--- license: cc-by-sa-4.0 tags: - reap - moe - expert-pruning - mixture-of-experts - bob --- # REAP scores: 28Bob "Riker" Riker is one of Bob's own brains: Qwen3.6-35B-A3B cut to 208 experts per layer and healed on Bob's lessons. This page holds its experts, scored and ranked by REAP, and the keep lists that were tested, in **one file**: `28Bob-Riker.json`. Use it to run the model with fewer experts **without cutting the model file**. Made for [Bob](https://github.com/MouseWurX/Bob), the open-source desktop assistant. Bob and his brains' names are inspired by Dennis E. Taylor's novels (not affiliated). ## What REAP is REAP (Router-weighted Expert Activation Pruning, Cerebras 2025) scores each expert by **router weight × the size of the expert's output**, summed over every word it was picked for. Here the sums run over **100 of Bob's training lessons (270,267 tokens)**, with the model served at 12 experts per word from MouseWurX/28Bob-Riker: 28Bob-Q4_K_M.gguf. Experts that are picked rarely but matter a lot when they are keep a high score; counting picks alone would miss them. ## The file `28Bob-Riker.json`: `model`, `base`, `method`, `lessons`, `tokens`, `layers` (40), `experts` (208 per layer), `experts_per_word` (12), `scores.picks` and `scores.mass` (one row per layer, one number per expert), `experts_by_layer` (each layer's expert ids, strongest first), `keep_lists` (by percent kept: one list of expert ids per layer; `null` = every expert on), `results` (the held-out score at each step) and `picked`. ## Using a keep list (no file cut) Brain Engine (Bob's llama.cpp build with the expert-mask patch) switches experts on and off live: ```bash # keep only the listed experts in each layer (here the 35% list) jq '{keep: .keep_lists["35"]}' 28Bob-Riker.json | curl -X POST http://127.0.0.1:8080/expert-mask -H "Content-Type: application/json" -d @- # every expert back on curl -X POST http://127.0.0.1:8080/expert-mask -H "Content-Type: application/json" -d '{"keep": null}' ``` A mask changes which experts the router may pick; it doesn't free memory by itself. To save memory, load only the kept experts (for example, keep the rest in system RAM), or cut a file from the same list. ## Held-out results Judged on Bob's 196 held-out lessons (314 assistant turns, never trained on), thinking off. "Right" means the same tools and arguments as the full Qwen3.6-35B-A3B teacher, or correctly no tool. | Kept per layer | Share | Right tool | Right arguments | Correctly no tool | Held-out overall | Tokens/s | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---| | 208 of 208 | 100% | 70/123 | 47/123 | 163/191 | **210/314** (66.9%) | 114.4 | | 156 of 208 | 75% | 66/123 | 45/123 | 159/191 | **204/314** (65.0%) | 94.2 | | 104 of 208 | 50% | 64/123 | 32/123 | 131/191 | **163/314** (51.9%) | 97.7 | | 73 of 208 | 35% | 66/123 | 33/123 | 39/191 | **72/314** (22.9%) | 92.5 | The calibration's own pick (smallest step within 2 points of the full score): **75%**. Read it with the table: 75% is 6 points down. ## Part of Bob This is part of **[Bob](https://github.com/MouseWurX/Bob)**, a free, open-source AI agent that runs on your own computer (Windows, Mac, Linux, Raspberry Pi, Android). Nothing goes online unless you turn it on. **What Bob does** - **A real agent:** researches with sources, writes, runs and fixes code, reads and edits documents and files, works other apps, and makes pictures, clips, music and a voice. - **His own brains:** models cut and retrained to run Bob on everyday graphics cards, with every score, lesson set and dollar published. - **Bob-Net:** your Bobs share graphics cards and memory and check each other's work, on your home network. - **Gaming friendly:** the brain unloads when idle, and a Gaming session gives the graphics card back to your game. - **Private:** no account, no telemetry. Everything optional starts switched off. **The Computer Science Lab** ([guide](https://github.com/MouseWurX/Bob/blob/main/app/docs/USER-GUIDE.md#make-your-own-brain-the-lab), [code](https://github.com/MouseWurX/Bob/tree/main/app/model-lab)), where this was made and measured. It's a workbench inside Bob, with no command line: - **Make a brain:** shrink it, cut experts, or take out sight, hearing or the refusal habit. A brain is usable only after it has been tested. - **Forge:** every way to make a new brain, side by side. It writes the plan for jobs that need a rented card. - **Test:** scored challenges, one brain in six sizes, long-context and speed tests, and blind taste tests. - **Teach:** teach a brain a lesson set, or have a bigger brain teach a smaller one. - **Look inside:** see which experts your work uses. **fNRI** scans a brain while it answers and plays it back in 3D. **Training protocols** ([Forge guide](https://github.com/MouseWurX/Bob/blob/main/app/model-lab/forge/README.md), [Forge journal](https://github.com/MouseWurX/Bob/blob/main/app/docs/FORGE-JOURNAL.md), [Making smaller models](https://github.com/MouseWurX/Bob/blob/main/app/docs/MAKING-SMALLER-MODELS.md)). Every model goes through the same steps, in order: baseline → clean first → analyse → train → cut in steps → heal → check every target → learn from its own answers → blend → live dials → publish. Each step is benchmarked. Why we chose this order: - **Baseline first,** so every change is measured against the untouched model, not against a guess. - **Clean before teaching, cut after training,** so a cut keeps what training taught and no fault gets baked in. - **Measure before cutting (REAP),** so the experts that do the least work are the ones removed, per job, from real traces. - **Cut in steps and heal from the full model's odds** (distillation), because small steps show where quality breaks, and copying the teacher's odds recovers more than plain answers can. - **No target may drop,** so a gain in tools can't quietly cost coding, facts or safety. - **Learn from its own answers** (on-policy, reward for tool calls that really work), because a model fixes the mistakes it actually makes, not the ones a teacher imagines. - **Honest data:** test items are never taught, surgery and evil-check data never train, and everything is scrubbed of private data first. **The plan:** what comes next, and why, in the [roadmap](https://github.com/MouseWurX/Bob/pull/230). **Costs:** every rental, its card, its hours and what it bought, on the [costs page](https://github.com/MouseWurX/Bob/blob/main/app/docs/COSTS.md). ## Credit Base model: Qwen3.6-35B-A3B by Alibaba's Qwen team (Apache 2.0, https://huggingface.co/Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B). The scores and keep lists here are CC BY-SA 4.0. ## Other REAP scores - [35Bob "Bobert"](https://huggingface.co/datasets/MouseWurX/REAP-scores-35Bob-Bobert) - [gpt-oss-120b](https://huggingface.co/datasets/MouseWurX/REAP-scores-gpt-oss-120b) - Bob's lessons, and the answers from this benchmark run: [MouseWurX/bob-lessons](https://huggingface.co/datasets/MouseWurX/bob-lessons)