{ "n_queries": 300, "n_judged_pairs": 8371, "kappa": 0.6320636300053946, "confusion": { "1-1": 1367, "0-1": 735, "0-0": 5041, "2-2": 457, "1-2": 330, "1-0": 294, "0-2": 11, "2-1": 134, "2-0": 2 }, "official_grade2": [ 272, 300, [ 0.8684138011961098, 0.9346362090723985 ] ], "official_grade_ge1": [ 298, 300, [ 0.9760219257685385, 0.9981698899670288 ] ], "random_grade0": [ 600, 600, [ 0.9936380666717896, 1.0000000000000002 ] ], "queries_with_nonofficial_grade2": [ 174, 300, [ 0.5234821059002049, 0.6344949453001573 ] ], "nonofficial_grade2_per_query_mean": 1.3533333333333333, "nonofficial_grade1_per_query_mean": 7.6066666666666665, "pool_yield_grade2_by_source": { "bge-m3_text": 257, "bm25_text": 245, "me5-base_text": 231, "rerank_text": 262 }, "systems": [ "bm25_text", "bm25tuned_text", "me5-base_text", "me5-large_text", "bge-m3_text", "me5-base-ft_text", "rrf_text", "rerank_text" ], "mrr_official": { "bm25_text": 0.5931693121693121, "bm25tuned_text": 0.5994378306878307, "me5-base_text": 0.5423015873015874, "me5-large_text": 0.509063492063492, "bge-m3_text": 0.5583677248677249, "me5-base-ft_text": 0.41965211640211636, "rrf_text": 0.628117724867725, "rerank_text": 0.5303875661375662 }, "mrr_augmented": { "bm25_text": 0.71444708994709, "bm25tuned_text": 0.7217711640211641, "me5-base_text": 0.6694603174603174, "me5-large_text": 0.6092724867724867, "bge-m3_text": 0.6780674603174603, "me5-base-ft_text": 0.4997103174603174, "rrf_text": 0.7448082010582011, "rerank_text": 0.6647354497354497 }, "kendall_tau_b": 1.0, "kendall_tau_b_ci": [ 0.6428571428571429, 1.0 ], "pairwise_reversals": [], "families": [ "judge-claude", "judge-gpt" ], "held_out": [ "me5-large_text", "me5-base-ft_text", "rrf_text", "bm25tuned_text" ], "t": "2026-10-20T10:47:57+00:00", "judged_at_10": { "bm25_text": 0.9996666666666667, "bm25tuned_text": 0.9106666666666666, "me5-base_text": 0.973, "me5-large_text": 0.5666666666666667, "bge-m3_text": 0.9913333333333333, "me5-base-ft_text": 0.30633333333333335, "rrf_text": 0.8823333333333333, "rerank_text": 1.0 }, "weighted": { "queries_with_nonofficial_grade2": 0.4793760262725809, "queries_with_nonofficial_grade2_ci": [ 0.4053347929210027, 0.5531825092744661 ], "nonofficial_grade2_per_query_mean": 1.2217685337225626, "mrr_official": { "bm25_text": 0.5573996147345014, "bm25tuned_text": 0.5622977481612792, "me5-base_text": 0.5001263059786162, "me5-large_text": 0.4547558337653234, "bge-m3_text": 0.5464715853419584, "me5-base-ft_text": 0.3951252566586471, "rrf_text": 0.6138232335079653, "rerank_text": 0.5137735042363784 }, "mrr_augmented": { "bm25_text": 0.6732859797530506, "bm25tuned_text": 0.6911709870268553, "me5-base_text": 0.6218179299533096, "me5-large_text": 0.5390944416932401, "bge-m3_text": 0.6560206659079153, "me5-base-ft_text": 0.45190621811375575, "rrf_text": 0.7285021068452951, "rerank_text": 0.6349257840215718 }, "strata_population": { "hit0_cite0": 5813, "hit0_cite1": 250, "hit1_cite0": 4749, "hit1_cite1": 150 }, "strata_sampled": { "hit0_cite0": 75, "hit0_cite1": 75, "hit1_cite0": 75, "hit1_cite1": 75 } }, "kendall_tau_b_unweighted": 1.0, "bootstrap": "stratified (within-stratum resampling), population-weighted; n_boot=1000", "cited_by_official_reply_by_grade": { "0": { "cited": 1, "n": 5383, "rate": 0.0001857700167193015 }, "1": { "cited": 81, "n": 2282, "rate": 0.03549517966695881 }, "2": { "cited": 69, "n": 406, "rate": 0.16995073891625614 } }, "table_rows": [ [ "Sampled test queries / judged pairs", "300 / 8371" ], [ "Inter-judge Cohen's $\\kappa$ (3 grades)", "0.632" ], [ "Official answers graded 2 (95\\% CI)", "272/300 (87--93\\%)" ], [ "Random controls graded 0 (95\\% CI)", "600/600 (99--100\\%)" ], [ "Queries with $\\geq$1 non-official grade-2 answer in the pool, sample", "174/300 (52--63\\%)" ], [ "\\quad same, weighted to the test population (95\\% CI)", "48\\% (41--55\\%)" ], [ "Non-official grade-2 / grade-1 answers per query (sample)", "1.35 / 7.61" ], [ "Kendall's $\\tau_b$ of weighted orderings (95\\% CI)", "1.000 (0.643--1.000)" ], [ "Pairwise system reversals", "0 of 28" ], [ "Judged@10: pooled runs (min) / held-out run(s)", "0.97 / 0.91, 0.57, 0.31, 0.88" ], [ "Cited by the official reply: grade 2 / 1 / 0 (non-official)", "17\\% / 4\\% / 0\\%" ] ] }