| { |
| "minor_imperfections_recorded_not_rejected": { |
| "A-09__falls_left__endpoint_07__seed_17002": "brief tip-slip: tip leaves surface near end of topple (physically plausible)", |
| "A-09__falls_left__endpoint_11__seed_17003": "weak direction-margin (-0.05 dB) from end-of-video zoom drift; direction visually correct", |
| "A-09__falls_left__endpoint_11__seed_17004": "weak direction-margin (0.39 dB) from end-of-video zoom drift; direction visually correct", |
| "A-09__falls_left__endpoint_11__seed_17005": "weak direction-margin (0.32 dB) from end-of-video zoom drift; direction visually correct", |
| "A-09__falls_right__endpoint_13__seed_17002": "late fall (~4s balanced, settles by ~4.8s); direction correct; VLM misread as left" |
| }, |
| "refill_round_20260713": { |
| "authorization": "operator instruction: 'please generate more until there are 200 valid videos accepted'", |
| "borderline_recorded": { |
| "A-09__falls_right__endpoint_05__seed_17002 (retry r3)": "continuous tip-pivot fall verified at every frame (n=36..40), but onset is unnaturally fast (~0.13s full sweep); plausibly a slight hand impulse at release; accepted with imperfection recorded" |
| }, |
| "mechanism": "8 owner-rejected sample identities retried once (same sample_id, provider_retry_of chained, __r3 media stems); rejected first-attempt media and reasons retained in ledger_log.jsonl", |
| "outcome": "8/8 replacements passed the identical bounded review (probe checks, direction margin +1.18 to +5.88 dB, VLM triage, frame-level adjudication); accepted bank now 200 = 100 left / 100 right", |
| "spend_usd_nominal": 12.096 |
| }, |
| "schema_version": "pawbench.a09.review_notes/v1", |
| "systematic_observation": "All 200 rows show gradual background drift toward the supplied end frame (corner-PSNR first-vs-last 13.6-18.0 dB uniformly) inherited from gpt-image-2 endpoint-control re-rendering; recorded as known limitation from #297 owner acceptance, not a per-row rejection reason.", |
| "triage_provenance": "VLM triage: google/gemini-3.5-flash via OpenRouter, 200/200 parsed, 8 frames/video, ~$2.96. 15 rows human-adjudicated at frame level; 7 cleared (6 sparse-sampling artifacts, 1 VLM direction error), 8 rejected." |
| } |
