Hyy279279 commited on
Commit
3583cc2
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): bd6e982

Update set_046/set_046_黄誉扬.json

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. set_046/set_046_黄誉扬.json +100 -100
set_046/set_046_黄誉扬.json CHANGED
@@ -1,101 +1,101 @@
1
- {
2
- "set_id": "set_046",
3
- "annotator": "黄誉扬",
4
- "qa_pairs": [
5
- {
6
- "id": 1,
7
- "domain": "Culture",
8
- "task_type": {
9
- "L1": "III. Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
10
- "L2": "6. Integrated Summarization",
11
- "L3": "(2) Comparative Summarization"
12
- },
13
- "question": "Comparing Video A and Video B, what is the essential difference in narrative perspective when describing the original intention of Starship development?",
14
- "options": {
15
- "A": "Video A takes the perspective of an 'interstellar civilization builder', viewing Starship as a necessary insurance for the survival of the human species; Video B takes the perspective of an 'industry observer', viewing it as the disruption and challenge of private capital to the traditional aerospace field.",
16
- "B": "Video A focuses on how to make money through Mars colonization, while Video B focuses on how to save money through Mars colonization.",
17
- "C": "Both videos regard SpaceX as just a branch of NASA, except Video A thinks the branch is more important.",
18
- "D": "Video A targets professional engineers, while Video B targets science fiction readers."
19
- },
20
- "answer": "A",
21
- "evidence": [],
22
- "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:14:42.152477"
23
- },
24
- {
25
- "id": 2,
26
- "domain": "Culture",
27
- "task_type": {
28
- "L1": "III. Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
29
- "L2": "6. Integrated Summarization",
30
- "L3": "(2) Comparative Summarization"
31
- },
32
- "question": "Video A deeply discusses the structural simplification of the Raptor 3 engine, while Video B mostly shows protests or external comments at the launch site. What difference in focus does this reflect between the two?",
33
- "options": {
34
- "A": "Video A believes the launch site is safe, while Video B believes the launch site is dangerous.",
35
- "B": "Video A focuses on the engineering empirical logic of 'How to build'; Video B focuses on the social evaluation logic of 'Why the debate'.",
36
- "C": "Video A conceals the cost, while Video B exaggerates the cost.",
37
- "D": "Both videos focus on the engine; Video A uses Chinese while Video B uses English."
38
- },
39
- "answer": "B",
40
- "evidence": [],
41
- "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:15:19.719468"
42
- },
43
- {
44
- "id": 3,
45
- "domain": "Culture",
46
- "task_type": {
47
- "L1": "III. Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
48
- "L2": "6. Integrated Summarization",
49
- "L3": "(2) Comparative Summarization"
50
- },
51
- "question": "Regarding the ambitious goal of 'achieving Mars landing by 2027', what is the divergence in the 'tone of trust' presented by Video A and Video B?",
52
- "options": {
53
- "A": "Video A admits it cannot achieve the goal, while Video B encourages the audience to trust SpaceX.",
54
- "B": "Both videos believe people can live on Mars by 2025 with no disagreement.",
55
- "C": "Video A's timeline is randomly generated, while Video B's timeline is legally certified.",
56
- "D": "Video A shows 'activist urgency', supporting the rationality of the timeline by listing capacity improvements; Video B shows 'prudent skepticism', reminding the audience of risks by reviewing repeated delays in aerospace history."
57
- },
58
- "answer": "D",
59
- "evidence": [],
60
- "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:15:46.046616"
61
- },
62
- {
63
- "id": 4,
64
- "domain": "Culture",
65
- "task_type": {
66
- "L1": "III. Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
67
- "L2": "6. Integrated Summarization",
68
- "L3": "(2) Comparative Summarization"
69
- },
70
- "question": "Observing the live speech footage in Video A and the historical archive clips in Video B, how do their audiovisual languages serve their respective positions?",
71
- "options": {
72
- "A": "Video A uses a lot of Hollywood special effects, while Video B is entirely hand-drawn comics.",
73
- "B": "Video A has extremely noisy sound, while Video B has extremely quiet sound.",
74
- "C": "Video A inspires the audience's admiration for technological breakthroughs through the 'realism of industrial scenes'; Video B places SpaceX in the grand political narrative coordinate through the 'contrast of Cold War competition'.",
75
- "D": "Video A focuses on shooting the sky, while Video B focuses on shooting the ground."
76
- },
77
- "answer": "C",
78
- "evidence": [],
79
- "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:16:13.347811"
80
- },
81
- {
82
- "id": 5,
83
- "domain": "Culture",
84
- "task_type": {
85
- "L1": "III. Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
86
- "L2": "6. Integrated Summarization",
87
- "L3": "(2) Comparative Summarization"
88
- },
89
- "question": "Regarding the classic question 'Why not solve Earth's problems first?', what is the difference in treatment between Video A and Video B?",
90
- "options": {
91
- "A": "Video A claims Earth has been destroyed, while Video B claims Earth never existed.",
92
- "B": "Both videos believe the only way to solve Earth's problems is to launch more Starlink satellites.",
93
- "C": "Video A calls for donations, while Video B calls for strikes.",
94
- "D": "Video A treats it as the ultimate logic that 'a species should not put all eggs in one basket' and directly skips social debates; Video B takes it as one of the core contradictions, conducting multi-party interviews and presenting the value divide between capital expansion and livelihood priority."
95
- },
96
- "answer": "D",
97
- "evidence": [],
98
- "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:16:41.403021"
99
- }
100
- ]
101
  }
 
1
+ {
2
+ "set_id": "set_046",
3
+ "annotator": "黄誉扬",
4
+ "qa_pairs": [
5
+ {
6
+ "id": 1,
7
+ "domain": "Culture",
8
+ "task_type": {
9
+ "L1": "Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
10
+ "L2": "Integrated Summarization",
11
+ "L3": "Comparative Summarization"
12
+ },
13
+ "question": "Comparing Video A and Video B, what is the essential difference in narrative perspective when describing the original intention of Starship development?",
14
+ "options": {
15
+ "A": "Video A focuses on the future scenario of Starship realizing large-scale manned Mars landing and building a permanent base, while Video B emphasizes its role in reducing commercial launch costs and seizing the global satellite launch market share",
16
+ "B": "Video A takes the perspective of an industry observer, seeing it as private capital's disruption to traditional aerospace; Video B takes the perspective of an interstellar civilization builder, seeing Starship as a guarantee for human survival",
17
+ "C": "Video A takes the perspective of an interstellar civilization builder, seeing Starship as a guarantee for human survival; Video B takes the perspective of an industry observer, seeing it as private capital's disruption to traditional aerospace",
18
+ "D": "Video A analyzes Starship from an industry perspective, regarding it as a subversion of the traditional aerospace pattern and a challenge brought by commercial capital; Video B interprets its R&D original intention from the perspective of human interstellar migration, taking it as a key project to ensure the long-term survival and continuation of human civilization"
19
+ },
20
+ "answer": "C",
21
+ "evidence": [],
22
+ "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:14:42.152477"
23
+ },
24
+ {
25
+ "id": 2,
26
+ "domain": "Culture",
27
+ "task_type": {
28
+ "L1": "Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
29
+ "L2": "Integrated Summarization",
30
+ "L3": "Comparative Summarization"
31
+ },
32
+ "question": "What core difference in thematic focus is reflected between the different content selections of Video A and Video B?",
33
+ "options": {
34
+ "A": "Video A pays attention to the thrust performance and fuel efficiency indicators of the engine, while Video B criticizes the noise and ecological pollution caused by the launch site",
35
+ "B": "Video A focuses on the engineering empirical logic of 'How to build'; Video B focuses on the social evaluation logic of 'Why the debate'.",
36
+ "C": "Video A focuses on the social evaluation logic of 'Why the debate'; Video B focuses on the engineering empirical logic of 'How to build'",
37
+ "D": "Video A criticizes the noise and ecological pollution caused by the launch site, while Video B pays attention to the thrust performance and fuel efficiency indicators of the engine"
38
+ },
39
+ "answer": "B",
40
+ "evidence": [],
41
+ "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:15:19.719468"
42
+ },
43
+ {
44
+ "id": 3,
45
+ "domain": "Culture",
46
+ "task_type": {
47
+ "L1": "Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
48
+ "L2": "Integrated Summarization",
49
+ "L3": "Comparative Summarization"
50
+ },
51
+ "question": "Regarding the ambitious goal of 'achieving Mars landing by 2027', based on the content and tone of the two videos, what might be the possible difference in perspectives between Video A and Video B?",
52
+ "options": {
53
+ "A": "Video A emphasizes the pioneering significance of the Mars landing goal for human space exploration; Video B focuses more on the practical value of such projects for Earth's aerospace technology iteration",
54
+ "B": "Video A focuses more on the practical value of such projects for Earth's aerospace technology iteration; Video B emphasizes the pioneering significance of the Mars landing goal for human space exploration",
55
+ "C": "Video A tends to focus on potential risks and challenges, holding a prudent view on the 2027 timetable; Video B tends to affirm technical progress, believing it improves the feasibility of the schedule",
56
+ "D": "Video A tends to affirm technical progress, believing it improves the feasibility of the 2027 timetable; Video B tends to focus on potential risks and challenges, holding a prudent and objective view on the goal"
57
+ },
58
+ "answer": "D",
59
+ "evidence": [],
60
+ "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:15:46.046616"
61
+ },
62
+ {
63
+ "id": 4,
64
+ "domain": "Culture",
65
+ "task_type": {
66
+ "L1": "Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
67
+ "L2": "Integrated Summarization",
68
+ "L3": "Comparative Summarization"
69
+ },
70
+ "question": "By comparing the audiovisual materials of Video A and Video B, how do their respective audiovisual languages serve their positions?",
71
+ "options": {
72
+ "A": "Video A creates a passionate and forward-looking atmosphere with bright tones and tight editing; Video B renders a calm and reflective tone with steady narration and gentle rhythm",
73
+ "B": "Video A renders a calm and reflective tone with steady narration and gentle rhythm; Video B creates a passionate and forward-looking atmosphere with bright tones and tight editing",
74
+ "C": "Video A mainly presents on-site speeches and industrial pictures to highlight the progress of space technology; Video B mostly uses historical archive clips to interpret the project from a longitudinal historical perspective",
75
+ "D": "Video A mostly uses historical archive clips to interpret the project from a longitudinal historical perspective; Video B mainly presents on-site speeches and industrial pictures to highlight the progress of space technology."
76
+ },
77
+ "answer": "C",
78
+ "evidence": [],
79
+ "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:16:13.347811"
80
+ },
81
+ {
82
+ "id": 5,
83
+ "domain": "Culture",
84
+ "task_type": {
85
+ "L1": "Cross-Video Integrated Reasoning",
86
+ "L2": "Integrated Summarization",
87
+ "L3": "Comparative Summarization"
88
+ },
89
+ "question": "Regarding the classic question 'Why not solve Earth's problems first?', what is the difference in treatment between Video A and Video B?",
90
+ "options": {
91
+ "A": "Video A believes that space exploration can promote technological progress to indirectly deal with Earth’s problems and has no intention to get entangled in related social disputes, while Video B insists that global livelihood issues should be prioritized over costly space programs",
92
+ "B": "Video A insists that global livelihood issues should be prioritized over costly space programs, while Video B believes that space exploration can promote technological progress to indirectly deal with Earths problems and has no intention to get entangled in related social disputes",
93
+ "C": "Video A takes this question as a core conflict and shows the value divide via multi-party interviews; Video B bypasses social disputes with the logic of not putting all eggs in one basket",
94
+ "D": "Video A bypasses social disputes with the logic of not putting all eggs in one basket; Video B takes this question as a core conflict and shows the value divide via multi-party interviews"
95
+ },
96
+ "answer": "D",
97
+ "evidence": [],
98
+ "created_at": "2026-02-25T21:16:41.403021"
99
+ }
100
+ ]
101
  }