{ "dataset": "data/multi_agent/full.jsonl", "n_dataset": 360, "runs": [ { "label": "mistral-small", "model": "mistralai/mistral-small-2603", "repeat": 1, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-small-2603" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 360, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 291, "n": 360, "accuracy": 80.83 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 230, "n": 360, "accuracy": 63.89 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 311, "n": 360, "accuracy": 86.39 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 195, "n": 360, "accuracy": 54.17 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 17, "n": 120, "accuracy": 14.17 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 11, "n": 72, "accuracy": 15.28 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 31, "n": 106, "accuracy": 29.25 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 93, "n": 110, "accuracy": 84.55 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 12, "n": 110, "rate": 10.91 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 68, "n": 106, "rate": 64.15 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 71, "n": 166, "accuracy": 42.77 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 144, "n": 179, "accuracy": 80.45 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 56.67, "source": 35.0, "closure": 75.83, "full": 19.17 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 85.83, "source": 75.83, "closure": 88.33, "full": 66.67 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 80.83, "closure": 95.0, "full": 76.67 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 34.91, "source": 30.19, "closure": 86.79, "full": 29.25 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 30.56, "closure": 95.83, "full": 26.39 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 72.22, "full": 72.22 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 94.55, "closure": 89.09, "full": 84.55 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 71, "n": 166, "accuracy": 42.77 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 144, "n": 179, "accuracy": 80.45 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 8, "n": 21, "accuracy": 38.1 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 25, "n": 42, "accuracy": 59.52 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 18, "n": 39, "accuracy": 46.15 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 18, "n": 45, "accuracy": 40.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 1, "n": 27, "accuracy": 3.7 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 27, "n": 36, "accuracy": 75.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 25, "n": 36, "accuracy": 69.44 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 12, "n": 27, "accuracy": 44.44 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 30, "n": 36, "accuracy": 83.33 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 31, "n": 51, "accuracy": 60.78 } }, "error_types": { "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 68, "correct": 195, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 60, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 24, "closure_leakage_open_treated_closed": 12, "truth_wrong": 1 } } }, { "label": "mistral-small", "model": "mistralai/mistral-small-2603", "repeat": 2, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-small-2603" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 360, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 265, "n": 360, "accuracy": 73.61 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 254, "n": 360, "accuracy": 70.56 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 292, "n": 360, "accuracy": 81.11 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 241, "n": 360, "accuracy": 66.94 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 40, "n": 120, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 10, "n": 72, "accuracy": 13.89 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 15, "n": 106, "accuracy": 14.15 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 102, "n": 110, "accuracy": 92.73 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 6, "n": 110, "rate": 5.45 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 89, "n": 106, "rate": 83.96 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 74, "n": 166, "accuracy": 44.58 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 165, "n": 179, "accuracy": 92.18 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 50.83, "source": 50.0, "closure": 60.0, "full": 45.83 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 72.5, "source": 70.0, "closure": 88.33, "full": 66.67 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 97.5, "source": 91.67, "closure": 95.0, "full": 88.33 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 14.15, "source": 14.15, "closure": 50.0, "full": 14.15 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 83.33, "closure": 95.83, "full": 79.17 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 93.06, "full": 93.06 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 96.36, "source": 97.27, "closure": 93.64, "full": 92.73 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 74, "n": 166, "accuracy": 44.58 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 165, "n": 179, "accuracy": 92.18 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 7, "n": 21, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 16, "n": 42, "accuracy": 38.1 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 12, "n": 39, "accuracy": 30.77 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 36, "n": 45, "accuracy": 80.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 21, "n": 27, "accuracy": 77.78 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 33, "n": 36, "accuracy": 91.67 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 34, "n": 36, "accuracy": 94.44 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 20, "n": 27, "accuracy": 74.07 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 28, "n": 36, "accuracy": 77.78 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 34, "n": 51, "accuracy": 66.67 } }, "error_types": { "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 89, "correct": 241, "closure_leakage_open_treated_closed": 6, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 13, "truth_wrong": 3, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 8 } } }, { "label": "mistral-small", "model": "mistralai/mistral-small-2603", "repeat": 3, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-small-2603" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 360, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 267, "n": 360, "accuracy": 74.17 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 253, "n": 360, "accuracy": 70.28 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 290, "n": 360, "accuracy": 80.56 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 231, "n": 360, "accuracy": 64.17 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 31, "n": 120, "accuracy": 25.83 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 8, "n": 72, "accuracy": 11.11 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 17, "n": 106, "accuracy": 16.04 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 98, "n": 110, "accuracy": 89.09 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 10, "n": 110, "rate": 9.09 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 88, "n": 106, "rate": 83.02 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 75, "n": 166, "accuracy": 45.18 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 163, "n": 179, "accuracy": 91.06 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 50.83, "source": 49.17, "closure": 60.83, "full": 40.83 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 75.0, "source": 70.83, "closure": 90.0, "full": 69.17 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 96.67, "source": 90.83, "closure": 90.83, "full": 82.5 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 16.04, "source": 16.04, "closure": 55.66, "full": 16.04 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 77.78, "closure": 97.22, "full": 75.0 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 86.11, "full": 86.11 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 96.36, "source": 98.18, "closure": 90.0, "full": 89.09 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 75, "n": 166, "accuracy": 45.18 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 163, "n": 179, "accuracy": 91.06 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 8, "n": 21, "accuracy": 38.1 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 17, "n": 42, "accuracy": 40.48 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 11, "n": 39, "accuracy": 28.21 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 35, "n": 45, "accuracy": 77.78 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 19, "n": 27, "accuracy": 70.37 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 29, "n": 36, "accuracy": 80.56 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 33, "n": 36, "accuracy": 91.67 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 21, "n": 27, "accuracy": 77.78 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 28, "n": 36, "accuracy": 77.78 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 30, "n": 51, "accuracy": 58.82 } }, "error_types": { "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 88, "correct": 231, "closure_leakage_open_treated_closed": 10, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 17, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 12, "truth_wrong": 2 } } }, { "label": "deepseek-flash", "model": "deepseek-v4-flash", "repeat": 1, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-flash" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 102, "rate": 28.33 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 326, "n": 360, "accuracy": 90.56 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 353, "n": 360, "accuracy": 98.06 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 342, "n": 360, "accuracy": 95.0 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 326, "n": 360, "accuracy": 90.56 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 96, "n": 120, "accuracy": 80.0 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 48, "n": 72, "accuracy": 66.67 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 101, "n": 106, "accuracy": 95.28 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 81, "n": 110, "accuracy": 73.64 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 29, "n": 110, "rate": 26.36 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 5, "n": 106, "rate": 4.72 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 161, "n": 166, "accuracy": 96.99 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 177, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.88 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 96.67, "source": 96.67, "closure": 96.67, "full": 96.67 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 86.67, "source": 99.17, "closure": 92.5, "full": 86.67 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 88.33, "source": 98.33, "closure": 95.83, "full": 88.33 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 95.28, "source": 95.28, "closure": 95.28, "full": 95.28 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 73.64, "source": 98.18, "closure": 88.18, "full": 73.64 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 161, "n": 166, "accuracy": 96.99 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 177, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.88 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 17, "n": 21, "accuracy": 80.95 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 42, "n": 42, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 38, "n": 39, "accuracy": 97.44 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 45, "n": 45, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 27, "n": 27, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 12, "n": 27, "accuracy": 44.44 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 24, "n": 36, "accuracy": 66.67 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 49, "n": 51, "accuracy": 96.08 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 326, "closure_leakage_open_treated_closed": 29, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 5 } } }, { "label": "deepseek-flash", "model": "deepseek-v4-flash", "repeat": 2, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-flash" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 17, "json_valid": { "n": 154, "rate": 42.78 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 321, "n": 360, "accuracy": 89.17 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 352, "n": 360, "accuracy": 97.78 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 330, "n": 360, "accuracy": 91.67 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 297, "n": 360, "accuracy": 82.5 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 73, "n": 120, "accuracy": 60.83 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 45, "n": 72, "accuracy": 62.5 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 101, "n": 106, "accuracy": 95.28 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 76, "n": 110, "accuracy": 69.09 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 34, "n": 110, "rate": 30.91 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 5, "n": 106, "rate": 4.72 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 161, "n": 166, "accuracy": 96.99 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 176, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.32 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 95.83, "source": 95.83, "closure": 95.83, "full": 95.83 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 88.33, "source": 99.17, "closure": 91.67, "full": 80.83 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 83.33, "source": 98.33, "closure": 87.5, "full": 70.83 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 95.28, "source": 95.28, "closure": 95.28, "full": 95.28 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 98.61, "closure": 68.06, "full": 66.67 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 69.09, "source": 98.18, "closure": 98.18, "full": 69.09 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 161, "n": 166, "accuracy": 96.99 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 176, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.32 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 16, "n": 21, "accuracy": 76.19 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 42, "n": 42, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 38, "n": 39, "accuracy": 97.44 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 34, "n": 45, "accuracy": 75.56 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 14, "n": 27, "accuracy": 51.85 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 9, "n": 27, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 25, "n": 36, "accuracy": 69.44 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 47, "n": 51, "accuracy": 92.16 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 297, "closure_leakage_open_treated_closed": 34, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 23, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 5, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 1 } } }, { "label": "deepseek-flash", "model": "deepseek-v4-flash", "repeat": 3, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-flash" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 15, "json_valid": { "n": 151, "rate": 41.94 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 320, "n": 360, "accuracy": 88.89 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 351, "n": 360, "accuracy": 97.5 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 332, "n": 360, "accuracy": 92.22 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 297, "n": 360, "accuracy": 82.5 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 73, "n": 120, "accuracy": 60.83 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 45, "n": 72, "accuracy": 62.5 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 101, "n": 106, "accuracy": 95.28 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 75, "n": 110, "accuracy": 68.18 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 35, "n": 110, "rate": 31.82 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 5, "n": 106, "rate": 4.72 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 161, "n": 166, "accuracy": 96.99 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 175, "n": 179, "accuracy": 97.77 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 95.83, "source": 95.83, "closure": 95.83, "full": 95.83 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 87.5, "source": 99.17, "closure": 91.67, "full": 80.0 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 83.33, "source": 97.5, "closure": 89.17, "full": 71.67 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 95.28, "source": 95.28, "closure": 95.28, "full": 95.28 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 97.22, "closure": 70.83, "full": 68.06 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 68.18, "source": 98.18, "closure": 98.18, "full": 68.18 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 161, "n": 166, "accuracy": 96.99 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 175, "n": 179, "accuracy": 97.77 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 16, "n": 21, "accuracy": 76.19 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 42, "n": 42, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 38, "n": 39, "accuracy": 97.44 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 34, "n": 45, "accuracy": 75.56 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 15, "n": 27, "accuracy": 55.56 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 9, "n": 27, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 24, "n": 36, "accuracy": 66.67 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 47, "n": 51, "accuracy": 92.16 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 297, "closure_leakage_open_treated_closed": 35, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 21, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 5, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 2 } } }, { "label": "deepseek-pro", "model": "deepseek-v4-pro", "repeat": 1, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-pro" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 359, "rate": 99.72 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 343, "n": 360, "accuracy": 95.28 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 338, "n": 360, "accuracy": 93.89 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 339, "n": 360, "accuracy": 94.17 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 327, "n": 360, "accuracy": 90.83 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 94, "n": 120, "accuracy": 78.33 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 55, "n": 72, "accuracy": 76.39 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 89, "n": 106, "accuracy": 83.96 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 103, "n": 110, "accuracy": 93.64 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 110, "rate": 0.0 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 17, "n": 106, "rate": 16.04 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 153, "n": 166, "accuracy": 92.17 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 170, "n": 179, "accuracy": 94.97 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 87.5, "source": 90.83, "closure": 90.0, "full": 87.5 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 98.33, "source": 95.0, "closure": 97.5, "full": 94.17 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 95.83, "closure": 95.0, "full": 90.83 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 83.96, "source": 87.74, "closure": 86.79, "full": 83.96 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 97.22, "closure": 90.28, "full": 87.5 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 93.64, "closure": 100.0, "full": 93.64 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 153, "n": 166, "accuracy": 92.17 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 170, "n": 179, "accuracy": 94.97 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 15, "n": 21, "accuracy": 71.43 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 38, "n": 42, "accuracy": 90.48 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 38, "n": 39, "accuracy": 97.44 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 38, "n": 45, "accuracy": 84.44 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 25, "n": 27, "accuracy": 92.59 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 14, "n": 27, "accuracy": 51.85 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 51, "n": 51, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 327, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 9, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 17, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 7 } } }, { "label": "deepseek-pro", "model": "deepseek-v4-pro", "repeat": 2, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-pro" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 360, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 345, "n": 360, "accuracy": 95.83 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 352, "n": 360, "accuracy": 97.78 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 351, "n": 360, "accuracy": 97.5 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 344, "n": 360, "accuracy": 95.56 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 108, "n": 120, "accuracy": 90.0 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 61, "n": 72, "accuracy": 84.72 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 91, "n": 106, "accuracy": 85.85 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 110, "n": 110, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 110, "rate": 0.0 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 15, "n": 106, "rate": 14.15 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 158, "n": 166, "accuracy": 95.18 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 179, "n": 179, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 90.83, "source": 96.67, "closure": 96.67, "full": 90.83 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 96.67, "source": 96.67, "closure": 95.83, "full": 95.83 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 85.85, "source": 92.45, "closure": 92.45, "full": 85.85 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 98.61, "full": 98.61 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 158, "n": 166, "accuracy": 95.18 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 179, "n": 179, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 11, "n": 21, "accuracy": 52.38 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 41, "n": 42, "accuracy": 97.62 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 39, "n": 39, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 45, "n": 45, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 26, "n": 27, "accuracy": 96.3 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 23, "n": 27, "accuracy": 85.19 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 51, "n": 51, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 344, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 15, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 1 } } }, { "label": "deepseek-pro", "model": "deepseek-v4-pro", "repeat": 3, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "deepseek-v4-pro" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 360, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 346, "n": 360, "accuracy": 96.11 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 351, "n": 360, "accuracy": 97.5 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 346, "n": 360, "accuracy": 96.11 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 339, "n": 360, "accuracy": 94.17 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 103, "n": 120, "accuracy": 85.83 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 61, "n": 72, "accuracy": 84.72 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 92, "n": 106, "accuracy": 86.79 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 110, "n": 110, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 110, "rate": 0.0 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 14, "n": 106, "rate": 13.21 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 158, "n": 166, "accuracy": 95.18 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 178, "n": 179, "accuracy": 99.44 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 91.67, "source": 96.67, "closure": 96.67, "full": 91.67 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 96.67, "source": 96.67, "closure": 95.83, "full": 95.83 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 99.17, "closure": 95.83, "full": 95.0 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 86.79, "source": 92.45, "closure": 92.45, "full": 86.79 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 98.61, "closure": 91.67, "full": 90.28 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 158, "n": 166, "accuracy": 95.18 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 178, "n": 179, "accuracy": 99.44 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 11, "n": 21, "accuracy": 52.38 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 42, "n": 42, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 39, "n": 39, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 40, "n": 45, "accuracy": 88.89 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 25, "n": 27, "accuracy": 92.59 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 23, "n": 27, "accuracy": 85.19 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 51, "n": 51, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 339, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 14, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 6, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 1 } } }, { "label": "mistral-medium", "model": "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5", "repeat": 1, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 360, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 329, "n": 360, "accuracy": 91.39 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 333, "n": 360, "accuracy": 92.5 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 285, "n": 360, "accuracy": 79.17 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 262, "n": 360, "accuracy": 72.78 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 48, "n": 120, "accuracy": 40.0 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 48, "n": 72, "accuracy": 66.67 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 75, "n": 106, "accuracy": 70.75 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 110, "n": 110, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 110, "rate": 0.0 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 31, "n": 106, "rate": 29.25 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 141, "n": 166, "accuracy": 84.94 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 177, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.88 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 80.0, "source": 85.0, "closure": 76.67, "full": 61.67 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 94.17, "source": 94.17, "closure": 80.0, "full": 76.67 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 98.33, "closure": 80.83, "full": 80.0 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 70.75, "source": 76.42, "closure": 91.51, "full": 70.75 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 97.22, "closure": 55.56, "full": 54.17 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 52.78, "full": 52.78 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 141, "n": 166, "accuracy": 84.94 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 177, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.88 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 7, "n": 21, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 37, "n": 42, "accuracy": 88.1 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 36, "n": 39, "accuracy": 92.31 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 30, "n": 45, "accuracy": 66.67 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 9, "n": 27, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 14, "n": 36, "accuracy": 38.89 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 24, "n": 36, "accuracy": 66.67 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 20, "n": 27, "accuracy": 74.07 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 49, "n": 51, "accuracy": 96.08 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 262, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 31, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 65, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 2 } } }, { "label": "mistral-medium", "model": "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5", "repeat": 2, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 360, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 330, "n": 360, "accuracy": 91.67 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 336, "n": 360, "accuracy": 93.33 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 315, "n": 360, "accuracy": 87.5 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 297, "n": 360, "accuracy": 82.5 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 73, "n": 120, "accuracy": 60.83 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 49, "n": 72, "accuracy": 68.06 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 76, "n": 106, "accuracy": 71.7 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 110, "n": 110, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 110, "rate": 0.0 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 30, "n": 106, "rate": 28.3 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 143, "n": 166, "accuracy": 86.14 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 178, "n": 179, "accuracy": 99.44 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 80.83, "source": 86.67, "closure": 95.83, "full": 80.83 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 94.17, "source": 94.17, "closure": 86.67, "full": 86.67 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 99.17, "closure": 80.0, "full": 80.0 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 71.7, "source": 78.3, "closure": 88.68, "full": 71.7 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 98.61, "closure": 54.17, "full": 54.17 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 143, "n": 166, "accuracy": 86.14 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 178, "n": 179, "accuracy": 99.44 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 7, "n": 21, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 35, "n": 42, "accuracy": 83.33 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 35, "n": 39, "accuracy": 89.74 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 30, "n": 45, "accuracy": 66.67 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 9, "n": 27, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 22, "n": 27, "accuracy": 81.48 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 51, "n": 51, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 297, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 30, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 32, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 1 } } }, { "label": "mistral-medium", "model": "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5", "repeat": 3, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "mistralai/mistral-medium-3-5" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 360, "rate": 100.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 330, "n": 360, "accuracy": 91.67 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 337, "n": 360, "accuracy": 93.61 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 316, "n": 360, "accuracy": 87.78 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 297, "n": 360, "accuracy": 82.5 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 73, "n": 120, "accuracy": 60.83 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 49, "n": 72, "accuracy": 68.06 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 76, "n": 106, "accuracy": 71.7 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 110, "n": 110, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 110, "rate": 0.0 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 30, "n": 106, "rate": 28.3 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 143, "n": 166, "accuracy": 86.14 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 179, "n": 179, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 80.83, "source": 86.67, "closure": 95.83, "full": 80.83 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 94.17, "source": 94.17, "closure": 87.5, "full": 86.67 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 80.0, "full": 80.0 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 71.7, "source": 78.3, "closure": 89.62, "full": 71.7 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 54.17, "full": 54.17 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 143, "n": 166, "accuracy": 86.14 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 179, "n": 179, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 7, "n": 21, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 37, "n": 42, "accuracy": 88.1 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 34, "n": 39, "accuracy": 87.18 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 30, "n": 45, "accuracy": 66.67 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 9, "n": 27, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 21, "n": 27, "accuracy": 77.78 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 51, "n": 51, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 297, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 30, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 33 } } }, { "label": "llama-scout", "model": "meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "repeat": 1, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-scout" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 11, "json_valid": { "n": 104, "rate": 28.89 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 278, "n": 360, "accuracy": 77.22 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 274, "n": 360, "accuracy": 76.11 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 267, "n": 360, "accuracy": 74.17 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 248, "n": 360, "accuracy": 68.89 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 42, "n": 120, "accuracy": 35.0 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 10, "n": 72, "accuracy": 13.89 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 18, "n": 106, "accuracy": 16.98 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 106, "n": 110, "accuracy": 96.36 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 1, "n": 110, "rate": 0.91 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 76, "n": 106, "rate": 71.7 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 92, "n": 166, "accuracy": 55.42 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 167, "n": 179, "accuracy": 93.3 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 58.33, "source": 65.83, "closure": 54.17, "full": 50.0 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 74.17, "source": 66.67, "closure": 70.0, "full": 62.5 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 99.17, "source": 95.83, "closure": 98.33, "full": 94.17 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 27.36, "source": 33.02, "closure": 23.58, "full": 16.98 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 95.83, "source": 87.5, "closure": 95.83, "full": 84.72 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 94.44, "closure": 90.28, "full": 87.5 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 98.18, "source": 98.18, "closure": 98.18, "full": 96.36 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 92, "n": 166, "accuracy": 55.42 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 167, "n": 179, "accuracy": 93.3 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 8, "n": 21, "accuracy": 38.1 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 17, "n": 42, "accuracy": 40.48 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 16, "n": 39, "accuracy": 41.03 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 39, "n": 45, "accuracy": 86.67 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 22, "n": 27, "accuracy": 81.48 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 31, "n": 36, "accuracy": 86.11 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 32, "n": 36, "accuracy": 88.89 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 22, "n": 27, "accuracy": 81.48 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 27, "n": 36, "accuracy": 75.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 34, "n": 51, "accuracy": 66.67 } }, "error_types": { "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 76, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 21, "correct": 248, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 9, "closure_leakage_open_treated_closed": 1, "truth_wrong": 2, "parse_failure": 3 } } }, { "label": "llama-scout", "model": "meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "repeat": 2, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-scout" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 6, "json_valid": { "n": 118, "rate": 32.78 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 277, "n": 360, "accuracy": 76.94 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 281, "n": 360, "accuracy": 78.06 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 270, "n": 360, "accuracy": 75.0 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 255, "n": 360, "accuracy": 70.83 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 42, "n": 120, "accuracy": 35.0 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 11, "n": 72, "accuracy": 15.28 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 24, "n": 106, "accuracy": 22.64 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 104, "n": 110, "accuracy": 94.55 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 5, "n": 110, "rate": 4.55 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 74, "n": 106, "rate": 69.81 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 89, "n": 166, "accuracy": 53.61 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 177, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.88 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 57.5, "source": 59.17, "closure": 55.83, "full": 48.33 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 76.67, "source": 75.83, "closure": 75.0, "full": 71.67 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 96.67, "source": 99.17, "closure": 94.17, "full": 92.5 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 28.3, "source": 33.02, "closure": 28.3, "full": 22.64 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 90.28, "closure": 93.06, "full": 83.33 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 98.61, "source": 98.61, "closure": 94.44, "full": 93.06 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 94.55, "source": 100.0, "closure": 95.45, "full": 94.55 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 89, "n": 166, "accuracy": 53.61 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 177, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.88 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 7, "n": 21, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 20, "n": 42, "accuracy": 47.62 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 18, "n": 39, "accuracy": 46.15 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 38, "n": 45, "accuracy": 84.44 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 22, "n": 27, "accuracy": 81.48 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 33, "n": 36, "accuracy": 91.67 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 34, "n": 36, "accuracy": 94.44 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 21, "n": 27, "accuracy": 77.78 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 26, "n": 36, "accuracy": 72.22 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 36, "n": 51, "accuracy": 70.59 } }, "error_types": { "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 74, "correct": 255, "closure_leakage_open_treated_closed": 5, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 12, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 10, "truth_wrong": 4 } } }, { "label": "llama-scout", "model": "meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "repeat": 3, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-scout" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 10, "json_valid": { "n": 121, "rate": 33.61 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 275, "n": 360, "accuracy": 76.39 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 286, "n": 360, "accuracy": 79.44 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 266, "n": 360, "accuracy": 73.89 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 260, "n": 360, "accuracy": 72.22 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 48, "n": 120, "accuracy": 40.0 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 11, "n": 72, "accuracy": 15.28 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 24, "n": 106, "accuracy": 22.64 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 105, "n": 110, "accuracy": 95.45 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 3, "n": 110, "rate": 2.73 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 76, "n": 106, "rate": 71.7 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 97, "n": 166, "accuracy": 58.43 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 175, "n": 179, "accuracy": 97.77 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 53.33, "source": 63.33, "closure": 52.5, "full": 50.83 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 77.5, "source": 76.67, "closure": 74.17, "full": 72.5 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 98.33, "source": 98.33, "closure": 95.0, "full": 93.33 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 24.53, "source": 36.79, "closure": 22.64, "full": 22.64 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 98.61, "source": 91.67, "closure": 91.67, "full": 84.72 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 97.22, "full": 97.22 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 96.36, "source": 99.09, "closure": 96.36, "full": 95.45 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 97, "n": 166, "accuracy": 58.43 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 175, "n": 179, "accuracy": 97.77 }, "both": { "correct": 14, "n": 15, "accuracy": 93.33 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 7, "n": 21, "accuracy": 33.33 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 19, "n": 42, "accuracy": 45.24 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 19, "n": 39, "accuracy": 48.72 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 41, "n": 45, "accuracy": 91.11 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 20, "n": 27, "accuracy": 74.07 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 34, "n": 36, "accuracy": 94.44 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 18, "n": 27, "accuracy": 66.67 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 28, "n": 36, "accuracy": 77.78 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 38, "n": 51, "accuracy": 74.51 } }, "error_types": { "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 76, "correct": 260, "parse_failure": 3, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 9, "closure_leakage_open_treated_closed": 3, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 6, "truth_wrong": 3 } } }, { "label": "llama-maverick", "model": "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick", "repeat": 1, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 360, "n": 360, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 351, "n": 360, "accuracy": 97.5 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 351, "n": 360, "accuracy": 97.5 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 343, "n": 360, "accuracy": 95.28 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 106, "n": 120, "accuracy": 88.33 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 60, "n": 72, "accuracy": 83.33 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 93, "n": 106, "accuracy": 87.74 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 108, "n": 110, "accuracy": 98.18 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 110, "rate": 0.0 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 106, "rate": 0.0 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 159, "n": 166, "accuracy": 95.78 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 177, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.88 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 95.0, "full": 95.0 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 93.33, "closure": 98.33, "full": 92.5 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 99.17, "closure": 99.17, "full": 98.33 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 100.0, "source": 93.4, "closure": 93.4, "full": 87.74 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 97.22, "full": 97.22 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 98.18, "closure": 100.0, "full": 98.18 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 159, "n": 166, "accuracy": 95.78 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 177, "n": 179, "accuracy": 98.88 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 12, "n": 21, "accuracy": 57.14 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 40, "n": 42, "accuracy": 95.24 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 38, "n": 39, "accuracy": 97.44 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 43, "n": 45, "accuracy": 95.56 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 27, "n": 27, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 24, "n": 27, "accuracy": 88.89 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 51, "n": 51, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 343, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 8, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 9 } } }, { "label": "llama-maverick", "model": "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick", "repeat": 2, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 354, "n": 360, "accuracy": 98.33 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 348, "n": 360, "accuracy": 96.67 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 350, "n": 360, "accuracy": 97.22 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 344, "n": 360, "accuracy": 95.56 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 104, "n": 120, "accuracy": 86.67 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 60, "n": 72, "accuracy": 83.33 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 94, "n": 106, "accuracy": 88.68 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 110, "n": 110, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 110, "rate": 0.0 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 6, "n": 106, "rate": 5.66 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 154, "n": 166, "accuracy": 92.77 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 179, "n": 179, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 95.0, "source": 95.0, "closure": 93.33, "full": 93.33 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 95.0, "closure": 99.17, "full": 94.17 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 99.17, "full": 99.17 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 94.34, "source": 88.68, "closure": 94.34, "full": 88.68 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 97.22, "full": 97.22 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 97.22, "full": 97.22 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 154, "n": 166, "accuracy": 92.77 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 179, "n": 179, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 15, "n": 21, "accuracy": 71.43 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 39, "n": 42, "accuracy": 92.86 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 37, "n": 39, "accuracy": 94.87 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 44, "n": 45, "accuracy": 97.78 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 26, "n": 27, "accuracy": 96.3 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 35, "n": 36, "accuracy": 97.22 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 35, "n": 36, "accuracy": 97.22 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 26, "n": 27, "accuracy": 96.3 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 51, "n": 51, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 344, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 4, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 6, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 6 } } }, { "label": "llama-maverick", "model": "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick", "repeat": 3, "temperature": 0.0, "report": { "n_dataset": 360, "n_scored": 360, "coverage": 100.0, "models": [ "meta-llama/llama-4-maverick" ], "api_errors": 0, "parse_failures": 0, "json_valid": { "n": 0, "rate": 0.0 }, "truth_accuracy": { "correct": 355, "n": 360, "accuracy": 98.61 }, "source_accuracy": { "correct": 350, "n": 360, "accuracy": 97.22 }, "closure_accuracy": { "correct": 348, "n": 360, "accuracy": 96.67 }, "full_accuracy": { "correct": 343, "n": 360, "accuracy": 95.28 }, "semantic_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 103, "n": 120, "accuracy": 85.83 }, "core_switch_full_accuracy": { "correct": 62, "n": 72, "accuracy": 86.11 }, "closed_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 96, "n": 106, "accuracy": 90.57 }, "open_absence_accuracy": { "correct": 110, "n": 110, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "closure_leakage_rate": { "count": 0, "n": 110, "rate": 0.0 }, "closure_loss_rate": { "count": 5, "n": 106, "rate": 4.72 }, "agent_a_source_accuracy": { "correct": 156, "n": 166, "accuracy": 93.98 }, "agent_b_source_accuracy": { "correct": 179, "n": 179, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "by_semantics": { "cwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 95.83, "source": 95.83, "closure": 93.33, "full": 93.33 }, "lcwa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 95.83, "closure": 97.5, "full": 93.33 }, "owa": { "n": 120, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 99.17, "full": 99.17 } }, "by_closure_handling": { "closed_absence": { "n": 106, "truth": 95.28, "source": 90.57, "closure": 95.28, "full": 90.57 }, "entailed_or_explicit": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 95.83, "full": 95.83 }, "explicit_negative": { "n": 72, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 94.44, "full": 94.44 }, "open_absence": { "n": 110, "truth": 100.0, "source": 100.0, "closure": 100.0, "full": 100.0 } }, "by_source_used": { "agent_a": { "correct": 156, "n": 166, "accuracy": 93.98 }, "agent_b": { "correct": 179, "n": 179, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "both": { "correct": 15, "n": 15, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "by_family": { "closed_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 16, "n": 21, "accuracy": 76.19 }, "closed_missing_direct": { "correct": 40, "n": 42, "accuracy": 95.24 }, "closed_missing_with_open_distractor": { "correct": 37, "n": 39, "accuracy": 94.87 }, "entailed_closed_conclusion": { "correct": 44, "n": 45, "accuracy": 97.78 }, "entailed_open_conclusion": { "correct": 25, "n": 27, "accuracy": 92.59 }, "explicit_negative_closed": { "correct": 34, "n": 36, "accuracy": 94.44 }, "explicit_negative_open": { "correct": 34, "n": 36, "accuracy": 94.44 }, "open_derived_missing_antecedent": { "correct": 26, "n": 27, "accuracy": 96.3 }, "open_missing_direct": { "correct": 36, "n": 36, "accuracy": 100.0 }, "open_missing_with_closed_distractor": { "correct": 51, "n": 51, "accuracy": 100.0 } }, "error_types": { "correct": 343, "closure_loss_closed_treated_open": 5, "truth_correct_source_wrong": 5, "truth_correct_closure_wrong": 7 } } } ] }