#!/usr/bin/env python3 """Exact finite checks for marginal kernels and separable coding obstructions. Only standard-library integers and fractions. These checks do not prove all-dimension statements or literature priority; proofs are in the manuscript. """ from fractions import Fraction as F from itertools import product, combinations from math import prod import json import random def points(shape): return list(product(*(range(q) for q in shape))) def dot(a, b): return sum((x * y for x, y in zip(a, b)), F(0)) def rank(rows): if not rows: return 0 a = [list(map(F, row)) for row in rows] nr, nc = len(a), len(a[0]) pivot = 0 for j in range(nc): found = next((i for i in range(pivot, nr) if a[i][j]), None) if found is None: continue a[pivot], a[found] = a[found], a[pivot] value = a[pivot][j] a[pivot] = [x / value for x in a[pivot]] for i in range(pivot + 1, nr): if a[i][j]: factor = a[i][j] a[i] = [x - factor * y for x, y in zip(a[i], a[pivot])] pivot += 1 if pivot == nr: break return pivot def marginal_matrix(shape): xs = points(shape) rows = [] descriptors = [] for i in range(len(shape)): other = [j for j in range(len(shape)) if j != i] for assignment in product(*(range(shape[j]) for j in other)): row = [int(all(x[j] == a for j, a in zip(other, assignment))) for x in xs] rows.append(row) descriptors.append((i, other, assignment)) return rows, descriptors def matvec(a, x): return [dot(row, x) for row in a] def transpose_matvec(a, x): return [sum((a[i][j] * x[i] for i in range(len(a))), F(0)) for j in range(len(a[0]))] def one_factor_basis(q): # Orthogonal integer Helmert contrasts; no square roots are approximated. out = [[F(1)] * q] for a in range(1, q): out.append([F(1 if x < a else -a if x == a else 0) for x in range(q)]) for i, u in enumerate(out): for v in out[:i]: assert dot(u, v) == 0 return out def tensor_vector(shape, basis, labels): return [F(prod(basis[i][labels[i]][x[i]] for i in range(len(shape)))) for x in points(shape)] def center_coordinate(shape, values, coordinate): xs = points(shape) lookup = dict(zip(xs, values)) out = [] for x in xs: total = F(0) for a in range(shape[coordinate]): y = list(x) y[coordinate] = a total += lookup[tuple(y)] out.append(total / shape[coordinate]) return out def observable_from_marginals(shape, sums): """Reconstruct (I-P_K)z using inclusion-exclusion of averaging maps. The input consists only of actual codimension-one sums; no original z or hidden tensor coefficients are available to this decoder. """ a, descriptions = marginal_matrix(shape) xs = points(shape) one_coordinate_averages = [] for i in range(len(shape)): entries = {} for value, (coord, other, assignment) in zip(sums, descriptions): if coord == i: entries[assignment] = value / shape[i] other = [j for j in range(len(shape)) if j != i] one_coordinate_averages.append([entries[tuple(x[j] for j in other)] for x in xs]) out = [F(0)] * len(xs) for size in range(1, len(shape) + 1): for subset in combinations(range(len(shape)), size): value = one_coordinate_averages[subset[0]] for i in subset[1:]: value = center_coordinate(shape, value, i) sign = 1 if size % 2 else -1 out = [x + sign * y for x, y in zip(out, value)] assert matvec(a, out) == sums return out def check_spectrum(): reports = [] count = 0 for shape in ((2, 2), (3, 3), (4, 4), (2, 3, 4), (3, 3, 3)): a, _ = marginal_matrix(shape) basis = [one_factor_basis(q) for q in shape] null_count = 0 spectral_multiplicity = {} for labels in product(*(range(q) for q in shape)): v = tensor_vector(shape, basis, labels) expected_eigenvalue = sum(q for q, label in zip(shape, labels) if label == 0) lhs = transpose_matvec(a, matvec(a, v)) assert lhs == [expected_eigenvalue * x for x in v] spectral_multiplicity[expected_eigenvalue] = spectral_multiplicity.get( expected_eigenvalue, 0) + 1 null_count += expected_eigenvalue == 0 count += 1 expected_nullity = prod(q - 1 for q in shape) actual_rank = rank(a) assert null_count == expected_nullity assert actual_rank == prod(shape) - expected_nullity assert min(e for e in spectral_multiplicity if e) == min(shape) reports.append({"shape": list(shape), "N": prod(shape), "rank": actual_rank, "kernel_dimension": expected_nullity, "gram_eigenvalues_and_multiplicities": spectral_multiplicity}) return {"exact_eigenvector_cases": count, "shapes": reports} def check_separable_channels(): reports = [] for shape in ((2, 2), (3, 3), (4, 4), (2, 3, 4), (3, 4, 4), (3, 3, 3)): a, _ = marginal_matrix(shape) xs = points(shape) for m in range(1, min(shape) + 1): stacked = [] coordinate_ranks = [] for q in shape: coordinate_ranks.append(rank([[(x + 1) ** j for x in range(q)] for j in range(m)])) for j in range(m): # All coordinate factors are strictly positive Vandermonde rows. mask = [prod((x[i] + 1) ** j for i in range(len(shape))) for x in xs] assert min(mask) > 0 stacked.extend([[F(value) * weight for value, weight in zip(row, mask)] for row in a]) expected_nullity = prod(q - r for q, r in zip(shape, coordinate_ranks)) actual_nullity = prod(shape) - rank(stacked) assert actual_nullity == expected_nullity assert expected_nullity == prod(max(q - m, 0) for q in shape) reports.append({"shape": list(shape), "channels": m, "coordinate_ranks": coordinate_ranks, "joint_nullity": actual_nullity}) # Repeating a proportional channel adds no information. repeated = a + [[3 * x for x in row] for row in a] assert rank(repeated) == rank(a) # Highlighted strict obstructions and their exact endpoints. summary = {(tuple(r['shape']), r['channels']): r['joint_nullity'] for r in reports} assert summary[((3, 3), 2)] == 1 and summary[((3, 3), 3)] == 0 assert summary[((4, 4), 3)] == 1 and summary[((4, 4), 4)] == 0 assert summary[((2, 3, 4), 2)] == 0 return {"stacked_rank_cases": len(reports), "proportional_channel_counterexamples": 6, "cases": reports} def check_scalar_completion(): rng = random.Random(20102026) completed = probe_count = orthogonality_checks = null_probe_tests = 0 examples = [] for shape in ((2, 2), (3, 3), (4, 4), (2, 3, 4), (3, 3, 3)): a, _ = marginal_matrix(shape) basis = [one_factor_basis(q) for q in shape] hidden = [tensor_vector(shape, basis, labels) for labels in product(*(range(1, q) for q in shape))] expected_d = prod(q - 1 for q in shape) assert len(hidden) == expected_d for i, u in enumerate(hidden): assert matvec(a, u) == [0] * len(a) for v in hidden[:i]: assert dot(u, v) == 0 orthogonality_checks += 1 for repetition in range(4): z = [F(rng.randrange(1, 100), rng.randrange(1, 20)) for _ in range(prod(shape))] sums = matvec(a, z) visible = observable_from_marginals(shape, sums) for h in hidden: assert dot(h, visible) == 0 total = sum(sums[:prod(shape) // shape[0]], F(0)) assert total == sum(z, F(0)) out = list(visible) for h in hidden: alpha = F(1, 1 + max(map(abs, h))) mask = [1 + alpha * x for x in h] assert min(mask) > 0 and max(mask) < 2 assert sum(mask, F(0)) == prod(shape) measured = dot(mask, z) coefficient = (measured - total) / (alpha * dot(h, h)) out = [x + coefficient * y for x, y in zip(out, h)] probe_count += 1 assert out == z completed += 1 # Omitting one orthogonal completion leaves a concrete positive # indistinguishable pair, illustrating the general rank lower bound. omitted = repetition % len(hidden) delta = min(z) / (2 * max(map(abs, hidden[omitted]))) alternative = [x + delta * y for x, y in zip(z, hidden[omitted])] assert min(alternative) > 0 and alternative != z assert matvec(a, alternative) == sums for i, h in enumerate(hidden): if i != omitted: assert dot(h, alternative) == dot(h, z) null_probe_tests += 1 examples.append({"shape": list(shape), "necessary_and_sufficient_extra_scalars": expected_d}) return {"positive_tensor_reconstructions": completed, "positive_mask_scalar_probes": probe_count, "orthogonality_checks": orthogonality_checks, "missing_probe_nonuniqueness_examples": null_probe_tests, "dimensions": examples} def check_bounded_fourier_completion(): """Exact fourth-root-of-unity cases of the general Fourier construction. Shapes use only 2 and 4, so real/imaginary character values are integers; no trigonometric approximation or complex floating point is involved. """ reports = [] noise_equalities = 0 rho = F(1, 2) roots = ((1, 0), (0, 1), (-1, 0), (0, -1)) for shape in ((2, 2), (4, 4), (2, 4, 4), (4, 4, 4)): xs = points(shape) a, _ = marginal_matrix(shape) contrasts = [] for frequency in product(*(range(1, q) for q in shape)): conjugate = tuple((-k) % q for k, q in zip(frequency, shape)) if frequency > conjugate: continue real, imag = [], [] for x in xs: phase = sum((4 // q) * k * xi for q, k, xi in zip(shape, frequency, x)) % 4 re, im = roots[phase] real.append(F(re)) imag.append(F(im)) contrasts.append(real) if frequency != conjugate: contrasts.append(imag) assert len(contrasts) == prod(q - 1 for q in shape) for i, h in enumerate(contrasts): assert matvec(a, h) == [0] * len(a) assert dot(h, h) in (prod(shape), F(prod(shape), 2)) for other in contrasts[:i]: assert dot(h, other) == 0 z = [F(2 + (i * 7) % 23, 5) for i in range(prod(shape))] visible = observable_from_marginals(shape, matvec(a, z)) total = sum(z, F(0)) reconstructed = list(visible) for h in contrasts: mask = [1 + rho * x for x in h] assert min(mask) >= F(1, 2) and max(mask) <= F(3, 2) coefficient = (dot(mask, z) - total) / (rho * dot(h, h)) reconstructed = [x + coefficient * y for x, y in zip(reconstructed, h)] assert reconstructed == z # Single-coordinate noise on a non-self-conjugate mode attains the # uniform sqrt(2/N)/rho bound. Binary-only shapes have the stronger one. target = min(contrasts, key=lambda h: dot(h, h)) epsilon = F(1, 1000) perturbation = [epsilon * x / (rho * dot(target, target)) for x in target] actual_error_squared = dot(perturbation, perturbation) exact_bound_squared = epsilon ** 2 / (rho ** 2 * dot(target, target)) assert actual_error_squared == exact_bound_squared if dot(target, target) == F(prod(shape), 2): assert actual_error_squared == 2 * epsilon ** 2 / (rho ** 2 * prod(shape)) noise_equalities += 1 reports.append({"shape": list(shape), "positive_probes": len(contrasts), "minimum_contrast_norm_squared": str(dot(target, target)), "recovered_exactly": True}) return {"exact_fourier_cases": len(reports), "sharp_noise_equalities": noise_equalities, "cases": reports} def run(): return {"status": "PASS", "arithmetic": "exact integers/Fractions", "spectrum": check_spectrum(), "separable_channels": check_separable_channels(), "scalar_completion": check_scalar_completion(), "bounded_fourier_completion": check_bounded_fourier_completion(), "scope": "Finite checks support proofs; no priority or physical-sensor optimality claim."} if __name__ == '__main__': print(json.dumps(run(), indent=2, sort_keys=True))