"""Did we try hard enough to make merging work? The obvious objection to SET 1's negative result is that a plain average of aligned weights is a weak merge: averaging two networks halves the variance of every pre-activation, and REPAIR (Jordan et al., ICLR 2023) shows that restoring those first- and second-order statistics recovers most of the remaining barrier on vision nets. This adds that rung, training-free: after the permutation-aligned average, walk the layers in order and affine-correct each Linear's pre-activations so their per-unit mean and std match the average of the two parents' own statistics on the same corpus. Rungs: M0 naive · M1 permutation-aligned average · M4 = M1 + REPAIR · M5 = M0 + REPAIR. Metrics: Δfloor in nats/token (FLORES-200 eng devtest) AND BLiMP accuracy, on the same merges.""" import os, sys, json, time, glob, itertools, argparse, gc, csv sys.path.insert(0, "/root/compose-audit") from common import * from transformers import AutoModelForCausalLM, AutoTokenizer import pyarrow.parquet as pq ap = argparse.ArgumentParser() ap.add_argument("--size", default="14m") ap.add_argument("--seeds", default="1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9") ap.add_argument("--blocks", type=int, default=48) ap.add_argument("--bs", type=int, default=16) ap.add_argument("--n_per_paradigm", type=int, default=200) ap.add_argument("--acts_rows", type=int, default=2048) A = ap.parse_args() SEEDS = [int(s) for s in A.seeds.split(",")] OUT = f"/root/compose-audit/results/repair_{A.size}.jsonl" DEV = "cuda" BLIMP = glob.glob("/root/hf_cache_brainalign/hub/datasets--nyu-mll--blimp/snapshots/*/")[0] def log(*a): print(f"[{time.strftime('%H:%M:%S')}]", *a, flush=True) def neox_head_match(sd_a, sd_b, d, nh, nl): hd, perms = d // nh, {} for L in range(nl): qk = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.query_key_value.weight" de = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.dense.weight" if qk not in sd_a: continue Aq = np.asarray(sd_a[qk], float).reshape(nh, 3 * hd, d) Bq = np.asarray(sd_b[qk], float).reshape(nh, 3 * hd, d) g = np.einsum("ixy,jxy->ij", Aq, Bq) Ad = np.asarray(sd_a[de], float).reshape(d, nh, hd) Bd = np.asarray(sd_b[de], float).reshape(d, nh, hd) perms[L] = AL._assignment(g + np.einsum("xiy,xjy->ij", Ad, Bd)) return perms def neox_apply_head(sd, perms, d, nh): hd, out = d // nh, dict(sd) for L, h in perms.items(): qk = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.query_key_value.weight" qb = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.query_key_value.bias" de = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.attention.dense.weight" out[qk] = np.asarray(sd[qk], float).reshape(nh, 3 * hd, d)[h].reshape(3 * d, d) if qb in sd: out[qb] = np.asarray(sd[qb], float).reshape(nh, 3 * hd)[h].reshape(3 * d) out[de] = np.asarray(sd[de], float).reshape(d, nh, hd)[:, h].reshape(d, d) return out def align_perm(sd_a, sd_b, d, aa, ab, nh, nl): sd, _ = AL.align_weights_full(sd_a, sd_b, d, acts_a=aa, acts_b=ab, n_heads=None, method="permutation", strict=True, accept_each=True) hp = neox_head_match(sd_a, sd, d, nh, nl) if hp: cand = neox_apply_head(sd, hp, d, nh) if AL.block_normalised_distance(sd_a, cand) <= AL.block_normalised_distance(sd_a, sd): sd = cand return sd # ------------------------------------------------------------------ REPAIR TARGETS = ("mlp.dense_h_to_4h", "attention.query_key_value") @torch.no_grad() def preact_stats(model, blocks, dev, bs, nl): """{(layer, target): (mean, std)} of each Linear's OUTPUT (= pre-activation), per unit.""" acc = {} hs = [] def mk(key): def hook(mod, inp, out): o = out.detach().float().reshape(-1, out.shape[-1]) s = acc.setdefault(key, [0.0, None, None]) s[0] += o.shape[0] s[1] = o.sum(0) if s[1] is None else s[1] + o.sum(0) s[2] = (o * o).sum(0) if s[2] is None else s[2] + (o * o).sum(0) return hook for L in range(nl): blk = model.gpt_neox.layers[L] hs.append(blk.mlp.dense_h_to_4h.register_forward_hook(mk((L, "mlp.dense_h_to_4h")))) hs.append(blk.attention.query_key_value.register_forward_hook(mk((L, "attention.query_key_value")))) for i in range(0, blocks.shape[0], bs): model(blocks[i:i + bs].to(dev)) for h in hs: h.remove() out = {} for k, (n, s1, s2) in acc.items(): m = s1 / n v = (s2 / n - m * m).clamp_min(1e-12) out[k] = (m.cpu().numpy().astype(np.float64), v.sqrt().cpu().numpy().astype(np.float64)) return out def repair(sd_merged, stats_a, stats_b, shell, blocks, dev, bs, nl): """Walk layers in order; after fixing layers < L the inputs to layer L are already corrected, so layer L's own statistics are re-measured before it is corrected. Affine correction on the Linear's weight/bias, so the model stays exactly a model of the same architecture.""" sd = {k: np.array(v, dtype=np.float64, copy=True) for k, v in sd_merged.items()} for L in range(nl): sd_load(shell, sd, dev) cur = preact_stats(shell, blocks, dev, bs, nl) for t in TARGETS: mu_t = 0.5 * (stats_a[(L, t)][0] + stats_b[(L, t)][0]) sd_t = 0.5 * (stats_a[(L, t)][1] + stats_b[(L, t)][1]) mu_m, sd_m = cur[(L, t)] g = sd_t / np.maximum(sd_m, 1e-8) wk, bk = f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.{t}.weight", f"gpt_neox.layers.{L}.{t}.bias" sd[wk] = sd[wk] * g[:, None] sd[bk] = (sd[bk] - mu_m) * g + mu_t return sd # ------------------------------------------------------------------ BLiMP def load_blimp(n_per): out = [] for d in sorted(glob.glob(BLIMP + "*/")): f = glob.glob(d + "*.parquet") if not f: continue t = pq.read_table(f[0]).to_pydict() out.append((os.path.basename(d.rstrip("/")), t["sentence_good"][:n_per], t["sentence_bad"][:n_per])) return out tok = AutoTokenizer.from_pretrained(f"EleutherAI/pythia-{A.size}") if tok.pad_token is None: tok.pad_token = tok.eos_token def enc(sents, maxlen=48): e = tok(sents, return_tensors="pt", padding=True, truncation=True, max_length=maxlen) return e["input_ids"], e["attention_mask"] ENC = [(n, enc(g), enc(b)) for n, g, b in load_blimp(A.n_per_paradigm)] lines = flores_lines("eng_Latn") blocks = make_blocks(tok, lines, block=512, max_blocks=A.blocks) shell = AutoModelForCausalLM.from_pretrained(f"EleutherAI/pythia-{A.size}-seed{SEEDS[0]}", dtype=torch.float32).to(DEV).eval() cfg = shell.config D, NH, NL = cfg.hidden_size, cfg.num_attention_heads, cfg.num_hidden_layers log(f"size={A.size} d={D} heads={NH} layers={NL} blimp_paradigms={len(ENC)}") @torch.no_grad() def bscore(ids, am): o = [] for i in range(0, ids.shape[0], 128): x, m = ids[i:i + 128].to(DEV), am[i:i + 128].to(DEV) lp = torch.log_softmax(shell(x, attention_mask=m).logits.float()[:, :-1], -1) o.append((lp.gather(-1, x[:, 1:].unsqueeze(-1)).squeeze(-1) * m[:, 1:].float()).sum(1).cpu()) return torch.cat(o).numpy() def evaluate(sd): sd_load(shell, sd, DEV) nll = nll_nats(shell, blocks, DEV, bs=A.bs) cor = tot = 0 for name, (gi, gm), (bi, bm) in ENC: sg, sb = bscore(gi, gm), bscore(bi, bm) cor += int((sg > sb).sum()); tot += len(sg) return nll, cor / tot SDS, ACTS, PAR, STATS = {}, {}, {}, {} for s in SEEDS: m = AutoModelForCausalLM.from_pretrained(f"EleutherAI/pythia-{A.size}-seed{s}", dtype=torch.float32).to(DEV).eval() SDS[s] = sd_np(m); ACTS[s] = capture_acts(m, blocks, DEV, n_rows=A.acts_rows, bs=A.bs) del m; torch.cuda.empty_cache() PAR[s] = evaluate(SDS[s]) log(f" seed{s} nll={PAR[s][0]:.4f} blimp={PAR[s][1]:.4f}") done = set() if os.path.exists(OUT): for l in open(OUT): try: done.add(tuple(json.loads(l)["pair"])) except Exception: pass fh = open(OUT, "a") for a, b in itertools.combinations(SEEDS, 2): if (a, b) in done: continue t0 = time.time() sa, sb = SDS[a], SDS[b] sbp = align_perm(sa, sb, D, ACTS[a], ACTS[b], NH, NL) sd_load(shell, sa, DEV); st_a = preact_stats(shell, blocks, DEV, A.bs, NL) sd_load(shell, sbp, DEV); st_b = preact_stats(shell, blocks, DEV, A.bs, NL) sd_load(shell, sb, DEV); st_braw = preact_stats(shell, blocks, DEV, A.bs, NL) rungs = {"M0_naive_avg": MG.average([sa, sb]), "M1_perm_avg": MG.average([sa, sbp])} rungs["M4_perm_repair"] = repair(rungs["M1_perm_avg"], st_a, st_b, shell, blocks, DEV, A.bs, NL) rungs["M5_naive_repair"] = repair(rungs["M0_naive_avg"], st_a, st_braw, shell, blocks, DEV, A.bs, NL) floor = min(PAR[a][0], PAR[b][0]); ceil = max(PAR[a][1], PAR[b][1]) res = {} for k, sd in rungs.items(): nll, acc = evaluate(sd) res[k] = {"nll": nll, "delta_floor": nll - floor, "blimp_acc": acc, "blimp_delta_vs_ceiling": acc - ceil} r = {"set": "set1_repair", "size": A.size, "pair": [a, b], "floor": floor, "blimp_ceiling": ceil, "parent_nll": {"a": PAR[a][0], "b": PAR[b][0]}, "parent_blimp": {"a": PAR[a][1], "b": PAR[b][1]}, "rungs": res, "secs": time.time() - t0} fh.write(json.dumps(r) + "\n"); fh.flush() log(f"pair {a},{b} floor={floor:.2f}/ceil={ceil:.3f} | " + " | ".join(f"{k}: {v['delta_floor']:+.2f}n {v['blimp_acc']:.3f}" for k, v in res.items()) + f" ({r['secs']:.0f}s)") del rungs, sbp; gc.collect() fh.close() log("DONE repair", A.size)