Consolidate reviewed rule and reference repairs

definitions/annotation-revisions/primary-content-20261103-provenance.json

@@ -6261,7 +6261,7 @@
   "scope_counterfactual_controls": {
     "previous_revision": "review-550-20261023",
     "proposed_revision": "primary-content-20261103",
-    "proposed_revision_sha256": "b23e2590186b4e3e2b93d22827dd4db2fd3c1d854c19b8bbbde3d5b770ecec22",
+    "proposed_revision_sha256": "5d661d01b06b5e640534fd8d371532b200c0c3db2a192be7401f0d8c51d147f5",
     "scoring_source_sha256": "7e95899ab22986ac839424377877b4ebf8bb7e4e20d3381ac256529f3f593dd8",
     "case_count": 66,
     "verification_date": "2026-11-05",
@@ -10364,5 +10364,61 @@
         "raw_capture_published": false
       }
     }
-  ]
+  ],
+  "consolidated_same_site_checks": {
+    "method": "Replay saved local answers and synthetic answers with only the verified UI labels removed.",
+    "scope": "Full task scoring with the frozen body reference. Saved answers and synthetic variants stay external.",
+    "cases": [
+      {
+        "suite": "articles",
+        "case_id": "article-044",
+        "removed_anchor_ids": [
+          "stable-29",
+          "stable-39",
+          "stable-4"
+        ],
+        "results": {
+          "saved_before": true,
+          "saved_after": true,
+          "clean_before": false,
+          "clean_after": true,
+          "shell_after": false
+        }
+      },
+      {
+        "suite": "articles",
+        "case_id": "article-102",
+        "removed_anchor_ids": [
+          "stable-27",
+          "stable-31",
+          "stable-5",
+          "stable-6"
+        ],
+        "results": {
+          "saved_before": true,
+          "saved_after": true,
+          "clean_before": false,
+          "clean_after": true,
+          "shell_after": false
+        }
+      },
+      {
+        "suite": "articles",
+        "case_id": "article-104",
+        "removed_anchor_ids": [
+          "stable-27",
+          "stable-37",
+          "stable-4"
+        ],
+        "results": {
+          "saved_before": true,
+          "saved_after": true,
+          "clean_before": false,
+          "clean_after": true,
+          "shell_after": false
+        }
+      }
+    ],
+    "revision_sha256": "6b0a346449b04198639f2592abe360c6481095f75512e491eeba41d4e032f059"
+  }
 }

definitions/annotation-revisions/primary-content-20261103-rationale.json

@@ -5,8 +5,8 @@
     "id": "review-550-20261023",
     "sha256": "1e9752b3797cbdf8f3e07faab38f0dcba9007447732b1dfb37510e6db23ce22f"
   },
-  "selection_method": "The original 91 candidates were selected after failures in 11 saved methods: 64 changed and 27 retained. The author subsequently authorized exactly two same-site corrections identified by review (article-009 and article-064), bringing the changed set to 66. This is not an outcome-independent dataset-wide correction; additional cases remain outside the approved scope.",
-  "changed_count": 66,
+  "selection_method": "The first 91 candidates were selected after failures in 11 saved methods: 64 changed and 27 retained. Review added two same-site corrections (article-009 and article-064). Consolidation audited all six Xueqiu articles and corrected three more (article-044, article-102 and article-104) using the same navigation criteria regardless of saved outcomes. This does not establish outcome-independent construction of the full dataset.",
+  "changed_count": 69,
   "retained_count": 27,
   "changes": [
     {
@@ -46820,6 +46820,90 @@
         "sha256": "5cdf2c183f597a65500033ec371799c87e9b78e7bc4919abdf24180c83c3d071",
         "scope": "Archived complete-page control for the explicitly approved same-site correction. Raw bytes remain external; not a fresh capture."
       }
+    },
+    {
+      "suite": "articles",
+      "case_id": "article-044",
+      "url": "https://www.xueqiu.com/2245748859/383327076",
+      "reason": "Apply the same article-content scope to Xueqiu articles. Omit only identified site navigation absent from the frozen body and ending references. Retain all other anchors and the ordered ending.",
+      "removed_navigation_anchors": [
+        {
+          "id": "stable-4",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "下载App"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "stable-29",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "关于雪球"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "stable-39",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "侵权投诉指引"
+          ]
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "suite": "articles",
+      "case_id": "article-102",
+      "url": "https://www.xueqiu.com/1247347556/412864128",
+      "reason": "Apply the same article-content scope to Xueqiu articles. Omit only identified site navigation absent from the frozen body and ending references. Retain all other anchors and the ordered ending.",
+      "removed_navigation_anchors": [
+        {
+          "id": "stable-5",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "下载App"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "stable-6",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "登录"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "stable-27",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "关于雪球"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "stable-31",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "侵权投诉指引"
+          ]
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "suite": "articles",
+      "case_id": "article-104",
+      "url": "https://www.xueqiu.com/7736566551/409968041",
+      "reason": "Apply the same article-content scope to Xueqiu articles. Omit only identified site navigation absent from the frozen body and ending references. Retain all other anchors and the ordered ending.",
+      "removed_navigation_anchors": [
+        {
+          "id": "stable-4",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "下载App"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "stable-27",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "关于雪球"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "stable-37",
+          "alternatives": [
+            "侵权投诉指引"
+          ]
+        }
+      ]
     }
   ],
   "retained": [
@@ -46966,14 +47050,14 @@
     "released": false,
     "population_definition": "definitions/populations/primary-content-20261103.json",
     "task_count": 530,
-    "change_scope": "Original 64 PR cases plus the two explicitly approved same-site articles, article-009 and article-064; 66 changes total. All other rules and published editions remain unchanged.",
+    "change_scope": "66 earlier scope corrections and three further Xueqiu articles verified during consolidation.",
     "allowed_uses": [
       "Fresh formal evaluations of the declared 530-task contract after adoption and input verification.",
       "Saved-answer sensitivity analysis, labelled separately from newly executed evaluations."
     ],
     "historical_ranking_certified": false,
     "dataset_wide_acceptance_correction_claim": false,
-    "bounded_source_context_review_count": 66,
+    "bounded_source_context_review_count": 69,
     "independent_historical_replay_of_all_removals": false,
     "formal_use_requirements": [
       "Adopt as a separate major edition through the existing release workflow; do not overwrite published editions.",

definitions/annotation-revisions/primary-content-20261103.json

@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
   "schema_version": 1,
   "kind": "task_scope_revision",
   "id": "primary-content-20261103",
-  "reason": "Cumulative 530-task contract with revised scopes in 66 cases: the original 64 plus two explicitly approved same-site articles. Preserve previous corrections and all other task rules; adopt as a separate major edition with fresh matched evaluations.",
+  "reason": "Cumulative scope corrections for 69 cases in the 530-task selection.",
   "parents": {
     "webfetch": {
       "tasks_sha256": "ae3aec6eab8d2d470cdeb18c4f80d238e5dd79e1108a729589b77a80fe869405",
@@ -7451,7 +7451,16 @@
       "suite": "articles",
       "case_id": "article-044",
       "before_sha256": "2824e2c91adc969da5c086f848e670378dd27973056e752ae7dc87be2b426b5f",
-      "body_ending_order": true
+      "body_ending_order": true,
+      "acceptance_patch": {
+        "anchors": {
+          "remove": [
+            "stable-4",
+            "stable-29",
+            "stable-39"
+          ]
+        }
+      }
     },
     {
       "suite": "articles",
@@ -12089,7 +12098,17 @@
       "suite": "articles",
       "case_id": "article-102",
       "before_sha256": "b38656f65092a60127478cb10c2149f29855e3d3517978208a510e1fa041afd2",
-      "body_ending_order": true
+      "body_ending_order": true,
+      "acceptance_patch": {
+        "anchors": {
+          "remove": [
+            "stable-5",
+            "stable-6",
+            "stable-27",
+            "stable-31"
+          ]
+        }
+      }
     },
     {
       "suite": "articles",
@@ -12169,7 +12188,16 @@
       "suite": "articles",
       "case_id": "article-104",
       "before_sha256": "5b7d6453f11f4cd90821f140780c9ce861f0e5671069fc1c590148c5ec63beeb",
-      "body_ending_order": true
+      "body_ending_order": true,
+      "acceptance_patch": {
+        "anchors": {
+          "remove": [
+            "stable-4",
+            "stable-27",
+            "stable-37"
+          ]
+        }
+      }
     },
     {
       "suite": "articles",
@@ -13893,8 +13921,8 @@
             "start": 16427,
             "end": 32813,
             "text_binding": {
-              "sha256": "8b7055e38453ffd67a8ca723fe15653d3fed27991bf7ede9bca0316b206d5d83",
-              "chars": 14771
+              "sha256": "f645beddb23b4b359eee715ca5fba7c40927fc23479a6bbbe26180d4f10076cc",
+              "chars": 15026
             },
             "source_text_binding": {
               "sha256": "7a6e185c78a758f543490e06bec6ad77e8ccad9947ad8d25c0ca1e6d0d90a817",
@@ -15669,8 +15697,8 @@
             "start": 8877,
             "end": 11102,
             "text_binding": {
-              "sha256": "c20189d5fca667d7650e06efccb63a0f5663ef1ac5a43e7171ff9e1b5648f955",
-              "chars": 1938
+              "sha256": "db1f08160c0a0b087c9e9ee1f64460a3e5fa84c3044c2c2e6cd0ae1f6d3b36e4",
+              "chars": 1933
             },
             "source_text_binding": {
               "sha256": "fdb7e2e68f692194f30b921c2a0faab8f38889801dbfc17e81841fbc63990cae",
@@ -16139,8 +16167,8 @@
             "start": 897,
             "end": 1122,
             "text_binding": {
-              "sha256": "dc4a2066296428e49eaef70b115c6b2e6e00ece028247cf1ff44709570388d2b",
-              "chars": 89
+              "sha256": "d33ffb2c8500aef9ce79b2fbea9c7e5d1c9db7380d6a7ce92a033de3d4427002",
+              "chars": 69
             },
             "source_text_binding": {
               "sha256": "7b5e92144c44da28771d5ce33e34cca3a487db09d01200e19eaad7b8ee8ec0b4",
@@ -25857,14 +25885,14 @@
     "released": false,
     "population_definition": "definitions/populations/primary-content-20261103.json",
     "task_count": 530,
-    "change_scope": "Original 64 PR cases plus the two explicitly approved same-site articles, article-009 and article-064; 66 changes total. All other rules and published editions remain unchanged.",
+    "change_scope": "66 earlier scope corrections and three further Xueqiu articles verified during consolidation.",
     "allowed_uses": [
       "Fresh formal evaluations of the declared 530-task contract after adoption and input verification.",
       "Saved-answer sensitivity analysis, labelled separately from newly executed evaluations."
     ],
     "historical_ranking_certified": false,
     "dataset_wide_acceptance_correction_claim": false,
-    "bounded_source_context_review_count": 66,
+    "bounded_source_context_review_count": 69,
     "independent_historical_replay_of_all_removals": false,
     "formal_use_requirements": [
       "Adopt as a separate major edition through the existing release workflow; do not overwrite published editions.",

definitions/annotation-revisions/primary-content-20261103.md

@@ -11,19 +11,21 @@ population definition and `tools/task_population.py --suite <suite>` to obtain
 the runner's comma-separated case IDs. The historical webfetch export contains
 150 tasks, so its default selection is not this proposed population.
 
-Exactly 66 cases change against `review-550-20261023`: 34 articles,
+Exactly 69 cases change against `review-550-20261023`: 37 articles,
 14 access-restriction tasks, six dynamic tasks and 12 popular-site tasks. The
-cumulative file includes earlier corrections. All other case rules, frozen input
-files, previously merged revisions, published tags and the historical default
-550-task viewer remain unchanged.
+cumulative file includes earlier corrections and the three reference verification
+repairs from PR #4. The verification repairs preserve the reference ranges and
+scoring thresholds. Frozen input files and previously published editions are
+preserved.
 
 ## Adoption and comparison
 
 This is a candidate new task contract, not an unchanged-task acceptance correction.
 The original candidates were selected after observing failures; that selection
-does not prove any requirement wrong. The author authorized the original 64 cases and exactly two additional
-same-site articles (article-009 and article-064). This PR therefore does not claim to correct every same-cause requirement
-in the catalog or to establish outcome-independent benchmark construction.
+does not prove any requirement wrong. Review added two same-site article
+corrections. A later audit of all six Xueqiu articles found three more that still
+required the same navigation labels: article-044, article-102 and article-104.
+This review does not establish outcome-independent construction of the full dataset.
 
 Under `VERSIONING.md`, changed output scope and population require a separate
 major edition. The intended use is formal evaluation of this fixed, explicitly
@@ -36,8 +38,9 @@ sensitivity analysis, not a newly executed benchmark.
 This does not establish outcome-independent construction or a universal policy
 for other tasks. The original outcome-selected construction remains a limitation
 even with fresh runs. Do not generalize these results beyond the declared workload.
-The 66 source-context records distinguish direct observations, frozen references
-and unresolved historical verification limits. Missing source evidence is never
+The earlier 66 source-context records distinguish direct observations, frozen
+references and unresolved historical verification limits. The three later
+Xueqiu checks record saved-answer replays separately. Missing source evidence is never
 a passing score or permission to bypass an input check.
 
 The PR proposes this contract; it does not create a release tag or certify an
@@ -82,6 +85,11 @@ selection. Export checks original inputs. Optional `--review-source` checks
 additional evidence files; omitting it reports those checks as unavailable.
 Successful export does not certify absent source evidence.
 
+The public archive contains task definitions and rule changes. Scoring the full
+530-task selection requires separately obtained, matching reference inputs under
+the terms described in THIRD_PARTY.md. The public archive alone cannot reproduce
+all 530 scores.
+
 After source files are uploaded, run `uv run --frozen python
 tools/rebuild_publication.py --source-revision <uploaded-full-HF-commit>` and
 `make check`. The builder preserves the historical `edition` metadata and viewer

definitions/annotation-revisions/reviews.json

@@ -18529,7 +18529,7 @@
       }
     },
     "primary-content-20261103": {
-      "revision_sha256": "b23e2590186b4e3e2b93d22827dd4db2fd3c1d854c19b8bbbde3d5b770ecec22",
+      "revision_sha256": "6b0a346449b04198639f2592abe360c6481095f75512e491eeba41d4e032f059",
       "changes": [
         {
           "suite": "webfetch",
@@ -25381,7 +25381,7 @@
         {
           "suite": "articles",
           "case_id": "article-044",
-          "changes_sha256": "4db4bdff0daf2b893ac44c1b6b5b011bff324d8db6a031754e7942d3ec13a260",
+          "changes_sha256": "3b20799c8d38ef47726cc4b35583cd8a2ef7d6fe853d2d39b6d83b7269e44b71",
           "sources": [
             {
               "path": "dataset.json",
@@ -25396,7 +25396,7 @@
             "ordered-body-ending-scattered",
             "ordered-body-ending-omitted"
           ],
-          "reason_ref": "reason-008"
+          "reason": "Apply the same article-content scope to Xueqiu articles. Omit only identified site navigation absent from the frozen body and ending references. Retain all other anchors and the ordered ending."
         },
         {
           "suite": "articles",
@@ -26937,7 +26937,7 @@
         {
           "suite": "articles",
           "case_id": "article-102",
-          "changes_sha256": "4db4bdff0daf2b893ac44c1b6b5b011bff324d8db6a031754e7942d3ec13a260",
+          "changes_sha256": "ea5ded3bdc9dd7645ae3c7a4596a0f13e772e808f728ede13e840247f4d289eb",
           "sources": [
             {
               "path": "dataset.json",
@@ -26952,7 +26952,7 @@
             "ordered-body-ending-scattered",
             "ordered-body-ending-omitted"
           ],
-          "reason_ref": "reason-008"
+          "reason": "Apply the same article-content scope to Xueqiu articles. Omit only identified site navigation absent from the frozen body and ending references. Retain all other anchors and the ordered ending."
         },
         {
           "suite": "articles",
@@ -26989,7 +26989,7 @@
         {
           "suite": "articles",
           "case_id": "article-104",
-          "changes_sha256": "4db4bdff0daf2b893ac44c1b6b5b011bff324d8db6a031754e7942d3ec13a260",
+          "changes_sha256": "2210e94d720da9e15725e023cee52484111a747fa26e0a0e3d50167f8f7513a5",
           "sources": [
             {
               "path": "dataset.json",
@@ -27004,7 +27004,7 @@
             "ordered-body-ending-scattered",
             "ordered-body-ending-omitted"
           ],
-          "reason_ref": "reason-008"
+          "reason": "Apply the same article-content scope to Xueqiu articles. Omit only identified site navigation absent from the frozen body and ending references. Retain all other anchors and the ordered ending."
         },
         {
           "suite": "articles",
@@ -27976,7 +27976,7 @@
         {
           "suite": "webfetch",
           "case_id": "live-041-python-programming-language",
-          "changes_sha256": "1231424fd07c0c2875bfee075a7e1a26c2dac47b33bb850d41f0d150d15981a1",
+          "changes_sha256": "8663da915d81a1eb7888284d6bdafc47fa107199faafe792f726fff4e04a4476",
           "sources": [
             {
               "path": "sources/live-041-python-programming-language/source.html.txt",
@@ -28901,7 +28901,7 @@
         {
           "suite": "webfetch",
           "case_id": "live-063-navigation-menu",
-          "changes_sha256": "5bb975973ac440aa36d20245488b62b09d06b4c77129ccd44d33ac6e0bfbc132",
+          "changes_sha256": "501ebe82038e29f425cd611a6ce30cd3c947fcdf295c82535e34c36b5bb9e9b1",
           "sources": [
             {
               "path": "sources/live-063-navigation-menu/current-source.html.txt",
@@ -29168,7 +29168,7 @@
         {
           "suite": "webfetch",
           "case_id": "live-069-navigation-menu",
-          "changes_sha256": "3e646181806b4ef9ab3c760057d4fad30df64d01b15590db24486f0b2eeeb0d0",
+          "changes_sha256": "73b30f48695c3393b7c475ec3558e1187f17d20beb8e6d205c9c0dc02d43ecef",
           "sources": [
             {
               "path": "sources/live-069-navigation-menu/current-source.html.txt",