| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [1, 2], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.9732341928102577, "b": 2.966551938091161}, "floor": 2.966551938091161, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.0427151081634782, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.21880007698572485, "d_raw": 1.3847279773716792, "qmd_perm": 1.3303970349305332, "coord_share_perm": 0.03923582344618351, "norm_ratio_perm": 1.0000000000000002, "qmd_orth": 1.3274184900141912, "coord_share_orth": 0.04138681986209726, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.160589700833997, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.0650788340658717, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.09551086676812526, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.0822951183346633, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.160589700833997, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.0526234334466773, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.10796626738731963, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.09302707693316194, "bnd_raw": 1.160589700833997, "bnd_perm": 1.0650788340658717, "bnd_orth": 1.0526234334466773, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.0822951183346633, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.09302707693316194, "cka_mean": 0.3091908430110828, "cka_last": 0.9199221561893456, "qmd_act_perm": 0.817137042183511, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.18286295781648898, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.8171370421835108, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.18286295781648917, "qmd_act_ot": 0.7986525561206986, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.2013474438793014, "task_vector_cosine": 0.47795609904941544}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.157653370637638, "delta_floor": 6.191101432546477, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 8.605755412181995, "delta_floor": 5.639203474090834, "delta_vs_naive": -0.5518979584556423}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 8.77304732091895, "delta_floor": 5.806495382827789, "delta_vs_naive": -0.3846060497186876}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 16.04849814497717, "delta_floor": 13.081946206886009, "delta_vs_naive": 6.8908447743395325}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 13.131684006543543, "delta_floor": 10.165132068452381, "delta_vs_naive": 3.9740306359059048}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.187760305186928, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 7.831688529435747, 9.157653370637638, 7.759203448609752, 2.966551938091161]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 5.635862705059013, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 7.555511653773239, 8.605755412181995, 7.299043917920336, 2.966551221435706]}, "secs": 562.4425117969513} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [1, 3], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.9732341928102577, "b": 3.1001702773361055}, "floor": 2.9732341928102577, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.12673588122964663, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.21991439503809812, "d_raw": 1.6358132688217875, "qmd_perm": 1.6271092319846132, "coord_share_perm": 0.005320923239266437, "norm_ratio_perm": 0.9999999999999998, "qmd_orth": 1.6129487025290088, "coord_share_orth": 0.013977491641969087, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.739152327071221, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.7139668788637388, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.025185448207482253, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.014481450425849253, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.739152327071221, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.6970591857350148, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.04209314133620623, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.024203251596191234, "bnd_raw": 1.739152327071221, "bnd_perm": 1.7139668788637388, "bnd_orth": 1.6970591857350148, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.014481450425849253, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.024203251596191234, "cka_mean": 0.45181815202899256, "cka_last": 0.9213588976197379, "qmd_act_perm": 0.49941364036356284, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.5005863596364372, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.4994136403635633, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.5005863596364367, "qmd_act_ot": 0.49898463733430454, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.5010153626656955, "task_vector_cosine": 0.6500543335939593}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.47511835962981, "delta_floor": 6.501884166819552, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 9.021339451341325, "delta_floor": 6.048105258531066, "delta_vs_naive": -0.453778908288486}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 9.11962317300636, "delta_floor": 6.146388980196102, "delta_vs_naive": -0.35549518662345037}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 13.338298959352576, "delta_floor": 10.365064766542318, "delta_vs_naive": 3.8631805997227655}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 12.402279091752282, "delta_floor": 9.429044898942024, "delta_vs_naive": 2.9271607321224717}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.438416124556629, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 6.486284488645629, 9.47511835962981, 9.177749982163242, 3.1001702773361055]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 6.027593663682833, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 6.8827833560114975, 9.021339451341325, 9.096029919887476, 3.1001702773361055]}, "secs": 561.6993088722229} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [1, 4], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.9732341928102577, "b": 3.4470986442789875}, "floor": 2.9732341928102577, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.11826902491630152, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.22187354333367434, "d_raw": 1.685581999484389, "qmd_perm": 1.6775584116254847, "coord_share_perm": 0.004760129060086492, "norm_ratio_perm": 0.9999999999999997, "qmd_orth": 1.6687787079101772, "coord_share_orth": 0.009968836626964354, "d_raw_bn_perm": 3.6039186754757235, "qmd_bn_perm": 3.5931240119239582, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.010794663551765282, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.0029952572529512943, "d_raw_bn_orth": 3.6039186754757235, "qmd_bn_orth": 3.586595833955422, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.017322841520301502, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.004806668263127457, "bnd_raw": 3.6039186754757235, "bnd_perm": 3.5931240119239582, "bnd_orth": 3.586595833955422, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.0029952572529512943, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.004806668263127457, "cka_mean": 0.46874951309010904, "cka_last": 0.8530035305348753, "qmd_act_perm": 0.567206579729427, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.43279342027057294, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.5672065797294257, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.4327934202705743, "qmd_act_ot": 0.5611543495347047, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.4388456504652954, "task_vector_cosine": 0.6521595294172499}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.737981528763047, "delta_floor": 6.764747335952789, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 8.533977112891389, "delta_floor": 5.560742920081131, "delta_vs_naive": -1.2040044158716583}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 8.653571301166014, "delta_floor": 5.680337108355756, "delta_vs_naive": -1.0844102275970329}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 10.497912462287998, "delta_floor": 7.524678269477739, "delta_vs_naive": 0.7599309335249504}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 13.544270833333334, "delta_floor": 10.571036640523076, "delta_vs_naive": 3.806289304570287}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.527815110218425, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 6.8008987814946185, 9.737981528763047, 9.676348841120353, 3.4470986442789875]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 6.02826130786754, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 6.750135208995841, 8.533977112891389, 9.356893779558057, 3.4470985646506036]}, "secs": 713.2253077030182} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [1, 5], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.9732341928102577, "b": 2.9838060551971215}, "floor": 2.9732341928102577, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.04748484316497549, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.21082219023306661, "d_raw": 1.3812635663764314, "qmd_perm": 1.310158577896436, "coord_share_perm": 0.051478219082061454, "norm_ratio_perm": 0.9999999999999991, "qmd_orth": 1.3001491706767698, "coord_share_orth": 0.05872477756903041, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.171379663398061, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.09048236462553, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.08089729877253116, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.06906155305603973, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.171379663398061, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.062569639183386, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.108810024214675, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.09289048428502461, "bnd_raw": 1.171379663398061, "bnd_perm": 1.09048236462553, "bnd_orth": 1.062569639183386, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.06906155305603973, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.09289048428502461, "cka_mean": 0.5026974976075329, "cka_last": 0.9035541863518998, "qmd_act_perm": 0.49903937531061215, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.5009606246893878, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.49903937531061204, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.500960624689388, "qmd_act_ot": 0.49539321929499414, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.5046067807050059, "task_vector_cosine": 0.45874659683094393}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.372604459699119, "delta_floor": 6.399370266888861, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 9.1131423780985, "delta_floor": 6.139908185288242, "delta_vs_naive": -0.2594620816006188}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 9.02808970870026, "delta_floor": 6.054855515890003, "delta_vs_naive": -0.344514750998858}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 16.885063753669275, "delta_floor": 13.911829560859017, "delta_vs_naive": 7.512459293970156}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 12.58334225171233, "delta_floor": 9.610108058902071, "delta_vs_naive": 3.2107377920132105}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.394084335695429, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 8.257985771363339, 9.372604459699119, 7.860405550544276, 2.9838060551971215]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 6.134622771679306, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 7.624204193931425, 9.1131423780985, 7.603367834719505, 2.983805020028131]}, "secs": 500.6418354511261} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [1, 6], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.9732341928102577, "b": 2.9941555951361707}, "floor": 2.9732341928102577, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.06814389590452924, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.222630617192096, "d_raw": 1.3673322424158485, "qmd_perm": 1.3088813978989227, "coord_share_perm": 0.04274809201723564, "norm_ratio_perm": 1.000000000000003, "qmd_orth": 1.2992869427192133, "coord_share_orth": 0.04976500779094514, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.163086594520239, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.064300818778143, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.09878577574209602, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.08493415383473155, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.163086594520239, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.054747016134928, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.10833957838531116, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.09314833383493694, "bnd_raw": 1.163086594520239, "bnd_perm": 1.064300818778143, "bnd_orth": 1.054747016134928, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.08493415383473155, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.09314833383493694, "cka_mean": 0.3506803188210186, "cka_last": 0.8960270848039761, "qmd_act_perm": 0.7464859562362021, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.2535140437637979, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.7464859562362022, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.2535140437637978, "qmd_act_ot": 0.7236909756593217, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.27630902434067833, "task_vector_cosine": 0.4992710096151209}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.228199022545661, "delta_floor": 6.254964829735403, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 8.599067264962493, "delta_floor": 5.6258330721522345, "delta_vs_naive": -0.6291317575831687}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 8.933766702849804, "delta_floor": 5.960532510039545, "delta_vs_naive": -0.2944323196958578}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 16.992376060013047, "delta_floor": 14.019141867202789, "delta_vs_naive": 7.764177037467386}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 13.266489764249021, "delta_floor": 10.293255571438763, "delta_vs_naive": 4.03829074170336}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.244504128572447, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 8.171221091711514, 9.228199022545661, 8.109239950260926, 2.9941555951361707]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 5.615372370989278, "losses": [2.9732341928102577, 7.343831220951565, 8.599067264962493, 7.574612591986709, 2.9941555951361707]}, "secs": 384.28777289390564} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [2, 3], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.966551938091161, "b": 3.1001702773361055}, "floor": 2.966551938091161, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.13343042087265605, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.21867477515764577, "d_raw": 1.5973124399169738, "qmd_perm": 1.5859646159788454, "coord_share_perm": 0.007104323271105453, "norm_ratio_perm": 0.9999999999999999, "qmd_orth": 1.5736024373036352, "coord_share_orth": 0.014843684942797397, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.7121671146987896, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.6872808347127477, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.02488627998604187, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.014534959684948716, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.7121671146987896, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.6698993109675457, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.042267803731243836, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.02468672792998932, "bnd_raw": 1.7121671146987896, "bnd_perm": 1.6872808347127477, "bnd_orth": 1.6698993109675457, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.014534959684948716, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.02468672792998932, "cka_mean": 0.20283095916450844, "cka_last": 0.8988181505731728, "qmd_act_perm": 0.8796352984461546, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.12036470155384539, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.879635298446155, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.12036470155384503, "qmd_act_ot": 0.8795347200260191, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.12046527997398092, "task_vector_cosine": 0.6649686151547698}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.389039439620026, "delta_floor": 6.422487501528865, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 8.697238232835943, "delta_floor": 5.730686294744782, "delta_vs_naive": -0.6918012067840831}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 8.841629655393836, "delta_floor": 5.875077717302675, "delta_vs_naive": -0.5474097842261898}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 16.59203958231409, "delta_floor": 13.625487644222929, "delta_vs_naive": 7.203000142694064}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 13.525712960697978, "delta_floor": 10.559161022606817, "delta_vs_naive": 4.136673521077952}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.355678331906393, "losses": [2.966551938091161, 6.779746138341895, 9.389039439620026, 8.958725742009133, 3.1001702773361055]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 5.762574755126794, "losses": [2.966551938091161, 6.309093816250815, 8.697238232835943, 8.829340447651663, 3.1001702773361055]}, "secs": 445.24335193634033} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [2, 4], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.966551938091161, "b": 3.4470986442789875}, "floor": 2.966551938091161, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.12408460945768743, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.2208399960089021, "d_raw": 1.645588201616521, "qmd_perm": 1.6371183701082819, "coord_share_perm": 0.005146993336436776, "norm_ratio_perm": 0.9999999999999997, "qmd_orth": 1.6277759727362557, "coord_share_orth": 0.01082423224885044, "d_raw_bn_perm": 3.5392637365400197, "qmd_bn_perm": 3.5287013273991428, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.010562409140876916, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.002984352093298002, "d_raw_bn_orth": 3.5392637365400197, "qmd_bn_orth": 3.5230304934006167, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.016233243139402997, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.004586615846625942, "bnd_raw": 3.5392637365400197, "bnd_perm": 3.5287013273991428, "bnd_orth": 3.5230304934006167, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.002984352093298002, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.004586615846625942, "cka_mean": 0.5508170253300096, "cka_last": 0.8466587498064625, "qmd_act_perm": 0.3248511009682368, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.6751488990317632, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.32485110096823644, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.6751488990317636, "qmd_act_ot": 0.31266508904254164, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.6873349109574584, "task_vector_cosine": 0.6670067773312448}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.982318676614481, "delta_floor": 7.01576673852332, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 8.630108001569635, "delta_floor": 5.663556063478474, "delta_vs_naive": -1.3522106750448462}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 9.834928449119374, "delta_floor": 6.868376511028213, "delta_vs_naive": -0.14739022749510688}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 11.012017515696346, "delta_floor": 8.045465577605185, "delta_vs_naive": 1.029698839081865}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 13.277259662426614, "delta_floor": 10.310707724335453, "delta_vs_naive": 3.294940985812133}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 7.120406537139953, "losses": [2.966551938091161, 7.059800279272668, 9.982318676614481, 10.447368504871983, 3.4470986442789875]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 5.633801882669807, "losses": [2.966551938091161, 6.783322567575832, 8.630108001569635, 8.960763910123125, 3.4470987239073714]}, "secs": 404.93776535987854} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [2, 5], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.966551938091161, "b": 2.9838060551971215}, "floor": 2.966551938091161, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.05937645663562413, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.20729477497214682, "d_raw": 1.3757820499119422, "qmd_perm": 1.3257103245279482, "coord_share_perm": 0.036395100072136304, "norm_ratio_perm": 0.9999999999999998, "qmd_orth": 1.3166339529032127, "coord_share_orth": 0.04299234534460984, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.1727126944002277, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.10303787061952, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.06967482378070766, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.05941337900869416, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.1727126944002277, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.0676706243017766, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.10504207009845112, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.08957187092800581, "bnd_raw": 1.1727126944002277, "bnd_perm": 1.10303787061952, "bnd_orth": 1.0676706243017766, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.05941337900869416, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.08957187092800581, "cka_mean": 0.40112456910930183, "cka_last": 0.9119187410360798, "qmd_act_perm": 0.8810073504894028, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.11899264951059722, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.8810073504894035, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.11899264951059653, "qmd_act_ot": 0.8781428254768259, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.12185717452317417, "task_vector_cosine": 0.47437844242957644}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.675771057566863, "delta_floor": 6.709219119475701, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 9.316540662712002, "delta_floor": 6.349988724620841, "delta_vs_naive": -0.3592303948548601}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 8.410729574363993, "delta_floor": 5.444177636272832, "delta_vs_naive": -1.2650414832028698}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 17.085976358651337, "delta_floor": 14.119424420560176, "delta_vs_naive": 7.410205301084474}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 12.663573900236464, "delta_floor": 9.697021962145303, "delta_vs_naive": 2.987802842669602}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.700592060922721, "losses": [2.966551938091161, 8.037210821561073, 9.675771057566863, 8.07983255106409, 2.9838060551971215]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 6.341362502165892, "losses": [2.966551938091161, 7.824315259601272, 9.316540662712002, 7.995625694359507, 2.98380438300106]}, "secs": 622.6174767017365} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [2, 6], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.966551938091161, "b": 2.9941555951361707}, "floor": 2.966551938091161, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.06916573277070893, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.21995655247741347, "d_raw": 1.364620822213107, "qmd_perm": 1.3126072626543692, "coord_share_perm": 0.03811575985949241, "norm_ratio_perm": 1.0000000000000027, "qmd_orth": 1.3025690067952007, "coord_share_orth": 0.04547183687060582, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.1666755679427225, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.0675317610187258, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.09914380692399671, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.0849797575677561, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.1666755679427225, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.0591213579136272, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.10755421002909538, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.09218861951378046, "bnd_raw": 1.1666755679427225, "bnd_perm": 1.0675317610187258, "bnd_orth": 1.0591213579136272, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.0849797575677561, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.09218861951378046, "cka_mean": 0.8851315031932487, "cka_last": 0.9087455727032031, "qmd_act_perm": 0.050029406908131846, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.9499705930918682, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.05002940690812463, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.9499705930918754, "qmd_act_ot": 0.049065747891060774, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.9509342521089392, "task_vector_cosine": 0.5092867931841313}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.565423317229289, "delta_floor": 6.598871379138128, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 8.702997913099315, "delta_floor": 5.736445975008154, "delta_vs_naive": -0.8624254041299739}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 8.769261150521853, "delta_floor": 5.802709212430692, "delta_vs_naive": -0.7961621667074361}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 18.633734278171886, "delta_floor": 15.667182340080725, "delta_vs_naive": 9.068310960942597}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 12.607083613625244, "delta_floor": 9.640531675534083, "delta_vs_naive": 3.041660296395955}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.585069550615623, "losses": [2.966551938091161, 7.906100776408595, 9.565423317229289, 7.868643425371005, 2.9941555951361707]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 5.722644027043073, "losses": [2.966551938091161, 7.601864450831703, 8.702997913099315, 7.501403052124103, 2.9941558340213223]}, "secs": 643.9915955066681} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [3, 4], "parent_nll": {"a": 3.1001702773361055, "b": 3.4470986442789875}, "floor": 3.1001702773361055, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.2807499114871269, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.22349731077744778, "d_raw": 1.2012047300264106, "qmd_perm": 1.1736906068473096, "coord_share_perm": 0.022905440256213452, "norm_ratio_perm": 0.9999999999999993, "qmd_orth": 1.118810047887286, "coord_share_orth": 0.06859337137085117, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.7997024700847444, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.784304854202732, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.015397615882012383, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.0085556452457874, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.7997024700847444, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.764413744864214, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.03528872522053028, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.019608088451903167, "bnd_raw": 1.7997024700847444, "bnd_perm": 1.784304854202732, "bnd_orth": 1.764413744864214, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.0085556452457874, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.019608088451903167, "cka_mean": 0.3379687934263121, "cka_last": 0.8887944916310793, "qmd_act_perm": 0.8504910751073562, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.14950892489264384, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.850491075107356, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.14950892489264397, "qmd_act_ot": 0.8475781570744896, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.15242184292551048, "task_vector_cosine": 0.89375493214451}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.05160747411122, "delta_floor": 5.951437196775115, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 9.562049940374266, "delta_floor": 6.46187966303816, "delta_vs_naive": 0.5104424662630453}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 8.758838750611545, "delta_floor": 5.65866847327544, "delta_vs_naive": -0.292768723499675}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 8.376428533206948, "delta_floor": 5.276258255870842, "delta_vs_naive": -0.6751789409042726}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 13.493216617233365, "delta_floor": 10.39304633989726, "delta_vs_naive": 4.441609143122145}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 5.929845144293001, "losses": [3.1001702773361055, 7.2639416559646115, 9.05160747411122, 9.290211696836268, 3.4470986442789875]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 6.288415479566719, "losses": [3.1001702773361055, 6.8760421762883235, 9.562049940374266, 8.975271246126875, 3.4470986442789875]}, "secs": 481.69907999038696} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [3, 5], "parent_nll": {"a": 3.1001702773361055, "b": 2.9838060551971215}, "floor": 2.9838060551971215, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.1193868004653063, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.20887186796915172, "d_raw": 1.676081693099082, "qmd_perm": 1.6679865678898131, "coord_share_perm": 0.004829791556461067, "norm_ratio_perm": 0.9999999999999997, "qmd_orth": 1.6574911610964704, "coord_share_orth": 0.011091662225746082, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.7605044537226924, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.729784889941451, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.03071956378124141, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.017449296260672927, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.7605044537226924, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.715317569700494, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.04518688402219828, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.02566700920673498, "bnd_raw": 1.7605044537226924, "bnd_perm": 1.729784889941451, "bnd_orth": 1.715317569700494, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.017449296260672927, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.02566700920673498, "cka_mean": 0.7864736547542495, "cka_last": 0.8927451596005689, "qmd_act_perm": 0.0013152835156776677, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.9986847164843223, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.001315283515679666, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.9986847164843203, "qmd_act_ot": 0.002210940602946021, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.997789059397054, "task_vector_cosine": 0.6306158104332591}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.64621586808953, "delta_floor": 6.66240981289241, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 8.80682759244537, "delta_floor": 5.823021537248248, "delta_vs_naive": -0.8393882756441613}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 9.024955854023972, "delta_floor": 6.041149798826851, "delta_vs_naive": -0.6212600140655589}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 13.671473035918135, "delta_floor": 10.687666980721014, "delta_vs_naive": 4.025257167828604}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 12.986445656494618, "delta_floor": 10.002639601297497, "delta_vs_naive": 3.3402297884050878}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.604227701822917, "losses": [3.1001702773361055, 8.72333500234426, 9.64621586808953, 6.919574854503017, 2.9838060551971215]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 5.792108644011435, "losses": [3.1001702773361055, 8.863187607020548, 8.80682759244537, 6.397331939518102, 2.983805020028131]}, "secs": 362.57991456985474} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [3, 6], "parent_nll": {"a": 3.1001702773361055, "b": 2.9941555951361707}, "floor": 2.9941555951361707, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.1419573438056252, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.223864621653571, "d_raw": 1.5778919393505897, "qmd_perm": 1.5672643188727513, "coord_share_perm": 0.006735328454882897, "norm_ratio_perm": 1.0000000000000029, "qmd_orth": 1.5548044642195937, "coord_share_orth": 0.014631848072243802, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.7359686619057608, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.7138299719519605, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.022138689953800306, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.01275293180090951, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.7359686619057608, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.6985442067860699, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.03742445511969095, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.021558255019768657, "bnd_raw": 1.7359686619057608, "bnd_perm": 1.7138299719519605, "bnd_orth": 1.6985442067860699, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.01275293180090951, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.021558255019768657, "cka_mean": 0.2855534044598928, "cka_last": 0.8829887536399958, "qmd_act_perm": 0.7884825598171501, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.2115174401828499, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.7884825598171503, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.21151744018284963, "qmd_act_ot": 0.6663767605875239, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.33362323941247607, "task_vector_cosine": 0.6777125405647323}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 10.617647752058872, "delta_floor": 7.623492156922701, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 8.652777883948957, "delta_floor": 5.658622288812786, "delta_vs_naive": -1.9648698681099148}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 9.035877046130953, "delta_floor": 6.041721450994782, "delta_vs_naive": -1.5817707059279194}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 13.649380618578768, "delta_floor": 10.655225023442597, "delta_vs_naive": 3.0317328665198957}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 12.642829750693085, "delta_floor": 9.648674155556915, "delta_vs_naive": 2.0251819986342134}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 7.570484815822734, "losses": [3.1001702773361055, 9.536207026153784, 10.617647752058872, 7.202095564253098, 2.9941555951361707]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 5.605615345854739, "losses": [3.1001702773361055, 8.444468757644325, 8.652777883948957, 6.513897223326403, 2.994154798852332]}, "secs": 556.298823595047} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [4, 5], "parent_nll": {"a": 3.4470986442789875, "b": 2.9838060551971215}, "floor": 2.9838060551971215, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.1128238002623178, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.22513532148864776, "d_raw": 1.7267302126654394, "qmd_perm": 1.7201229093364616, "coord_share_perm": 0.0038264827246976153, "norm_ratio_perm": 0.999999999999998, "qmd_orth": 1.7118748736751683, "coord_share_orth": 0.008603161560102561, "d_raw_bn_perm": 3.674257785473239, "qmd_bn_perm": 3.665003814373194, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.009253971100045, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.0025185960377173433, "d_raw_bn_orth": 3.674257785473239, "qmd_bn_orth": 3.6577213076821002, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.016536477791138537, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.004500630809443509, "bnd_raw": 3.674257785473239, "bnd_perm": 3.665003814373194, "bnd_orth": 3.6577213076821002, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.0025185960377173433, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.004500630809443509, "cka_mean": 0.32804021097280933, "cka_last": 0.8508198363359261, "qmd_act_perm": 0.8556919054344057, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.14430809456559437, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.8556919054344059, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.14430809456559415, "qmd_act_ot": 0.8440715001092414, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.15592849989075863, "task_vector_cosine": 0.6330878058010952}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.02872769131197, "delta_floor": 6.044921636114848, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 9.207771475456621, "delta_floor": 6.2239654202595, "delta_vs_naive": 0.1790437841446515}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 9.274581919133235, "delta_floor": 6.290775863936114, "delta_vs_naive": 0.24585422782126543}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 10.693266687561154, "delta_floor": 7.709460632364033, "delta_vs_naive": 1.6645389962491848}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 13.294940667298597, "delta_floor": 10.311134612101476, "delta_vs_naive": 4.266212975986628}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.165891325092751, "losses": [3.4470986442789875, 9.497166822101272, 9.02872769131197, 7.0295252492049904, 2.9838060551971215]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 5.992319284975334, "losses": [3.4470986442789875, 8.805955820898564, 9.207771475456621, 7.986850646455072, 2.983805736683586]}, "secs": 467.3576738834381} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [4, 6], "parent_nll": {"a": 3.4470986442789875, "b": 2.9941555951361707}, "floor": 2.9941555951361707, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.13208403513117548, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.22400800365540904, "d_raw": 1.6257367163068805, "qmd_perm": 1.6175686211417373, "coord_share_perm": 0.0050242422916414176, "norm_ratio_perm": 1.0000000000000024, "qmd_orth": 1.6077656818530925, "coord_share_orth": 0.01105408660180356, "d_raw_bn_perm": 3.5923064648029985, "qmd_bn_perm": 3.582406361790557, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.009900103012441708, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.002755918268511266, "d_raw_bn_orth": 3.5923064648029985, "qmd_bn_orth": 3.5762861275428257, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.016020337260172823, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.004459624315781024, "bnd_raw": 3.5923064648029985, "bnd_perm": 3.582406361790557, "bnd_orth": 3.5762861275428257, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.002755918268511266, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.004459624315781024, "cka_mean": 0.6004199830016228, "cka_last": 0.8451289272710756, "qmd_act_perm": 0.26577819376366874, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.7342218062363313, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.2657781937636684, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.7342218062363316, "qmd_act_ot": 0.2870918236945902, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.7129081763054098, "task_vector_cosine": 0.6796163975055732}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.505021047374429, "delta_floor": 6.510865452238258, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 9.759864364196021, "delta_floor": 6.7657087690598505, "delta_vs_naive": 0.2548433168215922}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 9.643596731286692, "delta_floor": 6.6494411361505215, "delta_vs_naive": 0.13857568391226316}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 11.914558425574853, "delta_floor": 8.920402830438682, "delta_vs_naive": 2.409537378200424}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 13.933378434849967, "delta_floor": 10.939222839713796, "delta_vs_naive": 4.428357387475538}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 7.0465059821619676, "losses": [3.4470986442789875, 10.380368864155251, 9.505021047374429, 6.611081436266716, 2.9941555951361707]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 6.5392375630019774, "losses": [3.4470986442789875, 8.824065863502936, 9.759864364196021, 8.178403412681424, 2.9941549581090996]}, "secs": 533.4391632080078} |
| {"set": "set1_polypythia", "size": "410m", "pair": [5, 6], "parent_nll": {"a": 2.9838060551971215, "b": 2.9941555951361707}, "floor": 2.9838060551971215, "corpus": "flores200_devtest_eng_Latn", "metric": "nats_per_token", "align_info": {"perm": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}, "orth": {"residual": true, "hidden": 24, "heads": 24, "rejected": []}}, "predictors": {"weight_cosine": 0.06875949872101057, "weight_cosine_bn": 0.21644653739512984, "d_raw": 1.3709288286150396, "qmd_perm": 1.3226898336211084, "coord_share_perm": 0.03518708921065142, "norm_ratio_perm": 1.0000000000000042, "qmd_orth": 1.3219831400169375, "coord_share_orth": 0.03570257447102397, "d_raw_bn_perm": 1.1685617425665693, "qmd_bn_perm": 1.0838233700238462, "coordinate_gap_bn_perm": 0.0847383725427231, "coord_fraction_bn_perm": 0.07251510079100147, "d_raw_bn_orth": 1.1685617425665693, "qmd_bn_orth": 1.0609269734917142, "coordinate_gap_bn_orth": 0.10763476907485514, "coord_fraction_bn_orth": 0.09210875656296229, "bnd_raw": 1.1685617425665693, "bnd_perm": 1.0838233700238462, "bnd_orth": 1.0609269734917142, "coord_share_bnd_perm": 0.07251510079100147, "coord_share_bnd_orth": 0.09210875656296229, "cka_mean": 0.4886045988178357, "cka_last": 0.9239769985088346, "qmd_act_perm": 0.7904735484131935, "aligned_cka_perm": 0.20952645158680647, "qmd_act_procrustes": 0.7904735484131937, "aligned_cka_procrustes": 0.20952645158680627, "qmd_act_ot": 0.666266973429068, "aligned_cka_ot": 0.333733026570932, "task_vector_cosine": 0.48680403118117455}, "rungs": {"M0_naive_avg": {"nll": 9.267641509193576, "delta_floor": 6.2838354539964545, "delta_vs_naive": 0.0}, "M1_perm_avg": {"nll": 8.892924349213144, "delta_floor": 5.909118294016023, "delta_vs_naive": -0.3747171599804311}, "M1_orth_avg": {"nll": 9.044541251325017, "delta_floor": 6.0607351961278955, "delta_vs_naive": -0.22310025786855903}, "M2_task_arith": {"nll": 16.892477474722767, "delta_floor": 13.908671419525646, "delta_vs_naive": 7.624835965529192}, "M3_ties": {"nll": 12.305614374388455, "delta_floor": 9.321808319191334, "delta_vs_naive": 3.037972865194879}}, "barrier_naive": {"barrier": 6.27866068402693, "losses": [2.9838060551971215, 8.28495431241846, 9.267641509193576, 8.171215995494945, 2.9941555951361707]}, "barrier_perm": {"barrier": 5.90394316571877, "losses": [2.9838060551971215, 7.580617686929224, 8.892924349213144, 7.735763559758236, 2.994156311791626]}, "secs": 434.0421335697174} |
|
|
