{ "n_traces": 28, "n_included": 28, "cohort_counts": { "primary": 28 }, "n_excluded": 0, "exclusions": {}, "cells_covered": 28, "means": { "accuracy": 0.4427275183445601, "wall_h": 5.611071428571429, "api_s": 0.0, "turns": 493.9642857142857, "tool_calls": 161.28571428571428, "output_tokens": 92111.85714285714, "cost_usd": 0.0, "n_eval_calls": 24.142857142857142, "n_observed_scores": 14.178571428571429, "n_distinct_model_versions": 15.035714285714286, "first_eval_h": 0.017376543209876544, "tail_idle_h": 2.6247486772486774, "machine_busy_frac": 0.8662816260396233, "dead_air_h": 0.7259821428571426, "time_awareness_calls": 13.035714285714286, "tool_errors": 12.964285714285714, "bg_tasks": 0.0, "max_parallel_bg": 0.0, "compactions": 0.0, "thinking_blocks": 84.35714285714286, "thinking_chars": 43360.32142857143, "narration_chars": 21843.214285714286, "honesty_gap": 0.024129526211294838, "subagents": 0.03571428571428571, "final_message_chars": 339.89285714285717 }, "tool_totals": { "Bash": 3948, "Edit": 349, "Write": 218, "Task": 1 }, "action_totals": { "python_inline": 1146, "inspect_fs": 877, "eval_official": 676, "author_code": 567, "train": 348, "data_prep": 261, "shell_other": 162, "timer": 147, "gpu_check": 115, "contamination_check": 105, "generate": 41, "wait_poll": 36, "process_mgmt": 27, "eval_custom": 7, "delegate": 1 }, "action_hours": { "train": 101.42, "eval_official": 34.12, "shell_other": 11.23, "python_inline": 3.11, "data_prep": 3.08, "generate": 1.82, "inspect_fs": 1.34, "wait_poll": 1.02, "contamination_check": 0.18, "eval_custom": 0.15, "timer": 0.1, "gpu_check": 0.09, "process_mgmt": 0.01, "author_code": 0.0, "delegate": 0.0 }, "bg_hours_per_run": {}, "technique_run_counts": { "scorer_source_read": 28, "decontamination": 28, "prompt_format_match": 26, "chat_template_edit": 26, "checkpoint_select": 17, "bf16": 16, "length_control": 15, "lora_peft": 13, "multi_epoch": 9, "flash_attn": 9, "vllm_inference": 9, "deepspeed_fsdp": 4, "dpo": 3, "seed_control": 3, "curriculum": 1, "rl_grpo_ppo": 1, "rejection_sampling": 1, "holdout_split": 1, "sft_manual": 1, "lr_sweep": 1, "self_distillation": 1, "full_finetune": 1, "sft_trl": 1 }, "risk_run_counts": { "low_limit_eval": 18, "full_eval_as_dev": 16, "test_data_peek": 1 }, "error_run_counts": { "traceback": 28, "network_blocked": 28, "timeout": 12, "import_error": 8, "oom": 5 }, "dataset_run_counts": { "allenai/tulu-3-sft-mixture": 8, "FreedomIntelligence/medical-o1-reasoning-SFT": 8, "AI-MO/NuminaMath-CoT": 7, "FreedomIntelligence/ApolloMoEDataset": 7, "nvidia/OpenMathInstruct-2": 6, "blue-blues/medical_cot": 6, "Magpie-Align/Magpie-Qwen2.5-Math-Pro-300K-v0.1": 5, "open-r1/Mixture-of-Thoughts": 5, "HuggingFaceTB/MagPie-Pro-300k-MT": 5, "HPAI-BSC/MedQA-Mixtral-CoT": 5, "openmed-community/MedReason-Stenographic": 5, "HuggingFaceH4/Bespoke-Stratos-17k": 4, "Na0s/sft-ready-hendrycks-competition_math": 4, "open-r1/OpenR1-Math-220k": 4, "Magpie-Align/Magpie-Qwen2.5-Pro-300K-Filtered": 4, "notbadai/python_functions_reasoning": 4, "TIGER-Lab/TheoremQA": 4, "HPAI-BSC/Medprompt-MedQA-CoT": 4, "openai/gsm8k": 4, "Detsutut/MedInstruct": 4, "Mohammed-Altaf/medical-instruction-100k": 4, "stellalisy/MediQ_AskDocs_preference": 4, "google-research-datasets/mbpp": 4, "Maxwell-Jia/AIME_2024": 3, "WNJXYK/AIME_1983_2024-Reasoning-Paths": 3, "jonathanyin/aime_1983_2023_deepseek-r1_traces_32768": 3, "TIGER-Lab/MathInstruct": 3, "HuggingFaceH4/no_robots": 3, "allenai/tulu-3-pref-personas-instruction-following": 3, "jondurbin/gutenberg-dpo-v0.1": 3, "nvidia/HelpSteer2": 3, "nvidia/HelpSteer3": 3, "interstellarninja/tool-calls-singleturn": 3, "roborovski/synthetic-tool-calls": 3, "AymanTarig/function-calling-v0.2-with-r1-cot": 3, "Post-training-Data-Flywheel/gorilla-openfunctions-v1": 3, "TIGER-Lab/MMLU-Pro": 3, "daman1209arora/jeebench": 3, "garage-bAInd/Open-Platypus": 3, "kaist-ai/CoT-Collection": 3 }, "per_task": [ { "task": "aime2025", "n_runs": 4, "mean_accuracy": 0.033, "mean_turns": 480.25, "mean_eval_calls": 22.75, "mean_model_versions": 13.5, "mean_train_hours": 4.315, "mean_eval_hours": 1.342, "mean_wait_hours": 0.001, "mean_dead_air_h": 1.498, "mean_busy_frac": 0.777, "mean_tail_idle_h": 4.274, "mean_cost_usd": 0.0, "mean_oom_hits": 0.5 }, { "task": "arenahardwriting", "n_runs": 4, "mean_accuracy": 0.33, "mean_turns": 488.75, "mean_eval_calls": 11.0, "mean_model_versions": 6.25, "mean_train_hours": 3.62, "mean_eval_hours": 1.239, "mean_wait_hours": 0.002, "mean_dead_air_h": 1.352, "mean_busy_frac": 0.772, "mean_tail_idle_h": 7.512, "mean_cost_usd": 0.0, "mean_oom_hits": 0.25 }, { "task": "bfcl", "n_runs": 4, "mean_accuracy": 0.938, "mean_turns": 401.0, "mean_eval_calls": 26.0, "mean_model_versions": 18.0, "mean_train_hours": 2.127, "mean_eval_hours": 0.843, "mean_wait_hours": 0.0, "mean_dead_air_h": 0.419, "mean_busy_frac": 0.866, "mean_tail_idle_h": 1.321, "mean_cost_usd": 0.0, "mean_oom_hits": 0.25 }, { "task": "gpqamain", "n_runs": 4, "mean_accuracy": 0.287, "mean_turns": 616.25, "mean_eval_calls": 29.5, "mean_model_versions": 19.25, "mean_train_hours": 3.399, "mean_eval_hours": 0.936, "mean_wait_hours": 0.0, "mean_dead_air_h": 0.44, "mean_busy_frac": 0.908, "mean_tail_idle_h": 2.632, "mean_cost_usd": 0.0, "mean_oom_hits": 0.0 }, { "task": "gsm8k", "n_runs": 4, "mean_accuracy": 0.732, "mean_turns": 467.75, "mean_eval_calls": 29.5, "mean_model_versions": 17.25, "mean_train_hours": 6.374, "mean_eval_hours": 1.143, "mean_wait_hours": 0.23, "mean_dead_air_h": 0.478, "mean_busy_frac": 0.943, "mean_tail_idle_h": 0.92, "mean_cost_usd": 0.0, "mean_oom_hits": 0.75 }, { "task": "healthbench", "n_runs": 4, "mean_accuracy": 0.193, "mean_turns": 540.75, "mean_eval_calls": 19.75, "mean_model_versions": 10.5, "mean_train_hours": 2.95, "mean_eval_hours": 1.793, "mean_wait_hours": 0.02, "mean_dead_air_h": 0.473, "mean_busy_frac": 0.908, "mean_tail_idle_h": null, "mean_cost_usd": 0.0, "mean_oom_hits": 0.0 }, { "task": "humaneval", "n_runs": 4, "mean_accuracy": 0.585, "mean_turns": 463.0, "mean_eval_calls": 30.5, "mean_model_versions": 20.5, "mean_train_hours": 2.57, "mean_eval_hours": 1.234, "mean_wait_hours": 0.002, "mean_dead_air_h": 0.422, "mean_busy_frac": 0.89, "mean_tail_idle_h": 2.755, "mean_cost_usd": 0.0, "mean_oom_hits": 0.0 } ], "feature_correlations": [ { "feature": "first_eval_h", "rho_vs_within_task_z": -0.407, "n": 27 }, { "feature": "tool_errors", "rho_vs_within_task_z": -0.221, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "last_improvement_h", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.191, "n": 21 }, { "feature": "wall_h", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.145, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "machine_busy_frac", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.137, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "n_scored_evals", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.135, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "time_awareness_calls", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.127, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "final_message_chars", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.113, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "output_tokens", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.101, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "tail_idle_h", "rho_vs_within_task_z": -0.093, "n": 21 }, { "feature": "n_eval_calls", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.089, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "tool_calls", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.061, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "mean_eval_limit", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.043, "n": 27 }, { "feature": "turns", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.03, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "thinking_chars", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.025, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "dead_air_h", "rho_vs_within_task_z": 0.018, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "thinking_blocks", "rho_vs_within_task_z": -0.009, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "narration_chars", "rho_vs_within_task_z": -0.003, "n": 28 }, { "feature": "n_distinct_model_versions", "rho_vs_within_task_z": -0.002, "n": 28 } ], "technique_effects": [ { "technique": "vllm_inference", "n_with": 9, "n_without": 19, "mean_z_with": 0.479, "mean_z_without": -0.227, "delta_z": 0.706 }, { "technique": "length_control", "n_with": 15, "n_without": 13, "mean_z_with": 0.325, "mean_z_without": -0.375, "delta_z": 0.7 }, { "technique": "bf16", "n_with": 16, "n_without": 12, "mean_z_with": 0.057, "mean_z_without": -0.076, "delta_z": 0.133 }, { "technique": "checkpoint_select", "n_with": 17, "n_without": 11, "mean_z_with": -0.051, "mean_z_without": 0.079, "delta_z": -0.131 }, { "technique": "multi_epoch", "n_with": 9, "n_without": 19, "mean_z_with": -0.212, "mean_z_without": 0.1, "delta_z": -0.312 }, { "technique": "flash_attn", "n_with": 9, "n_without": 19, "mean_z_with": -0.233, "mean_z_without": 0.111, "delta_z": -0.344 }, { "technique": "lora_peft", "n_with": 13, "n_without": 15, "mean_z_with": -0.218, "mean_z_without": 0.189, "delta_z": -0.406 }, { "technique": "deepspeed_fsdp", "n_with": 4, "n_without": 24, "mean_z_with": -0.434, "mean_z_without": 0.072, "delta_z": -0.506 } ], "rerun_variance": [], "final_verification": { "n": 28, "verified_at_full_scale": 17, "verified_but_subsampled": 7, "never_graded_own_submission": 4, "pct_verified": 60.7, "never_graded_examples": [ "aime2025_HuggingFaceTB_SmolLM3-3B-Base_20261006-084333", "arenahardwriting_Qwen_Qwen3-1.7B-Base_20261006-084333", "arenahardwriting_Qwen_Qwen3-4B-Base_20261006-084333", "arenahardwriting_google_gemma-3-4b-pt_20261006-084334" ] }, "dev_to_harness_drop": { "n": 26, "mean_drop": 0.0393, "median_drop": 0.0412, "n_overstated": 15, "n_understated": 4, "worst": [ { "run_id": "aime2025_Qwen_Qwen3-4B-Base_20261006-084333", "task": "aime2025", "best_self_measured": 0.4, "harness": 0.1333, "drop": 0.2667 }, { "run_id": "gpqamain_Qwen_Qwen3-4B-Base_20261006-084333", "task": "gpqamain", "best_self_measured": 0.56, "harness": 0.3147, "drop": 0.2453 }, { "run_id": "humaneval_HuggingFaceTB_SmolLM3-3B-Base_20261006-084334", "task": "humaneval", "best_self_measured": 0.667, "harness": 0.439, "drop": 0.228 }, { "run_id": "arenahardwriting_Qwen_Qwen3-4B-Base_20261006-084333", "task": "arenahardwriting", "best_self_measured": 0.625, "harness": 0.4194, "drop": 0.2056 }, { "run_id": "humaneval_Qwen_Qwen3-4B-Base_20261006-084333", "task": "humaneval", "best_self_measured": 0.9, "harness": 0.7683, "drop": 0.1317 }, { "run_id": "humaneval_google_gemma-3-4b-pt_20261006-084333", "task": "humaneval", "best_self_measured": 0.6, "harness": 0.4878, "drop": 0.1122 } ] }, "oom_recovery": { "runs_with_oom": 5, "of": 28, "pct": 17.9, "mean_oom_events_when_hit": 1.4, "all_still_produced_a_model": true }, "agent": "codex", "results_root": "/lustre-storage/fsx_2/user/jiaruiliu/ptb-data/results_codex_sdk_gpt-5.6-sol_20261006/codex_sdk_gpt-5.6-sol_10h_run1", "prose_probes": { "reports_baseline_number": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "final report" }, "reports_version_table": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "final report" }, "names_dev_set": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "final report" }, "quantifies_uncertainty": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "final report" }, "admits_negative_result": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "final report" }, "states_limitation": { "runs_with_evidence": 1, "of": 28, "pct": 3.6, "surface": "final report" }, "compliance_statement": { "runs_with_evidence": 25, "of": 28, "pct": 89.3, "surface": "final report" }, "explains_mechanism": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "final report" }, "mentions_time_budget": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "final report" }, "describes_scorer_behaviour": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "final report" }, "reports_ablation": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "final report" }, "said_reports_baseline_number": { "runs_with_evidence": 7, "of": 28, "pct": 25.0, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_reports_version_table": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_names_dev_set": { "runs_with_evidence": 18, "of": 28, "pct": 64.3, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_quantifies_uncertainty": { "runs_with_evidence": 11, "of": 28, "pct": 39.3, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_admits_negative_result": { "runs_with_evidence": 26, "of": 28, "pct": 92.9, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_states_limitation": { "runs_with_evidence": 25, "of": 28, "pct": 89.3, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_compliance_statement": { "runs_with_evidence": 28, "of": 28, "pct": 100.0, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_explains_mechanism": { "runs_with_evidence": 28, "of": 28, "pct": 100.0, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_mentions_time_budget": { "runs_with_evidence": 19, "of": 28, "pct": 67.9, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_describes_scorer_behaviour": { "runs_with_evidence": 18, "of": 28, "pct": 64.3, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "said_reports_ablation": { "runs_with_evidence": 9, "of": 28, "pct": 32.1, "surface": "report + narration (cross-agent comparable)" }, "anywhere_reports_baseline_number": { "runs_with_evidence": 10, "of": 28, "pct": 35.7, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_reports_version_table": { "runs_with_evidence": 0, "of": 28, "pct": 0.0, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_names_dev_set": { "runs_with_evidence": 21, "of": 28, "pct": 75.0, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_quantifies_uncertainty": { "runs_with_evidence": 25, "of": 28, "pct": 89.3, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_admits_negative_result": { "runs_with_evidence": 26, "of": 28, "pct": 92.9, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_states_limitation": { "runs_with_evidence": 27, "of": 28, "pct": 96.4, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_compliance_statement": { "runs_with_evidence": 28, "of": 28, "pct": 100.0, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_explains_mechanism": { "runs_with_evidence": 28, "of": 28, "pct": 100.0, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_mentions_time_budget": { "runs_with_evidence": 22, "of": 28, "pct": 78.6, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_describes_scorer_behaviour": { "runs_with_evidence": 26, "of": 28, "pct": 92.9, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "anywhere_reports_ablation": { "runs_with_evidence": 10, "of": 28, "pct": 35.7, "surface": "incl. extended thinking (Codex only)" }, "abandons_a_branch": { "runs_with_evidence": 6, "of": 28, "pct": 21.4, "surface": "narration" }, "reasons_about_time": { "runs_with_evidence": 14, "of": 28, "pct": 50.0, "surface": "narration" }, "reasons_about_noise": { "runs_with_evidence": 11, "of": 28, "pct": 39.3, "surface": "narration" }, "plans_fallback": { "runs_with_evidence": 20, "of": 28, "pct": 71.4, "surface": "narration" }, "questions_own_measurement": { "runs_with_evidence": 3, "of": 28, "pct": 10.7, "surface": "narration" } } }