{ "summary_schema_version": "1.0", "experiment_id": "tda_trace_pairs", "dataset_config": "opencode-reasoning2", "source_file": "experiment_outputs/exp_tda_trace_pairs/results_opencode-reasoning2.jsonl", "generated_at_utc": "2026-07-16T14:43:39.457405+00:00", "definitions": { "score_type": "out_of_fold_ols_ranking_score", "tie_tolerance": 1e-12, "readers": [ "length4", "format5", "tda28", "tda28_plus_format5" ], "primary_comparison": "tda28_plus_format5_minus_format5" }, "bootstrap": { "unit": "problem_id_with_all_model_groups", "samples": 5000, "base_seed": 42, "interval": "percentile_95", "bootstrap_se_definition": "sample standard deviation of bootstrap estimates" }, "overall": { "selected_pair_count": 2000, "valid_pair_count": 2000, "invalid_pair_count": 0, "invalid_reasons": {}, "extraction_modes": { "positive": { "think_tag": 2000 }, "negative": { "think_tag": 2000 } }, "reader_metrics": { "length4": { "positive": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.5071894139317054, "sample_std": 0.06212684124726951, "sample_median": 0.49316507054830117, "mean_pm_std": "0.507189 +/- 0.062127" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.4928658310243317, "sample_std": 0.05929150890793526, "sample_median": 0.48019000691486396, "mean_pm_std": "0.492866 +/- 0.059292" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.014323582907373709, "sample_std": 0.04694453411690589, "sample_median": 0.009314705135112483, "mean_pm_std": "0.014324 +/- 0.046945" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 1239, "negative_wins": 761, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.6195, "negative_win_rate": 0.3805, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.30511715957610136, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 2000, "two_sided_p_value": 8.45103904443044e-27 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 2000, "statistic": 662257.0, "two_sided_p_value": 3.508209521453721e-39 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5072064796814262, "bootstrap_se": 0.0013900632658627756, "ci95": [ 0.5044467357155822, 0.509871981959459 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.4928811332043906, "bootstrap_se": 0.001340419950961057, "ci95": [ 0.490299795396397, 0.49551511081923905 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.014325346477035537, "bootstrap_se": 0.001055174550518708, "ci95": [ 0.012272210170215746, 0.016343316061020314 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.619519, "bootstrap_se": 0.010877743518800762, "ci95": [ 0.598, 0.6405 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "format5": { "positive": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.5046766238968488, "sample_std": 0.0487486294508796, "sample_median": 0.5033415818082025, "mean_pm_std": "0.504677 +/- 0.048749" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.4950835659325768, "sample_std": 0.05062295433391072, "sample_median": 0.4934123024492939, "mean_pm_std": "0.495084 +/- 0.050623" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.009593057964271968, "sample_std": 0.04310851773795247, "sample_median": 0.007738626998233966, "mean_pm_std": "0.009593 +/- 0.043109" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 1147, "negative_wins": 853, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.5735, "negative_win_rate": 0.4265, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.2225327723533927, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 2000, "two_sided_p_value": 5.266034612996984e-11 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 2000, "statistic": 755106.0, "two_sided_p_value": 2.0887258708176974e-21 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5046742264707885, "bootstrap_se": 0.0010986083580355973, "ci95": [ 0.5024942424483513, 0.5068343178126332 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.4951025429584048, "bootstrap_se": 0.00113262927773923, "ci95": [ 0.49292303121533565, 0.49736315794923025 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.009571683512383591, "bootstrap_se": 0.0009484431208581575, "ci95": [ 0.007716882582514641, 0.011457347588174205 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5732779, "bootstrap_se": 0.010922027271800097, "ci95": [ 0.5515, 0.5945 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "tda28": { "positive": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.5118365460159019, "sample_std": 0.0800060985105462, "sample_median": 0.5139172300067467, "mean_pm_std": "0.511837 +/- 0.080006" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.48756737046893445, "sample_std": 0.08854797760219717, "sample_median": 0.48965802682514803, "mean_pm_std": "0.487567 +/- 0.088548" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.024269175546967524, "sample_std": 0.08804959935631239, "sample_median": 0.02224508115608681, "mean_pm_std": "0.024269 +/- 0.088050" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 1206, "negative_wins": 794, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.603, "negative_win_rate": 0.397, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.2756307322734869, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 2000, "two_sided_p_value": 2.897254431536813e-20 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 2000, "statistic": 703405.0, "two_sided_p_value": 1.2870460653926119e-30 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5118124127775208, "bootstrap_se": 0.0017930330270486939, "ci95": [ 0.5081904286433622, 0.515287964265395 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.48760997585701354, "bootstrap_se": 0.0019688870133862785, "ci95": [ 0.48375428440554136, 0.49143785502383 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.02420243692050718, "bootstrap_se": 0.001917072475314334, "ci95": [ 0.0204132256329958, 0.02791614736826224 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.602787, "bootstrap_se": 0.010760278236065443, "ci95": [ 0.5815, 0.624 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "tda28_plus_format5": { "positive": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.515597970457073, "sample_std": 0.09024148649179768, "sample_median": 0.5215836315999243, "mean_pm_std": "0.515598 +/- 0.090241" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.4841913657271041, "sample_std": 0.09860359963385383, "sample_median": 0.4899617446498321, "mean_pm_std": "0.484191 +/- 0.098604" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 0.031406604729968764, "sample_std": 0.09843093172625814, "sample_median": 0.026765712414587528, "mean_pm_std": "0.031407 +/- 0.098431" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 1220, "negative_wins": 780, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.61, "negative_win_rate": 0.39, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.31907251286935157, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 2000, "two_sided_p_value": 6.454816980406585e-23 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 2000, "statistic": 666476.0, "two_sided_p_value": 2.9759245229496716e-38 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5155706054931859, "bootstrap_se": 0.0019989395519185616, "ci95": [ 0.5115466011541546, 0.5194315189919101 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.48423637002492886, "bootstrap_se": 0.0021681370034708192, "ci95": [ 0.47983165789768356, 0.48843410399471654 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.03133423546825704, "bootstrap_se": 0.002152541959083756, "ci95": [ 0.027175716156791502, 0.035618987578502924 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.6099114, "bootstrap_se": 0.010725365109465798, "ci95": [ 0.589, 0.6305 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } } }, "incremental_validity": { "comparison": "tda28_plus_format5_minus_format5", "strict_pairwise_accuracy_difference": 0.03649999999999998, "bootstrap": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.03663350000000002, "bootstrap_se": 0.012107821753706316, "ci95": [ 0.013000000000000012, 0.06001249999999987 ] } }, "trace_diagnostics": { "step_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 698.4605, "sample_std": 306.5926645742448, "sample_median": 726.5, "mean_pm_std": "698.460500 +/- 306.592665" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 750.3975, "sample_std": 337.81897567175224, "sample_median": 772.5, "mean_pm_std": "750.397500 +/- 337.818976" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": -51.937, "sample_std": 270.3420878317444, "sample_median": -24.0, "mean_pm_std": "-51.937000 +/- 270.342088" } }, "reasoning_chars": { "positive": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 37120.558, "sample_std": 18543.052571029453, "sample_median": 38340.5, "mean_pm_std": "37120.558000 +/- 18543.052571" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 40879.3965, "sample_std": 19698.59603748988, "sample_median": 42801.5, "mean_pm_std": "40879.396500 +/- 19698.596037" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": -3758.8385, "sample_std": 14266.026687769297, "sample_median": -2132.5, "mean_pm_std": "-3758.838500 +/- 14266.026688" } }, "h0_total_interval_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 634.446, "sample_std": 273.0711207771727, "sample_median": 661.0, "mean_pm_std": "634.446000 +/- 273.071121" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 679.924, "sample_std": 297.410530640507, "sample_median": 701.5, "mean_pm_std": "679.924000 +/- 297.410531" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": -45.478, "sample_std": 232.56270815118083, "sample_median": -21.0, "mean_pm_std": "-45.478000 +/- 232.562708" } }, "h0_finite_death_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 633.446, "sample_std": 273.0711207771727, "sample_median": 660.0, "mean_pm_std": "633.446000 +/- 273.071121" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 678.924, "sample_std": 297.410530640507, "sample_median": 700.5, "mean_pm_std": "678.924000 +/- 297.410531" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": -45.478, "sample_std": 232.56270815118083, "sample_median": -21.0, "mean_pm_std": "-45.478000 +/- 232.562708" } }, "h1_total_interval_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 537.5745, "sample_std": 261.6886239745795, "sample_median": 553.5, "mean_pm_std": "537.574500 +/- 261.688624" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": 574.5655, "sample_std": 281.0526979398341, "sample_median": 596.0, "mean_pm_std": "574.565500 +/- 281.052698" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 2000, "sample_mean": -36.991, "sample_std": 221.49347755475702, "sample_median": -15.0, "mean_pm_std": "-36.991000 +/- 221.493478" } } }, "tda_step_correlations": { "h0_count": { "pearson": 0.994420245177072, "spearman": 0.9941698040384811 }, "h0_total_life": { "pearson": 0.9541303919835639, "spearman": 0.9530843255365824 }, "h0_max_life": { "pearson": -0.05930537801138189, "spearman": -0.04688859719592527 }, "h0_mean_life": { "pearson": -0.7227611783661866, "spearman": -0.6899799612084114 }, "h0_entropy": { "pearson": 0.9245528940941035, "spearman": 0.9838898962042598 }, "h0_skewness": { "pearson": 0.3038216290872412, "spearman": 0.2596501292105611 }, "h0_betti_width": { "pearson": -0.05909710248138732, "spearman": -0.04651161859956976 }, "h0_betti_centroid": { "pearson": -0.7792534453016035, "spearman": -0.7674014733253461 }, "h0_betti_spread": { "pearson": -0.7939488361748497, "spearman": -0.7929258397962148 }, "h0_landscape_mean": { "pearson": -0.03559002326528818, "spearman": -0.02657641302110653 }, "h0_landscape_max": { "pearson": -0.05854234506739979, "spearman": -0.04590075976598282 }, "h0_landscape_area": { "pearson": -0.06005827542537465, "spearman": -0.046906687027546135 }, "h1_count": { "pearson": 0.9721464076035162, "spearman": 0.9718868656596729 }, "h1_total_life": { "pearson": 0.9439097197870848, "spearman": 0.9447563963417173 }, "h1_max_life": { "pearson": 0.3957537377938438, "spearman": 0.3819237273886154 }, "h1_mean_life": { "pearson": -0.36915496572314355, "spearman": -0.34159703136559866 }, "h1_entropy": { "pearson": 0.907424879582287, "spearman": 0.96729441117715 }, "h1_skewness": { "pearson": 0.3300056271705838, "spearman": 0.3159717058109166 }, "h1_max_birth": { "pearson": -0.033671974211015934, "spearman": -0.03948741033925706 }, "h1_max_death": { "pearson": -0.09526523538008135, "spearman": -0.10646293823088208 }, "h1_betti_peak": { "pearson": 0.8561947509338335, "spearman": 0.870018996813593 }, "h1_betti_location": { "pearson": -0.40170000592365007, "spearman": -0.3681979744594846 }, "h1_betti_width": { "pearson": 0.5442881797498021, "spearman": 0.4815620870746568 }, "h1_betti_centroid": { "pearson": -0.6789559873484081, "spearman": -0.6395282772310774 }, "h1_betti_spread": { "pearson": 0.06409160524782682, "spearman": 0.05201506758771151 }, "h1_landscape_mean": { "pearson": 0.7715760657694526, "spearman": 0.7588247957364771 }, "h1_landscape_max": { "pearson": 0.39478483951318066, "spearman": 0.3812076959858891 }, "h1_landscape_area": { "pearson": 0.7602945673567774, "spearman": 0.7443741863024832 } } }, "by_source_subset": { "cpp": { "selected_pair_count": 409, "valid_pair_count": 409, "invalid_pair_count": 0, "invalid_reasons": {}, "extraction_modes": { "positive": { "think_tag": 409 }, "negative": { "think_tag": 409 } }, "reader_metrics": { "length4": { "positive": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.5010260798400806, "sample_std": 0.05711700183771347, "sample_median": 0.4919383980041181, "mean_pm_std": "0.501026 +/- 0.057117" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.4892428708838329, "sample_std": 0.05450037027843947, "sample_median": 0.481747547942704, "mean_pm_std": "0.489243 +/- 0.054500" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.011783208956247623, "sample_std": 0.04199382398326695, "sample_median": 0.008407400048145552, "mean_pm_std": "0.011783 +/- 0.041994" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 244, "negative_wins": 165, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.5965770171149144, "negative_win_rate": 0.4034229828850856, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.28059385496645445, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 409, "two_sided_p_value": 0.00010977620041132394 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 409, "statistic": 29275.0, "two_sided_p_value": 1.2429344116848695e-07 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5010052575892723, "bootstrap_se": 0.002798248610128302, "ci95": [ 0.49555610348738505, 0.5065422847302538 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.48925264261787405, "bootstrap_se": 0.0026693912210850974, "ci95": [ 0.4840273630821024, 0.4944857782711126 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.011752614971398331, "bootstrap_se": 0.002074929033737272, "ci95": [ 0.007771369133298656, 0.015880856694690613 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5963286063569683, "bootstrap_se": 0.024722892173872683, "ci95": [ 0.5476772616136919, 0.6430317848410758 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "format5": { "positive": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.4973330955671176, "sample_std": 0.04067139351660543, "sample_median": 0.49954048822846653, "mean_pm_std": "0.497333 +/- 0.040671" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.4865586216661975, "sample_std": 0.04064466403414119, "sample_median": 0.4854355439366556, "mean_pm_std": "0.486559 +/- 0.040645" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.01077447390092012, "sample_std": 0.04008496685389644, "sample_median": 0.009406244252273432, "mean_pm_std": "0.010774 +/- 0.040085" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 242, "negative_wins": 167, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.5916870415647921, "negative_win_rate": 0.4083129584352078, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.2687908896168338, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 409, "two_sided_p_value": 0.0002440623132972888 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 409, "statistic": 29059.0, "two_sided_p_value": 7.558528969038036e-08 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.4973696031957483, "bootstrap_se": 0.0020073548320320026, "ci95": [ 0.4935185331740135, 0.5013650830936942 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.4865972142180517, "bootstrap_se": 0.00201927500147789, "ci95": [ 0.4825854739307217, 0.4905016669146103 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0107723889776966, "bootstrap_se": 0.0019877174078576218, "ci95": [ 0.00684968194444283, 0.014658502453181805 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5920185819070904, "bootstrap_se": 0.0241661225109928, "ci95": [ 0.5452322738386308, 0.6405867970660146 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "tda28": { "positive": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.540752126585774, "sample_std": 0.07137590908554853, "sample_median": 0.543216427247617, "mean_pm_std": "0.540752 +/- 0.071376" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.519864479883303, "sample_std": 0.08415126829141566, "sample_median": 0.5176106742553566, "mean_pm_std": "0.519864 +/- 0.084151" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.020887646702471088, "sample_std": 0.08090853284245306, "sample_median": 0.022429502974982696, "mean_pm_std": "0.020888 +/- 0.080909" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 245, "negative_wins": 164, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.5990220048899756, "negative_win_rate": 0.40097799511002447, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.2581637062081448, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 409, "two_sided_p_value": 7.256428896165733e-05 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 409, "statistic": 29597.0, "two_sided_p_value": 2.5709138902031634e-07 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5407165999818185, "bootstrap_se": 0.0034505334210302606, "ci95": [ 0.5339624172854106, 0.5474969535810653 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5198954513398683, "bootstrap_se": 0.004110624833097673, "ci95": [ 0.5118130100935628, 0.5279648485737848 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.02082114864195015, "bootstrap_se": 0.003994657513940853, "ci95": [ 0.013038880133661912, 0.028539186836746704 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5992249388753056, "bootstrap_se": 0.024300505499780817, "ci95": [ 0.5501222493887531, 0.6455378973105126 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "tda28_plus_format5": { "positive": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.535581991855213, "sample_std": 0.08255253332975923, "sample_median": 0.5390256662174197, "mean_pm_std": "0.535582 +/- 0.082553" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.5108091104210377, "sample_std": 0.09456115332748395, "sample_median": 0.5152821463767386, "mean_pm_std": "0.510809 +/- 0.094561" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 0.024772881434175345, "sample_std": 0.09226717215750556, "sample_median": 0.02318750695320637, "mean_pm_std": "0.024773 +/- 0.092267" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 245, "negative_wins": 164, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.5990220048899756, "negative_win_rate": 0.40097799511002447, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.26849074112606985, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 409, "two_sided_p_value": 7.256428896165733e-05 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 409, "statistic": 29631.0, "two_sided_p_value": 2.773133017032424e-07 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5355755126536825, "bootstrap_se": 0.00399070741998883, "ci95": [ 0.527811183735534, 0.5434011882549529 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5108721088868798, "bootstrap_se": 0.004614098786114971, "ci95": [ 0.5018732227463766, 0.5200081677014173 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.024703403766802676, "bootstrap_se": 0.004526718321100012, "ci95": [ 0.015978776417302686, 0.033718448317509864 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5988215158924206, "bootstrap_se": 0.024324700556622586, "ci95": [ 0.5501222493887531, 0.6454767726161369 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } } }, "incremental_validity": { "comparison": "tda28_plus_format5_minus_format5", "strict_pairwise_accuracy_difference": 0.007334963325183463, "bootstrap": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0068029339853300725, "bootstrap_se": 0.02725409141345108, "ci95": [ -0.046454767726161306, 0.06112469437652812 ] } }, "trace_diagnostics": { "step_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 694.2029339853301, "sample_std": 243.92191854015869, "sample_median": 728.0, "mean_pm_std": "694.202934 +/- 243.921919" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 763.4767726161369, "sample_std": 261.6836326584511, "sample_median": 792.0, "mean_pm_std": "763.476773 +/- 261.683633" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": -69.27383863080685, "sample_std": 232.71625684760437, "sample_median": -36.0, "mean_pm_std": "-69.273839 +/- 232.716257" } }, "reasoning_chars": { "positive": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 37002.88508557457, "sample_std": 15179.260171752847, "sample_median": 39044.0, "mean_pm_std": "37002.885086 +/- 15179.260172" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 41096.122249388754, "sample_std": 15248.045724980526, "sample_median": 43971.0, "mean_pm_std": "41096.122249 +/- 15248.045725" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": -4093.237163814181, "sample_std": 11595.452725182782, "sample_median": -2829.0, "mean_pm_std": "-4093.237164 +/- 11595.452725" } }, "h0_total_interval_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 623.5305623471883, "sample_std": 211.7841799853921, "sample_median": 647.0, "mean_pm_std": "623.530562 +/- 211.784180" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 681.8068459657702, "sample_std": 223.41938132807073, "sample_median": 714.0, "mean_pm_std": "681.806846 +/- 223.419381" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": -58.27628361858191, "sample_std": 194.64938174473005, "sample_median": -35.0, "mean_pm_std": "-58.276284 +/- 194.649382" } }, "h0_finite_death_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 622.5305623471883, "sample_std": 211.7841799853921, "sample_median": 646.0, "mean_pm_std": "622.530562 +/- 211.784180" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 680.8068459657702, "sample_std": 223.41938132807073, "sample_median": 713.0, "mean_pm_std": "680.806846 +/- 223.419381" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": -58.27628361858191, "sample_std": 194.64938174473005, "sample_median": -35.0, "mean_pm_std": "-58.276284 +/- 194.649382" } }, "h1_total_interval_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 533.8215158924205, "sample_std": 210.11696072185737, "sample_median": 551.0, "mean_pm_std": "533.821516 +/- 210.116961" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": 583.075794621027, "sample_std": 214.5761933917804, "sample_median": 613.0, "mean_pm_std": "583.075795 +/- 214.576193" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 409, "sample_mean": -49.25427872860636, "sample_std": 188.1640499501895, "sample_median": -37.0, "mean_pm_std": "-49.254279 +/- 188.164050" } } }, "tda_step_correlations": { "h0_count": { "pearson": 0.9876216859263307, "spearman": 0.9854990918237081 }, "h0_total_life": { "pearson": 0.9334908649727027, "spearman": 0.9267134672174655 }, "h0_max_life": { "pearson": -0.046883758240558265, "spearman": -0.02349950458898365 }, "h0_mean_life": { "pearson": -0.7063671962853072, "spearman": -0.6252375532203002 }, "h0_entropy": { "pearson": 0.9267758740320605, "spearman": 0.9666111223247603 }, "h0_skewness": { "pearson": 0.27194140346573353, "spearman": 0.2302128015665233 }, "h0_betti_width": { "pearson": -0.045973648667952074, "spearman": -0.024109761929824506 }, "h0_betti_centroid": { "pearson": -0.7579312973493132, "spearman": -0.6910158403115209 }, "h0_betti_spread": { "pearson": -0.7626378982092842, "spearman": -0.7261700469743976 }, "h0_landscape_mean": { "pearson": -0.016013162897430197, "spearman": 0.0037157856895295226 }, "h0_landscape_max": { "pearson": -0.04438701254745795, "spearman": -0.022037466845328108 }, "h0_landscape_area": { "pearson": -0.047270073300847607, "spearman": -0.02340726729254636 }, "h1_count": { "pearson": 0.9547770938239534, "spearman": 0.9506789475843151 }, "h1_total_life": { "pearson": 0.9137365157577809, "spearman": 0.9092258035525459 }, "h1_max_life": { "pearson": 0.31477372304920637, "spearman": 0.2884727649045689 }, "h1_mean_life": { "pearson": -0.33088826006718275, "spearman": -0.28099558966313276 }, "h1_entropy": { "pearson": 0.9084101087974079, "spearman": 0.9418824850846501 }, "h1_skewness": { "pearson": 0.2903044137373113, "spearman": 0.261320573114548 }, "h1_max_birth": { "pearson": -0.07489370552814509, "spearman": -0.050679135196705694 }, "h1_max_death": { "pearson": -0.13037656519484866, "spearman": -0.11262171934429711 }, "h1_betti_peak": { "pearson": 0.800029475848683, "spearman": 0.8000216917958367 }, "h1_betti_location": { "pearson": -0.3689786605585862, "spearman": -0.33017843191877505 }, "h1_betti_width": { "pearson": 0.4754350395631001, "spearman": 0.3798744543972359 }, "h1_betti_centroid": { "pearson": -0.6214050359654907, "spearman": -0.5415640211134017 }, "h1_betti_spread": { "pearson": 0.10555732996901546, "spearman": 0.08945088073361644 }, "h1_landscape_mean": { "pearson": 0.7218538124554801, "spearman": 0.671889969503132 }, "h1_landscape_max": { "pearson": 0.31619132121025284, "spearman": 0.28928632556027933 }, "h1_landscape_area": { "pearson": 0.7159087298391502, "spearman": 0.6600941392255 } } }, "python": { "selected_pair_count": 1591, "valid_pair_count": 1591, "invalid_pair_count": 0, "invalid_reasons": {}, "extraction_modes": { "positive": { "think_tag": 1591 }, "negative": { "think_tag": 1591 } }, "reader_metrics": { "length4": { "positive": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.5087738285410545, "sample_std": 0.06327070190658794, "sample_median": 0.4934245978348983, "mean_pm_std": "0.508774 +/- 0.063271" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.493797189099419, "sample_std": 0.06044293301433626, "sample_median": 0.4794907849007005, "mean_pm_std": "0.493797 +/- 0.060443" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.014976639441635539, "sample_std": 0.0481255983276685, "sample_median": 0.009854728733284301, "mean_pm_std": "0.014977 +/- 0.048126" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 995, "negative_wins": 596, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.6253928346951603, "negative_win_rate": 0.37460716530483973, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.311199028418627, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 1591, "two_sided_p_value": 1.115944453054696e-23 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 1591, "statistic": 413304.0, "two_sided_p_value": 3.609975114773937e-33 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5087904873817233, "bootstrap_se": 0.0015856783352280223, "ci95": [ 0.505648846369964, 0.5119290624799088 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.49382531079245656, "bootstrap_se": 0.0015031143775891633, "ci95": [ 0.490874517834658, 0.49684135094550913 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.014965176589266676, "bootstrap_se": 0.0012123592521675205, "ci95": [ 0.012579794971598422, 0.017331549821570567 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.625255436832181, "bootstrap_se": 0.012093657938034562, "ci95": [ 0.6015084852294155, 0.6492771841609051 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "format5": { "positive": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.5065644322481121, "sample_std": 0.05045613806836232, "sample_median": 0.5048009870459892, "mean_pm_std": "0.506564 +/- 0.050456" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.49727508208905014, "sample_std": 0.052673360527960025, "sample_median": 0.4962463592366672, "mean_pm_std": "0.497275 +/- 0.052673" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.009289350159061979, "sample_std": 0.0438589533520638, "sample_median": 0.006679931913862847, "mean_pm_std": "0.009289 +/- 0.043859" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 905, "negative_wins": 686, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.5688246385920804, "negative_win_rate": 0.43117536140791957, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.21180054353998543, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 1591, "two_sided_p_value": 4.406993389411071e-08 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 1591, "statistic": 486987.0, "two_sided_p_value": 1.4814696515979703e-15 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5065742774266979, "bootstrap_se": 0.0012673972459534835, "ci95": [ 0.5040367776557538, 0.5090088739544236 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.4972899714565725, "bootstrap_se": 0.0013371668203810644, "ci95": [ 0.4946616762049274, 0.49990041998387236 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.009284305970125405, "bootstrap_se": 0.0010937546437179825, "ci95": [ 0.0071386793681798046, 0.011436464030614062 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5690038969201759, "bootstrap_se": 0.012345836294850714, "ci95": [ 0.5443117536140792, 0.5927089880578252 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "tda28": { "positive": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.50440318809442, "sample_std": 0.08043555403013879, "sample_median": 0.5068640494303045, "mean_pm_std": "0.504403 +/- 0.080436" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.4792647194629779, "sample_std": 0.08776798604375705, "sample_median": 0.4824815740112253, "mean_pm_std": "0.479265 +/- 0.087768" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.02513846863144209, "sample_std": 0.08979706779754071, "sample_median": 0.02211175519517311, "mean_pm_std": "0.025138 +/- 0.089797" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 961, "negative_wins": 630, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.6040226272784412, "negative_win_rate": 0.39597737272155875, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.2799475444801836, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 1591, "two_sided_p_value": 1.0152180076972911e-16 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 1591, "statistic": 444616.0, "two_sided_p_value": 7.795355711495224e-25 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5044175921261022, "bootstrap_se": 0.00203744346402568, "ci95": [ 0.5004316651943934, 0.5083412973869259 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.4792770176472739, "bootstrap_se": 0.0021891135573037725, "ci95": [ 0.4750126038642539, 0.48344437410800467 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.02514057447882818, "bootstrap_se": 0.002238824140405818, "ci95": [ 0.020666765137190162, 0.029557247773567465 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.6039922061596481, "bootstrap_se": 0.012360521276535481, "ci95": [ 0.57950974230044, 0.6279226901319922 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "tda28_plus_format5": { "positive": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.5104606576023656, "sample_std": 0.0914354163689716, "sample_median": 0.5163244963017876, "mean_pm_std": "0.510461 +/- 0.091435" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.47734871482841224, "sample_std": 0.09848885261170702, "sample_median": 0.48258549668510364, "mean_pm_std": "0.477349 +/- 0.098489" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 0.03311194277395337, "sample_std": 0.09991060230320956, "sample_median": 0.027208563228300675, "mean_pm_std": "0.033112 +/- 0.099911" }, "ordering": { "positive_wins": 975, "negative_wins": 616, "ties": 0, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": 0.6128221244500315, "negative_win_rate": 0.3871778755499686, "tie_rate": 0.0, "cohens_dz": 0.3314157057472736, "exact_sign_test": { "non_tied_pairs": 1591, "two_sided_p_value": 1.9980584768590692e-19 }, "paired_wilcoxon": { "nonzero_pairs": 1591, "statistic": 415178.0, "two_sided_p_value": 1.2351088364577303e-32 } }, "bootstrap": { "positive_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.5104917299076577, "bootstrap_se": 0.002295349768743169, "ci95": [ 0.505935298647282, 0.5149967016612258 ] }, "negative_mean": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.47737558513750217, "bootstrap_se": 0.002465788476214885, "ci95": [ 0.47256552787688183, 0.4821725798373673 ] }, "mean_difference": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.03311614477015542, "bootstrap_se": 0.0025282377779548286, "ci95": [ 0.02816097808027231, 0.038142756511652505 ] }, "strict_pairwise_accuracy": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.6128808296668762, "bootstrap_se": 0.012435148380145016, "ci95": [ 0.5883092394720302, 0.6373350094280327 ] }, "tie_rate": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.0, "bootstrap_se": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } } }, "incremental_validity": { "comparison": "tda28_plus_format5_minus_format5", "strict_pairwise_accuracy_difference": 0.043997485857951046, "bootstrap": { "bootstrap_mean": 0.04387693274670019, "bootstrap_se": 0.013923109381515815, "ci95": [ 0.016970458830923962, 0.07165304839723452 ] } }, "trace_diagnostics": { "step_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 699.5549968573224, "sample_std": 320.7887889728631, "sample_median": 725.0, "mean_pm_std": "699.554997 +/- 320.788789" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 747.0351979886864, "sample_std": 354.7539585224757, "sample_median": 763.0, "mean_pm_std": "747.035198 +/- 354.753959" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": -47.48020113136392, "sample_std": 279.08889628421605, "sample_median": -19.0, "mean_pm_std": "-47.480201 +/- 279.088896" } }, "reasoning_chars": { "positive": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 37150.808296668765, "sample_std": 19317.46330802617, "sample_median": 37980.0, "mean_pm_std": "37150.808297 +/- 19317.463308" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 40823.68258956631, "sample_std": 20692.35579045884, "sample_median": 42094.0, "mean_pm_std": "40823.682590 +/- 20692.355790" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": -3672.874292897549, "sample_std": 14877.287932726327, "sample_median": -1989.0, "mean_pm_std": "-3672.874293 +/- 14877.287933" } }, "h0_total_interval_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 637.2520427404148, "sample_std": 286.7076304623256, "sample_median": 666.0, "mean_pm_std": "637.252043 +/- 286.707630" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 679.4399748585795, "sample_std": 313.68168179755935, "sample_median": 693.0, "mean_pm_std": "679.439975 +/- 313.681682" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": -42.187932118164674, "sample_std": 241.29377017907157, "sample_median": -16.0, "mean_pm_std": "-42.187932 +/- 241.293770" } }, "h0_finite_death_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 636.2520427404148, "sample_std": 286.7076304623256, "sample_median": 665.0, "mean_pm_std": "636.252043 +/- 286.707630" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 678.4399748585795, "sample_std": 313.68168179755935, "sample_median": 692.0, "mean_pm_std": "678.439975 +/- 313.681682" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": -42.187932118164674, "sample_std": 241.29377017907157, "sample_median": -16.0, "mean_pm_std": "-42.187932 +/- 241.293770" } }, "h1_total_interval_count": { "positive": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 538.539283469516, "sample_std": 273.4283865573129, "sample_median": 554.0, "mean_pm_std": "538.539283 +/- 273.428387" }, "negative": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": 572.3777498428661, "sample_std": 295.7556040738655, "sample_median": 586.0, "mean_pm_std": "572.377750 +/- 295.755604" }, "difference": { "sample_count": 1591, "sample_mean": -33.838466373350094, "sample_std": 229.22732048452346, "sample_median": -12.0, "mean_pm_std": "-33.838466 +/- 229.227320" } } }, "tda_step_correlations": { "h0_count": { "pearson": 0.9955691191382094, "spearman": 0.9957871674323059 }, "h0_total_life": { "pearson": 0.9577234307666652, "spearman": 0.9584836659557283 }, "h0_max_life": { "pearson": -0.061655520217850514, "spearman": -0.05170520671813631 }, "h0_mean_life": { "pearson": -0.7285144733776189, "spearman": -0.7104110182882497 }, "h0_entropy": { "pearson": 0.9250712554221302, "spearman": 0.9869548516907712 }, "h0_skewness": { "pearson": 0.3166661693273074, "spearman": 0.2715232567985809 }, "h0_betti_width": { "pearson": -0.06158483970149543, "spearman": -0.05112817208164808 }, "h0_betti_centroid": { "pearson": -0.7859998825150604, "spearman": -0.790486299494388 }, "h0_betti_spread": { "pearson": -0.8002690276714653, "spearman": -0.8098596760050911 }, "h0_landscape_mean": { "pearson": -0.03926442065582231, "spearman": -0.03266668282131462 }, "h0_landscape_max": { "pearson": -0.061217872515940956, "spearman": -0.05076316147582035 }, "h0_landscape_area": { "pearson": -0.06243681649527801, "spearman": -0.051714835293761745 }, "h1_count": { "pearson": 0.9746655266988198, "spearman": 0.9757014833369362 }, "h1_total_life": { "pearson": 0.9488827033941465, "spearman": 0.9517401213856153 }, "h1_max_life": { "pearson": 0.4132948600341997, "spearman": 0.40395173986514954 }, "h1_mean_life": { "pearson": -0.38160137612230055, "spearman": -0.3587428324496269 }, "h1_entropy": { "pearson": 0.90848162807089, "spearman": 0.9718746986416057 }, "h1_skewness": { "pearson": 0.3378625205165805, "spearman": 0.3285049585012412 }, "h1_max_birth": { "pearson": -0.02642138685278324, "spearman": -0.03625742203942346 }, "h1_max_death": { "pearson": -0.08942333106242428, "spearman": -0.10428588801100035 }, "h1_betti_peak": { "pearson": 0.8654563661884083, "spearman": 0.8835998791784085 }, "h1_betti_location": { "pearson": -0.4139951907587493, "spearman": -0.38150781501181247 }, "h1_betti_width": { "pearson": 0.5557507241587293, "spearman": 0.5029931989902972 }, "h1_betti_centroid": { "pearson": -0.6932667230158808, "spearman": -0.6662764969885966 }, "h1_betti_spread": { "pearson": 0.0570210434928646, "spearman": 0.04577970780924086 }, "h1_landscape_mean": { "pearson": 0.7818314932339699, "spearman": 0.7787189161184225 }, "h1_landscape_max": { "pearson": 0.4118970399681828, "spearman": 0.40286629313981726 }, "h1_landscape_area": { "pearson": 0.7691781908189564, "spearman": 0.7632989359372097 } } } } }