{ "models": [ "qwen3-1.7b", "qwen3-4b", "qwen3-8b", "qwen3-14b", "qwen3-4b-long" ], "regimes": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "g": 0.05, "sigma": 0.15, "seeds": 24, "T": 600, "L_in": 14, "L_read": 20 }, "qwen3-4b": { "g": 0.1, "sigma": 0.05, "seeds": 24, "T": 600, "L_in": 18, "L_read": 25 }, "qwen3-8b": { "g": 0.05, "sigma": 0.05, "seeds": 24, "T": 600, "L_in": 18, "L_read": 25 }, "qwen3-14b": { "g": 0.05, "sigma": 0.15, "seeds": 24, "T": 600, "L_in": 20, "L_read": 28 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "g": 0.1, "sigma": 0.05, "seeds": 8, "T": 2000, "L_in": 18, "L_read": 25 } }, "tests": { "ring_err_vs_vel.explore": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 1.571259405877855, "se": 0.13342483405762298, "t": 11.776363950351746, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 2.066930267545912, "se": 0.17941768900166613, "t": 11.520214528717498, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 2.479503790537516, "se": 0.07711407568910708, "t": 32.153712125577144, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.31125901805029965, "se": 0.17905950876786486, "t": -1.7382992960950205, "pos": 6, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 1.9936415354410801, "se": 0.20344249483031718, "t": 9.799533460813546, "pos": 8, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 26.85599565427568, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_vel.stuck": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.03916666666666666, "se": 0.003427122565961948, "t": -11.428440597855623, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.00041666666666666675, "se": 0.00227057155119193, "t": -0.18350739330277382, "pos": 7, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.0004166666666666667, "se": 0.0007915236331504884, "t": 0.52641089819165, "pos": 6, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.04895833333333335, "se": 0.004494150451979124, "t": -10.89379046306142, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.0, "se": 0.002112885636821291, "t": 0.0, "pos": 3, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -10.989663778014084, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_vel.skill": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.008786940888967365, "se": 0.0003471667285748998, "t": 25.310434917070744, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.020362794554481905, "se": 0.0007938730198955095, "t": -25.649939025717337, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.0033248472415531674, "se": 0.0007578242349162713, "t": 4.387359348464906, "pos": 20, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.019252751721069217, "se": 0.000715441283529083, "t": -26.910316981011324, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.013982269447296858, "se": 0.0009764187629364132, "t": 14.319951621215843, "pos": 8, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -11.431230870596506, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_vel.lag100": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.008188590407371521, "se": 0.0007729090736472085, "t": -10.594506762265251, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.05252092828353246, "se": 0.0014706198492683202, "t": -35.713463482533086, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.014701406160990397, "se": 0.00088879761947894, "t": -16.540780306780228, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.04975641270478567, "se": 0.0019913345285445254, "t": -24.98646610680368, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.019606925547122955, "se": 0.0014471588458636025, "t": -13.54856490230164, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -43.917608329191125, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_yoked_err.explore": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.40636143419477655, "se": 0.14498849237081216, "t": 2.802715081383809, "pos": 16, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 1.3082263469696045, "se": 0.20461895657024767, "t": 6.393475799591802, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.1962983873155381, "se": 0.0877015552001718, "t": 2.2382543487114077, "pos": 16, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 4.332918445269267, "se": 0.21352177223806984, "t": 20.29263058213194, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.3947339057922359, "se": 0.32678295273819247, "t": 1.2079390998969382, "pos": 5, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 15.86353790590948, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_yoked_err.stuck": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.000833333333333333, "se": 0.0019427183505006539, "t": 0.4289522117905441, "pos": 9, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.0006250000000000004, "se": 0.002278453343318919, "t": -0.27430888669837383, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -3.614007241618348e-20, "se": 0.0009028938981432691, "t": -4.0026931725314264e-17, "pos": 8, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.018541666666666665, "se": 0.003964050029054912, "t": -4.677455261856841, "pos": 3, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.003125, "se": 0.0024888142615654197, "t": 1.255618005834807, "pos": 6, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -2.2614059683823355, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_yoked_err.skill": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.0041528733757634955, "se": 0.0005042223498178214, "t": -8.236194562307588, "pos": 1, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.010671824449673295, "se": 0.0010270950746614097, "t": -10.39029853511015, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.003802737376342217, "se": 0.0007158206623935029, "t": -5.312416330127903, "pos": 3, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.007102881092578173, "se": 0.0010203521834914998, "t": -6.961205363694255, "pos": 2, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.0014774883165955544, "se": 0.0006709263641964375, "t": -2.2021616610119783, "pos": 1, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -15.450057395619947, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_yoked_err.lag100": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.000265561044216156, "se": 0.0007060772434587154, "t": 0.37610763790560187, "pos": 11, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.011830359697341919, "se": 0.0027809590784405322, "t": 4.254057454155703, "pos": 19, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.001283109188079834, "se": 0.0009506061855664955, "t": 1.349779969415189, "pos": 14, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.022528874377409618, "se": 0.002924601240256649, "t": 7.703229441095564, "pos": 22, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.0018082931637763977, "se": 0.0015368197787939287, "t": -1.1766462071405126, "pos": 2, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 6.841587251286029, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_shuf_err.explore": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 2.269059737523397, "se": 0.11421919904226471, "t": 19.86583478565432, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 2.01252802213033, "se": 0.22198918818838587, "t": 9.065883066442163, "pos": 22, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 1.223527325524224, "se": 0.10550456404357013, "t": 11.596913712841323, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 3.0846829944186744, "se": 0.20065594807244955, "t": 15.372995538138285, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 2.0253290335337315, "se": 0.26399113135233243, "t": 7.671958611483246, "pos": 8, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 27.950813551538044, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_shuf_err.stuck": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.0012499999999999998, "se": 0.0021121199598123403, "t": 0.5918224455920871, "pos": 9, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.008333333333333333, "se": 0.001494757343821469, "t": 5.575040903982774, "pos": 19, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.0010416666666666667, "se": 0.0009507418283396338, "t": -1.09563567691749, "pos": 6, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.002708333333333334, "se": 0.0038657166342889594, "t": 0.7006031713008606, "pos": 13, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.0006249999999999997, "se": 0.0029028157512515813, "t": 0.21530818817230268, "pos": 3, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 2.8859154219791163, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_shuf_err.skill": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.00691648933570832, "se": 0.0004267176618365238, "t": -16.208584631676292, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.03179753998604914, "se": 0.001068588247913892, "t": -29.75658776720088, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.010473975368464986, "se": 0.0008065215662947577, "t": -12.986602970312992, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.027848743678381045, "se": 0.000842823798438678, "t": -33.042189518106326, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.004539201036095619, "se": 0.0010243174221151838, "t": -4.4314398428587785, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -45.99698244364825, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_shuf_err.lag100": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.00046720852454503375, "se": 0.0008724175646346534, "t": 0.5355331477544116, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.012396946549415588, "se": 0.0019988379555397513, "t": -6.202076819212696, "pos": 2, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.0021251564224561057, "se": 0.001040764165573684, "t": 2.0419192865702573, "pos": 15, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.01360683391491572, "se": 0.0020793013007234713, "t": -6.54394527151085, "pos": 2, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.014439061284065247, "se": 0.003334449305467128, "t": 4.330268647476846, "pos": 7, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -5.084284828199438, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_rand_err.explore": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 3.158723990122477, "se": 0.11247746868253164, "t": 28.08317103079547, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 3.6499556435479055, "se": 0.1892555727385221, "t": 19.28585558001365, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 3.334867517153422, "se": 0.08480006803500063, "t": 39.32623633953901, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 4.746671769354079, "se": 0.2496579236896128, "t": 19.01270225757136, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 1.7438871065775543, "se": 0.1675692218181923, "t": 10.406965477643745, "pos": 8, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 52.85398260395974, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_rand_err.stuck": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.007291666666666668, "se": 0.0030392833624866113, "t": -2.399140125157971, "pos": 4, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.018125, "se": 0.0020370770655560614, "t": -8.89755243258429, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.0075, "se": 0.0012038585308576921, "t": -6.229967897188555, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.12583333333333332, "se": 0.007576103417665911, "t": -16.609241769313225, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.0125, "se": 0.003895968612369898, "t": -3.2084447395987397, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -17.06795111212202, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_rand_err.skill": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.00988980762213032, "se": 0.0003750430669332066, "t": -26.36979188283901, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.045980095075113546, "se": 0.000659157377044247, "t": -69.75586813773467, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.011592626649265489, "se": 0.0006897152019926156, "t": -16.807845637987842, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.039053027518093586, "se": 0.0007874026313837225, "t": -49.59727839550741, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.0039537157863378525, "se": 0.0009123068744498944, "t": -4.333756433351306, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -81.26539202703447, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_rand_err.lag100": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.03092057506243388, "se": 0.0006614933555083048, "t": -46.74359130738945, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.09420181810855865, "se": 0.0016129163210118957, "t": -58.4046530383295, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.046011862655480705, "se": 0.0008473579633140951, "t": -54.30038383722042, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.09744920084873836, "se": 0.0019624284758387213, "t": -49.657453531950814, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.04601640999317169, "se": 0.0026096495100355723, "t": -17.633176338896345, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -104.5530408574451, "n_models": 4 }, "freeze_effect.explore": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -2.199879063500299, "se": 0.1587147695804532, "t": -13.860581906242638, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -3.901391016112434, "se": 0.20500038154348324, "t": -19.03114026782871, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -1.8741796016693117, "se": 0.12414516688374912, "t": -15.096677935310312, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -4.993962420357598, "se": 0.2785164029114248, "t": -17.930586378949478, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -1.5921951532363883, "se": 0.5962286063619694, "t": -2.6704440817617683, "pos": 1, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -32.95949324416557, "n_models": 4 }, "freeze_effect.stuck": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.009375, "se": 0.002048163281109921, "t": 4.577271786124195, "pos": 19, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.012291666666666668, "se": 0.0027580443388167688, "t": 4.45666028412724, "pos": 19, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.005624999999999999, "se": 0.0017629566938378908, "t": 3.190662606552509, "pos": 14, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.04624999999999999, "se": 0.00637199773010504, "t": 7.258320225302024, "pos": 23, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.010000000000000004, "se": 0.003895968612369899, "t": -2.5667557916789923, "pos": 1, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 9.741457451052984, "n_models": 4 }, "freeze_effect.skill": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.07764681081365173, "se": 0.0016731582678283985, "t": -46.407331754951045, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.11361958102012674, "se": 0.003174233498120477, "t": -35.79433620349701, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.05819085403345525, "se": 0.002442184531801618, "t": -23.82737801984497, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.1200076158468922, "se": 0.004245944165926139, "t": -28.26405886586023, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.04681903473101556, "se": 0.0016768112694582045, "t": -27.92146950809991, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -67.14655242207662, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_content.explore": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.6407192415661279, "se": 0.09761583907843806, "t": -6.563681136329582, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.03576232327355274, "se": 0.2117044794292718, "t": -0.16892568059950072, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -1.8227192958196003, "se": 0.07499105489962736, "t": -24.305822851261926, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 1.1034910380840302, "se": 0.24293230513658043, "t": 4.542380798073068, "pos": 22, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -1.9340980052948005, "se": 0.3972660783668815, "t": -4.868520396318939, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -13.24802443505897, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_content.stuck": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.10875, "se": 0.007085464300088322, "t": -15.348323750448422, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.13645833333333332, "se": 0.00854696724894798, "t": -15.965702144246494, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.09833333333333333, "se": 0.003897075578896675, "t": -25.232595915210116, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.04979166666666665, "se": 0.009481480646056601, "t": -5.251465306463002, "pos": 3, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.129375, "se": 0.011473474844178636, "t": -11.276008511548858, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -30.89904355818402, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_content.skill": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.012044079270140173, "se": 0.0002932879177202465, "t": 41.0657191873429, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.026397683696510892, "se": 0.0005316148699266209, "t": 49.655653349490734, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.039995704727819735, "se": 0.0006796298572854453, "t": 58.849246099294746, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.011708612871492127, "se": 0.0005675301605884684, "t": 20.63082050009737, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.025369700764713343, "se": 0.0006958940276657852, "t": 36.45627028846635, "pos": 8, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 85.10071956811286, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_content.selffulfil": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.010512560606002808, "se": 0.00031891393584148925, "t": -32.963628818114415, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.008488232890764872, "se": 0.0005937851761527109, "t": -14.295124283435884, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.01473598430554072, "se": 0.00048153424881226586, "t": 30.6021520626787, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.005526378750801086, "se": 0.00040431340778743886, "t": -13.668551782745947, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.006952337920665741, "se": 0.0007652008023607063, "t": 9.085638566004135, "pos": 8, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -15.162576410808771, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_yoked_pred.explore": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.21537843015458838, "se": 0.08324981542590269, "t": -2.5871340260962867, "pos": 7, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.3531675868564181, "se": 0.21340307955938262, "t": -1.6549320074743528, "pos": 8, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.07121478186713322, "se": 0.07616953110491541, "t": -0.934951034017033, "pos": 10, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.4371467961205378, "se": 0.2734224828314918, "t": -1.598796088725257, "pos": 10, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.524754921595256, "se": 0.3784127223448858, "t": -1.3867264249033195, "pos": 1, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -3.387906578156464, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_yoked_pred.stuck": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.017083333333333336, "se": 0.004503588209781733, "t": 3.7932716175578767, "pos": 19, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.018958333333333327, "se": 0.00670265985669789, "t": 2.8284791021266704, "pos": 16, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.0010416666666666667, "se": 0.002211202675136633, "t": 0.4710860195582482, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.02708333333333333, "se": 0.00951694078135137, "t": 2.8458024438277105, "pos": 18, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.001875, "se": 0.007315437444199765, "t": 0.2563072973150283, "pos": 3, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 4.969319591535253, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_yoked_pred.skill": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.0006502896442649823, "se": 0.00025398552399754753, "t": -2.5603413691847314, "pos": 7, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.0006811102794017643, "se": 0.0005000931188318767, "t": 1.361966909268237, "pos": 13, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.000890348261843125, "se": 0.0006310289102692671, "t": 1.4109468636915594, "pos": 15, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -8.51168612522694e-05, "se": 0.00028057167317911826, "t": -0.30336940393098916, "pos": 10, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.00024008238688111305, "se": 0.00046126060186882725, "t": 0.5204918562487316, "pos": 3, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -0.04539850007796212, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_yoked_pred.selffulfil": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.0023065085212389627, "se": 0.0003057523750790651, "t": 7.543714159677478, "pos": 21, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.00245856245358785, "se": 0.0007680932483765348, "t": 3.2008645549018198, "pos": 20, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.001153804361820221, "se": 0.0005869066367271614, "t": 1.9659078456742625, "pos": 15, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.0019233102599779766, "se": 0.0006177941399825505, "t": 3.1131895489204546, "pos": 16, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.0011526718735694885, "se": 0.0007261949540532875, "t": 1.5872760711649154, "pos": 6, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 7.911838054587007, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_free.explore": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 3.732862671216329, "se": 0.10948773921441128, "t": 34.09388757133998, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 5.303774568769667, "se": 0.16173998999486242, "t": 32.791980319388784, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 3.737376001146105, "se": 0.07651460563099959, "t": 48.84526255248608, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 5.370046509636773, "se": 0.1821623042490503, "t": 29.47946081256693, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 2.9560827016830435, "se": 0.2699657933925726, "t": 10.949841698590442, "pos": 8, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 72.6052956278909, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_free.stuck": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.016458333333333335, "se": 0.002241715154909025, "t": -7.34184862750828, "pos": 1, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.05145833333333333, "se": 0.003398091518217774, "t": -15.143304133351334, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.012291666666666666, "se": 0.0016478787052004585, "t": -7.459084596382007, "pos": 1, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.17312499999999997, "se": 0.00871141856449322, "t": -19.873341949798895, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.025625000000000002, "se": 0.003463779418084075, "t": -7.397988412949804, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -24.90878965352026, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_err_vs_free.skill": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.00819827444714368, "se": 0.00042171081576284155, "t": -19.440512646832758, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.042398684019038534, "se": 0.000658789495880662, "t": -64.35847001834854, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.010563736393426856, "se": 0.0006427761574172659, "t": -16.434549215193243, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.038136585343939565, "se": 0.0007437766546702567, "t": -51.27424355749227, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.0013314476236701012, "se": 0.0007627907875024839, "t": -1.7454951547455149, "pos": 2, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -75.75388771893341, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_free.explore": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -2.825601670477125, "se": 0.125883612244708, "t": -22.446143863304258, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -4.072103977203369, "se": 0.2349074725670436, "t": -17.33492737674053, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -3.0343478388256497, "se": 0.07252846618929767, "t": -41.83664701947605, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -6.264971494674683, "se": 0.27107945174962583, "t": -23.111200256008818, "pos": 0, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -5.196801424026489, "se": 0.17723249799292615, "t": -29.3219442420425, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -52.36445925776483, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_free.stuck": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.06645833333333334, "se": 0.003704178587711699, "t": 17.941449570979994, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.06874999999999999, "se": 0.0051274516935379535, "t": 13.40821993245583, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.009583333333333334, "se": 0.0028854436442520568, "t": 3.3212685863485145, "pos": 16, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.60125, "se": 0.013430072517528974, "t": 44.76893175485438, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.05937500000000001, "se": 0.008042160113160784, "t": 7.382966661262362, "pos": 8, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 39.71993492231936, "n_models": 4 }, "ring_pred_vs_free.skill": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.00018206280852458198, "se": 0.00034442640260799485, "t": -0.5285971317703968, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.0049340408089240855, "se": 0.0004025269624383607, "t": 12.257665372365308, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.005277442668254177, "se": 0.0004798595004191953, "t": 10.997891390383879, "pos": 23, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.011173793121997733, "se": 0.0005014867166414346, "t": 22.28133418334797, "pos": 24, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.007059758063405752, "se": 0.00045080522466357857, "t": -15.660328845288388, "pos": 0, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 22.50414690716338, "n_models": 4 } }, "privileged": { "free": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.00010121340458602024, "se": 0.0022039697390755656, "t": 0.045923227888089446, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.0005089084322378104, "se": 0.0077353100680467345, "t": 0.0657903080498383, "pos": 10, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.0005954653247913962, "se": 0.0032687002904597147, "t": -0.18217189459962668, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.0004834246664219578, "se": 0.008411347584883341, "t": 0.05747291519503442, "pos": 10, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.00046528033392062573, "se": 0.0036792539056173645, "t": -0.12646051233655034, "pos": 5, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -0.006492721733332256 }, "ring_err": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": -0.0041274910911987634, "se": 0.0033930754826176687, "t": -1.2164454084040925, "pos": 8, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.007586714021202756, "se": 0.004813760717992702, "t": -1.5760471834101368, "pos": 9, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.005087347450894686, "se": 0.0021344946749124473, "t": -2.38339664684493, "pos": 9, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": -0.009805369891670482, "se": 0.006803589189818468, "t": -1.4412054605448785, "pos": 9, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.0003160441793180341, "se": 0.00137308091097591, "t": -0.2301715629368173, "pos": 3, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": -3.3085473496020192 }, "ring_pred": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.002833321610317805, "se": 0.0031343535671523428, "t": 0.9039572433725036, "pos": 13, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.011129989668003396, "se": 0.024236931796450367, "t": 0.4592161153679297, "pos": 9, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": 0.00405927455571523, "se": 0.004298911772038305, "t": 0.9442563074027797, "pos": 13, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.01598608513762945, "se": 0.02972384320162289, "t": 0.5378202619759691, "pos": 11, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.0006557752478927037, "se": 0.004784027632475378, "t": 0.13707597411041475, "pos": 5, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 1.4226249640595912 }, "content": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.0005768011016876925, "se": 0.004531484012482837, "t": 0.1272874625837328, "pos": 11, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": -0.0026171326904828734, "se": 0.018586495588323187, "t": -0.14080829159247565, "pos": 10, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.003817749059472001, "se": 0.004623838619556955, "t": -0.825666588648764, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.01088822533517683, "se": 0.011358099995146212, "t": 0.9586308748672596, "pos": 13, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": 0.0013672125634052873, "se": 0.006826414793049536, "t": 0.2002826673816166, "pos": 4, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 0.0597217286048764 }, "vel": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 4.957640627367236e-05, "se": 0.0025171528143387483, "t": 0.0196954296899515, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.0010095710322187978, "se": 0.005757300831901127, "t": 0.17535492094225444, "pos": 10, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.001437855628187358, "se": 0.0049521393548730384, "t": -0.2903503971010972, "pos": 13, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.0020023322474355906, "se": 0.0072341655646715455, "t": 0.2767882804914077, "pos": 11, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.0001645946193030018, "se": 0.0036389835380621263, "t": -0.0452309326440794, "pos": 4, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 0.0907441170112582 }, "yoked_err": { "per_model": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "diff": 0.0014801084216697323, "se": 0.0038267031347957088, "t": 0.38678422901721876, "pos": 12, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b": { "diff": 0.0010230477975724957, "se": 0.006177372494207974, "t": 0.16561212692479294, "pos": 13, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-8b": { "diff": -0.0003057052970157533, "se": 0.004523232997190352, "t": -0.06758557368272758, "pos": 11, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-14b": { "diff": 0.004101827435338175, "se": 0.006740582380631991, "t": 0.6085271574046975, "pos": 15, "n": 24 }, "qwen3-4b-long": { "diff": -0.00164014949281166, "se": 0.003889399803189963, "t": -0.42169732498738266, "pos": 4, "n": 8 } }, "stouffer_z": 0.5466689698319909 } }, "gains": { "qwen3-1.7b": { "gstar": 0.0351274962790774, "picked": 0.05, "rows": [ { "g": 0.0125, "rel": 0.3558465966572527, "free_beta": 0.8261647126492421, "stuck": { "free": 0.0009375, "content": 0.001875, "ring_err": 0.0, "vel": 0.0021875 }, "vs": { "vel": 1.2823286056518552, "yoked_err": 0.05338235696156768, "shuf_err": 0.9477869272232051, "rand_err": 1.170043508211771 }, "freeze": -0.8866413434346516, "sync": [ 0.8848941326141357, 0.07931248098611832 ] }, { "g": 0.025, "rel": 0.7116931933145054, "free_beta": 0.8987542279582299, "stuck": { "free": 0.0037500000000000003, "content": 0.016875, "ring_err": 0.000625, "vel": 0.0125 }, "vs": { "vel": 1.7058785557746892, "yoked_err": 0.2487399975458784, "shuf_err": 1.4847734769185388, "rand_err": 2.1404505372047433 }, "freeze": -1.3628993829091394, "sync": [ 0.8887441754341125, 0.08361257612705231 ] }, { "g": 0.05, "rel": 1.4233863866290108, "free_beta": 1.10509499429043, "stuck": { "free": 0.025625, "content": 0.2008333333333333, "ring_err": 0.009166666666666667, "vel": 0.04833333333333334 }, "vs": { "vel": 1.571259405877855, "yoked_err": 0.40636143419477655, "shuf_err": 2.269059737523397, "rand_err": 3.158723990122477 }, "freeze": -2.199879063500299, "sync": [ 0.893667995929718, 0.08951885253190994 ] }, { "g": 0.1, "rel": 2.8467727732580217, "free_beta": 1.3915757117747143, "stuck": { "free": 0.2528125, "content": 0.8096875, "ring_err": 0.0909375, "vel": 0.079375 }, "vs": { "vel": -1.0983047684033713, "yoked_err": 1.2733757098515825, "shuf_err": 2.434966484705607, "rand_err": 2.945293207963308 }, "freeze": -3.872229715188344, "sync": [ 0.8789941668510437, 0.09917474538087845 ] }, { "g": 0.2, "rel": 5.693545546516043, "free_beta": 1.8214792496023495, "stuck": { "free": 0.9075, "content": 0.9996875000000001, "ring_err": 0.34125, "vel": 0.024062500000000004 }, "vs": { "vel": -5.5384824474652605, "yoked_err": 2.99508735537529, "shuf_err": 3.293389081954956, "rand_err": 3.13596510887146 }, "freeze": -5.843354284763336, "sync": [ 0.7884216904640198, 0.08035120368003845 ] } ] }, "qwen3-4b": { "gstar": 0.08830481204412925, "picked": 0.1, "rows": [ { "g": 0.025, "rel": 0.2831102792847411, "free_beta": 0.4483423440793043, "stuck": { "free": 0.0, "content": 0.0021875, "ring_err": 0.0, "vel": 0.0 }, "vs": { "vel": 2.032401919364929, "yoked_err": 0.15488870938619015, "shuf_err": 0.7166480620702109, "rand_err": 1.3851010402043662 }, "freeze": -0.5540957848231001, "sync": [ 0.8884552121162415, 0.5475438833236694 ] }, { "g": 0.05, "rel": 0.5662205585694822, "free_beta": 0.6472074199460054, "stuck": { "free": 0.0059375, "content": 0.0534375, "ring_err": 0.0003125, "vel": 0.0040625 }, "vs": { "vel": 2.722402016321817, "yoked_err": 0.29009318351745517, "shuf_err": 1.2421263853708897, "rand_err": 2.4610731601715083 }, "freeze": -1.1777116060256945, "sync": [ 0.8789880871772766, 0.5080907940864563 ] }, { "g": 0.1, "rel": 1.1324411171389643, "free_beta": 1.0771465789627068, "stuck": { "free": 0.064375, "content": 0.26958333333333334, "ring_err": 0.012916666666666668, "vel": 0.013333333333333334 }, "vs": { "vel": 2.066930267545912, "yoked_err": 1.3082263469696045, "shuf_err": 2.01252802213033, "rand_err": 3.6499556435479055 }, "freeze": -3.901391016112434, "sync": [ 0.8308307528495789, 0.3951006829738617 ] }, { "g": 0.2, "rel": 2.2648822342779287, "free_beta": 1.4987620397131898, "stuck": { "free": 0.3490625, "content": 0.7040625, "ring_err": 0.09031249999999999, "vel": 0.013437500000000002 }, "vs": { "vel": -5.581790347894033, "yoked_err": 4.957843532164891, "shuf_err": 2.0271235505739846, "rand_err": 1.1694662372271218 }, "freeze": -5.981341203053792, "sync": [ 0.6808127760887146, 0.23374664783477783 ] }, { "g": 0.4, "rel": 4.529764468555857, "free_beta": 1.9394012586256975, "stuck": { "free": 0.84625, "content": 0.9793749999999999, "ring_err": 0.1121875, "vel": 0.0396875 }, "vs": { "vel": -8.685451308886211, "yoked_err": 5.544669359922409, "shuf_err": 5.373540361722311, "rand_err": 4.25643747051557 }, "freeze": -7.992318059007326, "sync": [ 0.45186400413513184, 0.06960289180278778 ] } ] }, "qwen3-8b": { "gstar": 0.09039852966097231, "picked": 0.05, "rows": [ { "g": 0.0125, "rel": 0.1382765853258852, "free_beta": 0.2838960974430731, "stuck": { "free": 0.0, "content": 0.0, "ring_err": 0.0, "vel": 0.0 }, "vs": { "vel": 1.1132447520891828, "yoked_err": 0.09131451447804739, "shuf_err": 0.3483376502990725, "rand_err": 0.6938565770785012 }, "freeze": -0.2066547473271685, "sync": [ 0.9219492077827454, 0.590043306350708 ] }, { "g": 0.025, "rel": 0.2765531706517704, "free_beta": 0.39010212624673507, "stuck": { "free": 0.0, "content": 0.0053124999999999995, "ring_err": 0.0, "vel": 0.0003125 }, "vs": { "vel": 1.65495095650355, "yoked_err": 0.08997340997060133, "shuf_err": 0.5940713683764138, "rand_err": 1.643476108709971 }, "freeze": -0.4544316331545508, "sync": [ 0.9175398349761963, 0.5714636445045471 ] }, { "g": 0.05, "rel": 0.5531063413035407, "free_beta": 0.6043748546375828, "stuck": { "free": 0.015, "content": 0.12291666666666667, "ring_err": 0.0027083333333333334, "vel": 0.0022916666666666667 }, "vs": { "vel": 2.479503790537516, "yoked_err": 0.1962983873155381, "shuf_err": 1.223527325524224, "rand_err": 3.334867517153422 }, "freeze": -1.8741796016693117, "sync": [ 0.8973915576934814, 0.4950920045375824 ] }, { "g": 0.1, "rel": 1.1062126826070815, "free_beta": 1.067434868389526, "stuck": { "free": 0.2828125, "content": 0.6921875, "ring_err": 0.0484375, "vel": 0.010312499999999999 }, "vs": { "vel": 1.64973239103953, "yoked_err": 1.7123371164004009, "shuf_err": 1.7063290874163308, "rand_err": 5.2007539470990505 }, "freeze": -4.172081192334494, "sync": [ 0.8229377865791321, 0.3430536985397339 ] }, { "g": 0.2, "rel": 2.212425365214163, "free_beta": 1.347552104241835, "stuck": { "free": 0.7853125, "content": 0.8834375, "ring_err": 0.3375, "vel": 0.0103125 }, "vs": { "vel": -5.5011245012283325, "yoked_err": 3.7296273708343506, "shuf_err": 1.1700916488965352, "rand_err": 3.8457094828287754 }, "freeze": -4.893509268760681, "sync": [ 0.650681734085083, 0.22108566761016846 ] } ] }, "qwen3-14b": { "gstar": 0.030199240318276276, "picked": 0.05, "rows": [ { "g": 0.0125, "rel": 0.41391769687779617, "free_beta": 0.5991689165011511, "stuck": { "free": 0.000625, "content": 0.003125, "ring_err": 0.0003125, "vel": 0.003125 }, "vs": { "vel": 2.6740959088007603, "yoked_err": 0.2941359281539908, "shuf_err": 1.3689936399459832, "rand_err": 2.023640831311543 }, "freeze": -1.1669350465138746, "sync": [ 0.8324160575866699, 0.08321615308523178 ] }, { "g": 0.025, "rel": 0.8278353937555923, "free_beta": 0.863480286907939, "stuck": { "free": 0.005625, "content": 0.1171875, "ring_err": 0.000625, "vel": 0.01625 }, "vs": { "vel": 2.5541615088780714, "yoked_err": 0.45068768660227465, "shuf_err": 2.281461040178934, "rand_err": 3.096144040425618 }, "freeze": -2.1989347139994297, "sync": [ 0.8385881185531616, 0.08588185906410217 ] }, { "g": 0.05, "rel": 1.6556707875111847, "free_beta": 1.3643153739515286, "stuck": { "free": 0.19833333333333333, "content": 0.8493749999999999, "ring_err": 0.025208333333333333, "vel": 0.07416666666666667 }, "vs": { "vel": -0.31125901805029965, "yoked_err": 4.332918445269267, "shuf_err": 3.0846829944186744, "rand_err": 4.746671769354079 }, "freeze": -4.993962420357598, "sync": [ 0.8215686678886414, 0.07936698943376541 ] }, { "g": 0.1, "rel": 3.3113415750223694, "free_beta": 1.7644102477969614, "stuck": { "free": 0.970625, "content": 1.0, "ring_err": 0.3025, "vel": 0.125 }, "vs": { "vel": -7.069129546483358, "yoked_err": 4.516823634505272, "shuf_err": 2.883931557337443, "rand_err": 4.987844616174698 }, "freeze": -5.6468882486224174, "sync": [ 0.7224088907241821, 0.06767614185810089 ] }, { "g": 0.2, "rel": 6.622683150044739, "free_beta": 1.824627331433701, "stuck": { "free": 0.999375, "content": 1.0, "ring_err": 0.634375, "vel": 0.1225 }, "vs": { "vel": -6.998625536759694, "yoked_err": 3.623907481630643, "shuf_err": 1.8278543551762898, "rand_err": 4.3247221286098165 }, "freeze": -4.343528849383196, "sync": [ 0.5643088221549988, 0.043589528650045395 ] } ] } } }