Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2005 to 2006?
Reference time interval: 2005-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 41%.

Rejected response: -18%.

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2005 to 2006?

Answer: 41%

we entered into these contingent guarantees in the normal course of business , and they include guaranteed obligations related to our headquarters building , equipment financings , and affiliated operations .

millions of dollars the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ; the rental income of 2005 is $ 59 ; the rental income of 2004 is $ 55 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2006 is $ 118 ; the total of 2005 is $ 145 ; the total of 2004 is $ 88 ;

Answer: 41%

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -18%

other income other income included the following for the years ended december 31 : millions of dollars 2008 2007 2006 .

millions of dollars the rental income of 2008 is $ 87 ; the rental income of 2007 is $ 68 ; the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2008 is $ 92 ; the total of 2007 is $ 116 ; the total of 2006 is $ 118 ;

Answer: -18%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2005 to 2006?
Reference time interval: 2005-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 41%.

Rejected response: 28%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in rental income <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2005 to 2006?

Answer: 41%

millions of dollars the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ; the rental income of 2005 is $ 59 ; the rental income of 2004 is $ 55 ;

millions of dollars The interest income of 2006 is 29 ; The interest income of 2005 is 17 ; The interest income of 2004 is 10 ;

other income other income included the following for the years ended december 31 : millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

we entered into these contingent guarantees in the normal course of business , and they include guaranteed obligations related to our headquarters building , equipment financings , and affiliated operations .

millions of dollars the total of 2006 is $ 118 ; the total of 2005 is $ 145 ; the total of 2004 is $ 88 ;

Answer: 41%

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 28%

millions of dollars the rental income of 2008 is $ 87 ; the rental income of 2007 is $ 68 ; the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ;

millions of dollars The interest income of 2008 is 21 ; The interest income of 2007 is 50 ; The interest income of 2006 is 29 ;

other income other income included the following for the years ended december 31 : millions of dollars 2008 2007 2006 .

millions of dollars the total of 2008 is $ 92 ; the total of 2007 is $ 116 ; the total of 2006 is $ 118 ;

Answer: 28%

Constructed heuristically from grouped FinQA questions after replacing time expressions with <TIME>.


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2005 to 2006?
Reference time interval: 2005-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 41%.

Rejected response: 7%.

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2005 to 2006?

Answer: 41%

we entered into these contingent guarantees in the normal course of business , and they include guaranteed obligations related to our headquarters building , equipment financings , and affiliated operations .

millions of dollars the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ; the rental income of 2005 is $ 59 ; the rental income of 2004 is $ 55 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2006 is $ 118 ; the total of 2005 is $ 145 ; the total of 2004 is $ 88 ;

Answer: 41%

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2004 to 2005?

Answer: 7%

other income other income included the following for the years ended december 31 : millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

Answer: 7%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2004 to 2005?
Reference time interval: 2004-01-01 00:00:00 to 2006-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 7%.

Rejected response: -18%.

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2004 to 2005?

Answer: 7%

other income other income included the following for the years ended december 31 : millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

millions of dollars the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ; the rental income of 2005 is $ 59 ; the rental income of 2004 is $ 55 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2006 is $ 118 ; the total of 2005 is $ 145 ; the total of 2004 is $ 88 ;

Answer: 7%

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -18%

other income other income included the following for the years ended december 31 : millions of dollars 2008 2007 2006 .

millions of dollars the rental income of 2008 is $ 87 ; the rental income of 2007 is $ 68 ; the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2008 is $ 92 ; the total of 2007 is $ 116 ; the total of 2006 is $ 118 ;

Answer: -18%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2004 to 2005?
Reference time interval: 2004-01-01 00:00:00 to 2006-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 7%.

Rejected response: 28%.

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2004 to 2005?

Answer: 7%

other income other income included the following for the years ended december 31 : millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

millions of dollars the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ; the rental income of 2005 is $ 59 ; the rental income of 2004 is $ 55 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2006 is $ 118 ; the total of 2005 is $ 145 ; the total of 2004 is $ 88 ;

Answer: 7%

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 28%

other income other income included the following for the years ended december 31 : millions of dollars 2008 2007 2006 .

millions of dollars the rental income of 2008 is $ 87 ; the rental income of 2007 is $ 68 ; the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2008 is $ 92 ; the total of 2007 is $ 116 ; the total of 2006 is $ 118 ;

Answer: 28%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2004 to 2005?
Reference time interval: 2004-01-01 00:00:00 to 2006-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 7%.

Rejected response: 41%.

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2004 to 2005?

Answer: 7%

other income other income included the following for the years ended december 31 : millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

millions of dollars the rental income of 2006 is $ 83 ; the rental income of 2005 is $ 59 ; the rental income of 2004 is $ 55 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2006 is $ 118 ; the total of 2005 is $ 145 ; the total of 2004 is $ 88 ;

Answer: 7%

Question: what was the percentage change in rental income from 2005 to 2006?

Answer: 41%

we entered into these contingent guarantees in the normal course of business , and they include guaranteed obligations related to our headquarters building , equipment financings , and affiliated operations .

Answer: 41%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -2.0%.

Rejected response: 15.4%.

BLK || what is the growth rate in operating income <TIME>?

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: -2.0%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5272 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5287 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2015 is $ 4695 ;

Answer: -2.0%

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 15.4%

Answer: 15.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -2.0%.

Rejected response: 4.2%.

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: -2.0%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5272 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5287 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2015 is $ 4695 ;

Answer: -2.0%

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2014 to 2015?

Answer: 4.2%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2014 is $ 4474 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4695 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2014 is $ 4563 ;

( in millions ) the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4462 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4595 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2014 is $ 4425 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4566 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4625 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of 2014 is $ 4507 ;

Answer: 4.2%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 15.4%.

Rejected response: -2.0%.

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 15.4%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5272 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5287 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2015 is $ 4695 ;

Answer: 15.4%

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: -2.0%

Answer: -2.0%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 15.4%.

Rejected response: 4.2%.

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 15.4%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5272 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5287 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2015 is $ 4695 ;

Answer: 15.4%

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2014 to 2015?

Answer: 4.2%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2014 is $ 4474 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4695 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2014 is $ 4563 ;

( in millions ) the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4462 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4595 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2014 is $ 4425 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4566 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4625 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of 2014 is $ 4507 ;

Answer: 4.2%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2014 to 2015?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2016-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 4.2%.

Rejected response: -2.0%.

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2014 to 2015?

Answer: 4.2%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2014 is $ 4474 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4695 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2014 is $ 4563 ;

( in millions ) the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4462 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4595 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2014 is $ 4425 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4566 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4625 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of 2014 is $ 4507 ;

Answer: 4.2%

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: -2.0%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5272 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5287 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2015 is $ 4695 ;

Answer: -2.0%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2014 to 2015?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2016-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 4.2%.

Rejected response: 15.4%.

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2014 to 2015?

Answer: 4.2%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2014 is $ 4474 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4695 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2014 is $ 4563 ;

( in millions ) the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4462 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4595 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2014 is $ 4425 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4566 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4625 ; the income before income taxes ( 2 ) of 2014 is $ 4507 ;

Answer: 4.2%

Question: what is the growth rate in operating income from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 15.4%

( in millions ) the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5272 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4570 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2015 is $ 4664 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2017 is $ 5287 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of gaap 2016 is $ 4674 ; the operating income ( 1 ) of 2015 is $ 4695 ;

Answer: 15.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2017?
Reference time interval: 2017-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 100.

Rejected response: 82.

MO || what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states <TIME>?

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2017?

Answer: 100

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 100

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2015?

Answer: 82

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 82


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2017?
Reference time interval: 2017-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 100.

Rejected response: 84.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2017?

Answer: 100

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 100

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2016?

Answer: 84

Answer: 84


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2017?
Reference time interval: 2017-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 100.

Rejected response: 85.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2017?

Answer: 100

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 100

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2014?

Answer: 85

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 85


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2015?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2016-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 82.

Rejected response: 100.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2015?

Answer: 82

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 82

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2017?

Answer: 100

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 100


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2015?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2016-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 82.

Rejected response: 84.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2015?

Answer: 82

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 82

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2016?

Answer: 84

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 84


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2015?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2016-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 82.

Rejected response: 85.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2015?

Answer: 82

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 82

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2014?

Answer: 85

Answer: 85


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2016?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 84.

Rejected response: 100.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2016?

Answer: 84

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 84

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2017?

Answer: 100

Answer: 100


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2016?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 84.

Rejected response: 82.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2016?

Answer: 84

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 84

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2015?

Answer: 82

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 82


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2016?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 84.

Rejected response: 85.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2016?

Answer: 84

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 84

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2014?

Answer: 85

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 85


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2014?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 85.

Rejected response: 100.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2014?

Answer: 85

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 85

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2017?

Answer: 100

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 100


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2014?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 85.

Rejected response: 82.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2014?

Answer: 85

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 85

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2015?

Answer: 82

Answer: 82


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2014?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 85.

Rejected response: 84.

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2014?

Answer: 85

the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2015 is 65 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 2 ) of 2014 is 67 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2015 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 3 ) of 2014 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2015 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 4 ) of 2014 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2014 is 12 ;

Answer: 85

Question: what are the total number of pending tobacco-related cases in united states in 2016?

Answer: 84

the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2017 is 92 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2016 is 70 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of 2015 is 65 ;

the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2017 is 4 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2016 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of 2015 is 5 ;

the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2017 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2016 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of 2015 is 1 ;

the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2017 is 3 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2016 is 8 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of 2015 is 11 ;

Answer: 84


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: by what amount is the non-operating income gaap basis higher in 2013 compare to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 170.

Rejected response: 60.

BLK || by what amount is the non-operating income gaap basis higher <TIME> compare to <TIME>?

Question: by what amount is the non-operating income gaap basis higher in 2013 compare to 2012?

Answer: 170

( in millions ) the nonoperating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2013 is $ 116 ; the nonoperating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the nonoperating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ;

( in millions ) 2013 2012 2011 nonoperating income ( expense ) , gaap basis $ 116 $ ( 54 ) $ ( 114 ) less : net income ( loss ) attributable to nci 19 ( 18 ) 2 .

management uses both gaap and non-gaap financial measures in evaluating blackrock 2019s financial performance .

( in millions ) the nonoperating income ( expense ) of 2013 is 97 ; the nonoperating income ( expense ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the nonoperating income ( expense ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ;

Answer: 170

Question: by what amount is the non-operating income gaap basis higher in 2012 compare to 2011?

Answer: 60

Answer: 60


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: by what amount is the non-operating income gaap basis higher in 2012 compare to 2011?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 60.

Rejected response: 170.

Question: by what amount is the non-operating income gaap basis higher in 2012 compare to 2011?

Answer: 60

( in millions ) 2013 2012 2011 nonoperating income ( expense ) , gaap basis $ 116 $ ( 54 ) $ ( 114 ) less : net income ( loss ) attributable to nci 19 ( 18 ) 2 .

( in millions ) the nonoperating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2013 is $ 116 ; the nonoperating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the nonoperating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ;

( in millions ) the nonoperating income ( expense ) of 2013 is 97 ; the nonoperating income ( expense ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the nonoperating income ( expense ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ;

Answer: 60

Question: by what amount is the non-operating income gaap basis higher in 2013 compare to 2012?

Answer: 170

Answer: 170


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in accrued wages and vacation from 2014 to 2015?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2016-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -4%.

Rejected response: 4%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in accrued wages and vacation <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in accrued wages and vacation from 2014 to 2015?

Answer: -4%

millions the accrued wages and vacation of dec . 31 2015 is 391 ; the accrued wages and vacation of dec . 31 2014 is 409 ;

millions The accrued casualty costs of dec . 31 2015 is 181 ; The accrued casualty costs of dec . 31 2014 is 249 ;

the 2015 dividends paid amount includes the fourth quarter 2014 dividend of $ 438 million , which was paid on january 2 , 2015 , the first quarter 2015 dividend of $ 484 million , which was paid on march 30 , 2015 , the second quarter 2015 dividend of $ 479 million , which was paid on june 30 , 2015 , the third quarter 2015 dividend of $ 476 million , which was paid on september 30 , 2015 , as well as the fourth quarter 2015 dividend of $ 467 million , which was paid on december 30 , 2015 .

Answer: -4%

Question: what was the percentage change in accrued wages and vacation from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 4%

millions the accrued wages and vacation of dec . 31 2012 is 376 ; the accrued wages and vacation of dec . 312011 is 363 ;

millions The accrued casualty costs of dec . 31 2012 is 213 ; The accrued casualty costs of dec . 312011 is 249 ;

a large portion of our capital expenditures is for replacement of existing track assets and other road properties , which is typically performed by our employees , and for track line expansion and other capacity projects .

normal repairs and maintenance , including rail grinding , are also expensed as incurred , while costs incurred that extend the useful life of an asset , improve the safety of our operations or improve operating efficiency are capitalized .

Answer: 4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in accrued wages and vacation from 2011 to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 4%.

Rejected response: -4%.

Question: what was the percentage change in accrued wages and vacation from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 4%

a large portion of our capital expenditures is for replacement of existing track assets and other road properties , which is typically performed by our employees , and for track line expansion and other capacity projects .

normal repairs and maintenance , including rail grinding , are also expensed as incurred , while costs incurred that extend the useful life of an asset , improve the safety of our operations or improve operating efficiency are capitalized .

millions the accrued wages and vacation of dec . 31 2012 is 376 ; the accrued wages and vacation of dec . 312011 is 363 ;

Answer: 4%

Question: what was the percentage change in accrued wages and vacation from 2014 to 2015?

Answer: -4%

millions the accrued wages and vacation of dec . 31 2015 is 391 ; the accrued wages and vacation of dec . 31 2014 is 409 ;

the 2015 dividends paid amount includes the fourth quarter 2014 dividend of $ 438 million , which was paid on january 2 , 2015 , the first quarter 2015 dividend of $ 484 million , which was paid on march 30 , 2015 , the second quarter 2015 dividend of $ 479 million , which was paid on june 30 , 2015 , the third quarter 2015 dividend of $ 476 million , which was paid on september 30 , 2015 , as well as the fourth quarter 2015 dividend of $ 467 million , which was paid on december 30 , 2015 .

Answer: -4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2014?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 23%.

Rejected response: 24%.

UNP || what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel <TIME>?

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2014?

Answer: 23%

millions the fuel of 2014 is 3539 ; the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is - ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ;

millions the total of 2014 is $ 15235 ; the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 5% ( 5 % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2% ( 2 % ) ;

expenses for purchased services increased 8% ( 8 % ) compared to 2013 primarily due to volume- 2014 operating expenses .

millions the depreciation of 2014 is 1904 ; the depreciation of 2013 is 1777 ; the depreciation of 2012 is 1760 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 7 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 1 ;

Answer: 23%

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2013?

Answer: 24%

operating expenses millions 2014 2013 2012 % (  % ) change 2014 v 2013 % (  % ) change 2013 v 2012 .

Answer: 24%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2014?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 23%.

Rejected response: 25%.

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2014?

Answer: 23%

millions the fuel of 2014 is 3539 ; the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is - ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ;

millions the depreciation of 2014 is 1904 ; the depreciation of 2013 is 1777 ; the depreciation of 2012 is 1760 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 7 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 1 ;

millions the total of 2014 is $ 15235 ; the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 5% ( 5 % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2% ( 2 % ) ;

Answer: 23%

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2012?

Answer: 25%

millions the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of 2011 is 3581 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2012 v 2011 is 1 ;

millions the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of 2011 is $ 13833 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2 % ( % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2012 v 2011 is 3% ( 3 % ) ;

operating expenses millions 2013 2012 2011 % (  % ) change 2013 v 2012 % (  % ) change 2012 v 2011 .

higher locomotive diesel fuel prices , which averaged $ 3.22 per gallon ( including taxes and transportation costs ) in 2012 , compared to $ 3.12 in 2011 , increased expenses by $ 105 million .

Answer: 25%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2013?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 24%.

Rejected response: 23%.

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2013?

Answer: 24%

millions the fuel of 2014 is 3539 ; the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is - ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ;

millions the depreciation of 2014 is 1904 ; the depreciation of 2013 is 1777 ; the depreciation of 2012 is 1760 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 7 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 1 ;

millions the total of 2014 is $ 15235 ; the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 5% ( 5 % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2% ( 2 % ) ;

Answer: 24%

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2014?

Answer: 23%

Answer: 23%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2013?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 24%.

Rejected response: 25%.

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2013?

Answer: 24%

millions the fuel of 2014 is 3539 ; the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is - ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ;

millions the depreciation of 2014 is 1904 ; the depreciation of 2013 is 1777 ; the depreciation of 2012 is 1760 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 7 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 1 ;

millions the total of 2014 is $ 15235 ; the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 5% ( 5 % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2% ( 2 % ) ;

Answer: 24%

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2012?

Answer: 25%

millions the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of 2011 is 3581 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2012 v 2011 is 1 ;

millions the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of 2011 is $ 13833 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2 % ( % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2012 v 2011 is 3% ( 3 % ) ;

higher locomotive diesel fuel prices , which averaged $ 3.22 per gallon ( including taxes and transportation costs ) in 2012 , compared to $ 3.12 in 2011 , increased expenses by $ 105 million .

Answer: 25%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2012?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 25%.

Rejected response: 23%.

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2012?

Answer: 25%

millions the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of 2011 is 3581 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2012 v 2011 is 1 ;

millions the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of 2011 is $ 13833 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2 % ( % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2012 v 2011 is 3% ( 3 % ) ;

higher locomotive diesel fuel prices , which averaged $ 3.22 per gallon ( including taxes and transportation costs ) in 2012 , compared to $ 3.12 in 2011 , increased expenses by $ 105 million .

Answer: 25%

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2014?

Answer: 23%

millions the fuel of 2014 is 3539 ; the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is - ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ;

millions the depreciation of 2014 is 1904 ; the depreciation of 2013 is 1777 ; the depreciation of 2012 is 1760 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 7 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 1 ;

millions the total of 2014 is $ 15235 ; the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 5% ( 5 % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2% ( 2 % ) ;

Answer: 23%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2012?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 25%.

Rejected response: 24%.

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2012?

Answer: 25%

millions the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of 2011 is 3581 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2012 v 2011 is 1 ;

millions the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of 2011 is $ 13833 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2 % ( % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2012 v 2011 is 3% ( 3 % ) ;

higher locomotive diesel fuel prices , which averaged $ 3.22 per gallon ( including taxes and transportation costs ) in 2012 , compared to $ 3.12 in 2011 , increased expenses by $ 105 million .

Answer: 25%

Question: what percentage of total operating expenses was fuel in 2013?

Answer: 24%

millions the fuel of 2014 is 3539 ; the fuel of 2013 is 3534 ; the fuel of 2012 is 3608 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is - ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is -2 ( 2 ) ;

millions the depreciation of 2014 is 1904 ; the depreciation of 2013 is 1777 ; the depreciation of 2012 is 1760 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 7 ; the depreciation of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 1 ;

millions the total of 2014 is $ 15235 ; the total of 2013 is $ 14517 ; the total of 2012 is $ 14181 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2014 v 2013 is 5% ( 5 % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2013 v 2012 is 2% ( 2 % ) ;

Answer: 24%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in net sales of the commodity chemicals business that will be reclassified and reported as discontinued operations from 2011 to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -2%.

Rejected response: 21%.

PPG || what was the percentage change in net sales of the commodity chemicals business that will be reclassified and reported as discontinued operations <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in net sales of the commodity chemicals business that will be reclassified and reported as discontinued operations from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: -2%

millions the net sales of year-ended 2012 is $ 1700 ; the net sales of year-ended 2011 is $ 1741 ; the net sales of year-ended 2010 is $ 1441 ;

the net sales and income before income taxes of the commodity chemicals business that will be reclassified and reported as discontinued operations are presented in the table below for the years ended december 31 , 2012 , 2011 and 2010: .

in the ppg results for prior periods , presented for comparative purposes beginning with the first quarter 2013 , the results of its former commodity chemicals business will be reclassified from continuing operations and presented as the results from discontinued operations .

income before income taxes for the year ended december 31 , 2012 , 2011 and 2010 is $ 4 million lower , $ 6 million higher and $ 2 million lower , respectively , than segment earnings for the ppg commodity chemicals segment reported for these periods .

Answer: -2%

Question: what was the percentage change in net sales of the commodity chemicals business that will be reclassified and reported as discontinued operations from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: 21%

Answer: 21%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in net sales of the commodity chemicals business that will be reclassified and reported as discontinued operations from 2010 to 2011?
Reference time interval: 2010-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 21%.

Rejected response: -2%.

Question: what was the percentage change in net sales of the commodity chemicals business that will be reclassified and reported as discontinued operations from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: 21%

the net sales and income before income taxes of the commodity chemicals business that will be reclassified and reported as discontinued operations are presented in the table below for the years ended december 31 , 2012 , 2011 and 2010: .

millions the net sales of year-ended 2012 is $ 1700 ; the net sales of year-ended 2011 is $ 1741 ; the net sales of year-ended 2010 is $ 1441 ;

income before income taxes for the year ended december 31 , 2012 , 2011 and 2010 is $ 4 million lower , $ 6 million higher and $ 2 million lower , respectively , than segment earnings for the ppg commodity chemicals segment reported for these periods .

Answer: 21%

Question: what was the percentage change in net sales of the commodity chemicals business that will be reclassified and reported as discontinued operations from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: -2%

Answer: -2%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the total tobacco-related cases pending in the united states as of december 31 , 2014?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 85.

Rejected response: 89.

MO || what is the total tobacco-related cases pending in the united states as of december 31 , <TIME>?

Question: what is the total tobacco-related cases pending in the united states as of december 31 , 2014?

Answer: 85

type of case the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2014 is 67 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2013 is 67 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2012 is 77 ;

type of case the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2014 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2013 is 6 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2012 is 7 ;

type of case the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2014 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2013 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2012 is 1 ;

type of case the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2014 is 12 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2013 is 15 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2012 is 14 ;

Answer: 85

Question: what is the total tobacco-related cases pending in the united states as of december 31 , 2013?

Answer: 89

Answer: 89


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the total tobacco-related cases pending in the united states as of december 31 , 2013?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 89.

Rejected response: 85.

Question: what is the total tobacco-related cases pending in the united states as of december 31 , 2013?

Answer: 89

type of case the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2014 is 67 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2013 is 67 ; the individual smoking and health cases ( 1 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2012 is 77 ;

type of case the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2014 is 5 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2013 is 6 ; the smoking and health class actions and aggregated claims litigation ( 2 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2012 is 7 ;

type of case the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2014 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2013 is 1 ; the health care cost recovery actions ( 3 ) of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2012 is 1 ;

type of case the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2014 is 12 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2013 is 15 ; the 201clights/ultra lights 201d class actions of number of casespending as ofdecember 31 2012 is 14 ;

Answer: 89

Question: what is the total tobacco-related cases pending in the united states as of december 31 , 2014?

Answer: 85

Answer: 85


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what portion of the net mark-to-market loss were driven by cost of good sold in 2016?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 48.3%.

Rejected response: 68.2%.

CAT || what portion of the net mark-to-market loss were driven by cost of good sold <TIME>?

Question: what portion of the net mark-to-market loss were driven by cost of good sold in 2016?

Answer: 48.3%

( millions of dollars ) the cost of goods sold of years ended december 31 , 2017 is $ -29 ( 29 ) ; the cost of goods sold of years ended december 31 , 2016 is $ 476 ; the cost of goods sold of years ended december 31 , 2015 is $ 122 ;

( millions of dollars ) the total of years ended december 31 , 2017 is $ 301 ; the total of years ended december 31 , 2016 is $ 985 ; the total of years ended december 31 , 2015 is $ 179 ;

the net mark-to-market losses were in the following results of operations line items: .

2022 2015 net mark-to-market loss of $ 179 million - primarily due to the difference between the actual return on plan assets compared to the expected return on plan assets ( u.s .

Answer: 48.3%

Question: what portion of the net mark-to-market loss were driven by cost of good sold in 2015?

Answer: 68.2%

Answer: 68.2%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what portion of the net mark-to-market loss were driven by cost of good sold in 2015?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2016-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 68.2%.

Rejected response: 48.3%.

Question: what portion of the net mark-to-market loss were driven by cost of good sold in 2015?

Answer: 68.2%

2022 2015 net mark-to-market loss of $ 179 million - primarily due to the difference between the actual return on plan assets compared to the expected return on plan assets ( u.s .

( millions of dollars ) the cost of goods sold of years ended december 31 , 2017 is $ -29 ( 29 ) ; the cost of goods sold of years ended december 31 , 2016 is $ 476 ; the cost of goods sold of years ended december 31 , 2015 is $ 122 ;

( millions of dollars ) the total of years ended december 31 , 2017 is $ 301 ; the total of years ended december 31 , 2016 is $ 985 ; the total of years ended december 31 , 2015 is $ 179 ;

Answer: 68.2%

Question: what portion of the net mark-to-market loss were driven by cost of good sold in 2016?

Answer: 48.3%

Answer: 48.3%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in brent oil prices from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 24.0%.

Rejected response: 31.8%.

BKR || what is the growth rate in brent oil prices <TIME>?

Question: what is the growth rate in brent oil prices from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 24.0%

the brent oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 1 ) of 2018 is $ 71.34 ; the brent oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 1 ) of 2017 is $ 54.12 ; the brent oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 1 ) of 2016 is $ 43.64 ;

The wti oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 2 ) of 2018 is 65.23 ; The wti oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 2 ) of 2017 is 50.80 ; The wti oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 2 ) of 2016 is 43.29 ;

for the first three quarters of 2018 , brent oil prices increased sequentially .

brent oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 1 ) $ 71.34 $ 54.12 $ 43.64 wti oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 2 ) 65.23 50.80 43.29 natural gas prices ( $ /mmbtu ) ( 3 ) 3.15 2.99 2.52 ( 1 ) energy information administration ( eia ) europe brent spot price per barrel ( 2 ) eia cushing , ok wti ( west texas intermediate ) spot price ( 3 ) eia henry hub natural gas spot price per million british thermal unit 2018 demonstrated the volatility of the oil and gas market .

average brent oil prices increased to $ 71.34/bbl in 2018 from $ 54.12/bbl in 2017 , and ranged from a low of $ 50.57/bbl in december 2018 , to a high of $ 86.07/bbl in october 2018 .

Answer: 24.0%

Question: what is the growth rate in brent oil prices from 2017 to 2018?

Answer: 31.8%

Answer: 31.8%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in brent oil prices from 2017 to 2018?
Reference time interval: 2017-01-01 00:00:00 to 2019-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 31.8%.

Rejected response: 24.0%.

Question: what is the growth rate in brent oil prices from 2017 to 2018?

Answer: 31.8%

the brent oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 1 ) of 2018 is $ 71.34 ; the brent oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 1 ) of 2017 is $ 54.12 ; the brent oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 1 ) of 2016 is $ 43.64 ;

brent oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 1 ) $ 71.34 $ 54.12 $ 43.64 wti oil prices ( $ /bbl ) ( 2 ) 65.23 50.80 43.29 natural gas prices ( $ /mmbtu ) ( 3 ) 3.15 2.99 2.52 ( 1 ) energy information administration ( eia ) europe brent spot price per barrel ( 2 ) eia cushing , ok wti ( west texas intermediate ) spot price ( 3 ) eia henry hub natural gas spot price per million british thermal unit 2018 demonstrated the volatility of the oil and gas market .

average brent oil prices increased to $ 71.34/bbl in 2018 from $ 54.12/bbl in 2017 , and ranged from a low of $ 50.57/bbl in december 2018 , to a high of $ 86.07/bbl in october 2018 .

Answer: 31.8%

Question: what is the growth rate in brent oil prices from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 24.0%

Answer: 24.0%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in equipment rents payable from 2014 to 2015?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2016-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 5%.

Rejected response: 6%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in equipment rents payable <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in equipment rents payable from 2014 to 2015?

Answer: 5%

millions the equipment rents payable of dec . 31 2015 is 105 ; the equipment rents payable of dec . 31 2014 is 100 ;

millions The interest payable of dec . 31 2015 is 208 ; The interest payable of dec . 31 2014 is 178 ;

millions the accounts payable of dec . 31 2015 is $ 743 ; the accounts payable of dec . 31 2014 is $ 877 ;

millions the interest payable of dec . 31 2015 is 208 ; the interest payable of dec . 31 2014 is 178 ;

Answer: 5%

Question: what was the percentage change in equipment rents payable from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 6%

millions the equipment rents payable of dec . 31 2012 is 95 ; the equipment rents payable of dec . 312011 is 90 ;

millions The interest payable of dec . 31 2012 is 172 ; The interest payable of dec . 312011 is 197 ;

millions the accounts payable of dec . 31 2012 is $ 825 ; the accounts payable of dec . 312011 is $ 819 ;

millions the dividends payable of dec . 31 2012 is 318 ; the dividends payable of dec . 312011 is 284 ;

Answer: 6%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in equipment rents payable from 2011 to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 6%.

Rejected response: 5%.

Question: what was the percentage change in equipment rents payable from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 6%

millions the accounts payable of dec . 31 2012 is $ 825 ; the accounts payable of dec . 312011 is $ 819 ;

millions the dividends payable of dec . 31 2012 is 318 ; the dividends payable of dec . 312011 is 284 ;

millions the equipment rents payable of dec . 31 2012 is 95 ; the equipment rents payable of dec . 312011 is 90 ;

Answer: 6%

Question: what was the percentage change in equipment rents payable from 2014 to 2015?

Answer: 5%

millions the accounts payable of dec . 31 2015 is $ 743 ; the accounts payable of dec . 31 2014 is $ 877 ;

millions the interest payable of dec . 31 2015 is 208 ; the interest payable of dec . 31 2014 is 178 ;

millions the equipment rents payable of dec . 31 2015 is 105 ; the equipment rents payable of dec . 31 2014 is 100 ;

Answer: 5%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in operating revenue from 2001 to 2002?
Reference time interval: 2001-01-01 00:00:00 to 2003-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -3.3%.

Rejected response: 25.5%.

D || what is the growth rate in operating revenue <TIME>?

Question: what is the growth rate in operating revenue from 2001 to 2002?

Answer: -3.3%

( millions except pershare amounts ) the operating revenue of 2002 is $ 5940 ; the operating revenue of 2001 is $ 6144 ; the operating revenue of 2000 is $ 4894 ;

( millions except pershare amounts ) The operating expenses of 2002 is 4520 ; The operating expenses of 2001 is 4749 ; The operating expenses of 2000 is 3939 ;

net income for 2002 reflected lower operating revenue ( $ 204 million ) , operating expenses ( $ 229 million ) and other income ( $ 27 million ) .

( millions except pershare amounts ) the operating expenses of 2002 is 4520 ; the operating expenses of 2001 is 4749 ; the operating expenses of 2000 is 3939 ;

Answer: -3.3%

Question: what is the growth rate in operating revenue from 2000 to 2001?

Answer: 25.5%

( millions except pershare amounts ) the electricity supplied* ( million mwhrs ) of 2002 is 101 ; the electricity supplied* ( million mwhrs ) of 2001 is 95 ; the electricity supplied* ( million mwhrs ) of 2000 is 83 ;

Answer: 25.5%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in operating revenue from 2000 to 2001?
Reference time interval: 2000-01-01 00:00:00 to 2002-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 25.5%.

Rejected response: -3.3%.

Question: what is the growth rate in operating revenue from 2000 to 2001?

Answer: 25.5%

( millions except pershare amounts ) the operating revenue of 2002 is $ 5940 ; the operating revenue of 2001 is $ 6144 ; the operating revenue of 2000 is $ 4894 ;

( millions except pershare amounts ) the operating expenses of 2002 is 4520 ; the operating expenses of 2001 is 4749 ; the operating expenses of 2000 is 3939 ;

( millions except pershare amounts ) the electricity supplied* ( million mwhrs ) of 2002 is 101 ; the electricity supplied* ( million mwhrs ) of 2001 is 95 ; the electricity supplied* ( million mwhrs ) of 2000 is 83 ;

Answer: 25.5%

Question: what is the growth rate in operating revenue from 2001 to 2002?

Answer: -3.3%

net income for 2002 reflected lower operating revenue ( $ 204 million ) , operating expenses ( $ 229 million ) and other income ( $ 27 million ) .

Answer: -3.3%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the expected growth rate in amortization expense in 2017?
Reference time interval: 2017-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -0.9%.

Rejected response: -1.9%.

CAT || what is the expected growth rate in amortization expense <TIME>?

Question: what is the expected growth rate in amortization expense in 2017?

Answer: -0.9%

amortization expense related to intangible assets was $ 323 million , $ 326 million and $ 337 million for 2017 , 2016 and 2015 , respectively .

as of december 31 , 2017 , amortization expense related to intangible assets is expected to be : ( millions of dollars ) .

goodwill there were no goodwill impairments during 2017 or 2015 .

Answer: -0.9%

Question: what is the expected growth rate in amortization expense in 2019?

Answer: -1.9%

Answer: -1.9%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the expected growth rate in amortization expense in 2019?
Reference time interval: 2019-01-01 00:00:00 to 2020-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -1.9%.

Rejected response: -0.9%.

Question: what is the expected growth rate in amortization expense in 2019?

Answer: -1.9%

amortization expense related to intangible assets was $ 323 million , $ 326 million and $ 337 million for 2017 , 2016 and 2015 , respectively .

as of december 31 , 2017 , amortization expense related to intangible assets is expected to be : ( millions of dollars ) .

Answer: -1.9%

Question: what is the expected growth rate in amortization expense in 2017?

Answer: -0.9%

Answer: -0.9%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the change in cash provided by operating activities from 2010 to 2011 , in millions?
Reference time interval: 2010-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 1768.

Rejected response: 901.

UNP || what was the change in cash provided by operating activities <TIME> , in millions?

Question: what was the change in cash provided by operating activities from 2010 to 2011 , in millions?

Answer: 1768

cash flowsmillions the cash provided by operating activities of 2011 is $ 5873 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2010 is $ 4105 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3204 ;

operating activities higher net income and lower cash income tax payments in 2011 increased cash provided by operating activities compared to 2010 .

cash flowsmillions the net change in cash and cashequivalents of 2011 is $ 131 ; the net change in cash and cashequivalents of 2010 is $ -764 ( 764 ) ; the net change in cash and cashequivalents of 2009 is $ 601 ;

in addition , the adoption of a new accounting standard in january of 2010 changed the accounting treatment for our receivables securitization facility from a sale of undivided interests ( recorded as an operating activity ) to a secured borrowing ( recorded as a financing activity ) , which decreased cash provided by operating activities by $ 400 million in 2010 .

Answer: 1768

Question: what was the change in cash provided by operating activities from 2009 to 2010 , in millions?

Answer: 901

higher net income in 2010 increased cash provided by operating activities compared to 2009 .

Answer: 901


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the change in cash provided by operating activities from 2009 to 2010 , in millions?
Reference time interval: 2009-01-01 00:00:00 to 2011-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 901.

Rejected response: 1768.

Question: what was the change in cash provided by operating activities from 2009 to 2010 , in millions?

Answer: 901

cash flowsmillions the cash provided by operating activities of 2011 is $ 5873 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2010 is $ 4105 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3204 ;

cash flowsmillions the net change in cash and cashequivalents of 2011 is $ 131 ; the net change in cash and cashequivalents of 2010 is $ -764 ( 764 ) ; the net change in cash and cashequivalents of 2009 is $ 601 ;

in addition , the adoption of a new accounting standard in january of 2010 changed the accounting treatment for our receivables securitization facility from a sale of undivided interests ( recorded as an operating activity ) to a secured borrowing ( recorded as a financing activity ) , which decreased cash provided by operating activities by $ 400 million in 2010 .

Answer: 901

Question: what was the change in cash provided by operating activities from 2010 to 2011 , in millions?

Answer: 1768

Answer: 1768


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the percentage change net provision for interest and penalties from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 11.8%.

Rejected response: 70.0%.

CAT || what is the percentage change net provision for interest and penalties <TIME>?

Question: what is the percentage change net provision for interest and penalties from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 11.8%

we recognized a net provision for interest and penalties of $ 38 million , $ 34 million and $ 20 million during the years ended december 31 , 2017 , 2016 and 2015 , respectively .

we classify interest and penalties on income taxes as a component of the provision for income taxes .

the total amount of interest and penalties accrued was $ 157 million and $ 120 million as of december a031 , 2017 and 2016 , respectively .

we currently believe the ultimate disposition of this matter will not have a material adverse effect on our consolidated financial position , liquidity or results of operations .

Answer: 11.8%

Question: what is the percentage change net provision for interest and penalties from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 70.0%

due to the uncertainty related to the timing and potential outcome of audits , we cannot estimate the range of reasonably possible change in unrecognized tax benefits in the next 12 months. .

Answer: 70.0%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the percentage change net provision for interest and penalties from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 70.0%.

Rejected response: 11.8%.

Question: what is the percentage change net provision for interest and penalties from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 70.0%

we recognized a net provision for interest and penalties of $ 38 million , $ 34 million and $ 20 million during the years ended december 31 , 2017 , 2016 and 2015 , respectively .

the total amount of interest and penalties accrued was $ 157 million and $ 120 million as of december a031 , 2017 and 2016 , respectively .

we currently believe the ultimate disposition of this matter will not have a material adverse effect on our consolidated financial position , liquidity or results of operations .

Answer: 70.0%

Question: what is the percentage change net provision for interest and penalties from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 11.8%

Answer: 11.8%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in revenue related technology and risk management from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 12.7%.

Rejected response: 13.8%.

BLK || what is the growth rate in revenue related technology and risk management <TIME>?

Question: what is the growth rate in revenue related technology and risk management from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 12.7%

for 2017 , 2016 and 2015 , performance fee revenue ( which included recognized carried interest ) totaled $ 594 million , $ 295 million and $ 621 million , respectively .

for 2017 , 2016 and 2016 , technology and risk management revenue totaled $ 677 million , $ 595 million and $ 528 million , respectively .

fees earned for technology and risk management revenue are recorded as services are performed and are generally determined using the value of positions on the aladdin platform or on a fixed-rate basis .

( in millions ) the ending balance of 2017 is $ 219 ; the ending balance of 2016 is $ 152 ;

Answer: 12.7%

Question: what is the growth rate in revenue related technology and risk management from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 13.8%

Answer: 13.8%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in revenue related technology and risk management from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 13.8%.

Rejected response: 12.7%.

Question: what is the growth rate in revenue related technology and risk management from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 13.8%

( in millions ) the ending balance of 2017 is $ 219 ; the ending balance of 2016 is $ 152 ;

for 2017 , 2016 and 2015 , performance fee revenue ( which included recognized carried interest ) totaled $ 594 million , $ 295 million and $ 621 million , respectively .

for 2017 , 2016 and 2016 , technology and risk management revenue totaled $ 677 million , $ 595 million and $ 528 million , respectively .

Answer: 13.8%

Question: what is the growth rate in revenue related technology and risk management from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 12.7%

Answer: 12.7%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in open claims ending balance at december 31 from 2005 to 2006?
Reference time interval: 2005-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -2%.

Rejected response: 4%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in open claims ending balance at december 31 <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in open claims ending balance at december 31 from 2005 to 2006?

Answer: -2%

claims activity the open claims ending balance at december 31 of 2006 is 4126 ; the open claims ending balance at december 31 of 2005 is 4197 ; the open claims ending balance at december 31 of 2004 is 4028 ;

claims activity The open claims beginning balance of 2006 is 4197 ; The open claims beginning balance of 2005 is 4028 ; The open claims beginning balance of 2004 is 4085 ;

for the year ended december 31 , 2006 , depreciation expense was $ 1.2 billion .

claims activity the open claims beginning balance of 2006 is 4197 ; the open claims beginning balance of 2005 is 4028 ; the open claims beginning balance of 2004 is 4085 ;

Answer: -2%

Question: what was the percentage change in open claims ending balance at december 31 from 2004 to 2005?

Answer: 4%

our personal injury claims activity was as follows : claims activity 2006 2005 2004 .

Answer: 4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in open claims ending balance at december 31 from 2004 to 2005?
Reference time interval: 2004-01-01 00:00:00 to 2006-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 4%.

Rejected response: -2%.

Question: what was the percentage change in open claims ending balance at december 31 from 2004 to 2005?

Answer: 4%

our personal injury claims activity was as follows : claims activity 2006 2005 2004 .

claims activity the open claims beginning balance of 2006 is 4197 ; the open claims beginning balance of 2005 is 4028 ; the open claims beginning balance of 2004 is 4085 ;

claims activity the open claims ending balance at december 31 of 2006 is 4126 ; the open claims ending balance at december 31 of 2005 is 4197 ; the open claims ending balance at december 31 of 2004 is 4028 ;

Answer: 4%

Question: what was the percentage change in open claims ending balance at december 31 from 2005 to 2006?

Answer: -2%

for the year ended december 31 , 2006 , depreciation expense was $ 1.2 billion .

Answer: -2%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in cash during 2018?
Reference time interval: 2018-01-01 00:00:00 to 2019-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -3179.

Rejected response: 5997.

BKR || what is the net change in cash <TIME>?

Question: what is the net change in cash during 2018?

Answer: -3179

( in millions ) the operating activities of 2018 is $ 1762 ; the operating activities of 2017 is $ -799 ( 799 ) ; the operating activities of 2016 is $ 262 ;

( in millions ) the investing activities of 2018 is -578 ( 578 ) ; the investing activities of 2017 is -4123 ( 4123 ) ; the investing activities of 2016 is -472 ( 472 ) ;

( in millions ) the financing activities of 2018 is -4363 ( 4363 ) ; the financing activities of 2017 is 10919 ; the financing activities of 2016 is -102 ( 102 ) ;

Answer: -3179

Question: what is the net change in cash during 2017?

Answer: 5997

Answer: 5997


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in cash during 2017?
Reference time interval: 2017-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 5997.

Rejected response: -3179.

Question: what is the net change in cash during 2017?

Answer: 5997

( in millions ) the operating activities of 2018 is $ 1762 ; the operating activities of 2017 is $ -799 ( 799 ) ; the operating activities of 2016 is $ 262 ;

( in millions ) the investing activities of 2018 is -578 ( 578 ) ; the investing activities of 2017 is -4123 ( 4123 ) ; the investing activities of 2016 is -472 ( 472 ) ;

( in millions ) the financing activities of 2018 is -4363 ( 4363 ) ; the financing activities of 2017 is 10919 ; the financing activities of 2016 is -102 ( 102 ) ;

Answer: 5997

Question: what is the net change in cash during 2018?

Answer: -3179

Answer: -3179


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the expected growth rate in operating leases from 2019 to 2020?
Reference time interval: 2019-01-01 00:00:00 to 2021-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -9.1%.

Rejected response: 0.7%.

ABMD || what is the expected growth rate in operating leases <TIME>?

Question: what is the expected growth rate in operating leases from 2019 to 2020?

Answer: -9.1%

fiscal years ending march 31 , the 2019 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is $ 2078 ;

fiscal years ending march 31 , the 2020 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is 1888 ;

fiscal years ending march 31, The thereafter of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is 1923 ;

fiscal years ending march 31, the 2022 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is 1408 ;

Answer: -9.1%

Question: what is the expected growth rate in operating leases from 2020 to 2021?

Answer: 0.7%

fiscal years ending march 31 , the 2021 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is 1901 ;

fiscal years ending march 31, the 2019 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is $ 2078 ;

Answer: 0.7%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the expected growth rate in operating leases from 2020 to 2021?
Reference time interval: 2020-01-01 00:00:00 to 2022-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 0.7%.

Rejected response: -9.1%.

Question: what is the expected growth rate in operating leases from 2020 to 2021?

Answer: 0.7%

fiscal years ending march 31, the 2019 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is $ 2078 ;

fiscal years ending march 31 , the 2020 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is 1888 ;

fiscal years ending march 31 , the 2021 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is 1901 ;

Answer: 0.7%

Question: what is the expected growth rate in operating leases from 2019 to 2020?

Answer: -9.1%

fiscal years ending march 31 , the 2019 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is $ 2078 ;

fiscal years ending march 31, the 2022 of operating leases ( in $ 000s ) is 1408 ;

Answer: -9.1%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the value of operating expenses and other costs concerning the activities , in 2007?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 4871.

Rejected response: 8129.

IP || what is the value of operating expenses and other costs concerning the activities , <TIME>?

Question: what is the value of operating expenses and other costs concerning the activities , in 2007?

Answer: 4871

Explanation: it is the value of sales ( operating income ) subtracted by the value of operating profit .

in millions the sales of 2009 is $ 8890 ; the sales of 2008 is $ 7690 ; the sales of 2007 is $ 5245 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2009 is 761 ; the operating profit of 2008 is 390 ; the operating profit of 2007 is 374 ;

operating profits in 2009 were $ 791 million ( $ 682 million excluding alternative fuel mixture cred- its , mill closure costs and costs associated with the cbpr integration ) compared with $ 322 million ( $ 414 million excluding charges related to the write-up of cbpr inventory to fair value , cbpr integration costs and other facility closure costs ) in 2008 and $ 305 million in 2007 .

Answer: 4871

Question: what is the value of operating expenses and other costs concerning the activities , in 2009?

Answer: 8129

Answer: 8129


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the value of operating expenses and other costs concerning the activities , in 2009?
Reference time interval: 2009-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 8129.

Rejected response: 4871.

Question: what is the value of operating expenses and other costs concerning the activities , in 2009?

Answer: 8129

Explanation: it is the value of sales ( operating income ) subtracted by the value of operating profit .

in millions the sales of 2009 is $ 8890 ; the sales of 2008 is $ 7690 ; the sales of 2007 is $ 5245 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2009 is 761 ; the operating profit of 2008 is 390 ; the operating profit of 2007 is 374 ;

operating profits in 2009 were $ 791 million ( $ 682 million excluding alternative fuel mixture cred- its , mill closure costs and costs associated with the cbpr integration ) compared with $ 322 million ( $ 414 million excluding charges related to the write-up of cbpr inventory to fair value , cbpr integration costs and other facility closure costs ) in 2008 and $ 305 million in 2007 .

Answer: 8129

Question: what is the value of operating expenses and other costs concerning the activities , in 2007?

Answer: 4871

Answer: 4871


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -21%.

Rejected response: 11%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -21%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2009 is $ 601 ; The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2008 is $ 371 ; The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2007 is $ 51 ;

higher net income and changes in working capital combined to increase cash provided by operating activities in 2008 compared to 2007 .

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: -21%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2005 and 2006?

Answer: 11%

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

cash flowsmillions of dollars The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2006 is $ 54 ; The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2005 is $ -204 ( 204 ) ; The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2004 is $ 450 ;

cash provided by operating activities 2013 higher income in 2006 generated the increased cash provided by operating activities , which was partially offset by higher income tax payments , $ 150 million in voluntary pension contributions , higher material and supply inventories , and higher management incentive payments in 2006 .

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

Answer: 11%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -21%.

Rejected response: 15%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -21%

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: -21%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2004 and 2005?

Answer: 15%

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

Answer: 15%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -21%.

Rejected response: 24%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -21%

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: -21%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 24%

Answer: 24%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2005 and 2006?
Reference time interval: 2005-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 11%.

Rejected response: -21%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2005 and 2006?

Answer: 11%

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

Answer: 11%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -21%

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: -21%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2005 and 2006?
Reference time interval: 2005-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 11%.

Rejected response: 15%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2005 and 2006?

Answer: 11%

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

Answer: 11%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2004 and 2005?

Answer: 15%

Answer: 15%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2005 and 2006?
Reference time interval: 2005-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 11%.

Rejected response: 24%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2005 and 2006?

Answer: 11%

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

Answer: 11%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 24%

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: 24%