full_answer": "The leaves are hanging above the truck.", "question": "What is hanging above the truck?", "question_id": "03894840", "semantic": [{"argument": "truck (319809)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging above,s (319822)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "mirror", "full_answer": "The mirror is hanging above the sink.", "question": "What is hanging above the sink?", "question_id": "18861245", "semantic": [{"argument": "sink (4413958)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hanging above,s (3991692)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["319807", "319813", "319815", "319816", "319819", "319820", "319821", "319822", "319823", "319828", "319830", "319831", "319832", "319836", "319837", "319838", "319841", "319842", "319843", "319846"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["leaves"], "predicate": "hanging above", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "319822", "query_target_entity_name": "leaves", "relation_object_entity_id": "319809", "relation_subject_entity_id": "319822", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "319809", "selected_entity_name": "truck"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "truck", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["319809"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "truck", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3991691", "3991692", "3991693", "3991696", "3991718", "3991719", "3991720", "3991722", "3991723", "3991726", "3991727", "4413959", "4413964", "4413973", "4413975", "4413981", "4413984", "4413987"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mirror"], "predicate": "hanging above", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3991692", "query_target_entity_name": "mirror", "relation_object_entity_id": "4413958", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3991692", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4413958", "selected_entity_name": "sink"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4413958"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0b58b15c32daa23bd75384c9b27b3015", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9619e79400e6604783b51f8c7898f882d06c8b733a5f7aa04bd5a95f6cd003d3", "image_sha256_b": "2e6722895ef7c90300b30382dc95414e0cc8345fb10f2cda5a2755c88f8d910f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "bc823fa6935edc62226eb5b4fad5c16713ef3430589af3ac60c61847005afdb3", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "75caf56238724a1fd98fd12dabf5e343", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5571e890ad788c765e7232f38d58a4ebb14b449207c472ad576e339f04687025"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6292eef6c4774e6ceaf68c6d960f3fa6ef170b71656cb30d91e2a6b6718b5936", "request_id": "5498eb1417d866c351cf4b87b4cfd3f9", "response_sha256": "01bdf45323c75a4a29c6de9702d6bd898c84cef9e646094e5e7b919b1f988063", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c1fa60dc8469b9ca7f35328db76025447c214417b4c697a3df3c9b2ec0ef1807", "request_id": "4b4c96539e6c5545c3b20afc4e28a07c", "response_sha256": "e67b0d8f1e3c94766a6f33ef2cdfc90eced642267cc8317c4000708ec078e700", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "0d351cd17a8659d589046bb362f3e8a5", "candidate_priority_rank": 25975, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a2d06936875ca6bc:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a2d06936875ca6bc:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a2d06936875ca6bc:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a2d06936875ca6bc:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dresser<->kitchen", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dresser", "B": "kitchen"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dresser<->kitchen", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2366255", "image_sha256": "eb6301487ee2c432788d019b439581d1adbbb3b1d92750f1241cd740c88c1b91", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2366255.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2366255.jpg", "width": 397}, "B": {"height": 384, "image_id": "4285", "image_sha256": "03df43efc054c0b1835749cc159280d3cd6d88cfc9ae033284e6997d798cef50", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/4285.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/4285.jpg", "width": 512}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a2d06936875ca6bc", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dresser", "diff_b": "kitchen", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dresser", "component_b": "kitchen"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["artwork", "bed", "drawers", "dresser", "floor lamp", "hair", "lock", "man", "outlet", "room", "shoes", "suit", "suitcase", "table lamp", "tag", "tie", "wall", "watch"], "detected_components": ["dresser"], "masked_program_sha256": "3097cdc74d8cf83721b0e57df448d3154de3c24fe65d0efc54c54aa1998d429e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dresser", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dresser", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dresser", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a36c616f605e95607521544c5db17f1a7293d42fad1e4989e447713a7ae03546"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02100561", "text": "What pieces of furniture are in the dresser?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["apples", "basket", "cabinet doors", "ceiling", "chair", "chairs", "counter", "kitchen", "mushroom", "pineapple", "plant", "pot", "pump", "sink", "tree trunk", "window"], "detected_components": ["kitchen"], "masked_program_sha256": "3097cdc74d8cf83721b0e57df448d3154de3c24fe65d0efc54c54aa1998d429e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["kitchen", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "kitchen", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["kitchen", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4d0bc76a312272355e1b95681edc2a40cb805ff32c10575ae7901e22df33c3af"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01162339", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25975, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "788061c4b702bf856a99b4632b4d715cc206a4bb63147c6ed443bd3caa4cf2c8", "selected_component": "kitchen", "selected_source_question_id": "01162339", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What pieces of furniture are in the kitchen?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what pieces of furniture are in the ?", "program_group_hash": "788061c4b702bf856a99b4632b4d715cc206a4bb63147c6ed443bd3caa4cf2c8", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "dresser"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what pieces of furniture are in the ?", "program_group_hash": "788061c4b702bf856a99b4632b4d715cc206a4bb63147c6ed443bd3caa4cf2c8", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "kitchen"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "drawers", "full_answer": "The pieces of furniture are drawers.", "question": "What pieces of furniture are in the dresser?", "question_id": "02100561", "semantic": [{"argument": "dresser (2228232)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in,s (2228233)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chairs", "full_answer": "The pieces of furniture are chairs.", "question": "What pieces of furniture are in the kitchen?", "question_id": "01162339", "semantic": [{"argument": "kitchen (4367753)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in,s (4367770)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2228233", "2403091"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["drawers"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2228233", "query_target_entity_name": "drawers", "relation_object_entity_id": "2228232", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2228233", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2228232", "selected_entity_name": "dresser"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dresser", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2228232"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "kitchen", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dresser", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4367711", "4367712", "4367770"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chairs"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "4367770", "query_target_entity_name": "chairs", "relation_object_entity_id": "4367753", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4367770", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4367753", "selected_entity_name": "kitchen"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "kitchen", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4367753"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0d351cd17a8659d589046bb362f3e8a5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "eb6301487ee2c432788d019b439581d1adbbb3b1d92750f1241cd740c88c1b91", "image_sha256_b": "03df43efc054c0b1835749cc159280d3cd6d88cfc9ae033284e6997d798cef50", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e9df724913168afa6948b37250e6b4afa362f9a239e71b9bea570b3a7331ae9e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "dda2098c728a3da2a5ffaac86a6ce9eb", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6c3a025993c34cd9184b3cb9d34eb62c381b86f432807adcd374c025b4368d4e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d72cd846933e0f90ff9366f5ee7acdeba7cf707bc0adb159a670d153e056345f", "request_id": "062ce83d33faf04e8c69a5037d7edd6b", "response_sha256": "166115f720760e51e8e8d0bd0a1ea4a9726d4e9f300195028df6aab1872147c9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a8ef8ea74da8b57664fa8a906f348e7e95f1c5d853f03ce107942b606910c5e5", "request_id": "0f447bc168d8770298dec45ce2cecdbe", "response_sha256": "d635788e371b01a488b2b04617a14e82b44ea4e5adbcfdffaa9ddc18b7d1679e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "c56cd1d443911ac195a5a9897a1fef13", "candidate_priority_rank": 26012, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-791a24e6ad0461fb:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-791a24e6ad0461fb:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-791a24e6ad0461fb:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-791a24e6ad0461fb:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "field<->water", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "water", "B": "field"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "water<->field", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 354, "image_id": "2376332", "image_sha256": "5f9d72c5e65671b1289a843d757a16ca7a1a1af179d4b5fe77024d11816d563e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376332.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376332.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2325316", "image_sha256": "7e0548b0a3f0357ab1d514b97a282cbfc0ac0411a263816d9d7763c9ccaee43a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2325316.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2325316.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-791a24e6ad0461fb", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "water", "diff_b": "field", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "water", "component_b": "field"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 7, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ground", "horse", "horses", "log", "man", "people", "person", "sand", "shirt", "trees", "water"], "detected_components": ["water"], "masked_program_sha256": "666e7fb5753e03ed722f3606b7785b8efea497e267e812354347627e8f7f2278", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "water", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a04ef414d7d98e73a23131ad25ca45dd8ce5e51a5acfd909c238cb8356faaee6"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01942822", "text": "What animals are walking in the water?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["birds", "clouds", "cows", "elephants", "field", "grass", "sky"], "detected_components": ["field"], "masked_program_sha256": "666e7fb5753e03ed722f3606b7785b8efea497e267e812354347627e8f7f2278", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "field", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dda835c424538a679d4bb37a5f530b90a34851e57099e00d24cfab7c2ab6600f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15891392", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26012, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b7951ea03e1ddf9543015df1f6e5da2e4ca4ac522d12d7d809108bb34c23504e", "selected_component": "field", "selected_source_question_id": "15891392", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animals are walking in the field?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are walking in the ?", "program_group_hash": "b7951ea03e1ddf9543015df1f6e5da2e4ca4ac522d12d7d809108bb34c23504e", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking in", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are walking in the ?", "program_group_hash": "b7951ea03e1ddf9543015df1f6e5da2e4ca4ac522d12d7d809108bb34c23504e", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking in", "select_category": "field"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "horses", "full_answer": "The animals are horses.", "question": "What animals are walking in the water?", "question_id": "01942822", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (2508584)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking in,s (2188339)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephants", "full_answer": "The animals are elephants.", "question": "What animals are walking in the field?", "question_id": "15891392", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (4008822)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking in,s (4008830)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1700209", "1960133", "2188339", "2607241"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horses"], "predicate": "walking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2188339", "query_target_entity_name": "horses", "relation_object_entity_id": "2508584", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2188339", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2508584", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2508584"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4008792", "4008796", "4008801", "4008811", "4008824", "4008825", "4008827", "4008830", "4008831", "4008838"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 7, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "walking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4008796", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "4008822", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4008796", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4008822", "selected_entity_name": "field"}, {"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "walking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4008824", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "4008822", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4008824", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4008822", "selected_entity_name": "field"}, {"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "walking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4008825", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "4008822", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4008825", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4008822", "selected_entity_name": "field"}, {"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "walking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4008827", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "4008822", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4008827", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4008822", "selected_entity_name": "field"}, {"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "walking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4008830", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "4008822", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4008830", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4008822", "selected_entity_name": "field"}, {"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "walking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4008831", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "4008822", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4008831", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4008822", "selected_entity_name": "field"}, {"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "walking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4008838", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "4008822", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4008838", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4008822", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4008822"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c56cd1d443911ac195a5a9897a1fef13", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5f9d72c5e65671b1289a843d757a16ca7a1a1af179d4b5fe77024d11816d563e", "image_sha256_b": "7e0548b0a3f0357ab1d514b97a282cbfc0ac0411a263816d9d7763c9ccaee43a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3919f3fa24d2c53761f50ca60035b8499ae9e35c165140af556b1f996130a279", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "321dd172fa0f0557615385dd7bd64dec", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f0c068d4a177e3f7aa869da87ecda03bcb7e0cb9dcd57635646d499967494fa5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4d686bab6facd5871486268cba44a09bb29bfe714fe698bf1651a8fde66c2e6a", "request_id": "5b99e91924ca629bc5305bb4c75b76d3", "response_sha256": "0eab7a0f4dd07c1923467d90e6fecb9b6eb24232ebdcb064ad2adab443b2725c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7754ed07d27b30ba80f9874b36e5ae2e9e29ed0adc225ecbe72cdb2920ad6056", "request_id": "450080fbd507e461dbdfa7bcaf3ee861", "response_sha256": "20eb1d4c38fa37d3d94a693a37049663e8342cdcafab1b6fc9b5be97a324eab6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "8a23bf9becf3cc651498b67c01d784f1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26063, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-14496282c1def148:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-14496282c1def148:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-14496282c1def148:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-14496282c1def148:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "knife<->lid", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "knife", "B": "lid"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "knife<->lid", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2415386", "image_sha256": "364907baa7ef3461894eae0914d4fea10046865baf1cac4559f4abefa1f36de2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2415386.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2415386.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2395361", "image_sha256": "3d757a08d50e79b15314411baf1c748e6736438921d2cf821746ca2d3da3576b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395361.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395361.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-14496282c1def148", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "knife", "diff_b": "lid", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "knife", "component_b": "lid"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "cabinet door", "cup", "cutting board", "glass", "glasses", "kitchen", "knife", "lady", "pitcher", "shirt", "table", "vegetable"], "detected_components": ["knife"], "masked_program_sha256": "9be7f6bed3715614b85c11a6e5987a74b5a8b792afc9afddf700266f56358021", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["knife", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "knife", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["knife", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "06561bb407b43ae89ac54621628d629344bda3c5b56c154eb11497aecadfdd4f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14994427", "text": "What is the cooking utensil that the knife is on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "broccoli", "can", "cheese", "cutting board", "dish", "garlic", "jar", "label", "lid", "meat", "mushroom", "mushrooms", "onions", "pepper", "pizza", "plate", "sauce", "spice", "tomato", "tomato sauce", "vegetable"], "detected_components": ["lid"], "masked_program_sha256": "9be7f6bed3715614b85c11a6e5987a74b5a8b792afc9afddf700266f56358021", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["lid", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "lid", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["lid", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0928b509818bbda331d79b35b4c5c862df7972a4d4de46ce494aa0efc423c411"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06347341", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26063, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "04cd595fa3f6d1217e8be2f1d942c5cc8231be216fd71a6b28c300b8ae816281", "selected_component": "lid", "selected_source_question_id": "06347341", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the cooking utensil that the lid is on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cooking utensil that the is on?", "program_group_hash": "04cd595fa3f6d1217e8be2f1d942c5cc8231be216fd71a6b28c300b8ae816281", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "knife"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cooking utensil that the is on?", "program_group_hash": "04cd595fa3f6d1217e8be2f1d942c5cc8231be216fd71a6b28c300b8ae816281", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "lid"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cutting board", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a cutting board.", "question": "What is the cooking utensil that the knife is on?", "question_id": "14994427", "semantic": [{"argument": "knife (3132419)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,o (3132420)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cutting board", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a cutting board.", "question": "What is the cooking utensil that the lid is on?", "question_id": "06347341", "semantic": [{"argument": "lid (455439)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,o (455443)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3132420"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cutting board"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3132420", "query_target_entity_name": "cutting board", "relation_object_entity_id": "3132420", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3132419", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3132419", "selected_entity_name": "knife"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "knife", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3132419"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lid", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "knife", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["455443"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cutting board"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["plastic", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "455443", "query_target_entity_name": "cutting board", "relation_object_entity_id": "455443", "relation_subject_entity_id": "455439", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "455439", "selected_entity_name": "lid"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lid", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["455439"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:8a23bf9becf3cc651498b67c01d784f1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "364907baa7ef3461894eae0914d4fea10046865baf1cac4559f4abefa1f36de2", "image_sha256_b": "3d757a08d50e79b15314411baf1c748e6736438921d2cf821746ca2d3da3576b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "423f901ec11276b7c86756a5c8de022d4be9f6b83e535b2454d525517c4a7b6a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e564007cf1972024935e67f0245afabf", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9b6ca51d356d23db2dd09d6df50a6f6ea3f36aff79643475aa11cd7fe2164877"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "20b3f30be5df5a8c9833babc69afb0ed5b694f7e2ba948ec79eaf98258927515", "request_id": "aa4b9a5b502be003020112d4e9be70c7", "response_sha256": "cf8ddb8cdc1babbfc692ebd4faeac357c5e48044363ff43216e77956cdaeda72", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f641eb502c800b3b25c22febbdb4b3ba6433abf9cb4ae83282b6524059e7ec46", "request_id": "bd703ebfbd3e086f6a03834656908c16", "response_sha256": "2226bea59cb4b98f5dc2fca97aee53059eb164d8c4f529ad0c5915977cc7b5a2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "5c62c07bf5aaa033b13bdcdf52f945dd", "candidate_priority_rank": 26109, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-128a5220c4fb015c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-128a5220c4fb015c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-128a5220c4fb015c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-128a5220c4fb015c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "table<->wall", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "table", "B": "wall"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "table<->wall", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2371653", "image_sha256": "057c3f3e8cea99908362a81e819efca09131e883c8a3efda7388b1ddea4160e6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371653.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371653.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2319287", "image_sha256": "e0a2a7480399b4c1c9c9ca0de157d70dd3f79223999e6a7dec71a283a71bef97", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2319287.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2319287.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-128a5220c4fb015c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "table", "diff_b": "wall", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "table", "component_b": "wall"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bush", "chair", "curtain", "curtains", "flower", "flowers", "glass", "leaves", "table", "vase", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["table"], "masked_program_sha256": "2890fd2df6ded0734a1b45464e5a8ff58e949e996f917808af59716e3fbadea9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "table", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b13962e22e85aad1eddc08f39885db193811895bd089c655dc42e8342bda220d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0568856", "text": "What is on the table in this scene?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["box", "bricks", "building", "clock", "cross", "decorations", "doorway", "fence", "ground", "pillars", "stone", "tower", "tree", "trees", "wall", "watch", "window", "windows"], "detected_components": ["wall"], "masked_program_sha256": "2890fd2df6ded0734a1b45464e5a8ff58e949e996f917808af59716e3fbadea9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wall", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3b85bd1d83bd6e7f801798725a3354daff08d3355e48fd6a22d32f471528afb7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03563970", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26109, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5c8f62a8b887e660c275c4b9839a667a5291219f796e3a5d2c03044b08aac779", "selected_component": "wall", "selected_source_question_id": "03563970", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the wall in this scene?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the in this scene?", "program_group_hash": "5c8f62a8b887e660c275c4b9839a667a5291219f796e3a5d2c03044b08aac779", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the in this scene?", "program_group_hash": "5c8f62a8b887e660c275c4b9839a667a5291219f796e3a5d2c03044b08aac779", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "vase", "full_answer": "The vase is on the table.", "question": "What is on the table in this scene?", "question_id": "0568856", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (2670534)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (2515159)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is on the wall.", "question": "What is on the wall in this scene?", "question_id": "03563970", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1003285)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (1003267)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1704250", "1704251", "1808088", "1836248", "2145154", "2292266", "2376858", "2484885", "2515155", "2515156", "2515157", "2515158", "2515159", "2526361", "2605841", "3519677", "3519678"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["vase"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2515159", "query_target_entity_name": "vase", "relation_object_entity_id": "2670534", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2515159", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2670534", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2670534"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1704250", "1704251", "1808088", "1836248", "2145154", "2292266", "2376858", "2484885", "2515155", "2515156", "2515157", "2515158", "2515159", "2605841", "2670534", "3519677", "3519678"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2526361"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1003267", "1003269", "1003273", "1003274", "1003275", "1003276", "1003277", "1003278", "1003279", "1003281", "1003286", "1003287", "1003288", "1003289", "1003290", "1003292", "1003294", "1003295"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "1003267", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "1003285", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1003267", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1003285", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1003285"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:5c62c07bf5aaa033b13bdcdf52f945dd", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "057c3f3e8cea99908362a81e819efca09131e883c8a3efda7388b1ddea4160e6", "image_sha256_b": "e0a2a7480399b4c1c9c9ca0de157d70dd3f79223999e6a7dec71a283a71bef97", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5cffbdfebcc264d84826ad225f8d7cfddc6074494933eb95c2022a066949b8f9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "432d2d4ba2b1f4e622df19017d0787d0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "828a6ef0f52bc1809da06bd39ed88a1da850ddfabee654f528f95cb0d2a24fd9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "64f0d610f93dc91c60d13fd3f0dc54444060ee4eab49ce01bfe3ba711c082cae", "request_id": "ef4c3db37d73bffe72e89c9b7e781e9a", "response_sha256": "4887cbb8ecd02044ff0aa594f4347ec626ca45d53ee2cfbeb65acae15a33675b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4ab511f518696771a0ba12a6d5c560647e1a7425fe673a2e966f91182a34bb2f", "request_id": "f88d19f76b261051d3dd3b2c59eec994", "response_sha256": "345a28475b251edece3013534c755512f587cbb9b48696e5195eb20c0e79f691", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "a4a764002d03778892d9bb3cfc7448f5", "candidate_priority_rank": 25212, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ce88ab498910cf5a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ce88ab498910cf5a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ce88ab498910cf5a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ce88ab498910cf5a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "building<->sidewalk", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sidewalk", "B": "building"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sidewalk<->building", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2406432", "image_sha256": "2ffe807deb0853ef7ca3a4c0c68b8815062150e7cb7ce7526e42ee08acd5d98a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2406432.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2406432.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2326987", "image_sha256": "06bd3bf5d9e73cd1b7dcbe662f1fea680875ef082f7d7957030dc4decc23a946", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326987.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326987.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ce88ab498910cf5a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sidewalk", "diff_b": "building", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sidewalk", "component_b": "building"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "license plate", "mirror", "motorcycle", "numbers", "plant", "planter", "sidewalk", "sign", "store", "windows"], "detected_components": ["sidewalk"], "masked_program_sha256": "2890fd2df6ded0734a1b45464e5a8ff58e949e996f917808af59716e3fbadea9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sidewalk"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sidewalk", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sidewalk"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9ce1c67a3a2077c989c684805d55ec29b7f9181ab349491ac2c6e0a960e747f8"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18374141", "text": "What is on the sidewalk in this photo?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "clock", "flag", "poster", "roof", "window"], "detected_components": ["building"], "masked_program_sha256": "2890fd2df6ded0734a1b45464e5a8ff58e949e996f917808af59716e3fbadea9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "building", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "28a88bde068295270989be1cb036a162d755fe093786114e7f29d6d4d4e8c9fc"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1776043", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25212, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "89b48a879a206088554739b1b6a949e7c3fc361e823cf31d73859dc7d32beca6", "selected_component": "building", "selected_source_question_id": "1776043", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the building in this photo?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the in this photo?", "program_group_hash": "89b48a879a206088554739b1b6a949e7c3fc361e823cf31d73859dc7d32beca6", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "sidewalk"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the in this photo?", "program_group_hash": "89b48a879a206088554739b1b6a949e7c3fc361e823cf31d73859dc7d32beca6", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "building"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "motorcycle", "full_answer": "The motorcycle is on the sidewalk.", "question": "What is on the sidewalk in this photo?", "question_id": "18374141", "semantic": [{"argument": "sidewalk (4144828)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (4144810)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "clock", "full_answer": "The clock is on the building.", "question": "What is on the building in this photo?", "question_id": "1776043", "semantic": [{"argument": "building (2928811)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (3283761)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4144810", "4144811", "4144812", "4144821", "4144822", "4144826", "4144833", "4144834", "4144838", "4144840"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["motorcycle"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "metal"], "query_target_entity_id": "4144810", "query_target_entity_name": "motorcycle", "relation_object_entity_id": "4144828", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4144810", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4144828", "selected_entity_name": "sidewalk"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sidewalk", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4144828"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4144810", "4144812", "4144821", "4144822", "4144826", "4144828", "4144833", "4144834", "4144838", "4144840"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "building", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4144811"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sidewalk", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2884911", "2888083", "2924384", "3283761", "3430577", "3430578", "3430579", "3430580", "3430581"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["clock"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3283761", "query_target_entity_name": "clock", "relation_object_entity_id": "2928811", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3283761", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2928811", "selected_entity_name": "building"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "building", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2928811"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a4a764002d03778892d9bb3cfc7448f5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2ffe807deb0853ef7ca3a4c0c68b8815062150e7cb7ce7526e42ee08acd5d98a", "image_sha256_b": "06bd3bf5d9e73cd1b7dcbe662f1fea680875ef082f7d7957030dc4decc23a946", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0964ad5654e2adfaf635b2dffd919f65db99958dbded0c8ebb982ec471090634", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d2652af20e109fe46f15069b46084d75", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "cc3de5ba2f36b1b8bdafc357cc922eb5197c3b28bc2238b9ebef637638ad4afc"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "120b01faa2a946e44c5632314a78f9ada131b9fc92c88e1f30ad9f37eeb328c1", "request_id": "5815e44cb5c058e488bae594323c8982", "response_sha256": "42736af337be900e0f341bc65f93297fea1c7cd933ba458c7850d7d5e47cb618", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "310b79aa65aa9ada1f6e96ac834d6d1363737b45cdba8912c9772d9d225648eb", "request_id": "5fa745615abb96c5d29224bd469d78e0", "response_sha256": "2df109ecee52affa76bc2efd7f07acf8e2b9ebfd29d39cc01e8c61fb8c333c2a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "170fb3911556e7e8ec376cdf8982c975", "candidate_priority_rank": 25558, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38a4fdfc9d09bee9:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38a4fdfc9d09bee9:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38a4fdfc9d09bee9:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38a4fdfc9d09bee9:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bottle<->glass", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "glass", "B": "bottle"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "glass<->bottle", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2362235", "image_sha256": "5a7389d99f67a428579cec8550fab59d26a53c9034bd96656a012d06cfa00746", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2362235.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2362235.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 331, "image_id": "2393932", "image_sha256": "a685e02491fe9976f491867b2da75dea261128e92c09935f200357acf1f433fb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2393932.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2393932.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38a4fdfc9d09bee9", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "glass", "diff_b": "bottle", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "glass", "component_b": "bottle"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bacon", "balcony", "cereal box", "coffee", "cup", "eggs", "glass", "juice", "milk carton", "plate", "sausages", "silverware", "table", "tomato", "window"], "detected_components": ["glass"], "masked_program_sha256": "c488c7b3b6351e0a5c65c81c044b8de0367f9afeed9fcd5af64f8581a83ba14c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["glass", "drink"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "glass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["glass", "drink"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "de269434c1c62d04ffc8874099e4368b614ee678952aa0b2c1c5ca01d8fd261b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02155086", "text": "What is the drink in the glass?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basil", "beer", "bottle", "cup", "face", "glasses", "hair", "jar", "lettuce", "man", "napkins", "pan", "people", "pepper", "pizza", "plate", "shirt", "spatula", "table", "water", "woman", "women"], "detected_components": ["bottle"], "masked_program_sha256": "c488c7b3b6351e0a5c65c81c044b8de0367f9afeed9fcd5af64f8581a83ba14c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle", "drink"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bottle", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle", "drink"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "efb23ea2e7b9d8db0ac579004e7e33cd0222a531fd1df7f618a066721fe44372"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04841476", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25558, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 18, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1206189731fe0b0365791ed51b405c74dab0a9b50bfdf97b9a8ee79bbb8fb52d", "selected_component": "bottle", "selected_source_question_id": "04841476", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the drink in the bottle?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the drink in the ?", "program_group_hash": "1206189731fe0b0365791ed51b405c74dab0a9b50bfdf97b9a8ee79bbb8fb52d", "queried_category": "drink", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "glass"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the drink in the ?", "program_group_hash": "1206189731fe0b0365791ed51b405c74dab0a9b50bfdf97b9a8ee79bbb8fb52d", "queried_category": "drink", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bottle"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "juice", "full_answer": "The drink is juice.", "question": "What is the drink in the glass?", "question_id": "02155086", "semantic": [{"argument": "glass (775977)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s (775978)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "beer", "full_answer": "The drink is beer.", "question": "What is the drink in the bottle?", "question_id": "04841476", "semantic": [{"argument": "bottle (468530)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s (468531)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["775978", "775980"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["juice"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "775978", "query_target_entity_name": "juice", "relation_object_entity_id": "775977", "relation_subject_entity_id": "775978", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "775977", "selected_entity_name": "glass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["775977"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["468531"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["beer"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "468531", "query_target_entity_name": "beer", "relation_object_entity_id": "468530", "relation_subject_entity_id": "468531", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "468530", "selected_entity_name": "bottle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["468530"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:170fb3911556e7e8ec376cdf8982c975", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5a7389d99f67a428579cec8550fab59d26a53c9034bd96656a012d06cfa00746", "image_sha256_b": "a685e02491fe9976f491867b2da75dea261128e92c09935f200357acf1f433fb", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ab8df8bdceffc8ebb703531a876e06238a0397e3e9b0f7573c525f23135da7a7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "192bd6576507d7b3a2cac236437030b8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "bd7c2662c90b38fbae45aaa2f52706820d5434587843381038d266650979489a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "865e3f23caf0763175264f555eb702e42eb3882f8dc387fb7ccd66ad279ed8b1", "request_id": "d123d481e7be15254e7e7ba6a3e15abd", "response_sha256": "307932c65f8729d68ed8f0c4d1b50801b7ce9b509f85e4b933622227d5c96870", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3fcfbff7f16e591dfeb5ff3f9f0054374332e48a2a940fd3dc8eea77763f945a", "request_id": "aabd3b119003ddc279c126e38572f9c9", "response_sha256": "8ebbab9a720b6c3c33415f6e720de7bb7591a9dd6c1543c7b7d76d31064cf7a3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "fbe434ceeb83f28012ce6240f35d83e1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25625, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-489f8fc37163b862:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-489f8fc37163b862:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-489f8fc37163b862:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-489f8fc37163b862:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "backpack<->dog", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "backpack", "B": "dog"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "backpack<->dog", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2408362", "image_sha256": "1af7b1728eab7598b0d84b2d3520bc48903a327ef2d02870b78a979c89ad8817", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408362.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408362.jpg", "width": 396}, "B": {"height": 472, "image_id": "2386795", "image_sha256": "9d0670e8e6b561545c7e29f44723707fb28aba563a791050dd36f5ec020ed119", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386795.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386795.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "activity_state", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-489f8fc37163b862", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "backpack", "diff_b": "dog", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "backpack", "component_b": "dog"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "sportactivity", "question_intent": "activity_state:sportactivity", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["backpack", "hand", "mountain", "pants", "person", "pole", "ski", "skier", "skis", "snow", "tents", "tree", "trees"], "detected_components": ["backpack"], "masked_program_sha256": "2ac4979a7d1347a9b3250633195e8c3d4ff1d3f029c60c6a5f72f8aedd314460", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["backpack", "person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "backpack", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["backpack", "person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7a5fa24091f305a282424f4470d220deffd11833fe7db33cb5de908a174e44ae"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12776787", "text": "What is the person with the backpack doing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bandana", "dog", "ear", "eye", "face", "glove", "ground", "head", "jacket", "nose", "pants", "pine tree", "ski", "snow", "woman"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "2ac4979a7d1347a9b3250633195e8c3d4ff1d3f029c60c6a5f72f8aedd314460", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0691f185564b7f983cd24ff083c00c20ca142b006f175787d832ee700f2d4521"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04687938", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25625, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "62d742a04d326f7036f0c546a4ce29812c51bbe7f6ce05ea548e5abad56db9b4", "selected_component": "dog", "selected_source_question_id": "04687938", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person with the dog doing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,with,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "sportactivity", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person with the doing?", "program_group_hash": "62d742a04d326f7036f0c546a4ce29812c51bbe7f6ce05ea548e5abad56db9b4", "queried_category": "person", "query_role": "sportactivity", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "with", "select_category": "backpack"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,with,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "sportactivity", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person with the doing?", "program_group_hash": "62d742a04d326f7036f0c546a4ce29812c51bbe7f6ce05ea548e5abad56db9b4", "queried_category": "person", "query_role": "sportactivity", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "with", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "skiing", "full_answer": "The person is skiing.", "question": "What is the person with the backpack doing?", "question_id": "12776787", "semantic": [{"argument": "backpack (1093566)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,with,s (1093561)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "sportActivity", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "skiing", "full_answer": "The woman is skiing.", "question": "What is the person with the dog doing?", "question_id": "04687938", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (516759)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,with,s (516762)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "sportActivity", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1093561"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["skiing"], "predicate": "with", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["skiing"], "query_target_entity_id": "1093561", "query_target_entity_name": "person", "relation_object_entity_id": "1093566", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1093561", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1093566", "selected_entity_name": "backpack"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "backpack", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1093566"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "backpack", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["516762"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["skiing"], "predicate": "with", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["skiing"], "query_target_entity_id": "516762", "query_target_entity_name": "woman", "relation_object_entity_id": "516759", "relation_subject_entity_id": "516762", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "516759", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["516759"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:fbe434ceeb83f28012ce6240f35d83e1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1af7b1728eab7598b0d84b2d3520bc48903a327ef2d02870b78a979c89ad8817", "image_sha256_b": "9d0670e8e6b561545c7e29f44723707fb28aba563a791050dd36f5ec020ed119", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5a1a7c1f091849fa35ddf9ea19b827f4a83cbb1a7d564bedc71b04822c816dd6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a038025e94bcce0433312fb1af8f49e3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "abe0b9a89e3ad13e0bf282116191d20ba9bde01fa7e4a5ea61889af8c0918027"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e4dc0b332fa9c1f96b7e6e7dae6f21f8eb59d837276f0e6e966c81a693d05960", "request_id": "1441e079c334f8aef44fd8a65a116bd8", "response_sha256": "d3e35c1daada7635cb47308c719f9a688cad36b3d1aa6a3a5a7b9433446071eb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c66dbceffc4f9128249454a06139d8d0d38f7aac1a49de0de737d058dd688bca", "request_id": "b1a90ec29d41741a99c1f01bef749317", "response_sha256": "d74826e8bcc3cd78c2d71d26520b93e16e966886e798a402a7504c6f61b8f21c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "f23124d940e065bc03ef2038d0ced884", "candidate_priority_rank": 25774, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f1b28be9435bb884:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f1b28be9435bb884:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f1b28be9435bb884:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f1b28be9435bb884:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "wagon<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "wagon"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->wagon", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 320, "image_id": "2398225", "image_sha256": "b5ed58369db1a5c0d4f4e344b276a7e703b2750ac14fa49f47ea82d51c789181", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398225.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398225.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 329, "image_id": "2409656", "image_sha256": "22c282c8735006f8ac7492596c71829d56e85b2fe82da7f4cd064ee629f850cb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2409656.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2409656.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f1b28be9435bb884", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "wagon", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "wagon"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["hair", "hands", "hill", "legs", "mountains", "orange", "rope", "sky", "snow", "tree", "water", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "a772e032c479080b90b57c0fa69a7fda12c8defe617b44c6afaf786639ef62dc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0c1bd92f9975e7ed5f789b51428ac6275dc07ee149f8cced3549e5b87eb41aeb"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00525546", "text": "What is the woman pulled by?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "barrier", "chains", "helmet", "jacket", "jeans", "license plate", "man", "motorcycle", "people", "person", "road", "seat", "shoe", "shoes", "tire", "wagon", "water", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["wagon"], "masked_program_sha256": "a772e032c479080b90b57c0fa69a7fda12c8defe617b44c6afaf786639ef62dc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wagon"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wagon", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wagon"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d982397f8b78ecc795e4a8867f7ba6aefa70cf842007fb905edacae755ae3d0b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19126624", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25774, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 16, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "7b69d3ee45c4a7b84534f6ff51aece7de55b618348b3e4bbe9def5945e89cc74", "selected_component": "wagon", "selected_source_question_id": "19126624", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the wagon pulled by?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,pulled by,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the pulled by?", "program_group_hash": "7b69d3ee45c4a7b84534f6ff51aece7de55b618348b3e4bbe9def5945e89cc74", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "pulled by", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,pulled by,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the pulled by?", "program_group_hash": "7b69d3ee45c4a7b84534f6ff51aece7de55b618348b3e4bbe9def5945e89cc74", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "pulled by", "select_category": "wagon"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "rope", "full_answer": "The woman is pulled by the rope.", "question": "What is the woman pulled by?", "question_id": "00525546", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (1181468)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,pulled by,o (1181480)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "motorcycle", "full_answer": "The wagon is pulled by the motorcycle.", "question": "What is the wagon pulled by?", "question_id": "19126624", "semantic": [{"argument": "wagon (236952)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,pulled by,o (236947)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1181471", "1181475", "1181476", "1181477", "1181480", "1181484", "1181486", "1181487", "1181489", "1181490", "1181491"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["rope"], "predicate": "pulled by", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1181480", "query_target_entity_name": "rope", "relation_object_entity_id": "1181480", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1181468", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1181468", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1181468"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wagon", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["236943", "236945", "236946", "236947", "236948", "236950", "236953", "236954", "236955", "236956", "236957", "236958", "236960", "236961", "236962", "236965", "236966", "236967"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["motorcycle"], "predicate": "pulled by", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["colorful", "large", "purple"], "query_target_entity_id": "236947", "query_target_entity_name": "motorcycle", "relation_object_entity_id": "236947", "relation_subject_entity_id": "236952", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "236952", "selected_entity_name": "wagon"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wagon", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["236952"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f23124d940e065bc03ef2038d0ced884", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b5ed58369db1a5c0d4f4e344b276a7e703b2750ac14fa49f47ea82d51c789181", "image_sha256_b": "22c282c8735006f8ac7492596c71829d56e85b2fe82da7f4cd064ee629f850cb", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ab6e31b904535853a1ac5bd61aeceb1663c76d31f184f93c17fac33347f84d6b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ebec62d3e77960bf93b513f8cfb6fb0e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9bb75a75fc670cbaef14823f200a2fc0bb3396fcbe491e690b2a86c3a3a39d32"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "63ab444262ef4938663e4444d83232fbb5c1cd519328333cce65e73ee031b841", "request_id": "0c281577aba6ca2180f045b241629591", "response_sha256": "395e342df12b600d1db29ea0e2f783101ca6237664f2e6cda9f6a799b7db531f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "069874c369ea266db696df46d477271b4eca1f2b70b46e9f0ee2b903ff02bf21", "request_id": "da75e5b8137b269fd13be6ab89e36adc", "response_sha256": "2dc189c7c91717f15922c9e8db85818abb954ebdc5afd6bf8dc069400f9b9df3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "f777bc5100b2879d20057db2396e8e59", "candidate_priority_rank": 25953, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df0281cf6f776ac9:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df0281cf6f776ac9:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df0281cf6f776ac9:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df0281cf6f776ac9:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "mouse pad<->screen", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "mouse pad", "B": "screen"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "mouse pad<->screen", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 600, "image_id": "2457", "image_sha256": "03b56ba47be8b54c27b38434c4241a3595c44203cbb2725d5c176f8a4c045413", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2457.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2457.jpg", "width": 800}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2407742", "image_sha256": "04415d8a32355011d0db3c5f16ea215ad92bebb90750eb5b3bad9ed1611f2d81", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407742.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407742.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df0281cf6f776ac9", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "mouse pad", "diff_b": "screen", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "mouse pad", "component_b": "screen"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.1975, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.0725, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 4}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.221, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.072, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "bowl", "box", "chair", "computer mouse", "cup", "ear", "hair", "headphones", "keyboard", "mouse pad", "person", "screen", "shirt", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["mouse pad"], "masked_program_sha256": "ff478ca0b045755cb0d118e6f3507c8df5ebb02d9623c8b9cc8b0dda387a229c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mouse pad", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mouse pad", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mouse pad", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5f8b2e9d637072a0b3517843496e071e4bc75987d40407139df83e3fca5c51d3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16109466", "text": "What device is on the right of the mouse pad?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ceiling", "cell phone", "eyes", "glass", "glasses", "ice", "jacket", "ketchup", "ketchup bottle", "lid", "man", "mustard bottle", "nose", "plate", "screen", "shirt", "table", "woman"], "detected_components": ["screen"], "masked_program_sha256": "ff478ca0b045755cb0d118e6f3507c8df5ebb02d9623c8b9cc8b0dda387a229c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["screen", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "screen", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["screen", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "85b3919d0e751db27266ee33083699ba51a12aec6e099e6ac77f39a8a363f63e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13779594", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25953, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 21, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b8f4f5a0002bf10bf8d07f1570ad9a1c2d7cbcfd963230ead23fef146716d8a7", "selected_component": "screen", "selected_source_question_id": "13779594", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What device is on the right of the screen?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what device is on the right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "b8f4f5a0002bf10bf8d07f1570ad9a1c2d7cbcfd963230ead23fef146716d8a7", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "mouse pad"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what device is on the right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "b8f4f5a0002bf10bf8d07f1570ad9a1c2d7cbcfd963230ead23fef146716d8a7", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "screen"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "headphones", "full_answer": "The device is headphones.", "question": "What device is on the right of the mouse pad?", "question_id": "16109466", "semantic": [{"argument": "mouse pad (4540374)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,to the right of,s (4540349)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cell phone", "full_answer": "The device is a cell phone.", "question": "What device is on the right of the screen?", "question_id": "13779594", "semantic": [{"argument": "screen (323446)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,to the right of,s (323420)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4540349", "4540353", "4540356", "4540361"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["headphones"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "4540349", "query_target_entity_name": "headphones", "relation_object_entity_id": "4540374", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4540349", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4540374", "selected_entity_name": "mouse pad"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mouse pad", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4540374"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4540349", "4540356", "4540361"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "screen", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4540353"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mouse pad", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["323420"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cell phone"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "323420", "query_target_entity_name": "cell phone", "relation_object_entity_id": "323446", "relation_subject_entity_id": "323420", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "323446", "selected_entity_name": "screen"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "screen", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["323446"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f777bc5100b2879d20057db2396e8e59", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "03b56ba47be8b54c27b38434c4241a3595c44203cbb2725d5c176f8a4c045413", "image_sha256_b": "04415d8a32355011d0db3c5f16ea215ad92bebb90750eb5b3bad9ed1611f2d81", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a7be183eeaeca9a9d7eb3c51e032fb974a7c254da95c178cd901db66f799b7b1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e52992ea936025b6002f486ad79d6c4b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4758d3a8651d17be2653f862c278eb531d88fb45f1fd2c467391066344487ad4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4fa489af4928d7615ba49d91cff7ada6c14a28669c66018171a70427f056ccbb", "request_id": "f002f8bf96c88411fc1a4a4ac1b28281", "response_sha256": "acec0c86f858c17eb41f9b5b239876c4491554b265be328813d4fb91aad2b792", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f18b3878e53bedb26ee26b239ab953e8753081fcdb5d0f80a3bce15711b260e6", "request_id": "8df57464947f33a1ae757f33778a26b8", "response_sha256": "cdf8f731c670c30a57b79dad7be3425f5f185915816c833f69561bb7e73fbc9e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "4c689c9906a7b2172a10137d0133bbeb", "candidate_priority_rank": 26008, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e0e3a8a87860096:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e0e3a8a87860096:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e0e3a8a87860096:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e0e3a8a87860096:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "driver<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "driver", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "driver<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 330, "image_id": "2400474", "image_sha256": "018ed98b9f6f60aa678f4b68d4362435d790d4b25927d5e123bc2df312b2dbdf", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400474.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400474.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2364024", "image_sha256": "1562e38504faf2628dbc1fa9569a15540ac8252654df1e749b8dac173eb088b0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364024.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364024.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e0e3a8a87860096", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "driver", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "driver", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cars", "door", "driver", "leaves", "number", "sidewalk", "sky", "street", "train", "trees", "trunk", "windows", "windshield"], "detected_components": ["driver"], "masked_program_sha256": "a72ee37c1c42f0ae174733294a585d47bad6e43a76244ac5f8294a15ce917672", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["driver"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "driver", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["driver"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "af68cd388c2e1116496e76becdf9e780db086b5e53aa5c6ac010e438dacf3894"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14120598", "text": "What's the driver driving?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "boat", "cap", "collar", "dog", "ear", "face", "head", "man", "nose", "rope", "sailboat", "shirt", "sign", "water"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "a72ee37c1c42f0ae174733294a585d47bad6e43a76244ac5f8294a15ce917672", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ec55e15810da9501dbce271fad5e3b7fc73edbb8b2856f6d9463a7ed173618f0"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10479092", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26008, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4cbf132c4be237aba4ff632878a4b03ee75972abc4ec9ca4285f934cc137036c", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "10479092", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's the man driving?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,driving,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the driving?", "program_group_hash": "4cbf132c4be237aba4ff632878a4b03ee75972abc4ec9ca4285f934cc137036c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "driving", "select_category": "driver"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,driving,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the driving?", "program_group_hash": "4cbf132c4be237aba4ff632878a4b03ee75972abc4ec9ca4285f934cc137036c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "driving", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "train", "full_answer": "The driver is driving the train.", "question": "What's the driver driving?", "question_id": "14120598", "semantic": [{"argument": "driver (1158546)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,driving,o (1158564)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "boat", "full_answer": "The man is driving the boat.", "question": "What's the man driving?", "question_id": "10479092", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (760158)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,driving,o (760151)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1158545", "1158547", "1158548", "1158549", "1158551", "1158552", "1158558", "1158564", "1158569", "1158570", "1158572", "1158574"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["train"], "predicate": "driving", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1158564", "query_target_entity_name": "train", "relation_object_entity_id": "1158564", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1158546", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1158546", "selected_entity_name": "driver"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "driver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1158546"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "driver", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["760150", "760151", "760152", "760153", "760156", "760159", "760160", "760164", "760166", "760168", "760169", "760170", "760171", "760172", "760175", "760176", "760177", "760178"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["boat"], "predicate": "driving", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "760151", "query_target_entity_name": "boat", "relation_object_entity_id": "760151", "relation_subject_entity_id": "760158", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "760158", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["760158"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4c689c9906a7b2172a10137d0133bbeb", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "018ed98b9f6f60aa678f4b68d4362435d790d4b25927d5e123bc2df312b2dbdf", "image_sha256_b": "1562e38504faf2628dbc1fa9569a15540ac8252654df1e749b8dac173eb088b0", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f1d8fc0eea802ad4f5a2ad79e20341b9d44755ad2dc3cc0c9beba6721643e705", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "da23900658acdaab9ebc0c6cca7ee0ce", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "09349bcd13e95ad4b26c217673385425a1e43aee5c844d34f9b5cde7ce58fc38"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e88f716db3bc56c1ff052a7555a2af7d655a98d96dd2bc4b0cc4b0c6d0474456", "request_id": "7157bef3dfd1c62edafe73455dc3a74f", "response_sha256": "ea5d8857f005a3435642b29249060d75b98b915bfd3a056f5e0e4c9140c0108d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a3495a3d3fb4e3dc47c17df72990d80adae1221b2aa897bf4e91ca6f7200c19e", "request_id": "13a018d17dd4681ff6252282abc93797", "response_sha256": "7ab73db69891b13278bb0ee180db3c1d3fa01018a9e930ead31ce92bbbd27e1d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "f2c488b6f9fc02d3cd87003977fc78d4", "candidate_priority_rank": 26234, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59d18d6bd538fe50:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59d18d6bd538fe50:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59d18d6bd538fe50:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59d18d6bd538fe50:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bowl<->raincoat", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "raincoat", "B": "bowl"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "raincoat<->bowl", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2356327", "image_sha256": "6ae61f2087660d317033a59eeb16b47d8f8ca1477009c20f50153da036e489e0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2356327.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2356327.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2317091", "image_sha256": "c8939c9870bd79099082078d537f7e143d1105c5743e038b9d529c8e160715f4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317091.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317091.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59d18d6bd538fe50", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "raincoat", "diff_b": "bowl", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "raincoat", "component_b": "bowl"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "dress", "hair", "license plate", "mouth", "purse", "rain", "raincoat", "road", "sandals", "shoe", "sidewalk", "tree", "umbrella", "woman"], "detected_components": ["raincoat"], "masked_program_sha256": "fabb9bcb977265b9b76cb7eca42332070163f0fb1834dee866b4432e80d9d8cc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["raincoat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "raincoat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["raincoat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "56df134052de0833b7d097c1635782205b39fbd8580e3807613a1e305b965b12"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13935005", "text": "What's underneath the raincoat?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "bread", "food", "plate", "utensil", "window"], "detected_components": ["bowl"], "masked_program_sha256": "fabb9bcb977265b9b76cb7eca42332070163f0fb1834dee866b4432e80d9d8cc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bowl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3067ff86ae50753b33c10cfd847ded8a75d82ac6051715d4ff6f7b63c7af0352"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09434608", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26234, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 11, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d194f8feb13bc4132fc707881599baaf192cea04318885f4373397ca0583f6d3", "selected_component": "bowl", "selected_source_question_id": "09434608", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's underneath the bowl?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's underneath the ?", "program_group_hash": "d194f8feb13bc4132fc707881599baaf192cea04318885f4373397ca0583f6d3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "underneath", "select_category": "raincoat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's underneath the ?", "program_group_hash": "d194f8feb13bc4132fc707881599baaf192cea04318885f4373397ca0583f6d3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "underneath", "select_category": "bowl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dress", "full_answer": "The dress is underneath the raincoat.", "question": "What's underneath the raincoat?", "question_id": "13935005", "semantic": [{"argument": "raincoat (821524)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s (821525)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "plate", "full_answer": "The plate is underneath the bowl.", "question": "What's underneath the bowl?", "question_id": "09434608", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (1023660)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s (1023661)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3772580", "821522", "821523", "821525", "821526", "821527", "821528", "821529", "821530", "821531", "821532", "821534", "821535", "821537"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dress"], "predicate": "underneath", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["wet", "yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "821525", "query_target_entity_name": "dress", "relation_object_entity_id": "821524", "relation_subject_entity_id": "821525", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "821524", "selected_entity_name": "raincoat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "raincoat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["821524"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "raincoat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1023659", "1023661", "1023662", "1023663", "1023664"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["plate"], "predicate": "underneath", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["round", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1023661", "query_target_entity_name": "plate", "relation_object_entity_id": "1023660", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1023661", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1023660", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1023660"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f2c488b6f9fc02d3cd87003977fc78d4", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6ae61f2087660d317033a59eeb16b47d8f8ca1477009c20f50153da036e489e0", "image_sha256_b": "c8939c9870bd79099082078d537f7e143d1105c5743e038b9d529c8e160715f4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0897262714cdb9def5879962f03218df853456260a8c34a449ab26d153bf11ca", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "45b4244d53b7bb006862a5e541cbefa9", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b0cf4a1b6fea1d8e143256b9a586b275cde3744daea1702c2f024668dc8a8fd8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d5637ffd88d9c7649f3a13881f865bb99feb0569914e2c5f1bde8379b8055f76", "request_id": "638fe8439ce32dbdf47cd564cf97e0d6", "response_sha256": "d2c3e97111c8e3c9c1f658ef1230a47e24ea1a6f46a553692991d883b1fdeb0f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "06236466edef9656d52c3bc69f0a091818edeefb064c76b63ca71d4786c17c1c", "request_id": "6481e23d112e1f8fabd0f3b8a2d530ca", "response_sha256": "59a0e1de5d39b89312b7329e6d9b072c29f3030afdd356e6d0bb7789cb5555eb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "b08b4ad589fdf3a6ddc42907d273a3de", "candidate_priority_rank": 26246, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-99f2099f7a862881:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-99f2099f7a862881:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-99f2099f7a862881:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-99f2099f7a862881:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bottle<->glass", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bottle", "B": "glass"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bottle<->glass", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2392200", "image_sha256": "ca2bdcbd601cd21741e47d210f70366be2620951ebe0e3ae49e6d43667014a2d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392200.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392200.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2371504", "image_sha256": "b8adb7ace927a979b402af4db595019c21e067da744cf8046bf18b925ae76339", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371504.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371504.jpg", "width": 374}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-99f2099f7a862881", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bottle", "diff_b": "glass", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bottle", "component_b": "glass"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "cow", "door", "ear", "eye", "face", "fence", "floor", "hand", "head", "jacket", "jeans", "milk", "nose", "person"], "detected_components": ["bottle"], "masked_program_sha256": "c488c7b3b6351e0a5c65c81c044b8de0367f9afeed9fcd5af64f8581a83ba14c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle", "drink"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bottle", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bottle", "drink"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "efb23ea2e7b9d8db0ac579004e7e33cd0222a531fd1df7f618a066721fe44372"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19263545", "text": "What is the drink in the bottle?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bread", "cheese", "container", "flower", "food", "glass", "ground", "leaf", "mat", "meat", "pepper", "plate", "salad", "table", "tomato", "wine"], "detected_components": ["glass"], "masked_program_sha256": "c488c7b3b6351e0a5c65c81c044b8de0367f9afeed9fcd5af64f8581a83ba14c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["glass", "drink"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "glass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["glass", "drink"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "de269434c1c62d04ffc8874099e4368b614ee678952aa0b2c1c5ca01d8fd261b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02315298", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26246, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 15, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1206189731fe0b0365791ed51b405c74dab0a9b50bfdf97b9a8ee79bbb8fb52d", "selected_component": "glass", "selected_source_question_id": "02315298", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the drink in the glass?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the drink in the ?", "program_group_hash": "1206189731fe0b0365791ed51b405c74dab0a9b50bfdf97b9a8ee79bbb8fb52d", "queried_category": "drink", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bottle"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the drink in the ?", "program_group_hash": "1206189731fe0b0365791ed51b405c74dab0a9b50bfdf97b9a8ee79bbb8fb52d", "queried_category": "drink", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "glass"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "milk", "full_answer": "The drink is milk.", "question": "What is the drink in the bottle?", "question_id": "19263545", "semantic": [{"argument": "bottle (1232880)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s (1232893)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "wine", "full_answer": "The drink is wine.", "question": "What is the drink in the glass?", "question_id": "02315298", "semantic": [{"argument": "glass (1980706)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "drink,in,s (1980707)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1232893"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["milk"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1232893", "query_target_entity_name": "milk", "relation_object_entity_id": "1232880", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1232893", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1232880", "selected_entity_name": "bottle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1232880"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1980707"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wine"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "1980707", "query_target_entity_name": "wine", "relation_object_entity_id": "1980706", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1980707", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1980706", "selected_entity_name": "glass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "glass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1980706"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b08b4ad589fdf3a6ddc42907d273a3de", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ca2bdcbd601cd21741e47d210f70366be2620951ebe0e3ae49e6d43667014a2d", "image_sha256_b": "b8adb7ace927a979b402af4db595019c21e067da744cf8046bf18b925ae76339", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ac38692a479bbba3069046048ceceac439d58dfd2ca47f2eceb4b7793d19d02e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a8e0f10991c7d5f83f36af05fd5dea5c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5248be7f445c441b485cadeeed5b9fda80f5aa9bec4c174a50ba6dee11f17968"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a1f83f059543cc1f86ba821b02b3a528098db46c83066776f55ae7d18bdb3e29", "request_id": "c1b655d3a2a2eecedc0df0528bf496a5", "response_sha256": "34190f76b614b78651d05d570358cc5e2e5a1c10a1bf1cdb43a3e8a38d13b0aa", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b9d203bdd1141cdc7c74fc63230ea1733b4a23f82b28745f8e653d80d1d0a64a", "request_id": "324667263dfa243719e872c7f875d930", "response_sha256": "3533025795d4dd5e14eafa31d7f0acf76e7c100f2a510af31226ca8a0c3221cc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "b5efe5a3f6efbfabffb8762d0df0f07e", "candidate_priority_rank": 26266, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cdeada36f2941e37:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cdeada36f2941e37:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cdeada36f2941e37:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cdeada36f2941e37:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "magazine<->pillow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "pillow", "B": "magazine"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "pillow<->magazine", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 377, "image_id": "2337217", "image_sha256": "5345166cf75d07b330835ea6da296336b1145009963c8dac797df5ce40421fa9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2337217.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2337217.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 600, "image_id": "2006", "image_sha256": "6fe86e197668528e51d1ad11372458f032c7466daba66661d74b2dccbdea6f96", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2006.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2006.jpg", "width": 800}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cdeada36f2941e37", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "pillow", "diff_b": "magazine", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "pillow", "component_b": "magazine"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "bed", "blanket", "book", "bookcase", "books", "bookshelf", "chair", "dresser", "ground", "hearts", "mirror", "pillow", "plant", "window"], "detected_components": ["pillow"], "masked_program_sha256": "0daf575b077a08727295a94c5d75a33ba86f0da0a2ce4e29070c39f428672504", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pillow", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pillow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pillow", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3edc1f711db524ef21db884d12327eb2261ff7ef0e93a6f3a6b46b559bc671aa"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05104116", "text": "What is the piece of furniture that the pillow is sitting on called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "blanket", "building", "coffee table", "couch", "desk", "ground", "lamp", "magazine", "painting", "wall"], "detected_components": ["magazine"], "masked_program_sha256": "0daf575b077a08727295a94c5d75a33ba86f0da0a2ce4e29070c39f428672504", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["magazine", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "magazine", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["magazine", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "744034d52c9969567a073e4b6589eec8f76b4a70cccc047d4f7c0b411adfd36b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09469996", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26266, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5189e7a96626e011a692681fbf926529ebcc9a9b53e9f1c5965e7d029229b2dd", "selected_component": "magazine", "selected_source_question_id": "09469996", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the piece of furniture that the magazine is sitting on called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that the is sitting on called?", "program_group_hash": "5189e7a96626e011a692681fbf926529ebcc9a9b53e9f1c5965e7d029229b2dd", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "pillow"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that the is sitting on called?", "program_group_hash": "5189e7a96626e011a692681fbf926529ebcc9a9b53e9f1c5965e7d029229b2dd", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "magazine"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a chair.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that the pillow is sitting on called?", "question_id": "05104116", "semantic": [{"argument": "pillow (3445116)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (3445117)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "coffee table", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a coffee table.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that the magazine is sitting on called?", "question_id": "09469996", "semantic": [{"argument": "magazine (2402409)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (2402410)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2120228", "2290543", "3384355", "3436157", "3445117"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3445117", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "3445117", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3445116", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3445116", "selected_entity_name": "pillow"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pillow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3445116"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "magazine", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pillow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2265115", "2402410", "3639225"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["coffee table"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2402410", "query_target_entity_name": "coffee table", "relation_object_entity_id": "2402410", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2402409", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2402409", "selected_entity_name": "magazine"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "magazine", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2402409"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b5efe5a3f6efbfabffb8762d0df0f07e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5345166cf75d07b330835ea6da296336b1145009963c8dac797df5ce40421fa9", "image_sha256_b": "6fe86e197668528e51d1ad11372458f032c7466daba66661d74b2dccbdea6f96", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a5b4c6f07dd60ca4369f30e5ff3274c2e295e8edc4a3953d24a0dd195f3a0163", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8eab4551fe0d6be0b9a3294be71a5ddf", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "75715402bdf63aa0bd6449e5821845276bded65f515c5ee0d5a14eb0a7696223"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a7b78e9368267a78ce49505655d41a615eb996f81788349e9d7e83df69abb309", "request_id": "0a1df2af3201231e74836843c9d70a50", "response_sha256": "3930d0a125a1c4fb1f982fac33a50aad1ad3a6c88109755ba0893cf908d71d09", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "19ba7b81627f5abfac26361af6ad1f1be29e57f4e14990f43f0ed54d03459594", "request_id": "3f78935c58fe67c1b36eb0c7192373c4", "response_sha256": "563b55e60f2d04b9eca49b7271c796ab135a15fb4d180bd915e6fd1283ea76cc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "4924407feccd23bd2bef7e3066ac8a3c", "candidate_priority_rank": 26290, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9714d6c0effc21ec:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9714d6c0effc21ec:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9714d6c0effc21ec:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9714d6c0effc21ec:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "boy<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "boy", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "boy<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2389491", "image_sha256": "93f18f5c9aa650f6b0c6668e0012105bf4b185eca50401989438dfb6b1897e42", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389491.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389491.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2381105", "image_sha256": "4ebd427bd4a7944970b6417ecc8aca4721438cde6b861f27bea774f4e11c619a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2381105.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2381105.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9714d6c0effc21ec", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "boy", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "boy", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ball", "bat", "boy", "child", "fence", "ground", "helmet", "jeans", "man", "pants", "shirt", "shoes", "sign"], "detected_components": ["boy"], "masked_program_sha256": "056dcd48ea7bffb7df00bc63aa84331d2b3061e72e815bfdf1be390e62b84403", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "helmet"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "boy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "helmet"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3c3d6b611bfadb88ce66eeaa859840558bda56547fb34aaf01aaf8d68692fc6d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0067782", "text": "What color do you think the helmet the boy is wearing is?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cone", "ground", "head", "helmet", "man", "shirt", "shoe", "shorts", "sign", "skateboard", "wheel", "woman"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "056dcd48ea7bffb7df00bc63aa84331d2b3061e72e815bfdf1be390e62b84403", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "helmet"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "helmet"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "298eb3da9aa21c72d31ff6b0052af359149d9a92b09b6dcf904a7f6b7e12b6b2"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13942735", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26290, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "77f966819f21aec27beefaf115fb03d598a0abaf821fac1935e0d761fbcd059b", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "13942735", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color do you think the helmet the man is wearing is?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "helmet,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color do you think the helmet the is wearing is?", "program_group_hash": "77f966819f21aec27beefaf115fb03d598a0abaf821fac1935e0d761fbcd059b", "queried_category": "helmet", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "boy"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "helmet,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color do you think the helmet the is wearing is?", "program_group_hash": "77f966819f21aec27beefaf115fb03d598a0abaf821fac1935e0d761fbcd059b", "queried_category": "helmet", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "blue", "full_answer": "The helmet is blue.", "question": "What color do you think the helmet the boy is wearing is?", "question_id": "0067782", "semantic": [{"argument": "boy (668533)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "helmet,wearing,o (668535)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "beige", "full_answer": "The helmet is beige.", "question": "What color do you think the helmet the man is wearing is?", "question_id": "13942735", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1339266)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "helmet,wearing,o (1339268)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["668535"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blue"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "668535", "query_target_entity_name": "helmet", "relation_object_entity_id": "668535", "relation_subject_entity_id": "668533", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "668533", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["668533"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["668535"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["668537"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1339268", "1339273"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["beige"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["beige"], "query_target_entity_id": "1339268", "query_target_entity_name": "helmet", "relation_object_entity_id": "1339268", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1339266", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1339266", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1339266"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4924407feccd23bd2bef7e3066ac8a3c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "93f18f5c9aa650f6b0c6668e0012105bf4b185eca50401989438dfb6b1897e42", "image_sha256_b": "4ebd427bd4a7944970b6417ecc8aca4721438cde6b861f27bea774f4e11c619a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4114e42ed4b3929bfed481442dc446d18c77ecbdf8d4fec42367be97cb66f06a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "cd8f3110d14ec92f40ab90cf28910f8b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "84ed034aa822962ad4890ff0c693b4d706d27d591bb6b540829286759681dfc7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6213bf593ede2269bb748db5dc27b6a8ea93dfa3a41d74abf08428ecb22d9d4d", "request_id": "6ea92747140ed5513d8dbf96cf0da1c8", "response_sha256": "2ef16dfeceee01964bccd3a5e5f7413edbdb49b1f1a113a90ca3833a3ee29792", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8cc17dbb559aa4342556f183f27ec658f6bf6be541e2c1e6912236c3fb8db6a9", "request_id": "85695921a386af203fbb9bd7b2adbab2", "response_sha256": "4fe86b5fe145237f95c4c34a3f23f3421259dc87b1431f2f879215b76b48c913", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "83a4e9cbd579bea62293d4f304fca90c", "candidate_priority_rank": 26358, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-411af11e275fa116:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-411af11e275fa116:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-411af11e275fa116:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-411af11e275fa116:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "picture<->sink", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "picture", "B": "sink"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "picture<->sink", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2320200", "image_sha256": "cc92aff2507e85513acf45744e3647dcdc6ea165212c14d8bf96e67cb33bd91a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2320200.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2320200.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2385278", "image_sha256": "e89e9512149b262c2ac218f27cc3d6b0fd0bf31f5e432f93bb8300f301c8e420", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2385278.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2385278.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-411af11e275fa116", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "picture", "diff_b": "sink", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "picture", "component_b": "sink"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["armchair", "arms", "balcony", "bed", "bedspread", "blanket", "cabinets", "chair", "curtain", "deck", "desk", "doors", "floor", "floor lamp", "hotel room", "lamp", "lamp shade", "outlet", "phone", "picture", "remote control", "sheet", "television", "trash can", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["picture"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["picture", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "picture", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["picture", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "56ace2a614bcb852caf1d525da8be87351f090084e4bcd6d59e32bdb0483a946"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07672844", "text": "What item of furniture is below the picture?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "counter", "cup", "dishes", "faucet", "kitchen", "microwave", "mug", "papers", "sink", "table", "trees", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["sink"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sink", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dacb13082ee4a033143484694a5bd07a7e81e1a732af0b769e16b206e727f88b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00354758", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26358, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "075674909b7d7d5ff5d580cd722f2fb2e2960528ad34040ccf6ed9641773201d", "selected_component": "sink", "selected_source_question_id": "00354758", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What item of furniture is below the sink?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "075674909b7d7d5ff5d580cd722f2fb2e2960528ad34040ccf6ed9641773201d", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "picture"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "075674909b7d7d5ff5d580cd722f2fb2e2960528ad34040ccf6ed9641773201d", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "sink"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "desk", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a desk.", "question": "What item of furniture is below the picture?", "question_id": "07672844", "semantic": [{"argument": "picture (4476525)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (4035406)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cabinet", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a cabinet.", "question": "What item of furniture is below the sink?", "question_id": "00354758", "semantic": [{"argument": "sink (1298889)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (1298895)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4035406", "4035418", "4035429", "4035435", "4035445", "4035453"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["desk"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4035406", "query_target_entity_name": "desk", "relation_object_entity_id": "4476525", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4035406", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4476525", "selected_entity_name": "picture"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "picture", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4476525"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "picture", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1298895", "1298904", "1298910"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cabinet"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "1298895", "query_target_entity_name": "cabinet", "relation_object_entity_id": "1298889", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1298895", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1298889", "selected_entity_name": "sink"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1298889"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:83a4e9cbd579bea62293d4f304fca90c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "cc92aff2507e85513acf45744e3647dcdc6ea165212c14d8bf96e67cb33bd91a", "image_sha256_b": "e89e9512149b262c2ac218f27cc3d6b0fd0bf31f5e432f93bb8300f301c8e420", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b51093da45af1de4838f44d296076ae9c51338182c96b54960c89e136708b55a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b4b60416e40a3b89473192b1b21f32cf", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b1a97966298b786495ab933e87251b98eede1b173ce56618034edbd285253b24"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "63029aa38e9c10decbf63137842a5636ee7bb7c884b9c4c19e2aa6ec1c1749df", "request_id": "90d38e22ef8a60463cb51e255d351766", "response_sha256": "805524746f375f5a1d14d4f7bcbd3079e2e10775edb0884cb03ed1127a7917b8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "eb6fdb4178b9a75b7393b33226ddc8f165477ce32fa95c0209dbd90a93bcf8fd", "request_id": "43d14cc56a0d746e38f4f99f8fe80fcc", "response_sha256": "776b81034772713dcdf4a4df90ee76e5bb282fd5011f6e3e344fc61eb1ca3f84", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "0212907d6d0370deef253ab9cbb44bdb", "candidate_priority_rank": 26370, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9378f6754f9643:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9378f6754f9643:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9378f6754f9643:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9378f6754f9643:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "couch<->rug", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "couch", "B": "rug"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "couch<->rug", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2397277", "image_sha256": "af3a3a0adb0ac5263d666e1100205dcb022f8c3271e7913dbb840179ecab3ab4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397277.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397277.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2394191", "image_sha256": "4fae39825a744cfce9b29f5ab2085e4999f43236a26ce307b4816e337e739bf5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2394191.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2394191.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9378f6754f9643", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "couch", "diff_b": "rug", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "couch", "component_b": "rug"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.416, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.09, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 2}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.325, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.04, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "balcony", "books", "carpet", "cat", "chair", "couch", "dog", "door", "laptop", "pillow", "room", "towel", "window"], "detected_components": ["couch"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae99fda9595454813e2240b181cffb29ec13a452f4a876c59df1f60b1366e99e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["couch", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "couch", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["couch", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b5a522f43f4ca46b0fa3cdd93214cb91b865fe1807e1a719a17001f01aed461a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14622752", "text": "What is the color of the animal to the left of the couch?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["books", "cabinets", "chairs", "clock", "dish", "dog", "dvds", "ears", "kitchen", "refrigerator", "rug", "sculpture", "shelf", "stove", "utensils", "wall"], "detected_components": ["rug"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae99fda9595454813e2240b181cffb29ec13a452f4a876c59df1f60b1366e99e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["rug", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "rug", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["rug", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "901063f4b8ac5acc7bdb3e36100869e3241516eb0cd46768dff33d97da5a69a5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16384497", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26370, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "51bbaecb22f0b847867bf8b750e38408f49164e4a94de2e1c1640af2b03705dd", "selected_component": "rug", "selected_source_question_id": "16384497", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the color of the animal to the left of the rug?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the color of the animal to the left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "51bbaecb22f0b847867bf8b750e38408f49164e4a94de2e1c1640af2b03705dd", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "couch"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the color of the animal to the left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "51bbaecb22f0b847867bf8b750e38408f49164e4a94de2e1c1640af2b03705dd", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "rug"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "brown", "full_answer": "The cat is brown.", "question": "What is the color of the animal to the left of the couch?", "question_id": "14622752", "semantic": [{"argument": "couch (1191322)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,to the left of,s (1191319)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "gray", "full_answer": "The dog is gray.", "question": "What is the color of the animal to the left of the rug?", "question_id": "16384497", "semantic": [{"argument": "rug (1213494)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,to the left of,s (1213493)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1191317", "1191319"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["brown", "lying", "sleeping"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "lying", "sleeping"], "query_target_entity_id": "1191319", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1191322", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1191319", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1191322", "selected_entity_name": "couch"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "couch", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1191322"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "rug", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "couch", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1213493"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["gray", "grey"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "1213493", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "1213494", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1213493", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1213494", "selected_entity_name": "rug"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "rug", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1213494"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0212907d6d0370deef253ab9cbb44bdb", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "af3a3a0adb0ac5263d666e1100205dcb022f8c3271e7913dbb840179ecab3ab4", "image_sha256_b": "4fae39825a744cfce9b29f5ab2085e4999f43236a26ce307b4816e337e739bf5", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f622aac6e44524e7b2f77b9bb4d46ec9e73f8a088d7776646b07b3e3dfaee4fc", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0e319e0033da143d5f0a784ac6a5a7bb", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "672bd67f51ba3b98db0b5120ef3e9bdf7b12bf6f254c3bf998419df9c0146671"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b9e3da506a52b86aa3982f0e8b9dab169b64c7b0eedd3493fa959d9c325a67bf", "request_id": "6d8e3ec406d3290443defc0edff71f76", "response_sha256": "bd57f5d74fffddc568f7109027c9df25fd3174c9b00e5eaa7ea467788e8db4e2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7b8a8aa11d23bd7a0ae084308bc062eda49f05cec8e163acc88257c2d9f3fcc8", "request_id": "ee632d0805fa094c95d9ddb02145dcd9", "response_sha256": "689a2ee4e2bf1748433e45c090f540fece7d6ffe4baa6ad8134729ccdaf9c250", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "d5760b559fe126606865bc85cb58c3da", "candidate_priority_rank": 26412, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbcc6c2764f2ee41:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbcc6c2764f2ee41:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbcc6c2764f2ee41:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbcc6c2764f2ee41:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "faucet<->pie", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "pie", "B": "faucet"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "pie<->faucet", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 376, "image_id": "2403518", "image_sha256": "52cce0bd3b161d13f1172cedbef868956046ad29588606ea9eb4c69bfe19020e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2403518.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2403518.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 461, "image_id": "2405020", "image_sha256": "5b79ea974e0a30e1498865be01010dcb3d7ea7ba671195ad3a18abf48ea5af69", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405020.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405020.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbcc6c2764f2ee41", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "pie", "diff_b": "faucet", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "pie", "component_b": "faucet"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.593, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.228, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.153, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.032, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 3}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blender", "bottle", "counter", "crust", "cutting board", "food", "glass", "knife", "milkshake", "oil", "pie", "scissors", "whipped cream"], "detected_components": ["pie"], "masked_program_sha256": "21e0c06d38ce3ce78c7b6a7b5ed241f03245db0a049cca8107b1ed8404ec2d6f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pie", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pie", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pie", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2f07e883dc9fb57f94a80452725ad5405c894cc42e58583946dcc002f77eda14"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04330320", "text": "What appliance is right of the pie?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "cabinets", "ceiling", "coffee maker", "countertop", "dishwasher", "display", "drawers", "faucet", "kitchen", "microwave", "sink", "wall"], "detected_components": ["faucet"], "masked_program_sha256": "21e0c06d38ce3ce78c7b6a7b5ed241f03245db0a049cca8107b1ed8404ec2d6f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["faucet", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "faucet", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["faucet", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fa19f5d45b2bb6ce5d560b1a9d1e73ae2390f7029c1974722cb0639b14b4cf53"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14222669", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26412, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3f1ddf93e7b80917b3cb59c6da59197fa4e7c1a7818b8d8f37d8e52831d97d32", "selected_component": "faucet", "selected_source_question_id": "14222669", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What appliance is right of the faucet?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "3f1ddf93e7b80917b3cb59c6da59197fa4e7c1a7818b8d8f37d8e52831d97d32", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "pie"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "3f1ddf93e7b80917b3cb59c6da59197fa4e7c1a7818b8d8f37d8e52831d97d32", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "faucet"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "blender", "full_answer": "The appliance is a blender.", "question": "What appliance is right of the pie?", "question_id": "04330320", "semantic": [{"argument": "pie (381082)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s (381080)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "coffee maker", "full_answer": "The appliance is a coffee maker.", "question": "What appliance is right of the faucet?", "question_id": "14222669", "semantic": [{"argument": "faucet (335706)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the right of,s (335699)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["381080"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blender"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "381080", "query_target_entity_name": "blender", "relation_object_entity_id": "381082", "relation_subject_entity_id": "381080", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "381082", "selected_entity_name": "pie"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pie", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["381082"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "faucet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pie", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["335695", "335699", "335700"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["coffee maker"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["electric"], "query_target_entity_id": "335699", "query_target_entity_name": "coffee maker", "relation_object_entity_id": "335706", "relation_subject_entity_id": "335699", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "335706", "selected_entity_name": "faucet"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "faucet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["335706"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:d5760b559fe126606865bc85cb58c3da", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "52cce0bd3b161d13f1172cedbef868956046ad29588606ea9eb4c69bfe19020e", "image_sha256_b": "5b79ea974e0a30e1498865be01010dcb3d7ea7ba671195ad3a18abf48ea5af69", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d1d455804e37b239637f74c1c382195a0d314005226be29ae82ad777ac84fb50", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "94bfb59c8d1dc6cb9fea444e90e85e89", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a8a731822cacd4188ad481dd2e66a379f8c21c985ed719fe25b60947c75baedc"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c0d0580491c1051111a535bf81a8d63b170f0a28705e00e8f3e980b86b1714bb", "request_id": "2d0a81e7635962c30d909551a774eb4f", "response_sha256": "4399eb54d04ea25b29f9e4ea768f7304a69d6d4957dae1c3cb124d4730a4cd5c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "212931c37c696ebeb01d32ea2c3068d585101d8723292c40db9f2823bdbac21a", "request_id": "22e726f08a2ec6071e50fb2bdbd0f423", "response_sha256": "e33c932c4664ff2e1b3533ba321789d10caf9708f05e49aa3808f6d5516c2d5b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "3a99e3083fba4eeabdfa31708681ac06", "candidate_priority_rank": 26440, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2d0678e20f9b1840:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2d0678e20f9b1840:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2d0678e20f9b1840:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2d0678e20f9b1840:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "mirror<->sink", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sink", "B": "mirror"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sink<->mirror", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 331, "image_id": "2402991", "image_sha256": "c367e5994e7f03ac8c55f5f8cd116e223bb51f9e0f5318abc0ee172cde47d636", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402991.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402991.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2375574", "image_sha256": "15fb170fb2a1ccc68fdf63aeafe453e6d360566c9a8d80fe73d3f78892d69f25", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2375574.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2375574.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2d0678e20f9b1840", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sink", "diff_b": "mirror", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sink", "component_b": "mirror"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "bowls", "box", "cabinet", "chair", "container", "cup", "cupboard", "dishes", "dishwasher", "faucet", "floor", "kitchen", "man", "plates", "rug", "shelf", "sink", "stove", "towel", "trash", "utensils", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["sink"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sink", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dacb13082ee4a033143484694a5bd07a7e81e1a732af0b769e16b206e727f88b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14613467", "text": "What item of furniture is below the sink?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "book", "chair", "drawer", "dresser", "glass", "headboard", "lamp", "mirror", "nightstand", "phone", "picture", "rug", "tray", "wall"], "detected_components": ["mirror"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mirror", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "457d8c3a1e8f1683d7f7c8d644263ad68f60ddcf031ffe72b6b9320befd47afa"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "091029459", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26440, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "075674909b7d7d5ff5d580cd722f2fb2e2960528ad34040ccf6ed9641773201d", "selected_component": "mirror", "selected_source_question_id": "091029459", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What item of furniture is below the mirror?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "075674909b7d7d5ff5d580cd722f2fb2e2960528ad34040ccf6ed9641773201d", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "sink"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "075674909b7d7d5ff5d580cd722f2fb2e2960528ad34040ccf6ed9641773201d", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "mirror"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cabinet", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a cabinet.", "question": "What item of furniture is below the sink?", "question_id": "14613467", "semantic": [{"argument": "sink (384409)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (384410)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dresser", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a dresser.", "question": "What item of furniture is below the mirror?", "question_id": "091029459", "semantic": [{"argument": "mirror (721768)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (721770)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["384406", "384410", "384418", "384420", "384422"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cabinet"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "384410", "query_target_entity_name": "cabinet", "relation_object_entity_id": "384409", "relation_subject_entity_id": "384410", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "384409", "selected_entity_name": "sink"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["384409"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["721770", "721771", "721775", "721776", "721781"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dresser"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "721770", "query_target_entity_name": "dresser", "relation_object_entity_id": "721768", "relation_subject_entity_id": "721770", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "721768", "selected_entity_name": "mirror"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["721768"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:3a99e3083fba4eeabdfa31708681ac06", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c367e5994e7f03ac8c55f5f8cd116e223bb51f9e0f5318abc0ee172cde47d636", "image_sha256_b": "15fb170fb2a1ccc68fdf63aeafe453e6d360566c9a8d80fe73d3f78892d69f25", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1bde1eab1256f89cc40c2cfbbac5334e161a6dc3b1b5d3a3b1a047c149d5aeb1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "46cf66a1027ecc4257bc22a9cae5db37", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2cbe774a6c514392d98c512a940dca4b82cac94df6e68253100bd8d08b63d2f7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a1b3a19970ab58db876472cd32473b3db09c817ef990784f40c2ce71badd8067", "request_id": "4ae1e5c2d90fdb4557d671caf00ef42a", "response_sha256": "fd0a85c96551d2136cccb3055288fe4733f5ca0d5cf29d7a4ad7e57af85b2673", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bfb32a8906e62d701bd16f9fddcf2a7ef321e4bb4d10b1ac54af5202d359e8d8", "request_id": "40dddfde634180f4784bc68b10da63a6", "response_sha256": "c061a16bb24e4a7911bb2047fd20dfea73acf193fe7b0bae299db5d13d1a2278", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "859defb5b7d49f74352d406707291d56", "candidate_priority_rank": 26476, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c36fb22ff78162b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c36fb22ff78162b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c36fb22ff78162b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c36fb22ff78162b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->truck", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "truck"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->truck", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 600, "image_id": "4591", "image_sha256": "121149dde4160e7d3067d16d37771d1353dac54588ed59b7fe2df0a0f1822f29", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/4591.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/4591.jpg", "width": 800}, "B": {"height": 307, "image_id": "2382145", "image_sha256": "9263288ce8e345ce3744288834beb127f81455c89347795c39b883b6ca4f6eba", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382145.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382145.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0c36fb22ff78162b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "truck", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "truck"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.375, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.24875, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.469, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.066, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "car", "ear", "grass", "ground", "leg", "man", "mirror", "stairs", "tunnel"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "e576126176f73461d9da50e86682746c1b48fbc22b4c7f1051c9f9e769afec2c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "61df42779ba56d4ac04c41e8b81df898405e1f1d1631d977c92d644b53b3b2ac"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05750487", "text": "What kind of vehicle is on the left of the man?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ground", "hand", "hat", "head", "horse", "man", "pants", "rocks", "sky", "tire", "trailer", "truck", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["truck"], "masked_program_sha256": "e576126176f73461d9da50e86682746c1b48fbc22b4c7f1051c9f9e769afec2c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["truck", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "truck", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["truck", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bd97d6cd03d64ffe9da6951762da6e6942daf7490d0849d584e004dd0b706806"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02668638", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26476, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "dc7de719dd1d22b7b4e17ad99659e88b403e0861b16d750d4953d6a3c5ebdfb8", "selected_component": "truck", "selected_source_question_id": "02668638", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of vehicle is on the left of the truck?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of vehicle is on the left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "dc7de719dd1d22b7b4e17ad99659e88b403e0861b16d750d4953d6a3c5ebdfb8", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of vehicle is on the left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "dc7de719dd1d22b7b4e17ad99659e88b403e0861b16d750d4953d6a3c5ebdfb8", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "truck"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a car.", "question": "What kind of vehicle is on the left of the man?", "question_id": "05750487", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1656439)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the left of,s (1656441)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "trailer", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a trailer.", "question": "What kind of vehicle is on the left of the truck?", "question_id": "02668638", "semantic": [{"argument": "truck (1330618)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the left of,s (1330619)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1656441"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1656441", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "1656439", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1656441", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1656439", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1656439"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "truck", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1330618", "1330619"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1330621"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1330619"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trailer"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["small", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1330619", "query_target_entity_name": "trailer", "relation_object_entity_id": "1330618", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1330619", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1330618", "selected_entity_name": "truck"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "truck", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1330618"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:859defb5b7d49f74352d406707291d56", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "121149dde4160e7d3067d16d37771d1353dac54588ed59b7fe2df0a0f1822f29", "image_sha256_b": "9263288ce8e345ce3744288834beb127f81455c89347795c39b883b6ca4f6eba", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0f2b2c47117404c5297bcc09d33271c8777316f0688db83435988c79183f397e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f4c7eb3a8923d88204ced26fe2c378b1", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d851581e0633b989f90eed406907c0ff0bd1b06f7b108276a2fe537178244741"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f671d7ff3e1babb754f664cc6f0405a5c4101461a5ac85441ac1abc6604ccf72", "request_id": "ec89de8277e7c7591fcc3fd0b1ff15f8", "response_sha256": "2929b619baac9fbdeb7f68e9daffa177aeedfdea781dbd58da46195aafcf7ab7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "75a359adc6ac20acc1bab9271bfd7fda2b19edd63c0e0c80be43de9ef2b59cfd", "request_id": "8389a3c0dd81f9dd46fded6fabe44b54", "response_sha256": "70701e2cf40327c0c598cc2e42a8b0149f0f492ee6f73340536ab85eaaca3df4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "1de7855436a3b13c8f160fef9d6c84e7", "candidate_priority_rank": 26563, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-49ddc990f31e7cb3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-49ddc990f31e7cb3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-49ddc990f31e7cb3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-49ddc990f31e7cb3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "girl<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "girl", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "girl<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2384248", "image_sha256": "8ab2802405ecb7328147c065d74502383f5e973c80b70e344f045d624adaecca", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384248.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384248.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2326288", "image_sha256": "b01259ae74a95a1c753f9d4b62864a195a6cb0a4cb25e4c9b9c2be3db6c644ec", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326288.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326288.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-49ddc990f31e7cb3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "girl", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "girl", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bracelet", "bracelets", "eyes", "face", "fence", "girl", "grass", "hair", "hand", "hot dog", "jeans", "leaves", "palm tree", "paper", "park", "shirt", "shoe", "sign", "sky", "sweater", "tree", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["girl"], "masked_program_sha256": "68f941ffbf971e587047423945131dda2165acb8edcd677a8d8cf3ddd95a77be", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "girl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9f3b82960b2decf28ac8e19c1c42938cc56df290e800b984dd728f40025db318"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03133468", "text": "What kind of fast food is the girl holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beer", "bench", "collar", "cup", "door", "face", "frame", "hair", "hand", "man", "necklace", "onion", "picture", "pizza", "plate", "sausage", "shirt", "wall", "window", "woman"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "68f941ffbf971e587047423945131dda2165acb8edcd677a8d8cf3ddd95a77be", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "cd508e6abf850d38b299b1456dcf5dc50e542f1a70e7901432d621394920996f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04773568", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26563, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "46d4aa501c7f58b614aa7bf54d97c1e65ac5b759c8a2d073258eb9aedec35e4e", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "04773568", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of fast food is the man holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "46d4aa501c7f58b614aa7bf54d97c1e65ac5b759c8a2d073258eb9aedec35e4e", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "girl"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "46d4aa501c7f58b614aa7bf54d97c1e65ac5b759c8a2d073258eb9aedec35e4e", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "hot dog", "full_answer": "The girl is holding the hot dog.", "question": "What kind of fast food is the girl holding?", "question_id": "03133468", "semantic": [{"argument": "girl (1311735)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,holding,o (1311757)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The man is holding the pizza.", "question": "What kind of fast food is the man holding?", "question_id": "04773568", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (3986378)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,holding,o (4135874)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1311757"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hot dog"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1311757", "query_target_entity_name": "hot dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "1311757", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1311735", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1311735", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1311735"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3986395", "4135874"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4135874", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "4135874", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3986378", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3986378", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3986378"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1de7855436a3b13c8f160fef9d6c84e7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8ab2802405ecb7328147c065d74502383f5e973c80b70e344f045d624adaecca", "image_sha256_b": "b01259ae74a95a1c753f9d4b62864a195a6cb0a4cb25e4c9b9c2be3db6c644ec", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1300642f3f4ea7fb6af25267438a64e9775b2e2f243d61718eb9ce256bc2e72f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "31e838806130e1182333518d3e64ac83", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "923e5c8f1ce157052384946561d9fccfe8b921caf47714883007d24a4ae7b40b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4ddfcde1bcf2a8abce5aa55aae2b8033a49c49f93998ec11f14b7a0bd34df3da", "request_id": "63b976b02b025f1216cf3ba2dfecbb7f", "response_sha256": "80579f1a87e134c657c523d5de6b05e3cae594191b924c82d51f6b40b8a0c500", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cc38c1dd6157c96103dfc291a921d8286ba69bcc6c2c3f9c25443045169bdf9e", "request_id": "2867dcbf16677161bc287068b751af3e", "response_sha256": "beb1f77b93e6678908f7b5f6b812a7ee101a9ad69e1d7078aff2baa463da6cce", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "30a9cc54ab6c38bb1cabaffb7c383ab5", "candidate_priority_rank": 26606, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1516267f5bbdca1c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1516267f5bbdca1c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1516267f5bbdca1c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1516267f5bbdca1c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->plant", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "plant"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->plant", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2388942", "image_sha256": "3f041b67f618868800384d710eb77b191efcacaf4fa7338f18cd3eda82c9f5c0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388942.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388942.jpg", "width": 334}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2396221", "image_sha256": "9054691ba24fe38c8d4028c999de3dfd04b22bbe1e85e42ff9ccebc333376fb5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396221.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396221.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1516267f5bbdca1c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "plant", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "plant"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "clouds", "ear", "elephant", "field", "foot", "hair", "hand", "head", "leg", "man", "mouth", "shirt", "sky", "tree", "trees", "trunk", "undershirt"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "77901cffa028b657790411e08a10393d0580b3828c2d4ff1cd2165f6a5260dc3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b6d0331176fb2dfd2c11210cbe0d7b8ca6d021da2da57f6d741419e0eee4fae9"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07426022", "text": "What type of animal is the man in front of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "cat", "chair", "flower pot", "head", "leaf", "leg", "lid", "plant", "pot", "table", "window"], "detected_components": ["plant"], "masked_program_sha256": "77901cffa028b657790411e08a10393d0580b3828c2d4ff1cd2165f6a5260dc3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plant", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "plant", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plant", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "578e39ceb2b0dba1de13600b8d80f7d1adabf943d11c2e900503cca69950b2b0"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00294721", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26606, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d83f84d83ccb3e8ccf52c74e4a5e31f94e0fbba2d048404a43564a8d5e1a9ef1", "selected_component": "plant", "selected_source_question_id": "00294721", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of animal is the plant in front of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is the in front of?", "program_group_hash": "d83f84d83ccb3e8ccf52c74e4a5e31f94e0fbba2d048404a43564a8d5e1a9ef1", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is the in front of?", "program_group_hash": "d83f84d83ccb3e8ccf52c74e4a5e31f94e0fbba2d048404a43564a8d5e1a9ef1", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "plant"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The man is in front of the elephant.", "question": "What type of animal is the man in front of?", "question_id": "07426022", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1265401)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,o (1265404)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The plant is in front of the cat.", "question": "What type of animal is the plant in front of?", "question_id": "00294721", "semantic": [{"argument": "plant (1199639)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,o (1199638)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1265399", "1265404"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1265404", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "1265404", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1265401", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1265401", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1265401"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plant", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1199638"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "1199638", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1199638", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1199639", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1199639", "selected_entity_name": "plant"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plant", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1199639"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:30a9cc54ab6c38bb1cabaffb7c383ab5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3f041b67f618868800384d710eb77b191efcacaf4fa7338f18cd3eda82c9f5c0", "image_sha256_b": "9054691ba24fe38c8d4028c999de3dfd04b22bbe1e85e42ff9ccebc333376fb5", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1b7b1d5d6bff7960ff4675913b2b250c31982bf40d9d800ce02393919ce98a8d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ad93cf81d580dd25c89bf9df5954c8a2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "604896e5dee992ef67218305d48f32ecd78a676b20531211745e18a3e9c53469"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7c280751fe9e87b4342848c7b50f220bfeef3a95b6bc923962f16179e52b8f2f", "request_id": "eed3b6b0bd3221ca00afd89cbb8d7091", "response_sha256": "8894f4d1cf4c8fe1e37b58835495ba026c9d5341e77748990589625911cc9dd7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "40602d5965fc15b41169802c248b6ed66c89390836de4f02e0d7a1b5c3827ac9", "request_id": "d1d80f04cb521a40fb3d64506f36c5b5", "response_sha256": "4d17078c16678ebd8af317e7cb340caa785d7f5b33f2a6fe44f5361c6d3a593c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.2-2025-12-11", "candidate_key": "ee6ec1cb74d063578ee0bfff349971a4", "candidate_priority_rank": 26650, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a3eb52b9a1fbf884:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a3eb52b9a1fbf884:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a3eb52b9a1fbf884:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a3eb52b9a1fbf884:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "grass<->snow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "snow", "B": "grass"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "snow<->grass", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 310, "image_id": "2343405", "image_sha256": "f398be5c72fd65a5f0c44abb25eb5d4f6406c8ecdda6630bff1ca6b7b32614ad", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343405.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343405.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2365645", "image_sha256": "b4bb72199c85875abb1cb7df5519f167c09ac079a47eb9940405bafb056c268c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365645.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365645.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a3eb52b9a1fbf884", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "snow", "diff_b": "grass", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "snow", "component_b": "grass"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "bush", "cloud", "fence", "hilltop", "jacket", "mountain", "pole", "roof", "sky", "snow", "tree", "words"], "detected_components": ["snow"], "masked_program_sha256": "5a725865b6593baa4b0aa7fcbc07ed470dc7457671355240aa2a53de112e3f9b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["snow"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "snow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["snow"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5ac259c0e05cb500abd0ea5a73ebdabdf2cd0c0c7cc07f0e54a9868b61b75e54"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09324768", "text": "What is running across the snow?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arms", "bush", "fence", "floor", "girl", "grass", "ground", "helmet", "hose", "pants", "path", "planter", "plants", "pot", "shirt", "shoe", "skateboard", "wheels"], "detected_components": ["grass"], "masked_program_sha256": "5a725865b6593baa4b0aa7fcbc07ed470dc7457671355240aa2a53de112e3f9b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "grass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6378016586f0a14e6b0d01be1d618018e2de12fbfd2154d56bf05cb7b3f63958"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16886725", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 26650, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b3445708e5999c17a9ba49321f6bbf8843669a28ed1081d191f09066d4841e5e", "selected_component": "grass", "selected_source_question_id": "16886725", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is running across the grass?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,running across,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is running across the ?", "program_group_hash": "b3445708e5999c17a9ba49321f6bbf8843669a28ed1081d191f09066d4841e5e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "running across", "select_category": "snow"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,running across,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is running across the ?", "program_group_hash": "b3445708e5999c17a9ba49321f6bbf8843669a28ed1081d191f09066d4841e5e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "running across", "select_category": "grass"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "fence", "full_answer": "The fence is running across the snow.", "question": "What is running across the snow?", "question_id": "09324768", "semantic": [{"argument": "snow (924042)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,running across,s (924043)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hose", "full_answer": "The hose is running across the grass.", "question": "What is running across the grass?", "question_id": "16886725", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (1749310)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,running across,s (2525227)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3917199", "924040", "924043", "924048", "924049", "924050", "924052", "924062", "924064", "924068", "924073", "924074", "924076", "924077", "924079"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fence"], "predicate": "running across", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "924043", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "924042", "relation_subject_entity_id": "924043", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "924042", "selected_entity_name": "snow"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "snow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["924042"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "snow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1664874", "1689645", "1698731", "1765520", "1779828", "1779829", "1784555", "1804048", "1852455", "2452985", "2452986", "2525227", "2525228", "2532976", "2532977", "2546458", "2655007", "2655008", "2683480", "3883186", "3883187"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hose"], "predicate": "running across", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "2525227", "query_target_entity_name": "hose", "relation_object_entity_id": "1749310", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2525227", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1749310", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1749310"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ee6ec1cb74d063578ee0bfff349971a4", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f398be5c72fd65a5f0c44abb25eb5d4f6406c8ecdda6630bff1ca6b7b32614ad", "image_sha256_b": "b4bb72199c85875abb1cb7df5519f167c09ac079a47eb9940405bafb056c268c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4c26da61458b27132c96fcc4d2fa0c6f2634e96816e6ba85810d31e34c6fdc37", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d90627334891c2540e40fdf721e023b6", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "04cb432cd184d7d949f34a7f39af42e02f9cd5c24c57f9ca6d8c6d900224141f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ddfc95b1d1c9bb25930d2446d7842d082c32a6d2825b1c1b732a4aa2a8e81ade", "request_id": "5df90b1d45e7d9b9148ece2fe5a5a92b", "response_sha256": "b1d82eb424add47a31cf55812878edcbdfd943cf4af3072c20f65f9d22753b4d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5f1bc10ef90145c6c3e5203cd43f87614042e7deaefe332c07c96f83597fc53f", "request_id": "bd6ca8950850241e33ea99628908a717", "response_sha256": "114ca4bfe4397350d996cf715e4b9bf929ff6ff4f3f3a63bdfc60432f08c6c64", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "42e7bb227656e01654323f872bb6429e", "candidate_priority_rank": 12504, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c6a2007a0ebcda9:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c6a2007a0ebcda9:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c6a2007a0ebcda9:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c6a2007a0ebcda9:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cake<->pizza", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cake", "B": "pizza"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cake<->pizza", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2385356", "image_sha256": "dbca774d8136a7bc7714fb911eee4549dff80dfb9bfb6aeb5df3abd01b7123bf", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2385356.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2385356.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2403314", "image_sha256": "e5d86040739ae995895c80e1c67ac8682ee53ef254147f05bd809a94da0f2069", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2403314.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2403314.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c6a2007a0ebcda9", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cake", "diff_b": "pizza", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cake", "component_b": "pizza"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cake", "floor", "fork", "frosting", "plate", "table"], "detected_components": ["cake"], "masked_program_sha256": "8d07445f8591828c6db28bedea03bf5ba26dc31cb5aad94e840a459f2b734a6a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cake", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e1830ea43f6f7fa86bfd00da266c3114f923a4ee9a1946df82e24a1e539256b4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14842778", "text": "What is the cake topped with?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bacon", "countertop", "crust", "herbs", "onion", "onions", "pizza", "sauce", "spatula"], "detected_components": ["pizza"], "masked_program_sha256": "8d07445f8591828c6db28bedea03bf5ba26dc31cb5aad94e840a459f2b734a6a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pizza", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bf92e1b9eb78b855180fe17418db4a00196ce161bd988a12731dab494d0cdb26"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00354621", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12504, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "559b87c054fff586aa0542fcfb274c55dd9451dd5c1fd957397ce561d7e8bd2c", "selected_component": "pizza", "selected_source_question_id": "00354621", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the pizza topped with?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,topped with,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the topped with?", "program_group_hash": "559b87c054fff586aa0542fcfb274c55dd9451dd5c1fd957397ce561d7e8bd2c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "topped with", "select_category": "cake"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,topped with,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the topped with?", "program_group_hash": "559b87c054fff586aa0542fcfb274c55dd9451dd5c1fd957397ce561d7e8bd2c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "topped with", "select_category": "pizza"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "frosting", "full_answer": "The cake is topped with frosting.", "question": "What is the cake topped with?", "question_id": "14842778", "semantic": [{"argument": "cake (688517)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,topped with,o (688524)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "herbs", "full_answer": "The pizza is topped with herbs.", "question": "What is the pizza topped with?", "question_id": "00354621", "semantic": [{"argument": "pizza (382345)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,topped with,o (382346)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["688518", "688519", "688521", "688524", "688530"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["frosting"], "predicate": "topped with", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "chocolate"], "query_target_entity_id": "688524", "query_target_entity_name": "frosting", "relation_object_entity_id": "688524", "relation_subject_entity_id": "688517", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "688517", "selected_entity_name": "cake"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["688517"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["382346", "382347", "382349", "382350", "382353", "382358", "382359", "382360", "382363"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["herbs"], "predicate": "topped with", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["fresh", "green"], "query_target_entity_id": "382346", "query_target_entity_name": "herbs", "relation_object_entity_id": "382346", "relation_subject_entity_id": "382345", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "382345", "selected_entity_name": "pizza"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["382345"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:42e7bb227656e01654323f872bb6429e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "dbca774d8136a7bc7714fb911eee4549dff80dfb9bfb6aeb5df3abd01b7123bf", "image_sha256_b": "e5d86040739ae995895c80e1c67ac8682ee53ef254147f05bd809a94da0f2069", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "6ff28144b3f591d083dd6c6a801c131a5ad487daa81b80e0fe5bd986389aa659", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e873ee80271ff29d3b330e52412bb2df", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "786478891adfa5d5264c3ce02d4e80c4b0eebd73a918380f66721b1e5f80ce4c"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "97ac6e889162280510c5f406bb4bf913f599cbfca0004939843683ff0074c0eb", "request_id": "3e0959278dec95930b336145d55354ac", "response_sha256": "8086c7b18bae711774767b5a7b6fe2f7df0fdfc3e2040db20aff1b841216586d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3dbe2ebc9eaaabd240901eeb81e1afb0abac9bfc40a34daf3f4441ec113eb879", "request_id": "045d55cdfbe4f05bfbfc2d9d42e8ed25", "response_sha256": "89b0c4ce8d8ba2c265d22b0c775ab6a17ba51caa2d4263985b9fcdb287413d60", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "a30e6cc7dac08a84ced2427dd97b3cb6", "candidate_priority_rank": 12561, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e50d63b7913b8497:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e50d63b7913b8497:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e50d63b7913b8497:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e50d63b7913b8497:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dryer<->window", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dryer", "B": "window"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dryer<->window", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2346234", "image_sha256": "0b30d9b87908a7432eeed47037b1bb4ea77bb2f6e93bfcca55ff3ab5e6db01ed", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2346234.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2346234.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2351100", "image_sha256": "d6469a67244d7a0050ed81a6966763113189a2e45601cd4e0ce396ace6f7ec29", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2351100.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2351100.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e50d63b7913b8497", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dryer", "diff_b": "window", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dryer", "component_b": "window"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bathroom", "cup", "dryer", "faucet", "medicine cabinet", "shampoo", "shelf", "shower", "shower curtain", "sink", "tiles", "toothpaste", "towel", "wall", "washing machine"], "detected_components": ["dryer"], "masked_program_sha256": "f11eea5f17e41ef8fdaf6321840498ac19576c49fdcd17b786e67a588b7083a7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dryer", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dryer", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dryer", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8124d4972df6197a2409ba939d32cd3a79528fbe0d97ab0db86fc46958b7814a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "071016650", "text": "What kind of appliance is below the dryer?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "box", "chair", "cup", "curtain", "desk", "floor", "lamp", "laptop", "leg", "radiator", "room", "sculpture", "shelf", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["window"], "masked_program_sha256": "f11eea5f17e41ef8fdaf6321840498ac19576c49fdcd17b786e67a588b7083a7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["window", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "window", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["window", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ccfac8735a51593528bdc5805a5a6cffe2f27fe76f14f69cb96478abf21914e6"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0372547", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12561, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2390e99a991c5e6d875caaf4a3440452c7fc3cea31f3945885030117b40e0cbe", "selected_component": "window", "selected_source_question_id": "0372547", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of appliance is below the window?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of appliance is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "2390e99a991c5e6d875caaf4a3440452c7fc3cea31f3945885030117b40e0cbe", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "dryer"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of appliance is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "2390e99a991c5e6d875caaf4a3440452c7fc3cea31f3945885030117b40e0cbe", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "window"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "washing machine", "full_answer": "The appliance is a washing machine.", "question": "What kind of appliance is below the dryer?", "question_id": "071016650", "semantic": [{"argument": "dryer (901379)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,below,s (901380)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "radiator", "full_answer": "The appliance is a radiator.", "question": "What kind of appliance is below the window?", "question_id": "0372547", "semantic": [{"argument": "window (863117)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,below,s (863134)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["901380"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["washing machine"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "901380", "query_target_entity_name": "washing machine", "relation_object_entity_id": "901379", "relation_subject_entity_id": "901380", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "901379", "selected_entity_name": "dryer"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dryer", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["901379"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dryer", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["863134"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["radiator"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "863134", "query_target_entity_name": "radiator", "relation_object_entity_id": "863117", "relation_subject_entity_id": "863134", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "863117", "selected_entity_name": "window"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["863117"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a30e6cc7dac08a84ced2427dd97b3cb6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "0b30d9b87908a7432eeed47037b1bb4ea77bb2f6e93bfcca55ff3ab5e6db01ed", "image_sha256_b": "d6469a67244d7a0050ed81a6966763113189a2e45601cd4e0ce396ace6f7ec29", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3b845d439173c9a64744dd7f3bf9299ecad3a01ac9942d5553c595c4162146b8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "975dc8c0e29b7a3fbddc72ce737261cf", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "8f747a124f9e2df60bafc19239561ab77693135ff1b4118190c02e55460cb834"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e106713fb533d8fe4d30177fa010e1d6938c130f0666f80e02a96f47e9d13962", "request_id": "eeb821c424873e7033b79b573a92010f", "response_sha256": "92706b2a5826200fce68b3ff0171651e14a05cef5de6edf0c72b41235152c13b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "984f0db98c634b3b736a209bd87f23eb75c7a8230f42b8b8627faf3940011bc5", "request_id": "cc1398663d38fd465ca8d4cd97e9fbb9", "response_sha256": "303403f12b9732dfe09eed1061a0bb65e2fe860f4cf9df42e164cfdf0550c659", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "bdca9785de9d8e4178a3a2f2f01cbe0f", "candidate_priority_rank": 12604, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-da8484d8031c5f95:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-da8484d8031c5f95:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-da8484d8031c5f95:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-da8484d8031c5f95:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bus<->ocean", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bus", "B": "ocean"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bus<->ocean", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2374398", "image_sha256": "8fbcc06495a74c127ab71232ffb3d600ebc387483b69a1ffae45da6e505602cd", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2374398.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2374398.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2397680", "image_sha256": "357d2fbb5e71c5fda2c3ad8ac4b37cd326d4cc55cb76399e91fcb8c29f422c2c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397680.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397680.jpg", "width": 299}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-da8484d8031c5f95", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bus", "diff_b": "ocean", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bus", "component_b": "ocean"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "buildings", "bus", "car", "city", "flag", "flags", "intersection", "license plate", "parking meter", "pole", "road", "sign", "traffic light", "trailer", "window"], "detected_components": ["bus"], "masked_program_sha256": "90fa032b63fb2b362108fc883b4bd2f015135779e438686c85818f7e9b22c6ab", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bus"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bus", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bus"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c285e1ca4afc75ebd7213962a9e7b23b89f69a22ebc0e74776f1f0eeb4913cfb"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05572955", "text": "What is the bus approaching?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beach", "box", "ocean", "pizza", "rock", "sky"], "detected_components": ["ocean"], "masked_program_sha256": "90fa032b63fb2b362108fc883b4bd2f015135779e438686c85818f7e9b22c6ab", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ocean"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ocean", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ocean"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8372fa8a82d59af3e275685d70dc66afd23737475df6109c5f0982a80cd4d622"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01563402", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12604, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f389ba935f22020703fbcdc01d47a5c7ed5711d6ae62a331db11a9fd32ef83bc", "selected_component": "ocean", "selected_source_question_id": "01563402", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the ocean approaching?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,approaching,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the approaching?", "program_group_hash": "f389ba935f22020703fbcdc01d47a5c7ed5711d6ae62a331db11a9fd32ef83bc", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "approaching", "select_category": "bus"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,approaching,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the approaching?", "program_group_hash": "f389ba935f22020703fbcdc01d47a5c7ed5711d6ae62a331db11a9fd32ef83bc", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "approaching", "select_category": "ocean"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "intersection", "full_answer": "The bus is approaching the intersection.", "question": "What is the bus approaching?", "question_id": "05572955", "semantic": [{"argument": "bus (727032)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,approaching,o (727061)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "beach", "full_answer": "The ocean is approaching the beach.", "question": "What is the ocean approaching?", "question_id": "01563402", "semantic": [{"argument": "ocean (431707)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,approaching,o (431716)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["727034", "727035", "727037", "727038", "727039", "727040", "727041", "727045", "727046", "727047", "727048", "727049", "727051", "727052", "727053", "727054", "727055", "727059", "727060", "727061", "727062", "727066", "727067"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 23, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["intersection"], "predicate": "approaching", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "727061", "query_target_entity_name": "intersection", "relation_object_entity_id": "727061", "relation_subject_entity_id": "727032", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "727032", "selected_entity_name": "bus"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bus", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["727032"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ocean", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bus", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["431708", "431709", "431712", "431713", "431716"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["beach"], "predicate": "approaching", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["sandy"], "query_target_entity_id": "431716", "query_target_entity_name": "beach", "relation_object_entity_id": "431716", "relation_subject_entity_id": "431707", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "431707", "selected_entity_name": "ocean"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ocean", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["431707"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:bdca9785de9d8e4178a3a2f2f01cbe0f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8fbcc06495a74c127ab71232ffb3d600ebc387483b69a1ffae45da6e505602cd", "image_sha256_b": "357d2fbb5e71c5fda2c3ad8ac4b37cd326d4cc55cb76399e91fcb8c29f422c2c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "17c9adc9de3b1f8fc81bda1b7ec031f4bb0d5a645b6b980b1343b15138f84025", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f9c5bbed88c2ea49cdd3f69e35ebd14d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a79f1c4ed78b7334332a819ade94849a46271f4026e9f70600b5b76bb15c1777"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f1a3a168ee0e299382b88ecb2c3ab9df695e8277eaea2596dca9bbc176a217cc", "request_id": "ef57aa83a7d5c1bf152aa10a8a157c01", "response_sha256": "5d6d7227ee38bb1f89ee6d0655b2e04be9bad4609906ad4c954c7577122f3c59", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "14857ca40bb3e951cf5ea71e98ff3586ebb2ff4183b17ccdb1a7e5cc2e87d964", "request_id": "cf082e0c096df12bd933b49fca950876", "response_sha256": "6b0773c7f23701e2e46b7f457e229f17c9baca8aec1e8e36234d0b5c32bacfad", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "0d8018eb16b9b349cc28c7781f31d028", "candidate_priority_rank": 12627, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-88f88543d9d0dc64:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-88f88543d9d0dc64:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-88f88543d9d0dc64:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-88f88543d9d0dc64:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "field<->table", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "field", "B": "table"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "field<->table", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2379947", "image_sha256": "bc2152623449ab49d0c4555e5c7f31fb7b28a12aacc24497d06034ad2923e1ce", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2379947.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2379947.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2384359", "image_sha256": "3e7cca35aa495ff7fa5f2cea8566319ade9c351b2248bb31f4d5fcee79ef14eb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384359.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384359.jpg", "width": 281}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-88f88543d9d0dc64", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "field", "diff_b": "table", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "field", "component_b": "table"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cow", "cows", "field", "straw"], "detected_components": ["field"], "masked_program_sha256": "1cecb4f796105ee3743f86530e11442550ae6d36bcee747ff9c84bc3cd8fd1a1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "field", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "caea9d9e113b3e79e917d3b64023f8879f03b8b490a16e40b281bda42f02915b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "17311767", "text": "What animals are on top of the field?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beak", "bird", "birds", "floor", "head", "leg", "letters", "paper", "plate", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["table"], "masked_program_sha256": "1cecb4f796105ee3743f86530e11442550ae6d36bcee747ff9c84bc3cd8fd1a1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "table", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dead3c2953414b50b0da41d9ac33c4235c3f465d2b8db52b7bf96714ae9b3e39"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16858762", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12627, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "eebd6eae43f0287325da96a995017ca4ab622d9269d80c3e5f9e51c9de5521b5", "selected_component": "table", "selected_source_question_id": "16858762", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animals are on top of the table?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "eebd6eae43f0287325da96a995017ca4ab622d9269d80c3e5f9e51c9de5521b5", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "field"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "eebd6eae43f0287325da96a995017ca4ab622d9269d80c3e5f9e51c9de5521b5", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "table"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cows", "full_answer": "The animals are cows.", "question": "What animals are on top of the field?", "question_id": "17311767", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (1352439)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on top of,s (1352438)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "birds", "full_answer": "The animals are birds.", "question": "What animals are on top of the table?", "question_id": "16858762", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (3846990)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on top of,s (691935)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1352438", "1352440", "1352441", "1352442", "1352443"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cows"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "grouped", "lying", "sitting"], "query_target_entity_id": "1352438", "query_target_entity_name": "cows", "relation_object_entity_id": "1352439", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1352438", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1352439", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1352439"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["691934", "691935", "691938"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["birds"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "691935", "query_target_entity_name": "birds", "relation_object_entity_id": "3846990", "relation_subject_entity_id": "691935", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3846990", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3846990"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0d8018eb16b9b349cc28c7781f31d028", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bc2152623449ab49d0c4555e5c7f31fb7b28a12aacc24497d06034ad2923e1ce", "image_sha256_b": "3e7cca35aa495ff7fa5f2cea8566319ade9c351b2248bb31f4d5fcee79ef14eb", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "893d3afb3858f20d5d30771222068198a1f0f96d4faeb71c9a17469d41381f91", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1b8e08fff9332fe6d55ba1b7769fa73f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "fdaf96789c6a7396ecbc90ae77878550f72b8b72501222fce854b6f3be682b6d"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "10992418f11aa45217ce02d71f1893ad99b4e864e12d74216f87a09daad45796", "request_id": "124e9e586479fec9732b4c209ed7a3df", "response_sha256": "67e2d694d7892e43945372db2f39b0fa7b3f89feaaadd5f95a95e76b41add8d2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6e44ed2392d927e1b050637aa64480aef465e8afd1b5433aec4e73a02dc67a89", "request_id": "47ed665bbca4f377393fb0e836ba18b1", "response_sha256": "7e69595654838effcbddfa89d0a6f5dd6e2e14efb57d931774dc65e08998c7c2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "833b54e4b41d450eec38d45173715c14", "candidate_priority_rank": 12631, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-87af670edfc2f218:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-87af670edfc2f218:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-87af670edfc2f218:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-87af670edfc2f218:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "chicken<->tomato sauce", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "tomato sauce", "B": "chicken"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "tomato sauce<->chicken", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2412990", "image_sha256": "ba391776232fd6dd8242b623ef5adf49f8cb60661f1670209c5a198494f19bfa", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412990.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412990.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2377564", "image_sha256": "7bf761ceba6471f83e7046b1f9f7e1f8e85c0d59ef9b9627ebd149f722953ec8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2377564.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2377564.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-87af670edfc2f218", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "tomato sauce", "diff_b": "chicken", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "tomato sauce", "component_b": "chicken"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "fish", "food", "fork", "glass", "head", "knife", "lemon", "meat", "napkin", "phone", "plate", "seed", "table", "tail", "tomato sauce", "tomatoes", "vegetables", "wine", "wine glass"], "detected_components": ["tomato sauce"], "masked_program_sha256": "6e8762191dceba804aa8bd767c9c276f5bfb1a53303b1780d18696b2d759a3c9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tomato sauce"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tomato sauce", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tomato sauce"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "97075e73f017691e86b270952dfd35e28e3f6ac51e0836145ef249c7666b4bb0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01403866", "text": "What is under the tomato sauce in the picture?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bun", "cell phone", "chicken", "food", "fries", "glass", "ground", "lettuce", "napkin", "plate", "salt shaker", "sandwich", "table", "tree"], "detected_components": ["chicken"], "masked_program_sha256": "6e8762191dceba804aa8bd767c9c276f5bfb1a53303b1780d18696b2d759a3c9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["chicken"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "chicken", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["chicken"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a13e1f2548e6eda4d4fead58901af37fd268b6aa4aeb9a5701d1fa22d1d83b59"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03306993", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12631, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "07f77cff601b02846034497509f059b666e104091f39e36ed668ff274d69fe8c", "selected_component": "chicken", "selected_source_question_id": "03306993", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is under the chicken in the picture?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is under the in the picture?", "program_group_hash": "07f77cff601b02846034497509f059b666e104091f39e36ed668ff274d69fe8c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "tomato sauce"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is under the in the picture?", "program_group_hash": "07f77cff601b02846034497509f059b666e104091f39e36ed668ff274d69fe8c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "chicken"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "fish", "full_answer": "The fish is under the tomato sauce.", "question": "What is under the tomato sauce in the picture?", "question_id": "01403866", "semantic": [{"argument": "tomato sauce (1617368)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,under,s (1617367)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "lettuce", "full_answer": "The lettuce is under the chicken.", "question": "What is under the chicken in the picture?", "question_id": "03306993", "semantic": [{"argument": "chicken (1676667)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,under,s (2630879)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1617355", "1617358", "1617359", "1617360", "1617363", "1617364", "1617365", "1617366", "1617367", "1617369", "1617370", "1617372", "1617373", "1617377", "1617379", "1617380", "1617382", "1617383", "1617386", "1617387", "1617389", "1617390", "182505", "182506", "182508", "182509", "182510", "182512", "182513", "182515", "182516", "182518", "182522", "182525", "182529", "182532", "182534", "3802071", "3802072"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 39, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fish"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["cooked"], "query_target_entity_id": "1617367", "query_target_entity_name": "fish", "relation_object_entity_id": "1617368", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1617367", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1617368", "selected_entity_name": "tomato sauce"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tomato sauce", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1617368"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "chicken", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tomato sauce", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1742100", "1791394", "1827560", "1834267", "1834268", "1834269", "1906598", "1947970", "1971571", "2089199", "2089200", "2305176", "2580229", "2600433", "2630879", "2700646"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["lettuce"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2630879", "query_target_entity_name": "lettuce", "relation_object_entity_id": "1676667", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2630879", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1676667", "selected_entity_name": "chicken"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "chicken", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1676667"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:833b54e4b41d450eec38d45173715c14", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ba391776232fd6dd8242b623ef5adf49f8cb60661f1670209c5a198494f19bfa", "image_sha256_b": "7bf761ceba6471f83e7046b1f9f7e1f8e85c0d59ef9b9627ebd149f722953ec8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "db73b55db3f9492f265d05b2bd17b76188ee74da8ee1d1ae9ea6cd9acb52ffe3", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5ecc7d1437561fc9dee4a43c3af69c28", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "dd523020c5fd30a66de51754a77dc95f18f33a188cbabb09d710eb0badeedc20"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a033fa0a94dbea34f985131f3d5aa28be0ae807f2dc8510815ba26da92cced6e", "request_id": "a87d19481c872ca2976b6f4e2b1cf75d", "response_sha256": "e85de72452901b0d792b07a31daa5c826bc47996e59bfe2a7c5566002e7dabf7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f91694efaf2f8e53e21f1b6cd3317fb661ede7c835d8313556821e0489694535", "request_id": "20a88caed9b43c651700644fd5546d25", "response_sha256": "a81aa02b29a00ddc20f195725ed8d9f5100361f3c30fac39cccbe47902e5737c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "314b0e9d0557df97fc03db23b00208d9", "candidate_priority_rank": 12650, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21347ef35c1fd028:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21347ef35c1fd028:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21347ef35c1fd028:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21347ef35c1fd028:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "basket<->dish", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dish", "B": "basket"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dish<->basket", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2348412", "image_sha256": "8d9d13bb210ed1e2f206e56fc272e62ff30ea9d38064802c3291668d7ba76dcf", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2348412.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2348412.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2375161", "image_sha256": "a4373367138fa63921c4822c0a694cb1343b3c5615df4e2a90eced75094a19d8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2375161.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2375161.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21347ef35c1fd028", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dish", "diff_b": "basket", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dish", "component_b": "basket"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "bowl", "collar", "cup", "dish", "dog", "ear", "earring", "ground", "hand", "leg", "logo", "pants", "pocket", "shirt", "tail", "water", "water bottle", "woman"], "detected_components": ["dish"], "masked_program_sha256": "5e84dfc0cd5ed52b4d1e0cd82b7797cbbe237a7245165106a20557622bd8a00d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dish", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dish", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dish", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f65ee627444f9b6eb59274362f905718b9c6e01c78890347a0304024a4d3e6cf"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10164167", "text": "What animal is eating from the dish?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "bush", "fence", "foot", "giraffe", "goat", "grass", "ground", "hay", "horn", "leg", "mouth", "post", "tail", "tree trunk", "wire"], "detected_components": ["basket"], "masked_program_sha256": "5e84dfc0cd5ed52b4d1e0cd82b7797cbbe237a7245165106a20557622bd8a00d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "basket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4ad77b35b1440be958002abc8781d5d01711427eb8956cc7dc2edadbae8b74b4"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14896661", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12650, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "030b88b2f6e8c897b6f30cde1263fa13a93b7a3928b60723109098a5eb968f10", "selected_component": "basket", "selected_source_question_id": "14896661", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is eating from the basket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,eating from,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is eating from the ?", "program_group_hash": "030b88b2f6e8c897b6f30cde1263fa13a93b7a3928b60723109098a5eb968f10", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "eating from", "select_category": "dish"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,eating from,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is eating from the ?", "program_group_hash": "030b88b2f6e8c897b6f30cde1263fa13a93b7a3928b60723109098a5eb968f10", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "eating from", "select_category": "basket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is eating from a dish.", "question": "What animal is eating from the dish?", "question_id": "10164167", "semantic": [{"argument": "dish (3605708)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,eating from,s (2648152)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The animal is a giraffe.", "question": "What animal is eating from the basket?", "question_id": "14896661", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (583895)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,eating from,s (583889)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2648152"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "eating from", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "2648152", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "3605708", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2648152", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3605708", "selected_entity_name": "dish"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dish", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3605708"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dish", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["583889", "583891", "583892", "583893", "583894"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "eating from", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["tall"], "query_target_entity_id": "583889", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "583895", "relation_subject_entity_id": "583889", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "583895", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["583895"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:314b0e9d0557df97fc03db23b00208d9", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8d9d13bb210ed1e2f206e56fc272e62ff30ea9d38064802c3291668d7ba76dcf", "image_sha256_b": "a4373367138fa63921c4822c0a694cb1343b3c5615df4e2a90eced75094a19d8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "61cfe85182cea16a5f3b0fbbca4380b8f325349004b2738a81a24f532e78200e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "4ca058eaf8d718a7454bbe8a97091d33", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "78f61fba26083cb898f4a725c6b68726e699ed8a5c2aa0f6b7062edb097af98b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cae599c4a9a8320e139d7dcc7fa43ea2f68bf06d00f5fda673de1a8918208c01", "request_id": "62d606276eec3aef7e33857a16248730", "response_sha256": "e42c77e6850b0e52697f99aa464f1f278bf1959ac1a01878a44ba4e0e54887cb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b80e1ea82f2ffa189dccc4b620a8e5d291ca6fd647b4ea9ed47d97b265520309", "request_id": "da67a55c4985aa362505c62ef7d8f6c4", "response_sha256": "5deca79e424b9ed6d5b84a258c57eb957a9eb323da3f785b6dee45f95e0f415f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "786678ce4420745a0fefc16b5ada351f", "candidate_priority_rank": 12660, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1ff11c6681751c91:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1ff11c6681751c91:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1ff11c6681751c91:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1ff11c6681751c91:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "fruit<->monkey", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "monkey", "B": "fruit"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "monkey<->fruit", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2413718", "image_sha256": "8398ca1a2b71248cb457833fd42eb58e1f87b7186b52cd980f1b2e17a8d68f0f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2413718.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2413718.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2384194", "image_sha256": "54d92fa0125fdba3e681cdbaa6fbc0d9b47268ad554f6cf2caff2b3aa15ee2f2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384194.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384194.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1ff11c6681751c91", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "monkey", "diff_b": "fruit", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "monkey", "component_b": "fruit"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cord", "floor", "microwave", "monkey", "plate", "scarf"], "detected_components": ["monkey"], "masked_program_sha256": "612e09c0921d041d463efa48e0c45243af69eed2837c2662845c207ff01b3785", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["monkey", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "monkey", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["monkey", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d057e4e0e75f4707d4799b42b53ef6d419cbe37058c4da80d86eef446beaf1d5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1556994", "text": "What appliance is the monkey inside of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blender", "fruit", "lid", "mug", "wall"], "detected_components": ["fruit"], "masked_program_sha256": "612e09c0921d041d463efa48e0c45243af69eed2837c2662845c207ff01b3785", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fruit", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "fruit", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fruit", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2228d946293944794a880d410e826c0aad0e9f574dbee7701f4677a285c2c9a3"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08986218", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12660, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2dcd6311513e544f5445624fa1e366ddb12baaf9d708b0b886cb42924b8e2a0f", "selected_component": "fruit", "selected_source_question_id": "08986218", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What appliance is the fruit inside of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is the inside of?", "program_group_hash": "2dcd6311513e544f5445624fa1e366ddb12baaf9d708b0b886cb42924b8e2a0f", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "monkey"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is the inside of?", "program_group_hash": "2dcd6311513e544f5445624fa1e366ddb12baaf9d708b0b886cb42924b8e2a0f", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "fruit"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "microwave", "full_answer": "The monkey is inside the microwave.", "question": "What appliance is the monkey inside of?", "question_id": "1556994", "semantic": [{"argument": "monkey (167694)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,inside,o (167680)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "blender", "full_answer": "The fruit is inside the blender.", "question": "What appliance is the fruit inside of?", "question_id": "08986218", "semantic": [{"argument": "fruit (1312301)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,inside,o (1312291)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["167680"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["microwave"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "167680", "query_target_entity_name": "microwave", "relation_object_entity_id": "167680", "relation_subject_entity_id": "167694", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "167694", "selected_entity_name": "monkey"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "monkey", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["167694"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fruit", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "monkey", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1312291"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blender"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["edged", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1312291", "query_target_entity_name": "blender", "relation_object_entity_id": "1312291", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1312301", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1312301", "selected_entity_name": "fruit"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fruit", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1312301"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:786678ce4420745a0fefc16b5ada351f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8398ca1a2b71248cb457833fd42eb58e1f87b7186b52cd980f1b2e17a8d68f0f", "image_sha256_b": "54d92fa0125fdba3e681cdbaa6fbc0d9b47268ad554f6cf2caff2b3aa15ee2f2", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "bda1799cbc8ccdfb26113e964826b1defbf273c35f4d7a2ed75f9f05a5b2d045", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d1890094dce2a17e37d7908bdcfdebf9", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d05425dbfec4f290597def43e9fee909167d4b79702917882343eea6d4cc7f99"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3beb1104dc17b12b3e9ca4f13658d44f13370b9a8d9bd0153b99ad83fd2f9d71", "request_id": "022eec2210176db7b154cdea83c86d2c", "response_sha256": "542622b2a9c0ac1608fd824e7615609c834446d7adb6bff96a473ccd2da223f6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ed72ebe2ca01deae85c4121ec62b127f6eb88c3fc7fe107e45bdc19a474ee680", "request_id": "afa1461754daa003ecaf066effe71ed8", "response_sha256": "6f0d0c6b7217d206946d1cba3f4f4272226c68b923cedc3da8c3c89082c0c3a8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "a64c67a6085d7305cf76075972a8c333", "candidate_priority_rank": 12666, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1ecc8e64baed877:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1ecc8e64baed877:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1ecc8e64baed877:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1ecc8e64baed877:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bacon<->sauce", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bacon", "B": "sauce"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bacon<->sauce", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 365, "image_id": "2408574", "image_sha256": "90d56151d9720a710135733befdfa4b85c27ff763426048926d1c391d848cfec", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408574.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408574.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2346943", "image_sha256": "cc8bd8c04b019b3ebdc332660baaf7092659254ea8125f5e5d9443ef8eb496aa", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2346943.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2346943.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1ecc8e64baed877", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bacon", "diff_b": "sauce", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bacon", "component_b": "sauce"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bacon", "bread", "crust", "dressing", "food", "fork", "ham", "knife", "leaves", "lettuce", "plate", "salad", "sandwich", "table", "utensils"], "detected_components": ["bacon"], "masked_program_sha256": "b273d5f11a7ab9717115658f7166755f2db682ad236578546f02744476d18cc5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bacon", "food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bacon", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bacon", "food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b08abd0410019fba56142e2967a9cced24bd535cf947fe54d59dc074f9370444"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1271106", "text": "What is the food that the bacon is on called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["broccoli", "cheese", "fork", "herb", "meat", "noodles", "plate", "sauce", "table", "tomato", "utensil"], "detected_components": ["sauce"], "masked_program_sha256": "b273d5f11a7ab9717115658f7166755f2db682ad236578546f02744476d18cc5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sauce", "food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sauce", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sauce", "food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1e2b5bcb30331a3067e3105f161f12f0a1f248a9b930af772274eab7f157d0d1"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19935909", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12666, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3ffd364364589af87c7cca489c323a52767d6cc7055528601f262c3c7439cda5", "selected_component": "sauce", "selected_source_question_id": "19935909", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the food that the sauce is on called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food that the is on called?", "program_group_hash": "3ffd364364589af87c7cca489c323a52767d6cc7055528601f262c3c7439cda5", "queried_category": "food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "bacon"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food that the is on called?", "program_group_hash": "3ffd364364589af87c7cca489c323a52767d6cc7055528601f262c3c7439cda5", "queried_category": "food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "sauce"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "salad", "full_answer": "The food is salad.", "question": "What is the food that the bacon is on called?", "question_id": "1271106", "semantic": [{"argument": "bacon (259059)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,on,o (259054)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "noodles", "full_answer": "The food is noodles.", "question": "What is the food that the sauce is on called?", "question_id": "19935909", "semantic": [{"argument": "sauce (895138)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,on,o (895146)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["259052", "259054", "259055", "259061", "259069"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["salad"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "259054", "query_target_entity_name": "salad", "relation_object_entity_id": "259054", "relation_subject_entity_id": "259059", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "259059", "selected_entity_name": "bacon"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bacon", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["259059"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sauce", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bacon", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["895142", "895143", "895146"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["noodles"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["cooked"], "query_target_entity_id": "895146", "query_target_entity_name": "noodles", "relation_object_entity_id": "895146", "relation_subject_entity_id": "895138", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "895138", "selected_entity_name": "sauce"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sauce", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["895138"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a64c67a6085d7305cf76075972a8c333", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "90d56151d9720a710135733befdfa4b85c27ff763426048926d1c391d848cfec", "image_sha256_b": "cc8bd8c04b019b3ebdc332660baaf7092659254ea8125f5e5d9443ef8eb496aa", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b37bfbdd4a8b7ae2e0634a226f83c4df5cfdd715bdcc95f4dbe83e2554013a3e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e599a76e1b5fd6c69f6462eb2ce9de0e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "65d36ceccbeccb8f3a8da4c64e68f4415f0c84630c304a0234dc2eacdeaa2b47"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a3ade8d2525d2efdb67ff69c7a44b1eacb84a9bb42d1cc4abca359fa02d89ed9", "request_id": "cf4fc40951c55985d8fe53f1eae19183", "response_sha256": "71728b63a0e4d9625ba8a3f045f12963c8fe2fe95ff64c53d4e1a76cc803945d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4459cd14cd817713b897a97ed5c029b79e5fd981de30f6920cee222b6d50c7c6", "request_id": "56d36de27d8b5106497f3855382b37d9", "response_sha256": "de0f7ac6badc18239b6bc5cd5905feb2a94e0634b21a5362222a974e4ce87422", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "3d87a5c53fbf783fa6b3d6e1c670d78a", "candidate_priority_rank": 12673, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-96e89ba2ef87187d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-96e89ba2ef87187d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-96e89ba2ef87187d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-96e89ba2ef87187d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "apple<->dirt", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dirt", "B": "apple"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dirt<->apple", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2397645", "image_sha256": "721c4e8155786ff2d79653ba3ec305551369862f7dada2bba6af7460e43a4e15", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397645.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397645.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2404313", "image_sha256": "11873ef3584114fdec10c335bc836b7de13a90c2c4d020280e91fc28fde5adc9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404313.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404313.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-96e89ba2ef87187d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dirt", "diff_b": "apple", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dirt", "component_b": "apple"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["dirt", "ears", "eye", "ground", "hay", "head", "leg", "mane", "neck", "nose", "plant", "rock", "straw", "zebra"], "detected_components": ["dirt"], "masked_program_sha256": "69a9e162e7869a92d3bccd7942db0dd3a42367404e59a8d177c61d3264858009", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dirt", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dirt", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dirt", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4a7a3ca6dffeaa07fadf20d0876415d8883c9bb4e9cc4501f76a1eecdde2f3dd"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "171009002", "text": "What animal is sniffing the dirt?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["apple", "arm", "cat", "ear", "eye", "hair", "hand", "leg", "man", "nose", "pants", "paw"], "detected_components": ["apple"], "masked_program_sha256": "69a9e162e7869a92d3bccd7942db0dd3a42367404e59a8d177c61d3264858009", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["apple", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "apple", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["apple", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6fb90cbc7fd41690cbd6095f68550f204049ad6ef80b4625ca0ba3bb2e8a55a7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "191021130", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12673, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "7334cde75b1985a9ccb6980da00ae4c497ed0e0f0ddbd9e52b790f402213bcb4", "selected_component": "apple", "selected_source_question_id": "191021130", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is sniffing the apple?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sniffing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is sniffing the ?", "program_group_hash": "7334cde75b1985a9ccb6980da00ae4c497ed0e0f0ddbd9e52b790f402213bcb4", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sniffing", "select_category": "dirt"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sniffing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is sniffing the ?", "program_group_hash": "7334cde75b1985a9ccb6980da00ae4c497ed0e0f0ddbd9e52b790f402213bcb4", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sniffing", "select_category": "apple"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "zebra", "full_answer": "The zebra is sniffing the dirt.", "question": "What animal is sniffing the dirt?", "question_id": "171009002", "semantic": [{"argument": "dirt (432035)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sniffing,s (432030)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is sniffing the apple.", "question": "What animal is sniffing the apple?", "question_id": "191021130", "semantic": [{"argument": "apple (344139)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sniffing,s (344135)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["432030"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["zebra"], "predicate": "sniffing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["grazing", "large", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "432030", "query_target_entity_name": "zebra", "relation_object_entity_id": "432035", "relation_subject_entity_id": "432030", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "432035", "selected_entity_name": "dirt"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["432035"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "apple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["344135"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "sniffing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "344135", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "344139", "relation_subject_entity_id": "344135", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "344139", "selected_entity_name": "apple"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "apple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["344139"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:3d87a5c53fbf783fa6b3d6e1c670d78a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "721c4e8155786ff2d79653ba3ec305551369862f7dada2bba6af7460e43a4e15", "image_sha256_b": "11873ef3584114fdec10c335bc836b7de13a90c2c4d020280e91fc28fde5adc9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "672590dfa29c729923b2a9b7397394f838c1a463061c6f100ee3777ee47f9cc2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "4fed87caa72dc10e4efa43f9088438fa", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2622ba5e6d159a63c0746cffe2a6b413e6c5f7ede0389b492dfc3bfc722abf7a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9ce16095bbd476e1acd391254b827bc70edb7777fae9ca744b90f70442ab1927", "request_id": "11f054b1de1f5732f17d1d946fb0f07e", "response_sha256": "8074dcd3bd59c4b5f1431469733803ad1bf223032d48d5ac7275e9f11f28a9bc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "59abf0427dda20522c3612dc2b5bcc0c201a70d204aa713732362287bb4015e2", "request_id": "13a128162c4b25f542f287f3bc110717", "response_sha256": "17b90e517db3b020fc966a2fd1e9063723b8d430441ffce236b33eae4ef5cde8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "eb82766a5126f5b64e4f1ac555d4517d", "candidate_priority_rank": 12678, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db7dd9f53c2f0b01:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db7dd9f53c2f0b01:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db7dd9f53c2f0b01:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db7dd9f53c2f0b01:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->zebra", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "zebra", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "zebra<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2372553", "image_sha256": "43882aa8ea85e03c5fb93ed367849c4c47ac0661965d13cbed0488465de4ef6a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2372553.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2372553.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2404313", "image_sha256": "11873ef3584114fdec10c335bc836b7de13a90c2c4d020280e91fc28fde5adc9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404313.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404313.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db7dd9f53c2f0b01", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "zebra", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "zebra", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ground", "head", "leg", "zebra"], "detected_components": ["zebra"], "masked_program_sha256": "73eead368ec917450c8992a60c581f562ce102ed4da2011ae33dc39b8b79c969", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["zebra"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "zebra", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["zebra"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7d591f9e89fa23c10ffa34cd4094491afeada12cffc9433c0944efc87b65807b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00460594", "text": "What is the zebra sniffing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["apple", "arm", "cat", "ear", "eye", "hair", "hand", "leg", "man", "nose", "pants", "paw"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "73eead368ec917450c8992a60c581f562ce102ed4da2011ae33dc39b8b79c969", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c0f37d7629bee9ad1f860abfdb6382462ba73374657a4b8f6d0b689192131eec"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "191021137", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12678, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "113c14648f012ffc2836ce3abc6b9d6ca0ea838a5301b1ada8de11eaebe8c36a", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "191021137", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the cat sniffing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sniffing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the sniffing?", "program_group_hash": "113c14648f012ffc2836ce3abc6b9d6ca0ea838a5301b1ada8de11eaebe8c36a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sniffing", "select_category": "zebra"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sniffing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the sniffing?", "program_group_hash": "113c14648f012ffc2836ce3abc6b9d6ca0ea838a5301b1ada8de11eaebe8c36a", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sniffing", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "ground", "full_answer": "The zebra is sniffing the ground.", "question": "What is the zebra sniffing?", "question_id": "00460594", "semantic": [{"argument": "zebra (591351)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sniffing,o (3852646)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "apple", "full_answer": "The cat is sniffing the apple.", "question": "What is the cat sniffing?", "question_id": "191021137", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (344135)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sniffing,o (344139)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3852641", "3852646", "3852654", "591349"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ground"], "predicate": "sniffing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3852646", "query_target_entity_name": "ground", "relation_object_entity_id": "3852646", "relation_subject_entity_id": "591351", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "591351", "selected_entity_name": "zebra"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "zebra", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["591351"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "zebra", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["344134", "344136", "344137", "344138", "344139", "344140", "344141", "344142", "344143", "344144", "344146", "344153", "344162"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["apple"], "predicate": "sniffing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "344139", "query_target_entity_name": "apple", "relation_object_entity_id": "344139", "relation_subject_entity_id": "344135", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "344135", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["344135"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:eb82766a5126f5b64e4f1ac555d4517d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "43882aa8ea85e03c5fb93ed367849c4c47ac0661965d13cbed0488465de4ef6a", "image_sha256_b": "11873ef3584114fdec10c335bc836b7de13a90c2c4d020280e91fc28fde5adc9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f2b5e9fb654c8a218f8d7c02d06b72a04e494909bed986dd19fb37639e2eef77", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5140bc2e9eece54be1f2b391c8b3b053", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d5227a34d9e725a5e3c4e5763a1a8afc1d3ca2f9d2c2ceae1cfab94e7eaece36"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "82d02252b083674fc6352354d300bd7534cdebef3611be7b17ba2364f7742ae7", "request_id": "0a9ef2b75da7caf4f399aa0ce5d45107", "response_sha256": "43353f1b6ecfa16cb6f03136e6b87eaa90d1c6ece3ed76e9fd4a91006ce1b608", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1c11d082020f66a3bd6a96eb7692ff70ba7395e22cd8f5a7e4014ba37ab6745f", "request_id": "4eeae150517828b23b62e3a7090f96ad", "response_sha256": "db072c8c8d6de7d254cc6d90ddb38b5375efc83ad059d66ba7f130292ef1fa83", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "f773d51ff34fd148d7ef011de150565b", "candidate_priority_rank": 12690, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f933d6dc62c64e3c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f933d6dc62c64e3c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f933d6dc62c64e3c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f933d6dc62c64e3c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bun<->donut", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bun", "B": "donut"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bun<->donut", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2331786", "image_sha256": "065f559144ee682ae8401ecdcc23b6b852d61a25f8a0e82b69e50797b6eda94a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2331786.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2331786.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2403336", "image_sha256": "71f42f9fc52a2603642d1d506b0429d7dfd706d40d556db494174210e957185f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2403336.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2403336.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f933d6dc62c64e3c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bun", "diff_b": "donut", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bun", "component_b": "donut"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bun", "ear", "face", "glasses", "hand", "hat", "paper", "topping", "woman"], "detected_components": ["bun"], "masked_program_sha256": "ab6601254492056f1ac74c19c3ee2891a6856e1c4f0bd7c089b7fc9bc91ec63d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bun"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bun", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bun"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1f4d39d71fb4a1decb65c4d68c8744cadff82ba3efaf3e6e797ab19dfdaa0f67"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00841138", "text": "What's the bun wrapped in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["chocolate", "cooler", "cups", "donut", "flower", "girl", "hair", "hat", "head", "leaf", "lid", "napkin", "pastries", "shirt", "table", "tablecloth", "tray", "tree"], "detected_components": ["donut"], "masked_program_sha256": "ab6601254492056f1ac74c19c3ee2891a6856e1c4f0bd7c089b7fc9bc91ec63d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["donut"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "donut", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["donut"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bee84f36b84bc474fa4ecd8cd95bc554f39084e87d908c1d6c124ef16e506f89"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00205808", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12690, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a0a47c0c1cc12712e4f39f4a13875fbdea072c78353f0d735c7079df805ed069", "selected_component": "donut", "selected_source_question_id": "00205808", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's the donut wrapped in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the wrapped in?", "program_group_hash": "a0a47c0c1cc12712e4f39f4a13875fbdea072c78353f0d735c7079df805ed069", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wrapped in", "select_category": "bun"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the wrapped in?", "program_group_hash": "a0a47c0c1cc12712e4f39f4a13875fbdea072c78353f0d735c7079df805ed069", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wrapped in", "select_category": "donut"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "paper", "full_answer": "The bun is wrapped in paper.", "question": "What's the bun wrapped in?", "question_id": "00841138", "semantic": [{"argument": "bun (4654115)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,o (4654103)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "napkin", "full_answer": "The doughnut is wrapped in a napkin.", "question": "What's the donut wrapped in?", "question_id": "00205808", "semantic": [{"argument": "donut (354320)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,o (354336)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4654091", "4654092", "4654095", "4654097", "4654099", "4654100", "4654101", "4654103", "4654104", "4654105", "4654106", "4654108", "4654110", "4654111", "4654112", "4654114"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["paper"], "predicate": "wrapped in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4654103", "query_target_entity_name": "paper", "relation_object_entity_id": "4654103", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4654115", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4654115", "selected_entity_name": "bun"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bun", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4654115"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "donut", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bun", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["354319", "354321", "354322", "354323", "354324", "354325", "354326", "354327", "354328", "354329", "354330", "354331", "354332", "354333", "354334", "354335", "354336", "354337", "354338", "354339", "354340", "354341", "354342", "354343"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 24, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["napkin"], "predicate": "wrapped in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "354336", "query_target_entity_name": "napkin", "relation_object_entity_id": "354336", "relation_subject_entity_id": "354320", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "354320", "selected_entity_name": "donut"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "donut", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["354320"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f773d51ff34fd148d7ef011de150565b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "065f559144ee682ae8401ecdcc23b6b852d61a25f8a0e82b69e50797b6eda94a", "image_sha256_b": "71f42f9fc52a2603642d1d506b0429d7dfd706d40d556db494174210e957185f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "05288d5f56e5ca7c7d40d078475a5a210d003cc0ef539a1f883d79e951b4a954", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a97ccac0a2e48dc5bdcfc39c4e7dbdca", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "774e76d442b0962e3610a4f04db4733715d8c15a3a682a88b54ef59564927997"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4c282365d4880a5222050fa7db3485acd1421fc55ae0cf362790e2e0751abc2d", "request_id": "6e5e69d8c181261dc9c008560876a423", "response_sha256": "2520bd6f957c65d08ef727159ac00a2977e9dcfcd7206ff96bac052e1fa48220", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2d68680ff96f4fbf04184dbc64ada587462a4c0cb36e72831287c82619a8bbd8", "request_id": "8eb48cf9151c8aec66ac827ab8809bca", "response_sha256": "d0a5666e56e553fc3894bf07e0f9a998aaf3ca943920e1addfdd1af3cd129cf6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "b12d4a5e9c45ad25f4b4c08b0feca8c1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12708, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d46be1849352aab7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d46be1849352aab7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d46be1849352aab7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d46be1849352aab7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "boy<->dog", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "boy", "B": "dog"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "boy<->dog", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2362369", "image_sha256": "4c75c40f567afb03c86f26158a78cf5f848d20e995c50b5998578d856aed0a55", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2362369.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2362369.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2368563", "image_sha256": "fb61955cde59230e27d275439f3ebded1a60f804d92f8d18c3a83c65c95472ac", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2368563.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2368563.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d46be1849352aab7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "boy", "diff_b": "dog", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "boy", "component_b": "dog"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boy", "ear", "giraffe", "ground", "hair", "head", "horns", "pen", "pole", "shirt"], "detected_components": ["boy"], "masked_program_sha256": "281f8a349604dedfffadbe72fb8e06226227f5032b2518b170de876b44c22eb9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "boy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fd0c8e4531bae9b9bdf7e83f16b7c2829a81acc8a01f5f1fe163649cf571c131"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09927507", "text": "What kind of animal is looking at the boy?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "collar", "dog", "door", "grass", "ground", "head", "paw", "tail", "tire"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "281f8a349604dedfffadbe72fb8e06226227f5032b2518b170de876b44c22eb9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a0e7b3c3905958106a2a80c28c88afd8ebac5c987bbb2b75f5fb48ada9d3448f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06232572", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12708, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "433dd40ab35dbb525c8a9df8db7427d7ac7d208722f977ae3593fdc97a02c411", "selected_component": "dog", "selected_source_question_id": "06232572", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of animal is looking at the dog?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,looking at,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is looking at the ?", "program_group_hash": "433dd40ab35dbb525c8a9df8db7427d7ac7d208722f977ae3593fdc97a02c411", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "looking at", "select_category": "boy"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,looking at,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is looking at the ?", "program_group_hash": "433dd40ab35dbb525c8a9df8db7427d7ac7d208722f977ae3593fdc97a02c411", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "looking at", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The animal is a giraffe.", "question": "What kind of animal is looking at the boy?", "question_id": "09927507", "semantic": [{"argument": "boy (2159511)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,looking at,s (1722182)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What kind of animal is looking at the dog?", "question_id": "06232572", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (745928)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,looking at,s (745927)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1722182"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "looking at", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1722182", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "2159511", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1722182", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2159511", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2159511"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["745927"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "looking at", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "745927", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "745928", "relation_subject_entity_id": "745927", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "745928", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["745928"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b12d4a5e9c45ad25f4b4c08b0feca8c1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4c75c40f567afb03c86f26158a78cf5f848d20e995c50b5998578d856aed0a55", "image_sha256_b": "fb61955cde59230e27d275439f3ebded1a60f804d92f8d18c3a83c65c95472ac", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "078545d7a418a57eb066881872c3840188328d5e9dd71dcde445e511e1b53f06", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a1147293b0dd3ed05dba0fd2ca6d095d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ca1d55b98710e46fbfb3f7ce6ca02fbe9c119db500147fcf7aae8adb14fe0c23"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7ddd70e9b953035fa88e28e1cdf11e60af5fd6778e827a78194a25bd82573a9e", "request_id": "c8c5738e6423472696227aa82b9fdb38", "response_sha256": "024bc11fa1c6e7b8b61edd481fd779ffa24b8ebe84f7da2c5a5b318af00568f1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "59b4d0f42e2074f0399018aca530f43e20d6ba63ea0773e10a1d515b2e69a1a4", "request_id": "b47bd031d7f3831868dc12589c966535", "response_sha256": "f4658cc21f5895f7070cf7fe871a38ea77ee190af8659f002314790e6c03f7e5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "833fb1826bf3a02771e4dd2758f28d7b", "candidate_priority_rank": 12759, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-66f44d49bfc2d2ad:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-66f44d49bfc2d2ad:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-66f44d49bfc2d2ad:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-66f44d49bfc2d2ad:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "garlic<->pizza", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "pizza", "B": "garlic"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "pizza<->garlic", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2333747", "image_sha256": "0ffa3cb9db04a27be5f0cfc38651e2b150534ce5618e0ccc4c62d7d8b8a4d735", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2333747.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2333747.jpg", "width": 374}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2389625", "image_sha256": "27452614b70ae6e3aa6b400b3ec1bdc940e0eb3398c84cf17311697146f496e6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389625.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389625.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-66f44d49bfc2d2ad", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "pizza", "diff_b": "garlic", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "pizza", "component_b": "garlic"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "bracelet", "cheese", "counter", "ear", "finger", "glasses", "hair", "hand", "head", "kettle", "man", "nose", "pan", "pants", "pizza", "ring", "shelf", "shirt", "stove", "towel", "wall"], "detected_components": ["pizza"], "masked_program_sha256": "9be7f6bed3715614b85c11a6e5987a74b5a8b792afc9afddf700266f56358021", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pizza", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "348c732f31bb53f242bd160ee8e3db71a4e0c69817c02502ab6fa01e26a83363"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "15707401", "text": "What kind of cooking utensil is the pizza on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["carrot", "cutting board", "garlic", "mushroom", "parsley", "wall"], "detected_components": ["garlic"], "masked_program_sha256": "9be7f6bed3715614b85c11a6e5987a74b5a8b792afc9afddf700266f56358021", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["garlic", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "garlic", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["garlic", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8bb08ce93c349a901230b80bcc786c562d1687cb6dd532b25eab890c0eb95387"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16155979", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12759, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "78157acfb6de3315fbf6f999ecda3241f828771cbd22425653de972ebd766c36", "selected_component": "garlic", "selected_source_question_id": "16155979", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of cooking utensil is the garlic on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of cooking utensil is the on?", "program_group_hash": "78157acfb6de3315fbf6f999ecda3241f828771cbd22425653de972ebd766c36", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "pizza"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of cooking utensil is the on?", "program_group_hash": "78157acfb6de3315fbf6f999ecda3241f828771cbd22425653de972ebd766c36", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "garlic"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pan", "full_answer": "The pizza is on the pan.", "question": "What kind of cooking utensil is the pizza on?", "question_id": "15707401", "semantic": [{"argument": "pizza (966718)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,o (966738)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cutting board", "full_answer": "The garlic is on the cutting board.", "question": "What kind of cooking utensil is the garlic on?", "question_id": "16155979", "semantic": [{"argument": "garlic (503709)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,o (503700)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["966726", "966738"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pan"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "966738", "query_target_entity_name": "pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "966738", "relation_subject_entity_id": "966718", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "966718", "selected_entity_name": "pizza"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["966718"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "garlic", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["503700"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cutting board"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "503700", "query_target_entity_name": "cutting board", "relation_object_entity_id": "503700", "relation_subject_entity_id": "503709", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "503709", "selected_entity_name": "garlic"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "garlic", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["503709"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:833fb1826bf3a02771e4dd2758f28d7b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "0ffa3cb9db04a27be5f0cfc38651e2b150534ce5618e0ccc4c62d7d8b8a4d735", "image_sha256_b": "27452614b70ae6e3aa6b400b3ec1bdc940e0eb3398c84cf17311697146f496e6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3b2ba3abd8972207e5104fb6f2f73e453b8397732aa285d46bbf85c24091e42d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ffccc28223b0c3dc4c15971cb1e93e5c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7bd1ec5beeaa7df6985ab10b1562a431ded65f31a7750a41328b95be1e8fc2d2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f549018fc949130350ee12104467eb753c36f5e6b03ed61d17751080e02e0709", "request_id": "fb2c19988e8e2fa75bb0b7ec0967f061", "response_sha256": "9409b5bd8688d89132b2ca67d20b3fe0dc56000ef08e76751d02437c9c00d9e3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e74779b2f51649506e0ec0fa2636e574058519de6a401417554363518cfca37a", "request_id": "88abd1265337df186f9adaf1c98c7910", "response_sha256": "fff24c26c8f629f09aacd892f4c2af9c26caa00492adedf62ad8c1a12e1a427c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "1b0540da80a1546ec6f62278f98d51f8", "candidate_priority_rank": 12778, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba0dcfd5ce29509:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba0dcfd5ce29509:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba0dcfd5ce29509:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba0dcfd5ce29509:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "arrow<->paper", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "paper", "B": "arrow"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "paper<->arrow", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2402910", "image_sha256": "568db2074947a325e2b440057db6f945874ed51aaf34c6bbc0351ad9f2bad07c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402910.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402910.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2363940", "image_sha256": "872086fe74412a6a30181a04b9eb30ca404c3de3103f64d88e7c8cf6fa92096c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2363940.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2363940.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7ba0dcfd5ce29509", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "paper", "diff_b": "arrow", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "paper", "component_b": "arrow"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["grass", "house", "letter", "number", "paper", "road", "sign", "sign post", "sky", "stop sign", "tape", "tree"], "detected_components": ["paper"], "masked_program_sha256": "ebffb905b585d380b0f301d8bdb780703ae14982122d3d0d343315e6256e9c8d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "sign"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "paper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "sign"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "af0687bd4a2cf5df66500cbe4e925a89a846fcccc1cd975624163092d15862d2"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "021070679", "text": "What sign is the paper on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arrow", "barrier", "car", "clouds", "cone", "grass", "ground", "letter", "pole", "road", "roadside", "sky", "street sign", "trees"], "detected_components": ["arrow"], "masked_program_sha256": "ebffb905b585d380b0f301d8bdb780703ae14982122d3d0d343315e6256e9c8d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["arrow", "sign"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "arrow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["arrow", "sign"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c8f88aa2a2ec152c151d6659db4f12afb97e8b000855105ff0a4659a86ef60c3"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09912017", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12778, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 12, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d991a41b49c050f8558b976ad5eaa32aaba8e99953aff16817fc588eb090893e", "selected_component": "arrow", "selected_source_question_id": "09912017", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What sign is the arrow on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sign,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what sign is the on?", "program_group_hash": "d991a41b49c050f8558b976ad5eaa32aaba8e99953aff16817fc588eb090893e", "queried_category": "sign", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "paper"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sign,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what sign is the on?", "program_group_hash": "d991a41b49c050f8558b976ad5eaa32aaba8e99953aff16817fc588eb090893e", "queried_category": "sign", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "arrow"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "stop sign", "full_answer": "The paper is on the stop sign.", "question": "What sign is the paper on?", "question_id": "021070679", "semantic": [{"argument": "paper (1130133)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sign,on,o (1130129)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "street sign", "full_answer": "The arrow is on the street sign.", "question": "What sign is the arrow on?", "question_id": "09912017", "semantic": [{"argument": "arrow (2210593)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "sign,on,o (2581270)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1130129", "1130141", "1130144"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stop sign"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1130129", "query_target_entity_name": "stop sign", "relation_object_entity_id": "1130129", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1130133", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1130133", "selected_entity_name": "paper"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1130133"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "arrow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2581270"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["street sign"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2581270", "query_target_entity_name": "street sign", "relation_object_entity_id": "2581270", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2210593", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2210593", "selected_entity_name": "arrow"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "arrow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2210593"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1b0540da80a1546ec6f62278f98d51f8", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "568db2074947a325e2b440057db6f945874ed51aaf34c6bbc0351ad9f2bad07c", "image_sha256_b": "872086fe74412a6a30181a04b9eb30ca404c3de3103f64d88e7c8cf6fa92096c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "576285b33ba4c6b8935f835ec79bb1b558a73fa196bb903a1474f0e4d4dbd8b6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a2894ee0c0bbffc6d56e9f1b1c03eee2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0172a5d64cd24eb3ae34a0c1be397ae7187fbb201cbce50e110a511008228476"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "aee3f5c3085eaec0f0d2ebf0325b5016f0203c8886cdca1363aa127b0eaa67cf", "request_id": "f970ab9ea50c6e3adcb07a6bce53aa80", "response_sha256": "10323f5c921368354710adab980da0fd742726f0c6a104adc1cd15e1a12d3a85", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "aa147ea0617c3a4e899e880ba2af3b04b56a9b89760f9c79a942341537ce5521", "request_id": "559061562108419e78049ed2c9cb9f07", "response_sha256": "2e5f07ea419ec657668caf1c46cbcac45fe47a05311e050e4ab3d7a261470dd2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "c7c5968f24fdae59124166e0f8131367", "candidate_priority_rank": 12801, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38b1b98e03a82056:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38b1b98e03a82056:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38b1b98e03a82056:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38b1b98e03a82056:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "shirt<->toaster", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "shirt", "B": "toaster"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "shirt<->toaster", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2371919", "image_sha256": "96ab22aa3d96033021b6dc02f8848a7667e999520228b9698af58322361fa6c7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371919.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371919.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2387027", "image_sha256": "7ac7b825941f02989217f6acb85117c0897a2ea45a2121de22686abef91ac10d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387027.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387027.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-38b1b98e03a82056", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "shirt", "diff_b": "toaster", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "shirt", "component_b": "toaster"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "closet", "clothes", "finger", "hand", "man", "shirt", "tie", "wall"], "detected_components": ["shirt"], "masked_program_sha256": "1b482394d60d2d3a61e5c8e48a74a23939ecf4457a56f9764704849ade971000", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["shirt", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "shirt", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["shirt", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f157c40333aa74edce972dc21ec8270671959b3189334146a42dd55fc96d5686"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18865206", "text": "What item of furniture is the shirt in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "basket", "cord", "cupboard", "door", "kettle", "outlet", "plate", "table", "toaster", "towel", "wall"], "detected_components": ["toaster"], "masked_program_sha256": "1b482394d60d2d3a61e5c8e48a74a23939ecf4457a56f9764704849ade971000", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["toaster", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "toaster", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["toaster", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8868eabc70d1889e6bbad0ee4e1a285e2cd1c29bd8d0b7134801c42fb9473bb1"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18283820", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12801, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "be9f2d7073393d1d85ff8a5c7b8ab7a5edbf38636d78380bd5479f46b977fbce", "selected_component": "toaster", "selected_source_question_id": "18283820", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What item of furniture is the toaster in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is the in?", "program_group_hash": "be9f2d7073393d1d85ff8a5c7b8ab7a5edbf38636d78380bd5479f46b977fbce", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "shirt"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is the in?", "program_group_hash": "be9f2d7073393d1d85ff8a5c7b8ab7a5edbf38636d78380bd5479f46b977fbce", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "toaster"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "closet", "full_answer": "The shirt is in the closet.", "question": "What item of furniture is the shirt in?", "question_id": "18865206", "semantic": [{"argument": "shirt (738072)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in,o (738096)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cupboard", "full_answer": "The toaster is in the cupboard.", "question": "What item of furniture is the toaster in?", "question_id": "18283820", "semantic": [{"argument": "toaster (515624)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in,o (515623)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["738096"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["closet"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "738096", "query_target_entity_name": "closet", "relation_object_entity_id": "738096", "relation_subject_entity_id": "738072", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "738072", "selected_entity_name": "shirt"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "shirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["738072"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "toaster", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "shirt", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["515622", "515623"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cupboard"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["open", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "515623", "query_target_entity_name": "cupboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "515623", "relation_subject_entity_id": "515624", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "515624", "selected_entity_name": "toaster"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "toaster", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["515624"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c7c5968f24fdae59124166e0f8131367", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "96ab22aa3d96033021b6dc02f8848a7667e999520228b9698af58322361fa6c7", "image_sha256_b": "7ac7b825941f02989217f6acb85117c0897a2ea45a2121de22686abef91ac10d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "064bc215877f5a81b69c6d885b444fbd7fef3055a017056ec7fe85f6c90513c2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0220384c5287218c7ab90ca7a24c0943", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "718af1dd1d1344d01c97e8a3f30bf1929e4b750f95e8dd96f93da584c5e3a929"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "98a3f9af1750921a45d105819560cebe0942f666aaf9aa842db749b4dd3d41d2", "request_id": "9e8ba139220ce54b4b40cdd5feef3985", "response_sha256": "1d1c8da377d20f56f95d4d9cfb4ebef36f13290ebaada153464415efe88dabca", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "99b992fd7de34e99f10e16a371286bf3cf1d72906d892ea06a279e84b62fa4dc", "request_id": "cff47b6eb1f2a254f9a658e8f6d40998", "response_sha256": "a6487652a49559704642dba0312e3ee2dc1a3c967a6e8af8173aa09ef8222cf5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "bf7a179f7ebac0a27e756d486bcde991", "candidate_priority_rank": 12803, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e71dbb6f680d927:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e71dbb6f680d927:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e71dbb6f680d927:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e71dbb6f680d927:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "boy<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "boy", "B": "woman"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "boy<->woman", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 354, "image_id": "2343639", "image_sha256": "7a152b6dbbd7ee9759b9415115dd55e41d0bdcb778d1f5d7e874ede110cbd77e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343639.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343639.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2365985", "image_sha256": "5009f5d5d3e1e061d8254b0e989aed5b21b1da6a13cc63024eef14dbd1104dcd", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365985.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365985.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6e71dbb6f680d927", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "boy", "diff_b": "woman", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "boy", "component_b": "woman"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boy", "bus", "cell phone", "coat", "hat", "head", "jacket", "people", "pole", "shirt", "window"], "detected_components": ["boy"], "masked_program_sha256": "7f704cbfd278761970ef217d33ee4a6c3e1fd1f2210a20ff14bf8f69156b8f1b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "boy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bce090b02ab65d532777675dcfad9bc65f799d5b9bef3245361189d5720681e5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12710631", "text": "What kind of vehicle is the boy sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["american flag", "carriage", "cart", "face", "girl", "glasses", "hat", "hedge", "horse", "leaves", "leg", "man", "mane", "people", "person", "road", "tree", "wall", "wheel", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "7f704cbfd278761970ef217d33ee4a6c3e1fd1f2210a20ff14bf8f69156b8f1b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c94d034ec4d33d2bbd63eb9394086f1d44332dda943c67adfc897729905c0faf"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05770844", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12803, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "cb540b3159cb580c0a21330dc11e17675475793fb027aa5c4eadb4fd3b7ab79c", "selected_component": "woman", "selected_source_question_id": "05770844", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of vehicle is the woman sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of vehicle is the sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "cb540b3159cb580c0a21330dc11e17675475793fb027aa5c4eadb4fd3b7ab79c", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "boy"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of vehicle is the sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "cb540b3159cb580c0a21330dc11e17675475793fb027aa5c4eadb4fd3b7ab79c", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "woman"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bus", "full_answer": "The boy is sitting on the bus.", "question": "What kind of vehicle is the boy sitting on?", "question_id": "12710631", "semantic": [{"argument": "boy (2858114)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting on,o (2709333)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "carriage", "full_answer": "The woman is sitting on the carriage.", "question": "What kind of vehicle is the woman sitting on?", "question_id": "05770844", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (2144898)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting on,o (3881514)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2709333"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bus"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2709333", "query_target_entity_name": "bus", "relation_object_entity_id": "2709333", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2858114", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2858114", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2858114"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3881514"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["carriage"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3881514", "query_target_entity_name": "carriage", "relation_object_entity_id": "3881514", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2144898", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2144898", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2144898"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:bf7a179f7ebac0a27e756d486bcde991", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7a152b6dbbd7ee9759b9415115dd55e41d0bdcb778d1f5d7e874ede110cbd77e", "image_sha256_b": "5009f5d5d3e1e061d8254b0e989aed5b21b1da6a13cc63024eef14dbd1104dcd", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4c77ebdbe3185cb74ea5fda4a598f7ff53380ee2f09426028dd2bf9c6d6d47bf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "bced071086547a9c1c8d2adb0f95d17b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f3ff80f1fb209f3a6832058d1e2c27a0a9304ff959c369f1f9ae3fa08d1c6a47"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8bedea1e4db7c2db773f5b118e82d5f9c231d67aed208bec5431058fea844fcf", "request_id": "99f1b5a0e09536cc2eb99fb00ad452a1", "response_sha256": "49dbf712565540a79bdd0f67c5b537ff796ed4d7b1c9683a65fa68d965088781", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b15e6d6620c96a3c3e42eef07411adc3a902f50c585c845a198331cb2e783ab5", "request_id": "76314016a7940f0f05e400405253cca3", "response_sha256": "49f857ab6a0397716bfa794c567d04ff59fdad7f5b549cad16e8179f748e4a38", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "027a9162841153748920fe421ab4e418", "candidate_priority_rank": 12828, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f70f8b8b82ae4b4f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f70f8b8b82ae4b4f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f70f8b8b82ae4b4f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f70f8b8b82ae4b4f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "mirror<->towel", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "mirror", "B": "towel"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "mirror<->towel", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2365870", "image_sha256": "d0adadea6933117ea93683d233519b84f95c2a5f92b3cdc2407e1502229878d2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365870.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365870.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2358241", "image_sha256": "d7ae2a1d573969a8e95683241bf59096b8dc9c2757d83dbe9f11baea33f41e83", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2358241.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2358241.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f70f8b8b82ae4b4f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "mirror", "diff_b": "towel", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "mirror", "component_b": "towel"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "bathroom", "brush", "faucet", "floor", "lid", "mirror", "seat", "shower curtain", "sink", "toilet paper", "wall"], "detected_components": ["mirror"], "masked_program_sha256": "d5e374b56baca5a28fee7009c841beb45163572e34c6ce313b3226d5ef487894", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mirror", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "63fe21fa3a0bd5bbea2d55e1eac5b45ecd785902d3177d7aa46bf00d49911877"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "111041500", "text": "What is the mirror hung on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "cabinet", "cabinets", "carpet", "countertop", "cupboards", "dress", "floor", "girl", "hair", "kettle", "knife block", "oven", "person", "pot", "shirt", "stove", "towel", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["towel"], "masked_program_sha256": "d5e374b56baca5a28fee7009c841beb45163572e34c6ce313b3226d5ef487894", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "towel", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c89e6e3b089d5b8bb33a5371064edb64e355fdcbba4a48eec6b234b5bb90b6c8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1281092", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12828, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9861eaac2ea2ab6a69276d5aca60a287c14ddbd9872e8c9b2c2717f2e7e88732", "selected_component": "towel", "selected_source_question_id": "1281092", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the towel hung on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hung on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the hung on?", "program_group_hash": "9861eaac2ea2ab6a69276d5aca60a287c14ddbd9872e8c9b2c2717f2e7e88732", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hung on", "select_category": "mirror"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hung on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the hung on?", "program_group_hash": "9861eaac2ea2ab6a69276d5aca60a287c14ddbd9872e8c9b2c2717f2e7e88732", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "hung on", "select_category": "towel"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "wall", "full_answer": "The mirror is hung on the wall.", "question": "What is the mirror hung on?", "question_id": "111041500", "semantic": [{"argument": "mirror (1740324)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hung on,o (1740325)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stove", "full_answer": "The towel is hung on the stove.", "question": "What is the towel hung on?", "question_id": "1281092", "semantic": [{"argument": "towel (804798)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,hung on,o (804762)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1698032", "1698033", "1740325", "1789896", "1789897", "1866612", "2153506", "2227506", "2253498", "2431310", "2702774", "3882113"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wall"], "predicate": "hung on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1740325", "query_target_entity_name": "wall", "relation_object_entity_id": "1740325", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1740324", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1740324", "selected_entity_name": "mirror"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1740324"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "towel", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["804761", "804762", "804765", "804766", "804768", "804773", "804774", "804779", "804783", "804785", "804788", "804789", "804790", "804793", "804794", "804795", "804801", "804803", "804804"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stove"], "predicate": "hung on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "804762", "query_target_entity_name": "stove", "relation_object_entity_id": "804762", "relation_subject_entity_id": "804798", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "804798", "selected_entity_name": "towel"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "towel", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["804798"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:027a9162841153748920fe421ab4e418", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d0adadea6933117ea93683d233519b84f95c2a5f92b3cdc2407e1502229878d2", "image_sha256_b": "d7ae2a1d573969a8e95683241bf59096b8dc9c2757d83dbe9f11baea33f41e83", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "788b2e624c6a7cbacf721c34a8507a4706ca98cf0b36a574e380a395ff93ab07", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "de49b017840dc91c0b5c1beaf445ad40", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d922e32a0043c2898aad868c9637121ef235e339cc3be8da7a928bae4f5246ac"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7ba0415aeee78fff26ed1914e619d94256ead23761f81da37ed6dc49f809444d", "request_id": "c4920ede914c621bba86165b95a771a6", "response_sha256": "1fec0ebeaa5ae34d2615a8afa58fb8ada6aa930eb3c334d8ecc90ea7947a67a2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5ddab1b9d771fe248b1ab337b8a169cc0330266aca16a76ff16d13329bbfcee9", "request_id": "387f684f813c446fb2e728be21961fba", "response_sha256": "0e2655d1f61d104c0d8e068904d57bbf77df1df6ce02554fac7ab20763df8ed6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "87153a9403c0fc47298bcd2fa519ac9c", "candidate_priority_rank": 12837, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3805811029945cb:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3805811029945cb:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3805811029945cb:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3805811029945cb:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cake<->sandwich", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sandwich", "B": "cake"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sandwich<->cake", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2399287", "image_sha256": "3ed41500ec45570eb370e15aae51ad161761469a6f6282967a7187ab4f7dc53c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399287.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399287.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2397757", "image_sha256": "23ccb0d0df333662b6c3f890f2cb0d1cd580dc80401737299fe8e9d4b2f9aeb2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397757.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397757.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c3805811029945cb", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sandwich", "diff_b": "cake", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sandwich", "component_b": "cake"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bacon", "cup", "glass", "glasses", "ketchup", "knife", "liquid", "plate", "sandwich"], "detected_components": ["sandwich"], "masked_program_sha256": "cfaccb4cb808a3c332567313fe24f1b8eba8cb980c63cd8a7a3c0369cfd844c1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sandwich"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sandwich", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sandwich"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a3d48acb93297138885923d1343b80ce0a59682784bf9cb7c09e494621c745fc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00662548", "text": "What's stuck in the sandwich?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cake", "chocolate", "finger", "frosting", "hand", "man", "plate", "shirt", "sprinkles", "utensil", "wall"], "detected_components": ["cake"], "masked_program_sha256": "cfaccb4cb808a3c332567313fe24f1b8eba8cb980c63cd8a7a3c0369cfd844c1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cake", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2cb979c31dd06e0dd92628fcc4a7e2185a7cd5727a5ea8369d569ba89d9740de"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1069815", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12837, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a76e519e6ec6c7b8a65ff159062ff31c65eab1ca005d5bdaf5f5d173bb9d3d53", "selected_component": "cake", "selected_source_question_id": "1069815", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's stuck in the cake?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,stuck in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's stuck in the ?", "program_group_hash": "a76e519e6ec6c7b8a65ff159062ff31c65eab1ca005d5bdaf5f5d173bb9d3d53", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "stuck in", "select_category": "sandwich"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,stuck in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's stuck in the ?", "program_group_hash": "a76e519e6ec6c7b8a65ff159062ff31c65eab1ca005d5bdaf5f5d173bb9d3d53", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "stuck in", "select_category": "cake"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "knife", "full_answer": "The knife is stuck in the sandwich.", "question": "What's stuck in the sandwich?", "question_id": "00662548", "semantic": [{"argument": "sandwich (417542)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,stuck in,s (417547)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "utensil", "full_answer": "The utensil is stuck in the cake.", "question": "What's stuck in the cake?", "question_id": "1069815", "semantic": [{"argument": "cake (1186671)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,stuck in,s (1186676)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["417533", "417537", "417539", "417540", "417541", "417544", "417545", "417547"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["knife"], "predicate": "stuck in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "417547", "query_target_entity_name": "knife", "relation_object_entity_id": "417542", "relation_subject_entity_id": "417547", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "417542", "selected_entity_name": "sandwich"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sandwich", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["417542"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sandwich", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1186672", "1186673", "1186674", "1186675", "1186676", "1186677", "1186680", "1186681", "1186684", "1186685", "1186686"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["utensil"], "predicate": "stuck in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["plastic", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1186676", "query_target_entity_name": "utensil", "relation_object_entity_id": "1186671", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1186676", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1186671", "selected_entity_name": "cake"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1186671"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:87153a9403c0fc47298bcd2fa519ac9c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3ed41500ec45570eb370e15aae51ad161761469a6f6282967a7187ab4f7dc53c", "image_sha256_b": "23ccb0d0df333662b6c3f890f2cb0d1cd580dc80401737299fe8e9d4b2f9aeb2", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "aa19a62a496e594e40d040ac48b6cbf9d2b3e3e73ca9aad7fbf5de0db4d1970c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a60216b76f097ce6949cafec33861182", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "401c7a412f924d8646bb6a688ade7fdc60290832fb3da6c5ada9d5337c479bd4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b3d5c95d4e28f421edc5e2bd3940db68dff1c0d5e66c684f26c2980cec7dbeb7", "request_id": "4c80f80f3fc9de635874c9baffa5c8f0", "response_sha256": "6747456b378cd299e621242c1e8fe39cfa16e6725456d761252ace11547f6ad4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "76ff5e565442398151a7ed56bd796eeaa4cfdf7479a0063566a016c1aa753da4", "request_id": "0f19aa51b8dd4ca1d2353e369d72165e", "response_sha256": "cfa49f4cf4ef8244a536438801f9c4f8cca0bbbf666b2e89fbbcb9717a447045", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "c63028cb21c2644a71d540cacfc5c480", "candidate_priority_rank": 12870, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbf851c9eda342d0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbf851c9eda342d0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbf851c9eda342d0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbf851c9eda342d0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "microwave<->sheep", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sheep", "B": "microwave"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sheep<->microwave", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 383, "image_id": "2325633", "image_sha256": "39325fd49a9ff399bbd0281f12c7f231b9c6c1ccd189bb064925c4b5b17910af", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2325633.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2325633.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 276, "image_id": "2408324", "image_sha256": "b408fbade71313ee68c1696e55b3bfb696c6a554799aedea7d31059a7dc9a22a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408324.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408324.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bbf851c9eda342d0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sheep", "diff_b": "microwave", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sheep", "component_b": "microwave"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bird", "ear", "eye", "fur", "ground", "head", "mouth", "nose", "sheep", "tail", "wool"], "detected_components": ["sheep"], "masked_program_sha256": "041d75995f40a4341e1c5624f47120050f7487191d8c1a71954671972f06c3b2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sheep", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sheep", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sheep", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5b59af052edd94fec61a9dab76b24dcc0897c0c175766a32d6c9429b5ad386c6"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14467710", "text": "What animal is perched on the sheep?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "cat", "counter", "dishwasher", "eye", "faucet", "microwave", "paw", "plate", "pot", "screen", "sink", "towel", "wall"], "detected_components": ["microwave"], "masked_program_sha256": "041d75995f40a4341e1c5624f47120050f7487191d8c1a71954671972f06c3b2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["microwave", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "microwave", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["microwave", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a41af407e28a0b925be21c6adfb1a11c4d0385b9d77508f3922bc8477cf16de0"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1727951", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12870, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "57a0da31424d75e058edf6553eba72882e9d8c9698739a2bc67a3f4904e018b3", "selected_component": "microwave", "selected_source_question_id": "1727951", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is perched on the microwave?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,perched on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is perched on the ?", "program_group_hash": "57a0da31424d75e058edf6553eba72882e9d8c9698739a2bc67a3f4904e018b3", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "perched on", "select_category": "sheep"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,perched on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is perched on the ?", "program_group_hash": "57a0da31424d75e058edf6553eba72882e9d8c9698739a2bc67a3f4904e018b3", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "perched on", "select_category": "microwave"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bird", "full_answer": "The animal is a bird.", "question": "What animal is perched on the sheep?", "question_id": "14467710", "semantic": [{"argument": "sheep (985773)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,perched on,s (985774)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What animal is perched on the microwave?", "question_id": "1727951", "semantic": [{"argument": "microwave (649912)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,perched on,s (649911)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["985772", "985774"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bird"], "predicate": "perched on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["perched", "small", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "985774", "query_target_entity_name": "bird", "relation_object_entity_id": "985773", "relation_subject_entity_id": "985774", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "985773", "selected_entity_name": "sheep"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sheep", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["985773"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "microwave", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sheep", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["649911"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "perched on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "striped"], "query_target_entity_id": "649911", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "649912", "relation_subject_entity_id": "649911", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "649912", "selected_entity_name": "microwave"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "microwave", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["649912"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c63028cb21c2644a71d540cacfc5c480", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "39325fd49a9ff399bbd0281f12c7f231b9c6c1ccd189bb064925c4b5b17910af", "image_sha256_b": "b408fbade71313ee68c1696e55b3bfb696c6a554799aedea7d31059a7dc9a22a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e64bfb4043b0d699f0b2c4a5726ad8ace2f2a9d267beb8795d89dc444aa68878", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "de3cdc6f583b51bfb47cd3d082a18efe", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b4b3439a0f7fb865ddde29b23a8104a58fbab2600df58aabaf39bbbb3cff2e37"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "13823b76f52c583898bd40dab26a21dd1e92f20069e1ec91244b42e8d44ffab1", "request_id": "7da71e2a9d338a30311da587aa12ec76", "response_sha256": "d69ada850a5ff708aaf2b7bb087201c2f9dd13685c7b854501fefa0c36134b63", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8a3eef00f3cb05b615cd0a788da08e00b2c1934c87c4e4f559d1a0ae9e549ade", "request_id": "4e0d3c945b384b4edd1daa80d57b983e", "response_sha256": "4e3d253c10cabf84d259ad3d05eca8ee0ed1870e3427aea5045d87d0a08af055", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "4193caf9da9d4a07100fbaacf55067bd", "candidate_priority_rank": 12876, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-925b5558c243d4b9:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-925b5558c243d4b9:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-925b5558c243d4b9:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-925b5558c243d4b9:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "beach<->wall", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "beach", "B": "wall"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "beach<->wall", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2358182", "image_sha256": "614e5896615d9571a1f9b8270b4b967ade189f59a9bcb3691e410a758d7b319a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2358182.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2358182.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 768, "image_id": "150490", "image_sha256": "6071fd1b9a4e88d2373939e5d7456e0463fc4fed8bbd74aa15999fe1621587ee", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/150490.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/150490.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-925b5558c243d4b9", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "beach", "diff_b": "wall", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "beach", "component_b": "wall"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beach", "buildings", "chair", "chairs", "clouds", "pole", "sand", "sky", "umbrella", "umbrellas", "water"], "detected_components": ["beach"], "masked_program_sha256": "ed5e2a55be562502761936bc904fba808f0addaea36c345f6f0d9eb111aa247e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["beach", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "beach", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["beach", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9d173261704c78a0dccd57394c0272a49256c244c2c60f9b23fc114573f55a5b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0613953", "text": "What are the items of furniture on the beach?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blender", "bottle", "building", "cabinet", "clothes", "counter", "cup", "cupboards", "door", "glasses", "hair", "head", "jeans", "kitchen", "lemonade", "liquid", "man", "pot", "sharks", "shirt", "shoe", "sink", "skirt", "stove", "trees", "wall", "window", "wine glass", "woman"], "detected_components": ["wall"], "masked_program_sha256": "ed5e2a55be562502761936bc904fba808f0addaea36c345f6f0d9eb111aa247e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wall", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "51d07e9b4288a6581cd49cf8dedaada2f12a0bbdcf0a4790ccc4d1cbf4581012"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11544248", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12876, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "96b9cf35778f842649ce7d8813b3ed0cde4ca4848f68bda24a753a952ab616db", "selected_component": "wall", "selected_source_question_id": "11544248", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the items of furniture on the wall?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the items of furniture on the ?", "program_group_hash": "96b9cf35778f842649ce7d8813b3ed0cde4ca4848f68bda24a753a952ab616db", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "beach"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the items of furniture on the ?", "program_group_hash": "96b9cf35778f842649ce7d8813b3ed0cde4ca4848f68bda24a753a952ab616db", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chairs", "full_answer": "The pieces of furniture are chairs.", "question": "What are the items of furniture on the beach?", "question_id": "0613953", "semantic": [{"argument": "beach (3768828)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s (805290)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cupboards", "full_answer": "The pieces of furniture are cupboards.", "question": "What are the items of furniture on the wall?", "question_id": "11544248", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (4395012)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s (4395036)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3768827", "805290"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chairs"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "805290", "query_target_entity_name": "chairs", "relation_object_entity_id": "3768828", "relation_subject_entity_id": "805290", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3768828", "selected_entity_name": "beach"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "beach", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3768828"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "beach", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4394982", "4395036"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cupboards"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4395036", "query_target_entity_name": "cupboards", "relation_object_entity_id": "4395012", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4395036", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4395012", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4395012"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4193caf9da9d4a07100fbaacf55067bd", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "614e5896615d9571a1f9b8270b4b967ade189f59a9bcb3691e410a758d7b319a", "image_sha256_b": "6071fd1b9a4e88d2373939e5d7456e0463fc4fed8bbd74aa15999fe1621587ee", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "58063a2460fee1abaadf4c794f4b8cf77901b481c376cedbb9195bf174d649fc", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c6ae897fe71cfd9c7aea38b0d3f366f7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7ef83227f8b69c02d5e21a9b6329ecfd5f9573ff7ae1412b9fd3de39319ae42f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "082c050f4016eb9d8b76d9a521d9436f71301da3265e806cb603064e82a4b553", "request_id": "1fefbb785b966139e27cedd8179b4945", "response_sha256": "35d38dee371b635edfbc179f7d963d64e7b31245a3ea15422bd89f3328201099", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5697cc75e0cc2727393b3d3563ec54171d244f75d52d347d4c7b7155dc1aaf06", "request_id": "6f6307cd203ce2ed3014ed3b49f89ec3", "response_sha256": "21f7c798fa957b182af8ab54c2cb68651d4f72eb3c5f41b2e609745b6b721dca", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "ce4d0cbf68e0cbb3b2a4fcc30021c555", "candidate_priority_rank": 12878, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6819f16cb8e88b0b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6819f16cb8e88b0b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6819f16cb8e88b0b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6819f16cb8e88b0b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blanket<->mud", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "mud", "B": "blanket"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "mud<->blanket", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2391170", "image_sha256": "5daedda65e9296cc6c82ff8e99efb7d948224f324a6e0e4b79b224b7e7b0a23e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2391170.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2391170.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 494, "image_id": "2349842", "image_sha256": "40063f3ab2c82175d4b7296cfba3c6a928bcdeb0df209bb26198f880058936c6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2349842.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2349842.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6819f16cb8e88b0b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "mud", "diff_b": "blanket", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "mud", "component_b": "blanket"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["elephant", "eyes", "flower", "grass", "mound", "mud", "sand", "trunk"], "detected_components": ["mud"], "masked_program_sha256": "8064fb4f082626f4d57a5a19325622bdc31919eefe6b11eb8315479e7ac9842a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mud", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mud", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mud", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2e6cd97411b19ac05c7af9092e7ffa919de7bd4e1df42a350836dde02b6f1862"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "061002732", "text": "What animal is covered with the mud?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "ears", "fence", "fence post", "gravel", "ground", "hills", "hillside", "horse", "trees", "wire"], "detected_components": ["blanket"], "masked_program_sha256": "8064fb4f082626f4d57a5a19325622bdc31919eefe6b11eb8315479e7ac9842a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blanket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "45c774e2ed8425033fc54660f9e920945a483b072b5bfc4f691b989e307e7e57"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14546014", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12878, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "64513cd27d04dfde718cd5e71f981ab6102b4a2642f2a93d626516bf5d017825", "selected_component": "blanket", "selected_source_question_id": "14546014", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is covered with the blanket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covered with,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is covered with the ?", "program_group_hash": "64513cd27d04dfde718cd5e71f981ab6102b4a2642f2a93d626516bf5d017825", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "covered with", "select_category": "mud"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covered with,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is covered with the ?", "program_group_hash": "64513cd27d04dfde718cd5e71f981ab6102b4a2642f2a93d626516bf5d017825", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "covered with", "select_category": "blanket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The elephant is covered with mud.", "question": "What animal is covered with the mud?", "question_id": "061002732", "semantic": [{"argument": "mud (490950)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covered with,s (490946)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The animal is a horse.", "question": "What animal is covered with the blanket?", "question_id": "14546014", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (2457993)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covered with,s (2480694)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["490946"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "covered with", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "lying", "old"], "query_target_entity_id": "490946", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "490950", "relation_subject_entity_id": "490946", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "490950", "selected_entity_name": "mud"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mud", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["490950"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mud", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2480694", "2505703"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "covered with", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "2480694", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "2457993", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2480694", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2457993", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2457993"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ce4d0cbf68e0cbb3b2a4fcc30021c555", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5daedda65e9296cc6c82ff8e99efb7d948224f324a6e0e4b79b224b7e7b0a23e", "image_sha256_b": "40063f3ab2c82175d4b7296cfba3c6a928bcdeb0df209bb26198f880058936c6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3a639e5d322ce2483f602f9598c83f9dcf02c3c046e555fe8313dd084ba5b3ea", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a291d3038570b54e31b9872e08075189", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "65ae495313070c6aae9e8d0835013b4999e1347bc9b21993989cb421578aeae8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "65659b568b1e4a104044acc19618a2a920d1ea1e4257af7864e7416e0497cb4c", "request_id": "c4df7a34a30b488f7e4d10e177931155", "response_sha256": "86d0da95dbdb840d3dde9c75ac61e78b6299a13ba3cbf56d8c00d33db6a7c4ed", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d266000c3dafb0f1d906e10222be7bb410eeafa8d31b12edd3c9d80c684eb578", "request_id": "1bd660f9d39c7925cd48db926b085370", "response_sha256": "f663a5c316b3246c85f7725ed636fda790e14b30a73e5776c396a5372ae13f08", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "9d060c995292ae07d629b72f93cd04d6", "candidate_priority_rank": 12925, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50dbe995250294db:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50dbe995250294db:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50dbe995250294db:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50dbe995250294db:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cake<->microwave", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "microwave", "B": "cake"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "microwave<->cake", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2366984", "image_sha256": "caef69b9bf15cd8e5dcb01086ed5d193afb2bc2c837def47987c5f098d4863bf", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2366984.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2366984.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 683, "image_id": "285935", "image_sha256": "43f446ea2e5c96749684fd5e3f4601ea993abec41d6d41d361af33de067ba8e8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/285935.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/285935.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50dbe995250294db", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "microwave", "diff_b": "cake", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "microwave", "component_b": "cake"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["counter", "cup", "dishwasher", "door", "drawer", "faucet", "floor", "microwave", "shelf", "sink", "wall"], "detected_components": ["microwave"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["microwave", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "microwave", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["microwave", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a29d76f4e4b3278e5f2b99f0d2c4c52095591325d68ab8372e4d626894f3a1d3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18735310", "text": "What type of furniture is that microwave on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "beer", "berries", "blueberries", "cake", "coffee table", "crackers", "cup", "dress", "foot", "knife", "person", "raspberry", "sofa", "wine"], "detected_components": ["cake"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cake", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "727803b4820e8ae313b6170fe44047c640a6640b27dc890d662b739b90719fa9"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15755473", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12925, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 23, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6106dfb08844e4350a6a028e40cc7426cadb8af9f70da521e178cfb27ab65044", "selected_component": "cake", "selected_source_question_id": "15755473", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of furniture is that cake on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of furniture is that on?", "program_group_hash": "6106dfb08844e4350a6a028e40cc7426cadb8af9f70da521e178cfb27ab65044", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "microwave"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of furniture is that on?", "program_group_hash": "6106dfb08844e4350a6a028e40cc7426cadb8af9f70da521e178cfb27ab65044", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "cake"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "shelf", "full_answer": "The microwave is on the shelf.", "question": "What type of furniture is that microwave on?", "question_id": "18735310", "semantic": [{"argument": "microwave (2258873)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (3876050)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "coffee table", "full_answer": "The cake is on the coffee table.", "question": "What type of furniture is that cake on?", "question_id": "15755473", "semantic": [{"argument": "cake (4409585)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (4409607)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2258874", "3876042", "3876049", "3876050"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["shelf"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3876050", "query_target_entity_name": "shelf", "relation_object_entity_id": "3876050", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2258873", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2258873", "selected_entity_name": "microwave"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "microwave", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2258873"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "microwave", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4409607", "4409608"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["coffee table"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "4409607", "query_target_entity_name": "coffee table", "relation_object_entity_id": "4409607", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4409585", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4409585", "selected_entity_name": "cake"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4409585"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:9d060c995292ae07d629b72f93cd04d6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "caef69b9bf15cd8e5dcb01086ed5d193afb2bc2c837def47987c5f098d4863bf", "image_sha256_b": "43f446ea2e5c96749684fd5e3f4601ea993abec41d6d41d361af33de067ba8e8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7a85fef5ebd47e3870e79f8c3f6c17edbcc18b75646a7e175a646c1d1053e30e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1f986c968224ab970371bb87f66be61c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "30c6e5a70f2f306753a3d448e4ac4992ebfecf59b0656b58b6883e9098adb5dc"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "147d3095a47817c9cb2dd112a9e9c246ca5c59ad38fd6fd9ac7274c20bc8da1c", "request_id": "73e3fcb0e1a6882eba157cb34e7b3069", "response_sha256": "b1452961bd45f8332b459ce69757a126554c9b661cf64fcc7ad65826f987e084", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c77797b9088e2b63ef64bf9560f9a6e431bebbb5518a2797808815ce665decc7", "request_id": "a7d7752d731fd374ec098db7f693f8d8", "response_sha256": "223d4a67d24020f6421858ec231e13fde111cdeafe77e5e7c0d7a7e69938ceb9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "49022bcf62451b54d1df0b89f7f16f19", "candidate_priority_rank": 12941, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-916eee82ced1db82:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-916eee82ced1db82:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-916eee82ced1db82:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-916eee82ced1db82:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "curtain<->mirror", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "curtain", "B": "mirror"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "curtain<->mirror", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2411601", "image_sha256": "0ad38da222b38be064fb418cd373bf39761cebb2383b1e7040bb3967fa84075d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2411601.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2411601.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2387632", "image_sha256": "fa228964b66fb2c9a2553146e0e2c38655152e3bbdb429b349e181b780c1ba0b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387632.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387632.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-916eee82ced1db82", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "curtain", "diff_b": "mirror", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "curtain", "component_b": "mirror"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bedroom", "curtain", "dog", "fireplace", "lamp", "picture", "pillow", "tray", "wall"], "detected_components": ["curtain"], "masked_program_sha256": "b7a8879eb2df5079b2a1c1cd8f3faf77d717cd514ee18a9ead3a6b42dee3dae9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["curtain", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "curtain", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["curtain", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "03ee1c5ceca79b41d0911a92828ec06b93f8508f331f0d1375113f8ad514feb1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19222964", "text": "What is the item of furniture in front of the curtain called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["chair", "mirror", "plates", "sticker", "table", "vase", "wall"], "detected_components": ["mirror"], "masked_program_sha256": "b7a8879eb2df5079b2a1c1cd8f3faf77d717cd514ee18a9ead3a6b42dee3dae9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mirror", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "69600f33b14da35dac7d4fe4bda2665ef4d25bea907d4a263be52ccbc899b36d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00338610", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12941, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "52de3a96c6c2ffcc9b7d975fc2f0ae226f9bda11f5b22e66285e6c3b95583724", "selected_component": "mirror", "selected_source_question_id": "00338610", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the item of furniture in front of the mirror called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture in front of the called?", "program_group_hash": "52de3a96c6c2ffcc9b7d975fc2f0ae226f9bda11f5b22e66285e6c3b95583724", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "curtain"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture in front of the called?", "program_group_hash": "52de3a96c6c2ffcc9b7d975fc2f0ae226f9bda11f5b22e66285e6c3b95583724", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "mirror"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What is the item of furniture in front of the curtain called?", "question_id": "19222964", "semantic": [{"argument": "curtain (309518)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s (309514)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a table.", "question": "What is the item of furniture in front of the mirror called?", "question_id": "00338610", "semantic": [{"argument": "mirror (1274287)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,in front of,s (1274282)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["309514"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "309514", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "309518", "relation_subject_entity_id": "309514", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "309518", "selected_entity_name": "curtain"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "curtain", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["309518"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "curtain", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1274282", "1274291"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "glass"], "query_target_entity_id": "1274282", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "1274287", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1274282", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1274287", "selected_entity_name": "mirror"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1274287"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:49022bcf62451b54d1df0b89f7f16f19", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "0ad38da222b38be064fb418cd373bf39761cebb2383b1e7040bb3967fa84075d", "image_sha256_b": "fa228964b66fb2c9a2553146e0e2c38655152e3bbdb429b349e181b780c1ba0b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "25d7fae6968b78963812be0d314b150926ef013682e4e7a1037422927a2445e7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "29f38194f482b33818fba1dd13f8f448", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "35eec4fcafc790a2a994428857988ab388b53e16dde6997c6350a83c6b8cd402"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7f143c250102da732b75c086f89e3c7c0d0f3f201eab37edf55e2cc0dcd0eb9f", "request_id": "cba4fb05a0b74e0cc9b1b1cb26303749", "response_sha256": "b9488e58be7ee7c2f7f7eea6bfc60f1a09bd337e482157ff1a40bb42e5666300", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "20f9c3598bd44cd81373162290729449bee3641395fde489a94321067061347e", "request_id": "593dcbbe9f7bc08b5b59f6e9120ea879", "response_sha256": "c204ca49f150a327957f7d10c1299f9d6533aeaf4abec8474771166a00e19c7a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "4215f56ea56fa9356046b67623fd7c73", "candidate_priority_rank": 12954, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0b410fdda2e42161:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0b410fdda2e42161:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0b410fdda2e42161:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0b410fdda2e42161:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "mirror<->plant", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "plant", "B": "mirror"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "plant<->mirror", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2383641", "image_sha256": "db4adb9c76326a5e317b94fcf2b6dd19e77394793e92b10722491b0670b95a54", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2383641.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2383641.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2386220", "image_sha256": "d16a6edb8cf6f2557f98d6440dfd695b4a2365b15029f85f8ba62ae97cd6c487", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386220.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386220.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0b410fdda2e42161", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "plant", "diff_b": "mirror", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "plant", "component_b": "mirror"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arrow", "bed", "book", "cable", "cat", "comforter", "cord", "ear", "floor", "leg", "plant", "radiator", "radio", "screen", "shelf", "speaker", "television", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["plant"], "masked_program_sha256": "7e047c4f2a1e0276881f06134b4b447446acd2c9f6427aa5d92ebc40531806b2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plant", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "plant", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plant", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fe5481e7fbfa26d84ac24b83d7379a32714836b9e34506d2e2b8b8c8125713c6"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0421549", "text": "What is the device in front of the plant?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "ceiling", "chair", "chairs", "clock", "cupboard", "dining room", "dining table", "fan", "flowers", "jeans", "living room", "man", "mirror", "plant", "pot", "rug", "speaker", "television", "vase", "woman"], "detected_components": ["mirror"], "masked_program_sha256": "7e047c4f2a1e0276881f06134b4b447446acd2c9f6427aa5d92ebc40531806b2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mirror", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3e722205ce64318353fa125084215d69729df1b3a4705649e857695cf7aed651"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01562946", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12954, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a51b64bfed92cdd9d1179a7bccd0f9584c78a2a9b8e03e0acc2375ce7b90b7f6", "selected_component": "mirror", "selected_source_question_id": "01562946", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the device in front of the mirror?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the device in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "a51b64bfed92cdd9d1179a7bccd0f9584c78a2a9b8e03e0acc2375ce7b90b7f6", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "plant"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the device in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "a51b64bfed92cdd9d1179a7bccd0f9584c78a2a9b8e03e0acc2375ce7b90b7f6", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "mirror"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "television", "full_answer": "The device is a television.", "question": "What is the device in front of the plant?", "question_id": "0421549", "semantic": [{"argument": "plant (531174)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,in front of,s (531167)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "television", "full_answer": "The device is a television.", "question": "What is the device in front of the mirror?", "question_id": "01562946", "semantic": [{"argument": "mirror (1288271)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,in front of,s (1288256)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["531166", "531167", "531186", "531191"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["television"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "on"], "query_target_entity_id": "531167", "query_target_entity_name": "television", "relation_object_entity_id": "531174", "relation_subject_entity_id": "531167", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "531174", "selected_entity_name": "plant"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plant", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["531174"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1288256", "1288274"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plant", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 2, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1288259", "1288260"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1288256", "1288274"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["television"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["large"], "query_target_entity_id": "1288256", "query_target_entity_name": "television", "relation_object_entity_id": "1288271", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1288256", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1288271", "selected_entity_name": "mirror"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1288271"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4215f56ea56fa9356046b67623fd7c73", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "db4adb9c76326a5e317b94fcf2b6dd19e77394793e92b10722491b0670b95a54", "image_sha256_b": "d16a6edb8cf6f2557f98d6440dfd695b4a2365b15029f85f8ba62ae97cd6c487", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "31452a6ad8c4d41643a88197c770bd1f3388c5ef9d5c9530d96b1d0d091ba9c4", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9399c87aacc0c50543486286060f8fda", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "37e27d96b2b4befb008b2a412a57a5e9b4a03c596df03af6503a77f47cc63ccb"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cc0af123790ca7e67f65aafaa2395747ac2335b892d72b471c7eb61908da2125", "request_id": "040a040d76b23169588c7986102c1849", "response_sha256": "6f194e9a1477f80e8649dc11b1147f936d1914421d519baadc552c828ef8c9f6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "176ad7a27f8bb88e291d4d67290d1b0890261f904b4f9e6a4cac799139608fe4", "request_id": "393e6f2b7b9c63b523a65a33c88d3c13", "response_sha256": "0fd3f76088d0374ed79042b64d65e8bd7194a836ff9633b1bf26f28492f25062", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "e6d0bbab78690ae0cb7f966889addd74", "candidate_priority_rank": 12972, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7c3df4f1f9d37c37:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7c3df4f1f9d37c37:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7c3df4f1f9d37c37:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7c3df4f1f9d37c37:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "woman"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->woman", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2383123", "image_sha256": "035afe1bd8a2c7eaac6950a5889e7f4add3accbe811e8a410b1598731afe6ffc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2383123.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2383123.jpg", "width": 332}, "B": {"height": 346, "image_id": "2318376", "image_sha256": "c5d6af1fe6f91b0d529100a65a464278e7ad6737bef69bcce9d7ea3c48ac9edc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2318376.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2318376.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7c3df4f1f9d37c37", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "woman", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "woman"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["glove", "goggles", "hand", "jacket", "man", "pants", "pine tree", "pocket", "ski", "snow", "tree", "trees"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "af6e56baab93eccd3821e4028534039c26901d3edf399827885c6f5c8e68b4e2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "411404867f2a8c6f1a89652a8f6a0386927849b2009a83d641db4588ca8853f8"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1986509", "text": "What color are the trousers that the man is wearing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "bottle", "branches", "chains", "dirt", "earring", "floor", "frisbee", "grass", "ground", "hair", "hand", "leaves", "pants", "shirt", "tree", "tree trunk", "weeds", "woman", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "af6e56baab93eccd3821e4028534039c26901d3edf399827885c6f5c8e68b4e2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7659df6403464fab4e9d635b287b8d4c228e15322546d8f726b18e48844712ed"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14803747", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12972, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 19, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1e2f55730ba497d4e110c18c6b97dabe6c028291ecff2c1790e50e3749717c5e", "selected_component": "woman", "selected_source_question_id": "14803747", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color are the trousers that the woman is wearing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "pants,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color are the trousers that the is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1e2f55730ba497d4e110c18c6b97dabe6c028291ecff2c1790e50e3749717c5e", "queried_category": "pants", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "pants,wearing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color are the trousers that the is wearing?", "program_group_hash": "1e2f55730ba497d4e110c18c6b97dabe6c028291ecff2c1790e50e3749717c5e", "queried_category": "pants", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wearing", "select_category": "woman"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "white", "full_answer": "The trousers are white.", "question": "What color are the trousers that the man is wearing?", "question_id": "1986509", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (4538161)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "pants,wearing,o (4538244)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "black", "full_answer": "The trousers are black.", "question": "What color are the trousers that the woman is wearing?", "question_id": "14803747", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (1011312)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "pants,wearing,o (1011319)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4538244"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["white"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "4538244", "query_target_entity_name": "pants", "relation_object_entity_id": "4538244", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4538161", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4538161", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4538161"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1011319"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["black"], "predicate": "wearing", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1011319", "query_target_entity_name": "pants", "relation_object_entity_id": "1011319", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1011312", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1011312", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1011312"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e6d0bbab78690ae0cb7f966889addd74", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "035afe1bd8a2c7eaac6950a5889e7f4add3accbe811e8a410b1598731afe6ffc", "image_sha256_b": "c5d6af1fe6f91b0d529100a65a464278e7ad6737bef69bcce9d7ea3c48ac9edc", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c2e24db4c7849d1a0590841876c832e52f50593ce33d78dc2eff69096950a316", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b7b2c3b68881e57284ce4e348119c3af", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "116bf228a65726634a438d2725f1259dc32f724e1ac5938bc36258e49d395197"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d349de92b1618e5f0bc1fbbd3024c45531841d92906d25c3115aeb1ad6620fd7", "request_id": "23996bb9d76be2892dc731e6ea4507bb", "response_sha256": "386b099fd0a12ba6cea47df1f4105d3532b156ada0f42d8e6c56c2d21a87f233", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a9594b9cde501e5ec52cd100f914065d5be8ef1629cac0b13ef7d5129b45e44f", "request_id": "fa6d16c4c338be05fa5585583f81b3ff", "response_sha256": "e4fcc57d45d80db92d0f532ca3f531b2ff120920d295e60d4a9a7ccb55b39fb7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "4d19bba7f8b20707928952775390c710", "candidate_priority_rank": 12979, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3073ee1bf6816a5c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3073ee1bf6816a5c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3073ee1bf6816a5c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3073ee1bf6816a5c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bike<->bowl", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bowl", "B": "bike"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bowl<->bike", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2376557", "image_sha256": "76465b09b32e1cfcec4fc020ee17cd4f27e837c2ee3a01e67a03790920a4889e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376557.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376557.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2337435", "image_sha256": "ebd0b28bf60452ac5be297c9683ed7b7b22f0d1ac5764b2369c3c6a53619af11", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2337435.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2337435.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3073ee1bf6816a5c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bowl", "diff_b": "bike", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bowl", "component_b": "bike"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bowl", "carpet", "ear", "envelope", "eye", "foot", "leg", "nose", "orange", "sofa", "stuffed animal", "table"], "detected_components": ["bowl"], "masked_program_sha256": "6a1a6d5b952e3680259d7b3b9dcb00f104108597cec04819e0dc0e01a1973bc6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bowl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e55a6743a0cd87f41597d1d138cd8bd53bb3c13389780a2804a9f124560a406a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0556213", "text": "What toy is in front of the bowl?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bike", "doll", "drink", "ear", "foot", "ground", "hand", "hat", "head", "jeans", "leg", "man", "mouth", "nose", "pole", "seat", "straw"], "detected_components": ["bike"], "masked_program_sha256": "6a1a6d5b952e3680259d7b3b9dcb00f104108597cec04819e0dc0e01a1973bc6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bike", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bike", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bike", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3b2b99be490018466246393d9e9e2f49243276a017c6fcfb2f709ca0309283a7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19812844", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12979, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4f2522142fa428bb8e4e3a5e20a84b9b124b5d3ffbc3cbb88c44816fb0c0222f", "selected_component": "bike", "selected_source_question_id": "19812844", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What toy is in front of the bike?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what toy is in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "4f2522142fa428bb8e4e3a5e20a84b9b124b5d3ffbc3cbb88c44816fb0c0222f", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "bowl"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what toy is in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "4f2522142fa428bb8e4e3a5e20a84b9b124b5d3ffbc3cbb88c44816fb0c0222f", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "bike"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "stuffed animal", "full_answer": "The toy is a stuffed animal.", "question": "What toy is in front of the bowl?", "question_id": "0556213", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (571779)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,in front of,s (571776)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "doll", "full_answer": "The toy is a doll.", "question": "What toy is in front of the bike?", "question_id": "19812844", "semantic": [{"argument": "bike (957608)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,in front of,s (957577)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["571776"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stuffed animal"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["small"], "query_target_entity_id": "571776", "query_target_entity_name": "stuffed animal", "relation_object_entity_id": "571779", "relation_subject_entity_id": "571776", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "571779", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["571779"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bike", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["957577"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["doll"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "957577", "query_target_entity_name": "doll", "relation_object_entity_id": "957608", "relation_subject_entity_id": "957577", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "957608", "selected_entity_name": "bike"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bike", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["957608"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4d19bba7f8b20707928952775390c710", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "76465b09b32e1cfcec4fc020ee17cd4f27e837c2ee3a01e67a03790920a4889e", "image_sha256_b": "ebd0b28bf60452ac5be297c9683ed7b7b22f0d1ac5764b2369c3c6a53619af11", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ddaa2bcec7a5de4ea92efa776f6cc474bfb8344840862005ecc7b1e699de4d96", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8af3dee7e1415019644c849874de232e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ee1732725059b197fccf6c3f4b4660dca806c3ef14c7ab16b25b606ca3c2eae2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "77038bd5bded6202cffda1e3528ae3586128ed362666600ca3714790bae6d74a", "request_id": "72f5d5a55c3c0bccaf66c9a69ffe98d3", "response_sha256": "173607c0ab663cfc5f18a822085ee37413d9fed375cb40ca49c47409f55d6ded", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "729d2140e510ec9901ea28867319a17588827415b34a38fedcd3b5092cdd80da", "request_id": "23b1e365624aebf57516b18a7edea34d", "response_sha256": "2d91e6c42311fc0938363e2e246e8241bb6b4b7cf8e671d17d5b63062fcc2026", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "b90f6c026484e1ffdada93790197fc7a", "candidate_priority_rank": 12982, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-aeb072295a438918:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-aeb072295a438918:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-aeb072295a438918:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-aeb072295a438918:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "building<->sidewalk", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sidewalk", "B": "building"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sidewalk<->building", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2398073", "image_sha256": "5acfcef815d087e3b9e273d6c2564d9384050b38f930ea3089594d3e695b5250", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398073.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398073.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 372, "image_id": "2375620", "image_sha256": "df79c4f6ecb6c8e48d1e42419395928f95edda5c4ef947c3db1339444e894783", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2375620.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2375620.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-aeb072295a438918", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sidewalk", "diff_b": "building", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sidewalk", "component_b": "building"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "cone", "ground", "license plate", "mirror", "motorcycle", "seat", "sidewalk", "tail", "tire", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["sidewalk"], "masked_program_sha256": "712f433a305e82de264e54b44b75f9823f67cadbfab42b1c9a00080951c3c6fb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sidewalk"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sidewalk", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sidewalk"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ff74a3f6fc93e4239c5a9e049509658245b5d41384dbd7d02117a7f0823faac8"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02380446", "text": "What is parked next to the sidewalk?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["backpack", "branches", "building", "bush", "clock", "dirt", "fence", "grass", "hands", "jeans", "lamp", "man", "people", "person", "post", "sign", "sky", "stairs", "street", "tire", "tree", "trees", "truck", "windows", "windshield"], "detected_components": ["building"], "masked_program_sha256": "712f433a305e82de264e54b44b75f9823f67cadbfab42b1c9a00080951c3c6fb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "building", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "11887f9304df48bf7cf400c3422c53c692aa87c0700f9b2670f0b5efc156c686"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "151015154", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12982, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 11, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b6ad1b0f20fd415137f59582135075c48352a0dc15da3c8bd892ba9915965fad", "selected_component": "building", "selected_source_question_id": "151015154", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is parked next to the building?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked next to,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is parked next to the ?", "program_group_hash": "b6ad1b0f20fd415137f59582135075c48352a0dc15da3c8bd892ba9915965fad", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "parked next to", "select_category": "sidewalk"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked next to,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is parked next to the ?", "program_group_hash": "b6ad1b0f20fd415137f59582135075c48352a0dc15da3c8bd892ba9915965fad", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "parked next to", "select_category": "building"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "motorcycle", "full_answer": "The motorcycle is parked next to the sidewalk.", "question": "What is parked next to the sidewalk?", "question_id": "02380446", "semantic": [{"argument": "sidewalk (428557)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked next to,s (428537)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "truck", "full_answer": "The truck is parked next to the building.", "question": "What is parked next to the building?", "question_id": "151015154", "semantic": [{"argument": "building (580996)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked next to,s (581000)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["428536", "428537", "428538", "428540", "428541", "428542", "428544", "428546", "428548", "428550", "428551", "428555", "428556"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["motorcycle"], "predicate": "parked next to", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["beautiful", "clean", "gold", "pretty", "shiny"], "query_target_entity_id": "428537", "query_target_entity_name": "motorcycle", "relation_object_entity_id": "428557", "relation_subject_entity_id": "428537", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "428557", "selected_entity_name": "sidewalk"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sidewalk", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["428557"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "building", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sidewalk", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["580995", "580997", "580998", "580999", "581000", "581001", "581002", "581003", "581004", "581005", "581006", "581007", "581008", "581009", "581010", "581011", "581012", "581013", "581014", "581015", "581016", "581017", "581018", "581019", "581020", "581022", "581023"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 27, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["truck"], "predicate": "parked next to", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["parked", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "581000", "query_target_entity_name": "truck", "relation_object_entity_id": "580996", "relation_subject_entity_id": "581000", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "580996", "selected_entity_name": "building"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "building", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["580996"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b90f6c026484e1ffdada93790197fc7a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5acfcef815d087e3b9e273d6c2564d9384050b38f930ea3089594d3e695b5250", "image_sha256_b": "df79c4f6ecb6c8e48d1e42419395928f95edda5c4ef947c3db1339444e894783", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7a6d331cee92aa05b79cf088f775f05a60155978706981184fd708f0f6d475ec", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "34270edcfbd87a3adfe9cd0a44648dc5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1b714863d376ceb05bf50641696dce0252815a406eba623d0e3cc1eb55806db8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "254add079d25bc18edf144709337848fb1fc6bfeb4afc67e47eacc8e2ff7c9a4", "request_id": "0bb660e681cc31f898aa92f7f0171919", "response_sha256": "7f00b9e874198628f86d1675e0a0673c8a1d904dd44082557032da428d7b36d5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "63ae71407257cc1f8750b2fe36b90fba3cbabc0f00b081bf311ea27bbac526a6", "request_id": "6dd503e5fc9c5136135bd734a00c0350", "response_sha256": "aaf4d48edb241a2bf9d2d92bf7ee83379f6c3c8eac9370531f382a04f1765ad7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "13b1ee90537d573f45da768374f04771", "candidate_priority_rank": 13004, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db382528cd11b359:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db382528cd11b359:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db382528cd11b359:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db382528cd11b359:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->table", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "table", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "table<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 600, "image_id": "407", "image_sha256": "bfe7fc1e9697ede7879a5f16367473e03e5d632cea9d9b0868b0e92a50c84773", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/407.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/407.jpg", "width": 800}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2413005", "image_sha256": "df6bac21bf687f64f11aac8aa4ce50aa4dd044ff1b22b3a55bb6cae910937c5c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2413005.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2413005.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-db382528cd11b359", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "table", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "table", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bookshelf", "cap", "chair", "computer", "computer monitor", "computer mouse", "helmet", "keyboard", "man", "notebook", "phone", "soda", "soda bottle", "soda can", "sweatshirt", "table", "window"], "detected_components": ["table"], "masked_program_sha256": "74e8c4ab259f1d6adbf662a39129543f64374575d08cb1b566c407c2e94ab5b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "table", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c7468b314345af21aead0d9c8c8bc038c35bb60fc9191977d2160ff501406b46"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1176555", "text": "What kind of device is under the table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "ear", "eye", "head", "leg", "logo", "mouth", "nose", "remote control"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "74e8c4ab259f1d6adbf662a39129543f64374575d08cb1b566c407c2e94ab5b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5bb1535b98067353960e35dcc6c5df88d9a99f9fc46a92b3509602bc4681455f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02348667", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13004, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c7b66441528ef240f3865401ff1c107e81f6ebf03f078229a6ee00ae82208969", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "02348667", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of device is under the cat?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of device is under the ?", "program_group_hash": "c7b66441528ef240f3865401ff1c107e81f6ebf03f078229a6ee00ae82208969", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of device is under the ?", "program_group_hash": "c7b66441528ef240f3865401ff1c107e81f6ebf03f078229a6ee00ae82208969", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "computer", "full_answer": "The device is a computer.", "question": "What kind of device is under the table?", "question_id": "1176555", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (1622629)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,under,s (1622613)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "remote control", "full_answer": "The device is a remote control.", "question": "What kind of device is under the cat?", "question_id": "02348667", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (3801961)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,under,s (3801960)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1622611", "1622613", "1622618", "1622625", "1622626"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["computer"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1622613", "query_target_entity_name": "computer", "relation_object_entity_id": "1622629", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1622613", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1622629", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1622629"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3801960"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["remote control"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "3801960", "query_target_entity_name": "remote control", "relation_object_entity_id": "3801961", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3801960", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3801961", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3801961"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:13b1ee90537d573f45da768374f04771", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bfe7fc1e9697ede7879a5f16367473e03e5d632cea9d9b0868b0e92a50c84773", "image_sha256_b": "df6bac21bf687f64f11aac8aa4ce50aa4dd044ff1b22b3a55bb6cae910937c5c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a9ce52783fbef0a97643544b23a955a94ce1bbba45ac4a64a11d1c7e8cdc6441", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "95fd42de5a058403f30e7abfcdfa873e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "878d91181142eb93a71c5c99300508b20163570f8ed628e3897a44183571ed47"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e9db26a9ebb6a6d642e1678a6ad1a31c16d302ecf31d28843b5b109d79c4f763", "request_id": "8792797aaa715ddde91d877fe6acee7a", "response_sha256": "4f4350546accfec7bd0d42760728194f14f5cbda5f7b630dcb40b991ef4e4de6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a627b3f1490cc7852544737df9b260d53267c1da8cf6501b520b8f48a55756ea", "request_id": "1ad11ac23a2c420035c9b96357207806", "response_sha256": "089bb4ab46649e5934c612eecf8044ccba59cb9136dd1e7c542e88039241e12f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "6c5373257fa6ab31cd948832e7527ef6", "candidate_priority_rank": 13022, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b182cb365fd4ba05:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b182cb365fd4ba05:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b182cb365fd4ba05:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b182cb365fd4ba05:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "fork<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "fork", "B": "woman"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "fork<->woman", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2371787", "image_sha256": "a77b940cd7f3b7b9d62316894b271069305fde3c22e893e92f25c429a030cbfc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371787.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371787.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2375528", "image_sha256": "d3571d6bd615b807b5082e8ca2533684159632475e78efb87752b2e6527c4d3f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2375528.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2375528.jpg", "width": 338}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b182cb365fd4ba05", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "fork", "diff_b": "woman", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "fork", "component_b": "woman"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beans", "bread", "eggs", "food", "fork", "ham", "meat", "mushrooms", "napkin", "plate", "sausages", "table"], "detected_components": ["fork"], "masked_program_sha256": "b8b5af47c115c57be412573e2857274745296f3f9e79691a7dc0f8c9c3834e70", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fork"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "fork", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fork"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6f47f55af07994e562d44192fb52d0fccb2b1d5aba0eb5a983eedcff6992a1db"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0690139", "text": "What is wrapped around the fork?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "comb", "door", "ear", "hair", "hand", "head", "thumb", "towel", "wall", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "b8b5af47c115c57be412573e2857274745296f3f9e79691a7dc0f8c9c3834e70", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "524225ad9d9e9636bdf8e838d4dd31d28689ad2045546fedb6ed3bbfd217445a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "181023322", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13022, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2870df949beb3379608a415ef73ae5a30ba7b2c57c4b137c1724851e49041972", "selected_component": "woman", "selected_source_question_id": "181023322", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is wrapped around the woman?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped around,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is wrapped around the ?", "program_group_hash": "2870df949beb3379608a415ef73ae5a30ba7b2c57c4b137c1724851e49041972", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "wrapped around", "select_category": "fork"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped around,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is wrapped around the ?", "program_group_hash": "2870df949beb3379608a415ef73ae5a30ba7b2c57c4b137c1724851e49041972", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "wrapped around", "select_category": "woman"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "napkin", "full_answer": "The napkin is wrapped around the fork.", "question": "What is wrapped around the fork?", "question_id": "0690139", "semantic": [{"argument": "fork (595864)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped around,s (595866)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "towel", "full_answer": "The towel is wrapped around the woman.", "question": "What is wrapped around the woman?", "question_id": "181023322", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (2001562)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped around,s (3841911)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["595857", "595858", "595860", "595861", "595863", "595865", "595866", "595867", "595868", "595870", "595872", "595874"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["napkin"], "predicate": "wrapped around", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "595866", "query_target_entity_name": "napkin", "relation_object_entity_id": "595864", "relation_subject_entity_id": "595866", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "595864", "selected_entity_name": "fork"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fork", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["595864"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fork", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1674501", "1674502", "1738740", "2401461", "2743639", "2881439", "3041080", "3041081", "3380223", "3841911", "3841912"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["towel"], "predicate": "wrapped around", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["tied", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "3841911", "query_target_entity_name": "towel", "relation_object_entity_id": "2001562", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3841911", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2001562", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2001562"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:6c5373257fa6ab31cd948832e7527ef6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a77b940cd7f3b7b9d62316894b271069305fde3c22e893e92f25c429a030cbfc", "image_sha256_b": "d3571d6bd615b807b5082e8ca2533684159632475e78efb87752b2e6527c4d3f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5cefa1f2fe95b73a6bea95aa4424aa271e600e7e3a19ca86045a1aac94cc8546", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "21e19c563e35d35b8ff79d3fbd590f31", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1bfce762190a752db8f778b7c880e58ffbb5a77bc0171526818ba902bed35a4e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "799bc9f2bb486c1e88809869713e3ea1061b5eb1b14f2485a89317d9f21b3acb", "request_id": "c807ed4d7ff69fbafa7d4c89f7c6a1e3", "response_sha256": "3ed4cef150bbbd72261b9e251f9a5439e05ecb44c3d241a0a6e8f44a02bfe44c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fe5d3a185ad4c7388193889da51909c6be132a8b8e6b8949f60469e037bf6e77", "request_id": "573e8ffe903aba4b5a7950a839bd7531", "response_sha256": "8d882feb9f3b48de4e9d2a3ddf3f9e077bc2601b304abacd3dc3ae2f73a55b91", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "c35dd7316a8c8f529e79b10aa112a90e", "candidate_priority_rank": 13023, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-140a7a75626bb324:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-140a7a75626bb324:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-140a7a75626bb324:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-140a7a75626bb324:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "napkin<->paper", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "napkin", "B": "paper"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "napkin<->paper", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2371787", "image_sha256": "a77b940cd7f3b7b9d62316894b271069305fde3c22e893e92f25c429a030cbfc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371787.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371787.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2338837", "image_sha256": "a4fc37ba247ff06d656391e77527e0087e58b5780b5a92c556ebfea234f29094", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2338837.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2338837.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-140a7a75626bb324", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "napkin", "diff_b": "paper", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "napkin", "component_b": "paper"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beans", "bread", "eggs", "food", "fork", "ham", "meat", "mushrooms", "napkin", "plate", "sausages", "table"], "detected_components": ["napkin"], "masked_program_sha256": "5d163776c9986001bb962d4b556534faec3772ce5667b44254a3e5448609e871", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["napkin"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "napkin", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["napkin"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bb6abff18dac25fc14225488d9dbca8e87245a9b55bcf49e66b016431765a554"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0690070", "text": "What is wrapped in the napkin?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bicycle", "bicycles", "bike", "bird", "bus", "doors", "feet", "hand", "hat", "head", "leg", "man", "pants", "paper", "people", "person", "pole", "shirt", "sidewalk", "sign", "sticker", "street", "street light", "tires", "van", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["paper"], "masked_program_sha256": "5d163776c9986001bb962d4b556534faec3772ce5667b44254a3e5448609e871", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "paper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "15e8b1ca840dc53a2cbc656427cb7f3c5412618d0d50ed6516866b3c82d29ec9"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13115643", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13023, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5f3a8e7e8979bde3de42c9edbbf1ee3810230be5a31c17955f38601e50eb906b", "selected_component": "paper", "selected_source_question_id": "13115643", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is wrapped in the paper?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is wrapped in the ?", "program_group_hash": "5f3a8e7e8979bde3de42c9edbbf1ee3810230be5a31c17955f38601e50eb906b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "wrapped in", "select_category": "napkin"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is wrapped in the ?", "program_group_hash": "5f3a8e7e8979bde3de42c9edbbf1ee3810230be5a31c17955f38601e50eb906b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "wrapped in", "select_category": "paper"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "fork", "full_answer": "The fork is wrapped in the napkin.", "question": "What is wrapped in the napkin?", "question_id": "0690070", "semantic": [{"argument": "napkin (595866)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,s (595864)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pole", "full_answer": "The pole is wrapped in paper.", "question": "What is wrapped in the paper?", "question_id": "13115643", "semantic": [{"argument": "paper (952991)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,s (952975)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["595857", "595858", "595860", "595861", "595863", "595864", "595865", "595867", "595868", "595870", "595872", "595874"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fork"], "predicate": "wrapped in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "595864", "query_target_entity_name": "fork", "relation_object_entity_id": "595866", "relation_subject_entity_id": "595864", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "595866", "selected_entity_name": "napkin"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "napkin", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["595866"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "napkin", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["952954", "952955", "952956", "952959", "952960", "952961", "952963", "952964", "952965", "952968", "952969", "952970", "952971", "952972", "952973", "952974", "952975", "952976", "952978", "952979", "952980", "952981", "952982", "952983", "952984", "952985", "952986", "952989", "952990", "952993", "952994", "952995"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 32, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pole"], "predicate": "wrapped in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["metal", "silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "952975", "query_target_entity_name": "pole", "relation_object_entity_id": "952991", "relation_subject_entity_id": "952975", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "952991", "selected_entity_name": "paper"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["952991"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c35dd7316a8c8f529e79b10aa112a90e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a77b940cd7f3b7b9d62316894b271069305fde3c22e893e92f25c429a030cbfc", "image_sha256_b": "a4fc37ba247ff06d656391e77527e0087e58b5780b5a92c556ebfea234f29094", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "914e33f9fa92c604756e7cf3d09a5b06068332fa3f5f279d7c636ae6a9b325d2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5405ea041db6e96e7a4f25158363d408", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c69583f2e9ef7f750988b6ee184a35e792c7e862cdd7d7a894a6a98e8e324769"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1a96ded49db80425757284c7ff766489f211c13e0f6469cc5d52656b75c7df47", "request_id": "024be8b3bb9b69dcc6966af57437abff", "response_sha256": "0623d4431ef9142e9ceb1be19c4fa507ea06340f062ece9d6d90389c7be5bbb8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ff9584d4eddeb739373bd952a9f78e65ce00b768535eaa52115167f303a8432c", "request_id": "c86baa1949ed1733f1ab9761e18525be", "response_sha256": "8e1ec63ae326121bf2fb90dd562c9ccc97fad3cc9b18da001d30342c4a44119a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "f8b031ca90a2bb8f3fd1822da8802df1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13046, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dc4b39041c9ba44c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dc4b39041c9ba44c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dc4b39041c9ba44c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dc4b39041c9ba44c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "floor<->ground", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "floor", "B": "ground"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "floor<->ground", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2407890", "image_sha256": "a10e90afcdff67a4be3b47d7c58329b25d52224ff4ee7b2913cd91948cc8270a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407890.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407890.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2358987", "image_sha256": "174e72bacedcf6c902340a34c39089ff43d15359712651273710e54d978175df", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2358987.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2358987.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dc4b39041c9ba44c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "floor", "diff_b": "ground", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "floor", "component_b": "ground"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "door", "ears", "eyes", "face", "feet", "floor", "frame", "hallway", "paws", "tail", "wall"], "detected_components": ["floor"], "masked_program_sha256": "883d3e02afa92e18010e6b533480931f2d8b31caf3a8a41fd0bc9d637ab3519b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["floor", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "floor", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["floor", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7fcade65baea04eb589dfb574f0349924a5e09fca8afb506adc1a18fca7cfcfc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19186681", "text": "What is the animal that is lying on the floor called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["baby", "computer", "ear", "elephant", "ground", "leg", "tail", "trunk"], "detected_components": ["ground"], "masked_program_sha256": "883d3e02afa92e18010e6b533480931f2d8b31caf3a8a41fd0bc9d637ab3519b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ground", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9da55f56fc60d4b8787a0b2546af32b8de6cc381f7ef0eb72d3a7233d1f2d659"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1447034", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13046, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "495a42769345a5cd1f035abd924b92e65a03ca4c832e106feaa9dc3c136530af", "selected_component": "ground", "selected_source_question_id": "1447034", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal that is lying on the ground called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is lying on the called?", "program_group_hash": "495a42769345a5cd1f035abd924b92e65a03ca4c832e106feaa9dc3c136530af", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "floor"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is lying on the called?", "program_group_hash": "495a42769345a5cd1f035abd924b92e65a03ca4c832e106feaa9dc3c136530af", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "ground"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What is the animal that is lying on the floor called?", "question_id": "19186681", "semantic": [{"argument": "floor (271880)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (271872)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The animal is an elephant.", "question": "What is the animal that is lying on the ground called?", "question_id": "1447034", "semantic": [{"argument": "ground (3767335)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (3540922)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["271872", "271873"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "lying"], "query_target_entity_id": "271872", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "271880", "relation_subject_entity_id": "271872", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "271880", "selected_entity_name": "floor"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "floor", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["271880"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "floor", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3540919", "3540922"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3540922", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "3767335", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3540922", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3767335", "selected_entity_name": "ground"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3767335"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f8b031ca90a2bb8f3fd1822da8802df1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a10e90afcdff67a4be3b47d7c58329b25d52224ff4ee7b2913cd91948cc8270a", "image_sha256_b": "174e72bacedcf6c902340a34c39089ff43d15359712651273710e54d978175df", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0244308466a2e0a296788f25ff903c2851b5fbef8ed620978fafe3e4f569d779", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "822b91b30315ecb9592f11b122898867", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "86f1ea6159d2bc4d1b82d54b237b590a679b21128556d40ac845688f9e9e5234"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0ca966c6ade8538e1bdf4056f42e75611999df7a2f3226431cef742d0edb0ada", "request_id": "cc7169b1d0c94961af69b662e34af9b4", "response_sha256": "a1a13bade1a89919d41d4b5587410e71d5174e10e1c68ec11bdccad62d411957", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0da8abcd6ac5a9434f782551ec79f18cd133562229f2eb02d8f532a3dfba9477", "request_id": "f5772bb5f480d90f131a6c9fb41ea284", "response_sha256": "b137612a66f3bc0718f0cb862f236a0f8d036ede8b56135f3eec629c1c0cdfeb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "299b77048f213a721c3486c85a428fd9", "candidate_priority_rank": 13050, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3b3930923342e342:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3b3930923342e342:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3b3930923342e342:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3b3930923342e342:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "broccoli<->crust", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "broccoli", "B": "crust"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "broccoli<->crust", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2352214", "image_sha256": "05a057da5ea0a9aa4688c606cbd2806f1976ed168bc1190d6d2dc934e1b23221", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2352214.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2352214.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2410451", "image_sha256": "90cd4fe72961ca0e6100f6c995a6c4b17a16b535112013090e26c08bb63050e6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410451.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410451.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3b3930923342e342", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "broccoli", "diff_b": "crust", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "broccoli", "component_b": "crust"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["broccoli", "food", "oven", "pan", "pepper", "sausage", "spatula"], "detected_components": ["broccoli"], "masked_program_sha256": "b2d4e3671cef87e0bd5c7dee90da81029f2ca741e01f4f101d24b8a4d7fae8cf", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["broccoli", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "broccoli", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["broccoli", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "cee082a4386cef2da4cb5a8b20300cd866e6700d4e49d7f6b0004675d2b49955"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "061015640", "text": "What is the cooking utensil that the broccoli is in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["appetizer", "collar", "crust", "cucumber", "fence", "glass", "herbs", "liquid", "neck", "necklace", "pan", "shirt", "table", "water", "woman"], "detected_components": ["crust"], "masked_program_sha256": "b2d4e3671cef87e0bd5c7dee90da81029f2ca741e01f4f101d24b8a4d7fae8cf", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["crust", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "crust", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["crust", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b2508b7648a49a9f6f048050f0f349014edc5510d660c87ad66a7eeac4d82fdb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14826033", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13050, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6ce5f0db365b6b82579956f43e5b150002db0aabd80700b663c965f3c888ace5", "selected_component": "crust", "selected_source_question_id": "14826033", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the cooking utensil that the crust is in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cooking utensil that the is in?", "program_group_hash": "6ce5f0db365b6b82579956f43e5b150002db0aabd80700b663c965f3c888ace5", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "broccoli"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cooking utensil that the is in?", "program_group_hash": "6ce5f0db365b6b82579956f43e5b150002db0aabd80700b663c965f3c888ace5", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "crust"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pan", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a pan.", "question": "What is the cooking utensil that the broccoli is in?", "question_id": "061015640", "semantic": [{"argument": "broccoli (855451)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,in,o (855448)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pan", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a pan.", "question": "What is the cooking utensil that the crust is in?", "question_id": "14826033", "semantic": [{"argument": "crust (217229)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,in,o (217230)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["855448", "855453"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pan"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "full"], "query_target_entity_id": "855448", "query_target_entity_name": "pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "855448", "relation_subject_entity_id": "855451", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "855451", "selected_entity_name": "broccoli"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "broccoli", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["855451"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "crust", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "broccoli", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["217230"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pan"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "heavy"], "query_target_entity_id": "217230", "query_target_entity_name": "pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "217230", "relation_subject_entity_id": "217229", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "217229", "selected_entity_name": "crust"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "crust", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["217229"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:299b77048f213a721c3486c85a428fd9", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "05a057da5ea0a9aa4688c606cbd2806f1976ed168bc1190d6d2dc934e1b23221", "image_sha256_b": "90cd4fe72961ca0e6100f6c995a6c4b17a16b535112013090e26c08bb63050e6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c9aa81a1a9ae10ad4cb6bebc638a6c28fafa2b0a588f1168fb0907789b422f55", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b4408a88a7d30bc2c5259d7896e18b13", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "aca69b3845421ea7b3e51ec5f422cbc09fc04ec39df264b1f06024343ced527a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2bfc7ebfe9c550d6f134f887d2acb7db9e795e6c73ae4ffa9183dca59b9fae89", "request_id": "860e5521f662e90dd12f1842093a8c3d", "response_sha256": "294786eddc369029187da5aae24ee6f0f23b0aec1ec58c3821291e473732fe7f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ec1bc86fa62029d086dda95e0045b55095eaeb39eb58583f9149446b16930e92", "request_id": "526abd89b15abb5b5959e709644bde3e", "response_sha256": "9bf6351ccbc1f23bb12ab899e36bdf66e5f981a3a4ca7b1b300f39755739912b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "aafb8e4dc40e6aa02f9dcd40092485e4", "candidate_priority_rank": 13055, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c48048aefac193f3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c48048aefac193f3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c48048aefac193f3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c48048aefac193f3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "basket<->cow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "basket", "B": "cow"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "basket<->cow", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2340683", "image_sha256": "f98b0ea669bf3bb8afec267cc1baa99dd80170a890c20cb2b3e111ab1568f8b6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2340683.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2340683.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2385136", "image_sha256": "cb7c2e42ac038152fd4e0b2b3539e1d491bb4a9a6d52a40b93fea5f108aebaef", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2385136.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2385136.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "activity_state", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c48048aefac193f3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "basket", "diff_b": "cow", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "basket", "component_b": "cow"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "pose", "question_intent": "activity_state:pose", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["balloon", "basket", "bird", "cap", "cars", "clouds", "ground", "highway", "man", "people", "pole", "road", "shirt", "shorts", "street light", "street sign", "truck", "workers"], "detected_components": ["basket"], "masked_program_sha256": "3bed79cf8bd5e9c41b17b161cea257801bab837ffab00a0acbe76db1055b4188", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "basket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7f2c5129a4e3da0506d2e333657c185fd27b78ccf3377c86b8ec3db7a51a394e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09934275", "text": "What is the person next to the basket doing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cloud", "cow", "eye", "fence", "ground", "hair", "head", "hill", "horn", "house", "man", "pants", "shoe", "sky", "sweatshirt", "telephone pole", "tree", "watch", "window", "yard"], "detected_components": ["cow"], "masked_program_sha256": "3bed79cf8bd5e9c41b17b161cea257801bab837ffab00a0acbe76db1055b4188", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cow", "person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cow", "person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3d084130a3172353b988c3c8d8d825db0bab2f8092096dea298070ad660e12fd"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10599085", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13055, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f69abfe0bb15a00a5a952e8c322fd3265c80fadf7e195c59e6e0f9c5c3932fd8", "selected_component": "cow", "selected_source_question_id": "10599085", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person next to the cow doing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,next to,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person next to the doing?", "program_group_hash": "f69abfe0bb15a00a5a952e8c322fd3265c80fadf7e195c59e6e0f9c5c3932fd8", "queried_category": "person", "query_role": "pose", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "next to", "select_category": "basket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,next to,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person next to the doing?", "program_group_hash": "f69abfe0bb15a00a5a952e8c322fd3265c80fadf7e195c59e6e0f9c5c3932fd8", "queried_category": "person", "query_role": "pose", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "next to", "select_category": "cow"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bending", "full_answer": "The man is bending.", "question": "What is the person next to the basket doing?", "question_id": "09934275", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (946351)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,next to,s (946368)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "crouching", "full_answer": "The man is crouching.", "question": "What is the person next to the cow doing?", "question_id": "10599085", "semantic": [{"argument": "cow (1300591)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,next to,s (1300593)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["946367", "946368"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bending"], "predicate": "next to", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["bending"], "query_target_entity_id": "946368", "query_target_entity_name": "man", "relation_object_entity_id": "946351", "relation_subject_entity_id": "946368", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "946351", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["946351"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1300593"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["crouched", "crouching", "squatting"], "predicate": "next to", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["crouched", "crouching", "squatting"], "query_target_entity_id": "1300593", "query_target_entity_name": "man", "relation_object_entity_id": "1300591", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1300593", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1300591", "selected_entity_name": "cow"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1300591"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:aafb8e4dc40e6aa02f9dcd40092485e4", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f98b0ea669bf3bb8afec267cc1baa99dd80170a890c20cb2b3e111ab1568f8b6", "image_sha256_b": "cb7c2e42ac038152fd4e0b2b3539e1d491bb4a9a6d52a40b93fea5f108aebaef", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a6b34a71fea29fb0d365d7189d0590e965fb0a77d2c94a6bae5f2069462ba022", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "742b5449b38effd26c057d29e800acce", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "39bf64d4c3d0ce496ce749d8041094769919ff4cae730fa6e1a0b1452ce32ca4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a135d9c2c5ae31818b46a703b93273eecf1b3b2729e7dc43092ac4e28472c302", "request_id": "2f0d8a88c0d48e737064739d3a5df9ce", "response_sha256": "059d3a67b69bd154a4a703155da3b448f6166497e17a35885363ffb646db6def", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9f916207e52c44e0a047312173b8c4081fdb3d4b078a29f2d31a53e67a269beb", "request_id": "b12f73a0ce552e233c7d8c39b5348c49", "response_sha256": "04e0f4ebb0df7f465044287ae70745a294c60b4be50ba38cb13990c6ec8ae18c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "c32f61444300d341da6446b4a93e1ba7", "candidate_priority_rank": 13105, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9bb2f48da70851e0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9bb2f48da70851e0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9bb2f48da70851e0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9bb2f48da70851e0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "mirror<->sign", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sign", "B": "mirror"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sign<->mirror", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2315453", "image_sha256": "dc11442b3950fbedafa3d89bb61c420e3c689dd31652ff127e904159606d28cb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2315453.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2315453.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2389610", "image_sha256": "2bcfb88562e6a6d7c83bcb0b441820261e22e070780a120f39781066d8b6ce1c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389610.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389610.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9bb2f48da70851e0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sign", "diff_b": "mirror", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sign", "component_b": "mirror"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["display", "door", "frame", "ground", "hallway", "letter", "parking meter", "rug", "sign", "tiles", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["sign"], "masked_program_sha256": "b596451d0fdb483d6ca13ab13c509d337ab0fb0f1002069d94f26ed933534e40", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sign"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sign", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sign"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "18bae6148483736f74cb09048e1314a64fc39c683e4123b456d6f24edf6bdadc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07259419", "text": "What is the sign mounted on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bathroom", "cabinet", "door", "faucet", "floor", "glass", "mirror", "pipe", "pole", "sign", "sink", "urinal", "wall"], "detected_components": ["mirror"], "masked_program_sha256": "b596451d0fdb483d6ca13ab13c509d337ab0fb0f1002069d94f26ed933534e40", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mirror", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0ad6bc950154e20b33c1151e2f166836769c7d7b2d3e4d9d74f005b9203abcce"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05369648", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13105, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "776d645ec6bc9caa4ffdf6c8d0fedd7bfd2dfb57673e7ae1edf4e08db8f87439", "selected_component": "mirror", "selected_source_question_id": "05369648", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the mirror mounted on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,mounted on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the mounted on?", "program_group_hash": "776d645ec6bc9caa4ffdf6c8d0fedd7bfd2dfb57673e7ae1edf4e08db8f87439", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "mounted on", "select_category": "sign"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,mounted on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the mounted on?", "program_group_hash": "776d645ec6bc9caa4ffdf6c8d0fedd7bfd2dfb57673e7ae1edf4e08db8f87439", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "mounted on", "select_category": "mirror"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "parking meter", "full_answer": "The sign is mounted on the meter.", "question": "What is the sign mounted on?", "question_id": "07259419", "semantic": [{"argument": "sign (4251497)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,mounted on,o (4251424)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "wall", "full_answer": "The mirror is mounted on the wall.", "question": "What is the mirror mounted on?", "question_id": "05369648", "semantic": [{"argument": "mirror (1258984)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,mounted on,o (1258985)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4251423", "4251424", "4251426", "4251441", "4251454", "4251455", "4251458", "4251474", "4251483", "4499880", "4499882"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["parking meter"], "predicate": "mounted on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "4251424", "query_target_entity_name": "parking meter", "relation_object_entity_id": "4251424", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4251497", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4251497", "selected_entity_name": "sign"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sign", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4251497"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1258981", "1258983", "1258984", "1258985", "1258986", "1258989", "1258990", "1258991", "1258993", "1258995", "1258996", "1258997", "1259000", "1259003", "1259006", "1259009"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sign", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 2, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1258981", "1258983"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1258981", "1258983", "1258985", "1258986", "1258989", "1258990", "1258991", "1258993", "1258995", "1258996", "1258997", "1259000", "1259003", "1259006", "1259009"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wall"], "predicate": "mounted on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1258985", "query_target_entity_name": "wall", "relation_object_entity_id": "1258985", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1258984", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1258984", "selected_entity_name": "mirror"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1258984"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c32f61444300d341da6446b4a93e1ba7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "dc11442b3950fbedafa3d89bb61c420e3c689dd31652ff127e904159606d28cb", "image_sha256_b": "2bcfb88562e6a6d7c83bcb0b441820261e22e070780a120f39781066d8b6ce1c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "751c1ecd7750a1f5d427f386a04586d34372ce58155ed9752de57f7a9c4d08cd", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7384ce295368ecb95aba60d9f1788242", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6715fbc9dcece8b97dc94f791e692318ad147be68043a1c836bb9e15b6657a54"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2761083ffd89e8f83ace08bcaba6b105ebe53b1456167527fe20547c5071d244", "request_id": "6910ca210f6181b5c44413757d765f32", "response_sha256": "37a554b3ec3bbd64e5c9517c60d2e0c0f270954b922c7b70d1bbb08557ebb1c3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "573dbd5c4d1fff4665c4fa9c1e916b58f6d782a4874aff04b76af40183de147a", "request_id": "3c9068f6bef8983c6e5e3b7d53403027", "response_sha256": "5ea893d6cded8468ded3e3f3163c5251ca91877783bab6d3be889138bcdc41e3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "5343a9f01f5e182ac22f895d94032201", "candidate_priority_rank": 13118, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3656ce600670851d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3656ce600670851d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3656ce600670851d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3656ce600670851d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "restroom<->window", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "window", "B": "restroom"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "window<->restroom", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2389469", "image_sha256": "4a92d4d1cc97f60e535d3f0fc1b3bc683bf69681a0cda12d355771558902d016", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389469.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389469.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2392155", "image_sha256": "8f5db5b531263b5aec7ca0378e8429f62893bc76d9dea6ba92fbe5df3ced42af", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392155.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392155.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3656ce600670851d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "window", "diff_b": "restroom", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "window", "component_b": "restroom"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["air conditioner", "building", "curtains", "pole", "sticker", "stop sign", "window", "window frame"], "detected_components": ["window"], "masked_program_sha256": "2c0e81d46c3586145d6a7313a6868badc790731a762f490d23134fd6b3d30c8e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["window"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "window", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["window"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ed75246bb584d5949a8799cdca6f1b442f6b2abd8697d95c85c2383cc5d422a1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01475129", "text": "What is sitting inside the window?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "lid", "restroom", "toilet", "toilet seat", "trash", "trash can"], "detected_components": ["restroom"], "masked_program_sha256": "2c0e81d46c3586145d6a7313a6868badc790731a762f490d23134fd6b3d30c8e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["restroom"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "restroom", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["restroom"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "09afd0cba260d10327d19b66eec57203398266db0037ef8b2ee1fc653a6ffc6b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05647741", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13118, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "fd86ae026759384ea9b6ec3b8562c403e35760a2460b186cef8e7d4613a7e027", "selected_component": "restroom", "selected_source_question_id": "05647741", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is sitting inside the restroom?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is sitting inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "fd86ae026759384ea9b6ec3b8562c403e35760a2460b186cef8e7d4613a7e027", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting inside", "select_category": "window"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is sitting inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "fd86ae026759384ea9b6ec3b8562c403e35760a2460b186cef8e7d4613a7e027", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting inside", "select_category": "restroom"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "air conditioner", "full_answer": "The air conditioner is sitting inside the window.", "question": "What is sitting inside the window?", "question_id": "01475129", "semantic": [{"argument": "window (1260614)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting inside,s (1260613)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "toilet", "full_answer": "The toilet is sitting inside the restroom.", "question": "What is sitting inside the restroom?", "question_id": "05647741", "semantic": [{"argument": "restroom (3826200)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting inside,s (3826202)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1260613", "1260615", "1260616", "1260617", "1260619", "1260620", "1260621"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["air conditioner"], "predicate": "sitting inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1260613", "query_target_entity_name": "air conditioner", "relation_object_entity_id": "1260614", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1260613", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1260614", "selected_entity_name": "window"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1260614"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "restroom", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3826188", "3826189", "3826202", "3826211", "3826217", "482619", "482620"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["toilet"], "predicate": "sitting inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3826202", "query_target_entity_name": "toilet", "relation_object_entity_id": "3826200", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3826202", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3826200", "selected_entity_name": "restroom"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "restroom", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3826200"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:5343a9f01f5e182ac22f895d94032201", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4a92d4d1cc97f60e535d3f0fc1b3bc683bf69681a0cda12d355771558902d016", "image_sha256_b": "8f5db5b531263b5aec7ca0378e8429f62893bc76d9dea6ba92fbe5df3ced42af", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f3e9e397365777a88d5a924d2073245fb9737000de33674219201aca77c94723", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3ad57760c2df2d5b18751b21ae2b389c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "812b5efe11b937d0981f46d9a6362580caabfdae92009b6691491c16adedc4d5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "54c095dd2f506097539dba5752ecbedf84da945efe2e23f3ea2d35cfd124cfc7", "request_id": "214a16a84db90b5a768c82693512eea4", "response_sha256": "f52ace83265228d94d7582735b2fa9781a1b4f96cad8b684b2ad14f82d68b776", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "448c80dad84c1a4c46aff90627f411088f004ca5ab76a53bd8a9b09c384a87a0", "request_id": "bd13e582e3f87fc8e838be2090a00693", "response_sha256": "c79baef82870aca7fcc182c7df3ff9ae4206f356778f45473301828f0999b2d0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "96fff8d134bf469e3b06de3252be56a9", "candidate_priority_rank": 13142, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a1fddeab534bd19d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a1fddeab534bd19d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a1fddeab534bd19d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a1fddeab534bd19d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "basket<->store", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "basket", "B": "store"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "basket<->store", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2387727", "image_sha256": "6e5cb193c9b9ddc2197e19166ae20956a211e7e3f336af58b51f372d0fab9c4f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387727.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387727.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 360, "image_id": "2386250", "image_sha256": "c67315923f02e5c57b6cd1cf7c3fb5ff047ddc9fb7f1c9c56ab4833458f975ef", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386250.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386250.jpg", "width": 480}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a1fddeab534bd19d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "basket", "diff_b": "store", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "basket", "component_b": "store"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "ball", "basket", "box", "carpet", "cat", "ears", "floor", "paper", "post", "remote control", "remote controls", "toy"], "detected_components": ["basket"], "masked_program_sha256": "2733c5c50fb2afcca23b8840181e8c722e033ccbbc59d3d511ada4f3dbe81ad8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "basket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "072f7eb2b2ea746fdad29ee11c4d8272cda750cf660067d3d0eeebdd1bdd7665"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04285488", "text": "What kind of device is inside the basket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "cabinet", "display", "entrance", "eye glasses", "floor", "hat", "jacket", "pants", "person", "phone", "price tag", "rose", "store", "television", "tiles", "window"], "detected_components": ["store"], "masked_program_sha256": "2733c5c50fb2afcca23b8840181e8c722e033ccbbc59d3d511ada4f3dbe81ad8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["store", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "store", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["store", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "cb37d858947fa8870aa769be09225811ab39e5806e03fda3e8b838ba2272f0cb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17840832", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13142, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5c30318c9d9f15dc4c61027d2696ddcb2cf9bcd3b7aae4962e7796568c413d63", "selected_component": "store", "selected_source_question_id": "17840832", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of device is inside the store?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of device is inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "5c30318c9d9f15dc4c61027d2696ddcb2cf9bcd3b7aae4962e7796568c413d63", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "basket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of device is inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "5c30318c9d9f15dc4c61027d2696ddcb2cf9bcd3b7aae4962e7796568c413d63", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "store"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "remote controls", "full_answer": "The devices are remote controls.", "question": "What kind of device is inside the basket?", "question_id": "04285488", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (511486)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,inside,s (511493)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "television", "full_answer": "The device is a television.", "question": "What kind of device is inside the store?", "question_id": "17840832", "semantic": [{"argument": "store (682947)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,inside,s (682936)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["511493", "511502", "511503"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["remote controls"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "511493", "query_target_entity_name": "remote controls", "relation_object_entity_id": "511486", "relation_subject_entity_id": "511493", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "511486", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["511486"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "store", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["682936", "682940"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["television"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "flat"], "query_target_entity_id": "682936", "query_target_entity_name": "television", "relation_object_entity_id": "682947", "relation_subject_entity_id": "682936", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "682947", "selected_entity_name": "store"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "store", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["682947"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:96fff8d134bf469e3b06de3252be56a9", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6e5cb193c9b9ddc2197e19166ae20956a211e7e3f336af58b51f372d0fab9c4f", "image_sha256_b": "c67315923f02e5c57b6cd1cf7c3fb5ff047ddc9fb7f1c9c56ab4833458f975ef", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ccceb4d3af4954ba4d109fddcb5ece8708d738fb0ea70674c0ccaf57544a03ce", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0cdb38e8bf376d6ff25cb8de35b5dca7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2452bac4063a9e2907eafe1fbfe101d4ae217275392a77bb8ef74d3a00ccc4eb"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b8a0273836e7b03ae4e05a39cb636ff6bacb0f36b2c91d427bbbf724e4a2da42", "request_id": "25442d2b4cbb5daa52ff3c8ddd4bb703", "response_sha256": "298ccc8b413f5b55bbe701e28a5b098c4f33b691d7b56fab8b56128f0822a024", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "62b557a5572f1cc1e27fad0114a3f180237b239e15f91682dba28335b4d75a39", "request_id": "43cb6fea1a3733faef07efecd883f593", "response_sha256": "c8a613d1ebd4ce3d3fbad3d97f6d0c8fba04951fcb569c439b822b4dc5c6b0df", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "440bf52214220a451b9a05649d2f2925", "candidate_priority_rank": 13152, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7635cff124ada291:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7635cff124ada291:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7635cff124ada291:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7635cff124ada291:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->guy", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "guy", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "guy<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2401063", "image_sha256": "296bdfa04d4e5a3a42aa711df3b4aff93a6ec8ab7c27b684662bd9de218b488d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401063.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401063.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2319924", "image_sha256": "07eb7ad4c1ef8e600ec0176ea9df040570e6f366a8afecfcbb10c83a3ce94c55", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2319924.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2319924.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7635cff124ada291", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "guy", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "guy", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["chair", "eyes", "floor", "glass", "guy", "hand", "hat", "head", "lady", "man", "people", "shirt", "table", "tank top", "umbrella", "umbrellas", "wall", "watch", "wine", "woman"], "detected_components": ["guy"], "masked_program_sha256": "5bb21bccf29265196e3d747fade3431b5873bf8779417e3d863c6fcc4c7d2ab6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["guy", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "guy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["guy", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e7c58af34cc1a1a9e656b04ed69fea0557a1bcc6cd93528a8cd45a4f79215d29"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07424299", "text": "What item of furniture is the guy at?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "collar", "computer", "computer mouse", "desk", "ears", "eyes", "foot", "leg", "mouth", "nose", "paw", "tail"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "5bb21bccf29265196e3d747fade3431b5873bf8779417e3d863c6fcc4c7d2ab6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "afa40ffdafa41889b0c60ba39f4926d93bb32d86c74127a22762d25d75041dde"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04429725", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13152, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "bd955acd97a05d76799ebeed4db1cf4efe644b32ca4b0b63372151d59e9181de", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "04429725", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What item of furniture is the cat at?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is the at?", "program_group_hash": "bd955acd97a05d76799ebeed4db1cf4efe644b32ca4b0b63372151d59e9181de", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "at", "select_category": "guy"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is the at?", "program_group_hash": "bd955acd97a05d76799ebeed4db1cf4efe644b32ca4b0b63372151d59e9181de", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "at", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The guy is at the table.", "question": "What item of furniture is the guy at?", "question_id": "07424299", "semantic": [{"argument": "guy (402710)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,at,o (402716)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "desk", "full_answer": "The cat is at the desk.", "question": "What item of furniture is the cat at?", "question_id": "04429725", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (997545)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,at,o (997551)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["402716", "402733"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "at", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["round", "tan", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "402716", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "402716", "relation_subject_entity_id": "402710", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "402710", "selected_entity_name": "guy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "guy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["402710"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "guy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["997551"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["desk"], "predicate": "at", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "997551", "query_target_entity_name": "desk", "relation_object_entity_id": "997551", "relation_subject_entity_id": "997545", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "997545", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["997545"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:440bf52214220a451b9a05649d2f2925", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "296bdfa04d4e5a3a42aa711df3b4aff93a6ec8ab7c27b684662bd9de218b488d", "image_sha256_b": "07eb7ad4c1ef8e600ec0176ea9df040570e6f366a8afecfcbb10c83a3ce94c55", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "029b8384bf3a9d066dce04dc285827e503e8acc744a517da3f10d6ba9966411c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "30d4943b291511b0c497696dabdb5303", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6f80179f7b245dc4bf588b3002898a19d3c3e965fc219ddadb7ee6bb2058067b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5c4525be087c74bdb6cc95728fda852b8c56d56c60fdb16f3368dd5d1df27f6a", "request_id": "52bd16a918b06bd4e0b1512acbf2cd13", "response_sha256": "e1a2dfc26b46631f4b8475f2180b966c8c9aa4a2a09307e25b786ff393863965", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "917429a8112a2c13f07571f4e9bc960c765624fff609943fe0d6d6b5ab1ced6a", "request_id": "a45b34971a528bf36ad9cb8c3ddc5deb", "response_sha256": "9ba5f4332cc9c78744f0cdcfd3fa8524abe76f9fb48d7f5c592fdcf4a30f6b53", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "e6121ef90c5a5cb1b563969f45d1f564", "candidate_priority_rank": 13156, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-844e8dd61caea8b4:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-844e8dd61caea8b4:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-844e8dd61caea8b4:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-844e8dd61caea8b4:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "jacket<->sweater", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sweater", "B": "jacket"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sweater<->jacket", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2404994", "image_sha256": "fd1646a2bde97388182d6c322944516cdcb05b81a7a8c7f42cee8e8e5f1a2500", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404994.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404994.jpg", "width": 332}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2347674", "image_sha256": "645475254f7a478d8b71002677000057c395c24d1a154bf982e5e8348d593e5e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2347674.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2347674.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-844e8dd61caea8b4", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sweater", "diff_b": "jacket", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sweater", "component_b": "jacket"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "ear", "eye", "face", "flower", "girl", "hair", "hat", "head", "necklace", "shirt", "sweater", "teeth", "wall"], "detected_components": ["sweater"], "masked_program_sha256": "d3f36de00a255b73a1091867e69b2845e68d0b73d4234c672e3d4c1edcdb8ffe", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sweater", "shirt"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sweater", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sweater", "shirt"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8d67e7d8d69dd58a477cf52edf23c978549bb4cdf05c42bf6a0a4a0e350c475d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03326036", "text": "What color is the shirt under the sweater?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cell phone", "earrings", "fence", "hair", "hand", "jacket", "man", "mouth", "pants", "person", "pole", "purse", "ring", "shirt", "sign", "woman"], "detected_components": ["jacket"], "masked_program_sha256": "d3f36de00a255b73a1091867e69b2845e68d0b73d4234c672e3d4c1edcdb8ffe", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["jacket", "shirt"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "jacket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["jacket", "shirt"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e736546b81758f4218fda266057028c31e4996d20a9fd1986094c375d626c206"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11660941", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13156, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6a5e9d25f8654e4452f9485dcd3e64e3717c73d5f2678df67ec864bb352826d3", "selected_component": "jacket", "selected_source_question_id": "11660941", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color is the shirt under the jacket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "shirt,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the shirt under the ?", "program_group_hash": "6a5e9d25f8654e4452f9485dcd3e64e3717c73d5f2678df67ec864bb352826d3", "queried_category": "shirt", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "sweater"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "shirt,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the shirt under the ?", "program_group_hash": "6a5e9d25f8654e4452f9485dcd3e64e3717c73d5f2678df67ec864bb352826d3", "queried_category": "shirt", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "jacket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "gray", "full_answer": "The shirt is gray.", "question": "What color is the shirt under the sweater?", "question_id": "03326036", "semantic": [{"argument": "sweater (655327)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "shirt,under,s (655328)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "blue", "full_answer": "The shirt is blue.", "question": "What color is the shirt under the jacket?", "question_id": "11660941", "semantic": [{"argument": "jacket (888635)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "shirt,under,s (888639)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["655328"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["gray", "grey"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "655328", "query_target_entity_name": "shirt", "relation_object_entity_id": "655327", "relation_subject_entity_id": "655328", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "655327", "selected_entity_name": "sweater"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sweater", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["655327"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "jacket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sweater", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["888639", "888649", "888651"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blue"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "888639", "query_target_entity_name": "shirt", "relation_object_entity_id": "888635", "relation_subject_entity_id": "888639", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "888635", "selected_entity_name": "jacket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "jacket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["888635"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e6121ef90c5a5cb1b563969f45d1f564", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "fd1646a2bde97388182d6c322944516cdcb05b81a7a8c7f42cee8e8e5f1a2500", "image_sha256_b": "645475254f7a478d8b71002677000057c395c24d1a154bf982e5e8348d593e5e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3082a9dda8b5fec2976391743f7b3bc8836a4ab9f9a41d9b62de565038a8a1ee", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d6b6223394f40b68cc670a29979356f0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f355ab433f8a5af270db957374ef5d96ac4a9c703c9cf7d04839a6bda1b26c1b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "370e159110768907f29b5c182e9ce3bbb2167a8db22cfca76788d08a26413286", "request_id": "d3e645a5fda8c1546452f479b38cb431", "response_sha256": "3a75712ade582c4b8b8f8a9ab6542630f7626427931f5a355d04b67286df6e0c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a7bd551a33b73948dfa7af73175d2785a2b469c60566cb6e013f0e1fc72794e3", "request_id": "96a42e52a14899021e9c7a66d65e8d56", "response_sha256": "cc44836e793330379f5ccc65f140c4ae2b40ab37f295a4ea47be30a5a64acb5a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "a80a1f4d3fefadbde967544c9f3e237c", "candidate_priority_rank": 13158, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f5efb8b38098fd2:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f5efb8b38098fd2:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f5efb8b38098fd2:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f5efb8b38098fd2:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "airplane<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "airplane", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "airplane<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2384667", "image_sha256": "a2cad741162941f6015f25e150fea2dd97d8c893225a5c7cd6c6f208152b2a50", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384667.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384667.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 335, "image_id": "2383952", "image_sha256": "25273e8c700f800efdb78b6857fa99fb03d2bdfe957386fa316552b4ecba2a8c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2383952.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2383952.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6f5efb8b38098fd2", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "airplane", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "airplane", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["airplane", "boots", "cone", "hat", "man", "nose", "runway", "safety jacket", "shirt", "shorts", "sign", "stairs", "truck", "window", "wing"], "detected_components": ["airplane"], "masked_program_sha256": "36d62209cc2af7f534886f63c10094c653a02ff46176646118c2a383ce908610", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["airplane"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "airplane", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["airplane"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4c85f2a71cf0873a222a75c51e4dc0a60e8c9800c58203ddc457ea22e21c4d77"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12686845", "text": "What is parked by the airplane?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bike", "cart", "grass", "hand", "jeans", "man", "pole", "rope", "seat", "shirt", "toy", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "36d62209cc2af7f534886f63c10094c653a02ff46176646118c2a383ce908610", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bf5770af9c14200601bd4300b1fc8e8ea88db05e8874c0cba3c88864d60bed38"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "161043198", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13158, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 16, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1170d07c6cf846dbfabd129604b291c813e238dd99f645d49295c4cbfb7afef6", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "161043198", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is parked by the man?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked by,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is parked by the ?", "program_group_hash": "1170d07c6cf846dbfabd129604b291c813e238dd99f645d49295c4cbfb7afef6", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "parked by", "select_category": "airplane"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked by,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is parked by the ?", "program_group_hash": "1170d07c6cf846dbfabd129604b291c813e238dd99f645d49295c4cbfb7afef6", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "parked by", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "truck", "full_answer": "The truck is parked by the airplane.", "question": "What is parked by the airplane?", "question_id": "12686845", "semantic": [{"argument": "airplane (1306590)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked by,s (1306598)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bike", "full_answer": "The bike is parked by the man.", "question": "What is parked by the man?", "question_id": "161043198", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1314985)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked by,s (1314986)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1306584", "1306585", "1306586", "1306587", "1306589", "1306591", "1306592", "1306594", "1306595", "1306596", "1306597", "1306598", "1306601", "1306602", "1306603", "1306605", "1306606", "1306607", "1306608", "1306609", "1306610", "1306611"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["truck"], "predicate": "parked by", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large"], "query_target_entity_id": "1306598", "query_target_entity_name": "truck", "relation_object_entity_id": "1306590", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1306598", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1306590", "selected_entity_name": "airplane"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "airplane", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1306590"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1306584", "1306585", "1306586", "1306587", "1306589", "1306590", "1306591", "1306592", "1306594", "1306595", "1306596", "1306597", "1306598", "1306601", "1306602", "1306603", "1306605", "1306606", "1306607", "1306608", "1306609", "1306610", "1306611"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 23, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 2, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1306594", "1306608"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "airplane", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1314986", "1314987", "1314988", "1314990", "1314991", "1314992", "1314993", "1314994", "1314995", "1314996", "1314997", "1314998", "1314999"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bike"], "predicate": "parked by", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "large", "parked"], "query_target_entity_id": "1314986", "query_target_entity_name": "bike", "relation_object_entity_id": "1314985", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1314986", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1314985", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1314985"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a80a1f4d3fefadbde967544c9f3e237c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a2cad741162941f6015f25e150fea2dd97d8c893225a5c7cd6c6f208152b2a50", "image_sha256_b": "25273e8c700f800efdb78b6857fa99fb03d2bdfe957386fa316552b4ecba2a8c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8110e86db6f0ccad8031cb183847bc25219ffe635c02d68f779b6ff0671cc2d2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8b437c5136411961f1ea908061cf7572", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d648d5e6fe43e6a99d1ce81d55861e47f8d10ac246abdb90b4c21b081e5e5883"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dbabccdb7465272ef2b4989b9c08ea1ca2b63c71806fc656149da8d6456737b6", "request_id": "2f8d7b68a6b181e6c8a91236d67247b9", "response_sha256": "5f898a9d6a51e9c9be63172899b2bf7be8a2796c15fb6eed31c4c597a3d51bda", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "de3c5d7a6a813ae423440e2d691010901dfce7d2088951f255a3981ffcb41de4", "request_id": "869c4d18a832f078cfe37b747a67dd22", "response_sha256": "35347ea53be687aaa08a6bd57723276c0ede0a169eb7bb753d773e9d7703b40d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "529b3b813d0df3b5406bf9e3d970afb5", "candidate_priority_rank": 13176, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-018cc66472f1a0e8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-018cc66472f1a0e8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-018cc66472f1a0e8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-018cc66472f1a0e8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "counter<->window", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "counter", "B": "window"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "counter<->window", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2367977", "image_sha256": "7c88c57bb4b56e76640dcee1d1879676e01531aa55a4747a90dab42b023063e6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367977.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367977.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2401271", "image_sha256": "702c8e331093d9d391420d2cd60dfe167b176aec182f3b743dcd9aee7fe75ab3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401271.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401271.jpg", "width": 488}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-018cc66472f1a0e8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "counter", "diff_b": "window", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "counter", "component_b": "window"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "bowl", "counter", "dishwasher", "door", "drawer", "faucet", "kitchen", "lid", "light switch", "microwave", "onion", "outlet", "paper towel", "pitcher", "pot", "refrigerator", "roll", "sink", "soap", "soda can", "towel", "utensils", "wall"], "detected_components": ["counter"], "masked_program_sha256": "9ace63388917c2ece84008039b65c587df47481b139997a5df15d576720e32bd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["counter", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "counter", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["counter", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "abb33c60a628c734cd4ef911b9e0ae724a4d4e8e0c049ade625704f5c6c5a7c2"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12171121", "text": "What appliance is under the counter?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["chair", "dog", "eye", "floor", "frame", "head", "nose", "paw", "radiator", "tail", "tongue", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["window"], "masked_program_sha256": "9ace63388917c2ece84008039b65c587df47481b139997a5df15d576720e32bd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["window", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "window", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["window", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a39f9741a6b8bcc06f83a09a88ca213f0938eae261aa6dc78098af027617b859"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06315364", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13176, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9ebedbe31bbc7bd6c63925afe31250286527777db396dc75267f034a47048e67", "selected_component": "window", "selected_source_question_id": "06315364", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What appliance is under the window?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is under the ?", "program_group_hash": "9ebedbe31bbc7bd6c63925afe31250286527777db396dc75267f034a47048e67", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "counter"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,under,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is under the ?", "program_group_hash": "9ebedbe31bbc7bd6c63925afe31250286527777db396dc75267f034a47048e67", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "under", "select_category": "window"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dishwasher", "full_answer": "The appliance is a dishwasher.", "question": "What appliance is under the counter?", "question_id": "12171121", "semantic": [{"argument": "counter (2512768)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,under,s (2512767)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "radiator", "full_answer": "The appliance is a radiator.", "question": "What appliance is under the window?", "question_id": "06315364", "semantic": [{"argument": "window (1149428)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,under,s (1149427)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1725688", "1735032", "2512767"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dishwasher"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2512767", "query_target_entity_name": "dishwasher", "relation_object_entity_id": "2512768", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2512767", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2512768", "selected_entity_name": "counter"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "counter", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2512768"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "counter", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1149427"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["radiator"], "predicate": "under", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1149427", "query_target_entity_name": "radiator", "relation_object_entity_id": "1149428", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1149427", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1149428", "selected_entity_name": "window"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1149428"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:529b3b813d0df3b5406bf9e3d970afb5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7c88c57bb4b56e76640dcee1d1879676e01531aa55a4747a90dab42b023063e6", "image_sha256_b": "702c8e331093d9d391420d2cd60dfe167b176aec182f3b743dcd9aee7fe75ab3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c2ac4365b1030bc2df0d73009181e39fd87e6742df7bb97d17b03241bb697b8f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "75c0efa470d513e52c8248cb7ad67752", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "50894119dd986c559cc6cecfa546a5df53a4a8d1e2b50ffdbec63f9e8c509d3a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ab7292a050e0bd950c0d19262bdb523108732dc3e15e8c35c993f03b1d7ccbc0", "request_id": "6f30ce0f4c92809c03bc0fd4375bd877", "response_sha256": "f8af545ab235f9b5658f987a8bd862fe87a794b138dbca717b21dcad2526df2c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f9123cf4a0ee42a3ce6049049018fa9d9aa975d54fca8a347d335eebcf7cb380", "request_id": "6affcdf362262d0a1927cccc732213de", "response_sha256": "bddbaa5e2082040d256bd4dfcc40884f839213076bffa5c9c18ce10e62141439", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "e8e4db88e215d2307e8c928bd878aa0b", "candidate_priority_rank": 13184, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec558d68ebe02fc:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec558d68ebe02fc:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec558d68ebe02fc:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec558d68ebe02fc:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "horse<->tag", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "horse", "B": "tag"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "horse<->tag", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2404710", "image_sha256": "283df1c36ce09bfcf28f1bb9f44c498fe4734c69b726eb2f6ac4838d3f21adec", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404710.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404710.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2385083", "image_sha256": "0e3f486f239a05cab439e985f3ef88786bf89df33a8f216ab0e313149630c9a3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2385083.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2385083.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec558d68ebe02fc", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "horse", "diff_b": "tag", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "horse", "component_b": "tag"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "curtain", "curtains", "figure", "horse", "lamp", "letter", "light bulb", "mane", "roof", "sign", "wire"], "detected_components": ["horse"], "masked_program_sha256": "96fb3d1275b342ca439d2e6ea96e8ecea66c96a897f7c763c53f9099105405fc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["horse"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "horse", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["horse"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d7b704c5c9b0a2c2468dc98f1b044ae9eaee48fb9e2ef4bb1a04330ea7766ede"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12682023", "text": "What's the horse attached to?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "ear", "eye", "face", "floor", "fur", "head", "mouth", "nose", "suitcase", "tag", "tail"], "detected_components": ["tag"], "masked_program_sha256": "96fb3d1275b342ca439d2e6ea96e8ecea66c96a897f7c763c53f9099105405fc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["tag"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "tag", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["tag"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d0a5729acbc0375225da00ed04fc428a0d92f525ca2919cb9ec83fb1ed2d5839"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07399569", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13184, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8c0b3c60608d8c422f5bcf17fadd2f39c4f75912f779780e8f69a70217dd211c", "selected_component": "tag", "selected_source_question_id": "07399569", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's the tag attached to?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,attached to,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the attached to?", "program_group_hash": "8c0b3c60608d8c422f5bcf17fadd2f39c4f75912f779780e8f69a70217dd211c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "attached to", "select_category": "horse"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,attached to,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the attached to?", "program_group_hash": "8c0b3c60608d8c422f5bcf17fadd2f39c4f75912f779780e8f69a70217dd211c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "attached to", "select_category": "tag"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sign", "full_answer": "The horse is attached to the sign.", "question": "What's the horse attached to?", "question_id": "12682023", "semantic": [{"argument": "horse (339037)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,attached to,o (339009)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "suitcase", "full_answer": "The tag is attached to the suitcase.", "question": "What's the tag attached to?", "question_id": "07399569", "semantic": [{"argument": "tag (1301276)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,attached to,o (1301272)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["339009", "339013", "339019", "339031", "339034", "339038", "339039", "339041", "339043", "339045", "339047"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sign"], "predicate": "attached to", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "decorative", "hanging"], "query_target_entity_id": "339009", "query_target_entity_name": "sign", "relation_object_entity_id": "339009", "relation_subject_entity_id": "339037", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "339037", "selected_entity_name": "horse"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "horse", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["339037"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tag", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "horse", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1301264", "1301265", "1301266", "1301267", "1301268", "1301269", "1301270", "1301271", "1301272", "1301273", "1301274", "1301275", "1301286"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["suitcase"], "predicate": "attached to", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue", "open"], "query_target_entity_id": "1301272", "query_target_entity_name": "suitcase", "relation_object_entity_id": "1301272", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1301276", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1301276", "selected_entity_name": "tag"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "tag", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1301276"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e8e4db88e215d2307e8c928bd878aa0b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "283df1c36ce09bfcf28f1bb9f44c498fe4734c69b726eb2f6ac4838d3f21adec", "image_sha256_b": "0e3f486f239a05cab439e985f3ef88786bf89df33a8f216ab0e313149630c9a3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d72de97eda174df5c13af87d38b32b1719c6f9dfe603e11e167e785daca43453", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f59e7c1ac82ec13eef64def905118611", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "10766fb2e0acf76a264978962bb5651247a1a607009c51ef977f545c4632af6f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7502b643a4f5194f9ac947160d1414a26eb490711d6becd2881599fb9f52aded", "request_id": "2b98ccd1ff2a95b2df2ddaaf9a4d5b92", "response_sha256": "bf89b0d6407ca3a949d2d0b7610ee1697998ed4b673f39690ba7b79a66a7ea34", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1187ab20b76948e95cbc0b4d14d4b611b8f375b04bed558fcdcddc26a114b1ef", "request_id": "bd6fb9f8f4e887aada372575b00b6d10", "response_sha256": "a936fbc7015f91eff204165c60334993141fead92403a40544a33e1f175eb109", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "3b7bd1ca2c0be5e9b012fb1e6b5c2b34", "candidate_priority_rank": 13193, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-199578df3ef6c4ad:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-199578df3ef6c4ad:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-199578df3ef6c4ad:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-199578df3ef6c4ad:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "mirror<->window", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "window", "B": "mirror"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "window<->mirror", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2398951", "image_sha256": "b9e5088f0d221060c7da59fe9673d2daaa4a81a4ffd1152b1e9045b267f4a339", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398951.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398951.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2381760", "image_sha256": "9a40ab658908c285ba2855d766f78e0810bfc55303163bc3400a14cf3d52074e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2381760.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2381760.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-199578df3ef6c4ad", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "window", "diff_b": "mirror", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "window", "component_b": "mirror"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "cat", "curtain", "ear", "eyes", "frame", "grass", "head", "sun", "window"], "detected_components": ["window"], "masked_program_sha256": "e0ad73a419d88b212057e4fa6f80003c21341d84506040faacc3b81238af62ec", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["window", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "window", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["window", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d42a48dab2a29842360a263ff1512b1aef493469a09dc81da7e57ed182c010e5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12642884", "text": "What animal is looking in the window?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "box", "carpet", "collar", "dog", "eye", "frame", "mirror", "room", "wall", "wire"], "detected_components": ["mirror"], "masked_program_sha256": "e0ad73a419d88b212057e4fa6f80003c21341d84506040faacc3b81238af62ec", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mirror", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b08c0632e6ff660b270c88ab3e33aff80b7c9776260568a03406c219199dc4bd"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05520076", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13193, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8fa29f338775e4633d2b42ece19ddbbcc62cd789d7f5ba6c15458ad19b354a9b", "selected_component": "mirror", "selected_source_question_id": "05520076", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is looking in the mirror?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,looking in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is looking in the ?", "program_group_hash": "8fa29f338775e4633d2b42ece19ddbbcc62cd789d7f5ba6c15458ad19b354a9b", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "looking in", "select_category": "window"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,looking in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is looking in the ?", "program_group_hash": "8fa29f338775e4633d2b42ece19ddbbcc62cd789d7f5ba6c15458ad19b354a9b", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "looking in", "select_category": "mirror"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What animal is looking in the window?", "question_id": "12642884", "semantic": [{"argument": "window (1173853)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,looking in,s (1173852)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The animal is a dog.", "question": "What animal is looking in the mirror?", "question_id": "05520076", "semantic": [{"argument": "mirror (1334197)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,looking in,s (1334196)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1173852", "1173854"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "looking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "striped"], "query_target_entity_id": "1173852", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1173853", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1173852", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1173853", "selected_entity_name": "window"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1173853"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1334196"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "looking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1334196", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "1334197", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1334196", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1334197", "selected_entity_name": "mirror"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1334197"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:3b7bd1ca2c0be5e9b012fb1e6b5c2b34", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b9e5088f0d221060c7da59fe9673d2daaa4a81a4ffd1152b1e9045b267f4a339", "image_sha256_b": "9a40ab658908c285ba2855d766f78e0810bfc55303163bc3400a14cf3d52074e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a6260f99641f4c159730323b33521e01e63639c3c9b921b8237d1e24305c0087", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f5c4395f73cf94656388d5ae8444b881", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3f2d5b4f0d8dc6f57c3e7174b4931c2545370d8749ffc9b015ab6d88227889d0"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a23c15e9c549bda0aed33d97d97f04a911ad54149331894441db74fa1e4ca976", "request_id": "04a38311f6359fa8e0cd20a10d726616", "response_sha256": "b2f0529440c107f452f19e83bef4963de6946cd8be803e35d50ef6c4209d1b6d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8f4d0b758d1db843a69f88ec5293694baa257a02e31a802e262c27bb4d13492f", "request_id": "18d8c2d60121112566647f93f611425c", "response_sha256": "f5fccaa39eef2e094c8a6f6dc76f7c2ab24ced1fa5c7d98e9e6f9f265a1e6b88", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "1e8ab6215ee9abebd34a8df19ae9b4c6", "candidate_priority_rank": 13224, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3a76134eec9cf15c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3a76134eec9cf15c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3a76134eec9cf15c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3a76134eec9cf15c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "mirror<->picture", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "mirror", "B": "picture"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "mirror<->picture", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2405882", "image_sha256": "f74d57179fed650b203628b3cd9bd3782ba4ef73f4f61672ea79dcccf6cd9908", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405882.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405882.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2388691", "image_sha256": "4ae9944d8fa743e6b8f179c9dfd05215e0fef67ae12ead790e12643191e047f6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388691.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388691.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3a76134eec9cf15c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "mirror", "diff_b": "picture", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "mirror", "component_b": "picture"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bedroom", "carpet", "door", "drawers", "dresser", "floor", "frame", "mirror", "stick", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["mirror"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mirror", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b2dd1947e2cf019e85b238cd49195f34aebff4848ee3e6d22dd8118a43a7c501"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04875267", "text": "What type of furniture is below the mirror?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bedspread", "bench", "canoe", "ceiling", "curtains", "fish", "floor", "headboard", "lamp", "nightstand", "picture", "pillows", "post", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["picture"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["picture", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "picture", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["picture", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "68e3a331682e3f165409b7a46774e2f96f51113dedcff68c930f0052def00e44"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1980064", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13224, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "196faa3d35f78151deb18d36fad9d14e955cc7106642438311f718c3654e383b", "selected_component": "picture", "selected_source_question_id": "1980064", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of furniture is below the picture?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "196faa3d35f78151deb18d36fad9d14e955cc7106642438311f718c3654e383b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "mirror"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "196faa3d35f78151deb18d36fad9d14e955cc7106642438311f718c3654e383b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "picture"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dresser", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a dresser.", "question": "What type of furniture is below the mirror?", "question_id": "04875267", "semantic": [{"argument": "mirror (1105571)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (1105569)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What type of furniture is below the picture?", "question_id": "1980064", "semantic": [{"argument": "picture (671489)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (671486)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1105568", "1105569", "1105577"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dresser"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1105569", "query_target_entity_name": "dresser", "relation_object_entity_id": "1105571", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1105569", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1105571", "selected_entity_name": "mirror"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1105571"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "picture", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["671486", "671500"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["dark", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "671486", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "671489", "relation_subject_entity_id": "671486", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "671489", "selected_entity_name": "picture"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "picture", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["671489"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1e8ab6215ee9abebd34a8df19ae9b4c6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f74d57179fed650b203628b3cd9bd3782ba4ef73f4f61672ea79dcccf6cd9908", "image_sha256_b": "4ae9944d8fa743e6b8f179c9dfd05215e0fef67ae12ead790e12643191e047f6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ba69460faa671fa37c4149c0aadcf05f2d284a628dc520c8a9de3ead7168c7b8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "452e8cd4dd67179039fffbef3ef7456e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e9e25e71d8851a5cf289a93b4a0d952f250afb921d74ab5000ec74b9646a31f4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "66be0d5ca4cc7722e029da6472562543e9d8804e1f800d0b59e2ba8313a0310a", "request_id": "9f980a286eaf70ae3964cdd3d9c24c66", "response_sha256": "cfc01f749d1fb03539991208a7e3346e1a90d1b1c9dfac03245d965c6f2764a8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "047ee46d3dd78e425abd2b3a83ca20e8aa16162049a80bef96c87a696eae08c4", "request_id": "ff257454a895a231addc30fe5eec107f", "response_sha256": "c4063225943e4ff1b5cd36302836848360992aa54274fa1999bf63002eaa3001", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "1888875a54a0cb1cbd8ff707e602f57e", "candidate_priority_rank": 13229, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21e75a3a2c09c271:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21e75a3a2c09c271:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21e75a3a2c09c271:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21e75a3a2c09c271:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "woman"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->woman", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2336016", "image_sha256": "a646e088f4df1d5b2f271f32f7f8650999c6b1909e7f302685f8d83e659cc66d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2336016.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2336016.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2338163", "image_sha256": "a72b5e593d27b72b36228b289f07dc84608a962f63d5b856b2221c717cf358a1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2338163.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2338163.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-21e75a3a2c09c271", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "woman", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "woman"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["belt", "car", "cell phone", "collar", "door", "ear", "face", "hair", "hand", "head", "laptop", "man", "mouth", "nose", "paper", "pocket", "shirt", "street", "symbol", "tag", "truck", "wheel", "window"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "5915d11a3c20582369ea067a8c1d57859b52e18879bfa5ec9d7e69b0f9d437d0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "562f9c5d754eb4b441d7800b915aceb562144df85e0f82abdefcab121ceac0bf"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05696187", "text": "What is that man using?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["american flag", "boots", "cake", "camera", "coat", "flower", "hair", "man", "pants", "people", "scissors", "shirt", "soldier", "table", "tie", "uniform", "wall", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "5915d11a3c20582369ea067a8c1d57859b52e18879bfa5ec9d7e69b0f9d437d0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "035f434328fe7d9267b894674bd7105758bb13044dea091f95649400b950ea43"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07509399", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13229, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "da7f79da693b0e2a6f42428e271503c498e1a2ea6ec62fc1a1bd6bf5db3bfc3c", "selected_component": "woman", "selected_source_question_id": "07509399", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is that woman using?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,using,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is that using?", "program_group_hash": "da7f79da693b0e2a6f42428e271503c498e1a2ea6ec62fc1a1bd6bf5db3bfc3c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "using", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,using,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is that using?", "program_group_hash": "da7f79da693b0e2a6f42428e271503c498e1a2ea6ec62fc1a1bd6bf5db3bfc3c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "using", "select_category": "woman"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "laptop", "full_answer": "The man is using a laptop.", "question": "What is that man using?", "question_id": "05696187", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (4607451)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,using,o (4607528)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "camera", "full_answer": "The woman is using a camera.", "question": "What is that woman using?", "question_id": "07509399", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (955102)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,using,o (955106)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4534313", "4607462", "4607463", "4607464", "4607465", "4607466", "4607472", "4607478", "4607484", "4607486", "4607494", "4607497", "4607507", "4607508", "4607510", "4607514", "4607523", "4607528", "4607539", "4607541", "4607543", "4618891", "4618895", "4618899", "4618904", "4618944", "4618946"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 27, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["laptop"], "predicate": "using", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "4607528", "query_target_entity_name": "laptop", "relation_object_entity_id": "4607528", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4607451", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4607451", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4607451"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["955099", "955100", "955101", "955102", "955103", "955104", "955105", "955106", "955108", "955109", "955111", "955112", "955113", "955115", "955116", "955117", "955118", "955119", "955121", "955122"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 2, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["955108", "955116"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["955099", "955100", "955101", "955103", "955104", "955105", "955106", "955108", "955109", "955111", "955112", "955113", "955115", "955116", "955117", "955118", "955119", "955121", "955122"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 19, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["camera"], "predicate": "using", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "955106", "query_target_entity_name": "camera", "relation_object_entity_id": "955106", "relation_subject_entity_id": "955102", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "955102", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["955102"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1888875a54a0cb1cbd8ff707e602f57e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a646e088f4df1d5b2f271f32f7f8650999c6b1909e7f302685f8d83e659cc66d", "image_sha256_b": "a72b5e593d27b72b36228b289f07dc84608a962f63d5b856b2221c717cf358a1", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "27a0169fe8b03d0d11cf5c05d61744549c43f2dcd701f894523b542cc6e058c7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "eb96819955a58bf06b979f383676a88c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9cf3ff97dff98c467f2a8ce14bf3262f0f90308aa4c30d9c2ac534203662c40e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bb348b685ef17976cf5976aa163c108fb1f5428f3834531cc32e238af596ed90", "request_id": "2741f8e6049ebee271cdd4aca993f628", "response_sha256": "2eecc62b0538e636c195752992b23901ac78e21d1902deb921e27ec1108e3521", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1d406a92180a55334353cf207461a6979d1d8353f47fec7f1dfb8016515b7c91", "request_id": "578c1ed736164c8b0b3558057757a5d4", "response_sha256": "691519b0afabc927cb6bf095faf2093ed0088b143ec0aa42d8b27be3f17b316a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "15351c6cb2fdedc85eb9f8575e604e64", "candidate_priority_rank": 13233, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19aae565771eb863:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19aae565771eb863:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19aae565771eb863:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19aae565771eb863:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "silverware<->straw", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "silverware", "B": "straw"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "silverware<->straw", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2383947", "image_sha256": "68a330d07249a251121085f70aef6579c5438eb03c0b27186d3a1323687ca9c3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2383947.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2383947.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2409339", "image_sha256": "0813de7cbe4118dafc4dac58a541cb8fbdb55587e4faea7efbb721f36d1cf5b4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2409339.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2409339.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19aae565771eb863", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "silverware", "diff_b": "straw", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "silverware", "component_b": "straw"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "broccoli", "carrot", "carrots", "cup", "mushroom", "silverware", "soup", "vegetables"], "detected_components": ["silverware"], "masked_program_sha256": "39bad7562ea265ba25e65edc21b09180f6eae0ddd70406e3413d70778f0259d5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["silverware", "food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "silverware", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["silverware", "food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ba856fdc12f16844fea5cf90863182f844a8e832cf3361abe6ab0db6b80a3379"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19351321", "text": "What kind of food is the silverware in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "cake", "dessert", "drink", "frosting", "glass", "ice", "ice cream", "icing", "plate", "plates", "restaurant", "sauce", "saucer", "spoon", "straw", "table"], "detected_components": ["straw"], "masked_program_sha256": "39bad7562ea265ba25e65edc21b09180f6eae0ddd70406e3413d70778f0259d5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["straw", "food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "straw", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["straw", "food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5eea31040395d3883b8891be56056ff75b133fea7724a3cb966380e63176b450"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1071355", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13233, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 15, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f0f6dfe3ca370bbb89adbeb8e8979b7bd6421ea70d1f02211e78516198dcb62e", "selected_component": "straw", "selected_source_question_id": "1071355", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of food is the straw in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of food is the in?", "program_group_hash": "f0f6dfe3ca370bbb89adbeb8e8979b7bd6421ea70d1f02211e78516198dcb62e", "queried_category": "food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "silverware"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of food is the in?", "program_group_hash": "f0f6dfe3ca370bbb89adbeb8e8979b7bd6421ea70d1f02211e78516198dcb62e", "queried_category": "food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "straw"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "soup", "full_answer": "The silverware is in the soup.", "question": "What kind of food is the silverware in?", "question_id": "19351321", "semantic": [{"argument": "silverware (1315049)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,in,o (1315055)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dessert", "full_answer": "The straw is in the dessert.", "question": "What kind of food is the straw in?", "question_id": "1071355", "semantic": [{"argument": "straw (243954)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "food,in,o (243963)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1315051", "1315055"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["soup"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["mixed"], "query_target_entity_id": "1315055", "query_target_entity_name": "soup", "relation_object_entity_id": "1315055", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1315049", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1315049", "selected_entity_name": "silverware"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "silverware", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1315049"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "straw", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "silverware", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["243956", "243963"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dessert"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["frozen", "pink"], "query_target_entity_id": "243963", "query_target_entity_name": "dessert", "relation_object_entity_id": "243963", "relation_subject_entity_id": "243954", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "243954", "selected_entity_name": "straw"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "straw", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["243954"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:15351c6cb2fdedc85eb9f8575e604e64", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "68a330d07249a251121085f70aef6579c5438eb03c0b27186d3a1323687ca9c3", "image_sha256_b": "0813de7cbe4118dafc4dac58a541cb8fbdb55587e4faea7efbb721f36d1cf5b4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "78ad16843f1a756a764126404b92cc771a7b5d409ee489b93369e58b71514219", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "152fb64bcfa7ab14a876ef1e6c3532cf", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5079e405ac2aee12f3219e90910ab6b6cdebf620aab0f2f41c078e572a4e9fb4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "eabb9a64c48fb494368f78050d7867c6d0b332ba8768d1f59cc88e721c430363", "request_id": "5d796b73c03ab69850b1071fcb8f27e1", "response_sha256": "d970a0a12b2c1dde3e88b557b53dd34f1ff5111413bf30a3df8eca12225979e7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e243cc6309764462ef1541b0b673193a9b5ca412b8ee4b2c359a0bd1dfb09ee4", "request_id": "5a9d3346c5bd33fd922ca84e5e282ee8", "response_sha256": "cb01df22cf327c26edc917b21dd06cf92a3e15a64a1b8f4da696ddf575c97139", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "50c0f39daf47ac9cbf3757af32279c36", "candidate_priority_rank": 13241, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-770382f82d26a2cf:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-770382f82d26a2cf:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-770382f82d26a2cf:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-770382f82d26a2cf:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "microwave<->mirror", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "mirror", "B": "microwave"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "mirror<->microwave", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2335120", "image_sha256": "b43749424b5cde424c1f44faecc9c21d8648bab162411721fbbc0ec6ab494858", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2335120.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2335120.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2407453", "image_sha256": "d224d03242e1c36b38c10118d31fb16460db015b770cfc78a77db6561badf88a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407453.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407453.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-770382f82d26a2cf", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "mirror", "diff_b": "microwave", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "mirror", "component_b": "microwave"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.34684684684684686, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.13513513513513514, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 2}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.442, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.14, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bathroom", "counter", "floor", "hand soap", "mirror", "roll", "seat", "shampoo", "shelf", "shelves", "shower door", "sink", "tiles", "toilet", "toilet tank", "towel", "trash can", "wall", "waste basket"], "detected_components": ["mirror"], "masked_program_sha256": "7b40ec84b72ced553396181f591bf24f452766711ddeae362e14f9dd4e2e816a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mirror", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c92adf95d34ed397f042b1775a39b510c72a1be6933eb8dc010877fb5f430764"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01979048", "text": "What are the items of furniture to the left of the mirror called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["book", "bottle", "bottles", "cabinets", "candy", "counter", "dishwasher", "door", "glasses", "jar", "kitchen", "microwave", "placemat", "sink", "stove", "towels", "wall", "window", "wine"], "detected_components": ["microwave"], "masked_program_sha256": "7b40ec84b72ced553396181f591bf24f452766711ddeae362e14f9dd4e2e816a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["microwave", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "microwave", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["microwave", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ae2897cd1289bdae55456bb25af28eb80e919601ce0e952a9ab99dcb539d6b72"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10434184", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13241, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b603709da46d1eefa1c05c262a322a0a30ac8454934084fe5add25681437ad1c", "selected_component": "microwave", "selected_source_question_id": "10434184", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the items of furniture to the left of the microwave called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the items of furniture to the left of the called?", "program_group_hash": "b603709da46d1eefa1c05c262a322a0a30ac8454934084fe5add25681437ad1c", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "mirror"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the items of furniture to the left of the called?", "program_group_hash": "b603709da46d1eefa1c05c262a322a0a30ac8454934084fe5add25681437ad1c", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "microwave"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "shelves", "full_answer": "The pieces of furniture are shelves.", "question": "What are the items of furniture to the left of the mirror called?", "question_id": "01979048", "semantic": [{"argument": "mirror (2639198)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,to the left of,s (2344550)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cabinets", "full_answer": "The pieces of furniture are cabinets.", "question": "What are the items of furniture to the left of the microwave called?", "question_id": "10434184", "semantic": [{"argument": "microwave (279162)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,to the left of,s (279181)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2265960", "2344550"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["shelves"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["metal"], "query_target_entity_id": "2344550", "query_target_entity_name": "shelves", "relation_object_entity_id": "2639198", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2344550", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2639198", "selected_entity_name": "mirror"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2639198"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "microwave", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["279181"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cabinets"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "279181", "query_target_entity_name": "cabinets", "relation_object_entity_id": "279162", "relation_subject_entity_id": "279181", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "279162", "selected_entity_name": "microwave"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "microwave", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["279162"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:50c0f39daf47ac9cbf3757af32279c36", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b43749424b5cde424c1f44faecc9c21d8648bab162411721fbbc0ec6ab494858", "image_sha256_b": "d224d03242e1c36b38c10118d31fb16460db015b770cfc78a77db6561badf88a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f03ba6954f47428223a0fb111ba5e9657e7284e4b0391c5ba933953be16bd101", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5716c210487fb04b5d9c482176ef6552", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "63d0b3fa9e0979106a5f221bfd018ebb69633f98ba7fe96fdd7dda36f6d6cad8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5424ab3cd74beaa76d6314634d255a7ec41bee394862f07485341e19c44a94be", "request_id": "d559f335e1d29895545a7de51b6ef864", "response_sha256": "2689d1375fdc04ef134d69df5f0f7c2a2ae8bce6b3e9f7fc1e51408a76b53ecb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3a240f116764da03cdc13c0edf568c16bbf1baef6bfa899702e4fdfabd3d7d40", "request_id": "5b80f67276ed4294fd954c40cebccdbc", "response_sha256": "e775175bb5b19b822483d3123772794ca99c8a0bca629da08b83b07628f8352b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "11b6b125eb823425e9e749b643e7a25c", "candidate_priority_rank": 13242, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-602c684cba32fa67:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-602c684cba32fa67:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-602c684cba32fa67:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-602c684cba32fa67:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "grass<->vine", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "grass", "B": "vine"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "grass<->vine", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2393724", "image_sha256": "e016e862a4902ffb1d2e234f3774703ee44b858fa5affcd49355f031c1bf1a6b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2393724.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2393724.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2354203", "image_sha256": "18aca239eab2ddbc08e45731189728387711cb028e9b5f8e902ce10fe6f671a0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2354203.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2354203.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-602c684cba32fa67", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "grass", "diff_b": "vine", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "grass", "component_b": "vine"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["airplane", "beach", "bird", "buildings", "bush", "grass", "helmet", "island", "people", "person", "rock", "rocks", "sand", "sky", "statue", "surfboard", "wetsuit"], "detected_components": ["grass"], "masked_program_sha256": "6bc3bb179009e9e9db56682be3791aa6dcc901d6bdf9295cac83689a43e01e21", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "grass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "54bba9d42752507fbc1af8089dac2d3bea4d3ea1ca8563a34b34c19101a02541"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16969465", "text": "What's the grass growing on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["branch", "ground", "head", "leaves", "log", "mane", "plant", "rock", "rocks", "stick", "tail", "vine", "wall", "zebra"], "detected_components": ["vine"], "masked_program_sha256": "6bc3bb179009e9e9db56682be3791aa6dcc901d6bdf9295cac83689a43e01e21", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["vine"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "vine", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["vine"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e4d73a3cc67f5219c076526eecda3377359a4520db76ee8b51b5678415eee04a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01960897", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13242, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c859328e2b6057e9e1d99002b9703aaa4712bd6576ae4d601324060f934dba76", "selected_component": "vine", "selected_source_question_id": "01960897", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's the vine growing on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the growing on?", "program_group_hash": "c859328e2b6057e9e1d99002b9703aaa4712bd6576ae4d601324060f934dba76", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "growing on", "select_category": "grass"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the growing on?", "program_group_hash": "c859328e2b6057e9e1d99002b9703aaa4712bd6576ae4d601324060f934dba76", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "growing on", "select_category": "vine"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sand", "full_answer": "The grass is growing on the sand.", "question": "What's the grass growing on?", "question_id": "16969465", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (470166)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing on,o (470167)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "wall", "full_answer": "The vine is growing on the wall.", "question": "What's the vine growing on?", "question_id": "01960897", "semantic": [{"argument": "vine (1665257)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing on,o (1665258)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["470151", "470152", "470153", "470155", "470156", "470157", "470158", "470160", "470161", "470162", "470163", "470164", "470165", "470167", "470168", "470169", "470170"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sand"], "predicate": "growing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "470167", "query_target_entity_name": "sand", "relation_object_entity_id": "470167", "relation_subject_entity_id": "470166", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "470166", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["470166"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "vine", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1665258", "1894695", "1954357", "1962483", "1983445", "1990772", "2001195", "2001871", "2098178", "2183525", "2183526", "2412627", "2435407", "2506214", "3778036", "3778038", "3778041"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wall"], "predicate": "growing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1665258", "query_target_entity_name": "wall", "relation_object_entity_id": "1665258", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1665257", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1665257", "selected_entity_name": "vine"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "vine", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1665257"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:11b6b125eb823425e9e749b643e7a25c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e016e862a4902ffb1d2e234f3774703ee44b858fa5affcd49355f031c1bf1a6b", "image_sha256_b": "18aca239eab2ddbc08e45731189728387711cb028e9b5f8e902ce10fe6f671a0", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ae19c7fbb18cced6e4d3f55f54ad73d1c2b4a68b85cfbd7b01d04d79ee2efb94", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e3f441a0ada73a23a79114b8a9c05767", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "147443cfdda7d4ea75acd699f2c94e4cc6c3e0863d3dce4c04af8ddc416d6e39"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dfd789e21f4d8ac6225fd56a05683263e3c4f4396c531f4387d7a60e68f76af4", "request_id": "0cd839e248cc1147322aa2800aff0fba", "response_sha256": "7a5ac924facfb0c0ac45d66fd725552bea0c6e8f1987988a910c99968f958c9b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9a5e45b9ef4f59285d2a26e98a9040021ff973310a425648fe58f216e8ed6fd0", "request_id": "22afe7ae1c8360596839611ca2e71804", "response_sha256": "5f7420b23fc2a28ee0b48bde6a2bb4b8ba7dfbe17e24c7b3beba84fb6740b830", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "333df8973553ba7dd3a8098e9944fec6", "candidate_priority_rank": 13332, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34e1f5889ec17ce2:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34e1f5889ec17ce2:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34e1f5889ec17ce2:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34e1f5889ec17ce2:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "beach<->carpet", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "beach", "B": "carpet"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "beach<->carpet", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2383374", "image_sha256": "5c04d1168c983717765cc5ae65264983c5d8173fde625918d13dd975591df22b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2383374.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2383374.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2345068", "image_sha256": "930d1fde05980e0eed4562643861fa92f7205edb32bbe129bfdcd43d13114eef", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345068.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345068.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34e1f5889ec17ce2", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "beach", "diff_b": "carpet", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "beach", "component_b": "carpet"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "beach", "boy", "bucket", "chair", "child", "eyes", "father", "hair", "ocean", "pole", "sand", "skin", "sky", "towel", "truck", "umbrella", "watch", "water", "woman"], "detected_components": ["beach"], "masked_program_sha256": "ed5e2a55be562502761936bc904fba808f0addaea36c345f6f0d9eb111aa247e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["beach", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "beach", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["beach", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7e3b8248bdc78f3b270f09b4fb504dd253505e3b2e408af6187cc337ab037cf1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19634521", "text": "What is the piece of furniture that is on the beach?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "carpet", "collar", "dog", "ear", "floor", "ground", "head", "label", "nose", "pillow", "tag", "tail"], "detected_components": ["carpet"], "masked_program_sha256": "ed5e2a55be562502761936bc904fba808f0addaea36c345f6f0d9eb111aa247e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["carpet", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "carpet", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["carpet", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bd2795206dd114c933abf1fdcfb2c0e40ebffaf8bef2db47d53bd4e5dae051e5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07174966", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13332, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e64977017bcdf54488af54e295c9a3cbff53f05b414503c36d208fa1daf8e404", "selected_component": "carpet", "selected_source_question_id": "07174966", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the piece of furniture that is on the carpet?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "e64977017bcdf54488af54e295c9a3cbff53f05b414503c36d208fa1daf8e404", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "beach"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "e64977017bcdf54488af54e295c9a3cbff53f05b414503c36d208fa1daf8e404", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "carpet"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a chair.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that is on the beach?", "question_id": "19634521", "semantic": [{"argument": "beach (533102)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s (533095)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that is on the carpet?", "question_id": "07174966", "semantic": [{"argument": "carpet (2722466)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s (2888025)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["533095"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "533095", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "533102", "relation_subject_entity_id": "533095", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "533102", "selected_entity_name": "beach"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "beach", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["533102"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "carpet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "beach", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2888025"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["plaid"], "query_target_entity_id": "2888025", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "2722466", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2888025", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2722466", "selected_entity_name": "carpet"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "carpet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2722466"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:333df8973553ba7dd3a8098e9944fec6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5c04d1168c983717765cc5ae65264983c5d8173fde625918d13dd975591df22b", "image_sha256_b": "930d1fde05980e0eed4562643861fa92f7205edb32bbe129bfdcd43d13114eef", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "21c538f2ef69100093ff973bb72cdb703b5a3af1d610281896bca608ae213a2c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3dfd72685a37b12cb41a8c45efdde596", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b5915761a48c82379cdda071a4e91b1a0112ad2984110fb50041fd973ddf0138"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "50b092a53dee4d5c381220a54dc01780eddc5a36541741ac8779636f2027c147", "request_id": "3191f7042daaccf893287e5c10857a95", "response_sha256": "934cd3861c61c0285a875812720643a5c5ab9073180fbaea5f90bf6f0acf0b83", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "752aee51bbf477bf1e5462325eb3a1e98934f8010c52cdfcc74c7a831c3107cf", "request_id": "f8014c31640398a0ba9ca67d29c57f87", "response_sha256": "93a2ccbd25ca515e0b355149b9ea3f2873cf2db36e1d49eaa24637ce037b001e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "4539a3a1f20f1598b28d4f3d040ea9a7", "candidate_priority_rank": 13355, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3988b04e2efb6bd9:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3988b04e2efb6bd9:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3988b04e2efb6bd9:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3988b04e2efb6bd9:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "fence<->wall", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "wall", "B": "fence"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wall<->fence", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2376984", "image_sha256": "1f0d0736c838dd0cd0f6b9249487addee650dfaf396e85f1ac6740c2a9d48846", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376984.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376984.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2384244", "image_sha256": "94700b9628aa424c772bda41e846096c1c36511fd21b7f8fd11dea2d1207a3ec", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384244.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384244.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3988b04e2efb6bd9", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wall", "diff_b": "fence", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wall", "component_b": "fence"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "ear", "eye", "face", "foot", "ground", "head", "moss", "nose", "stick", "stuffed bear", "wall"], "detected_components": ["wall"], "masked_program_sha256": "6d90bc8ee671bf012b3a1704d63b5f493137d4566fbd95de5ea326d78a689547", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wall", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7f8f12664e6de43db8cb52566da26bbc5bc771b6f2875301e67661bd90462c6e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "021003467", "text": "What kind of toy is on the wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["animals", "boot", "building", "clouds", "cow", "cows", "cross", "fence", "field", "grass", "ground", "people", "pillars", "roof", "sky", "stuffed dog", "tower", "tree", "window", "wire"], "detected_components": ["fence"], "masked_program_sha256": "6d90bc8ee671bf012b3a1704d63b5f493137d4566fbd95de5ea326d78a689547", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "fence", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "44613a28eddd44015d25e305b7fbff5a197bfeee59333448898353ffd69b775c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03750499", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13355, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 12, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "f61966cd3c5716c0dc3a6eb0f2bc0fc0dddeabace34310118db1c415f44e3bc1", "selected_component": "fence", "selected_source_question_id": "03750499", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of toy is on the fence?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of toy is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "f61966cd3c5716c0dc3a6eb0f2bc0fc0dddeabace34310118db1c415f44e3bc1", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of toy is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "f61966cd3c5716c0dc3a6eb0f2bc0fc0dddeabace34310118db1c415f44e3bc1", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "fence"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "stuffed bear", "full_answer": "The toy is a stuffed bear.", "question": "What kind of toy is on the wall?", "question_id": "021003467", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (568599)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,on,s (568595)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stuffed dog", "full_answer": "The toy is a stuffed dog.", "question": "What kind of toy is on the fence?", "question_id": "03750499", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (692248)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,on,s (692247)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["568595"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stuffed bear"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["fuzzy", "gray", "grey", "sitting"], "query_target_entity_id": "568595", "query_target_entity_name": "stuffed bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "568599", "relation_subject_entity_id": "568595", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "568599", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["568599"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["692247"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stuffed dog"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["small"], "query_target_entity_id": "692247", "query_target_entity_name": "stuffed dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "692248", "relation_subject_entity_id": "692247", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "692248", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["692248"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4539a3a1f20f1598b28d4f3d040ea9a7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1f0d0736c838dd0cd0f6b9249487addee650dfaf396e85f1ac6740c2a9d48846", "image_sha256_b": "94700b9628aa424c772bda41e846096c1c36511fd21b7f8fd11dea2d1207a3ec", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e1e3fbade66364ae35e48018b7178183e746b884d31cf7188b66f85656991b32", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9060e060f79d630629a3d1bd6398dbbc", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "df2e18da5e3126485993a713a05e0d676b49376037d5448023e22b3474e23abc"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "01f11b870bc07e65862c4f2e6c14652d865f28470b33c2ba07e2ddb2d9a9f2c4", "request_id": "d338969d5788a8e7926fa9aa6d92f85b", "response_sha256": "b7af680134692984fc5b7406c9c8a984ab7afa6f0864577d0c80d3643472bab8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9fc5b1af93398decc8973bee5893468571407891a5c2639947ec27762937ebaa", "request_id": "66c65d1b8485a03b0b36cedc90d2f19e", "response_sha256": "101e193619b797ab2fad50aa2264db849943ffe271b82c62101468187bb8a2d1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "25f89923824bbe5f05dcb629bab9f576", "candidate_priority_rank": 13363, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e4185f02a395e421:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e4185f02a395e421:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e4185f02a395e421:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e4185f02a395e421:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blanket<->oven", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "oven", "B": "blanket"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "oven<->blanket", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2322761", "image_sha256": "8a580693106f20b7f52b6e2aa0a41ae5fcdbfac1fecf8577ae046ee03aebbc8e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2322761.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2322761.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2409514", "image_sha256": "8619fb20e7c8f9b1be44502b51444fd02d8c25349f07c9b97c9f955dfa642700", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2409514.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2409514.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e4185f02a395e421", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "oven", "diff_b": "blanket", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "oven", "component_b": "blanket"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.442, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.124, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.376, "direction": "left", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.138, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "coffee maker", "dish", "jar", "light switch", "oven", "shirt", "woman"], "detected_components": ["oven"], "masked_program_sha256": "81decf8b99167c854cb8fc9fb5aa72dd77ce7c5e258d8aafb2edaab9dbc2285e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["oven", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "oven", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["oven", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "53807af8b913eb13dda98b5aea6917b5dd7f5c34f5f00f69419d2ddbce18011e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12786630", "text": "What appliance is left of the oven?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "book", "books", "ceiling", "curtains", "feet", "floor", "glass", "lamp", "ornament", "picture", "pillow", "radiator", "remote control", "rug", "screen", "sofa", "sticks", "table", "vase", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["blanket"], "masked_program_sha256": "81decf8b99167c854cb8fc9fb5aa72dd77ce7c5e258d8aafb2edaab9dbc2285e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blanket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5fff67cc7f38d84e3345c88a7ed551735320f57aba4de461d3023ca40a52ebfc"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0968071", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13363, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "203255ad3e09e7be98bead6176cf64b7b24baa0029ae6db7ec395781fb0d92f7", "selected_component": "blanket", "selected_source_question_id": "0968071", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What appliance is left of the blanket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "203255ad3e09e7be98bead6176cf64b7b24baa0029ae6db7ec395781fb0d92f7", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "oven"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the left of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what appliance is left of the ?", "program_group_hash": "203255ad3e09e7be98bead6176cf64b7b24baa0029ae6db7ec395781fb0d92f7", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the left of", "select_category": "blanket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "coffee maker", "full_answer": "The appliance is a coffee maker.", "question": "What appliance is left of the oven?", "question_id": "12786630", "semantic": [{"argument": "oven (2738089)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the left of,s (3466934)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "radiator", "full_answer": "The appliance is a radiator.", "question": "What appliance is left of the blanket?", "question_id": "0968071", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (240227)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,to the left of,s (240216)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3466934"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["coffee maker"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "3466934", "query_target_entity_name": "coffee maker", "relation_object_entity_id": "2738089", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3466934", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2738089", "selected_entity_name": "oven"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "oven", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2738089"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "oven", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["240216"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["radiator"], "predicate": "to the left of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "240216", "query_target_entity_name": "radiator", "relation_object_entity_id": "240227", "relation_subject_entity_id": "240216", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "240227", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["240227"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:25f89923824bbe5f05dcb629bab9f576", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8a580693106f20b7f52b6e2aa0a41ae5fcdbfac1fecf8577ae046ee03aebbc8e", "image_sha256_b": "8619fb20e7c8f9b1be44502b51444fd02d8c25349f07c9b97c9f955dfa642700", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7067c5988805e7b7fd9f9d19d8f9522989332acfceb4cb11c25a47bb8f3056d0", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "aeda41c152a9878183465c6e763e0c78", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9765c42c045ba0a42c387af89727823e6888b0c764edc3d154e7b65f34cf908e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0cf27081b8752b5bb2aaceff87f4942d76d8b705ae574c47bd82636933f48a4b", "request_id": "304a459e4d580bb6a005226bfc997a6e", "response_sha256": "9b8ce3dc52f7049b457f9ec570ac6430d54a2da289a4bc34ed43a6d828c3b106", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7595054fb4648c83700fc9f24de4485795bb4723ebbbbc4e33b690dd17113346", "request_id": "801960c9dc0fa259b21f230df2fcd9d4", "response_sha256": "c2f30928d30339f570773055e366cedb5032bee189530b27ff94e392b4b2324f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "7cdb5e7ee23ccfda688401d7041bfd50", "candidate_priority_rank": 13382, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-704fd667793821a8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-704fd667793821a8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-704fd667793821a8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-704fd667793821a8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "machine<->wall", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "wall", "B": "machine"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wall<->machine", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2400524", "image_sha256": "34c422076905ed34a6ec2c442f7b1cdf05e807cfbb28c1303f4080daaae75945", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400524.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400524.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 600, "image_id": "333", "image_sha256": "8b039a6b08365d4481e763b9914798c8afe090cbab64810d7e4c97e9b5247299", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/333.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/333.jpg", "width": 800}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-704fd667793821a8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wall", "diff_b": "machine", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wall", "component_b": "machine"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["doorway", "ear", "eye", "face", "hand", "head", "kitchen towel", "man", "mustache", "nose", "orange", "pan", "pot", "shirt", "thumb", "wall", "watch", "whisk", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["wall"], "masked_program_sha256": "ecf9d6bb925dd1f804e210594f108ba40ab4e8bc4c77673a91c801be07b97b5a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wall", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "47bedaf7ef8cafaea05b9d10ead46a05e5eb2fb8603628dd81d7eaa588b11f91"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11564655", "text": "What type of cooking utensil is on the wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "box", "building", "coffee", "coffee cups", "coffee pot", "counter", "cups", "faucet", "machine", "mug", "packages", "pot", "shelf", "sink", "wall"], "detected_components": ["machine"], "masked_program_sha256": "ecf9d6bb925dd1f804e210594f108ba40ab4e8bc4c77673a91c801be07b97b5a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["machine", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "machine", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["machine", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3b6dfbd9ed6778d95a0e7b216379d268561672fab64b0eaa21f4590f5a33344b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12816669", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13382, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8365261616ee03953d8b78bf758a92b2dbed4220b711563ae0951400131c4764", "selected_component": "machine", "selected_source_question_id": "12816669", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of cooking utensil is on the machine?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of cooking utensil is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "8365261616ee03953d8b78bf758a92b2dbed4220b711563ae0951400131c4764", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of cooking utensil is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "8365261616ee03953d8b78bf758a92b2dbed4220b711563ae0951400131c4764", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "machine"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pan", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a pan.", "question": "What type of cooking utensil is on the wall?", "question_id": "11564655", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1157910)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,s (1157911)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "coffee pot", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a coffee pot.", "question": "What type of cooking utensil is on the machine?", "question_id": "12816669", "semantic": [{"argument": "machine (4293766)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,on,s (4293786)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1157905", "1157911"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pan"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["metal"], "query_target_entity_id": "1157911", "query_target_entity_name": "pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "1157910", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1157911", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1157910", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1157910"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "machine", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4293786"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 2, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4293784", "4521529"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4293786"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["coffee pot"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4293786", "query_target_entity_name": "coffee pot", "relation_object_entity_id": "4293766", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4293786", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4293766", "selected_entity_name": "machine"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "machine", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4293766"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:7cdb5e7ee23ccfda688401d7041bfd50", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "34c422076905ed34a6ec2c442f7b1cdf05e807cfbb28c1303f4080daaae75945", "image_sha256_b": "8b039a6b08365d4481e763b9914798c8afe090cbab64810d7e4c97e9b5247299", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0564663c62d3c38c78d075bc4457ed01b95023296c7e6241a554ae06dabf7350", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "454aa7e61c937324744cf18e9fe677d6", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5f8ec7b36fa59b18b3bbfe540ffcdbac04922150befc1880d2b8516bf7f62144"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7190402aa726e9b69a80c0a0b46a2a1ae154223561aa966d267ba716afea2616", "request_id": "8dbd035ac3581263dafef050068e17a7", "response_sha256": "dbc8369f124191fe018a70e29e57775de08c4f582266d9eaedd493670762a97d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1d2342c02ce8c70f10e9d1119a4c481edce7ac7f0fb2829844da950a113866b5", "request_id": "c497ace6856c7b71036a481b318073a7", "response_sha256": "29c4a0cb717ed1a3988d6df393fbd0bfa8dfd1ff6105dc894eb6b5d522f0ea4d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "e53f344f98866186aa6a8622c00fffd2", "candidate_priority_rank": 13396, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2558e38d682703ce:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2558e38d682703ce:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2558e38d682703ce:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2558e38d682703ce:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "soup<->towel", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "towel", "B": "soup"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "towel<->soup", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2358339", "image_sha256": "efe25cb13ea7beb526103582fc3cb1baa7e79566c66f62745c17b4499652ccdb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2358339.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2358339.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2325762", "image_sha256": "1ee344af8258870b3cdd9a6080e9ce6921276cf1f0eca75963a77e2b07df1f56", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2325762.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2325762.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2558e38d682703ce", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "towel", "diff_b": "soup", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "towel", "component_b": "soup"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "bottles", "bread box", "cabinet doors", "cabinets", "counter", "cupboards", "door", "fruit", "microwave", "oven", "paper towel", "papers", "refrigerator", "toaster", "towel"], "detected_components": ["towel"], "masked_program_sha256": "2d39c02ec2aeefc125b14067a8f9036baee83528e7d65637ce92ee5602a5d1ae", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "towel", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["towel", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c77abbff3901ca5419e4edcb9b7a76ede14bea9539ebc8a56c74a84f7390077e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01525779", "text": "What is the appliance that that towel is on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["burner", "pot", "soup", "spoon", "stove", "table"], "detected_components": ["soup"], "masked_program_sha256": "2d39c02ec2aeefc125b14067a8f9036baee83528e7d65637ce92ee5602a5d1ae", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["soup", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "soup", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["soup", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5400b6423770e163284ccbdbfa0bbd698206665128ac27446646d0ae21d9959b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14329152", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13396, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a3c86db32b84f4fd0695da3cc1cafdf7f6c020b104e245e4ecf831164a6939ee", "selected_component": "soup", "selected_source_question_id": "14329152", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the appliance that that soup is on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the appliance that that is on?", "program_group_hash": "a3c86db32b84f4fd0695da3cc1cafdf7f6c020b104e245e4ecf831164a6939ee", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "towel"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the appliance that that is on?", "program_group_hash": "a3c86db32b84f4fd0695da3cc1cafdf7f6c020b104e245e4ecf831164a6939ee", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "soup"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "oven", "full_answer": "The appliance is an oven.", "question": "What is the appliance that that towel is on?", "question_id": "01525779", "semantic": [{"argument": "towel (803840)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,o (803846)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stove", "full_answer": "The appliance is a stove.", "question": "What is the appliance that that soup is on?", "question_id": "14329152", "semantic": [{"argument": "soup (984986)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,on,o (984989)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["803843", "803846", "803848", "803851"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["oven"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "803846", "query_target_entity_name": "oven", "relation_object_entity_id": "803846", "relation_subject_entity_id": "803840", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "803840", "selected_entity_name": "towel"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "towel", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["803840"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "soup", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "towel", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["984989"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stove"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["off", "silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "984989", "query_target_entity_name": "stove", "relation_object_entity_id": "984989", "relation_subject_entity_id": "984986", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "984986", "selected_entity_name": "soup"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "soup", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["984986"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e53f344f98866186aa6a8622c00fffd2", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "efe25cb13ea7beb526103582fc3cb1baa7e79566c66f62745c17b4499652ccdb", "image_sha256_b": "1ee344af8258870b3cdd9a6080e9ce6921276cf1f0eca75963a77e2b07df1f56", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4610ce09a34f4730b9fa16303498710564abf31a99c9de072b414c680da50015", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a2d5339c6c1a702a5791a9bde4989eed", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "6de23ddec0ed4b161fb70f182efa89d51b6164a85529eb095e3036ad9ef243f5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "583b7dcaa4086ff035aa05bf7dbfc995a2760f050e15b9bc485acdb5586c2bd1", "request_id": "8ae36777253494abfcfece933f0e1c22", "response_sha256": "b7368283ad14e28e6e1c40363ae621f61cf197ac81e9a4d7e997ef0c7446ce17", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7a544200874e979b6ae81f17a01f3a6a2a8fc23947e8526d838877aad31243f4", "request_id": "a358aa990fb39b61332343b4a946284f", "response_sha256": "8897b640ff044ac8f7ec3bf01be536fefd4e5584f1f883c3c3ebd4d39c3fba57", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "a319dd3fbfd40d726d4cd41345dc466b", "candidate_priority_rank": 13409, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-81d3bc4f714021ef:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-81d3bc4f714021ef:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-81d3bc4f714021ef:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-81d3bc4f714021ef:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "carriage<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "carriage"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->carriage", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2375891", "image_sha256": "8d0c619fe920200eba8843aa7493fa9e4be02b99e6e5691405cbb5c2d9b3e450", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2375891.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2375891.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2397604", "image_sha256": "dfea96239c1ea76f0fc4cfb249267e8944a8898b06bdbb81b7e48a1bf40d7281", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397604.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397604.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-81d3bc4f714021ef", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "carriage", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "carriage"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.244, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.0, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": true, "center_margin_ratio": 0.466, "direction": "right", "edge_margin_ratio": 0.208, "matched_path_uniqueness_required": true, "max_overlap_ratio": 0.03, "overlap_ratio": 0.0, "scene_candidate_counts": {"anchor": 1, "subject": 1}, "visual_overlap_or_crowding_must_be_false": true}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["appetizers", "apron", "arm", "arrow", "balls", "beads", "bushes", "cakes", "dessert", "desserts", "girl", "hair", "hand", "icing", "jacket", "lip", "mouth", "necklace", "platter", "ring", "sign", "sweater", "teeth", "tray", "trees", "van", "woman", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "be194360e42bf94ce2e9cbf2e52999ee0740445b814657086ce50461dd2a272e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a8026dbd70d4bd0cd5547af58bc952a7f5e3a8cd0495263ea69eb61509bda245"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01153252", "text": "What is the name of the vehicle that is to the right of the woman?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bikes", "bucket", "building", "carriage", "man", "people", "road", "shirt", "sidewalk", "steps", "tree", "van"], "detected_components": ["carriage"], "masked_program_sha256": "be194360e42bf94ce2e9cbf2e52999ee0740445b814657086ce50461dd2a272e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["carriage", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "carriage", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["carriage", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "07e7f9c8766222aed794d6d0cc5ffd71e67cba0b81b24de5a835ce5a8e60168e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12662678", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13409, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4392cf898f0f690e1442248797bddecdc4e5c955d57ce3de55df7f2675f9adad", "selected_component": "carriage", "selected_source_question_id": "12662678", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the name of the vehicle that is to the right of the carriage?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the name of the vehicle that is to the right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "4392cf898f0f690e1442248797bddecdc4e5c955d57ce3de55df7f2675f9adad", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the right of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the name of the vehicle that is to the right of the ?", "program_group_hash": "4392cf898f0f690e1442248797bddecdc4e5c955d57ce3de55df7f2675f9adad", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "to the right of", "select_category": "carriage"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "van", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a van.", "question": "What is the name of the vehicle that is to the right of the woman?", "question_id": "01153252", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (578325)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the right of,s (578302)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "van", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a van.", "question": "What is the name of the vehicle that is to the right of the carriage?", "question_id": "12662678", "semantic": [{"argument": "carriage (4290574)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,to the right of,s (4418198)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["578302"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["van"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "578302", "query_target_entity_name": "van", "relation_object_entity_id": "578325", "relation_subject_entity_id": "578302", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "578325", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["578325"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "carriage", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4418198"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["van"], "predicate": "to the right of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "4418198", "query_target_entity_name": "van", "relation_object_entity_id": "4290574", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4418198", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4290574", "selected_entity_name": "carriage"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "carriage", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4290574"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a319dd3fbfd40d726d4cd41345dc466b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8d0c619fe920200eba8843aa7493fa9e4be02b99e6e5691405cbb5c2d9b3e450", "image_sha256_b": "dfea96239c1ea76f0fc4cfb249267e8944a8898b06bdbb81b7e48a1bf40d7281", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8462becfa273df035835d3d43006e5e28823c0e436b20211d44f1ae76651587d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "6104c536f7defd93b3186870fc2ccb09", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "46f9dec049468074af99b923df789cd80c52d67f80da3f0d8621bfd9957cd2f3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "45cc3cec3dba17173606b268b42426af9a025a4a438f430f6fb8c0d8650fa904", "request_id": "3b12e76022d692b3fffeee676bc0fa10", "response_sha256": "d971f29dc173387607d2b1a78f76552a24d91d5d7e5b5c0f568c3c52dde807bf", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "31e6df0953ed569bbed77c335dea5f31cd4e1d5fadaf48b535756a38463ad135", "request_id": "7f9d4400ab9a95c89b9d3985eb0f4ecc", "response_sha256": "a74e5bb83a4983663a6d83d090bebd5a064ee25a46b6337ae2ca46a7bc3c3a0f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "candidate_key": "75200647ab0355709db80497419a9e19", "candidate_priority_rank": 13418, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f7db15afdd58b386:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f7db15afdd58b386:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f7db15afdd58b386:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f7db15afdd58b386:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "trees<->vines", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "trees", "B": "vines"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "trees<->vines", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2374573", "image_sha256": "dd9152e0b1e380edd25fd41b40142c009d538e142f85cc32f3ab18dd77dac7fe", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2374573.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2374573.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2367339", "image_sha256": "d4914fcff6bc84b57f94410b0c64671b6818fe0bde02ce5c44a66efdb51731fd", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367339.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367339.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f7db15afdd58b386", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "trees", "diff_b": "vines", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "trees", "component_b": "vines"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beach", "bucket", "clouds", "dog", "girl", "grass", "hill", "jeans", "kite", "sand", "shirt", "sky", "stick", "swimsuit", "tail", "trees", "woman"], "detected_components": ["trees"], "masked_program_sha256": "6bc3bb179009e9e9db56682be3791aa6dcc901d6bdf9295cac83689a43e01e21", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["trees"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "trees", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["trees"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7a118663f53b8ea767cd533e5868eac0fab5fad46bec5fc0dd50f5ba80a4ae4e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06834088", "text": "What are the trees growing on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bird", "building", "clock", "cloud", "face", "hand", "sky", "tower", "vines", "window"], "detected_components": ["vines"], "masked_program_sha256": "6bc3bb179009e9e9db56682be3791aa6dcc901d6bdf9295cac83689a43e01e21", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["vines"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "vines", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["vines"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3baca5b2b5ef80cf6a2a32714eb0971b0f880a209077970179bc44eef984c121"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06512305", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 13418, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3faef07ffef46c751abaf22922e7116f28a0898f496cda35d00e5cf86b6bf54b", "selected_component": "vines", "selected_source_question_id": "06512305", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the vines growing on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the growing on?", "program_group_hash": "3faef07ffef46c751abaf22922e7116f28a0898f496cda35d00e5cf86b6bf54b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "growing on", "select_category": "trees"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the growing on?", "program_group_hash": "3faef07ffef46c751abaf22922e7116f28a0898f496cda35d00e5cf86b6bf54b", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "growing on", "select_category": "vines"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "hill", "full_answer": "The trees are growing on the hill.", "question": "What are the trees growing on?", "question_id": "06834088", "semantic": [{"argument": "trees (2003137)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing on,o (3849017)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "tower", "full_answer": "The vines are growing on the tower.", "question": "What are the vines growing on?", "question_id": "06512305", "semantic": [{"argument": "vines (2264285)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing on,o (2491595)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1662566", "1673057", "1673058", "1683119", "1731446", "1731447", "1768984", "1811025", "1945846", "2010321", "2029803", "2072890", "2195973", "2195974", "2448872", "2542189", "2573035", "2621941", "2631458", "3719635", "3719636", "3719643", "3719644", "3719645", "3849017", "3849019"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 26, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hill"], "predicate": "growing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3849017", "query_target_entity_name": "hill", "relation_object_entity_id": "3849017", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2003137", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2003137", "selected_entity_name": "trees"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "trees", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2003137"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "vines", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "trees", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2249212", "2257845", "2291450", "2325414", "2381071", "2472121", "2491595", "2566148", "2587760", "3874467", "3874469", "3874470", "3874471", "3874472", "3874473", "3874475"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["tower"], "predicate": "growing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["red", "tall"], "query_target_entity_id": "2491595", "query_target_entity_name": "tower", "relation_object_entity_id": "2491595", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2264285", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2264285", "selected_entity_name": "vines"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "vines", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2264285"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:75200647ab0355709db80497419a9e19", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "dd9152e0b1e380edd25fd41b40142c009d538e142f85cc32f3ab18dd77dac7fe", "image_sha256_b": "d4914fcff6bc84b57f94410b0c64671b6818fe0bde02ce5c44a66efdb51731fd", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4b4bb141b09b5af288f632ba960bc53b4817cf81447cce9aeb0dae8e48947034", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b9a967995dcfbb1f5e7152e14112173d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "bceaa7f2a06e7881af1f139c457b0a3ada4d4fcaf73048c5462eede0351c8103"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "063d8c9398b222075dc61ce509e44524d7ddbfc58e8b85dbb01f66873281a88b", "request_id": "b27f7593f3c66071a77c6359518f692a", "response_sha256": "cba4bd101f9b17912557d05d19c79a17e9d168fe655bddd34c8d1935f249d9c2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0b6d1e7b1fee4eb0ba37e690a3fedc46c4c9c1c4d74c46a52cf80e33adfc3a75", "request_id": "48d71cf04b4ba4d5a1c0d38709de7c46", "response_sha256": "9249c215ad06648646a64abacbcb91928e6b4742024155986998978cefa347c8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "12da62306b8571bb137dd4a4a2d7076b", "candidate_priority_rank": 1, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cc220469ead780fb:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cc220469ead780fb:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cc220469ead780fb:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cc220469ead780fb:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "basket<->box", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "box", "B": "basket"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "box<->basket", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2391013", "image_sha256": "19dea18095a978620f4f2c2cd38b107d47fef33da7cd198f5310db3712542ec3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2391013.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2391013.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2345138", "image_sha256": "3c23ce3038c1e152070da89a624db86d7123d443bd7d33b7ae8fa958d759b181", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345138.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345138.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cc220469ead780fb", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "box", "diff_b": "basket", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "box", "component_b": "basket"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["box", "cheese", "pepperoni", "pizza", "sauce"], "detected_components": ["box"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae0e0a6e17a798a830e478717a7590b8f9fa6be061107f612abd0987a199f2bd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["box", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "box", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["box", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "425778c4fb9102f198a9c32f84059545f38bde4c11e8f2b441c390dbd9e523ee"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18947881", "text": "What kind of fast food is in the box?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "cheese", "crust", "herbs", "jeans", "man", "pepperoni", "pizza", "shoes", "spice", "table", "tissue", "tomato"], "detected_components": ["basket"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae0e0a6e17a798a830e478717a7590b8f9fa6be061107f612abd0987a199f2bd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "basket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b2a3c8e7d78cc24a27287386e6a2d4fc6a769dc7b0f24230e8e7df2f00255b05"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1459379", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 1, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 16, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c0a83d89a6d4397d5f427214ae24952e7e4d34539b486ebf71bd2c0b20381006", "selected_component": "basket", "selected_source_question_id": "1459379", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of fast food is in the basket?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "c0a83d89a6d4397d5f427214ae24952e7e4d34539b486ebf71bd2c0b20381006", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "box"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "c0a83d89a6d4397d5f427214ae24952e7e4d34539b486ebf71bd2c0b20381006", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "basket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The food is a pizza.", "question": "What kind of fast food is in the box?", "question_id": "18947881", "semantic": [{"argument": "box (1244922)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s (1244921)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The food is a pizza.", "question": "What kind of fast food is in the basket?", "question_id": "1459379", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (3365977)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s (2048169)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1244921"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["cheese", "cooked", "gold", "sliced"], "query_target_entity_id": "1244921", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "1244922", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1244921", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1244922", "selected_entity_name": "box"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "box", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1244922"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "box", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2048169"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2048169", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "3365977", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2048169", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3365977", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3365977"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:12da62306b8571bb137dd4a4a2d7076b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "19dea18095a978620f4f2c2cd38b107d47fef33da7cd198f5310db3712542ec3", "image_sha256_b": "3c23ce3038c1e152070da89a624db86d7123d443bd7d33b7ae8fa958d759b181", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d63a910a6b491afad736635a6ac775e661722db282bccd77c439403e5879cef6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5bef5dd1ca54a105dcf7cd5ad58d57e3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1fdbb5a90c4d4a78674672430bb33c4eb2257996f2fc915f73b8daacd816d3a7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "726cb48b8986460a39cbd289088114db4c2a699e53e20f89db837d1e5bd56c66", "request_id": "e720bcada41db30c335c3ac6a69effed", "response_sha256": "1bd9789c2aab4fbe1178761c7f48d0df125b8706d57da6915a7e00bb9c7093dc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5d2a6d52577089e9867a7addf1a6dc8f80c37202fe43d9200e6ce08b7d7aed48", "request_id": "3e551f1e6306ba9f9e46bf6f5ed24a89", "response_sha256": "b60f3ee56d438b655b5b5311390f76f23224cd4a8c60ad3762d89a32336c8201", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "b94fff6b3428131baf3955ff7837e705", "candidate_priority_rank": 2, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9eec6a0d11aa917a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9eec6a0d11aa917a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9eec6a0d11aa917a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9eec6a0d11aa917a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bed<->dog", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dog", "B": "bed"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dog<->bed", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2390301", "image_sha256": "49bdc03390d5eebd93df24dec159a06ff9a526f9fd5e54834f8d34960c6dfe1e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390301.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390301.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2404332", "image_sha256": "aedf3688325aa9d9cb1dfbe0c08c1eeda7593b951f14cb034a05ef2f79181c0f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404332.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404332.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9eec6a0d11aa917a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dog", "diff_b": "bed", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dog", "component_b": "bed"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beach", "dog", "ear", "eye", "face", "foot", "hair", "head", "leg", "neck", "nose", "ocean", "ring", "tail", "tongue"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6910bedf3580fd8f149ee5b2e0fd0bf290df1e9368b310b60dc3a5c9ca948fb5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05355701", "text": "What is this dog inside of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "chair", "floor", "headboard", "hotel room", "lamp", "pillow", "sheet", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["bed"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bed", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1d220aa4397b27b6829421558f158fc6ed64007f2571a40ddc2912f6b6d14cc7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0454087", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 2, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "selected_component": "bed", "selected_source_question_id": "0454087", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this bed inside of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this inside of?", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this inside of?", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "bed"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "ocean", "full_answer": "The dog is inside the ocean.", "question": "What is this dog inside of?", "question_id": "05355701", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (1251747)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (1251748)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hotel room", "full_answer": "The bed is inside the hotel room.", "question": "What is this bed inside of?", "question_id": "0454087", "semantic": [{"argument": "bed (377738)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (377736)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1251748", "1251750", "1251751", "1251752", "1251753", "1251754", "1251755", "1251756", "1251757", "1251758", "1251759", "1251762", "1251763", "1251764", "1251765", "1251766", "1251767", "1251768"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ocean"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["clear"], "query_target_entity_id": "1251748", "query_target_entity_name": "ocean", "relation_object_entity_id": "1251748", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1251747", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1251747", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1251747"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["377736", "377737", "377740", "377741", "377743", "377744", "377745", "377746", "377749", "377751"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hotel room"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "377736", "query_target_entity_name": "hotel room", "relation_object_entity_id": "377736", "relation_subject_entity_id": "377738", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "377738", "selected_entity_name": "bed"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["377738"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b94fff6b3428131baf3955ff7837e705", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "49bdc03390d5eebd93df24dec159a06ff9a526f9fd5e54834f8d34960c6dfe1e", "image_sha256_b": "aedf3688325aa9d9cb1dfbe0c08c1eeda7593b951f14cb034a05ef2f79181c0f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d31fb9d3ae78c956b2c42e5c6d270bb21a50b31e4a9c9490755dc3954aba32ba", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "069d52c482412819556897fb165ef032", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4880b7c6f4d8e3cc30d3f18dddcb3cefc3bcf8cfc680c423e81753de364d3fa6"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4e391eeb7b94ff5456bdfc72f1254040dfbe01787297c551dfe9f0eb58d8bd22", "request_id": "e9bfa6759a705260702f7d2f4fbe8dd0", "response_sha256": "595f298aded67e05a2bdf938079d634d46bc1e2cbb28899f623c223c4e6c5065", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a99fae62a98cf877c6cbd685d0ab9bc6b6722da9b4f5df507caa3dc91d952c17", "request_id": "4af926a67f341652fd886a33468f2028", "response_sha256": "7959a292507f544b77f624db7c241be261a2d982a93b0361c24e764a36429048", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "c4ef0c1a78cf590f9cf8416e4336ee34", "candidate_priority_rank": 9, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca38c1c52070e80b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca38c1c52070e80b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca38c1c52070e80b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca38c1c52070e80b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "deck<->grass", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "deck", "B": "grass"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "deck<->grass", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2381777", "image_sha256": "a51badade29667019184b8b699dd7abfd58b135287e08ade9f470fa2de2e0b41", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2381777.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2381777.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2375133", "image_sha256": "e87c65c96676f9b7a7a139c58032bab3c575a92ab0aafbab1abdc0a872315e19", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2375133.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2375133.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca38c1c52070e80b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "deck", "diff_b": "grass", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "deck", "component_b": "grass"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["deck", "dog", "ear", "eyes", "head", "jacket", "nose", "paws", "sand", "tag"], "detected_components": ["deck"], "masked_program_sha256": "9f977a01027d3edce27de8245062ea4466e929f11ef1b5897ba4995c496f9992", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["deck", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "deck", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["deck", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b8b8ab8c000b5bf249e0f31b1876cbd26126873d8a464b85696ad801f0905322"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08451417", "text": "What is the animal that is on the deck called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ears", "eyes", "grass", "head", "leg", "legs", "mane", "tail", "trees", "trunks", "zebra"], "detected_components": ["grass"], "masked_program_sha256": "9f977a01027d3edce27de8245062ea4466e929f11ef1b5897ba4995c496f9992", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "grass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4dbf250ba371fa883598186ad7f94193dbef030090e605b32c9f8bce28dda974"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05728878", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 9, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "db661ca0639b665806bf7d9180c84fd1a1589b0c3ce619c066b368881033db22", "selected_component": "grass", "selected_source_question_id": "05728878", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal that is on the grass called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is on the called?", "program_group_hash": "db661ca0639b665806bf7d9180c84fd1a1589b0c3ce619c066b368881033db22", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "deck"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is on the called?", "program_group_hash": "db661ca0639b665806bf7d9180c84fd1a1589b0c3ce619c066b368881033db22", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "grass"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The animal is a dog.", "question": "What is the animal that is on the deck called?", "question_id": "08451417", "semantic": [{"argument": "deck (701902)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (701900)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "zebra", "full_answer": "The animal is a zebra.", "question": "What is the animal that is on the grass called?", "question_id": "05728878", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (723542)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (723535)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["701900"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["standing", "wet", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "701900", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "701902", "relation_subject_entity_id": "701900", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "701902", "selected_entity_name": "deck"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "deck", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["701902"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "deck", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["723535"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["zebra"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "723535", "query_target_entity_name": "zebra", "relation_object_entity_id": "723542", "relation_subject_entity_id": "723535", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "723542", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["723542"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c4ef0c1a78cf590f9cf8416e4336ee34", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a51badade29667019184b8b699dd7abfd58b135287e08ade9f470fa2de2e0b41", "image_sha256_b": "e87c65c96676f9b7a7a139c58032bab3c575a92ab0aafbab1abdc0a872315e19", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1ecc325dab27f5a365e962cc05670c0a23ff2737eead82159ce90b4e7d6efa6f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0d209ce2f85818e9e33806c53d02860b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "75c7c31023f1ac2e666652226febdc959da82d8ab7a90ad506e7b0f0a835da2f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ffdf89bb803f4bbce97a56b5d3ba45ce38c71121cfce11403bef266b5c95aa30", "request_id": "70f32e32cd3a4681523690c93c317051", "response_sha256": "3591d548c59b271235014a4a7e77d27f8d859905b1f6216570ddb6c4f858e83c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ac5851ded173639b9696516ac15849484a23fb91821df010d6aedc560e2c88fb", "request_id": "d1a7200c7ee4684f34d2716908536640", "response_sha256": "4a5dfeffffeeddaba24268c43b8c4d75a4d0eff24acf3505c55ca8e6705a88f6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "55b3339cb3eb8749150b768dd4052ba1", "candidate_priority_rank": 10, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a96f2c7b9af1f97:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a96f2c7b9af1f97:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a96f2c7b9af1f97:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a96f2c7b9af1f97:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bread<->cake", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cake", "B": "bread"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cake<->bread", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2345180", "image_sha256": "46752777ebb37640d88268060d4f71358a8c9148d46d180773d2f3897401591c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345180.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345180.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2392221", "image_sha256": "cfa3cbe7f5095c51a8ec8416ac49260a8b10ce1dd662384fa903bdd4b4d15350", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392221.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392221.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5a96f2c7b9af1f97", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cake", "diff_b": "bread", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cake", "component_b": "bread"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["baking pan", "baking sheet", "cake", "candle", "candles", "counter", "pan", "sprinkles", "tray"], "detected_components": ["cake"], "masked_program_sha256": "d4f1d7df6846512fabc86071ca540dead813eb347d3b14b5ba909f330cdd7b88", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cake", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f9371e6e3465c016112d68755acca498725ec3ab17671cce8d8cc31519f08887"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13891513", "text": "What cooking utensil is the cake sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bread", "cutting board", "table"], "detected_components": ["bread"], "masked_program_sha256": "d4f1d7df6846512fabc86071ca540dead813eb347d3b14b5ba909f330cdd7b88", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bread", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e98718c3537733f2264ddd4785b145fc7b6a4d6790f3f28f10476ce58a4db9c5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06880511", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 10, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8bcc98ad98f709edcb68ff2be627b65840ec9331ee2a2eb350194b40d2165a59", "selected_component": "bread", "selected_source_question_id": "06880511", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What cooking utensil is the bread sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what cooking utensil is the sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "8bcc98ad98f709edcb68ff2be627b65840ec9331ee2a2eb350194b40d2165a59", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "cake"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what cooking utensil is the sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "8bcc98ad98f709edcb68ff2be627b65840ec9331ee2a2eb350194b40d2165a59", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "bread"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pan", "full_answer": "The cake is sitting on the pan.", "question": "What cooking utensil is the cake sitting on?", "question_id": "13891513", "semantic": [{"argument": "cake (4502549)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,sitting on,o (4502554)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cutting board", "full_answer": "The bread is sitting on the cutting board.", "question": "What cooking utensil is the bread sitting on?", "question_id": "06880511", "semantic": [{"argument": "bread (1232594)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,sitting on,o (1232596)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4502554", "4542641", "4542642"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pan"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4502554", "query_target_entity_name": "pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "4502554", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4502549", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4502549", "selected_entity_name": "cake"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4502549"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1232596"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cutting board"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "striped", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1232596", "query_target_entity_name": "cutting board", "relation_object_entity_id": "1232596", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1232594", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1232594", "selected_entity_name": "bread"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1232594"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:55b3339cb3eb8749150b768dd4052ba1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "46752777ebb37640d88268060d4f71358a8c9148d46d180773d2f3897401591c", "image_sha256_b": "cfa3cbe7f5095c51a8ec8416ac49260a8b10ce1dd662384fa903bdd4b4d15350", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d411ac154bff2a421a89988121ba77b092a3cd44b84b5327f15bbea2bee735f6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "bfbddf96f1183a0b8f15310b87448b65", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "01cffa0ae293612970597ca5db498df4d91bdac5d55cfcb199d85cb383bb4c35"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ef9ce31f8759ee7ab1ae73134d93c512d1b65cc37157e653de289025df60ca69", "request_id": "e87bcc1924ce720feb4d16bd88792189", "response_sha256": "f6ddc09d5ea55ee07a91a2953edd2c386165242cea71d79c2109fda5690ba126", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a5abc45ef7b977f579fb318782fa6b7ca128399c59880aaf5413ca88e6f268cd", "request_id": "220457828e58ed1e49aa91f1f0a52ba8", "response_sha256": "ace596e95c6a3c00016934ff9d31a54049275a0659023fcbffbdfa103b69a9c3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "fd792b565c82cde62af4ac29a0d5f8c6", "candidate_priority_rank": 12, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9d62323491f04c74:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9d62323491f04c74:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9d62323491f04c74:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9d62323491f04c74:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dog<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dog", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dog<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2385466", "image_sha256": "ddcb33c7f4239d94917e35f9ebff82f62ca9bdd261becebdb9c4f2383aa91584", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2385466.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2385466.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2389065", "image_sha256": "041b97b12e03083f6cf42dc7bffb3be5c9943d7cc2ee2e7413376972ea5acfcb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389065.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389065.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9d62323491f04c74", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dog", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dog", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "collar", "dog", "ear", "eye", "face", "mouth", "nose", "tag", "window", "windshield"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "24634d024e17e6cfe6e5593b9e731263b8942b73d37d4c0dfe1a4a4aaad38a7e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9bead5830f99174986d66a04129b34263b9f1b3b2b6ada93b23e27a0d228db50"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16438578", "text": "What vehicle is the dog sitting in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "car", "computer mouse", "finger", "floor", "hand", "hat", "jeans", "laptop", "logo", "man", "neck", "shirt", "shoe", "steering wheel", "watch"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "24634d024e17e6cfe6e5593b9e731263b8942b73d37d4c0dfe1a4a4aaad38a7e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a00bb9349cc87a77e7c82d9963ef47c38af22a88a805cf7ec9b0b53f75607c5b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "031043285", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 12, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d875a0544fae4d8b73265fd4c67474cc32ddd05a05aa9d6a1903acef4940e7ab", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "031043285", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What vehicle is the man sitting in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicle is the sitting in?", "program_group_hash": "d875a0544fae4d8b73265fd4c67474cc32ddd05a05aa9d6a1903acef4940e7ab", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting in", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicle is the sitting in?", "program_group_hash": "d875a0544fae4d8b73265fd4c67474cc32ddd05a05aa9d6a1903acef4940e7ab", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting in", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The dog is sitting in the car.", "question": "What vehicle is the dog sitting in?", "question_id": "16438578", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (687826)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting in,o (687827)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The man is sitting in the car.", "question": "What vehicle is the man sitting in?", "question_id": "031043285", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1264431)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting in,o (1264429)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["687827"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "sitting in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "687827", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "687827", "relation_subject_entity_id": "687826", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "687826", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["687826"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1264429"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "sitting in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1264429", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "1264429", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1264431", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1264431", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1264431"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:fd792b565c82cde62af4ac29a0d5f8c6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ddcb33c7f4239d94917e35f9ebff82f62ca9bdd261becebdb9c4f2383aa91584", "image_sha256_b": "041b97b12e03083f6cf42dc7bffb3be5c9943d7cc2ee2e7413376972ea5acfcb", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a19cfa3334e5d888d5d0c379887e753d1e17b35b6a1d8fde34670cd5bbea2e6f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1956a50d8b4703ed372b16eeb24df681", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b5a5662c9a6d33a198b2c30b0244be42f0fdc955e741f77567c76e12af5c8296"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6aaaee63b9e7c4eb0a66751435bdcde917f1305561740f69f0c3adad7290b398", "request_id": "5eb0e51ee9a1e4f95bdce87e3f68a35c", "response_sha256": "b09f7cb4249d0a8d9ded2de23f84c401163e1486d1a5074839bcb2f1d25e57a2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1df94d3e080b69a2b2b4ba8682831825a71b66888a71f051d8f0a760c0739dec", "request_id": "1c30940b72f4c00b273c0016e8a96537", "response_sha256": "7d27f7adff905b7b19682a67585f9c49c3476a535184576109afce27c6d3b38f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ff15975ddfdff0cb35d0fd9f85ec7a11", "candidate_priority_rank": 14, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c2f61199268c6028:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c2f61199268c6028:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c2f61199268c6028:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c2f61199268c6028:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "field<->zoo", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "zoo", "B": "field"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "zoo<->field", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2351929", "image_sha256": "7012ab35a0dd4fe7e7239af17d0e03e5c6d57531d0e904c5180d5945983960ae", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2351929.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2351929.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2386733", "image_sha256": "e3c6e9db56af0468b94336362c08f7b35bdf6b24609aae0a81901a11bb3ef059", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2386733.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2386733.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "activity_state", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c2f61199268c6028", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "zoo", "diff_b": "field", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "zoo", "component_b": "field"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "pose", "question_intent": "activity_state:pose", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "dirt", "ear", "eye", "face", "foot", "grass", "head", "leaves", "leg", "mouth", "nose", "panda bear", "paw", "rock", "stones", "tree trunk", "zoo"], "detected_components": ["zoo"], "masked_program_sha256": "5b374ca360f9258bdb784fbb0c3e384cac925ec62fbd2ea29da0ceb067661e53", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["zoo", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "zoo", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["zoo", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ebe7a357d4b6cdb46092dffbd921f7a2fac968ab16a37d0c437ce4ea601391b0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13396182", "text": "What is the animal in the zoo doing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "field", "head", "leg", "mane", "nose", "rock", "tail", "zebra"], "detected_components": ["field"], "masked_program_sha256": "5b374ca360f9258bdb784fbb0c3e384cac925ec62fbd2ea29da0ceb067661e53", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "field", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c99e957ac6653407b486e3a31f2dd1fad9ad5285e515dfde260daebf155b12ef"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01131207", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 14, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "79b9344468a964ffacfa980b73f5e14acaecfdc60b7b3ef3430d9d8bc2008d93", "selected_component": "field", "selected_source_question_id": "01131207", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal in the field doing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal in the doing?", "program_group_hash": "79b9344468a964ffacfa980b73f5e14acaecfdc60b7b3ef3430d9d8bc2008d93", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "pose", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "zoo"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal in the doing?", "program_group_hash": "79b9344468a964ffacfa980b73f5e14acaecfdc60b7b3ef3430d9d8bc2008d93", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "pose", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "field"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "lying", "full_answer": "The panda bear is lying.", "question": "What is the animal in the zoo doing?", "question_id": "13396182", "semantic": [{"argument": "zoo (857183)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (857182)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "standing", "full_answer": "The zebra is standing.", "question": "What is the animal in the field doing?", "question_id": "01131207", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (1283019)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (1283018)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["857182"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["brown", "lying"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "lying"], "query_target_entity_id": "857182", "query_target_entity_name": "panda bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "857183", "relation_subject_entity_id": "857182", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "857183", "selected_entity_name": "zoo"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "zoo", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["857183"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "zoo", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1283018"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["black", "standing", "striped"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "standing", "striped"], "query_target_entity_id": "1283018", "query_target_entity_name": "zebra", "relation_object_entity_id": "1283019", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1283018", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1283019", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1283019"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ff15975ddfdff0cb35d0fd9f85ec7a11", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7012ab35a0dd4fe7e7239af17d0e03e5c6d57531d0e904c5180d5945983960ae", "image_sha256_b": "e3c6e9db56af0468b94336362c08f7b35bdf6b24609aae0a81901a11bb3ef059", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "af254be8329c7a57e59ad8fbfd7446f857003a24fc479df65e218ac9ca9e86a6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "fc9c237a4213dcdd1a733fd023ce6541", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3a66db341b2dc5cb63cb750ef9ea78e4c4242a4a0967d5f9f5f6829ab294ea37"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "74489451011da0acff27568ac4ea6d582a44c67e931d879d02e9c75eeb0e9b62", "request_id": "55d3b66a41e95e435ecd541d30cecac3", "response_sha256": "0200ec6ddf4bd1994e2be736910d4d509652b0fccaa9e642c2c5e5324e17bce3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5afe96e92d40281ba4cdfc149715073ae9b6e3fe079979ef24614d7962fd6e1c", "request_id": "7cf05eb080456ead730144d43b3d6786", "response_sha256": "3036ed5f1d14e59ca7b6e2631452369a376ba2cb85108f19a4dafaaa09ab2ba5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "31276b110755ee44d8e75d550eefa264", "candidate_priority_rank": 16, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9d18fcadf3f771:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9d18fcadf3f771:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9d18fcadf3f771:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9d18fcadf3f771:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "umbrella<->water", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "water", "B": "umbrella"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "water<->umbrella", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2394427", "image_sha256": "34f0b20798153117ee2b3c91f3681397da20604c06e986be02a20ff66a6b7626", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2394427.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2394427.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2345572", "image_sha256": "b10f8f0ea20fb297c2e3ea26d7eabf31a55e1edba74a176886d5ed1a03627e3c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345572.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345572.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0a9d18fcadf3f771", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "water", "diff_b": "umbrella", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "water", "component_b": "umbrella"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "cone", "ear", "eye", "head", "leg", "mouth", "nose", "polar bear", "rock", "tail", "water"], "detected_components": ["water"], "masked_program_sha256": "70cbc6657b766c26069c9bb892ee58d253932847c0329acf15d28fb99328dd42", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "water", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fc156e0a71289f1ea589d68bc41d489a4d01e35156e39a64f815e32d5ae97a8b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03445832", "text": "What kind of animal is below the water?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "ear", "eye", "floor", "head", "leg", "nose", "paws", "stick", "tail", "umbrella"], "detected_components": ["umbrella"], "masked_program_sha256": "70cbc6657b766c26069c9bb892ee58d253932847c0329acf15d28fb99328dd42", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["umbrella", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "umbrella", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["umbrella", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "19947a8c77831962bc5b6659ad07f327a0808a6c50f749db7076bc3b85ab15da"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08926998", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 16, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4f485377676f42a6a0b34fd88bcaadd43609805d35897f120c947861922df2b7", "selected_component": "umbrella", "selected_source_question_id": "08926998", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of animal is below the umbrella?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "4f485377676f42a6a0b34fd88bcaadd43609805d35897f120c947861922df2b7", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "4f485377676f42a6a0b34fd88bcaadd43609805d35897f120c947861922df2b7", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "umbrella"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "polar bear", "full_answer": "The animal is a polar bear.", "question": "What kind of animal is below the water?", "question_id": "03445832", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (464204)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,below,s (464203)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What kind of animal is below the umbrella?", "question_id": "08926998", "semantic": [{"argument": "umbrella (2026030)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,below,s (3446207)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["464203"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["polar bear"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["adult", "floating", "heavy", "huge", "large", "wet", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "464203", "query_target_entity_name": "polar bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "464204", "relation_subject_entity_id": "464203", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "464204", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["464204"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "umbrella", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3446207"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3446207", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "2026030", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3446207", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2026030", "selected_entity_name": "umbrella"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "umbrella", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2026030"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:31276b110755ee44d8e75d550eefa264", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "34f0b20798153117ee2b3c91f3681397da20604c06e986be02a20ff66a6b7626", "image_sha256_b": "b10f8f0ea20fb297c2e3ea26d7eabf31a55e1edba74a176886d5ed1a03627e3c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7977f26c16285be56136e95d95ddd74a7648ae486f2171366a24eb1c844eb08b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "802753f341b2811fa60e69f6dabd56fc", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "96cf52ba7cc1eb219dd7971333978dace1cecc01bfe99fa5fad281844b043ed1"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4856d94910880c70df0e6f937c66f783fb12aeecc6c53b297ecdea5990cb0726", "request_id": "c981fee358424e59ea098ed65d6fe467", "response_sha256": "507c59b745b42aa9f77931cb5e325a424020d297bcbe797feaa783c867011718", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9db770e413213919051debef29f1b9e650ea7bb2e8e4ddd43d609c090cc87e0f", "request_id": "b02b270a9782ed40934696eb05c9c29a", "response_sha256": "15b1947b62e4a5758a11379b6b145f5c7090049ea125c38d29b290dc5dff638b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "11c81347a35c16a225e0d5e3f0dc76f6", "candidate_priority_rank": 20, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e6f54bdd7ac4a352:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e6f54bdd7ac4a352:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e6f54bdd7ac4a352:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e6f54bdd7ac4a352:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "baby<->cat", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "baby", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "baby<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2389930", "image_sha256": "928a8fc1999f246d9aa72d3c5e2c89b8d499e28f8859d67a495b1ab670c8b6bd", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389930.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389930.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2345391", "image_sha256": "5f71f4d05bcf8bd7ce81ff6e475d49c544e66419843987deec9039312e0c8953", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345391.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345391.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e6f54bdd7ac4a352", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "baby", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "baby", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["baby", "clothes", "elephant", "hair", "hand", "jacket", "lid", "person", "ring", "stuffed bear", "suitcase", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["baby"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "baby", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "85abfef26b2aa1d945388f8da15ea62b86cf0bcbb02a3d518b5cef35d7758f0e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11706879", "text": "What is this baby inside of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "cat", "ear", "eye", "fur", "head", "mouth", "nose", "pouch", "wall"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b90056f631873f6d211915590c2777bf23f81fbfbc9b0ca05d8312d37b247522"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02468113", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 20, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "02468113", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this cat inside of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this inside of?", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "baby"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this inside of?", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "suitcase", "full_answer": "The baby is inside the suitcase.", "question": "What is this baby inside of?", "question_id": "11706879", "semantic": [{"argument": "baby (1255855)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (1255857)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bag", "full_answer": "The cat is inside the bag.", "question": "What is this cat inside of?", "question_id": "02468113", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (2300053)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (2322756)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1255856", "1255857", "1255859", "1255860", "1255861", "1255863", "1255864", "1255866", "1255867", "1255868", "1255872", "1255874"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["suitcase"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1255857", "query_target_entity_name": "suitcase", "relation_object_entity_id": "1255857", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1255855", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1255855", "selected_entity_name": "baby"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1255855"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2232133", "2316149", "2322756", "2328101", "2566058", "2570131", "2740764", "2823726", "3242314", "3331479", "3331480", "3331481", "3331482", "3331483", "3624948", "3632249"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bag"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["red"], "query_target_entity_id": "2322756", "query_target_entity_name": "bag", "relation_object_entity_id": "2322756", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2300053", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2300053", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2300053"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:11c81347a35c16a225e0d5e3f0dc76f6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "928a8fc1999f246d9aa72d3c5e2c89b8d499e28f8859d67a495b1ab670c8b6bd", "image_sha256_b": "5f71f4d05bcf8bd7ce81ff6e475d49c544e66419843987deec9039312e0c8953", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "51d04ae099d7b727720cb3b388df95e0b1ad7e8a2f6f706bf91c3f8e7d352d35", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "210c7ec397eef1ba6bf985bf78fe2503", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "18500413acbd39dd1fcc77fe15a76af8df1cd25e932a7ed25a1d6003c69811d4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6966024ab66ae0475e1e59fdec4105cb9953c18da5a3f8f9a91b7bd5d0cd1ba3", "request_id": "ea297ee98cad4996b9f016da2a59b504", "response_sha256": "5c3f23a9a2e20c59f64259e4ed19987080ee9458412f1339e0b7233aad316d02", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0b25e4e0490d389deb696a1344595f36f0d3cc6cea8fd59a3d8280c55be236c4", "request_id": "2db4eec71f268f6a855731f339629a4f", "response_sha256": "8c55f65f2a6cec5fa6666df720e79e339fc412381fffcae261cd6c77461c06c0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "63a99bd2edb4894ccb01367496487f9f", "candidate_priority_rank": 25, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a70e688ea9ec02ec:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a70e688ea9ec02ec:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a70e688ea9ec02ec:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a70e688ea9ec02ec:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->girl", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "girl", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "girl<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2336555", "image_sha256": "b66146a9d72026e260f891890b6c561a524aed12da4ee459354891ebb4463219", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2336555.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2336555.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2362213", "image_sha256": "bb8423cd48dd527504bc836955616d35a5f3594b1c229b8b1a5f2096780806c7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2362213.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2362213.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a70e688ea9ec02ec", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "girl", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "girl", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "cell phone", "girl", "grass", "hand", "head", "logo", "mirror", "nose", "phone", "steering wheel", "tie", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["girl"], "masked_program_sha256": "24634d024e17e6cfe6e5593b9e731263b8942b73d37d4c0dfe1a4a4aaad38a7e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "girl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ead4f3ca07e51ee7204be3cf33dddf82020afcb3e6b18661de864d748e602239"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04880670", "text": "What is the vehicle that the girl is sitting in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "car", "cat", "ear", "eye", "fur", "head", "leaves", "mouth", "tree", "window"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "24634d024e17e6cfe6e5593b9e731263b8942b73d37d4c0dfe1a4a4aaad38a7e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "188c12c368e772a2ea8ece946ff440ea63b68519ab043b4ea5851a94281e334b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15350477", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 25, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3c1ca133506d48234fbff809f287516407c4138de4568646fd24fcf4c7e2f8c5", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "15350477", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the vehicle that the cat is sitting in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vehicle that the is sitting in?", "program_group_hash": "3c1ca133506d48234fbff809f287516407c4138de4568646fd24fcf4c7e2f8c5", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting in", "select_category": "girl"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vehicle that the is sitting in?", "program_group_hash": "3c1ca133506d48234fbff809f287516407c4138de4568646fd24fcf4c7e2f8c5", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting in", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a car.", "question": "What is the vehicle that the girl is sitting in?", "question_id": "04880670", "semantic": [{"argument": "girl (2474596)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting in,o (2528492)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a car.", "question": "What is the vehicle that the cat is sitting in?", "question_id": "15350477", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (2355846)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,sitting in,o (2406393)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2528492"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "sitting in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2528492", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "2528492", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2474596", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2474596", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2474596"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2406393"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "sitting in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2406393", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "2406393", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2355846", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2355846", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2355846"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:63a99bd2edb4894ccb01367496487f9f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b66146a9d72026e260f891890b6c561a524aed12da4ee459354891ebb4463219", "image_sha256_b": "bb8423cd48dd527504bc836955616d35a5f3594b1c229b8b1a5f2096780806c7", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5f76d1758c52b8a92358eee75729b34513784bd5dcee4d2e9a39b12ef36df0ff", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e6a4342a008d71fee6dbab7212d62d3f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2b296cbbd53cdfad6c590d677e9f11e993bb7da4682d9efed49e5d10f1d11060"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "236391bd1e4fb6aedc1d8ccb51008153bf647462d225ff09df52eec1069dc9a2", "request_id": "56aebd01b6e81ae2b6aa05a0700ea60b", "response_sha256": "48a32f6ffb257d05eb166f5b04641ea97d7ec3e0977d32fb92af9109a3832feb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6d4865785123f07d12d398eb6db148d5c6957166b2cf3b7676da901186153e7a", "request_id": "b0121058170e5f908a8debf8ce64b353", "response_sha256": "01d3aa6befa9fc7e6eb91bf14c909b74e4c4cb40f87ba05266047cfe82b551c8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "cefa16fbee5f199496e7f2d63fb23d5a", "candidate_priority_rank": 41, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9555dd0f624e1e2:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9555dd0f624e1e2:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9555dd0f624e1e2:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9555dd0f624e1e2:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cat", "B": "woman"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cat<->woman", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2406719", "image_sha256": "b5f9d8e78f987d3c9b30f96e9946655cf3ffbac0ffe56a0ba242811b799910d0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2406719.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2406719.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2388916", "image_sha256": "c8fade161e90c92394ac5ff99af9b7a9cea4fc0bfdb7d43025b0e2027a35af7f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388916.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388916.jpg", "width": 464}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9555dd0f624e1e2", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cat", "diff_b": "woman", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cat", "component_b": "woman"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "cable", "cables", "cat", "collar", "ear", "eye", "foot", "headphones", "laptop", "paw", "sheet", "tail", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f71ced46434bc9eee2136d9578f9d0ed07c83eaa726da437e70376daedda680d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07490129", "text": "What is the piece of furniture that this cat is on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "couch", "device", "floor", "foot", "glasses", "jeans", "laptop", "outlet", "remote control", "shirt", "tree", "wall", "wire", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0cc69d59c52a4a82710724f471c6fdef9e383cda4afe7a24d37d0cfea2124ebd"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18800093", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 41, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e1a2f0a725d29960cb442cf6d1e17980ac7aa7e8ef5a34d8291b6bb3a749df01", "selected_component": "woman", "selected_source_question_id": "18800093", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the piece of furniture that this woman is on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that this is on?", "program_group_hash": "e1a2f0a725d29960cb442cf6d1e17980ac7aa7e8ef5a34d8291b6bb3a749df01", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that this is on?", "program_group_hash": "e1a2f0a725d29960cb442cf6d1e17980ac7aa7e8ef5a34d8291b6bb3a749df01", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "woman"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that this cat is on?", "question_id": "07490129", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (291224)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (291234)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a couch.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that this woman is on?", "question_id": "18800093", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (1265617)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (1265618)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["291234"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "291234", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "291234", "relation_subject_entity_id": "291224", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "291224", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["291224"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1265618"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "1265618", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "1265618", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1265617", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1265617", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1265617"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:cefa16fbee5f199496e7f2d63fb23d5a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b5f9d8e78f987d3c9b30f96e9946655cf3ffbac0ffe56a0ba242811b799910d0", "image_sha256_b": "c8fade161e90c92394ac5ff99af9b7a9cea4fc0bfdb7d43025b0e2027a35af7f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "71ee93e160bfbfcb7fa6b1d7314e12073a6e2bbaadc1121ca361e887203e46bf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a3aa9107a8b4b65d46ba942018d20eda", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "454041028af122c7569a7c3985af019773e7e5204a0fbe91ba9df790b41ea3d3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6fe94604c4b80bc8a2f81f34335bdbb7153def7906f110bfbf1cccfac8341b3f", "request_id": "c45870acb38d6e132ccc2f77fcbe8af3", "response_sha256": "dbc0730baf61a6e43e0b95c1352ba7c4b5627654126aa73ba69cae439ac6408a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ecd6616e3d6aa708de7808f9d1dad5b4cdfb7a977094efc06cce3e30e9c9a0bc", "request_id": "000fdbf7626f01c0d1f82fd6717e2376", "response_sha256": "ce8aa7eeb52e4fd97c899fce3de529754b682cdc8dac29b48f8142dee3276140", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "327a09e53bd8c2055b40e59b8bd9f9aa", "candidate_priority_rank": 42, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cae075ed3be48c73:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cae075ed3be48c73:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cae075ed3be48c73:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cae075ed3be48c73:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bookcase<->sofa", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bookcase", "B": "sofa"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bookcase<->sofa", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2380643", "image_sha256": "7c2f64927cf9c56a28384223be9f0b889404638678a54014ae4818000bd2d1b0", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2380643.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2380643.jpg", "width": 400}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2341670", "image_sha256": "0c8d75abee373e014fdde60a4a69ff4483d971847090bfb14fefaa57de6b2554", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2341670.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2341670.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cae075ed3be48c73", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bookcase", "diff_b": "sofa", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bookcase", "component_b": "sofa"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "book", "bookcase", "ear", "eye", "head", "leg", "letter", "mouth", "nose", "shelf", "teddy bear", "word"], "detected_components": ["bookcase"], "masked_program_sha256": "d8e3b4db357843c2d2f75a990715771d2b5521cb70cb08d9290ef0450ffc6fb3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bookcase", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bookcase", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bookcase", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "530a6cd12aa39b487751c5382eb14040347da60b83bda4afbefa97606beb8400"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "001042989", "text": "What toy is sitting on the bookcase?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "ear", "eye", "hands", "head", "leg", "nose", "sofa", "teddy bear", "wall"], "detected_components": ["sofa"], "masked_program_sha256": "d8e3b4db357843c2d2f75a990715771d2b5521cb70cb08d9290ef0450ffc6fb3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sofa", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sofa", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sofa", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "88f5d9ff8bdf949c40a23b3993a664e6aa597f7b19a0c9c7f30e7eaa907827b0"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17779145", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 42, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e528d02f4f914f480748e18c94e0785888f4fac77225101c6c4dc0e5d5065ea2", "selected_component": "sofa", "selected_source_question_id": "17779145", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What toy is sitting on the sofa?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,sitting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what toy is sitting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "e528d02f4f914f480748e18c94e0785888f4fac77225101c6c4dc0e5d5065ea2", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "bookcase"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,sitting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what toy is sitting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "e528d02f4f914f480748e18c94e0785888f4fac77225101c6c4dc0e5d5065ea2", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "sofa"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "teddy bear", "full_answer": "The toy is a teddy bear.", "question": "What toy is sitting on the bookcase?", "question_id": "001042989", "semantic": [{"argument": "bookcase (1344255)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,sitting on,s (1344254)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "teddy bear", "full_answer": "The toy is a teddy bear.", "question": "What toy is sitting on the sofa?", "question_id": "17779145", "semantic": [{"argument": "sofa (940769)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,sitting on,s (940768)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1344254"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["teddy bear"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "furry", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "1344254", "query_target_entity_name": "teddy bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "1344255", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1344254", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1344255", "selected_entity_name": "bookcase"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bookcase", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1344255"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sofa", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bookcase", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["940768"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["teddy bear"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["furry", "fuzzy", "light brown", "stuffed", "toy"], "query_target_entity_id": "940768", "query_target_entity_name": "teddy bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "940769", "relation_subject_entity_id": "940768", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "940769", "selected_entity_name": "sofa"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sofa", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["940769"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:327a09e53bd8c2055b40e59b8bd9f9aa", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7c2f64927cf9c56a28384223be9f0b889404638678a54014ae4818000bd2d1b0", "image_sha256_b": "0c8d75abee373e014fdde60a4a69ff4483d971847090bfb14fefaa57de6b2554", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "98be1a077d644695ae561417c748987832a501a01f2254fe15636d67927cd7e2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "443dfa77c62af6a8483460c78b760ca1", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "cdb7f270772b34b05f2f40d71cb261b0b32f1ce7849fb803f03cf4f66cf3b2af"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3450600d04d5732393443e990c7d4d9fe32cb1bbfa0f85539a8d7cf5387bcaf6", "request_id": "d0e5c3fc4fa117090aa90ad5d98a563f", "response_sha256": "a8511a93ada8a6b1a243d829b9db94347100efa5849c95068c807d0245a39b81", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4ac3c3ced95f301ceedf072d580446f0bdc5bc6e8d05ea518d014777289fe120", "request_id": "3f6ed58d735d4ad0197431300c042840", "response_sha256": "8e1e6e724e96461794e3d3c7a6335df23dc4bc9e541a9075d96a650569337f13", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "139b35ae42e760d514d0a30c57639226", "candidate_priority_rank": 57, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68808576535582ed:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68808576535582ed:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68808576535582ed:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68808576535582ed:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cutting board<->paper", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cutting board", "B": "paper"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cutting board<->paper", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 348, "image_id": "2393177", "image_sha256": "d0baa67c11e520981222a27cdcbdd88eb4547dd77acb2924809123b57db4f568", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2393177.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2393177.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2389789", "image_sha256": "a7241d194219661a54172c7ad4c2cd409e4124fa08495f7262132cacd21fed82", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389789.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389789.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68808576535582ed", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cutting board", "diff_b": "paper", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cutting board", "component_b": "paper"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blueberry", "cheesecake", "cream", "crust", "cutting board", "foot", "napkins", "pie", "plate", "table"], "detected_components": ["cutting board"], "masked_program_sha256": "24b787120c3f577c9b23eb4b9be9c5016c1e6a19976e570fb649a3ff935369fc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cutting board", "baked good"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cutting board", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cutting board", "baked good"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8d1f824e0bae4588a229734ca7fd7658deef37c36eacc4d7cf719fb945e1948b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05621925", "text": "What kind of baked good is above the cutting board?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bacon", "bun", "crust", "cup", "fork", "meat", "paper", "pepper", "salt", "seeds", "table", "towels"], "detected_components": ["paper"], "masked_program_sha256": "24b787120c3f577c9b23eb4b9be9c5016c1e6a19976e570fb649a3ff935369fc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "baked good"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "paper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "baked good"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "34d1de94c74cf1fdd5f9af022b9f188f24eea6b07f1a9ca0a24140d87c3e49a8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13702353", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 57, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2ded3ae347e27fb6dadb099acc6270e372bbf1531a7c56e29ab47704985074b7", "selected_component": "paper", "selected_source_question_id": "13702353", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of baked good is above the paper?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of baked good is above the ?", "program_group_hash": "2ded3ae347e27fb6dadb099acc6270e372bbf1531a7c56e29ab47704985074b7", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "cutting board"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of baked good is above the ?", "program_group_hash": "2ded3ae347e27fb6dadb099acc6270e372bbf1531a7c56e29ab47704985074b7", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "paper"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pie", "full_answer": "The food is a pie.", "question": "What kind of baked good is above the cutting board?", "question_id": "05621925", "semantic": [{"argument": "cutting board (1222215)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,above,s (1222217)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bun", "full_answer": "The food is a bun.", "question": "What kind of baked good is above the paper?", "question_id": "13702353", "semantic": [{"argument": "paper (1257175)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,above,s (1257172)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1222217"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pie"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1222217", "query_target_entity_name": "pie", "relation_object_entity_id": "1222215", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1222217", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1222215", "selected_entity_name": "cutting board"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cutting board", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1222215"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cutting board", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1257172"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bun"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1257172", "query_target_entity_name": "bun", "relation_object_entity_id": "1257175", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1257172", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1257175", "selected_entity_name": "paper"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1257175"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:139b35ae42e760d514d0a30c57639226", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d0baa67c11e520981222a27cdcbdd88eb4547dd77acb2924809123b57db4f568", "image_sha256_b": "a7241d194219661a54172c7ad4c2cd409e4124fa08495f7262132cacd21fed82", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ea9f34e9e8b6ff309c82d892bc90473410cbeee37ccf43f858d7c7a73d692c74", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "6969f2f2627b1b4512ec9c7bdd7c7cd4", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3d2477ff6747bb036bce886086042bcbfdc0bfcc6c0c6a2636a24e101895fac0"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ab1b42676f32ff17deb04b2785e2986b6cf00e9e2f3e4446567f4da732028037", "request_id": "88c94045694d5fd91f2d9e5f60532d37", "response_sha256": "29f43e513303dda74f17aea84e365a2ab5ac72591dd9852728a0e4d1170f3a40", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7e6c3673c77fc24d7a1fb19c5e642f4315519bed645394d8412ca38c33159ec6", "request_id": "fd5cd557685fb46b078cbac3dc6777bc", "response_sha256": "582d157aa551c10bc023efa9b4018bf5df55513c8728e75a2038081c02537b89", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "60a63c811527e6c56c2e2f5995f58482", "candidate_priority_rank": 61, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2b016e5960d2cda8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2b016e5960d2cda8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2b016e5960d2cda8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2b016e5960d2cda8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "giraffe<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "giraffe"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->giraffe", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2394406", "image_sha256": "5ff4e44a0704689bb21a040da11469bd01ec014160ba8d2b6db45960b70b1acf", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2394406.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2394406.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2364521", "image_sha256": "18bb7311db9664c77fdb6d60edf1653410080438038a39a6975f208787c903f4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364521.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364521.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2b016e5960d2cda8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "giraffe", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "giraffe"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["head", "helmet", "man", "parking lot", "ski", "snow", "suv", "tire"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "29b706afd4fba01a2d6f6ecc85ef5790bb740741db5ae5d1601c1810e2923c07", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "36c817f3f07ea5433e08058e6a7d5635a81cbf9d1729c67e8719cf8aca34f93b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16245349", "text": "What is the man walking through?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "giraffe", "hair", "hay", "head", "leg", "neck", "sheep", "spots", "window"], "detected_components": ["giraffe"], "masked_program_sha256": "29b706afd4fba01a2d6f6ecc85ef5790bb740741db5ae5d1601c1810e2923c07", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "giraffe", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f1548fa7b2e7513a12a6ebd07db61abc33b468b5e8d355eec42b144a9e7cbad0"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01388628", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 61, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9ae65e88585e99ddd8011c640074899f876bba128ac3c6e7be03bac67dd5ff8c", "selected_component": "giraffe", "selected_source_question_id": "01388628", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the giraffe walking through?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,walking through,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the walking through?", "program_group_hash": "9ae65e88585e99ddd8011c640074899f876bba128ac3c6e7be03bac67dd5ff8c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "walking through", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,walking through,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the walking through?", "program_group_hash": "9ae65e88585e99ddd8011c640074899f876bba128ac3c6e7be03bac67dd5ff8c", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "walking through", "select_category": "giraffe"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "parking lot", "full_answer": "The man is walking through the parking lot.", "question": "What is the man walking through?", "question_id": "16245349", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (666894)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,walking through,o (666895)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hay", "full_answer": "The giraffe is walking through the hay.", "question": "What is the giraffe walking through?", "question_id": "01388628", "semantic": [{"argument": "giraffe (1779147)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,walking through,o (3738119)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["666893", "666895", "666900", "666905", "666906", "666907", "666909", "666910"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["parking lot"], "predicate": "walking through", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "666895", "query_target_entity_name": "parking lot", "relation_object_entity_id": "666895", "relation_subject_entity_id": "666894", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "666894", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["666894"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2099912", "2113333", "2212226", "2392347", "2507189", "2651399", "3738109", "3738110", "3738111", "3738112", "3738113", "3738116", "3738119", "3738122"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hay"], "predicate": "walking through", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["dried"], "query_target_entity_id": "3738119", "query_target_entity_name": "hay", "relation_object_entity_id": "3738119", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1779147", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1779147", "selected_entity_name": "giraffe"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1779147"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:60a63c811527e6c56c2e2f5995f58482", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5ff4e44a0704689bb21a040da11469bd01ec014160ba8d2b6db45960b70b1acf", "image_sha256_b": "18bb7311db9664c77fdb6d60edf1653410080438038a39a6975f208787c903f4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "9081d6afd8a5faea04a88e93c0dd078b4e40890aaba1f4486a040c14ea66b3b3", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e2ec4ee0fd03d81d5eb45980e903fcc4", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "84caa9c667c3a3596c5589e24ba5bce670521ac8895890b17729bbe17f1a1158"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d7ea7051da1d47e7cb47bcd0081beca015f568be148055784423599e7e38c1f6", "request_id": "42aee552eaca005f0816041cc0737403", "response_sha256": "029baecdfc57cae83a33c22a68f837f1f0d1a833eb1563d8a12223bfde9c1863", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8439838b740bf36fbd44b2cf9ea7e1e4ca075ecdc2499b4f607023086dced9ba", "request_id": "2aea8bc443715481fc6bf3f38eaaf323", "response_sha256": "1bd339aec77e6eef342b4d253384e98b5dbe18999c7f3619ca8f64524c427e61", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "1e3f874547186b345642a6b69c0647e0", "candidate_priority_rank": 62, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3071f4e70261d419:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3071f4e70261d419:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3071f4e70261d419:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3071f4e70261d419:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bun<->table", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "table", "B": "bun"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "table<->bun", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2408917", "image_sha256": "6e073c6335c05399cd78c66c1dbc66bcf77d95cc5fa6b9b7458ef3bd1532346e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408917.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408917.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 266, "image_id": "2325342", "image_sha256": "c5c13ae8ce6a27e2efeac2e1ee83979cdce2dc61fc8815253de9da941aab692f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2325342.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2325342.jpg", "width": 400}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3071f4e70261d419", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "table", "diff_b": "bun", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "table", "component_b": "bun"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["broccoli", "carrot", "eye", "face", "grape", "mouth", "nose", "table", "watermelon"], "detected_components": ["table"], "masked_program_sha256": "5c4ca9bf4a8052c7beda3f9f4713aa344c1ff0b8ec2b6259a7383b79e2e4ad6b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "fruit"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "table", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "fruit"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2e3886f9aa2e3828afad4df02edafc8cad5210ce38701c9695a4c5480bc50eb4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16878348", "text": "What kind of fruit is above the table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["banana", "bun", "food", "napkin", "paper towel", "peanut butter", "table"], "detected_components": ["bun"], "masked_program_sha256": "5c4ca9bf4a8052c7beda3f9f4713aa344c1ff0b8ec2b6259a7383b79e2e4ad6b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bun", "fruit"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bun", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bun", "fruit"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "04979c24ff5ef86d3bf515cfccfe7be0b5eab165185307409bfb6c8c29306c97"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00670041", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 62, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "43ba3a6c7dc5f003cf07a3c7f730aa3de16831c619c85fb3fb714e9fe281adcd", "selected_component": "bun", "selected_source_question_id": "00670041", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of fruit is above the bun?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fruit is above the ?", "program_group_hash": "43ba3a6c7dc5f003cf07a3c7f730aa3de16831c619c85fb3fb714e9fe281adcd", "queried_category": "fruit", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fruit is above the ?", "program_group_hash": "43ba3a6c7dc5f003cf07a3c7f730aa3de16831c619c85fb3fb714e9fe281adcd", "queried_category": "fruit", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "bun"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "watermelon", "full_answer": "The fruit is a watermelon.", "question": "What kind of fruit is above the table?", "question_id": "16878348", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (252663)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,above,s (252648)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "banana", "full_answer": "The fruit is a banana.", "question": "What kind of fruit is above the bun?", "question_id": "00670041", "semantic": [{"argument": "bun (3490898)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,above,s (2722986)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["252648", "252659", "252660"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["watermelon"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["round"], "query_target_entity_id": "252648", "query_target_entity_name": "watermelon", "relation_object_entity_id": "252663", "relation_subject_entity_id": "252648", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "252663", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["252663"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bun", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2722986", "3307019"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3941661"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2722986", "3307019"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["banana"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2722986", "query_target_entity_name": "banana", "relation_object_entity_id": "3490898", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2722986", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3490898", "selected_entity_name": "bun"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bun", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3490898"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1e3f874547186b345642a6b69c0647e0", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6e073c6335c05399cd78c66c1dbc66bcf77d95cc5fa6b9b7458ef3bd1532346e", "image_sha256_b": "c5c13ae8ce6a27e2efeac2e1ee83979cdce2dc61fc8815253de9da941aab692f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "125da38165212b3591459be80936f51570f0b5de8ac99bdb33813f866c7e7daf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a9e32018448b04d5f75b75672d7899e2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "92358098a573443c126203f6072c06c428b0aef039101c5c4a4b24fc3939c593"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "07f0755b82840e738871554fdf65873785e2451a49beed9073c68d29840f9d15", "request_id": "c8fca304414a5ad812445b10b5397d90", "response_sha256": "1b605492b06824c2aed5d9637027a1e43eeedc589781ee8b24db2f33a1160fce", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f4e6b18807e667ef9952fb5cff0fbd93cd8f7237652573bfe1d3ae03ca1338fc", "request_id": "47c07365ad1d051bbb004380a28f1065", "response_sha256": "b11e933a36fe87e562f1664000c58bd1d09e94b8643dcdc3fba152b5b64d9870", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "0ed37e0c22dfc2dd746f2cb060a00394", "candidate_priority_rank": 63, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4be97519de12aae8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4be97519de12aae8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4be97519de12aae8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4be97519de12aae8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bed<->pillow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "pillow", "B": "bed"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "pillow<->bed", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2395473", "image_sha256": "02c46fd302825c289bca69d0258f17a634c6aa990c893144543dcf5c4153fcad", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395473.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395473.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2411207", "image_sha256": "b768411da9281707613d3d52b4908d29e0e91ff4d4345f0e5fc8842eb8896767", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2411207.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2411207.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4be97519de12aae8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "pillow", "diff_b": "bed", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "pillow", "component_b": "bed"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["book", "bookcase", "carpet", "cross", "curtains", "dog", "ear", "eye", "head", "nose", "paw", "pillow", "speaker", "stuffed animal", "tail", "window"], "detected_components": ["pillow"], "masked_program_sha256": "b13e44f8e4412b70e297e51c43c4cb5e60254237650037696c97be387f934cf5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pillow", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pillow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pillow", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "50a8844ac837b0c3f619fce3ae6066262d3a1156849007ed65429afd21c292d8"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11889063", "text": "What animal is resting on the pillow?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bed", "cat", "ear", "hand", "head", "nose", "sheet", "wii", "wii controller"], "detected_components": ["bed"], "masked_program_sha256": "b13e44f8e4412b70e297e51c43c4cb5e60254237650037696c97be387f934cf5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bed", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9ea2f92733a8751df52b3ed4616ae3c32f0a091406c4dd95adef76f14cb86d68"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16747880", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 63, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 14, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "aad513da51a6069004a367aaed183cf10976d38daa6eca45e93fcd5e97f34116", "selected_component": "bed", "selected_source_question_id": "16747880", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is resting on the bed?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is resting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "aad513da51a6069004a367aaed183cf10976d38daa6eca45e93fcd5e97f34116", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "pillow"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is resting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "aad513da51a6069004a367aaed183cf10976d38daa6eca45e93fcd5e97f34116", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "bed"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is resting on the pillow.", "question": "What animal is resting on the pillow?", "question_id": "11889063", "semantic": [{"argument": "pillow (454231)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s (454230)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is resting on the bed.", "question": "What animal is resting on the bed?", "question_id": "16747880", "semantic": [{"argument": "bed (1081811)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s (360140)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["454230"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "lying", "sleepy"], "query_target_entity_id": "454230", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "454231", "relation_subject_entity_id": "454230", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "454231", "selected_entity_name": "pillow"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pillow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["454231"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pillow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["360140"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "360140", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1081811", "relation_subject_entity_id": "360140", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1081811", "selected_entity_name": "bed"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1081811"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0ed37e0c22dfc2dd746f2cb060a00394", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "02c46fd302825c289bca69d0258f17a634c6aa990c893144543dcf5c4153fcad", "image_sha256_b": "b768411da9281707613d3d52b4908d29e0e91ff4d4345f0e5fc8842eb8896767", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5fc0920e43f5ed635eac7dd95b8a84160fa4b3652ec79d145c9c4b35d2565918", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9e19223f0d49247e54ddf15eabfdd01d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "58abef188581333a25731f6505ec392a3c455941d51dbd7ced892ba26a552bb5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1da6cd07e34958695807964462a6a3dae25350e316c1af7e6e93d6c4640b6a4c", "request_id": "b0e68356e554ad454137ecec9ac68b60", "response_sha256": "ac5dfe8c4a47ef0e2213728bfafbc99d9c9cb1f05fa73ad2aebda13e4f95b562", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "23242eea3a24521d1a53f3600750d10e5f275fa82ffeb4e34fada2c0af344684", "request_id": "7358ec2841d272eb7e6869759499efd0", "response_sha256": "1fc3a8c30fd4d2521f0633ee854d759f4f47e679c20c6502b3d39dcf8baee963", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "7e73cf0dfb79c49b14f181cc607a9376", "candidate_priority_rank": 64, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec32963747f6a61:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec32963747f6a61:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec32963747f6a61:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec32963747f6a61:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2362743", "image_sha256": "d208ad6b56b6d5d833fc1d01b4876ee6c5ec3235a6eb8f430f7d0e4a6499c5fc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2362743.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2362743.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2411207", "image_sha256": "b768411da9281707613d3d52b4908d29e0e91ff4d4345f0e5fc8842eb8896767", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2411207.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2411207.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dec32963747f6a61", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["fingers", "hand", "leg", "man", "pants", "paper", "phone", "shirt", "shoe", "sidewalk", "socks", "wall"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e7fd9b96d64e6a138581cd2db3144186d933001e3e861b3f7882c8da2a3fbedb"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04602061", "text": "What is this man lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bed", "cat", "ear", "hand", "head", "nose", "sheet", "wii", "wii controller"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "caed50c8d27aaba2ff46fe7a086db089477558621772c5fd9f5a5eb43820cf6f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16747871", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 64, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6bdb4e7d9c3021d0dfe72b24995ac6efb02332f0db528ff4730124c74dbfd8f2", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "16747871", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this cat lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this lying on?", "program_group_hash": "6bdb4e7d9c3021d0dfe72b24995ac6efb02332f0db528ff4730124c74dbfd8f2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this lying on?", "program_group_hash": "6bdb4e7d9c3021d0dfe72b24995ac6efb02332f0db528ff4730124c74dbfd8f2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "sidewalk", "full_answer": "The man is lying on the sidewalk.", "question": "What is this man lying on?", "question_id": "04602061", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (771564)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (771568)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the bed.", "question": "What is this cat lying on?", "question_id": "16747871", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (360140)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (1081811)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["771563", "771565", "771566", "771568", "771569", "771571", "771572", "771573", "771574", "771575", "771576", "771577", "771578", "771579"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sidewalk"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "771568", "query_target_entity_name": "sidewalk", "relation_object_entity_id": "771568", "relation_subject_entity_id": "771564", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "771564", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["771564"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1081802", "1081803", "1081805", "1081807", "1081808", "1081809", "1081811", "1081812", "360136", "360137", "360139"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1081811", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "1081811", "relation_subject_entity_id": "360140", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "360140", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["360140"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:7e73cf0dfb79c49b14f181cc607a9376", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d208ad6b56b6d5d833fc1d01b4876ee6c5ec3235a6eb8f430f7d0e4a6499c5fc", "image_sha256_b": "b768411da9281707613d3d52b4908d29e0e91ff4d4345f0e5fc8842eb8896767", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7ab77d86213b11838eec1a709f8870ca4d666c9ad4a77f9fc02a9431ec7806cd", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "865bd76d57dcdf6b86ec4f17925eb86b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "20683b1f11db4c7685ecc1453bcb0c68d248e208e303761dc191800ddf8b9be3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5a5e4dd53886d97f568a1fbac6d29d253bb7c29c158c6d821e1ae62c349f42c6", "request_id": "647a3aa63e598d286fa388dba8663838", "response_sha256": "8fbb3819dca5dfd3fd35d1b5ecd9affa6739f07121d89b987f4698de5ae46a1e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "65cd6d0e0cddfbcd69bc1c8dc59eaf0d4c7dda8c4578fe4820f4ab6d6b1b084d", "request_id": "6cb1d1fdcb8724f4891ec4363d5fce29", "response_sha256": "81b21a095e33362bf4d136583ea61095b16357eb9d1309b371cb2e018f822df2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a28c39af15cff8f67b75a52a75f03289", "candidate_priority_rank": 74, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1dfe450e616c6fda:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1dfe450e616c6fda:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1dfe450e616c6fda:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1dfe450e616c6fda:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "brush<->camera", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "brush", "B": "camera"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "brush<->camera", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2365615", "image_sha256": "bec6958fb8c45939ac9921b8797105d58009ef19045ab16f0bd7a0773ff80f78", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365615.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365615.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2343042", "image_sha256": "d645943cd6d00dcd6e4863db82809a0ab4d4e3acd80371f14c7ac3fa2966e644", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2343042.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2343042.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1dfe450e616c6fda", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "brush", "diff_b": "camera", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "brush", "component_b": "camera"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["belt", "boy", "brush", "ear", "eyes", "face", "hair", "hand", "hat", "head", "horses", "jeans", "leaf", "leg", "mane", "shirt", "sun", "tail"], "detected_components": ["brush"], "masked_program_sha256": "74d449568575bb97759832ad2139159f9821f45d9856dc8c799eeab7fdea13ab", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["brush"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "brush", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["brush"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bb884c46dbc00394ad092cc86b4f29873ed809ddd8bbb1d5b5efcd1b5b3cd023"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "1787832", "text": "What animals are facing the brush?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bucket", "camera", "cow", "cows", "ear", "field", "ground", "leg", "legs", "tag", "tail"], "detected_components": ["camera"], "masked_program_sha256": "74d449568575bb97759832ad2139159f9821f45d9856dc8c799eeab7fdea13ab", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["camera"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "camera", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["camera"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3018b65fe84a85cf8558650742408206d2f26257de53164111ae468cf7a7bf43"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1193941", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 74, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0f005418627514a9f578e6196e9f27e852f9b8a95ce5efa730cc7bfb4e8a2b19", "selected_component": "camera", "selected_source_question_id": "1193941", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animals are facing the camera?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,facing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are facing the ?", "program_group_hash": "0f005418627514a9f578e6196e9f27e852f9b8a95ce5efa730cc7bfb4e8a2b19", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "facing", "select_category": "brush"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,facing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are facing the ?", "program_group_hash": "0f005418627514a9f578e6196e9f27e852f9b8a95ce5efa730cc7bfb4e8a2b19", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "facing", "select_category": "camera"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "horses", "full_answer": "The animals are horses.", "question": "What animals are facing the brush?", "question_id": "1787832", "semantic": [{"argument": "brush (632930)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,facing,s (632931)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cows", "full_answer": "The animals are cows.", "question": "What animals are facing the camera?", "question_id": "1193941", "semantic": [{"argument": "camera (3643039)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,facing,s (3183138)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["632931"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horses"], "predicate": "facing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["standing"], "query_target_entity_id": "632931", "query_target_entity_name": "horses", "relation_object_entity_id": "632930", "relation_subject_entity_id": "632931", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "632930", "selected_entity_name": "brush"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "brush", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["632930"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "camera", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "brush", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2401342", "2473166", "3086724", "3183138"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cows"], "predicate": "facing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3183138", "query_target_entity_name": "cows", "relation_object_entity_id": "3643039", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3183138", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3643039", "selected_entity_name": "camera"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "camera", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3643039"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a28c39af15cff8f67b75a52a75f03289", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bec6958fb8c45939ac9921b8797105d58009ef19045ab16f0bd7a0773ff80f78", "image_sha256_b": "d645943cd6d00dcd6e4863db82809a0ab4d4e3acd80371f14c7ac3fa2966e644", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "569e9959f635a731d9c6a73c2c6a957d457ecdb1bf694a97c50ec264e719cad6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9f3ac17d8c2d285135da56f1d9f8d66d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "01701154af4fa1289b269083696d40373fb238c40e836c3db7ecb571da114188"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3b1ce7b0854d608941da7ebd61ec3d874afa7b21aad7e36397a716da88c86f87", "request_id": "a492ff023eb8c3836f9921aa8cb16307", "response_sha256": "b75f5dc7daaf2063db33457999b45d06b1bae07ccfd71cc33bfd6b65441b93b0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "895eb515ba0e1966e493661b6a4accb4e22355b5155c0d1c92f49fcf032e7ba4", "request_id": "17e38eabd605967d7ee79317b471cf23", "response_sha256": "b29641bc435b57f9afc2091be5e91bd462c55b69838eea09242a3ae336141e76", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "b6a1c2223f3978a5300764cd8ee436a9", "candidate_priority_rank": 75, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b8d98b98c0daa574:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b8d98b98c0daa574:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b8d98b98c0daa574:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b8d98b98c0daa574:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "boy<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "boy"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->boy", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2394763", "image_sha256": "22ccc5d65f70d52d93a906d8cf7b3a164f95d0343ede8f07cddcaffdb98ea35e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2394763.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2394763.jpg", "width": 324}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2364460", "image_sha256": "dbbe0a98249fd27612aaf2c52cfcbce6f68173afa2131b97582dd7215a378c6e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364460.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364460.jpg", "width": 366}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b8d98b98c0daa574", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "boy", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "boy"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "garment", "hair", "head", "mirror", "neck", "teeth", "toothbrush", "wall", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "5b69f25bfc173a31ef2acb8206616334a689f7735ea7e72f16194ad28d945b2d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2a45c5b9e1f0f21edc7708a0ed10e1530f99e1cf9f9447db8fe4fbd50e2b0b0c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11444791", "text": "What is this woman looking at?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "boy", "bracelet", "flower", "flower pot", "grass", "ground", "hand", "house", "plant", "road", "shoe", "shorts", "sidewalk", "skateboard", "socks", "sun", "tree", "window", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["boy"], "masked_program_sha256": "5b69f25bfc173a31ef2acb8206616334a689f7735ea7e72f16194ad28d945b2d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "boy", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b177b7e65372300eb8c6b6d99823524359042930834523cbcf98b0d0067afeac"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04293918", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 75, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2dce12281f20c2649c6d0e8abae121f98f76887be4414d71174cd04c31428ab9", "selected_component": "boy", "selected_source_question_id": "04293918", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this boy looking at?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this looking at?", "program_group_hash": "2dce12281f20c2649c6d0e8abae121f98f76887be4414d71174cd04c31428ab9", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking at", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this looking at?", "program_group_hash": "2dce12281f20c2649c6d0e8abae121f98f76887be4414d71174cd04c31428ab9", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking at", "select_category": "boy"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "mirror", "full_answer": "The woman is looking at the mirror.", "question": "What is this woman looking at?", "question_id": "11444791", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (1209989)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking at,o (1209987)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "ground", "full_answer": "The boy is looking at the ground.", "question": "What is this boy looking at?", "question_id": "04293918", "semantic": [{"argument": "boy (1773820)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking at,o (1773821)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1209987", "1209988", "1209990", "1209991", "1209992", "1209997", "1209998", "1209999", "1210000", "1210001", "1210002", "1210003", "1210004"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mirror"], "predicate": "looking at", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "1209987", "query_target_entity_name": "mirror", "relation_object_entity_id": "1209987", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1209989", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1209989", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1209989"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1773821", "1814021", "1949679", "1949680", "1950887", "2178395", "2195088", "2195089", "2195091", "2195092", "2200986", "2200987", "2213565", "2215536", "2367646", "2471966", "2520093", "2611110", "2653977", "3738664", "3738666", "3738667", "3738668", "3738670", "3738671", "3738672", "3738675"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 27, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ground"], "predicate": "looking at", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1773821", "query_target_entity_name": "ground", "relation_object_entity_id": "1773821", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1773820", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1773820", "selected_entity_name": "boy"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boy", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1773820"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b6a1c2223f3978a5300764cd8ee436a9", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "22ccc5d65f70d52d93a906d8cf7b3a164f95d0343ede8f07cddcaffdb98ea35e", "image_sha256_b": "dbbe0a98249fd27612aaf2c52cfcbce6f68173afa2131b97582dd7215a378c6e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1fa812bbc2484f208e4d3eff48a2bff402cf45b25d9acc3c38a6898b61002bd9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c1715abc3326de822aa6fa06add74e6f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f84c04f6df5dc1c87c535f4dbe7b89633cf6445cea4defc85a6e7003a9ee93f5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c902a20262ce60747b29071e32eb0b81586d0695c70e62d6e17ca905a01ec9d3", "request_id": "5d8f9beca0c3aa8eac62d4f43161ad3d", "response_sha256": "110b2d55e58716ec08ef28a0769e710dda83b61210aaffba15ab0d889c75f674", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fc8e5c2e67f9a4dc8ebc600dd37b201d397084d7cdfac15bf079d07adc241c34", "request_id": "31eab944f7e0aa1128a31b1010e3dd86", "response_sha256": "a73d8232ccb046e5c7e859be4cb53d82d1dde616ca9d88befe0dec5c15334abb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "5780b5fdfcc3ee18b158085a9bd35be2", "candidate_priority_rank": 76, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-805b67e344a80a39:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-805b67e344a80a39:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-805b67e344a80a39:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-805b67e344a80a39:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bed<->ground", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bed", "B": "ground"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bed<->ground", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2390745", "image_sha256": "3ba5f8f891aee41276b015cefa573b8468c8d4091e766466d74dd7e0ffe99f1f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390745.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390745.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 685, "image_id": "61582", "image_sha256": "979cf020985dc764a7c2456fc58a7595c67b2d43485acd7eddbd0fbbf0669926", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/61582.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/61582.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-805b67e344a80a39", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bed", "diff_b": "ground", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bed", "component_b": "ground"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "dog", "dress", "ear", "eye", "floor", "hand", "head", "leg", "legs", "nose", "paw", "star"], "detected_components": ["bed"], "masked_program_sha256": "883d3e02afa92e18010e6b533480931f2d8b31caf3a8a41fd0bc9d637ab3519b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bed", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "126529878ca80006f7bc7a63b58d89318fd3d447f4f4fc0d94ebfeba01d03422"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18962202", "text": "What animal do you think is lying on the bed?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bugs", "cow", "ground", "head"], "detected_components": ["ground"], "masked_program_sha256": "883d3e02afa92e18010e6b533480931f2d8b31caf3a8a41fd0bc9d637ab3519b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ground", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8703fa1015c55b5b0785d325d53863881688b6489209e2b054d010d61810ef1d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19459462", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 76, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b0e0fe97581c8ddba2c732c4eed44664ac1241ed14a9c2e53987174e2dd75379", "selected_component": "ground", "selected_source_question_id": "19459462", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal do you think is lying on the ground?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal do you think is lying on the ?", "program_group_hash": "b0e0fe97581c8ddba2c732c4eed44664ac1241ed14a9c2e53987174e2dd75379", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "bed"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal do you think is lying on the ?", "program_group_hash": "b0e0fe97581c8ddba2c732c4eed44664ac1241ed14a9c2e53987174e2dd75379", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "ground"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the bed.", "question": "What animal do you think is lying on the bed?", "question_id": "18962202", "semantic": [{"argument": "bed (1247505)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (1247498)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cow", "full_answer": "The cow is lying on the ground.", "question": "What animal do you think is lying on the ground?", "question_id": "19459462", "semantic": [{"argument": "ground (4145477)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (4145476)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1247498"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "1247498", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "1247505", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1247498", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1247505", "selected_entity_name": "bed"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1247505"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4145476"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cow"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4145476", "query_target_entity_name": "cow", "relation_object_entity_id": "4145477", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4145476", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4145477", "selected_entity_name": "ground"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4145477"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:5780b5fdfcc3ee18b158085a9bd35be2", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3ba5f8f891aee41276b015cefa573b8468c8d4091e766466d74dd7e0ffe99f1f", "image_sha256_b": "979cf020985dc764a7c2456fc58a7595c67b2d43485acd7eddbd0fbbf0669926", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "18e56cfbe22302a40b2b88e04269660bd6457075a086102eb92b9010ed92bdf2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "feca672043c26cc690e132f410bf6c4c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e6d7de46ffb9848e090485c05a9c5817a587707efd7ff00c7f6e8d46acd3fc73"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b4515fba198579f910dbbc2d0ced610b4f1a18281aeffac905116e3981156821", "request_id": "cbac1b83c07ae0a3b8f7ac7a10cfa45e", "response_sha256": "ef8de72d1fab598a7fafe4e3addfaec56dad268279c098478c0654b3bfe93fc9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6b66ce4baaf0b601673d028998c30c5222c2b310f6ddb6e8e18f14719f47cc13", "request_id": "3f1be62a59d0dc05a8ee6084b3191045", "response_sha256": "1e730a4562d6568b1255bc511cff38c572dbda56a9258392c133e6a8c2973409", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "67bca22a462669dc98d65c05ace5b04c", "candidate_priority_rank": 79, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12ea77c3e4ff5330:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12ea77c3e4ff5330:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12ea77c3e4ff5330:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12ea77c3e4ff5330:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2408949", "image_sha256": "1e53e4daf2fec86f1db5ee16f53586ae0f1f16d07550f1601ba2238cefc6917b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408949.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408949.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2359509", "image_sha256": "5a6b48050afa98edd97a4d38d4c6573fb3b165f0ecddd7eb55236bee9244bc9d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2359509.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2359509.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12ea77c3e4ff5330", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bear", "couch", "eyes", "finger", "hair", "hand", "head", "pillow", "ring", "sheet", "shirt", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "018379a36fbc4a353ad0b61adc5076e4a816534943fd8690a21f208a3626fa7b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8cd16a504b8442debb1ddc142a63a6777ccd0ac8360fcead06fba621e89a1ebb"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07777020", "text": "What is the item of furniture that the woman is lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cable", "cat", "cords", "desk", "ears", "eyes", "head", "keyboard", "laptop", "nose", "screen", "speaker", "tag", "water"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "018379a36fbc4a353ad0b61adc5076e4a816534943fd8690a21f208a3626fa7b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f4c851ff8c1632280d3503f17664596a3897e501099f16ef0048f87164f0cd31"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05490131", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 79, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "630967e3baf7335bd03fe2a61fb78f18fb6d1b650c057ae8c69d61bff6ec09dc", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "05490131", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the item of furniture that the cat is lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that the is lying on?", "program_group_hash": "630967e3baf7335bd03fe2a61fb78f18fb6d1b650c057ae8c69d61bff6ec09dc", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that the is lying on?", "program_group_hash": "630967e3baf7335bd03fe2a61fb78f18fb6d1b650c057ae8c69d61bff6ec09dc", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a couch.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that the woman is lying on?", "question_id": "07777020", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (252121)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o (252127)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "desk", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a desk.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that the cat is lying on?", "question_id": "05490131", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (1967945)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o (1834660)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["252127"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "252127", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "252127", "relation_subject_entity_id": "252121", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "252121", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["252121"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1834660"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["desk"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1834660", "query_target_entity_name": "desk", "relation_object_entity_id": "1834660", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1967945", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1967945", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1967945"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:67bca22a462669dc98d65c05ace5b04c", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1e53e4daf2fec86f1db5ee16f53586ae0f1f16d07550f1601ba2238cefc6917b", "image_sha256_b": "5a6b48050afa98edd97a4d38d4c6573fb3b165f0ecddd7eb55236bee9244bc9d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "01b115f5ff4f1104ebeb59ebe44ef3ede2bc233f2ac40afb728516e7e087aa99", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "43d95c81133025a02b410b91e2c1faff", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "84448c39f48a6f597e00e539989ebcfa05364a81db24aea038b6472e845091c9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a7284b983ca821f2ceefe01fce256174d358ccc78d61ec44b5525fd699e058e9", "request_id": "7cb61dc1e81120cd82b1e7321c54ce71", "response_sha256": "a3673ff1e4782c083d070a57e17093940710c35ee9871d93d3231388fe6dde86", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e224067a24604a5986dd02e7dcf5564bcee51d78368a51317e70ee902915ca3f", "request_id": "23b59d18940fe39b5e13850ebaa11dba", "response_sha256": "2cc7db691e18fa6cee814d39827d13b86f73974ac2a9ff6c0c691085b71df46a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "3069d8a8c943719fa72f6a43e81d57f7", "candidate_priority_rank": 90, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e8c4fbe64f7cbd3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e8c4fbe64f7cbd3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e8c4fbe64f7cbd3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e8c4fbe64f7cbd3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "clothes<->stuffed animals", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "clothes", "B": "stuffed animals"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "clothes<->stuffed animals", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2399027", "image_sha256": "b4a2b915c3215939115c1a6b7bcdf22c265f2f28aff2ea5ef10a4911f9065281", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399027.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399027.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 313, "image_id": "2417462", "image_sha256": "0d725aec29c3a1dddf930e9b488562096ddf223d53a18704f2c8eea859f61bf9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2417462.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2417462.jpg", "width": 470}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e8c4fbe64f7cbd3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "clothes", "diff_b": "stuffed animals", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "clothes", "component_b": "stuffed animals"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "cat", "clothes", "ear", "eye", "eyes", "headboard", "nose", "pants", "pillow", "pocket", "shirt", "shorts", "socks", "sweater", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["clothes"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["clothes", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "clothes", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["clothes", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2441bd609b20ceaa0b54764a32dede9cc61f81e9ebeac8344f7f9bfb27006cac"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11196765", "text": "What is the piece of furniture that the clothes are on called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bear", "bears", "chair", "hearts", "stuffed animals"], "detected_components": ["stuffed animals"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["stuffed animals", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stuffed animals", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["stuffed animals", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "463780cd247c5c6153ab8e59fcb369ccb29695c6902dccbaa5a8b69c1fefe3c4"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01437155", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 90, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "bba2bd39f872f456e717711ae82a409f940275c10ecca8977a70bc895d2664d6", "selected_component": "stuffed animals", "selected_source_question_id": "01437155", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the piece of furniture that the stuffed animals are on called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that the are on called?", "program_group_hash": "bba2bd39f872f456e717711ae82a409f940275c10ecca8977a70bc895d2664d6", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "clothes"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the piece of furniture that the are on called?", "program_group_hash": "bba2bd39f872f456e717711ae82a409f940275c10ecca8977a70bc895d2664d6", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "stuffed animals"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that the clothes are on called?", "question_id": "11196765", "semantic": [{"argument": "clothes (1173091)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (1173090)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a chair.", "question": "What is the piece of furniture that the stuffed animals are on called?", "question_id": "01437155", "semantic": [{"argument": "stuffed animals (2860007)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (3557130)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1173090", "1173099"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1173090", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "1173090", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1173091", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1173091", "selected_entity_name": "clothes"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "clothes", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1173091"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stuffed animals", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "clothes", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3557130"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "large"], "query_target_entity_id": "3557130", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "3557130", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2860007", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2860007", "selected_entity_name": "stuffed animals"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stuffed animals", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2860007"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:3069d8a8c943719fa72f6a43e81d57f7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b4a2b915c3215939115c1a6b7bcdf22c265f2f28aff2ea5ef10a4911f9065281", "image_sha256_b": "0d725aec29c3a1dddf930e9b488562096ddf223d53a18704f2c8eea859f61bf9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "47063a9f2299068bba6b78919085a3a0e89b10ef9ae79a5f08b0a07316c26842", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ef1335aed4b0a5ca5937f0a100b86028", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "348ead62d481c70a5648200bfdd7a36ffcf1f8c799709989d3d45cb051ac63a9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1998d671bae487a02f7fc5fa5d1cd2d0b4dd0d6defa5f52e61d4ea3ddbe50ade", "request_id": "d59303cada47b3f22e879a1de5b6e73e", "response_sha256": "1096525f99b8416826afe197771201cff583763283cabd68c7baa564da5273ad", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fec301195e9bf1c51cc4aecd62facdbcba171971ae1d4ad623f6285c81ac8d0a", "request_id": "96b55d98213ff1ed43a2a101fd08e9e5", "response_sha256": "911771173f560ea9492f63e51633ac3f9a3b982c25160b7e9ff1db740eecc72b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "1adee59576208abb4ad48c593a79c74e", "candidate_priority_rank": 91, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37efbde6ab60d07f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37efbde6ab60d07f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37efbde6ab60d07f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37efbde6ab60d07f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->zebra", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "zebra", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "zebra<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2395874", "image_sha256": "1d4c8b7d8022e8371dd3390f21d6a193122e426498079623342f47a08b1c01f6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395874.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395874.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2317863", "image_sha256": "16a78b98f30691b1687ba9d6e86d1e256ea2010353c01d7b6335949f3c4b603e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317863.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317863.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37efbde6ab60d07f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "zebra", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "zebra", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "jacket", "jeans", "trees", "windshield", "zebra"], "detected_components": ["zebra"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["zebra"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "zebra", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["zebra"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "38cba61cbdebcbf8427c1a93ae0cb3ee62701f51767dd941696d417179644459"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01888023", "text": "What do you think is the zebra inside of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "cat", "collar", "dog", "ear", "eyes", "phone", "pillow", "suitcase", "table"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "405c8a826a46ff24dc83cbed7083a699b4f65e395e25d35ec549ef1482d10966"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06985540", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 91, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "862171eb602ac25ef21c36f74ca75e761fa12fb9a6ed319bee3074ba275b2914", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "06985540", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What do you think is the cat inside of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what do you think is the inside of?", "program_group_hash": "862171eb602ac25ef21c36f74ca75e761fa12fb9a6ed319bee3074ba275b2914", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "zebra"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what do you think is the inside of?", "program_group_hash": "862171eb602ac25ef21c36f74ca75e761fa12fb9a6ed319bee3074ba275b2914", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The zebra is inside the car.", "question": "What do you think is the zebra inside of?", "question_id": "01888023", "semantic": [{"argument": "zebra (665622)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (665623)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "suitcase", "full_answer": "The cat is inside the suitcase.", "question": "What do you think is the cat inside of?", "question_id": "06985540", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (1016673)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (1016677)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["665623", "665624", "665625", "665627", "665629"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "665623", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "665623", "relation_subject_entity_id": "665622", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "665622", "selected_entity_name": "zebra"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "zebra", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["665622"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "zebra", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1016674", "1016675", "1016676", "1016677", "1016678", "1016679", "1016680", "1016682", "1016685", "1016686"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["suitcase"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "1016677", "query_target_entity_name": "suitcase", "relation_object_entity_id": "1016677", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1016673", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1016673", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1016673"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1adee59576208abb4ad48c593a79c74e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1d4c8b7d8022e8371dd3390f21d6a193122e426498079623342f47a08b1c01f6", "image_sha256_b": "16a78b98f30691b1687ba9d6e86d1e256ea2010353c01d7b6335949f3c4b603e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d222a4274ea0dbaac61da51d9081a0aad696527225805688099898554e05c979", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1bd9db878514564d9b009966554a633e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "401318563970c45980f21dc4420bf9bada5a835a51b8dfaf536ebe4bc6d3d0c2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a639767095b4ca9f6748ee820986de8e03b278ad96117af9e850972e27622e2a", "request_id": "b710f82d711921fc7792be9db103b1fc", "response_sha256": "e3b7d6796d37e7735a3ac65c7dda90461ac25749717305abd36f14e9f5a0aeca", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1785a05c73b2667f99f59ce7c20e11797b82e6840db7381db1735497d230e918", "request_id": "1298230ac4f9b12260eabc49f7e8a5ff", "response_sha256": "671dc2ec0bcb6da60e07e968a137f79ab3a7ed0bebb87d3ca37f54322e7367b8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "f3d69460df76c829c959414b10fc3a0b", "candidate_priority_rank": 98, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-01322028240b0039:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-01322028240b0039:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-01322028240b0039:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-01322028240b0039:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bread<->sandwich", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sandwich", "B": "bread"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sandwich<->bread", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2378034", "image_sha256": "d1495ebfb071a5797388c7db191b9c53f4143c2450e65c22b030b0cd49c9586e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2378034.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2378034.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2392221", "image_sha256": "cfa3cbe7f5095c51a8ec8416ac49260a8b10ce1dd662384fa903bdd4b4d15350", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392221.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392221.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-01322028240b0039", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sandwich", "diff_b": "bread", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sandwich", "component_b": "bread"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beef", "bread", "carrot", "lettuce", "plate", "salad", "sandwich", "sauce", "table", "vegetable"], "detected_components": ["sandwich"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae4f2df839337ece0b966e1b9bdd5a0f20c09b0c8055c496cabc6326cf4d1774", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sandwich"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sandwich", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sandwich"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2c9ccd43043adb5f1231ac74899d792f71343b03c6d5b49091827efbaaddb5ae"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08505609", "text": "What is the sandwich served on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bread", "cutting board", "table"], "detected_components": ["bread"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae4f2df839337ece0b966e1b9bdd5a0f20c09b0c8055c496cabc6326cf4d1774", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bread", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ad13b05c3fdbc2ce78b55359c70c862dbc267d480cdf21fa2a2c4da57f38b62e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06880522", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 98, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "513a844127595b12aeaeb4788d9e35b699f3f7ae154e9817c15d0364afd42331", "selected_component": "bread", "selected_source_question_id": "06880522", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the bread served on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,served on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the served on?", "program_group_hash": "513a844127595b12aeaeb4788d9e35b699f3f7ae154e9817c15d0364afd42331", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "served on", "select_category": "sandwich"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,served on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the served on?", "program_group_hash": "513a844127595b12aeaeb4788d9e35b699f3f7ae154e9817c15d0364afd42331", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "served on", "select_category": "bread"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "plate", "full_answer": "The sandwich is served on a plate.", "question": "What is the sandwich served on?", "question_id": "08505609", "semantic": [{"argument": "sandwich (562536)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,served on,o (562538)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cutting board", "full_answer": "The bread is served on a cutting board.", "question": "What is the bread served on?", "question_id": "06880522", "semantic": [{"argument": "bread (1232594)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,served on,o (1232596)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["562538", "562539", "562541", "562542", "562543", "562547", "562548", "562549", "562550", "562551", "562552", "562554", "562556", "562557"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["plate"], "predicate": "served on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "562538", "query_target_entity_name": "plate", "relation_object_entity_id": "562538", "relation_subject_entity_id": "562536", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "562536", "selected_entity_name": "sandwich"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sandwich", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["562536"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["562536", "562538", "562539", "562541", "562542", "562543", "562547", "562548", "562549", "562550", "562551", "562552", "562554", "562556", "562557"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 2, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["562541", "562550"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sandwich", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1232596", "1232604"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cutting board"], "predicate": "served on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "striped", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1232596", "query_target_entity_name": "cutting board", "relation_object_entity_id": "1232596", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1232594", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1232594", "selected_entity_name": "bread"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1232594"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f3d69460df76c829c959414b10fc3a0b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d1495ebfb071a5797388c7db191b9c53f4143c2450e65c22b030b0cd49c9586e", "image_sha256_b": "cfa3cbe7f5095c51a8ec8416ac49260a8b10ce1dd662384fa903bdd4b4d15350", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "bc344b50099e9e1ef28d5ec158c6d46c935ca02ce46ce7762eeaaf627e02a0e1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ad2509d980fba28a77a068778d573c09", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ab241ba6eb076ca1bca9311cc15947cf551d90ffb270dc7c456411f547d93284"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a9ab249c112133e8a91828d78b5ddc1d5efc8a73e99ecdd6ef47a0621745ae28", "request_id": "aba6234ea07fdb0c8015ad672f7e6df2", "response_sha256": "9afda49f4ddc9529bf813afd7d64338636feb3fba2baeca42149326ceb01a286", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1dbc8b62ffc41c62aa98fd104b1bbcd1fbe985eb879b05a1dd246dad08409a0b", "request_id": "ef0083d91b6045e06a48e4d776f2848f", "response_sha256": "72bec28ad69df86fa12461d6f6b4066b79c73cdbfb6e0d003b3f06e712ab1cbd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "d949168e7cb55917c948a0cc52d0868b", "candidate_priority_rank": 106, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-106f4c4c59dd59c5:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-106f4c4c59dd59c5:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-106f4c4c59dd59c5:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-106f4c4c59dd59c5:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "lake<->store", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "lake", "B": "store"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "lake<->store", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2349802", "image_sha256": "04eaadcfbfc27dc06e3e87f59bbfea702d26d54f8a5f8f1b598bd9e70c13a253", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2349802.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2349802.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2380786", "image_sha256": "7da99e424c9ac480657234317bd96d497152412245fcaeceb859d1b7143fabd8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2380786.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2380786.jpg", "width": 335}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-106f4c4c59dd59c5", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "lake", "diff_b": "store", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "lake", "component_b": "store"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["airplane", "backpack", "dirt", "fog", "grass", "guy", "hills", "lake", "luggage", "man", "people", "wing"], "detected_components": ["lake"], "masked_program_sha256": "2e7f139bdfcd896b67c949fc2251575129e953ddb02f79903a87706f36839e0f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["lake"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "lake", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["lake"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3eeb929f03cc2b825a2f47874c5c5b204b4e17fe5fc5fd7a312c60d08e05cd1e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09301918", "text": "What is standing in the lake?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bears", "door", "floor", "mat", "sign", "store", "teddy bear", "teddy bears"], "detected_components": ["store"], "masked_program_sha256": "2e7f139bdfcd896b67c949fc2251575129e953ddb02f79903a87706f36839e0f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["store"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "store", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["store"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "21bc6476c7421e460d4435363e23b54190aedab6594c17bec1333e3d45085c4e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02576742", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 106, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9c7035a523ac0b3349fa8edd8e3433bbe5f4f00d4499a0513be6836ae97a00df", "selected_component": "store", "selected_source_question_id": "02576742", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is standing in the store?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,standing in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is standing in the ?", "program_group_hash": "9c7035a523ac0b3349fa8edd8e3433bbe5f4f00d4499a0513be6836ae97a00df", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "standing in", "select_category": "lake"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,standing in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is standing in the ?", "program_group_hash": "9c7035a523ac0b3349fa8edd8e3433bbe5f4f00d4499a0513be6836ae97a00df", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "standing in", "select_category": "store"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "airplane", "full_answer": "The airplane is standing in the lake.", "question": "What is standing in the lake?", "question_id": "09301918", "semantic": [{"argument": "lake (3597147)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,standing in,s (1684871)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "teddy bear", "full_answer": "The teddy bear is standing in the store.", "question": "What is standing in the store?", "question_id": "02576742", "semantic": [{"argument": "store (1342368)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,standing in,s (1342364)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1684871", "1954401", "2019717", "2270866", "2270867", "2270868", "2270869", "2287041", "2287042", "2489482", "2504861", "2576174", "2654940", "3597148"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["airplane"], "predicate": "standing in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["orange", "water"], "query_target_entity_id": "1684871", "query_target_entity_name": "airplane", "relation_object_entity_id": "3597147", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1684871", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3597147", "selected_entity_name": "lake"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3597147"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "store", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "lake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1342363", "1342364", "1342365", "1342367", "1342369", "1342370", "3833284"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["teddy bear"], "predicate": "standing in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "large", "standing", "tall"], "query_target_entity_id": "1342364", "query_target_entity_name": "teddy bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "1342368", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1342364", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1342368", "selected_entity_name": "store"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "store", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1342368"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:d949168e7cb55917c948a0cc52d0868b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "04eaadcfbfc27dc06e3e87f59bbfea702d26d54f8a5f8f1b598bd9e70c13a253", "image_sha256_b": "7da99e424c9ac480657234317bd96d497152412245fcaeceb859d1b7143fabd8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "fe79ef35aee7e89a5ba522f26acd9b7bfba5b6f2323f7781ee6d9533e5a94331", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8508d06fd56c365aa66986549d1bca0a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "66a5bc43ac333e6773e0e910992f2f7c48144793e6d1ae5dafb941deaa23df29"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d52030810fd561c753ccac4932190ef86fdb26db4d2efcfbe9176dcf842662c4", "request_id": "d973de3d8889142405fcbf218fab0464", "response_sha256": "5779e28592e635e174b4874e3565316873e9b63074da0b79b801344d21cb3832", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f42eff644fbe9f081e4ac51cd07b8c25a93c732c60cc5038dafe34c9003c7930", "request_id": "cde7b1d7799cafd19d91e3a29f5a87b1", "response_sha256": "b7345782ee2a56810122696966f72348e507fa384db3896dfa2d38673484eb20", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "cdaf9b26420fe8b32b4647b4c2b381a0", "candidate_priority_rank": 108, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ec8a832906aae480:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ec8a832906aae480:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ec8a832906aae480:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ec8a832906aae480:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bed<->window", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "window", "B": "bed"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "window<->bed", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2404138", "image_sha256": "bec48767305528db61f288c18cf907446c7dcbf5914b00a0d1d0dd292ddb9ce7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404138.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404138.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2360657", "image_sha256": "7700c6aef086b829448449c735fa074a0c62e2e92eec5be12ac4ce9e0cfc7f42", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2360657.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2360657.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ec8a832906aae480", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "window", "diff_b": "bed", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "window", "component_b": "bed"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "cord", "feet", "frame", "paws", "radiator", "tail", "tree", "trunk", "twigs", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["window"], "masked_program_sha256": "a01b67e44742ab883fefe2bdbfcadf756a8c6d0882f8a8208587a2d7bd7019ec", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["window"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "window", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["window"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c1513eb7bb7efc949887d9d60bed579841d3bb599c611281d12e8ac3219f6614"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "181024577", "text": "What's surrounding the window?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "curtain", "headboard", "pillow", "post", "shirt", "teddy bear"], "detected_components": ["bed"], "masked_program_sha256": "a01b67e44742ab883fefe2bdbfcadf756a8c6d0882f8a8208587a2d7bd7019ec", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bed", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e39f02e33ce86ea6be7cbc0655d3ad4a9cb97c8b71ef2e4419fe9cce72c69320"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10462312", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 108, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6c0b3d0b84f585509029d9c2e92f410c0e00cef43717f85aeec5f00479447997", "selected_component": "bed", "selected_source_question_id": "10462312", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's surrounding the bed?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,surrounding,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's surrounding the ?", "program_group_hash": "6c0b3d0b84f585509029d9c2e92f410c0e00cef43717f85aeec5f00479447997", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "surrounding", "select_category": "window"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,surrounding,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's surrounding the ?", "program_group_hash": "6c0b3d0b84f585509029d9c2e92f410c0e00cef43717f85aeec5f00479447997", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "surrounding", "select_category": "bed"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "wall", "full_answer": "The wall is surrounding the window.", "question": "What's surrounding the window?", "question_id": "181024577", "semantic": [{"argument": "window (1118529)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,surrounding,s (1118522)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "curtain", "full_answer": "The curtain is surrounding the bed.", "question": "What's surrounding the bed?", "question_id": "10462312", "semantic": [{"argument": "bed (786722)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,surrounding,s (786721)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1118522", "1118524", "1118526", "1118527", "1118530", "1118532", "1118535", "1118537", "1118538", "1118539", "1118540"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["wall"], "predicate": "surrounding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1118522", "query_target_entity_name": "wall", "relation_object_entity_id": "1118529", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1118522", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1118529", "selected_entity_name": "window"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1118529"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "window", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["786720", "786721", "786723", "786726", "786729", "786730", "786731"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["curtain"], "predicate": "surrounding", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "786721", "query_target_entity_name": "curtain", "relation_object_entity_id": "786722", "relation_subject_entity_id": "786721", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "786722", "selected_entity_name": "bed"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["786722"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:cdaf9b26420fe8b32b4647b4c2b381a0", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bec48767305528db61f288c18cf907446c7dcbf5914b00a0d1d0dd292ddb9ce7", "image_sha256_b": "7700c6aef086b829448449c735fa074a0c62e2e92eec5be12ac4ce9e0cfc7f42", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8c8c84b2a06bd9210509b2e9ca470a7ef0d5646df63fa459d3b715caff014ae6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9d49cfcb4c7a4c49ceb26e65b1b13de2", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5febd8eb95fe000db890ae0a98a5d73020a8d2d8a4247294b6632c258dea8ef2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "01c46be85b2ac548c0ae01bdbfabc4561b0fe73f1db3bf703cc8d81a28d7af25", "request_id": "a8a09cb99c716f5ee152be50f07667c4", "response_sha256": "e5493ec3286a80733f6a4de409650cd879b742bac2d20df39cb91d334cab26fe", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1bd3014efb89679e5bdbe82eb382440023d2c25debc6e33cc8c6b464a601eec5", "request_id": "c03ce9bc25db1fd602d445c5be01fd86", "response_sha256": "565a6582373e9d098bfb0ef4a450807daf5865a3c97674ea5989ff8a0190c687", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "14c2858aec5eb3f180fee08c84d4e050", "candidate_priority_rank": 109, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca92705be09cf6ad:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca92705be09cf6ad:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca92705be09cf6ad:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca92705be09cf6ad:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dish<->table", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "table", "B": "dish"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "table<->dish", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2336315", "image_sha256": "91269bf961e2ac1be2494dcf6ff29da7ae8bc29c5c3799ede6b44453b7e4be45", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2336315.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2336315.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2388778", "image_sha256": "99cd83b6332062b6534daf42475dec4d8b3ccfbf19203967f84d31a6a37dd53e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388778.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388778.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ca92705be09cf6ad", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "table", "diff_b": "dish", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "table", "component_b": "dish"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "crust", "food", "fork", "glass", "herbs", "knife", "pizza", "pizza slice", "plate", "table"], "detected_components": ["table"], "masked_program_sha256": "a343d424be98f592c7ce3da849dcf60a6809e9a3a1a0107c5f00c442cb4c4dfa", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "table", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["table", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b12ef7cf034371e7b4b04ce7d585d87293936d35065d7bc5c7909cde03c5f656"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05456070", "text": "What kind of fast food is on top of the table?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["burner", "cheese", "dish", "pizza"], "detected_components": ["dish"], "masked_program_sha256": "a343d424be98f592c7ce3da849dcf60a6809e9a3a1a0107c5f00c442cb4c4dfa", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dish", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dish", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dish", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "beda36999970ff6c69273a00d10d98c63afc762aefa713a6bb7373de5034112f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15610710", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 109, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c186a0c6c3dbb4b7fb5a9a37d5744781aeb9aa322255be6bc238ade87253a782", "selected_component": "dish", "selected_source_question_id": "15610710", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of fast food is on top of the dish?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "c186a0c6c3dbb4b7fb5a9a37d5744781aeb9aa322255be6bc238ade87253a782", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "table"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "c186a0c6c3dbb4b7fb5a9a37d5744781aeb9aa322255be6bc238ade87253a782", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "dish"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The food is a pizza.", "question": "What kind of fast food is on top of the table?", "question_id": "05456070", "semantic": [{"argument": "table (2270098)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,on top of,s (3048902)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The food is a pizza.", "question": "What kind of fast food is on top of the dish?", "question_id": "15610710", "semantic": [{"argument": "dish (670797)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,on top of,s (670796)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2825274", "3048902"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["burnt", "sliced"], "query_target_entity_id": "3048902", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "2270098", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3048902", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2270098", "selected_entity_name": "table"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2270098"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dish", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "table", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["670796"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["browned", "glowing", "plain", "round", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "670796", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "670797", "relation_subject_entity_id": "670796", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "670797", "selected_entity_name": "dish"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dish", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["670797"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:14c2858aec5eb3f180fee08c84d4e050", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "91269bf961e2ac1be2494dcf6ff29da7ae8bc29c5c3799ede6b44453b7e4be45", "image_sha256_b": "99cd83b6332062b6534daf42475dec4d8b3ccfbf19203967f84d31a6a37dd53e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ed3fd374e522e1104664a4552676da90cb0b9e1bc0eb526ce32c45f644681de9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7f0a8919ccffa78573b9f80897aa86fa", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "acd6a9837837a376f4d84380a0d17c5f835aaf3a62f14a22a467b07e2d550813"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8aed8cdaea45b526623b611a3461c15de4289d98be26062c00110e4cb602ceac", "request_id": "21acc5930d8b334b88431011ecbba7aa", "response_sha256": "cc0a08b6b81edab8fe8d497184cf5c4816b6a770747f6c292aca830161bdf90f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "49b01b6d9027871d26b8a840e8723982518bb9770cf825c5d82bb932422f9410", "request_id": "8aa813b736eda3275d004b706572144f", "response_sha256": "9dcd9da63142e7beea8060e9985e7e840ee6fe5317d719e90e9397f3fa843b64", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "44b1b8f7a772a4bb56c1414f07e379b8", "candidate_priority_rank": 114, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4ab7dbab1a68d7c4:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4ab7dbab1a68d7c4:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4ab7dbab1a68d7c4:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4ab7dbab1a68d7c4:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "box<->bread", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "box", "B": "bread"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "box<->bread", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2382985", "image_sha256": "913118654a7c66f1fe159cd3cdbd1496f37185d9e0ffc2599910a1d1df9df389", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382985.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382985.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2348390", "image_sha256": "c027aa812b9f783f347349293090db91ed709135cdfbecbe88b957a378c96850", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2348390.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2348390.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4ab7dbab1a68d7c4", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "box", "diff_b": "bread", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "box", "component_b": "bread"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["box", "cheese", "crust", "pepperoni", "pizza", "tomato"], "detected_components": ["box"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae0e0a6e17a798a830e478717a7590b8f9fa6be061107f612abd0987a199f2bd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["box", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "box", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["box", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "425778c4fb9102f198a9c32f84059545f38bde4c11e8f2b441c390dbd9e523ee"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "15448238", "text": "What kind of fast food is in the box?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bread", "hot dog", "ketchup", "mustard", "onion", "spices"], "detected_components": ["bread"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae0e0a6e17a798a830e478717a7590b8f9fa6be061107f612abd0987a199f2bd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bread", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6d52f535c2d6b4dfa7ccb89e3224a87f6c778cf4cea9c1de5dbccddb964c51bf"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17248383", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 114, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 14, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c0a83d89a6d4397d5f427214ae24952e7e4d34539b486ebf71bd2c0b20381006", "selected_component": "bread", "selected_source_question_id": "17248383", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of fast food is in the bread?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "c0a83d89a6d4397d5f427214ae24952e7e4d34539b486ebf71bd2c0b20381006", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "box"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "c0a83d89a6d4397d5f427214ae24952e7e4d34539b486ebf71bd2c0b20381006", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bread"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The food is a pizza.", "question": "What kind of fast food is in the box?", "question_id": "15448238", "semantic": [{"argument": "box (535889)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s (535888)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hot dog", "full_answer": "The food is a hot dog.", "question": "What kind of fast food is in the bread?", "question_id": "17248383", "semantic": [{"argument": "bread (882551)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s (882550)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["535888", "535897"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "535888", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "535889", "relation_subject_entity_id": "535888", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "535889", "selected_entity_name": "box"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "box", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["535889"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "box", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["882550"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hot dog"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["cooked"], "query_target_entity_id": "882550", "query_target_entity_name": "hot dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "882551", "relation_subject_entity_id": "882550", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "882551", "selected_entity_name": "bread"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["882551"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:44b1b8f7a772a4bb56c1414f07e379b8", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "913118654a7c66f1fe159cd3cdbd1496f37185d9e0ffc2599910a1d1df9df389", "image_sha256_b": "c027aa812b9f783f347349293090db91ed709135cdfbecbe88b957a378c96850", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "fed40b96410cca89012f2d626907ad370b7788f04eb0c0464f298914b60c1c31", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "186df6b9f6ba053b20328c883649c0f3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "8c867dcda2526fd09deb39f6f80c988f3ec840cc111e2df768ced494db11d9d4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "eb5317d101568cb3c7a61c09b286f563a9d7ed43f50793933bd196b08e7c59d1", "request_id": "caa6a50cd0462f5ed3901c668b14ac83", "response_sha256": "2754ff7f49b68e6fec248cf8c45a197cabaed1d2fe8610cba6a9ac1cd4e5c08a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2fe2078af3245ba438eb027bf1d54610e83a7b7234432744d8cbe10127304b20", "request_id": "bfa353f9d5ae48b88859c590fc0bb5a2", "response_sha256": "2eeb88c3bcc972dcf3932b2b2bf90a3039a19d2a773218e1ddb2c4087f0652fe", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "1dc3dfdcd865d1b09ae85e1c72f65e33", "candidate_priority_rank": 118, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ea8bcf970a22807:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ea8bcf970a22807:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ea8bcf970a22807:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ea8bcf970a22807:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blanket<->pillow", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "blanket", "B": "pillow"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blanket<->pillow", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2382757", "image_sha256": "791215d2dd4cdf518ec9a054fb9854a5abbbb6996f558e0d051652a8870679c5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382757.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382757.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2395473", "image_sha256": "02c46fd302825c289bca69d0258f17a634c6aa990c893144543dcf5c4153fcad", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395473.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395473.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9ea8bcf970a22807", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blanket", "diff_b": "pillow", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blanket", "component_b": "pillow"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "cat", "chair", "desk", "eye glasses", "eyes", "keyboard", "monitor", "paper", "pen", "plant"], "detected_components": ["blanket"], "masked_program_sha256": "b13e44f8e4412b70e297e51c43c4cb5e60254237650037696c97be387f934cf5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blanket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e1a77c6419f787d67e0c66e0bb329b8665d4d1b7f386e08aa8f13e83e1f74143"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12932418", "text": "What is the animal that is resting on the blanket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["book", "bookcase", "carpet", "cross", "curtains", "dog", "ear", "eye", "head", "nose", "paw", "pillow", "speaker", "stuffed animal", "tail", "window"], "detected_components": ["pillow"], "masked_program_sha256": "b13e44f8e4412b70e297e51c43c4cb5e60254237650037696c97be387f934cf5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pillow", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pillow", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pillow", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d932d1a82aae2c4525bfd06e60bcc2b7c104b4ee7ac22bdbf2d5cf3c793445e8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11889065", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 118, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b7776efa3c01b257b281a120abe29997a1c97e79b6c01072ea4c126235f06c0b", "selected_component": "pillow", "selected_source_question_id": "11889065", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal that is resting on the pillow?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is resting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "b7776efa3c01b257b281a120abe29997a1c97e79b6c01072ea4c126235f06c0b", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "blanket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is resting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "b7776efa3c01b257b281a120abe29997a1c97e79b6c01072ea4c126235f06c0b", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "pillow"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What is the animal that is resting on the blanket?", "question_id": "12932418", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (1326387)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s (1326378)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The animal is a dog.", "question": "What is the animal that is resting on the pillow?", "question_id": "11889065", "semantic": [{"argument": "pillow (454231)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s (454230)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1326378"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "resting"], "query_target_entity_id": "1326378", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1326387", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1326378", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1326387", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1326387"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pillow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["454230"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "lying", "sleepy"], "query_target_entity_id": "454230", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "454231", "relation_subject_entity_id": "454230", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "454231", "selected_entity_name": "pillow"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pillow", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["454231"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1dc3dfdcd865d1b09ae85e1c72f65e33", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "791215d2dd4cdf518ec9a054fb9854a5abbbb6996f558e0d051652a8870679c5", "image_sha256_b": "02c46fd302825c289bca69d0258f17a634c6aa990c893144543dcf5c4153fcad", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b01e799f4595792ed12a675334045d1dd53437077b1ef481d1773efea3263315", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "891f3c4fd34426efb8f312d41ce91364", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7843c6ea5d6ee10f18594235af282a4506884c1cf7a059f95cdc753b89759671"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3719a53ce12062a278c5bb20cd202d96ab5092070c6dc8a3f4dbe7cec4978196", "request_id": "511cef234c602b25dc70c0df59e8d8a4", "response_sha256": "c2c557b19bc4454493134a1bdd278082525217a2a5f9553aec7c20ebe96998e1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "340ea3191b920a1f4944e3f515aeb7c78e5554c0fbe4b12b985e3c54ece33d49", "request_id": "174163477c42315b32e3c8c0b04430c9", "response_sha256": "a4c9ce2fc45a5f12922d6f27805b264946a67d21f4d10e13816c1ebd3fb8d832", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "26167bc1434ce1904518ea26603a1d88", "candidate_priority_rank": 120, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb6e7ed64f22771f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb6e7ed64f22771f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb6e7ed64f22771f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb6e7ed64f22771f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "fence<->water", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "fence", "B": "water"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "fence<->water", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 281, "image_id": "2342557", "image_sha256": "d017a0a33d5d92dfb253b98effb166fcd3726b6c9aa1c2e75343e7ac7706ec16", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2342557.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2342557.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 390, "image_id": "2377541", "image_sha256": "66eea8db48d3d3471981dd14e8144b7c81544524d1289888ee943395b9c526b9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2377541.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2377541.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb6e7ed64f22771f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "fence", "diff_b": "water", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "fence", "component_b": "water"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["chair", "collar", "dog", "ear", "eyes", "fence", "ground", "head", "leg", "mouth", "nose", "paw", "post", "tail", "wall"], "detected_components": ["fence"], "masked_program_sha256": "de83293f6ed192fb66defd5fb0c5d160d7dc1ced1b4e5f04f3e1812959aa24f9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "fence", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "476970495305d0fa7debe36699970947313684e113673b4a2261e98edb899d66"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07462543", "text": "What type of animal is in front of the fence?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["branch", "dirt", "dog", "ear", "eyes", "legs", "nose", "ring", "tail", "toy", "water"], "detected_components": ["water"], "masked_program_sha256": "de83293f6ed192fb66defd5fb0c5d160d7dc1ced1b4e5f04f3e1812959aa24f9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "water", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ca3748e8c1194a934663724a45da616fe3734a63defaaca76933730c1f44829c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10116905", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 120, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 14, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1172701ac9c0c2fea1cd6188fd5290fa98a5a59035388a0d19f9bff97352bbaa", "selected_component": "water", "selected_source_question_id": "10116905", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of animal is in front of the water?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "1172701ac9c0c2fea1cd6188fd5290fa98a5a59035388a0d19f9bff97352bbaa", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "1172701ac9c0c2fea1cd6188fd5290fa98a5a59035388a0d19f9bff97352bbaa", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "water"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The animal is a dog.", "question": "What type of animal is in front of the fence?", "question_id": "07462543", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (932807)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (932803)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The animal is a dog.", "question": "What type of animal is in front of the water?", "question_id": "10116905", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (717530)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (717517)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["932803"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["tan"], "query_target_entity_id": "932803", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "932807", "relation_subject_entity_id": "932803", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "932807", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["932807"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["717517"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wet", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "717517", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "717530", "relation_subject_entity_id": "717517", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "717530", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["717530"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:26167bc1434ce1904518ea26603a1d88", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d017a0a33d5d92dfb253b98effb166fcd3726b6c9aa1c2e75343e7ac7706ec16", "image_sha256_b": "66eea8db48d3d3471981dd14e8144b7c81544524d1289888ee943395b9c526b9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "225e42eacda0000afcfa902e77d1402e349b81f6caf20f4dd08d17b72d0dce01", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "808382e9166bb12ca37b578b6b8ae79a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5555eca27d30779e47dec4bbd29806d971f641d6513071c55ba0646bbda36a9b"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fddb7d29a8d92fd2168a29ba69552e6bfe0d91f79c041c717e88bb2ed968354f", "request_id": "19c8a0cbb3b6096f754654c0f19a527a", "response_sha256": "d555d753dc0aae3678bbf09e7935b9fc44c32958ec5b621f2d8234635c7148e1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6a582cc58206ede391ebc0acdd5ac622dca60198bb8e3c4995e1df90eae96eae", "request_id": "d434e2438020abc9d5851bde45c018e8", "response_sha256": "ee98cf3c7f97d780600131a53633a1a84ec5e60fc4980710e49b2db28a4fdb50", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ec509178e92c3c4a0857119c6c2088c4", "candidate_priority_rank": 127, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b873c1087816fdc7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b873c1087816fdc7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b873c1087816fdc7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b873c1087816fdc7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "basket<->bowl", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "basket", "B": "bowl"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "basket<->bowl", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2355097", "image_sha256": "c20e2c195328a7b3d348e9f497a8917f17499d0b6340403d8cc57904dda8d7d4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2355097.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2355097.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 382, "image_id": "2417081", "image_sha256": "eae0f4931b8761fdc18e2f446bbb7fd8440f296f9b41074dbbebbfe98d2a17ae", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2417081.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2417081.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b873c1087816fdc7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "basket", "diff_b": "bowl", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "basket", "component_b": "bowl"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "cream", "donut", "donuts", "drawing", "frosting", "glass", "grass", "icing", "letter", "paper", "sign", "sprinkles"], "detected_components": ["basket"], "masked_program_sha256": "12c9fc01fa7fa8f4356528defffe82ff1eb8809b953bcdc6577a95dd3f525287", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "basket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0b62be7161c2c3489e7ecd5a0210d0d84895cd1447bf77f18088453eed1ff2d5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12370661", "text": "What is the food in the basket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "donuts", "letters", "table", "thumb"], "detected_components": ["bowl"], "masked_program_sha256": "12c9fc01fa7fa8f4356528defffe82ff1eb8809b953bcdc6577a95dd3f525287", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bowl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6e6f39fa34aa5fcae6a5d4a3ac904b45d9a6b84c669f3426ece04ef45463f417"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00926056", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 127, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "854b5df64e0cac7842fc96cc7d779897b82831d65c009a27a5bb42ae51257b65", "selected_component": "bowl", "selected_source_question_id": "00926056", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the food in the bowl?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food in the ?", "program_group_hash": "854b5df64e0cac7842fc96cc7d779897b82831d65c009a27a5bb42ae51257b65", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "basket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food in the ?", "program_group_hash": "854b5df64e0cac7842fc96cc7d779897b82831d65c009a27a5bb42ae51257b65", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "donuts", "full_answer": "The food is donuts.", "question": "What is the food in the basket?", "question_id": "12370661", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (832850)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,in,s (832865)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "donuts", "full_answer": "The food is donuts.", "question": "What is the food in the bowl?", "question_id": "00926056", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (3186273)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,in,s (2865758)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["832844", "832865"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["donuts"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "832865", "query_target_entity_name": "donuts", "relation_object_entity_id": "832850", "relation_subject_entity_id": "832865", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "832850", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["832850"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2865758"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["donuts"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2865758", "query_target_entity_name": "donuts", "relation_object_entity_id": "3186273", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2865758", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3186273", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3186273"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ec509178e92c3c4a0857119c6c2088c4", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c20e2c195328a7b3d348e9f497a8917f17499d0b6340403d8cc57904dda8d7d4", "image_sha256_b": "eae0f4931b8761fdc18e2f446bbb7fd8440f296f9b41074dbbebbfe98d2a17ae", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "282f24818d5b26d397c5e87fcc9eef64f379070265372e8597a489dab14029ea", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1215c93e5b504ec8ce714d83dd0640e7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "78d148c3793ad5f7b4fe293669461390f39c1a05566592fcd96ed18666f81521"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ebd4911c837e4b081173fb1404c6f984f3c69779c7f46cb8a5a82bba5895f5b7", "request_id": "3468a6052bb44f21a63e01545ca7220b", "response_sha256": "86b2605d1a0bfd5d4e39af56a5a27d76ad598713c9cf6489de774eb28bd004d9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dfb26dc884cccd5cf0c65c02868b763e6c57f66abfe07b7027b8dc2140f66e24", "request_id": "e9d92a46621cb696539d1273a9dab0dc", "response_sha256": "2bd4e1962212166055c6516320cb42de7ad9c993fc067cd3d14b2f4935460ad0", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "fb18fb3c546d2fef418b8af67edbfc67", "candidate_priority_rank": 129, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-023626954ca421fe:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-023626954ca421fe:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-023626954ca421fe:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-023626954ca421fe:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "oven<->pan", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "oven", "B": "pan"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "oven<->pan", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2351848", "image_sha256": "ec50cda67ab189b740074ce446f5745e767b42a4339c9119005ed369778da0db", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2351848.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2351848.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2389804", "image_sha256": "2960331636f6061609218690b92865ff78b77f2ed0f9c1aad17eeefb1cd9d4a9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389804.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389804.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-023626954ca421fe", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "oven", "diff_b": "pan", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "oven", "component_b": "pan"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cinnamon roll", "foil", "orange", "oven", "pan", "wall"], "detected_components": ["oven"], "masked_program_sha256": "3a60898c4a08b2b2e95e87964cf4a598d23727528ddf6bf9d829a2b29a992df7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["oven", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "oven", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["oven", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "018b4d8e24fe081a55186758ec6a7da336b0dd174695ed93bc627299da27ae2c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19146999", "text": "What cooking utensil is inside the oven?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "finger", "fork", "hand", "man", "pan", "pepperoni", "pizza", "plate", "sauce", "spatula", "table", "tomato"], "detected_components": ["pan"], "masked_program_sha256": "3a60898c4a08b2b2e95e87964cf4a598d23727528ddf6bf9d829a2b29a992df7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pan", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pan", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pan", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1b9a41509ee27c1e66985c23cc46f9a0c096cee325f1b2ec20d1012d5018039d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17865859", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 129, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ec6066f762133f5fc63a0feaff41d0561ea2161acf5cfd5f87df345a1afdacd1", "selected_component": "pan", "selected_source_question_id": "17865859", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What cooking utensil is inside the pan?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what cooking utensil is inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "ec6066f762133f5fc63a0feaff41d0561ea2161acf5cfd5f87df345a1afdacd1", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "oven"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what cooking utensil is inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "ec6066f762133f5fc63a0feaff41d0561ea2161acf5cfd5f87df345a1afdacd1", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "pan"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pan", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a pan.", "question": "What cooking utensil is inside the oven?", "question_id": "19146999", "semantic": [{"argument": "oven (857820)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,inside,s (857828)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "spatula", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a spatula.", "question": "What cooking utensil is inside the pan?", "question_id": "17865859", "semantic": [{"argument": "pan (1257026)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,inside,s (1257041)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["857828"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pan"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["curled"], "query_target_entity_id": "857828", "query_target_entity_name": "pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "857820", "relation_subject_entity_id": "857828", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "857820", "selected_entity_name": "oven"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "oven", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["857820"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["857828"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "oven", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1257041"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["spatula"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1257041", "query_target_entity_name": "spatula", "relation_object_entity_id": "1257026", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1257041", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1257026", "selected_entity_name": "pan"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1257026"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:fb18fb3c546d2fef418b8af67edbfc67", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ec50cda67ab189b740074ce446f5745e767b42a4339c9119005ed369778da0db", "image_sha256_b": "2960331636f6061609218690b92865ff78b77f2ed0f9c1aad17eeefb1cd9d4a9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "31dc733ed277b0be4d621e6333971294fc942613b1910418f2ffb49c3814f755", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b09b7df2502e8db6d35f7c85944eb603", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "07570bf26e47183e8efe471bf62dcc1931b5ebd381f71130ba6082dd7c3ace68"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5c25a14fa9d4ded4b5dbc519cca9f27968faedc217f985ce296dcc280fcce997", "request_id": "a45b00fb14f593b0673ecd8d81b236df", "response_sha256": "dca5f114ef9f14344b6480c68f2a8ba9f8cadc07582dbcfd94c664ffe6085565", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9184acaad554258eec9882a1b03dc68bea87d5a7d4423e94fac2a14924c28d60", "request_id": "e45017b4c6bda64ff2f7500937e20c85", "response_sha256": "b913867e3abcea1063c19bb8de8b47f96c1329b828bfe97594e42e047299ce27", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a43dd2e9c88353fed56eecab9a2f65d6", "candidate_priority_rank": 130, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93417b614a7a877b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93417b614a7a877b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93417b614a7a877b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93417b614a7a877b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->umbrella", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "umbrella"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->umbrella", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2405452", "image_sha256": "41ba4bcd7f309faa523204089c3728810e16407b7172d7fafb9bbdadaab5386f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2405452.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2405452.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2412499", "image_sha256": "d076cbb5d5a18feecc55bde7287cf118ba97a8b15d820cdafd231e88f7493eeb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412499.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412499.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-93417b614a7a877b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "umbrella", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "umbrella"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beard", "bed", "bedroom", "bracelet", "laptop", "logo", "man", "pants", "pillowcase", "remote control", "shirt", "sticker", "wall"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9ba4a27e0360803158910c4a3d4365295a2238f12773da9dd2c6ad7c18149102"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03947061", "text": "What is the item of furniture that this man is on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["floor", "flowers", "leaf", "paper", "ribs", "table", "umbrella"], "detected_components": ["umbrella"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["umbrella", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "umbrella", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["umbrella", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5e42d9b5ca23e2a4b3c2c4c21adc15fa4cb14427736d6404b5c409d16d10ef76"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12567595", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 130, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "bf3d3978eea770c3d03c6433be9c4b06ddcafcc91a4c70b8a40f6de8fd8719ad", "selected_component": "umbrella", "selected_source_question_id": "12567595", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the item of furniture that this umbrella is on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that this is on?", "program_group_hash": "bf3d3978eea770c3d03c6433be9c4b06ddcafcc91a4c70b8a40f6de8fd8719ad", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that this is on?", "program_group_hash": "bf3d3978eea770c3d03c6433be9c4b06ddcafcc91a4c70b8a40f6de8fd8719ad", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "umbrella"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that this man is on?", "question_id": "03947061", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (331974)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (331975)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a table.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that this umbrella is on?", "question_id": "12567595", "semantic": [{"argument": "umbrella (193057)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (193059)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["331975"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "331975", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "331975", "relation_subject_entity_id": "331974", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "331974", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["331974"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "umbrella", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["193059"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["dark", "stained", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "193059", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "193059", "relation_subject_entity_id": "193057", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "193057", "selected_entity_name": "umbrella"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "umbrella", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["193057"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a43dd2e9c88353fed56eecab9a2f65d6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "41ba4bcd7f309faa523204089c3728810e16407b7172d7fafb9bbdadaab5386f", "image_sha256_b": "d076cbb5d5a18feecc55bde7287cf118ba97a8b15d820cdafd231e88f7493eeb", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "aed22e4f58b0e53a2cc1e3804774de57465752f214aa14050f7d2fae22a7ab31", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "49b1fc262c01b8453b815c741785970a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5dfee993aa58f3407386f24f17f4b1405c057a569780f05bef1c8e48128fa7bb"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4454fda84a0d9456ac0495c9fa6c17ed3a4b396041eb57d6896b7ee0e69795b4", "request_id": "2a70113f32eff09f1d3cd8a49f032716", "response_sha256": "8f4b2d7684b1cd68e52cb5590960758ddf3224d165dad5636411d41f06026250", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "32a07ed465c087d3e12f9f46b2f1a3411b77075a6271be7f0484a693f18afa05", "request_id": "eadc2ca54392a8a93fd913f5a1836a5a", "response_sha256": "5863b8dc29e79b39f21cd8c498e91bcb963c98374c38fa204ea915ba643eccf8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "74f95b18d33f50f16507010cf55bbf44", "candidate_priority_rank": 135, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34195c7d26dd3c3e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34195c7d26dd3c3e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34195c7d26dd3c3e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34195c7d26dd3c3e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "parking lot<->yard", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "parking lot", "B": "yard"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "parking lot<->yard", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 355, "image_id": "2316396", "image_sha256": "22e4a1c2410cbd43ce3369dee98350e7f9c5d75c754d064be19b6b51d0811679", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2316396.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2316396.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2398775", "image_sha256": "708870d0b556c7c1700314f8e879da152dd98043d0690e73d09c3c979bdf7655", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398775.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398775.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-34195c7d26dd3c3e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "parking lot", "diff_b": "yard", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "parking lot", "component_b": "yard"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "bus", "buses", "clouds", "license plate", "parking lot", "road", "roof", "sky", "street", "street light", "tire", "vehicle", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["parking lot"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4b65b82473a90961ecc11c0a56a11d033667b9903bc679a60e58cdb4254b191", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["parking lot"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "parking lot", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["parking lot"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a2a2d2a53a3555b097a177d39fa435795d23c0292c8db8e69f8dfc9ac3c90a0f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11864346", "text": "What vehicles are in the parking lot?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "car", "cars", "ground", "numbers", "pole", "sand", "sign", "snow", "train", "trains", "trees", "windshield", "yard"], "detected_components": ["yard"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4b65b82473a90961ecc11c0a56a11d033667b9903bc679a60e58cdb4254b191", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["yard"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "yard", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["yard"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1a6d6071b69cc04eaa22d25f2f5d5166c84b7b4ab0ad93148e47104782b5659a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16954759", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 135, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5583be64818fa26be3f10694e8954e65aabb262a7c6f3733f9ad8ec8f718c16e", "selected_component": "yard", "selected_source_question_id": "16954759", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What vehicles are in the yard?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicles are in the ?", "program_group_hash": "5583be64818fa26be3f10694e8954e65aabb262a7c6f3733f9ad8ec8f718c16e", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "parking lot"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicles are in the ?", "program_group_hash": "5583be64818fa26be3f10694e8954e65aabb262a7c6f3733f9ad8ec8f718c16e", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "yard"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "buses", "full_answer": "The vehicles are buses.", "question": "What vehicles are in the parking lot?", "question_id": "11864346", "semantic": [{"argument": "parking lot (4074349)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s (4074348)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "trains", "full_answer": "The vehicles are trains.", "question": "What vehicles are in the yard?", "question_id": "16954759", "semantic": [{"argument": "yard (422103)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,s (422094)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4074348", "4123356", "4123366", "4123470", "4487127", "4487152", "4487153", "4487154"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["buses"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4074348", "query_target_entity_name": "buses", "relation_object_entity_id": "4074349", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4074348", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4074349", "selected_entity_name": "parking lot"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "parking lot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4074349"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "yard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "parking lot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["422080", "422084", "422087", "422091", "422094", "422097"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trains"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "422094", "query_target_entity_name": "trains", "relation_object_entity_id": "422103", "relation_subject_entity_id": "422094", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "422103", "selected_entity_name": "yard"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "yard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["422103"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:74f95b18d33f50f16507010cf55bbf44", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "22e4a1c2410cbd43ce3369dee98350e7f9c5d75c754d064be19b6b51d0811679", "image_sha256_b": "708870d0b556c7c1700314f8e879da152dd98043d0690e73d09c3c979bdf7655", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "37c6df1ab37f1a9d483784a8f686b5778d77bd12d61be25f7266c5c8cd7133ad", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d5687c17be114e4e8b0c301bb8ff592d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "007b62cb6da82cec6ccf6ca5c54981d6196ae902c75ee87517e70d0adc6a9535"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8545e59e117590399b995895dcd93f919675e94acf3af9a72fcf75bf09d0870c", "request_id": "0c19d14de23db1126053889b2c60002d", "response_sha256": "bbfec0ed22bbe2a89ba0e38d158143dc28abbfb6df30e583ed99609608c06846", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "799efbcd1f9a8ba223a72dc609944364fb50da653b2a326ee705239b4484b3be", "request_id": "204aa932c27d37c9f86e945dc907851c", "response_sha256": "54bd6af4373b8df3881588320512049c8bca3d019d32bab8a8dbf900f13371bd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "dac54a6b9986e7779193089ca6f949f1", "candidate_priority_rank": 136, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1a803b9f96d58e7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1a803b9f96d58e7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1a803b9f96d58e7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1a803b9f96d58e7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "couch<->sign", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "couch", "B": "sign"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "couch<->sign", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2367871", "image_sha256": "1ccb13f31f12b5d23ae3447d2806dffc77fac01d2013ac59f594cf98dbe8e102", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367871.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367871.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2396914", "image_sha256": "bc134c432a963b035f0a21c1d62ed760393c91fa07c70175700331bad4ce439c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396914.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396914.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e1a803b9f96d58e7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "couch", "diff_b": "sign", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "couch", "component_b": "sign"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["couch", "ear", "eye", "eyes", "ground", "head", "neck", "nose", "paw", "spots", "stuffed bear", "tag"], "detected_components": ["couch"], "masked_program_sha256": "2890fd2df6ded0734a1b45464e5a8ff58e949e996f917808af59716e3fbadea9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["couch"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "couch", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["couch"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "21f14cfd7f2005a82b2c00fee6e7bcb0780a7313578256c84282967c0c986235"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07728121", "text": "What is on the couch in this photograph?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bush", "grass", "ground", "letters", "plants", "sign", "trees"], "detected_components": ["sign"], "masked_program_sha256": "2890fd2df6ded0734a1b45464e5a8ff58e949e996f917808af59716e3fbadea9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sign"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sign", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sign"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9e6aaee691604118fcdd93d3ddc1a4243115fa4ba9ea2b9523538474822d41c5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19478896", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 136, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "679ef4064b89983724ed847c8dcf50f03645327c9500080b3cb2f1a7b05cfa17", "selected_component": "sign", "selected_source_question_id": "19478896", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is on the sign in this photograph?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the in this photograph?", "program_group_hash": "679ef4064b89983724ed847c8dcf50f03645327c9500080b3cb2f1a7b05cfa17", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "couch"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is on the in this photograph?", "program_group_hash": "679ef4064b89983724ed847c8dcf50f03645327c9500080b3cb2f1a7b05cfa17", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "sign"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "stuffed bear", "full_answer": "The stuffed bear is on the couch.", "question": "What is on the couch in this photograph?", "question_id": "07728121", "semantic": [{"argument": "couch (3871874)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (3458867)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "letters", "full_answer": "The letters are on the sign.", "question": "What is on the sign in this photograph?", "question_id": "19478896", "semantic": [{"argument": "sign (439365)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,on,s (439367)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1803590", "1875817", "1892890", "2280022", "2333853", "2445937", "2459938", "2648300", "2648301", "3181821", "3291633", "3391714", "3458867"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stuffed bear"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3458867", "query_target_entity_name": "stuffed bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "3871874", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3458867", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3871874", "selected_entity_name": "couch"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "couch", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3871874"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sign", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "couch", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["439367", "439370", "439372", "439374", "439376", "439377"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["letters"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "439367", "query_target_entity_name": "letters", "relation_object_entity_id": "439365", "relation_subject_entity_id": "439367", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "439365", "selected_entity_name": "sign"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sign", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["439365"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:dac54a6b9986e7779193089ca6f949f1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1ccb13f31f12b5d23ae3447d2806dffc77fac01d2013ac59f594cf98dbe8e102", "image_sha256_b": "bc134c432a963b035f0a21c1d62ed760393c91fa07c70175700331bad4ce439c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b5c27b94aa854aaa19b639fde4c632beead99c197d0f54014e9d1eafb7fc340d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ea452c3cdfa5b32825eb76f2333db262", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "00d8984be90f70c890d31480b193ba5ce62c8f709e00501e7a2b32b49fc6e1c4"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3b052cf16480e0638c99d0c5542d5133bee4725451abedfbd8246a3857c99a47", "request_id": "3b56d9f148d7f96810c0db0e611bb6b1", "response_sha256": "5a0e0661c05fae61a9ba57847e942580de75666c6ed87ad208ba9947dfd914c7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "57d3fdb828f51b8a0302f31a08015ebab4b71441716d82d90b35a67d4217742c", "request_id": "bf90435a851647da16539805ca8247d3", "response_sha256": "6a284d2afdffba96732719b9fe1b00f579b15239d5c3414b6a425d81b11e48bb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "e76971438ba0b68b03f00563208ebfe1", "candidate_priority_rank": 139, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12bc598365bfb5d4:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12bc598365bfb5d4:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12bc598365bfb5d4:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12bc598365bfb5d4:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "sink<->sky", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sky", "B": "sink"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sky<->sink", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2404330", "image_sha256": "05e3e0859b6bf7c3b19e30e4861d60ba25a175f10033b335986e4b1dc5481de6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404330.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404330.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2371082", "image_sha256": "f758dddd129766c221fdd0c91ad4dc1d73b3823e365a6a9356f2e23e50363ef4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371082.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371082.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-12bc598365bfb5d4", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sky", "diff_b": "sink", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sky", "component_b": "sink"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "pig", "sky"], "detected_components": ["sky"], "masked_program_sha256": "82cf86727a35bb4d3d75e37bcf0ece98ebb765c61b04a4a8bd062721fd3e05ec", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sky", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sky", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sky", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ccc9d5b8bdb6a97ad14f16c082dad906fd8f0befd283da2798d91621469de761"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04865296", "text": "What animal do you think is in the sky?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "ear", "eye", "eyes", "faucet", "ground", "person", "shower", "sink", "toothbrush", "toothbrushes"], "detected_components": ["sink"], "masked_program_sha256": "82cf86727a35bb4d3d75e37bcf0ece98ebb765c61b04a4a8bd062721fd3e05ec", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sink", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "07605d028859b33018b87725443472cb998d1782ad3bc88f7e45f5db01b1e9e7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03157519", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 139, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 15, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9a17fdae9499f6b150ec9ce9344f09ada95281cad88930f200f0cbbf05afea8c", "selected_component": "sink", "selected_source_question_id": "03157519", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal do you think is in the sink?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal do you think is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "9a17fdae9499f6b150ec9ce9344f09ada95281cad88930f200f0cbbf05afea8c", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "sky"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal do you think is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "9a17fdae9499f6b150ec9ce9344f09ada95281cad88930f200f0cbbf05afea8c", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "sink"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pig", "full_answer": "The pig is in the sky.", "question": "What animal do you think is in the sky?", "question_id": "04865296", "semantic": [{"argument": "sky (343954)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (343946)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is in the sink.", "question": "What animal do you think is in the sink?", "question_id": "03157519", "semantic": [{"argument": "sink (2545568)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (2481067)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["343946"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pig"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["inflatable", "inflated", "pink"], "query_target_entity_id": "343946", "query_target_entity_name": "pig", "relation_object_entity_id": "343954", "relation_subject_entity_id": "343946", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "343954", "selected_entity_name": "sky"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sky", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["343954"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sky", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2481067"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["large"], "query_target_entity_id": "2481067", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "2545568", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2481067", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2545568", "selected_entity_name": "sink"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2545568"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e76971438ba0b68b03f00563208ebfe1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "05e3e0859b6bf7c3b19e30e4861d60ba25a175f10033b335986e4b1dc5481de6", "image_sha256_b": "f758dddd129766c221fdd0c91ad4dc1d73b3823e365a6a9356f2e23e50363ef4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "72e356106a299afc37f66e5655cfe46c4ccc2d8551fbe7cc123e387ee7a07b8e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "44ec53bc391181b042d10a40b5858e7b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2a807aa9c6a1fab94384c07c3db0ff48e723b1102babc1ec8b6e4b43b598e239"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f8702d68b268998dcfa137a1504426c66738fe49a7a74fc38f7e5c0af96ffb3b", "request_id": "6ab1d45b58b87985eeadb6cf6d76ff16", "response_sha256": "b455bd00f4939d29c23a17680af368b40838a52415740e439bedc81e56229a1f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d6363acec9bab7a049f784a8d67d373726461e0f0c90446b3c5a1b4b065baf80", "request_id": "5828a904f59c0b4a1b232e8d92e9be61", "response_sha256": "20c369bb67c434d341d7266553dc77730ccefb04743e2d3ee70fbd2c79e28391", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "023f3f30d0debd08c990a443a695667d", "candidate_priority_rank": 140, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-296d01205d32e193:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-296d01205d32e193:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-296d01205d32e193:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-296d01205d32e193:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bowl<->pizza", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "pizza", "B": "bowl"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "pizza<->bowl", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2393561", "image_sha256": "fb9f675b74177fd254cb3436b4cd8bbb6090f04d0dde7db8916c311991680f9f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2393561.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2393561.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2317091", "image_sha256": "c8939c9870bd79099082078d537f7e143d1105c5743e038b9d529c8e160715f4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317091.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317091.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-296d01205d32e193", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "pizza", "diff_b": "bowl", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "pizza", "component_b": "bowl"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "counter", "countertop", "cutting board", "grinder", "lid", "pepper", "pepperoni", "pizza", "salt", "skillet", "stove", "tea kettle"], "detected_components": ["pizza"], "masked_program_sha256": "fabb9bcb977265b9b76cb7eca42332070163f0fb1834dee866b4432e80d9d8cc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pizza", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dae3443cec5b9e2ebc7fed1c552eb4a032bb155cb8b0c1a1a481baa2f1cbb0c2"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01498707", "text": "What's underneath the pizza?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "bread", "food", "plate", "utensil", "window"], "detected_components": ["bowl"], "masked_program_sha256": "fabb9bcb977265b9b76cb7eca42332070163f0fb1834dee866b4432e80d9d8cc", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bowl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3067ff86ae50753b33c10cfd847ded8a75d82ac6051715d4ff6f7b63c7af0352"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09434608", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 140, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d194f8feb13bc4132fc707881599baaf192cea04318885f4373397ca0583f6d3", "selected_component": "bowl", "selected_source_question_id": "09434608", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's underneath the bowl?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's underneath the ?", "program_group_hash": "d194f8feb13bc4132fc707881599baaf192cea04318885f4373397ca0583f6d3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "underneath", "select_category": "pizza"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's underneath the ?", "program_group_hash": "d194f8feb13bc4132fc707881599baaf192cea04318885f4373397ca0583f6d3", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "underneath", "select_category": "bowl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cutting board", "full_answer": "The cutting board is underneath the pizza.", "question": "What's underneath the pizza?", "question_id": "01498707", "semantic": [{"argument": "pizza (471637)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s (471645)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "plate", "full_answer": "The plate is underneath the bowl.", "question": "What's underneath the bowl?", "question_id": "09434608", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (1023660)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,underneath,s (1023661)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["471636", "471642", "471643", "471644", "471645", "471646", "471655", "471659", "471661", "471662", "471665", "471668", "471669", "471670", "471674", "471675"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cutting board"], "predicate": "underneath", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "471645", "query_target_entity_name": "cutting board", "relation_object_entity_id": "471637", "relation_subject_entity_id": "471645", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "471637", "selected_entity_name": "pizza"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["471637"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1023659", "1023661", "1023662", "1023663", "1023664"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["plate"], "predicate": "underneath", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["round", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1023661", "query_target_entity_name": "plate", "relation_object_entity_id": "1023660", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1023661", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1023660", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1023660"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:023f3f30d0debd08c990a443a695667d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "fb9f675b74177fd254cb3436b4cd8bbb6090f04d0dde7db8916c311991680f9f", "image_sha256_b": "c8939c9870bd79099082078d537f7e143d1105c5743e038b9d529c8e160715f4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "bb9b3968d1aaac5367c67ea6aa3d6ce46ca7312b0ed921eea94d4c4a8a5b5021", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "838aa96c48a22f653f84c70d96b8b7d0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1f5b2c074c8de9a6ec1cb63c4c9a04eeda0e9f7a23d682a67d3c90afa36e0aeb"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "25927442ced6241ca6bb3128cea47e8e10a74fae7b6a983adf31f3f98f4eb0eb", "request_id": "5063c5b2186bcb854e63982f2f22f606", "response_sha256": "4cd7f516953a0e6c1622b40acb5fed3fbd9786ae19da54546831d0f1a5aab16b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4f5f08131514ea608354d16434631b63789bcb4b5e0d774ac2155dd2a78f6040", "request_id": "4ee689e53749512de794ea352856c4a0", "response_sha256": "c6c650489ea4833c796e34560f4907cd3e0d0b4e0b87aefeeb90b38622f84fe1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "42f5a798115c42661687f5aa3e558572", "candidate_priority_rank": 141, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1c9734211572c0d8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1c9734211572c0d8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1c9734211572c0d8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1c9734211572c0d8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "hot dog<->pizza", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "pizza", "B": "hot dog"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "pizza<->hot dog", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2393561", "image_sha256": "fb9f675b74177fd254cb3436b4cd8bbb6090f04d0dde7db8916c311991680f9f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2393561.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2393561.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2379691", "image_sha256": "7c2fcc49984d9f443687c3e061ef9bcef80cbde00fb9e0f149e99bdeee4fe4ec", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2379691.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2379691.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1c9734211572c0d8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "pizza", "diff_b": "hot dog", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "pizza", "component_b": "hot dog"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "counter", "countertop", "cutting board", "grinder", "lid", "pepper", "pepperoni", "pizza", "salt", "skillet", "stove", "tea kettle"], "detected_components": ["pizza"], "masked_program_sha256": "c28afe86cf1653d57d6b312e76050b44c0483cbf83c7796beed5fc0f33b968cb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pizza", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5cfdde24e1d11a4fe540a8a627c4687006afc0118dee412c9b5a4669e99e1680"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01498720", "text": "What cooking utensil is below the pizza?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bun", "cutting board", "drinks", "glass", "hot dog", "ice", "napkin", "napkins", "onion", "onions", "paper", "straw", "table", "tray", "vegetable", "wine glass"], "detected_components": ["hot dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "c28afe86cf1653d57d6b312e76050b44c0483cbf83c7796beed5fc0f33b968cb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["hot dog", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "hot dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["hot dog", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a77b38e18477adfb2e6cf4d35fe4afe837126543808b6b1ea6334f407a2b501c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0790437", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 141, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "7b8e4645d5943bd352011832b6a870b524381a644e4588126302af98c3948637", "selected_component": "hot dog", "selected_source_question_id": "0790437", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What cooking utensil is below the hot dog?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what cooking utensil is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "7b8e4645d5943bd352011832b6a870b524381a644e4588126302af98c3948637", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "pizza"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what cooking utensil is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "7b8e4645d5943bd352011832b6a870b524381a644e4588126302af98c3948637", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "hot dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cutting board", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a cutting board.", "question": "What cooking utensil is below the pizza?", "question_id": "01498720", "semantic": [{"argument": "pizza (471637)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,below,s (471645)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cutting board", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a cutting board.", "question": "What cooking utensil is below the hot dog?", "question_id": "0790437", "semantic": [{"argument": "hot dog (1355127)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,below,s (1355130)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["471642", "471643", "471645"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cutting board"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "471645", "query_target_entity_name": "cutting board", "relation_object_entity_id": "471637", "relation_subject_entity_id": "471645", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "471637", "selected_entity_name": "pizza"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["471637"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "hot dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1355130"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cutting board"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1355130", "query_target_entity_name": "cutting board", "relation_object_entity_id": "1355127", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1355130", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1355127", "selected_entity_name": "hot dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "hot dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1355127"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:42f5a798115c42661687f5aa3e558572", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "fb9f675b74177fd254cb3436b4cd8bbb6090f04d0dde7db8916c311991680f9f", "image_sha256_b": "7c2fcc49984d9f443687c3e061ef9bcef80cbde00fb9e0f149e99bdeee4fe4ec", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "60d49080a68725ce76633156e59597634ea859a26a6da9711379dfb59835076f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "cd8c87eaf96fda582d5667ba24c16a57", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ebbf3cd334aee8c241890db8e827b065a41eabd41b1a5d16fade6e1da9198c93"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0ab111278afc3a317a60ed417fa1c3243c51f92e7978b97172143cbc01f93465", "request_id": "d8cc6d86c7ef1783d4d00c13472d111a", "response_sha256": "651ae66e05233b4518c304c47d840cc173ed0d435ceaa274aee7ee1a7693a73d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d49a0bf6a89553a6a3ec5f041488b87f77dc0601d1dcc26520b05627a8af1f76", "request_id": "abb61ff948717d2a3d686d749ceccbde", "response_sha256": "d9bb375e8dbb97c0e95b119ab5746e702c9d8649269885c74fdce8b91d7a53bd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "9fca28db5939c8e08c18f113aa4418c5", "candidate_priority_rank": 146, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0bc74e7970d7703c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0bc74e7970d7703c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0bc74e7970d7703c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0bc74e7970d7703c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->girl", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cat", "B": "girl"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cat<->girl", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2408093", "image_sha256": "bddf8044788b97e80a296ad34db3c0370a1ada7c903ea0c72a023e7d9f4a0f27", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2408093.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2408093.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2356287", "image_sha256": "a892b1d99ac2941ddebbe687d672e59e8dd1ac3c260ee3d5da7b5fbfd71787ea", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2356287.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2356287.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0bc74e7970d7703c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cat", "diff_b": "girl", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cat", "component_b": "girl"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "cat", "collar", "couch", "floor", "hair", "head", "legs", "pillow", "remote control", "shoes", "tail"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "18e63fb9d1c7adfeb1215a9e72f0bdf81828dd318909c0683b532583b0732113"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19578785", "text": "What item of furniture is this cat on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bag", "blind", "book", "door", "face", "girl", "hair", "jeans", "laptop", "legs", "light switch", "logo", "phone", "shirt", "socks", "sofa", "sweater", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["girl"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "girl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "17f54003c45255cecf8ab220d94914d0525bf3bb3d51a3e7ff1771b97f697ce5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "08585718", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 146, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c2f23f089c7fae28c8ed128b9a9a5019c1b84ded7421b059bfb6014589f18d03", "selected_component": "girl", "selected_source_question_id": "08585718", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What item of furniture is this girl on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is this on?", "program_group_hash": "c2f23f089c7fae28c8ed128b9a9a5019c1b84ded7421b059bfb6014589f18d03", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what item of furniture is this on?", "program_group_hash": "c2f23f089c7fae28c8ed128b9a9a5019c1b84ded7421b059bfb6014589f18d03", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "girl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The cat is on the couch.", "question": "What item of furniture is this cat on?", "question_id": "19578785", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (268348)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (268347)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "sofa", "full_answer": "The girl is on the sofa.", "question": "What item of furniture is this girl on?", "question_id": "08585718", "semantic": [{"argument": "girl (821912)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (821918)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["268347"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "268347", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "268347", "relation_subject_entity_id": "268348", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "268348", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["268348"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["821918", "821930"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sofa"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "821918", "query_target_entity_name": "sofa", "relation_object_entity_id": "821918", "relation_subject_entity_id": "821912", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "821912", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["821912"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:9fca28db5939c8e08c18f113aa4418c5", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bddf8044788b97e80a296ad34db3c0370a1ada7c903ea0c72a023e7d9f4a0f27", "image_sha256_b": "a892b1d99ac2941ddebbe687d672e59e8dd1ac3c260ee3d5da7b5fbfd71787ea", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "448a6f228ba5ed0f4050b73e1381f00903e4f4550e23eb24cf25ede55ba8af8f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e8681a55e406ac6db6e134a3b2071ce5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "dbe1e1f1285e86744248b482c08656ae7556e5d2641487f9d6c5058c1623f7a5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "910726ffff89e7120f0904fc67fd458cb5d828cbe7208ee77bca097187f66270", "request_id": "ce9d03330242b931612a18416de1054b", "response_sha256": "dba9cd976f61dda1e9b251cc58ca4349ab4b013b1b29848bb497b0cc7d860afa", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "027def352049abc9a6cd82b6c504b72533f93f7d009d906404ccd4f65815dd01", "request_id": "165c5371039e99b806f444b39421804a", "response_sha256": "9738d6a7d6b64ecbebefa0368900f1552af6b26b952d727bc99d323d9c28b019", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "8f2e129551dd2e18c85c9718ae2d54b2", "candidate_priority_rank": 154, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a8fe66ec268fc0a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a8fe66ec268fc0a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a8fe66ec268fc0a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a8fe66ec268fc0a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bed<->grass", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bed", "B": "grass"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bed<->grass", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 196, "image_id": "2326609", "image_sha256": "6be96dd5e5c1d28c94c5311c0c4a61e3bea0a4dcc3c5c15b541fb7f3ac7ad15f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326609.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326609.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2390419", "image_sha256": "6ef6102dd5c35a89131e7098d24d4fc2af1f64ba02256c7c8debe7b753cbe1e2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390419.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390419.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a8fe66ec268fc0a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bed", "diff_b": "grass", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bed", "component_b": "grass"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "blanket", "books", "box", "cat", "cats", "ear", "eye", "face", "fur", "lamp", "paper", "room", "stuffed animal", "stuffed animals", "tail"], "detected_components": ["bed"], "masked_program_sha256": "82cf86727a35bb4d3d75e37bcf0ece98ebb765c61b04a4a8bd062721fd3e05ec", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bed", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f5b4edbe9a9b940d9662a280bf6a71359a73f8882931b1ebc8cd0b2ae951933e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06283337", "text": "What are the animals in the bed called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bell", "clouds", "collar", "cow", "cows", "ear", "face", "grass", "hair", "hill", "neck", "nose", "sky", "tag", "tree"], "detected_components": ["grass"], "masked_program_sha256": "82cf86727a35bb4d3d75e37bcf0ece98ebb765c61b04a4a8bd062721fd3e05ec", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "grass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bb54aa664be0ca32ae04c424ac061756e11826deac0d195eb7b46152aad2b1f3"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03853027", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 154, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e15aa908e19d54ccb24a2e1e53e31b82b0f3892bf25c4515bfb300da91652d73", "selected_component": "grass", "selected_source_question_id": "03853027", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the animals in the grass called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the animals in the called?", "program_group_hash": "e15aa908e19d54ccb24a2e1e53e31b82b0f3892bf25c4515bfb300da91652d73", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bed"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the animals in the called?", "program_group_hash": "e15aa908e19d54ccb24a2e1e53e31b82b0f3892bf25c4515bfb300da91652d73", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "grass"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cats", "full_answer": "The animals are cats.", "question": "What are the animals in the bed called?", "question_id": "06283337", "semantic": [{"argument": "bed (3981801)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (3981803)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cows", "full_answer": "The animals are cows.", "question": "What are the animals in the grass called?", "question_id": "03853027", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (497696)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (497689)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3981784", "3981803"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cats"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3981803", "query_target_entity_name": "cats", "relation_object_entity_id": "3981801", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3981803", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3981801", "selected_entity_name": "bed"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3981801"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["497689", "497693"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cows"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "grazing"], "query_target_entity_id": "497689", "query_target_entity_name": "cows", "relation_object_entity_id": "497696", "relation_subject_entity_id": "497689", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "497696", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["497696"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:8f2e129551dd2e18c85c9718ae2d54b2", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6be96dd5e5c1d28c94c5311c0c4a61e3bea0a4dcc3c5c15b541fb7f3ac7ad15f", "image_sha256_b": "6ef6102dd5c35a89131e7098d24d4fc2af1f64ba02256c7c8debe7b753cbe1e2", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "984febde59eafad0a190ff2e5d238d26039fb88f29b4141f87de1f86cec17dac", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ba6c71836d28985e9a51a2c2180f2d17", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "dac673ea3301fa2e0899586cdf059ce09668dfe1fea50cca20c2178b0fce7cb8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3e302de6fbe31db6e2bd79555acbabcb7241ea9e11411f6e4f45a3a85c31d38a", "request_id": "1bf06d4e226a9f82219c2fe6afc243a0", "response_sha256": "b9d9b4d06744c4d684818229e56b879211a268b6198c04ae835d240bea35bc5a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "563830e2937b0722cb1578442f9047b773918bf8198dc5cbd00ad1f9c973d8e5", "request_id": "8041d763aaed13b7d422af397c1f5516", "response_sha256": "c28632ed5ee3f676f051a61635821880a4887682156e1442b74eb2ed2239f9d3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "d0d07f46dfcf9f0071f55ffd8254bbd2", "candidate_priority_rank": 158, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5012c6afbdb1d430:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5012c6afbdb1d430:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5012c6afbdb1d430:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5012c6afbdb1d430:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blanket<->field", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "blanket", "B": "field"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blanket<->field", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 384, "image_id": "2392445", "image_sha256": "5acebb91ad8380a0a39625ac86bb2c7644791f50ce438d577a7435b04d7a4874", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392445.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392445.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2371795", "image_sha256": "f6b1e38edda1b3bb974e00733671af5ca2db451af2933e26e1f8fb1ba44bff72", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371795.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371795.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5012c6afbdb1d430", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blanket", "diff_b": "field", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blanket", "component_b": "field"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "blanket", "cat", "couch", "ear", "eye", "face", "food", "fork", "mouth", "nose", "paw"], "detected_components": ["blanket"], "masked_program_sha256": "883d3e02afa92e18010e6b533480931f2d8b31caf3a8a41fd0bc9d637ab3519b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blanket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "42475ec7583163b72e5f0caa565145fbd80a1bfa2568d1e1d8a17d65d60e5867"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00456186", "text": "What type of animal is lying on the blanket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "face", "field", "grass", "head", "hillside", "horse", "leaves", "mane", "mud", "nose", "rock"], "detected_components": ["field"], "masked_program_sha256": "883d3e02afa92e18010e6b533480931f2d8b31caf3a8a41fd0bc9d637ab3519b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "field", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "78d0624a18853c71baca1f8673e2b71e96077be39a472c39e27b3eda6860346f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02129705", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 158, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6ca35c159c1ec3869153c3e118c5c530771b48865f1a6c39dc9a97e118655fb8", "selected_component": "field", "selected_source_question_id": "02129705", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of animal is lying on the field?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is lying on the ?", "program_group_hash": "6ca35c159c1ec3869153c3e118c5c530771b48865f1a6c39dc9a97e118655fb8", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "blanket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is lying on the ?", "program_group_hash": "6ca35c159c1ec3869153c3e118c5c530771b48865f1a6c39dc9a97e118655fb8", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "field"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What type of animal is lying on the blanket?", "question_id": "00456186", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (1230016)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (3825935)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The animal is a horse.", "question": "What type of animal is lying on the field?", "question_id": "02129705", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (2449520)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (2340597)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3825935"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "furry", "soft"], "query_target_entity_id": "3825935", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1230016", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3825935", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1230016", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1230016"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2340597"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2340597", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "2449520", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2340597", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2449520", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2449520"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:d0d07f46dfcf9f0071f55ffd8254bbd2", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5acebb91ad8380a0a39625ac86bb2c7644791f50ce438d577a7435b04d7a4874", "image_sha256_b": "f6b1e38edda1b3bb974e00733671af5ca2db451af2933e26e1f8fb1ba44bff72", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1c7d056aa86801696bbc22bf401647e8a23982cda2c7c9bf337a4cd2265306ba", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "18eea766b3c08b497b6adb5dcd13281e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e19fecb9099e4a3a4870cf075671313a06f98430743c249bb8f36cbc96ce5fdf"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "72ebf88d0cbd21cd1855449085c5fdb877a8d302edecd540bc681c551f56b162", "request_id": "c28f31c0baee034913caa668e9838bad", "response_sha256": "83e8939ce93bd38cd8b702f7f9f7d6046ba9b5016c05b58fae44264447aa4542", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "23628bf77dff0c88d1aa82acd9d3569d557ec818c4ecdfa00b2f758eaeaae148", "request_id": "c05c9d8ab5d79afc5807f7d9495f9eaa", "response_sha256": "54c002fbf725183c33402363821153669ed45654915605e8fdee0ccec83f1466", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "8876b793ad931bacc391b9f3ba08d417", "candidate_priority_rank": 160, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb2582338825c85e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb2582338825c85e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb2582338825c85e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb2582338825c85e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cake<->pizza", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cake", "B": "pizza"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cake<->pizza", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2406935", "image_sha256": "4b47b8b89345c82de61113251c0f73f859634d8997dd4e623cea3ed5c53b0cf2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2406935.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2406935.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2352614", "image_sha256": "4496f8359a8550afba883a63db0d385fe14e123d3257fc39b0ff971b75e51b27", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2352614.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2352614.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-fb2582338825c85e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cake", "diff_b": "pizza", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cake", "component_b": "pizza"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "cake", "cake pan", "foil", "food", "fork", "hand", "jar", "knife", "man", "meat", "pan", "pickles", "plate", "sauce", "spoon", "table", "utensil"], "detected_components": ["cake"], "masked_program_sha256": "b2d4e3671cef87e0bd5c7dee90da81029f2ca741e01f4f101d24b8a4d7fae8cf", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cake", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cake", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "655721ee6de1dd39ae2e0853f75e37eece9f6d32dad00ffb888ca98d272dff8a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13348565", "text": "What is the cooking utensil that this cake is in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["baking pan", "burner", "cheese", "crust", "eye", "ground", "ham", "leaf", "onions", "peppers", "pizza", "plate", "sauce"], "detected_components": ["pizza"], "masked_program_sha256": "b2d4e3671cef87e0bd5c7dee90da81029f2ca741e01f4f101d24b8a4d7fae8cf", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza", "cooking utensil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pizza", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza", "cooking utensil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e7804c72b9906e26e78ef237811fb9b45e0dca190fa5586c9d6242c3b8d7d5c2"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15586688", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 160, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e4300936964b52ec0bb8ab0d8e8d7a91076f7c21b1d500ee1dc86952f73f30fe", "selected_component": "pizza", "selected_source_question_id": "15586688", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the cooking utensil that this pizza is in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cooking utensil that this is in?", "program_group_hash": "e4300936964b52ec0bb8ab0d8e8d7a91076f7c21b1d500ee1dc86952f73f30fe", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "cake"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the cooking utensil that this is in?", "program_group_hash": "e4300936964b52ec0bb8ab0d8e8d7a91076f7c21b1d500ee1dc86952f73f30fe", "queried_category": "cooking utensil", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "pizza"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cake pan", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a cake pan.", "question": "What is the cooking utensil that this cake is in?", "question_id": "13348565", "semantic": [{"argument": "cake (287949)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,in,o (287954)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "baking pan", "full_answer": "The cooking utensil is a baking pan.", "question": "What is the cooking utensil that this pizza is in?", "question_id": "15586688", "semantic": [{"argument": "pizza (1990526)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "cooking utensil,in,o (3782747)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["287954", "287956"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cake pan"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "287954", "query_target_entity_name": "cake pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "287954", "relation_subject_entity_id": "287949", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "287949", "selected_entity_name": "cake"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["287949"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cake", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3782747"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["baking pan"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3782747", "query_target_entity_name": "baking pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "3782747", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1990526", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1990526", "selected_entity_name": "pizza"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1990526"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:8876b793ad931bacc391b9f3ba08d417", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4b47b8b89345c82de61113251c0f73f859634d8997dd4e623cea3ed5c53b0cf2", "image_sha256_b": "4496f8359a8550afba883a63db0d385fe14e123d3257fc39b0ff971b75e51b27", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "184494661fee010b0359fade72cb577612a09a624ea807fced11d455037333c1", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d16a83a89a82457f24f83389cade54bf", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5b6620be36c7468616201c6387d2699ea81908b0556be1e15cd0dc96759455b8"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4fc16af9f4bce5b64e23e94ba0d2e77545d08a6ec2c23d5cb567ede1ef75cd2f", "request_id": "79920cb025aa7d32ae89581bf651792b", "response_sha256": "d5f2d8e43a31b60a86f9f85610b33087a1e9e20ca57d8d10ebb960c062608457", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0fb8617402230eb4742f10076e82941484c84f763bac67ce75453d97af958409", "request_id": "cf63fcefd3815fd1d9e049ab9b95293e", "response_sha256": "4a6b01751d8479a18278959a27724b3a021ea12268297d7a650a2919d125be6c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "158726e2c4ce3431b17b1cfefe8186c6", "candidate_priority_rank": 165, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3bc8e3cc3d695bc3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3bc8e3cc3d695bc3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3bc8e3cc3d695bc3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3bc8e3cc3d695bc3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "living room<->restroom", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "restroom", "B": "living room"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "restroom<->living room", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2392155", "image_sha256": "8f5db5b531263b5aec7ca0378e8429f62893bc76d9dea6ba92fbe5df3ced42af", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392155.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392155.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2321841", "image_sha256": "2e870a2912694d051dd31854ec5f1173434153ce41285d72745533462557a505", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2321841.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2321841.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-3bc8e3cc3d695bc3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "restroom", "diff_b": "living room", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "restroom", "component_b": "living room"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "lid", "restroom", "toilet", "toilet seat", "trash", "trash can"], "detected_components": ["restroom"], "masked_program_sha256": "2c0e81d46c3586145d6a7313a6868badc790731a762f490d23134fd6b3d30c8e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["restroom"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "restroom", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["restroom"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "09afd0cba260d10327d19b66eec57203398266db0037ef8b2ee1fc653a6ffc6b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05647741", "text": "What is sitting inside the restroom?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["controller", "couch", "curtain", "curtains", "dog", "frame", "glasses", "hair", "lady", "lamp", "living room", "pants", "pillow", "remote control", "shirt", "table", "towel", "video game", "wall", "wallpaper", "watch", "wii controller", "windows", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["living room"], "masked_program_sha256": "2c0e81d46c3586145d6a7313a6868badc790731a762f490d23134fd6b3d30c8e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["living room"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "living room", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["living room"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fd3a2c78666928a55645402bc668d5b5dbebc55bdfed3415defd3d2d864aa29c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03577968", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 165, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "fd86ae026759384ea9b6ec3b8562c403e35760a2460b186cef8e7d4613a7e027", "selected_component": "living room", "selected_source_question_id": "03577968", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is sitting inside the living room?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is sitting inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "fd86ae026759384ea9b6ec3b8562c403e35760a2460b186cef8e7d4613a7e027", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting inside", "select_category": "restroom"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is sitting inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "fd86ae026759384ea9b6ec3b8562c403e35760a2460b186cef8e7d4613a7e027", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting inside", "select_category": "living room"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "toilet", "full_answer": "The toilet is sitting inside the restroom.", "question": "What is sitting inside the restroom?", "question_id": "05647741", "semantic": [{"argument": "restroom (3826200)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting inside,s (3826202)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The couch is sitting inside the living room.", "question": "What is sitting inside the living room?", "question_id": "03577968", "semantic": [{"argument": "living room (4185122)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting inside,s (4185106)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3826188", "3826189", "3826202", "3826211", "3826217", "482619", "482620"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["toilet"], "predicate": "sitting inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3826202", "query_target_entity_name": "toilet", "relation_object_entity_id": "3826200", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3826202", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3826200", "selected_entity_name": "restroom"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "restroom", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3826200"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "living room", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "restroom", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4185078", "4185083", "4185084", "4185086", "4185087", "4185095", "4185106", "4185114", "4185119", "4185127", "4185133", "4185135", "4185136", "4185138", "4185140", "4185141", "4185143", "4185144", "4185148", "4185152", "4185153", "4185154", "4185155", "4185158"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 24, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "sitting inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "large", "leather"], "query_target_entity_id": "4185106", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "4185122", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4185106", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4185122", "selected_entity_name": "living room"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "living room", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4185122"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:158726e2c4ce3431b17b1cfefe8186c6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "8f5db5b531263b5aec7ca0378e8429f62893bc76d9dea6ba92fbe5df3ced42af", "image_sha256_b": "2e870a2912694d051dd31854ec5f1173434153ce41285d72745533462557a505", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7e42a1458cf88ed3af07fe49ab490c6bd0182f8e737db061d0008d6e7358becd", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "84b290befa1222ea5794823e6d6ee506", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "48333194ffbdd76049f6ba2889aa4598a59379ec90078bc9f05d1e77750de2be"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "37bdeac5bbf37846268292fb14dbbf34b23fe8ba9f020ee26a16169fb6401378", "request_id": "2f3abb2ea896bf8b22c8e996f7d3fde0", "response_sha256": "e33f86ea64b7d902ad4a35060e0ba1f060a967090d9f336d66bea52ba18c9ea4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "80939574fbd1c93f265690648bd2a5918c0b241e7658be4abd63d2014390888c", "request_id": "29a3ccf8af942e8eaef75ccf61cfd10b", "response_sha256": "c08aab82d689d43f9cd2e025f875b4b3081d19184f3f58a4b456ad201c5e5ffa", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "18a158e5371fd0acae4a1afd1ce629ea", "candidate_priority_rank": 190, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68eafecea9e420bc:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68eafecea9e420bc:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68eafecea9e420bc:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68eafecea9e420bc:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "giraffe<->train", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "train", "B": "giraffe"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "train<->giraffe", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2338129", "image_sha256": "d163e1412bb4f6e4fa261a7e28900923f12044c7883bd543134229ba0adb9b1f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2338129.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2338129.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 324, "image_id": "2348314", "image_sha256": "5d8e46a3119a54eb3e293145ba4d2583a196e48fd965e09550fe6ec8c32a474b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2348314.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2348314.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-68eafecea9e420bc", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "train", "diff_b": "giraffe", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "train", "component_b": "giraffe"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bracelet", "cow", "door", "eye", "foot", "hand", "head", "horn", "leg", "man", "mustache", "nose", "pants", "shirt", "tail", "train", "wall", "window", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["train"], "masked_program_sha256": "0442b5a86e27e9293bb07a2c3cff75ce6b55263d4465da22e3e5e6b6c27e7083", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["train", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "train", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["train", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a9945a12b52c98e84bdafc879ae08806e76498341969701e95fa4612cb22e2c5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12850044", "text": "What animal is walking past the train?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "fence", "field", "giraffe", "hair", "horn", "neck", "spots", "tail", "tree", "zebra", "zoo"], "detected_components": ["giraffe"], "masked_program_sha256": "0442b5a86e27e9293bb07a2c3cff75ce6b55263d4465da22e3e5e6b6c27e7083", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "giraffe", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2bf2606597d136b84c154079813a71a49ead9d8820e0c665e390f3a6df917a23"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05103003", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 190, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "94990af4f7c63f72343cf1834eafa801810dea1dc9e8a80f4c182f769c850972", "selected_component": "giraffe", "selected_source_question_id": "05103003", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is walking past the giraffe?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking past,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is walking past the ?", "program_group_hash": "94990af4f7c63f72343cf1834eafa801810dea1dc9e8a80f4c182f769c850972", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking past", "select_category": "train"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking past,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is walking past the ?", "program_group_hash": "94990af4f7c63f72343cf1834eafa801810dea1dc9e8a80f4c182f769c850972", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking past", "select_category": "giraffe"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cow", "full_answer": "The cow is walking past the train.", "question": "What animal is walking past the train?", "question_id": "12850044", "semantic": [{"argument": "train (955176)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking past,s (955158)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "zebra", "full_answer": "The zebra is walking past the giraffe.", "question": "What animal is walking past the giraffe?", "question_id": "05103003", "semantic": [{"argument": "giraffe (1931404)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking past,s (3606110)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["955158"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cow"], "predicate": "walking past", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "walking"], "query_target_entity_id": "955158", "query_target_entity_name": "cow", "relation_object_entity_id": "955176", "relation_subject_entity_id": "955158", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "955176", "selected_entity_name": "train"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "train", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["955176"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "train", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3606110"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["zebra"], "predicate": "walking past", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3606110", "query_target_entity_name": "zebra", "relation_object_entity_id": "1931404", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3606110", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1931404", "selected_entity_name": "giraffe"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1931404"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:18a158e5371fd0acae4a1afd1ce629ea", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d163e1412bb4f6e4fa261a7e28900923f12044c7883bd543134229ba0adb9b1f", "image_sha256_b": "5d8e46a3119a54eb3e293145ba4d2583a196e48fd965e09550fe6ec8c32a474b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8bf9b455870f8265e3b47f7950561f9ef87560c27c7d6b6e7877b59585104f13", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3f50475a9c1413e0176cb5f126a1f36b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3da1a6951d45103e5b0d7ed41b502adc2fc36e6232b52041c65f6fce9a734a29"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d017cb9a88deb35f67833baafc060269961782ef7b9e6d711bbb241c6ce1228d", "request_id": "783d69d819893eb8d5af9f423f982585", "response_sha256": "686c55fb118a1fb35dec0e9adf63dafd436195993ce6a39599b7ab56739eac91", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "67acbe3356ff90972e41f57a40d888c834b112c351182ace13cef458d47aee9d", "request_id": "776fc00948190831cb8ea8be138c5bda", "response_sha256": "015104dd883120bbb9abefccf04b68550a588da4c7012ae5a4f055e0095fcc32", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ce4ae8baeb950bc30139f9dd85a6b4b3", "candidate_priority_rank": 194, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-92bb5db9480badf7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-92bb5db9480badf7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-92bb5db9480badf7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-92bb5db9480badf7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blanket<->laptop", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "blanket", "B": "laptop"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blanket<->laptop", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2341891", "image_sha256": "e2a3d82395d29faf6fe6d48ae2c40b0c7e1944e9607a3b5345685e50f5b47448", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2341891.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2341891.jpg", "width": 387}, "B": {"height": 331, "image_id": "2323389", "image_sha256": "a47dc6bed5de0413f050f8b65f4c2e1222fc7134430bf28a04ffedfbc4c88c2a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2323389.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2323389.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-92bb5db9480badf7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blanket", "diff_b": "laptop", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blanket", "component_b": "laptop"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "blanket", "dog", "ear", "eye", "floor", "foot", "ground", "hair", "leg", "paw", "pillow", "wall"], "detected_components": ["blanket"], "masked_program_sha256": "b13e44f8e4412b70e297e51c43c4cb5e60254237650037696c97be387f934cf5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blanket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "643a2776d65be9dbd2dba6d5a9ccb4b8e6ff0efb9eb43845a6c01bd618fc31d0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06926432", "text": "What animal is resting on the blanket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "ear", "eye", "fur", "keyboard", "laptop", "nose"], "detected_components": ["laptop"], "masked_program_sha256": "b13e44f8e4412b70e297e51c43c4cb5e60254237650037696c97be387f934cf5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["laptop", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "laptop", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["laptop", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3e88d8f4f1b034f8739153c6fc4041e01cbfa3c34d86d3afc4f65984d5efa3d4"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00466920", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 194, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 12, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "aad513da51a6069004a367aaed183cf10976d38daa6eca45e93fcd5e97f34116", "selected_component": "laptop", "selected_source_question_id": "00466920", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is resting on the laptop?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is resting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "aad513da51a6069004a367aaed183cf10976d38daa6eca45e93fcd5e97f34116", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "blanket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is resting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "aad513da51a6069004a367aaed183cf10976d38daa6eca45e93fcd5e97f34116", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "laptop"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is resting on the blanket.", "question": "What animal is resting on the blanket?", "question_id": "06926432", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (3652059)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s (2022193)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is resting on the laptop.", "question": "What animal is resting on the laptop?", "question_id": "00466920", "semantic": [{"argument": "laptop (4151640)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s (4151636)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2022193"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2022193", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "3652059", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2022193", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3652059", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3652059"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "laptop", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4151636"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "4151636", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "4151640", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4151636", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4151640", "selected_entity_name": "laptop"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "laptop", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4151640"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ce4ae8baeb950bc30139f9dd85a6b4b3", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e2a3d82395d29faf6fe6d48ae2c40b0c7e1944e9607a3b5345685e50f5b47448", "image_sha256_b": "a47dc6bed5de0413f050f8b65f4c2e1222fc7134430bf28a04ffedfbc4c88c2a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0c3ce2440708e9a37133dec5219539d6558e5090c97fb1e1c4457d2f5ce5132f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "e5d9ee39809ae046447cb7407471a2d7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "86739587de65fd13b32ea50bb0fc79641b5bbfed698e0757c20b5fa24a021f4a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "87ba69f3aea332291c02a8c4525a3d8f0c3486830020b588ed5cf2b877a51762", "request_id": "ab40355e7f76487e03b50f164b2edcee", "response_sha256": "ab6681dcafc8280fb057fdde6a8d26b857cab89d66170eff9723e5e7b8f9bb2b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "71a296ab9c8561c73eb3739598f2047e66e179ec06b925b2ed193e85db66024c", "request_id": "f541b9e9d9130bb803e0c9b13d7bd990", "response_sha256": "a98d8f36ed5a143f7c9e052ad68cfe108059360cf5fdd8709c8026dc9787da6d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "c150f6556d3aa13b045623fb415f28cf", "candidate_priority_rank": 202, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e98c09a42c066be:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e98c09a42c066be:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e98c09a42c066be:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e98c09a42c066be:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->pan", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cat", "B": "pan"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cat<->pan", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2369033", "image_sha256": "e7b6021e7abece3e044285f7ddd2d61cabcdcbd9e8b86ac1a8e87e50dddd13b1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369033.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369033.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2351848", "image_sha256": "ec50cda67ab189b740074ce446f5745e767b42a4339c9119005ed369778da0db", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2351848.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2351848.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e98c09a42c066be", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cat", "diff_b": "pan", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cat", "component_b": "pan"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "box", "cat", "cord", "ground", "hair", "lid", "pizza", "tail", "towel", "toy"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b90056f631873f6d211915590c2777bf23f81fbfbc9b0ca05d8312d37b247522"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01134298", "text": "What is this cat inside of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cinnamon roll", "foil", "orange", "oven", "pan", "wall"], "detected_components": ["pan"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pan"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pan", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pan"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "da37a43d0d811871726bd1ec73e5d539b81bc93dee474a0fc491790fa28379bb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "19147000", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 202, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 12, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "selected_component": "pan", "selected_source_question_id": "19147000", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this pan inside of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this inside of?", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this inside of?", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "pan"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "box", "full_answer": "The cat is inside the box.", "question": "What is this cat inside of?", "question_id": "01134298", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (2140526)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (2622862)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "oven", "full_answer": "The pan is inside the oven.", "question": "What is this pan inside of?", "question_id": "19147000", "semantic": [{"argument": "pan (857828)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (857820)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1694963", "1695762", "1840482", "1855364", "2452562", "2492504", "2620645", "2622862", "2622863", "2678985"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["box"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2622862", "query_target_entity_name": "box", "relation_object_entity_id": "2622862", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2140526", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2140526", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2140526"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["857819", "857820", "857821", "857822", "857823", "857824", "857825", "857827", "857834", "857836"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["oven"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["dark"], "query_target_entity_id": "857820", "query_target_entity_name": "oven", "relation_object_entity_id": "857820", "relation_subject_entity_id": "857828", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "857828", "selected_entity_name": "pan"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pan", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["857828"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c150f6556d3aa13b045623fb415f28cf", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e7b6021e7abece3e044285f7ddd2d61cabcdcbd9e8b86ac1a8e87e50dddd13b1", "image_sha256_b": "ec50cda67ab189b740074ce446f5745e767b42a4339c9119005ed369778da0db", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5b417ffd85cac974121591042c5ce4e9ee996ec7029b6e9e85e09190b065219a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "32f190f8749a87df1b7f4da73a1dbc9f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f19f2ba75f8a3f24c5494dd94aaab2196bc6701a520431548193ca8bf5952370"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "438ed3627771b693641ce49059ce508715615c2c9a65faddd4d063226f21055b", "request_id": "d0e42a18cf002f537ec770ee44d34c04", "response_sha256": "81acc938a0b36bcba43eae676037483a34e6cad695b38af30cf81b96fe8fce43", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ce7e4eb4b398ad0ce3ea7131dd1e053916b32ea655c12ed987a210e07d41d3cb", "request_id": "7d3884ca8948ece990bb7156a0830c3a", "response_sha256": "f2efbf071e9bb1495169eb1e708ae70c7e3b7b1049df2fbd5ef65b85a6d437b9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "60d16ddbb2a3abb6df06fe4cfb0e5e50", "candidate_priority_rank": 205, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf51312cb8d53035:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf51312cb8d53035:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf51312cb8d53035:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf51312cb8d53035:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "baby<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "baby", "B": "woman"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "baby<->woman", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2334377", "image_sha256": "d0cd878813b2ba28aa9d6350728432f7df0717e256090c37a339537b429226f8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2334377.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2334377.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2396612", "image_sha256": "caa249c84ae94f9901abca0bff4f19e4e3d4798419daeba4f14a730ef526baab", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396612.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396612.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-bf51312cb8d53035", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "baby", "diff_b": "woman", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "baby", "component_b": "woman"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["apple", "baby", "camera", "car", "chair", "couch", "cup", "food", "hair", "hand", "lid", "light switch", "machine", "pajamas", "placemat", "table"], "detected_components": ["baby"], "masked_program_sha256": "af47ac7a8821161534aa12c7d793273f2ff7e1300b9efa8e867dc983723577ae", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "baby", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d6bd729d588ac8f950eb8c8869ba3ce2ec69fb9011ae872723f147a9166d729e"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00791502", "text": "What is the baby smiling at?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "blankets", "closet", "dirt", "door", "ear", "earring", "eyes", "feet", "foot", "hair", "lamp", "laptop", "mouth", "sheet", "shirt", "shorts", "sign", "teeth", "wall", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "af47ac7a8821161534aa12c7d793273f2ff7e1300b9efa8e867dc983723577ae", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b4b232aaa97634d12120f1ad2481692ecf405bc975d7747db29d9b1082ca0b98"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1314126", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 205, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6214b3923a53ff94a42ee14e7c1bd56edf831c8de3629eb52892e6f812e3e3ad", "selected_component": "woman", "selected_source_question_id": "1314126", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the woman smiling at?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,smiling at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the smiling at?", "program_group_hash": "6214b3923a53ff94a42ee14e7c1bd56edf831c8de3629eb52892e6f812e3e3ad", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "smiling at", "select_category": "baby"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,smiling at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the smiling at?", "program_group_hash": "6214b3923a53ff94a42ee14e7c1bd56edf831c8de3629eb52892e6f812e3e3ad", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "smiling at", "select_category": "woman"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "camera", "full_answer": "The baby is smiling at the camera.", "question": "What is the baby smiling at?", "question_id": "00791502", "semantic": [{"argument": "baby (4653628)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,smiling at,o (4653662)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "laptop", "full_answer": "The woman is smiling at the laptop.", "question": "What is the woman smiling at?", "question_id": "1314126", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (442378)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,smiling at,o (442379)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4633778", "4633779", "4633780", "4633781", "4633782", "4633786", "4633789", "4633790", "4653622", "4653626", "4653629", "4653633", "4653634", "4653640", "4653650", "4653652", "4653654", "4653655", "4653656", "4653662", "4653663", "4653664", "4653665", "4653667", "4653668", "4653673"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 26, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["camera"], "predicate": "smiling at", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4653662", "query_target_entity_name": "camera", "relation_object_entity_id": "4653662", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4653628", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4653628", "selected_entity_name": "baby"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4653628"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["442377", "442379", "442380", "442381", "442382", "442383", "442385", "442386", "442387", "442388", "442389", "442391", "442392", "442393", "442394", "442396", "442398", "442399", "442402", "442403", "442404"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["laptop"], "predicate": "smiling at", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "open"], "query_target_entity_id": "442379", "query_target_entity_name": "laptop", "relation_object_entity_id": "442379", "relation_subject_entity_id": "442378", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "442378", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["442378"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:60d16ddbb2a3abb6df06fe4cfb0e5e50", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d0cd878813b2ba28aa9d6350728432f7df0717e256090c37a339537b429226f8", "image_sha256_b": "caa249c84ae94f9901abca0bff4f19e4e3d4798419daeba4f14a730ef526baab", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "29ff969b8828897aa2eb9a4598a1d4809547a33c281d38841daa6c67358e1b6a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a7da7c3443b6f1c3cdcd1f1d820d96bb", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "46924482f1c7c79ad63dea148c1f6a1686559917de4c114bf11d9cc386534167"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "60d3d086d6c8b7afd02d6098e65b2d57cea44fd61357770f7a9dba9d034b97db", "request_id": "4ee1fbc01b571d5150721f4161cd42d8", "response_sha256": "c637d0de01b67d384941d354b73cbdd21f9bc5508756727888015a6f7394ec64", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "187f20960bde9897efcdd1c13f17c3d990134dda53daf46a03a13377f1032acd", "request_id": "454a363be970b699907fca2486d141f3", "response_sha256": "8cd160db15e0dc266804df6100fb4d6c05e0689aab5672412b3d3d1e602d9847", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "9a15396ac44a966585f6c4a2f157cd4e", "candidate_priority_rank": 218, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d2c637bb37824237:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d2c637bb37824237:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d2c637bb37824237:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d2c637bb37824237:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "ground<->hay", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "hay", "B": "ground"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "hay<->ground", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2364521", "image_sha256": "18bb7311db9664c77fdb6d60edf1653410080438038a39a6975f208787c903f4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364521.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364521.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2328153", "image_sha256": "c163e069fd2403c9153f16f97715c67dadaeab9bdbf995f3b0b87e0b7981a8ec", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2328153.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2328153.jpg", "width": 373}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d2c637bb37824237", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "hay", "diff_b": "ground", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "hay", "component_b": "ground"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "giraffe", "hair", "hay", "head", "leg", "neck", "sheep", "spots", "window"], "detected_components": ["hay"], "masked_program_sha256": "9d101c86b63c1693b6803bccde91431dc0f12d8f9bc1d7f08119d3d92ad9829f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["hay", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "hay", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["hay", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0f4dbf7c7a7b18769e668f0a0cc2edba44ad8ce131fded1ad0e508753f8bdff6"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01388650", "text": "What kind of animal is walking on the hay?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "elephant", "foot", "ground", "head", "leg", "man", "pants", "person", "plants", "platform", "rope", "scarf", "trunk"], "detected_components": ["ground"], "masked_program_sha256": "9d101c86b63c1693b6803bccde91431dc0f12d8f9bc1d7f08119d3d92ad9829f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ground", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "56de57efacf312bccb7b9d0cd21120f40353c6ea2c84e28a597dc8db8a13a303"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "051044910", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 218, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 16, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e993f495ffac273c7eeb7b45314da6f1be935ec849362fd5b2f59fb1e43d28cf", "selected_component": "ground", "selected_source_question_id": "051044910", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of animal is walking on the ground?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is walking on the ?", "program_group_hash": "e993f495ffac273c7eeb7b45314da6f1be935ec849362fd5b2f59fb1e43d28cf", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "hay"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is walking on the ?", "program_group_hash": "e993f495ffac273c7eeb7b45314da6f1be935ec849362fd5b2f59fb1e43d28cf", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "ground"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The animal is a giraffe.", "question": "What kind of animal is walking on the hay?", "question_id": "01388650", "semantic": [{"argument": "hay (3738119)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s (1779147)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The animal is an elephant.", "question": "What kind of animal is walking on the ground?", "question_id": "051044910", "semantic": [{"argument": "ground (3365202)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s (3365201)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1779147", "2507189"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["baby"], "query_target_entity_id": "1779147", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "3738119", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1779147", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3738119", "selected_entity_name": "hay"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "hay", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3738119"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "hay", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3365201"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3365201", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "3365202", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3365201", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3365202", "selected_entity_name": "ground"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3365202"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:9a15396ac44a966585f6c4a2f157cd4e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "18bb7311db9664c77fdb6d60edf1653410080438038a39a6975f208787c903f4", "image_sha256_b": "c163e069fd2403c9153f16f97715c67dadaeab9bdbf995f3b0b87e0b7981a8ec", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "da8f2f29d2f39b171a0edb6496304ded71686d877c82e1a00d75129d668bfa56", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7d56ae760705f4d4daf5557ff30b9279", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "34bab0093a980c59c699c088b25d8a609a855f568769ea4112bbbde8565fd994"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "532215a65e4b2fb50d9b63f8305321326c7097bac22c1e8d2a2ae8b41557f061", "request_id": "74a790898c3abb11b83bb40817492d8f", "response_sha256": "2f8372c50feff7abb3d38066dbfaa62415e6372574bf870eee17b11bdc465236", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "476b82e1ca0f79a5b03133e00ba1747cbeca91d2e2a8cd8e80e76d8cbd517572", "request_id": "3570e31ae684b75979a58ec07e935eee", "response_sha256": "61d5a1b47c4bb9e0d88d6127deef665106914fae51fa3f2bb79750909baa70ed", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "8b3989e8424bf50fe56016c5445e3ec6", "candidate_priority_rank": 219, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-acfe9f7848f17369:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-acfe9f7848f17369:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-acfe9f7848f17369:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-acfe9f7848f17369:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->dog", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dog", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dog<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2402433", "image_sha256": "260d9b8d29ef64d1576d046f2e9206e0f18d9b49f9b820ac8ad623a2cda0e2c5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402433.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402433.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 378, "image_id": "2371084", "image_sha256": "0eb6e2c0fddeaa629d82a07500b3c628e5cc6769ff6f6c7770c0e21e286f4ec9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371084.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371084.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-acfe9f7848f17369", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dog", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dog", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["collar", "dog", "ear", "eye", "fur", "grass", "house", "mouth", "nose", "road", "roof", "sidewalk", "teeth", "tongue", "tree", "truck", "window"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "c50480a1d262d238b2062ba1b80068a91be181210aeb45a12c8de880564a4a1d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f419a97b6cd4e506e6d8edb0834f47efe97f1be4fa14cf5c3ac1f23052b76168"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13313867", "text": "What vehicle is this dog in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bushes", "car", "cat", "ear", "eye", "eyes", "fur", "grass", "highway", "leaves", "neck", "nose", "person", "road", "sky", "trees", "window"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "c50480a1d262d238b2062ba1b80068a91be181210aeb45a12c8de880564a4a1d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "79a415d5e9b9e601e6db3e8497e22d77231399006552bf41cf9ac085a25bdd8d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03156762", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 219, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "be1b8f81cce9df64305be550f5e63cce87a60b87bf4758006b64a5631254ea14", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "03156762", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What vehicle is this cat in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicle is this in?", "program_group_hash": "be1b8f81cce9df64305be550f5e63cce87a60b87bf4758006b64a5631254ea14", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what vehicle is this in?", "program_group_hash": "be1b8f81cce9df64305be550f5e63cce87a60b87bf4758006b64a5631254ea14", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "truck", "full_answer": "The dog is in the truck.", "question": "What vehicle is this dog in?", "question_id": "13313867", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (1136251)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o (1136280)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The cat is in the car.", "question": "What vehicle is this cat in?", "question_id": "03156762", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (599823)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o (599825)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1136280"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["truck"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "1136280", "query_target_entity_name": "truck", "relation_object_entity_id": "1136280", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1136251", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1136251", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1136251"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["599825"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "599825", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "599825", "relation_subject_entity_id": "599823", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "599823", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["599823"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:8b3989e8424bf50fe56016c5445e3ec6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "260d9b8d29ef64d1576d046f2e9206e0f18d9b49f9b820ac8ad623a2cda0e2c5", "image_sha256_b": "0eb6e2c0fddeaa629d82a07500b3c628e5cc6769ff6f6c7770c0e21e286f4ec9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "cd44914d93b043e67d6742e0a748ce32a27ff855af4ef73d41b5f254c31ad259", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8c8565e82a3bf7c0fee0787085f3aa18", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1f5ecddbb82b9a48067fa1426fbfbaabc3f577a09abb6750995c381cb62ef97f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d20dfef9feef60308fd60c0b785f60a4c103c3e381f1d0b0b3492e6b644e4321", "request_id": "c8dffa03a306fa6602f577fea39b8980", "response_sha256": "aa07f58deba42acdf4dd90c506d6bbe97b39d195ded63f302f120449b408d045", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2592c43bab1b12a0bb99a134bca407edd64f4eb84d86a487af0c99225a23a245", "request_id": "b92329dc708a120b35b089520e0c95cb", "response_sha256": "b96144dd5c48e4c9fb41b30f1d02ef41d33697fb7e264dee8612eaab91517947", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "e194b67c3bdb3bc03f83780f52479c88", "candidate_priority_rank": 220, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-246ebad6c21d0e1f:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-246ebad6c21d0e1f:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-246ebad6c21d0e1f:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-246ebad6c21d0e1f:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "carpet<->wall", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "wall", "B": "carpet"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wall<->carpet", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2387027", "image_sha256": "7ac7b825941f02989217f6acb85117c0897a2ea45a2121de22686abef91ac10d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387027.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387027.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2388443", "image_sha256": "a3dae00035282d779f2419c27bb7f702d3a17717d54b52646e8abb6b1639ad88", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388443.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388443.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-246ebad6c21d0e1f", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wall", "diff_b": "carpet", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wall", "component_b": "carpet"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "basket", "cord", "cupboard", "door", "kettle", "outlet", "plate", "table", "toaster", "towel", "wall"], "detected_components": ["wall"], "masked_program_sha256": "ed5e2a55be562502761936bc904fba808f0addaea36c345f6f0d9eb111aa247e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wall", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f2a03844c9c5943f7f6d39923c7ea6fe40c254e4d71174b3d551dbc8af10eae6"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18283866", "text": "What is the item of furniture that is on the wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "cabinet", "carpet", "curtains", "headboard", "sheet", "wall"], "detected_components": ["carpet"], "masked_program_sha256": "ed5e2a55be562502761936bc904fba808f0addaea36c345f6f0d9eb111aa247e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["carpet", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "carpet", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["carpet", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "66266d605a5b1bbda60d38150e823a83dc96cdc9987482506e94927364dc56d0"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16119110", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 220, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "44569fd5e388ddb0495c1f3eabee224a1477650aad67f06362bbcb15c255cf6b", "selected_component": "carpet", "selected_source_question_id": "16119110", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the item of furniture that is on the carpet?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "44569fd5e388ddb0495c1f3eabee224a1477650aad67f06362bbcb15c255cf6b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "44569fd5e388ddb0495c1f3eabee224a1477650aad67f06362bbcb15c255cf6b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "carpet"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cupboard", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a cupboard.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that is on the wall?", "question_id": "18283866", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (515629)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s (515623)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a bed.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that is on the carpet?", "question_id": "16119110", "semantic": [{"argument": "carpet (3829379)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,s (1268808)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["515622", "515623"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cupboard"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["open", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "515623", "query_target_entity_name": "cupboard", "relation_object_entity_id": "515629", "relation_subject_entity_id": "515623", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "515629", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["515629"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "carpet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1268808", "3829357"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1268811"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1268808", "3829357"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["blue", "made", "neat"], "query_target_entity_id": "1268808", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "3829379", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1268808", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3829379", "selected_entity_name": "carpet"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "carpet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3829379"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e194b67c3bdb3bc03f83780f52479c88", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7ac7b825941f02989217f6acb85117c0897a2ea45a2121de22686abef91ac10d", "image_sha256_b": "a3dae00035282d779f2419c27bb7f702d3a17717d54b52646e8abb6b1639ad88", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b470331c6a7f8a9b49f5b311f909708d700f1189ca9b19bbf8e9d2983843b820", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "421c10e1090b90e05efdfab9a9c10111", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1654654bf4d2d6ea74cd15214344037801abbc3e5558eb8e993f6d2616cf137f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0872c32f8f861fc0346bfd473b142a3bd9bca5c9238b267dd2b87209c6bca8af", "request_id": "7eb6161fe1454366036e60772a205d71", "response_sha256": "ae3cdaa576cf563554514224700b5a8e95e82f84bf5b96ecb6eae4a56925ff11", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "68549992e77059c262d5f2408db09dde42f96a638aa21b1a73f11f34ced01a15", "request_id": "2b457dfabd1be7ca00d82f4f7068aa63", "response_sha256": "252d5639b11c4f2619bf260de21312bb97d21110d26f9527a557220a56bb7012", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ef7e9a324a3a35ec3f37b2d003b1a664", "candidate_priority_rank": 235, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0679d70011f2b944:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0679d70011f2b944:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0679d70011f2b944:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0679d70011f2b944:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->dog", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cat", "B": "dog"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cat<->dog", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2414820", "image_sha256": "7db59999b250e2ab3c85a51292c6318cd63705216ee0d5e5ed06099908e13a2f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2414820.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2414820.jpg", "width": 439}, "B": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2324418", "image_sha256": "0fa5570ec492a27db3dce98150ce5684d377f7e720ba721450a8fcf573a06b02", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2324418.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2324418.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0679d70011f2b944", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cat", "diff_b": "dog", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cat", "component_b": "dog"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "eye", "leg", "mirror", "nose", "remote control"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "90ed3ed50f90f1495897bb45594a6232b06dc54b6aa3ace0925fb09054ffb38e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0bfacf9d01ca9d77fa035c2004f76f1120cc539afb667a5d67791d97c9c7200d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03284052", "text": "What is the cat looking in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["collar", "dog", "door", "ear", "entrance", "hair", "leg", "mat", "nose", "pavement", "sign", "store", "tail"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "90ed3ed50f90f1495897bb45594a6232b06dc54b6aa3ace0925fb09054ffb38e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "187a36b544e514b12240a1be132706e601bb90664083e51618960a216e0c7023"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15381880", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 235, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3cf44c18743aa9412304042c9885e8972f80b8400e2e6de316afd64271e1a24e", "selected_component": "dog", "selected_source_question_id": "15381880", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the dog looking in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the looking in?", "program_group_hash": "3cf44c18743aa9412304042c9885e8972f80b8400e2e6de316afd64271e1a24e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking in", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the looking in?", "program_group_hash": "3cf44c18743aa9412304042c9885e8972f80b8400e2e6de316afd64271e1a24e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking in", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "mirror", "full_answer": "The cat is looking in the mirror.", "question": "What is the cat looking in?", "question_id": "03284052", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (151314)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking in,o (151311)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "store", "full_answer": "The dog is looking in the store.", "question": "What is the dog looking in?", "question_id": "15381880", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (2839274)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking in,o (3956795)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["151309", "151310", "151311", "151312", "151313", "151315", "151316"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["mirror"], "predicate": "looking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["metal", "round", "silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "151311", "query_target_entity_name": "mirror", "relation_object_entity_id": "151311", "relation_subject_entity_id": "151314", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "151314", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["151314"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2720685", "2786175", "2839273", "2920799", "2974425", "2974426", "3009075", "3057534", "3142916", "3176396", "3234936", "3393628", "3571452", "3571495", "3956795", "3956797"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["store"], "predicate": "looking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3956795", "query_target_entity_name": "store", "relation_object_entity_id": "3956795", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2839274", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2839274", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2839274"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ef7e9a324a3a35ec3f37b2d003b1a664", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7db59999b250e2ab3c85a51292c6318cd63705216ee0d5e5ed06099908e13a2f", "image_sha256_b": "0fa5570ec492a27db3dce98150ce5684d377f7e720ba721450a8fcf573a06b02", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "50e345d4ebdfb2e9d603e02f6312022783d1cd34d32a7c9b0219cd864f9fcce4", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3f81f001415d00b2dd5c13775b5ddaae", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "cea1feeef41e75f536f803c9585728afc71cacb96a96d0841321f86e3acd4800"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "066c5946dfd1efa10ba49f0198db7b32c7394dea1221f90b1bf459eaaf8e9197", "request_id": "6a4c0abda1175e21a562ec01881b041e", "response_sha256": "ec19d413d689c6da35f5f34f77a9b4c395e70d2b0d27a4a4ad6e51d261947477", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f1b8bf86c6ee218eed3fdc098d275177567ef3108dc9385ae96d826e1ac8d920", "request_id": "5d5c1e9ba308483820cdb6353fdbf0a8", "response_sha256": "1490b8379e55c25793a151ef9d5c01d320140d0615c75db401bafb933e9dcdf7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "374573b744a568d8b5d20b1d0674dd16", "candidate_priority_rank": 236, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-95249dbeb1538d6c:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-95249dbeb1538d6c:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-95249dbeb1538d6c:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-95249dbeb1538d6c:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bag<->dish", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dish", "B": "bag"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dish<->bag", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2400946", "image_sha256": "5fb5880c3a040dc809ee3bb66cce3b0289c7826c960cf1c9ac29cc03be18490e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2400946.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2400946.jpg", "width": 374}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2412335", "image_sha256": "c95ea281593b7474d8be7b996fd97968d3ba911d27232e5bddeb8bb2ee43111d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412335.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412335.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-95249dbeb1538d6c", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dish", "diff_b": "bag", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dish", "component_b": "bag"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bell", "cat", "chair", "curtain", "dish", "ear", "eye", "radiator", "table", "tag", "tail", "vase", "wall"], "detected_components": ["dish"], "masked_program_sha256": "dd9c3d4f445b6881411cd9520deed49c340f4d598eeebf91c1800fa7495fa166", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dish", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dish", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dish", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "50ef1d532a636d8822ad5ee95e0f64170428991d901fef15f7893f33f4f71e58"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13777561", "text": "What color is the animal on the dish?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "cat", "door", "ear", "eye", "face", "fur", "mouth", "nose", "picture", "toy"], "detected_components": ["bag"], "masked_program_sha256": "dd9c3d4f445b6881411cd9520deed49c340f4d598eeebf91c1800fa7495fa166", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bag", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bag", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d7eed2b73f87c90a0ab235d9eac9d3335e8b542e6f29ec0c7bfb09c1f0fc23de"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01414792", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 236, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 10, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8e9ef23110304153744e854df3fa9d6f1b16fa045663251bc40b2d3eef972a8d", "selected_component": "bag", "selected_source_question_id": "01414792", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color is the animal on the bag?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the animal on the ?", "program_group_hash": "8e9ef23110304153744e854df3fa9d6f1b16fa045663251bc40b2d3eef972a8d", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "dish"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the animal on the ?", "program_group_hash": "8e9ef23110304153744e854df3fa9d6f1b16fa045663251bc40b2d3eef972a8d", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "bag"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "white", "full_answer": "The cat is white.", "question": "What color is the animal on the dish?", "question_id": "13777561", "semantic": [{"argument": "dish (1153379)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (1153378)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "orange", "full_answer": "The cat is orange.", "question": "What color is the animal on the bag?", "question_id": "01414792", "semantic": [{"argument": "bag (196819)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on,s (196818)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1153378"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["white"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1153378", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1153379", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1153378", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1153379", "selected_entity_name": "dish"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dish", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1153379"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bag", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dish", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["196818"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["lying", "orange"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["lying", "orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "196818", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "196819", "relation_subject_entity_id": "196818", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "196819", "selected_entity_name": "bag"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bag", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["196819"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:374573b744a568d8b5d20b1d0674dd16", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5fb5880c3a040dc809ee3bb66cce3b0289c7826c960cf1c9ac29cc03be18490e", "image_sha256_b": "c95ea281593b7474d8be7b996fd97968d3ba911d27232e5bddeb8bb2ee43111d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d0e538df415284dbf8745c3ab8287552d4a2c65a399897957382d042d6da4dbb", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "df5ce1d275aa62f1d6ba232b5b9101dd", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c3648c76452fade545d68fe86ec5a79bce714ca13bcbb778f3c8c23354b524f9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "23c7a8b49675d6e86ede5ce405f01aca5f14dbf6134e40ab9833c8b5f27109ab", "request_id": "b045f9f461552007d29757065d50f4a4", "response_sha256": "be87e6a9dd972f00ba6c36bb58261d2bfe55700deebe09e7e90c69ca7b63e5be", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8f488fce15300918402dc1f8cea110f24c9f50562802659ae2097385ceca379b", "request_id": "fadfce01ecafde88973e987a08e6c182", "response_sha256": "a09c96728e51235e3c61e7f26c3257d58ec143d1ba3bd47dedb2c98b22a3285e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ce529ff2b5323df3814e28b31c18560a", "candidate_priority_rank": 242, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df46289d2d75b923:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df46289d2d75b923:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df46289d2d75b923:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df46289d2d75b923:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bread<->oven", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "oven", "B": "bread"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "oven<->bread", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2364297", "image_sha256": "a23ef63b7fc6298a92791095c095bb523fa7fe536bf19908e80ad7034e033f38", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364297.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364297.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2339499", "image_sha256": "adc9c4e700dad91a49377485b9003f97fa443f82017da2e0d88f39f2b54a92e3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2339499.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2339499.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-df46289d2d75b923", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "oven", "diff_b": "bread", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "oven", "component_b": "bread"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cheese", "crust", "mushrooms", "olives", "onion", "oven", "peppers", "pineapples", "pizza", "plate"], "detected_components": ["oven"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae0e0a6e17a798a830e478717a7590b8f9fa6be061107f612abd0987a199f2bd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["oven", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "oven", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["oven", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b91e6dadd96a00fe6be5be109aa7f0d0eed19f3dc7b243da77fccf13821a66fa"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02842288", "text": "What kind of fast food is in the oven?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "bread", "bun", "food", "glass", "hot dog", "man", "mustard", "onion", "onions", "plate", "table", "water"], "detected_components": ["bread"], "masked_program_sha256": "ae0e0a6e17a798a830e478717a7590b8f9fa6be061107f612abd0987a199f2bd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread", "fast food"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bread", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread", "fast food"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6d52f535c2d6b4dfa7ccb89e3224a87f6c778cf4cea9c1de5dbccddb964c51bf"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11108610", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 242, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "c0a83d89a6d4397d5f427214ae24952e7e4d34539b486ebf71bd2c0b20381006", "selected_component": "bread", "selected_source_question_id": "11108610", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of fast food is in the bread?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "c0a83d89a6d4397d5f427214ae24952e7e4d34539b486ebf71bd2c0b20381006", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "oven"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of fast food is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "c0a83d89a6d4397d5f427214ae24952e7e4d34539b486ebf71bd2c0b20381006", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bread"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The food is a pizza.", "question": "What kind of fast food is in the oven?", "question_id": "02842288", "semantic": [{"argument": "oven (641989)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s (641987)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "hot dog", "full_answer": "The food is a hot dog.", "question": "What kind of fast food is in the bread?", "question_id": "11108610", "semantic": [{"argument": "bread (2637632)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,in,s (3485844)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["641987"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["pizza", "round"], "query_target_entity_id": "641987", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "641989", "relation_subject_entity_id": "641987", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "641989", "selected_entity_name": "oven"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "oven", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["641989"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "oven", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3485844"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hot dog"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3485844", "query_target_entity_name": "hot dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "2637632", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3485844", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2637632", "selected_entity_name": "bread"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2637632"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ce529ff2b5323df3814e28b31c18560a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a23ef63b7fc6298a92791095c095bb523fa7fe536bf19908e80ad7034e033f38", "image_sha256_b": "adc9c4e700dad91a49377485b9003f97fa443f82017da2e0d88f39f2b54a92e3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "e708a30911146908fddc915c67309c639a7e553f8e8790705aad128482fa0b93", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "85f4ff7e76ea5c10d45762438f51ab75", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "eee0ccb1aede8cf1bec533515369155e44dc1517571b293b2571dca3cc613335"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4698e089722544fa7bcaf91ffcb107e27932e767e08de8ca57460ddf02754df8", "request_id": "ababcdd259c069861e7f3c68f6b2de7a", "response_sha256": "133e440a4b5ceea56cff0d2bd96872772ac3eac32cd69d9ec8d7bdd7a87c40ef", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2a1155704350fb2a576a05aac22450ca2888de4c400a67bbd6bc1225e4608351", "request_id": "b5f412bbf7168ebb40a037b1cfd8ca9b", "response_sha256": "d19f8709ef86858b906c0af710963c644ad84e79854abbc71fa6019935393d10", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "700c414c20de6028c67381ce5dca7c6b", "candidate_priority_rank": 245, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59c9f2801870ba76:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59c9f2801870ba76:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59c9f2801870ba76:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59c9f2801870ba76:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->pizza", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "pizza"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->pizza", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2407116", "image_sha256": "ba656ae49c2f2c5d6b274eb80a87973b02735bdda3c200bf890b0b12d2be316d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2407116.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2407116.jpg", "width": 334}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2364297", "image_sha256": "a23ef63b7fc6298a92791095c095bb523fa7fe536bf19908e80ad7034e033f38", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364297.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364297.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-59c9f2801870ba76", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "pizza", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "pizza"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "floor", "man", "refrigerator"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "c6b1cfe78bc5102c10f8fcdc1838557575d5386353a1a45d8eaef5ea560cb242", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1033592caa50f66a102af9940152922c677bb0049209a64d1b09a9c07221d0b5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0724287", "text": "What is the appliance that the man is in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cheese", "crust", "mushrooms", "olives", "onion", "oven", "peppers", "pineapples", "pizza", "plate"], "detected_components": ["pizza"], "masked_program_sha256": "c6b1cfe78bc5102c10f8fcdc1838557575d5386353a1a45d8eaef5ea560cb242", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza", "appliance"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pizza", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza", "appliance"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d1974e02f0ffb92d5fe047d6e96910cda44c294b7e14f2928eae17138b607143"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02842291", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 245, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "dae8f520e1c2a48fd52b4bf86c7bdde68edf9caaccefa8c8bf26682b6d916a64", "selected_component": "pizza", "selected_source_question_id": "02842291", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the appliance that the pizza is in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the appliance that the is in?", "program_group_hash": "dae8f520e1c2a48fd52b4bf86c7bdde68edf9caaccefa8c8bf26682b6d916a64", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the appliance that the is in?", "program_group_hash": "dae8f520e1c2a48fd52b4bf86c7bdde68edf9caaccefa8c8bf26682b6d916a64", "queried_category": "appliance", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "pizza"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "refrigerator", "full_answer": "The appliance is a refrigerator.", "question": "What is the appliance that the man is in?", "question_id": "0724287", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1098886)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,in,o (1098887)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "oven", "full_answer": "The appliance is an oven.", "question": "What is the appliance that the pizza is in?", "question_id": "02842291", "semantic": [{"argument": "pizza (641987)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "appliance,in,o (641989)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1098887"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["refrigerator"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["bright", "dark", "open"], "query_target_entity_id": "1098887", "query_target_entity_name": "refrigerator", "relation_object_entity_id": "1098887", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1098886", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1098886", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1098886"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["641989"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["oven"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "641989", "query_target_entity_name": "oven", "relation_object_entity_id": "641989", "relation_subject_entity_id": "641987", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "641987", "selected_entity_name": "pizza"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["641987"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:700c414c20de6028c67381ce5dca7c6b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ba656ae49c2f2c5d6b274eb80a87973b02735bdda3c200bf890b0b12d2be316d", "image_sha256_b": "a23ef63b7fc6298a92791095c095bb523fa7fe536bf19908e80ad7034e033f38", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "81309124d4c45e35a42beed65becf61df09fca19b148e59fb6aacc7a79688005", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1114f8bd5dc4a29e51e9eecf92eb5476", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "69ffaae89a1cf66a5cc993bca681e7ff7c6d01fc44805234ce485714ba1f50df"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "365a90d71fcee850f08986697e8ea31b21f8baa25a7d16871cbbb90acdc9aa76", "request_id": "badf843d9d449f9ce4fe85cca13155cb", "response_sha256": "81818d026c10e89dc4ab3e47fcde8aca451a7c379a70ffd7e335ed9c496d23e8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5711a59bc8e7739568257cd93024d0fd4216e86dcf488cd8bbddda3bc0197cf3", "request_id": "401838c0047b4c3702c0849f3db2e792", "response_sha256": "b7be874d7e7054e8c1ac0e2cb12aa36b8f544b4f1ff813ec997dfbb2b3b10150", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "d96a69b3757e62ec0318d019de9a53ab", "candidate_priority_rank": 250, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8c52d71332400cdb:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8c52d71332400cdb:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8c52d71332400cdb:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8c52d71332400cdb:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->dog", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dog", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dog<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2415378", "image_sha256": "3651ed10776b40e52f47e365133be4a5bd38ad73aa737c9325c6e98128160556", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2415378.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2415378.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2348595", "image_sha256": "fc49d6453562ef48db6465c44ccb9eb732f6fa15a18da5e44ac0c2133cea1206", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2348595.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2348595.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8c52d71332400cdb", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dog", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dog", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "character", "dog", "eyes", "face", "fur", "hair", "head", "mouth", "nose", "scarf"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a8aa13edcdd7ab8e5d1561272a2d8fe3e51a79e8102ba9f66b69ecdfad858e96"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "17753246", "text": "What is this dog lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["backpack", "branch", "cat", "collar", "dirt", "ground", "head", "leaf", "plant"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "caed50c8d27aaba2ff46fe7a086db089477558621772c5fd9f5a5eb43820cf6f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14965144", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 250, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6bdb4e7d9c3021d0dfe72b24995ac6efb02332f0db528ff4730124c74dbfd8f2", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "14965144", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this cat lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this lying on?", "program_group_hash": "6bdb4e7d9c3021d0dfe72b24995ac6efb02332f0db528ff4730124c74dbfd8f2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this lying on?", "program_group_hash": "6bdb4e7d9c3021d0dfe72b24995ac6efb02332f0db528ff4730124c74dbfd8f2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "blanket", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the blanket.", "question": "What is this dog lying on?", "question_id": "17753246", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (3156351)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (3156352)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "ground", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the ground.", "question": "What is this cat lying on?", "question_id": "14965144", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (2217838)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (3905249)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2808374", "2812758", "2826319", "2930585", "2934939", "2971111", "3120099", "3156352", "3220837", "3329201", "3371833", "3425851", "3425852", "3425853", "3425854"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["blanket"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["pink"], "query_target_entity_id": "3156352", "query_target_entity_name": "blanket", "relation_object_entity_id": "3156352", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3156351", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3156351", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3156351"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1731482", "1764440", "1764441", "1764442", "1868023", "1892814", "1892815", "1892816", "2194889", "2217139", "2217140", "3905245", "3905249"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["ground"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3905249", "query_target_entity_name": "ground", "relation_object_entity_id": "3905249", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2217838", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2217838", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2217838"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:d96a69b3757e62ec0318d019de9a53ab", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3651ed10776b40e52f47e365133be4a5bd38ad73aa737c9325c6e98128160556", "image_sha256_b": "fc49d6453562ef48db6465c44ccb9eb732f6fa15a18da5e44ac0c2133cea1206", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "163c4fcb0d11a9c93d7e7baf34c61de6e993051799ac5f581bf9df4f340c645e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "13406c5993b3973733e0c40428b1c69b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ededfd970f58cc14702a975dfc89559ea22c993b0eba9c14bd7bed27fb716d40"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "69ece5c959af9ee673e0d639e405da39118d1071d0808159fafd1e061eca5fc6", "request_id": "1ee0b8c1f4e473ca9a1e0f7106658681", "response_sha256": "9e176b7ec3c7151ec45beda958aead9391f80d90eb31b0b1cdc7f26283a95f17", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "65a5c9da669ecd2f5aecf551f8514dabe1f780c16779feb1eb07b236085e037d", "request_id": "a045fb48f528354d583b2d8a321d56c0", "response_sha256": "6b9f4e6dbd740cac508f1bbedca43acecd5bbad28e09a7a4f19fd7a6f4d29b13", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "4be9319abd8efc3cb5239a4eb180cb49", "candidate_priority_rank": 252, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9573fea9981874e2:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9573fea9981874e2:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9573fea9981874e2:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9573fea9981874e2:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "kitchen<->living room", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "living room", "B": "kitchen"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "living room<->kitchen", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2373712", "image_sha256": "465692e55fb2e6de6d03e7fcaef160f789991b08dd075a36dd5f68a5fc0482f8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2373712.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2373712.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 576, "image_id": "498324", "image_sha256": "abe0bcd3bc8f9c4babaa71711fbf86ec1b364d197533c45dfe13c25fcb07bf7b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/498324.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/498324.jpg", "width": 1024}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9573fea9981874e2", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "living room", "diff_b": "kitchen", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "living room", "component_b": "kitchen"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bench", "carpet", "cat", "chair", "eye", "ground", "leaf", "living room", "palm tree", "piano", "pot", "wire"], "detected_components": ["living room"], "masked_program_sha256": "0503a9fd58312f59d688445046f2717b3127c1074c4c9305b42371a0557d134d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["living room", "instrument"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "living room", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["living room", "instrument"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5b1a6f49a8cc6fe3dadbcd19f5cfdba6ef3ce885a57d9f030c0a2843e70ce530"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01536567", "text": "What instrument is in the living room?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["box", "counter", "dishwasher", "drum", "hand", "jeans", "kitchen", "man", "mat", "oven door", "shirt", "stove", "towel"], "detected_components": ["kitchen"], "masked_program_sha256": "0503a9fd58312f59d688445046f2717b3127c1074c4c9305b42371a0557d134d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["kitchen", "instrument"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "kitchen", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["kitchen", "instrument"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b4fba1a5d5ea3cf996a0ae262db6859e4483b12e1a9a90385ef2a49e2e613361"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05408515", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 252, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "fb63d47b6d56cb0373b56b5d3509dd8b97496c9ad0b793fd4bc5aecac295f186", "selected_component": "kitchen", "selected_source_question_id": "05408515", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What instrument is in the kitchen?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "instrument,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what instrument is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "fb63d47b6d56cb0373b56b5d3509dd8b97496c9ad0b793fd4bc5aecac295f186", "queried_category": "instrument", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "living room"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "instrument,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what instrument is in the ?", "program_group_hash": "fb63d47b6d56cb0373b56b5d3509dd8b97496c9ad0b793fd4bc5aecac295f186", "queried_category": "instrument", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "kitchen"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "piano", "full_answer": "The instrument is a piano.", "question": "What instrument is in the living room?", "question_id": "01536567", "semantic": [{"argument": "living room (2659116)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "instrument,in,s (1861025)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "drum", "full_answer": "The instrument is a drum.", "question": "What instrument is in the kitchen?", "question_id": "05408515", "semantic": [{"argument": "kitchen (3595496)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "instrument,in,s (3734431)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1861025"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["piano"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "1861025", "query_target_entity_name": "piano", "relation_object_entity_id": "2659116", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1861025", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2659116", "selected_entity_name": "living room"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "living room", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2659116"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "kitchen", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "living room", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3734431"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["drum"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3734431", "query_target_entity_name": "drum", "relation_object_entity_id": "3595496", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3734431", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3595496", "selected_entity_name": "kitchen"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "kitchen", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3595496"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4be9319abd8efc3cb5239a4eb180cb49", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "465692e55fb2e6de6d03e7fcaef160f789991b08dd075a36dd5f68a5fc0482f8", "image_sha256_b": "abe0bcd3bc8f9c4babaa71711fbf86ec1b364d197533c45dfe13c25fcb07bf7b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f255ad0cb2e828cfc1f41cbcea9ecdbac90ad0ae26489b6d623cf3c5e924a6c7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a6d5ca28ae5f73afd1ed933e1251a226", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "eeee93f2771ee3cb7e8ddf2ca3374751f9a6825cf2ac902d4cabd5ab30a2c664"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "38adca3b4740282c24798f82cf2bbc1828b290335f12527f6ce2bf637dc9a73d", "request_id": "03429b489b50ced7413d9cc364c43361", "response_sha256": "090b94dbff43f3443d8778b709e3653ddfcb086de4f9a768c5d153b9541c951c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "09bb999b2ca80dfc82d9c9ae29bc80364980b0fd11b5aba7dea07421e09b0596", "request_id": "fa7879499a3a3b71d00998f6dd6fa0e5", "response_sha256": "7e9370f80fb273994ca32144ff46ed0f3ec2b8c63afd0368a26ab7a949d75c44", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "4549a53e5525ecc4a31a8eb3f32d9435", "candidate_priority_rank": 261, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5cef65436da15557:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5cef65436da15557:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5cef65436da15557:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5cef65436da15557:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "foil<->paper", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "paper", "B": "foil"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "paper<->foil", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2417844", "image_sha256": "308388b5027fc53636cdea6ee1b711cf22dcd270cbd422a0f1be2213a56026a8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2417844.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2417844.jpg", "width": 318}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2328942", "image_sha256": "95ec0873d88c70e9d13ad1f20339584785e470d6310520b4d5cc10526f776774", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2328942.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2328942.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5cef65436da15557", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "paper", "diff_b": "foil", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "paper", "component_b": "foil"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "bun", "dog", "drawing", "hot dog", "paper", "seeds", "table", "tablecloth", "tomato"], "detected_components": ["paper"], "masked_program_sha256": "bab70cf9edd311995f6cdb592cd7e0ac0fd7d344d86e3cd46e1a1345ba8b20e2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "paper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2385fe3566a5d5c16b8ad0e6cfb201238926853cfd6c7799473101cab89777a5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04740708", "text": "What is the food on the paper called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["finger", "fingers", "foil", "hand", "olive", "olives", "pizza", "sauce", "spoon", "topping"], "detected_components": ["foil"], "masked_program_sha256": "bab70cf9edd311995f6cdb592cd7e0ac0fd7d344d86e3cd46e1a1345ba8b20e2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["foil"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "foil", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["foil"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ec7716db171b74ad7212588b6bccf6b6424c53232388dc64ad48f8227bf34c1c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1637273", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 261, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9507d25b370908939697dc89c992e048d4b3517e9027e781b421424b16f3ac07", "selected_component": "foil", "selected_source_question_id": "1637273", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the food on the foil called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food on the called?", "program_group_hash": "9507d25b370908939697dc89c992e048d4b3517e9027e781b421424b16f3ac07", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "paper"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food on the called?", "program_group_hash": "9507d25b370908939697dc89c992e048d4b3517e9027e781b421424b16f3ac07", "queried_category": "fast food", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "foil"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "hot dog", "full_answer": "The food is a hot dog.", "question": "What is the food on the paper called?", "question_id": "04740708", "semantic": [{"argument": "paper (3361029)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,on,s (2908917)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "pizza", "full_answer": "The food is a pizza.", "question": "What is the food on the foil called?", "question_id": "1637273", "semantic": [{"argument": "foil (4109364)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fast food,on,s (4109397)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2908917"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["hot dog"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2908917", "query_target_entity_name": "hot dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "3361029", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2908917", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3361029", "selected_entity_name": "paper"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3361029"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "foil", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4109397"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pizza"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["handmade", "uncooked"], "query_target_entity_id": "4109397", "query_target_entity_name": "pizza", "relation_object_entity_id": "4109364", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4109397", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4109364", "selected_entity_name": "foil"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "foil", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4109364"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4549a53e5525ecc4a31a8eb3f32d9435", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "308388b5027fc53636cdea6ee1b711cf22dcd270cbd422a0f1be2213a56026a8", "image_sha256_b": "95ec0873d88c70e9d13ad1f20339584785e470d6310520b4d5cc10526f776774", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a71ca6b77662e0029c8a9f4a334be1e6ced9eafb9d1a731886f67a5e502632de", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a5c497159326b62c5268944fda158f30", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f659a521756e5bf8f61b3191d30a7fc075cbc7c5cdb381ef67803d219d417290"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8a898804b4f970147fe2d1e847de7a3159dc951eb726ecb69d897e5d942ed760", "request_id": "3af7ba68e1a2f523de9187ed2a1c27da", "response_sha256": "14505a1e43f76019ded7d647554beff98278939df7e8608c3f3bc3bf8fc38456", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "eface150ec6acbb6ef4c06c026c106d351e6c2bb1db1a5958a855521b81a4806", "request_id": "7f926f135ddcc1d69bbb8845f542ae11", "response_sha256": "57804352165a9eacbfbe7082d27726d821340d1bdea714e374b8f3002d7024ec", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "75581781e98372ce920d24e93e611fb9", "candidate_priority_rank": 263, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8803700113d92ef3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8803700113d92ef3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8803700113d92ef3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8803700113d92ef3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "apple<->pie", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "apple", "B": "pie"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "apple<->pie", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2410601", "image_sha256": "49526b9200b0685ea72fdfda9fef20b78f698b2823aff8af5fde8a47a65b1980", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410601.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410601.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2401458", "image_sha256": "7fb77204968c481d20a72b37fce5aa7c2db210d53a347573974aacfbd50b9854", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401458.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401458.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8803700113d92ef3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "apple", "diff_b": "pie", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "apple", "component_b": "pie"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["apple", "knife", "table"], "detected_components": ["apple"], "masked_program_sha256": "fc8f6d992a5664e7bc695725e248927d7b7ea15b42ae1f168e9b71c94924dd82", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["apple"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "apple", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["apple"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "90330b460bc2147942b66f4366c0486f5c84bcb911db3938568591af2dd90b9d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "141006691", "text": "What is cutting the apple?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["crumbs", "knife", "pie", "plate", "table"], "detected_components": ["pie"], "masked_program_sha256": "fc8f6d992a5664e7bc695725e248927d7b7ea15b42ae1f168e9b71c94924dd82", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pie"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pie", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pie"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9f9ec29a26797b441ce714fae9b4e004aaff7dbdd9c71977e57f965c525b40df"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "09411047", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 263, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "a9da49b9d4eb78599764a2ef659bd4741bf0608e125a77010c2fab6a768557ee", "selected_component": "pie", "selected_source_question_id": "09411047", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is cutting the pie?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,cutting,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is cutting the ?", "program_group_hash": "a9da49b9d4eb78599764a2ef659bd4741bf0608e125a77010c2fab6a768557ee", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "cutting", "select_category": "apple"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,cutting,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is cutting the ?", "program_group_hash": "a9da49b9d4eb78599764a2ef659bd4741bf0608e125a77010c2fab6a768557ee", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "cutting", "select_category": "pie"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "knife", "full_answer": "The knife is cutting the apple.", "question": "What is cutting the apple?", "question_id": "141006691", "semantic": [{"argument": "apple (213823)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,cutting,s (213822)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "knife", "full_answer": "The knife is cutting the pie.", "question": "What is cutting the pie?", "question_id": "09411047", "semantic": [{"argument": "pie (1147711)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,cutting,s (1147710)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["213822", "213824"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["knife"], "predicate": "cutting", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["long", "metal", "sharp", "shiny", "silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "213822", "query_target_entity_name": "knife", "relation_object_entity_id": "213823", "relation_subject_entity_id": "213822", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "213823", "selected_entity_name": "apple"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "apple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["213823"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pie", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "apple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1147710", "1147712", "3817291", "3817293"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["knife"], "predicate": "cutting", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["metal", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1147710", "query_target_entity_name": "knife", "relation_object_entity_id": "1147711", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1147710", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1147711", "selected_entity_name": "pie"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pie", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1147711"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:75581781e98372ce920d24e93e611fb9", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "49526b9200b0685ea72fdfda9fef20b78f698b2823aff8af5fde8a47a65b1980", "image_sha256_b": "7fb77204968c481d20a72b37fce5aa7c2db210d53a347573974aacfbd50b9854", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f50bb994ea1412b33f595dace2a6ffff3265d65fa01a19c2a6b5de55f0d19fae", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "332e9e0ed82512ee0a962dc2e8558173", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9aee8a1a2b10fd1f6fc4a4d04a6b4930976669762c965cb158c26f43b281dd77"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "df02affd8a0b2669ea36fded805b560b8dd1e5a46637264822a6613fed2651fd", "request_id": "9346c1cf84cc83bab1ddbd9a45f5d347", "response_sha256": "9bece9e6f8badd7c47d57cf9f7daf9a52c3a11fb6debacaf1290d0d430fe3c8c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7bf71138ecab7bdd58f4ec257fee82e8113fc31937d1f3bc98ffeb2f9f2cc44e", "request_id": "307341157bcafd0c81d920ced06ff42d", "response_sha256": "c60e08b0517db75b7b97077fcae5cb4f1bbfa30a7b98364eea44e0c294e91bbe", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "43d730d7f5b116a3d99ef4c13330c69e", "candidate_priority_rank": 264, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4143bc6f99b051da:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4143bc6f99b051da:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4143bc6f99b051da:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4143bc6f99b051da:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dog<->path", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dog", "B": "path"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dog<->path", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2316635", "image_sha256": "fb34eeaf312502f151aa4625908a343727da1aba7d257d23ce05c299a49204b7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2316635.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2316635.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2340838", "image_sha256": "1f17258a18da31707c4708b16c45ec4f6ff1c1558dd53c4940872ada066e9d9f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2340838.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2340838.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4143bc6f99b051da", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dog", "diff_b": "path", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dog", "component_b": "path"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["collar", "dog", "ear", "snow", "tail", "tennis ball", "water"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "17c308e211b9fdbaef05780b1111d4311fa74b6aaa54f8745acce825ed7fd81d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b8b62b704551ecb1699a1b8876dede610b76b45d8e4198fcadc5295c8fdd8de0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10969189", "text": "What is the dog going through?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bench", "bush", "grass", "leg", "park", "path", "person", "plants", "rock", "seat", "sidewalk", "sky", "stone", "tree"], "detected_components": ["path"], "masked_program_sha256": "17c308e211b9fdbaef05780b1111d4311fa74b6aaa54f8745acce825ed7fd81d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["path"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "path", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["path"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "081a1f29b8f5994000b8f75ce3c689404b9bdb9f7450f1f478cbddbb806e5204"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17579333", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 264, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "5ef5126eb4e8ae5cecfbf0b15b514723523bebb3cbf4298df669d9b3086dd586", "selected_component": "path", "selected_source_question_id": "17579333", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the path going through?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,going through,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the going through?", "program_group_hash": "5ef5126eb4e8ae5cecfbf0b15b514723523bebb3cbf4298df669d9b3086dd586", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "going through", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,going through,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the going through?", "program_group_hash": "5ef5126eb4e8ae5cecfbf0b15b514723523bebb3cbf4298df669d9b3086dd586", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "going through", "select_category": "path"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "snow", "full_answer": "The dog is going through the snow.", "question": "What is the dog going through?", "question_id": "10969189", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (1052662)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,going through,o (1052666)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "park", "full_answer": "The path is going through the park.", "question": "What is the path going through?", "question_id": "17579333", "semantic": [{"argument": "path (3362877)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,going through,o (3658292)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1052663", "1052664", "1052666", "1052668", "1052672", "1052673"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["snow"], "predicate": "going through", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["flat", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "1052666", "query_target_entity_name": "snow", "relation_object_entity_id": "1052666", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1052662", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1052662", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1052662"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "path", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2152860", "2152861", "2248686", "2257555", "2418419", "2601004", "3060200", "3072289", "3072290", "3072291", "3072292", "3307201", "3373531", "3373532", "3385792", "3658292", "3658295", "3658301"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["park"], "predicate": "going through", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["metal", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "3658292", "query_target_entity_name": "park", "relation_object_entity_id": "3658292", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3362877", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3362877", "selected_entity_name": "path"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "path", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3362877"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:43d730d7f5b116a3d99ef4c13330c69e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "fb34eeaf312502f151aa4625908a343727da1aba7d257d23ce05c299a49204b7", "image_sha256_b": "1f17258a18da31707c4708b16c45ec4f6ff1c1558dd53c4940872ada066e9d9f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4e3e78e4d8dc40a25fe10bb782cfcc8dc1f764ef177be538204f9014b5965c7f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7091d0021282b919d1b2c81001d537da", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9cd942f43d9328066fa532fac56cb87175c1be1f9b10062de67c39b3cd7e4289"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "62acb6cae47786e8c0378cd492736fc7b50d0cc73a6f02369204b0763bda098c", "request_id": "5b3d08c277c20c94b25525569c5b57f4", "response_sha256": "3f93a47e0c704aa3a76d0ecda8ae9841d04f272f856651b7f86f597ad025e4c6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "abb17cdb0ab3afeb475e2a87757dcf00d2e5f6010f690a151c85cde8eae13dcc", "request_id": "f8a8fc17decb0671754ad6ba84e763bc", "response_sha256": "9284ea42715a6d637592c332ba1d73a9ac2946e2cffd325ecce50cd0f3b0700c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "4566ddcb8490f7becd14d298d34d9a82", "candidate_priority_rank": 266, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b7ba8252b2ee1ac5:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b7ba8252b2ee1ac5:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b7ba8252b2ee1ac5:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b7ba8252b2ee1ac5:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dog<->plate", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "plate", "B": "dog"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "plate<->dog", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2345825", "image_sha256": "3a6bc5a65eefc4f41fef1d487d0630331229701b6b09e96a99044ff937546763", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345825.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345825.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2321237", "image_sha256": "91d5fa16b8436e665646148306067a044678a60cda934c68cb8bc9a0417c5fb5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2321237.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2321237.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b7ba8252b2ee1ac5", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "plate", "diff_b": "dog", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "plate", "component_b": "dog"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "bread", "cheese", "chili", "computer mouse", "desk", "dogs", "ground", "hot dog", "paper", "plate", "sauce", "spoon", "table"], "detected_components": ["plate"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "plate", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f6113b2c6dbc13d4f9c1b0d6593e2006bc2ef3e85c8cf3f1b827eef7d35b1f7a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "05635647", "text": "What kind of furniture is this plate on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "blanket", "collar", "couch", "curtains", "dog", "eye", "head", "mouth", "neck", "nose", "paw", "table", "tag"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2f9250faacbf85372099b4385b460dba3e780530c7e1626d69b54ba87e5a1a5a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0834788", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 266, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "02b454038976962bacb0824c1f6a60949257315f8069374377e2f8fe211fe081", "selected_component": "dog", "selected_source_question_id": "0834788", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of furniture is this dog on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture is this on?", "program_group_hash": "02b454038976962bacb0824c1f6a60949257315f8069374377e2f8fe211fe081", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture is this on?", "program_group_hash": "02b454038976962bacb0824c1f6a60949257315f8069374377e2f8fe211fe081", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "desk", "full_answer": "The plate is on the desk.", "question": "What kind of furniture is this plate on?", "question_id": "05635647", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (3621756)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (3621755)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The dog is on the couch.", "question": "What kind of furniture is this dog on?", "question_id": "0834788", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (4208217)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (4208218)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3621749", "3621755"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["desk"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "3621755", "query_target_entity_name": "desk", "relation_object_entity_id": "3621755", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3621756", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3621756", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plate", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3621756"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plate", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4208218", "4208234", "4208268"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4208218", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "4208218", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4208217", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4208217", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4208217"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4566ddcb8490f7becd14d298d34d9a82", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3a6bc5a65eefc4f41fef1d487d0630331229701b6b09e96a99044ff937546763", "image_sha256_b": "91d5fa16b8436e665646148306067a044678a60cda934c68cb8bc9a0417c5fb5", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "75d93adfed1102758b42b9b00b2c9adcfeff36ff2b9a457e4225a6908c16468c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "eca25bc8e316c2dc4d405c75602ec080", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "dd0cd53c04b8d0b4862b42a6dc8e0f013cfcaf10ae35b838e76d44a57ec457a3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f45559e9942f6ca8c5371edd22121bf802ede460b55cfcd24dc5de1da8d24893", "request_id": "14d86d5489c7b93a39bc017cda244959", "response_sha256": "dc1dec8761a202699229eaa9bbab638aab67dd1234b731ac2b5cb4b34a688ca1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8a6906d21490e6c33b1e277582f88db722848147206c8955a1f1dab5721f7714", "request_id": "b92f9b49641c557d5b25343a888a5d76", "response_sha256": "e0772c657592d662a8fd7238fbb6bd92388196644642ad5affabe4659bba41d3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a8cd716131d036a3668f8e62aaa096c0", "candidate_priority_rank": 270, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-129cda122370919d:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-129cda122370919d:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-129cda122370919d:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-129cda122370919d:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->dog", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dog", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dog<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2389773", "image_sha256": "2d0b45810febe715d9ff8a1aff820ff53883892446df3af54ad1012942b2c05c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389773.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389773.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2360751", "image_sha256": "0d1362b10840487db2abde48bc1cd2c361adfb248a76e8c41764a3791a7e163b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2360751.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2360751.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-129cda122370919d", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dog", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dog", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bedroom", "bottle", "carpet", "coffee cup", "collar", "container", "containers", "cords", "dog", "fan", "floor", "logo", "nightstand", "nose", "paper", "pillow", "sheets", "stuffed animal", "tie", "wall"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "65d9576831cd6aea51ef337a6e2dc6c13377e79cb3ae01535e05e5a0b63445d6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "faf665b8119da0d72ad7a670494e1861372441d86e052c51ad1491ae86401510"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04513554", "text": "What is this dog sitting in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bathtub", "cat", "ear", "eye", "face", "shower curtain", "tail"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "65d9576831cd6aea51ef337a6e2dc6c13377e79cb3ae01535e05e5a0b63445d6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "633a9246de0f5cc8bcee4ba07a96853114a1355e4f787c5ef9754afd3ea2c36f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10195641", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 270, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9829f20c0881ae561232787ca29936479f97b2081b5279a7c38b5442356a430f", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "10195641", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this cat sitting in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this sitting in?", "program_group_hash": "9829f20c0881ae561232787ca29936479f97b2081b5279a7c38b5442356a430f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting in", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this sitting in?", "program_group_hash": "9829f20c0881ae561232787ca29936479f97b2081b5279a7c38b5442356a430f", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting in", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bedroom", "full_answer": "The dog is sitting in the bedroom.", "question": "What is this dog sitting in?", "question_id": "04513554", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (4483606)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting in,o (4483639)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bathtub", "full_answer": "The cat is sitting in the bathtub.", "question": "What is this cat sitting in?", "question_id": "10195641", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (786174)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting in,o (786175)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4483613", "4483622", "4483628", "4483629", "4483630", "4483636", "4483637", "4483639", "4483640", "4483649", "4483652", "4483656", "4483659", "4483660", "4483661", "4483664", "4483666", "4483672", "4483674", "4483677", "4483678", "4483679"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 22, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bedroom"], "predicate": "sitting in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4483639", "query_target_entity_name": "bedroom", "relation_object_entity_id": "4483639", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4483606", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4483606", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4483606"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["786175", "786176", "786177", "786178", "786180", "786181", "786182", "786184"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bathtub"], "predicate": "sitting in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["ceramic", "large", "porcelain", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "786175", "query_target_entity_name": "bathtub", "relation_object_entity_id": "786175", "relation_subject_entity_id": "786174", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "786174", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["786174"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a8cd716131d036a3668f8e62aaa096c0", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2d0b45810febe715d9ff8a1aff820ff53883892446df3af54ad1012942b2c05c", "image_sha256_b": "0d1362b10840487db2abde48bc1cd2c361adfb248a76e8c41764a3791a7e163b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3a1e7cb4f8cd7ebe571357e3e4430767ff3d497ddf39343a18cb902f8de5ab13", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "c410cf233a3205c850eb5f9e20c26c81", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d92292fa03d7ecd54e9af5dd8cf981bc13cde6c93930095eab16f843a3a29a33"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7a3ba24e0aadfd3af5b065dfc8203c37347fdd245f3985c3c55de25ee5ea87dd", "request_id": "e95fab309fb11bcab9ec231166133531", "response_sha256": "e63acece415f48a6f841f452cb8fc486b048e3a0a017205077542b4879745b2a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ba892e22a71aada86504fd566ff99dc7ef55dbd0ade1030b08f93b6f392cb5a4", "request_id": "4522bfd1e534914395cf98932ef11d64", "response_sha256": "79f936b521ea79ff205b0d999ccf642e5b72b4578d2209937d6f70b0ff16f263", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "0f62f969dd17d42beb724add7166d51a", "candidate_priority_rank": 275, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dde0b3139fbab756:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dde0b3139fbab756:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dde0b3139fbab756:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dde0b3139fbab756:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blanket<->field", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "blanket", "B": "field"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "blanket<->field", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 196, "image_id": "2326609", "image_sha256": "6be96dd5e5c1d28c94c5311c0c4a61e3bea0a4dcc3c5c15b541fb7f3ac7ad15f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326609.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326609.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2379947", "image_sha256": "bc2152623449ab49d0c4555e5c7f31fb7b28a12aacc24497d06034ad2923e1ce", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2379947.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2379947.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-dde0b3139fbab756", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "blanket", "diff_b": "field", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "blanket", "component_b": "field"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "blanket", "books", "box", "cat", "cats", "ear", "eye", "face", "fur", "lamp", "paper", "room", "stuffed animal", "stuffed animals", "tail"], "detected_components": ["blanket"], "masked_program_sha256": "1cecb4f796105ee3743f86530e11442550ae6d36bcee747ff9c84bc3cd8fd1a1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blanket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dfd6b6f2ff402035faa8f8566488d2cd8faa7705df6bda3c00c097bc6ec61b7c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06283332", "text": "What animals are on top of the blanket?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cow", "cows", "field", "straw"], "detected_components": ["field"], "masked_program_sha256": "1cecb4f796105ee3743f86530e11442550ae6d36bcee747ff9c84bc3cd8fd1a1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "field", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "caea9d9e113b3e79e917d3b64023f8879f03b8b490a16e40b281bda42f02915b"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17311767", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 275, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "eebd6eae43f0287325da96a995017ca4ab622d9269d80c3e5f9e51c9de5521b5", "selected_component": "field", "selected_source_question_id": "17311767", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animals are on top of the field?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "eebd6eae43f0287325da96a995017ca4ab622d9269d80c3e5f9e51c9de5521b5", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "blanket"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "eebd6eae43f0287325da96a995017ca4ab622d9269d80c3e5f9e51c9de5521b5", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "field"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cats", "full_answer": "The animals are cats.", "question": "What animals are on top of the blanket?", "question_id": "06283332", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (3981778)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on top of,s (3981803)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cows", "full_answer": "The animals are cows.", "question": "What animals are on top of the field?", "question_id": "17311767", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (1352439)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,on top of,s (1352438)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3981784", "3981803"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cats"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3981803", "query_target_entity_name": "cats", "relation_object_entity_id": "3981778", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3981803", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3981778", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3981778"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1352438", "1352440", "1352441", "1352442", "1352443"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cows"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "grouped", "lying", "sitting"], "query_target_entity_id": "1352438", "query_target_entity_name": "cows", "relation_object_entity_id": "1352439", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1352438", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1352439", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1352439"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0f62f969dd17d42beb724add7166d51a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6be96dd5e5c1d28c94c5311c0c4a61e3bea0a4dcc3c5c15b541fb7f3ac7ad15f", "image_sha256_b": "bc2152623449ab49d0c4555e5c7f31fb7b28a12aacc24497d06034ad2923e1ce", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "9b92248151c1ad8990bd13b1dcd97ccdc81afd9720bbe038cf03be34a6fcd9f6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "bc906af3c9a57796f70e3384ee0ce955", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "29c7b0865131d9caeaf36419dd4b1e9faf0e406183e5a36284a7384fa0e7b137"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5f640d104c17af5e9a7f4e347c50e18d9698b98fe135d01386fab6f394eadb57", "request_id": "d1311188efa83142ba041fb0d48b88a6", "response_sha256": "33123977d3e79f211636b93261986667e75c30b4f272aba65130f3e413001cd2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6317461470af2f2e24b676311d09e8f7439569316911f574e005b9607e0b419a", "request_id": "8592c317f5a3122f480a9415728c9cb9", "response_sha256": "216655a868c953c5ca015b65b914fd49fe98aca70f1f0aab7b389f8d189f1de5", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "cc2c64aceefab8a842ec0897462e586d", "candidate_priority_rank": 280, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5423f55468e53003:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5423f55468e53003:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5423f55468e53003:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5423f55468e53003:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "ground<->platform", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "platform", "B": "ground"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "platform<->ground", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2339494", "image_sha256": "9556175d2b39722325f19df6adf81cccefd1cc6282cdcb7e4930539f3bffffc7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2339494.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2339494.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 338, "image_id": "2352180", "image_sha256": "4e104d1e76f67c3507c1d7979f4585f35b7f397ec4c05039a7d2e44d868723f6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2352180.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2352180.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5423f55468e53003", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "platform", "diff_b": "ground", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "platform", "component_b": "ground"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bear", "ear", "fur", "ice", "leg", "paint", "platform", "rock", "rocks", "sand", "stairs", "step", "steps", "swimming pool", "water"], "detected_components": ["platform"], "masked_program_sha256": "907a7adb74b44e04ac3bc2b2f2bc1725280d60646bcc803ab7985199f9db7043", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["platform", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "platform", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["platform", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d2eb9ea594c544e0a120241ec66e8fc84e0686458ef6e64f4dab68520544a7f0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11106899", "text": "What is the animal that is standing on the platform called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "earrings", "elephant", "eye", "ground", "leaf", "legs", "man", "people", "purse", "shirt", "trunk", "wristband"], "detected_components": ["ground"], "masked_program_sha256": "907a7adb74b44e04ac3bc2b2f2bc1725280d60646bcc803ab7985199f9db7043", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ground", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a9938beb0089ab68cf92f3b9b39f8e19ab51e3d3b28efd4cb9cabb6fce67fd9a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18724198", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 280, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "30bdd12e02a1323777b56d31f99f50b36b0b6542b48d88c370f6584b0a61b7b2", "selected_component": "ground", "selected_source_question_id": "18724198", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal that is standing on the ground called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,standing on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is standing on the called?", "program_group_hash": "30bdd12e02a1323777b56d31f99f50b36b0b6542b48d88c370f6584b0a61b7b2", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "platform"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,standing on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is standing on the called?", "program_group_hash": "30bdd12e02a1323777b56d31f99f50b36b0b6542b48d88c370f6584b0a61b7b2", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "standing on", "select_category": "ground"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bear", "full_answer": "The animal is a bear.", "question": "What is the animal that is standing on the platform called?", "question_id": "11106899", "semantic": [{"argument": "platform (4584153)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,standing on,s (4467586)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The animal is an elephant.", "question": "What is the animal that is standing on the ground called?", "question_id": "18724198", "semantic": [{"argument": "ground (2222114)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,standing on,s (3784368)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4467586"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bear"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wet"], "query_target_entity_id": "4467586", "query_target_entity_name": "bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "4584153", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4467586", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4584153", "selected_entity_name": "platform"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "platform", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4584153"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "platform", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2421638", "3784368"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "standing on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3784368", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "2222114", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3784368", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2222114", "selected_entity_name": "ground"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2222114"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:cc2c64aceefab8a842ec0897462e586d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9556175d2b39722325f19df6adf81cccefd1cc6282cdcb7e4930539f3bffffc7", "image_sha256_b": "4e104d1e76f67c3507c1d7979f4585f35b7f397ec4c05039a7d2e44d868723f6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3a135b0521c2e63048c8bfd355f12f9ce8d4f452573eb73d24d7d3facfc4655d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3c7da2a2aea9a20b5af8825898e55846", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d79f6a2cef8e79830c4367c50062e76fa75989c18d741d1886688b06cdb058bc"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "8fb84fe230b6a9796e84ad986f3819f6f5c549131c3a1bc36e5ab80361504a1b", "request_id": "c4482c034f658a98a955f0b1a54c4961", "response_sha256": "37fa21237ab742ba008f594407186ad73f1c983d8859e61e24d742b02be34a28", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "322dce9eabc4f9e6161449aad068223f4f07413af4127a2b2e8c0fb4b9c28d2f", "request_id": "bc1df2f13251b700bdf9b1261f0da6f3", "response_sha256": "95acf741c221cb7d52cb87a431b4ae28a459f262bfe5c71dd05005a4193124de", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "30684eea72ecba842fe2753721f8f752", "candidate_priority_rank": 282, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8ec00c9b7faa93f8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8ec00c9b7faa93f8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8ec00c9b7faa93f8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8ec00c9b7faa93f8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cage<->fence", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "fence", "B": "cage"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "fence<->cage", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2355196", "image_sha256": "c690b55f0bc8af93cc311fd5fb5204aa85309c784a497db0bffafa9c79d314b5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2355196.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2355196.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2402772", "image_sha256": "66adf0ed81bba56996233bbd740a66b6f2e8c78ea3e85d6b689bb9d142ce4473", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402772.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402772.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8ec00c9b7faa93f8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "fence", "diff_b": "cage", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "fence", "component_b": "cage"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cap", "collar", "ear", "fence", "field", "hair", "hand", "horse", "pants", "pole", "shirt", "woman"], "detected_components": ["fence"], "masked_program_sha256": "77901cffa028b657790411e08a10393d0580b3828c2d4ff1cd2165f6a5260dc3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "fence", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dfed8f36b4d31dbdcd069f95739b2596a21d1275971e9727a8717a91b33cc1d1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01174327", "text": "What is the animal that this fence is in front of called?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cage", "ear", "eye", "face", "giraffe", "grass", "neck", "toy", "wall"], "detected_components": ["cage"], "masked_program_sha256": "77901cffa028b657790411e08a10393d0580b3828c2d4ff1cd2165f6a5260dc3", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cage", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cage", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cage", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "132c90c071e009da20b9ee8e27e20f9e514f3e9135f2207a0f791679e68b22f9"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03395619", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 282, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "d2969a9e21db550b4b97bd67493fd9efa4a9b91ca493b47f05c3fac491ad5f57", "selected_component": "cage", "selected_source_question_id": "03395619", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal that this cage is in front of called?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that this is in front of called?", "program_group_hash": "d2969a9e21db550b4b97bd67493fd9efa4a9b91ca493b47f05c3fac491ad5f57", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that this is in front of called?", "program_group_hash": "d2969a9e21db550b4b97bd67493fd9efa4a9b91ca493b47f05c3fac491ad5f57", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "cage"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The animal is a horse.", "question": "What is the animal that this fence is in front of called?", "question_id": "01174327", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (831890)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,o (831888)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The animal is a giraffe.", "question": "What is the animal that this cage is in front of called?", "question_id": "03395619", "semantic": [{"argument": "cage (1131811)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,o (3816321)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["831888"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "831888", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "831888", "relation_subject_entity_id": "831890", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "831890", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["831890"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cage", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3816317", "3816321"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3816321", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "3816321", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1131811", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1131811", "selected_entity_name": "cage"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cage", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1131811"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:30684eea72ecba842fe2753721f8f752", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c690b55f0bc8af93cc311fd5fb5204aa85309c784a497db0bffafa9c79d314b5", "image_sha256_b": "66adf0ed81bba56996233bbd740a66b6f2e8c78ea3e85d6b689bb9d142ce4473", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "cd213d667c7683cc5f9cdf33a171a9abf60afa587566d6285f4bdcd1678cce6d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "fa98ce89c1858dd190cbd32929b0e713", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ccafe04b884af4faad239b14ec8d2481327e53b4a2d1f399d739c300fa292ea2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "505e1ec599d02fe1c91764b87b181edc1ebbb207d49377ab902c4f902e06a116", "request_id": "86018d1eadec2a27a5c67ddfabcc63be", "response_sha256": "318e33737210140875f72bb09125124db016f5741534f80fcfe052acb8ff7dbc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5cdb49b67cb5ac46c08b9dfa32f05ae8379de385cc5bc8c5747481b791dda534", "request_id": "4456e5addfbb0abea3bf363fea01b80d", "response_sha256": "46a178909ff5004960f47ad5cf69846961b4847e1bf95ba76fb1b55d0371dd13", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "b61f34544aa2213f72e9b8300a75e97e", "candidate_priority_rank": 284, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-728802ec7f987c83:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-728802ec7f987c83:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-728802ec7f987c83:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-728802ec7f987c83:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "building<->parking lot", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "parking lot", "B": "building"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "parking lot<->building", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2370008", "image_sha256": "d716618eacd429604e4ce7f1c0aced36f11d8d59ba51cbb39c2a9240e16bcf15", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2370008.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2370008.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2378970", "image_sha256": "f093b62beacf3646ea564726e3f9043c120668ea44b03d15241e27b08c0504c2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2378970.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2378970.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-728802ec7f987c83", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "parking lot", "diff_b": "building", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "parking lot", "component_b": "building"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bus", "car", "cloud", "clouds", "grass", "number", "parking lot", "sky", "tire", "trees", "windows", "windshield"], "detected_components": ["parking lot"], "masked_program_sha256": "2470d9ed27618b66426c5c15088db186dec53c34551406b552fd6b1367b62bea", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["parking lot"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "parking lot", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["parking lot"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "44c8af1e48eb3a4636acb0c341b8048ccd26c21f8e8b88491c3394ec2a0ea11f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19617292", "text": "What is parked in the parking lot?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "floor", "license plate", "newspaper", "road", "shelves", "van", "wall", "wheel", "window"], "detected_components": ["building"], "masked_program_sha256": "2470d9ed27618b66426c5c15088db186dec53c34551406b552fd6b1367b62bea", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "building", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["building"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "32cffb1d256eae35a154e8d1e15eae53b19766303a05b4856488bde07c3b202e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16388198", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 284, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 15, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "54a0a113b3b012459cf263ebd33ff3bcca464d25987bb11de2739da331828521", "selected_component": "building", "selected_source_question_id": "16388198", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is parked in the building?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is parked in the ?", "program_group_hash": "54a0a113b3b012459cf263ebd33ff3bcca464d25987bb11de2739da331828521", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "parked in", "select_category": "parking lot"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is parked in the ?", "program_group_hash": "54a0a113b3b012459cf263ebd33ff3bcca464d25987bb11de2739da331828521", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "parked in", "select_category": "building"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bus", "full_answer": "The bus is parked in the parking lot.", "question": "What is parked in the parking lot?", "question_id": "19617292", "semantic": [{"argument": "parking lot (2436652)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked in,s (2253657)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "van", "full_answer": "The van is parked in the building.", "question": "What is parked in the building?", "question_id": "16388198", "semantic": [{"argument": "building (1362404)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked in,s (1362376)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1776813", "1776814", "1776815", "1874346", "1876895", "1952934", "2003351", "2177807", "2253657", "2299094", "2299095", "2401256", "2638139", "3860621"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bus"], "predicate": "parked in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2253657", "query_target_entity_name": "bus", "relation_object_entity_id": "2436652", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2253657", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2436652", "selected_entity_name": "parking lot"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "parking lot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2436652"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "building", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "parking lot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1362375", "1362376", "1362378", "1362380", "1362383", "1362386", "1362388", "1362389", "1362397", "1362403", "1362416"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["van"], "predicate": "parked in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1362376", "query_target_entity_name": "van", "relation_object_entity_id": "1362404", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1362376", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1362404", "selected_entity_name": "building"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "building", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1362404"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:b61f34544aa2213f72e9b8300a75e97e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d716618eacd429604e4ce7f1c0aced36f11d8d59ba51cbb39c2a9240e16bcf15", "image_sha256_b": "f093b62beacf3646ea564726e3f9043c120668ea44b03d15241e27b08c0504c2", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "baffd892014f62817ce1b58f8f88f536b24a63ea3967b9283dcb61bdffce780f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "fe58ce455b64f765fd1477ce14aa2c36", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "189512d6c8712cfbadf25ae995fe45ba65e699e5a5154daec3e1fd2708de66af"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2dac8094f04bcab2a7f9b17608fbbadcf4afb69fab395f5df9a6eb05612e9749", "request_id": "eb34af679a9be3a8e2b2d7cbc0272562", "response_sha256": "18d82862f272db7c6b0a5c083a373651d5195d85e777c24aaac4d00193ef12bf", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "cd138c2890b7b9319346cf79714e1d76a9147a8bd26da91cddb09531bf98421d", "request_id": "e538626318bea1a9b73863c350d5be24", "response_sha256": "d51e1f9948c8d85095571eb120495fd844d72457f6f3111c282e743e443ec0b8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "5513461da7d1870c34398bb530459e67", "candidate_priority_rank": 290, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-142aeeec69629cb2:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-142aeeec69629cb2:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-142aeeec69629cb2:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-142aeeec69629cb2:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "carpet<->floor", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "carpet", "B": "floor"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "carpet<->floor", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2401377", "image_sha256": "2e2d748bf70b71c8757a8e372b7fe4bbdce959cc982ec991606d18bfcbd07508", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401377.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401377.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 311, "image_id": "2363487", "image_sha256": "63503e6613db58b40c2fd70a884f7b979f689729c330b351d0bd53c4f8eddbc6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2363487.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2363487.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-142aeeec69629cb2", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "carpet", "diff_b": "floor", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "carpet", "component_b": "floor"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "cabinets", "carpet", "cat", "chair", "dishes", "eyes", "face", "feet", "floor", "fur", "laptop", "paw", "seat", "television", "wall"], "detected_components": ["carpet"], "masked_program_sha256": "871fd658738c3fa8c4c4332fd61de1f0d7839b68b93b7b063081c85c521813f0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["carpet", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "carpet", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["carpet", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8f87e52298ac39edd66d12ae09d65732440a487fb4f420a5e760adb08b3cb7cc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "161060777", "text": "What is the item of furniture above the carpet?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "cord", "couch", "ear", "face", "floor", "head", "lamp", "leg", "nose", "rug", "tail", "wall"], "detected_components": ["floor"], "masked_program_sha256": "871fd658738c3fa8c4c4332fd61de1f0d7839b68b93b7b063081c85c521813f0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["floor", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "floor", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["floor", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b0a21c56da9e91878c1496f3d7a0cdf09fe89f825826d2d21927bee4fff6e99a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11888236", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 290, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 11, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "93adaaeb5f0350842e82e7960bfed8fb091efb16e8d558540054f9f8d30bd692", "selected_component": "floor", "selected_source_question_id": "11888236", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the item of furniture above the floor?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture above the ?", "program_group_hash": "93adaaeb5f0350842e82e7960bfed8fb091efb16e8d558540054f9f8d30bd692", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "carpet"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture above the ?", "program_group_hash": "93adaaeb5f0350842e82e7960bfed8fb091efb16e8d558540054f9f8d30bd692", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "floor"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a chair.", "question": "What is the item of furniture above the carpet?", "question_id": "161060777", "semantic": [{"argument": "carpet (399969)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,above,s (399964)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a couch.", "question": "What is the item of furniture above the floor?", "question_id": "11888236", "semantic": [{"argument": "floor (764708)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,above,s (764700)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["399964", "399984"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "399964", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "399969", "relation_subject_entity_id": "399964", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "399969", "selected_entity_name": "carpet"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "carpet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["399969"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["399964", "399984"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "floor", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["399971"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "carpet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["764700"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "leather"], "query_target_entity_id": "764700", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "764708", "relation_subject_entity_id": "764700", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "764708", "selected_entity_name": "floor"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "floor", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["764708"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:5513461da7d1870c34398bb530459e67", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "2e2d748bf70b71c8757a8e372b7fe4bbdce959cc982ec991606d18bfcbd07508", "image_sha256_b": "63503e6613db58b40c2fd70a884f7b979f689729c330b351d0bd53c4f8eddbc6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5b84e385f61a5ae95d99d61bb908b68f38bb93a4b662455d14e7bd652ee0c116", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a39a198e7d81b319d54424994bc093ea", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ab7bdc43295d9a1c194c5bae90fc14616a61199cfc163f8570a06457e48be096"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6efdbfbb3dc86398407a9706edaac4b5a7608ccfd300a32ebf0652894352d571", "request_id": "722d8a97787fdc620824983b567266ea", "response_sha256": "7180183c997ea3a234cce3f4ea03a485541571a08dd490e1adf3773641fce107", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5aa9d313cfcffaea030aeb081cad04916731ec40e184a7538c15f970eaab25ce", "request_id": "8156ff6adc042a715cb620ab22d485a7", "response_sha256": "830a0f077ef226b4c333c6db3f930e2fdbccb9606cda1b541f7bf66ac26ccc8a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "341b0b5139eb2bd78f46f609b1990a23", "candidate_priority_rank": 293, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62f07d10cadd9010:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62f07d10cadd9010:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62f07d10cadd9010:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62f07d10cadd9010:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->plate", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "plate", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "plate<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2317784", "image_sha256": "57f6b4ff150abecd3259bea7b2825fc4feacaf9de8517700b338ffbf408de03f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2317784.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2317784.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2365107", "image_sha256": "d557acf4547fbd8203ce37cceb3116fdba04c8e8aec861c25cf67f986a541785", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365107.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365107.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62f07d10cadd9010", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "plate", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "plate", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cheese", "coffee", "crumbs", "crust", "cup", "pepperoni", "pizza", "plate", "sausage", "table", "toppings"], "detected_components": ["plate"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "plate", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e6c54f4a4eaaa26b67516e41a49ff7e2f2cd0f583894f8d16026779b0c086019"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14308210", "text": "What piece of furniture is below the plate?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "chair", "cup", "ear", "head", "magazine", "map", "newspaper", "paw", "placemat", "remote control", "table"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "a0fd2128c8cbd6a02fc0f97c1f2af88251fb3e5aab5732b0aaef1b2273809cc1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "875fc032ee0a985a2420c9e1d055e495e27236ff7c88834e953556099b1657b3"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18125174", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 293, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e0299e89b810188269c40e5516a573a5f07ee9952353c08a91d4c031049666d7", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "18125174", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What piece of furniture is below the cat?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what piece of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "e0299e89b810188269c40e5516a573a5f07ee9952353c08a91d4c031049666d7", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what piece of furniture is below the ?", "program_group_hash": "e0299e89b810188269c40e5516a573a5f07ee9952353c08a91d4c031049666d7", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "below", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a table.", "question": "What piece of furniture is below the plate?", "question_id": "14308210", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (1017416)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (1017420)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a table.", "question": "What piece of furniture is below the cat?", "question_id": "18125174", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (2216384)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,below,s (2242076)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1017420"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1017420", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "1017416", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1017420", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1017416", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plate", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1017416"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plate", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1975390", "2242076"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "below", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2242076", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "2216384", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2242076", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2216384", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2216384"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:341b0b5139eb2bd78f46f609b1990a23", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "57f6b4ff150abecd3259bea7b2825fc4feacaf9de8517700b338ffbf408de03f", "image_sha256_b": "d557acf4547fbd8203ce37cceb3116fdba04c8e8aec861c25cf67f986a541785", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "1889b9cf927c240d938de99f1b0976dfb87ba6db655929de263863f8d4cf1f2c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5cbd4c53f2c2e0cc3a337eb28449d481", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "cccd67f904eebb4c89aed66c740ade603ca81850e0b9f1053cd0eda4cf6f970c"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d2a1ea5fee59ff336a6fa445b3882d1800d0ab2f1a519b10b6cc92231bac4f61", "request_id": "9b3eab1733e2d9ef64c1c659ea006b65", "response_sha256": "705aa347ffb2f7084f50f7d71a87e29c2eff21f86f9ccbfb95a53fc036cbfddc", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3acd8d8f6c8794c7189751954aa192e9a9f1b9adb5f401c2ec73f5f0ef6dee6b", "request_id": "c1727c14bd3707b38a7042a40d129cad", "response_sha256": "2f7cdf90f97f2d9c362a386012533ed26013911c97ebd5f0c8fcc7bd671e8006", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "4fd8130af59656dd5191bcb3ee31f90f", "candidate_priority_rank": 294, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c16734fded442b4b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c16734fded442b4b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c16734fded442b4b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c16734fded442b4b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dog<->zebra", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "zebra", "B": "dog"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "zebra<->dog", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2395874", "image_sha256": "1d4c8b7d8022e8371dd3390f21d6a193122e426498079623342f47a08b1c01f6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395874.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395874.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2373852", "image_sha256": "6893e1720cf760a14fb2309bcfaadd494a62fb6667bbd571df9aaab04a93facb", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2373852.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2373852.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c16734fded442b4b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "zebra", "diff_b": "dog", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "zebra", "component_b": "dog"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "jacket", "jeans", "trees", "windshield", "zebra"], "detected_components": ["zebra"], "masked_program_sha256": "c50480a1d262d238b2062ba1b80068a91be181210aeb45a12c8de880564a4a1d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["zebra", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "zebra", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["zebra", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9fbf0732688a0c39558d30724394fad952be5e049b048db260712859e28d2217"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01888012", "text": "What is the vehicle that that zebra is in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "dog", "ear", "eyes", "face", "fur", "ground", "head", "mirror", "nose", "pine tree", "pine trees", "road", "snow", "window"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "c50480a1d262d238b2062ba1b80068a91be181210aeb45a12c8de880564a4a1d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2783e0a9b02d81b51ec52dd1bf8769eb073a9510fbe597b5339984944b204d89"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "03517377", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 294, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "68931b6d64a46600791ac778d73fcc4dca0f1e20432aca272685953a0264c8a1", "selected_component": "dog", "selected_source_question_id": "03517377", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the vehicle that that dog is in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vehicle that that is in?", "program_group_hash": "68931b6d64a46600791ac778d73fcc4dca0f1e20432aca272685953a0264c8a1", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "zebra"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vehicle that that is in?", "program_group_hash": "68931b6d64a46600791ac778d73fcc4dca0f1e20432aca272685953a0264c8a1", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a car.", "question": "What is the vehicle that that zebra is in?", "question_id": "01888012", "semantic": [{"argument": "zebra (665622)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o (665623)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a car.", "question": "What is the vehicle that that dog is in?", "question_id": "03517377", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (730321)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o (730329)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["665623"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "665623", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "665623", "relation_subject_entity_id": "665622", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "665622", "selected_entity_name": "zebra"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "zebra", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["665622"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "zebra", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["730329"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "730329", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "730329", "relation_subject_entity_id": "730321", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "730321", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["730321"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4fd8130af59656dd5191bcb3ee31f90f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "1d4c8b7d8022e8371dd3390f21d6a193122e426498079623342f47a08b1c01f6", "image_sha256_b": "6893e1720cf760a14fb2309bcfaadd494a62fb6667bbd571df9aaab04a93facb", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "328503feac6f782e81dc02855d8c0509170ed5d71cd49807033852ba519131d2", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3ade3e07296b8f1e0c052a7d669bfd66", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d6e736b2b3c6d984920c2b1c27641d3ad48307df6198981e8118500b53c90b7e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a54aa7db6fea3082752237ac39564367c8e32cf1f40d1cea03bc461b1b9af5a3", "request_id": "f4efea0516ed8ef0b3b6148cfebcd637", "response_sha256": "b733e003075467e9dc8e804de1b1b483678a97dcf8c23aea487c6be0e6fada7e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "04373e6bc578327fb6d717c7503bd490d00c4edf776fc74b8a5f2decd6ffad18", "request_id": "2cfaf84a3d2d306009f789906556a98f", "response_sha256": "298264df1e504c924d9ce05a3a0acd744139823ffa2750f9872701910a2dd8ab", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "205478bb3d659d64610077022ed3c35e", "candidate_priority_rank": 298, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5f396cb721ea4eb5:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5f396cb721ea4eb5:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5f396cb721ea4eb5:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5f396cb721ea4eb5:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "car<->giraffe", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "giraffe", "B": "car"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "giraffe<->car", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2350889", "image_sha256": "d74ecee94add0062e5a7cedd65cee1d8c4d9354cf2fa8067b25a954c19538a64", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2350889.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2350889.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2326569", "image_sha256": "88e19f6de5c01e431068e79c464c90ffafe9404dfda60700f8d8ac68c38d4fcc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2326569.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2326569.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-5f396cb721ea4eb5", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "giraffe", "diff_b": "car", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "giraffe", "component_b": "car"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["branches", "bush", "ears", "field", "giraffe", "grass", "head", "horn", "leaf", "leg", "neck", "nose", "plants", "tree", "trees"], "detected_components": ["giraffe"], "masked_program_sha256": "433e021b4cde27db5e32ae2a45178f066df3c167a2bbc2d9e4c976a1e24434fb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "giraffe", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "513502876c8d36cd3c9f3d38d112f896cd77ace26692d7ac262823c44e11c013"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06323747", "text": "What is growing behind the giraffe?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "collar", "dog", "eye", "glass", "grass", "gravel", "grill", "logo", "neck", "path", "person", "tail", "trees"], "detected_components": ["car"], "masked_program_sha256": "433e021b4cde27db5e32ae2a45178f066df3c167a2bbc2d9e4c976a1e24434fb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["car"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "car", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["car"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fb6907d58328c4bfa475029bbe0bd24375a864ac9c949cbd11faafede7c18f43"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06637970", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 298, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "55dac46db767a4d9c992c9e3d77675edac208e5af5f8bba3c12992ca7a5cd156", "selected_component": "car", "selected_source_question_id": "06637970", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is growing behind the car?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing behind,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is growing behind the ?", "program_group_hash": "55dac46db767a4d9c992c9e3d77675edac208e5af5f8bba3c12992ca7a5cd156", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "growing behind", "select_category": "giraffe"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing behind,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is growing behind the ?", "program_group_hash": "55dac46db767a4d9c992c9e3d77675edac208e5af5f8bba3c12992ca7a5cd156", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "growing behind", "select_category": "car"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "trees", "full_answer": "The trees are growing behind the giraffe.", "question": "What is growing behind the giraffe?", "question_id": "06323747", "semantic": [{"argument": "giraffe (1813152)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing behind,s (3899313)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "trees", "full_answer": "The trees are growing behind the car.", "question": "What is growing behind the car?", "question_id": "06637970", "semantic": [{"argument": "car (3030023)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,growing behind,s (3042530)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1666271", "1724496", "1813151", "1870476", "1903311", "1939317", "1939318", "2246057", "2277764", "2306400", "2493283", "2493284", "2631097", "2631098", "2631099", "2631100", "3899313", "3899317", "3899318", "3899319"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 20, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trees"], "predicate": "growing behind", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3899313", "query_target_entity_name": "trees", "relation_object_entity_id": "1813152", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3899313", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1813152", "selected_entity_name": "giraffe"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1813152"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "car", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2724831", "2941717", "2986213", "3028163", "3042530", "3132776", "3175837", "3211028", "3221619", "3344153", "3344154", "3428601", "3481209", "3507867", "3939095", "3939100"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trees"], "predicate": "growing behind", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["tall"], "query_target_entity_id": "3042530", "query_target_entity_name": "trees", "relation_object_entity_id": "3030023", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3042530", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3030023", "selected_entity_name": "car"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "car", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3030023"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:205478bb3d659d64610077022ed3c35e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d74ecee94add0062e5a7cedd65cee1d8c4d9354cf2fa8067b25a954c19538a64", "image_sha256_b": "88e19f6de5c01e431068e79c464c90ffafe9404dfda60700f8d8ac68c38d4fcc", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "6a09f86bf116a19bd60c4d0730a1854be35aeb3d530e47cf33a34615359d6405", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b4b6536f612cd4bd17f1f2073eacc876", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "81b40c0ec2b1ebf8b3ceb6eb6da5ad07f7ec5cf8376c2316291fd038d53810bf"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "18c2b3805693d860bae4506fb2a30cf3acf5fd05a02fe73d6429e55f7eb2eaae", "request_id": "0fc08701fcbee69611bd7a5eadee6e1d", "response_sha256": "34dedb425bbf1a0b73cb65a8e2fac3fb0b8e8759162ca78d71f420db325aa6d9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "d4662199e45015b2f587efc53c4799bfa941f8f6030ff0879cf83a0723030349", "request_id": "948770c01631732a46e18a5a9ecfd0df", "response_sha256": "9fa1eb8af03aa152ecdc59e058179ce7aa905083a619a6e63eaa4af8dc00885d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "2d7aba936e79fcf2172926fb6525af03", "candidate_priority_rank": 303, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-025ad61ad8860fe9:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-025ad61ad8860fe9:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-025ad61ad8860fe9:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-025ad61ad8860fe9:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "grass<->ground", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "grass", "B": "ground"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "grass<->ground", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2331295", "image_sha256": "973ec6505ac69cbf9e098479b4aa051aca63cd7762f4959b950a55b6adb6add6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2331295.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2331295.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2365412", "image_sha256": "41f1dbd832a327d60615c915a6fdc0eaf1a3f98a8955dfdf4d510ad058792d59", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2365412.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2365412.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-025ad61ad8860fe9", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "grass", "diff_b": "ground", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "grass", "component_b": "ground"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bear", "grass"], "detected_components": ["grass"], "masked_program_sha256": "9d101c86b63c1693b6803bccde91431dc0f12d8f9bc1d7f08119d3d92ad9829f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "grass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "83e9a23c46cb56b69244b10f6a49f8a1e1999ad27a1458be70cc42cbe2d030af"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19793039", "text": "What kind of animal is walking on the grass?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["branch", "chicken", "eye", "face", "foot", "ground", "head", "leaf", "leg", "neck", "pole", "straw", "tail", "wing"], "detected_components": ["ground"], "masked_program_sha256": "9d101c86b63c1693b6803bccde91431dc0f12d8f9bc1d7f08119d3d92ad9829f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ground", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "56de57efacf312bccb7b9d0cd21120f40353c6ea2c84e28a597dc8db8a13a303"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "031027176", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 303, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e993f495ffac273c7eeb7b45314da6f1be935ec849362fd5b2f59fb1e43d28cf", "selected_component": "ground", "selected_source_question_id": "031027176", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of animal is walking on the ground?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is walking on the ?", "program_group_hash": "e993f495ffac273c7eeb7b45314da6f1be935ec849362fd5b2f59fb1e43d28cf", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "grass"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of animal is walking on the ?", "program_group_hash": "e993f495ffac273c7eeb7b45314da6f1be935ec849362fd5b2f59fb1e43d28cf", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "ground"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bear", "full_answer": "The animal is a bear.", "question": "What kind of animal is walking on the grass?", "question_id": "19793039", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (3609696)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s (3243679)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chicken", "full_answer": "The animal is chicken.", "question": "What kind of animal is walking on the ground?", "question_id": "031027176", "semantic": [{"argument": "ground (634339)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s (634340)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3243679"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bear"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3243679", "query_target_entity_name": "bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "3609696", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3243679", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3609696", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3609696"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["634340"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chicken"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "fancy", "feathered", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "634340", "query_target_entity_name": "chicken", "relation_object_entity_id": "634339", "relation_subject_entity_id": "634340", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "634339", "selected_entity_name": "ground"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["634339"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:2d7aba936e79fcf2172926fb6525af03", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "973ec6505ac69cbf9e098479b4aa051aca63cd7762f4959b950a55b6adb6add6", "image_sha256_b": "41f1dbd832a327d60615c915a6fdc0eaf1a3f98a8955dfdf4d510ad058792d59", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7d2f4dbb6a35f8193519e4327bcafbf4628e751e0c8501d4adfefef88b28233f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1eb1c3ab1be1f822af954f741f57cf83", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "dca6aaf34d61d5cc7c405eeda07cf2f5a6ca5fa3feb97ef064b1b522251a33bb"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1aaf7e1d42d5c1ac2822eb55f2ac4c0dd508f37beff00fbad16badff6ee19488", "request_id": "1e296009c200789c1c56609a1107164a", "response_sha256": "620db8166078c0dbec9b4a0eaff3c6f859240b3a2865e6ebeb7114796b48b3a1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "822aa23b019b2c62e1f18f415b5e8c7203d8cfdafa3e294d77ad22c9a8ea0535", "request_id": "31c67254756917df10abaf1b84bb1b97", "response_sha256": "2be7854cf0bb01d3bd149d89c811c5364fad01158c396e333ad99d05df996c6f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "e0e2464df20699602c77bba76360ba80", "candidate_priority_rank": 319, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6c0a1aea362ea85e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6c0a1aea362ea85e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6c0a1aea362ea85e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6c0a1aea362ea85e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "air<->water", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "water", "B": "air"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "water<->air", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2415171", "image_sha256": "ff616e4be227de02d7c524fd2a8f3684b1541b4fae6ac3bac4546c642597cf53", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2415171.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2415171.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 406, "image_id": "2396996", "image_sha256": "ee01bc51f5807cf4aa861f21ffc86aa08b75743f179a1dd454a6c72432214f91", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396996.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396996.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "activity_state", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6c0a1aea362ea85e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "water", "diff_b": "air", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "water", "component_b": "air"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "pose", "question_intent": "activity_state:pose", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "hair", "leg", "logo", "surfboard", "waist", "water", "wetsuit", "woman"], "detected_components": ["water"], "masked_program_sha256": "0a23973da8bc7cf25c49b314c5977f348c834aeda071cd0a8bfbaa0d2176a474", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "water", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["water", "woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "59792b0c948d901756ef31bf68986083b78630a0940b35d85cc8ab9f6c9308bc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12444158", "text": "What is the woman in the water doing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["air", "fence", "finger", "frisbee", "grass", "hair", "logo", "people", "shirt", "shorts", "sneakers", "tape", "trees", "woman", "wristband"], "detected_components": ["air"], "masked_program_sha256": "0a23973da8bc7cf25c49b314c5977f348c834aeda071cd0a8bfbaa0d2176a474", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["air", "woman"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "air", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["air", "woman"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1df5e03f4ee893eff7bee19728d509593bb7ca064f94abb9e84358ab9d1d8979"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "16659831", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 319, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2b0496e52b5e600032a39cfa6283aac6c152b18851a18b54240c9417db22a66d", "selected_component": "air", "selected_source_question_id": "16659831", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the woman in the air doing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "woman,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the woman in the doing?", "program_group_hash": "2b0496e52b5e600032a39cfa6283aac6c152b18851a18b54240c9417db22a66d", "queried_category": "woman", "query_role": "pose", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "water"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "woman,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the woman in the doing?", "program_group_hash": "2b0496e52b5e600032a39cfa6283aac6c152b18851a18b54240c9417db22a66d", "queried_category": "woman", "query_role": "pose", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "air"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bending", "full_answer": "The woman is bending.", "question": "What is the woman in the water doing?", "question_id": "12444158", "semantic": [{"argument": "water (144594)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "woman,in,s (144589)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "jumping", "full_answer": "The woman is jumping.", "question": "What is the woman in the air doing?", "question_id": "16659831", "semantic": [{"argument": "air (438407)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "woman,in,s (438408)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "pose", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["144589"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bending", "blond", "large", "surfing", "swimming"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["bending", "blond", "large", "surfing", "swimming"], "query_target_entity_id": "144589", "query_target_entity_name": "woman", "relation_object_entity_id": "144594", "relation_subject_entity_id": "144589", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "144594", "selected_entity_name": "water"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["144594"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "air", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "water", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["438408", "438419"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["jumping"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["jumping"], "query_target_entity_id": "438408", "query_target_entity_name": "woman", "relation_object_entity_id": "438407", "relation_subject_entity_id": "438408", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "438407", "selected_entity_name": "air"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "air", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["438407"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e0e2464df20699602c77bba76360ba80", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ff616e4be227de02d7c524fd2a8f3684b1541b4fae6ac3bac4546c642597cf53", "image_sha256_b": "ee01bc51f5807cf4aa861f21ffc86aa08b75743f179a1dd454a6c72432214f91", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ca5a5786e066d10151b47b05c2374b5e848e51f099cd6bebd118919b9640973a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "d1c94c939995f6500df9f1c7382a6626", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "551fbb033ce7f0c37ad9a52721840f8d0c75278e206ebf6b93b8dfc81685cd4c"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0b13ccee685829c4a18cb6021c29691fb48ee971752352c37cd6141f3c2e8c98", "request_id": "0cfe1a1924789423c9b71552a295b348", "response_sha256": "bb32d818f740730df66b7ee2708f585af90910ae21a040879471f0c22b0521ce", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "dd15cc3f711bde308073ce23bbf611f565e71f02cbb523bbd05ef1efd8a868ac", "request_id": "407f97caab0e31ce19fc20d325d46549", "response_sha256": "b90056cc821ed7741a1638e8de602d9b021c645ac7bf6cadbc58b8e18f5e8dda", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "629cabe734c72a62948298b247ab4f32", "candidate_priority_rank": 324, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-178a3d4ff1508ccb:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-178a3d4ff1508ccb:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-178a3d4ff1508ccb:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-178a3d4ff1508ccb:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->rabbit", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "rabbit"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->rabbit", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 394, "image_id": "2345524", "image_sha256": "d5952150006158251f003f36519a5c3621fc53a41bc1e0eac205dff7834c4d57", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345524.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345524.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2366474", "image_sha256": "e804f6d59d01fd2e8cc3414ff5690b4d6a54fc0d29ca59d1e08784e386aede5c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2366474.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2366474.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-178a3d4ff1508ccb", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "rabbit", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "rabbit"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "belt", "face", "feet", "flowers", "hair", "hat", "jeans", "laptop", "man", "painting", "pants", "shirt", "wall", "woman"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b56688f395a0fa9cf64cd1b19b65ab9f800dae14d8ea191a1179178051265d99"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19834724", "text": "What is that man lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["banana", "carpet", "ear", "eye", "floor", "fur", "nose", "rabbit", "sign", "word"], "detected_components": ["rabbit"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["rabbit"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "rabbit", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["rabbit"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "6df37623ff06dab34ad308bb74e3194a7642c54327788b40787c0d1970aba4a1"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "1943085", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 324, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ccdd1ae41d0306e5d5fc3ab743c217f8cde48040e3e9e89abd2773791785bf78", "selected_component": "rabbit", "selected_source_question_id": "1943085", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is that rabbit lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is that lying on?", "program_group_hash": "ccdd1ae41d0306e5d5fc3ab743c217f8cde48040e3e9e89abd2773791785bf78", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is that lying on?", "program_group_hash": "ccdd1ae41d0306e5d5fc3ab743c217f8cde48040e3e9e89abd2773791785bf78", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "rabbit"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The man is lying on the bed.", "question": "What is that man lying on?", "question_id": "19834724", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (2150396)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (3624007)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "floor", "full_answer": "The rabbit is lying on the floor.", "question": "What is that rabbit lying on?", "question_id": "1943085", "semantic": [{"argument": "rabbit (2685121)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (2283842)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2200131", "2275479", "2336282", "2362146", "2454795", "2502387", "2560230", "2666319", "2677102", "2690350", "2690351", "3624003", "3624004", "3624006", "3624007", "3624012", "3624013"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3624007", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "3624007", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2150396", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2150396", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2150396"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "rabbit", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1944765", "2021528", "2133691", "2283842", "2335968", "2511804", "2620660", "2683027", "2685120"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 9, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["floor"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2283842", "query_target_entity_name": "floor", "relation_object_entity_id": "2283842", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2685121", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2685121", "selected_entity_name": "rabbit"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "rabbit", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2685121"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:629cabe734c72a62948298b247ab4f32", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d5952150006158251f003f36519a5c3621fc53a41bc1e0eac205dff7834c4d57", "image_sha256_b": "e804f6d59d01fd2e8cc3414ff5690b4d6a54fc0d29ca59d1e08784e386aede5c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "248449514131d9da77383ffea86a0e68539329c375683be29ad3068933d68135", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "6822343e365bfdfda355bc853a181f39", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "522d4885a4e7aab30a52698b417ee827947798f9dc7acdfa0bdf0761245e4f8a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "60f3a831bec483dbf6505ed988fd23e0c978f6b407844b6837a98641cdc89b9f", "request_id": "367de9977f4ebb84d3bc1a31774d3929", "response_sha256": "0c8d0dbd8175753f01f3e04670d2f694431c5ce5b525c0915486986edc87b153", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "610b5fc61a744031471cea670d2b4670607cae4f9514bd77ec9fab7e7c1be94c", "request_id": "5050f507d491f9a877c074bcab43a979", "response_sha256": "6759a27eb736858ad53de2a698d3aefd76683acdde29c7caf70660f482a80e7d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "f0edf8b40e2ccf2132eff2c538cf57c1", "candidate_priority_rank": 331, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6fe5bd3b2297a432:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6fe5bd3b2297a432:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6fe5bd3b2297a432:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6fe5bd3b2297a432:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "clock<->mirror", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "clock", "B": "mirror"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "clock<->mirror", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2375539", "image_sha256": "01e89c1f27bd9fa90474803e461a5a755c7618ff3167eda1c095e067a8ed7bbe", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2375539.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2375539.jpg", "width": 410}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2390798", "image_sha256": "f2ef168d2df590bb54596970a9e80d2b851bcae93c49657c4647fdde787d6f93", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2390798.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2390798.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6fe5bd3b2297a432", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "clock", "diff_b": "mirror", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "clock", "component_b": "mirror"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["animal", "clock", "collar", "dog", "flower", "numbers"], "detected_components": ["clock"], "masked_program_sha256": "af2a80d3a9094de09f830f2860b7f62be6d24d97f590c83f81f8a3486ffffafd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["clock", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "clock", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["clock", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "568273056684aab436162c315dca757632fdc7b2f3189418a4878bcdc6f9c935"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "15239644", "text": "What is the animal that is staring at the clock?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["carpet", "cat", "collar", "doorway", "ear", "eyes", "floor", "mirror", "nose", "paws", "tag", "tail", "wall"], "detected_components": ["mirror"], "masked_program_sha256": "af2a80d3a9094de09f830f2860b7f62be6d24d97f590c83f81f8a3486ffffafd", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "mirror", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["mirror", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "84d12387c40ae84192c835fe77400c63d5a8da756463f7f1b2ef9fce8332b53a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07116230", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 331, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9dda925f5966aa8b589d991bb0784e5e218db73594f3b8f2ae0451b4c9c2c643", "selected_component": "mirror", "selected_source_question_id": "07116230", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal that is staring at the mirror?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,staring at,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is staring at the ?", "program_group_hash": "9dda925f5966aa8b589d991bb0784e5e218db73594f3b8f2ae0451b4c9c2c643", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "staring at", "select_category": "clock"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,staring at,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is staring at the ?", "program_group_hash": "9dda925f5966aa8b589d991bb0784e5e218db73594f3b8f2ae0451b4c9c2c643", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "staring at", "select_category": "mirror"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The animal is a dog.", "question": "What is the animal that is staring at the clock?", "question_id": "15239644", "semantic": [{"argument": "clock (1948498)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,staring at,s (2514958)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What is the animal that is staring at the mirror?", "question_id": "07116230", "semantic": [{"argument": "mirror (493965)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,staring at,s (493964)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2514958", "3691692"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "staring at", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gold"], "query_target_entity_id": "2514958", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "1948498", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2514958", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1948498", "selected_entity_name": "clock"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "clock", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1948498"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "clock", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["493964"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "staring at", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["furry", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "493964", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "493965", "relation_subject_entity_id": "493964", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "493965", "selected_entity_name": "mirror"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "mirror", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["493965"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f0edf8b40e2ccf2132eff2c538cf57c1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "01e89c1f27bd9fa90474803e461a5a755c7618ff3167eda1c095e067a8ed7bbe", "image_sha256_b": "f2ef168d2df590bb54596970a9e80d2b851bcae93c49657c4647fdde787d6f93", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4ac1ef31404929b55c14c0b5a5ccb2aa840828ab771e181fc720e3d2ef47c172", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "5d0ed79c4efe5775aec6efc49a2f26ed", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "578f1b126e06914155dbb340bbf203ab25a4e0d6914796b59a94a36b67c3cd49"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e5609f143dadad69e18bc208331fd2d94f0e656c079860062a74e41f8586e767", "request_id": "afec6b61e207e435cc62d1a7e9e7ad00", "response_sha256": "3435d69202b41d0602344ce5f3b33d4e19344d0b32c8f05968b510cd89d216af", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "13a56edb30afbb61b08665839912d4c3377fc351a52d45d9f7a4608142fa541b", "request_id": "b4f1498d67a71c8205daccc745a4024b", "response_sha256": "5633dfdc33dc5cf64a099ed883e66841de4404e0029ca790860d18caaf717581", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "4cb9cbf983aca8d06a6d1877876de51d", "candidate_priority_rank": 340, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b52cf14dcda254c8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b52cf14dcda254c8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b52cf14dcda254c8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b52cf14dcda254c8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dog<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dog", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dog<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2394322", "image_sha256": "a5349a8f081a7db59ad2f9b29ff7d7759397e8c621bc3bbe0e561f24783635a3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2394322.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2394322.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2323719", "image_sha256": "63819838f4f4564cab421910c9ae896654a10b14476e71955dad1abf234fff92", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2323719.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2323719.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b52cf14dcda254c8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dog", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dog", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["alarm clock", "bed", "blanket", "comforter", "dog", "eyes", "face", "headboard", "lamp", "nose", "paw", "pillow", "post", "wall"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "018379a36fbc4a353ad0b61adc5076e4a816534943fd8690a21f208a3626fa7b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2cbabe2c0fd21daabc4c215cffd5f52dd6919a444b7ba97b10e2a53ab851adbb"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "041055894", "text": "What piece of furniture is the dog lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bedspread", "cell phone", "clothes", "comforter", "fingers", "hand", "head", "lamp", "man", "pants", "wall"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "018379a36fbc4a353ad0b61adc5076e4a816534943fd8690a21f208a3626fa7b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d8c81f79136bbab9a433eff76f1e8d5b1902990ba9066a577bdf1e1520147fee"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05134334", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 340, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0f49a2bfc8312224f5cb90591ca1075457c00c687e4177630b2a73757a4e96e9", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "05134334", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What piece of furniture is the man lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what piece of furniture is the lying on?", "program_group_hash": "0f49a2bfc8312224f5cb90591ca1075457c00c687e4177630b2a73757a4e96e9", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what piece of furniture is the lying on?", "program_group_hash": "0f49a2bfc8312224f5cb90591ca1075457c00c687e4177630b2a73757a4e96e9", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the bed.", "question": "What piece of furniture is the dog lying on?", "question_id": "041055894", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (465236)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o (465237)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The man is lying on the bed.", "question": "What piece of furniture is the man lying on?", "question_id": "05134334", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (3141243)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o (3277945)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["465237"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "465237", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "465237", "relation_subject_entity_id": "465236", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "465236", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["465236"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3277945"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "3277945", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "3277945", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3141243", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3141243", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3141243"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:4cb9cbf983aca8d06a6d1877876de51d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "a5349a8f081a7db59ad2f9b29ff7d7759397e8c621bc3bbe0e561f24783635a3", "image_sha256_b": "63819838f4f4564cab421910c9ae896654a10b14476e71955dad1abf234fff92", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "b6475a811ec45ec07ecb4cf659eac6820b99adc3d4355c6f8836cb38e4128309", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ea6b821a6b4a33f8a3b64079d56c60c8", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "4bb34e9a8a89f04a6259e99cd38515267ea0d7435c9d7abb9dadc4202b38a88a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0cf9e2fa751282f4657a1bb31d93d3a5d82d79525f725603713579670cbcb304", "request_id": "a950653d24384869d2cf3072d8f277ed", "response_sha256": "ea4ce5735cd94cef1e30910e7bfedb9159c69002a0999d5e0df26e53187cc278", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f70d04b0ec3fb8fbc93a52ce53c6a9097ffa6957c6866a86473fdb235eeb9b87", "request_id": "ac07c1764de783f8188738e0fcff244f", "response_sha256": "bd10f0cc7d5ea85587f366c5bc733f042456ca15cae6a0aaa213c1c6f105267f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a16a6c5afa3456e6d3819b1b9f09abd9", "candidate_priority_rank": 341, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-58f7250a321a6ada:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-58f7250a321a6ada:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-58f7250a321a6ada:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-58f7250a321a6ada:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "blanket<->grass", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "grass", "B": "blanket"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "grass<->blanket", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2369384", "image_sha256": "755d0482121d82509398c072cf1fb36ebd06357c042f7e5c01ecdc9e58a28b7e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369384.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369384.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2357733", "image_sha256": "802f4dd85fd18b2973523226748665d93162c0b59aff24d29a508a3118df0dcc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2357733.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2357733.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-58f7250a321a6ada", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "grass", "diff_b": "blanket", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "grass", "component_b": "blanket"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["elephants", "field", "grass", "trees"], "detected_components": ["grass"], "masked_program_sha256": "d18bc6a59880581553ee839c411185c25653de32e9517cdaa9c9a4cf2e6e6c68", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "grass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b8450425b382e5c7a6492478a8b601a3ba500707e077569aee618a29f7965da3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "051033787", "text": "What animal is the grass covering?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "cat", "ears", "eyes", "legs", "mouth", "nose", "paw", "pillow"], "detected_components": ["blanket"], "masked_program_sha256": "d18bc6a59880581553ee839c411185c25653de32e9517cdaa9c9a4cf2e6e6c68", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "blanket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["blanket", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3470cd57fe7820ed2e2335fdb842b96c6eb36e2d5c5ac4011c51315782edd861"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11536004", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 341, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "cf16388ec0df6663f5628b194e961031de4712110ceeb3c5d3bdb4af29a3fba9", "selected_component": "blanket", "selected_source_question_id": "11536004", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is the blanket covering?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covering,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is the covering?", "program_group_hash": "cf16388ec0df6663f5628b194e961031de4712110ceeb3c5d3bdb4af29a3fba9", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "covering", "select_category": "grass"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covering,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is the covering?", "program_group_hash": "cf16388ec0df6663f5628b194e961031de4712110ceeb3c5d3bdb4af29a3fba9", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "covering", "select_category": "blanket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "elephants", "full_answer": "The grass is covering the elephants.", "question": "What animal is the grass covering?", "question_id": "051033787", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (611853)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covering,o (611851)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The blanket is covering the cat.", "question": "What animal is the blanket covering?", "question_id": "11536004", "semantic": [{"argument": "blanket (809263)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covering,o (809262)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["611851"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "covering", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "large", "wild"], "query_target_entity_id": "611851", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "611851", "relation_subject_entity_id": "611853", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "611853", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["611853"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["809262"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "covering", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "809262", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "809262", "relation_subject_entity_id": "809263", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "809263", "selected_entity_name": "blanket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "blanket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["809263"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a16a6c5afa3456e6d3819b1b9f09abd9", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "755d0482121d82509398c072cf1fb36ebd06357c042f7e5c01ecdc9e58a28b7e", "image_sha256_b": "802f4dd85fd18b2973523226748665d93162c0b59aff24d29a508a3118df0dcc", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "95f8a50a2a425d651e9d7a3489c7e6a98e78bc4c859d0c0be0b476a2f932e47f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b738266db6783dadfb2739be66389aa1", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7f9fc51812e187fce847123ea96fc5989d15d83e0853218a853daa02098a4a9a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "2661039401c84a0e45e3503f7de50a9bd408f9e8c4a5a176b9912c45af7a29a1", "request_id": "88817614b55bc887a93e0d58d949c5bd", "response_sha256": "2c845aad21a1793b25222439dff77a8127e1bfd9a8ae515156be36e520bfbf57", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9015ee26aec2fb636710a006ac3da2ac005a65ff23c1a08a1f200c6810cf927b", "request_id": "c50b24a9bad8d3166e8437773a7d5389", "response_sha256": "0d8880aade50876941b7f0f8546488b70da17ea23292528eb9924e0d1676f70c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "53d5e67a4ed17b7da68b1e19877db9ba", "candidate_priority_rank": 357, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1b89d898a13a1f93:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1b89d898a13a1f93:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1b89d898a13a1f93:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1b89d898a13a1f93:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "paper<->picture", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "picture", "B": "paper"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "picture<->paper", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2414455", "image_sha256": "ac78df91c09a89e8568416f4b9a66a1a8e1f9c4f3bcdeb47fcb1fcec0d4f9736", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2414455.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2414455.jpg", "width": 333}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2331602", "image_sha256": "27fdc40f9ddd4b6e086b9d259505741a3add5d5268b4da7cb0e63900c879406a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2331602.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2331602.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1b89d898a13a1f93", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "picture", "diff_b": "paper", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "picture", "component_b": "paper"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["apron", "bottle", "cake", "cap", "cross", "decoration", "face", "flower", "hands", "leaf", "napkin", "number", "picture", "plate", "shoes", "wall"], "detected_components": ["picture"], "masked_program_sha256": "5e900ba6caa0c76205ec386bfbf9d95d2d827fb522f8f86eecd0160ae1a4aa6d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["picture", "dessert"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "picture", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["picture", "dessert"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "40538d5f9c8c861e4f47635add27e5b969d4968b119f732b205932693529f5ae"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13285126", "text": "What kind of dessert is the picture on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["burner", "cake", "cream", "eye", "frosting", "gas stove", "pan", "paper", "sprinkles"], "detected_components": ["paper"], "masked_program_sha256": "5e900ba6caa0c76205ec386bfbf9d95d2d827fb522f8f86eecd0160ae1a4aa6d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "dessert"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "paper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "dessert"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c5bb2d964f02bbb2f3efb38b55187ce90c62f42051286f676c30e501b98c7005"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14883266", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 357, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0ddf78b701a5338d11c247351ae7cb2c7626c4530a66a8c006d434a9ffd592c6", "selected_component": "paper", "selected_source_question_id": "14883266", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of dessert is the paper on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dessert,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of dessert is the on?", "program_group_hash": "0ddf78b701a5338d11c247351ae7cb2c7626c4530a66a8c006d434a9ffd592c6", "queried_category": "dessert", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "picture"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dessert,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of dessert is the on?", "program_group_hash": "0ddf78b701a5338d11c247351ae7cb2c7626c4530a66a8c006d434a9ffd592c6", "queried_category": "dessert", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "paper"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cake", "full_answer": "The picture is on the cake.", "question": "What kind of dessert is the picture on?", "question_id": "13285126", "semantic": [{"argument": "picture (295121)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dessert,on,o (295118)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cake", "full_answer": "The paper is on the cake.", "question": "What kind of dessert is the paper on?", "question_id": "14883266", "semantic": [{"argument": "paper (3114553)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "dessert,on,o (3479355)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["295118"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cake"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "295118", "query_target_entity_name": "cake", "relation_object_entity_id": "295118", "relation_subject_entity_id": "295121", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "295121", "selected_entity_name": "picture"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "picture", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["295121"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "picture", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3479355"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cake"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["frosted", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "3479355", "query_target_entity_name": "cake", "relation_object_entity_id": "3479355", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3114553", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3114553", "selected_entity_name": "paper"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3114553"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:53d5e67a4ed17b7da68b1e19877db9ba", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ac78df91c09a89e8568416f4b9a66a1a8e1f9c4f3bcdeb47fcb1fcec0d4f9736", "image_sha256_b": "27fdc40f9ddd4b6e086b9d259505741a3add5d5268b4da7cb0e63900c879406a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c2413505349cca9a9e96131ad0435e6377c0e24360d979434b00e6be31ba32d9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "99a589bb5f97d0c6383d0afab20d688d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "195eb7dcaeb89284cfd61dddded2215e37f36561b2bf90d80ee75129c6dcda3a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "55c662efe5f8f7868896fadbd84c302cf6f82d07ad1d89bd303ac6f44d46e46f", "request_id": "5b101b5ceb5f2fc6db1fddaddb17517c", "response_sha256": "00c9313c7c5c121dd044933d76b31a88247dd476cc70a248427eca3880e78f83", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fa11ed7b3d2acab48fea4e766da6e4f60a54956b43bee5e8a2f921086cb17648", "request_id": "16aafd3102712f964698251c58dffea3", "response_sha256": "0eb95cdc66562a608cb960cac957dfadc1ea94e725ab351c8b0f957bcb7986dd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "255cb8d16c1d850d37f8d5a21c1a0e6b", "candidate_priority_rank": 360, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d4b9f54262eacad0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d4b9f54262eacad0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d4b9f54262eacad0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d4b9f54262eacad0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dog<->giraffe", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "giraffe", "B": "dog"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "giraffe<->dog", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2318591", "image_sha256": "f642469a6df0f7b1a3882171df4bfbc8d4a917398c1cc6c45277182b05c49550", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2318591.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2318591.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 336, "image_id": "2383524", "image_sha256": "cdcdb3e5b70a0afe1ce4234a20628be071deb4d2bec81d7e1b10f4bfed8f0fd1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2383524.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2383524.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d4b9f54262eacad0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "giraffe", "diff_b": "dog", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "giraffe", "component_b": "dog"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "face", "fence", "giraffe", "hair", "head", "horn", "leaves", "mouth", "neck", "nose", "pole", "skin"], "detected_components": ["giraffe"], "masked_program_sha256": "16a57b392b4ff2d34143060ad1594328d5eaa22c84834c1ca82beee2c4ef747e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "giraffe", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "245712abfed3553250b8550cf6ad39e7bdb41f7be796d2013fe6755c6b3e61e3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16846330", "text": "What is the giraffe chewing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["dog", "ear", "eye", "face", "floor", "fur", "head", "mouth", "nose", "paw", "tag", "toy"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "16a57b392b4ff2d34143060ad1594328d5eaa22c84834c1ca82beee2c4ef747e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b2dfd400834c14faa44e6b08470096eef827594432cc1a61bb74b626460e5965"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "151058263", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 360, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "fdbce93612b1a959adc2d441b17e871f59f1d341ac4914f30572eec5188eeb78", "selected_component": "dog", "selected_source_question_id": "151058263", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the dog chewing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,chewing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the chewing?", "program_group_hash": "fdbce93612b1a959adc2d441b17e871f59f1d341ac4914f30572eec5188eeb78", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "chewing", "select_category": "giraffe"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,chewing,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the chewing?", "program_group_hash": "fdbce93612b1a959adc2d441b17e871f59f1d341ac4914f30572eec5188eeb78", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "chewing", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "fence", "full_answer": "The giraffe is chewing the fence.", "question": "What is the giraffe chewing?", "question_id": "16846330", "semantic": [{"argument": "giraffe (1009262)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,chewing,o (1009263)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "toy", "full_answer": "The dog is chewing the toy.", "question": "What is the dog chewing?", "question_id": "151058263", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (532117)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,chewing,o (532114)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1009263", "1009264", "1009265", "1009267", "1009268", "1009269", "1009270", "1009271", "1009272", "1009273", "1009274", "1009275", "1009282", "1009283", "1009284", "1009286", "1009288"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 17, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fence"], "predicate": "chewing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["metal", "silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "1009263", "query_target_entity_name": "fence", "relation_object_entity_id": "1009263", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1009262", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1009262", "selected_entity_name": "giraffe"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1009262"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["532114", "532118", "532119", "532120", "532121", "532122", "532124", "532125", "532126", "532127", "532128", "532129", "532130", "532131"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["toy"], "predicate": "chewing", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "hairy", "stuffed"], "query_target_entity_id": "532114", "query_target_entity_name": "toy", "relation_object_entity_id": "532114", "relation_subject_entity_id": "532117", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "532117", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["532117"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:255cb8d16c1d850d37f8d5a21c1a0e6b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f642469a6df0f7b1a3882171df4bfbc8d4a917398c1cc6c45277182b05c49550", "image_sha256_b": "cdcdb3e5b70a0afe1ce4234a20628be071deb4d2bec81d7e1b10f4bfed8f0fd1", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7ab531946bef2c39e9cfe239567b3d67b56e18959b61f53b36148e33e2892a2a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "82a322ef940cce6bc3983947614ad0e3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f0f4d5495bca732a46397e8792a4aa83dc431d18c2fe42116233e740c711a28e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5785b296fdbfcceb7d8b91ef31314115aefa3ffd04c23f393117c4b6e9a3971c", "request_id": "03d29af0dc8021542e7a894e61f44e4e", "response_sha256": "3aaa02d5f9c48f3b34f5887e8bcf911cd8bf582eafbe2fa9d8db54b03f9f24d7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c344a0d3e06f0f156b036fcfda21397c1995ee39c6b4eb36717c8ca51ec3208a", "request_id": "3a8d027f2b154fcefdd0753f6e517e2e", "response_sha256": "99ab5d2c8c805277206b932bffbe3cc39dcc1cdd0e2fc663d9fc7a5a213ee8e2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "91bea12767938ef64cde5f0b44b348b1", "candidate_priority_rank": 375, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50fb5afade5c72cf:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50fb5afade5c72cf:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50fb5afade5c72cf:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50fb5afade5c72cf:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->girl", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "girl", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "girl<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 400, "image_id": "2381811", "image_sha256": "71a54874d69029a5af326d2c4c8cbdddd441f0fe3150c4e703fb96e77f584cb2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2381811.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2381811.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2413428", "image_sha256": "04043cde3120660fe1f9454f3816fc028cd03065d228657a682c31010d097a8b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2413428.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2413428.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50fb5afade5c72cf", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "girl", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "girl", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["books", "bookshelf", "bottle", "can", "clock", "control panel", "countertop", "door", "girl", "glove", "hair", "kitchen", "microwave", "oven", "shirt"], "detected_components": ["girl"], "masked_program_sha256": "90ed3ed50f90f1495897bb45594a6232b06dc54b6aa3ace0925fb09054ffb38e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "girl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "df30a1d75fefd13f20c9305057c5be00108387aabf131fc804ca5ff4cc5943d5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "16161985", "text": "What is the girl looking in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bathtub", "bell", "bottle", "cap", "cat", "collar", "curtain", "floor", "foot", "pipe", "tail", "toilet", "toilet lid", "toilet seat", "wall"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "90ed3ed50f90f1495897bb45594a6232b06dc54b6aa3ace0925fb09054ffb38e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0bfacf9d01ca9d77fa035c2004f76f1120cc539afb667a5d67791d97c9c7200d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06711439", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 375, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "3cf44c18743aa9412304042c9885e8972f80b8400e2e6de316afd64271e1a24e", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "06711439", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the cat looking in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the looking in?", "program_group_hash": "3cf44c18743aa9412304042c9885e8972f80b8400e2e6de316afd64271e1a24e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking in", "select_category": "girl"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the looking in?", "program_group_hash": "3cf44c18743aa9412304042c9885e8972f80b8400e2e6de316afd64271e1a24e", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking in", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "oven", "full_answer": "The girl is looking in the oven.", "question": "What is the girl looking in?", "question_id": "16161985", "semantic": [{"argument": "girl (1333839)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking in,o (1333850)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "toilet", "full_answer": "The cat is looking in the toilet.", "question": "What is the cat looking in?", "question_id": "06711439", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (173748)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,looking in,o (173749)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1333838", "1333840", "1333841", "1333845", "1333846", "1333848", "1333849", "1333850", "1333855", "1333856", "1333857", "1333859", "1333860", "1333861"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["oven"], "predicate": "looking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["open"], "query_target_entity_id": "1333850", "query_target_entity_name": "oven", "relation_object_entity_id": "1333850", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1333839", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1333839", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1333839"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["173745", "173746", "173749", "173752", "173753", "173755", "173757", "173758", "173759", "173760", "173761", "173764", "173765", "173766", "173767", "173768"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["toilet"], "predicate": "looking in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["open", "shiny", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "173749", "query_target_entity_name": "toilet", "relation_object_entity_id": "173749", "relation_subject_entity_id": "173748", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "173748", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["173748"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:91bea12767938ef64cde5f0b44b348b1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "71a54874d69029a5af326d2c4c8cbdddd441f0fe3150c4e703fb96e77f584cb2", "image_sha256_b": "04043cde3120660fe1f9454f3816fc028cd03065d228657a682c31010d097a8b", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a7455d84fde704bde1f83ea600a881822292e429c36ff7be623df13adf9bdc08", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ac648082bd623ad0aa22c17a1cfc7df4", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e4bd0a4cd97325a9099daaf60a7d217e8da794f85e28344624f36dd20abc9d3e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0ae6db8ccaa7f0c22dbb8957c208df87370c81c1b2ebbb04c17b1929839cbf05", "request_id": "986f0948db881961d20d9ac1ce044574", "response_sha256": "6efda771e0c69c701394e095d0e2a7f296b9d5c22a68fbfc89441b6af5c44366", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "233a1f24eb436fb7a0ff14f8e614e13ebf9930b72887a2284810e53fea609a13", "request_id": "4dd3e58c5281e3a419a2ad15a15d7932", "response_sha256": "96274e4df5c6dc936e2afb08626a34be602b6ee0fb6bca0b3c81ecc90742e856", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "54c49cf5a6823ff5e0939636affa2af1", "candidate_priority_rank": 380, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91877f9ceae58c17:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91877f9ceae58c17:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91877f9ceae58c17:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91877f9ceae58c17:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "baby<->child", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "baby", "B": "child"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "baby<->child", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2373101", "image_sha256": "745791d6a4576c12ddb48702c4402f92681dd7f93e96f24fa32639d6322ceb00", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2373101.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2373101.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2364005", "image_sha256": "b47dd565a0a30a4d857d3db38c4c9a6c226720f3d6969df7ea37ee64385f62a8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364005.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364005.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-91877f9ceae58c17", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "baby", "diff_b": "child", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "baby", "component_b": "child"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["animals", "arm", "baby", "bed", "blanket", "doll", "floor", "foot", "hair", "head", "legs", "pillows", "toy", "wall"], "detected_components": ["baby"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4f6bf09d9fd9680ba6724c4211d5fb88c9e96ec74ffbd1ce95733a25fa3e3e6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "baby", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "19b9211e7e19256898625069673f5014b7b4c80bc2e6186016d8990235194139"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08209982", "text": "What is this baby sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["broccoli", "cap", "chair", "chicken", "child", "eye", "floor", "food", "hair", "neck", "plate", "shirt", "stuffed dog", "table", "tray"], "detected_components": ["child"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4f6bf09d9fd9680ba6724c4211d5fb88c9e96ec74ffbd1ce95733a25fa3e3e6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["child"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "child", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["child"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "51d2e7b0038d1311f37b5426fd3db3725eb09cc0a2273ec099ffb840bac3f639"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17126064", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 380, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4e2bcf764f875c6e1185f017215386725a6d3d6c085940bfc349665e45f0c680", "selected_component": "child", "selected_source_question_id": "17126064", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this child sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "4e2bcf764f875c6e1185f017215386725a6d3d6c085940bfc349665e45f0c680", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "baby"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "4e2bcf764f875c6e1185f017215386725a6d3d6c085940bfc349665e45f0c680", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "child"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The baby is sitting on the bed.", "question": "What is this baby sitting on?", "question_id": "08209982", "semantic": [{"argument": "baby (1919441)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (1717230)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The child is sitting on the chair.", "question": "What is this child sitting on?", "question_id": "17126064", "semantic": [{"argument": "child (2768005)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (3299186)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1711611", "1717230", "1765139", "1781542", "1838545", "1884821", "1964255", "2026230", "2027070", "2027071", "3532984", "3729382", "3729383", "3729385", "3851772", "3851773"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1717230", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "1717230", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1919441", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1919441", "selected_entity_name": "baby"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1919441"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "child", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1660789", "1822773", "1955193", "1999865", "1999866", "2059951", "2220732", "2499137", "2595769", "2623479", "2768006", "3094369", "3094370", "3112806", "3299186", "3464306", "3741999", "3742003"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 18, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["high"], "query_target_entity_id": "3299186", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "3299186", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2768005", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2768005", "selected_entity_name": "child"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "child", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2768005"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:54c49cf5a6823ff5e0939636affa2af1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "745791d6a4576c12ddb48702c4402f92681dd7f93e96f24fa32639d6322ceb00", "image_sha256_b": "b47dd565a0a30a4d857d3db38c4c9a6c226720f3d6969df7ea37ee64385f62a8", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c8e03e98babd7d1ee89e4391add783945f4533d81dafe160e1c7ac479c976293", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "7460e403c84f80ccae432854c043771f", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "64f3e886c85b607565e6370296113a5bd94c244ee902f5248d41eddf259cd820"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e6e9d519eb34ec64a93aa758060d88b86c30bba8334e4b2a2d11b6ef76429ee9", "request_id": "a671779dd40fc6281b7adebd7d79deb0", "response_sha256": "ffd852e1dd2b37cb80fb11990a0d15717092cc12d376c08111ddaa5331bd105a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "727190dab4326fcca31f984e5c7f72e439b63c19dd9ac4e57a366cca21bd93eb", "request_id": "857ddbcd43aaa6327aa41c163f01e9a9", "response_sha256": "d10b07d917c3fd91a3058fc7aeaa857e3388a2de6df3b01d7d0089a90d00f3d7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "32424b76185326916eefb2abedab31e6", "candidate_priority_rank": 387, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-abbe1141603b2885:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-abbe1141603b2885:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-abbe1141603b2885:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-abbe1141603b2885:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "child<->girl", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "child", "B": "girl"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "child<->girl", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2355417", "image_sha256": "cdab9c720e61ce35cee504cf02f047b427c0ff857055c3c01cc3ad68da29f354", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2355417.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2355417.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2358282", "image_sha256": "dfbe391f2d35075c7f00484235a4b55a47f50779921c192e8d665fe71007dd91", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2358282.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2358282.jpg", "width": 332}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-abbe1141603b2885", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "child", "diff_b": "girl", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "child", "component_b": "girl"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "child", "floor", "guitar", "jeans", "pants", "suitcase", "wall", "wheel", "window"], "detected_components": ["child"], "masked_program_sha256": "36e69910b1be9cb28cec9947a4f48e88c86600cdd616d59a4ae27a5f6c2d11c7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["child"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "child", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["child"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "745ee786bee981331bba2d6469fa0ed17a492382c7a3b123e7ac19bd1c63188d"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13583081", "text": "What is the child dragging?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boots", "coat", "girl", "goggles", "ground", "hair", "hill", "hillside", "pants", "skis", "snow"], "detected_components": ["girl"], "masked_program_sha256": "36e69910b1be9cb28cec9947a4f48e88c86600cdd616d59a4ae27a5f6c2d11c7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "girl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f0a4bd2584ab28e58c6a012cc6dd69a38aa0af7c681832d4bb15304e945bd1f7"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17323771", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 387, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "7bebaec6d04c4291f19df61b8e5d4d555a56f7c3a4579492e3687a0b70b2f032", "selected_component": "girl", "selected_source_question_id": "17323771", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the girl dragging?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,dragging,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the dragging?", "program_group_hash": "7bebaec6d04c4291f19df61b8e5d4d555a56f7c3a4579492e3687a0b70b2f032", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "dragging", "select_category": "child"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,dragging,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the dragging?", "program_group_hash": "7bebaec6d04c4291f19df61b8e5d4d555a56f7c3a4579492e3687a0b70b2f032", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "dragging", "select_category": "girl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "suitcase", "full_answer": "The kid is dragging the suitcase.", "question": "What is the child dragging?", "question_id": "13583081", "semantic": [{"argument": "child (829731)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,dragging,o (829732)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "skis", "full_answer": "The girl is dragging the skis.", "question": "What is the girl dragging?", "question_id": "17323771", "semantic": [{"argument": "girl (2664326)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,dragging,o (2664328)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["829732", "829734", "829735", "829737", "829740", "829741", "829742", "829745", "829747", "829748", "829750", "829751"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["suitcase"], "predicate": "dragging", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "829732", "query_target_entity_name": "suitcase", "relation_object_entity_id": "829732", "relation_subject_entity_id": "829731", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "829731", "selected_entity_name": "child"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "child", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["829731"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "child", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1709091", "1857249", "1875310", "1953677", "2080304", "2099481", "2267002", "2272615", "2300260", "2568176", "2568177", "2568178", "2568179", "2664328", "3893371"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["skis"], "predicate": "dragging", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2664328", "query_target_entity_name": "skis", "relation_object_entity_id": "2664328", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2664326", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2664326", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2664326"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:32424b76185326916eefb2abedab31e6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "cdab9c720e61ce35cee504cf02f047b427c0ff857055c3c01cc3ad68da29f354", "image_sha256_b": "dfbe391f2d35075c7f00484235a4b55a47f50779921c192e8d665fe71007dd91", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "86d25bb768a5f2d9e1b1dba9b5ad0697164a6bd141a9589f80562a029be8304f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "77fdf4c169c2153d03e866201a43672b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "665d3d37906d7fa3f66260e7f7bf3abf00ccc0395904b78e6fc6cbf95d393baa"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "32649f0eaf1b7b4c88688b2fc25b8da15703653c2ba4690c8286918df423d339", "request_id": "349fc95268f325145a9362a03f59ace8", "response_sha256": "01c86fa7bfd10918b27697a6894f3a1bdb0dfe236fdbac807f13da4680937c8c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "30feb94c1968bffb8475026faab53b2b971319fc027d45c31dc49cf9b9c917d3", "request_id": "0bac6b7df9b8c5a3b20f1e056252ba27", "response_sha256": "b9de7e3f278395cc05c9451d47f16d8877a3598201c5746ad7e0476fc2230ac6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ebcddec1527408ec43af5bc4b721fe26", "candidate_priority_rank": 391, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62815493ee983dfd:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62815493ee983dfd:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62815493ee983dfd:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62815493ee983dfd:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->dog", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dog", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dog<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2371691", "image_sha256": "e8a0288213b0680f7992db71201cce75a44133d8d724c1f7e4ecd92137f91721", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371691.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371691.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2347638", "image_sha256": "f918861335a60b559f51755a448ca6c88856a8923e8cf3e3ede8f733419aed1d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2347638.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2347638.jpg", "width": 332}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-62815493ee983dfd", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dog", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dog", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "camera", "chair", "dog", "drawer", "ear", "floor", "nose", "paw", "shoe", "sock"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2f9250faacbf85372099b4385b460dba3e780530c7e1626d69b54ba87e5a1a5a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13977739", "text": "What kind of furniture is this dog on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bed", "bottle", "cat", "clothes", "ear", "eye", "frame", "head", "logo", "man", "mirror", "nose", "picture", "pillow", "pump", "sheet", "tail", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "157c2f108cf8e86a74d6033b1df0c7049a5eb3304a0df1f1d63c97a7b8ec9ecb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4308fedb7147015cfa9e80467b292732c3073c0bbbf452cfcc1c50ac25b7ae37"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13969540", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 391, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "02b454038976962bacb0824c1f6a60949257315f8069374377e2f8fe211fe081", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "13969540", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of furniture is this cat on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture is this on?", "program_group_hash": "02b454038976962bacb0824c1f6a60949257315f8069374377e2f8fe211fe081", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture is this on?", "program_group_hash": "02b454038976962bacb0824c1f6a60949257315f8069374377e2f8fe211fe081", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "chair", "full_answer": "The dog is on the chair.", "question": "What kind of furniture is this dog on?", "question_id": "13977739", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (596286)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (596291)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The cat is on the bed.", "question": "What kind of furniture is this cat on?", "question_id": "13969540", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (888979)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,on,o (888980)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["596291", "596298", "596300"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["chair"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "596291", "query_target_entity_name": "chair", "relation_object_entity_id": "596291", "relation_subject_entity_id": "596286", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "596286", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["596286"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["888980"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "888980", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "888980", "relation_subject_entity_id": "888979", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "888979", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["888979"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ebcddec1527408ec43af5bc4b721fe26", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e8a0288213b0680f7992db71201cce75a44133d8d724c1f7e4ecd92137f91721", "image_sha256_b": "f918861335a60b559f51755a448ca6c88856a8923e8cf3e3ede8f733419aed1d", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0eb9919dae0c75ef1f6b2a4058ab3ab08d2dd0e735561f1f52d053987beca860", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "77b86af18d786348cf0526c0095f7bf7", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3b3e5df85a0e0f7ac47ded17da40d972f7cbfcb3f52db25e2eb3b114b8d51014"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a26e9bbc3c14c1a594dfdcb5f83e908867c3f9d5443703b34384f7518053702a", "request_id": "e4efbac62de37b1e69fdfa0c5bc45fee", "response_sha256": "89532409b0e718e169a2717a388cf4fff7d955696327a9bbaef05085ffc95748", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4b8db179d9c6378c264d407da99f0b04facb8cad5ebb65006b3eac7d166313cb", "request_id": "47330b90abece99199719b93f96c880d", "response_sha256": "544fa63a0d967861439c77c2e963ad269461842c08aaca6ec7139a77eae9d92d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a0ac84707e93d23637cc2556896c8b56", "candidate_priority_rank": 401, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-835fe0c1854bc502:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-835fe0c1854bc502:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-835fe0c1854bc502:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-835fe0c1854bc502:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "ceiling<->computer", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "computer", "B": "ceiling"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "computer<->ceiling", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2376123", "image_sha256": "065c4416e9115aaf23bee74b35d71f539c22e01abae13ddcbd2d39a4f01ec073", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376123.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376123.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 425, "image_id": "2319609", "image_sha256": "17da63faefcf0be6dc2d5bd7baa50b09c7a03145874b3d12316a75f3ccb06ad3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2319609.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2319609.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-835fe0c1854bc502", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "computer", "diff_b": "ceiling", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "computer", "component_b": "ceiling"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["carpet", "cat", "computer", "cord", "ear", "floor", "ground", "keyboard", "lid", "paw", "pen", "toy"], "detected_components": ["computer"], "masked_program_sha256": "1185ecb357ab99898936dcda6862efd1955f63ba9d9e06dfa8b721110806c7f2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["computer", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "computer", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["computer", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "468ea4c0986a9deb50df17f7ad945893ea09ad1883405933b8d83d4754e62538"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07103637", "text": "What animal is touching the computer?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ceiling", "ear", "eye", "giraffe", "head", "mouth", "neck", "nose", "tongue"], "detected_components": ["ceiling"], "masked_program_sha256": "1185ecb357ab99898936dcda6862efd1955f63ba9d9e06dfa8b721110806c7f2", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ceiling", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ceiling", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ceiling", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0e3c09f5ab54dafb076cbdf2f6e3860cdd67c3c0b07ecdb11cdb6bd71eb6edd5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01421042", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 401, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4ba210f58209172079d0831b7efd63e52197ebd0c8c43e95a498835ef9a57b75", "selected_component": "ceiling", "selected_source_question_id": "01421042", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is touching the ceiling?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,touching,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is touching the ?", "program_group_hash": "4ba210f58209172079d0831b7efd63e52197ebd0c8c43e95a498835ef9a57b75", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "touching", "select_category": "computer"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,touching,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is touching the ?", "program_group_hash": "4ba210f58209172079d0831b7efd63e52197ebd0c8c43e95a498835ef9a57b75", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "touching", "select_category": "ceiling"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is touching the computer.", "question": "What animal is touching the computer?", "question_id": "07103637", "semantic": [{"argument": "computer (1984252)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,touching,s (1984251)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The giraffe is touching the ceiling.", "question": "What animal is touching the ceiling?", "question_id": "01421042", "semantic": [{"argument": "ceiling (1000325)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,touching,s (1000316)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1984251"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "touching", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "1984251", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1984252", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1984251", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1984252", "selected_entity_name": "computer"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "computer", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1984252"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ceiling", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "computer", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1000316"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "touching", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "indoors"], "query_target_entity_id": "1000316", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "1000325", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1000316", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1000325", "selected_entity_name": "ceiling"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ceiling", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1000325"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a0ac84707e93d23637cc2556896c8b56", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "065c4416e9115aaf23bee74b35d71f539c22e01abae13ddcbd2d39a4f01ec073", "image_sha256_b": "17da63faefcf0be6dc2d5bd7baa50b09c7a03145874b3d12316a75f3ccb06ad3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8040411749034dfaf5d8609d91e8f982e73c798fd2a087ae641b1d54c0c855a9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "88238162ea78ed1d44569fe24f9263e5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "13ba058db8d4246b9e5750996bdef731ee14cfd0ed715a6c612fdc1712171ba3"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "06e00d9ccca1e6a4dac98eeef99e82d4a168b4591719e19c4fd9af6f03a82636", "request_id": "7c48f4a32b8ed36e7df0ad21eb2a479f", "response_sha256": "510541aed1845af99ab831a47941345bbf68155f5f6fdb69fe019f2faddc0b13", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0b1ba73b94ee791bfe9d80da0a9caec8c4690c91dee70ee46e6ff8cfccb0859f", "request_id": "0398fe81b3d5bbc95f16b142d1c734f7", "response_sha256": "91af1d5ccc799227aec4bc0092d23c872a056217ac72cd69a068988aae21b60e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a6f4f5f44aa9a8ba45eb9dc7cf22345b", "candidate_priority_rank": 407, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ab1f773054868bf3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ab1f773054868bf3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ab1f773054868bf3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ab1f773054868bf3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->man", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "man", "B": "cat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "man<->cat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2404832", "image_sha256": "bed8c598188df5e010d77af52cfd0ec900a30def8f20e8c75277d555c7554554", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404832.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404832.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 301, "image_id": "2361243", "image_sha256": "aa62ea01749ef7d9000b748b78500ed203c77e7449f2fea5a25f70446add01b5", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2361243.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2361243.jpg", "width": 216}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-ab1f773054868bf3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "man", "diff_b": "cat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "man", "component_b": "cat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "bed", "books", "bookshelf", "box", "closet", "clothes", "door", "flip flops", "food", "foot", "leg", "man", "shoes", "shorts", "towel"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b56688f395a0fa9cf64cd1b19b65ab9f800dae14d8ea191a1179178051265d99"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11418984", "text": "What is that man lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "ear", "fish", "fur", "head", "logo", "paw", "screen", "tail", "television"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bf901d1085f531f834838da39d80ee2963b12cbf40c5623f24d289e6302ace3d"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12209138", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 407, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ccdd1ae41d0306e5d5fc3ab743c217f8cde48040e3e9e89abd2773791785bf78", "selected_component": "cat", "selected_source_question_id": "12209138", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is that cat lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is that lying on?", "program_group_hash": "ccdd1ae41d0306e5d5fc3ab743c217f8cde48040e3e9e89abd2773791785bf78", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "man"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is that lying on?", "program_group_hash": "ccdd1ae41d0306e5d5fc3ab743c217f8cde48040e3e9e89abd2773791785bf78", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "cat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The man is lying on the bed.", "question": "What is that man lying on?", "question_id": "11418984", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1112691)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (375704)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "television", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the television.", "question": "What is that cat lying on?", "question_id": "12209138", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (1724342)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (2681088)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1112692", "1112695", "1112697", "1112698", "1112699", "1112700", "1112701", "1112703", "1112704", "1112705", "1112714", "1112715", "1112716", "1112718", "375703", "375704"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 16, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "375704", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "375704", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1112691", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1112691", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1112691"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1724341", "1839817", "1962363", "2019722", "2445487", "2681088", "2701924", "3756044", "3756045", "3756046"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 10, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["television"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2681088", "query_target_entity_name": "television", "relation_object_entity_id": "2681088", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1724342", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1724342", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1724342"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a6f4f5f44aa9a8ba45eb9dc7cf22345b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "bed8c598188df5e010d77af52cfd0ec900a30def8f20e8c75277d555c7554554", "image_sha256_b": "aa62ea01749ef7d9000b748b78500ed203c77e7449f2fea5a25f70446add01b5", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "aaef1b385c20f5744eef9923fd845c408a3e9b580d5f7b5f45e2c03e333cbfdb", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "b311a23999cbc0b776cb30de259e5341", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5bfa1280c8cd9fdc7912304738bfcdbb69ca04c70f149625f66635658590f352"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "418025bc984188e0e4dd7b29702526d3ff46f3b8f6c61bd29e8de9b3b6574fef", "request_id": "e401e7094feae6ff02df911df09c1f4c", "response_sha256": "d0fbfb5dd48731b37951e90dea0200fee9547033a6fd1c853fe07505526d8d3a", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "180c857fe117104f71f4d252f8eb3e3f8a6a7723b832cd892b437b4f0e975952", "request_id": "64ae28e6162f19b8c06b7e5145694b94", "response_sha256": "2cb81df154ac3ffa43b68f393a66c3d9229f7323d75de9627c0a79573c6f2a2d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a3064401dd36ccf5cf46822d71dd726b", "candidate_priority_rank": 414, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2e7d6cc3f4a61b1b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2e7d6cc3f4a61b1b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2e7d6cc3f4a61b1b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2e7d6cc3f4a61b1b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "paper<->plate", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "plate", "B": "paper"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "plate<->paper", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2323014", "image_sha256": "5f52a0d94c8a9a0436e07af21107912cce10476ceed46f3c91c703b9f7aa5603", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2323014.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2323014.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2381250", "image_sha256": "730776bb4f626a3bea09b02e7ac19eb212f0bbbf7cb4c5f18f39ccacdd7a2b7c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2381250.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2381250.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-2e7d6cc3f4a61b1b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "plate", "diff_b": "paper", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "plate", "component_b": "paper"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["flowers", "fork", "pie", "plate", "platter", "table"], "detected_components": ["plate"], "masked_program_sha256": "69a253db9bd332a1412c7af840f0bd87c2cf96153ef2f4b31511afe1022d38b0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "baked good"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "plate", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["plate", "baked good"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "4ec9cae1c86c9d50f049f9a9d8e3abbe69754e35dbc4b645cc08e8b5d7cd5799"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "03231289", "text": "What type of baked good is on the plate?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bun", "corn", "hot dog", "paper", "parsley", "sauce", "tomatoes", "toppings"], "detected_components": ["paper"], "masked_program_sha256": "69a253db9bd332a1412c7af840f0bd87c2cf96153ef2f4b31511afe1022d38b0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "baked good"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "paper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "baked good"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ef2b1c370b46d28fa19a0a2c36c3c61239d7c9946f896b57528a820a0e5aa805"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18181569", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 414, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 12, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "359f11a0b3e114264bfecf2649fc993ac477d1de5b281e33045906405e5c636e", "selected_component": "paper", "selected_source_question_id": "18181569", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of baked good is on the paper?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of baked good is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "359f11a0b3e114264bfecf2649fc993ac477d1de5b281e33045906405e5c636e", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "plate"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of baked good is on the ?", "program_group_hash": "359f11a0b3e114264bfecf2649fc993ac477d1de5b281e33045906405e5c636e", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on", "select_category": "paper"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pie", "full_answer": "The food is a pie.", "question": "What type of baked good is on the plate?", "question_id": "03231289", "semantic": [{"argument": "plate (3240722)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s (3365417)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bun", "full_answer": "The food is a bun.", "question": "What type of baked good is on the paper?", "question_id": "18181569", "semantic": [{"argument": "paper (705954)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,on,s (705952)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3365417"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pie"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3365417", "query_target_entity_name": "pie", "relation_object_entity_id": "3240722", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3365417", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3240722", "selected_entity_name": "plate"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plate", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3240722"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "plate", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["705952"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bun"], "predicate": "on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "705952", "query_target_entity_name": "bun", "relation_object_entity_id": "705954", "relation_subject_entity_id": "705952", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "705954", "selected_entity_name": "paper"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["705954"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a3064401dd36ccf5cf46822d71dd726b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5f52a0d94c8a9a0436e07af21107912cce10476ceed46f3c91c703b9f7aa5603", "image_sha256_b": "730776bb4f626a3bea09b02e7ac19eb212f0bbbf7cb4c5f18f39ccacdd7a2b7c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "ecacce78c867277ea14f06714520915eb5493755736889d5679378dcd60f39d5", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "176fe12662bbf0c435da51b0dead6d89", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d1afcfaef372c29d68a97d625e250a386aedd4831fb64402a436e98ec069a671"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "544848752bdb185563c669b1405258c0c53b4f91e3989c5838d0673088f6b6fb", "request_id": "eef9e7c3603be4d610ab3c1f1209e297", "response_sha256": "8f5b8fbf2391e1fc7ad35cf4180eae0eb6a02432e53ee275258c34eecb123849", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "45932d026e600f5823d2cd08b5d3429178f909947cc6e5f57f2f1b4c2cde88f9", "request_id": "78bc340056151da5be006572b1a2aa1a", "response_sha256": "1a589b81d0ed82630e189d945384b6982fff44e5f51493eb5b6d141dfb593cb9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "84d2d514aa89481402052f848a34bc32", "candidate_priority_rank": 419, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9eb46fdea0379e6:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9eb46fdea0379e6:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9eb46fdea0379e6:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9eb46fdea0379e6:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "paper<->sandwich", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "sandwich", "B": "paper"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "sandwich<->paper", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 288, "image_id": "2350905", "image_sha256": "72eafd553a6f2849d07862c49622ff4ab40a6086998ad20ddeaf212844e76c2f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2350905.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2350905.jpg", "width": 432}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2401525", "image_sha256": "fd28bd0635d0ace38842a321d87eed228a237cd80ee5e3d726d3c2de1d55fa1a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2401525.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2401525.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-f9eb46fdea0379e6", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "sandwich", "diff_b": "paper", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "sandwich", "component_b": "paper"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bread", "man", "meat", "sandwich", "table", "tie"], "detected_components": ["sandwich"], "masked_program_sha256": "dd7b7a058dd8169084d15f32c8e6f5e6ffeee58af7567c88c9423e42eeed91f4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sandwich", "baked good"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sandwich", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sandwich", "baked good"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "43e0c8fa211b622275f76ab07db6683fe581fb4726217133c371655179b53715"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "19629113", "text": "What type of baked good is on top of the sandwich?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cup", "donut", "paper", "person", "road", "thumb"], "detected_components": ["paper"], "masked_program_sha256": "dd7b7a058dd8169084d15f32c8e6f5e6ffeee58af7567c88c9423e42eeed91f4", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "baked good"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "paper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "baked good"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e86e297a2e654ffda337f66e13775bd41f63bb4856fd4efcfc934fad6aa7d4f5"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "001050337", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 419, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "38f4a535c58e2ef756f942ae06a4b36c43fb6d7226bfa2edb231a284c6369387", "selected_component": "paper", "selected_source_question_id": "001050337", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of baked good is on top of the paper?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of baked good is on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "38f4a535c58e2ef756f942ae06a4b36c43fb6d7226bfa2edb231a284c6369387", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "sandwich"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of baked good is on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "38f4a535c58e2ef756f942ae06a4b36c43fb6d7226bfa2edb231a284c6369387", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "on top of", "select_category": "paper"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bread", "full_answer": "The food is a bread.", "question": "What type of baked good is on top of the sandwich?", "question_id": "19629113", "semantic": [{"argument": "sandwich (864501)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,on top of,s (864510)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "donut", "full_answer": "The food is a donut.", "question": "What type of baked good is on top of the paper?", "question_id": "001050337", "semantic": [{"argument": "paper (1146913)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,on top of,s (1146911)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["864510", "864511"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bread"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["white"], "query_target_entity_id": "864510", "query_target_entity_name": "bread", "relation_object_entity_id": "864501", "relation_subject_entity_id": "864510", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "864501", "selected_entity_name": "sandwich"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sandwich", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["864501"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sandwich", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1146911"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["donut"], "predicate": "on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "frosted", "glazed", "round"], "query_target_entity_id": "1146911", "query_target_entity_name": "donut", "relation_object_entity_id": "1146913", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1146911", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1146913", "selected_entity_name": "paper"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1146913"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:84d2d514aa89481402052f848a34bc32", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "72eafd553a6f2849d07862c49622ff4ab40a6086998ad20ddeaf212844e76c2f", "image_sha256_b": "fd28bd0635d0ace38842a321d87eed228a237cd80ee5e3d726d3c2de1d55fa1a", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "f81bd0af8e068705c89363f3a2a994b94319f1f768af9d423ab1ec719a0beff0", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "29c75bf331575a0b6fae9ffeaeccfad4", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "dc93ad25040bada80938d4a7d7d8619c15ac1110072c025873b93cf4c6643285"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "328e3ef534334bd99d5aefcd81438a628ca8c9d3f57acfefb4203793bb5e9402", "request_id": "a58748abe559fd4c26a23ba6cc510e74", "response_sha256": "dffded4b535bbf1d2ab7d5a540d75d8909a17fb676100b3977db8faf91beb301", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1f36fa47a32edcb5fe6e858b06288b022ef2fce715d83b0915e6a7bdd0579f8d", "request_id": "6f5d2ed4c571ced4dccc94ad22501b59", "response_sha256": "b0b51f140b1786aaa2e031e899904ace2f767ad594501469eaca6a09a5dff980", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "c80b98949249471d1a84030bf91f770a", "candidate_priority_rank": 422, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-71312068d2dc1f1e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-71312068d2dc1f1e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-71312068d2dc1f1e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-71312068d2dc1f1e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->girl", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cat", "B": "girl"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cat<->girl", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2379821", "image_sha256": "63d922d66a8bd4155fa49df84db14077f574adc0b33044ff48493a4b453ff6f1", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2379821.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2379821.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2353456", "image_sha256": "9e59695e7679bcccc3b920e8823d3b86eeeead33b8c81dc2e4f21d218d19bed2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2353456.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2353456.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-71312068d2dc1f1e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cat", "diff_b": "girl", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cat", "component_b": "girl"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "ear", "figure", "foot", "head", "keypad", "laptop", "leg", "screen", "table", "touchpad"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "1a2f12cbaf96801ffa17ab2cbfeeb19003c672ab4156c0b2bbd398487550c3e1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "34faa2b5ecc838924df28afbcb6160af3dd7bfe06d02ec6ac29e7ddd44deffe4"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "07722969", "text": "What kind of device is the cat looking at?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["computer", "computer mouse", "couch", "girl", "hair", "keyboard", "logo", "person", "shirt", "shoe"], "detected_components": ["girl"], "masked_program_sha256": "1a2f12cbaf96801ffa17ab2cbfeeb19003c672ab4156c0b2bbd398487550c3e1", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "device"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "girl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["girl", "device"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "bb10ded67a54bb6ee10e8b5e7243d971a969a3c4dcf02325d1453986ffb573f6"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10220727", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 422, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 14, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "1334520afb1bc9a4b0f7e76042bb92ab09a856d10280513512eea6e1aae47930", "selected_component": "girl", "selected_source_question_id": "10220727", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of device is the girl looking at?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,looking at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of device is the looking at?", "program_group_hash": "1334520afb1bc9a4b0f7e76042bb92ab09a856d10280513512eea6e1aae47930", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking at", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,looking at,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of device is the looking at?", "program_group_hash": "1334520afb1bc9a4b0f7e76042bb92ab09a856d10280513512eea6e1aae47930", "queried_category": "device", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "looking at", "select_category": "girl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "laptop", "full_answer": "The cat is looking at the laptop computer.", "question": "What kind of device is the cat looking at?", "question_id": "07722969", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (550082)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,looking at,o (550080)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "computer", "full_answer": "The girl is looking at the computer.", "question": "What kind of device is the girl looking at?", "question_id": "10220727", "semantic": [{"argument": "girl (845828)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "device,looking at,o (845829)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["550080", "550090"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["laptop"], "predicate": "looking at", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "on", "open"], "query_target_entity_id": "550080", "query_target_entity_name": "laptop", "relation_object_entity_id": "550080", "relation_subject_entity_id": "550082", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "550082", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["550082"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["845829", "845835", "845844"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["computer"], "predicate": "looking at", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "845829", "query_target_entity_name": "computer", "relation_object_entity_id": "845829", "relation_subject_entity_id": "845828", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "845828", "selected_entity_name": "girl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "girl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["845828"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c80b98949249471d1a84030bf91f770a", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "63d922d66a8bd4155fa49df84db14077f574adc0b33044ff48493a4b453ff6f1", "image_sha256_b": "9e59695e7679bcccc3b920e8823d3b86eeeead33b8c81dc2e4f21d218d19bed2", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "6327a1e0f105b930f7ae5e135ed22727b59467e37d88f9cfec6f965c0e0fe8c3", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3f8e7e4dd1954740072be4832ff0b9af", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "2558a64f57313874533c34d0f7de74e4289fcab1eb0710f3bb6f31dbd36f774d"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "863e95ef7527192bb8ed0e3c3c3180e06dcf1374efb444187266ac56095bc445", "request_id": "a603b3918fa354843a1bf7577830bc44", "response_sha256": "2ee925a1b1eceaf05a0735b010997d3ca566f8cbb99b7b67c791b6046687ccfb", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "19e0ce567289de6b48555765d56ffc2946edfa25d133e8e50bf9c6742f7136a9", "request_id": "7c7aa421aecf86150a3e7338c4db8d47", "response_sha256": "36d542a771e57b0c0df79879ab033947cfe5f05d08695e6c46220347df90a6fa", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "632136bc876545ac794d58fd8afbc9a6", "candidate_priority_rank": 423, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-28a7034ad29d979e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-28a7034ad29d979e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-28a7034ad29d979e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-28a7034ad29d979e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 368, "image_id": "2393593", "image_sha256": "0ad94ddb8abd4d5dbc8e95a2ebaf463d70d4e32bb1631ea11cbe60eb7a222692", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2393593.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2393593.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2348976", "image_sha256": "91fb8e2f984a241cecd33306dce7c801209f68ba1f8ff90c7979fda5c4778630", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2348976.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2348976.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-28a7034ad29d979e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["hair", "letters", "man", "nose", "pants", "ring", "shirt", "sign", "teddy bear", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "c64d2b51acd98d594be9b4b43328a2aa76d8f33ea5b5d2a06f58fb53ca6d02f0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8e2f58562a97f084029e88abd7747044374fe012c50463046130212036d896cc"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "131049293", "text": "What toy is the woman holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bottle", "cigarette", "cup", "glasses", "hand", "logo", "man", "shirt", "straw", "stuffed animal", "table", "tag", "television", "wall", "watch", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "c64d2b51acd98d594be9b4b43328a2aa76d8f33ea5b5d2a06f58fb53ca6d02f0", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ba312e6e3748a24ea92d762897f451dc62d52f1be795c36982e8c1be28b2e375"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12394643", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 423, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0d032e6c54cc937b5d16a09448ecc3a820cebe168067b51a1e524f5de6a6f2cd", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "12394643", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What toy is the man holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what toy is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "0d032e6c54cc937b5d16a09448ecc3a820cebe168067b51a1e524f5de6a6f2cd", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what toy is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "0d032e6c54cc937b5d16a09448ecc3a820cebe168067b51a1e524f5de6a6f2cd", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "teddy bear", "full_answer": "The woman is holding the teddy bear.", "question": "What toy is the woman holding?", "question_id": "131049293", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (471346)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,holding,o (471347)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stuffed animal", "full_answer": "The man is holding the stuffed animal.", "question": "What toy is the man holding?", "question_id": "12394643", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (2683695)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,holding,o (3601970)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["471347"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["teddy bear"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "huge"], "query_target_entity_id": "471347", "query_target_entity_name": "teddy bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "471347", "relation_subject_entity_id": "471346", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "471346", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["471346"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["471347"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["471352"], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3601970"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stuffed animal"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3601970", "query_target_entity_name": "stuffed animal", "relation_object_entity_id": "3601970", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2683695", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2683695", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2683695"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:632136bc876545ac794d58fd8afbc9a6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "0ad94ddb8abd4d5dbc8e95a2ebaf463d70d4e32bb1631ea11cbe60eb7a222692", "image_sha256_b": "91fb8e2f984a241cecd33306dce7c801209f68ba1f8ff90c7979fda5c4778630", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "cd32537bcba062d8e1f0ffe195b8736303207e5b0649efbb517232d091903974", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "cd84edb7ff5803ccdfcc649669e2b784", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d043001059c0fe0505d04228df161398b04f9c21d529981163e266bebd325ba1"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3702b10abe51ac446c4fa88adbb95e114e730dd8c4d9bac951cc6667475e0986", "request_id": "37fd8e74e7d04347fd603648f71ca6d8", "response_sha256": "432cf1445a59666df2a77a4dd2d3199e34ebeaae7ea758347159067239319719", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1c4016a09f496cf7beb5c823c58213f353f89d654b8502013a12acbf5bc1161e", "request_id": "2bfde32e50713646d2f6f916a251ab58", "response_sha256": "2565b44fb595dbd9414503a7a0d7d07ad0e2e3f626a169736605fcf2c578f9c8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "9d070f73ba952cc47c52fc2087e955ab", "candidate_priority_rank": 436, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-045d2e3bf2844bd3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-045d2e3bf2844bd3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-045d2e3bf2844bd3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-045d2e3bf2844bd3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "motorcycle<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "motorcycle"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->motorcycle", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2396590", "image_sha256": "cbc39255ca3a54cf6ab402c5029045030b630a7f86a6c0253c534f211298ac4d", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396590.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396590.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2382027", "image_sha256": "e0e854b4c03e50ae82954899f96bf74e22cc540b07678214dce7488abdcd82c6", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2382027.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2382027.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-045d2e3bf2844bd3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "motorcycle", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "motorcycle"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arrow", "battery", "building", "car", "clock", "heels", "legs", "windows", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "c50480a1d262d238b2062ba1b80068a91be181210aeb45a12c8de880564a4a1d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "5dd7b9a0378e66b66de6c7e7d3b5fedf8e20b6fddfe464934941d852d930db19"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0716666", "text": "What is the vehicle that the woman is in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["building", "fence", "girl", "grass", "ground", "hair", "logo", "motorcycle", "pants", "plate", "seat", "shoe", "sky", "sweater", "tank top", "trailer", "tree", "wall", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["motorcycle"], "masked_program_sha256": "c50480a1d262d238b2062ba1b80068a91be181210aeb45a12c8de880564a4a1d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["motorcycle", "vehicle"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "motorcycle", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["motorcycle", "vehicle"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0231add386ba859a5df04a56a57f09f16f2e2d026a4d99302be9cfc55a940c0a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "11740371", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 436, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 9, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "60188d793fd6db32db20d6fe1c248417e5ca4a8275316721a59033aa630ab232", "selected_component": "motorcycle", "selected_source_question_id": "11740371", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the vehicle that the motorcycle is in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vehicle that the is in?", "program_group_hash": "60188d793fd6db32db20d6fe1c248417e5ca4a8275316721a59033aa630ab232", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the vehicle that the is in?", "program_group_hash": "60188d793fd6db32db20d6fe1c248417e5ca4a8275316721a59033aa630ab232", "queried_category": "vehicle", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "motorcycle"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a car.", "question": "What is the vehicle that the woman is in?", "question_id": "0716666", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (1196694)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o (1196695)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "trailer", "full_answer": "The vehicle is a trailer.", "question": "What is the vehicle that the motorcycle is in?", "question_id": "11740371", "semantic": [{"argument": "motorcycle (1331921)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "vehicle,in,o (3831906)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1196695"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1196695", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "1196695", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1196694", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1196694", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1196694"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "motorcycle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3831906"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["trailer"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["silver"], "query_target_entity_id": "3831906", "query_target_entity_name": "trailer", "relation_object_entity_id": "3831906", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1331921", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1331921", "selected_entity_name": "motorcycle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "motorcycle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1331921"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:9d070f73ba952cc47c52fc2087e955ab", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "cbc39255ca3a54cf6ab402c5029045030b630a7f86a6c0253c534f211298ac4d", "image_sha256_b": "e0e854b4c03e50ae82954899f96bf74e22cc540b07678214dce7488abdcd82c6", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "20d5d827a3c765136d867b9d6bbe7fca9f5ba8054e85b36886351693a66e26ac", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a4e3b01b73242adf617b86d5a568d1dc", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3f2b193588c7cdbdd27763f5f0c742d1e866b0a0a758bbc9fbb62289e00e9f43"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "194a4b04ba0028d25bb13ff17c3bfc1eeb138f0f2c69f48ba4a0b5d3c3890c19", "request_id": "8f72839786fcd3aa5e785b48c19b96ad", "response_sha256": "dd95504f9b2811c624149ec76a606c5e9d38a5c33371b3c7e4c311d1dfb60c2c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7819882efc1b888fec88cfb7591b9adc06dc9d085f9324f8394ae11425de3dac", "request_id": "8a9935571abc5c9f243ca032216f67fb", "response_sha256": "179646aec83537ea7ded420f936a04734b426c833762a6a7ebf306177fdafa07", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "f86f1a13d297c1c5772f5a041dc4726d", "candidate_priority_rank": 442, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c65a9567a4f251e4:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c65a9567a4f251e4:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c65a9567a4f251e4:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c65a9567a4f251e4:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "paper<->sweater", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "paper", "B": "sweater"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "paper<->sweater", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 335, "image_id": "2416814", "image_sha256": "f781b2f6aab78c977ddd322fb859c79b7ca182fc8f2ac1cc623711f4e5ab5722", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2416814.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2416814.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2377461", "image_sha256": "d3c0a53f58777f33b97d1f549a3e2e4fa1f90fae468a6b028095cf307d0bf3cc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2377461.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2377461.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c65a9567a4f251e4", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "paper", "diff_b": "sweater", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "paper", "component_b": "sweater"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "cord", "eye", "head", "paper", "tail", "window"], "detected_components": ["paper"], "masked_program_sha256": "883d3e02afa92e18010e6b533480931f2d8b31caf3a8a41fd0bc9d637ab3519b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "paper", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["paper", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "12048ece16b5d987b1e05486b9a00a140b1410daf2a9e55de4585bd63638458c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18989999", "text": "What type of animal is lying on the paper?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["books", "bottle", "cat", "ear", "ears", "eye", "floor", "ground", "hard drive", "laptop", "nose", "sweater", "table"], "detected_components": ["sweater"], "masked_program_sha256": "883d3e02afa92e18010e6b533480931f2d8b31caf3a8a41fd0bc9d637ab3519b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sweater", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sweater", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sweater", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "313f9698b1ee8e6e0dd029f5c93413f7718bf99e938a1d4aef12c78310feecfc"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "01430562", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 442, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "6ca35c159c1ec3869153c3e118c5c530771b48865f1a6c39dc9a97e118655fb8", "selected_component": "sweater", "selected_source_question_id": "01430562", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What type of animal is lying on the sweater?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is lying on the ?", "program_group_hash": "6ca35c159c1ec3869153c3e118c5c530771b48865f1a6c39dc9a97e118655fb8", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "paper"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what type of animal is lying on the ?", "program_group_hash": "6ca35c159c1ec3869153c3e118c5c530771b48865f1a6c39dc9a97e118655fb8", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "sweater"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What type of animal is lying on the paper?", "question_id": "18989999", "semantic": [{"argument": "paper (2707617)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (3421393)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What type of animal is lying on the sweater?", "question_id": "01430562", "semantic": [{"argument": "sweater (2058021)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,lying on,s (3838246)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3421393"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3421393", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "2707617", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3421393", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2707617", "selected_entity_name": "paper"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2707617"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sweater", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "paper", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3838246"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "3838246", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "2058021", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3838246", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2058021", "selected_entity_name": "sweater"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sweater", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2058021"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f86f1a13d297c1c5772f5a041dc4726d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f781b2f6aab78c977ddd322fb859c79b7ca182fc8f2ac1cc623711f4e5ab5722", "image_sha256_b": "d3c0a53f58777f33b97d1f549a3e2e4fa1f90fae468a6b028095cf307d0bf3cc", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "71147a8d4ff00039f7e8e2492db3258438719ed66a8ab48bc472c01e71a4ae36", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "73486dd9243fcba7257aff904aeca897", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "9e33ef631d35ad66feb29aba46d82eb632849acfc91e22a1a69bb4df32a0328f"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0dc22ed4a98b6ebb2a830f43f17d8bfdfa4a3f3ea1f6b5d371def1c3e726862d", "request_id": "000b28f9166da3445f8dcb9747636b9a", "response_sha256": "7d234f5b2e962b972dbd5881e8bd22fdcf53726788b82338331938a7334520ac", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "519ada44b9e60d2ed66f964a20dff828c78f17afd8b949b7fd094321ded11d82", "request_id": "0df64edacd004195889db1f7c622e31d", "response_sha256": "8b454a12c9bdf54c2e8b7150c15fdd756c23df5bf91dcfa6461a23504c721615", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a138125beda6dc5f0849566cdae4091f", "candidate_priority_rank": 455, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1202cd556ff189a9:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1202cd556ff189a9:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1202cd556ff189a9:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1202cd556ff189a9:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "field<->sink", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "field", "B": "sink"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "field<->sink", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2395278", "image_sha256": "12404c673d22ebdf7a6efe4c46b51a60b93c5506fda05d8f976700af3f96f452", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395278.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395278.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 353, "image_id": "2345064", "image_sha256": "3a83bec6717eb7bb0cfe3fcd245c8f9492fc7eaf33c1ed9ae33f11c72fb3af5c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345064.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345064.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1202cd556ff189a9", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "field", "diff_b": "sink", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "field", "component_b": "sink"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cow", "ear", "eyes", "field", "forest", "hair", "leg", "nose", "tag", "tree"], "detected_components": ["field"], "masked_program_sha256": "31acbb96c046e590112aa306b800153ed97226286f69ac8fe20c0f1faa9b68cb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "field", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["field", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "01238e158f9e46e238e16112940810b7f760b272a257f6631c7cea51b73d799f"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09913319", "text": "What color is the animal in the field?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "counter", "faucet", "label", "mug", "nose", "paw", "sink", "soap", "tail", "toothbrush"], "detected_components": ["sink"], "masked_program_sha256": "31acbb96c046e590112aa306b800153ed97226286f69ac8fe20c0f1faa9b68cb", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sink", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sink", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "75522160ee7bd5da4c632e0836fc9786a979891ecd2e253f003da8cfdec772ce"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07174543", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 455, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4b353e811b41688e289ceb08195e29296d2e0e841e46b444c7ac121407f4aa91", "selected_component": "sink", "selected_source_question_id": "07174543", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What color is the animal in the sink?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the animal in the ?", "program_group_hash": "4b353e811b41688e289ceb08195e29296d2e0e841e46b444c7ac121407f4aa91", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "field"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what color is the animal in the ?", "program_group_hash": "4b353e811b41688e289ceb08195e29296d2e0e841e46b444c7ac121407f4aa91", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "sink"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "brown", "full_answer": "The cow is brown.", "question": "What color is the animal in the field?", "question_id": "09913319", "semantic": [{"argument": "field (456289)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (456284)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "orange", "full_answer": "The cat is orange.", "question": "What color is the animal in the sink?", "question_id": "07174543", "semantic": [{"argument": "sink (910936)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in,s (910920)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["456284"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["brown", "large", "standing"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "large", "standing"], "query_target_entity_id": "456284", "query_target_entity_name": "cow", "relation_object_entity_id": "456289", "relation_subject_entity_id": "456284", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "456289", "selected_entity_name": "field"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["456289"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "field", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["910920"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["fluffy", "orange"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["fluffy", "orange"], "query_target_entity_id": "910920", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "910936", "relation_subject_entity_id": "910920", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "910936", "selected_entity_name": "sink"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sink", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["910936"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a138125beda6dc5f0849566cdae4091f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "12404c673d22ebdf7a6efe4c46b51a60b93c5506fda05d8f976700af3f96f452", "image_sha256_b": "3a83bec6717eb7bb0cfe3fcd245c8f9492fc7eaf33c1ed9ae33f11c72fb3af5c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "9fba87db27f23b8056c967185c45c0f9a8afb46da652714c7dc33070f46b043e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "90049165320b58f218edd0cf1e9c7890", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f1859a1ea0a313c62e5105fa02f04cbb6b2f8004c38fade197d699a747e54ae5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4e2cc9854bf9cc583880a8e4cfbdf6d16cb562b4ccb51a7cf5c5089c8851adb8", "request_id": "b0ce4f53d57d0d801e683d7b8de313a4", "response_sha256": "cac8cfd1411361214cbb104cf21823ac09c295db7e70cc720ebd6ca30e7e3158", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9a17ec8b110d21ce5b07e8c3e3d3cf04e289d57534797c41eb060abeeb788024", "request_id": "d0ebf39882d8f170d98e931869dd6fe2", "response_sha256": "aa18de7671bdd9b5f8ae112114431b8fd37156b00bccc3e975272b0bc876ecf8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "d72acde5aeabe2dbc6803785e3aec978", "candidate_priority_rank": 459, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6277d1e97c8b3be4:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6277d1e97c8b3be4:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6277d1e97c8b3be4:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6277d1e97c8b3be4:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "giraffe<->wall", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "wall", "B": "giraffe"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "wall<->giraffe", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2410643", "image_sha256": "7767ef95f70f1dfc4b9ecc569870f5fb023e559abf34367a093085d6d022b8dd", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2410643.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2410643.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2396510", "image_sha256": "3a1af73c8685e780e61a4e1f59a867d2bd9d8bb62f0e404fc7c9f294634c6def", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2396510.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2396510.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6277d1e97c8b3be4", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "wall", "diff_b": "giraffe", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "wall", "component_b": "giraffe"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "couch", "ear", "ears", "eye", "eyes", "fur", "hair", "hat", "head", "mouth", "nose", "picture", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["wall"], "masked_program_sha256": "de83293f6ed192fb66defd5fb0c5d160d7dc1ced1b4e5f04f3e1812959aa24f9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wall", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wall", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "459caaef45e0de96fda0a411a85557fc59f94c75adbce89aa0aeaf6ab68a3615"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00255055", "text": "What animal do you think is in front of the wall?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "giraffe", "grass", "hair", "leaves", "leg", "legs", "mound", "tail", "trees", "zebra", "zebras"], "detected_components": ["giraffe"], "masked_program_sha256": "de83293f6ed192fb66defd5fb0c5d160d7dc1ced1b4e5f04f3e1812959aa24f9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "giraffe", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["giraffe", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d823be683e0059d7d7a154ef307cf7b713bb66aa765e5cfc7044a35bd72f0620"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "171005511", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 459, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 11, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9ac37fb6653517a0ac600897db83c5d07e94147560d53aa3cda0b1752f1cd4f7", "selected_component": "giraffe", "selected_source_question_id": "171005511", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal do you think is in front of the giraffe?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal do you think is in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "9ac37fb6653517a0ac600897db83c5d07e94147560d53aa3cda0b1752f1cd4f7", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "wall"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal do you think is in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "9ac37fb6653517a0ac600897db83c5d07e94147560d53aa3cda0b1752f1cd4f7", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "giraffe"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is in front of the wall.", "question": "What animal do you think is in front of the wall?", "question_id": "00255055", "semantic": [{"argument": "wall (1619114)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (1619098)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "zebras", "full_answer": "The zebras are in front of the giraffe.", "question": "What animal do you think is in front of the giraffe?", "question_id": "171005511", "semantic": [{"argument": "giraffe (443527)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (443528)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1619098"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["angry", "black", "fancy", "sleepy", "small"], "query_target_entity_id": "1619098", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1619114", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1619098", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1619114", "selected_entity_name": "wall"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1619114"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wall", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["443528", "443535", "443554"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 3, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["zebras"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["grazing", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "443528", "query_target_entity_name": "zebras", "relation_object_entity_id": "443527", "relation_subject_entity_id": "443528", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "443527", "selected_entity_name": "giraffe"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "giraffe", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["443527"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:d72acde5aeabe2dbc6803785e3aec978", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "7767ef95f70f1dfc4b9ecc569870f5fb023e559abf34367a093085d6d022b8dd", "image_sha256_b": "3a1af73c8685e780e61a4e1f59a867d2bd9d8bb62f0e404fc7c9f294634c6def", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7793553d5741d33795ec232081ee72fa26bdc3d6a2d2fa5828326e3a93fda012", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "76b830347d24ced152c1d5300573d079", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b0c1843c595e68dfe9dd9d26bca2806a0ea1c234760932e000fd809e84ed2403"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "27b8d480c7da4f79283fa65c42c474c7cd7d147785f3a0002776ea6fe9c60198", "request_id": "9e427c11e5f02c27a12e9da73bb0880f", "response_sha256": "e3fe704d5dcfdd5b4237151d5b82880c7064b7d934c7837f678b81062e4371e9", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "f81841ee7e73ae001271734917a42f5adb0107cc6e9fed10eb7b1ed61bafefd5", "request_id": "8aff4e32fed16044b38bde62cf1b8315", "response_sha256": "73f48244f8780756af9bee2cc2c7af829d4794afa4bb816a5b1b0eefaa7ac798", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "1e916426a8ed54d2c7fab6964016d5d8", "candidate_priority_rank": 464, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1201a0fcf02cdcc8:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1201a0fcf02cdcc8:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1201a0fcf02cdcc8:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1201a0fcf02cdcc8:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "camera<->computer", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "computer", "B": "camera"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "computer<->camera", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 374, "image_id": "2399138", "image_sha256": "e0e4ba8778b19e7f3c0383fc55f19c95ffd66c9d8b2e3fff219fd734046cf597", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399138.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399138.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2398309", "image_sha256": "7fd7993f69f961e302912b1e0f3f632f59c598c36c1458b5d8461652a060b722", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2398309.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2398309.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1201a0fcf02cdcc8", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "computer", "diff_b": "camera", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "computer", "component_b": "camera"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["books", "cat", "computer", "dvds", "ear", "floor", "fur", "head", "keypad", "letters", "numbers", "paw", "screen", "shelf", "shoe", "table", "wii"], "detected_components": ["computer"], "masked_program_sha256": "74d449568575bb97759832ad2139159f9821f45d9856dc8c799eeab7fdea13ab", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["computer", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "computer", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["computer", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ba59aa6e70306ff89640acf8688214ab810c2d5fa761c99a5f942c9ac0d2bd0b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10661940", "text": "What animal is facing the computer?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["camera", "clouds", "ear", "ears", "eyes", "face", "grass", "head", "leaves", "mane", "nose", "sky", "trees", "zebra"], "detected_components": ["camera"], "masked_program_sha256": "74d449568575bb97759832ad2139159f9821f45d9856dc8c799eeab7fdea13ab", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["camera", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "camera", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["camera", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "75f5c7e183802825c74ff5f365260558105baad8649aa4fb3c3937d6c157d087"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10325444", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 464, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e9eccbd7b9602f8af4fd1145498d2f5398056246df406333fc33eba90f22bc94", "selected_component": "camera", "selected_source_question_id": "10325444", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is facing the camera?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,facing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is facing the ?", "program_group_hash": "e9eccbd7b9602f8af4fd1145498d2f5398056246df406333fc33eba90f22bc94", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "facing", "select_category": "computer"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,facing,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is facing the ?", "program_group_hash": "e9eccbd7b9602f8af4fd1145498d2f5398056246df406333fc33eba90f22bc94", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "facing", "select_category": "camera"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is facing the computer.", "question": "What animal is facing the computer?", "question_id": "10661940", "semantic": [{"argument": "computer (418736)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,facing,s (418735)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "zebra", "full_answer": "The zebra is facing the camera.", "question": "What animal is facing the camera?", "question_id": "10325444", "semantic": [{"argument": "camera (426613)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,facing,s (426608)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["418735"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "facing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["calico", "colorful", "tan"], "query_target_entity_id": "418735", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "418736", "relation_subject_entity_id": "418735", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "418736", "selected_entity_name": "computer"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "computer", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["418736"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "camera", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "computer", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["426608"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["zebra"], "predicate": "facing", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "healthy", "large", "pretty", "standing", "striped"], "query_target_entity_id": "426608", "query_target_entity_name": "zebra", "relation_object_entity_id": "426613", "relation_subject_entity_id": "426608", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "426613", "selected_entity_name": "camera"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "camera", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["426613"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:1e916426a8ed54d2c7fab6964016d5d8", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "e0e4ba8778b19e7f3c0383fc55f19c95ffd66c9d8b2e3fff219fd734046cf597", "image_sha256_b": "7fd7993f69f961e302912b1e0f3f632f59c598c36c1458b5d8461652a060b722", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a91cf4ceb5a2fb7ffdb1aa22dd6f3bc88a004231fa6042749e5dec17b932ef1d", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "987b07d49b86c7ba292b88da668b971a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0d1078eed9c03da486c20f39f6f12dd0f568baad02ee226c4e262d78451efda5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "935f255eb7c083f9f1f8df129e94e132d48fe92d727a06928d1fc619f970653d", "request_id": "5ca1b6938de494f3cdd219772a244a8f", "response_sha256": "b41607b31d8a183dc6dbf58b14230e2ac5373debebe3a6436d4949f4958bf6f7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e99e6f442883ca6e487e44dfd206719f4cfc1e0ae96770a776f37ee9b4a7f2bb", "request_id": "e866c4a1b26edfff265c40a3e25ba767", "response_sha256": "96e8c86cccc4ffa24b4c057fce4ff47beba9b0922461b697bb384ace86afaddd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "e63b18daae2810fe041e685a4517137d", "candidate_priority_rank": 471, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19805ab845cf5380:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19805ab845cf5380:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19805ab845cf5380:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19805ab845cf5380:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "baby<->couple", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "baby", "B": "couple"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "baby<->couple", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2329006", "image_sha256": "d256a66f79aa0fad8cb7f0505931643e12f64f4c89d27dc16189fdd6334db348", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2329006.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2329006.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2328074", "image_sha256": "cee5dbab6ff543d71e9412dc9709a80baad9e7afaf8bbcc988b2bdc5132da430", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2328074.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2328074.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-19805ab845cf5380", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "baby", "diff_b": "couple", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "baby", "component_b": "couple"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "baby", "blanket", "book", "face", "floor", "flower", "hair", "hand", "head", "keyboard", "laptop", "monitor", "pillow", "screen", "shirt", "shorts", "table"], "detected_components": ["baby"], "masked_program_sha256": "0f9e1c27e2825d297978c2920647a0e9539cd14158261a406b66b2f2fe046b09", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "baby", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c9f507da524d2e662f02f8eac8a7d3ce2df05432d382340d406a165a7074f3ee"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "101047936", "text": "What is the baby sitting in front of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bench", "boat", "cap", "coat", "couple", "dock", "head", "man", "person", "sky", "water"], "detected_components": ["couple"], "masked_program_sha256": "0f9e1c27e2825d297978c2920647a0e9539cd14158261a406b66b2f2fe046b09", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["couple"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "couple", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["couple"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ab5e54af6855ba95edb290913c61451aa5313dd4ec8a3af3f0b56eb1cce9a543"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12616777", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 471, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "761a3491265d3dc54a69f145fbdc5964fcba1a73386e0e69b93ee9ca0d23d6fd", "selected_component": "couple", "selected_source_question_id": "12616777", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the couple sitting in front of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting in front of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the sitting in front of?", "program_group_hash": "761a3491265d3dc54a69f145fbdc5964fcba1a73386e0e69b93ee9ca0d23d6fd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting in front of", "select_category": "baby"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting in front of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the sitting in front of?", "program_group_hash": "761a3491265d3dc54a69f145fbdc5964fcba1a73386e0e69b93ee9ca0d23d6fd", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting in front of", "select_category": "couple"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "laptop", "full_answer": "The baby is sitting in front of the laptop.", "question": "What is the baby sitting in front of?", "question_id": "101047936", "semantic": [{"argument": "baby (4108284)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting in front of,o (4108275)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "water", "full_answer": "The couple is sitting in front of the water.", "question": "What is the couple sitting in front of?", "question_id": "12616777", "semantic": [{"argument": "couple (2784181)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting in front of,o (2764470)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4108275", "4108287", "4108298", "4108299", "4108308", "4108311", "4108319", "4108321", "4108326", "4108328", "4108329", "4108331", "4108336", "4108339", "4108343", "4108344", "4108345", "4108350", "4108352", "4676736", "4676761"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 21, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["laptop"], "predicate": "sitting in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4108275", "query_target_entity_name": "laptop", "relation_object_entity_id": "4108275", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4108284", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4108284", "selected_entity_name": "baby"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4108284"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "couple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2746636", "2764470", "2770278", "2770279", "2826721", "2856072", "3270940", "3394274", "3736655", "3736660", "3736661"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["water"], "predicate": "sitting in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2764470", "query_target_entity_name": "water", "relation_object_entity_id": "2764470", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2784181", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2784181", "selected_entity_name": "couple"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "couple", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2784181"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:e63b18daae2810fe041e685a4517137d", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d256a66f79aa0fad8cb7f0505931643e12f64f4c89d27dc16189fdd6334db348", "image_sha256_b": "cee5dbab6ff543d71e9412dc9709a80baad9e7afaf8bbcc988b2bdc5132da430", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "429d7232240ba50c4a97c0ed0e739c3127a523477efbc90311ad490aeaa62a3b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3f4d768196f5c8929a8cfab1f2b35c6d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "725b4410d548f12e0549b70e38b8ae26882bb593b4f6533fa3400e541899de58"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5dc5c7449dfaa5c15f5b8b3fad9f423484936b500bbad5f7d4868f5cb2ff6695", "request_id": "aa5ab533515f4d07039ccc781d2a42d6", "response_sha256": "f76fa159a07fc76084627bd3a559d07399ce01aeaa36acc80795da859fa03b39", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "985c363f5e30f31223c0bbb5b9cfa43933ef6504252dc04881c66473eb9135be", "request_id": "2743909cd674a5f57159a1aa1614acc4", "response_sha256": "8abaf1ca30b9304e6365a4c0eaf5f5492699dbbfa135ef91c9b9e67c47b71dec", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "0a3f4a8eff414b81cbdb03d70e78807b", "candidate_priority_rank": 489, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37e279ac4c017e0a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37e279ac4c017e0a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37e279ac4c017e0a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37e279ac4c017e0a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bread<->elephant", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bread", "B": "elephant"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bread<->elephant", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2319740", "image_sha256": "3f47355dbdbe323b564019846b15502ed9834154576ea96b4a08e22378ce8fe9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2319740.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2319740.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2391818", "image_sha256": "2a961c73db07ba26d7c0736a7962156930dd4fdfd93c267b3b8cdd34b2202114", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2391818.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2391818.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-37e279ac4c017e0a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bread", "diff_b": "elephant", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bread", "component_b": "elephant"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bread", "ham", "lettuce", "man", "motorcycle", "onion", "paper", "tomato"], "detected_components": ["bread"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bread", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "1f5e933c12af897fac087b13c4e525b72cc89bf20c4abadfc4063dd88cb7ff82"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0347551", "text": "What is this bread inside of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["elephant", "hat", "head", "man", "pants", "river", "shirt", "stick"], "detected_components": ["elephant"], "masked_program_sha256": "b70dcad61cf1d99c30484c87b564f836def562b38aff6a14b01341d49c2f436e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["elephant"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "elephant", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["elephant"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "14e4a2cf102752060ecbaddf0fcb44fc2a3ca4914bee37061a11a2f37692389c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14191128", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 489, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 10, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "selected_component": "elephant", "selected_source_question_id": "14191128", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this elephant inside of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this inside of?", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "bread"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this inside of?", "program_group_hash": "4f6ab4f775a8f8c5d92d1e2895990d6b321ce0eceb29ecd1c89a4a92f13eed75", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "elephant"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "paper", "full_answer": "The bread is inside the paper.", "question": "What is this bread inside of?", "question_id": "0347551", "semantic": [{"argument": "bread (999225)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (999228)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "river", "full_answer": "The elephant is inside the river.", "question": "What is this elephant inside of?", "question_id": "14191128", "semantic": [{"argument": "elephant (1237101)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,inside,o (1237102)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["999228", "999233", "999234", "999235", "999236", "999242", "999248"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["paper"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "999228", "query_target_entity_name": "paper", "relation_object_entity_id": "999228", "relation_subject_entity_id": "999225", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "999225", "selected_entity_name": "bread"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["999225"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "elephant", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1237100", "1237102", "1237103", "1237104", "1237106", "1237107", "1237108"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["river"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "calm", "rippled", "wavy", "wet"], "query_target_entity_id": "1237102", "query_target_entity_name": "river", "relation_object_entity_id": "1237102", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1237101", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1237101", "selected_entity_name": "elephant"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "elephant", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1237101"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0a3f4a8eff414b81cbdb03d70e78807b", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3f47355dbdbe323b564019846b15502ed9834154576ea96b4a08e22378ce8fe9", "image_sha256_b": "2a961c73db07ba26d7c0736a7962156930dd4fdfd93c267b3b8cdd34b2202114", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c7d3fdf40d7f4d04f8911e9359d2acd3e5ab10615392d9cb4f441486c96bb34c", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "8056c84b4ed8d943301722e8f9e29d48", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "556aea303beceac914faa22aaddfc9e7fe099f23e92ef501c17252587d9a38ad"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "97c3ec39ba06f72dbc84f0eb09cc7053fc0de007ceb44f32ef922990303ca90b", "request_id": "83345af97d4de92ce8ba51376fb6e620", "response_sha256": "8844184770ef10000304cce966878cf0f668c09eebcf89d24c1aab15eb68f4fd", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "03947481255d4e24d89f77a5057584b8da4b5fdef59684738e704758a13f0a2a", "request_id": "b2479e827cd7863ccf985a378de8e504", "response_sha256": "fbf19406cf92aa03677b363048dad62124d6aa4a919947ee0cfe4fb22e90c8ab", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "6f19826025b3a4ea8793c7b95def333e", "candidate_priority_rank": 490, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-780815d69a56df4a:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-780815d69a56df4a:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-780815d69a56df4a:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-780815d69a56df4a:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bread<->bun", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bun", "B": "bread"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bun<->bread", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 341, "image_id": "2371291", "image_sha256": "4fc5b151f315bdd02a81a5f431c500c2aae4f23b5fd06a5f45120ba629b60899", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2371291.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2371291.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2319740", "image_sha256": "3f47355dbdbe323b564019846b15502ed9834154576ea96b4a08e22378ce8fe9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2319740.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2319740.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-780815d69a56df4a", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bun", "diff_b": "bread", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bun", "component_b": "bread"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bun", "foil", "hand", "thumb", "toppings"], "detected_components": ["bun"], "masked_program_sha256": "ab6601254492056f1ac74c19c3ee2891a6856e1c4f0bd7c089b7fc9bc91ec63d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bun"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bun", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bun"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7f308290e5954e8c85bbeacefa9f1a33b03c320f0b57dfde3329a3cbb92deaa5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01374175", "text": "What is the bun wrapped in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bread", "ham", "lettuce", "man", "motorcycle", "onion", "paper", "tomato"], "detected_components": ["bread"], "masked_program_sha256": "ab6601254492056f1ac74c19c3ee2891a6856e1c4f0bd7c089b7fc9bc91ec63d", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bread", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bread"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "07f231f7073758956dc07ad74f97a512ca8c22e892b060bbdcf8c0d22b1530b8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "0347544", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 490, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8ed491b37c570823f8996199132838ab4f9d2d11ea0150b8b4466d3ae474a230", "selected_component": "bread", "selected_source_question_id": "0347544", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the bread wrapped in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the wrapped in?", "program_group_hash": "8ed491b37c570823f8996199132838ab4f9d2d11ea0150b8b4466d3ae474a230", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wrapped in", "select_category": "bun"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the wrapped in?", "program_group_hash": "8ed491b37c570823f8996199132838ab4f9d2d11ea0150b8b4466d3ae474a230", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "wrapped in", "select_category": "bread"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "foil", "full_answer": "The bun is wrapped in foil.", "question": "What is the bun wrapped in?", "question_id": "01374175", "semantic": [{"argument": "bun (3522876)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,o (2287698)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "paper", "full_answer": "The bread is wrapped in paper.", "question": "What is the bread wrapped in?", "question_id": "0347544", "semantic": [{"argument": "bread (999225)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,wrapped in,o (999228)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2287698", "2369115", "2487819", "3522872", "3522875"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 5, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["foil"], "predicate": "wrapped in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2287698", "query_target_entity_name": "foil", "relation_object_entity_id": "2287698", "relation_subject_entity_id": "3522876", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3522876", "selected_entity_name": "bun"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bun", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3522876"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bun", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["999228", "999233", "999234", "999235", "999236", "999242", "999248"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 7, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["paper"], "predicate": "wrapped in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "999228", "query_target_entity_name": "paper", "relation_object_entity_id": "999228", "relation_subject_entity_id": "999225", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "999225", "selected_entity_name": "bread"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["999225"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:6f19826025b3a4ea8793c7b95def333e", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4fc5b151f315bdd02a81a5f431c500c2aae4f23b5fd06a5f45120ba629b60899", "image_sha256_b": "3f47355dbdbe323b564019846b15502ed9834154576ea96b4a08e22378ce8fe9", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "6cff10186bbaa64415888a6fe82d09ce216a563c674bc6b3b799f01bc9cdccdf", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9f5bb7e938ce7f6a661fedcb9cc43a11", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "d93b370f7354552d8d908db84e67d38808c9e8ac40aa75139b61091fe1be05e2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ba4d61105f44a5bdb73890ab2c072509d0e8015bfe4bb11f9994245caf53d968", "request_id": "2ede9834a1d5c1c0928f5c8da0e942c1", "response_sha256": "fa2b65b598b14413a1c5f4676a783659647148d245ea7cf6774a336e97e85140", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "bfa9273df96a7ada13dce87ec6648ab1e446ee4022adb65dfd9a201ac890c4dd", "request_id": "ba60a477b6745752f8d235744f3a9921", "response_sha256": "63b7c3e370dd008fd9c52225b81bafd505772f8396071774889203433773ee59", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "0d2b1da2e72574d31a804bb783584991", "candidate_priority_rank": 514, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8b43f7ca038abb81:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8b43f7ca038abb81:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8b43f7ca038abb81:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8b43f7ca038abb81:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "fence<->forest", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "forest", "B": "fence"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "forest<->fence", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2318820", "image_sha256": "6a5d53c30e86846fa1ca241e1104ef134f1ffe4033f01b8faf6e6d97a98db9cc", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2318820.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2318820.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2388576", "image_sha256": "75bc9ed943d2d31d21063c1ac88ddfcdde218654bf84e1992a4ad818de005ac4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2388576.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2388576.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-8b43f7ca038abb81", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "forest", "diff_b": "fence", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "forest", "component_b": "fence"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bears", "ears", "face", "forest", "fur", "grass", "ground", "head", "paw"], "detected_components": ["forest"], "masked_program_sha256": "de83293f6ed192fb66defd5fb0c5d160d7dc1ced1b4e5f04f3e1812959aa24f9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["forest"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "forest", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["forest"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c2f5406317d92f1f3629982fa891680280d84947f2c3797d5ca98ec38274e0dd"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01243784", "text": "What are the animals in front of the forest?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "fence", "fur", "ground", "hair", "leaves", "pen", "tail", "tree", "zebra", "zebras", "zoo"], "detected_components": ["fence"], "masked_program_sha256": "de83293f6ed192fb66defd5fb0c5d160d7dc1ced1b4e5f04f3e1812959aa24f9", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "fence", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["fence"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "20b5245ad4db292a8c7ddf868bc50144c44d0ca511e654fc5b7224887ce1d884"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "06572258", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 514, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0495d0e7de88b511723a68c55157cccff71ac37d8303ebb130dffb8c08c2ba5d", "selected_component": "fence", "selected_source_question_id": "06572258", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What are the animals in front of the fence?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the animals in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "0495d0e7de88b511723a68c55157cccff71ac37d8303ebb130dffb8c08c2ba5d", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "forest"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what are the animals in front of the ?", "program_group_hash": "0495d0e7de88b511723a68c55157cccff71ac37d8303ebb130dffb8c08c2ba5d", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "fence"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bears", "full_answer": "The animals are bears.", "question": "What are the animals in front of the forest?", "question_id": "01243784", "semantic": [{"argument": "forest (1006801)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (1006797)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "zebras", "full_answer": "The animals are zebras.", "question": "What are the animals in front of the fence?", "question_id": "06572258", "semantic": [{"argument": "fence (672483)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,in front of,s (672481)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1006797"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bears"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["standing"], "query_target_entity_id": "1006797", "query_target_entity_name": "bears", "relation_object_entity_id": "1006801", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1006797", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1006801", "selected_entity_name": "forest"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "forest", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1006801"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "forest", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3829284", "672481"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["zebras"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "672481", "query_target_entity_name": "zebras", "relation_object_entity_id": "672483", "relation_subject_entity_id": "672481", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "672483", "selected_entity_name": "fence"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "fence", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["672483"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0d2b1da2e72574d31a804bb783584991", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6a5d53c30e86846fa1ca241e1104ef134f1ffe4033f01b8faf6e6d97a98db9cc", "image_sha256_b": "75bc9ed943d2d31d21063c1ac88ddfcdde218654bf84e1992a4ad818de005ac4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "2c2afa0f851aecb3450bfe236f8d9d13c7414eeee655a9988bf190911d57f267", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "71dcf33054349c93ad3314377737512e", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "98fc9539d6c548c25848c525c145bfc3bebbbbeb62d3da11db2f64296bab8ff9"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0ef824f1842704908924d53b5dbc9998e865349bc824ec29ad205c32ba7d8aa0", "request_id": "94bffff4b73b6f91be9cc13bd60b073d", "response_sha256": "91efeb6b27c710f6cf9d15f12a198b85d33bac73c08f381f4b998dfed12ce9db", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c471685385e38f190e9b3dbdd8b5e3abf807e1d2ce13bb3deff06fc8393cbb61", "request_id": "86c99e1eafdcfbf47d752c770fc70ce3", "response_sha256": "4eb13ce008c488a7f02f3f726e20614ddd48b6044bc0a1106f6f78cb9267b072", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "3c90cab3257f1ead0cd3d8b2ca48fa7f", "candidate_priority_rank": 517, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9f7b532f501aca57:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9f7b532f501aca57:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9f7b532f501aca57:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9f7b532f501aca57:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bike<->stuffed bear", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "stuffed bear", "B": "bike"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "stuffed bear<->bike", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2404913", "image_sha256": "804e4a876c669ed325f20bec90b33f3bc2606b0cdde3eb9b002bd7846dae11ae", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404913.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404913.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2384295", "image_sha256": "d0082b1c3a9260f77632ee7ff73ed3b9819cbc0ac43ab7017a1770ba78014e8f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384295.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384295.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "activity_state", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9f7b532f501aca57", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "stuffed bear", "diff_b": "bike", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "stuffed bear", "component_b": "bike"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "activity", "question_intent": "activity_state:activity", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "eyes", "hair", "leaves", "man", "nose", "paw", "shirt", "sign", "star", "stuffed bear", "tree"], "detected_components": ["stuffed bear"], "masked_program_sha256": "e03103f7ed194cc8efc0d2ab30585bc118e467f51d93f86cee537a443b5eb63b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["stuffed bear", "person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "stuffed bear", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["stuffed bear", "person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e94603cd9f39854f56d455be46cd65b7afeb7ced4b51d70ac090218a2003094c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "13797821", "text": "What is the person in front of the stuffed bear doing?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bike", "boy", "ear", "eye", "flag", "gate", "hair", "nose", "pants", "parking meter", "pole", "shirt", "shoe", "sidewalk", "wheel", "window"], "detected_components": ["bike"], "masked_program_sha256": "e03103f7ed194cc8efc0d2ab30585bc118e467f51d93f86cee537a443b5eb63b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bike", "person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bike", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bike", "person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f97404d1254a9d9ad8f7de07f423a3464de97cceab4cf83dd0fb026d3d1baf83"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "14361621", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 517, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b89a0eca8b1a6e554104105e91cd96a705cd0e8387180a2e6f77a8f5d4792af7", "selected_component": "bike", "selected_source_question_id": "14361621", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the person in front of the bike doing?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "activity", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person in front of the doing?", "program_group_hash": "b89a0eca8b1a6e554104105e91cd96a705cd0e8387180a2e6f77a8f5d4792af7", "queried_category": "person", "query_role": "activity", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "stuffed bear"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "activity_state", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,in front of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "activity", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the person in front of the doing?", "program_group_hash": "b89a0eca8b1a6e554104105e91cd96a705cd0e8387180a2e6f77a8f5d4792af7", "queried_category": "person", "query_role": "activity", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in front of", "select_category": "bike"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "posing", "full_answer": "The man is posing.", "question": "What is the person in front of the stuffed bear doing?", "question_id": "13797821", "semantic": [{"argument": "stuffed bear (336659)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,in front of,s (336658)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "activity", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "eating", "full_answer": "The boy is eating.", "question": "What is the person in front of the bike doing?", "question_id": "14361621", "semantic": [{"argument": "bike (1311260)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "person,in front of,s (1311261)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "activity", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["336658"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["posing"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["posing"], "query_target_entity_id": "336658", "query_target_entity_name": "man", "relation_object_entity_id": "336659", "relation_subject_entity_id": "336658", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "336659", "selected_entity_name": "stuffed bear"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stuffed bear", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["336659"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bike", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "stuffed bear", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1311261"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["eating"], "predicate": "in front of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["eating"], "query_target_entity_id": "1311261", "query_target_entity_name": "boy", "relation_object_entity_id": "1311260", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1311261", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1311260", "selected_entity_name": "bike"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bike", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1311260"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:3c90cab3257f1ead0cd3d8b2ca48fa7f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "804e4a876c669ed325f20bec90b33f3bc2606b0cdde3eb9b002bd7846dae11ae", "image_sha256_b": "d0082b1c3a9260f77632ee7ff73ed3b9819cbc0ac43ab7017a1770ba78014e8f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "49bef727a3d68c63bbd246c28bb46045189bb6a686011bc71f3d12787636bb6f", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "f47e2291ee282acc33f87621ec52d5b3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a07e30029e2fa237e4eff0d354576b5b92d99d3792f2fc79c389928e26eddf97"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e03ff38e2a5002e1b2be665768e0541e4f02a2ee4f5b9a9d3f255b3082d4f1df", "request_id": "c0e6e41bd8f023fc30d81aed8185fdfa", "response_sha256": "d69ee1512d05e3b1652d3de8d0718a994d8c23ada5b1f0a76b61a87d427d1319", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "6f6f0f03bee8eb73a4def074b9a193b8fd24a8a5ae0203dbcaf88157d37f9332", "request_id": "7294061efec852f199f4f59daa7211e4", "response_sha256": "74e92c6a195225293cbb96e60c56846cf80ac075a511b332a3623551c3481d7e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "7372f368be90243ec1e0f1d68c43580f", "candidate_priority_rank": 524, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e2036f01031693d0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e2036f01031693d0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e2036f01031693d0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e2036f01031693d0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "child<->train", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "child", "B": "train"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "child<->train", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2362874", "image_sha256": "368872d2f1eb283d3583d42fce6b9d693844313bd76aae306c5d0710e0e4a2a7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2362874.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2362874.jpg", "width": 378}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2369290", "image_sha256": "add7a9cd51841835b38b08683554c1fa10033e2c3734b4a1dabc4942de544440", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369290.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369290.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e2036f01031693d0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "child", "diff_b": "train", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "child", "component_b": "train"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "child", "flower", "foot", "hair", "pillow", "shirt", "wallpaper", "wire"], "detected_components": ["child"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4f6bf09d9fd9680ba6724c4211d5fb88c9e96ec74ffbd1ce95733a25fa3e3e6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["child"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "child", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["child"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "51d2e7b0038d1311f37b5426fd3db3725eb09cc0a2273ec099ffb840bac3f639"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10454210", "text": "What is this child sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["graffiti", "grass", "gravel", "leaves", "paint", "park", "steering wheel", "train", "tree", "tree trunk", "trees", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["train"], "masked_program_sha256": "c4f6bf09d9fd9680ba6724c4211d5fb88c9e96ec74ffbd1ce95733a25fa3e3e6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["train"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "train", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["train"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "621c471eb7ab0b9ecc05ef37473272762fe1225ae1b4dc072014428994a7fdd4"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "18104039", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 524, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 18, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "4e2bcf764f875c6e1185f017215386725a6d3d6c085940bfc349665e45f0c680", "selected_component": "train", "selected_source_question_id": "18104039", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is this train sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "4e2bcf764f875c6e1185f017215386725a6d3d6c085940bfc349665e45f0c680", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "child"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is this sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "4e2bcf764f875c6e1185f017215386725a6d3d6c085940bfc349665e45f0c680", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "train"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The child is sitting on the bed.", "question": "What is this child sitting on?", "question_id": "10454210", "semantic": [{"argument": "child (770382)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (770387)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "gravel", "full_answer": "The train is sitting on the gravel.", "question": "What is this train sitting on?", "question_id": "18104039", "semantic": [{"argument": "train (612579)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,sitting on,o (612597)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["770383", "770387", "770388", "770389", "770390", "770391", "770392", "770394"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 8, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["colorful", "pink"], "query_target_entity_id": "770387", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "770387", "relation_subject_entity_id": "770382", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "770382", "selected_entity_name": "child"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "child", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["770382"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "train", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "child", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["3864180", "612580", "612584", "612586", "612587", "612588", "612590", "612592", "612593", "612597", "612598", "612599"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["gravel"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "612597", "query_target_entity_name": "gravel", "relation_object_entity_id": "612597", "relation_subject_entity_id": "612579", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "612579", "selected_entity_name": "train"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "train", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["612579"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:7372f368be90243ec1e0f1d68c43580f", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "368872d2f1eb283d3583d42fce6b9d693844313bd76aae306c5d0710e0e4a2a7", "image_sha256_b": "add7a9cd51841835b38b08683554c1fa10033e2c3734b4a1dabc4942de544440", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "7553a275066324149a1630cd0b2370a5ce5aa5d3858e2a4961d3adcd08f509f8", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1a080583eafedd9160b5a5ddb361dc67", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e794af6cefc3eb67a92e53b53744a91a8597999dccafdb61e5ac0d99321d1bf5"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "7895d1995834146f45326c40a8b86d67ec7eecad407a83381e345d24d3b134b0", "request_id": "540f9bf3c4946de1fe99947e4b705450", "response_sha256": "d0f86a63797eba21c127c73de6c832d00ffde935aff07d067c789531708a0c18", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c55743ffe5e3440e804ded7800bd13210e260d83dd77b5b187079dd38debbdb9", "request_id": "581a7a75b30ba9fb2f8a7514f9fc15df", "response_sha256": "066d9b0b0d6fcde45fa8bff3b191c31005b46cd7938cdf258d9c8cf422a28427", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "9208f07f331942704cbf24339d8e2fc6", "candidate_priority_rank": 532, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b79254304ca62786:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b79254304ca62786:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b79254304ca62786:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b79254304ca62786:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bedspread<->ground", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bedspread", "B": "ground"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bedspread<->ground", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 361, "image_id": "2399526", "image_sha256": "d3c51525ef4df7b192081a4f71725a7e2b9bc09ade3eae9d1978b7768e2932a8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399526.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399526.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2397062", "image_sha256": "fca117bc3055b8f8b2cac01cc5ff9be09a4d454524dd981105dee7b3e1d929b7", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397062.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397062.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b79254304ca62786", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bedspread", "diff_b": "ground", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bedspread", "component_b": "ground"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bedspread", "book", "bookshelf", "cat", "eyes", "floor", "leg", "nose", "paw", "tail", "wall"], "detected_components": ["bedspread"], "masked_program_sha256": "4f5a650cdcc6e0a060d4db888a2ccc0442a0c818aa6835cda98887c47b6bcda7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bedspread", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bedspread", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bedspread", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c8608130e5da7ea2d5c16683b3981dec8b74a8cb6636dd3101ac8b2721348bc0"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06250147", "text": "What is the animal that is above the bedspread?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["canopy", "dirt", "ear", "elephant", "eye", "fence", "foot", "ground", "hay", "head", "leg", "mouth", "post", "rope", "sign", "tent", "trees", "trunk"], "detected_components": ["ground"], "masked_program_sha256": "4f5a650cdcc6e0a060d4db888a2ccc0442a0c818aa6835cda98887c47b6bcda7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ground", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a55ec1094a7836965fece618179eedd400e1f479a11814ec362f85847f7adf24"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02884737", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 532, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "8146c0064473aa2d3a07d2ecc60799b82adf5d8c0b9caf0519ede977c833a0c8", "selected_component": "ground", "selected_source_question_id": "02884737", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the animal that is above the ground?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is above the ?", "program_group_hash": "8146c0064473aa2d3a07d2ecc60799b82adf5d8c0b9caf0519ede977c833a0c8", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "bedspread"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,above,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the animal that is above the ?", "program_group_hash": "8146c0064473aa2d3a07d2ecc60799b82adf5d8c0b9caf0519ede977c833a0c8", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "above", "select_category": "ground"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What is the animal that is above the bedspread?", "question_id": "06250147", "semantic": [{"argument": "bedspread (1168952)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,above,s (1168951)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The animal is an elephant.", "question": "What is the animal that is above the ground?", "question_id": "02884737", "semantic": [{"argument": "ground (1193032)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,above,s (1193030)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1168951"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["orange", "staring"], "query_target_entity_id": "1168951", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "1168952", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1168951", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1168952", "selected_entity_name": "bedspread"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bedspread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1168952"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bedspread", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1193030", "1193048"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "above", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "large", "wrinkled"], "query_target_entity_id": "1193030", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "1193032", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1193030", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1193032", "selected_entity_name": "ground"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1193032"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:9208f07f331942704cbf24339d8e2fc6", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "d3c51525ef4df7b192081a4f71725a7e2b9bc09ade3eae9d1978b7768e2932a8", "image_sha256_b": "fca117bc3055b8f8b2cac01cc5ff9be09a4d454524dd981105dee7b3e1d929b7", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "35fad170e6e47ea9855249785414c2aeaf11c1f3954fbfaa5ec79b2815c35e85", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9ef3b920045578503bfb87158cb0805a", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "3c9f0a227211aeee000920f9356d240d50ec78e8abcfe82133a6aa1dd1fc4496"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ed4aedc9fedd2b1000354b46f151a1326e865b2430df0e39bc3f5eb6a4f648d4", "request_id": "46158f99e0ac653ef662090b1f5ad2c6", "response_sha256": "f3970f5c11beb3abad756310acec649672b67b31c7f4d26e26b60ae96febeca8", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e874b95e5bb790f28deea35e2da3fdbe112d122191a48bea4372527135a2a9af", "request_id": "91acbd9823110bb21edb772dfb9fc690", "response_sha256": "437589b4801070b914454db68c0a4256d9e948078cb2ab293ef0034a6d9847c6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "a2e2e282104414dbd8b9939650e7a0a0", "candidate_priority_rank": 533, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c5085ff48817d09:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c5085ff48817d09:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c5085ff48817d09:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c5085ff48817d09:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "comforter<->pizza", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "pizza", "B": "comforter"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "pizza<->comforter", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 274, "image_id": "2328564", "image_sha256": "9b65f6e09653640e0da642e746a2a3ba58b0b48d8572e7c3038d7e761acd05f3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2328564.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2328564.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2318312", "image_sha256": "11f56018748875ec0b9f8f36df3c1ed03620e2f6ff7e4a03b8fa9b42fce1bb23", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2318312.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2318312.jpg", "width": 333}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4c5085ff48817d09", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "pizza", "diff_b": "comforter", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "pizza", "component_b": "comforter"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basil", "cheese", "cords", "counter", "cream", "crust", "door", "foil", "kitchen", "olive", "olives", "pan", "pizza", "tomato", "topping"], "detected_components": ["pizza"], "masked_program_sha256": "04a844c972330e567aa2d6690ba0ad48013565736fd722162226e44aa2bb1ec8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pizza", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pizza"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8124e214337bc7025893ef83775bd28308cd3a0444feb9c966de1d3e815c3152"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "11197872", "text": "What is the pizza lying on top of?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "bedroom", "ceiling", "chair", "comforter", "headboard", "lamp", "lamp shade", "light switch", "nightstand", "pillows", "post", "table", "wall"], "detected_components": ["comforter"], "masked_program_sha256": "04a844c972330e567aa2d6690ba0ad48013565736fd722162226e44aa2bb1ec8", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["comforter"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "comforter", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["comforter"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "29bdad6ef498d76a955c1cf64596d40065afc2752dc320f52cbcf9146d62107e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12180258", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 533, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "82e4db939b068f9e5d3e58ba15026fca410508519a9dbd5a37a35fc512288eca", "selected_component": "comforter", "selected_source_question_id": "12180258", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the comforter lying on top of?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on top of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the lying on top of?", "program_group_hash": "82e4db939b068f9e5d3e58ba15026fca410508519a9dbd5a37a35fc512288eca", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on top of", "select_category": "pizza"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on top of,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the lying on top of?", "program_group_hash": "82e4db939b068f9e5d3e58ba15026fca410508519a9dbd5a37a35fc512288eca", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on top of", "select_category": "comforter"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "pan", "full_answer": "The pizza is lying on top of the pan.", "question": "What is the pizza lying on top of?", "question_id": "11197872", "semantic": [{"argument": "pizza (4258873)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on top of,o (4258872)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The bed cover is lying on top of the bed.", "question": "What is the comforter lying on top of?", "question_id": "12180258", "semantic": [{"argument": "comforter (4056346)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on top of,o (4056305)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4115850", "4115858", "4115861", "4115866", "4115870", "4115872", "4115889", "4115896", "4115900", "4115918", "4258872", "4258914", "4258916", "4425520", "4678817"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["pan"], "predicate": "lying on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4258872", "query_target_entity_name": "pan", "relation_object_entity_id": "4258872", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4258873", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4258873", "selected_entity_name": "pizza"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4258873"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "comforter", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pizza", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4056288", "4056298", "4056305", "4056316", "4056319", "4056321", "4056324", "4056326", "4056327", "4056328", "4056341", "4056342", "4056348", "4056353", "4056354"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 15, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4056305", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "4056305", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4056346", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4056346", "selected_entity_name": "comforter"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "comforter", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4056346"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:a2e2e282104414dbd8b9939650e7a0a0", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "9b65f6e09653640e0da642e746a2a3ba58b0b48d8572e7c3038d7e761acd05f3", "image_sha256_b": "11f56018748875ec0b9f8f36df3c1ed03620e2f6ff7e4a03b8fa9b42fce1bb23", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "fc73d526bb33077e590dde0c9c9819c9bb41b7040a233ad5eef7b5e9df7033c0", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "88e04d22582f4cab6300426a24443741", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "71ffa0c4374619b68848d51b83e885dbd8cf3a6b9b20101f29b3cfad5088c562"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "da11d9c4a33ecab0a4d03ecfbd4161257c661818cd5c71fea208e7f8cf865d39", "request_id": "332898d38a36ce729e9bdc843bc8da4b", "response_sha256": "6cdf3bfb7b1a6a049ede57f3a48dfe9f60fd6feb1414deb9f1538fcb36c6b3b4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5f6992130e3efc4d0b0449aeb00f318449fda588f56498fd0a2bb400b2c4ce62", "request_id": "dc393ab9f4b9e98ef8bb90950d83c99c", "response_sha256": "a85776269416e31b7007d7ea911153e22966db7584cad9ab8c4fef8ae6582684", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "afb7d4a96f3aaca10a11ff0378101586", "candidate_priority_rank": 542, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e1400a1888a4166:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e1400a1888a4166:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e1400a1888a4166:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e1400a1888a4166:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "pavement<->sand", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "pavement", "B": "sand"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "pavement<->sand", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2351225", "image_sha256": "00c71e61b34005e202f5071d041e03ad515d15d8e8b004339e1573aa103549af", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2351225.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2351225.jpg", "width": 390}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2397644", "image_sha256": "42e74523b1efb516e99e19b540ed7a967a9665a82002f43d02025006efbeb6e2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397644.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397644.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-9e1400a1888a4166", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "pavement", "diff_b": "sand", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "pavement", "component_b": "sand"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "explicit_plural"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["buildings", "car", "cars", "elephants", "hat", "jacket", "man", "pavement", "people", "shirt", "sidewalk", "street", "suit", "trees", "water"], "detected_components": ["pavement"], "masked_program_sha256": "9d101c86b63c1693b6803bccde91431dc0f12d8f9bc1d7f08119d3d92ad9829f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["pavement"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "pavement", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["pavement"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7f881cbf186ef881da5f27dc162f4d3985aa0d9d26848583019b05edf99b3efb"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "041033336", "text": "What animals are walking on the pavement?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boat", "clouds", "head", "helmet", "horses", "leg", "legs", "number", "pants", "people", "person", "road", "sand", "sky", "tail", "water"], "detected_components": ["sand"], "masked_program_sha256": "9d101c86b63c1693b6803bccde91431dc0f12d8f9bc1d7f08119d3d92ad9829f", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["sand"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "sand", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["sand"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7e8d6d3c41f4db193e26edd87d5d57cff207a47c75afc4e6dd926d4df154335a"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17989600", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 542, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "ee4d2717edb40810ce16ec24e97c23c77ab70629fbfd29b0f93dd152c9e9be49", "selected_component": "sand", "selected_source_question_id": "17989600", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animals are walking on the sand?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are walking on the ?", "program_group_hash": "ee4d2717edb40810ce16ec24e97c23c77ab70629fbfd29b0f93dd152c9e9be49", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "pavement"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animals are walking on the ?", "program_group_hash": "ee4d2717edb40810ce16ec24e97c23c77ab70629fbfd29b0f93dd152c9e9be49", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "walking on", "select_category": "sand"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "elephants", "full_answer": "The animals are elephants.", "question": "What animals are walking on the pavement?", "question_id": "041033336", "semantic": [{"argument": "pavement (3590050)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s (2226009)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "horses", "full_answer": "The animals are horses.", "question": "What animals are walking on the sand?", "question_id": "17989600", "semantic": [{"argument": "sand (1188058)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,walking on,s (1188050)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2226009"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2226009", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "3590050", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2226009", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3590050", "selected_entity_name": "pavement"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pavement", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3590050"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sand", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "pavement", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1188050"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horses"], "predicate": "walking on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["walking"], "query_target_entity_id": "1188050", "query_target_entity_name": "horses", "relation_object_entity_id": "1188058", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1188050", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1188058", "selected_entity_name": "sand"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "sand", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1188058"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:afb7d4a96f3aaca10a11ff0378101586", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "00c71e61b34005e202f5071d041e03ad515d15d8e8b004339e1573aa103549af", "image_sha256_b": "42e74523b1efb516e99e19b540ed7a967a9665a82002f43d02025006efbeb6e2", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "895bc70042a359254717b36b1c0b18481c7bb46ea7b963c5eec25963174b1497", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "a0c72edb3d28dcf0beda5a9d47a58652", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a48ce4d871431d82a4b07777e083a7e4326bfa3e4ddfcd254066704dd207d668"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b614dab45d65be0b6e362f26fcd1ddaa7539f44054dae32d82732e35ff32096e", "request_id": "6ada4facce23b36a198f763fb7a61da6", "response_sha256": "ff5b00faa5a5bcd4ba7e2522b6f1f69234227c0e36874286bd36602520e160f2", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e27865bfd45ea44f655c492e60651d72a7d4fed8ffb7bd14c13e15be3ef9e425", "request_id": "b484e2a588a17b091b88f49d7bd5592e", "response_sha256": "cdc6604aaa680a94aef3f303ea965db9490a4c2addf2b77e784a49937c609671", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "cdefe181b55c4fa275353ab8ce6915a7", "candidate_priority_rank": 550, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a8012c6897b47e19:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a8012c6897b47e19:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a8012c6897b47e19:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a8012c6897b47e19:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "parking lot<->rain", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "rain", "B": "parking lot"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "rain<->parking lot", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2384319", "image_sha256": "62aa211c86e1594abe256a49b488e15b3076e5d10c41571ebed567ea6dd1cda8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384319.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384319.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2339290", "image_sha256": "13b564e3d657b27671c49a9f93a1235540f3d22c98e12334c8d349bfddcdd044", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2339290.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2339290.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a8012c6897b47e19", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "rain", "diff_b": "parking lot", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "rain", "component_b": "parking lot"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["car", "person", "rain", "umbrella", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["rain"], "masked_program_sha256": "2470d9ed27618b66426c5c15088db186dec53c34551406b552fd6b1367b62bea", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["rain"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "rain", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["rain"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "da371a9141d5abdae4d8f9a7f6cdda2c6752716e0a16ef8f26049cb6407664d1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "09833999", "text": "What is parked in the rain?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["helmet", "mirror", "motorcycle", "parking lot", "seat", "wall", "wheel"], "detected_components": ["parking lot"], "masked_program_sha256": "2470d9ed27618b66426c5c15088db186dec53c34551406b552fd6b1367b62bea", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["parking lot"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "parking lot", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["parking lot"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "44c8af1e48eb3a4636acb0c341b8048ccd26c21f8e8b88491c3394ec2a0ea11f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "17994170", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 550, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 5, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "54a0a113b3b012459cf263ebd33ff3bcca464d25987bb11de2739da331828521", "selected_component": "parking lot", "selected_source_question_id": "17994170", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is parked in the parking lot?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is parked in the ?", "program_group_hash": "54a0a113b3b012459cf263ebd33ff3bcca464d25987bb11de2739da331828521", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "parked in", "select_category": "rain"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is parked in the ?", "program_group_hash": "54a0a113b3b012459cf263ebd33ff3bcca464d25987bb11de2739da331828521", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "parked in", "select_category": "parking lot"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "car", "full_answer": "The car is parked in the rain.", "question": "What is parked in the rain?", "question_id": "09833999", "semantic": [{"argument": "rain (4470638)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked in,s (4470637)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "motorcycle", "full_answer": "The motorcycle is parked in the parking lot.", "question": "What is parked in the parking lot?", "question_id": "17994170", "semantic": [{"argument": "parking lot (2692140)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,parked in,s (2692139)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4268320", "4268321", "4373890", "4470637"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 4, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["car"], "predicate": "parked in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "4470637", "query_target_entity_name": "car", "relation_object_entity_id": "4470638", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4470637", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4470638", "selected_entity_name": "rain"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "rain", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4470638"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "parking lot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "rain", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2378835", "2552962", "2692139", "2697859", "3194424", "3359295"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["motorcycle"], "predicate": "parked in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2692139", "query_target_entity_name": "motorcycle", "relation_object_entity_id": "2692140", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2692139", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2692140", "selected_entity_name": "parking lot"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "parking lot", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2692140"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:cdefe181b55c4fa275353ab8ce6915a7", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "62aa211c86e1594abe256a49b488e15b3076e5d10c41571ebed567ea6dd1cda8", "image_sha256_b": "13b564e3d657b27671c49a9f93a1235540f3d22c98e12334c8d349bfddcdd044", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "a831def6d97de52da8c03e521de4cda5a03a50cc51014a4eb1601208f22772fc", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "cdcb62eb5d304161d60c7aa4f8afa5c3", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "0e83cb30d561e19d78a5cb5e0ef93e9e0522ae785ac4f2edecee369558462e80"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c554eae07ebdc79b6914676d053ab8950cf8718cc1e9f16d5fc17a7754069c2f", "request_id": "fa83d28d5203bbb39863afeddafd36af", "response_sha256": "b9c22d496d898feec149512699f72310e64ee45713bb3080b265cac75c18809f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "13d952d7bb8fbb8660b7a2d2196c871a5acb1e2f411770882b050e38abcf64f2", "request_id": "ef57c0578607482dcba127bca1f26c9a", "response_sha256": "c01f0899e3dd973f8e42e2a5d2cd25af186931140d49efd3a2d2a9b845df147f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "0af9bbe0417e4eb1be28a490579f1b25", "candidate_priority_rank": 557, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-52cbfd861cf06af7:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-52cbfd861cf06af7:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-52cbfd861cf06af7:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-52cbfd861cf06af7:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->dough", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cat", "B": "dough"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cat<->dough", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2384728", "image_sha256": "dc30b190d11c6fb0865e755e93b41addc61e4faeae1304544425d4fe5692e2ac", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2384728.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2384728.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 283, "image_id": "2337539", "image_sha256": "df6317c98af15e27fa8c7eef2b1932db95b576cd9839a52d4a6bbbe3b2f35c19", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2337539.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2337539.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-52cbfd861cf06af7", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cat", "diff_b": "dough", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cat", "component_b": "dough"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "cat", "couch", "ear", "eye", "fur", "keyboard", "laptop", "nose", "paw", "screen"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "e19aae45a4406e86087a2bf41b6d29d86417b1e100e7be1c4119139b5cda05f5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "49f535514b86f6a01f04cd397c9d25818c6bb217e9358edf9b01f7e13a164cf1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00333685", "text": "What's the cat resting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["burner", "cabinets", "dough", "finger", "flour", "hand", "knife", "skillet", "thumb"], "detected_components": ["dough"], "masked_program_sha256": "e19aae45a4406e86087a2bf41b6d29d86417b1e100e7be1c4119139b5cda05f5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dough"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dough", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dough"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "eaf2f94e91414a575db2e187ef97c27dd2d9ee9c58af365de8eaa8238f0caedb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13364440", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 557, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 13, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "b86c911d27afa37e66270e83664679dd07000b91ad953801e010f7057522a8c2", "selected_component": "dough", "selected_source_question_id": "13364440", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What's the dough resting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,resting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the resting on?", "program_group_hash": "b86c911d27afa37e66270e83664679dd07000b91ad953801e010f7057522a8c2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,resting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what's the resting on?", "program_group_hash": "b86c911d27afa37e66270e83664679dd07000b91ad953801e010f7057522a8c2", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "dough"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The cat is resting on the couch.", "question": "What's the cat resting on?", "question_id": "00333685", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (691074)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,resting on,o (691085)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "skillet", "full_answer": "The dough is resting on the skillet.", "question": "What's the dough resting on?", "question_id": "13364440", "semantic": [{"argument": "dough (957277)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,resting on,o (957271)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["691072", "691073", "691075", "691076", "691078", "691079", "691080", "691081", "691083", "691084", "691085", "691086", "691087"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey"], "query_target_entity_id": "691085", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "691085", "relation_subject_entity_id": "691074", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "691074", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["691074"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dough", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["957271", "957272", "957274", "957275", "957276", "957278", "957279", "957280", "957281", "957282", "957283"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 11, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["skillet"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["black", "upside down"], "query_target_entity_id": "957271", "query_target_entity_name": "skillet", "relation_object_entity_id": "957271", "relation_subject_entity_id": "957277", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "957277", "selected_entity_name": "dough"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dough", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["957277"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:0af9bbe0417e4eb1be28a490579f1b25", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "dc30b190d11c6fb0865e755e93b41addc61e4faeae1304544425d4fe5692e2ac", "image_sha256_b": "df6317c98af15e27fa8c7eef2b1932db95b576cd9839a52d4a6bbbe3b2f35c19", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "5ec73b3283efb1ebf5d651cc3cc49699e48c83013dc2ed3e0a639aa70446e11e", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "ef1cae07be9d9eef61da583e5e71ad44", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b54234ef3874e2079cd6819bcbaab54b91b5f8a633fe2bf6a5dfb452643f92b0"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e9bb0b7ee305507ef8f5de3059842b65f7946445aeeba68d775e95efd0467d9d", "request_id": "28f78f9856808458226d91e2b09796b8", "response_sha256": "6e212766ae87540bf0417e8a0302622e9210c467d714bd5a0a4b72794f06575f", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "23b13dc9ae4f984af48c6ae88aae41a7ae21c94064a7676c94976497b0da77c8", "request_id": "ea2bbd871ea3930ceb009d1201f55f75", "response_sha256": "e40abda92327f6c99d4b52114b7bb4b4e169c16a1b88ee88c5097cc4bed70133", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "74d80e0cf0c85a2f9b2a92643a077567", "candidate_priority_rank": 563, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a40ec0a9e687d736:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a40ec0a9e687d736:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a40ec0a9e687d736:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a40ec0a9e687d736:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "baby<->bed", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bed", "B": "baby"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bed<->baby", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2402337", "image_sha256": "c894c721fd6d8f92eb79553b500ee17a9b84e8105c8981bee5b21657f11ae33a", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402337.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402337.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2376189", "image_sha256": "4f1ea32edd685af7631c4bd0af55e7381427a2c60a0fb5939205daca33b1f1da", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2376189.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2376189.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-a40ec0a9e687d736", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bed", "diff_b": "baby", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bed", "component_b": "baby"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "blanket", "ear", "ears", "eye", "eyes", "head", "mouth", "nose", "paw", "pillow", "shirt", "teddy bear"], "detected_components": ["bed"], "masked_program_sha256": "36542fec0a1609af072d53fd03c6ecdc7bd5a0036155702a7787a969de804c59", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bed", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "d3dd210cb94d834b0dd830d9b579681fa8ecd9b8e7b73ce65f7b38099caad75c"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10189797", "text": "What toy is lying on the bed?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["baby", "car", "eye", "face", "fence", "hair", "head", "nose", "shirt", "stuffed animal", "trees", "window"], "detected_components": ["baby"], "masked_program_sha256": "36542fec0a1609af072d53fd03c6ecdc7bd5a0036155702a7787a969de804c59", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby", "toy"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "baby", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["baby", "toy"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e9f1087678d8750a0ea48bda6708ccbc3fb04c284538e85589483d96df55094e"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "05314735", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 563, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2227b537bc282ceef769f2935d238d28824ea055da9538cff0a6625324e2d700", "selected_component": "baby", "selected_source_question_id": "05314735", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What toy is lying on the baby?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what toy is lying on the ?", "program_group_hash": "2227b537bc282ceef769f2935d238d28824ea055da9538cff0a6625324e2d700", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "bed"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,lying on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what toy is lying on the ?", "program_group_hash": "2227b537bc282ceef769f2935d238d28824ea055da9538cff0a6625324e2d700", "queried_category": "toy", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "baby"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "teddy bear", "full_answer": "The toy is a teddy bear.", "question": "What toy is lying on the bed?", "question_id": "10189797", "semantic": [{"argument": "bed (1137408)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,lying on,s (1137396)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "stuffed animal", "full_answer": "The toy is a stuffed animal.", "question": "What toy is lying on the baby?", "question_id": "05314735", "semantic": [{"argument": "baby (575267)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "toy,lying on,s (575275)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1137396"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["teddy bear"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "stuffed"], "query_target_entity_id": "1137396", "query_target_entity_name": "teddy bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "1137408", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1137396", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1137408", "selected_entity_name": "bed"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1137408"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["575275"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["stuffed animal"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "stuffed"], "query_target_entity_id": "575275", "query_target_entity_name": "stuffed animal", "relation_object_entity_id": "575267", "relation_subject_entity_id": "575275", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "575267", "selected_entity_name": "baby"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "baby", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["575267"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:74d80e0cf0c85a2f9b2a92643a077567", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "c894c721fd6d8f92eb79553b500ee17a9b84e8105c8981bee5b21657f11ae33a", "image_sha256_b": "4f1ea32edd685af7631c4bd0af55e7381427a2c60a0fb5939205daca33b1f1da", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "385d1ecea3fec20c94734250e915fec1a95a9e7b294cfcbfb0e860eefcaaa039", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "530ec42d1b50215dc8fd78ce5b9d3987", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "1be545980a40521dc6a3ac13d9f6e275eec243eda3266fafd7837981fb5be4a7"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "0ff9aef98a9cd4534305693e41bde72fa9cf4127625ad9ccfea57a3fd93bd13f", "request_id": "434f9654d2a63cb972e47831a8bba6c5", "response_sha256": "7c9cf6ae2d92dacb5a7b43059cd3dfa93dbbdf5cf949e7f1f70db7456f739ec7", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "168b7513e6835deba537ade5151a8a3956d158d2d66a4fefb14c73b2df674f6a", "request_id": "49ce6c8c7c176a1139f521fa71536db3", "response_sha256": "8f98370059143adace760cc256da288f4cdc9de796415fb3ff96775d78bd4f15", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "f2eed3a090393b315ab71992d2f32de2", "candidate_priority_rank": 586, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50595e0bd87e0209:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50595e0bd87e0209:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50595e0bd87e0209:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50595e0bd87e0209:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "boat<->elephant", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "elephant", "B": "boat"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "elephant<->boat", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2336148", "image_sha256": "4b08816baed4552e43f86369c0df442f25de49c566d45463a97e8d60ba9d7b73", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2336148.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2336148.jpg", "width": 414}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2348039", "image_sha256": "d112f602559675ba74c09f54cc27dd7490b63ec49533bde52737bd59b22db331", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2348039.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2348039.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-50595e0bd87e0209", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "elephant", "diff_b": "boat", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "elephant", "component_b": "boat"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "color", "question_intent": "appearance_attribute:color", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "couple", "cowboy hat", "ears", "elephant", "eyes", "face", "forest", "hand", "hat", "head", "leg", "man", "tail", "trunk", "water", "woman"], "detected_components": ["elephant"], "masked_program_sha256": "8663e766efa40aac060f82ad7694427b0fe7d2f214177de64fae35f61c2c464e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["elephant", "water"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "elephant", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["elephant", "water"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "24f3d5f2264db0164b2ac054f4ab8f043b923390568dc1e606a13d4bc5ace5a9"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "0739078", "text": "What is the color of the water the elephant is in?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["boat", "hand", "hat", "life jacket", "life preserver", "logo", "man", "rope", "shield", "shorts", "water", "wheel", "woman"], "detected_components": ["boat"], "masked_program_sha256": "8663e766efa40aac060f82ad7694427b0fe7d2f214177de64fae35f61c2c464e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["boat", "water"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "boat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["boat", "water"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a32997f2b25714583aec0ba9661f4ecd11e1692310a88c99cb131b32e19e2fff"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "15702229", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 586, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 7, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2aeba9981fe87506fcb117adad04124f74f4d531ddbf31def63941c2761e4186", "selected_component": "boat", "selected_source_question_id": "15702229", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the color of the water the boat is in?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "water,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the color of the water the is in?", "program_group_hash": "2aeba9981fe87506fcb117adad04124f74f4d531ddbf31def63941c2761e4186", "queried_category": "water", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "elephant"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "appearance_attribute", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "water,in,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the color of the water the is in?", "program_group_hash": "2aeba9981fe87506fcb117adad04124f74f4d531ddbf31def63941c2761e4186", "queried_category": "water", "query_role": "color", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "boat"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "green", "full_answer": "The water is green.", "question": "What is the color of the water the elephant is in?", "question_id": "0739078", "semantic": [{"argument": "elephant (1045270)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "water,in,o (1045271)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dark blue", "full_answer": "The water is dark blue.", "question": "What is the color of the water the boat is in?", "question_id": "15702229", "semantic": [{"argument": "boat (1901002)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "water,in,o (1803307)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "color", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1045271"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["green"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["green"], "query_target_entity_id": "1045271", "query_target_entity_name": "water", "relation_object_entity_id": "1045271", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1045270", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1045270", "selected_entity_name": "elephant"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "elephant", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1045270"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "elephant", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1701104", "1803307"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dark blue"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "query_target_attributes": ["dark blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1803307", "query_target_entity_name": "water", "relation_object_entity_id": "1803307", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1901002", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1901002", "selected_entity_name": "boat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "boat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1901002"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f2eed3a090393b315ab71992d2f32de2", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "4b08816baed4552e43f86369c0df442f25de49c566d45463a97e8d60ba9d7b73", "image_sha256_b": "d112f602559675ba74c09f54cc27dd7490b63ec49533bde52737bd59b22db331", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8e4b090818db5547769c7d45a2d03a27d2d3a78ac271262174660aa5b39e01d6", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9febabb5ed1e00e3703584c417034aee", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "32dd8e874f5f9ae77f546a038ca6654eb2dd9d98cfec2479956bc08c374b89dc"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3575c985dd044a779853293868d383a884f8499ec050cd5ad300e39640605d8b", "request_id": "bc739da09721a40ca18b30de9629ca73", "response_sha256": "9da33118771d8f6be54e15a3d584d35021a1bbd5e9809805f592905b9b0e773c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "b6bb6a4d41a6874bf4d2cdd8e673d78103429a77bac9bee2457cc379a6a51563", "request_id": "b4e6dcafd31daf9ef31c2494efc81457", "response_sha256": "2a16ac574ab4b46db2cbba25754bd7981d44514aa080e7e25ae6402525c7f455", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "ae421509b49bcd7c9952a53998b91c46", "candidate_priority_rank": 594, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a0eeb772fad0687:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a0eeb772fad0687:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a0eeb772fad0687:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a0eeb772fad0687:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2404163", "image_sha256": "f8055030eee8d45269244fad4ac37d86dda1dea7de65dc2c87d9448e9dc600d9", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2404163.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2404163.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2350706", "image_sha256": "a35e5ab48a814dde55e7195ceebef54539afcef75b166cc9f22e5d7c2177c8a4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2350706.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2350706.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-4a0eeb772fad0687", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["arm", "bracelet", "collar", "dog", "dress", "eye", "feet", "ground", "hand", "nose", "sandals", "scarf", "woman", "wrist"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "510e046d2fda28fd1b15eb6f46b453c2c2c44e4e6dd014ce043a675c10e28983", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "cdf16f63f308a676b592be8e0f97bd62cff00df0620fccedd2c22f2c0e66d905"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00340679", "text": "What animal is the woman petting?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["belt", "chimney", "ear", "glasses", "hand", "horse", "house", "logo", "man", "shirt", "woman"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "510e046d2fda28fd1b15eb6f46b453c2c2c44e4e6dd014ce043a675c10e28983", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2f00919e1aa41b540330331bfc9146dbb62ad7ea878408105488a7372b1f8aee"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07336589", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 594, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "370135999d475e899c943a4a1355aad1ca87679d4936cac2c55de5fd2a0bd87a", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "07336589", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is the man petting?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,petting,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is the petting?", "program_group_hash": "370135999d475e899c943a4a1355aad1ca87679d4936cac2c55de5fd2a0bd87a", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "petting", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,petting,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is the petting?", "program_group_hash": "370135999d475e899c943a4a1355aad1ca87679d4936cac2c55de5fd2a0bd87a", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "petting", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The woman is petting the dog.", "question": "What animal is the woman petting?", "question_id": "00340679", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (345862)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,petting,o (345860)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "horse", "full_answer": "The man is petting the horse.", "question": "What animal is the man petting?", "question_id": "07336589", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (866023)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,petting,o (866024)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["345860"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "petting", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["adult", "beautiful", "black", "looking up"], "query_target_entity_id": "345860", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "345860", "relation_subject_entity_id": "345862", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "345862", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["345862"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["866024", "866040"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["866036"], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["866024", "866040"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["horse"], "predicate": "petting", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["short", "white"], "query_target_entity_id": "866024", "query_target_entity_name": "horse", "relation_object_entity_id": "866024", "relation_subject_entity_id": "866023", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "866023", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["866023"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:ae421509b49bcd7c9952a53998b91c46", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "f8055030eee8d45269244fad4ac37d86dda1dea7de65dc2c87d9448e9dc600d9", "image_sha256_b": "a35e5ab48a814dde55e7195ceebef54539afcef75b166cc9f22e5d7c2177c8a4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d060bc75a722eb044ea6e4862b5c676baae0a4068179587ad12e7debcce57d8a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "4cd9ea5d6251f9f25c2688fb397b214b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "64a82b03f532bc966b1f0d324e2741180b5e66ff12d21bc7205e44cb2a8e7444"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c7656d39c71d82504903ec40f03d18c2972224232756bbce43b05ba8aad12fe6", "request_id": "5220b4de84983874806ea82ea0db0481", "response_sha256": "a374822f7eb43602b05b825c6077d72f17ac60a340990e530785f52a8ef1422b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "04b53c202993b6c9a6b08bbf328983f80d7a5ffb11aca078c7fcc2a863621279", "request_id": "3bd2a2dd42f95b01f34c0770e809cc97", "response_sha256": "f23f6d0d7a4320def503f1462de9494b9940289e7a519e49eb8d98f0b4f7865c", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "7ac9f16a5d45fd9cdf198e7384ca7afb", "candidate_priority_rank": 604, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d3a80d60a2506a82:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d3a80d60a2506a82:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d3a80d60a2506a82:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d3a80d60a2506a82:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "grass<->umbrella", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "umbrella", "B": "grass"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "umbrella<->grass", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2397731", "image_sha256": "20fa606af4f16ea352bb8a01d2ebe073e49852c533b13be7885c9a0448884c1b", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2397731.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2397731.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2369384", "image_sha256": "755d0482121d82509398c072cf1fb36ebd06357c042f7e5c01ecdc9e58a28b7e", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2369384.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2369384.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-d3a80d60a2506a82", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "umbrella", "diff_b": "grass", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "umbrella", "component_b": "grass"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bandana", "boot", "collar", "dog", "ear", "eyes", "face", "foot", "ground", "hair", "head", "jeans", "leg", "logo", "mouth", "nose", "person", "shoe", "tail", "umbrella", "wall"], "detected_components": ["umbrella"], "masked_program_sha256": "250dcb0aa2a77bfabb70df0970c24d4c5f76fd0a193b92037a9e6969047d5f3a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["umbrella", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "umbrella", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["umbrella", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a732aea3413937e1de0f77799a05a6375ab22d6f91b043bb98bbae668e135f95"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "18202554", "text": "What animal is covered by the umbrella?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["elephants", "field", "grass", "trees"], "detected_components": ["grass"], "masked_program_sha256": "250dcb0aa2a77bfabb70df0970c24d4c5f76fd0a193b92037a9e6969047d5f3a", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "grass", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["grass", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c6755ded88ba141de670a8bf95680bcd34228220f23f1c6f7231651f03f99e74"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "051033720", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 604, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "dc8899f83fbadbf88be29c9de931f4bc627998330a293f02e47ab4b693e7b789", "selected_component": "grass", "selected_source_question_id": "051033720", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is covered by the grass?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covered by,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is covered by the ?", "program_group_hash": "dc8899f83fbadbf88be29c9de931f4bc627998330a293f02e47ab4b693e7b789", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "covered by", "select_category": "umbrella"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covered by,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is covered by the ?", "program_group_hash": "dc8899f83fbadbf88be29c9de931f4bc627998330a293f02e47ab4b693e7b789", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "covered by", "select_category": "grass"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is covered by the umbrella.", "question": "What animal is covered by the umbrella?", "question_id": "18202554", "semantic": [{"argument": "umbrella (1187097)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covered by,s (1187088)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "elephants", "full_answer": "The elephants are covered by the grass.", "question": "What animal is covered by the grass?", "question_id": "051033720", "semantic": [{"argument": "grass (611853)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,covered by,s (611851)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1187088"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "covered by", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["small", "wet"], "query_target_entity_id": "1187088", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "1187097", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1187088", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1187097", "selected_entity_name": "umbrella"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "umbrella", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1187097"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "umbrella", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["611851"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephants"], "predicate": "covered by", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["gray", "grey", "large", "wild"], "query_target_entity_id": "611851", "query_target_entity_name": "elephants", "relation_object_entity_id": "611853", "relation_subject_entity_id": "611851", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "611853", "selected_entity_name": "grass"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "grass", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["611853"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:7ac9f16a5d45fd9cdf198e7384ca7afb", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "20fa606af4f16ea352bb8a01d2ebe073e49852c533b13be7885c9a0448884c1b", "image_sha256_b": "755d0482121d82509398c072cf1fb36ebd06357c042f7e5c01ecdc9e58a28b7e", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "0302506f6b621dbee1ec50a64d89c47088d9f126fbf25a72bf72562dca59a977", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "551c1f7d10f683a840c0ae00bb244c74", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "e92bdc8c9d0b514803d3be94451dcfb79bce4415f3b93413182ef4b44e2b6c94"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "88ca4a9695fb681fd8f17634aaf7c5d7b4fa5f7fe0f515d0d4f200ac96da7292", "request_id": "921e54f9222def6ecdc20ff4c812d7ff", "response_sha256": "db6ea2313b1e8f28c2c2104558e89bcaa94dc0ba800c9b82ba4851210b8e7720", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "01801a71ad7004bac149687527524db7cdcaf67df59fc43c67f3114e396699bf", "request_id": "7cde554bbdef9ad98139a94c8420bd6a", "response_sha256": "f81652caf7f057a1208d8625fe0be46b749b98d17d8e9e0ac5944002e193900e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "7103712e68e25439f692804feb6c2d98", "candidate_priority_rank": 609, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c211fce2908b49d0:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c211fce2908b49d0:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c211fce2908b49d0:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c211fce2908b49d0:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dog<->wine bottle", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "dog", "B": "wine bottle"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "dog<->wine bottle", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2399560", "image_sha256": "154942e324c5ac6cf01dcc46e08abd2a8c0a93527ae58bc61062d179994a4706", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399560.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399560.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 399, "image_id": "2393592", "image_sha256": "2bce716863ac2f4be7e567e467b19f5f7da3fec796a95705fff4978f1f3bff03", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2393592.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2393592.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c211fce2908b49d0", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "dog", "diff_b": "wine bottle", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "dog", "component_b": "wine bottle"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "clothes", "collar", "curtain", "dog", "ear", "eye", "flower", "frame", "pillow", "sheet", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "25eb5c66b6c5faf3c170d8b55939f6962712f0553bfad730db0b8e32d4ed73c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "7d45cec23a2ab6a95d4beda8dd6bcc7e2076deb889e1bbdf6de39d607d3cce1b"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01968447", "text": "What kind of furniture is the dog resting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "label", "numbers", "table", "wine bottle", "wine glass", "words"], "detected_components": ["wine bottle"], "masked_program_sha256": "25eb5c66b6c5faf3c170d8b55939f6962712f0553bfad730db0b8e32d4ed73c5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["wine bottle", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "wine bottle", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["wine bottle", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "a289be95d91c789287ba9667f641a05a3c1ef51e20c61bfe07315f1f7c2ea6e1"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "131048925", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 609, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "af5607a9cf206e4d2df19ec1f1d0d9049faf11e1e11222355260ce1d21b07039", "selected_component": "wine bottle", "selected_source_question_id": "131048925", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What kind of furniture is the wine bottle resting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,resting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture is the resting on?", "program_group_hash": "af5607a9cf206e4d2df19ec1f1d0d9049faf11e1e11222355260ce1d21b07039", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "dog"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,resting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what kind of furniture is the resting on?", "program_group_hash": "af5607a9cf206e4d2df19ec1f1d0d9049faf11e1e11222355260ce1d21b07039", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "wine bottle"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The dog is resting on the bed.", "question": "What kind of furniture is the dog resting on?", "question_id": "01968447", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (415474)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,resting on,o (415475)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The wine bottle is resting on the table.", "question": "What kind of furniture is the wine bottle resting on?", "question_id": "131048925", "semantic": [{"argument": "wine bottle (471366)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,resting on,o (471375)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["415475"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "415475", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "415475", "relation_subject_entity_id": "415474", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "415474", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["415474"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wine bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["471375"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "471375", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "471375", "relation_subject_entity_id": "471366", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "471366", "selected_entity_name": "wine bottle"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "wine bottle", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["471366"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:7103712e68e25439f692804feb6c2d98", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "154942e324c5ac6cf01dcc46e08abd2a8c0a93527ae58bc61062d179994a4706", "image_sha256_b": "2bce716863ac2f4be7e567e467b19f5f7da3fec796a95705fff4978f1f3bff03", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "833faa1f2d7826bdf76628bcc286d17dc7a4bf7455e2e3366b5b56a1c9a51b79", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "117e226b973f170386130026c3333b5b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f48d40c9d7afa8eb3b1edd322f05a92a25ae1e1ba4b1d329d3975e6a7e31b1cc"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "eb41db64c8afd2746bcce9c2cb1222ca9a62f0c1a6046ca8ce5567ddfb8fa048", "request_id": "f4c0331ccd444bb8162df5272c513566", "response_sha256": "b00566fc3152e12a03e4ff8d943d5f09e6bca3c351384b4f76c978e7ff7ebeb4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e33fd4730362e96c117579d3fe96b1b9a1da670af3dfd9f3934f1470f401f741", "request_id": "d8da16e99be7f65a5d257bb243a0981c", "response_sha256": "9dc2d55bd66332216beb41e2644e716ea820e90fb4e3a3303064495b468508c4", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "781e3a2b58b08d63e21e720a192a7af1", "candidate_priority_rank": 97, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6d9215f943fdc9db:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6d9215f943fdc9db:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6d9215f943fdc9db:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6d9215f943fdc9db:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cat<->dog", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cat", "B": "dog"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cat<->dog", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2367693", "image_sha256": "60702c83179e2c5d4fe0f6b1826d2ad0e246bfe3ad5ec8f1658ccd2b8f6a29c8", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2367693.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2367693.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2345068", "image_sha256": "930d1fde05980e0eed4562643861fa92f7205edb32bbe129bfdcd43d13114eef", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2345068.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2345068.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-6d9215f943fdc9db", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cat", "diff_b": "dog", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cat", "component_b": "dog"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cat", "couch", "ear", "eye", "head", "mouth", "nose", "paw", "tail"], "detected_components": ["cat"], "masked_program_sha256": "018379a36fbc4a353ad0b61adc5076e4a816534943fd8690a21f208a3626fa7b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cat", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cat", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "c870bc80cabc4b668a26c24022f11231b89d0795d670ef9f5dd8d7baf0ed0c1a"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "02726240", "text": "What piece of furniture is the cat lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "carpet", "collar", "dog", "ear", "floor", "ground", "head", "label", "nose", "pillow", "tag", "tail"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "018379a36fbc4a353ad0b61adc5076e4a816534943fd8690a21f208a3626fa7b", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2cbabe2c0fd21daabc4c215cffd5f52dd6919a444b7ba97b10e2a53ab851adbb"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "07175067", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 97, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 6, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "0f49a2bfc8312224f5cb90591ca1075457c00c687e4177630b2a73757a4e96e9", "selected_component": "dog", "selected_source_question_id": "07175067", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What piece of furniture is the dog lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what piece of furniture is the lying on?", "program_group_hash": "0f49a2bfc8312224f5cb90591ca1075457c00c687e4177630b2a73757a4e96e9", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "cat"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what piece of furniture is the lying on?", "program_group_hash": "0f49a2bfc8312224f5cb90591ca1075457c00c687e4177630b2a73757a4e96e9", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "couch", "full_answer": "The cat is lying on the couch.", "question": "What piece of furniture is the cat lying on?", "question_id": "02726240", "semantic": [{"argument": "cat (621005)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o (621013)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the bed.", "question": "What piece of furniture is the dog lying on?", "question_id": "07175067", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (2024718)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,lying on,o (2888025)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["621013"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["couch"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "621013", "query_target_entity_name": "couch", "relation_object_entity_id": "621013", "relation_subject_entity_id": "621005", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "621005", "selected_entity_name": "cat"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["621005"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cat", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2888025"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["plaid"], "query_target_entity_id": "2888025", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "2888025", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2024718", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "2024718", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["2024718"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:781e3a2b58b08d63e21e720a192a7af1", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "60702c83179e2c5d4fe0f6b1826d2ad0e246bfe3ad5ec8f1658ccd2b8f6a29c8", "image_sha256_b": "930d1fde05980e0eed4562643861fa92f7205edb32bbe129bfdcd43d13114eef", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "df7d575551efcdddb8077bc073c3db26852d1ae85f78fc71819625441e15feb5", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "59bf3e7a55c9a3fffe91993519eeee27", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "f276f8cd015709551accd16cce4d03791de17e684cf7f6c3de00fd8483e57b19"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "084826193dda907283f3e5706d274f00e0b3146650117b9772543283244701cd", "request_id": "5f5f48cb0bf8974d4dca3f081525dab6", "response_sha256": "236a75a939c9326774653816f9c936ce86e1e0da0fb0304164e34c3c84d8dcc1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1727126f7bde6dcfcc5c93151a74106f0e204a5db304675c5b8af481b891fdbc", "request_id": "356351e2c6f9ddce81555a26b1bea1a0", "response_sha256": "199079d01458b880d5ea6965d005a5b527b9f510bb611e2eea42f5c94be2ae58", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "98e4ca10c9891cda74752a2f0987bf81", "candidate_priority_rank": 189, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0df663c91befe2e3:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0df663c91befe2e3:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0df663c91befe2e3:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0df663c91befe2e3:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "teddy bear<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "teddy bear", "B": "woman"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "teddy bear<->woman", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2379626", "image_sha256": "65b9759b8c623da56f5c9b741a9b0a93b81da63a6a3c568069b6be361ffbbd55", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2379626.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2379626.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2392868", "image_sha256": "b40122a8bcc7aa55743b02fe210e49b42c418b246e048fdf98d5956a2db93c81", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392868.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392868.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-0df663c91befe2e3", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "teddy bear", "diff_b": "woman", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "teddy bear", "component_b": "woman"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["beer", "ear", "glass", "head", "paper", "person", "table", "tag", "teddy bear"], "detected_components": ["teddy bear"], "masked_program_sha256": "0daf575b077a08727295a94c5d75a33ba86f0da0a2ce4e29070c39f428672504", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["teddy bear", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "teddy bear", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["teddy bear", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "3ffb8c99f4159015354c59b1bf0b555e9980b52618c25419b0d83ceb9b72cfc1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01363453", "text": "What is the item of furniture that the teddy bear is sitting on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bag", "book", "foot", "hair", "hand", "laptop", "leg", "paper", "sofa", "table", "towel", "watch", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "0daf575b077a08727295a94c5d75a33ba86f0da0a2ce4e29070c39f428672504", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "furniture"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "furniture"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e63bbd7547881657e6800203b9551252cd18d55c3476fa260fb3e1721665f3e4"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "141036262", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 189, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "81fdee507e02b869cb91dccc811b9eaa988d64f34b7d88f6e338de5f00a34f2b", "selected_component": "woman", "selected_source_question_id": "141036262", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the item of furniture that the woman is sitting on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that the is sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "81fdee507e02b869cb91dccc811b9eaa988d64f34b7d88f6e338de5f00a34f2b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "teddy bear"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the item of furniture that the is sitting on?", "program_group_hash": "81fdee507e02b869cb91dccc811b9eaa988d64f34b7d88f6e338de5f00a34f2b", "queried_category": "furniture", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "sitting on", "select_category": "woman"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "table", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a table.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that the teddy bear is sitting on?", "question_id": "01363453", "semantic": [{"argument": "teddy bear (1355819)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (1355822)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "sofa", "full_answer": "The piece of furniture is a sofa.", "question": "What is the item of furniture that the woman is sitting on?", "question_id": "141036262", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (1225152)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "furniture,sitting on,o (1225154)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1355822"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["table"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["wood"], "query_target_entity_id": "1355822", "query_target_entity_name": "table", "relation_object_entity_id": "1355822", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1355819", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1355819", "selected_entity_name": "teddy bear"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "teddy bear", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1355819"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "teddy bear", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1225154", "1225155"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["sofa"], "predicate": "sitting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "1225154", "query_target_entity_name": "sofa", "relation_object_entity_id": "1225154", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1225152", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1225152", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1225152"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:98e4ca10c9891cda74752a2f0987bf81", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "65b9759b8c623da56f5c9b741a9b0a93b81da63a6a3c568069b6be361ffbbd55", "image_sha256_b": "b40122a8bcc7aa55743b02fe210e49b42c418b246e048fdf98d5956a2db93c81", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "d83c2c9a58fa0dbf49f1f864aa9db362523b9fd50d72e385ed51bf93d76202c7", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "cb58f781db94e1fba188d8cdfd76c085", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "7ec8422e996fc9a94e4cd332176fb48a91497a49d770eb8c79bacaa90a8d2172"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "fa03ef7bcd24afc1b4e939a6bc8d2e4a35609fa31c45a3e679ea2562e526f6cc", "request_id": "60a8a8cc1cf15b856cc21b899a17206d", "response_sha256": "59666e0b0b7c3a4756699349b27f6dac440a7b2d2b1bc61302754fc10fd88947", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "a4de4e95a139e43957a6a9f6c7bbc23ff51301e9d7eddecb4a6c2361ad5a6a78", "request_id": "c9084870202084bb21a67602fbbd9be2", "response_sha256": "045aef749d71a89e30acfa7b3a7413f3d4fa5e0896ecfec2236f140c82c9d3f1", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "44a11b4a4c652cd42cb847d77596b1ea", "candidate_priority_rank": 621, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c20d841d5621b662:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c20d841d5621b662:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c20d841d5621b662:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c20d841d5621b662:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "bed<->ground", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "bed", "B": "ground"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "bed<->ground", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2399560", "image_sha256": "154942e324c5ac6cf01dcc46e08abd2a8c0a93527ae58bc61062d179994a4706", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2399560.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2399560.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 373, "image_id": "2350534", "image_sha256": "151453e7a63e2b4b30b6b9fbefb28565839b431b3258894bb2ed4beef90604f3", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2350534.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2350534.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-c20d841d5621b662", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "bed", "diff_b": "ground", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "bed", "component_b": "ground"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity", "path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "clothes", "collar", "curtain", "dog", "ear", "eye", "flower", "frame", "pillow", "sheet", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["bed"], "masked_program_sha256": "b13e44f8e4412b70e297e51c43c4cb5e60254237650037696c97be387f934cf5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bed", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bed", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "9ea2f92733a8751df52b3ed4616ae3c32f0a091406c4dd95adef76f14cb86d68"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "01968436", "text": "What animal is resting on the bed?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bear", "bush", "ears", "fence", "floor", "ground", "log", "nose", "pole", "sand", "wall"], "detected_components": ["ground"], "masked_program_sha256": "b13e44f8e4412b70e297e51c43c4cb5e60254237650037696c97be387f934cf5", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "ground", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["ground", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "711bc05c1235020c9d5a36843a2b8c049867e1e320157ede1393e3441c9eac34"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "001022851", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 621, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "aad513da51a6069004a367aaed183cf10976d38daa6eca45e93fcd5e97f34116", "selected_component": "ground", "selected_source_question_id": "001022851", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is resting on the ground?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is resting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "aad513da51a6069004a367aaed183cf10976d38daa6eca45e93fcd5e97f34116", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "bed"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is resting on the ?", "program_group_hash": "aad513da51a6069004a367aaed183cf10976d38daa6eca45e93fcd5e97f34116", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "resting on", "select_category": "ground"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The dog is resting on the bed.", "question": "What animal is resting on the bed?", "question_id": "01968436", "semantic": [{"argument": "bed (415475)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s (415474)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "bear", "full_answer": "The bear is resting on the ground.", "question": "What animal is resting on the ground?", "question_id": "001022851", "semantic": [{"argument": "ground (1922217)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,resting on,s (2567743)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["415474"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["black"], "query_target_entity_id": "415474", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "415475", "relation_subject_entity_id": "415474", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "415475", "selected_entity_name": "bed"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["415475"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bed", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2567743"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bear"], "predicate": "resting on", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["round"], "query_target_entity_id": "2567743", "query_target_entity_name": "bear", "relation_object_entity_id": "1922217", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2567743", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1922217", "selected_entity_name": "ground"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "ground", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1922217"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:44a11b4a4c652cd42cb847d77596b1ea", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "154942e324c5ac6cf01dcc46e08abd2a8c0a93527ae58bc61062d179994a4706", "image_sha256_b": "151453e7a63e2b4b30b6b9fbefb28565839b431b3258894bb2ed4beef90604f3", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "8b3d4518fdca5a21fab3ce3edf01d42f741c1e97c7a8e42d9245ae0a558d1deb", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "00f4fdf5ba7080bd67a09c69a1bb795d", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "c10a4d5829778e23dff82d07b96995cb99092f24e76ff7af188edc875d9a157a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "3cee45fb5b81d920195c10e7e9de174a51b47578a6ff40a602a21264add585b9", "request_id": "4cb909f1b26eb8e17212f41e400a0c30", "response_sha256": "2ec22089e860e51c0a5fc8a44c8745a7971aeeb46b933ab70c52992c3552247d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9bef997604223c7fee32b2043d6fb826b69df8edc4af00048c387233ffbb2713", "request_id": "1ee8465574400981b83aa830ee8ae341", "response_sha256": "ecdf86d2bfc5043ecd4a9632b207130d1d9a65378c4bf068125e943bdd03aa8d", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "774df3eb434761e85145e26f6c6aaff4", "candidate_priority_rank": 630, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7f8a4c8f89c8db23:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7f8a4c8f89c8db23:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7f8a4c8f89c8db23:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7f8a4c8f89c8db23:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "dog<->figure", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "figure", "B": "dog"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "figure<->dog", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2387182", "image_sha256": "12ae29c3617b586e0d63a6d81279739d023139f1e2e87f0fdeddb09c89651223", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2387182.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2387182.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 355, "image_id": "2412707", "image_sha256": "422130b632b9f0c2c9fee9f3645c726b4dcacb16481f53004c0500cc434a7818", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2412707.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2412707.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-7f8a4c8f89c8db23", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "figure", "diff_b": "dog", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "figure", "component_b": "dog"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": []}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["artwork", "bed", "drawer", "drawers", "figure", "floor", "headboard", "nightstand", "pillow", "sheets", "wall", "window"], "detected_components": ["figure"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["figure"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "figure", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["figure"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "473d29d1d36424d8eb7ab321937685dd05015988dc5f66cbbd64af60646d2776"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "04282754", "text": "What do you think is the figure lying on?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["carpet", "dog", "ear", "eye", "face", "foot", "legs", "nose", "paw", "shoe lace", "sneakers", "toy"], "detected_components": ["dog"], "masked_program_sha256": "240506a03681365d3641e58967b9762169b1ec8f37db0f3b1dbdb51143c956b7", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "dog", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["dog"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "46caddcfe5929f6e447f186a2bfcd9e0d42b2b1f9facb5871a061422f943eb69"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "075257", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 630, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 2, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "13006e9950464c55e8c39a4f81f6682dd2779df3dfb674bbd464094eb2469970", "selected_component": "dog", "selected_source_question_id": "075257", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What do you think is the dog lying on?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what do you think is the lying on?", "program_group_hash": "13006e9950464c55e8c39a4f81f6682dd2779df3dfb674bbd464094eb2469970", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "figure"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what do you think is the lying on?", "program_group_hash": "13006e9950464c55e8c39a4f81f6682dd2779df3dfb674bbd464094eb2469970", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "lying on", "select_category": "dog"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "bed", "full_answer": "The figure is lying on the bed.", "question": "What do you think is the figure lying on?", "question_id": "04282754", "semantic": [{"argument": "figure (678815)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (678816)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "carpet", "full_answer": "The dog is lying on the carpet.", "question": "What do you think is the dog lying on?", "question_id": "075257", "semantic": [{"argument": "dog (1618194)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,lying on,o (1618222)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["678816", "678817", "678819", "678821", "678823", "678824", "678826", "678827", "678828", "678829", "678830", "678835", "678836"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 13, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["bed"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "678816", "query_target_entity_name": "bed", "relation_object_entity_id": "678816", "relation_subject_entity_id": "678815", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "678815", "selected_entity_name": "figure"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "figure", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["678815"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "figure", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1618195", "1618197", "1618203", "1618204", "1618208", "1618217", "1618220", "1618221", "1618222", "188571", "188572", "3803464", "3803465", "3803467"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 14, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["carpet"], "predicate": "lying on", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "1618222", "query_target_entity_name": "carpet", "relation_object_entity_id": "1618222", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1618194", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1618194", "selected_entity_name": "dog"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "dog", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1618194"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:774df3eb434761e85145e26f6c6aaff4", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "12ae29c3617b586e0d63a6d81279739d023139f1e2e87f0fdeddb09c89651223", "image_sha256_b": "422130b632b9f0c2c9fee9f3645c726b4dcacb16481f53004c0500cc434a7818", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "050751841d1935258e965d7cbf748858495a54aacc5343c16e40c11fa5944021", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "60cf87448977dbfa4f117d44b59d549c", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5d8e1f329225d930b65cc7b279abff9f9a70d394ffaa15d22d79bea08efb451a"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e99fbec04b5b5c8574abd77287c73de8faae11a0bd1148dab19c7c7b42f72e30", "request_id": "5559117ee8f11304188f4b6d785246a0", "response_sha256": "5e65429b31442010f1a9d6f238b590192061c832e53017f063dea6fb44b5a42e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "1e95e86baf4cf0a5f9f19d8c2a9ec03432278c409a9599817a83541040dfd054", "request_id": "d55ee66a39c6e82791ce58124204ec2b", "response_sha256": "76d10b77087ac02cbed6e436f68b99a6fd502c134c966fdcdba0894cbf3c2a66", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "c50b2d27d4d7a7e9cef6c3d4f1220b53", "candidate_priority_rank": 632, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-028551dd1491d86e:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-028551dd1491d86e:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-028551dd1491d86e:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-028551dd1491d86e:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "airport<->bowl", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "airport", "B": "bowl"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "airport<->bowl", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 333, "image_id": "2364120", "image_sha256": "577e112a43c568b9bf06a24c35facbfc8ce2e085aba1971574150b6a34c14212", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2364120.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2364120.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 410, "image_id": "2406137", "image_sha256": "8feb400dfb23e92d26d86a444d5d1061a78a7b354f3910877f38e51bdcdead40", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2406137.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2406137.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-028551dd1491d86e", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "airport", "diff_b": "bowl", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "airport", "component_b": "bowl"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["airplane", "airport", "barrier", "door", "fence", "glasses", "man", "nose", "post", "sign", "sky", "window", "windows"], "detected_components": ["airport"], "masked_program_sha256": "07110f07685ccc99d28a4a4796620133b39612e7660dd9cb528504c31a097d63", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["airport"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "airport", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["airport"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "f38438a149b218d4a378903872ffb8f415fe3753f7f9b2ee99d012f400b8aaa5"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "12857734", "text": "What is in the airport in this picture?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bowl", "juice", "liquid", "orange", "spots", "table", "water"], "detected_components": ["bowl"], "masked_program_sha256": "07110f07685ccc99d28a4a4796620133b39612e7660dd9cb528504c31a097d63", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "bowl", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["bowl"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "de24355ca48f52c1aafcc6402567609d0de892ffb06ea95a3babdc165422174c"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "00257063", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 632, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 3, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "bfd77a4860b01ba03f5ddbf9a878e9a2a250f03460c8a2e72cea5e661b120b2d", "selected_component": "bowl", "selected_source_question_id": "00257063", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is in the bowl in this picture?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the in this picture?", "program_group_hash": "bfd77a4860b01ba03f5ddbf9a878e9a2a250f03460c8a2e72cea5e661b120b2d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "airport"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,in,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is in the in this picture?", "program_group_hash": "bfd77a4860b01ba03f5ddbf9a878e9a2a250f03460c8a2e72cea5e661b120b2d", "queried_category": "_", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "in", "select_category": "bowl"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "airplane", "full_answer": "The airplane is in the airport.", "question": "What is in the airport in this picture?", "question_id": "12857734", "semantic": [{"argument": "airport (642877)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (642872)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "orange", "full_answer": "The orange is in the bowl.", "question": "What is in the bowl in this picture?", "question_id": "00257063", "semantic": [{"argument": "bowl (326179)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "_,in,s (326178)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["642871", "642872", "642878", "642881", "642882", "642883", "642884", "642885", "642886", "642890", "642891", "642892"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 12, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["airplane"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["blue"], "query_target_entity_id": "642872", "query_target_entity_name": "airplane", "relation_object_entity_id": "642877", "relation_subject_entity_id": "642872", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "642877", "selected_entity_name": "airport"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "airport", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["642877"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "airport", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["326178", "326180", "326181", "326186", "326188", "326193"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 6, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["orange"], "predicate": "in", "queried_category_match_basis": "semantic_wildcard", "query_target_attributes": ["cut", "juicy", "sliced"], "query_target_entity_id": "326178", "query_target_entity_name": "orange", "relation_object_entity_id": "326179", "relation_subject_entity_id": "326178", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "326179", "selected_entity_name": "bowl"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "bowl", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["326179"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c50b2d27d4d7a7e9cef6c3d4f1220b53", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "577e112a43c568b9bf06a24c35facbfc8ce2e085aba1971574150b6a34c14212", "image_sha256_b": "8feb400dfb23e92d26d86a444d5d1061a78a7b354f3910877f38e51bdcdead40", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "771148b4e2052dee305ceaa5f68d04506ccb851925963602a9a3348af8519087", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1a7cef59ac70a98e6d858e050857fe4b", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "fc5fe17a98eab35065f26fbde1b59f174cc9634f193ee64d1c5e466b864b90d2"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "c4f2f92db11381fc135c2de7659508132740dae5fe8ba1005839ef88b42d2f10", "request_id": "f0cb8aa63915b16822fa01c0a1fed20c", "response_sha256": "06dac13e900ea069403f750769ae2fbf6a66443beaa7388bf82767cac05e618b", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "71dd43fdd56895012a325366f505ad244720de9dd281fcb15e37c9fae53d2076", "request_id": "c4e13357fc3ae0d4e844a1dacf38ff1b", "response_sha256": "94a12cab5fffaa30da6b28900c48d6b83ba425b1c973bb1a840bd370030c7048", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "8949a32b74f1dfc894e83fd6e9e00802", "candidate_priority_rank": 634, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1eb7876af1ee5d0b:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1eb7876af1ee5d0b:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1eb7876af1ee5d0b:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1eb7876af1ee5d0b:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2392190", "image_sha256": "b9d6fdff7e41b55f83a21861a349fc6d973772750540d6d4fde0acc4e9877de2", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2392190.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2392190.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2389771", "image_sha256": "c84584577f8437c3fdb6d8572ac5d7e1ca68d8b64e0ff20bb099e77f36a3332c", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2389771.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2389771.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1eb7876af1ee5d0b", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["banana", "eye", "hat", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "29cc42bc280f3a7721f778b3dabf97cf4b01e94b0dacf0b94a82da013c3ed76e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "fruit"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "fruit"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "936da27db4bcf7e6eb57bb70d3471e903148f97442c019b39acea020c1b7c282"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "10937566", "text": "What fruit is the woman holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["banana", "beard", "blinds", "box", "hair", "hand", "head", "leaves", "lock", "man", "nose", "plant", "planter", "pot", "shelf", "window"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "29cc42bc280f3a7721f778b3dabf97cf4b01e94b0dacf0b94a82da013c3ed76e", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "fruit"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "fruit"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "ebb70e7e748f004e1074ff2913128765fe2fbc97d8e1162c5b8a523c1da8eb1f"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "13605369", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 634, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 11, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2ad9f71eba863f489e1d3500f314fe20b4cf37fe7b48f4e70f6840c4a5055bc6", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "13605369", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What fruit is the man holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what fruit is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "2ad9f71eba863f489e1d3500f314fe20b4cf37fe7b48f4e70f6840c4a5055bc6", "queried_category": "fruit", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what fruit is the holding?", "program_group_hash": "2ad9f71eba863f489e1d3500f314fe20b4cf37fe7b48f4e70f6840c4a5055bc6", "queried_category": "fruit", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "banana", "full_answer": "The woman is holding the banana.", "question": "What fruit is the woman holding?", "question_id": "10937566", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (4106866)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,holding,o (4106758)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "banana", "full_answer": "The man is holding the banana.", "question": "What fruit is the man holding?", "question_id": "13605369", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (1257279)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "fruit,holding,o (1257278)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4106758"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["banana"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["large", "ripe"], "query_target_entity_id": "4106758", "query_target_entity_name": "banana", "relation_object_entity_id": "4106758", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4106866", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4106866", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4106866"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1257278"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["banana"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["hollow", "yellow"], "query_target_entity_id": "1257278", "query_target_entity_name": "banana", "relation_object_entity_id": "1257278", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1257279", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1257279", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1257279"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:8949a32b74f1dfc894e83fd6e9e00802", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "b9d6fdff7e41b55f83a21861a349fc6d973772750540d6d4fde0acc4e9877de2", "image_sha256_b": "c84584577f8437c3fdb6d8572ac5d7e1ca68d8b64e0ff20bb099e77f36a3332c", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "4cd935cccbe71ff86fb95d3d6350ca2d0baa1f6af200c59e85c8b15ce3091a9b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "0b712488171123af1a256ea2ebbaa6bc", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "5819cf13e5c8e00421a3d145b78ef42cde420130e71c4dc5aa2b2bfcbf008a69"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "e814166d689ca5107099a1ad1144997b321ead5d221acb01ce6005716bdeb871", "request_id": "6b440040d92a88764eaf198b4097ac1a", "response_sha256": "8747b16c0d35fd23ce6708f00c9ca746ae360ddb1a6986a306ad12a72e01cad3", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "071a83dec1d718faacc5f76652e3d62c59fe73d50fb3725e52ba27eba803a7f8", "request_id": "b597ee4d8ca94220b590497e5f6a52d3", "response_sha256": "5d27e30a65643ce8c57a3f0ab555fb0f89ab4885c9da788734dd7b69b5b8ef7e", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "f66a3e9409c77215892f67ee35b95aec", "candidate_priority_rank": 639, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b6ec81846668e0ac:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b6ec81846668e0ac:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b6ec81846668e0ac:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b6ec81846668e0ac:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "basket<->person", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "person", "B": "basket"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "person<->basket", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2402283", "image_sha256": "ef88a8db9dfcb3f7ca61996188feb1b7cc4e52c56aaa3ff630560da0ef2ca363", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2402283.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2402283.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2355097", "image_sha256": "c20e2c195328a7b3d348e9f497a8917f17499d0b6340403d8cc57904dda8d7d4", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2355097.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2355097.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-b6ec81846668e0ac", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "person", "diff_b": "basket", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "person", "component_b": "basket"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["donut", "finger", "person", "table", "thumb"], "detected_components": ["person"], "masked_program_sha256": "ac51012c54e37bb3a20f5c07990f2a2be49e00d50e5b799c4819e82cc048d32c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "person", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["person"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "fe2334364e6a9fd7b95669195ce94031b06c04c10263d70fda3f28baea3442b1"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "14776134", "text": "What is the food that the person is holding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["basket", "cream", "donut", "donuts", "drawing", "frosting", "glass", "grass", "icing", "letter", "paper", "sign", "sprinkles"], "detected_components": ["basket"], "masked_program_sha256": "ac51012c54e37bb3a20f5c07990f2a2be49e00d50e5b799c4819e82cc048d32c", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "basket", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["basket"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "0b60cb6b3873937f7a8906394f4f5af49e2ccf8ef80f9a121ab50bcfd56d1003"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "12370614", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 639, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 4, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "9e815d25d20efe3c97a4f3dd128f7d4cb8f5822055850bb0bc24d88cea0c34fb", "selected_component": "basket", "selected_source_question_id": "12370614", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What is the food that the basket is holding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food that the is holding?", "program_group_hash": "9e815d25d20efe3c97a4f3dd128f7d4cb8f5822055850bb0bc24d88cea0c34fb", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "person"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,holding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what is the food that the is holding?", "program_group_hash": "9e815d25d20efe3c97a4f3dd128f7d4cb8f5822055850bb0bc24d88cea0c34fb", "queried_category": "baked good", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "holding", "select_category": "basket"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "donut", "full_answer": "The food is a donut.", "question": "What is the food that the person is holding?", "question_id": "14776134", "semantic": [{"argument": "person (1138114)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,holding,o (1138111)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "donuts", "full_answer": "The food is donuts.", "question": "What is the food that the basket is holding?", "question_id": "12370614", "semantic": [{"argument": "basket (832850)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "baked good,holding,o (832865)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["1138111"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["donut"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "cooked", "frosted", "soft"], "query_target_entity_id": "1138111", "query_target_entity_name": "donut", "relation_object_entity_id": "1138111", "relation_subject_entity_id": "1138114", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "1138114", "selected_entity_name": "person"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "person", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["1138114"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "person", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["832844", "832865"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 2, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["donuts"], "predicate": "holding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "832865", "query_target_entity_name": "donuts", "relation_object_entity_id": "832865", "relation_subject_entity_id": "832850", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "832850", "selected_entity_name": "basket"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "basket", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["832850"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:f66a3e9409c77215892f67ee35b95aec", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "ef88a8db9dfcb3f7ca61996188feb1b7cc4e52c56aaa3ff630560da0ef2ca363", "image_sha256_b": "c20e2c195328a7b3d348e9f497a8917f17499d0b6340403d8cc57904dda8d7d4", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "3585a1966d529c08b0d631a7cce866a96e7ea4e7017f2e92824bf308866debb9", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "3ea22e6b5193b68a045f81c09aea3cc6", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "509b8f9cab18dae08f20aaf224538fff3c2e69b3c7a466663acac43f91eac89e"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "92439f889f620fdf21cc7ee1d927663abc0afe75b19233914d361bf1cb7bc6c0", "request_id": "b51980b7e0394b350851ad32dca4f6e9", "response_sha256": "0b220557505cb1bbc1f56fa7ddf8038cd738ef724e37bf2939d3b0b26ef06fca", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "5ced2a671046e0e871bdb63584bd4dd6e690adcb74d236fce54340940f2c7c0f", "request_id": "882aa4dccd9235a937a0105e7ea78585", "response_sha256": "5f0a0e6eb584d12827127c34fc3311f511e1365206ee656eebf8336077a786db", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "5bc1d4096bd4704551b1a97f479e0779", "candidate_priority_rank": 643, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cee2d655be10be79:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cee2d655be10be79:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cee2d655be10be79:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cee2d655be10be79:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "suitcase<->toilet", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "suitcase", "B": "toilet"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "suitcase<->toilet", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2395173", "image_sha256": "6758ffb473654b0f933592624b4ca383a3f98cd11c55a45138fe4514ad8207bd", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2395173.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2395173.jpg", "width": 375}, "B": {"height": 500, "image_id": "2319038", "image_sha256": "831ac4739bea70c83932d44f8f8d9d69c28bd84464c2377eac528b19ea303fee", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2319038.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2319038.jpg", "width": 375}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-cee2d655be10be79", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "suitcase", "diff_b": "toilet", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "suitcase", "component_b": "toilet"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["blanket", "cat", "couch", "dresser", "ears", "floor", "gadget", "nose", "pen", "pillow", "rug", "suitcase", "table", "tail"], "detected_components": ["suitcase"], "masked_program_sha256": "d14a4e5a4497aa434d7b11715d8a4beb5dee0b8add4e92126d9f998a9ac3d434", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["suitcase", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "suitcase", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["suitcase", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "dd7f2afb10eac3c4926f12633c5ab88f48175cf7cf23b2107e9dc1be83291afd"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "08522010", "text": "What animal is sitting on top of the suitcase?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["dog", "ear", "eye", "head", "legs", "nose", "paw", "pipe", "toilet", "toilet lid", "wall"], "detected_components": ["toilet"], "masked_program_sha256": "d14a4e5a4497aa434d7b11715d8a4beb5dee0b8add4e92126d9f998a9ac3d434", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["toilet", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "toilet", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["toilet", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "2a364f180e8c1fe0a7699e29f55d2d03c632a1e3c308f48225ede563bc3983da"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "10172863", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 643, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 1, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "67ae778dee900ce4a4f476450cc21eab65684b8ee1d1a62afdbbfd0d683ada83", "selected_component": "toilet", "selected_source_question_id": "10172863", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is sitting on top of the toilet?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sitting on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is sitting on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "67ae778dee900ce4a4f476450cc21eab65684b8ee1d1a62afdbbfd0d683ada83", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting on top of", "select_category": "suitcase"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sitting on top of,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is sitting on top of the ?", "program_group_hash": "67ae778dee900ce4a4f476450cc21eab65684b8ee1d1a62afdbbfd0d683ada83", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "sitting on top of", "select_category": "toilet"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The animal is a cat.", "question": "What animal is sitting on top of the suitcase?", "question_id": "08522010", "semantic": [{"argument": "suitcase (457227)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sitting on top of,s (457223)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "dog", "full_answer": "The animal is a dog.", "question": "What animal is sitting on top of the toilet?", "question_id": "10172863", "semantic": [{"argument": "toilet (4048881)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,sitting on top of,s (4048866)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "val_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["457223"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "sitting on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown", "small", "tabby"], "query_target_entity_id": "457223", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "457227", "relation_subject_entity_id": "457223", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "457227", "selected_entity_name": "suitcase"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "suitcase", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["457227"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "toilet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "suitcase", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["4048866"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["dog"], "predicate": "sitting on top of", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["fluffy"], "query_target_entity_id": "4048866", "query_target_entity_name": "dog", "relation_object_entity_id": "4048881", "relation_subject_entity_id": "4048866", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "4048881", "selected_entity_name": "toilet"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "toilet", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["4048881"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:5bc1d4096bd4704551b1a97f479e0779", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "6758ffb473654b0f933592624b4ca383a3f98cd11c55a45138fe4514ad8207bd", "image_sha256_b": "831ac4739bea70c83932d44f8f8d9d69c28bd84464c2377eac528b19ea303fee", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "871e3f0a95f17f43cdc94d26530eda6c5f32029f43fe674c46ba21ca1cd2544a", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "9c4451fbfb3dee116408ce048f8fc9d5", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "ef62e157b7db6e6dafefb695f0d187e8130f2dd561fdfc8596698500f64eb3a0"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "4d8aafb63207453c4b515821fd7860c28ca7e3661f1ce26c08f06d4e7367d149", "request_id": "8eff4bedd70fafa717f0cdda2280ffc5", "response_sha256": "47145533cb428130fb74d4c6e5fe0032134321ef68d71930aa732471d407f471", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "9406b08bb04665774d0997b4a2def76b91ce7c4c76e277cab86a7f8287d75e83", "request_id": "b72e2ebed14c5f1636ab2f98428365db", "response_sha256": "b70d3f86fc3547e0e2804a12bab1ead2ddfc9bde21bc597bf57fba11d52905ab", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "c20860df3ea954d01a0fc9e449ab2abe", "candidate_priority_rank": 644, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a9ddc815bba6044:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a9ddc815bba6044:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a9ddc815bba6044:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a9ddc815bba6044:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "cupboard<->suitcase", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "cupboard", "B": "suitcase"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "cupboard<->suitcase", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2416054", "image_sha256": "3a2e118f830887a8b5f2fd859e2595605fd2c00c89757653b7b4426e368fdd60", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2416054.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2416054.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 375, "image_id": "2414640", "image_sha256": "50544f9b89f4a78dadaddb2e72835238314a610219c5a5191668081db434f68f", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2414640.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2414640.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-1a9ddc815bba6044", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "cupboard", "diff_b": "suitcase", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "cupboard", "component_b": "suitcase"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["cabinet", "cat", "cup", "cupboard", "dishes", "door", "ear", "ears", "eye", "face", "glass", "nose", "paw", "shelf", "shelves"], "detected_components": ["cupboard"], "masked_program_sha256": "cb23709d6793bfaaa4170a0b0b275ce71e7b117f71a51970c7333989ef347ce6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["cupboard", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "cupboard", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["cupboard", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "8bbb995403273bf54a41c28ef5509ed287f2e275100ea904a35f674c60fc79b3"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "06952187", "text": "What animal do you think is inside the cupboard?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["bed", "cat", "ear", "eye", "nose", "pillow", "suitcase"], "detected_components": ["suitcase"], "masked_program_sha256": "cb23709d6793bfaaa4170a0b0b275ce71e7b117f71a51970c7333989ef347ce6", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["suitcase", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "suitcase", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["suitcase", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "aa0266f7587aa3c5a991e2e753cfe833dc7fcaf47ba6a6d9c16680628dc161af"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "04717756", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 644, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 0, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "e14fa4291abade4b160b6996576edd12e565e53a1ebe7b207dddfe6928fa0b13", "selected_component": "suitcase", "selected_source_question_id": "04717756", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal do you think is inside the suitcase?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal do you think is inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "e14fa4291abade4b160b6996576edd12e565e53a1ebe7b207dddfe6928fa0b13", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "cupboard"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,inside,s", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal do you think is inside the ?", "program_group_hash": "e14fa4291abade4b160b6996576edd12e565e53a1ebe7b207dddfe6928fa0b13", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "s", "relation_predicate": "inside", "select_category": "suitcase"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is inside the cupboard.", "question": "What animal do you think is inside the cupboard?", "question_id": "06952187", "semantic": [{"argument": "cupboard (3544970)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,inside,s (2823730)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "cat", "full_answer": "The cat is inside the suitcase.", "question": "What animal do you think is inside the suitcase?", "question_id": "04717756", "semantic": [{"argument": "suitcase (154817)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,inside,s (154816)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "train_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["2823730"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": [], "query_target_entity_id": "2823730", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "3544970", "relation_subject_entity_id": "2823730", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "3544970", "selected_entity_name": "cupboard"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cupboard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["3544970"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "suitcase", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "cupboard", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["154816"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["cat"], "predicate": "inside", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["furry", "striped"], "query_target_entity_id": "154816", "query_target_entity_name": "cat", "relation_object_entity_id": "154817", "relation_subject_entity_id": "154816", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "154817", "selected_entity_name": "suitcase"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "suitcase", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["154817"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:c20860df3ea954d01a0fc9e449ab2abe", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "3a2e118f830887a8b5f2fd859e2595605fd2c00c89757653b7b4426e368fdd60", "image_sha256_b": "50544f9b89f4a78dadaddb2e72835238314a610219c5a5191668081db434f68f", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "54d71a46ee230accc02c5d52a89669f2b23aa62d0344967ebd70cd41321bafab", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "1cc668c071a6283c3799ccbe497c95bb", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "b65f545157418434b063af9b95f1b7397ddd790d106054886518d28a488ea270"}} +{"answer_generation_provenance": {"AB": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "89b96b3cfbc2dce603ac4c0a3108eaadf1c7352f32263ded9e7483b6655c7cfe", "request_id": "fdc3b19a273f8a8351838dcd95181ad9", "response_sha256": "d2132c0962df7ff1d4343dd5671ef59317d68382053f4d5a30b9358ce2f64ad6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}, "BA": {"api_used": true, "method": "MMMC_Appendix_B.1.3_answer_generation", "request_body_sha256": "ff4d101b4ffab452273da8cf4d1315812444dec257dbf9e764b3d4bde6e54c5d", "request_id": "1dee616dbf13f6a4d8f13657b7499c48", "response_sha256": "5cd619bb0fd738937132652f24f0ef1e98f9643084d94caba85504243f5ea5a6", "retry_count": 0, "template_block_id": "answer_generation", "template_sha256": "009a6a0426c4c2e1c620a950d1da778a02e99a6df4c8a90ee04387702c15c189"}}, "answer_target_distinct_from_modified_component": true, "api_base_url_host": "127.0.0.1", "api_model": "ep-20260506214350-vvx5p", "candidate_key": "fbca105e20adc0fc08654938ac01c856", "candidate_priority_rank": 647, "cell_ids": ["cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e224ffacca399b91:v7_4_scale300:AA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e224ffacca399b91:v7_4_scale300:AB", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e224ffacca399b91:v7_4_scale300:BA", "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e224ffacca399b91:v7_4_scale300:BB"], "component_family": "man<->woman", "component_is_answer_slot": false, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "components": {"A": "woman", "B": "man"}, "cross_reference_absence_scopes": {"AB": ["entity", "path"], "BA": ["entity", "path"]}, "cross_reference_validation": {"AB": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, "BA": {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}}, "dataset_status": "PASS_UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL_AUTOMATED_QUALITY_NOT_GOLD", "deterministic_gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "diversity_cap_provenance": {"adaptive_finite_schedule": true, "component_family_cap": 10, "phase": 0, "program_group_template_cap": 10}, "family": "woman<->man", "future_split_policy": "image_connected_group_atomic_80_10_10", "gold_claimed": false, "human_review": {"mode": "calibration_and_exception_only", "required": false}, "images": {"A": {"height": 334, "image_id": "2414858", "image_sha256": "5bef0497f16b169c8851ea3b32b9e82c62ada61daed7b7afdffb95028c451bed", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2414858.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "val", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K_2/2414858.jpg", "width": 500}, "B": {"height": 332, "image_id": "2328736", "image_sha256": "ba099ec265ea38eddad965041903a76947a8e95e7d86b88b2b6c4880b94e8e29", "local_path": "/mnt/bn/embodied-lf/masiyuan/ConflictOrbit-data/workspace_phase1/image_cache/2328736.jpg", "raw_scene_graph_split": "train", "vg_url": "https://cs.stanford.edu/people/rak248/VG_100K/2328736.jpg", "width": 500}}, "intent_family": "entity_identity", "leakage_group_id": "PENDING_GLOBAL_IMAGE_COMPONENT_MERGE", "llm_api_used": true, "official_test_used": false, "pair_id": "cgrp-next-v7-4-scale300-object-e224ffacca399b91", "pool_role": "UNSPLIT_EVALUATION_POOL", "quality_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300", "quality_gates": {"decisions": [{"details": {"observed": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}}, "gate": "four_cell_matrix", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {}, "gate": "question_observability", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"diff_a": "woman", "diff_b": "man", "diff_block_count": 1}, "gate": "single_component_substitution", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"component_a": "woman", "component_b": "man"}, "gate": "conflict_ontology", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qA", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"aligned_path_count": 1, "crossed_path_count": 0, "multiplicity_mode": "single"}, "gate": "unique_grounding_qB", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "ranked_locator_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"applicable": false}, "gate": "cross_directional_geometry", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["path"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}, {"details": {"required_absence_scopes": ["entity"]}, "gate": "cross_reference_scope", "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "reason": "pass"}], "gate_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_quality_gates.v1", "passed": true, "rejection_reasons": []}, "quality_level": "AUTOMATED_RULE_AND_GPT_VISUAL_PASS_NOT_GOLD", "query_role": "name", "question_intent": "entity_identity:name", "question_prefix": "What", "questions": {"qA": {"generation_role": "source_original", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["antenna", "bottle", "ear", "elephant", "eye", "fence", "hair", "hand", "jacket", "mouth", "nose", "pants", "radio", "sticker", "trunk", "woman"], "detected_components": ["woman"], "masked_program_sha256": "921baee786cb982ec4c7cd80b5a9e4f2cc8b7c64a7be30fc5e2358dbaa254394", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "woman", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["woman", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "e2f64f972578c8b2a993d76865e62ce0e2a80eddddd370b5d5b71773e66d4282"}, "question_alignment_side": "A", "source_question_id": "00296230", "text": "What animal is the woman feeding?"}, "qB": {"generation_role": "source_original_retrieved_by_masked_component_slot", "key_component_detection": {"api_used": false, "candidate_words": ["ear", "eye", "giraffe", "hat", "head", "leaves", "man", "mouth", "t-shirt", "tongue", "tree"], "detected_components": ["man"], "masked_program_sha256": "921baee786cb982ec4c7cd80b5a9e4f2cc8b7c64a7be30fc5e2358dbaa254394", "matched_semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "animal"], "method": "semantic_program_component_detection.v1", "other_detected_typed_components_preserved": [], "selected_component_from_semantic_slot": "man", "selected_component_surface_occurrences": 1, "semantic_program_slot_count": 1, "semantic_subject_anchors": ["man", "animal"], "source_original_qa": true, "source_question_sha256": "b165b8c46407a0af0416cb69d0f2d5edad80707fb44c96caa573f679981143c8"}, "question_alignment_side": "B", "source_question_id": "02526439", "source_slot_retrieval": {"api_used": false, "b1_3_execution_version": "parallel_ab_ba_deterministic_merge.v1", "candidate_priority_rank": 647, "execution_policy_version": "conflict_orbit_v7_4_scale300_efficiency.v4", "masked_program_equal": true, "masked_surface_equal": true, "max_qb_per_origin": 64, "method": "v7_4_scale300_source_slot_priority_manifest.v1", "origin_qb_rank": 8, "pre_api_gate_version": "v7_4_scale300_pre_api_risk_gates_2026_08_15.v1", "program_group_hash": "2f5d32bee3ed41a9fbea8e3153e5ece04ce03b2d6e23012a9ec5685afb411c1d", "selected_component": "man", "selected_source_question_id": "02526439", "source_original_only": true, "static_recomputed_online": true}, "text": "What animal is the man feeding?"}}, "schema_version": "cgrp_vl_next.conflict_orbit_pair.v7_4_scale300", "semantic_program_contract": {"answer_target_is_downstream_of_component": true, "masked_program_equal": true, "object_relation_explicit_in_surface": true, "qA": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,feeding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is the feeding?", "program_group_hash": "2f5d32bee3ed41a9fbea8e3153e5ece04ce03b2d6e23012a9ec5685afb411c1d", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "feeding", "select_category": "woman"}, "qB": {"attribute_axis": null, "component_role": "presupposed_object_condition", "intent_family": "entity_identity", "masked_program": [{"argument": "", "component_slot": true, "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,feeding,o", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "component_slot": false, "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "masked_surface": "what animal is the feeding?", "program_group_hash": "2f5d32bee3ed41a9fbea8e3153e5ece04ce03b2d6e23012a9ec5685afb411c1d", "queried_category": "animal", "query_role": "name", "relation_direction": "o", "relation_predicate": "feeding", "select_category": "man"}, "single_component_slot_only": true}, "source_families": ["VG/GQA"], "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_qa": {"qA": {"answer": "elephant", "full_answer": "The woman is feeding the elephant.", "question": "What animal is the woman feeding?", "question_id": "00296230", "semantic": [{"argument": "woman (150507)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,feeding,o (150508)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "val_balanced"}, "qB": {"answer": "giraffe", "full_answer": "The man is feeding the giraffe.", "question": "What animal is the man feeding?", "question_id": "02526439", "semantic": [{"argument": "man (976406)", "dependencies": [], "operation": "select"}, {"argument": "animal,feeding,o (976403)", "dependencies": [0], "operation": "relate"}, {"argument": "name", "dependencies": [1], "operation": "query"}], "source_dataset": "GQA v1.2 balanced", "source_family": "VG/GQA", "source_original_natural_qa": true, "split": "train_balanced"}}, "source_question_and_answer_verbatim": true, "source_split_provenance": {"qA": "val_balanced", "qB": "train_balanced"}, "support_evidence": {"A": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["150508"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["elephant"], "predicate": "feeding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["baby", "drinking", "gray", "grey", "happy", "small", "young"], "query_target_entity_id": "150508", "query_target_entity_name": "elephant", "relation_object_entity_id": "150508", "relation_subject_entity_id": "150507", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "150507", "selected_entity_name": "woman"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["150507"], "supported": true}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}}, "B": {"qA": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": [], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 0, "matched_path_count": 0, "matched_paths": [], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "woman", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 0, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": [], "supported": false}, "qB": {"endpoint_candidate_entity_ids": ["976403"], "endpoint_candidates_scanned": 1, "matched_path_count": 1, "matched_paths": [{"answer_values": ["giraffe"], "predicate": "feeding", "queried_category_match_basis": "source_derived_category_membership", "query_target_attributes": ["brown"], "query_target_entity_id": "976403", "query_target_entity_name": "giraffe", "relation_object_entity_id": "976403", "relation_subject_entity_id": "976406", "selected_category_match_basis": "exact_category", "selected_entity_id": "976406", "selected_entity_name": "man"}], "matched_paths_truncated": false, "pair_type": "object", "question_component": "man", "rule": "all_instance_role_constrained_semantic_path_v7_4_strict", "select_candidates_scanned": 1, "selected_candidate_entity_ids": ["976406"], "supported": true}}}, "support_matrix": {"A": {"qA": true, "qB": false}, "B": {"qA": false, "qB": true}}, "text_generation_mode": "source_semantic_detection_source_slot_retrieval_and_mmmc_b1_3_api", "text_llm_api_used": true, "type": "object", "usage_claim_owner": "v7_4_scale300:object:fbca105e20adc0fc08654938ac01c856", "visual_validation": {"acceptance_mode": "strict", "acceptance_policy": "v7_4_scale300_sol_controlled_single_exception.v2", "accepted": true, "api_key_recorded": false, "cache_hit": false, "confidence": 0.98, "controlled_exception": null, "controlled_exception_policy": null, "endpoint_host": "127.0.0.1", "historical_cache_endpoint_host": null, "historical_exact_cache_reused": false, "image_sha256_a": "5bef0497f16b169c8851ea3b32b9e82c62ada61daed7b7afdffb95028c451bed", "image_sha256_b": "ba099ec265ea38eddad965041903a76947a8e95e7d86b88b2b6c4880b94e8e29", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-24", "prompt_sha256": "ddd6f6a40d078517a82d1c80f8292d0870678eadab40e8304f3661663c40aac4", "prompt_version": "conflict-orbit-v7.4-scale300-labeled-images-2026-08-13.1", "qa_sha256": "c19e1f7c067b88fa1e7fe1b07ac040c53fcd3e1067e7072aa625c9eee75c3b7b", "rejection_code": null, "request_id": "6ee2742775fc04f9cc565673bb2f89d0", "strict_accepted": true, "strict_confidence": 0.98, "strict_rejection_code": null, "strict_uncertain": false, "uncertain": false, "validation_key": "a5324481ea719ac916cd008a6170c311b19166514e150ee0216b55c36e6e6e82"}}