File size: 5,400 Bytes
9affda1 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 | import pandas as pd
import numpy as np
# 读取原始文件
file_path = "outputs/phase2/task_2_3_appE_full.csv"
df = pd.read_csv(file_path)
print("========================================================")
print("1. 原始文件基础信息")
print("========================================================")
print(f"总行数: {len(df)}")
pair_info = df.groupby('pair_id').agg(
base=('base', 'first'),
variant=('variant', 'first'),
scene_count=('scene', 'nunique'),
row_count=('scene', 'count')
).reset_index()
print(pair_info.to_markdown(index=False))
print("\n========================================================")
print("2. 生成新版 Appendix E (仅保留 P01-P04)")
print("========================================================")
df_new = df[df['pair_id'].isin(['P01', 'P02', 'P03', 'P04'])].copy()
new_file_path = "outputs/phase2/task_2_3_appE_filtered_P01_P04.csv"
df_new.to_csv(new_file_path, index=False)
print(f"已过滤掉 P05，新表行数: {len(df_new)}")
print(f"新表已保存至: {new_file_path}")
print("\n========================================================")
print("3. Table 3 Summary Aggregation (目标统计)")
print("========================================================")
targets = {
'P01': ('delta_opacity_net_effect', -1), # Expected Negative
'P02': ('delta_coverage_error_fraction', -1), # Expected Negative
'P03': ('delta_opacity_pathology_rate', -1), # Expected Negative (Design intent)
'P04': ('delta_opacity_net_effect', -1) # Expected Negative
}
for pid in ['P01', 'P02', 'P03', 'P04']:
sub = df[df['pair_id'] == pid]
if sub.empty: continue
base = sub['base'].iloc[0]
variant = sub['variant'].iloc[0]
target_col, exp_sign = targets[pid]
median_val = sub[target_col].median()
iqr_val = sub[target_col].quantile(0.75) - sub[target_col].quantile(0.25)
# 根据设计预期计算 Agreement
agree_design_cnt = (sub[target_col] < 0).sum() if exp_sign == -1 else (sub[target_col] > 0).sum()
agree_design_frac = agree_design_cnt / len(sub)
print(f"Pair ID: {pid} | Base: {base} | Variant: {variant}")
print(f"Target Channel: {target_col}")
print(f"Median Δ: {median_val:.3f} | IQR: {iqr_val:.3f}")
if pid == 'P03': # 特殊处理 LightGaussian (Counter-finding)
reverse_cnt = (sub[target_col] > 0).sum()
reverse_frac = reverse_cnt / len(sub)
print(f"Dir. Agreement (Design Intent): {agree_design_cnt}/{len(sub)} ({agree_design_frac:.3f})")
print(f"Dir. Agreement (Observed Reverse): {reverse_cnt}/{len(sub)} ({reverse_frac:.3f})")
print("Status: Counter-finding")
else:
status = "Validated" if agree_design_frac == 1.0 else ("Directional" if agree_design_frac >= 0.8 else "Unknown")
print(f"Dir. Agreement: {agree_design_cnt}/{len(sub)} ({agree_design_frac:.3f})")
print(f"Status: {status}")
print("-" * 50)
print("\n========================================================")
print("4. P05 剔除数据统计 (Dropped / Inconclusive)")
print("========================================================")
p05 = df[df['pair_id'] == 'P05']
if not p05.empty:
target_col = 'delta_coverage_error_fraction'
median_val = p05[target_col].median()
iqr_val = p05[target_col].quantile(0.75) - p05[target_col].quantile(0.25)
agree_cnt = (p05[target_col] < 0).sum()
print(f"Pair ID: P05 | Base: {p05['base'].iloc[0]} | Variant: {p05['variant'].iloc[0]}")
print(f"Target Channel: {target_col}")
print(f"Median Δ: {median_val:.3f} | IQR: {iqr_val:.3f}")
print(f"Dir. Agreement: {agree_cnt}/{len(p05)} ({(agree_cnt/len(p05)):.3f})")
print("Status: Inconclusive")
print("删除理由: Median 值过小且 IQR 方差极大，无法形成强力结论，故移出正文 main text。")
else:
print("未找到 P05 数据。")
print("\n========================================================")
print("5. 论文一致性 Sanity Checks")
print("========================================================")
# 提取计算结果用于快速比对
def check_pid(pid, expect_str):
sub = df[df['pair_id'] == pid]
if sub.empty: return "N/A"
cnt = (sub[targets[pid][0]] < 0).sum()
if pid == 'P03': cnt = (sub[targets[pid][0]] > 0).sum() # P03我们check reverse
return f"{cnt}/{len(sub)}"
print(f"[Check 1] P01 (PGSR) 是否 31/31? 实际: {check_pid('P01', '31/31')} -> {'PASS' if check_pid('P01', '31/31') == '31/31' else 'FAIL'}")
print(f"[Check 2] P02 (eRankGS) 是否 31/31? 实际: {check_pid('P02', '31/31')} -> {'PASS' if check_pid('P02', '31/31') == '31/31' else 'FAIL'}")
print(f"[Check 3] P03 (LightGaussian) 是否 Counter-finding? 实际反向符合数: {check_pid('P03', 'reverse')}")
print(f"[Check 4] P04 (SteepGS) 是否 26/31 (0.839)? 实际: {check_pid('P04', '26/31')} -> {'PASS' if check_pid('P04', '26/31') == '26/31' else 'FAIL'}")
print(f"[Check 5] 新版 Appendix E 总行数是否为 124? 实际: {len(df_new)} -> {'PASS' if len(df_new) == 124 else 'FAIL'}")
if len(df) == 155 and len(df_new) == 124:
print("\n⚠️ 论文修改提醒:")
print("原版 Appendix E 描述中提到有 155 行数据。请确保在更新 LaTeX 时：")
print("1. 将 Appendix E 表述改为 124 行 (4 pairs x 31 scenes)。")
print("2. 在 Supplementary 中说明 P05 已作为 Inconclusive Pair 被移除。")
|