"""Sanity: is the alignment actually FUNCTION-PRESERVING? Every M1 rung is only meaningful if g.th_B computes exactly what th_B computes. A permutation of the residual basis, of the free MLP hidden axis and of the attention heads is exact in theory; a bug in applying it produces a plausible-looking state dict whose merges are quietly garbage. This checks it empirically on both substrates: evaluate the parent, then evaluate the aligned parent, and compare. An orthogonal map is NOT expected to be exact (it does not commute with the elementwise LayerNorm gain), so its drift is reported as a magnitude, not as a pass/fail.""" import sys, json, glob sys.path.insert(0, "/root/compose-audit") from common import * import gpt2_align as G2 from transformers import AutoModelForCausalLM, AutoTokenizer from mergeschool.core.models import load_hf from set4_goldfish_lib import sent_acts DEV = "cuda" out = {} def neox_head_match(sd_a, sd_b, d, nh, nl): hd, perms = d // nh, {} for L in range(nl): qk = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.query_key_value.weight" de = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.dense.weight" if qk not in sd_a: continue Aq = np.asarray(sd_a[qk], float).reshape(nh, 3 * hd, d) Bq = np.asarray(sd_b[qk], float).reshape(nh, 3 * hd, d) Ad = np.asarray(sd_a[de], float).reshape(d, nh, hd) Bd = np.asarray(sd_b[de], float).reshape(d, nh, hd) perms[L] = AL._assignment(np.einsum("ixy,jxy->ij", Aq, Bq) + np.einsum("xiy,xjy->ij", Ad, Bd)) return perms def neox_apply_head(sd, perms, d, nh): hd, o = d // nh, dict(sd) for L, h in perms.items(): qk = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.query_key_value.weight" qb = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.query_key_value.bias" de = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.dense.weight" o[qk] = np.asarray(sd[qk], float).reshape(nh, 3 * hd, d)[h].reshape(3 * d, d) if qb in sd: o[qb] = np.asarray(sd[qb], float).reshape(nh, 3 * hd)[h].reshape(3 * d) o[de] = np.asarray(sd[de], float).reshape(d, nh, hd)[:, h].reshape(d, d) return o # ---------------- SET 1 / GPTNeoX tok = AutoTokenizer.from_pretrained("EleutherAI/pythia-14m") blocks = make_blocks(tok, flores_lines("eng_Latn"), block=512, max_blocks=24) ma = AutoModelForCausalLM.from_pretrained("EleutherAI/pythia-14m-seed1", dtype=torch.float32).to(DEV).eval() mb = AutoModelForCausalLM.from_pretrained("EleutherAI/pythia-14m-seed2", dtype=torch.float32).to(DEV).eval() D, NH, NL = ma.config.hidden_size, ma.config.num_attention_heads, ma.config.num_hidden_layers sa, sb = sd_np(ma), sd_np(mb) aa, ab = capture_acts(ma, blocks, DEV), capture_acts(mb, blocks, DEV) base = nll_nats(mb, blocks, DEV, bs=16) res = {} for method in ("permutation", "orthogonal"): sd, info = AL.align_weights_full(sa, sb, D, acts_a=aa, acts_b=ab, n_heads=None, method=method, strict=True, accept_each=False) sd_load(mb, sd, DEV); res[f"{method}_residual+mlp"] = nll_nats(mb, blocks, DEV, bs=16) - base if method == "permutation": hp = neox_head_match(sa, sd, D, NH, NL) sd2 = neox_apply_head(sd, hp, D, NH) sd_load(mb, sd2, DEV); res["permutation_full(+heads)"] = nll_nats(mb, blocks, DEV, bs=16) - base sd_load(mb, sb, DEV) out["set1_pythia14m"] = {"parent_nll": base, "nll_change_after_alignment": res} print("SET1", json.dumps(out["set1_pythia14m"], indent=1)) del ma, mb; torch.cuda.empty_cache() # ---------------- SET 4 / GPT-2 (Conv1D) m_e, tok_e = load_hf("goldfish-models/eng_latn_1000mb", dtype=torch.float32, device=DEV); m_e.eval() m_x, tok_x = load_hf("goldfish-models/nld_latn_1000mb", dtype=torch.float32, device=DEV); m_x.eval() D2, NH2 = m_e.config.n_embd, m_e.config.n_head lines_e = flores_lines("eng_Latn")[:300]; lines_x = flores_lines("nld_Latn")[:300] ae = sent_acts(m_e, tok_e, lines_e, DEV); ax = sent_acts(m_x, tok_x, lines_x, DEV) sde, sdx = sd_np(m_e), sd_np(m_x) bl = make_blocks(tok_x, lines_x, block=512, max_blocks=16) b0 = nll_nats(m_x, bl, DEV, bs=8) res2 = {} for tag, sd in (("perm_residual_only", G2.apply_resid(sdx, D2, perm=AL.residual_basis_map(ae, ax, "permutation")[1])), ("mlp_only", G2.apply_mlp(sdx, G2.mlp_match(sde, sdx))), ("heads_only", G2.apply_head(sdx, G2.head_match(sde, sdx, D2, NH2), D2, NH2)), ("perm_full", G2.align_full(sde, sdx, D2, NH2, ae, ax, "permutation", accept_each=False)[0]), ("orth_full", G2.align_full(sde, sdx, D2, NH2, ae, ax, "orthogonal", accept_each=False)[0])): sd_load(m_x, sd, DEV); res2[tag] = nll_nats(m_x, bl, DEV, bs=8) - b0 out["set4_goldfish_nld"] = {"parent_nll": b0, "nll_change_after_alignment": res2} print("SET4", json.dumps(out["set4_goldfish_nld"], indent=1)) json.dump(out, open("/root/compose-audit/results/alignment_health.json", "w"), indent=1)