artifacts/phase4_decisions.json

{
  "recorded_utc": "2026-10-21 05:11 UTC",
  "version": "phase01-v8",
  "decisions": {
    "D4-1": {
      "choice": "three panels inline (benchmark / generalisation / FN rates) + non-comparability note; C4-C6 inline, flagged as the recorded factorial extension",
      "rationale": "Part 7 names C0-C3; the bouncer trio joined by the recorded 2026-10-03 addendum - visible, not smuggled in."
    },
    "D4-2": {
      "choice": "headline condition = C1; C5 only if audit_c5 lands in band",
      "rationale": "C1 is the best *trained* condition with its gate closed; C5's audit is the open one (section 3)."
    },
    "D4-3": {
      "choice": "the ~0.95 published number is framed as a pair-regime difference (reconciliation as a limitation)",
      "rationale": "Corpus-wide natural prevalence (ceiling 0.2406) vs the near-clone-heavy published splits; MAP@R carries the prevalence-robust companion. Not chased as a harness defect."
    },
    "D4-4": {
      "choice": "the denoising delta-ladder on C3, ONLY after a completed draft AND a SCOPE amendment",
      "rationale": "SCOPE's own 'natural next experiment' (Part 6 rule 7 keeps the bar: a clear 9-page write-up beats a half-finished extension)."
    }
  }
}