{ "dataset": "data/ask_act/full.jsonl", "n_dataset": 960, "manifest": "results/reports/closurebench_ask_act_replicate_manifest.json", "runs": { "deepseek-flash": { "model": "deepseek-v4-flash", "n_repeats": 3, "replicates": [ { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-flash" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 955, "rate": 99.48 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 895, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.23 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 895, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.23 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 895, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.23 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 277, "n": 320, "accuracy": 86.56 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 277, "n": 320, "accuracy": 86.56 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 149, "n": 192, "accuracy": 77.6 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 149, "n": 192, "accuracy": 77.6 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 282, "model_asks": 341, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 82.7, "recall": 97.92, "f1": 89.67 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 282, "n": 288, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 229, "n": 288, "accuracy": 79.51 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 282, "n": 288, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 6, "n": 288, "rate": 2.08 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 59, "n": 672, "rate": 8.78 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 59, "n": 288, "rate": 20.49 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 53, "n": 59, "rate": 89.83 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 6, "n": 6, "rate": 100.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 93.12, "action_accuracy": 93.12, "full_accuracy": 93.12 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 86.56, "action_accuracy": 86.56, "full_accuracy": 86.56 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 87.71, "action_accuracy": 87.71, "full_accuracy": 87.71 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 97.92, "action_accuracy": 97.92, "full_accuracy": 97.92 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 88.54, "action_accuracy": 88.54, "full_accuracy": 88.54 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 61.46, "action_accuracy": 61.46, "full_accuracy": 61.46 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 93.75, "action_accuracy": 93.75, "full_accuracy": 93.75 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 42, "n": 96, "accuracy": 43.75 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 94, "n": 96, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 93, "n": 96, "accuracy": 96.88 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 90, "n": 96, "accuracy": 93.75 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 895, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 59, "premature_denial_from_unresolved_absence": 6 }, "repeat": 1, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_deepseek-flash_repeat_1_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-flash" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 954, "rate": 99.38 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 892, "n": 960, "accuracy": 92.92 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 892, "n": 960, "accuracy": 92.92 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 892, "n": 960, "accuracy": 92.92 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 276, "n": 320, "accuracy": 86.25 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 276, "n": 320, "accuracy": 86.25 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 148, "n": 192, "accuracy": 77.08 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 148, "n": 192, "accuracy": 77.08 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 282, "model_asks": 344, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 81.98, "recall": 97.92, "f1": 89.24 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 282, "n": 288, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 226, "n": 288, "accuracy": 78.47 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 282, "n": 288, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 6, "n": 288, "rate": 2.08 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 62, "n": 672, "rate": 9.23 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 62, "n": 288, "rate": 21.53 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 53, "n": 62, "rate": 85.48 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 5, "n": 6, "rate": 83.33 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 92.5, "action_accuracy": 92.5, "full_accuracy": 92.5 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 86.25, "action_accuracy": 86.25, "full_accuracy": 86.25 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 87.08, "action_accuracy": 87.08, "full_accuracy": 87.08 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 97.92, "action_accuracy": 97.92, "full_accuracy": 97.92 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 87.5, "action_accuracy": 87.5, "full_accuracy": 87.5 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 60.42, "action_accuracy": 60.42, "full_accuracy": 60.42 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 93.75, "action_accuracy": 93.75, "full_accuracy": 93.75 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 41, "n": 96, "accuracy": 42.71 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 93, "n": 96, "accuracy": 96.88 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 92, "n": 96, "accuracy": 95.83 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 90, "n": 96, "accuracy": 93.75 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 892, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 62, "premature_denial_from_unresolved_absence": 6 }, "repeat": 2, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_deepseek-flash_repeat_2_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-flash" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 958, "rate": 99.79 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 894, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.12 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 894, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.12 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 894, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.12 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 277, "n": 320, "accuracy": 86.56 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 277, "n": 320, "accuracy": 86.56 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 149, "n": 192, "accuracy": 77.6 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 149, "n": 192, "accuracy": 77.6 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 283, "model_asks": 344, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 82.27, "recall": 98.26, "f1": 89.56 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 283, "n": 288, "accuracy": 98.26 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 227, "n": 288, "accuracy": 78.82 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 283, "n": 288, "accuracy": 98.26 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 5, "n": 288, "rate": 1.74 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 61, "n": 672, "rate": 9.08 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 61, "n": 288, "rate": 21.18 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 59, "n": 61, "rate": 96.72 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 4, "n": 5, "rate": 80.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 92.81, "action_accuracy": 92.81, "full_accuracy": 92.81 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 86.56, "action_accuracy": 86.56, "full_accuracy": 86.56 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 87.29, "action_accuracy": 87.29, "full_accuracy": 87.29 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 98.26, "action_accuracy": 98.26, "full_accuracy": 98.26 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 88.02, "action_accuracy": 88.02, "full_accuracy": 88.02 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 60.42, "action_accuracy": 60.42, "full_accuracy": 60.42 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 94.79, "action_accuracy": 94.79, "full_accuracy": 94.79 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 41, "n": 96, "accuracy": 42.71 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 93, "n": 96, "accuracy": 96.88 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 93, "n": 96, "accuracy": 96.88 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 91, "n": 96, "accuracy": 94.79 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 894, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 61, "premature_denial_from_unresolved_absence": 5 }, "repeat": 3, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_deepseek-flash_repeat_3_scored.jsonl" } ], "metrics": { "action_accuracy": { "mean": 93.09, "sd": 0.16, "ci95_half_width": 0.39, "min": 92.92, "max": 93.23, "values": [ 93.23, 92.92, 93.12 ] }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "mean": 93.09, "sd": 0.16, "ci95_half_width": 0.39, "min": 92.92, "max": 93.23, "values": [ 93.23, 92.92, 93.12 ] }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 86.46, "sd": 0.18, "ci95_half_width": 0.44, "min": 86.25, "max": 86.56, "values": [ 86.56, 86.25, 86.56 ] }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 77.43, "sd": 0.3, "ci95_half_width": 0.75, "min": 77.08, "max": 77.6, "values": [ 77.6, 77.08, 77.6 ] }, "ask_precision": { "mean": 82.32, "sd": 0.36, "ci95_half_width": 0.9, "min": 81.98, "max": 82.7, "values": [ 82.7, 81.98, 82.27 ] }, "ask_recall": { "mean": 98.03, "sd": 0.2, "ci95_half_width": 0.49, "min": 97.92, "max": 98.26, "values": [ 97.92, 97.92, 98.26 ] }, "ask_f1": { "mean": 89.49, "sd": 0.22, "ci95_half_width": 0.55, "min": 89.24, "max": 89.67, "values": [ 89.67, 89.24, 89.56 ] }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "mean": 78.93, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.31, "min": 78.47, "max": 79.51, "values": [ 79.51, 78.47, 78.82 ] }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "mean": 98.03, "sd": 0.2, "ci95_half_width": 0.49, "min": 97.92, "max": 98.26, "values": [ 97.92, 97.92, 98.26 ] }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "mean": 21.07, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.31, "min": 20.49, "max": 21.53, "values": [ 20.49, 21.53, 21.18 ] }, "premature_denial_rate": { "mean": 1.97, "sd": 0.2, "ci95_half_width": 0.49, "min": 1.74, "max": 2.08, "values": [ 2.08, 2.08, 1.74 ] } }, "item_decision_consistency": { "n": 960, "consistent": 948, "rate": 98.75 }, "mean_parse_failures": 0.0, "mean_api_errors": 0.0 }, "deepseek-pro": { "model": "deepseek-v4-pro", "n_repeats": 3, "replicates": [ { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-pro" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 958, "rate": 99.79 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 899, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.65 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 899, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.65 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 899, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.65 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 284, "n": 320, "accuracy": 88.75 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 284, "n": 320, "accuracy": 88.75 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 156, "n": 192, "accuracy": 81.25 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 156, "n": 192, "accuracy": 81.25 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 288, "model_asks": 349, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 82.52, "recall": 100.0, "f1": 90.42 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 227, "n": 288, "accuracy": 78.82 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 61, "n": 672, "rate": 9.08 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 61, "n": 288, "rate": 21.18 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 46, "n": 61, "rate": 75.41 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 92.19, "action_accuracy": 92.19, "full_accuracy": 92.19 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 88.75, "action_accuracy": 88.75, "full_accuracy": 88.75 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 87.29, "action_accuracy": 87.29, "full_accuracy": 87.29 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 86.98, "action_accuracy": 86.98, "full_accuracy": 86.98 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 62.5, "action_accuracy": 62.5, "full_accuracy": 62.5 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 39, "n": 96, "accuracy": 40.62 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 92, "n": 96, "accuracy": 95.83 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 899, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 61 }, "repeat": 1, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_deepseek-pro_repeat_1_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-pro" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 957, "rate": 99.69 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 896, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.33 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 896, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.33 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 896, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.33 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 282, "n": 320, "accuracy": 88.12 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 282, "n": 320, "accuracy": 88.12 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 154, "n": 192, "accuracy": 80.21 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 154, "n": 192, "accuracy": 80.21 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 288, "model_asks": 352, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 81.82, "recall": 100.0, "f1": 90.0 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 224, "n": 288, "accuracy": 77.78 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 64, "n": 672, "rate": 9.52 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 64, "n": 288, "rate": 22.22 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 56, "n": 64, "rate": 87.5 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 91.88, "action_accuracy": 91.88, "full_accuracy": 91.88 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 88.12, "action_accuracy": 88.12, "full_accuracy": 88.12 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 86.67, "action_accuracy": 86.67, "full_accuracy": 86.67 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 86.46, "action_accuracy": 86.46, "full_accuracy": 86.46 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 60.42, "action_accuracy": 60.42, "full_accuracy": 60.42 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 38, "n": 96, "accuracy": 39.58 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 94, "n": 96, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 92, "n": 96, "accuracy": 95.83 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 896, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 64 }, "repeat": 2, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_deepseek-pro_repeat_2_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-pro" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 957, "rate": 99.69 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 897, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.44 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 897, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.44 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 897, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.44 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 283, "n": 320, "accuracy": 88.44 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 283, "n": 320, "accuracy": 88.44 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 155, "n": 192, "accuracy": 80.73 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 155, "n": 192, "accuracy": 80.73 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 288, "model_asks": 351, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 82.05, "recall": 100.0, "f1": 90.14 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 225, "n": 288, "accuracy": 78.12 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 63, "n": 672, "rate": 9.38 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 63, "n": 288, "rate": 21.88 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 53, "n": 63, "rate": 84.13 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 91.88, "action_accuracy": 91.88, "full_accuracy": 91.88 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 88.44, "action_accuracy": 88.44, "full_accuracy": 88.44 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 86.88, "action_accuracy": 86.88, "full_accuracy": 86.88 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 86.46, "action_accuracy": 86.46, "full_accuracy": 86.46 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 61.46, "action_accuracy": 61.46, "full_accuracy": 61.46 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 38, "n": 96, "accuracy": 39.58 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 95, "n": 96, "accuracy": 98.96 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 92, "n": 96, "accuracy": 95.83 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 897, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 63 }, "repeat": 3, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_deepseek-pro_repeat_3_scored.jsonl" } ], "metrics": { "action_accuracy": { "mean": 93.47, "sd": 0.16, "ci95_half_width": 0.4, "min": 93.33, "max": 93.65, "values": [ 93.65, 93.33, 93.44 ] }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "mean": 93.47, "sd": 0.16, "ci95_half_width": 0.4, "min": 93.33, "max": 93.65, "values": [ 93.65, 93.33, 93.44 ] }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 88.44, "sd": 0.32, "ci95_half_width": 0.78, "min": 88.12, "max": 88.75, "values": [ 88.75, 88.12, 88.44 ] }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 80.73, "sd": 0.52, "ci95_half_width": 1.29, "min": 80.21, "max": 81.25, "values": [ 81.25, 80.21, 80.73 ] }, "ask_precision": { "mean": 82.13, "sd": 0.36, "ci95_half_width": 0.89, "min": 81.82, "max": 82.52, "values": [ 82.52, 81.82, 82.05 ] }, "ask_recall": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "ask_f1": { "mean": 90.19, "sd": 0.21, "ci95_half_width": 0.53, "min": 90.0, "max": 90.42, "values": [ 90.42, 90.0, 90.14 ] }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "mean": 78.24, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.32, "min": 77.78, "max": 78.82, "values": [ 78.82, 77.78, 78.12 ] }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "mean": 21.76, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.32, "min": 21.18, "max": 22.22, "values": [ 21.18, 22.22, 21.88 ] }, "premature_denial_rate": { "mean": 0.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 0.0, "max": 0.0, "values": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "item_decision_consistency": { "n": 960, "consistent": 948, "rate": 98.75 }, "mean_parse_failures": 0.0, "mean_api_errors": 0.0 }, "llama-maverick": { "model": "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick", "n_repeats": 3, "replicates": [ { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 320, "n": 320, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 320, "n": 320, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 192, "n": 192, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 192, "n": 192, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 288, "model_asks": 288, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 100.0, "recall": 100.0, "f1": 100.0 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 672, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 960 }, "repeat": 1, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_llama-maverick_repeat_1_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 320, "n": 320, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 320, "n": 320, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 192, "n": 192, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 192, "n": 192, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 288, "model_asks": 288, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 100.0, "recall": 100.0, "f1": 100.0 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 672, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 960 }, "repeat": 2, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_llama-maverick_repeat_2_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 320, "n": 320, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 320, "n": 320, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 192, "n": 192, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 192, "n": 192, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 288, "model_asks": 288, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 100.0, "recall": 100.0, "f1": 100.0 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 672, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 960 }, "repeat": 3, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_llama-maverick_repeat_3_scored.jsonl" } ], "metrics": { "action_accuracy": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "ask_precision": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "ask_recall": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "ask_f1": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "mean": 0.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 0.0, "max": 0.0, "values": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "premature_denial_rate": { "mean": 0.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 0.0, "max": 0.0, "values": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "item_decision_consistency": { "n": 960, "consistent": 960, "rate": 100.0 }, "mean_parse_failures": 0.0, "mean_api_errors": 0.0 }, "llama-scout": { "model": "meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "n_repeats": 3, "replicates": [ { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-scout" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 13, "json_valid": { "n": 703, "rate": 73.23 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 692, "n": 960, "accuracy": 72.08 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 684, "n": 960, "accuracy": 71.25 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 681, "n": 960, "accuracy": 70.94 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 148, "n": 320, "accuracy": 46.25 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 146, "n": 320, "accuracy": 45.62 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 23, "n": 192, "accuracy": 11.98 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 23, "n": 192, "accuracy": 11.98 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 160, "model_asks": 288, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 55.56, "recall": 55.56, "f1": 55.56 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 160, "n": 288, "accuracy": 55.56 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 143, "n": 288, "accuracy": 49.65 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 160, "n": 288, "accuracy": 55.56 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 943, "n": 960, "accuracy": 98.23 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 121, "n": 288, "rate": 42.01 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 16, "n": 768, "rate": 2.08 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 128, "n": 672, "rate": 19.05 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 128, "n": 288, "rate": 44.44 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 1, "n": 960, "rate": 0.1 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 145, "rate": 0.0 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 2, "n": 129, "rate": 1.55 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 82.19, "action_accuracy": 80.62, "full_accuracy": 80.31 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 47.19, "action_accuracy": 47.19, "full_accuracy": 46.88 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 86.88, "action_accuracy": 85.94, "full_accuracy": 85.62 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 99.48, "action_accuracy": 98.44, "full_accuracy": 97.92 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 70.62, "action_accuracy": 69.79, "full_accuracy": 69.58 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 56.25, "action_accuracy": 55.56, "full_accuracy": 55.21 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 99.48, "action_accuracy": 98.44, "full_accuracy": 97.92 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 99.48, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 99.48 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 70.31, "action_accuracy": 67.71, "full_accuracy": 67.71 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 13.54, "action_accuracy": 13.54, "full_accuracy": 13.54 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 11.46, "action_accuracy": 11.46, "full_accuracy": 11.46 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 78.65, "action_accuracy": 77.6, "full_accuracy": 77.08 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 31, "n": 96, "accuracy": 32.29 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 45, "n": 96, "accuracy": 46.88 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 69, "n": 96, "accuracy": 71.88 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 94, "n": 96, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 95, "n": 96, "accuracy": 98.96 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 37, "n": 96, "accuracy": 38.54 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 55, "n": 96, "accuracy": 57.29 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 66, "n": 96, "accuracy": 68.75 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 681, "parse_failure": 4, "premature_denial_from_unresolved_absence": 121, "truth_correct_action_wrong": 9, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 128, "corrupt_action_success_truth_wrong": 1, "missed_closure_denial": 10, "premature_approval_from_unresolved_absence": 4, "other_decision_error": 1, "untargeted_or_wrong_information_request": 1 }, "repeat": 1, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_llama-scout_repeat_1_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-scout" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 11, "json_valid": { "n": 676, "rate": 70.42 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 694, "n": 960, "accuracy": 72.29 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 696, "n": 960, "accuracy": 72.5 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 687, "n": 960, "accuracy": 71.56 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 155, "n": 320, "accuracy": 48.44 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 148, "n": 320, "accuracy": 46.25 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 27, "n": 192, "accuracy": 14.06 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 23, "n": 192, "accuracy": 11.98 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 163, "model_asks": 291, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 56.01, "recall": 56.6, "f1": 56.3 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 160, "n": 288, "accuracy": 55.56 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 149, "n": 288, "accuracy": 51.74 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 163, "n": 288, "accuracy": 56.6 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 945, "n": 960, "accuracy": 98.44 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 118, "n": 288, "rate": 40.97 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 14, "n": 768, "rate": 1.82 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 128, "n": 672, "rate": 19.05 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 128, "n": 288, "rate": 44.44 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 4, "n": 960, "rate": 0.42 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 140, "rate": 0.0 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 2, "n": 130, "rate": 1.54 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 81.88, "action_accuracy": 81.56, "full_accuracy": 80.94 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 49.38, "action_accuracy": 49.69, "full_accuracy": 49.38 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 85.62, "action_accuracy": 86.25, "full_accuracy": 84.38 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 71.04, "action_accuracy": 71.04, "full_accuracy": 70.21 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 55.9, "action_accuracy": 56.6, "full_accuracy": 54.86 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 99.48, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 98.44 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 70.31, "action_accuracy": 69.27, "full_accuracy": 69.27 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 15.62, "action_accuracy": 16.67, "full_accuracy": 15.62 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 15.62, "action_accuracy": 15.62, "full_accuracy": 15.62 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 76.04, "action_accuracy": 77.08, "full_accuracy": 74.48 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 33, "n": 96, "accuracy": 34.38 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 50, "n": 96, "accuracy": 52.08 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 66, "n": 96, "accuracy": 68.75 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 36, "n": 96, "accuracy": 37.5 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 60, "n": 96, "accuracy": 62.5 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 67, "n": 96, "accuracy": 69.79 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 687, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 128, "premature_denial_from_unresolved_absence": 118, "truth_correct_action_wrong": 2, "other_decision_error": 5, "corrupt_action_success_truth_wrong": 4, "missed_closure_denial": 9, "premature_approval_from_unresolved_absence": 5, "untargeted_or_wrong_information_request": 1, "parse_failure": 1 }, "repeat": 2, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_llama-scout_repeat_2_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-scout" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 12, "json_valid": { "n": 680, "rate": 70.83 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 682, "n": 960, "accuracy": 71.04 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 683, "n": 960, "accuracy": 71.15 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 676, "n": 960, "accuracy": 70.42 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 145, "n": 320, "accuracy": 45.31 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 142, "n": 320, "accuracy": 44.38 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 21, "n": 192, "accuracy": 10.94 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 21, "n": 192, "accuracy": 10.94 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 162, "model_asks": 300, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 54.0, "recall": 56.25, "f1": 55.1 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 160, "n": 288, "accuracy": 55.56 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 141, "n": 288, "accuracy": 48.96 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 162, "n": 288, "accuracy": 56.25 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 945, "n": 960, "accuracy": 98.44 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 122, "n": 288, "rate": 42.36 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 12, "n": 768, "rate": 1.56 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 138, "n": 672, "rate": 20.54 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 138, "n": 288, "rate": 47.92 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 5, "n": 960, "rate": 0.52 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 147, "rate": 0.0 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 3, "n": 130, "rate": 2.31 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 80.62, "action_accuracy": 80.0, "full_accuracy": 80.0 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 46.88, "action_accuracy": 46.88, "full_accuracy": 46.56 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 85.62, "action_accuracy": 86.56, "full_accuracy": 84.69 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 98.96, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 98.96 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 69.17, "action_accuracy": 68.54, "full_accuracy": 68.33 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 55.56, "action_accuracy": 56.25, "full_accuracy": 54.86 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 98.96, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 98.96 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 98.96, "action_accuracy": 97.92, "full_accuracy": 97.4 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 67.71, "action_accuracy": 67.19, "full_accuracy": 67.19 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 12.5, "action_accuracy": 12.5, "full_accuracy": 12.5 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 12.5, "action_accuracy": 12.5, "full_accuracy": 12.5 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 77.08, "action_accuracy": 78.12, "full_accuracy": 76.04 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 32, "n": 96, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 52, "n": 96, "accuracy": 54.17 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 58, "n": 96, "accuracy": 60.42 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 94, "n": 96, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 94, "n": 96, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 39, "n": 96, "accuracy": 40.62 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 60, "n": 96, "accuracy": 62.5 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 62, "n": 96, "accuracy": 64.58 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 676, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 138, "premature_denial_from_unresolved_absence": 122, "truth_correct_action_wrong": 4, "corrupt_action_success_truth_wrong": 5, "premature_approval_from_unresolved_absence": 3, "missed_closure_denial": 8, "untargeted_or_wrong_information_request": 2, "parse_failure": 2 }, "repeat": 3, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_llama-scout_repeat_3_scored.jsonl" } ], "metrics": { "action_accuracy": { "mean": 71.63, "sd": 0.75, "ci95_half_width": 1.87, "min": 71.15, "max": 72.5, "values": [ 71.25, 72.5, 71.15 ] }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "mean": 70.97, "sd": 0.57, "ci95_half_width": 1.42, "min": 70.42, "max": 71.56, "values": [ 70.94, 71.56, 70.42 ] }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 46.67, "sd": 1.61, "ci95_half_width": 3.99, "min": 45.31, "max": 48.44, "values": [ 46.25, 48.44, 45.31 ] }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 12.33, "sd": 1.59, "ci95_half_width": 3.95, "min": 10.94, "max": 14.06, "values": [ 11.98, 14.06, 10.94 ] }, "ask_precision": { "mean": 55.19, "sd": 1.05, "ci95_half_width": 2.62, "min": 54.0, "max": 56.01, "values": [ 55.56, 56.01, 54.0 ] }, "ask_recall": { "mean": 56.14, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.31, "min": 55.56, "max": 56.6, "values": [ 55.56, 56.6, 56.25 ] }, "ask_f1": { "mean": 55.65, "sd": 0.61, "ci95_half_width": 1.5, "min": 55.1, "max": 56.3, "values": [ 55.56, 56.3, 55.1 ] }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "mean": 50.12, "sd": 1.45, "ci95_half_width": 3.6, "min": 48.96, "max": 51.74, "values": [ 49.65, 51.74, 48.96 ] }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "mean": 56.14, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.31, "min": 55.56, "max": 56.6, "values": [ 55.56, 56.6, 56.25 ] }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "mean": 45.6, "sd": 2.01, "ci95_half_width": 4.99, "min": 44.44, "max": 47.92, "values": [ 44.44, 44.44, 47.92 ] }, "premature_denial_rate": { "mean": 41.78, "sd": 0.72, "ci95_half_width": 1.8, "min": 40.97, "max": 42.36, "values": [ 42.01, 40.97, 42.36 ] } }, "item_decision_consistency": { "n": 960, "consistent": 812, "rate": 84.58 }, "mean_parse_failures": 12.0, "mean_api_errors": 0.0 }, "mistral-medium": { "model": "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5", "n_repeats": 3, "replicates": [ { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 960, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 894, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.12 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 894, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.12 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 894, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.12 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 269, "n": 320, "accuracy": 84.06 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 269, "n": 320, "accuracy": 84.06 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 141, "n": 192, "accuracy": 73.44 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 141, "n": 192, "accuracy": 73.44 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 288, "model_asks": 354, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 81.36, "recall": 100.0, "f1": 89.72 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 222, "n": 288, "accuracy": 77.08 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 66, "n": 672, "rate": 9.82 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 66, "n": 288, "rate": 22.92 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 6, "n": 66, "rate": 9.09 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 95.31, "action_accuracy": 95.31, "full_accuracy": 95.31 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 84.06, "action_accuracy": 84.06, "full_accuracy": 84.06 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 86.25, "action_accuracy": 86.25, "full_accuracy": 86.25 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 92.19, "action_accuracy": 92.19, "full_accuracy": 92.19 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 46.88, "action_accuracy": 46.88, "full_accuracy": 46.88 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 49, "n": 96, "accuracy": 51.04 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 87, "n": 96, "accuracy": 90.62 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 86, "n": 96, "accuracy": 89.58 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 894, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 66 }, "repeat": 1, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_mistral-medium_repeat_1_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 960, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 891, "n": 960, "accuracy": 92.81 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 891, "n": 960, "accuracy": 92.81 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 891, "n": 960, "accuracy": 92.81 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 267, "n": 320, "accuracy": 83.44 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 267, "n": 320, "accuracy": 83.44 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 139, "n": 192, "accuracy": 72.4 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 139, "n": 192, "accuracy": 72.4 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 288, "model_asks": 357, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 80.67, "recall": 100.0, "f1": 89.3 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 219, "n": 288, "accuracy": 76.04 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 69, "n": 672, "rate": 10.27 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 69, "n": 288, "rate": 23.96 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 7, "n": 69, "rate": 10.14 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 95.0, "action_accuracy": 95.0, "full_accuracy": 95.0 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 83.44, "action_accuracy": 83.44, "full_accuracy": 83.44 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 85.62, "action_accuracy": 85.62, "full_accuracy": 85.62 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 91.67, "action_accuracy": 91.67, "full_accuracy": 91.67 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 44.79, "action_accuracy": 44.79, "full_accuracy": 44.79 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 48, "n": 96, "accuracy": 50.0 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 84, "n": 96, "accuracy": 87.5 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 87, "n": 96, "accuracy": 90.62 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 891, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 69 }, "repeat": 2, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_mistral-medium_repeat_2_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 960, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 893, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.02 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 893, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.02 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 893, "n": 960, "accuracy": 93.02 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 266, "n": 320, "accuracy": 83.12 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 266, "n": 320, "accuracy": 83.12 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 138, "n": 192, "accuracy": 71.88 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 138, "n": 192, "accuracy": 71.88 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 288, "model_asks": 355, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 81.13, "recall": 100.0, "f1": 89.58 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 221, "n": 288, "accuracy": 76.74 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 288, "n": 288, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 288, "rate": 0.0 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 768, "rate": 0.0 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 67, "n": 672, "rate": 9.97 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 67, "n": 288, "rate": 23.26 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 7, "n": 67, "rate": 10.45 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 0, "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 95.94, "action_accuracy": 95.94, "full_accuracy": 95.94 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 83.12, "action_accuracy": 83.12, "full_accuracy": 83.12 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 86.04, "action_accuracy": 86.04, "full_accuracy": 86.04 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 93.23, "action_accuracy": 93.23, "full_accuracy": 93.23 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 43.75, "action_accuracy": 43.75, "full_accuracy": 43.75 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 51, "n": 96, "accuracy": 53.12 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 85, "n": 96, "accuracy": 88.54 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 85, "n": 96, "accuracy": 88.54 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 893, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 67 }, "repeat": 3, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_mistral-medium_repeat_3_scored.jsonl" } ], "metrics": { "action_accuracy": { "mean": 92.98, "sd": 0.16, "ci95_half_width": 0.39, "min": 92.81, "max": 93.12, "values": [ 93.12, 92.81, 93.02 ] }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "mean": 92.98, "sd": 0.16, "ci95_half_width": 0.39, "min": 92.81, "max": 93.12, "values": [ 93.12, 92.81, 93.02 ] }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 83.54, "sd": 0.48, "ci95_half_width": 1.19, "min": 83.12, "max": 84.06, "values": [ 84.06, 83.44, 83.12 ] }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 72.57, "sd": 0.79, "ci95_half_width": 1.97, "min": 71.88, "max": 73.44, "values": [ 73.44, 72.4, 71.88 ] }, "ask_precision": { "mean": 81.05, "sd": 0.35, "ci95_half_width": 0.87, "min": 80.67, "max": 81.36, "values": [ 81.36, 80.67, 81.13 ] }, "ask_recall": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "ask_f1": { "mean": 89.53, "sd": 0.21, "ci95_half_width": 0.53, "min": 89.3, "max": 89.72, "values": [ 89.72, 89.3, 89.58 ] }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "mean": 76.62, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.32, "min": 76.04, "max": 77.08, "values": [ 77.08, 76.04, 76.74 ] }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "mean": 100.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 100.0, "max": 100.0, "values": [ 100.0, 100.0, 100.0 ] }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "mean": 23.38, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.32, "min": 22.92, "max": 23.96, "values": [ 22.92, 23.96, 23.26 ] }, "premature_denial_rate": { "mean": 0.0, "sd": 0.0, "ci95_half_width": 0.0, "min": 0.0, "max": 0.0, "values": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "item_decision_consistency": { "n": 960, "consistent": 934, "rate": 97.29 }, "mean_parse_failures": 0.0, "mean_api_errors": 0.0 }, "mistral-small": { "model": "mistralai/mistral-small-2603", "n_repeats": 3, "replicates": [ { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-small-2603" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 960, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 807, "n": 960, "accuracy": 84.06 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 807, "n": 960, "accuracy": 84.06 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 802, "n": 960, "accuracy": 83.54 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 187, "n": 320, "accuracy": 58.44 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 186, "n": 320, "accuracy": 58.12 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 65, "n": 192, "accuracy": 33.85 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 64, "n": 192, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 253, "model_asks": 369, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 68.56, "recall": 87.85, "f1": 77.02 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 248, "n": 288, "accuracy": 86.11 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 176, "n": 288, "accuracy": 61.11 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 253, "n": 288, "accuracy": 87.85 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 35, "n": 288, "rate": 12.15 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 2, "n": 768, "rate": 0.26 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 116, "n": 672, "rate": 17.26 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 110, "n": 288, "rate": 38.19 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 2, "n": 112, "rate": 1.79 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 6, "n": 40, "rate": 15.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 90.0, "action_accuracy": 90.0, "full_accuracy": 90.0 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 64.06, "action_accuracy": 64.06, "full_accuracy": 63.75 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 98.12, "action_accuracy": 98.12, "full_accuracy": 96.88 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 75.42, "action_accuracy": 75.42, "full_accuracy": 75.42 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 87.85, "action_accuracy": 87.85, "full_accuracy": 86.11 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 96.88, "action_accuracy": 96.88, "full_accuracy": 96.88 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 83.33, "action_accuracy": 83.33, "full_accuracy": 83.33 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 16.67, "action_accuracy": 16.67, "full_accuracy": 16.67 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 63.54, "action_accuracy": 63.54, "full_accuracy": 62.5 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 97.92 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 53, "n": 96, "accuracy": 55.21 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 68, "n": 96, "accuracy": 70.83 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 66, "n": 96, "accuracy": 68.75 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 90, "n": 96, "accuracy": 93.75 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 71, "n": 96, "accuracy": 73.96 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 85, "n": 96, "accuracy": 88.54 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 86, "n": 96, "accuracy": 89.58 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 802, "excessive_ask_on_determined_case": 6, "premature_denial_from_unresolved_absence": 35, "untargeted_or_wrong_information_request": 5, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 110, "missed_closure_denial": 2 }, "repeat": 1, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_mistral-small_repeat_1_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-small-2603" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 960, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 799, "n": 960, "accuracy": 83.23 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 799, "n": 960, "accuracy": 83.23 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 795, "n": 960, "accuracy": 82.81 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 189, "n": 320, "accuracy": 59.06 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 187, "n": 320, "accuracy": 58.44 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 65, "n": 192, "accuracy": 33.85 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 63, "n": 192, "accuracy": 32.81 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 249, "model_asks": 366, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 68.03, "recall": 86.46, "f1": 76.15 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 245, "n": 288, "accuracy": 85.07 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 170, "n": 288, "accuracy": 59.03 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 249, "n": 288, "accuracy": 86.46 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 37, "n": 288, "rate": 12.85 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 7, "n": 768, "rate": 0.91 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 117, "n": 672, "rate": 17.41 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 113, "n": 288, "rate": 39.24 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 3, "n": 118, "rate": 2.54 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 8, "n": 43, "rate": 18.6 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 89.06, "action_accuracy": 89.06, "full_accuracy": 89.06 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 62.19, "action_accuracy": 62.19, "full_accuracy": 62.19 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 98.44, "action_accuracy": 98.44, "full_accuracy": 97.19 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 99.48, "action_accuracy": 99.48, "full_accuracy": 99.48 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 74.79, "action_accuracy": 74.79, "full_accuracy": 74.79 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 86.46, "action_accuracy": 86.46, "full_accuracy": 85.07 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 99.48, "action_accuracy": 99.48, "full_accuracy": 99.48 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 98.44, "action_accuracy": 98.44, "full_accuracy": 98.44 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 81.77, "action_accuracy": 81.77, "full_accuracy": 81.77 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 13.54, "action_accuracy": 13.54, "full_accuracy": 13.54 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 60.42, "action_accuracy": 60.42, "full_accuracy": 60.42 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 99.48, "action_accuracy": 99.48, "full_accuracy": 97.4 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 47, "n": 96, "accuracy": 48.96 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 67, "n": 96, "accuracy": 69.79 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 65, "n": 96, "accuracy": 67.71 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 95, "n": 96, "accuracy": 98.96 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 93, "n": 96, "accuracy": 96.88 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 69, "n": 96, "accuracy": 71.88 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 85, "n": 96, "accuracy": 88.54 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 86, "n": 96, "accuracy": 89.58 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 795, "excessive_ask_on_determined_case": 4, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 113, "premature_denial_from_unresolved_absence": 37, "premature_approval_from_unresolved_absence": 2, "untargeted_or_wrong_information_request": 4, "missed_closure_denial": 5 }, "repeat": 2, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_mistral-small_repeat_2_scored.jsonl" }, { "n_dataset": 960, "n_scored": 960, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-small-2603" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 960, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 797, "n": 960, "accuracy": 83.02 }, "action_accuracy": { "correct": 797, "n": 960, "accuracy": 83.02 }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "correct": 792, "n": 960, "accuracy": 82.5 }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 184, "n": 320, "accuracy": 57.5 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 181, "n": 320, "accuracy": 56.56 }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "correct": 59, "n": 192, "accuracy": 30.73 }, "core_semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 56, "n": 192, "accuracy": 29.17 }, "ask_metrics": { "true_positive": 243, "model_asks": 360, "gold_asks": 288, "precision": 67.5, "recall": 84.38, "f1": 75.0 }, "targeted_information_accuracy": { "correct": 238, "n": 288, "accuracy": 82.64 }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "correct": 173, "n": 288, "accuracy": 60.07 }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "correct": 243, "n": 288, "accuracy": 84.38 }, "internal_action_consistency": { "correct": 960, "n": 960, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "premature_denial_rate": { "count": 42, "n": 288, "rate": 14.58 }, "premature_approval_rate": { "count": 4, "n": 768, "rate": 0.52 }, "excessive_ask_rate": { "count": 117, "n": 672, "rate": 17.41 }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "count": 114, "n": 288, "rate": 39.58 }, "corrupt_action_success_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 960, "rate": 0.0 }, "latent_self_correction_markers": { "closure_false_errors_with_false_or_deny_marker": { "count": 3, "n": 115, "rate": 2.61 }, "unresolved_errors_with_unknown_or_request_marker": { "count": 9, "n": 50, "rate": 18.0 } }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 90.0, "action_accuracy": 90.0, "full_accuracy": 90.0 }, "lcwa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 60.0, "action_accuracy": 60.0, "full_accuracy": 60.0 }, "owa": { "n": 320, "truth_accuracy": 99.06, "action_accuracy": 99.06, "full_accuracy": 97.5 } }, "by_gold_action": { "approve": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 99.48, "action_accuracy": 99.48, "full_accuracy": 99.48 }, "deny": { "n": 480, "truth_accuracy": 75.62, "action_accuracy": 75.62, "full_accuracy": 75.62 }, "request_information": { "n": 288, "truth_accuracy": 84.38, "action_accuracy": 84.38, "full_accuracy": 82.64 } }, "by_gold_reason_type": { "entailed_by_fact_or_rule": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 99.48, "action_accuracy": 99.48, "full_accuracy": 99.48 }, "explicit_negative_fact": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 98.96, "action_accuracy": 98.96, "full_accuracy": 98.96 }, "global_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 83.33, "action_accuracy": 83.33, "full_accuracy": 83.33 }, "local_closed_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 13.54, "action_accuracy": 13.54, "full_accuracy": 13.54 }, "local_open_world_underivable": { "n": 96, "truth_accuracy": 53.12, "action_accuracy": 53.12, "full_accuracy": 53.12 }, "open_world_underivable": { "n": 192, "truth_accuracy": 100.0, "action_accuracy": 100.0, "full_accuracy": 97.4 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 46, "n": 96, "accuracy": 47.92 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 66, "n": 96, "accuracy": 68.75 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 68, "n": 96, "accuracy": 70.83 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 95, "n": 96, "accuracy": 98.96 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 96, "n": 96, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 94, "n": 96, "accuracy": 97.92 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 69, "n": 96, "accuracy": 71.88 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 86, "n": 96, "accuracy": 89.58 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 81, "n": 96, "accuracy": 84.38 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 792, "excessive_ask_under_closure_false": 114, "premature_denial_from_unresolved_absence": 42, "premature_approval_from_unresolved_absence": 3, "untargeted_or_wrong_information_request": 5, "excessive_ask_on_determined_case": 3, "missed_closure_denial": 1 }, "repeat": 3, "scored": "results/scored/ask_act_replicates/closure_contract_v3_ask_act_mistral-small_repeat_3_scored.jsonl" } ], "metrics": { "action_accuracy": { "mean": 83.44, "sd": 0.55, "ci95_half_width": 1.37, "min": 83.02, "max": 84.06, "values": [ 84.06, 83.23, 83.02 ] }, "full_decision_accuracy": { "mean": 82.95, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.33, "min": 82.5, "max": 83.54, "values": [ 83.54, 82.81, 82.5 ] }, "semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 58.33, "sd": 0.79, "ci95_half_width": 1.95, "min": 57.5, "max": 59.06, "values": [ 58.44, 59.06, 57.5 ] }, "core_semantic_switch_action_accuracy": { "mean": 32.81, "sd": 1.8, "ci95_half_width": 4.48, "min": 30.73, "max": 33.85, "values": [ 33.85, 33.85, 30.73 ] }, "ask_precision": { "mean": 68.03, "sd": 0.53, "ci95_half_width": 1.32, "min": 67.5, "max": 68.56, "values": [ 68.56, 68.03, 67.5 ] }, "ask_recall": { "mean": 86.23, "sd": 1.75, "ci95_half_width": 4.34, "min": 84.38, "max": 87.85, "values": [ 87.85, 86.46, 84.38 ] }, "ask_f1": { "mean": 76.06, "sd": 1.01, "ci95_half_width": 2.52, "min": 75.0, "max": 77.02, "values": [ 77.02, 76.15, 75.0 ] }, "closure_denial_accuracy": { "mean": 60.07, "sd": 1.04, "ci95_half_width": 2.58, "min": 59.03, "max": 61.11, "values": [ 61.11, 59.03, 60.07 ] }, "unresolved_ask_accuracy": { "mean": 86.23, "sd": 1.75, "ci95_half_width": 4.34, "min": 84.38, "max": 87.85, "values": [ 87.85, 86.46, 84.38 ] }, "excessive_ask_on_closure_false_rate": { "mean": 39.0, "sd": 0.72, "ci95_half_width": 1.8, "min": 38.19, "max": 39.58, "values": [ 38.19, 39.24, 39.58 ] }, "premature_denial_rate": { "mean": 13.19, "sd": 1.25, "ci95_half_width": 3.11, "min": 12.15, "max": 14.58, "values": [ 12.15, 12.85, 14.58 ] } }, "item_decision_consistency": { "n": 960, "consistent": 864, "rate": 90.0 }, "mean_parse_failures": 0.0, "mean_api_errors": 0.0 } } }