Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2004 and 2005?
Reference time interval: 2004-01-01 00:00:00 to 2006-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 15%.

Rejected response: -21%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2004 and 2005?

Answer: 15%

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

Answer: 15%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -21%

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: -21%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2004 and 2005?
Reference time interval: 2004-01-01 00:00:00 to 2006-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 15%.

Rejected response: 11%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2004 and 2005?

Answer: 15%

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

cash flowsmillions of dollars The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2006 is $ 54 ; The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2005 is $ -204 ( 204 ) ; The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2004 is $ 450 ;

cash provided by operating activities 2013 higher income in 2006 generated the increased cash provided by operating activities , which was partially offset by higher income tax payments , $ 150 million in voluntary pension contributions , higher material and supply inventories , and higher management incentive payments in 2006 .

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

Answer: 15%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2005 and 2006?

Answer: 11%

Answer: 11%

Constructed heuristically from grouped FinQA questions after replacing time expressions with <TIME>.


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2004 and 2005?
Reference time interval: 2004-01-01 00:00:00 to 2006-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 15%.

Rejected response: 24%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2004 and 2005?

Answer: 15%

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

Answer: 15%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 24%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2009 is $ 601 ; The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2008 is $ 371 ; The net change in cash and cash equivalents of 2007 is $ 51 ;

higher net income and changes in working capital combined to increase cash provided by operating activities in 2008 compared to 2007 .

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: 24%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 24%.

Rejected response: -21%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 24%

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: 24%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -21%

Answer: -21%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 24%.

Rejected response: 11%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 24%

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: 24%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2005 and 2006?

Answer: 11%

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

Answer: 11%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 24%.

Rejected response: 15%.

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 24%

cash flows millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in financing activities of 2009 is -458 ( 458 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2008 is -935 ( 935 ) ; the cash used in financing activities of 2007 is -800 ( 800 ) ;

Answer: 24%

Question: what was the percentage change in cash provided by operating activities between 2004 and 2005?

Answer: 15%

at both december 31 , 2006 and 2005 , we had a working capital deficit of approximately $ 1.1 billion .

financial condition cash flows millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

cash flowsmillions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2005 is $ 2595 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2004 is $ 2257 ;

Answer: 15%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in net earnings attributable to altria group inc . in 2017?
Reference time interval: 2017-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -28.2%.

Rejected response: 171.7%.

MO || what is the growth rate in net earnings attributable to altria group inc . <TIME>?

Question: what is the growth rate in net earnings attributable to altria group inc . in 2017?

Answer: -28.2%

( in millions ) the net earnings attributable to altria group inc . of for the years ended december 31 , 2017 is $ 10222 ; the net earnings attributable to altria group inc . of for the years ended december 31 , 2016 is $ 14239 ; the net earnings attributable to altria group inc . of for the years ended december 31 , 2015 is $ 5241 ;

net earnings attributable to altria group , inc .

these performance measures consist of altria group , inc . 2019s adjusted diluted earnings per share ( 201ceps 201d ) compounded annual growth rate and altria group , inc . 2019s total shareholder return relative to a predetermined peer group .

$ 10222 $ 14239 $ 5241 less : distributed and undistributed earnings attributable to share-based awards ( 14 ) ( 24 ) ( 10 ) earnings for basic and diluted eps $ 10208 $ 14215 $ 5231 weighted-average shares for basic and diluted eps 1921 1952 1961 .

Answer: -28.2%

Question: what is the growth rate in net earnings attributable to altria group inc . in 2016?

Answer: 171.7%

Answer: 171.7%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the growth rate in net earnings attributable to altria group inc . in 2016?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 171.7%.

Rejected response: -28.2%.

Question: what is the growth rate in net earnings attributable to altria group inc . in 2016?

Answer: 171.7%

( in millions ) the net earnings attributable to altria group inc . of for the years ended december 31 , 2017 is $ 10222 ; the net earnings attributable to altria group inc . of for the years ended december 31 , 2016 is $ 14239 ; the net earnings attributable to altria group inc . of for the years ended december 31 , 2015 is $ 5241 ;

net earnings attributable to altria group , inc .

$ 10222 $ 14239 $ 5241 less : distributed and undistributed earnings attributable to share-based awards ( 14 ) ( 24 ) ( 10 ) earnings for basic and diluted eps $ 10208 $ 14215 $ 5231 weighted-average shares for basic and diluted eps 1921 1952 1961 .

Answer: 171.7%

Question: what is the growth rate in net earnings attributable to altria group inc . in 2017?

Answer: -28.2%

Answer: -28.2%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what portion of the total multi-assets is related to asset allocation as of december 31 , 2012?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 52.3%.

Rejected response: 56.0%.

BLK || what portion of the total multi-assets is related to asset allocation as of december 31 , <TIME>?

Question: what portion of the total multi-assets is related to asset allocation as of december 31 , 2012?

Answer: 52.3%

( dollar amounts in millions ) the asset allocation of 12/31/2011 is $ 126067 ; the asset allocation of net new business is $ 1575 ; the asset allocation of net acquired is $ 78 ; the asset allocation of market /fx app ( dep ) is $ 12440 ; the asset allocation of 12/31/2012 is $ 140160 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the multi-asset of 12/31/2011 is $ 225170 ; the multi-asset of net new business is $ 15817 ; the multi-asset of net acquired is $ 78 ; the multi-asset of market /fx app ( dep ) is $ 26683 ; the multi-asset of 12/31/2012 is $ 267748 ;

multi-asset class component changes in multi-asset class aum ( dollar amounts in millions ) 12/31/2011 net new business acquired market /fx app ( dep ) 12/31/2012 .

multi-asset class aum totaled $ 267.7 billion at year-end 2012 , up 19% ( 19 % ) , or $ 42.6 billion , reflecting $ 15.8 billion in net new business and $ 26.7 billion in portfolio valuation gains .

Answer: 52.3%

Question: what portion of the total multi-assets is related to asset allocation as of december 31 , 2011?

Answer: 56.0%

Answer: 56.0%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what portion of the total multi-assets is related to asset allocation as of december 31 , 2011?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 56.0%.

Rejected response: 52.3%.

Question: what portion of the total multi-assets is related to asset allocation as of december 31 , 2011?

Answer: 56.0%

( dollar amounts in millions ) the asset allocation of 12/31/2011 is $ 126067 ; the asset allocation of net new business is $ 1575 ; the asset allocation of net acquired is $ 78 ; the asset allocation of market /fx app ( dep ) is $ 12440 ; the asset allocation of 12/31/2012 is $ 140160 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the multi-asset of 12/31/2011 is $ 225170 ; the multi-asset of net new business is $ 15817 ; the multi-asset of net acquired is $ 78 ; the multi-asset of market /fx app ( dep ) is $ 26683 ; the multi-asset of 12/31/2012 is $ 267748 ;

multi-asset class aum totaled $ 267.7 billion at year-end 2012 , up 19% ( 19 % ) , or $ 42.6 billion , reflecting $ 15.8 billion in net new business and $ 26.7 billion in portfolio valuation gains .

Answer: 56.0%

Question: what portion of the total multi-assets is related to asset allocation as of december 31 , 2012?

Answer: 52.3%

Answer: 52.3%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage did the balance increase from 2007 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 83.6%.

Rejected response: 86.5%.

ADI || what percentage did the balance increase <TIME>?

Question: what percentage did the balance increase from 2007 to 2009?

Answer: 83.6%

Explanation: to find the percentage increase one must subtract the two year's balances and then divide the answer by the balance for 2007 .

balance november 3 2007 the balance october 31 2009 of $ 9889 is $ 18161 ;

the following table summarizes the changes in the total amounts of uncertain tax positions for fiscal 2008 and fiscal 2009. .

balance november 3 2007 The balance november 1 2008 of $ 9889 is 13750 ;

balance november 3 2007 the balance november 1 2008 of $ 9889 is 13750 ;

Answer: 83.6%

Question: what percentage did the balance increase from 2007 to 2010?

Answer: 86.5%

Explanation: to find the percentage increase from 2007 to 2010 one must take the balance for 2010 and subtract that by the balance for 2007 . then take the answer and divide it by the balance for 2007 .

balance november 3 2007 the additions for tax positions of 2008 of $ 9889 is 3861 ;

balance november 3 2007 the additions for tax positions of 2009 of $ 9889 is 4411 ;

balance november 3 2007 the balance october 31 2009 of $ 9889 is 18161 ;

balance november 3 2007 the additions for tax positions of 2010 of $ 9889 is 286 ;

balance november 3 2007 the balance october 30 2010 of $ 9889 is $ 18447 ;

the following table summarizes the changes in the total amounts of uncertain tax positions for fiscal 2008 through fiscal 2010. .

Answer: 86.5%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage did the balance increase from 2007 to 2010?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2011-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 86.5%.

Rejected response: 83.6%.

Question: what percentage did the balance increase from 2007 to 2010?

Answer: 86.5%

Explanation: to find the percentage increase from 2007 to 2010 one must take the balance for 2010 and subtract that by the balance for 2007 . then take the answer and divide it by the balance for 2007 .

the following table summarizes the changes in the total amounts of uncertain tax positions for fiscal 2008 through fiscal 2010. .

balance november 3 2007 the additions for tax positions of 2008 of $ 9889 is 3861 ;

balance november 3 2007 the balance november 1 2008 of $ 9889 is 13750 ;

balance november 3 2007 the additions for tax positions of 2009 of $ 9889 is 4411 ;

balance november 3 2007 the balance october 31 2009 of $ 9889 is 18161 ;

balance november 3 2007 the additions for tax positions of 2010 of $ 9889 is 286 ;

balance november 3 2007 the balance october 30 2010 of $ 9889 is $ 18447 ;

Answer: 86.5%

Question: what percentage did the balance increase from 2007 to 2009?

Answer: 83.6%

Explanation: to find the percentage increase one must subtract the two year's balances and then divide the answer by the balance for 2007 .

the following table summarizes the changes in the total amounts of uncertain tax positions for fiscal 2008 and fiscal 2009. .

balance november 3 2007 the balance october 31 2009 of $ 9889 is $ 18161 ;

Answer: 83.6%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the operating margin for the coatings segment in 2005?
Reference time interval: 2005-01-01 00:00:00 to 2006-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 11%.

Rejected response: 15%.

PPG || what was the operating margin for the coatings segment <TIME>?

Question: what was the operating margin for the coatings segment in 2005?

Answer: 11%

( millions ) the coatings of net sales 2005 is $ 5566 ; the coatings of net sales 2004 is $ 5275 ; the coatings of net sales 2005 is $ 609 ; the coatings of 2004 is $ 777 ;

coatings sales increased $ 291 million or 5% ( 5 % ) in 2005 .

production capacity on higher margin direct process products .

( millions ) the glass of net sales 2005 is 2237 ; the glass of net sales 2004 is 2204 ; the glass of net sales 2005 is 56 ; the glass of 2004 is 169 ;

Answer: 11%

Question: what was the operating margin for the coatings segment in 2004?

Answer: 15%

results of business segments net sales operating income ( millions ) 2005 2004 2005 2004 .

the federal glass class action antitrust legal settlement of $ 61 million , the $ 49 million impact of rising natural gas costs and the absence of the $ 19 million gain in 2004 from the sale/ leaseback of precious metal combined to account for a reduction in operating earnings of $ 129 million .

Answer: 15%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the operating margin for the coatings segment in 2004?
Reference time interval: 2004-01-01 00:00:00 to 2005-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 15%.

Rejected response: 11%.

Question: what was the operating margin for the coatings segment in 2004?

Answer: 15%

( millions ) the coatings of net sales 2005 is $ 5566 ; the coatings of net sales 2004 is $ 5275 ; the coatings of net sales 2005 is $ 609 ; the coatings of 2004 is $ 777 ;

coatings sales increased $ 291 million or 5% ( 5 % ) in 2005 .

the federal glass class action antitrust legal settlement of $ 61 million , the $ 49 million impact of rising natural gas costs and the absence of the $ 19 million gain in 2004 from the sale/ leaseback of precious metal combined to account for a reduction in operating earnings of $ 129 million .

Answer: 15%

Question: what was the operating margin for the coatings segment in 2005?

Answer: 11%

( millions ) the glass of net sales 2005 is 2237 ; the glass of net sales 2004 is 2204 ; the glass of net sales 2005 is 56 ; the glass of 2004 is 169 ;

Answer: 11%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what portion of total rig count is in north america in 2017?
Reference time interval: 2017-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 53.3%.

Rejected response: 55.3%.

BKR || what portion of total rig count is in north america <TIME>?

Question: what portion of total rig count is in north america in 2017?

Answer: 53.3%

the international of 2018 is 988 ; the international of 2017 is 948 ; the international of 2016 is 956 ;

the worldwide of 2018 is 2211 ; the worldwide of 2017 is 2030 ; the worldwide of 2016 is 1598 ;

the north america of 2018 is 1223 ; the north america of 2017 is 1082 ; the north america of 2016 is 642 ;

Answer: 53.3%

Question: what portion of total rig count is in north america in 2018?

Answer: 55.3%

the rig count in north america increased 13% ( 13 % ) in 2018 compared to 2017 .

the rig counts are summarized in the table below as averages for each of the periods indicated. .

Answer: 55.3%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what portion of total rig count is in north america in 2018?
Reference time interval: 2018-01-01 00:00:00 to 2019-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 55.3%.

Rejected response: 53.3%.

Question: what portion of total rig count is in north america in 2018?

Answer: 55.3%

the rig counts are summarized in the table below as averages for each of the periods indicated. .

the north america of 2018 is 1223 ; the north america of 2017 is 1082 ; the north america of 2016 is 642 ;

the worldwide of 2018 is 2211 ; the worldwide of 2017 is 2030 ; the worldwide of 2016 is 1598 ;

Answer: 55.3%

Question: what portion of total rig count is in north america in 2017?

Answer: 53.3%

the international of 2018 is 988 ; the international of 2017 is 948 ; the international of 2016 is 956 ;

Answer: 53.3%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the difference in track miles of rail replaced between 2012 and 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -130.

Rejected response: 69.

UNP || what was the difference in track miles of rail replaced <TIME>?

Question: what was the difference in track miles of rail replaced between 2012 and 2013?

Answer: -130

the track miles of rail replaced of 2013 is 834 ; the track miles of rail replaced of 2012 is 964 ; the track miles of rail replaced of 2011 is 895 ;

The track miles of rail capacity expansion of 2013 is 97 ; The track miles of rail capacity expansion of 2012 is 139 ; The track miles of rail capacity expansion of 2011 is 69 ;

The miles of track surfaced of 2013 is 11017 ; The miles of track surfaced of 2012 is 11049 ; The miles of track surfaced of 2011 is 11284 ;

the track miles of rail capacity expansion of 2013 is 97 ; the track miles of rail capacity expansion of 2012 is 139 ; the track miles of rail capacity expansion of 2011 is 69 ;

the miles of track surfaced of 2013 is 11017 ; the miles of track surfaced of 2012 is 11049 ; the miles of track surfaced of 2011 is 11284 ;

Answer: -130

Question: what was the difference in track miles of rail replaced between 2011 and 2012?

Answer: 69

Answer: 69


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the difference in track miles of rail replaced between 2011 and 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 69.

Rejected response: -130.

Question: what was the difference in track miles of rail replaced between 2011 and 2012?

Answer: 69

the track miles of rail replaced of 2013 is 834 ; the track miles of rail replaced of 2012 is 964 ; the track miles of rail replaced of 2011 is 895 ;

the track miles of rail capacity expansion of 2013 is 97 ; the track miles of rail capacity expansion of 2012 is 139 ; the track miles of rail capacity expansion of 2011 is 69 ;

the miles of track surfaced of 2013 is 11017 ; the miles of track surfaced of 2012 is 11049 ; the miles of track surfaced of 2011 is 11284 ;

Answer: 69

Question: what was the difference in track miles of rail replaced between 2012 and 2013?

Answer: -130

Answer: -130


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2010 to 2011?
Reference time interval: 2010-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 152.

Rejected response: 394.

BLK || what is the net change in non-operating income <TIME>?

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: 152

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) The non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; The non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; The non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) 2012 2011 2010 non-operating income ( expense ) , gaap basis .

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 152

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: 394

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) The non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; The non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; The non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

( b ) non-operating income ( expense ) , less net income ( loss ) attributable to non-controlling interests , as adjusted : non-operating income ( expense ) , less net income ( loss ) attributable to non-controlling interests ( 201cnci 201d ) , as adjusted , equals non-operating income ( expense ) , gaap basis , less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci , gaap basis , adjusted for compensation expense associated with depreciation/ ( appreciation ) on investments related to certain blackrock deferred compensation plans .

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 394


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2010 to 2011?
Reference time interval: 2010-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 152.

Rejected response: 64.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: 152

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 152

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2009 to 2010?

Answer: 64

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 64


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2010 to 2011?
Reference time interval: 2010-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 152.

Rejected response: 80.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: 152

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 152

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 80

Answer: 80


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 394.

Rejected response: 152.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: 394

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 394

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: 152

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 152


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 394.

Rejected response: 64.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: 394

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 394

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2009 to 2010?

Answer: 64

Answer: 64


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 394.

Rejected response: 80.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: 394

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 394

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 80

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 80


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2009 to 2010?
Reference time interval: 2009-01-01 00:00:00 to 2011-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 64.

Rejected response: 152.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2009 to 2010?

Answer: 64

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 64

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: 152

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 152


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2009 to 2010?
Reference time interval: 2009-01-01 00:00:00 to 2011-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 64.

Rejected response: 394.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2009 to 2010?

Answer: 64

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 64

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: 394

Answer: 394


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2009 to 2010?
Reference time interval: 2009-01-01 00:00:00 to 2011-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 64.

Rejected response: 80.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2009 to 2010?

Answer: 64

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 64

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 80

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 80


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2011 to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 80.

Rejected response: 152.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 80

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 80

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: 152

Answer: 152


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2011 to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 80.

Rejected response: 394.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 80

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 80

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: 394

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 394


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2011 to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 80.

Rejected response: 64.

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 80

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2012 is $ -54 ( 54 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2011 is $ -114 ( 114 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of 2010 is $ 23 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2012 is -36 ( 36 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2011 is -116 ( 116 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of 2010 is 36 ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2012 is $ -42 ( 42 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2011 is $ -113 ( 113 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of 2010 is $ 25 ;

Answer: 80

Question: what is the net change in non-operating income from 2009 to 2010?

Answer: 64

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 23 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -6 ( 6 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) gaap basis of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -577 ( 577 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2010 is 36 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2009 is -28 ( 28 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) ( 1 ) of yearended december 31 , 2008 is -422 ( 422 ) ;

( dollar amounts in millions ) the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2010 is $ 25 ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2009 is $ -46 ( 46 ) ; the non-operating income ( expense ) less net income ( loss ) attributable to nci as adjusted of yearended december 31 , 2008 is $ -384 ( 384 ) ;

Answer: 64


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the change in millions of interest payments from 2009 to 2010?
Reference time interval: 2009-01-01 00:00:00 to 2011-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -12.

Rejected response: -27.

PPG || what was the change in millions of interest payments <TIME>?

Question: what was the change in millions of interest payments from 2009 to 2010?

Answer: -12

interest payments in 2010 , 2009 and 2008 totaled $ 189 million , $ 201 million and $ 228 million , respectively .

( millions ) The total of 2010 is $ 24 ; The total of 2009 is $ 268 ;

short-term debt outstanding as of december 31 , 2010 and 2009 , was as follows : ( millions ) 2010 2009 20ac650 million revolving credit facility , 0.8% ( 0.8 % ) as of dec .

( millions ) the total of 2010 is $ 24 ; the total of 2009 is $ 268 ;

Answer: -12

Question: what was the change in millions of interest payments from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -27

Answer: -27


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the change in millions of interest payments from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -27.

Rejected response: -12.

Question: what was the change in millions of interest payments from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -27

interest payments in 2010 , 2009 and 2008 totaled $ 189 million , $ 201 million and $ 228 million , respectively .

( millions ) the total of 2010 is $ 24 ; the total of 2009 is $ 268 ;

Answer: -27

Question: what was the change in millions of interest payments from 2009 to 2010?

Answer: -12

Answer: -12


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in total expense for repairs and maintenance from 2011 to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -5%.

Rejected response: 10%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in total expense for repairs and maintenance <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in total expense for repairs and maintenance from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: -5%

total expense for repairs and maintenance incurred was $ 2.3 billion for 2013 , $ 2.1 billion for 2012 , and $ 2.2 billion for 2011 .

normal repairs and maintenance are also expensed as incurred , while costs incurred that extend the useful life of an asset , improve the safety of our operations or improve operating efficiency are capitalized .

millions the total accounts payable and othercurrent liabilities of dec . 31 2013 is $ 3086 ; the total accounts payable and othercurrent liabilities of dec . 312012 is $ 2923 ;

Answer: -5%

Question: what was the percentage change in total expense for repairs and maintenance from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 10%

millions The total accounts payable and othercurrent liabilities of dec . 31 2013 is $ 3086 ; The total accounts payable and othercurrent liabilities of dec . 312012 is $ 2923 ;

Answer: 10%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in total expense for repairs and maintenance from 2012 to 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 10%.

Rejected response: -5%.

Question: what was the percentage change in total expense for repairs and maintenance from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 10%

total expense for repairs and maintenance incurred was $ 2.3 billion for 2013 , $ 2.1 billion for 2012 , and $ 2.2 billion for 2011 .

millions the total accounts payable and othercurrent liabilities of dec . 31 2013 is $ 3086 ; the total accounts payable and othercurrent liabilities of dec . 312012 is $ 2923 ;

Answer: 10%

Question: what was the percentage change in total expense for repairs and maintenance from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: -5%

Answer: -5%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2013
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 4.7%.

Rejected response: 6.4%.

IP || what was the consumer packaging profit margin <TIME>

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2013

Answer: 4.7%

in millions the sales of 2015 is $ 2940 ; the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ;

in millions the operating profit ( loss ) of 2015 is -25 ( 25 ) ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2013 is 161 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2015 were $ 319 million compared with $ 365 million in 2014 and $ 380 million in 2013 .

Answer: 4.7%

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2006

Answer: 6.4%

in millions the sales of 2007 is $ 3015 ; the sales of 2006 is $ 2685 ; the sales of 2005 is $ 2435 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2007 is $ 198 ; the operating profit of 2006 is $ 172 ; the operating profit of 2005 is $ 160 ;

consumer packaging in millions 2007 2006 2005 .

european consumer packaging net sales in 2007 were $ 280 million compared with $ 230 million in 2006 and $ 190 million in 2005 .

Answer: 6.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2013
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 4.7%.

Rejected response: 7.4%.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2013

Answer: 4.7%

in millions the sales of 2015 is $ 2940 ; the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ;

in millions the operating profit ( loss ) of 2015 is -25 ( 25 ) ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2013 is 161 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2015 were $ 319 million compared with $ 365 million in 2014 and $ 380 million in 2013 .

Answer: 4.7%

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2003

Answer: 7.4%

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 2590 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 2605 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 2465 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 126 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 161 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 183 ;

consumer packaging in millions 2005 2004 2003 .

Answer: 7.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2013
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 4.7%.

Rejected response: 8.45%\\n.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2013

Answer: 4.7%

in millions the sales of 2015 is $ 2940 ; the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ;

in millions the operating profit ( loss ) of 2015 is -25 ( 25 ) ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2013 is 161 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2015 were $ 319 million compared with $ 365 million in 2014 and $ 380 million in 2013 .

Answer: 4.7%

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2012

Answer: 8.45%\\n

in millions the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 3170 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit of 2013 is 161 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 268 ;

operating profits were $ 92 million ( $ 100 million excluding sheet plant closure costs ) in 2014 compared with $ 63 million ( $ 110 million excluding paper machine shutdown costs and costs related to the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2013 and $ 165 million ( $ 162 million excluding a gain associated with the sale of the shorewood business in 2012 ) .

Answer: 8.45%\\n


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2006
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 6.4%.

Rejected response: 4.7%.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2006

Answer: 6.4%

in millions the sales of 2007 is $ 3015 ; the sales of 2006 is $ 2685 ; the sales of 2005 is $ 2435 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2007 is $ 198 ; the operating profit of 2006 is $ 172 ; the operating profit of 2005 is $ 160 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2007 were $ 280 million compared with $ 230 million in 2006 and $ 190 million in 2005 .

Answer: 6.4%

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2013

Answer: 4.7%

in millions the sales of 2015 is $ 2940 ; the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ;

in millions the operating profit ( loss ) of 2015 is -25 ( 25 ) ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2013 is 161 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2015 were $ 319 million compared with $ 365 million in 2014 and $ 380 million in 2013 .

Answer: 4.7%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2006
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 6.4%.

Rejected response: 7.4%.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2006

Answer: 6.4%

in millions the sales of 2007 is $ 3015 ; the sales of 2006 is $ 2685 ; the sales of 2005 is $ 2435 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2007 is $ 198 ; the operating profit of 2006 is $ 172 ; the operating profit of 2005 is $ 160 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2007 were $ 280 million compared with $ 230 million in 2006 and $ 190 million in 2005 .

Answer: 6.4%

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2003

Answer: 7.4%

consumer packaging in millions 2005 2004 2003 .

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 2590 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 2605 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 2465 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 126 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 161 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 183 ;

Answer: 7.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2006
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 6.4%.

Rejected response: 8.45%\\n.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2006

Answer: 6.4%

in millions the sales of 2007 is $ 3015 ; the sales of 2006 is $ 2685 ; the sales of 2005 is $ 2435 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2007 is $ 198 ; the operating profit of 2006 is $ 172 ; the operating profit of 2005 is $ 160 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2007 were $ 280 million compared with $ 230 million in 2006 and $ 190 million in 2005 .

Answer: 6.4%

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2012

Answer: 8.45%\\n

in millions the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 3170 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit of 2013 is 161 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 268 ;

operating profits were $ 92 million ( $ 100 million excluding sheet plant closure costs ) in 2014 compared with $ 63 million ( $ 110 million excluding paper machine shutdown costs and costs related to the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2013 and $ 165 million ( $ 162 million excluding a gain associated with the sale of the shorewood business in 2012 ) .

Answer: 8.45%\\n


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2003
Reference time interval: 2003-01-01 00:00:00 to 2004-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 7.4%.

Rejected response: 4.7%.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2003

Answer: 7.4%

consumer packaging in millions 2005 2004 2003 .

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 2590 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 2605 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 2465 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 126 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 161 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 183 ;

Answer: 7.4%

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2013

Answer: 4.7%

in millions the sales of 2015 is $ 2940 ; the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ;

in millions the operating profit ( loss ) of 2015 is -25 ( 25 ) ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2013 is 161 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2015 were $ 319 million compared with $ 365 million in 2014 and $ 380 million in 2013 .

Answer: 4.7%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2003
Reference time interval: 2003-01-01 00:00:00 to 2004-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 7.4%.

Rejected response: 6.4%.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2003

Answer: 7.4%

consumer packaging in millions 2005 2004 2003 .

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 2590 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 2605 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 2465 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 126 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 161 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 183 ;

Answer: 7.4%

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2006

Answer: 6.4%

in millions the sales of 2007 is $ 3015 ; the sales of 2006 is $ 2685 ; the sales of 2005 is $ 2435 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2007 is $ 198 ; the operating profit of 2006 is $ 172 ; the operating profit of 2005 is $ 160 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2007 were $ 280 million compared with $ 230 million in 2006 and $ 190 million in 2005 .

Answer: 6.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2003
Reference time interval: 2003-01-01 00:00:00 to 2004-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 7.4%.

Rejected response: 8.45%\\n.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2003

Answer: 7.4%

consumer packaging in millions 2005 2004 2003 .

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 2590 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 2605 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 2465 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 126 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 161 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 183 ;

Answer: 7.4%

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2012

Answer: 8.45%\\n

in millions the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 3170 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit of 2013 is 161 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 268 ;

operating profits were $ 92 million ( $ 100 million excluding sheet plant closure costs ) in 2014 compared with $ 63 million ( $ 110 million excluding paper machine shutdown costs and costs related to the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2013 and $ 165 million ( $ 162 million excluding a gain associated with the sale of the shorewood business in 2012 ) .

Answer: 8.45%\\n


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2012
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 8.45%\\n.

Rejected response: 4.7%.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2012

Answer: 8.45%\\n

in millions the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 3170 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit of 2013 is 161 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 268 ;

operating profits were $ 92 million ( $ 100 million excluding sheet plant closure costs ) in 2014 compared with $ 63 million ( $ 110 million excluding paper machine shutdown costs and costs related to the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2013 and $ 165 million ( $ 162 million excluding a gain associated with the sale of the shorewood business in 2012 ) .

Answer: 8.45%\\n

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2013

Answer: 4.7%

in millions the sales of 2015 is $ 2940 ; the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ;

in millions the operating profit ( loss ) of 2015 is -25 ( 25 ) ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit ( loss ) of 2013 is 161 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2015 were $ 319 million compared with $ 365 million in 2014 and $ 380 million in 2013 .

Answer: 4.7%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2012
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 8.45%\\n.

Rejected response: 6.4%.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2012

Answer: 8.45%\\n

in millions the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 3170 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit of 2013 is 161 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 268 ;

operating profits were $ 92 million ( $ 100 million excluding sheet plant closure costs ) in 2014 compared with $ 63 million ( $ 110 million excluding paper machine shutdown costs and costs related to the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2013 and $ 165 million ( $ 162 million excluding a gain associated with the sale of the shorewood business in 2012 ) .

Answer: 8.45%\\n

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2006

Answer: 6.4%

in millions the sales of 2007 is $ 3015 ; the sales of 2006 is $ 2685 ; the sales of 2005 is $ 2435 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2007 is $ 198 ; the operating profit of 2006 is $ 172 ; the operating profit of 2005 is $ 160 ;

european consumer packaging net sales in 2007 were $ 280 million compared with $ 230 million in 2006 and $ 190 million in 2005 .

Answer: 6.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2012
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 8.45%\\n.

Rejected response: 7.4%.

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2012

Answer: 8.45%\\n

in millions the sales of 2014 is $ 3403 ; the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 3170 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2014 is 178 ; the operating profit of 2013 is 161 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 268 ;

operating profits were $ 92 million ( $ 100 million excluding sheet plant closure costs ) in 2014 compared with $ 63 million ( $ 110 million excluding paper machine shutdown costs and costs related to the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2013 and $ 165 million ( $ 162 million excluding a gain associated with the sale of the shorewood business in 2012 ) .

Answer: 8.45%\\n

Question: what was the consumer packaging profit margin in 2003

Answer: 7.4%

consumer packaging in millions 2005 2004 2003 .

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 2590 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 2605 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 2465 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 126 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 161 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 183 ;

Answer: 7.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the estimated growth rate in net periodic pension cost from 2011 to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 14.1%.

Rejected response: 24.7%.

UNP || what is the estimated growth rate in net periodic pension cost <TIME>?

Question: what is the estimated growth rate in net periodic pension cost from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 14.1%

millions the net periodic pension cost of est.2013 is $ 111 ; the net periodic pension cost of 2012 is $ 89 ; the net periodic pension cost of 2011 is $ 78 ; the net periodic pension cost of 2010 is $ 51 ;

millions The net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of est.2013 is 15 ; The net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of 2012 is 13 ; The net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of 2011 is -6 ( 6 ) ; The net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of 2010 is -14 ( 14 ) ;

the following table presents the net periodic pension and opeb cost/ ( benefit ) for the years ended december 31 : millions 2013 2012 2011 2010 .

millions the net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of est.2013 is 15 ; the net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of 2012 is 13 ; the net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of 2011 is -6 ( 6 ) ; the net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of 2010 is -14 ( 14 ) ;

our net periodic pension cost is expected to increase to approximately $ 111 million in 2013 from $ 89 million in 2012 .

Answer: 14.1%

Question: what is the estimated growth rate in net periodic pension cost from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 24.7%

Answer: 24.7%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the estimated growth rate in net periodic pension cost from 2012 to 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 24.7%.

Rejected response: 14.1%.

Question: what is the estimated growth rate in net periodic pension cost from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 24.7%

millions the net periodic pension cost of est.2013 is $ 111 ; the net periodic pension cost of 2012 is $ 89 ; the net periodic pension cost of 2011 is $ 78 ; the net periodic pension cost of 2010 is $ 51 ;

millions the net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of est.2013 is 15 ; the net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of 2012 is 13 ; the net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of 2011 is -6 ( 6 ) ; the net periodic opeb cost/ ( benefit ) of 2010 is -14 ( 14 ) ;

our net periodic pension cost is expected to increase to approximately $ 111 million in 2013 from $ 89 million in 2012 .

Answer: 24.7%

Question: what is the estimated growth rate in net periodic pension cost from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 14.1%

Answer: 14.1%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the printing papers profit margin in 2011
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 4.4%.

Rejected response: 6.4%.

IP || what was the printing papers profit margin <TIME>

Question: what was the printing papers profit margin in 2011

Answer: 4.4%

in millions the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 3170 ; the sales of 2011 is $ 3710 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2013 is 161 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 268 ; the operating profit of 2011 is 163 ;

net sales and operating profits include the shorewood business in 2011 .

operating profits were $ 63 million ( $ 110 million excluding paper machine shutdown costs and costs related to the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2013 compared with $ 165 million ( $ 162 million excluding charges associated with the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2012 and $ 35 million ( $ 236 million excluding asset impairment charges and other costs associated with the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2011 .

Answer: 4.4%

Question: what was the printing papers profit margin in 2003

Answer: 6.4%

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 7860 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 7670 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 7280 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 552 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 581 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 464 ;

printing papers in millions 2005 2004 2003 .

the printing papers segment took 995000 tons of downtime in 2005 , including 540000 tons of lack-of-order down- time to align production with customer demand .

Answer: 6.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the printing papers profit margin in 2003
Reference time interval: 2003-01-01 00:00:00 to 2004-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 6.4%.

Rejected response: 4.4%.

Question: what was the printing papers profit margin in 2003

Answer: 6.4%

the printing papers segment took 995000 tons of downtime in 2005 , including 540000 tons of lack-of-order down- time to align production with customer demand .

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 7860 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 7670 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 7280 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 552 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 581 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 464 ;

Answer: 6.4%

Question: what was the printing papers profit margin in 2011

Answer: 4.4%

in millions the sales of 2013 is $ 3435 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 3170 ; the sales of 2011 is $ 3710 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2013 is 161 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 268 ; the operating profit of 2011 is 163 ;

operating profits were $ 63 million ( $ 110 million excluding paper machine shutdown costs and costs related to the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2013 compared with $ 165 million ( $ 162 million excluding charges associated with the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2012 and $ 35 million ( $ 236 million excluding asset impairment charges and other costs associated with the sale of the shorewood business ) in 2011 .

Answer: 4.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -29%.

Rejected response: -38%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in free cash flow <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

free cash flow should be considered in addition to , rather than as a substitute for , cash provided by operating activities .

the following table reconciles cash provided by operating activities ( gaap measure ) to free cash flow ( non-gaap measure ) : millions 2014 2013 2012 .

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

Answer: -29%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

2022 free cash flow 2013 cash generated by operating activities totaled $ 3.2 billion , yielding free cash flow of $ 515 million in 2009 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

Answer: -38%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -29%.

Rejected response: -4%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

free cash flow should be considered in addition to , rather than as a substitute for , cash provided by operating activities .

free cash flow is defined as cash provided by operating activities less cash used in investing activities and dividends paid .

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

Answer: -4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -29%.

Rejected response: -6%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

2022 free cash flow 2013 cash generated by operating activities totaled a record $ 4.1 billion , yielding free cash flow of $ 825 million in 2008 .

the following table reconciles cash provided by operating activities ( gaap measure ) to free cash flow ( non-gaap measure ) : millions of dollars 2008 2007 2006 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

Answer: -6%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -29%.

Rejected response: 330%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -29%.

Rejected response: 51%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

Answer: 51%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -29%.

Rejected response: 69%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -29%.

Rejected response: 70%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -38%.

Rejected response: -29%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -38%.

Rejected response: -4%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -38%.

Rejected response: -6%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -38%.

Rejected response: 330%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -38%.

Rejected response: 51%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -38%.

Rejected response: 69%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

Answer: 69%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -38%.

Rejected response: 70%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%