model_key stringclasses 4
values | model_display_name stringclasses 4
values | row_idx int64 106 6.9k | image_id stringlengths 36 36 | rubric_writer stringclasses 1
value | rubric_scorer stringclasses 1
value | positive_criteria listlengths 6 8 | negative_criteria listlengths 5 7 | total_positive_weight_earned int64 15 60 | total_positive_weight_possible int64 37 64 | total_negative_weight_incurred int64 -23 0 | failure_count int64 0 5 | active_error_count int64 0 4 | severity_summary stringlengths 22 227 | net_score int64 2 60 | final_score float64 3.6 100 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 106 | 514829e2-729d-48dc-aa17-55f40d33e4bc | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows an open Bible with two visible facing pages.",
"weight": 7,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image clearly shows an open book with two facing pages visible."
},
{
"statement": "Most of the visible body text on the pages is rendered in... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry or anatomical artifacts in the book or human figures, such as fused pages, malformed hands, or distorted faces.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The figures and the book's geometry appear well-rendere... | 25 | 37 | -5 | 2 | 1 | The model failed to accurately depict the requested characters in the illustrations and included garbled English text headers. | 20 | 54.1 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 106 | 514829e2-729d-48dc-aa17-55f40d33e4bc | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The Bible is shown in a close-up view that fills most of the frame.",
"weight": 5,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The opened Bible dominates the image, taking up nearly the entire frame."
},
{
"statement": "The visible page text uses recognizably Hebre... | [
{
"statement": "The human figures in the page pictures exhibit anatomical distortions such as fused hands, extra fingers, missing features, or warped faces.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The hands of the king and the woman are fused and d... | 21 | 55 | -12 | 4 | 2 | The model failed to generate the second illustration entirely, merged the requested figures into a single incorrect scene, and produced garbled Latin-style text instead of Hebrew. | 9 | 16.4 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 106 | 514829e2-729d-48dc-aa17-55f40d33e4bc | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows an open book with two visible pages.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "An open book with two visible facing pages is centrally located in the image."
},
{
"statement": "The printed writing on the visible pages is rendered i... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or facial artifacts in the people shown in the inset images, such as fused hands, extra fingers, or distorted eyes.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The hands of the men on the left page are slig... | 31 | 46 | -16 | 2 | 3 | The model failed to generate the correct characters in the inset images (missing the queen and elderly woman) and produced garbled text. | 15 | 32.6 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 106 | 514829e2-729d-48dc-aa17-55f40d33e4bc | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image is a close-up or zoomed-in view of a Bible opened to two visible pages.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "An open book with two visible pages is prominently featured in a close-up perspective."
},
{
"statement": "The visible writ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts in the people shown in the page photographs, such as fused hands, missing body parts, or distorted facial features.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The people depicted in the photos appear anatomica... | 37 | 58 | -12 | 3 | 2 | The model failed to generate the correct number of people on the left page and included hallucinated objects like a candle and an extra book. | 25 | 43.1 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 302 | 872a9294-871a-439d-b1a0-6c27444238e3 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly three distinct building facades or building parts.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "There are three distinct building sections visible in the image."
},
{
"statement": "The leftmost building part is visibly shorter... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible architectural geometry, such as warped wall planes, non-rectangular door or window frames, or a balcony structure that cannot physically attach to the facade.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The architectural... | 46 | 52 | -9 | 1 | 3 | The leftmost building is taller instead of shorter, and the image includes unprompted fixtures with garbled text and inconsistent harsh shadows. | 37 | 71.2 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 302 | 872a9294-871a-439d-b1a0-6c27444238e3 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly three adjacent building sections.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "There are three distinct building facades shown side-by-side."
},
{
"statement": "The top of the left building section sits lower than the top of t... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible architectural geometry, such as bent rooflines, fused balcony rails, or distorted doors or windows.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The top balcony railing passes right through the mid... | 23 | 55 | -9 | 5 | 2 | The model failed multiple explicit prompt constraints regarding colors, counts, and heights, and introduced major geometric errors like a balcony railing intersecting a door. | 14 | 25.5 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 302 | 872a9294-871a-439d-b1a0-6c27444238e3 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly three distinct building sections or facades.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Three distinct building sections are clearly visible: one on the left, one in the middle, and one on the right."
},
{
"statement": "Exac... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or physically impossible architectural geometry, such as bent rooflines, malformed balcony railings, or distorted window frames.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The architectural geometry appears sound with strai... | 49 | 55 | 0 | 1 | 0 | The image is mostly accurate but misses a requested lantern on the rightmost building. | 49 | 89.1 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 302 | 872a9294-871a-439d-b1a0-6c27444238e3 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly three adjacent building sections.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Three distinct building sections are visible in the image."
},
{
"statement": "From left to right, the building-height pattern is short, tall, tall... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible architectural geometry in the buildings, balcony, window, or lanterns.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The architecture appears structurally sound and well-rendered."
},
{
"statement": "The ... | 54 | 54 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 54 | 100 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 453 | 5cdcbaa0-50db-403d-b6b9-0b4a39fa29a2 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly three snail shells appear as the primary subjects above the reflection line.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Three distinct snail shells are visible above the horizon line."
},
{
"statement": "Each of the three primary shells is ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed shell geometry, such as fused coils, impossible spiral topology, or broken non-manifold openings.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The shell on the right is composed of two overlapping or fused sp... | 55 | 55 | -6 | 0 | 1 | The generated image fulfills all positive criteria but exhibits a geometry artifact in the rightmost shell. | 49 | 89.1 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 453 | 5cdcbaa0-50db-403d-b6b9-0b4a39fa29a2 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly three primary snail shell forms before counting any reflections.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "There are three distinct shells visible floating above the reflection line."
},
{
"statement": "The three primary sh... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts such as fused tentacles, extra tentacles, missing tentacles, or impossible shell-body connections.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The central snail's body appears flatten... | 55 | 55 | -12 | 0 | 2 | The model successfully captured the requested composition and textures, but hallucinated full snail bodies instead of just the requested shells, introducing some anatomical artifacts in the process. | 43 | 78.2 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 453 | 5cdcbaa0-50db-403d-b6b9-0b4a39fa29a2 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly three snail shells that are not reflections.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "There are four distinct snail shells floating in mid-air, not three."
},
{
"statement": "All three non-reflected snail shells are... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible shell geometry, such as fused rims, broken spiral topology, or non-manifold openings.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The geometry of all visible shells appears natural and manifold without broken topology."
... | 20 | 50 | -6 | 4 | 1 | The image features four shells instead of the requested three and contains severe physics violations in the reflections. | 14 | 28 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 453 | 5cdcbaa0-50db-403d-b6b9-0b4a39fa29a2 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly three non-reflected snail shells.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "There are exactly three snail shells floating above the horizon line."
},
{
"statement": "Each of the three non-reflected shells is floating in mid... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible shell geometry, such as fused spirals, broken spiral continuity, or non-manifold edges.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The spiral structures of the shells appear coherent and unbroken."
},
{... | 54 | 54 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 54 | 100 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 467 | cc693a76-026e-427d-96df-85277a2c7b0e | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image includes an airplane marked \"AIR FRANCE\".",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "An old commercial-style airplane with 'AIR FRANCE' clearly painted on its side is visible in the background."
},
{
"statement": "The image includes a s... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible aircraft geometry such as fused wings, mismatched engine placement, malformed propellers, or unusable landing gear.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The warplane's propeller blades are malformed ... | 51 | 51 | -6 | 0 | 1 | The image meets all positive prompt requirements well but suffers from some structural geometry artifacts on the warplane's propeller and landing gear. | 45 | 88.2 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 467 | cc693a76-026e-427d-96df-85277a2c7b0e | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly one large passenger airplane bearing Air France livery or readable \"Air France\" branding is present.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING",
"explanation": "The large passenger plane has garbled text reading 'FRAN ACE I'FAME' instead of readable '... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed aircraft geometry, such as fused or impossibly shaped wings, engines, cockpit windows, or landing gear.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The passenger plane has distorted cockpit windows, nonsensi... | 36 | 52 | -17 | 2 | 3 | The image fails significantly on text rendering for both the main livery and the watermark, and contains structural geometry issues on the large aircraft. | 19 | 36.5 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 467 | cc693a76-026e-427d-96df-85277a2c7b0e | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image includes a passenger airplane bearing Air France livery.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A passenger airplane with 'AIR FRANCE' text and matching livery is clearly visible in the background."
},
{
"statement": "The image includ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible airplane geometry, such as fused or disconnected wings, engines, or landing-gear structures.",
"weight": -7,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The landing gear of the larger plane merges confusingly with the wing... | 31 | 45 | -17 | 3 | 3 | The image has significant structural issues with the aircraft, specifically the merging of landing gear and anomalous parts on the smaller plane, and fails to render the requested landscape orientation and weathered appearance. | 14 | 31.1 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 467 | cc693a76-026e-427d-96df-85277a2c7b0e | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image includes a passenger airplane bearing Air France livery or the text AIR FRANCE.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The text 'AIR FRANCE' is visible on the side of the larger passenger airplane."
},
{
"statement": "The image includ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed aircraft geometry such as fused parts, impossible wing or tail shapes, or inconsistent landing gear structures.",
"weight": -7,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The Air France plane has malformed front landing ge... | 51 | 51 | -11 | 0 | 2 | The image meets all positive criteria, but exhibits some malformed landing gear geometry and impossible intersection between the tree branches and the main airplane. | 40 | 78.4 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 905 | f4043b1c-bcec-47a8-a078-f914cea50741 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A dog appears on grass in the bottom-right area of the image.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A dog is sitting on the grass in the bottom right corner of the composition."
},
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly three houses.",
"w... | [
{
"statement": "The dog exhibits anatomical artifacts such as extra legs, fused paws, or malformed facial features.",
"weight": -7,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The dog appears anatomically correct with normal proportions and no visible artifacts."
},
{
"stat... | 49 | 49 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 49 | 100 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 905 | f4043b1c-bcec-47a8-a078-f914cea50741 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly one Dutch Smoushond-type dog: a small rough-coated tan dog with a shaggy muzzle.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A rough-coated, tan dog matching the general description of a Dutch Smoushond is visible."
},
{
"sta... | [
{
"statement": "The dog exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts such as extra legs, fused paws, malformed ears, or distorted facial features.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The dog is well-rendered with no obvious anatomical issues."
},
{
"st... | 49 | 55 | -2 | 1 | 1 | The dog is standing on the road instead of the grass, and there is minor text garbling on a gate plaque. | 47 | 85.5 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 905 | f4043b1c-bcec-47a8-a078-f914cea50741 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly one Dutch Smoushond dog is visible.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "One dog resembling a Smoushond is in the lower right."
},
{
"statement": "The dog is positioned in the bottom-right area of the frame.",
"weight": 8,
"me... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical distortions on the dog, such as extra limbs, fused paws, or malformed facial features.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The dog's anatomy appears normal with no visible distortions."
},
{
"statement": ... | 54 | 54 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 54 | 100 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 905 | f4043b1c-bcec-47a8-a078-f914cea50741 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly one dog.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Only one dog is visible in the frame."
},
{
"statement": "The dog is located in the bottom-right quadrant of the image on grass.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"fa... | [
{
"statement": "The dog exhibits anatomical artifacts such as extra or missing legs, fused paws, or distorted facial features.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The dog's anatomy appears normal with no visible artifacts."
},
{
"statement": "The ima... | 49 | 58 | 0 | 1 | 0 | The model rendered four houses instead of the requested three, but otherwise followed the prompt well. | 49 | 84.5 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 1,310 | 93bd4899-3196-4fa1-bf03-465574692f99 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "On the right side of the shelf, there are exactly three large blue hardback books.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Three large blue hardback books are clearly visible on the right."
},
{
"statement": "Each of the three large blue books h... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry in the books or shelf, such as fused volumes, severely warped hardback shapes, or broken shelf edges.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The books and shelf appear geometrically sound with no fused or w... | 52 | 52 | -11 | 0 | 2 | The image successfully meets all prompt requirements, but features significant text garbling and a hallucinated shelf tag. | 41 | 78.8 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 1,310 | 93bd4899-3196-4fa1-bf03-465574692f99 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly three large blue hardback books are visible on the right side of the shelf.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Three large blue books are clearly visible on the right side of the shelf."
},
{
"statement": "Each of the three large bl... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible book or shelf geometry, such as fused neighboring books, broken shelf edges, or severely warped rectangular spines.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The books and shelf appear geometrically sound."
},
{
... | 40 | 49 | -8 | 1 | 1 | The text on the book spines is heavily garbled, and the volume numbers are incorrect (9, 11, 11 instead of 9, 10, 11). | 32 | 65.3 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 1,310 | 93bd4899-3196-4fa1-bf03-465574692f99 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly three large blue books are grouped on the right side of the shelf.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Three distinct large blue books are positioned together on the right side of the shelf."
},
{
"statement": "Each of the three larg... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped, fused, or impossible geometry in the books or shelf.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The books and shelf maintain structurally sound and separate geometry."
},
{
"statement": "The image exhibits hallucin... | 43 | 53 | -8 | 1 | 1 | The image correctly renders the overall composition and aesthetic, but fails on text generation, showing '7' instead of '10' and widespread garbled text. | 35 | 66 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 1,310 | 93bd4899-3196-4fa1-bf03-465574692f99 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "On the right side of the shelf, exactly three large books are visible standing side by side.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Three large books are standing together on the far right of the shelf."
},
{
"statement": "The three large books... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or fused shelf or book geometry, such as bent rectangular spines, merged books, or impossible shelf edges.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The books and shelves maintain correct rectangular geometry without struc... | 56 | 56 | -10 | 0 | 2 | The image successfully captures the main prompt details, but suffers from some garbled text on smaller book spines and a duplicated book title. | 46 | 82.1 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 1,354 | c610b2a9-3122-4636-89de-b7769f755294 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly four beer glass bottles.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "There are only three bottles visible in the image, not four."
},
{
"statement": "Exactly two of the four bottles are the Lupia variant, identifiable ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible bottle or holder geometry, such as fused bottles, warped bottle necks, or holder bars that could not physically support the bottles.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The bottles and holder wire structure appea... | 34 | 53 | 0 | 2 | 0 | The model failed to generate the correct number of bottles, rendering three instead of four. | 34 | 64.2 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 1,354 | c610b2a9-3122-4636-89de-b7769f755294 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly four glass beer bottles.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Four distinct glass beer bottles are visible in the image."
},
{
"statement": "Exactly two of the four bottles have \"Lupia\" as the main label word.",
... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed bottle or holder geometry, such as fused bottle bodies, warped necks, or impossible carrier loops.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The bottles and holder have normal, intact geometry."
},
{
"statement"... | 34 | 52 | -3 | 3 | 1 | The main issue is significant text garbling on the Estrella bottles, along with an incorrect square aspect ratio. | 31 | 59.6 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 1,354 | c610b2a9-3122-4636-89de-b7769f755294 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly four beer bottles made of glass.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Four distinct glass beer bottles are visible in the image."
},
{
"statement": "All visible beer bottles are placed in a single visible holder/carrie... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry in the bottles or holder, such as fused bottle silhouettes, warped necks, or malformed caps.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The bottles and holder appear structurally sound without warped geometry."... | 52 | 52 | -10 | 0 | 2 | The main requested elements are present, but the image features garbled secondary text on the labels and an unsupported, floating bottle holder. | 42 | 80.8 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 1,354 | c610b2a9-3122-4636-89de-b7769f755294 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly four bottles are present, with this brand distribution: 2 labeled \"LUPIA\", 1 labeled \"Estrella Galicia Especial\", and 1 labeled as Estrella Galicia gluten-free, such as \"SIN GLUTEN\".",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "Five bott... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed bottle or holder geometry, such as fused bottle necks, impossible handle connections, or broken glass contours.",
"weight": -7,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The bottles and wooden holder appear geometrically sound."
},
... | 31 | 41 | -6 | 1 | 1 | The model generated five bottles instead of the requested four, and some smaller text on the labels is garbled. | 25 | 61 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 1,459 | df92c7fb-f706-4a09-b137-15c757f899f9 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly one brown ceramic vase.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A single brown ceramic vase is clearly visible at the center of the composition."
},
{
"statement": "The vase sits on a rough wooden shelf or wooden surface.... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits fused or impossible plant anatomy, such as petals, leaves, or stems merging unnaturally with each other or with the vase.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The stems, petals, and leaves are rendered cleanly without obviou... | 50 | 54 | -3 | 1 | 1 | The image miscounts the requested illuminated squares, providing three instead of two, and clones the design inside them. | 47 | 87 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 1,459 | df92c7fb-f706-4a09-b137-15c757f899f9 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A brown ceramic vase sits on a rough wooden shelf or surface.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A brown ceramic vase is clearly visible resting on a rough, textured wooden shelf."
},
{
"statement": "The bouquet contains sunflowers.",
"... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits fused petals, merged stems, or other impossible plant or vase geometry.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The plants, vase, and fruit appear structurally sound without bizarre mergers."
},
{
"statement": "The imag... | 42 | 55 | -6 | 2 | 1 | The image misses some text requirements, notably misrendering the name and omitting the date, and places the vase's stripes incorrectly. | 36 | 65.5 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 1,459 | df92c7fb-f706-4a09-b137-15c757f899f9 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows a brown ceramic vase resting on a wooden shelf or rough wooden surface.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A brown vase sits on a rough wooden shelf."
},
{
"statement": "The vase contains a bouquet with at least two visible ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or visibly warped geometry in solid objects such as the vase, fruit, shelf, or illuminated squares.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The objects have normal, stable geometry."
},
{
"statement": "The im... | 44 | 54 | -5 | 2 | 1 | The model missed the required date text and hallucinated an extra bottle-like object in the background. | 39 | 72.2 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 1,459 | df92c7fb-f706-4a09-b137-15c757f899f9 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly one brown ceramic vase.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A single brown ceramic vase is depicted on the right side of the image."
},
{
"statement": "The vase is placed on a wooden shelf or other visibly rough woode... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the vase, flower heads, stems, fruit, or illuminated squares.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The geometry of the objects appears coherent without obvious fusions or impossible structures... | 50 | 50 | -11 | 0 | 2 | The model accurately rendered the requested visual elements, but hallucinated a large block of misspelled descriptive text on the left side. | 39 | 78 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 1,465 | 393d4a54-1eda-4d75-8e08-f4b4402889ce | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "At least 10 wine corks are visible in the image.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "There are over 30 individual wine corks clearly visible in the image."
},
{
"statement": "The viewpoint is top-down, showing the corks from above in a close... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible cork geometry, such as fused corks or severely warped cork bodies.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "All corks maintain proper cylindrical or circular cross-section geometry without fusing."
},
{
"state... | 41 | 41 | -8 | 0 | 1 | The generated image perfectly captures all requested text and visual constraints, with only minor text garbling on background corks. | 33 | 80.5 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 1,465 | 393d4a54-1eda-4d75-8e08-f4b4402889ce | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image contains at least six visible wine corks.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "There are well over six distinct wine corks visible in the frame."
},
{
"statement": "Wine corks occupy more than half of the visible image area.",
"... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible cork geometry, such as fused corks or severely warped cylindrical shapes.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The cylindrical shapes of the corks appear structurally sound and distinct from one another."
},
{... | 43 | 52 | -8 | 1 | 1 | The image suffers from significant text garbling, failing to render the requested central phrase accurately and producing nonsensical words on surrounding corks. | 35 | 67.3 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 1,465 | 393d4a54-1eda-4d75-8e08-f4b4402889ce | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows at least 10 wine corks packed together in a single pile.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image clearly depicts a large pile containing well over 10 wine corks packed closely together."
},
{
"statement": "The camera vi... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits fused corks, broken cylindrical forms, or other impossible cork geometry.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The corks are distinct and appear as individual cylindrical objects without fusion."
},
{
"statement": "T... | 44 | 51 | -8 | 1 | 1 | The main quote is perfectly rendered, but many surrounding corks contain garbled or misspelled text, failing to accurately capture the specific requested brand names. | 36 | 70.6 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 1,465 | 393d4a54-1eda-4d75-8e08-f4b4402889ce | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows a pile of at least 10 wine corks.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "There are dozens of wine corks visible in the image."
},
{
"statement": "The camera viewpoint is top-down or overhead.",
"weight": 7,
"met": true,
... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed corks with fused bodies, impossible holes, or non-cylindrical geometry inconsistent with real wine corks.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The corks all appear to be well-formed cylinders with realistic shapes ... | 42 | 48 | -7 | 1 | 1 | The image is generally high quality but misses one of the specifically requested text strings and contains some minor text garbling. | 35 | 72.9 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 1,976 | 2823e601-3246-40a7-843b-cb3b0666ab18 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A military aircraft is the primary subject of the image.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A large gray military cargo aircraft dominates the center of the image."
},
{
"statement": "The aircraft is on a runway or airport tarmac with its l... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible aircraft geometry, such as detached wings, fused landing gear, or distorted engine nacelles.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The aircraft's structure appears structurally sound and well-rendered."
},
{
... | 60 | 60 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 60 | 100 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 1,976 | 2823e601-3246-40a7-843b-cb3b0666ab18 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A gray military aircraft is parked on a runway.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A large gray military-style aircraft is parked on the tarmac/runway in the foreground."
},
{
"statement": "The full aircraft, including nose, tail, wings, an... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or fused aircraft parts, such as impossible landing gear, engine, wing, or tail geometry.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The right wing appears detached or misaligned, and the landing gear setup... | 34 | 50 | -12 | 2 | 2 | The aircraft is partially cropped, features severe text garbling, and has geometric artifacts like misaligned engines. | 22 | 44 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 1,976 | 2823e601-3246-40a7-843b-cb3b0666ab18 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows a military aircraft.",
"weight": 7,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A gray military aircraft is prominently displayed in the center."
},
{
"statement": "The aircraft rests on its landing gear on a runway.",
"weight": 6,
"met": tr... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as malformed wings, fused landing gear, or impossible engine or tail attachments on the aircraft.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The aircraft has unusual geometric attachments and... | 38 | 38 | -5 | 0 | 1 | The image fulfills all positive prompt requirements but includes minor geometric artifacts on the aircraft's undercarriage. | 33 | 86.8 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 1,976 | 2823e601-3246-40a7-843b-cb3b0666ab18 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows a military aircraft on a runway.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A large grey military aircraft is prominently shown parked on a paved runway."
},
{
"statement": "The aircraft displays the identifier \"ZZ177\".",
"wei... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible aircraft geometry, such as malformed wings, fused engine parts, distorted landing gear, or an incoherent tail structure.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The aircraft's overall structure, including wings, tail... | 54 | 54 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 54 | 100 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 1,981 | e6934104-9944-4f9d-8f07-3e74d64679eb | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly 10 geese appear in the main foreground or midground action group.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "There are 7 geese in the main foreground action group taking off."
},
{
"statement": "Exactly 3 geese appear in the distant ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on the geese, such as fused wings, extra legs, or malformed beaks.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "Several foreground geese show wing melds, confused limb placements, and ... | 31 | 49 | -8 | 2 | 1 | The model failed the requested counts, generating 7 foreground and 2 background geese instead of 10 and 3, and introduced anatomical artifacts among the tightly grouped birds. | 23 | 46.9 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 1,981 | e6934104-9944-4f9d-8f07-3e74d64679eb | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly 10 geese in the main foreground or midground group.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "There are 8 geese visible taking off in the main group."
},
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly 3 smaller geese in the... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts on one or more geese, such as extra legs, fused wings, malformed beaks, or impossible body geometry.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "Several wings overlap in physically impossible ways... | 27 | 45 | -8 | 2 | 1 | The image fails to produce the correct number of geese in both the foreground and background, and suffers from anatomical artifacts in the wings. | 19 | 42.2 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 1,981 | e6934104-9944-4f9d-8f07-3e74d64679eb | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly 10 discernible full-sized geese as the main subjects.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "There are only 7 visible full-sized geese in the foreground, not 10."
},
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly 3 disce... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric defects in any goose, such as missing, fused, or impossibly shaped wings, legs, necks, or beaks.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "Some of the geese in the cluster appear to have merg... | 37 | 47 | -12 | 1 | 2 | The image contains an incorrect number of geese and exhibits some anatomical confusion where their bodies overlap. | 25 | 53.2 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 1,981 | e6934104-9944-4f9d-8f07-3e74d64679eb | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly 10 mature geese.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "There are 7 distinct mature geese visible taking off."
},
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly 3 small geese.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"fai... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed goose anatomy, such as extra or missing wings, legs, feet, heads, necks, or beaks.",
"weight": -9,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "Several mature geese have merged or malformed wings and bodies, particularly in ... | 42 | 52 | -12 | 1 | 2 | The image has the wrong number of mature geese and exhibits anatomical merging within the dense flock. | 30 | 57.7 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 2,189 | 69fc9b8b-c85d-42da-a8f9-7958d97aed2f | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The main roadside sign reads WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The sign on the right clearly reads 'WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA'."
},
{
"statement": "The main welcome sign is positioned ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible geometry in the sign faces or their support posts.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The signs and their posts appear structurally sound and geometrically consistent."
},
{
"statement": "The i... | 46 | 52 | -6 | 1 | 1 | The image contains an incorrect number of background signs and the text on those smaller signs is garbled. | 40 | 76.9 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 2,189 | 69fc9b8b-c85d-42da-a8f9-7958d97aed2f | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The largest roadside sign includes the text \"Welcome to the United States of America\".",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING",
"explanation": "The sign reads 'Welcome to the States United States of America'."
},
{
"statement": "A snow-covered road... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible geometry in the roadside signs, their borders, or their support posts.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The middle sign has a wavy, non-rectangular shape."
},
{
"statement": "Th... | 26 | 48 | -17 | 3 | 3 | The main text has a grammatical error, the black and white constraint was ignored, and there are extra signs and garbled text. | 9 | 18.8 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 2,189 | 69fc9b8b-c85d-42da-a8f9-7958d97aed2f | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image includes a main roadside sign that says WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A prominent blue sign on the right clearly reads 'WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA'."
},
{
"statement": "Th... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in one or more roadside signs, signposts, or road edges.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The signs and posts are structurally sound and appropriately placed."
},
{
"statement": "... | 42 | 46 | -13 | 1 | 2 | The image failed the monochrome constraint by rendering the main sign in bright blue, and features severely garbled text on the background signs. | 29 | 63 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 2,189 | 69fc9b8b-c85d-42da-a8f9-7958d97aed2f | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A main roadside sign displays the phrase \"WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA\".",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The large sign on the right clearly reads 'WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA'."
},
{
"statement": "The main welco... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in the signs, flagpole, road, or horizon line.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The structural elements appear solid and geometrically sound."
},
{
"statement": "The image exhibit... | 46 | 46 | -7 | 0 | 1 | The main sign and scene constraints are well-executed, but the text on the secondary signs to the left is garbled and nonsensical. | 39 | 84.8 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 2,474 | 767a9fee-c04a-4c60-86d4-21e606bc8e9c | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows a wooden direction sign in the foreground.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A wooden direction sign is clearly visible in the foreground."
},
{
"statement": "The direction sign includes arrows labeled \"Reception,\" \"Hube... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or malformed geometry in the vehicle body, the tent, or the wooden sign structure.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The geometry of the vehicle, tent, and sign appears normal."
},
{
"statement": "The i... | 50 | 50 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 50 | 100 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 2,474 | 767a9fee-c04a-4c60-86d4-21e606bc8e9c | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The full wooden direction sign, including its post, is visible in the foreground.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "INCOMPLETE_TRAJECTORY",
"explanation": "The signpost is cut off at the bottom and the top, so the full sign is not visible."
},
{
"statement": ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible geometry in the safari vehicle, the roof tent, or the wooden sign.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The vehicle, tent, and sign show realistic and consistent geometry."
},
{
"statement": "The... | 37 | 47 | -4 | 1 | 1 | The signpost is slightly cropped at the top and bottom, and there is garbled text on the vehicle's license plate. | 33 | 70.2 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 2,474 | 767a9fee-c04a-4c60-86d4-21e606bc8e9c | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A wooden multi-arrow direction signpost occupies the foreground of the image.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A multi-arrow signpost is prominently placed in the foreground."
},
{
"statement": "The signpost shows destination labels for \"... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts in the safari vehicle or signpost, such as fused supports, impossible arrow shapes, or malformed wheels.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The vehicle and signpost geometry appear structurally sound."
... | 41 | 49 | -11 | 2 | 2 | The main issues are an incorrect vehicle color, cropped signpost, and a duplicated 'River Lodge' sign arrow. | 30 | 61.2 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 2,474 | 767a9fee-c04a-4c60-86d4-21e606bc8e9c | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A wooden direction sign appears in the foreground.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A wooden direction sign is prominently placed in the foreground."
},
{
"statement": "The sign arrows are labeled Reception, Huberta, Indlovu, River Lodge,... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or warped geometry in the vehicle, tent, or direction sign, such as fused parts or nonfunctional shapes.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The objects appear structurally sound and correctly formed."
},
{
... | 49 | 55 | 0 | 1 | 0 | The base of the sign is slightly cropped, but the image is otherwise accurate. | 49 | 89.1 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 2,985 | d6737c9d-2c42-4b4c-9a68-87f41dbaad46 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image contains a brown road sign in the foreground.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A large brown sign is prominently positioned in the center foreground."
},
{
"statement": "The road sign is mounted on a metal pole.",
"weight": 6... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits visibly warped geometry in the signboard, pole, stone wall, or buildings.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The geometry of the main structures appears sound."
},
{
"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous peop... | 32 | 47 | -8 | 2 | 1 | The image suffers from significant text garbling, rendering the main sign text and logos incorrectly, and missing the requested Greek text line entirely. | 24 | 51.1 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 2,985 | d6737c9d-2c42-4b4c-9a68-87f41dbaad46 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows a brown directional road sign.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A brown directional road sign is prominently displayed in the center of the image."
},
{
"statement": "The sign is mounted on metal poles.",
"weight": 6,
... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits visibly warped or impossible geometry in the road sign, support poles, stone wall, or church structure.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The structural elements, including the sign, poles, wall, and building, have consis... | 34 | 52 | -16 | 2 | 3 | The image suffers from severe text garbling and misses the requested Greek script entirely. | 18 | 34.6 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 2,985 | d6737c9d-2c42-4b4c-9a68-87f41dbaad46 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The road sign background is brown.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The road sign in the image clearly has a brown background."
},
{
"statement": "The sign contains the exact English words \"Temple of Epikourios Apollonas\".",
"weight"... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible geometry in the road sign, its border, or its supporting pole.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The sign, its border, and the pole appear structurally sound without warped geometry."
},
{
"st... | 35 | 52 | -16 | 2 | 3 | The image suffers from significant text generation issues, including missing Greek script, duplicated English text, and garbled text under the duplicated UNESCO logos. | 19 | 36.5 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 2,985 | d6737c9d-2c42-4b4c-9a68-87f41dbaad46 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image contains a brown directional road sign.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A large brown directional road sign is prominently featured in the center of the image."
},
{
"statement": "The sign includes the English place name \"Temp... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry in the sign, pole, stone wall, or buildings, such as fused parts, warped edges, or broken topology.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The architectural and structural elements appear coherent without g... | 51 | 51 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 51 | 100 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 3,259 | 78c79c46-dcc3-434a-ab46-438355280ee5 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image is rendered in a photographic style rather than as an illustration or painting.",
"weight": 7,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image has realistic textures, depth of field, and lighting consistent with a photograph."
},
{
"statement": "The... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in the sign, signpost, or bridge, such as warped edges or structurally inconsistent connections.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The sign, post, and bridge appear structurally sound with... | 52 | 52 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 52 | 100 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 3,259 | 78c79c46-dcc3-434a-ab46-438355280ee5 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image uses only grayscale black-and-white tones, with no visible non-neutral colors.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image is entirely in black and white."
},
{
"statement": "The image is rendered in a photographic style rather th... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the sign hardware or bridge structure, such as merged bolts, non-manifold railings, or impossible support connections.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The sign hardware and bridge structu... | 56 | 56 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 56 | 100 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 3,259 | 78c79c46-dcc3-434a-ab46-438355280ee5 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image is rendered as a realistic photograph rather than as a drawing, painting, or graphic design.",
"weight": 4,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image features photographic textures, lighting, and depth of field, looking like a real photo."
},
{
... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in the sign border, signpost, or bridge structure.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The geometry of the sign, post, and bridge appear structurally sound and normal."
},
{
"stateme... | 52 | 52 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 52 | 100 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 3,259 | 78c79c46-dcc3-434a-ab46-438355280ee5 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image contains an octagonal street sign.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "An octagonal street sign is prominently featured on the right side of the image."
},
{
"statement": "The street sign text reads DON'T STOP LOVING.",
"weight"... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits visibly warped or impossible geometry in the sign outline, sign pole, or bridge structure.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The geometry of the sign and bridge appears standard and not warped."
},
{
"statement": ... | 52 | 52 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 52 | 100 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 3,407 | 29a5feda-9fb7-4e88-b233-ab9048bb8514 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene shows the ceiling of a church interior.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image clearly depicts an ornate church ceiling with arches, frescoes, and decorative molding."
},
{
"statement": "The viewpoint is from below, looking ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts in the angelic children, such as extra, missing, or fused limbs, hands, fingers, wings, or facial features.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The angel in the lower left has mangled, fus... | 57 | 57 | -8 | 0 | 1 | The image successfully captures all requested elements, but suffers from minor anatomical artifacts in one of the angel's hands. | 49 | 86 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 3,407 | 29a5feda-9fb7-4e88-b233-ab9048bb8514 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene depicts a church ceiling interior.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image clearly shows the ornate, vaulted ceiling of a building consistent with a church."
},
{
"statement": "The viewpoint looks directly upward from below at... | [
{
"statement": "The angelic children exhibit anatomical artifacts such as fused limbs, distorted hands, or malformed wings.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The hands of the angels holding the shield are somewhat melted/fused with the decora... | 57 | 57 | -11 | 0 | 2 | The model successfully generated all requested elements, but suffers from garbled text and minor anatomical artifacts on the cherubs' hands. | 46 | 80.7 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 3,407 | 29a5feda-9fb7-4e88-b233-ab9048bb8514 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image depicts an interior church ceiling viewed from directly below.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image shows a low-angle shot looking directly up at a vaulted church ceiling."
},
{
"statement": "A large white shield-shaped emb... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or fused angel anatomy, such as extra limbs, extra faces, missing body parts, or impossible wing attachments.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The sculpted angels around the shield are heavily fus... | 47 | 55 | -18 | 1 | 4 | The model hallucinated a literal hot air balloon on the ceiling and generated severely fused anatomy in the sculpted angels. | 29 | 52.7 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 3,407 | 29a5feda-9fb7-4e88-b233-ab9048bb8514 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene is framed as an upward-looking view of a decorated church ceiling.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image clearly shows an upward view of a highly decorated church ceiling."
},
{
"statement": "A large white shield is position... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed anatomy in human or angelic figures, such as extra limbs, fused hands, distorted faces, or impossible wing attachments.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "Several cherubs on the sides have fused lim... | 59 | 59 | -8 | 0 | 1 | The generated image successfully incorporates all elements from the prompt, but exhibits anatomical distortions in the cherub clusters. | 51 | 86.4 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 3,699 | 10d31ddb-ace5-4e07-9988-7a0cd599db40 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows a pizza placed inside an open carton pizza box with a white paper liner visible beneath it.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A pizza is shown inside a cardboard box resting on white paper."
},
{
"statement": "The camera vi... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the pizza, slice cuts, box, or paper liner.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The geometry of the pizza, slices, box, and paper appears normal and well-defined."
},
{
"statement": "... | 52 | 52 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 52 | 100 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 3,699 | 10d31ddb-ace5-4e07-9988-7a0cd599db40 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows a pizza placed inside an open carton pizza box with a white paper liner visible underneath it.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A pizza is shown inside a cardboard box resting on a white, slightly textured paper liner."
},
{
... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as fused pizza slices, impossible crust topology, or broken box structure.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The slices are neatly separated and the box structure looks normal."
},
{
"stat... | 59 | 59 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 59 | 100 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 3,699 | 10d31ddb-ace5-4e07-9988-7a0cd599db40 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows a pizza placed inside an open carton box.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A pizza is clearly placed inside a cardboard pizza box."
},
{
"statement": "A white paper liner is visible beneath the pizza inside the box.",
... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry or topology in the pizza, slices, box, or toppings, such as fused slices, intersecting objects, or malformed mushroom pieces.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "A long green bell pepper st... | 46 | 54 | -6 | 1 | 1 | The requested timestamp is entirely missing, and there is a minor geometry artifact with a pepper strip connecting two separate slices. | 40 | 74.1 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 3,699 | 10d31ddb-ace5-4e07-9988-7a0cd599db40 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The pizza is placed in an open carton box with a visible white paper liner at the bottom.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image shows a pizza inside an open cardboard box resting on a piece of white paper."
},
{
"statement": "The pizz... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or severely distorted geometry in the pizza, slice cuts, carton box, or paper liner.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The geometry of the box, pizza, and slice cuts appears normal and intact."
},
{
"st... | 55 | 55 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 55 | 100 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 3,714 | a4c04045-b312-46dd-af24-338b1aed7f4e | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The upper sign displays the large white numerals \"50.506\".",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The top sign clearly shows the numbers 50.506 in white."
},
{
"statement": "The lower sign displays the white text \"luteala maxima\" at the top... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible sign geometry, such as warped rigid panels, fused borders, or malformed rectangular sign shapes.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The sign panels have regular, rigid rectangular shapes."
},
{
"statemen... | 52 | 52 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 52 | 100 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 3,714 | a4c04045-b312-46dd-af24-338b1aed7f4e | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The topmost sign displays the number string \"50.506\" in large white characters.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The top sign clearly shows '50.506' in large white text on a red background."
},
{
"statement": "The sign displaying \"60\"... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or fused sign panels, borders, or mounting hardware that create impossible rigid-sign geometry.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The sign displaying 'DEP' on the right appears to fuse strangely with ... | 53 | 53 | -14 | 0 | 3 | The image accurately renders all requested text and signs, but introduces extra, unrequested signs on the left and right edges that clutter the composition and fuse awkwardly. | 39 | 73.6 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 3,714 | a4c04045-b312-46dd-af24-338b1aed7f4e | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The upper sign shows the numerals \"50.506\" in large white type on a red background.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The numerals '50.506' are clearly visible in large white type on a red background on the upper sign."
},
{
"statement":... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible sign geometry, such as bent planes, fused corners, or malformed borders.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The geometry of the signs, including their planes and borders, appears structurally sound."
... | 43 | 48 | 0 | 1 | 0 | The main issue is the incorrect color of the 'D' on the third sign, which should be white. | 43 | 89.6 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 3,714 | a4c04045-b312-46dd-af24-338b1aed7f4e | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The uppermost sign displays the large white number \"50.506\".",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The top sign clearly displays the number '50.506' in white on a red background."
},
{
"statement": "The top line of the lower sign reads \"lut... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused sign geometry, such as warped rectangular panels or merged border lines.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The signs have clear, distinct rectangular geometry with no warping or merging."
},
{
... | 51 | 51 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 51 | 100 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 4,076 | 0ef0ded0-1aff-4976-b1a7-76cb62e9dfbc | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image is divided into exactly three separate panels or frames.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image clearly contains three distinct vertical panels separated by white space."
},
{
"statement": "The three panels are arranged as a ... | [
{
"statement": "The hornbill exhibits anatomical distortions such as extra or missing toes, fused claws, malformed beak structure, or impossible wing or leg attachment.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The left panel shows a malformed left f... | 46 | 51 | -8 | 1 | 1 | The main issues are that the flying birds have their wings pointing up instead of downward, and there are some minor anatomical artifacts in the feet. | 38 | 74.5 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 4,076 | 0ef0ded0-1aff-4976-b1a7-76cb62e9dfbc | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The composition contains exactly three distinct image frames or panels.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISSING_STEP",
"explanation": "The image is split vertically into two distinct backgrounds, but it does not have three separate, bordered frames."
},
{
"... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on the bird or birds, such as extra claws or toes, fused digits, malformed beaks, or impossible wing attachment.",
"weight": -7,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The talons on the flying b... | 25 | 60 | -7 | 4 | 1 | The image fails to create three distinct frames, placing all birds into a single composition split vertically, and the flying birds have their wings curved upward instead of downward. | 18 | 30 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 4,076 | 0ef0ded0-1aff-4976-b1a7-76cb62e9dfbc | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image is divided into exactly three side-by-side panels separated by vertical boundaries.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image is divided into three distinct side-by-side vertical panels."
},
{
"statement": "Exactly two panels s... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on a hornbill, such as extra or missing toes, fused claws, distorted beaks, or impossible wing shapes.",
"weight": -7,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The hornbills are rendered cleanly without anatomi... | 45 | 51 | 0 | 1 | 0 | The main issue is that the flying hornbills have their wings pointed upwards instead of curved downwards as requested. | 45 | 88.2 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 4,076 | 0ef0ded0-1aff-4976-b1a7-76cb62e9dfbc | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly three separate photo frames or panels are visible.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image shows three distinct photo panels within a larger wooden frame."
},
{
"statement": "Exactly two of the frames show a hornbill bird in mi... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits hornbill anatomy or geometry errors such as extra wings, fused feathers, a malformed beak, or impossible leg attachment.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The hornbills are rendered with coherent anatomy and no obvious ge... | 52 | 52 | -5 | 0 | 1 | The model successfully generated all requested content but added an unrequested wooden frame and wall background. | 47 | 90.4 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 4,253 | be8b0858-4532-461e-ac0f-4415e0c904ca | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene is shown from a top-down / overhead viewpoint.",
"weight": 7,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image is clearly shot from directly above, looking down at the fabric, peppers, and paper."
},
{
"statement": "A blue fabric occupies most of the... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed chili peppers or stems, such as fused forms, broken parts, or impossible geometry.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The peppers and stems appear anatomically correct and distinct without geometric artifacts."
... | 52 | 52 | -7 | 0 | 1 | The image successfully meets all positive criteria, but the text on the printed sheet is garbled and illegible. | 45 | 86.5 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 4,253 | be8b0858-4532-461e-ac0f-4415e0c904ca | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene is shown from a top-down or overhead viewpoint.",
"weight": 6,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The camera angle is directly above looking down on the fabric and sheet."
},
{
"statement": "A textured light navy blue fabric is visible beneath th... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed chili peppers with fused stems, broken contours, or impossible pepper geometry.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The chili peppers appear to have normal, natural geometry."
},
{
"statement": "The image ... | 52 | 52 | -6 | 0 | 1 | The generated image perfectly matches the layout and subjects of the prompt, but the text on the reference sheet is heavily garbled. | 46 | 88.5 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 4,253 | be8b0858-4532-461e-ac0f-4415e0c904ca | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image is presented as a top-down overhead view.",
"weight": 7,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The camera angle is directly above the scene."
},
{
"statement": "A textured blue fabric occupies most of the frame as the background.",
"weight": 9,
... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits fused chili peppers, disconnected stems, or other impossible pepper geometry.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The chili peppers appear anatomically correct with proper stems and no fusion."
},
{
"statement": "Th... | 55 | 55 | -6 | 0 | 1 | The generated image successfully includes all requested elements, but suffers from garbled, illegible text on the reference sheet. | 49 | 89.1 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 4,253 | be8b0858-4532-461e-ac0f-4415e0c904ca | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image is shown from a top-down perspective.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The composition is framed looking straight down at the surface."
},
{
"statement": "A textured light navy blue fabric is visible beneath the chili peppers.",
... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits distorted or fused geometry in the chili peppers, printed sheet, or fabric.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The peppers, sheet, and fabric maintain coherent structures without unnatural melting or fusion."
},
{
... | 51 | 51 | -6 | 0 | 1 | The image successfully meets all prompt criteria but includes hallucinated metal tongs. | 45 | 88.2 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 4,461 | d66982f2-7f6c-4f88-adb3-b809994b1fca | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene is set inside an indoor swimming pool facility.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The environment is clearly an indoor pool with lanes and spectator seating."
},
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly four swimmers.",
"weight... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or body-geometry distortions in any person, such as fused limbs, malformed hands or feet, or impossible joint structure.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "Some of the officials holding clipboards ... | 55 | 55 | -8 | 0 | 1 | The image successfully meets all positive criteria but exhibits some minor hand malformations on the background figures. | 47 | 85.5 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 4,461 | d66982f2-7f6c-4f88-adb3-b809994b1fca | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene is set inside an indoor swimming pool facility.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The setting is clearly an indoor pool with lanes, starting blocks, and spectator seating above."
},
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly four you... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on people, such as extra, missing, or fused limbs, hands, feet, or facial features.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The swimmer in the middle has a partially missing/fused... | 23 | 51 | -16 | 3 | 3 | The image misses the required swimmer count and block numbers, features garbled text, and shows physical inconsistencies with splashes appearing before swimmers enter the water. | 7 | 13.7 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 4,461 | d66982f2-7f6c-4f88-adb3-b809994b1fca | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene is set inside an indoor pool facility rather than outdoors.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image clearly shows an indoor pool setting with tiled walls and spectator seating."
},
{
"statement": "Exactly four swimmers are pos... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on people, such as fused limbs, missing extremities, or distorted faces.",
"weight": -7,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The second swimmer has a distorted arm merging into their leg."
... | 43 | 52 | -13 | 1 | 2 | The image fails to render the correct block numbers (garbled digits) and includes minor anatomical artifacts on a swimmer. | 30 | 57.7 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 4,461 | d66982f2-7f6c-4f88-adb3-b809994b1fca | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene is set inside an indoor swimming pool facility.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image clearly shows an indoor pool setting with bleachers, lane lines, and pool tiles."
},
{
"statement": "Exactly four swimmers are positioned ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts on people, such as fused fingers, missing limbs, or impossible joint geometry.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The hands of the swimmers on the blocks exhibit fused and malformed finge... | 40 | 48 | -19 | 1 | 4 | The image has significant issues with garbled numbering on the blocks and severe anatomical distortions on the subjects. | 21 | 43.8 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 4,491 | 018eb62d-f580-4523-886f-15b009b9b904 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image depicts exactly two llamas.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "There are exactly two llamas visible in the field."
},
{
"statement": "The pair of llamas consists of one brown or light-brown llama and one white llama.",
"weight... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed llama anatomy such as extra legs, fused limbs, distorted heads, or impossible body topology.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Both llamas have normal, anatomically correct body structures."
},
{
"statem... | 52 | 52 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 52 | 100 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 4,491 | 018eb62d-f580-4523-886f-15b009b9b904 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly two llamas.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Two llamas are clearly visible in the image."
},
{
"statement": "One visible llama has brown or light brown fur.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts on the llamas, such as extra legs, fused limbs, malformed ears, or distorted facial features.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The llamas appear anatomically correct with normal limbs and features."
... | 57 | 57 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 57 | 100 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 4,491 | 018eb62d-f580-4523-886f-15b009b9b904 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly two llamas.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "Two llamas are visible in the image."
},
{
"statement": "One llama is predominantly light brown.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"expla... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on a llama, such as extra legs, fused limbs, missing ears, or distorted neck-to-head connections.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The brown llama has a weird gap/line near... | 55 | 55 | -8 | 0 | 1 | The image fulfills all positive requests but has minor anatomical artifacts on the brown llama's side and front leg. | 47 | 85.5 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 4,491 | 018eb62d-f580-4523-886f-15b009b9b904 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A brown llama is shown with its head lowered into the grass as if eating.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A brown llama is visible on the left side of the image with its head lowered into the grass."
},
{
"statement": "A white llama with ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits llamas with extra or missing legs, fused limbs, distorted necks, or malformed facial features.",
"weight": -8,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "All four llamas appear to have normal anatomy with appropriate numbers of limbs and normal f... | 42 | 48 | 0 | 1 | 0 | The image perfectly met almost all criteria, with only a minor spatial relationship error regarding the placement of the long-furred white llama. | 42 | 87.5 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 4,563 | 5ca3004d-5f20-442e-9e66-423d6cf9dfe8 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A laptop is visible in the foreground of the image.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A laptop is clearly the primary subject in the foreground."
},
{
"statement": "The word \"TOSHIBA\" is visible on the laptop.",
"weight": 8,
"met... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as a bent screen border, impossible hinge alignment, or fused keyboard keys.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The laptop's structure and keys are rendered cleanly."
},
{
"statement": "The... | 46 | 46 | 0 | 0 | 0 | No significant issues. | 46 | 100 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 4,563 | 5ca3004d-5f20-442e-9e66-423d6cf9dfe8 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A laptop appears in front of the background as the foreground subject.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A laptop is clearly visible in the foreground, dominating the scene."
},
{
"statement": "The laptop body displays the brand name \"TOSH... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the laptop screen, bezel, hinge, or keyboard.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The laptop's physical structure appears sound with distinct bezels, hinges, and keys."
},
{
"statemen... | 48 | 48 | -7 | 0 | 1 | The main issue is the presence of garbled, illegible text on the laptop screen interface. | 41 | 85.4 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 4,563 | 5ca3004d-5f20-442e-9e66-423d6cf9dfe8 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A laptop is visible in the foreground of the image.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A laptop is clearly visible in the foreground."
},
{
"statement": "The laptop body or bezel shows the brand name \"TOSHIBA\".",
"weight": 10,
"met... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible laptop geometry, such as fused hinges, warped screen edges, or key shapes that could not physically exist.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The laptop keys are melted and fused together in imposs... | 50 | 53 | -15 | 1 | 3 | The image captures the requested elements and colors well, but suffers from significant text garbling and melted keyboard geometry. | 35 | 66 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 4,563 | 5ca3004d-5f20-442e-9e66-423d6cf9dfe8 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "A laptop is visible in the foreground of the image.",
"weight": 10,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "A laptop is clearly the primary subject in the foreground."
},
{
"statement": "The visible laptop branding reads \"TOSHIBA\".",
"weight": 8,
"met... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible laptop geometry, such as fused keys, a broken hinge, or a warped screen frame.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The keyboard features fused and unevenly spaced keys."
},
{
"statement": "T... | 44 | 48 | -10 | 1 | 2 | The generation failed to use a high-angle shot and suffers from minor text garbling and keyboard geometry artifacts. | 34 | 70.8 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 4,709 | 1a3f0175-ff7d-4c47-9f44-291d4d333876 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Every visible playing card is from the clubs suit.",
"weight": 9,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "All visible symbols on the cards are clubs."
},
{
"statement": "A playing card with rank 5 is visible.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_cod... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits malformed card geometry or impossible club-symbol shapes, such as warped card edges, fused corners, or broken pips.",
"weight": -6,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The pips on the cards are mismatched with their ranks (e.... | 47 | 47 | -13 | 0 | 2 | The image has garbled bottom corner numbers on some cards and incorrect pip counts for the 6 and 8. | 34 | 72.3 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 4,709 | 1a3f0175-ff7d-4c47-9f44-291d4d333876 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly five distinct playing cards are visible in the image.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "Only four cards (5, 6, 8, 9) are visible, not five."
},
{
"statement": "All visible suit symbols on the cards are clubs symbols.",
"... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits impossible card geometry, such as fused card borders, severely warped corners, or non-rectangular card shapes.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The cards appear as solid, individual rectangular objects."
},
{
"st... | 44 | 54 | -7 | 1 | 1 | The model missed the count by generating only four cards instead of five, and introduced garbled card designs by putting face card artwork on number cards and a wrong numeral on the 9. | 37 | 68.5 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 4,709 | 1a3f0175-ff7d-4c47-9f44-291d4d333876 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "Exactly five playing cards are shown in the image.",
"weight": 10,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "There are six visible cards fanned out (ranks 5, 6, 8, 8, 9, and one mostly hidden on top)."
},
{
"statement": "Every visible card face belongs to ... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible card geometry, such as fused edges, non-rectangular corners, or cards intersecting unnaturally.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The top right corner of the spread shows cards melting i... | 43 | 53 | -17 | 1 | 3 | The image hallucinates six cards instead of five, duplicates the 8, includes the forbidden 7, and has some geometric artifacts near the top right. | 26 | 49.1 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 4,709 | 1a3f0175-ff7d-4c47-9f44-291d4d333876 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The image shows exactly five playing cards.",
"weight": 4,
"met": false,
"failure_code": "MISCOUNT",
"explanation": "Only four playing cards are visible in the image."
},
{
"statement": "The playing cards are depicted in a close-up view.",
"weight": 3,
"met": true... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits geometrically malformed playing cards, such as fused cards, impossible corners, or non-rectangular card shapes.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The cards have normal rectangular shapes with rounded corners."
},
{
... | 41 | 45 | -11 | 1 | 2 | The image is missing the fifth card entirely, includes an unrequested lamp, and features a garbled index number on the 9 of clubs. | 30 | 66.7 |
flux | Black Forest Labs FLUX.2 | 4,854 | f332db50-df70-49db-b4a7-9a3031e64ac4 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The hall walls are deep blue.",
"weight": 7,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The walls throughout the museum hall are painted a deep blue color."
},
{
"statement": "The left side of the hall contains exactly three tall framed paintings depicting human f... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits warped architectural geometry, such as crooked wall planes, impossible ceiling junctions, or distorted frame shapes.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The architecture and frames appear structurally sound."
},
{
"... | 53 | 53 | -2 | 0 | 1 | The image meets all positive criteria perfectly, but suffers from garbled text on the information panel. | 51 | 96.2 |
hunyuan3 | Hunyuan 3.0 | 4,854 | f332db50-df70-49db-b4a7-9a3031e64ac4 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The hall walls are deep blue.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The walls throughout the museum hall are a solid deep blue color."
},
{
"statement": "The left side contains exactly three tall framed paintings depicting historical characters... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric distortions in depicted human figures, such as malformed hands, faces, or limbs within the paintings.",
"weight": -4,
"triggered": true,
"failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT",
"explanation": "The figures in the large painting on the right ... | 52 | 56 | -12 | 1 | 3 | The image generally matches the prompt but misplaces the bench and includes minor visual artifacts in the paintings and text. | 40 | 71.4 |
ideogram | Ideogram 3.0 | 4,854 | f332db50-df70-49db-b4a7-9a3031e64ac4 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The visible walls of the hall are deep blue.",
"weight": 7,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The walls of the museum hall are painted a deep blue color."
},
{
"statement": "The left side contains exactly three tall paintings depicting historical characte... | [
{
"statement": "The human visitors exhibit anatomical artifacts such as fused limbs, missing body parts, or distorted hands.",
"weight": -7,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The visitors on the bench appear anatomically normal."
},
{
"statement": "The image exhib... | 45 | 53 | -3 | 1 | 1 | The image incorrectly features two glass-encased artworks instead of three, and text elements are garbled. | 42 | 79.2 |
nanobanana_pro | Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro) | 4,854 | f332db50-df70-49db-b4a7-9a3031e64ac4 | gpt5pro | gemini | [
{
"statement": "The scene is an indoor museum hall or gallery.",
"weight": 8,
"met": true,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The image clearly depicts an indoor museum hall with paintings on the walls and a bench for visitors."
},
{
"statement": "The hall walls are deep blue.",
"... | [
{
"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as warped picture frames, impossible wall or ceiling intersections, or a malformed bench structure.",
"weight": -5,
"triggered": false,
"failure_code": null,
"explanation": "The architecture, frames, and bench appear geometrically sound... | 57 | 57 | -3 | 0 | 1 | The image successfully meets all positive prompt requirements, with the only issue being garbled text on the informational display panel. | 54 | 94.7 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.