Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -4%.

Rejected response: -29%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -4%.

Rejected response: -38%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in free cash flow <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

free cash flow should be considered in addition to , rather than as a substitute for , cash provided by operating activities .

free cash flow is defined as cash provided by operating activities less cash used in investing activities and dividends paid .

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

Answer: -4%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

2022 free cash flow 2013 cash generated by operating activities totaled $ 3.2 billion , yielding free cash flow of $ 515 million in 2009 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

Answer: -38%

Constructed heuristically from grouped FinQA questions after replacing time expressions with <TIME>.


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -4%.

Rejected response: -6%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

2022 free cash flow 2013 cash generated by operating activities totaled a record $ 4.1 billion , yielding free cash flow of $ 825 million in 2008 .

the following table reconciles cash provided by operating activities ( gaap measure ) to free cash flow ( non-gaap measure ) : millions of dollars 2008 2007 2006 .

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

Answer: -6%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -4%.

Rejected response: 330%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

Answer: 330%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -4%.

Rejected response: 51%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

free cash flow should be considered in addition to , rather than as a substitute for , cash provided by operating activities .

the following table reconciles cash provided by operating activities ( gaap measure ) to free cash flow ( non-gaap measure ) : millions 2014 2013 2012 .

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

Answer: 51%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -4%.

Rejected response: 69%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -4%.

Rejected response: 70%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -6%.

Rejected response: -29%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -6%.

Rejected response: -38%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -6%.

Rejected response: -4%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -6%.

Rejected response: 330%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -6%.

Rejected response: 51%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -6%.

Rejected response: 69%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?
Reference time interval: 2006-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -6%.

Rejected response: 70%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

Answer: 70%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 330%.

Rejected response: -29%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 330%.

Rejected response: -38%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 330%.

Rejected response: -4%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

Answer: -4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 330%.

Rejected response: -6%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 330%.

Rejected response: 51%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 330%.

Rejected response: 69%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 330%.

Rejected response: 70%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 51%.

Rejected response: -29%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

Answer: -29%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 51%.

Rejected response: -38%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 51%.

Rejected response: -4%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 51%.

Rejected response: -6%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 51%.

Rejected response: 330%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 51%.

Rejected response: 69%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 51%.

Rejected response: 70%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 69%.

Rejected response: -29%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 69%.

Rejected response: -38%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

Answer: -38%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 69%.

Rejected response: -4%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 69%.

Rejected response: -6%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: -6%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 69%.

Rejected response: 330%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 69%.

Rejected response: 51%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 69%.

Rejected response: 70%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 70%.

Rejected response: -29%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2013 to 2014?

Answer: -29%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: -29%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 70%.

Rejected response: -38%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: -38%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: -38%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 70%.

Rejected response: -4%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: -4%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: -4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 70%.

Rejected response: -6%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2006 to 2007?

Answer: -6%

Answer: -6%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 70%.

Rejected response: 330%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 330%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2017 is $ 7230 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2016 is $ 7525 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2015 is $ 7344 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2017 is -3086 ( 3086 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2016 is -3393 ( 3393 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2015 is -4476 ( 4476 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2017 is $ 2162 ; the free cash flow of 2016 is $ 2253 ; the free cash flow of 2015 is $ 524 ;

Answer: 330%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 70%.

Rejected response: 51%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2012 to 2013?

Answer: 51%

millions the cash provided by operating activities of 2014 is $ 7385 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2013 is $ 6823 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2012 is $ 6161 ;

millions the cash used in investing activities of 2014 is -4249 ( 4249 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2013 is -3405 ( 3405 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2012 is -3633 ( 3633 ) ;

millions the free cash flow of 2014 is $ 1504 ; the free cash flow of 2013 is $ 2085 ; the free cash flow of 2012 is $ 1382 ;

Answer: 51%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 70%.

Rejected response: 69%.

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 70%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2006 is $ 2880 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2006 is -2042 ( 2042 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ; the free cash flow of 2006 is $ 516 ;

Answer: 70%

Question: what was the percentage change in free cash flow from 2007 to 2008?

Answer: 69%

millions of dollars the cash provided by operating activities of 2009 is $ 3234 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2008 is $ 4070 ; the cash provided by operating activities of 2007 is $ 3277 ;

millions of dollars the cash used in investing activities of 2009 is -2175 ( 2175 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2008 is -2764 ( 2764 ) ; the cash used in investing activities of 2007 is -2426 ( 2426 ) ;

millions of dollars the free cash flow of 2009 is $ 515 ; the free cash flow of 2008 is $ 825 ; the free cash flow of 2007 is $ 487 ;

Answer: 69%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the percentage change in the weight of smokeless products in operating income from 2016 to 2017?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 0.8%.

Rejected response: 2.3%.

MO || what is the percentage change in the weight of smokeless products in operating income <TIME>?

Question: what is the percentage change in the weight of smokeless products in operating income from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 0.8%

the smokeless products of 2017 is 13.2 ; the smokeless products of 2016 is 13.1 ; the smokeless products of 2015 is 12.8 ;

The all other of 2017 is -0.5 ( 0.5 ) ; The all other of 2016 is -1.1 ( 1.1 ) ; The all other of 2015 is -2.0 ( 2.0 ) ;

total smokeless products segment 2019s shipment volume was 841.3 million units in 2017 , a decrease of 1.4% ( 1.4 % ) from 2016 .

10-k altria ar release tuesday , february 27 , 2018 10:00pm andra design llc the relative percentages of operating companies income ( loss ) attributable to each reportable segment and the all other category were as follows: .

the smokeable products of 2017 is 85.8% ( 85.8 % ) ; the smokeable products of 2016 is 86.2% ( 86.2 % ) ; the smokeable products of 2015 is 87.4% ( 87.4 % ) ;

Answer: 0.8%

Question: what is the percentage change in the weight of smokeless products in operating income from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 2.3%

smokeless tobacco products : usstc is the leading producer and marketer of moist smokeless tobacco ( 201cmst 201d ) products .

Answer: 2.3%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what is the percentage change in the weight of smokeless products in operating income from 2015 to 2016?
Reference time interval: 2015-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 2.3%.

Rejected response: 0.8%.

Question: what is the percentage change in the weight of smokeless products in operating income from 2015 to 2016?

Answer: 2.3%

10-k altria ar release tuesday , february 27 , 2018 10:00pm andra design llc the relative percentages of operating companies income ( loss ) attributable to each reportable segment and the all other category were as follows: .

the smokeable products of 2017 is 85.8% ( 85.8 % ) ; the smokeable products of 2016 is 86.2% ( 86.2 % ) ; the smokeable products of 2015 is 87.4% ( 87.4 % ) ;

the smokeless products of 2017 is 13.2 ; the smokeless products of 2016 is 13.1 ; the smokeless products of 2015 is 12.8 ;

Answer: 2.3%

Question: what is the percentage change in the weight of smokeless products in operating income from 2016 to 2017?

Answer: 0.8%

Answer: 0.8%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total operating expenses was fuel in 2007?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 24%.

Rejected response: 29%.

UNP || what percent of total operating expenses was fuel <TIME>?

Question: what percent of total operating expenses was fuel in 2007?

Answer: 24%

millions of dollars the fuel of 2008 is 3983 ; the fuel of 2007 is 3104 ; the fuel of 2006 is 2968 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2008 v 2007 is 28 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2007 v 2006 is 5 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2008 is $ 13895 ; the total of 2007 is $ 12908 ; the total of 2006 is $ 12694 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2008 v 2007 is 8 % ( % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2007 v 2006 is 2% ( 2 % ) ;

operating expenses millions of dollars 2008 2007 2006 % (  % ) change 2008 v 2007 % (  % ) change 2007 v 2006 .

Answer: 24%

Question: what percent of total operating expenses was fuel in 2008?

Answer: 29%

operating expenses increased $ 987 million in 2008 .

Answer: 29%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total operating expenses was fuel in 2008?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 29%.

Rejected response: 24%.

Question: what percent of total operating expenses was fuel in 2008?

Answer: 29%

operating expenses millions of dollars 2008 2007 2006 % (  % ) change 2008 v 2007 % (  % ) change 2007 v 2006 .

millions of dollars the fuel of 2008 is 3983 ; the fuel of 2007 is 3104 ; the fuel of 2006 is 2968 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2008 v 2007 is 28 ; the fuel of % ( % ) change 2007 v 2006 is 5 ;

millions of dollars the total of 2008 is $ 13895 ; the total of 2007 is $ 12908 ; the total of 2006 is $ 12694 ; the total of % ( % ) change 2008 v 2007 is 8 % ( % ) ; the total of % ( % ) change 2007 v 2006 is 2% ( 2 % ) ;

Answer: 29%

Question: what percent of total operating expenses was fuel in 2007?

Answer: 24%

Answer: 24%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the change in millions of total stock-based compensation cost from 2010 to 2011?
Reference time interval: 2010-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -16.

Rejected response: 37.

PPG || what was the change in millions of total stock-based compensation cost <TIME>?

Question: what was the change in millions of total stock-based compensation cost from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: -16

total stock-based compensation cost was $ 73 million , $ 36 million and $ 52 million in 2012 , 2011 and 2010 , respectively .

( millions ) The total of 2012 is $ 149 ; The total of 2011 is $ 177 ; The total of 2010 is $ 180 ;

stock-based compensation the company 2019s stock-based compensation includes stock options , restricted stock units ( 201crsus 201d ) and grants of contingent shares that are earned based on achieving targeted levels of total shareholder return .

68 2012 ppg annual report and form 10-k december 31 , 2012 , 2011 and 2010 was $ ( 30 ) million , $ 98 million and $ 65 million , respectively .

( millions ) the total of 2012 is $ 149 ; the total of 2011 is $ 177 ; the total of 2010 is $ 180 ;

Answer: -16

Question: what was the change in millions of total stock-based compensation cost from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 37

Answer: 37


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the change in millions of total stock-based compensation cost from 2011 to 2012?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 37.

Rejected response: -16.

Question: what was the change in millions of total stock-based compensation cost from 2011 to 2012?

Answer: 37

68 2012 ppg annual report and form 10-k december 31 , 2012 , 2011 and 2010 was $ ( 30 ) million , $ 98 million and $ 65 million , respectively .

( millions ) the total of 2012 is $ 149 ; the total of 2011 is $ 177 ; the total of 2010 is $ 180 ;

total stock-based compensation cost was $ 73 million , $ 36 million and $ 52 million in 2012 , 2011 and 2010 , respectively .

Answer: 37

Question: what was the change in millions of total stock-based compensation cost from 2010 to 2011?

Answer: -16

Answer: -16


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: how did the percentage of operating income related to smokeless product change from 2012 to 2013 relative the total operating income?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -2.4%.

Rejected response: 9.8%.

MO || how did the percentage of operating income related to smokeless product change <TIME> relative the total operating income?

Question: how did the percentage of operating income related to smokeless product change from 2012 to 2013 relative the total operating income?

Answer: -2.4%

the smokeless products of 2014 is 13.4 ; the smokeless products of 2013 is 12.2 ; the smokeless products of 2012 is 12.5 ;

operating companies income for the segments is defined as operating income before amortization of intangibles and general corporate expenses .

The all other of 2014 is -2.3 ( 2.3 ) ; The all other of 2013 is 1.9 ; The all other of 2012 is 2.4 ;

the relative percentages of operating companies income ( loss ) attributable to each reportable segment and the all other category were as follows: .

Answer: -2.4%

Question: how did the percentage of operating income related to smokeless product change from 2013 to 2014 relative the total operating income?

Answer: 9.8%

Answer: 9.8%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: how did the percentage of operating income related to smokeless product change from 2013 to 2014 relative the total operating income?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 9.8%.

Rejected response: -2.4%.

Question: how did the percentage of operating income related to smokeless product change from 2013 to 2014 relative the total operating income?

Answer: 9.8%

the relative percentages of operating companies income ( loss ) attributable to each reportable segment and the all other category were as follows: .

the smokeless products of 2014 is 13.4 ; the smokeless products of 2013 is 12.2 ; the smokeless products of 2012 is 12.5 ;

Answer: 9.8%

Question: how did the percentage of operating income related to smokeless product change from 2012 to 2013 relative the total operating income?

Answer: -2.4%

Answer: -2.4%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in personal injury liability from 2004 to 2005?
Reference time interval: 2004-01-01 00:00:00 to 2006-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: -3%.

Rejected response: 2%.

UNP || what was the percentage change in personal injury liability <TIME>?

Question: what was the percentage change in personal injury liability from 2004 to 2005?

Answer: -3%

millions of dollars the ending balance at december 31 of 2006 is $ 631 ; the ending balance at december 31 of 2005 is $ 619 ; the ending balance at december 31 of 2004 is $ 639 ;

our personal injury liability activity was as follows : millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

our personal injury liability is discounted to present value using applicable u.s .

millions of dollars the beginning balance of 2006 is $ 619 ; the beginning balance of 2005 is $ 639 ; the beginning balance of 2004 is $ 619 ;

Answer: -3%

Question: what was the percentage change in personal injury liability from 2005 to 2006?

Answer: 2%

Answer: 2%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the percentage change in personal injury liability from 2005 to 2006?
Reference time interval: 2005-01-01 00:00:00 to 2007-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 2%.

Rejected response: -3%.

Question: what was the percentage change in personal injury liability from 2005 to 2006?

Answer: 2%

our personal injury liability activity was as follows : millions of dollars 2006 2005 2004 .

millions of dollars the beginning balance of 2006 is $ 619 ; the beginning balance of 2005 is $ 639 ; the beginning balance of 2004 is $ 619 ;

millions of dollars the ending balance at december 31 of 2006 is $ 631 ; the ending balance at december 31 of 2005 is $ 619 ; the ending balance at december 31 of 2004 is $ 639 ;

Answer: 2%

Question: what was the percentage change in personal injury liability from 2004 to 2005?

Answer: -3%

Answer: -3%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total freight revenues were energy in 2007?
Reference time interval: 2007-01-01 00:00:00 to 2008-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 20%.

Rejected response: 22%.

UNP || what percentage of total freight revenues were energy <TIME>?

Question: what percentage of total freight revenues were energy in 2007?

Answer: 20%

millions of dollars the energy of 2008 is 3810 ; the energy of 2007 is 3134 ; the energy of 2006 is 2949 ;

millions of dollars the total freight revenues of 2008 is $ 17118 ; the total freight revenues of 2007 is $ 15486 ; the total freight revenues of 2006 is $ 14791 ;

millions of dollars The total operating revenues of 2008 is $ 17970 ; The total operating revenues of 2007 is $ 16283 ; The total operating revenues of 2006 is $ 15578 ;

millions of dollars the total operating revenues of 2008 is $ 17970 ; the total operating revenues of 2007 is $ 16283 ; the total operating revenues of 2006 is $ 15578 ;

Answer: 20%

Question: what percentage of total freight revenues were energy in 2008?

Answer: 22%

Answer: 22%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total freight revenues were energy in 2008?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2009-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 22%.

Rejected response: 20%.

Question: what percentage of total freight revenues were energy in 2008?

Answer: 22%

millions of dollars the energy of 2008 is 3810 ; the energy of 2007 is 3134 ; the energy of 2006 is 2949 ;

millions of dollars the total freight revenues of 2008 is $ 17118 ; the total freight revenues of 2007 is $ 15486 ; the total freight revenues of 2006 is $ 14791 ;

millions of dollars the total operating revenues of 2008 is $ 17970 ; the total operating revenues of 2007 is $ 16283 ; the total operating revenues of 2006 is $ 15578 ;

Answer: 22%

Question: what percentage of total freight revenues were energy in 2007?

Answer: 20%

Answer: 20%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total aggregate debt maturities as of december 31 , 2011 are due in 2013?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 7%.

Rejected response: 8%.

UNP || what percent of total aggregate debt maturities as of december 31 , <TIME> are due <TIME>?

Question: what percent of total aggregate debt maturities as of december 31 , 2011 are due in 2013?

Answer: 7%

2012 the total debt of $ 309 is $ 8906 ;

debt maturities 2013 the following table presents aggregate debt maturities as of december 31 , 2011 , excluding market value adjustments : millions .

Answer: 7%

Question: what percent of total aggregate debt maturities as of december 31 , 2011 are due in 2014?

Answer: 8%

Answer: 8%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total aggregate debt maturities as of december 31 , 2011 are due in 2014?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 8%.

Rejected response: 7%.

Question: what percent of total aggregate debt maturities as of december 31 , 2011 are due in 2014?

Answer: 8%

2012 the total debt of $ 309 is $ 8906 ;

Answer: 8%

Question: what percent of total aggregate debt maturities as of december 31 , 2011 are due in 2013?

Answer: 7%

Answer: 7%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the industrial packaging profit margin in 2003
Reference time interval: 2003-01-01 00:00:00 to 2004-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 6.3%.

Rejected response: 8.0%.

IP || what was the industrial packaging profit margin <TIME>

Question: what was the industrial packaging profit margin in 2003

Answer: 6.3%

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 4935 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 4830 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 4170 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 230 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 380 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 264 ;

industrial packaging in millions 2005 2004 2003 .

Answer: 6.3%

Question: what was the industrial packaging profit margin in 2012

Answer: 8.0%

in millions the sales of 2012 is $ 13280 ; the sales of 2011 is $ 10430 ; the sales of 2010 is $ 9840 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2012 is 1066 ; the operating profit of 2011 is 1147 ; the operating profit of 2010 is 826 ;

net sales for the packaging operations were $ 400 million in 2012 compared with $ 410 million in 2011 and $ 255 million in 2010 .

Answer: 8.0%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the industrial packaging profit margin in 2012
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 8.0%.

Rejected response: 6.3%.

Question: what was the industrial packaging profit margin in 2012

Answer: 8.0%

in millions the sales of 2012 is $ 13280 ; the sales of 2011 is $ 10430 ; the sales of 2010 is $ 9840 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2012 is 1066 ; the operating profit of 2011 is 1147 ; the operating profit of 2010 is 826 ;

net sales for the packaging operations were $ 400 million in 2012 compared with $ 410 million in 2011 and $ 255 million in 2010 .

Answer: 8.0%

Question: what was the industrial packaging profit margin in 2003

Answer: 6.3%

industrial packaging in millions 2005 2004 2003 .

in millions the sales of 2005 is $ 4935 ; the sales of 2004 is $ 4830 ; the sales of 2003 is $ 4170 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2005 is $ 230 ; the operating profit of 2004 is $ 380 ; the operating profit of 2003 is $ 264 ;

Answer: 6.3%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what portion of the rig counts is related to north america in 2016?
Reference time interval: 2016-01-01 00:00:00 to 2017-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 40.2%.

Rejected response: 53.3%.

BKR || what portion of the rig counts is related to north america <TIME>?

Question: what portion of the rig counts is related to north america in 2016?

Answer: 40.2%

the north america of 2017 is 1082 ; the north america of 2016 is 642 ; the north america of 2015 is 1178 ;

the worldwide of 2017 is 2030 ; the worldwide of 2016 is 1598 ; the worldwide of 2015 is 2346 ;

the rig count in north america decreased 46% ( 46 % ) in 2016 compared to 2015 .

2016 compared to 2015 overall the rig count was 1598 in 2016 , a decrease of 32% ( 32 % ) as compared to 2015 due primarily to north american activity .

Answer: 40.2%

Question: what portion of the rig counts is related to north america in 2017?

Answer: 53.3%

bhge 2017 form 10-k | 29 the rig counts are summarized in the table below as averages for each of the periods indicated. .

Answer: 53.3%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what portion of the rig counts is related to north america in 2017?
Reference time interval: 2017-01-01 00:00:00 to 2018-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 53.3%.

Rejected response: 40.2%.

Question: what portion of the rig counts is related to north america in 2017?

Answer: 53.3%

the north america of 2017 is 1082 ; the north america of 2016 is 642 ; the north america of 2015 is 1178 ;

the worldwide of 2017 is 2030 ; the worldwide of 2016 is 1598 ; the worldwide of 2015 is 2346 ;

2016 compared to 2015 overall the rig count was 1598 in 2016 , a decrease of 32% ( 32 % ) as compared to 2015 due primarily to north american activity .

Answer: 53.3%

Question: what portion of the rig counts is related to north america in 2016?

Answer: 40.2%

Answer: 40.2%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2013?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 11%.

Rejected response: 12%.

UNP || what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due <TIME>?

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2013?

Answer: 11%

millions the 2013 of operatingleases is 489 ; the 2013 of capitalleases is 269 ;

millions the total minimum leasepayments of operatingleases is $ 4528 ; the total minimum leasepayments of capitalleases is $ 2559 ;

future minimum lease payments for operating and capital leases with initial or remaining non-cancelable lease terms in excess of one year as of december 31 , 2011 , were as follows : millions operating leases capital leases .

millions the 2012 of operatingleases is $ 525 ; the 2012 of capitalleases is $ 297 ;

Answer: 11%

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?

Answer: 12%

leases we lease certain locomotives , freight cars , and other property .

Answer: 12%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2013?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 11%.

Rejected response: 9%.

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2013?

Answer: 11%

millions the 2012 of operatingleases is $ 525 ; the 2012 of capitalleases is $ 297 ;

millions the 2013 of operatingleases is 489 ; the 2013 of capitalleases is 269 ;

millions the total minimum leasepayments of operatingleases is $ 4528 ; the total minimum leasepayments of capitalleases is $ 2559 ;

Answer: 11%

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?

Answer: 9%

millions of dollars the 2012 of operatingleases is 488 ; the 2012 of capital leases is 247 ;

millions of dollars the total minimum lease payments of operatingleases is $ 5312 ; the total minimum lease payments of capital leases is $ 2975 ;

future minimum lease payments for operating and capital leases with initial or remaining non-cancelable lease terms in excess of one year as of december 31 , 2009 were as follows : millions of dollars operating leases capital leases .

millions of dollars the 2010 of operatingleases is $ 576 ; the 2010 of capital leases is $ 290 ;

Answer: 9%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 12%.

Rejected response: 11%.

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?

Answer: 12%

leases we lease certain locomotives , freight cars , and other property .

millions the 2012 of operatingleases is $ 525 ; the 2012 of capitalleases is $ 297 ;

millions the total minimum leasepayments of operatingleases is $ 4528 ; the total minimum leasepayments of capitalleases is $ 2559 ;

Answer: 12%

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2013?

Answer: 11%

millions the 2013 of operatingleases is 489 ; the 2013 of capitalleases is 269 ;

Answer: 11%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 12%.

Rejected response: 9%.

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?

Answer: 12%

leases we lease certain locomotives , freight cars , and other property .

millions the 2012 of operatingleases is $ 525 ; the 2012 of capitalleases is $ 297 ;

millions the total minimum leasepayments of operatingleases is $ 4528 ; the total minimum leasepayments of capitalleases is $ 2559 ;

Answer: 12%

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?

Answer: 9%

millions of dollars the 2010 of operatingleases is $ 576 ; the 2010 of capital leases is $ 290 ;

millions of dollars the 2012 of operatingleases is 488 ; the 2012 of capital leases is 247 ;

millions of dollars the total minimum lease payments of operatingleases is $ 5312 ; the total minimum lease payments of capital leases is $ 2975 ;

Answer: 9%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 9%.

Rejected response: 11%.

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?

Answer: 9%

millions of dollars the 2010 of operatingleases is $ 576 ; the 2010 of capital leases is $ 290 ;

millions of dollars the 2012 of operatingleases is 488 ; the 2012 of capital leases is 247 ;

millions of dollars the total minimum lease payments of operatingleases is $ 5312 ; the total minimum lease payments of capital leases is $ 2975 ;

Answer: 9%

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2013?

Answer: 11%

millions the 2012 of operatingleases is $ 525 ; the 2012 of capitalleases is $ 297 ;

millions the 2013 of operatingleases is 489 ; the 2013 of capitalleases is 269 ;

millions the total minimum leasepayments of operatingleases is $ 4528 ; the total minimum leasepayments of capitalleases is $ 2559 ;

Answer: 11%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 9%.

Rejected response: 12%.

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?

Answer: 9%

millions of dollars the 2010 of operatingleases is $ 576 ; the 2010 of capital leases is $ 290 ;

millions of dollars the 2012 of operatingleases is 488 ; the 2012 of capital leases is 247 ;

millions of dollars the total minimum lease payments of operatingleases is $ 5312 ; the total minimum lease payments of capital leases is $ 2975 ;

Answer: 9%

Question: what percent of total minimum operating lease payments are due in 2012?

Answer: 12%

leases we lease certain locomotives , freight cars , and other property .

millions the 2012 of operatingleases is $ 525 ; the 2012 of capitalleases is $ 297 ;

millions the total minimum leasepayments of operatingleases is $ 4528 ; the total minimum leasepayments of capitalleases is $ 2559 ;

Answer: 12%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total miles were other main line in 2013?
Reference time interval: 2013-01-01 00:00:00 to 2014-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 13%.

Rejected response: 14%.

UNP || what percentage of total miles were other main line <TIME>?

Question: what percentage of total miles were other main line in 2013?

Answer: 13%

the other main line of 2014 is 6943 ; the other main line of 2013 is 6766 ;

the total miles of 2014 is 51172 ; the total miles of 2013 is 50861 ;

the route of 2014 is 31974 ; the route of 2013 is 31838 ;

Answer: 13%

Question: what percentage of total miles were other main line in 2014?

Answer: 14%

the other main line of 2015 is 7012 ; the other main line of 2014 is 6943 ;

the total miles of 2015 is 51439 ; the total miles of 2014 is 51172 ;

the following table describes track miles at december 31 , 2015 and 2014. .

Answer: 14%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total miles were other main line in 2014?
Reference time interval: 2014-01-01 00:00:00 to 2015-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 14%.

Rejected response: 13%.

Question: what percentage of total miles were other main line in 2014?

Answer: 14%

the following table describes track miles at december 31 , 2015 and 2014. .

the other main line of 2015 is 7012 ; the other main line of 2014 is 6943 ;

the total miles of 2015 is 51439 ; the total miles of 2014 is 51172 ;

Answer: 14%

Question: what percentage of total miles were other main line in 2013?

Answer: 13%

the route of 2014 is 31974 ; the route of 2013 is 31838 ;

the other main line of 2014 is 6943 ; the other main line of 2013 is 6766 ;

the total miles of 2014 is 51172 ; the total miles of 2013 is 50861 ;

Answer: 13%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the profit margin in 2011
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 11%.

Rejected response: 14%.

Question: what was the profit margin in 2011

Answer: 11%

in millions the sales of 2013 is $ 14810 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 13280 ; the sales of 2011 is $ 10430 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2013 is 1801 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 1066 ; the operating profit of 2011 is 1147 ;

net sales were $ 1.3 billion in 2013 compared with $ 1.0 billion in 2012 and $ 1.1 billion in 2011 .

operating profits in 2013 were $ 1.8 billion ( both including and excluding costs associated with the integration of temple-inland and other special items ) compared with $ 1.0 billion ( $ 1.3 billion excluding costs associated with the acquisition and integration of temple-inland and mill divestiture costs ) in 2012 and $ 1.1 billion ( both including and excluding costs associated with signing an agreement to acquire temple-inland ) in 2011 .

Answer: 11%

Question: what was the profit margin in 2011

Answer: 14%

in millions the sales of 2013 is $ 6205 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 6230 ; the sales of 2011 is $ 6215 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2013 is 271 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 599 ; the operating profit of 2011 is 872 ;

operating profits were $ 3 million in 2013 , 2012 and 2011 .

million excluding a gain on a bargain purchase price adjustment on the acquisition of a majority share of our operations in turkey and restructuring costs ) compared with $ 53 million ( $ 72 million excluding restructuring costs ) in 2012 and $ 66 million ( $ 61 million excluding a gain for a bargain purchase price adjustment on an acquisition by our then joint venture in turkey and costs associated with the closure of our etienne mill in france in 2009 ) in 2011 .

Answer: 14%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the profit margin in 2011
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 14%.

Rejected response: 11%.

Question: what was the profit margin in 2011

Answer: 14%

million excluding a gain on a bargain purchase price adjustment on the acquisition of a majority share of our operations in turkey and restructuring costs ) compared with $ 53 million ( $ 72 million excluding restructuring costs ) in 2012 and $ 66 million ( $ 61 million excluding a gain for a bargain purchase price adjustment on an acquisition by our then joint venture in turkey and costs associated with the closure of our etienne mill in france in 2009 ) in 2011 .

in millions the sales of 2013 is $ 6205 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 6230 ; the sales of 2011 is $ 6215 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2013 is 271 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 599 ; the operating profit of 2011 is 872 ;

Answer: 14%

Question: what was the profit margin in 2011

Answer: 11%

in millions the sales of 2013 is $ 14810 ; the sales of 2012 is $ 13280 ; the sales of 2011 is $ 10430 ;

in millions the operating profit of 2013 is 1801 ; the operating profit of 2012 is 1066 ; the operating profit of 2011 is 1147 ;

operating profits in 2013 were $ 1.8 billion ( both including and excluding costs associated with the integration of temple-inland and other special items ) compared with $ 1.0 billion ( $ 1.3 billion excluding costs associated with the acquisition and integration of temple-inland and mill divestiture costs ) in 2012 and $ 1.1 billion ( both including and excluding costs associated with signing an agreement to acquire temple-inland ) in 2011 .

Answer: 11%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total freight revenues was the industrial products commodity group in 2011?
Reference time interval: 2011-01-01 00:00:00 to 2012-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 17%.

Rejected response: 18%.

UNP || what percentage of total freight revenues was the industrial products commodity group <TIME>?

Question: what percentage of total freight revenues was the industrial products commodity group in 2011?

Answer: 17%

millions the industrial products of 2012 is 3494 ; the industrial products of 2011 is 3166 ; the industrial products of 2010 is 2639 ;

millions the total freight revenues of 2012 is $ 19686 ; the total freight revenues of 2011 is $ 18508 ; the total freight revenues of 2010 is $ 16069 ;

the following table provides freight revenue by commodity group : millions 2012 2011 2010 .

millions the total operatingrevenues of 2012 is $ 20926 ; the total operatingrevenues of 2011 is $ 19557 ; the total operatingrevenues of 2010 is $ 16965 ;

Answer: 17%

Question: what percentage of total freight revenues was the industrial products commodity group in 2012?

Answer: 18%

Answer: 18%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what percentage of total freight revenues was the industrial products commodity group in 2012?
Reference time interval: 2012-01-01 00:00:00 to 2013-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 18%.

Rejected response: 17%.

Question: what percentage of total freight revenues was the industrial products commodity group in 2012?

Answer: 18%

millions the industrial products of 2012 is 3494 ; the industrial products of 2011 is 3166 ; the industrial products of 2010 is 2639 ;

millions the total freight revenues of 2012 is $ 19686 ; the total freight revenues of 2011 is $ 18508 ; the total freight revenues of 2010 is $ 16069 ;

millions the total operatingrevenues of 2012 is $ 20926 ; the total operatingrevenues of 2011 is $ 19557 ; the total operatingrevenues of 2010 is $ 16965 ;

Answer: 18%

Question: what percentage of total freight revenues was the industrial products commodity group in 2011?

Answer: 17%

Answer: 17%


Instruction: Answer the question according to the given reference time interval.

Input:
Question: what was the change in millions of total other earnings from 2008 to 2009?
Reference time interval: 2008-01-01 00:00:00 to 2010-01-01 00:00:00

Chosen response: 13.

Rejected response: 36.

PPG || what was the change in millions of total other earnings <TIME>?

Question: what was the change in millions of total other earnings from 2008 to 2009?

Answer: 13

( millions ) the total of 2010 is $ 214 ; the total of 2009 is $ 178 ; the total of 2008 is $ 165 ;

other earnings ( millions ) 2010 2009 2008 .

( millions ) The other of 2010 is 69 ; The other of 2009 is 74 ; The other of 2008 is 61 ;

( millions ) the other of 2010 is 69 ; the other of 2009 is 74 ; the other of 2008 is 61 ;

Answer: 13

Question: what was the change in millions of total other earnings from 2009 to 2010?

Answer: 36

Answer: 36