{ "num_papers": 37899, "num_reviews": 102021, "papers_per_split": { "train": 31411, "test": 6488 }, "papers_per_venue_year": { "ICLR 2022": 2420, "ICLR 2023": 3431, "ICLR 2024": 6644, "ICLR 2025": 10474, "NeurIPS 2022": 2543, "NeurIPS 2023": 3108, "NeurIPS 2024": 3819, "NeurIPS 2025": 5460 }, "reviews_per_venue_year": { "ICLR 2022": 6056, "ICLR 2023": 7908, "ICLR 2024": 16102, "ICLR 2025": 26842, "NeurIPS 2022": 5587, "NeurIPS 2023": 8131, "NeurIPS 2024": 9347, "NeurIPS 2025": 22048 }, "reviews_per_paper": { "1": 6778, "2": 10294, "3": 9986, "4": 9563, "5": 1229, "6": 43, "7": 6 }, "eval_subset_size": 500, "novelty_score_by_split": { "test": { "-1": 583, "0": 1499, "1": 4121, "2": 285 }, "train": { "-1": 2341, "0": 6107, "1": 20056, "2": 2898 } }, "novelty_score_distribution": { "-1": 2924, "0": 7606, "1": 24177, "2": 3183 }, "novelty_score_missing": 9, "novelty_score_missing_ids": [ "BZ0igCEeoU", "BtPg90UEbw", "NCzNOKjKnD", "SfuH4dShOA", "ZsySJqavh3", "pKqLOmF3Lf", "phWwTrrJFv", "uNqTxj5brQ", "wCbOKbZ7kf" ], "novelty_summary_without_justification": 625, "novelty_extraction_parse_status": { "ok": 30655, "not_extracted": 5460, "repaired": 1345, "repaired_truncated": 200, "failed": 121, "recovered_heuristic": 118 }, "papers_with_no_novelty_excerpts": 5582, "mean_novelty_excerpts_per_paper": 5.49, "reviews_missing_rating": 22048, "reviews_missing_confidence": 22048, "titles_missing": 0, "abstracts_missing": 0, "title_from_openreview": 37897, "title_from_paper_text": 2, "abstract_from_openreview": 37897, "abstract_from_paper_text": 2, "papers_with_author_list": 37897, "redactions": { "abstract/author_name": 1, "abstract/url": 5803, "baseline_reviews/author_name": 50, "novelty_excerpts/author_name": 13, "novelty_excerpts/url": 2, "novelty_extraction_raw/author_name": 13, "novelty_extraction_raw/url": 2, "novelty_score_justification/author_name": 1, "novelty_summary/author_name": 1, "reviews/author_name": 1335, "reviews/url": 76 }, "papers_with_redactions": 6132, "baseline_reviews": { "num_rows": 2000, "models": [ "Llama-OpenReviewer-8B", "Llama-3.1-70B-Instruct", "Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct", "gpt-4o-2024-11-20", "claude-3.5-sonnet" ], "empty": 0 } }