Delete validation

validation/expert_validation_R1.csv

@@ -1,124 +0,0 @@
-NEST3D EXPERT ANNOTATION VALIDATION: FRITZ,,,,,,,,,,,,
-,,,,,,,,,,,,
-"INSTRUCTIONS: For each sample row below, click 'View image' to open the QC plot (top/side/front views in label colors and RGB), then select answers from the dropdown menus in columns Q1-Q9. Q10 is free text. Q9 and Q10 are optional.",,,,,,,,,,,,
-LABEL COLORS:  Green = Grass  |  Brown = Tree  |  Red = Nest,,,,,,,,,,,,
-,,,,,,,,,,,,
-QUESTION GUIDE — read before starting,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q1 — Nest Completeness: Does the labeled nest region capture the full extent of the visible nest structure?   OPTIONS: Yes - fully captured | Partial - some material missing | No - significant missing | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q2 — Nest Precision: Does the nest label include points that belong to the tree canopy rather than the nest? (false positives)   OPTIONS: None - label appears clean | Minor - small amounts of tree points | Significant - substantial mislabeling | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q3 — Tree/Nest Boundary: Is the boundary between nest and tree branch structure ecologically reasonable?   OPTIONS: Yes - ecologically reasonable | Acceptable - minor issues | No - does not reflect actual interface | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q4 — Grass / Ground Plane: Does the grass label correctly represent ground-level vegetation?   OPTIONS: Yes - well labeled | Acceptable - minor issues | No - significant issues | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-"Q5 — Overall Quality: Rate the overall annotation quality. 1=Very poor, 5=Excellent.   OPTIONS: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5",,,,,,,,,,,,
-"Q6 — Tree Species: Can you identify the tree species from canopy shape, branching, and morphology?   OPTIONS: Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn) | Boscia albitrunca (shepherd's tree) | Other (specify in Q10) | Uncertain",,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q6b — Species Confidence: How confident are you in your species identification?   OPTIONS: Confident | Somewhat confident | Uncertain,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q7 — Nest Activity: Estimate nest activity. Active=dense intact thatch. Abandoned=degraded/sparse.   OPTIONS: Active | Likely active | Likely abandoned | Abandoned | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q8 — Occlusion Severity: How much of the nest is obscured by the tree canopy?   OPTIONS: Low - mostly visible | Medium - partially occluded | High - heavily occluded,,,,,,,,,,,,
-,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q9 — Annotation Difficulty (optional): How difficult would it be for a human expert to annotate this sample?   OPTIONS: Easy | Moderate | Hard | Very hard,,,,,,,,,,,,
-"Q10 — Free Observations (optional): Any notable ecological or structural observations? e.g. unusual nest shape, multiple nests, damage, branch architecture. Free text.",,,,,,,,,,,,
-,,,,,,,,,,,,
-sample_id,image,Q1,Q2,Q3,Q4,Q5,Q6,Q6b,Q7,Q8,Q9,Q10
-sample001,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample002,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample003,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample004,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample005,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample006,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample007,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample008,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample009,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample010,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample011,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Nests with large surface areas, like in this tree, can serve as breeding platforms for Verreaux Eagle Owl Ketupa lactea."
-sample012,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Cannot assess,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"This tree representation shows a likely abandoned nest attached to a branch that appears to have fallen to the ground. The thatch density of this nest does not seem to be significantly different to the thatch density of the nest that is shown in the canopy of the tree and that is likely ""active"". Hence, visually assessed thatch density seems to be a weak indicator for nest activity. "
-sample013,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample014,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample015,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample016,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample017,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample018,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample019,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample020,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample021,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample022,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample023,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample024,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample025,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample026,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample027,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample028,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample029,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample030,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample031,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample032,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample033,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample034,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample035,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample036,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample037,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample038,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample039,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample040,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample041,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample042,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample043,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample044,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample045,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample046,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample047,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample048,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample049,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample050,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Nests with large surface areas, like in this tree, can serve as breeding platforms for Verreaux Eagle Owl Ketupa lactea."
-sample051,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Nests with large surface areas, like in this tree, can serve as breeding platforms for Verreaux Eagle Owl Ketupa lactea."
-sample052,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample053,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample054,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample055,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample056,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample057,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample058,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample059,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample060,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample061,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample062,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample063,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample064,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample065,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample066,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample067,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample068,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"This tree representation shows a likely abandoned nest attached to a branch that appears to have fallen to the ground. The thatch density of this nest does not seem to be visually different to the thatch density of other nests in other trees that are likely ""active"". Hence, visually assessed thatch density seems to be a weak indicator for nest activity. "
-sample069,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample070,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample071,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample072,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample073,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample074,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample075,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample076,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Nests with large surface areas, like in this tree, can serve as breeding platforms for Verreaux Eagle Owl Ketupa lactea."
-sample077,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample078,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample079,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Nests with large surface areas, like in this tree, can serve as breeding platforms for Verreaux Eagle Owl Ketupa lactea."
-sample080,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample081,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample082,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample083,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample084,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample085,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample086,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample087,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample088,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Hard,"Dead Vachellia erioloba tree. Notice that dead Vachellia erioloba trees are known to stand for many years (due to hard wood, which is more resistant to termite-caused degradation) serving as important eco-system structures such as nesting sites or hunting spots for raptors (due to little canopy obstrusion, visibility for raptors is increased). Is nesting by sociable weaver causing mortality in Vachellia erioloba?"
-sample089,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Hard,"Dead Vachellia erioloba tree. Notice that dead Vachellia erioloba trees are known to stand for many years (due to hard wood, which is more resistant to termite-caused degradation) serving as important eco-system structures such as nesting sites or hunting spots for raptors (due to little canopy obstrusion, visibility for raptors is increased). Is nesting by sociable weaver causing mortality in Vachellia erioloba? Long-term observational data of nest sizes and tree health will help to better understand this relationship. As such the data-set of this paper is a good starting point. "
-sample090,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample091,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample092,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample093,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample094,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Nests with large surface areas, like in this tree, can serve as breeding platforms for Verreaux Eagle Owl Ketupa lactea."
-sample095,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its flat shape and high location within the canopy this nest looks like a vulture nest (Torgos tracheliotos, or Gyps africanus, both of which are known to have nesting site at Kuzikus) rather than a sociable weaver nest. Candy Fahrenholz: Assessing vulture nesting site selection in Namibia: The influence of microscale landscape structures using drone-based methods. Survey of two endangered vulture species at Kuzikus Wildlife Reserve. M.Sc. Landschaftsökologie. Betreuung: Jan Lehmann, Sascha Buchholz 2024"
-sample096,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample097,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample098,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample099,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Due to its smaller size in comparison to all other captured images in the study, the nest shape of this tree could hint towards other bird species, such as the bird species Bubalornis niger (Red-billed Buffalo weaver) rather than Philetairus socius (Sociabe weaver). "
-sample100,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample101,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"Part of the nest in the tree seems to have fallen to the ground. It is known that sociable weavers are capable to recycle fallen nest material back into the active nest. It is alsoe known that wildlife, especially during drought, feed on the grass of fallen nests. "
-sample102,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,"This tree representation shows a likely abandoned nest that appears to have fallen to the ground. The thatch density of this nest does not seem to be significantly different to the thatch density of the nest that is shown in the canopy of the tree and that is likely ""active"". Hence, visually assessed thatch density seems to be a weak indicator for nest activity. "
-sample103,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample104,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,Multiple nests. Quantifying nest clusters in trees like in this tree can be particularly interesting for investigation of nest size development and population dynamics of sociable weavers and co-host animals accross different nests in the same tree. 

validation/expert_validation_R2.csv

@@ -1,124 +0,0 @@
-NEST3D EXPERT ANNOTATION VALIDATION: CLEMENT,,,,,,,,,,,,
-,,,,,,,,,,,,
-"INSTRUCTIONS: For each sample row below, click 'View image' to open the QC plot (top/side/front views in label colors and RGB), then select answers from the dropdown menus in columns Q1-Q9. Q10 is free text. Q9 and Q10 are optional.",,,,,,,,,,,,
-LABEL COLORS:  Green = Grass  |  Brown = Tree  |  Red = Nest,,,,,,,,,,,,
-,,,,,,,,,,,,
-QUESTION GUIDE — read before starting,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q1 — Nest Completeness: Does the labeled nest region capture the full extent of the visible nest structure?   OPTIONS: Yes - fully captured | Partial - some material missing | No - significant missing | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q2 — Nest Precision: Does the nest label include points that belong to the tree canopy rather than the nest? (false positives)   OPTIONS: None - label appears clean | Minor - small amounts of tree points | Significant - substantial mislabeling | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q3 — Tree/Nest Boundary: Is the boundary between nest and tree branch structure ecologically reasonable?   OPTIONS: Yes - ecologically reasonable | Acceptable - minor issues | No - does not reflect actual interface | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q4 — Grass / Ground Plane: Does the grass label correctly represent ground-level vegetation?   OPTIONS: Yes - well labeled | Acceptable - minor issues | No - significant issues | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-"Q5 — Overall Quality: Rate the overall annotation quality. 1=Very poor, 5=Excellent.   OPTIONS: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5",,,,,,,,,,,,
-"Q6 — Tree Species: Can you identify the tree species from canopy shape, branching, and morphology?   OPTIONS: Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn) | Boscia albitrunca (shepherd's tree) | Other (specify in Q10) | Uncertain",,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q6b — Species Confidence: How confident are you in your species identification?   OPTIONS: Confident | Somewhat confident | Uncertain,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q7 — Nest Activity: Estimate nest activity. Active=dense intact thatch. Abandoned=degraded/sparse.   OPTIONS: Active | Likely active | Likely abandoned | Abandoned | Cannot assess,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q8 — Occlusion Severity: How much of the nest is obscured by the tree canopy?   OPTIONS: Low - mostly visible | Medium - partially occluded | High - heavily occluded,,,,,,,,,,,,
-,,,,,,,,,,,,
-Q9 — Annotation Difficulty (optional): How difficult would it be for a human expert to annotate this sample?   OPTIONS: Easy | Moderate | Hard | Very hard,,,,,,,,,,,,
-"Q10 — Free Observations (optional): Any notable ecological or structural observations? e.g. unusual nest shape, multiple nests, damage, branch architecture. Free text.",,,,,,,,,,,,
-,,,,,,,,,,,,
-sample_id,image,Q1,Q2,Q3,Q4,Q5,Q6,Q6b,Q7,Q8,Q9,Q10
-sample001,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Low - mostly visible,Moderate,
-sample002,View image,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,High - heavily occluded,Very hard,Nest barely visible so difficult to assess
-sample003,View image,Partial - some material missing,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,3,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,High - heavily occluded,Hard,
-sample004,View image,Partial - some material missing,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,3,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample005,View image,Partial - some material missing,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample006,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample007,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample008,View image,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,No - significant issues,2,Boscia albitrunca (shepherd's tree),Uncertain,Likely abandoned,High - heavily occluded,Hard,
-sample009,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample010,View image,Partial - some material missing,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,3,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample011,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample012,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample013,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample014,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Acceptable - minor issues,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Somewhat confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample015,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Somewhat confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample016,View image,Partial - some material missing,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample017,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample018,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample019,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample020,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample021,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample022,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Moderate,
-sample023,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample024,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Low - mostly visible,Moderate,
-sample025,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample026,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample027,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Somewhat confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample028,View image,Partial - some material missing,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Acceptable - minor issues,3,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Low - mostly visible,Moderate,
-sample029,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample030,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Acceptable - minor issues,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample031,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample032,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,High - heavily occluded,Hard,
-sample033,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Moderate,
-sample034,View image,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,High - heavily occluded,Very hard,Nest barely visible
-sample035,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample036,View image,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,High - heavily occluded,Hard,
-sample037,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample038,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample039,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample040,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Somewhat confident,Active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample041,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample042,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Easy,
-sample043,View image,Partial - some material missing,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,3,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample044,View image,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample045,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample046,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Uncertain,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample047,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Uncertain,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample048,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,High - heavily occluded,Moderate,
-sample049,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample050,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Medium - partially occluded,Easy,
-sample051,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample052,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,High - heavily occluded,Hard,
-sample053,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample054,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Somewhat confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample055,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample056,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample057,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample058,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample059,View image,Partial - some material missing,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample060,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample061,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Uncertain,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample062,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample063,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample064,View image,Partial - some material missing,None - label appears clean,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Moderate,
-sample065,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample066,View image,Partial - some material missing,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Acceptable - minor issues,Yes - well labeled,3,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample067,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample068,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Acceptable - minor issues,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample069,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample070,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,High - heavily occluded,Hard,
-sample071,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample072,View image,Yes - fully captured,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,Low - mostly visible,Moderate,
-sample073,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample074,View image,Yes - fully captured,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample075,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Uncertain,Uncertain,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample076,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample077,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample078,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample079,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample080,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Acceptable - minor issues,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample081,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample082,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample083,View image,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Acceptable - minor issues,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample084,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample085,View image,Yes - fully captured,Cannot assess,Cannot assess,Acceptable - minor issues,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Abandoned,Medium - partially occluded,Hard,
-sample086,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample087,View image,Yes - fully captured,Minor - small amounts of tree points,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,4,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Moderate,
-sample088,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,No - significant issues,3,Uncertain,Uncertain,Abandoned,Low - mostly visible,Easy,
-sample089,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Low - mostly visible,Easy,"Dead tree: nest looks intact but would weavers stay in a leafless tree? Greater exposure to the sun, to predators..."
-sample090,View image,Yes - fully captured,None - label appears clean,Yes - ecologically reasonable,Yes - well labeled,5,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,Likely active,Medium - partially occluded,Moderate,
-sample091,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample092,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample093,View image,,,,,,Uncertain,Uncertain,,,,
-sample094,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample095,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample096,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample097,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample098,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample099,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample100,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample101,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample102,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample103,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,
-sample104,View image,,,,,,Vachellia erioloba (camel thorn),Confident,,,,