{ "format": "openai-math-metadata-spotcheck-v1", "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-11-11T03:24:37+00:00", "reviewer": "Codex independent curation spot-check", "status": "completed_with_two_metadata_clarifications", "selection": "Purposive sample of20 available worker summaries covering all17 disciplines; prioritizes needs_review and condition-rich manuscripts. This is not a random statistical sample.", "sample_size": 20, "sample_discipline_count": 17, "sample_needs_review_count": 15, "available_worker_records_at_snapshot": 480, "expected_full_corpus_papers": 721, "snapshot_files": { "worker_results_path": "work/worker-results/papers.jsonl", "worker_results_snapshot_sha256": "4ca263bec995ced9c4e3b65ca57ad1b885e488b6fcdf4ffbf59159f8336843ac", "worker_input_path": "work/staging/openai-math/worker-inputs.jsonl", "worker_inputs_sha256": "65f39eff600544e5029b89b5069eb29b77fc75223bc63dd298bab566f7772de5", "note": "Worker result aggregation was still in progress; per-summary hashes identify the reviewed responses independently of the growing aggregate file." }, "review_scope": "Compare headline mathematical claims and essential stated assumptions in worker summaries against the actual supplied abstract, main-statement snippets and relevant opening-excerpt/headings context. Does not establish correctness of source claims or completeness of proofs.", "major_fabricated_conclusions_observed": 0, "independent_verification_status_upgrades_observed": 0, "findings": [ { "severity": "moderate", "category": "scope_definition_omitted", "paper_id": "Failure-of-finite-assembly-for-a-chromatic-overlap-at-the-prime-three-September-25-2026", "summary_evidence": "in E(2)-local S-modules", "source_evidence": "At \\(p=n=3\\), with \\(S=S_3^\\wedge\\)", "source_evidence_field": "main_statement_snippets[0]", "finding": "The summary does not define S as the derived3-complete sphere. The ambient coefficient category is part of the statement scope, so leaving it unspecified can be read more generally than the source.", "recommended_action": "Keep raw worker response unchanged for provenance. Add a separate editorial clarification or corrected display summary explicitly saying E(2)-local modules over the derived3-complete sphere.", "impact": "AI indexing metadata scope only; source training text preserves the full statement." }, { "severity": "low", "category": "quantifier_clarity", "paper_id": "Finite-Circle-Obstructions-Binary-Codes-and-Histogram-Embeddings-for-Edit-Distance-September-27-2026", "summary_evidence": "uniformly over finite alphabets ... yielding matching order in the exponent", "source_evidence": "every finite alphabet $\\Sigma$ with\n$|\\Sigma|\\geq2$", "source_evidence_field": "main_statement_snippets[0]", "finding": "The source two-sided bound specifies alphabet size at least2. The summary separates binary lower constructions and a general-alphabet upper bound, but its final matching-order phrase could obscure this qualification. This is a clarity concern rather than a demonstrated fabricated theorem.", "recommended_action": "Add a separate editorial note that the claimed matching two-sided bound is for alphabets with at least two symbols; retain the raw worker response.", "impact": "AI indexing metadata clarity only; source training text contains the restriction." } ], "papers": [ { "paper_id": "A-Capacity-Criterion-for-Four-State-Potts-Reconstruction-on-Trees-October-5-2026", "discipline": "Probability and statistical mechanics", "worker_recommended_action": "needs_review", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0000", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "5bd535ae83461f27b352b67e4fbd66fe14c6e5b7ae773082f601337110e8a61c", "worker_input_sha256": "51bd8771d8b4352db8c904201f3e2d03eeb67b32b516bdf473ae65cbca336d56", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "no_material_issue_observed", "assessment": "Preserves ferromagnetic four-state model, 0= 2 with probability one. It reports worst-case polynomial gate and qubit bounds and a fixed finite gate set containing NOT, CNOT, Toffoli, Hadamard, diag(1,i), inverses, and singly controlled versions. The excerpt describes an order trial with prescribed dyadic success probability, exact dyadic sampling, classical records, deferred verification, one amplification step, and an appendix primality test adapted from AKS. The supplied metadata includes an unresolved preamble include, so complete extraction cannot be confirmed; correctness is not independently verified." }, { "paper_id": "Failure-of-finite-assembly-for-a-chromatic-overlap-at-the-prime-three-September-25-2026", "discipline": "Topology", "worker_recommended_action": "needs_review", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0028", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "5a470ab288eb9fdb043068ff5c0319b90b0a417ce96807fea6510f461e39d0c2", "worker_input_sha256": "12d153f06ee4b2a86d89e848313dc39d4ec6461d1f2fb91e964f850697529f75", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "clarification_recommended", "assessment": "Main finite-assembly claim matches, but summary leaves the coefficient sphere S undefined; source explicitly fixes the derived3-complete sphere.", "summary_sample": "The manuscript studies whether the height-three chromatic overlap at the prime three can be assembled from rational, height-one, and height-two local spheres. It claims that at p=n=3 the object L2 LK(3)S is not in the ordinary thick subcategory generated by L0S, L1S, L2S in E(2)-local S-modules, giving a negative answer to the ordinary finite-assembly question at that scope. The reported argument uses a detector stable under finite constructions, height-two Morava E-theory, connected marking towers, completed cohomology, integral markings, decompletion, and a surviving norm-character obstruction. It also discusses prior splitting results and the companion filtered construction." }, { "paper_id": "Finite-Circle-Obstructions-Binary-Codes-and-Histogram-Embeddings-for-Edit-Distance-September-27-2026", "discipline": "Convex and metric geometry", "worker_recommended_action": "needs_review", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0028", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "1461d3ac876db8af3604b6bf138a7f2f8fa666d9d47f51b8a6648aaa1b7b2173", "worker_input_sha256": "e036542ae1448ae6a57bba6e3cf98e29283304178399407122ddd5174a27dab9", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "clarification_recommended", "assessment": "Main binary lower and finite-dimensional upper claims match; clarify alphabet cardinality>=2 when describing matching two-sided order to avoid the singleton-alphabet reading.", "summary_sample": "The manuscript studies the least ℓ1 distortion required to represent edit distance on finite words. It claims two finite-circle constructions of binary strings with distortion exp(Ω(sqrt(log d log log d))), where d bounds word length, and two direct binary coding transfers with absolute distortion and logarithmic block width. It also reports developing the overlapping-substring method of Ostrovsky and Rabani into a finite histogram embedding at the same exponential scale, uniformly over finite alphabets and all words of length at most d, including the empty word. The matching upper bound is attributed to a deterministic finite-dimensional map, yielding matching order in the exponent." }, { "paper_id": "A-direct-proof-of-the-complete-Crouzeix-inequality-September-26-2026", "discipline": "Functional analysis", "worker_recommended_action": "keep_source", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0006", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "b0717e50db5ef0f501ab5ad27d48c2068148858b13fd07140e284464a3de33c6", "worker_input_sha256": "93015a4371d002db07ba18dd8ac48a291e9be34a2ab5237116bfe46ed5bddb1e", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "no_material_issue_observed", "assessment": "Retains complete/matrix-valued numerical-range inequality with constant2, arbitrary finite dimensions and degenerate numerical ranges; explicitly attributes unverified claims.", "summary_sample": "The manuscript presents a direct proof of the sharp constant-two numerical-range inequality for matrix-valued polynomials in all finite base and coefficient dimensions. It claims this resolves the complete Crouzeix conjecture in its matrix formulation, including matrices whose numerical ranges are points or line segments. The excerpt describes a Faber-coefficient and conformal-collar approach, a singular-vector amplification estimate, and comparison of coefficient norms; section headings cover exterior coordinates, enclosing domains, and the collar. The theorem statement and auxiliary coefficient estimate are reproduced, but the supplied excerpt stops before the full argument. Claims remain unverified and are attributed to the source." }, { "paper_id": "A-Modulus-Proof-of-Cannons-Conjecture-September-23-2026", "discipline": "Group theory", "worker_recommended_action": "keep_source", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0002", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "7f92923d9ebda1fe9669bf67e288b6eb8707801881e56fb6b7d2dcb1505facb9", "worker_input_sha256": "2cc79e674149986da3396fe1a89027458ad7cfc20c40331119824c0e197de3af", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "no_material_issue_observed", "assessment": "Retains hyperbolic group with S2 boundary, proper cocompact H3 action and finite kernel; proof mechanism is source-attributed.", "summary_sample": "The manuscript claims that every hyperbolic group whose boundary is homeomorphic to the two-sphere admits a proper cocompact isometric action on hyperbolic three-space with finite kernel, resolving Cannon's conjecture positively. The reported proof uses a visual metric and the Bourdon--Kleiner modulus criterion, reducing the problem to a uniform bound on combinatorial 2-modulus at small scales. Assuming failure, it derives a scalar limit with an oscillation-measure inequality, then splits into exponential and subexponential record-growth cases, using magnifications, separating levels, a probability flow on a tree of balls, and puncture comparisons. Boundary uniformization and straightening then yield the action; torsion-free consequences are also stated." }, { "paper_id": "Eventual-Categoricity-for-Abstract-Elementary-Classes-September-24-2026", "discipline": "Mathematical logic", "worker_recommended_action": "keep_source", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0026", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "c69d6be62fae0196a8e1e4fced3cc5819fd5c322d120590d046f8285472cd922", "worker_input_sha256": "7c09d1bd7ea80dc7b06449b039352a0bfa4f67510073aa36caa248aec37d4d5e", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "no_material_issue_observed", "assessment": "Retains ZFC, every infinite LS bound, uniform threshold and same threshold in premise/conclusion; source explicitly disclaims the listed additional structural hypotheses.", "summary_sample": "The manuscript claims to prove Shelah’s eventual categoricity conjecture for abstract elementary classes in ZFC. For each infinite bound on the Löwenheim–Skolem number, it reports a uniform threshold such that categoricity in any one cardinal at or above that threshold implies categoricity in every cardinal at or above the same threshold. A qualitative tail formulation is also stated. The abstract and introduction say no amalgamation, joint embedding, tameness, no-maximal-models, or arbitrarily-large-models hypothesis is assumed. The reported proof uses set-coded order presentations, bounded-tuple calculus, isolation and geometric systems before transferring results to all larger cardinals." }, { "paper_id": "An-isomorphism-of-the-free-group-factors-September-23-2026", "discipline": "Operator algebras", "worker_recommended_action": "keep_source", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0015", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "6431fda7b7da42414677d124f837fa76983c01ea681c33106c90c6d678dbab91", "worker_input_sha256": "ad5d61bae42ae79afc0ddf4a5c2baa4f73c1b5907cc0a1282c022257042fd267", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "no_material_issue_observed", "assessment": "Retains tracial von Neumann isomorphism L(F2)=L(F3), classical interpolated-factor consequence and attributed entropy-dimension consequence.", "summary_sample": "The manuscript claims affirmative solution of the free group factor isomorphism problem by proving L(F_2) and L(F_3) are isomorphic as tracial von Neumann algebras. It states the classical free group factor alternative then implies all interpolated free group factors, including L(F_∞), are isomorphic and have fundamental group R_{>0}. The reported construction gives unital trace-preserving normal *-isomorphisms between consecutive ranks starting at rank three, using freely generating Haar tuples, a bounded logarithm, conjugates of the free generators, trace-preserving polynomial flows with a formal trace identity, and a small-cocycle coefficient estimate built from free prefix words and Catalan moment counts. An adaptive perturbation and generating-limit argument produce the limit tuple. Corollaries reportedly show free entropy dimensions depend on generating tuples, giving a negative answer to Voiculescu's invariance question." }, { "paper_id": "Exact-Birch-Swinnerton-Dyer-Formula-from-Low-Selmer-Corank-October-7-2026", "discipline": "Number theory", "worker_recommended_action": "keep_source", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0026", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "072c733f9f2e50329a0caff016db45d3c67f95d1c10178f3bef407d16e40c723", "worker_input_sha256": "9b6c6881b87fef006fb5484cdeb3945c8f6fd3205aaf2f7d80cba6a6489b92e9", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "no_material_issue_observed", "assessment": "Retains elliptic curve overQ and some prime with full q-power Selmer corank0/1, all-prime leading-term formula and listed absence of extra hypotheses.", "summary_sample": "The manuscript claims to prove the full Birch–Swinnerton-Dyer leading-term formula for every elliptic curve over the rationals whose full q-power Selmer group has corank zero or one at some prime q. It reports equality of the analytic and Mordell–Weil ranks with that corank, finiteness of the Tate–Shafarevich group, and the exact formula including all prime factors, with no additional hypotheses on reduction, torsion, isogenies, complex multiplication, or residual representations. The reported argument uses low-corank inputs, integral cohomology and determinant comparisons, theta-series congruences, and auxiliary primes to establish the central integral equality." }, { "paper_id": "An-FPRAS-for-Common-Integer-Polymatroid-Bases-with-Binary-Capacities-October-5-2026", "discipline": "Theoretical computer science", "worker_recommended_action": "needs_review", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0013", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "2ce678757cd9baab9f2ddab4b9b413bf9ef7ee0237edf3586b244174176e3922", "worker_input_sha256": "3bd38ebb678a9905603d55e0e0b7d69e5f04489a6b5235ccee2df4cc1a12a020", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "no_material_issue_observed", "assessment": "Retains exact rank-value oracles, equal total rank, binary capacities and counting each integer vector once; does not expand binary capacities to labelled copies.", "summary_sample": "The manuscript presents a fully polynomial randomized approximation scheme for counting common integer bases of two polymatroids of equal total rank, supplied by exact rank-value oracles. It states that total rank and capacities are binary encoded and each integer vector is counted once, with oracle calls and bit work bounded by a fixed polynomial in ground-set size, binary input length, inverse relative-error tolerance, and logarithm of inverse failure probability. It reports handling binary capacities without expanding them into labelled copies. The excerpt outlines reductions using retained part totals, weighted volume approximation, discrete log-concavity inequalities, paired labels, and capped annealing, while attributing its counting framework to companion manuscripts." }, { "paper_id": "De-Giorgis-conjecture-in-dimension-eight-September-26-2026", "discipline": "Partial differential equations", "worker_recommended_action": "needs_review", "worker_batch_id": "batch-0023", "worker_run_id": "10317b54-74e1-4d0f-a63a-778f0db7f1c8", "summary_sha256": "5921f2e4625e015923de9e40d1b4af7b7833d1d2c6153df13fa2fe955e19b832", "worker_input_sha256": "9d0aaf3b38e2547425c17e2f5e6ead40e24a67d88f21bd896545f788a7a8963f", "primary_claim_evidence_fields": [ "abstract", "main_statement_snippets", "source_excerpt" ], "secondary_context_fields": [ "section_titles", "extraction_flags" ], "review_status": "no_material_issue_observed", "assessment": "Retains entire C2 bounded Allen-Cahn solution in dimension8 with positive directional derivative; stable dimension7 companion and absence of energy-growth hypothesis match source.", "summary_sample": "This manuscript reports a positive resolution of De Giorgi's conjecture in dimension eight: every entire C² solution u:R⁸→(−1,1) of Δu=u³−u with an everywhere positive directional derivative is claimed to be a planar heteroclinic. It also claims every stable solution v:R⁷→[−1,1] of the same equation is a constant well or a planar heteroclinic, without an energy-growth assumption. The excerpt outlines a reduction from stable end profiles, finite-density stable rigidity, Modica gradient and energy estimates, diffuse-interface geometry, reach and surface stability, and a dimension-nine comparison. The supplied extraction has an unresolved preamble include, so definitions or macros may be missing; all claims remain unverified." } ], "limitations": [ "20-paper purposive sample only; no corpus-wide summary-quality claim.", "No independent mathematical proof assessment or Lean/Comparator execution.", "Full source proofs and every secondary method detail were not checked.", "Raw worker responses and source training text were not edited by this review." ], "resolution": { "status": "corrected_by_same_omp_deepseek_worker", "corrected_papers": 2, "supersession_map": "worker-curation/supersession-map.json", "correction_records": "worker-curation/original-workers.jsonl", "mathematics_verified": false } }