{ "scope": "Necessary positional certificates, not an opacity decision procedure and not a solution of the minimum opaque-barrier problem.", "arithmetic": "Exact formulas evaluated in float64; numerical tests do not replace the analytic proofs.", "runtime": { "python": "3.12.14", "numpy": "2.3.5", "scipy": "1.17.0" }, "summary": { "all_assertions_passed": true, "analytic_cases": 6, "random_cases": 100, "positive_collinear_overlap_rejected": true, "max_random_quadrature_discrepancy": 2.6645352591003757e-15, "max_random_symmetry_discrepancy": 2.6645352591003757e-15, "actual_opaque_examples": 3 }, "analytic_cases": [ { "case": "parallel unit segments, separation 1", "expected": 0.8284271247461903, "endpoint_formula": 0.8284271247461903, "independent_quadrature": 0.8284271247461898, "quadrature_reported_error": 9.197388681172368e-15 }, { "case": "crossing orthogonal diameters of length 2", "expected": 2.3431457505076194, "endpoint_formula": 2.3431457505076194, "independent_quadrature": 2.34314575050762, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.601414362266152e-14 }, { "case": "right-triangle adjacent legs", "expected": 0.5857864376269049, "endpoint_formula": 0.5857864376269049, "independent_quadrature": 0.5857864376269049, "quadrature_reported_error": 6.50353590566538e-15 }, { "case": "collinear shared endpoint", "expected": 0.0, "endpoint_formula": 0.0, "independent_quadrature": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 0.0 }, { "case": "collinear disjoint segments", "expected": 0.0, "endpoint_formula": 0.0, "independent_quadrature": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 0.0 }, { "case": "degenerate isolated point", "expected": 0.0, "endpoint_formula": 0.0, "independent_quadrature": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 0.0 } ], "random_cases": [ { "index": 0, "first": [ [ -0.4468469859068067, 2.7638224228105006 ], [ 2.867691333756259, 2.1711630614953714 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.8217831760226755, -0.03546857480273591 ], [ -1.865922256578637, 1.6394356559868095 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.114051712773268, "independent_quadrature": 4.114051712773268, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.567514936019443e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 1, "first": [ [ -0.9422919322282626, -0.39994278185699494 ], [ 0.2635127758732745, -2.939837425261449 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.8213007391904954, 0.1654399137484095 ], [ 2.8950233868704753, 0.5645690904161733 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.24685075102487097, "independent_quadrature": 0.2468507510248709, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.326672684688674e-17, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.7405938743382363e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 2, "first": [ [ -2.5302051017883196, 0.6340877601802677 ], [ -1.3821077816646457, -2.052470391203479 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.15329506148451788, 0.373501119184819 ], [ 1.4326472753283053, -0.05699406593372469 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.9006124413018495, "independent_quadrature": 0.9006124413018495, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 9.998806685971857e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 3, "first": [ [ 1.6108631063212284, -0.3773317904741962 ], [ -2.242532703755285, -2.9474046206822746 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.2531276208907434, -1.9114750527953805 ], [ 2.640498777423268, -0.5111477630880463 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.4684391607510996, "independent_quadrature": 1.4684391607510991, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.6302949665271118e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 4, "first": [ [ 0.21289816673486772, -1.8076030653570316 ], [ -2.1592409470422966, -2.2164074648705423 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.07954183619551047, 2.397826403531048 ], [ -1.0530730736415943, -1.6666077181040249 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.5910272670602037, "independent_quadrature": 1.5910272670602037, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.766395104696676e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 5, "first": [ [ -2.096278766890631, 1.6825148117072946 ], [ 2.5393374916133826, -0.13502094019032418 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.855941808134772, -0.34514583863946147 ], [ 2.1297847713373637, 0.4709607481214939 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 7.370179349753792, "independent_quadrature": 7.37017934975379, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.6645352591003757e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 8.182542809713521e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 6, "first": [ [ -2.67258470176568, 0.6546835040874086 ], [ -1.3980563958592331, -1.4655561374187347 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.937035350647955, 1.7896880111358957 ], [ -0.7164206526733796, -1.6854606372237377 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.2469437251375863, "independent_quadrature": 2.2469437251375863, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.4946086586847674e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 7, "first": [ [ 1.6537927465851112, 1.9341652310201294 ], [ 0.710363534602724, -2.4748446955626955 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.4377647291949054, 1.1529979006308233 ], [ -2.100837466771831, 0.10975817673732635 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.9935051527302337, "independent_quadrature": 0.9935051527302327, "absolute_discrepancy": 9.992007221626409e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.103012295644837e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 8, "first": [ [ 2.870055486707666, -2.016640711332311 ], [ 1.3111444296565544, 2.360729525095077 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.4712758883230679, -1.6437962729573543 ], [ 2.237289406559843, 1.0185490628156675 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.4127317357808815, "independent_quadrature": 4.412731735780881, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.899116374558067e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 9, "first": [ [ 1.187315693447843, -1.1907201673421697 ], [ -2.610496519258464, 0.5785025440581251 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.633387531202534, 2.9363076025592214 ], [ -1.7228195096576409, 2.4985832020178327 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.6825752800404317, "independent_quadrature": 0.6825752800404317, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 7.578107919408513e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 10, "first": [ [ -2.303718993378788, -2.2343829644409245 ], [ -2.198372061764461, 0.30796453161561743 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.7376914393224245, 1.0831969787993874 ], [ -1.9835086428071713, 1.7616539911878633 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.14823005943173895, "independent_quadrature": 0.14823005943173861, "absolute_discrepancy": 3.3306690738754696e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.6456842492267157e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 11, "first": [ [ -2.2023149562262816, 2.4521192871648614 ], [ -2.986532479966132, -1.3747173236771932 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.37213004117966086, 0.5756456410950621 ], [ -2.6070128028684465, -1.9240595364195476 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.425303831473445, "independent_quadrature": 4.425303831473445, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.9130742046637425e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 12, "first": [ [ -1.0923270682245108, -0.04948877634712945 ], [ -2.2749845388357337, 1.6730794096800574 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.537148588321884, -1.740884143570464 ], [ 2.1144487168351285, -2.4190481005634896 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.1178816042822537, "independent_quadrature": 0.11788160428225308, "absolute_discrepancy": 6.106226635438361e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.3087487125390883e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 13, "first": [ [ 1.3879492754799303, -1.774566684012445 ], [ -2.223041481612781, -2.921954184283419 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.2924244708473438, 1.5527373414536862 ], [ -0.730066312903614, -0.7776647460592456 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.4071574936614337, "independent_quadrature": 1.407157493661435, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.3322676295501878e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.562258648736753e-14, "symmetry_error": 2.6645352591003757e-15 }, { "index": 14, "first": [ [ 2.084351340292728, 1.829161313290502 ], [ -1.6527169109470865, -2.5856649895793202 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.232264196971105, -1.5509112703914678 ], [ -1.2448176797074522, 1.177689210381959 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.689608514896562, "independent_quadrature": 4.689608514896562, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.2065113497163495e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 15, "first": [ [ 1.4292240455711998, -0.9075925656676285 ], [ -1.1118664938376042, -0.8928415759938488 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.26360919499834834, -0.8683050397921921 ], [ 2.510078794965114, -1.1578805741644589 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.376806655433738, "independent_quadrature": 3.3768066554337373, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 3.7490084985700025e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 16, "first": [ [ -1.223290592815104, -0.4760287011455051 ], [ 0.8686183152303739, 2.621606377462294 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.1977138691458924, -1.6246788416686186 ], [ -0.2978281510101888, 2.336788476004907 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 5.321271178632153, "independent_quadrature": 5.321271178632152, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.907797782791659e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 17, "first": [ [ -2.351979830070422, -2.605146607472648 ], [ 1.9243462001612945, -0.8837957278547881 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.3685500298860114, -0.5771853204752286 ], [ 1.3691616601074035, 0.6861310826325537 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.5690580436625319, "independent_quadrature": 1.5690580436625308, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.1102230246251565e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.742004367047446e-14, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 18, "first": [ [ -2.905497103919463, 1.8287990169551724 ], [ -0.13907869763435654, -2.3736346180629058 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.30384289879221527, -2.667792067713713 ], [ -1.0508040278691537, -0.20983949715977612 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.5846744802196255, "independent_quadrature": 4.584674480219626, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.0900111683512004e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 19, "first": [ [ 2.401450668607067, 1.313212837592733 ], [ 1.4138411840869534, 0.6808094412836994 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.6872435573742006, 2.724200599310657 ], [ -1.9464470816214117, -0.9368347956257956 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.70136870024221, "independent_quadrature": 0.7013687002422109, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 7.78675679760322e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 20, "first": [ [ 0.5313017951294796, 0.852266011385808 ], [ 0.04198034349316648, 1.9131739409148638 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.4562545602176786, 0.16997067546409728 ], [ 2.9201704500670598, -2.8699815787327925 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.9799895535520111, "independent_quadrature": 0.9799895535520098, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.3322676295501878e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.0880069662455691e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 21, "first": [ [ -0.7123011876273528, -1.727594644620519 ], [ -0.731969137678862, -0.09836143207004167 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.1707923794830446, -0.6485047084881943 ], [ -1.8742563336933582, 2.751273890751996 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.2801436871230092, "independent_quadrature": 1.280143687123009, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.421244996272507e-14, "symmetry_error": 6.661338147750939e-16 }, { "index": 22, "first": [ [ 1.3258199691839945, -0.6301006857635594 ], [ -1.4250060328806673, -2.486453640696657 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.00043533431685460755, -1.0540444182003936 ], [ -2.4148021318987194, -2.7931542907742077 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.9140523223231822, "independent_quadrature": 3.914052322323181, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.3322676295501878e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.34547100783076e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 23, "first": [ [ 0.8635830856434286, 2.956670916739659 ], [ 0.7697513464839032, -1.9471401629550997 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.7864867808846974, 2.4770658775937893 ], [ 2.7286113888999157, 0.5939706441835053 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.6819822672513416, "independent_quadrature": 2.681982267251342, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.97759846473882e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 24, "first": [ [ 2.408138922795894, -2.4981011069669328 ], [ 0.9181235871243225, -1.8758606948639527 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.0913736428337082, -1.9199960716351163 ], [ -0.5834042360293328, 2.763639631779454 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.5162076748081224, "independent_quadrature": 0.5162076748081217, "absolute_discrepancy": 6.661338147750939e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.731056460601921e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 25, "first": [ [ -0.6024460948100243, -2.1176655885120237 ], [ -1.7880426700292575, -1.8432345121776346 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.0993649252571478, -1.0783553514693998 ], [ -0.6173976771298362, 1.6322852155216863 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.8650331742522406, "independent_quadrature": 0.8650331742522401, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 9.603797471194221e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 26, "first": [ [ 2.5883828930338515, 2.029593944690747 ], [ -2.0904712719175973, 0.8888677958778874 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.8376436717249773, -0.09634891397393108 ], [ -0.554959747588029, -2.822172623358475 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.1681768657422062, "independent_quadrature": 2.1681768657422062, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.4071598778066042e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 27, "first": [ [ 0.39447749826225076, 1.6244386819792647 ], [ -2.4716259756949084, -2.375675177769677 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.0246325066649833, 1.872813042405805 ], [ 0.06677634255573928, -1.3460904639567939 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.786275983730935, "independent_quadrature": 4.786275983730936, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.313833799348506e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 28, "first": [ [ 2.196233073436928, -1.0141371426750159 ], [ -2.0743889640448945, 2.807901107496212 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.699889238962503, -2.963958451846798 ], [ -1.5178774665142107, -0.5956497981593305 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 5.765577841706117, "independent_quadrature": 5.765577841706116, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 6.401077270130746e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 29, "first": [ [ 1.6121049378181542, 2.6673830177630977 ], [ 1.388738641130578, 1.6245648054002153 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.291029875964912, -2.9612945191648237 ], [ -1.0515997331366653, 1.6641392140405245 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.5641554493811878, "independent_quadrature": 0.5641554493811878, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 6.263383693707467e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 30, "first": [ [ -1.152704052708308, 1.4578795862123215 ], [ 0.23875823700514243, 0.7126805042873388 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.556624479365663, 0.3581384746675478 ], [ 1.1272652460205954, -2.674539926776439 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.41495328450987, "independent_quadrature": 0.4149532845098714, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.3877787807814457e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.606906906066925e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 31, "first": [ [ 2.914047386053949, -0.9808305869819662 ], [ -0.5547868022768396, 2.8243734697625555 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.2754156254381128, 0.17979468683766608 ], [ -1.719145025648349, -1.7548481357437915 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.633786965004008, "independent_quadrature": 1.6337869650040093, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.3322676295501878e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.813867905879906e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 32, "first": [ [ 1.9518703531341162, -2.6201915104657196 ], [ -1.9630198710730467, -0.47423870340744 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.11586687446147437, -1.652802212378369 ], [ -2.055482182922921, 2.5609798870225386 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.3579027011486815, "independent_quadrature": 4.3579027011486815, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.8382439178914285e-14, "symmetry_error": 1.7763568394002505e-15 }, { "index": 33, "first": [ [ 2.3363358324388006, -1.0306211603411264 ], [ 2.9615400794114475, -1.4031741100164816 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.0533725835513623, -0.3292606452396938 ], [ -2.7003133910619246, -1.4317586100045512 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.11812632037160586, "independent_quadrature": 0.11812632037160564, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.3114656069080425e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 34, "first": [ [ -2.9082601856615398, 2.396355112981145 ], [ -0.6303255006647959, -2.980763095624163 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.570104495900715, -2.556545656121295 ], [ 2.549087601093243, -1.63286161667946 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.826680792310218, "independent_quadrature": 0.8266807923102184, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 9.178000496381715e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 35, "first": [ [ -1.785740968994696, -2.600285980985719 ], [ -1.2343933863901788, -1.6331808551488909 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.6589268506287267, -0.23203028481596188 ], [ 2.9567787269714207, 2.065967646248012 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.1646233516840141, "independent_quadrature": 0.16462335168401382, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.7755575615628914e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.8276863543055667e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 36, "first": [ [ 0.20858315295654517, 0.8836754829097146 ], [ 2.0983330941190967, 2.3447640707354225 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.938751286637117, 0.3972404492938182 ], [ 2.1426114209613463, 2.4728565704201007 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.7936791170055004, "independent_quadrature": 3.793679117005501, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.21182990373914e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 37, "first": [ [ -0.743814187928499, -2.466055633890243 ], [ -0.8355991700941452, -0.4408110111910011 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.1318916863257982, 0.40470380751610957 ], [ -2.504776471905959, 1.8992974608333935 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.16820588052467111, "independent_quadrature": 0.16820588052467067, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.8674604143583757e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 38, "first": [ [ 1.9478236658812467, 1.9125471855117286 ], [ -1.8035861994012174, -2.6711237898098523 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.9990273733542838, 0.831744814679896 ], [ -0.42212590026161934, 0.922950764105297 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.3536992177101244, "independent_quadrature": 2.353699217710124, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.6131310645439987e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 39, "first": [ [ -0.9777816876522571, 0.8615203236173361 ], [ -2.1064422447030595, -1.9689554139353413 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.432375472987059, 2.8039941171731186 ], [ -2.4149595243505386, -0.9944066529749804 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.530362614438129, "independent_quadrature": 4.530362614438127, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.7763568394002505e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.02971288445023e-14, "symmetry_error": 1.7763568394002505e-15 }, { "index": 40, "first": [ [ 0.7165588997174659, -2.113717349069634 ], [ 1.7340103587103473, -1.3630524230993293 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.0630869853108287, -1.85036089656909 ], [ -1.7273300394072133, 2.16082698646931 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.7429491869394202, "independent_quadrature": 1.7429491869394205, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.935062318091841e-14, "symmetry_error": 2.220446049250313e-16 }, { "index": 41, "first": [ [ 2.969648197218996, -1.5658410751127032 ], [ -2.50781821227808, -0.722191544790924 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.285760764293962, 2.2043165446746853 ], [ 1.7317859806288434, -2.2900871784737973 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 7.783502786750057, "independent_quadrature": 7.783502786750056, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 8.641424006083982e-14, "symmetry_error": 1.7763568394002505e-15 }, { "index": 42, "first": [ [ -1.041453820521063, 2.687581616297569 ], [ 2.286957641541531, -2.8920307146328583 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.8297065743968148, -0.1344328296282784 ], [ 1.5636808275705025, -0.043584098552120754 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.079471320153092, "independent_quadrature": 4.079471320153092, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.529122987931946e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 43, "first": [ [ 0.3471006606824045, 1.4413565790415994 ], [ 2.3376520340561546, -0.39204406377977197 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.2318709706135795, -2.4601545375724445 ], [ 1.5912156411498142, 0.7091739400968748 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.87782856037223, "independent_quadrature": 2.87782856037223, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 3.195031528649117e-14, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 44, "first": [ [ -1.6609449315868687, 0.571651933663591 ], [ -2.2309313802864423, -1.2162030189996968 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.9923068333315506, -0.2583673760558769 ], [ -2.3399091681386057, 2.424677651550631 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.4998783306504782, "independent_quadrature": 1.4998783306504784, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.6651994568245046e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 45, "first": [ [ -1.886624784748076, -1.1459657590697638 ], [ -2.337381324150174, -2.892500518365133 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.17651448447507923, 1.7028844042973583 ], [ -2.706524860099714, -2.881591171153299 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.3904000421339884, "independent_quadrature": 3.390400042133988, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 3.764100189467255e-14, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 46, "first": [ [ 1.495348989157625, -1.4138491510247144 ], [ -1.344167613365495, -0.8499741260806286 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.5174722973108956, 2.44047019588145 ], [ -2.4676771461015643, -2.9886303742171574 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.790085840590907, "independent_quadrature": 4.790085840590907, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.3180635901549717e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 47, "first": [ [ -1.6268621871956124, 1.295120617908811 ], [ -1.6830883992252843, -2.7881683076984007 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.5194074088574094, 1.5646316959434774 ], [ 1.3583709407746118, -1.2794117102865108 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.612676045227528, "independent_quadrature": 4.612676045227529, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.1210991505485125e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 48, "first": [ [ -1.5268630306994175, 1.1140086982275212 ], [ -0.6087420459862871, 0.39313319790815315 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.1348916810979972, 1.2718031618349457 ], [ -2.0061033376158965, -2.285244581257262 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.2088154183679918, "independent_quadrature": 1.208815418367992, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.3420547099940361e-14, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 49, "first": [ [ 0.8387615846439034, -2.3638000252069173 ], [ 1.3516624833810038, -2.939322831752697 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.39755183556068197, -1.0111739378718116 ], [ -1.8439764872810755, -0.4544445197392917 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.05805312228706838, "independent_quadrature": 0.058053122287068694, "absolute_discrepancy": 3.122502256758253e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 6.445191301448349e-16, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 50, "first": [ [ -0.5304766018877092, 0.6287836870642689 ], [ 1.6777159076057906, 2.6647755033064886 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.3068112477090637, -0.5940751547703762 ], [ 0.4675983754457147, 0.6625118262086747 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.8733687929113577, "independent_quadrature": 0.8733687929113573, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 9.696341428792691e-15, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 51, "first": [ [ -1.1317394513398742, -2.447735175964292 ], [ -2.459008242664636, -0.2513522635072949 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.8805202238418648, 0.31836165053951415 ], [ -0.6096667089502485, -1.5085499754920917 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.021290678104749, "independent_quadrature": 1.0212906781047488, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.1338604256669313e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 52, "first": [ [ 1.1330319610009347, 0.9572187484834376 ], [ 1.4158933734926276, -1.308161805812597 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.4931828811867645, -0.9020159012480016 ], [ -2.2064974451126, -2.002264895946402 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.6289323521886181, "independent_quadrature": 0.6289323521886179, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 6.982551783314615e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 53, "first": [ [ -0.2493980982749342, -2.617882179579344 ], [ -1.7067725142375405, -2.1742458580517106 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.4081628362349843, -1.8791551764325924 ], [ 2.437591332201597, 0.9112619086079063 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.41522858114658756, "independent_quadrature": 0.4152285811465871, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.609963312713763e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 54, "first": [ [ -0.3362383163995615, -1.360220667858155 ], [ -0.23887431410451976, 1.7411090982706776 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.7667227052874517, 1.5881091500389024 ], [ -2.6660522758157104, -1.2840064720352489 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.977424481212469, "independent_quadrature": 3.977424481212469, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.415828237749851e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 55, "first": [ [ 2.7137443317969847, -1.0651780832502302 ], [ 1.642004733047436, -0.8780515468315979 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.37582340077605414, 0.4734871481932945 ], [ 0.9387104982204408, 0.006399400621864171 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.015483304470237158, "independent_quadrature": 0.01548330447023667, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.874572967494828e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.7189921120138365e-16, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 56, "first": [ [ -2.2730337832380174, -1.2722440344792967 ], [ 1.4918805562896749, 1.2118781719078706 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.9499238038225686, 0.8527671005368735 ], [ 2.242182321726519, 0.33105090836976725 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 6.8226856795187905, "independent_quadrature": 6.8226856795187905, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 7.574702731182093e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 57, "first": [ [ -2.9625900107517937, 1.4714475619740384 ], [ -1.2004079043926055, 2.686573266769315 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.18379329254812182, 2.090156678670202 ], [ -1.42705698226732, -1.8319644524687695 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.549555039734982, "independent_quadrature": 2.549555039734982, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.8305747076628828e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 58, "first": [ [ 0.1762130348890234, -0.53467103129086 ], [ 0.7680239105119719, -0.8626030731880396 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.1313516975745952, 1.742394020971223 ], [ -2.6507663137244277, 1.7205579930414805 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.07049141949965998, "independent_quadrature": 0.07049141949965937, "absolute_discrepancy": 6.106226635438361e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 7.826119696703256e-16, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 59, "first": [ [ 0.1276374505434985, -2.7911558987966254 ], [ 2.166417273463642, -2.922298209044292 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.2753820763358128, -2.149696862684379 ], [ 0.5841546427857782, 1.0772526818714363 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.8980711995708359, "independent_quadrature": 0.8980711995708363, "absolute_discrepancy": 3.3306690738754696e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 9.970593235162764e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 60, "first": [ [ 0.9022071770034739, -1.9478427147397819 ], [ 0.8679269802042775, -1.2758144780200509 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.9919676291591877, -2.824098778042129 ], [ -2.8135804835562883, -2.1883543710768456 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.604045709392575, "independent_quadrature": 0.604045709392575, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 6.706254544936729e-15, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 61, "first": [ [ 0.21034488253175, -2.3687715868944528 ], [ -1.3300065433189168, 0.8680158533822127 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.2508590013880916, 2.94945225379501 ], [ 0.4867879021099366, 2.65095165146965 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.102261187631159, "independent_quadrature": 1.1022611876311588, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.2237557496587824e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 62, "first": [ [ -1.1934509014805303, 2.0629144905783114 ], [ 0.08347758532054517, -0.498843217249485 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.8895229344109674, -2.5530728742772384 ], [ 2.765702949484905, 2.069949687357129 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.659558384105666, "independent_quadrature": 3.659558384105665, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.062925977994142e-14, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 63, "first": [ [ -0.7601061357135688, -2.5365656568808266 ], [ 2.015523013646188, 1.1928079550455353 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.33829853128558973, 0.6806137153120035 ], [ -2.7763089210566907, 0.043555887317014985 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.3092088845981342, "independent_quadrature": 3.309208884598133, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.3322676295501878e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 3.6739598969749796e-14, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 64, "first": [ [ -0.5751271455545321, 0.9457076644842868 ], [ -2.7670747238271067, -1.6894198987363611 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.2272286111084547, 2.3552040728247468 ], [ 1.5574586941415545, 2.001475984541777 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.09061162091603014, "independent_quadrature": 0.09061162091603074, "absolute_discrepancy": 5.967448757360216e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.0059910783958374e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 65, "first": [ [ -1.0479976863365243, -0.8796295138011527 ], [ 0.3658513858062946, 1.5349643630749759 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.6063772038342856, -0.2606374522609478 ], [ 0.10364248792709185, 0.7893677122575049 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.6685800410450362, "independent_quadrature": 1.6685800410450355, "absolute_discrepancy": 6.661338147750939e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.8524959799981872e-14, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 66, "first": [ [ 1.6631508624988118, -1.9886588671174428 ], [ -0.4701670837680245, -0.8287349441161806 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.340604362778681, -2.3823921753041946 ], [ -2.1036424384168617, -2.010107384694332 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.178971493690176, "independent_quadrature": 4.178971493690176, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.639590371547015e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 67, "first": [ [ 2.5720120425480335, 1.000131439104794 ], [ 1.7763562485824362, 2.0795025414159545 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.503916765423872, -2.0275395004655477 ], [ 2.1042679236920634, -0.6861437443328584 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.10747838956962874, "independent_quadrature": 0.10747838956962827, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.718447854656915e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.1932498274983357e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 68, "first": [ [ -1.1888145952334255, -1.6598575095292951 ], [ 2.7616772343837708, 1.3460687612001 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.5024336151033264, -2.5476134934385537 ], [ 1.90200998439368, -0.2070598397390957 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.231634361412781, "independent_quadrature": 4.231634361412781, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.6980578998354407e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 69, "first": [ [ 2.086034471662261, 0.5866177349118082 ], [ -1.2697032145697158, 0.12204142292052422 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.8225379007150142, -1.433622368895342 ], [ -1.372081881180997, 0.9945712864208316 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.941404482622092, "independent_quadrature": 4.941404482622091, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.4860610305930044e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 70, "first": [ [ 0.8128231953583152, -1.682133021172577 ], [ 2.0209732659161617, 1.0130980186211715 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.4279317822485256, -2.8292719657864875 ], [ -2.460395226512338, 1.5200254357161418 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.714999106138643, "independent_quadrature": 2.714999106138643, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 3.01425451947184e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 71, "first": [ [ 2.1741980827315386, -0.4509553403047004 ], [ -0.5975133010875235, 0.12338472539080847 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.933086551641348, 1.6065147950866665 ], [ -2.9475466924648224, -0.9407646125130906 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.8897188331078667, "independent_quadrature": 0.8897188331078666, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.1102230246251565e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 9.877863339589804e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 72, "first": [ [ -0.34287922347076094, -2.000120339475724 ], [ 2.9733638763625505, -0.7975543422442302 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.9366335573549514, -1.9499172137892098 ], [ -2.3572538767542124, 1.589524939547501 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.7243994208575253, "independent_quadrature": 1.724399420857525, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.9144679406863094e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 73, "first": [ [ 0.9602935802691919, -2.3279402647814535 ], [ -2.198913383684406, 2.846625622572949 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.080229595744738, -2.95057391331194 ], [ 2.1963081964457096, -1.4449290850151078 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.4753016928070257, "independent_quadrature": 1.475301692807026, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.6379139076228297e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 74, "first": [ [ -1.7215915528728045, -2.293780626689209 ], [ 1.9722604058178064, 1.7436920194944285 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.5448422648946973, 1.6851828964109004 ], [ -2.216263349566873, 0.39777145639557343 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 6.379406585296727, "independent_quadrature": 6.379406585296727, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 7.082564074441775e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 75, "first": [ [ -0.12207961102438336, 2.8508168828640725 ], [ 2.046805587836479, 2.3895763620428854 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.9736435732419844, -2.712069149513499 ], [ -1.475307781193513, -1.2580939690981547 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.11222211763058532, "independent_quadrature": 0.1122221176305871, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.790234627208065e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.2459157886567053e-15, "symmetry_error": 1.7763568394002505e-15 }, { "index": 76, "first": [ [ -2.7124284973137205, 1.6682648881067381 ], [ 1.6095516701909052, -1.3004549579388591 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.5935764786288398, -0.29972791787249475 ], [ -1.081380874520516, 1.789050295728794 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.732513919497854, "independent_quadrature": 3.732513919497854, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.1439228931604054e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 77, "first": [ [ -2.200610456262424, -2.4611815895821323 ], [ -1.5744624071379325, -1.6615264380281656 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.6560616039002558, -2.5131204787918744 ], [ 2.7699024012528994, 0.8489878675233751 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.2627555107394222, "independent_quadrature": 1.2627555107394222, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.4019402424952057e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 78, "first": [ [ 2.593140359129265, 1.4245081017181498 ], [ 2.121333651802635, -1.7694413298277232 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.43439153173583, 2.4118995383641657 ], [ -2.5040988935126434, -1.2291899303411697 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.1499045244177504, "independent_quadrature": 2.149904524417751, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.386873503754384e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 79, "first": [ [ -0.13123170318371535, -2.98471698253731 ], [ -2.5656294481943496, 0.784754919229774 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.5299100211998415, 2.4141986426463315 ], [ 1.7182880223487693, -1.075920650185441 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.9537306254751163, "independent_quadrature": 3.9537306254751163, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.3895227735680954e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 80, "first": [ [ -0.9115462724307708, 2.8865336771291368 ], [ 1.9412236532307832, -0.26928720047050403 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.840408300090071, -1.7487972574589516 ], [ 1.1490956879953877, 1.9954657808104628 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.780661908070584, "independent_quadrature": 4.7806619080705826, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.7763568394002505e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.307600923288394e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 81, "first": [ [ -0.779105205854556, 0.3709313457057948 ], [ -2.148955771441982, 0.9578783133180604 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.39786949348550893, 0.9525581789501656 ], [ 1.6098866329741695, 2.7726499852346613 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.4475407293745177, "independent_quadrature": 0.4475407293745175, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.968700222091255e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 82, "first": [ [ 2.9637129778577993, 0.4840471105922184 ], [ 1.04665203350479, 0.8707321704915651 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.7961400838783748, 0.929236804420329 ], [ -1.4207054676717308, 2.1914035079126712 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.06239588874389246, "independent_quadrature": 0.062395888743892715, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.5673907444456745e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 6.927335232541932e-16, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 83, "first": [ [ -1.7206730040939278, -0.6272233686867725 ], [ 0.3013991747201681, -1.9924587076156146 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.05091643670602597, -2.218988369068626 ], [ 0.3911702861241029, -0.8244366518160007 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.7872431641630082, "independent_quadrature": 1.7872431641630084, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.9842385114576903e-14, "symmetry_error": 2.220446049250313e-16 }, { "index": 84, "first": [ [ 2.566586882377588, 1.0400672869881298 ], [ -1.92123240172072, 2.262886797944076 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.9891864196352875, 0.046247775732037866 ], [ 0.20068639552292566, 1.9046761603654838 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.9487319063405577, "independent_quadrature": 2.948731906340558, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 3.273750055866118e-14, "symmetry_error": 1.3322676295501878e-15 }, { "index": 85, "first": [ [ 1.0864692377261704, -1.5658774219649818 ], [ -0.03910865081521564, -0.8209872361371859 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.7164921856093542, 2.4445432593912635 ], [ -0.6455310411581081, -1.3208238904720877 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.384017046839943, "independent_quadrature": 1.3840170468399435, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.536567591875419e-14, "symmetry_error": 4.440892098500626e-16 }, { "index": 86, "first": [ [ 1.8229308703107456, -1.5142123209217166 ], [ -2.3282884696517687, -0.6827032105008013 ] ], "second": [ [ 0.15243688932519817, -2.439625410601489 ], [ 0.9896741891125274, -1.3598176198857772 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.0169571154718895, "independent_quadrature": 2.0169571154718895, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.239272229278432e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 87, "first": [ [ -0.0065449914799469155, 1.3803264194960772 ], [ 1.9224691571461747, -2.2239674079990714 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.140244476747789, -2.0938105473823985 ], [ 2.073159090319196, 0.6341038224495819 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.8148837085966845, "independent_quadrature": 4.814883708596684, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.345594754176601e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 88, "first": [ [ -1.9509996655633985, 2.9233840947862655 ], [ -0.8782931157186651, -1.5799460637814484 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.189721279428404, -2.7741175767619994 ], [ 1.846806319329838, -1.1686382634183816 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.5029576491535783, "independent_quadrature": 2.5029576491535797, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.3322676295501878e-15, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.7788412117519587e-14, "symmetry_error": 1.3322676295501878e-15 }, { "index": 89, "first": [ [ -2.798681271229513, 1.0921068557398819 ], [ -1.8431661197853144, 2.335897858916665 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.0016671015860163507, -0.651862972704766 ], [ 2.0281335665010483, 0.7514735625267299 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.8693443445684834, "independent_quadrature": 0.8693443445684832, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.220446049250313e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 9.651661076675957e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 90, "first": [ [ 0.3764422847298947, -1.958386139200895 ], [ -0.9198357028793782, -1.4010503010387778 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.935073067032934, 1.6957575573068127 ], [ 1.6109925815038881, -0.8169013484388645 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.6766643028215138, "independent_quadrature": 0.676664302821513, "absolute_discrepancy": 7.771561172376096e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 7.512482889343731e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 91, "first": [ [ 2.7442982470120114, 1.2529552779837712 ], [ -2.516683589457495, -1.7426167067465075 ] ], "second": [ [ -2.4678822055355707, -1.2182091381590592 ], [ -0.05868162859280357, -0.9999274831547567 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 4.487336791120935, "independent_quadrature": 4.487336791120935, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.981944624750029e-14, "symmetry_error": 8.881784197001252e-16 }, { "index": 92, "first": [ [ -2.546979625870205, 1.965283122478633 ], [ 2.471894614647243, 0.5722955567346979 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.6619439297967284, 2.4431998386812035 ], [ -2.238643394247631, 0.8026402060662825 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 6.686628369855334, "independent_quadrature": 6.686628369855334, "absolute_discrepancy": 0.0, "quadrature_reported_error": 7.423648773325168e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 93, "first": [ [ -0.8729073090544786, 2.2744741350927855 ], [ 2.142083882279181, -0.5531973513353243 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.880040426349291, 0.7518288095967698 ], [ -2.399683621035395, -1.9684294149038557 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 5.329925867973787, "independent_quadrature": 5.329925867973788, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 5.917406418169722e-14, "symmetry_error": 1.7763568394002505e-15 }, { "index": 94, "first": [ [ -1.9105840263421296, -2.4303730696229096 ], [ -1.9673350382122747, 0.7042079365319465 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.0031607705369754, 2.785882544773031 ], [ 2.3633408698872636, -1.5431747871514956 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 3.514520634762982, "independent_quadrature": 3.514520634762981, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 3.9019017292340815e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 95, "first": [ [ -1.7533327135492882, 1.8119340527338954 ], [ -1.6738352409471993, 0.5827489345964967 ] ], "second": [ [ 1.5273860508905006, -0.8677717977363173 ], [ 0.21229553796737122, 0.8099810565305376 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.41501654114648057, "independent_quadrature": 0.41501654114648073, "absolute_discrepancy": 1.6653345369377348e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.607609195811165e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 96, "first": [ [ 2.4499515848574687, -2.0640609047965146 ], [ 2.0981810753206496, 2.2801222168108692 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.88538976598963, -0.942241565401214 ], [ 1.5894520160145253, -0.541850183349605 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 2.293018731052409, "independent_quadrature": 2.2930187310524093, "absolute_discrepancy": 4.440892098500626e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 2.5457621911111442e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 97, "first": [ [ -1.8674010299984494, -0.2532890430009358 ], [ -0.5960893171501747, -0.11653762579248284 ] ], "second": [ [ -0.6535952938548082, -1.5513201003945218 ], [ -2.663795931804132, 0.11060460022058827 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.693939644886691, "independent_quadrature": 1.6939396448866904, "absolute_discrepancy": 6.661338147750939e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.8806507960785647e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 98, "first": [ [ -0.5289576033428021, 0.10116034812409813 ], [ 0.08110301861771818, -2.8662258951224464 ] ], "second": [ [ 2.2754236053409675, -2.607054035401857 ], [ 1.1097487751199955, -2.5089844051712937 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 0.4022572482391569, "independent_quadrature": 0.4022572482391566, "absolute_discrepancy": 2.7755575615628914e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 4.465952588174688e-15, "symmetry_error": 0.0 }, { "index": 99, "first": [ [ -2.5211163410756514, -2.2249819607105987 ], [ -1.8723205646245802, 0.4558074200080857 ] ], "second": [ [ -1.8761098942698007, -1.275159384925298 ], [ 2.302797979428666, -1.3705664542362388 ] ], "endpoint_formula": 1.7829839949543616, "independent_quadrature": 1.7829839949543624, "absolute_discrepancy": 8.881784197001252e-16, "quadrature_reported_error": 1.979509883736477e-14, "symmetry_error": 0.0 } ], "actual_opaque_examples": { "square_boundary": { "segment_count": 4, "nondegenerate_segment_count": 4, "total_segment_length": 8.0, "pair_overlaps": [ { "i": 0, "j": 1, "Q": 1.1715728752538097 }, { "i": 0, "j": 2, "Q": 1.6568542494923806 }, { "i": 0, "j": 3, "Q": 1.1715728752538097 }, { "i": 1, "j": 2, "Q": 1.1715728752538097 }, { "i": 1, "j": 3, "Q": 1.6568542494923806 }, { "i": 2, "j": 3, "Q": 1.1715728752538097 } ], "pair_energy": 8.0, "maximum_spanning_forest_edges": [ { "i": 0, "j": 2, "Q": 1.6568542494923806 }, { "i": 1, "j": 3, "Q": 1.6568542494923806 }, { "i": 0, "j": 1, "Q": 1.1715728752538097 } ], "maximum_spanning_forest_value": 4.485281374238571, "forest_necessary_lower_bound": 5.384233340709079, "automatic_hit_bound": 4, "automatic_pair_necessary_lower_bound": 5.141592653589793, "opacity_established": false, "arithmetic": "float64 evaluation of exact geometric formulas", "externally_assumed_max_hits": 2, "conditional_pair_necessary_lower_bound": 7.141592653589793, "max_hits_assumption_verified_by_this_code": false, "independent_geometric_facts": "The square boundary surrounds the unit disk, so every line meeting the disk meets the boundary. A line not containing an edge and not through a vertex meets a convex polygon boundary at most twice; the exceptional lines have zero line measure." }, "cross": { "segment_count": 2, "nondegenerate_segment_count": 2, "total_segment_length": 5.656854249492381, "pair_overlaps": [ { "i": 0, "j": 1, "Q": 3.313708498984761 } ], "pair_energy": 3.313708498984761, "maximum_spanning_forest_edges": [ { "i": 0, "j": 1, "Q": 3.313708498984761 } ], "maximum_spanning_forest_value": 3.313708498984761, "forest_necessary_lower_bound": 4.798446903082174, "automatic_hit_bound": 2, "automatic_pair_necessary_lower_bound": 4.798446903082174, "opacity_established": false, "arithmetic": "float64 evaluation of exact geometric formulas", "externally_assumed_max_hits": 2, "conditional_pair_necessary_lower_bound": 4.798446903082174, "max_hits_assumption_verified_by_this_code": false, "independent_geometric_facts": "The cross is connected. Its convex hull is the diamond |x|+|y|<=sqrt(2), which contains the unit disk. Every linear projection of a connected set is an interval, so containment of the disk in its convex hull makes it opaque. Two segments give the automatic almost-everywhere hit bound 2." }, "triangle_boundary": { "segment_count": 3, "nondegenerate_segment_count": 3, "total_segment_length": 10.392304845413264, "pair_overlaps": [ { "i": 0, "j": 1, "Q": 3.4641016151377544 }, { "i": 0, "j": 2, "Q": 3.4641016151377544 }, { "i": 1, "j": 2, "Q": 3.4641016151377544 } ], "pair_energy": 10.392304845413264, "maximum_spanning_forest_edges": [ { "i": 0, "j": 1, "Q": 3.4641016151377544 }, { "i": 0, "j": 2, "Q": 3.4641016151377544 } ], "maximum_spanning_forest_value": 6.928203230275509, "forest_necessary_lower_bound": 6.6056942687275475, "automatic_hit_bound": 3, "automatic_pair_necessary_lower_bound": 6.605694268727548, "opacity_established": false, "arithmetic": "float64 evaluation of exact geometric formulas", "externally_assumed_max_hits": 2, "conditional_pair_necessary_lower_bound": 8.337745076296425, "max_hits_assumption_verified_by_this_code": false, "independent_geometric_facts": "The equilateral triangle is circumscribed about the unit disk; its boundary is opaque and a generic line hits it at most twice." } }, "fractional_no_go": { "analytic_statement": "Half of the unit-circle boundary measure has cost pi and weighted intersection count 1 on every non-tangent line through the disk. Consequently line-count covering constraints allowing fractional density cannot imply a bound strictly greater than pi. For a regular circumscribed N-gon, half boundary density has cost N*tan(pi/N), tending to pi. This is a fractional relaxation, not a physical barrier.", "polygon_diagnostics": [ { "circumscribed_regular_polygon_sides": 3, "half_density_cost": 5.19615242270663, "excess_above_pi": 2.054559769116837 }, { "circumscribed_regular_polygon_sides": 4, "half_density_cost": 3.9999999999999996, "excess_above_pi": 0.8584073464102064 }, { "circumscribed_regular_polygon_sides": 6, "half_density_cost": 3.4641016151377544, "excess_above_pi": 0.32250896154796127 }, { "circumscribed_regular_polygon_sides": 12, "half_density_cost": 3.2153903091734723, "excess_above_pi": 0.07379765558367923 }, { "circumscribed_regular_polygon_sides": 24, "half_density_cost": 3.1596599420975, "excess_above_pi": 0.01806728850770689 }, { "circumscribed_regular_polygon_sides": 96, "half_density_cost": 3.1427145996453683, "excess_above_pi": 0.0011219460555751404 }, { "circumscribed_regular_polygon_sides": 384, "half_density_cost": 3.141662747056848, "excess_above_pi": 7.009346705499908e-05 } ] } }