msq6 commited on
Commit
e11298f
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 8dbe96c

Complete source controls for the remaining four reviewed cases

Browse files

Bind verified Amazon, NGA, Douyin and Elsevier answer sources. All 64 changed cases now have passing full-answer and rejected error-page controls. Keep task rules, frozen inputs and merged revisions unchanged. Record source projection limits; whole-population export remains unverified.

definitions/annotation-revisions/primary-content-20261103-provenance.json CHANGED
@@ -2214,7 +2214,17 @@
2214
  "decision": "Preserve gaming/forum categories, community identity and ten named thread links. Remove generic account controls and business/sales solicitation labels.",
2215
  "public_recheck": null,
2216
  "limitations": "The stable-page file proves registered labels, not their original visual placement. Original browser captures are not included. A public_recheck entry records only the independently inspected current footer destinations; absent entries are not independently verified page locations.",
2217
- "raw_capture_published": false
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
2218
  },
2219
  {
2220
  "suite": "popular-sites",
@@ -2237,7 +2247,17 @@
2237
  ]
2238
  },
2239
  "limitations": "The stable-page file proves registered labels, not their original visual placement. Original browser captures are not included. A public_recheck entry records only the independently inspected current footer destinations; absent entries are not independently verified page locations.",
2240
- "raw_capture_published": false
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
2241
  },
2242
  {
2243
  "suite": "popular-sites",
@@ -2271,7 +2291,17 @@
2271
  "decision": "Preserve shopping categories, returns/support and service destinations. Remove only generic conditions-of-use and privacy labels.",
2272
  "public_recheck": null,
2273
  "limitations": "The stable-page file proves registered labels, not their original visual placement. Original browser captures are not included. A public_recheck entry records only the independently inspected current footer destinations; absent entries are not independently verified page locations.",
2274
- "raw_capture_published": false
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
2275
  },
2276
  {
2277
  "suite": "popular-sites",
@@ -2386,7 +2416,17 @@
2386
  "decision": "Preserve content categories, creator/product services and account/help/discovery context. Remove only general legal, licensing and reporting-footer labels; do not remove the recommendation category itself.",
2387
  "public_recheck": null,
2388
  "limitations": "The stable-page file proves registered labels, not their original visual placement. Original browser captures are not included. A public_recheck entry records only the independently inspected current footer destinations; absent entries are not independently verified page locations.",
2389
- "raw_capture_published": false
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
2390
  },
2391
  {
2392
  "suite": "articles",
 
2214
  "decision": "Preserve gaming/forum categories, community identity and ten named thread links. Remove generic account controls and business/sales solicitation labels.",
2215
  "public_recheck": null,
2216
  "limitations": "The stable-page file proves registered labels, not their original visual placement. Original browser captures are not included. A public_recheck entry records only the independently inspected current footer destinations; absent entries are not independently verified page locations.",
2217
+ "raw_capture_published": false,
2218
+ "full_answer_control": {
2219
+ "origin": "evidence/research/popular-sites-name-link-v4-2026-09-16/selected-observations.json",
2220
+ "origin_sha256": "83957abe22d1d8a14e40b3a85260cd5cd9e0c96162c9c062baac65266ca7321b",
2221
+ "method": "Preserve the complete captured visible text and append only nonempty link labels and actual destinations from the same independent initial-load observation. No values are supplied from the acceptance rules.",
2222
+ "observation_date": "2026-09-16T08:26:57.590814+00:00",
2223
+ "date_scope": "Observation bundle creation time, not an inferred per-page capture time.",
2224
+ "input_path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-078-nga-cn/qualified-surface.md",
2225
+ "answer_sha256": "f85e2378638a41688785e541af4b1bf48d7bc3e9ec9cad1a8c723f499439b690",
2226
+ "raw_capture_published": false
2227
+ }
2228
  },
2229
  {
2230
  "suite": "popular-sites",
 
2247
  ]
2248
  },
2249
  "limitations": "The stable-page file proves registered labels, not their original visual placement. Original browser captures are not included. A public_recheck entry records only the independently inspected current footer destinations; absent entries are not independently verified page locations.",
2250
+ "raw_capture_published": false,
2251
+ "full_answer_control": {
2252
+ "origin": "popular-sites/review-evidence/popular-sites/homepages-selected-observations-20260916.json",
2253
+ "origin_sha256": "1f9147520aad811ada650cc29b3d1ae89cddb2d8f19b2c1890f61361bdf8bce2",
2254
+ "method": "Preserve captured visible text-node order and native heading levels. Replace a complete text-node label with its captured link only when the identical link label has exactly one observed destination. No rule-derived text, inferred DOM wrappers or ambiguous destinations are added.",
2255
+ "observation_date": "2026-09-16T09:59:03.591763+00:00",
2256
+ "date_scope": "Observation bundle creation time, not an inferred per-page capture time.",
2257
+ "input_path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-081-elsevier-com/qualified-surface.md",
2258
+ "answer_sha256": "00a5870f05a2434389d68955679a84a85c5ecaed62213b15acfdc19414462229",
2259
+ "raw_capture_published": false
2260
+ }
2261
  },
2262
  {
2263
  "suite": "popular-sites",
 
2291
  "decision": "Preserve shopping categories, returns/support and service destinations. Remove only generic conditions-of-use and privacy labels.",
2292
  "public_recheck": null,
2293
  "limitations": "The stable-page file proves registered labels, not their original visual placement. Original browser captures are not included. A public_recheck entry records only the independently inspected current footer destinations; absent entries are not independently verified page locations.",
2294
+ "raw_capture_published": false,
2295
+ "full_answer_control": {
2296
+ "origin": "evidence/research/popular-sites-name-link-v4-2026-09-16/selected-observations.json",
2297
+ "origin_sha256": "83957abe22d1d8a14e40b3a85260cd5cd9e0c96162c9c062baac65266ca7321b",
2298
+ "method": "Preserve the complete captured visible text and append only nonempty link labels and actual destinations from the same independent initial-load observation. No values are supplied from the acceptance rules.",
2299
+ "observation_date": "2026-09-16T08:26:57.590814+00:00",
2300
+ "date_scope": "Observation bundle creation time, not an inferred per-page capture time.",
2301
+ "input_path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-016-amazon-com/qualified-surface.md",
2302
+ "answer_sha256": "9a4baf258336a57ed88b793cd36a2369e8c3255fd707eca4168f555f5aa86cd6",
2303
+ "raw_capture_published": false
2304
+ }
2305
  },
2306
  {
2307
  "suite": "popular-sites",
 
2416
  "decision": "Preserve content categories, creator/product services and account/help/discovery context. Remove only general legal, licensing and reporting-footer labels; do not remove the recommendation category itself.",
2417
  "public_recheck": null,
2418
  "limitations": "The stable-page file proves registered labels, not their original visual placement. Original browser captures are not included. A public_recheck entry records only the independently inspected current footer destinations; absent entries are not independently verified page locations.",
2419
+ "raw_capture_published": false,
2420
+ "full_answer_control": {
2421
+ "origin": "popular-sites/review-evidence/popular-sites/initial-gap-homepages-20261023/douyin-card-visibility.json",
2422
+ "origin_sha256": "c6626f043ea0f2b46f1af5d2dc66f2531292ec27d0f06b05d575a4e393472813",
2423
+ "method": "Extract the html field verbatim from the declared archived DOM observation.",
2424
+ "observation_date": null,
2425
+ "date_scope": "Per-page capture time was not recorded in this archived observation.",
2426
+ "input_path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-085-douyin-com/qualified-surface.html",
2427
+ "answer_sha256": "ee4d104ec42b2a0e8ed0049a775196bc36b902b5409e2e1dde36070bdaefe800",
2428
+ "raw_capture_published": false
2429
+ }
2430
  },
2431
  {
2432
  "suite": "articles",
definitions/annotation-revisions/primary-content-20261103-review.md CHANGED
@@ -58,17 +58,22 @@ webfetch, popular sites, dynamic content and access restrictions.
58
 
59
  The declared review files for the four non-article suites were recovered and
60
  hash-checked. Complete source answers pass, and access-denied pages fail, for
61
- 14 revised access-restriction tasks, 6 dynamic tasks and 8 popular-site tasks.
62
- Together with the 32 article tasks, this covers 60 of the original 64 changes.
63
- Five additional bindings preserve complete archived HTML where text-only or
64
- missing controls could not exercise the unchanged link and record requirements.
65
- No acceptance rule was changed to make these checks pass.
66
 
67
- Full-answer verification remains incomplete for `china-homepage-078-nga-cn`,
68
- `china-homepage-081-elsevier-com`, `global-homepage-016-amazon-com` and
69
- `global-homepage-085-douyin-com`. The available references do not yet demonstrate
70
- a full-task pass. Do not treat them as verified or remove their requirements
71
- merely to accept an incomplete reference.
 
 
 
 
 
72
 
73
  These are per-case checks using recovered exact task definitions, not a full
74
  530-task export. The original webfetch dataset file was reconstructed with its
 
58
 
59
  The declared review files for the four non-article suites were recovered and
60
  hash-checked. Complete source answers pass, and access-denied pages fail, for
61
+ 14 revised access-restriction tasks, 6 dynamic tasks and all 12 popular-site tasks.
62
+ Together with the 32 article tasks, this covers all original 64 changes.
63
+ Nine additional bindings preserve complete archived HTML or faithful observation
64
+ projections where text-only or missing controls could not exercise the unchanged
65
+ link and record requirements. No acceptance rule was changed for these checks.
66
 
67
+ Amazon and NGA controls retain each independently observed visible text and its
68
+ actual named-link inventory; all three archived rounds pass for each case.
69
+ Douyin uses the archived HTML field verbatim and retains 39 complete video
70
+ records. Its companion visibility record reports scrollTop 0; the snapshot does
71
+ not supply a per-page capture timestamp or a complete interaction history.
72
+ Elsevier preserves the captured text-node order and native heading levels, and
73
+ adds a captured link only when its exact text-node label has one observed
74
+ destination. All three observations retain nine product records within the
75
+ declared text boundaries. No DOM ancestry or rule-derived content is invented.
76
+ The provenance file distinguishes raw DOM from these text projections.
77
 
78
  These are per-case checks using recovered exact task definitions, not a full
79
  530-task export. The original webfetch dataset file was reconstructed with its
definitions/annotation-revisions/primary-content-20261103.json CHANGED
@@ -24885,7 +24885,11 @@
24885
  "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-032-canva-com/source.json": "6b539f0f23db3fd1e009a3ce01b84fdfccd32b3e9b21435a37d5e701106a36da",
24886
  "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-044-spotify-com/source.json": "9c42910932c757003120fce99a299664757e93c85a2b2a4ceb4e2b8bed5e0e0f",
24887
  "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-046-zoom-us/source.json": "71f49456ade6587c9ba0c114d22cc141594f85e46f5a85353357461480f1a28b",
24888
- "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-085-douyin-com/source.json": "8ff5ff1bab0387df258a8e32cb8add38d7e4feca549b446d604741c0fb166124"
 
 
 
 
24889
  },
24890
  "articles": {
24891
  "review-evidence/articles/article-090/body.html": "0667feb4e6b962f0073241c2b277367e5869f72bc0e5ebab52fee555d82f1b1d",
 
24885
  "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-032-canva-com/source.json": "6b539f0f23db3fd1e009a3ce01b84fdfccd32b3e9b21435a37d5e701106a36da",
24886
  "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-044-spotify-com/source.json": "9c42910932c757003120fce99a299664757e93c85a2b2a4ceb4e2b8bed5e0e0f",
24887
  "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-046-zoom-us/source.json": "71f49456ade6587c9ba0c114d22cc141594f85e46f5a85353357461480f1a28b",
24888
+ "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-085-douyin-com/source.json": "8ff5ff1bab0387df258a8e32cb8add38d7e4feca549b446d604741c0fb166124",
24889
+ "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-016-amazon-com/qualified-surface.md": "9a4baf258336a57ed88b793cd36a2369e8c3255fd707eca4168f555f5aa86cd6",
24890
+ "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-078-nga-cn/qualified-surface.md": "f85e2378638a41688785e541af4b1bf48d7bc3e9ec9cad1a8c723f499439b690",
24891
+ "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-085-douyin-com/qualified-surface.html": "ee4d104ec42b2a0e8ed0049a775196bc36b902b5409e2e1dde36070bdaefe800",
24892
+ "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-081-elsevier-com/qualified-surface.md": "00a5870f05a2434389d68955679a84a85c5ecaed62213b15acfdc19414462229"
24893
  },
24894
  "articles": {
24895
  "review-evidence/articles/article-090/body.html": "0667feb4e6b962f0073241c2b277367e5869f72bc0e5ebab52fee555d82f1b1d",
definitions/annotation-revisions/reviews.json CHANGED
@@ -18529,7 +18529,7 @@
18529
  }
18530
  },
18531
  "primary-content-20261103": {
18532
- "revision_sha256": "a79c592e3db8f456fac89477a8925936c7433c825b881c8bad98cc5408d870fc",
18533
  "changes": [
18534
  {
18535
  "suite": "webfetch",
@@ -31406,6 +31406,11 @@
31406
  "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-081-elsevier-com/source.json",
31407
  "sha256": "829dc592baf1a9bcc4926ec8e6660680f55e5be060fa90463eaf44636a74c13b",
31408
  "scope": "Bound frozen task/reference record, not a fresh independent page capture for https://www.elsevier.com/en-us. Diagnostic scope review only."
 
 
 
 
 
31409
  }
31410
  ],
31411
  "regression_ids": [
@@ -34318,6 +34323,11 @@
34318
  "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-085-douyin-com/source.json",
34319
  "sha256": "8ff5ff1bab0387df258a8e32cb8add38d7e4feca549b446d604741c0fb166124",
34320
  "scope": "Bound frozen task/reference record, not a fresh independent page capture for https://douyin.com/. Diagnostic scope review only."
 
 
 
 
 
34321
  }
34322
  ],
34323
  "regression_ids": [
@@ -36150,6 +36160,11 @@
36150
  "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-016-amazon-com/source.json",
36151
  "sha256": "35519e57dc6f1b1f15ecdb08f56e3b0e618525f61b6778bb2f5f1e15881b4f89",
36152
  "scope": "Bound frozen task/reference record, not a fresh independent page capture for https://amazon.com/. Diagnostic scope review only."
 
 
 
 
 
36153
  }
36154
  ],
36155
  "regression_ids": [
@@ -36863,6 +36878,11 @@
36863
  "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-078-nga-cn/source.json",
36864
  "sha256": "23cd3a18fc9b2d6a0a60155a475fef4f595b84d1ce71a7e9170f736e9b416f1c",
36865
  "scope": "Bound frozen task/reference record, not a fresh independent page capture for https://nga.cn/. Diagnostic scope review only."
 
 
 
 
 
36866
  }
36867
  ],
36868
  "regression_ids": [
 
18529
  }
18530
  },
18531
  "primary-content-20261103": {
18532
+ "revision_sha256": "b71103e9019233e3d1d4035efbd94030ca7146c88c8339866d725e90bf0a0fb4",
18533
  "changes": [
18534
  {
18535
  "suite": "webfetch",
 
31406
  "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-081-elsevier-com/source.json",
31407
  "sha256": "829dc592baf1a9bcc4926ec8e6660680f55e5be060fa90463eaf44636a74c13b",
31408
  "scope": "Bound frozen task/reference record, not a fresh independent page capture for https://www.elsevier.com/en-us. Diagnostic scope review only."
31409
+ },
31410
+ {
31411
+ "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-081-elsevier-com/qualified-surface.md",
31412
+ "sha256": "00a5870f05a2434389d68955679a84a85c5ecaed62213b15acfdc19414462229",
31413
+ "scope": "Complete-answer control derived solely from the archived observation; provenance records the projection method."
31414
  }
31415
  ],
31416
  "regression_ids": [
 
34323
  "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-085-douyin-com/source.json",
34324
  "sha256": "8ff5ff1bab0387df258a8e32cb8add38d7e4feca549b446d604741c0fb166124",
34325
  "scope": "Bound frozen task/reference record, not a fresh independent page capture for https://douyin.com/. Diagnostic scope review only."
34326
+ },
34327
+ {
34328
+ "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-085-douyin-com/qualified-surface.html",
34329
+ "sha256": "ee4d104ec42b2a0e8ed0049a775196bc36b902b5409e2e1dde36070bdaefe800",
34330
+ "scope": "Complete-answer control derived solely from the archived observation; provenance records the projection method."
34331
  }
34332
  ],
34333
  "regression_ids": [
 
36160
  "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-016-amazon-com/source.json",
36161
  "sha256": "35519e57dc6f1b1f15ecdb08f56e3b0e618525f61b6778bb2f5f1e15881b4f89",
36162
  "scope": "Bound frozen task/reference record, not a fresh independent page capture for https://amazon.com/. Diagnostic scope review only."
36163
+ },
36164
+ {
36165
+ "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/global-homepage-016-amazon-com/qualified-surface.md",
36166
+ "sha256": "9a4baf258336a57ed88b793cd36a2369e8c3255fd707eca4168f555f5aa86cd6",
36167
+ "scope": "Complete-answer control derived solely from the archived observation; provenance records the projection method."
36168
  }
36169
  ],
36170
  "regression_ids": [
 
36878
  "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-078-nga-cn/source.json",
36879
  "sha256": "23cd3a18fc9b2d6a0a60155a475fef4f595b84d1ce71a7e9170f736e9b416f1c",
36880
  "scope": "Bound frozen task/reference record, not a fresh independent page capture for https://nga.cn/. Diagnostic scope review only."
36881
+ },
36882
+ {
36883
+ "path": "review-evidence/primary-content-20261103/popular-sites/china-homepage-078-nga-cn/qualified-surface.md",
36884
+ "sha256": "f85e2378638a41688785e541af4b1bf48d7bc3e9ec9cad1a8c723f499439b690",
36885
+ "scope": "Complete-answer control derived solely from the archived observation; provenance records the projection method."
36886
  }
36887
  ],
36888
  "regression_ids": [